Project Gutenberg Australia
a treasure-trove of literature
treasure found hidden with no evidence of ownership

Title: Found Dead
Author: Fred M. White
* A Project Gutenberg Australia eBook *
eBook No.: 1302921.txt
Language: English
Date first posted: May 2013
Date most recently updated: May 2013

Produced by: Maurie Mulcahy

Project Gutenberg Australia eBooks are created from printed editions
which are in the public domain in Australia, unless a copyright notice
is included. We do NOT keep any eBooks in compliance with a particular
paper edition.

Copyright laws are changing all over the world. Be sure to check the
copyright laws for your country before downloading or redistributing this

This eBook is made available at no cost and with almost no restrictions
whatsoever. You may copy it, give it away or re-use it under the terms
of the Project Gutenberg Australia Licence which may be viewed online at

To contact Project Gutenberg Australia go to


Title: Found Dead
Author: Fred M. White


Published in serial format in The Northern Herald, Cairns, Qld.,
commencing Wednesday, January 15, 1930, and also in the Goulburn
Evening Penny Post commencing October 23, 1930.



Sir John Mortmain turned over the Sunday papers idly in search of some
item of possible interest. It was one of those perfect mornings at the
end of June, without the semblance of a cloud in the sky and the warm,
languid air that conduces to sleepiness. Moreover, it was a Sunday
morning, and Mortmain had nothing whatever to do. He sat in a long cane
chair on the terrace in front of Mortmains, looking out across the
slumbering sea and half wondering how he was going to get through the

Mortmain was a good deal of a sportsman and, though a good many
people wondered what he did with himself half his time, he was no
idler despite the fact that he was a rich man in possession of one
of the finest estates in North Devon. More than that, he had been,
up to a certain time one of the most promising of the younger school
of novelists. His was a strange and whimsical fancy with a decided
bent in the direction of the gruesome and the grim--in fact, a sort
Stevenson-cum-Edgar Allen Poe frame of mind. In his earlier days he
had written a couple of novels on these lines, and they had found
decided favour in the eyes of the most discerning critics. In fact,
he was well on the way to making a name for himself when fate took a
hand in his affairs, and from a mere University graduate, more or less
fighting his way in Fleet-street, he found himself in the possession
of a title, to say nothing of a handsome income and one of the great
ancestral estates, on the northern side of the county of Devon. It had
only needed a motor accident in a fog along the romantic valley that
led up to Mortmains Lodge, and two lives that stood between him and the
twinkling of an eye. Then the late property had been swept away in the
late baronet, who was already an old man, bent before the shock of his
sons' death, and John Mortmain found himself master of the fine old
domain and the owner of a fortune that he had never expected.

He had come down there from London almost at once. He had turned his
back upon all his old friends and had shut himself up in that glorious
old house, where he entertained none and asked nobody, though there
were plenty of his own class in the neighbourhood who would have been
only too glad to have made much of the new owner of Mortmains.

Not that John Mortmain was in the least exclusive or distant. He was
friendly enough with his neighbours when they met. He rode regularly to
hounds and subscribed handsomely to the pack. He shot and fished and
played cricket with the local team. In a way, he was popular enough,
and yet there was that strange feeling of a gulf between himself and
the local inhabitants. Certainly he managed to convey the impression
that he wanted to be left alone, and that he was not particularly
anxious to exchange amenities outside the field of sport. He was
writing another book, or so he gave the people to understand, and
perhaps when that was finished he would be less exclusive.

But John Mortmain was not engaged upon another novel, at least, not in
the practical sense of the word. That he would publish something new
in the course of time was sure enough, but, so far, the plot was only
beginning to simmer in his mind. It was to be something of a tragic
nature, with a good deal of the sensational in it, and a lot connected
with Scotland Yard.

But Mortmain was too much of an artist to set about a romance of that
kind without having his facts correct to the last detail. If he wrote
about the modern detective and his ways, he would do so from life,
and not draw one of the sleuths who is so familiar in current works
of fiction. When he was ready to tackle that part of his story, then
he would go to the fountain head and obtain all his information first
hand. Or perhaps he might get the details he needed brought to him. It
was a happy thought, and Mortmain turned it over in his mind again and
again until it became almost an obsession with him.

Meanwhile, he had nothing much to do but to pass the golden days as
best he might and contemplate nature from the terrace in front of that
mediaeval house and soak his soul in some of the most wonderful scenery
that England boasts. Thus he was sitting there on that beautiful Sunday
morning late in June, smoking his cigarette and turning his papers over
idly with the full intention of staying where he was till luncheon.

And then, suddenly, a paragraph caught his eye and arrested his
attention. It was only personal allusion contained in a few lines, but
it served to hold Mortmain and cause him to draw a sharp breath between
his lips. It ran thus:--

"I looked in at the 'Frivolity' last night to find that the new revue
there is going as strong as ever. By the way, it has been considerably
strengthened by a new sketch written by Miss Margaret Debenham, whose
sprightly paragraphs in the 'Weekly Herald' are so well known to most
of my readers. Miss Debenham tells me that she has just finished a
comedy which will shortly see the light in the West End, though she
was charmingly discreet as to the name of the famous comedian who is
fathering it. Miss Debenham, by the way, is well worth watching."

Just a mere paragraph with a faint suggestion of the work of the Press
agent about it. But it was enough to bring a cloud across Mortmain's
handsome, bronzed face and a look of pain to his clear, brown eyes.
Those few lines in cold print brought back to him with startling
clearness something which he had hoped he had put behind him for all

He remembered, as if it had only been yesterday, his first meeting with
Margaret Debenham. It was barely two years ago, and in that time so
much had happened. He had been coming out of one of the Fleet-street
offices when she was going in, and just for a moment they had almost
collided. A half-apology on either side, and they had gone their
several ways. Just one of those chance meetings that mean so little--or
so much.

Mortmain had gone on towards Charing Cross, thinking a good deal of
those blue eyes and that lovely, clever little face, and had laughed
at himself as a cheap sentimentalist. He would never see her again, of
course, and, anyway, it would be all the same if he did. A man who was
making a bare living had no business to allow himself to think about
the future, especially a future in which a pretty girl was involved.

All the same, those two were destined to meet again more than once.
They seemed to have mutual friends in the Bohemian set in which they
moved, so that there came a time when Margaret became "Peggy" and John
Mortmain became "Jack." And so it progressed by easy stages until the
two were engaged.

There were many ties between them; they were both engaged in the same
literary pursuits, and both had their ambitions clearcut before them.
One was to become a great novelist and the other an equally famous
dramatist. Still, there was one advantage that Margaret held over her
lover. Whilst he had his pen to depend upon for a living, she had come
to London after the death of her father with some hundreds a year of
her own. And it was a long time before she could induce Mortmain to
regard this as anything but a personal disadvantage. She had overcome
his scruples at length and their marriage was dimly in sight when the
blow fell. It came out of nowhere, like a flash of lightning in a blue
sky, and it left Mortmain stunned and bewildered. Moreover it reached
him by the same post as the letter, telling him of the tragedy in the
Valley of Rocks, and that he was now heir to the title and property.
Would he come down to Devonshire at once.

Moved by this appeal, and being the really good fellow that he was,
John put his own troubles on one side and hastened down to Devonshire.
There would be time enough to untie the complicated knot after the
funeral, and meanwhile he would not communicate with Margaret or make
any attempt to see her and get an explanation of her most amazing

But he was detained by the grief-stricken and broken old gentleman
longer than he had expected. And when he found himself at liberty to
get back to London, it was too late. To begin with he could find no
trace of Margaret at her lodgings.

"Do you mean to say she has left?" he asked the landlady in
Bloomsbury-square. "Left altogether?"

The old lady looked at him wonderingly.

"Why, didn't you know that, sir?" she responded. "She went over a week
ago. Come in one night in a great hurry, she did, and told me she had
to go to Paris for some months. So we parted, and very sorry indeed
I was. And no one more surprised than me when I see a day or two
afterwards in one of the papers as she was married, and not to you,
sir, neither."

Mortmain remembered vividly how he stood there asking questions and
hoping that he was not showing his feelings too much to the good
natured old gossip who was more or less unconsciously dealing him an
almost mortal stab. And it was true, every word of it. He found that
out as soon as he could get amongst the Bohemian circle in which they
both moved. By that time he was prepared to face the inevitable, so
that he could hear exactly what had happened without betraying himself
too far. It was a little comedy actress who told him all he wanted.

"Yes, we were awfully surprised," she said. "And not at all the sort of
man one would have expected Peggy to marry. You ought not to have gone
away, Jack. She never told me what your quarrel was about, and I didn't
like to ask her. Oh, yes, a man named Grimshaw, Richard Grimshaw, a
rich Australian, so I am told. But what you call a rough diamond, all
the same. I can't say that he made a favourable impression upon us."

So Mortmain had turned away with a shrug of the shoulders and an
epigram on his lips. The wound had gone deep and the expiration of two
years had not cured it.


Mortmain sat there in the sunshine, turning it all over in his mind. He
wondered rather morbidly if he could have saved the situation had he
seen Margaret before he left London on the most momentous day of his
life. But it was no use to think about that now. After all, if the gods
had taken away with one hand, they had given liberally with the other,
and there was more than one Margaret in the world if he cared to seek

Still, what did that paragraph mean? He had not been in London for two
years, he had dropped out of the old Bohemian set entirely, and knew
nothing of the doings of that world in which, at one time, he had taken
so keen a delight. He had been under the impression that Margaret had
married that man Richard Grimshaw and had gone back to Australia with
him. And yet here she was, apparently still in London, living in the
same old environment and, what was more extraordinary, passing under
her maiden name. Now, why was she doing that? She was not an actress
nor had she ever had the slightest ambition that way. But there it was
plainly in print for everyone to see, and the more John turned it over
in his mind, the more puzzled he became.

But what did it all matter to him, he asked himself impatiently.
Margaret had turned him down over some fancied grievance, without
giving him even the chance to explain. And if for some reason, she had
parted with her Australian husband, then it would be all the same,
in any case. She was married now, and there was an end to it and, if
Mortmain had his way he would never see her again. Still, the old
memories were bitter in the mind and took away all the flavour of his

He was still trying to forget when the old family butler, Thomas
Farthing, came out of the house and approached the long basket chair in
which he was seated.

"Excuse me, sir," the elderly servitor said, "but would you be pleased
to come in for lunch?"

"Lord, I didn't know it was as late as that," Mortmain smiled. "Really,
Farthing, it is almost a pity to go in the house on a day like this.
The finest day we have had this year. The coast of Wales looks as
if it was cut out of marble. To-morrow morning I think I will go
out prawning. Let me see, what time is low water? I mean to-morrow
morning's tide?"

"Half-past three, sir," Farthing responded. The old man had been born
on the coast, and knew every trick and turn of the tide as he had done
from early boyhood. "Half-past three, sir, and the tide will be dead
out. And there won't be a breath of wind either. If you go down the
zig-zag path and start away out from under the Castle Rock you ought to
get a sackful."

"So I have been thinking," Mortmain smiled. "And not a soul to disturb
me. You get my traps together, as usual, and leave the rest to me. See
that everything is in my bedroom, so that I need not disturb anybody
at that time of the morning, and set my alarm clock for a quarter-past
three. It will be more or less daylight by then, and with any luck I
shall be back for a change and a bath before my breakfast at the usual
hour. And don't forget the alarm."

"Oh no, sir, of course not, sir. And if there is nothing else, sir,
perhaps you will come in to luncheon."

Mortmain followed languidly enough. He had the natural appetite of the
clean-living athlete, but he did not particularly feel the call to
the mid-day meal just then. And though he was looking forward keenly
enough to his sport on the morrow, his mind was half engaged on other
things. It was ten o'clock in the evening before he threw aside some
notes he was making with an air of impatience and went up to bed,
although outside it was still more or less daylight. But Mortmains was
an early household, and an hour later all its inhabitants were in bed
and asleep. Then morning came, as morning does, and the household began
to stir. First the maidservants, then Mrs. Morse, the housekeeper, and,
after her, the two footmen, followed by Farthing, whose work consisted
mainly at that time of the day in seeing that everything was in order
in the library.

He came down leisurely enough, as befitted his age and dignity and
threw open the library door. It was a majestic room in the left wing,
running the whole depth of the house, with a large mullioned window at
either end. At one time, it had been a sort of chapel, as shown by the
arched roof with its finely carved timbers and the floor of encaustic
tiles, covered, for the most part, with a magnificent Persian carpet,
which, however, showed the patterns of the tiles for some six feet
round the side of the room. The walls were covered with shelves bearing
volumes of various ages and in divers bindings. For the Mortmains'
library was a famous one, and more than one transatlantic visitor had
tried to buy it from its late owner. On the whole, a wonderful room,
placid and calm and dignified and filled with that ancient peace that
Tennyson sang about. In one window was a great carved writing desk, and
against one of the high shelves lay the light ladder which is usually
found where libraries are concerned. This rested on its side against a
book shelf, and Farthing scratched his head as he contemplated it.

"Um, that's a funny thing," he told himself. "What's that ladder doing
down there? I could have sworn that I put it under the far window
before I went to bed last night. And nobody couldn't have moved it,
because I was last out of the room."

With that, he made his way to the window facing the sea and pulled back
the heavy velvet curtains, so that the fine old apartment was flooded
with sunlight. Then the old man did a strange thing.

He stood there as if gasping for breath. He tottered across the room
and pulled back the other curtains. Then, almost mechanically he looked
to see if the windows had been properly fastened the night before. With
another gasp, he found that the window farthest from the sea was not
only unfastened, but opened a good two feet or more. Then, carrying
himself as best he might, he walked out into the corridors leading to
the domestic offices and thence into the steward's room where Charles,
one of the men servants in the house, was busily engaged on his
domestic duties. The old man clutched him frantically by the collar.

"Charles," he said quaveringly.

"Charles. Tell me, my boy, did ye ever see a ghost?"

"Well, I can't rightly recollect, as ever I seen one myself," Charles
replied gravely. "But my father he told me as he seen one once when he
was coming back from the Valley of Rocks one night very late, about the
time when he and my mother was keeping the lodge. But you look as if
you's seen one, Mr. Farthing."

"Well, perhaps I have and perhaps I haven't. But you run up to Sir
John's room and wake him up."

"Wake him up? Why he ain't in. Didn't you tell me your very self as he
was going prawning this morning?"

"Yes, I know that," the old man said impatiently. "But it's half-past
seven now and he must have been out at least four hours. And he
couldn't go prawning all that time, because the tide would be agin him.
No, he must have been back an hour or so. I know he hasn't come down
yet: but it stands to reason as he's in the house somewhere. If he
ain't in his bedroom, he's pretty sure to be in his bath. But go you up
and bring him down and tell him to come immediate."

Charles departed on his errand, leaving Farthing leaning heavily
against the table, as if in need of support. There was nobody in
the bath-room, the door of which was open, so Charles proceeded to
discreetly knock upon the door of his master's sleeping chamber. As
there came no reply, he ventured to steal into the room and cross
over to the bed. There lay John Mortmain fast asleep, and on a chair
by his bedside his fishing kit complete to the rubber-soled shoes
which he usually wore. One glance at these convinced the servant that
this morning, at least, the outfit by the bedside had not been worn.
Everything was as clean and dry as it had been when Farthing had placed
it there the night before. The alarm clock was ticking on merrily, as
if it had not been interfered with. It was quite plain to Charles that
the alarm had failed to function and that his master was still sleeping
placidly on. He bent down and laid a hand on Mortmain's shoulder and
shook him gently.

Mortmain turned over uneasily and opened his eyes.

"What is it, Charles?" he asked. "Why, it's after half-past seven. What
the dickens has happened? Oh, I see--that confounded clock never went
off. I shall have to get a new one. But what on earth are you looking
so worried about?"

"Blessed if I know, Sir John," Charles murmured. "Mr. Farthing, he's
seen a ghost in the library. Pretty well frightened him to death, it
has. So he sent me up here to fetch you, and said as how you was to
come down to the library at once, Sir John."

Mortmain dragged himself more or less unwillingly out of bed and,
donning a pair of slippers, went down the broad oak stairway in his
pyjamas, just as he was. He called aloud for Farthing as he turned into
the library. It was a white-faced Farthing that joined him and one,
apparently bereft of speech, because he could only point to an object
that lay on the brightly-hued tiles on one side of the great room.

"Good lord, man!" Mortmain cried. "What on earth is he doing here? And
how did he get in?"

"Through the window, Sir John," Farthing explained. "I found the far
window open this morning, though I swear I fastened it last night.
Anyway, there he is."

"And badly hurt," Mortmain inquired.

"Dead," Farthing said. "Aye, I've seen too many bodies in my time to be
deceived as to that, Sir John."

"Ah, I see. Some burglar, of course. Found his way into the house and
met with a nasty accident."

"Murdered," Farthing corrected solemnly. "Murdered."


Mortmain stood contemplating his aged retainer as if he were seeing him
for the first time. It seemed so strange that the quiet and retiring
Farthing should speak so emphatically.

"What makes you think that?" he asked. "My dear man, you are surely not
suggesting that a melodrama has been staged during the dead of night in
this aristocratic old library?"

"I don't know nothing about that, Sir John," Farthing said stubbornly.
"But I do know as that poor chap was murdered. You have only got to
look at him to see that."

"Well, at any rate, he is dead," Mortmain went on. "How he got here and
what happened is at present a mystery. But I can't admit that he was
the victim of violence under my roof."

"It isn't for me to say, Sir John," Farthing replied, in the same
rather obstinate tone. "But I do know this--I was in the room after
everybody had gone to bed last night, and I am prepared to swear that
both these windows were fastened up. And now, here is one of them open
wide enough to admit a man. And, of course, Sir John, if it is wide
enough to admit one man, it is wide enough to admit two. If my opinion
is worth having, I should say that a couple of burglars got into the
house by forcing that window, and that they had a quarrel when they got
inside. The one who got away knocked the other down and accidentally
killed him. The poor chap fell with his head on the mosaic tiles and
fractured his skull. And then the other man, seeing what he had done,
made off, and, no doubt, by this time is far enough away. That is how I
see it, Sir John, if I may make so bold."

"Well, up to a certain point, you may be right," Mortmain conceded.
"But you are wrong in your particulars. In the first place, what is the
library ladder doing where it is now?"

Farthing scratched his head thoughtfully.

"Well, I hadn't thought of that, sir. I am prepared to swear that, when
I went round the house last night after everybody had gone to bed, the
ladder was lying at length on the floor under the window facing the

"Where it always lies, in fact."

"That's right, Sir John. I am as certain of it as I am that I am
speaking to you now."

"And yet here is the ladder on the other side of the room altogether.
Lying on its side on the floor, by that body. And, more than that,
there is a book on the edge of the carpet."

Mortmain bent down and took the volume from the floor. It was a
rare early edition of Boccaccio's "Decameron," beautifully bound in
vellum and tooled in gold, perhaps one of the rarest books in all the
treasures the library contained. As he lifted the volume, Mortmain
glanced at one of the top shelves.

"Ah, there you are," he exclaimed. "You can see the space on the top
shelf left when somebody--never mind who it was--took it down with the
aid of the ladder. Now, I suppose that that book is worth anything up
to a thousand pounds. There are other books here of almost equal value.
My theory is that there were two thieves, and that they came here to
rifle my library."

"Very likely, sir," Farthing conceded. "But I don't see as how they
could do much good with those books when they had got them. I mean you
can't sell stuff like that."

"Ah, there, my dear old friend, you are absolutely wrong," Mortmain
smiled. "There is nobody on the face of the earth who is more unmoral
than your hardened bibliophile. He would steal a classic manuscript
as soon as look at it--especially your American collector. Nor would
he hesitate for a moment to buy that Decameron at any price the thief
liked to ask for it, and ask no questions. It is the sort of thing
that has happened over and over again, even in the case of historic
pictures. Now, what I think is this. These thieves knew all about my
treasures; in fact, there is a list of them in the Free Library Museum
at Instaple. They have only to have a look at that, and they would know
exactly what to come for."

To all of which Farthing listened respectfully enough. Of course, he
had not known that in the Free Library at Instaple, the big town some
twenty miles away, such a list was on record. But Sir John had said so,
and there was an end to the matter.

"So there you are," Mortmain went on. "Those chaps came here in the
middle of the night and forced the catch of the centre window, which
would not be a very difficult job to men who were familiar with that
sort of work. And the first thing they did was to erect the ladder and
lay their hands upon, perhaps, the most valuable book in the library.
What happened afterwards can only be a matter of conjecture. And mind
you, we are not bound to argue that the thieves even had a quarrel.
Suppose the ladder had slipped just as one of the thieves was about to
descend with this Decameron in his hand. He might have come crashing
backwards, or turned over as he fell, and even from the height of
ten feet it would be no extraordinary matter if he sustained that
fracture, which even my inexperienced eyes can detect. And this leads
us to another theory. Supposing the thief had been alone, and I cannot
see any reason why he should not have been. He comes by himself and
he meets with an accident. You find him dead when you come down this
morning and, not unnaturally, arrive at certain conclusions. I am not
saying you are wrong, Farthing, nor am I saying that my one-man theory
is correct. That will be for the police to ascertain later on. Anyhow,
the unfortunate individual is dead, and there is an end of it."

Mortmain spoke as if the conversation was finished, so far as he was
concerned; and bent down to examine the body. It was that of a man of
some forty years of age, clean-shaven and round-faced, and by no means
ill-looking. The head was crowned with short, curly hair of a reddish
hue, and the unfortunate individual seemed to have fallen backwards and
then turned over on his face with one of his arms doubled behind him.
Even to the lay eye, the cause of death was plain enough for there was
a deep indentation at the base of the skull, and on the soft collar
which the man was wearing a mass of blood had congealed.

For some little time both men stood contemplating that rather sinister
sight with no word spoken between them. It was Farthing who, at length,
broke the silence.

"What are we going to do about it, sir?" he asked.

"Do about it?" Mortmain echoed. "Oh, I see what you mean. Call in the
police and all that sort of thing. Yes, you are quite right. We had
better lock the door of this room and leave everything just as we found
it. Then you go into Watersmouth village and fetch the local constable
whilst I telephone to Instaple and call up the superintendent there.
Yes, Farthing, at the same time it would not be a bad thing if you
dropped on your way and asked Dr. Hartley Deacon to give me a call. As
a matter of fact, we ought to send for him first."

Farthing departed on his errand, and some quarter of an hour later
the local doctor arrived at Mortmains in his car. He was a small,
dry-looking man, brown faced and wiry, with every suggestion of the
athlete about him. As a matter of fact, he had been a famous county
cricketer in his time, before he had settled down to a country
practice, where he could get a decent living and follow his scientific
pursuits in quietness and comfort. Hartley Deacon was a man whose name
was known and respected far beyond the borders of the county of Devon.

"Hello, Mortmain," he cried. "What's all this story that Farthing has
been telling me. The old chap was so incoherent that I could hardly
make head or tail of the yarn. Something about a murdered man that he
found in the library."

"Come and see for yourself," Mortmain said briefly.

"Yes, a fractured skull, all right," Deacon said, after making a close
examination. "Now let us hear what you have to say about it . . .
. yes, I shouldn't wonder if you were right. There are certain
circumstances about the case which present themselves to me pretty
plainly, as they would to any scientific man. But I don't want to go
into them until the police have taken a hand in the game. Of course,
there will have to be an inquest."

Whilst Mortmain and Deacon were still discussing all the bearing on the
tragedy, the inspector from Instaple put in an appearance. He listened
gravely to all that the others had to say before making any statement
of his own.

"Well, Doctor," he said. "I am inclined to agree with you that we
cannot do any more for the moment. No doubt it will transpire that that
man was killed in the act of committing a burglary, thought I am not
going to rule a violent death out altogether until we have exhausted
the evidence. If you don't mind, Sir John, I should like to ask your
servants a few questions."

"Yes, I rather expected you to say that," Mortmain replied. "Of course,
you are at liberty to do as you like. For the moment, at any rate, you
can regard Mortmains as your own."

"In the servants," Inspector James Gore said, "I must ask you how many
servants you keep."

Mortmain went over the whole list. Butler, housekeeper, two footmen,
four indoor domestics, excluding the cook and kitchen maid. In addition
to those, were three gardeners, who however, did not live on the estate
and the aged lodge keeper and his wife. But a close cross-examination
of all these served to throw no ray of light upon the remarkable
tragedy. There was no questioning the fact that the whole of the
domestic staff had been in bed the night before quite early and,
indeed, Farthing testified to the fact that it was so light when he
went to bed himself that he had no occasion to switch on the electric
light, nor had anybody heard the slightest sound during the night,
except that one of the dogs in the kennels had barked.

"Well, I must leave it at that for the moment," Gore said. "I will get
back and see the coroner."

"And when will the inquest be?" Mortmain asked.

"I can't quite tell you that," the inspector explained. "But I should
say not before the day after to-morrow. If you don't mind I will take
the key of the library away with me."


It was only natural that, before many hours had passed, the amazing
tragedy at Mortmains was the only theme of discussion for many miles
around. Long before mid-day, the road leading to the old house was
thronged with those anxious to see the scene and to gather all there
was connected with the story. Representatives of at least two Press
agencies were on the spot as if by magic, and the six o'clock edition
of most of the evening papers contained columns on the subject of
what was destined to be known far and wide ere long as the Mortmains
mystery. It was a quiet time, with nothing more sensational than
cricket and racing to fill the daily Press, so that news editors
fell upon the happenings in Devonshire with avidity. The story was
widely discussed in London and the great towns within a few hours
of the preliminary details being flashed over the wires. And in the
interim the curious would have to wait, for the simple reason that
something like eight and forty hours must elapse between the discovery
of the body and the preliminary investigations into the cause of the
unfortunate man's death.

It was a full four and twenty hours later before Inspector Gore
re-appeared at Mortmains, arriving on this occasion in Dr. Deacon's
car. He had nothing very much to say, except that the inquest was fixed
to take place in the library at Mortmains on the following morning.

"The coroner will be here at 10 o'clock," he explained to Mortmain.
"And the jury is already summoned. I expect you will find it rather
a nuisance, Sir John, but in the circumstances, it cannot very well
be helped. You will have the house and grounds over-run with people
but, seeing that it is a public inquiry, I cannot very well keep them
out. But it shan't occur again. There is no occasion why the adjourned
inquest should not be held in the village. At the town hall, probably."

"Then you don't expect to finish to-morrow?" Mortmain asked.

"Most assuredly I don't. I have not the least idea, so far, who the
man is or where he comes from, and nobody has turned up to inquire for
him. In the circumstances, we can only take formal evidence and perhaps
get a certificate for the burial of the body. You see, I have still to
make a close examination of the dead man and that is why I brought the
doctor with me. But, as you know, Sir John, there were no papers on the

"Yes, I remember that," Mortmain said. "I suppose you don't mind my
being with you whilst you are doing this?"

"Oh, not in the least," the inspector said. "It is not likely to lead
to anything so far as I can see."

In which conclusion the inspector was right. To begin with, the pockets
of the dead man were absolutely empty. No papers of any kind were found
on him, no watch or purse, or even any markings on his under-linen. If
he had come there that fatal night with any sort of head covering, no
sign of such a thing was found either in the library or anywhere about
the grounds, although the gardeners made a careful search, lasting for
hours. As to the clothes themselves, they were shabby and worn, and
evidently the kind that are called "ready to wear," in other words,
ready made. But there was a certain suggestion about the cut of them
that caused the inspector to nod his head knowingly.

"Not English," he decided. "Those clothes were never brought in an
English shop. Look at the shoulders. And, again, look at the man's
shoes. They speak for themselves."

"What, precisely do they say?" Mortmain asked.

"Well, 'Hail, Columbia,' I should imagine," the inspector said drily.
"Brought in some cheap store in New York or San Francisco. Anyway, I
will swear the shoes were."

"Doesn't that rather bear out my theory?" Mortmain said thoughtfully.
"I mean my suggestion that this fellow was a book thief, and that
he came here to get hold of some of my rarer volumes. In fact, I
think I have already proved to you that he could have come here for
no other reason. There was the Decameron on the floor and we have
evidence to the fact that the ladder must have slipped and flung
the thief heavily on those tiles. More than that, most of our rare
volumes to-day go to America, where they can be disposed of at a
fancy price and no questions asked. I should not be at all surprised
if some wealthy American book lover hadn't given the man lying there
instructions to come over here and get that particular Decameron. If
that is correct, then we can wash out the idea of a murder altogether,
and the case resolves itself into one of vulgar theft, which will be
very disappointing to the sensation-loving Press, but a common sense
deduction, all the same.

"Very likely," the inspector admitted. "And again, very likely not.
What do you think, Doctor?"

All this time, Dr. Deacon had been saying nothing. He was on his knees
by the side of the corpse with a strong magnifying glass in his hand.
With the aid of this he examined the body from head to foot finishing
with a very minute inspection of the close-cropped, curly, red hair.

"Um," he said, as if speaking to himself and as if he had quite
forgotten the fact that he was not alone. "This is rather curious. Most
distinctly curious."

"Have you found anything out?" Mortmain asked.

"I have found everything or nothing," was the enigmatic reply. "Please
don't think me rude, but I am always averse from giving an opinion
until I am absolutely certain of my ground."

With that, he turned once more to the body and half turning it over,
proceeded to examine intently the little mass of congealed blood at the
base of the skull.

"Curiouser and curiouser," he said whimsically. "Most extraordinary.
Now, how the dickens----"

He broke off abruptly and refused to say anything more.

"But you can't leave it like that," the inspector protested.

"Oh, yes, I can," the doctor smiled. "I suppose I can make an
observation like that if I please? My dear police-man, if there is one
thing I hate more than another it is making a fool of myself. And if I
gratify your very natural curiosity, it is just possible that I shall
make a brilliant success in that direction. Whereas, if you leave me
alone I may be able to tell you something of the utmost importance, not
necessarily to-morrow, but at the adjourned inquest you spoke of. And
even then there is the possibility of my being wrong. You go your way
and I will go mine and we shall meet in the end all right."

And not a single word more would the man of science say. He turned away
from the others and wandered as far as the window looking over the
sea. Far down below, at the bottom of the sloping garden, lay the wide
stretch of golden sands, and to his left the bold, upstanding peak of
granite that was known locally as the Castle Rock. It stood clear of
the beach, some hundred feet in height, a bold sentinel, all by itself,
with a pathway along the fringe of it leading from the village to the
moor and beyond. It was a picturesque and majestic sight in itself and
it seemed to fascinate the doctor, though he had seen it scores of
times before. There was just the ghost of a smile on his lips as he
turned away and approached his companions again.

"I wonder if you would mind answering me a question, Mortmain?" he
asked, "just as a matter of form."

"A dozen, if you like," Mortmain smiled.

"Well, it's just this. You go prawning most of these mornings when the
tide is low. Which way do you go?"

"Oh, just down the zig-zag path on to the sands and past the Castle
Rock out to the far point fringing the next bay. But why do you ask?
What has that got to do with it?"

"Yes, that is just what I have to find out," Deacon said. "Very likely
nothing of the least importance, but, you never can tell. And, anyhow,
as I said just now, I never advance an idea unless I have something
sound behind it. And now, Inspector, if you have nothing more to do, I
will give you a lift back as far as the village. I don't mind admitting
that I am very interested in this case, but I have patients to attend,
and I seem to have been neglecting them quite a lot the last day or so."

"Well, I suppose I had better come along," the inspector said
reluctantly. "I hoped to find out something tangible this morning but
must confess to be just as much in the dark as ever. It looks to me as
if I shall have to fall back on Sir John's theory after all. I mean a
fatal accident."

"Ah, there I entirely agree with you," Deacon laughed. "After what I
have just said, it sounds like a paradox on my part, but you policemen
are meeting paradoxes all your life. Now, come long, I really must be

The two went off together, leaving Mortmain to his thoughts. They
were not altogether unpleasant thoughts, perhaps, for he smiled a
curious sort of smile as he returned to the house and proceeded to
the morning-room where the day's papers awaited him. For the present,
at any rate, he could not use the library, which was not altogether a
pleasing reflection.

He had hardly opened the "Times" before Farthing came to him with the
information that a visitor was in the drawing-room, a visitor who would
not give her name, but who stated that an interview was required with
Sir John on most important business.

He strode angrily into the drawing-room, then as he caught sight of his
visitor, started back.

"Margaret," he cried. "Peggy!"

"Jack," the woman murmured. "Jack."

Mortmain froze almost into immobility.

"Why this honour, Mrs. Grimshaw?" he asked icily.


It was Mortmain who first recovered his poise, to realize in a flash
how this amazing thing had happened. For here was the woman of his
dreams, the woman he had loved and lost and the one being in the
world he had never expected to see again. And, behold, here she was,
standing opposite him, as young and as beautiful as ever and not
changed one iota from the girl from whom he had parted just two years
ago with every hope of seeing her again on the morrow. And then had
come that letter which had touched his pride and sent him out into the
wilderness, a broken and unhappy man at the very moment when he had
deemed himself to be basking in fortune's most spacious smile.

It was not to be deemed for a moment that Margaret Grimshaw, as he had
to call her, had come there expecting to meet her old lover. At the
same time it was almost incredible to Mortmain to believe that she had
remained unaware of the startling change in his fortune.

"You wanted to speak to me?" he ventured.

"Oh, yes." Margaret said confusedly. "Of course I wanted speak to you.
But then, I want you to believe that I did not know whom I was going to
see, all the same."

"I am beginning to understand," Mortmain smiled. "You mean to say that
nobody ever told you that I am Sir John Mortmain and that this is my
country residence?"

"Indeed, no," Margaret murmured. "It is, perhaps, best to be plain.
When I set out from Watersmouth an hour ago to call upon Sir John
Mortmain, I had not the faintest idea that I was going to find myself
face to face with--with----"

"Your old lover," Mortmain finished the sentence grimly. "There is no
reason for us to beat about the bush over it. We can look back on that
now with equanimity. You are a happily married woman and I am a rather
lonely bachelor, pretending to be a popular novelist. I suppose some of
these days I shall write another book, in fact, I was working on the
plot when the tragedy everybody is speaking of, suddenly happened under
this peaceful roof. I suppose it was this tragic event that brought you
all this way to call at Mortmains."

"That is quite correct," Margaret said. "You see, I came down here a
few days ago on a fortnight's holiday. I am very fond of the world and
this is by no means my first visit. I am staying at the Crown Hotel in
Watersmouth and early this morning I had a telephone message from the
news editor of the 'Daily World' asking me to take up the story of the
Mortmains tragedy and send them what I pleased. So I came over here at
once to interview Sir John Mortmain--and----"

"And here you are," Mortmain smiled. "And here am I, for that matter.
And you see, when I received a certain letter of yours, I was just back
in London after helping to bury two cousins of mine who were killed
in a motor accident and when the late owner of this property died a
few weeks afterwards, more or less of a broken heart. I came into the
property and the title."

"But you never told me----" Margaret began.

"No? Well, when I come to think of it, I didn't. You see, at that time
I had not the least expectation of becoming head of the family, and
there was no object in telling everybody that I was the nephew of a
baronet. I always hated that sort of thing--it sounds so much like
swank. However, here you are and I must do my best to make you welcome.
I wonder if you will be offended if I ask you to join me in a bit of

"That is very kind of you," Margaret murmured. "I shall be only too
pleased. But are you quite sure----"

"Quite sure. Oh, I know what you are going to say. Then you can tell me
all about yourself and I will tell you what I have been doing since we
last met. So long as you are happy, the rest matters nothing."

It was rather a happy turn of speech and Margaret appreciated it
accordingly. And yet, though she smiled pleasantly enough, there
was very little about her to show that her married life had been a
desirable one. There was just a suggestion of pain in her eyes and
a faint shadow on her smooth brow that had certainly not been there
two years ago. A worn and worried look that told imaginative Mortmain
something of a tale. But it as not for him to comment on the subtle
change, and he led the way into the dining room where, at his request,
Farthing laid another place at the table. It was a glorious old room
with its panelled walls and carved ceiling looking out over the broad
expanse of sea, and Margaret exclaimed aloud at the beauty of it.

"What a glorious old house," she cried. "Do you know, I have often
wished for a chance to look over it. You are a fortunate man to have a
residence like this."

"Yes, I suppose I am," Mortmain said with something of a sigh. "But
then, we are never satisfied. Now, sit down and make yourself at
home. Farthing, you can put the lunch on the table and leave us. Mrs.
Grimshaw is an old friend of mine and we shall have quite a lot of
subjects to discuss."

Farthing did as he was told and discreetly vanished. It was not until
the meal was finished and Mortmain passed the silver cigarette box
across the table that he began to speak of those things which were
nearest to his heart.

"I suppose it is no use going over old grievances," he said. "But there
are one or two things which I should like to have explained. You are a
staid married woman now and our old romance is more or less forgotten."

"I suppose it is," Margaret agreed. All the same, she didn't altogether
look as it she thought so. In most ways, she was the old Margaret
still, but the trouble cloud still dimmed her eyes, and there was a
yearning look in them as she turned to her companion. Nor could she see
that he was in any way altered. But, deep down in her heart, she knew
that there had been no change, nor ever would be.

"In that case," Mortmain said. "Perhaps you would not mind answering me
a few questions. Why did you write me that dreadful letter? If I had
done anything wrong, why didn't you come to me and give me a chance of
righting myself?"

"But you must not put me on the defensive like that," Margaret cried.
"If I was rash and impulsive, surely I had cause?"

"My dear girl, that is just the question I am asking you. What was the
cause? You never said in your letter. And I think you will admit it was
rather a wild epistle. I am quite sure you were desperately angry with
me over something or another. And when you told me you never wanted to
see my face again, I could do no more than take you at your word. And
I didn't mind admitting that I have been sorry for it ever since. If
I had exercised my rights and compelled you to see me I am perfectly
certain that I could have explained everything, whatever it was."

"Even those other letters of yours?"

"What other letters? Come, Margaret, let us have it out now. A curious
chance has brought us together, otherwise we might never have met
again. You may say I have everything now that a man could wish, but you
would be wrong. Because I have this beautiful old house and all that
it stands for, it doesn't follow that I am satisfied. I shan't even
be satisfied when I have written the novel that is going to make my
reputation. Call it a form of conceit, if you like, but I like to stand
well in the eyes of every man, and when I say that, I mean every woman,
too. I was a poor man when I last saw you, but I think most people
would say an honourable one, and that is why I want to clear my name in
your sight, if you will only give me a chance. But it is strange that
you didn't know of my change of circumstances."

"Not so very strange I think," Margaret murmured. "I was just as
unhappy as you when I wrote that letter. I didn't want to see you
again, I didn't want to see anything that reminded me of you. So I just
slipped out of the old set and changed my lodgings. I suppose that is
why I never heard that Jack Mortmain had become Sir John Mortmain,
baronet. I hadn't the remotest idea, when I called here to-day, whom I
was going to see."

"Otherwise----" Mortmain queried. "Otherwise?"

"No," Margaret said firmly. "There is no otherwise about it. I had a
commission offered me, and I should have taken it even if I had known
that I was going to meet the man I used to be engaged to. I can't
afford to turn down work."

Mortmain gazed at Margaret in astonishment. For the first time he
noticed that she was not so well dressed as she used to be in the
old days. There was an indefinite air about her as of one who has a
struggle with life.

"But that is all nonsense," he explained. "I know you are making quite
a good income in Fleet-st., and, besides, you had some hundreds a year
of your own."

"We will come to that presently," Margaret said. "For the present I
have to work hard enough for a bare living. Let us confine ourselves
for the moment to the letter you complain of. I wrote it after seeing
another letter. I am speaking of the last communication you ever made
to Violet Graham."

"Violet Graham? I have never heard the name mentioned before."

"What--not the girl who used to be in the chorus of one of the
theatres? I forget which for the moment, but it doesn't matter. A girl
you used to take on the river. A very pretty girl, but terribly frail
and consumptive. And when her final illness came and she wrote to you
in distress, you turned your back upon her in the most brutal fashion."

"I give you my word of honour," Mortmain exclaimed. "This is the first
time I have heard a word of it."

"Perhaps you would like to see the letter," Margaret replied. "I have
it in my bag."


"Strangely enough," Margaret went on, "I found that letter, which I
thought I had destroyed, the morning I came away from London. So I
slipped it in my bag, heaven knows why. I suppose it was fate. It was
found amongst the poor girl's belongings after her death, and handed
over to me by someone whom I need not name just for the moment. But if
you would like to see it----"

"Like to see it?" Mortmain cried. "I would give half I possess for a
sight of it. Now, please----!"

The letter was handed over in silence, and Mortmain read it carefully
twice. There was no address and no date, and not more than a few lines
in a handwriting strangely like his own. And as Margaret had said, it
was, indeed, a brutal letter--the sort of letter a certain type of man
writes to a certain type of girl when he wishes all relationship to

"So this is the cause of the trouble, is it?" Mortmain asked. "I am
going to tell you, with all the earnestness in my power, that that
letter is nothing more or less than an impudent forgery. I admit that
the handwriting is very much like mine, and I suppose the scoundrel who
was responsible for this effort must have borrowed a specimen of my
handwriting with a view to the forgery. Now, did you ever know me to
write a letter without an address and without a date? It is a strange
fate that has brought us together here again to-day, but it will be a
fortunate one for me or the fault is altogether mine. I tell you again
that the girl you speak of was never known to me, and that I never put
pen to the paper on which that was written. I don't know how I am going
to prove it, but if you had given me a chance at the time, I could have
cleared myself easily enough. As it is, two years have elapsed, which
makes all the difference. But you can see for yourself that this matter
has got to be thrashed out, unless you disbelieve me, in which case,
there is no more to be said."

"But I don't disbelieve you," Margaret cried. "I think I would have
taken your word in any case. Oh, what a headstrong, silly fool I
was not to have given you the opportunity. Even when I wrote you in
the terms I did, I felt that it could not be true. But I was deeply
wounded, heartbroken almost, and I hardly knew what I was doing. And I
am very much afraid, Jack, that I have wrecked two lives."

"Looks very much like it," Mortmain said sadly. "It is good in a way to
see you again, Margaret, but I almost wish you had not come. Now, tell
me, who gave you that letter?"

Margaret replied under her breath. It was almost a whisper, but it
carried clearly enough to Mortmain's ears.

"My husband," she said.

"What!--the man Grimshaw? Do you mean to say that he it was who gave
you that letter? Oh come, there is a great deal more here than meets
the eye. Why should he do such a dastardly thing? He and I were not
even acquainted. I never heard of him till some time after we had
parted for good. And then a friend casually mentioned that my old
flame, Margaret Debenham, had married an Australian called Grimshaw."

Margaret sat there for a moment or two with her head in her hands. She
was crying gently. Then she looked up into Mortmain's face.

"I am not going to ask you to forgive me yet," she murmured. "That
will come presently. Perhaps, in the first place I had better tell you
all there is to know about my husband. He was an Englishman who had
travelled a good deal and finally came back to England where he began
to write about all sorts of strange happenings for the London papers.
I met him two or three times in the course of my work, and it was
not long before I began to see that he found me attractive. I am not
boasting--that is the sort of thing that every woman knows by instinct.
And then when he asked me to marry him, I told that I was already as
good as engaged. I never mentioned the fact to you, because I thought
it would not be quite fair. He seemed to take my refusal calmly enough
and in a few days had, apparently, forgotten all about it. I was always
meeting him in odd places and we were quite friendly. And then, when
you were taking your holidays two years ago I went out with him on
several occasions. He was interesting and amusing, and you know how
casual we used to be in that old Bohemian set of ours. Then, when I
got to know him better, he told me the sad story of Violet Graham. He
told it very well indeed, and I was very much moved by what he had to
say. And then, one day, when we were on the river at Hampton Court, he
brought up the subject of the girl again and, after warning me that I
must prepare for a great shock, produced the letter that is lying there
on the table."

"What an infernal scoundrel," Mortmain muttered.

"You can imagine what a blow it was to me," Margaret went on. "There
was your writing plainly before me and in the back of my mind was the
story of that poor girl. You must remember that I had heard it more
than once and I believed it implicitly. I was so furious against you
that when I got back to my rooms, I sat down and wrote you that letter."

"Yes, in which you mentioned no woman whatsoever," Mortmain smiled
sadly. "You brought no accusation against me, you merely said you never
wanted to see me again. And I suppose you regarded Richard Grimshaw
as a chivalrous gentleman who was doing his best for a poor girl that
I had been making love to behind your back. And because many a heart
is caught on the rebound you thought it would be just as well if you
married Grimshaw. But, my dear, a marriage like that could never be a
happy one."

"It wasn't," Margaret said with tears in her eyes. "In fact, I may
say that it was no marriage at all. We had arranged that the ceremony
should be private in the circumstances, and there was nobody present
except ourselves and the verger of the church and the pew opener. And
when we came into the street, a woman was standing outside. Directly my
husband caught sight of her he changed colour and tried to hide himself
behind a taxi that was crawling down the street. But the woman would
have none of it. She was not noisy, but still very determined. And I
wanted to hear what she had to say, because she looked a lady, despite
the shabbiness of her dress it was easy to see that she had seen better
times. Oh, it was dreadful."

"Don't go on unless you feel up to it," Mortmain said. "I can quite
understand what your feelings are."

"But I must go on," Margaret said firmly. "She told me the most
terrible things whilst the man stood by my side, white and shamefaced
and uttering never a word. And when the woman had turned away quietly
telling her story and warning me of the character of the man I had
married, I made up my mind there and then what to do."

"You left him, of course," Mortmain said.

"I left him there and then," Margaret went on. "I told him that we must
never meet again, and that though we had gone through the ceremony of
marriage, he was no husband of mine."

"And that was the unhappy finish?" Mortmain asked.

"Well, not quite," Margaret said with a watery smile. "The man was a
thorough adventurer. It was a proper shock to my pride to find that
he did not care for me in the least. He hated work himself, and did
as little of it as he possibly could. But he calculated that I did
very well, and was likely to do better, and that I had an income of my
own as well. In other words, he proposed to live upon me. And after
we had parted he wrote to me and suggested a bargain. Nobody knew we
were married, he said, and nobody need ever know, if I preferred it
that way. My opinion has always been that he has already got a wife
somewhere else, but that is by the way. His idea was that I should give
him my own income on condition that the so-called marriage remained
a secret, and that I should go on in the old way under my old name,
otherwise he would cause a scandal and practically ruin me in the eyes
of my friends. And I was so miserable that I consented. I insisted that
he should leave England which, for a considerable time, he did. When
he came back he began to blackmail me. He took my private income and a
good deal of my earnings besides. He keeps me so poor that sometimes I
have barely enough to eat. But why go on? I have told you the story of
my life which I felt bound to do when fate brought us together in this
amazing way. Do let me forget it for the moment and try and remember
that I came here entirely on business."

"Oh, of course, of course," Mortmain said with assumed briskness. "I
will tell you all I can, but I am afraid that I can't show you the room
where the tragedy took place, because the police have the key. Still,
there is a good deal of information that I can give you, and if you
want to be really thorough, I can take you to the room upstairs where
the body of the dead man is lying. But you will probably prefer to wait
for the inquest."

"I am not afraid to look at a corpse," Margaret said. "I have all sorts
of unpleasant things to do in the way of business, and I cannot afford
to neglect anything, however gruesome it is. My editor will expect
everything that I can send along and--well--will you think it very
unwomanly of me if I suggest----"

Mortmain got up from his chair readily enough. He didn't want to think
too much just then of the strange story he had just heard, because
there would be plenty of time for that. He led the way up the broad
stairs along a corridor and flung open the door of a room in which was
the bed where the dead man lay.

"There," he said. "But don't dwell on it too long."

Bravely enough, Margaret gazed down on the placid features of the dead
man. Then something like a stifled cry broke from her lips, and she
would have fallen had not Mortmain caught her.

"Heavens, what is the matter?" he cried.

"My husband," she gasped. "Richard Grimshaw."


The few words coming faintly from Margaret's lips seemed to have the
most extraordinary effect upon Mortmain. There was a look of mingled
horror and surprise in his eyes, together with what might have been
remorse, though it was an entirely different emotion. He glanced
hastily at Margaret to see if his feelings had conveyed any sort of
an impression to her, but she had dropped down on a settee, white and
motionless and for the moment entirely unable to move.

"This is horrible," Mortmain said thickly. "Are you quite sure that you
have not made some ghastly mistake?"

"Oh, there is no mistake," Margaret murmured. "That man lying there is
my husband."

Mortmain was silent for a moment or two, turning this new development
over in his mind. He hardly knew what to think or what to do for the
best. He was not unconscious of a certain satisfaction playing about in
the back of his brain, the satisfaction that there was no longer any
barrier between himself and the woman whom he still loved as dearly
as ever. He had cleared himself in her eyes, which was one good thing
done, and now fate had made the way plain for him to the inevitable

But there was much to do before that, much pain and gossip and scandal,
though perhaps Margaret, as yet, had not fully recognised it. To begin
with, the story of her marriage would have to be made public, she would
have to tell her amazing facts to the coroner's court for all the world
to gloat over. It was a cruel chance that had brought her to this pass,
but then, on the other hand, if she had not elected to do her work so
thoroughly the man lying on the bed might have been buried without
recognition and Margaret allowed to live for years under the impression
that she still had a husband in some part of the world.

"Do you quite understand the position?" Mortmain asked.

"I think so," Margaret replied. "I shall have to stand at the witness
table and testify that this man was my husband. I shall have to tell
the whole story, but I am not going to flinch from it. I shall be quite
ready when the time comes."

"You know all about him, of course?" Mortmain asked.

"As a matter of fact, I know nothing," Margaret said. "Oh, let us
get out of here. Downstairs I shall be able to think and speak more

Mortmain led the way back to the drawing room, and there Margaret grew
more calm and collected.

"It is a very strange fact," she said. "But I know nothing whatever
about Richard Grimshaw. He was always a very reticent man and, beyond
speaking casually from time to time about his relatives in Australia,
he told me very little. I don't even know if he has any parents or not.
There may be brothers and sisters, for all I know to the contrary. I
was not curious at the time, because I thought that I should learn
everything in due course. And you must remember that I had not known
Richard Grimshaw long before we were married. He always appeared to
have ample means, and was quite a clever journalist. I shall be able to
tell the coroner very little."

"Why should you tell the coroner anything at all?" Mortmain asked.
"Why should you face such a cruel and unnecessary ordeal? Let the man
be buried, and if the police authorities like to carry the case any
further, there is no reason why you should help them. Let it be a
secret between us."

"Oh, no, no, I couldn't do that," Margaret cried. "I should not dare.
I should be afraid to carry on my life, knowing what I know with the
chance that the truth might come to light at any moment. You never know
what trifle is going to turn out a fact of the greatest importance.
And if the real story ever did become public, how could I explain my
strange silence. No, Jack I must go through with it to the bitter end.
I must go into Instaple this very afternoon and tell the police there
everything. Oh, you must see that I am right."

Mortmain agreed reluctantly, but there was no occasion for Margaret to
go into Instaple, he said, because he was expecting Inspector Gore at
any moment. And, indeed, that individual put in an appearance whilst
the two were still discussing the amazing turn of recent events. He
listened to all that Margaret had to say with the deepest interest, and
when he had heard her to the end, he spoke with some decision.

"What an amazing series of events," he said. "I am exceedingly sorry
for you, Mrs. Grimshaw, but I am afraid you will have to go through
with it. Not necessarily to-morrow, when the first hearing will take
place here at 10 o'clock. I don't propose to call much evidence then,
merely to get the jury to view the body so that the doctor can give a
burial certificate, after which the inquiry will probably be adjourned
for a week or two and resumed in the town hall at Watersmouth. I have
strong reasons for not calling Mrs. Grimshaw to-morrow morning, and
for the moment, at any rate, what has just transpired must remain an
absolute secret between us three. Meanwhile, I have not been idle. I
shall have some evidence to call in the morning."

"You mean that you have found something out?" Mortmain asked.
"Something that is really of vital importance."

"Well, I am not going quite as far as that," Gore smiled. "But I can
certainly carry matters a good deal further. And I believe that this is
a very complicated case and that we are a long way, yet, from getting
to the bottom of it. It will probably be necessary for me to consult
other authorities."

"Exactly what I was going to suggest," Mortmain said eagerly. "With all
due deference to you, Inspector, this has looked to me like a Scotland
Yard case from the first. And if I may be allowed to make a suggestion,
I should like Captain Reginald Blake to have the chance of going into
the matter."

"That is all the same to me," Gore said. "Of course, I know the name of
Blake, but it doesn't follow that----"

"Oh, yes, it does, if he is at liberty," Mortmain declared. "You see,
he is an old friend of mine and we served during the war together
until he was transferred to the Secret Service, where he remained and
distinguished himself highly. After the trouble ceased, they were only
too glad to have him at Scotland Yard, and there he has been ever
since. If you can get him down here, I shall be only too glad to put
him up. It might be an advantage for him to stay here as my guest,
because, in that case, no questions will be asked and nobody will
identify him as a police officer. You see what I mean?"

"Yes, that is a very good suggestion," Gore agreed. "I wonder if you
would mind my using your telephone? I can get on to Scotland Yard from
here and settle the whole business."

It was even as the inspector said. He came back from the little office
in the hall where the telephone was situated in rather less time than
he had expected, with the cheerful announcement that he had been able
to get in touch with Captain Reginald Blake himself, and that that
individual might be expected to arrive at Mortmains some time the
following afternoon.

Mortmain heaved a sigh of obvious relief. He seemed strangely absent
and vague in his manner and conveyed the impression that something was
weighing heavily on his mind. It was a time, too, when he might have
been expected to take a cheerful view of things in the face of recent
events, but there was nothing cheerful about him, though he seemed
relieved when Gore had taken his departure.

"And what are we going to do next?" Margaret asked.

"What are we going to do next?" Mortmain echoed. "I don't know. I am
so utterly bewildered that I can't even think. Things have moved so
rapidly and so much has happened during the last few hours that I can
hardly grasp the situation. That may be a strange thing for a novelist
to say, but even fiction would seem to be less bewildering than fact.
Of one thing I am glad, and that is the fact that you will not be
called upon to give any evidence to-morrow. If I have my own way, and
if I can convince Blake that my view is a right one, perhaps there
will be no occasion for you to give evidence at all. Why should you?
You have identified the body to the satisfaction of the police and you
have told Gore all you can as to your husband's identity and family
connections. It would take months to get in contact with them, if ever
we found them at all."

"But there is my paper," Margaret pointed out. "It is my positive duty
to do the best I can for the people in Fleet-street, and I don't see
how I can keep the personal note out of it."

"Of course you can," Mortmain said impatiently. "You don't write the
stuff under your own name. You are called 'Our Special Correspondent'
and, as such, anonymous. But don't you think we are rather beating the
air? You leave everything to me and I will see what I can do when Blake

"Very well," Margaret agreed reluctantly. "And now do you think that
this tragedy was the result of an accident?"

"I don't know what to think," Mortmain confessed. "It might have been
an accident and, on the other hand, it might have been deliberate
murder. You see, all that business of the book taken from the upper
shelf and the ladder carefully arranged on the floor might have been
thought out by the murderer. But I do think that that wretched man had
some object in coming into this house which we have yet to discover.
You see, he knew all about me. He knew that you and I were engaged at
one time, and it was he who deliberately came between us and induced
you, by a disgraceful fraud, to marry him. But it is no use talking
like this. Now, are you walking back into Watersmouth, or shall I place
one of my cars at your disposal?"

"I shall be very grateful for it," Margaret said. "It is not very far
and I am fond of walking as a rule, but this afternoon I really don't
feel up to it."

"Then the car it is," Mortmain decided.


The preliminary inquiry into the death of Richard Grimshaw was almost
perfunctory. Inspector Gore had seen the coroner previous to the
inquest, and, between them, they had decided upon a certain line of
action. So that, quite early in the day, Margaret had been informed
that her attendance would not be required, though she had walked over
to Mortmain's with a view to doing the best she could for her paper.

First came Farthing, who testified to the finding of the body and,
after him, Charles the footman, who had been the second to be
acquainted with the strange tragedy. Then came Dr. Deacon, who said no
more than that he had been called in and testified to the fact that the
body had been dead for certainly not more than six or less than four
hours when he reached the library. Nothing whatever was said as to the
identity of the deceased and, at this point, Inspector Gore intimated
that he had no further evidence to call. He applied for an adjournment
for a week and intimated that, in the meantime, it was his intention
to enlist the services of Scotland Yard. The proceedings were over
almost before they were started and, with a curt intimation to the
effect that the inquest was adjourned until that day week in the town
hall at Watersmouth, the coroner closed his court and the more or less
disappointed gathering slowly dispersed.

It was a real relief to Mortmain to find himself alone, and in the
enjoyment of his own house once again. He sat for a long time in the
library, thinking matters over with a gloomy frown on his face and
a look of anxiety in his eyes. He was sitting there when Farthing
announced Captain Blake.

Blake came breezily into the room. He was a tall, thin man with
features burnt almost black by exposure to tropical suns, and looking
a great deal more like a sportsman than a detective. For the rest, he
was quietly dressed and his manner conveyed a certain heartiness and a
suspicion of simplicity that effectually disguised the keen, searching
look in his eyes.

"Well, here we are again," he said. "Do you mean to spend the rest of
your life down here doing nothing, or are we ever to see you in town
again? And what about that famous novel?"

"The famous novel will come along all in good time," Mortmain smiled.
"You see, one is rather handicapped, living in the country. It is like
being shut up in a house without any books. And besides, I don't want
to make a real start until I can have an opportunity of seeing a real
detective at work and studying his methods. That is why I sent for you,
old chap. It will be an education to me to see how you handle this
case. In all probability I shall found my book on it. I consider myself
very lucky to have a real original and startling plot developed for me
by an outside agency under my very roof. And now I suppose you want me
to tell you everything to the minutest detail."

"If you don't mind," Blake said. "And please don't forget those
details, in fact, there are none in my profession. Details as you call
them, are something of the utmost importance. You talk and I will
listen. Pass those cigarettes and ask your man to get me a cup of tea.
I shall want nothing else till dinner time. Now, go ahead with the
story of the tragedy. And, by the way, it took place in this very room,
didn't it?"

"In this very room," Mortmain echoed. "Now, don't interrupt, and ask
questions afterwards."

There was no interruption on Blake's part until the story was finished
down to the very last item.

"Yes, quite a case," Blake said critically. "Now, have you made up your
mind? I mean, have you any theories?"

"Speaking as a novelist, a dozen," Mortmain smiled. "But then, you see,
a novelist can twist his facts to fit into his plot. And when you come
to realities, it is a different matter. Speaking as a mere man, I have
no theories. That unfortunate individual might have been murdered, or
he might have met with an accident here whilst he was trying to steal
some of my literary treasures. It is impossible to say."

"For the moment, perhaps," Blake said thoughtfully. "Anyway, I am not
going to allow myself to be led astray by outward appearances. You
didn't know that man of course?"

"Never saw him in my life," Mortmain said. "I have already told you
what a sorry trick he served me, and I suppose he came down here with
the intention of serving me yet another one. At any rate, it is a
strange thing that he should have picked out perhaps the most valuable
book in my library."

"Yes, I haven't overlooked that point. Now, I wonder if he was aware
of the fact that his wife was down here at the same time as himself.
I mean, did he follow her here for some purpose? Did they meet and

"I am quite sure they didn't," Mortmain said with some warmth.
"Margaret would have told me that. You know her almost as well as I
do. Surely after identifying her husband and telling me who he was she
would never have played such a trick upon me as concealing the fact
that they had met down here."

"No, I don't think she would," Blake agreed diplomatically. "But
then we, at the Yard, never take anything for granted. We have to
treat everybody as suspect until we have proved their evidence. And
I am going to take the liberty of applying the same test to Mrs.
Grimshaw. Anyhow, I can't do anything till I have had an opportunity
of looking round, possibly not before I have studied the witnesses at
the adjourned inquiry. Meanwhile, nobody knows that I am down here in
connection with Scotland Yard, and that will be greatly in my favor.
And now, come and show me round this lovely old place of yours. After
being mewed up in London for the best part of a year, it is a blessed
privilege to come down to such a paradise as this."

For some time the two friends roamed about the house and then out into
the grounds, where Blake took a keen stock of everything. He wanted
to know how the sands were reached from the house and where that path
through the valley and over the crest of the Castle Rock led to. He
even wanted to know all about Mortmain's prawning expeditions and how
the household liked to be dragged out of bed at daybreak on those

"They don't," Mortmain explained. "You see, I have an alarm clock which
I set for very early, and I never see the household till I come in to
breakfast. But why do you ask?"

"Oh, nothing," Blake said, and with that the conversation dropped, save
that Blake expressed a desire to see Dr. Hartley Deacon, of whom he
seemed to have heard.

"A very clever fellow," was his verdict. "I cannot understand what he
is doing down in a quiet place like this. Do you remember that Hart
Lane case? Yes, I see you do. Well, your man, Deacon, worked out a
piece of analysis in connection with a couple of grey hairs that put us
on the track of the murderer. Most decidedly, I want to see him."

As a matter of fact, Blake saw Deacon not once, but many times, in
the course of the next few days. But he seemed to make no progress.
He pottered about for hours at a time, whilst Mortmain was otherwise
engaged. He seemed to spend whole mornings on the sands at the foot of
the Castle Rock and in the bay beyond. But if he was disappointed, he
said nothing, and if he discovered anything, he was equally reticent.
He was always smiling and cheerful and always hoping for the best.

"I don't believe you are troubling anything about the case," Mortmain
said to him on the morning of the adjourned inquest. "I believe that
you have fallen in love with this beautiful old place, and that the
scenery has hypnotised you."

"Well, there may be something in that," Blake agreed. "Still, I have
not been altogether idle. I warned you when I came down here that
things were not likely to move until after the adjourned inquest, and
I am still of the same opinion. I happened to run against Gore in
Watersmouth yesterday, and he seems to have got hold of a piece of
evidence which may help us considerably. You had better come in with me
this morning and hear it."

The town hall at Watersmouth was packed almost to suffocation when
Blake and his host arrived. They managed to push their way up to
the table in front of the platform on which the coroner was seated,
and there Mortmain saw Margaret, seated in a business-like attitude
with her notebook. He had not seen her since the startling events
of the week before, for he thought it better not to do so in the
circumstances. There would be plenty of time for that, he had decided,
and Margaret had tacitly agreed.

The proceedings dragged on for a time, and then at the witness-table
there appeared a little old woman in a cotton bonnet who curtseyed to
the coroner as her name was called.

"This is Mary Whiddon, sir," the inspector said. "She lives on a small
farm at the back of the Castle Rock, and she has something to tell you
as to the case in hand."

"Go on, my good woman," the coroner said. "Tell your own story in your
own way. Inspector, has the witness seen the body of the deceased or is
she speaking from hearsay?"

"She has identified the body as that of a man who has been lodging in
her farmhouse for some week or two."

"Yes, that is quite right, sir," the old lady said. "Only he didn't
call himself Grimshaw, because he said his name was Brown. He was a
quiet gentleman and came down for the fishing. No, sir, he didn't have
no letters all the time he was with me. And twice, when he was out all
night, he told me not to be alarmed, because sometimes he fished all
through the darkness. And nobody came near him, except one strange
gentleman that he didn't seem to get on with--a gentleman with a dark

"You would identify the stranger again?" the coroner asked.

"Aye, I should that, sir, because I see his face lit up by a match as
he was putting to a cigarette. And I seen that gentleman again this
morning--aye, that I do. Why, he was close behind me when I come into
court a quarter of an hour ago."


The old lady in the cotton bonnet was quite conscious of the effect
she was creating. In a way, it was the hour of her life, and she was
evidently going to make the most of it. She was well enough known to
a great majority of the people in the town hall, indeed, there had
been a Whiddon farming on the hillside beyond the Castle Rock for the
last three hundred years. It was one of those old Devonshire farms,
picturesque and low-gabled and, in the summer time, a favourite
rendezvous for visitors who know how to appreciate an old-fashioned
Devonshire tea with everything made on the premises, including the

The coroner looked up and wiped his spectacles. He was expecting
something sensational, as, indeed, were the rest of the spectators who
had gathered there.

"Go on," the coroner said. "I understood you to say that, within the
last half hour, at least, you have seen the man who was talking to
deceased. Look round the court and tell me if you can identify him. He
must be here."

But, apparently, he wasn't, for, after a long pause, the old lady shook
her head and murmured underneath her breath.

"No, sir," she said. "I can't see him anywhere. And I know he was here,
because he was just behind me."

"Very strange," the coroner said. "He must have slipped out in the last
minute or two. Has anybody left the building, officer? I mean, since
the witness came forward."

The policeman at the door did not know and said so. But it was just
possible that somebody might have left the building by the doorway
leading into the public offices.

"Well, for the moment it doesn't matter," the coroner went on. "Now,
Mrs. Whiddon, will you kindly tell the court all about your late lodger
and when he came to your house and when you saw him last. Particularly,
I want to know the date and the time when your lodger had the visitor
you speak of."

"Well, it's like this, sir," the witness explained. "The gentleman
what's dead, he come to me a week or two ago and asks me if I'd got
any lodgings to let. And, of course, I had, it being only the end of
June and very few visitors about, so far. I let two sets of rooms and
I haven't got any bookings till the fourteenth of July. So I told the
gentleman as how he could have room for a fortnight or more, but that
I couldn't take him afterwards. So he engaged a sitting-room and a
bedroom and I was to board him. He came down for the fishing, because,
you see, the fishing in the Lydd is good fishing and gentlemen come
from far and near for the trout in the stream."

"He brought his equipment with him, I suppose?"

"Equipment? Oh, I suppose you mean his tackle, sir. Yes, he brought a
rod and some odds and ends of stuff what's in my house at the present
moment. But he didn't fish very much, leastwise, not through the
daytime. Rare fond he was of going out late at night and coming back at
all sorts of hours. And one night he never come back at all."

"You mean the night of his death?" the coroner asked.

"No, I don't, sir. I mean once before that. And when finally, he didn't
come back and a whole day elapsed I didn't give myself much concern
until Inspector Gore came to me and asked me to go and identify a body.
And, of course, when I went up to Mortmains and did so, blest if it
wasn't my lodger."

"Then I understand you to say that you positively identified the dead
man as your lodger?" the coroner asked.

"That indeed I did, sir, and a rare shock it were."

"Um--Now, let us go a little further. Since we have established the
fact that the deceased was your lodger, we go on to consider the matter
of this mysterious visitor. But, first of all, Mrs. Whiddon, had the
deceased any correspondence?"

"You mean letters, sir? No, not one all the time he was with me. Not
even a newspaper."

"Very well, then. Now, in what circumstances did you see the deceased
talking to this mysterious visitor? You said just now that you
recognised his features when he was lighting a cigarette. From that,
I assume that you witnessed a meeting between the two men in the
darkness. As it is light at this time of the year till nearly eleven
o'clock, I assume that the meeting alluded to must have taken place
very late."

"Yes, that it did, sir. Matter of fact, I was upstairs and nearly
undressed when I recollected that I hadn't given a calf of mine that
was sick her dose. So I slips on a few clothes and goes out in my
stockinged feet, seeing as it was dry. And there under the shadow
of the barn, I see my lodger, or at least wise, I heard his voice
talking to somebody I couldn't see at all. And they was quarrelling.
I overheard words that left no doubt as to that. And the other man
was threatening my gentleman as to what would happen if he did not
find something, which I took to be money, in the next day or two. Then
the stranger, he strikes a match to light a cigarette and I see his
face. A youngish man, he was, with queer eyes and an expression as I
didn't much care for. He had a dark moustache, thick and matty like a
scrubbing brush it was. Then they both moved away out of hearing and I
didn't see any more or hear any more. When I had finished my job I went
back to bed. And that is all I can tell you, sir, if you was to keep me
here for a month."

One or two more trivial questions were asked and then the old lady
faded away into the back of the court. She had told the coroner very
little, save for the fact that the dead man had an enemy in the
neighbourhood and that the two of them had met a few hours previous
to what was beginning to look very much like a murder. The sensation
the audience had half expected was to come when Margaret stepped up to
the table. Most of the people knew her, indeed, in a gossiping little
village, especially so early in the season, few people were likely to
escape attention. So that Margaret, who was already known as the pretty
lady who was staying at the Crown, was a familiar figure.

"I think you knew the deceased," the coroner asked.

"I knew him very well," Margaret replied. "He was my husband. I did
not know that until I was confronted with his body but, nevertheless,
he was my husband and his name was Richard Grimshaw. That is my name,
though I prefer to be known as Margaret Debenham, which I was before my

"Really," the coroner said. "Perhaps you had better tell us exactly who
you are and what you are doing here."

Margaret proceeded to explain. She was quite calm and collected now
and ready to go through with it to the end. She told her story with a
simplicity that carried conviction to every hearer, including Blake,
who watched the proceedings in the guise of a holiday-maker in a
golfing suit and an air of absolute detachment. It was a big sensation,
that Margaret had created, though she appeared utterly unconscious of
the fact as she went back to her seat.

The coroner looked inquiring in the direction of Inspector Gore, but
the latter shook his head.

"I don't propose to go any further this morning, sir," he said. "We
have established the identity of the deceased and proved that he was
down here on some more or less secret mission. Also, the witness,
Whiddon, testified to the fact that he had a secret enemy somewhere in
the neighbourhood. I am not in the least satisfied that the deceased
met his death by accident, and as I have further inquiries to make, I
shall be obliged, sir, if you will postpone this inquiry for a week."

"Very well," the coroner said quietly. "The inquest stands adjourned
for seven days, the same place and hour."

More or less reluctantly, the excited audience faded away and gathered
in the street outside, discussing the sensational stories of the
morning in little animated groups. Margaret passed them almost unseen,
followed a moment later by Mortmain and, behind him came Blake, in
company with Mr. Deacon.

"Well, Margaret," Mortmain said. "You would tell your story though I
don t see the least necessity for it. There was no reason at all why
you should be dragged into the case."

"But what could I do?" Margaret asked. "And, after all, I have done no
wrong. Somebody had to identity Richard Grimshaw, and who better than
his own distracted wife?"

She spoke bitterly enough as Mortmain did not fail to notice. The cloud
that seemed to have settled over him for the last day or two still
brooded in his eyes and his air was one of utter dejection that verged
on absolute misery. If he had been guilty of the crime itself he could
not have looked more unhappy. It was so palpable that Margaret could
not fail to notice it.

"My dear, boy, why be so downcast? After all I am not the first woman
who has been the victim of a scoundrel. And now he is dead and I am
free. Can't you understand what that means to me, Jack? Free to go my
own way without fear of the morrow. Free to call my income my own,
and to spend it as I like. Free to buy what I like and not to have to
face semi-starvation every now and then because I dreaded a scandal.
Oh, of course, I know it will be a nine days' wonder, and that lots of
people will say there is more in it than meets the eye, but, so long
as my conscience is clear, what does the rest matter? Richard Grimshaw
is dead, and I am glad, yes, glad of it. He was never a husband of
mine, and if I had not been a reckless little fool I should never have
married him. And now that the story is told I feel all the easier in my
mind. Oh, you don't know what that means."

"What are you going to do now?"

"This moment, you mean? Well, look after the interests of my paper, to
begin with and watch events. And I think that I shall enjoy my lunch
when I get it."

"Well, in that case, why not walk out to Mortmains and have it with
me?" Mortmain suggested. "Don't say no."


Margaret responded a little shyly that she had not the least intention
of refusing. Besides, she could hear Blake and the doctor close behind
and it was her suggestion that they were asked to join the luncheon
party at Mortmains.

"Don't let us talk any more horrors," she pleaded. "Let us forget
all about it for the present on such a beautiful day as this. Then
afterwards you can show me all over your house and grounds and I shall
love it. My one regret will be that my own folly has prevented me from
sharing such a paradise with you."

"Yes, but has it?" Mortmain asked boldly. "I fail to appreciate your
logic. However, we can argue it out presently."

There was no time to pursue the subject any further, because Blake and
Deacon came up at the same moment. As the doctor declared that he had
nothing to do and that, if things didn't mend he would have to seek
a living elsewhere, it was not difficult to persuade him to become a
member of the luncheon party.

"Yes, do," Blake supplemented. "And then I will walk back to
Watersmouth with you, Deacon. There are one or two little matters in
which you can help me and I prefer not to discuss them in the presence
of the lady here, who must hate the very name of Grimshaw. Really, I
beg your pardon."

"There is no occasion," Margaret smiled. "At any rate, I want to forget
it for the moment and enjoy a perfect afternoon."

And, so far as she was concerned, it was a perfect afternoon, and none
the less when, shortly after luncheon was finished, Blake and the
doctor went off together in the direction of Watersmouth. Then Mortmain
turned to his companion.

"Come outside in the beautiful sunshine," he suggested. "I have shown
you some of the attractions of Mortmains, but you might be here a month
without discovering them all. I believe I could take you for a walk
round the domain twice a day for a week and show you something fresh
every time. Now we will climb up to the top of the Tower Rock and sit
in the sun there feeling as if the whole world was a thousand miles

Margaret followed, nothing loth. And there presently they sat looking
out over the broad channel with the floating gulls far below them and
gradually slipping into an easy discussion of old times.

"After all, it has been very wonderful," he said. "Fancy you coming
down here, just at this particular time, not knowing that I was within
leagues of you, and then to find----"

Margaret shuddered slightly.

"Please, please don't go into that," she implored.

"I really had no intention," Mortmain said. "I am giving myself over to
the enjoyment of the moment and I am not going to think about anything
else. Moreover, I am going to make love to you, my dear, if you have no
special objection."

She looked up at him out of those cloudless eyes of hers, and a happy
smile trembled about the corners of her lips.

"Why not," she asked demurely. "There is no obstacle in the way now,
and, morally speaking, there never was. But please don't allow yourself
to be carried away by----"

"Circumstances and the hour--is that what you mean?" Mortmain asked.
"My dear girl, we have been a couple of utter fools, but there is no
reason why we should go on playing those parts, though I must confess
that they fit us pretty well. Margaret, if I had come to you as I ought
to have done, I should have saved myself two years' misery, and that
scoundrel would never have played us off, one against the other. And,
though I was a fool, I was a faithful one, and I have never forgotten
you. I love you just as much now as ever I did, and if you will consent
to share this little paradise with me, I ask no more. But perhaps the
past two years have not been the same to you as they have to me."

"Indeed they have," Margaret, said calmly. "I did what I thought was
right and all for the best, but within a short time I began to see that
I had thrown away my life's happiness. Even before it was too late I
had the impulse, over and over again, to come to you and ask for an
explanation. And then, the next morning, I grew hard again. And then
it was too late. I had deliberately made my choice and for that choice
I suffered more than words can tell. I suppose I have really paid less
penalty than I deserve. But that is all over and done with now and, if
you are of the same mind still, Jack----"

Mortmain needed no further information. For a long time there was
silence, while they looked out over the summer sea with heart and
mind in perfect accord. And then, suddenly, Mortmain awoke to the
realisation of things. The cloud that had lifted for the last hour or
two came down again and seemed to stifle him.

"Well," he sighed. "So far we understand one another, and that is all
to the good. But there are many things to be done yet and much trouble
before us ere this tragedy can be relegated to forgetfulness. I am
perfectly certain that Richard Grimshaw was murdered, and am not the
only one who holds that opinion."

"But how could it possibly be?" Margaret asked. "You don't lure a man
into somebody else's house to murder him."

"No, perhaps not. But he was killed in my house, all the same. And both
Blake and Gore are convinced of it. I am almost sorry now, that I asked
Blake to come down here. He has got hold of a clue of sorts, though he
is inclined to deny it, and he is not the man to release his grip when
once he has fastened on anything or anybody. And I could not very well
ask him to. He has his reputation to think of, and, though we are old
friends, he would not listen to any suggestion to the contrary. Depend
upon it, Blake is working on the mystery now."

Mortmain spoke more truly than he knew, for Blake had not gone back
with Deacon to the latter's cosy bachelor house with the mere intention
of talking generalities. He had found something which, as yet was vague
and intangible, but which promised, with luck, to meet with startling
results. And in this conclusion the evidence he had heard that morning
had strengthened him. He knew now, at any rate, who the dead man was,
and could give a pretty shrewd guess as to what had brought him down in
that part of the world. And, moreover, he knew that not very far off
lurked one who was one of Grimshaw's deadliest enemies.

He sat in Deacon's consulting room, smoking a cigarette whilst he asked
any number of apparently pointless questions.

"Now, what, precisely, are you driving at?" Deacon asked presently. "My
dear chap, you can pick my brains for what they are worth, but I don't
think you will gain anything by not taking me into your confidence.
Both of us are perfectly convinced that that man Grimshaw was murdered,
but we don't know how or why or when or where----"

"Oh, come, we know where," Blake protested.

"Yes, I thought we do," Deacon said, thoughtfully. "But don't forget
that I may have something to say on the matter yet. I have been merely
asked to testify as to the time of his death, and, at that moment, I
could not have said any more. But I think, my dear fellow, that I can
improve upon that now."

"You mean to say you know something definite?" Blake asked, eagerly.
"Something I can make good use of."

"No, I don't," Deacon admitted. "I can give you some pretty strong
hints which may cause you to shift your point of view, but after
that, I must leave it to your own resources. Now, you are under the
impression that Grimshaw and some person or persons unknown came down
here with the intention of getting away from Mortmains with some of
those valuable books out of the library."

"Correct, so far," Blake admitted. "Everything points in that
direction. We have Grimshaw down here with no apparent object in the
world, pretending to fish, though there is no evidence that he ever
wetted a line. He takes lonely lodgings a couple of miles outside
Watersmouth, and develops a habit of staying out all night--ostensibly
fishing. But I don't believe it for a moment. We know now that he was
in contact with some mysterious individual who, I presume, is staying
somewhere in the neighborhood, and this man does not call upon Grimshaw
in the daytime, but has meetings with him late at night out-side the
farm where Grimshaw makes his headquarters. A very cautious individual,
evidently, and one who will probably be quite a match for me. It is not
the slightest use my making up my mind that that chap with the black
moustache is the actual murderer, though I have not the slightest doubt
of it. For the present, what I really want to know is how that murder
took place, and why; then I shall see my way a little more clearly.
Now, if you have any information to give me I shall be deeply obliged."

"Well, as a matter of fact, I have," Deacon said. "Would you mind
having a look at this?"

With that, he produced from a drawer an empty cigarette box, in which
was a small patch of what appeared to be red hair attached to a
fragment of skin.

"There you are," he said. "Now, that came from Grimshaw's head. It was
hanging loose from his scalp when I examined his body, and I looked at
it carefully through a strong magnifying glass, because I could see
small, glittering particles shining in the hair and congealed blood on
the strip of skin. Now, you take up this magnifying glass and examine
the scrap of skin in the strong light from the window. Then you will
see for yourself what I mean when I speak of shining particles."

"By jove--you are right!" Blake cried, as he placed the glass to his
eye. "These look like little particles of gold. Perhaps you will be
good enough to tell me what they are."

"Certainly," Deacon smiled. "What you take for particles of gold are
nothing but grains of sand of the fine drift sort you see on the beach
above high water-mark--blown sand."

"But how the dickens did they get there?"

"That," Deacon said, "is what we have to decide."


Blake sat for some considerable time smoking a contemplative cigarette
before he made any reply. This was a new departure which he had not in
the least expected, and one that tended to destroy all the theories
that he had been building up since he had first taken the case in hand.

"Yes," he said, at length. "I see what you mean. But supposing that
Grimshaw had had a little accident on his way to Mortmain's. He might
have fallen on the back of his head. His hair was crisp and curly and
might have retained a good deal of sand without his being any the
wiser. What then?"

"Of course that is possible," Deacon agreed. "But I don't think that
could have been so and I will tell you why. Now, as to the first thing
I noticed when I came to examine the fracture that undoubtedly led to
Grimshaw's death, I spotted one thing in particular. There was the fine
sand, ground into the wound, so to speak and under it. What I mean by
that is there was a certain amount of sand on the scalp at the base of
the skull when that wound was inflicted."

"Wait a moment," Blake interrupted. "How are we to know definitely
that that blow was inflicted? It might have been an accident, and the
suggestion that Grimshaw fell off the ladder in the library where he
was stealing that book might be the real cause of the man's death. I
say it might be."

"And I say it isn't," Deacon smiled. "And I was going to tell you why
when you interrupted me. If what you say is correct, then there must
have been a certain amount of fine sand about the dead man's shoulders,
in his ears and all that sort of thing. And certainly inside the welts
of his shoes. Now I examined that body three times altogether and I
could not find a single particle of sand, except that which was matted
in the hair in the wound and round about it. How do you account for

"Well, you certainly have me there," Blake confessed. "I thought I was
beginning to see my way when you first told me about the sand, but now
I am all at sea again. I shall have to reconsider my position and start

Blake spoke lightly enough, but, all the same, he was distinctly
annoyed to think that a certain amount of valuable time had been
wasted. He prowled about more or less aimlessly for the rest of the
day and then, the following morning, with the intention of opening out
inquiries in another direction, he came into Watersmouth rather hoping
to find Gore there. But though Gore had promised to come over the first
thing in the morning, he had not yet arrived, so that Blake fell back
upon a casual conversation with the village policeman. There was just
the chance, in the course of gossip, that he might hit upon something.
The local representative of the law was by no means averse from being
seen in intimate conversation with one of Sir John Mortmain's guests,
little realizing that he was face to face with one of the leading
lights of Scotland Yard. He was an old constable nearing his pension
and talkative, after the manner of his kind.

"I suppose nothing fresh has turned up?" Blake asked.

"Well sir, we haven't much to go on up to now," the old man said with
an air of importance. "And you must excuse me if I can't answer any
direct questions. Still, it's rather a funny thing what happened to
Julia Ridge."

"And who may Julia Ride be?" Blake asked.

"Oh, she be one of our old inhabitants. She lives in that white cottage
up over on the side of the hill. It's her own property, it is, husband
used to be in the Coastguards. She's got no call to do any work, seeing
as they saved a tidy bit o' money between them, but she do let lodgings
in the summer."

"You mean she has got a lodger now?"

The elderly officer coughed discreetly. Evidently he had a piece of
knowledge to impart and was leading up to it after the manner of one
who is an artist at that sort of thing.

"Well yes, sir, in a manner of speaking. A strange gentleman has come
down from London a week or two ago."

"Nothing very strange about that, is there?" Blake smiled.

"Well, no, sir. But that wasn't what I was going to say. He come down
from London, he did----"

"You are quite sure of that fact?" Blake cut in.

"At any rate, sir, he came off the London train, because the man who
drives the bus from the Crown Hotel told me so, and he asks where he
can get quiet rooms and Joe, being a sort of relative of Julia Ridge's,
recommended him there. And there he stays for about a week and then,
well he just disappears, leaving his baggage behind him and a word to
say as he will be back in a few clays and that's just about all. Still,
he owes a week's board and lodging and that looks rather suspicious."

A sudden thought flashed into Blake's mind.

"What sort of a man was he?" he demanded.

"Oh, youngish man, about forty, perhaps. I seen him about the village
two or three times. Might have been a gentleman and might not. Dark
eyes, and a scrubby black moustache."

Blake nodded thoughtfully. This was almost an exact description of the
man Mary Whiddon had seen in conversation with her lodger on the night
previous to his death in the shadow of the barn. Evidently a clue worth
following up. One of those little facts that appear on the face of them
so unimportant and yet which often lead to the most stupendous results.
It seemed strange that Gore should not have heard of this or that the
village policeman who was present at the inquest had not associated
the missing lodger in his mind with the mysterious individual with the
black moustache. At any rate, the local constabulary had seen nothing
significant in the matter, and Blake was exceedingly glad to know that
such was the case. The less the local authorities knew about it the
better. At any rate, Gore would have to know, and as Blake turned into
the dining-room at the Crown Hotel for a mouthful of luncheon, he was
pleased to see Gore there.

"Just the very man I want to meet," Blake said. "Now, let us have a
little refreshment, and then we can discuss a piece of information I
have picked up at our leisure."

Gore was considerably impressed with the information that Blake
conveyed to him. He could see plainly enough that there was some
connection between the missing lodger and the dead man.

"Funny thing that I didn't hear that," he said. "But then, I suppose
Smithers didn't reckon that it was of any importance. He only wanted to
tell you that one of the villagers had been bilked by some dishonest
visitor. That is a bit of gossip that would interest him a great deal
more than half a dozen murders. Not that it is anything new, because it
happens half a dozen times every season. But what do you want to do,
Captain Blake?"

"Well, I haven't quite made up my mind," Blake said. "It is pretty
certain that we have got on the track of the man with the black
moustache. And from what your constable told me, he intends to come
back here again. Otherwise, he would not have left all his traps behind
him. I take it that this Julia Ridge is one of the innocent type of
women who will believe any plausible tale that is told her. I mean,
she would have allowed her lodger to take all his traps away if he had
promised to send her a cheque directly he got back to London."

"Oh, Lord, yes," Gore smiled. "We are a very honest lot down here and
the man would easily get away with a yarn like that. It is pretty
certain he will come back again."

"Ah, that is as it may be," Blake said shrewdly. "He may not come back
himself, but somebody representing him will. There must have been some
powerful reason for his disappearing as he did, almost at a moment's
notice. Anyhow, I don't think we ought to lose any time in overhauling
his belongings. I suppose you have got a magistrate living in the
village? Oh, you have. Then you had better run along to him and get a
search warrant, and when that is done we will go up to the old woman's

"Yes, that wouldn't be a bad idea," Gore agreed. "I will go up to the
Manor House and see one of the district magistrates who lives there and
get his signature to a search warrant. There are sure to be one or two
at the local police station. If you will wait here for me, I shan't be
more than half an hour."

With that, Gore departed on his errand, leaving Blake to turn this new
discovery over in his mind, whilst he smoked a cigarette, and sipped
his coffee. He was not expecting too much, but it certainly looked to
him as if the little bit of gossip of the local constable had opened up
a fresh field for exploration. He was still deep in the consideration
of this new side of the problem when the door of the coffee-room opened
and Margaret came in. She was quite alone, and evidently in search of
luncheon. Blake welcomed her with a smile and suggested that she should
sit down at his table. The dining-room was empty, so that there were no
people present to overhear their conversation.

"I have finished my own lunch, as you see," Blake said. "And now I am
passing a half hour as best I can, waiting for my friend, Inspector
Gore, who has a little business to transact. Won't you come and sit
down by me and honor me with your company."

Margaret smilingly accepted the invitation. She was quite at home
there, for this was by no means the first time she had stayed at the
Crown Hotel, where she was always a welcome guest. She was fairly
well-known to the village people as a whole, and it was comforting
to find herself the recipient of so much sympathy from practically
everybody with whom she came in contact. She had almost dreaded the
result of her startling disclosures at the inquest, but now she was
glad that she had followed the braver course and told the truth as to
her unfortunate marriage.

"I shall be only too pleased," she said. "I have nothing to do and
nobody to talk to, and if I meet anybody I know, I have to listen to
all sorts of questions which I cannot answer. But, on the whole, I have
little to complain of. I suppose you and Inspector Gore have discovered
nothing fresh?"


The entrance of Gore himself at that moment saved Blake from answering
a rather awkward question. He passed a swift sign to the inspector,
who merely nodded and tapped his breast pocket before he took a vacant
seat at the table and murmured something more or less complimentary to

"Don't let me keep you," the latter said. "If you gentlemen have
anything pressing to do----"

"Oh, it is not so pressing as all that," Blake said. "Now, Miss
Margaret--really, I ought to have said Mrs. Grimshaw, but as I have
always known you----"

"Oh, please don't apologise," Margaret said. "I never have been called
Mrs. Grimshaw and I never shall be now. Is there anything more that I
can tell you."

"Possibly," Blake said. "There is just one question I should like to
ask you. Was Grimshaw a sportsman?"

"In the proper sense of the word, you mean?" Margaret asked. "People
who go to race meetings call themselves sportsmen, you know. And so do
men who attend prize fights, though they never struck a blow in their
lives. Mr. Grimshaw was that type of a sportsman, and I have often
heard him say so. But as for golf, or shooting or fishing----"

"But surely he was a fisherman?" Blake suggested.

"He might have been," Margaret said a little scornfully. "But I never
saw any signs of it. He didn't play any game whatever, and the only
time the subject of fishing cropped up between us was one night when we
were dining with a party of friends at the Hotel Victoria. There was
a boy present who was a great fisherman, and I remember Mr. Grimshaw
sneered at him."

"And yet he came down here for the fishing," Blake said reflectively.
"You remember that, Gore, don't you?"

Gore remembered it perfectly well. Indeed, Mary Whiddon had testified
to the fact that her unfortunate lodger had come down to Watersmouth on
purpose to fish.

"Yes, I recollect that," Gore said. "He told Mrs. Whiddon that he was
so keen that he frequently fished in the night. Of course, that was
untrue. It was only an excuse for being out at all sorts of hours
without arousing suspicion."

Blake appeared to be content with what he had heard, for he switched
off the conversation in another direction, and, at the end of a few
moments, excused Gore and himself on the score of their pressing
business, and vanished.

They walked up the side of the hill together in silence for a little
time before Blake spoke again.

"Well, we have established another fact, you see," he said, "it is
quite clear now that Grimshaw came down here with some sinister
purpose. Of course, fishing would be as good an excuse as any other.
Quite an ingenious idea in a neighbourhood like this, where the trout
attract so many sportsmen. And besides, it gave Grimshaw an excuse for
being out all night if he wanted to."

"Yes, I quite see that," Gore agreed. "And now we have to account for
the quarrelsome gentleman who wore a black moustache and who left the
neighbourhood so hurriedly after the discovery of Richard Grimshaw's
body. We may be utterly wrong, of course, we may be searching for the
wrong man, but I don't think this business is a mere coincidence.
However, we shall see."

Mrs. Julia Ridge was in her garden looking after her early peas when
her visitors arrived. She changed color and showed signs of confusion
when she caught sight of Gore, for the inspector was no stranger in

"Good afternoon, Mrs. Ridge," he said cheerfully. "You know who I am,
and you might guess what brings me here. This gentleman is Captain
Blake, from London, and a friend of mine who is interested in the way
we policemen work. Can't we come inside."

"Oh, certainly, sir," the old woman said. "I hope it isn't anything to
do with that there lodger of mine."

"Well, in a way, it is," Gore admitted. "I don't say that your late
lodger is the man I am looking for, but he might be, by the description
of him. And, anyhow, you don't want to lose your money, do you?"

Mrs. Ridge was understood to say that she did not in the least want to
lose her money, though she would much prefer that calamity to being
dragged into the trouble at Mortmain's.

"But why should you associate your lodger with Mortmain's?" Gore asked.
"I have not suggested anything of the kind."

"Well, begging your pardon, sir, but I was at that there inquest and
I heard what Mary Whiddon said about a man with a black moustache and
my gentleman had a black moustache too, a sort of scrubby one, just as
Mary described. You see, Mary and me are related and when I went over
to tea with her last night----"

"You had the whole thing out, of course," Gore smiled. "You see,
Captain Blake, everybody in this village is related to everybody else.
And if one of them has a secret the rest are bound to hear it. Look
here, Julia, you can make your mind easy. I am looking for somebody in
connection with a case that doesn't concern you and is never likely
to. I am not saying that your gentleman has anything whatever to do
with it, but I am bound to make inquiries, so I am taking you into my

Mrs. Ridge smirked and bridled. Here was something to talk about.
Actually, she was going to be taken into the confidence of the police.
Something to last her a lifetime.

"I am sure, sir," she said, "every word you say----"

"Oh, I am quite certain of that," Gore said, knowing perfectly well
that his visit to the cottage would be all over the district within the
next few hours. "I know you are a model of discretion. But let us have
everything properly in order. This paper I have in my hand is called a
search warrant. It enables me to go all over your cottage and look into
everything you have. I will read it to you if you like, but I don't
think you want me to do that when you see the signature at the bottom."

Julia Ridge glanced respectfully at the signature of the Lord of the
Manor, and declared that the inspector was welcome to search the
cottage from top to bottom.

"I have got nothing to be ashamed of," she declaimed proudly.

"Of course, you haven't," Gore said. "And, as a matter of fact, I don't
want to look at anything belonging to you. My task here is to examine
the belongings of your late lodger. If he comes back you can tell him
what happened, though I don't think you will have to bother about that.
However, you never can tell. Did he have a sitting-room and a bedroom?"

"He had my best sitting-room and my best bedroom and he paid me two
pounds a week, though, to be sure, I get more than double that in
August. I was to cook for him and get in everything he wanted, because,
being a bachelor gentleman, he didn't want to be bothered with all that
sort of thing. When I gave him his bill it come to just under five

"Which he did not pay," Gore suggested.

"No, he didn't, sir, and that's a fact. He said he had been
disappointed over some letter he had. Not that I saw any letter,
because the postman never came here all the time he was here. But I
understood him to say as he had given orders for all his letters to be
addressed to the Post Office, seeing as he didn't know where he was
going to stay when he came down here. And then the day as he went, he
came in and told me that he had had an urgent telegram calling him back
to town. And I didn't see no telegraph boy, though perhaps he met him,
in the village. So he packs up and catches the mid-day train, saying as
he was coming back in about a week, and that's all I knows, if you was
to talk to me for a month."

Blake and Gore were alone at length in the little bedroom over the
porch of the cottage, having convinced the old lady that her presence
was not required. There was nothing much in the room, except a rather
battered and travel-stained despatch case and a leather portmanteau
which was pushed under the bed.

The despatch case disclosed nothing. It was crammed with papers, mostly
cuttings from the leading London journals and a great many of them
marked in red ink. Gore turned the contents on to the bed and examined
the case to see if there was any sign of a false lining or double
bottom. But the most careful scrutiny disclosed nothing of the kind.

"Well, we hare drawn a blank here, at any rate," Gore said. "Though
perhaps you notice that most of these cuttings refer to different big
houses in the West End of London. Whether we are right or wrong in our
contentions, I should say that the owner of this case is well known to
the police."

Blake nodded in agreement. Then the portmanteau was turned out,
disclosing a wardrobe of a quite superior kind and, right at the bottom
of a mass of under-linen a sheet of paper on which someone had written
a letter. There was no address upon it, except the words "Orchard-st.,
Thursday night" and ran thus:--

"My dearest little girl,

Thanks for your phone and suggestion. It is so audaciously clever that
I am positively afraid of using it. However, there is one point which
I should like to discuss with you, but that will keep till we meet on
Sunday.--Yours ever, Jacques."

Beyond that, absolutely nothing to throw the slightest light on the
identity of the man with the black moustache. And yet Blake stood there
with the letter in his hand, turning it over until, finally, he handed
it to Gore.

"Does it tell you anything," Gore asked.

"Well, yes," Blake said, drawing a deep breath. "It tells me this much,
only this is to be quite between ourselves till the time to speak
comes. That letter is in the handwriting of my friend and host, Sir
John Mortmain."

Gore whistled softly between his teeth.

"The mystery grows deeper," he said.


"I wonder what you make of it," Gore went on. "I suppose that you are
quite sure that it is Sir John's handwriting."

"Of that I have not the slightest doubt," Blake said firmly. "I know
it so well and, besides, it is so characteristic. Not an easy hand to
forge as I am sure you will admit."

"Then I should like to know what you make of it."

Blake told himself that he could make a good deal, but, for the moment,
he was saying nothing. Not even to Gore was he going to give away his
friend until he could conceal his suspicions no longer. Nor could he
altogether forget the fact that he was down in this part of the world
in two capacities, first on behalf of the law and secondly, as the
guest under an old friend's roof.

"Hang me if I know," he said irritably. "There is no doubt that this
is an important discovery, though, at the same time, it may be capable
of quite an ordinary explanation. On the other hand, it may not. I
think, on the whole, we had better go each his own way and, possibly,
we may be able to hit upon a solution on what is a most strange and
fascinating crime. Meanwhile, not a word about this visit to a soul."

The two men parted a few moments later. Gore on his way back to
Instaple and Blake more or less at a loose end. He was more puzzled
and worried than he cared to admit. To begin with, everything seemed
to point to some connection between the dead man and the individual
whom he had so deeply wronged. And yet Mortmain had declared with every
sign of truth that he had never met Richard Grimshaw or even knew
what he was like. Still, Grimshaw had been found dead in mysterious
circumstances under the roof of his rival, and nobody could say as yet
whether Grimshaw had been murdered or had met with a fatal accident in
the course of some nefarious scheme which he had been in the act of
carrying out at the moment when he met with his tragic end.

There was a great deal here that wanted explaining and Blake was trying
to fit the jagged pieces of the puzzle together in his mind as he
walked along the lonely, picturesque road leading to Mortmains. He had
barely cleared the village when he came upon Margaret, who appeared
down a side lane and evidently as going in the same direction as

"Whither bound?" Blake asked lightly.

"Well, I was going to walk through the valley and over the moor,"
Margaret explained. "I have nothing to do at the moment, and I am
finding time hanging rather heavily on my hands. For the present,
at any rate, I think it just as well that I should not be seen at
Mortmains too often."

"Ah, there I quite agree with you," Blake said. "Really, this is a most
amazing case. If you remain down here long enough I think you will have
a startling story for your paper. And now I am going to take you into
my confidence. Not altogether, perhaps, but to a certain extent. You
have heard all about the man with the black moustache and formed your
own conclusions."

"Yes." Margaret admitted. "But only vaguely. It seemed to me more than
possible that the man with the black moustache was responsible for
Richard Grimshaw's death. If I were a detective, I should want to find
out all about that man."

"And you would be perfectly right. Now, for the last few hours, I
have been devoting my time to making inquiries with regard to that
mysterious individual and I found him."

"Do you mean to say that he is actually here?"

"No, he isn't," Blake admitted. "If he were still here I should be
all the less inclined to regard him as the actual culprit. But he has
vanished. I have been at his lodgings and together with Inspector Gore,
searched certain belongings that he left behind him. He disappeared
very hurriedly after receiving a telegram, or, at any rate saying he
had received a telegram, and he told his landlady he was coming back in
a few days. I don't believe he is for the simple reason that he left
owing some five pounds for board and lodging. I shall be more than
surprised if he turns up again. Still, you never can tell. But I think
we have established the fact that he was very short of ready money and
this knowledge might help us presently."

"And is that all?" Margaret asked.

"Not quite," Blake said drily. "I found a letter. Perhaps you would
like to have a look at it."

Without further palaver, Blake produced the letter and placed it in
Margaret's hand. If he had expected to see her show any signs of
confusion or distress, he was greatly mistaken, for after she had
glanced at the contents of the brief note, she looked up into Blake's
face in blank astonishment.

"Why, this is Jack's writing," she cried.

"Precisely. I was practically sure of it, but I thought I would ask
you before I was definitely certain. Now, I found that letter in the
portmanteau of the man with the black moustache. I am not going to
ask you to explain how it got there because, of course, you couldn't,
but you might have seen it before; it might have been intended for
you, because, you see, it is a familiar, not to say affectionate note,
and could only have been written to a woman with whom Mortmain was on
intimate terms."

"Yes, I see that," Margaret smiled. "But, all the same, it was
certainly never written to me. Whom it was intended for and how it got
into the possession of the man you are talking about is a mystery, and
I don't think you could exactly call it a love letter. You see, ours
was rather a Bohemian lot, and we were in the habit of addressing one
another in such warm terms. Lots of men in literary circles would write
to me like that, and nobody would think anything about it. But, if you
like, I will show that letter to Jack and ask him whether----"

"Ah, that is precisely what I don't want you to do. I showed the letter
to you because I wanted to know whether it had ever been one of yours.
But, since you say it isn't, I shall be greatly obliged if you will
say nothing whatever about it. Of course, I shall show it to Mortmain
when I am ready to do so, but till then I am going to ask you to remain

"Just as you like," Margaret said a little loftily. "You can rely upon
me to say nothing."

They parted a little later on. Margaret to her walk and Blake through
the lodge gates into the grounds of Mortmains. He smiled a little
cynically to himself as he thought of what Margaret had had to say
on the subject of the letter. Nor did he altogether agree with the
implicit faith which she had shown in Mortmain. Was it not more than
possible that the latter had been carrying on a flirtation with
the girl to whom that letter had been originally addressed, behind
Margaret's back? Knowing something of the world, Blake came to the
conclusion that he was right.

Then, suddenly, moved by an idea that had come to him, he retraced his
steps and walked across the moor to the picturesque farmhouse where
Richard Grimshaw had been staying. Mrs. Whiddon was pleased to see him,
as, indeed, she was pleased to see anybody out of the great world with
whom she could gossip. Would the gentleman come into the house? Would
he like a cup of tea and some home-made bread and jam, with some of her
own special Devonshire cream? And most important of all, had he found
out anything as to the identity of her late lodger?

"Well, no I haven't," Blake confessed. "There has been no time, to
begin with. I suppose the man had friends somewhere; and perhaps in a
day or two someone will come forward with particulars. But, really,
you know as much about him as I do. You heard what was said about him
at the inquest by the unfortunate lady who had the misfortune to call
herself his wife."

"Aye, that I did," the old woman said hotly. "And a rare nice young
lady she be. Many a time has she had her tea under this roof. It looks
to me, sir, as if I was giving house-room to a pretty sort of a scamp.
He's dead now, and I ought not to say much, but if I had known, he'd
never have come here. But I daresay you know more about him than I do."

"Indeed, I don't," Blake insisted. "But I want to get to the bottom of
this business because, you see, in a way, my friend, Sir John Mortmain,
is implicated."

"Aye, there's something in that, sir. Not as I'd hear a word breathed
against the squire. He keeps hisself to hisself, but he's a rare nice
gentleman when you come know him. I only wish that I could lend a
hand--that I do."

"As a matter of fact, you can," Blake said persuasively. "Now, I
want you to give me your permission to go over your late lodger's
belongings. Show me everything he had and allow me to open his
suit-case and all that sort of thing."

The old lady hesitated but for a moment. She was doing wrong, perhaps,
but curiosity was too strong for her.

"Well, sir," she said. "You be a gentleman and a friend of the squire's
and I know you won't get me into trouble. There is nothing down in
the sitting room except a fishing rod in its case, but in the bedroom
overhead you'll find a portmanteau for the most part empty and some
clothes in the chest of drawers."

Blake waited for no further invitation. For the best part of half an
hour he made a close search without coming upon anything that rewarded
his trouble. It struck him as a little singular that he could find
nothing in the way of fishing tackle beyond a new line which had
evidently never been wetted and a book of flies, every one of which
was just as it had come from the hands of the maker. A pretty fine
fisherman this, evidently.

Still, so far, Blake was conscious of the fact that he had been wasting
his time. He turned out the portmanteau and, after that, the whole
chest of drawers.

And then, at last in one of the small drawers at the top, under a
heap of ties and collars, he found something which might prove of
importance. It was a steel key with a flat brass handle, not unlike the
key of a Yale lock. On the brass disc was a number--74321, and round it
the legend "Mark Lane Safe Deposit."

"Ah, this might be all right," Blake said to himself under his breath.
"I think I'll borrow it."


Much to the old lady's disappointment, Blake had nothing to tell her.
He had no intention of mentioning the matter of the key, because that
concerned himself only, and Mrs. Whiddon would have been none the wiser
if he had explained to her the meaning of that particular talisman and
what might be behind it. With a promise to come again at an early date,
he retraced his footsteps and made his way towards Mortmains by the
Castle Rock route.

It was the first time be had done so, indeed, the first time it had
occurred to him to survey the land adjacent to the tragedy and the
prospect interested him. Here was a pathway through the valley that
closed in at the top, so that carts and foot passengers had to skirt
the great rock that rose like a citadel to the left of Mortmains. The
whole road was not more than twenty feet wide and the rugged pathway
itself came within two or three feet of the edge of the Castle Rock,
which dropped for a sheer two hundred feet onto the soft sands below.
It was only at spring tides in March and October that the foot of the
Castle Rock was washed by the sea. And now, for the last eight or ten
weeks there was nothing down below, above high water mark, but dry sand
covered almost with fragile seaweed that had become parched by the sun
and wind. One step off the path into the darkness, and certain death
would be the result. In his mind's eye, Blake could picture Grimshaw
being deliberately pushed off the narrow shelf of rock and being dashed
to pieces on the sands below, because he knew that the sands at the
foot of the Castle Rock above high water mark were very thin in places
and barely served to conceal the scores of jagged flints that lay below
the surface.

Was it possible that Richard Grimshaw had met his death in
circumstances something like these? And yet that was absolutely
impossible. A man could not be hurled over the rock to his certain
destruction under cover of darkness, and, at the same time almost, be
found dead in the library at Mortmains.

Still Blake was a long way from being satisfied. The mystery was an
absolute tangle that seemed to defy the finest efforts at unravelment,
and yet Blake had a sort of conviction in his mind that the solution
was easy enough if he could only get his fingers on the right end of
the thread. He would not altogether abandon the idea that had occurred
to him, and with the intention of satisfying himself on this point, he
went down the slope, through the little gate at Mortmains, and thence
into the house.

He was not altogether displeased to find that Mortmain was not there.
He had gone into Instaple for the afternoon and had left a message for
his friend to the effect that he would not be back very much before
dinner-time. To all of which, Blake listened quietly enough, and then,
after he had had his tea and smoked a contemplative cigarette he went
out on the terrace, and from thence by a zig-zag path cut into the
rock on to the wide stretch of sand that formed the beach below. From
there he could walk round the buttress at the foot of the Castle Rock
into the tiny bay beyond where Mortmain pursued his early habit of
prawning. He knew this because it had come out in casual conversation.
The time was not quite right just now, and it was only this that had
prevented Blake from suggesting an early morning in the pools amongst
the outlying rocks where the finest prawns were to be found.

The tide was fairly low as Blake set out on his ramble over the sands
in the direction of the great rock. He noticed that for some fifty feet
or so from the base of the huge bastion downwards the sand was dry and
light as thistledown. It had been many weeks since the sea had washed
past a certain line, and the whole of the dry beach was littered with
seaweed, friable as tinder and tossed in heaps here and there above
the reach of the waves. As he walked along he kicked this feathery
weed on one side in a listless sort of way, and then, quite suddenly,
he pulled up and looked down at his feet. He bent to examine what he
had found, then crept cautiously for another yard or so, lifting the
tindery weed out of his way and depositing it on one side. At the end
of five minutes he reversed the process, and replaced the vegetation as
nearly as possible whence he had moved it. Then thrusting a stick in
the sand so as to mark the spot where he had been at work, he retraced
his footsteps and went back to the house in a very thoughtful frame of

A quarter of an hour later he was walking rapidly in the direction of
Watersmouth. He wanted to send a telephone message which would have
been more or less impossible at Mortmains, seeing that the instrument
was in the hall where he would be liable to interruptions at any
moment, and, what was much more important, to be overheard by Farthing
or one of the servants. So that there was no help for it but to go into
Watersmouth and send his message from the exchange there. And then
another thought occurred to him. Why not call upon Dr. Deacon, who was
more or less in his confidence, and send the message from there?

Deacon was pleased enough to see him and quite ready to place his
telephone at Blake's disposal.

"Have you found anything out?" Deacon asked. "You look so grave and
important that----"

"It's not as important as all that," Blake interrupted. "But I haven't
been altogether wasting my time. To begin with, I have been up at Mrs.
Whiddon's farm examining the belongings of the unfortunate Grimshaw."

"Well?" Deacon asked. "And then?"

"Well, I discovered, first of all, that Grimshaw did no fishing when
he was down here. He didn't even wet a line. I have all his brand new
tackle to prove that. So we can come to the conclusion that he didn't
come down here for the sake of the trout. But perhaps I had better tell
you how Gore and myself have been spending the best part of the day."

With that, Blake went into details which were followed by Deacon with
rapt attention. He heard all about the man with the black moustache and
the sudden way he had vanished and, finally, Blake produced the safe
deposit key.

"Now we shall know something about Grimshaw and his movements," he
said. "This is a key of his secret hiding place. And I was just going
to telephone to Scotland Yard and ask the people there to go as far as
Mark Lane and open the safe that corresponds to the number on this key."

"But without the key?" Deacon interrupted.

"Oh, my dear fellow, there will be no trouble about that. The safe
deposit people have duplicate keys for the whole series. And when
Scotland Yard wants a thing, then Scotland Yard usually gets it.
Besides, the Company know all about the tragedy down here by this time
and will be quite aware of the fact that Grimshaw is dead. I came to
you because I could not telephone from Mortmains and I was on my way to
do so from the village call office when it suddenly occurred to me that
I could do much better here."

"Oh, by all means," Deacon said. "You will find the telephone in the
hall. Oh, you need not be afraid. I have a sound proof box there
because I am often in contact with the Instaple hospital, and I have
a very strong objection to my servants listening to my professional
conversations. Go and put your call through and then you can come back
here and smoke a cigarette whilst you are getting in touch with the
other end."

It was not more than five and twenty minutes later when Blake got his
summons and then returned to the dining room where Deacon was awaiting

"So that's all right," he said. "My people will get down to Mark Lane
at once and write me full particulars of what they discover addressed
to Mortmains. Now I am going to ask you to help me in another matter.
I know you are an expert photographer and very clever at enlargements.
Now, if I brought you a minute object in some material, do you think
you could enlarge it to such an extent that it would be easily
recognised for what it is. I know I have put that clumsily."

"Yes, but I follow your idea. And if you bring the object you are
speaking of to me, I think I shall be able to oblige you. But I hope it
is a distinct impression."

"Ah, that, for the moment, I can't tell you," Blake said. "I am not
going to enlighten you any further just now, because there must be no
guess work about what I want."

Deacon nodded in agreement. He was not the man to ask unnecessary
questions, so that the conversation drifted into another channel
until Blake suddenly jumped up and proclaimed that he must be off and
that he wanted to get back to Mortmains before Sir John returned from
Instaple, if possible. By the time he had reached the big house, it was
nearing seven o'clock and as yet there was no sign of his host. He rang
the bell in the library and in the course of a minute or so Farthing

"Yes, sir," he asked. "You rang for me."

"Quite right, Farthing," Blake smiled. "There are one or two little
things I want you to get for me. In the first place a small biscuit tin
with a lid. You know the sort of thing I want. I think they are called
'half-tins' and are supplied by nearly every biscuit manufacturer."

"Yes, sir, very good sir," Farthing replied. It occurred to him as
rather a singular request, but then Farthing was a well-trained servant
and would have expressed astonishment if Blake had asked him to bring
an elephant.

"Of course, we have such things in the house. Do you want it now, sir?"

"If you don't mind," Blake said.

Farthing re-appeared in a moment or two with a biscuit tin which Blake
pronounced to be exactly what he required.

"Excellent, Farthing," he said. "Now, one more little thing. Do you
think you could find me a pound, yes, a pound, of wax candles? You know
the sort I mean."

The immovable Farthing was quite sure of it.

"Piano candles, sir," he said. "Will they do?"

"Nothing could be better," Blake said gravely.


Farthing betrayed not the slightest sign of curiosity, though he was
itching to know why Blake was requiring these mysterious appliances.
But, like the well-trained servant that he was, he merely set out to
obtain that which Blake required and came back presently with a packet
of piano candles.

"Here you are, sir," he said. "I am sorry to say there are no more in
the house. You see, nobody plays the piano now and since the late Sir
Robert had the electric light installed, we have never had occasion to
use candles. Is there anything else sir, that you would like me to get?"

"Just one more thing," Blake said. "A small bottle--medicine bottle for
choice--of that old pre-war whisky of yours. You can put that in my
bedroom, if you don't mind."

So far as Farthing was concerned, the proceedings ended there, leaving
him in a state of delightful bewilderment and the wild desire to know
what all this mystery meant. But he quite understood that he was
expected to keep these things to himself, so that the servants' hall
benefited nothing in connection with something which might have been
twisted into a first-class scandal.

Nor did Blake say anything about it to Mortmain when he got back and
they sat down to dinner. All Blake seemed to think about was a fishing
excursion. More than once Mortmain had suggested a day on the water,
but one thing and another had come in the way and, now, apparently,
Blake was getting impatient.

"Touching that fishing excursion," he suggested. "When are we going out
after those prawns?"

"Not for a day or two, now, I am afraid," Mortmain said. "You see, we
must wait for the tides? No use prawning on this coast unless the water
is right and then you have to start earlier in the morning than you
will probably like. But about Monday, I should think. I couldn't go
to-morrow, any way, because it is Quarter Sessions in Instaple and I
always make it a point of duty to attend that. Must do it, you know."

Blake carried the matter no further. On the whole, he was rather glad
to have Mortmains to himself the next day and to know that he was not
likely to be interrupted in the course of certain experiments which
he had in his mind. No sooner, had he seen Mortmain through the lodge
gates on the following morning than he gathered his belongings together
and set out for the beach.

He knew that he would be alone there, because the only way to the sands
under the Castle Rock and into the next bay was by the zig-zag path
leading from the house down to sea level. To all intents and purposes
it was a private beach which could not be reached by any wandering
tourists, except by a flagrant act of trespassing. Blake looked around
him and when once satisfied that he was absolutely alone and out of
sight of the house, he began to set to work.

In the first place, he gathered together a little pile of dry wood and
lighted a fire. On the top of this he placed the biscuit tin until it
was hot and then, breaking the candles into fragments and withdrawing
the wicks, placed them in the tin until they had resolved themselves
into a plastic mass. Into this mass he kneaded the small amount of
alcohol Farthing had procured for him, and then proceeded to scatter
the fire. He had now a fairly large sized ball of wax in a semi-liquid
state, and this he proceeded to pour gently over a square foot of sand,
which he had marked with a stick the afternoon before. He waited until
the wax had hardened into an almost solid mass and this he carefully
wrapped in a sheet of brown paper. Half an hour later he was on the way
to Watersmouth with the parcel under his arm.

He was fortunate enough to catch Deacon in his surgery, and proceeded
to lay the wax impression on the table.

"Now, can you give me an hour?" he asked.

"As it happens, I can," Deacon said. "I have been all round the village
this morning and my outlying patients can wait till the afternoon. What
have you got there?"

"Well, I don't quite know," Blake said. "But, so far as I can judge, it
is the cast of a footprint. I took it at the base of the Castle Rock.
It was under a mass of seaweed, which I turned over more or less by
accident. The sand all round there was perfectly dry, except where that
drift had protected it, where it has remained damp enough to take an
impression. The weed is very dry and, no doubt, had been blown about by
puffs of wind. At any rate, I found that impression which lay in a sort
of hollow as if some heavy weight falling had displaced a quantity of
it. Now, do you think you can take a photograph of this sheet of wax?
If you can, I want it enlarged."

"Oh, I can do that easily enough," Deacon said. "And the enlargement
is a merely mechanical matter. If you will stay here for a quarter of
an hour and amuse yourself with the morning paper, I will get a good
negative. On a brilliant morning like this it will be easy enough and
ten minutes should be sufficient to print. The enlargement won't take
much longer."

Deacon came back within half an hour with the print in his hand. It was
an excellent one, and Blake was loud in his praises as he turned it to
the light.

"Just as I expected," he said. "This is a photograph of a footprint,
and not an ordinary footprint, either. The shoe, you will notice, is
by no means a common one. Scarf's patent rubber studs and imperforated
leather. The sort of shoes that you couldn't buy under three guineas."

"Yes, I noticed that," Deacon agreed. "They are Scarf's patent, right
enough, and I don't know anybody in this neighbourhood who can afford
anything of the kind, unless it is our friend Sir John Mortmain. But
why all this mystery? Why shouldn't Mortmain wear that type of shoe?
And what is extraordinary in finding an impression of it on his own
private beach?"

"Well, on the face of it, nothing," Blake said, more or less casually.
"But you know what I am down here for, and I must not leave anything
whatever to chance. Besides, it may not be Mortmain's, after all.
If it isn't, then I should like to know who has been trespassing on
his private beach. Mind you, that shoe could not have belonged to
the average tripper, and no gentleman would have taken the liberty
of strolling into Mortmain's grounds and walking down to the beach
that way. He would have been certain to have been seen by one of the
gardeners or servants and promptly turned back. And, if so, I should
have heard of it."

"Yes, if it happened in the daylight," Deacon agreed.

"My dear chap, you have hit the right nail on the head. Whoever the
owner of that shoe may be, he was on beach at the foot of the Castle
Rock some time after dark. At this time of the year that would be very
late, but it would be no difficult matter to slip through the lodge
gates and down to the beach by the zig-zag path, though it is rather
dangerous unless you happen to know it well. Still, anyone who liked
to study the lie of the land from a boat, say somebody who came out
of Watersmouth fishing, might visualise it well enough to be able to
ignore any risks in that direction. What I have to do is to find out
the owner of that shoe and----"

"And what then?" Deacon asked.

"Well, upon my word, I hardly know," Blake said. "I have had some queer
cases in my time, but never one that puzzled me as much as this. Every
step I take seems to land me deeper in the mire, and whenever I seem
to see my way clear, down comes the blinding rain again, so to speak,
and fogs my point of view. You may ask me why I am worrying about
footprints on the sands when Grimshaw's body was found in the library
at Mortmain's, but I am not altogether satisfied with regard to the

"What's the idea?" Deacon asked.

"Well, there again you have me. I have a dozen theories, and directly I
put them to the test I have to abandon them again. The one clue we have
to the murder being is the body, and it is the body that puzzles me all
the time. However, I won't detain you any longer now; I will take that
photograph away with me because I have a feeling that it is going to be
useful. At any rate, one thing I am sure of--the footprint from which
it was taken is a comparatively recent one. No, don't trouble to let me
out. I can hear you have some patients waiting."

Blake strode away without further words, and walked down the crazy,
pavement into the roadway. There he met Mrs. Ridge, who was just
turning into the gate.

"Ah, good morning, Mrs. Ridge," he said. "You don't look as if you had
occasion to see the doctor."

"Well, I have and I haven't, sir," the old lady said, as she pulled up,
ready for a gossip, "It's them rheumatics. They comes and they goes,
and whenever they're very bad, doctor, he gives me something as puts
them right."

"Wonderful man, the doctor!" Blake laughed. "I suppose you haven't
heard anything more about your lodger?"

"Not a single word, sir, but I got another one which don't happen often
this time o' year. August and September I be full, but just now I'm
glad to see anybody. And this new gentleman, he comes from London."

"Oh, indeed," Blake said politely. "Anything like your late lodger?"

"No, indeed, sir. He's quite a quiet gentleman, clean-shaved, just the
same as you be, and wearing blue glasses. Kind of delicate-looking,
just like a man who's just got over a serious illness. And almost
afraid to give the least trouble. I let him have my other lodger's
rooms, because he said he was only staying for a day or two. Gave the
name of Barton, he did, and paid me a week's rent in advance. Not as I
asked for it, but you never know, sir, do you? So I took the money."

"Quite right, too," Blake agreed. "I hope this new visitor of yours
will be more satisfactory than the last."


Blake went on his way down the village street in a contemplative frame
of mind. He was puzzled and annoyed over this case and in a mood just
then to suspect everything and everybody. It occurred to him as strange
that this old lady had secured a second lodger almost before the first
was gone, and, that at a time of the year when such birds of passage
were rare in Watersmouth. Was it possible, he wondered, if there were
any sort of connection between these two men. It required no great
acumen to know that the man with the black moustache had turned his
back hurriedly on the village directly he heard the evidence which
Mrs. Whiddon had tendered at the inquest on Richard Grimshaw. He had
actually been present during the inquiry, because the old woman had
seen him enter the town hall just behind her. Five minutes later, he
had vanished, and, almost at once, had left the village and made his
way somewhere else by the first available train.

In other words, he had been frightened out of the place, and, much
against his will, had absconded. If this meant anything, it meant
that he had been forced to disappear long before he had finished his
sinister work in Watersmouth. That he would come back sooner or later
Blake felt certain.

But supposing he had sent an accomplice in his place? Somebody who was
not ear-marked and who could take up the threads of the conspiracy
without being recognised. And supposing this somebody had actually
taken the same rooms which the man with the black moustache had vacated
so hurriedly. It was a long shot, but then long shots sometimes prove
more effective than short ones and Blake was going to leave nothing to

As he passed the post office it occurred to him to call and see if
there were any letters awaiting him, because the mid-day post was in
and, in ordinary circumstances any correspondence for Mortmains would
not be delivered till the following morning. There were two or three
people standing in front of the counter and one of these was a slight,
pale individual, wearing a pair of blue glasses and who asked for
letters that might be waiting there for one Mr. James Barton.

Blake stepped back a pace or two. He was in no hurry and he wanted
rather to study the man standing by the counter. At the same moment,
another man appeared, a tourist, undoubtedly, in a knickerbocker suit,
who gave Blake an unmistakable sign, and then walked over to where the
telegraph forms were placed. A minute later, the man called Barton had
vanished, empty handed, and Blake was in the road close by the tourist.

"You gave me the sign," Blake said. "Who are you?"

"Rattrey, sir," he said. "Sergeant Rattrey of the Yard. You may not
know me, sir."

"I don't know you personally," Blake said. "But the name is quite
familiar. Still, what are you doing down here?"

"I was sent by the Deputy Commissioner, sir. Matter of fact, I was
following that man with the blue glasses. I don't know who he is or
what he is doing, but yesterday he was pointed out to me in the Strand
by one of our men. I was told not to lose sight of him. I ran him down
to a small hotel off the Grays Inn-road and reported. Then I was told
to change into these clothes and pick him up again early this morning
and follow him wherever he went. So I was behind him when he took his
ticket at Waterloo Station at six o'clock this morning, and I took a
ticket here as well. Of course, I knew you were down here, sir, and I
was told to keep a look out for you."

"And that is all you know?" Blake asked.

"Practically, sir. Of course, I have read all about the strange affair
at Mortmains, and I knew that you had that in hand. It seems to me,
sir, that I was sent down here to follow somebody who is connected with
the murder. But I shall know more about that when I get my written
instructions. I have taken lodgings in the village and wired my address
to the Yard. Very likely you will be told all about me in the course of
a post or so. But here I am, sir, and if you want me am quite at your
disposal. So long as I keep that man with blue glasses in sight. I have
nothing else to do for the moment."

"Then you have not the least notion as to the real identity of the man
who calls himself Barton?" Blake asked.

"No, sir," Rattrey replied. "I am simply obeying instructions and
waiting here till I hear from the Yard. I have told them I have run
Barton to earth and, so far as I can make out, he doesn't mean to move
from here for some little time. At any rate, he has settled down in his
lodgings and paid a week's rent in advance."

"Oh, you have found that out already, have you?" Blake smiled. "Upon my
word, that was very smart of you. I happen to know that much myself,
but I learnt the fact quite by accident. Now, you keep your eye upon
Barton, especially at night. I don't think he will be in the least
dangerous in the daytime, but, after darkness falls, he will be a
different proposition altogether. And don't speak to me again if you
can help it."

With that, Blake turned his back on the village and walked slowly and
thoughtfully back to Mortmains. He had nothing whatever to do and he
could not see his way to following up a single clue or even to work out
a logical theory. He could only possess his soul in patience and wait,
like another Mr. Micawber, for something to turn up. He was essentially
a man of action and the prospect of a long, idle afternoon, even in
that beautiful warm sunshine, was not particularly thrilling to him.
Nor was he the more gratified when he reached Mortmains to receive the
information that Sir John had telephoned from Instaple to the effect
that the sessions had been unusually protracted and that he would not
be back home till the following afternoon.

There was no help for it, therefore, but to make the best of it and
wait. So, after a lonely afternoon and evening, Blake was prepared to
go early to bed when Farthing entered the library with the information
that somebody from Watersmouth was in the hall and wanted to see him on
private business.

"Oh, ask him who he is," Blake said impatiently.

"He wouldn't give his name, sir," Farthing explained. "He said that he
wouldn't keep you long."

Blake intimated that the stranger might be brought into the library and
expressed no astonishment when his eyes dwelt upon the stolid features
of Sergeant Rattrey.

"Well, what's up now?" he asked when Farthing had departed.

"That is what I want to know, sir," Rattrey said. "I have been keeping
my eye upon the man who calls himself Barton and about half an hour ago
I tracked him along the road here with another individual that I never
saw before. Chap who looks like a poacher. I had to keep a good way
behind them because the road was pretty straight and I don't want the
men to know they were being followed. But by dodging in the bracken I
managed to keep them in sight and they parted outside the gates here.
One of them went on across the moor, but it was so dark that I couldn't
tell you which it was and the other turned into the gates here, and he
is somewhere about the grounds now."

"The devil he is," Blake cried. "Now, what on earth can he be doing
here? You wait a moment whilst I put a pair of shoes on and change my
coat, then, we will go and investigate the matter. No occasion to alarm
the servants, because the less they know about this matter the better."

They pushed out into the grounds presently and for some time prowled
about the various pathways and shrubberies to the side of the house.
Then something moved in the shadows and Blake immediately challenged.
There followed the sound of flying footsteps in the direction of the
lodge, but though Blake was by no means slow of foot, he was not fast
enough to overtake the man in front who vaulted the low, iron gates and
disappeared headlong in the bracken on the other side of the road.

"Well, we have lost him, at any rate," he said. "Now I wonder which of
the two he was. If he was the gentleman with the blue spectacles he was
fairly nippy for an invalid. You had better hang about here for an hour
or so, and if you catch sight of either of those two, come back to the
house and let me know. But I don't think you will have any luck. Here
what's that? Didn't you hear someone shouting?"

A distant call came from across the moor beyond the Castle Rock. Then
the sounds of hurried footsteps and a boy of some fifteen years of age

"Here, what's wrong with you?" Blake demanded.

"It's over at Mrs. Widdon's farm," the boy panted. "A burglar tried
to get in the house. And nobody there besides the old woman and me.
Woke me up, he did, trying to open the window of the dairy. You see,
I sleep's over there, and I heard him. Then I fetched the gun wot I
shoots the rabbits with and fired at him. That woke the old lady up, so
she sends me into Watersmouth for the police. Not as I think they'll be
wanted; I skeered him off all right. Run like a hare, he did."

"Evidently quite a brave boy," Blake said. "I don't think you will have
to trouble much about the police and in any case, it's too late to lay
hands on the burglar now. Anyway, my friend and myself will come as far
as Mrs. Widdon's and see if we can be of any use. I happen to know her."

They moved quickly across the moor, until they reached the farmhouse
where, in the doorway, the lady herself awaited them. She did not seem
in the least alarmed, but stood there with a lantern in her hand and
some object she had picked up.

"You be welcome, gentlemen," she said. "If my eyes don't deceive me,
that's Captain Blake."

"That's right," Blake said. "I hope you have not been frightened. But
what have you got in your hand?"

"I just picked this up," the old lady said. "I found it lying on the
ground by the dairy door."

It was a pair of blue spectacles.


When Blake turned his back upon the moorland farm house half a hour
later he had that pair of blue spectacles in his pocket. He had taken
them up casually enough, with the suggestion that they might be of some
use to the police, and Mrs. Whiddon had made no objection. She was not,
of course, aware that she had parted with what might prove to be a
valuable clue.

"Well, good night," Blake said. "I don't think you need worry more."

"Oh, I ain't worrying," the old lady said stoutly. "I ain't afraid of
no burglars, though what they come looking after in a place like this
fair beats me."

"Now, look here, Rattrey," Blake said as he and the detective crossed
the moor together. "You go back into Watersmouth and keep your eye on
that cottage of Mrs. Ridge's. I think we can be pretty well sure that
the gentleman with the spectacles was her lodger. You might try and
find out what time he left the house this evening and, what is still
more important, what time he gets back. Probably he is on his way now.
How I make it out is this. Those two men set out from Watersmouth
this evening on some shady errand and they parted by the lodge gates
at Mortmains. I suggest that they knew they were being followed, and
they parted to blind you. The man that we disturbed inside the lodge
gates went there for no other purpose than to draw you off, whilst the
other chap went as far as the old lady's farm. I feel quite convinced
of that. However, we can't do any more now, but I will try and see you
in the morning. You had better come half way to Mortmains along the
valley and I will meet you there. If there is nobody about we can talk.
Anyway, if there are people in the neighborhood, you hang back till the
coast is clear."

When the two representatives of Scotland Yard met the next morning,
Rattrey had very little to say. He had managed to find out one or two
things, but nothing of real importance.

"It's like this, sir," he explained. "The man who calls himself Barton
went out last night at about nine o'clock, saying that he was going for
a stroll along the cliffs. Mrs. Ridge doesn't know what time he came
in, but she knows that he hadn't returned at eleven o'clock when she
went to bed. I am sorry I have nothing better for you, sir."

"Oh, well, that is something, at any rate," Blake smiled. "Keep your
eyes open, and if you want to give me a message you can easily send me
a letter."

So it was that a day or two passed without anything fresh coming to
light and, sooth to say, Blake was getting very impatient. Up to
a certain point, he could see his way clear enough, and then some
obstacle arose, like a great rock in his path, so that, perforce, he
had to find some way round it. And, beyond the problem that worried him
day and night, there was another thing that troubled him exceedingly.
Mortmain seemed to have changed altogether. He was moody and
absent-minded now, and, now and again, almost sullen. And yet in the
face of recent happenings, he ought to have been happy enough. Still he
kept himself very much to himself and Blake hardly saw him, except at
meal times and then without a smile upon his face until one afternoon
Farthing came into the library with an intimation that Miss Debenham
was waiting to see him in the drawing-room.

Mortmain rose with alacrity, leaving Blake to his own resources. He
found her in the big drawing-room, and she greeted him with the ghost
of a smile trembling on her lips.

"This is quite an unexpected honor," Mortmain said with a certain
coldness in his manner. "To what am I----"

"Oh, please, don't talk like that," Margaret said. "You know perfectly
well why I haven't been here. I should not have come to-day, only, my
work compels a visit. My editor asked me if I could get him certain
photographs of the house, so I came with my camera, hoping you would
not mind."

"Oh, I don't in the least mind," Mortmain said. "But what I cannot
understand is all the morbid curiosity. Why should people who have
nothing whatever to do with me want to see photographs of this place in
their favorite newspaper? Still, you have not answered my question."

"But I can't," Margaret pleaded. "How can I? How can I come here just
as if I were a casual friend of yours after all that has happened? Of
course, the people in the village are very kind and they regard me as
an unfortunate woman who has been the victim of a scoundrel. But you
know what these little country places are like. Until the mystery of
Richard Grimshaw's death is cleared up, the less we see of one another
the better."

"Yes, but suppose it never is cleared up?" Mortmain protested. "And
suppose it isn't a mystery, after all? Supposing that man came here by
an unhappy coincidence and tried to rob the library of the man he had
so cruelly injured. Nobody believes that Grimshaw's death was anything
but the result of an accident."

"But they do," Margaret cried. "There are lots of people in the village
who think he was murdered. And more than one gossip hints that you had
a hand in it."

Mortmain made no reply for a minute. He stood there, a little white of
face and a pained expression on his features as if someone had struck
him a sudden blow.

"I have anything to do with it?" he exclaimed. "What will people say
next? Oh, don't listen to such horrible scandal. I firmly believe that
the mystery never will be cleared up. And if I am right, what is to
become of us, Margaret?"

"I don't know," Margaret said, almost in tears. "A little time ago I
thought that everything was cleared up and that, after a time, I could
mend my broken happiness. But not just yet, Jack, not yet. Remember
that my story and the history of my unhappy life with Richard Grimshaw
is known to all England. I told that story freely and openly, and I
am not ashamed of it. It was the right thing to do, and I should not
hesitate to repeat it. But I knew what it meant. I knew that slanderous
tongues would attack my character if I did not go back to work as if
nothing had happened, and never see you again. Think of my unhappy
position, think a little less of yourself."

It was a stinging reproof, and Mortmain felt it none the less because
the words were so sadly uttered.

"That is all very well, up to a certain point," he said. "But surely
the thing cannot end here?"

"I am afraid it must, unless the law can put its hands on the man who
murdered Richard Grimshaw. Jack, you don't want a wife who can be
pointed at in the village street as one who connived with the murderer
of her first husband so that she could go to her second. And a poor
woman at that. A girl who was only too glad to become the mistress of a
house like Mortmains. You don't want to sell this place and go away, do

"Sell Mortmains?" the man exclaimed. "Good gracious, whatever could put
such an idea in your mind?"

"Ah, I see how you feel it," Margaret said sadly. "And that is why I
felt myself forced to raise the question."

"My dear girl, it would be absolutely cowardly."

"Of course it would," Margaret replied. "Cowardly and, perhaps in the
end, absolutely unnecessary. But in the face of what the whole country
knows, I can never consent to come here as mistress of Mortmains as
long as things remain as they are. And I am quite sure that everybody
will agree with me."

Mortmain seemed to be struggling with what Margaret hoped might be
his better feelings. For there was much in what she said. He had been
living long enough in that remote corner of Devonshire to know what
local gossip meant. And, besides, with his keen imagination he could
see far into the future. A time would come when, in the ordinary course
of nature, he would be the father of a family. The mere suggestion of
any scandal hanging over the heads of his innocent children stirred him
strangely and moved him to his deepest depths.

And yet he could not let Margaret go. She was as near and dear to him
now as ever she had been and, up to a day or two ago, it seemed as
if a kindly providence had directly intervened to bring him back the
happiness that he had lost.

Perhaps Margaret could see something of what was passing in his mind,
for she came to his side and laid her hand more or less tenderly on his

"I think you know that I am right, Jack," she said. "And I feel very
deeply for you and none the less because it was I, and I alone, who
brought all the trouble about. I ought to have known you better. I
ought to have flung that letter back into the face of the man who gave
it to me and denounced it as a forgery. Instead of that--well, we need
not go into it. I took my happiness in both hands and deliberately tore
it in two. And I am afraid that that is the end of it."

"Never," Mortmain cried. "I will not rest until I have got to the
bottom of this tragic business. You know how anxious I am to do so. You
know that it was I who contrived to get Blake down here and, at the
present moment, he is doing his best. Precisely what schemes he has
in hand I don't know, because he tacitly refused to take me into his
confidence, but I feel sure that he is not wasting his time. He is not
the sort of man to idle about in the country unless he can see his way
pretty clearly to some definite conclusion. And, meanwhile----"

"Meanwhile, I am afraid things must continue as they are," Margaret
said firmly. "I hate to speak like this, but I can see no other way.
It may be only for a time and, on the other hand, it may be for years.
But, sooner or later, the truth may be known, and then you will see
that I am right."

Mortmain turned away dejectedly.

"I am afraid that I can see that already," he said. "Margaret, you are
a better woman than I am a man."


It was an hour or two later when Blake walked into Watersmouth with
Margaret as his companion. She had taken her photographs and had
her tea, during which the subject of her recent conversation with
Mortmain had cropped up. And Blake had been entirely on Margaret's side
throughout. He had spoken quite plainly on the subject, so that there
had been almost a quarrel between the two men, which had been more or
less patched up, owing to Margaret's presence. It was she who threw oil
on the troubled waters and brought the others back to the normal again.

Still, Blake was feeling a little heated and only too pleased to
invent some reason for leaving the house for a little time. He had
no particular business in Watersmouth, but there was no reason why
Margaret should be told that. Therefore, he strode along by her side
and dropped her just as they came to the house where Dr. Deacon lived.
Blake held out his hand.

"I am going in here," he said. "One word, if I may be allowed the
liberty. You were perfectly right in the view you took this afternoon
and I can see that you are going to abide by it. But don't lose heart
and don't despair. I can promise you that the mystery is going to be
cleared up."

"Then you think that my husband was----"

"Murdered. Yes, I certainly do. And what is more, I have a hazy idea
of how it was done. Why it was done is another matter. It is this
'why' that is puzzling me. Very frequently, in my way of business, the
'how' is subordinate to the 'why.' In other words they react upon one
another. And as a rule, when you get the 'why,' the 'how' follows, as a
matter of course. I don't mind telling you that this is one of the most
amazing cases I have ever handled. Now, go along, Margaret, and don't
worry too much, because it isn't necessary."

With that, Blake turned into the doctor's gate and asked to see him.
As he stepped into the hall, a man came out of the consulting room
and passed him. It was a man of medium height, with rather sharp
features and a slight droop in the right shoulder that immediately
attracted Blake's attention. He had a vague idea that he had seen
this man somewhere before though he could not think where and in what
circumstances. He was still puzzling over the matter when Deacon
greeted him breezily.

"Hello," he said. "What's up now? Have you come to consult the oracle,
or merely to beg a cigarette."

"Well, as a matter of fact, I came because I had nothing else to do,"
Blake explained. "I walked in with Mrs. Grimshaw, rather glad to turn
my back upon Mortmain, who seemed to be suffering from a bad attack
of liver. But, be that as it may, his company latterly is well nigh
unbearable. But never mind Mortmain for the moment. Who is that man who
just went out?"

"A patient," Deacon said a little shortly.

"My dear chap, I know all about that. I am not asking you to give any
professional secrets away, but I have a strong impression that I have
met that chap before in very different circumstances. Now, come, can't
you stretch a point when a Scotland Yard man asks you what he believes,
to be a pertinent question?"

"Oh, well, perhaps, in that case," Deacon agreed. "As a matter of fact,
I never saw the man before. His name is Barton and he is staying at
Mrs. Ridge's cottage."

"Oh, the deuce he is. So that is the man, is it? Would you mind telling
we what is wrong with him?"

"Not very much," Deacon explained. "He has had a bit of an accident and
came to me to put him right."

"I wonder if I can guess what the trouble is," Blake smiled. "Was the
accident in connection with a shot gun?"

"Well, that's true," the puzzled Deacon replied. "He was wandering
about over the moor yesterday afternoon when somebody nearby fired
a shot, presumedly at a rabbit. My patient could not see who the
sportsman was, and he doesn't know now. But he got a few pellets in his
body and he came to me just now to extract them, which I did. Nothing
serious, of course, but very uncomfortable. I can't think why he didn't
come to me yesterday, though he did say that he felt no particular
inconvenience till after he had gone to bed."

Blake made some casual comment and allowed the subject to drop. All
the same, he felt that he had not been wasting his time. He knew, now,
beyond the shadow of a doubt, that the man called Barton was the owner
of the blue spectacles, and also the man who, for some mysterious
reason, had come from a long way off into these remote parts for the
express purpose of burgling a small farmhouse on a lonely Devonshire
moor. Blake thought it all over as he walked back to Mortmains, still
puzzled and annoyed with himself because he could not remember in
what circumstances he had met the man called Barton before. Where
had he seen that peculiar droop of the right shoulder? He knew that
he had done so somewhere, under rather dramatic conditions, though
the man's face conveyed nothing to him. But then, Blake was familiar
enough with the various ingenious manners in which the human features
can be disguised, almost beyond recognition. A pad in the mouth, the
drawing up of an eyebrow, the twist of a lip, and the thing was done.
It was more than possible that Rattrey might be able to help him in
this direction. Anyhow, it was possible to discover where those blue
spectacles had come from. He would send them up to London and get some
official from Scotland Yard to make inquiries.

It was characteristic of the man that he had put these details entirely
out of his mind, and was working along another track by the time he had
dressed for dinner. Moreover, he was pleased to find Mortmain in a much
more amiable frame of mind.

"I want to apologise to you, old chap," the latter said. "I know I
behaved very badly this afternoon, and now that I have come to think
matters over quietly, I see that I was altogether wrong. But you must
make allowances. I have been terribly worried lately, and when Margaret
spoke to me as she did this afternoon, I must have gone off the deep
end altogether. And that is not everything. When I asked you to come
down here I had a plot for a new story practically worked out in my
mind. All I needed for my melodrama was to see one of the big men from
Scotland Yard actively at work and study his methods. I didn't want
any trite commonplace sort of stuff one reads in the average detective
story. I was looking forward to seeing you and learning something of
your artifices, never dreaming for a moment that I was going to become
the centre of a vivid romance myself. For the time being, at any rate,
I shall have to abandon my plot altogether."

"Are you quite sure of that?" Blake asked quietly. "Are you quite sure
that you can't help me, just as much as I can help you? Oh, I know I am
firing a shot at random."

"Evidently a blank, cartridge," Mortmain laughed a little unsteadily.
"My dear chap, you must find your own salvation. And now, after that
apology of mine, let's drop the subject for a bit. You were very
anxious to do a morning's prawning, and if we started very early the
tide will serve us to-morrow."

"Nothing I should like better," Blake responded. "But don't you want
all sort of traps? Nets and all that kind of thing. And I suppose I
could not go in an ordinary suit of clothes."

"That you could not," Mortmain smiled. "You want a sort of bag net with
a long handle that you can shove under the crannies of the rocks at low
tide, and a fisherman's basket to carry your prey in as you catch them.
There is very little skill about it. You will require a pair of flannel
shorts and a fisherman's jersey, and, last, but not least, a pair of
shoes. Shoes with india-rubber soles would be the best, because they
give you a firm footing. But you can leave all that to me. I can fit
you with a kit. I will ask Farthing to look you out one and put it in
your room to-night. I don't disturb the household in the morning when
I am going fishing, so, to save that, I set my alarm clock at an early
hour, which wakes me when I am required. Then I will come along to your
room and pull you out of bed."

It seemed to Blake that he had only been asleep a few minutes when he
felt a hand shaking him by the shoulder, and he opened his eyes in the
still, dim light to see Mortmain standing over him.

"Come along," the latter said. "Get into your things. It's half-past
four--that is half-past three by Greenwich time, so that it will be
light enough to see by the time we get down to the Castle Rock. Come

The morning was beginning to brighten as they reached the sands and
made their way round into the next bay under the shadow of the Castle
Rock. They skirted it fairly closely, because, as Mortmain explained,
there were jagged flints just under the sand there, and they were apt
to prove painful to thinly shod feet. Then they emerged onto the wide
stretch of sand left by the receding tide and, for the best part of
three hours, were engaged in probing the tiny pools on the edge of
the surf, until that time had passed away and the whole landscape was
flooded with the sunshine of a perfect morning. When they got back to
the house again the servants were about and Farthing had provided a
preliminary breakfast in the dining-room.

"Now, just a mouthful or two," Mortmain suggested. "And then a warm
bath, and after that, what you like. You go on first and get off those
moist, sandy rags."

Blake accordingly went up to the bath-room, after which he repaired
to bedroom, where he dressed himself slowly, wondering what he was to
do with himself for the next hour or two. Then, as a sudden thought
occurred to him, he picked up the right shoe of the pair with which
Mortmain had provided him and examined it closely in the strong light.
After that, from a drawer in his wardrobe, he produced the photograph
that Deacon had taken from the wax cast which he had made some days

"Identical," he whispered softly. "Identical."


Blake placed the shoe back with its fellow and laid the pair together
with the kit that Mortmain had lent him. For the present, he was
content to leave things as they were, though he would know how to make
use of the piece of information he had just discovered when the right
time came. He dressed himself thoughtfully and, when he had finished,
went down to breakfast in a rather cheerful frame of mind. He found
Mortmain awaiting him with the old frown back on his forehead and the
brooding look in his eyes.

"Well, here I am," he said buoyantly. "And ready for the best breakfast
that your cook can turn out. What's the matter? Have you had some bad

"Nothing worse than usual," Mortmain replied. "Oh, yes, the post is in
but there is nothing for me, and there was nothing for you, either,
if it comes to that. What are you going to do with yourself to-day? I
suppose you wouldn't care to come over with me and have a day's golf at
Westward Ho?"

"My dear chap," Blake said smilingly. "There is nothing I should like
better. But you seem to forget that I am down here on business. If my
time was my own----"

"Well, isn't it?" Mortmain retorted with something of a sneer. "You
have been down here for well over a week now and, so far as I can
gather, you might have stayed away altogether."

"Isn't that a bit inhospitable?"' Blake asked.

Mortmain became all penitence at once.

"Upon my word, I beg your pardon," he said. "I hope you don't think I
meant anything by that remark. I mean anything calculated to make you
believe you are not welcome. I am afraid that this rotten business has
got on my nerves. I hoped when you came down here that you would be
able to do something."

"Well, how do you know I haven't? I might be able to put my hand
upon the culprit, or culprits, at any moment for all you know to the
contrary. But I do my work my own way. If I told you certain things
now, it would be as if you were reading an exciting novel with the last
hundred pages torn out. Of course, it must be very disappointing to
you with that analytical mind of yours not to be able to see the busy
brain of the master detective at work. But you can rest assured that it
will come all right in the end. Suppose I told you now exactly how that
mystery came about. What then?"

Mortmain looked up with genuine alarm. He opened his mouth as if about
to speak, then began to pace up and down the room with all the symptoms
of a conscience at work.

"Do you really mean that?" he stammered.

"Well, more or less. My dear fellow, you will have to wait, like
everybody else. And the lady will have to wait, too. Mind you, she is
quite right in the attitude she taken up. Don't forget that you can
burn a house down a great deal quicker than you can build it up again."

With which cryptic remark Blake turned to his breakfast and refused
to say any more. He had hardly finished and got through his first
cigarette when old Farthing came sedately into the room and told him he
was wanted at the telephone.

"Gentleman don't give his name, sir," he said sedately. "He said you
wouldn't know him, in any case."

"Is he waiting now?" Blake asked.

Farthing was understood to say that the stranger was still at the end
of the wire, so that Blake went out into the hall and took the receiver
off the hook.

"Are you there?" he called.

"Double X," came the voice out of nowhere.

"Double Z," Blake whispered. "Where are you?"

"In the telephone box at Watersmouth post office. Rattrey speaking,
sir. Of course you know that. Can I talk quite freely to you or are
listeners about?"

"Yes," Blake replied. "I can listen to all you have to say, and you can
speak freely, but----"

"I quite understand, sir. You can't say anything without being
overheard and I can speak openly, because I am in a sound proof box.
Things have been happening, sir."

"That is good news," Blake said cheerily. "Go on."

"Well, it's like this, sir. I have been going about with my eyes wide
open, and I have picked up quite a few useful pieces of information. To
begin with, Mrs. Whiddon is going away to-day and won't be back before
Saturday. She spends a couple of nights with a sister of hers just this
side of Torrington. A sort of annual affair, if you know what I mean,
sir, a birthday, I believe. So she shuts up the farmhouse and leaves it
to look after itself. Of course, everybody in Watersmouth knows this,
in fact, I have heard it from a dozen people. So it occurred to me that
perhaps our friend with the blue spectacles might make another attempt
to-night to get into the house."

"I think it is exceedingly probable," Blake said. "Most interesting.
Any, more?"

"Well, not much at the moment, sir. But if you will met me in an hour's
time in Watersmouth----"

"I can't very well do that," Blake said.

"Oh, I quite see what you mean, sir. Not openly. But if you will come
into the village and call at Yeo's shop you will see a bit of comedy
there that may interest you. You know the shop I mean, sir, it's the
one with all those beautiful old curios and china in the window. Known
all over the world, that shop is. If you drop in there at about eleven,

"You may take that for granted," Blake said. "And now, if you have
nothing more to say----"

"Just a second or two, sir," the voice at the other end of the wire
pleaded. "It wouldn't be safe for me to speak to you or for you to
speak to me in Yeo's shop, seeing that we are supposed to be strangers
to each other, so I should like to arrange a place where we can meet
half an hour afterwards. You had better return to Mortmains and hang
about the gorse near the Witch's Cave in the Valley of Rocks and I will
join you there."

Blake replaced the receiver on the hook and presently strolled
apparently aimlessly out of the house and along the road through the
valley into Watersmouth. He paused, at length, before the famous old
curio shop and turned in through the doorway just as the clock in the
church tower struck eleven. He was a bit of a collector in a small
way, and he had intended more than once to call upon John Yeo with a
view to doing a deal in connection with a small piece of square-marked
Worcester china which he had noticed in the window on more than one
occasion. There was one man in the shop when he entered, and he smiled
as he recognised the square shoulders of his man, Rattrey.

Rattrey was bending over the counter examining what appeared to be a
number of blue spectacles lying there.

"I am afraid those are all we have, sir," old John Yeo was saying. "I
only keep a few for the benefit of visitors who complain of the glare
off the sea sometimes. No, sir, I am afraid I haven't got a single pair
with wide lens."

"But you used to keep them," Rattrey suggested. "I saw a man yesterday
wearing a pair very like these."

"Oh, yes, sir, quite right," the shopkeeper said. "I did sell the last
pair I had yesterday morning. I am very sorry I cannot give you what
you want, but if you can wait a day or two I am quite certain that I
can get them.

"Very well," Rattrey said. "I will call in again."

With that he lounged out of the shop, leaving Blake to follow him as
best he might. The latter's business was soon finished, and with the
small piece of china in his pocket, Blake followed his subordinate
cautiously, at a distance, until they were able to meet and speak
without interruption.

"Well?" Blake said. "Well?"

"That was all right, sir, wasn't it?" Rattrey asked. "You see, the man
we are after had lost his blue spectacles and was bound to get another
pair. And now you know where he got the other pair from. I wanted you
to hear the shopkeeper say what he did say, because that proves to you
that our man got his second pair of glasses at Yeo's. That is why I
asked you to meet me in the shop at eleven o'clock."

"Very neatly done," Blake said approvingly. "I suppose the man we are
after has no suspicions--I mean, he is not tracking you as well as you
tracking him? I suppose that there is no chance of his having followed

"Not in the least, sir," Rattrey explained. "As a matter of fact, the
man who calls himself Barton has gone to Instaple. I saw him off from
the station myself. But he is coming back this evening, and I have a
feeling that late to-night he will pay another visit to the old farm on
the moor."

"I think we can take that for granted," Blake said. "When Barton comes
back this evening you keep an eye upon him and follow him along the
road if he shows any signs of another raid on the old lady's house.
I will be waiting for you just at the other side of the lodge gates,
and we can follow him up together. There is something hidden in the
farmhouse which Barton is more than anxious to get hold of. Moreover,
he knows pretty well where it is. What I suspect is that there are
papers or documents belonging to the late lamented Richard Grimshaw
which, when recovered from their hiding-place, will represent money to
that man Barton. But, of course, his name isn't Barton, and I can't for
the life of me recollect who he is. I know I have seen him before in
very different circumstances. That peculiar droop of his right shoulder
ought to tell me something--but it doesn't. However, if we can catch
him red-handed and strip him of that very clever disguise of his,
we may be able to kill more than one bird with the same stone. Now,
you get back to Watersmouth and I will return to Mortmains. I have a
feeling that this is going to be a really critical evening, because I,
too, have made a most remarkable discovery."


It was close on eleven the same evening when Blake crept out of his
bedroom and went very very cautiously down the broad oak staircase
in his stockinged feet, carrying a pair of stout shoes in his hand.
It had pleased him well enough when Mortmain had suggested a rather
early retirement, and Blake knew perfectly well that the household
staff had gone to bed some time since. There was no particular reason
why he should not have told Mortmain that he was bent on a nocturnal
expedition, but on the whole he thought it just as well for the time
being, to keep his movements to himself. He would have a good deal to
say before many hours had elapsed, but, meanwhile, silence was his best

He was dressed in a suit of shabby flannels, as he had changed into
these directly he had reached his bedroom. It was more than possible
that he would meet with some rough and tumble work and perhaps a
cross-country chase, so that he did not want to be overburdened with
clothes more than necessary. He donned his shoes and let himself out of
the house by a side door, without making the slightest noise. He crept
noiselessly past the lodge, vaulting the gates there and, when once he
was in the open, there was no more cause to fear anything in the way of
an unpleasant interruption.

And there he stood waiting in the warm, fragrant night, watching
intently for anything that might pass. It was not a dark night, by any
means, though there was no moon, but at that time of year it is easy
enough to distinguish large objects at a distance, and Blake had no
fear that his man would pass him in the gloom. For three-quarters of an
hour he stood there, and then, from the direction of the valley, came
the sound of soft footsteps, so soft, indeed, that Blake would hardly
have heard them but for the crackle of little dry sticks on the road.
And then a figure loomed in sight.

There was no doubt whose figure it was, for Blake could make out the
peculiar droop of the right shoulder and even notice that the eyes were
hidden behind dark glasses. Then, as the figure passed him and the thud
of those rubber shod feet died in the distance, another shadow loomed
up and Rattrey, appeared.

"Did you see him, sir?" the latter asked.

"Oh, I saw him right enough," Blake replied. "And it is our man, beyond
the shadow of a doubt."

"Yes, it's Barton," Rattrey murmured. "I have been hanging about Mrs.
Ridge's cottage for the last hour and a half. Indeed, I was on the
point of giving him up when I saw him come sneaking out, and as soon as
he turned in the direction of the valley, I knew where he was going.
Shall we follow, sir?"

"Why, of course. Anyway, there is no great hurry. We need not keep him
in sight, even. It will take him a good ten minutes to get into the
house, so we can hang behind a bit and talk. Then my idea is to get
into the house ourselves and actually watch the man at work. With any
luck, we'll take him red-handed."

"That would have been my idea, sir," Rattrey said. "Do you think, sir,
that he can tell us anything about Grimshaw's death? I mean, did he
have any hand in it?"

"Well, upon my word, I can't tell you yet," Blake confessed. "If you
look at the case from one angle, everything points to that conclusion.
I worked out the whole problem on certain lines and I couldn't see
but what the man, Barton, must have been responsible for the death of
Richard Grimshaw. And yet, in the face of certain discoveries I have
made recently, I am almost forced to the conclusion that there is a
much more sensational climax than that. I hope to goodness I am wrong,
but there are times when I wish to heaven I had never been brought into
this case. Still, I may be entirely mistaken. Now, going aside for a
moment, who do you suppose this Barton is?"

"I don't think it is for me to say, sir," Rattrey replied.

"Well, perhaps not. But there is one thing pretty obvious. The man
Smith had to disappear. It was not safe for him to stay in Watersmouth
a minute after Mrs. Whiddon's evidence at the inquest. So he just
vanished, leaving Mrs. Ridge in debt and saying he was returning. Of
course, he was returning, because it is imperative, for some reason or
other, that he should get hold of certain property which Grimshaw had
in his possession. So, being a master of disguise, he changes himself
out of all recognition and comes down here in the form of the guileless
Barton with the blue spectacles and innocent manner. You may depend
upon it, that this Barton is an exceedingly dangerous criminal and
when we arrest him to-night, which we shall do with any luck, we shall
probably lay by the heels a man who is badly wanted by the authorities
for something else."

"Upon my word, sir, I believe you are right," Rattrey said. "Only I
must say it never occurred to me that Mrs. Ridge's two lodgers are one
and the same man. Mind you, I thought they were confederates, but my
idea was that Barton came down here to finish something the other man
was unable to complete. But the more I think of what you say, the more
sure I am that you are right."

They lapsed into silence presently as they drew nearer to the farmhouse
that loomed up, black against a pallid sky. Not a sound did they make
as they drew nearer and nearer until it was possible for them to hear
the man they were searching for at work. As Blake had anticipated, the
burglar had not attempted to break into the house by means of the stout
oaken front door. The easiest means would be the more or less fragile
dairy window and there the man called Barton could be seen forcing the

It was evidently not a long or a serious job, for the shadowy form
vanished into the house and, standing close by the means of entrance,
Blake could see the glimmer of a light. With his hand on Rattrey's arm,
he followed and the detective crept silently behind him into a dim
passage which was faintly lighted by the lantern of the man in front.

It was quite plain that the man Barton was under the impression that he
had nothing to fear. He knew perfectly well that the house was empty
and that there was little likelihood of it being watched. Moreover, he
probably knew to a yard where the Watersmouth policeman was at that
moment, and therefore he could proceed on his business with an entirely
easy mind.

He crept into the kitchen and from thence into the sitting room where
Grimshaw had had his quarters in the days before the murder. He placed
the lantern on the high mantelshelf, so that the room was fairly well
lighted. In the shadow of the doorway, Blake and Rattrey watched him.

It was a thorough search that the man made. There was not a drawer or
a cupboard in the room that he didn't turn inside out, muttering and
cursing to himself all the time. Then he threw the carpet back and
heaped it in the middle of the room so that the uneven, creaking boards
beneath were exposed to view. Then he proceeded to tap every one of
them with his knuckles until at length he chuckled as one of them gave
out a hollow sound.

"Ah, here it is," he told himself. "This short piece. Evidently a
hiding place in the old days when the Doones and such like used to raid
the farms. Come up."

He bent down and contrived to raise a short piece of floorboard from
the skirting, disclosing a cavity below. Plunging his arm into the
recess, he brought to sight what appeared to be a bundle of letters
tied with a piece of string.

"Got 'em," he almost shouted. "Got 'em. I knew they were here
somewhere, and, if that fool had only----"

The speaker broke off abruptly at a sudden sound behind him. Rattrey
had moved forward a little too eagerly and a loose bit of flooring
under his foot seemed to go off with a crack like the sound of a pistol
shot. Instantly, Barton swung round and, at the same time, something
glistened in his hand. He did not wait or challenge, but fired a bullet
that struck within an inch of Blake's ear. He jumped back and closed
the door.

"Now, what's the next move?" Blake said.

"You parley with him," Rattrey whispered. "I will go round to the
window and see if I can get in that way. It's pretty sure to be
unfastened. They never properly shut in these old houses. Then you give
him a call, sir."

Blake waited for the best part of five minutes before he ventured to
raise his voice, in challenge.

"You had better drop that pistol and come out," he said. "You haven't
got a dog's chance. The house is surrounded, and we can afford to wait
till you come. Now, what about it?"

Almost to Blake's astonishment the bluff came off.

"All right," the man inside said. "I know when I am done. If you will
open that door----"

"No, I would much prefer that you opened the door," Blake replied.
"Open it and throw that weapon down at my feet. You can't open it too
far, because my foot is against it."

The door slid back and the automatic dropped with a dull thud a yard
away. Then there was a sudden rush, and, an instant later, Blake had
his hands full. He was still struggling desperately for the mastery
when Rattrey came to the rescue, and, between the two of them they had
Barton pinned to the floor.

"Well, you've made a bit of a mess of him, sir," Rattrey panted.

The man Barton lay there, minus his wig and one eyebrow. As he was
allowed to struggle to his feet, Rattrey looked at him almost dazed,
and then broke into a sudden cry.

"Cleghorn," he cried. "Cleghorn for a million. The man wanted for the
Wedbridge murder, sir."

"By George," Blake said almost unctuously. "You're right."


Truly the discomfited burglar presented a sorry sight as he stood there
panting in the light of the lantern that Rattrey had fetched from the
sitting-room. There was not an atom of fight in him after the first
wild dash and it seemed as if he had resigned himself to circumstances.
But at the first sound of the name that Rattrey had given him, he
looked up like a hunted animal and the shadow of a great fear crept
into his eyes. Rattrey went up to his prisoner and proceeded to do
certain things.

He literally peeled the unfortunate man's face, removing certain
substances that looked like wax, much in the same way as one peels a
banana. After that, he forced his fingers into the captive's mouth
and removed thence other objects. When he had finished, the man now
addressed as Cleghorn presented a different appearance altogether. It
was as if he had suddenly been transposed into quite another man.

"Very clever," Rattrey said. "But I think you will admit that other
people are just as clever as you are. This is the Wedbridge man, isn't
it, sir?"

"Not the slightest doubt about it," Blake said seriously. "The question
is, what are we going to do with him?"

The prisoner appeared to have lost all interest in the proceedings.
His face, stripped of its elaborate disguise, had turned a dull, ashy
grey and though there was a certain defiance in the eyes which had been
concealed behind blue spectacles, there was terror and something almost
like despair. For this was indeed the famous, or infamous, Jim Cleghorn
for whom the police had been hunting high and low for the best part of
a year. The Wedbridge affair had been a most sensational murder which
had captured the imagination of the public until other dramatic events
had wiped it out of the national mind. The police had been greatly
blamed at the time and Rattrey, at any rate, was grimly amused to know
that now Scotland Yard would be vindicated. And there would be no
occasion to tell the general public that this vindication had been the
result of a pure accident.

"You admit your identity?" Blake asked.

"No use doing anything else," the unfortunate prisoner said defiantly.
"And no credit to you, either. I was a fool to come here to-night. I
might have known the police would have watched. If I had only waited
till the old woman came back, everything would have been all right."

"Yes, rather unfortunate, wasn't it?" Blake said. "I take it that your
visit here to-night was dictated by a certain pressing need, in other
words, you had no time to lose. I am not going to ask you what you came
for, because I can see all the evidence I want in that direction lying
on the floor at your feet."

With that, Blake picked up the bundle of letters which had been the
lure that brought Cleghorn there that evening and placed them carefully
away in his pocket.

"We had better be moving, Rattrey," Blake said. "And now, Mr. Smith,
alias Barton, alias Cleghorn, I will trouble you to come along with
us. You can say what you like or as little as you like, but everything
you do say will be taken down in evidence against you. You know what a
strong case we have over that Wedbridge tragedy and, as to the rest,
everything lies absolutely on the surface. You came down here in the
first instance and called yourself, I think, Smith. At that time you
had a black moustache. But you had to sacrifice that when you heard
the evidence at the inquest on the body of Richard Grimshaw, and also
you had to get away from Watersmouth in double quick time. It was a
brilliant idea of yours to re-disguise yourself and come back here as
a mild-looking individual called Barton, and I don't mind telling you
that if we hadn't had a certain amount of luck that bluff of yours
might have been successful. Mind you, I am only telling you facts. I
am not asking you to commit yourself in any way, but I want you to
realise that the game is up and that I am arresting you for the murder
of John Dearley at Wedbridge on November 26, last year. You need not
say any more because that is quite as you please. But I think you must
realise how desperate your position is. I might arrest you on yet
another charge, but I am not going to do that for the simple reason
that you can't hang a man more than once and my case against you over
the Wedbridge business is overwhelming. Now then, come along and if you
like to speak freely to me on the way to Watersmouth you are quite at
liberty to do so."

"Very kind of you, I am sure," Cleghorn sneered. "But the least said,
soonest mended. Lead the way."

Which Rattrey proceeded to do, having previously found a piece of rope
with which he dexterously bound the prisoner's hands behind his back.
Without a word being spoken, they tramped through the Valley of Rocks
until they came to the village police station where the astonished
local constable received them with a reverence that almost amounted to

"Now, listen carefully to me," Blake commanded. "This is the famous
Wedbridge murderer."

"You don't say so, sir," the constable gasped.

"Yes I do," Blake went on. "We are two Scotland Yard men, which fact
you must keep to yourself. You have a telephone here, I see. Well, get
on to Inspector Gore at Instaple and tell him what I have just told
you. Ask him to send a couple of men out in a car and take this man
back to Instaple and lock him up in the prison. And mind you keep a
close eye on him in the meantime. Rattrey, you had better stay behind
and keep them company in case of unexpected developments. Meanwhile, I
am going back to Mortmains at once."

A few minutes later, and Blake was on his way through the Valley of
Rocks and presently reached the house where he let himself in very
quietly. He was about to proceed up the stairs when he saw the library
door was slightly open and that there was a light burning inside.

He crossed over and looked in. There, fully clad, with a cigarette
between his lips was Jack Mortmain.

"Come in," the latter said coolly, "I have been waiting for you. At
least, not exactly waiting, because I have been following you for the
last hour and a half. I heard you come down the stairs, so I slipped
on a few odds and ends, like this sweater and flannel bags, because
I wanted to know what was taking place. Nothing like seeing the real
thing if you want to be able to describe it properly."

Blake dropped into a chair and helped himself to a cigarette from the
silver box by his elbow.

"Quite right, my dear boy, quite right," he said cheerfully. "I should
think, from a novelist's point of view, that you must have been more
than satisfied."

"Well, I was and I wasn't. You see, I could follow you to a certain
extent, but I didn't think it prudent to carry on to the extent of
joining you inside the old lady's farmhouse. I knew you were after
somebody who had burgled it and I concluded that your companion was one
of the Scotland Yard watch-dogs, especially imported for the occasion."

"Perfectly correct," Blake smiled. "His name is Rattrey and he is
one of the cleverest trackers we have. It was he who established the
fact that the man with the black moustache and the man with the blue
spectacles was one and the same. But perhaps I had better tell you all
about that."

With that Blake began to relate certain recent happenings though
Mortmain was not aware of the fact that several of the more
important details were being kept back from him. At any rate, he was
informed that the man with the black moustache who was seen in angry
conversation with Richard Grimshaw on the night before his death had
turned out to be no less a person, from the criminal point of view,
than the Wedbridge murderer.

"A most interesting story," Mortmain said, when at length Blake had
come to the end of his narrative. "And yet, from a novelist's point of
view, rather disappointing. For instance, I can make very little out of
that arrest because, from the angle of fiction, it was a pure fluke on
your part."

"So are most of our wonderful discoveries," Blake agreed coolly. "You
see, after all, the really famous criminals are very few in number so
that it is not particularly marvellous that we, in following up one
clue, should blunder on another. Anyway, we have got hold a criminal we
have been looking for for months and months and the case is complete
against him to the minutest detail. But don't forget, we didn't run
him down, knowing the identity of the man we were looking for. We were
simply following a man in blue spectacles who was making a second
attempt to burgle a humble farmhouse on the Devonshire moors. I suppose
you can guess why we were so anxious to know all about the man in blue
spectacles? Now, Mr. Novelist."

Mortmain shewed signs of something like confusion.

"Oh, well," he hastened to say. "It was your business, wasn't it? I
mean, from a professional point."

"Well, there is something in what you say. But, on the other hand,
don't forget that I came down here especially to please you. You
managed to arrange that, and I was very glad to come, and all the more
so, because I think you would have found yourself in a pretty tight
place if I had failed to materialise."

"Now what do you mean by that?" Mortmain demanded.

"Gently, gently," Blake smiled. "We will come to that presently.
Now, why did you want me particularly to come down here? I am not a
superman, you know."

Again Mortmain showed signs of agitation.

"Oh, well," he said. "You are an old friend of mine and I wanted to see
the real Scotland Yard methods at work, and so far you have been as
dumb as the Delphic oracle."


Blake smiled as he took another cigarette. He had a good deal to say
yet, but he was not going to be hustled.

"You seem to forget," he said. "That I have come down here in charge
of a sensational criminal case. I didn't come here entirely to coach
you in Scotland Yard methods so that you might be able to get all your
details correct for your new book. Of course, I have not the slightest
objection to showing you all my tricks when the case is finished.
Meanwhile, don't forget that I have my own reputation to think about.
Even friendship must not be allowed to interfere. Now, you are under
the impression that I have been more or less idle since I have been
down here. Nothing of the kind, my dear chap. Would it astonish you
very much if I told you exactly how Richard Grimshaw was killed and
exactly what happened here in the library on the night of his death?
Yes, I see that shakes you up a bit."

"Impossible," Mortmain gasped. "Impossible."

"There is nothing impossible so far as Scotland Yard is concerned,"
Blake said didactically. "And now, let me show you how easily a case
can be built up. Let me show you, for instance, how I might implicate
you in the crime."

"Implicate me?" Mortmain cried. "You are joking."

"Not in the least, my dear fellow, not in the least. Let us put it this
way. Here you are, engaged to Margaret Debenham with whom you quarrel
and who subsequently marries the man who came between you by working a
cold-blooded fraud. You say you have never seen the man in your life,
but we have only your bare word for that. Now, don't get restive--in
criminal cases the law doesn't take anybody's bare word. Anyway, you
say you have never met the man, and possibly that might be true. On the
other hand, it might not. You come down here and shut yourself away
from the world a prey to suspicion and hatred of everybody. And then
the man who has so injured you turns up in the village. He comes here
to this very house late at night, presumably, when everybody has gone
to bed and he is found in this room the next morning with a fractured
skull. Oh, yes, I know all about the ladder and the book and all the
rest of it. But that is an ingenious sort of arrangement of properties
which would occur to a novelist with an imagination like yourself. You
leave the man here for dead and go to bed. The next morning your man
Farthing comes down and finds the body. Then he comes up to your room
and finds that you have not been out since you retired the evening
before when you had arranged to go prawning at daybreak. In the course
of casual conversation, you inform Farthing that your alarm clock has
gone wrong. Again, we have only your word for that. Suppose you had put
the clock back or so arranged it that the alarm would not strike. You
want to create an atmosphere that will throw no kind of suspicion upon
yourself. And, I must confess, you managed to do it. But do you really
suppose that a jury of intelligent Englishmen are going to believe you
when it comes out in the evidence that you were engaged to Margaret
Grimshaw and that her husband, by a trick, came between you when you
say that you didn't even know Grimshaw by sight? You ask that same jury
to believe that Grimshaw was in this neighbourhood more or less by
accident. And yet he is found dead under your very roof. The natural
inference is that you knew all about his treachery and that he came
down here at your instigation, or we will suppose that he came down
here to blackmail you. Either theory is equally damaging from the point
of view of the prosecution. At any rate, there is no getting away from
the fact that your deadliest enemy was found killed under your roof and
that, to the very last, you protested that you would not have known him
if you had met him in the street."

"Which would be a fact," Mortmain said under his breath.

"Well, you tell me that as a friend and not as a detective and I am
bound to believe you. But if you tell it to a detective, then I am by
no means so sure. Oh, I know that the law views every man as innocent
until he is proved guilty, but then, we sleuths of the law work on
a contrary basis; when we come to dissect our theories we generally
assume that every suspect is guilty until he is proved innocent. And I
am rather afraid that Margaret is somewhat inclined to share my police

Mortmain paced up and down the room in great agitation. He no longer
assumed an air of indifference, and it was clear that he was shaken to
his deepest depths.

"I don't know what to say or think," he said. "Of course, this theory
of yours is absolute nonsense. And yet, when you put it as you do, I
can see that it is not so illogical as it appears at first sight. Worst
of all, I fear Margaret takes a somewhat similar view. She refuses to
come near me and, worse than that, she declines to see me. And now
I have a note from her saying that she is leaving the neighbourhood
to-morrow. It is quite a cold little note saying that nothing can be
gained by staying where she is and that she can be of no further use to
her paper. And, because she is so terribly upset by recent events and
the blaze of publicity in which she moves in the village, she is going
to spend the rest of her holidays elsewhere. She won't even tell me
where she is going. However, perhaps I had better show you the letter
and you can judge for yourself."

Blake read the note carefully enough. It was a little cold and distant,
but Blake was shrewd enough to read a certain pathos between the lines.
She was going away, Margaret said, and, for the present at any rate
she did not want to be followed or in any way worried over the tragic
affair. Perhaps it would all work out smoothly enough at the finish and
then, if that was the case, then would come the time to knit up the
broken threads again with perhaps a prospect of happiness to follow.

"What do you think of that?" Mortmain asked.

"Well, it strikes me as rather pathetic," Blake admitted. "But all the
same, I can see nothing to which you can take exception."

"Except the tone," Mortmain pointed out. "Can't you read in it the
suggestion that I am, to a certain extent, responsible for the trouble?"

"Well, perhaps, you are," Blake smiled. "At any rate, if you hadn't
been so hot-headed, this would never have happened. My dear fellow,
you are regarding the whole question from your own point of view. If
your mind was a little less fantastically formed and if you were a
little less a disciple of the Edgar Allan Poe school, I am sure this
tragedy would never have taken place. You are too clever and ingenious
altogether. Too morbid-minded. But I suppose that comes from having
lived all this long time by yourself. However, that is a point we will
come to presently. In the interim, I think you will be wise to look at
the tragedy from Margaret's point of view. If she didn't care for you
as much as she does she would never have written that letter, and I
can't imagine how a man who knows as much of human psychology as you
do can imagine her acting any other way than that in which she has.
The poor girl is torn by conflicting doubts, so that she doesn't know
which way to turn. If you can dissipate those doubts, then she will be
the happiest woman in the world, but, until you can do so, you are best

"Perhaps you are right," Mortmain sighed heavily. "But it is a terrible
position for me. And the worst, if it is, I can't see any way out of
the difficulty."

"You might, perhaps, if you told us all you knew."

"Me tell you all I know?" Mortmain challenged. "Wouldn't it be a great
deal better if you told me all you know? You have given me a thrilling
story, but I feel convinced in my mind that you could tell me a great
deal more if you liked. For instance, I believe you know what brought
Grimshaw down to this neighbourhood. And you know why the man with the
black moustache followed him. Also, you know why the man with the black
moustache, the man subsequently disguised in the blue spectacles, came
so quickly after Grimshaw into the village. Why deny it?"

"I am not going to deny it," Blake said.

"Very well, then. Let us go a bit further. Have you any objection to
telling me why this man, Cleghorn, was so anxious to get inside Mrs.
Whiddon's house. He made two attempts, the second of which was fatal to
him--more fatal then he knew. What was he looking for? Oh, I haven't
overlooked the fact that he and Grimshaw had a violent quarrel on the
night of the latter's death, because we have that on the evidence of
Mrs. Whiddon herself. Was it money that was the cause of dispute?"

"That," Blake said quite frankly, "I cannot tell you. I may be able to
do so in a day or two, when Cleghorn recognises his hopeless position.
Once he does that, he may be disposed to speak. Meanwhile, I propose
to leave him severely alone in Instaple Gaol, knowing something of the
nature of such men."

"On the other hand," Mortmain went on, "It may be that documents were
the cause of the trouble. Grimshaw might have had some papers that
Cleghorn was anxious to obtain."

"As a matter of fact, it was," Blake said. "I didn't tell you that.
The papers were hidden under a board in the floor of the room occupied
by Grimshaw. They are in my possession at the present moment, but I
prefer not to examine them until I have Inspector Gore with me. It is
just possible they may throw important light upon the trouble, though,
on the other hand, they may relate to another rascality altogether.
Now, you have asked me several times to show you my methods, and, to a
certain extent, I have been able to comply--not fully, perhaps, because
my lips are sealed, but as one good turn deserves another, so I am
going to ask you to give me your confidence."

Mortmain looked at his friend in amazement.

"Give you my confidence," he cried. "What do you mean? My dear fellow,
I have no confidence to give."

"Oh, yes, you have," Blake said slowly. "I want you to tell me why and
how you murdered Richard Grimshaw."


Mortmain jumped suddenly from his chair and as suddenly sat down again.
Just for a moment it looked as if he were on the verge of a wild
outbreak, but, if so, he contained himself and confronted his friend

"So you think that I murdered my hated rival?" he asked almost coolly.
"But, you see, I have already told you that I have never met the man
in his lifetime. By an extraordinary coincidence Richard Grimshaw was
found dead in this room. Yes, the one man in the world I hated to my
very core, the one man I would have given half my fortune to be rid of.
And you accuse me of murdering him."

"As a matter of logical fact, I have done nothing of the kind," Blake
replied. "I asked how you killed him, but then, between killing and
murder there is often a very wide gap. Now, look here, Jack, I am
placed in a very invidious position, quite as awkward a position as
yours, as a matter of fact. I came down here to investigate this
mysterious affair, mainly because you wanted me to. I have plenty of
other work to do, so I could easily have made an excuse, but, out of
regard for our old friendship, I took on the job. I have been working
on it night and day, though you don't seem to recognise the fact all
the time you have been deliberately blocking my efforts."

"I have?" Mortmain cried. "In what way?"

"Oh, well, I am not going into that now. You seem to forget that,
whilst I am your friend, I am more or less of a Government servant,
highly trusted, and with, I hope, something of a distinguished career
before me. You wouldn't like to get up some morning and read in your
copy of the "Times" that Captain Reginald Blake had been ignominiously
dismissed from the Yard. Because if I played that sort of game, that
would be the inevitable result. Once I put my hand to the case, I was
a servant and not a master, and, whatever the consequences to you are,
this thing must be thrashed out and made more or less public. And
now, as it is past two o'clock and I have a heavy day's work before
me to-morrow, I think we had better go to bed. I am not going to ask
you to tell me anything more now, and I may not see much of you in the
morning, but I am going to ask you to turn this matter over in your
mind and let me know within the next day or so what you are prepared
to do, and, what is equally important, what you are prepared to say. I
think that is all for the present."

Blake turned from the room and walked resolutely away in the direction
of the staircase. But it was a long time before he finally undressed
and got into bed. He was down fairly early in the morning, before
Mortmain had shown, and, after a solitary breakfast, went off in
the direction of Watersmouth. Once there, he turned into the Crown
Hotel and asked to see Margaret. She came at once out of her private
sitting-room, looking unlike her usual self, so that Blake could see at
a glance that she was suffering from some unaccustomed strain.

"You wanted to see me?" she asked.

"I did," Blake said. "I hear you are leaving before very long, so I
thought perhaps if I came in----"

"I was going this morning," Margaret replied.

"No, I don't think I would, if I were you," Blake smiled. "I want you
to stay for another day or two, at any rate. In fact, speaking in my
official capacity, I am going as far as to declare that you must not
go. Do you follow me?"

Margaret looked up with alarm in her eyes.

"Does that mean that I am a prisoner," she asked a little unsteadily.
"Does that mean that I can't leave Watersmouth if I want to? Is there
another side to the tragedy?"

"Well, I don't want to put it quite as brutally as that," Blake said.
"And I don't want to tell you too much, for the moment. Just promise me
to remain for the present."

Margaret gave the desired assurance. Indeed, there was little else that
she could do in the circumstances.

"Now, that is very nice of you," Blake said. "Would you mind conferring
another favor on me? Will you honor me with your company, say, round
the North Walk, because there are certain things I have to say to you
which are for your ears only."

Margaret was only too willing and ready to comply. They turned out
together in the sunshine and made their way round the famous promenade
where they came to a quiet seat presently, and sat down to talk matters

"If it is anything very terrible," Margaret implored, "please tell me
at once. It is suspense that is so dreadful."

"Yes, I know," Blake nodded sympathetically. "Would you be very much
astonished if I told you that I was seriously contemplating arresting
Jack Mortmain for the murder of your husband?"

Margaret gazed at the speaker steadily.

"No, I shouldn't," she said. "Captain Blake, it is that horrible
thought that has been oppressing me for days. I cannot bring myself to
believe that my wretched husband found his way into Mortmains by sheer
coincidence. He must have come down here to see Jack, though heaven
knows why. And he must have come by arrangement. An appointment late
at night, after all the servants had gone to bed. I can see him being
let into the house by Jack Mortmain and them talking over something
very serious in the library. Even you, who are accustomed to all sorts
of extraordinary happenings, would hesitate to credit the fact that
Richard Grimshaw came down here without knowing that he was going to
meet the man from whom he had deliberately separated me. Yes, that is
the cloud that has been hanging over me and which has kept me from
sleeping for days. Oh, no--there was an appointment for some purpose or
another. Of that I am sure."

"Yes, I am bound to confess that I have gone on that theory myself. But
why should those two meet? Why should your late husband come down here
to meet Jack Mortmain?"

"Ah, that I cannot tell," Margaret said sadly. "But if I might make a

"You really ought to be one of us," Blake said. "I don't think that it
could have been anything else. Now, my suggestion is this. According
to what you told me some time ago, Richard Grimshaw had had all your
private fortune. About the time of his death, he was taking so much of
your professional earnings that you were hard put to it to live."

"Yes, it was even as bad as that," Margaret said.

"Very well, then. What you had to give that man would not be sufficient
for his requirements. Therefore, he hit upon some nefarious scheme for
getting money out of Jack Mortmain. That was the reason why they met.
Now, my theory is that they had a serious quarrel that led to blows
and that, in the course of the fight, Richard Grimshaw's skull was
fractured. Not deliberately murdered, of course, but a pure accident.
If Mortmain had faced the matter out at once, then I am quite sure
that no jury would have convicted him, especially after they had heard
his story and you had entered the witness-box to corroborate it. But
unfortunately, poor old Jack elected to keep silence and so he finds
himself in this terrible mess. But, even now, there is a way out of it,
if you will only listen to me and remain in Watersmouth for a day or
two longer."

"Oh, I will do anything you ask. You see how cruelly I am situated.
I was glad enough to be rid of a man who was dragging me down into
the gutter and am not going to be a hypocrite enough to pretend
that Richard Grimshaw's death was anything but a profound relief to
me. You cannot tell how I felt when I knew that I was to be at his
mercy no longer. And then, just as I was beginning to rejoice in my
freedom, this other blow falls on me. I did not realise at first that
the finding of Richard Grimshaw's body at Mortmains might take on so
serious an aspect, but directly I began to turn the tragedy over in my
mind, I saw that my troubles were likely to be increased a hundredfold.
Tell me, Captain Blake, are you going to arrest Jack?"

Blake smiled and shook his head.

"Well, not just yet, at any rate. Perhaps there will be no occasion
for me to do anything of the kind. Curiously enough, it is just on the
cards that you can help."

"I help?" Margaret cried. "How is it possible?"

"You ask me that question to-morrow afternoon," Blake went on
mysteriously. "I want you to come up to Mortmains about tea-time. I
may not be quite ready for you, even then, but, with any luck, I shall
be in a position to speak more freely. I know all this sounds mighty
mysterious, but it is a rule of mine not even to hint at possibilities
until I am sure of my ground."

"But it seems almost impossible," Margaret whispered, "that there is a
happy ending to all this misery. And yet, one never knows. I am just
as fond of Jack as ever I was, perhaps more so. But with this dreadful
doubt hanging over me, I have deliberately kept out of the way. I know
that he feels it, but what am I to do? To leave him to himself seems
cruel to him, but to meet him as if nothing had happened would be
equally cruel to both of us. Do you want me to help him to speak?"

"You have hit it exactly," Blake said. "That is precisely what I do
want. And that is why I am asking you to come up to Mortmains to-morrow
afternoon. You go on with your work, just as if nothing had happened,
and turn up at Jack's house, say, about half-past four. I shall be
there, and I will take care that Jack is there, too. And then we will
have a heart-to-heart talk. And now I am going to take you back into
Watersmouth again, because I have spent more time with you than I
intended, and I have a very busy afternoon before me. First of all, I
am going to Instaple to see an inmate of the prison there. When I have
done that, I think that the way will be clear."

More than that Blake declined to say, and he and Margaret went back
towards the village in thoughtful silence.


Ten minutes later, Blake turned into a garage and ordered a car to
take him, at once, as far as Instable. It was only a matter of 20
miles or so, and he arrived in the leading North Devon town in time
for luncheon. Once he had disposed of this, he walked over to the
police station and asked for Inspector Gore. The latter appeared almost

"Well, Captain," he said. "I had rather expected to see you and I am
quite at your disposal."

"Yes, you can help me to a certain extent. I suppose your man told you
posed to answer them. I suppose your man told you something of what
happened last night."

"Details, bare details," Gore said. "Of course, I know that I have a
most important criminal in my care, and that he happens to be the man
wanted for the Wedbridge murder, but, beyond that, I know practically

Blake proceeded to fill in the details with regard to the proceedings
of the night before and how the man who was now spoken of as Cleghorn
had been taken red-handed.

"But that is not the point," Blake went on. "You see, I know now why so
famous a criminal should have apparently wasted his time in burgling a
moorland farmhouse. He was after certain papers which belonged, or were
in the possession of, Richard Grimshaw. I know that, because I have
the papers in my pocket. They were found under the floor boards in the
sitting room of the farmhouse where Grimshaw was lodging at the time
of his death. They are letters and I have not even as much as looked
at them, because I wanted to open and examine them in the presence of
somebody in authority. Now, if you will lead the way into your private
office, we will have a look at the contents of that packet."

The packet was produced, and was found, as Blake had said, to consist
of a number of letters inside a large, blank envelope which, on being
slit, disclosed the amazing fact that the envelopes, one and all, were
in Mortmain's handwriting.

"Well, that is a strange thing," Blake murmured. "I suppose you don't
know my friend Mortmain's handwriting, but these envelopes are all his.
Suppose we look inside one of them."

As they did so, another surprise awaited them. It was not a pleasant
task, reading the private correspondence of other people, especially
when that correspondence takes the form of a series of impassioned
love letters between a man and the woman of his choice. But every one
of them was written on lines that conveyed the impression of a deep
affection. They were a little wild and florid, as one might naturally
expect from a literary man who prided himself upon his style and
language and, here and there, was certain expressions which might have
conveyed a wrong impression altogether to the casual or sarcastic
reader. Not compromising, exactly, at least, not to a properly
understanding mind. But by no means the sort of letters that the writer
would have cared to have seen in the possession of anybody but the
woman to whom they were written.

"What do you make of them, sir?" Gore asked.

"Well, upon my word, for the moment I don't know what to make of them."
Blake confessed. "Those letters were undoubtedly written by Sir John
Mortmain to the woman he loved previous to her marriage. It is pretty
obvious that they found their way, somehow, into the possession of the
scoundrel she married and that he had made up his mind to make use of

"By jove, you are right," Gore exclaimed. "That accounts for Grimshaw
turning up at Mortmains. He came down there to blackmail Sir John and
sell him his love letters at a fancy price. And then, when he had done

Gore pulled up as if short of breath.

"Well," Blake said, coolly. "What's stung you now?"

"Can't you see?" Gore cried. "If all this is correct, and I cannot
see any other conclusion, we have solved the problem of Grimshaw's
death. Those two men came to blows in the library and Grimshaw was
accidentally killed. That would account for his body being found there.
Then Sir John lost his head and set out to manufacture a first-class
alibi. He would have been much wiser to have come here and told the
whole story. But now I am afraid that I shall have to interfere."

"In other words, arrest Sir John Mortmain?"

"Well, I suppose that is what it amounts to," Gore said. "It is what
you would do if you were in my place."

"There I quite agree with you," Blake said. "But then there are one or
two little things I happen to know which place a different complexion
on the tragedy, and, at any rate, there is no violent hurry. Sir John
is not in the least likely to run away, so that you can pick him up
whenever you want. Moreover, as the case is still in my hands, I prefer
to carry it out in my own fashion. No offence, I hope, my dear fellow."

"Not in the least," Gore said formally. "So long as the responsibility
is off my shoulders I am quite indifferent, and, after all, you are my
superior officer."

"Yes, I thought you would take it that way," Blake said pleasantly.
"Now, I want to see your prisoner. There are a few questions I should
like to put to him, and I am sanguine that after a few hours' solitary
reflection he will be disposed to answer them. I suppose he hasn't gone

"No, he hasn't," Gore explained, "I am expecting a couple of your men
from the Yard this afternoon to come down and fetch him because I
understand by telephone that he is to be formally charged to-morrow
morning in London with the Wedbridge murder. They are fetching him to

"Oh, then I am only just in time," Blake said. "Kindly lead the way and
leave the rest to me."

Blake found the prisoner sitting moodily on his bed and contemplating
a ray of sunshine that filtered into the cell through a narrow window
near the ceiling. He looked up with a scowl as he realised who his
visitor was. Then the cell door closed and the hunter and hunted were

"I want you to answer a few questions," Blake said. "Of course, if you
don't like to do so, there is an end of the matter. But I don't think
you will refuse, when I tell you that you might be doing a good turn to
a second party."

Something like the ghost of a smile flickered about the haggard
features of the man known as Cleghorn.

"I have no grudge against you," he said. "Fact is, I have got no grudge
against anybody. I may be all that you police chaps make me out to be,
but I never turned on a pal, and I never refused to help anyone who was
in trouble. Oh, I know I am in a tight place. But I led you a bit of
a dance, didn't I? Nine months, more or less, wasn't it? and me going
about the country under your very noses. More than once, I have been
within a couple of yards of you and you the wiser."

"Oh, I admit all that," Blake said pleasantly. "But that merry dance
has come to an end now, I think."

The prisoner became suddenly grave.

"Yes, that is right, Captain," he said. "I am finished. I know what
evidence you have against me, because I read it all in the papers. And
I am not going to trouble to make any defence, nor to get one of those
barrister chaps to plead for me. I have had a good time, and I am ready
to pay for it. Mind you, I didn't kill the old man in cold blood. If
he had only let me get away with what I wanted, nothing would have
happened, but he tried to shoot me and then it was a question as to who
was going to come out of the business alive. You can make what use you
like of this, and I will sign it, if you want me to."

"We will come to that presently. In the meantime, why were you so
anxious to get hold of those letters which were in Richard Grimshaw's
possession when he came down here with the intention of paying a call
on Sir John Mortmain?"

"Oh you know that, do you?" the prisoner laughed. "Well, I might
just as well make a clean breast of it. You may say I am a bit of
a scoundrel, but I am not a dirty skunk and slimy worm like Dick
Grimshaw. He was always ready to round on his pals when it paid him
and he tried to round on me, though I had lent him money over and over
again. And when I was dodging about the country, never knowing when I
should be nabbed, he was living in clover and swearing he hadn't got
a penny. But I happened to hear about those letters and what he was
going to do with them, so I scraped enough together to get down here
and tracked him to his lodgings. Lord, the sight of his face when he
realised that I was fly to his little game! I very nearly did him in
that night outside the farmhouse. You know what I mean, because you
heard the old woman give her evidence about the man with the black
moustache. And that was me, of course."

"I am fully aware of the fact," Blake said.

"Very well, then. I see you know all about it, so I won't bother you
with a lot of detail. But I was not trusting Master Grimshaw a yard
further than I could see him. He thought that he had satisfied me for
the time being, and that I was well on my way back to Watersmouth when
he set out to call upon Sir John. Telling me, mind you, at the same
time, that he wasn't going to see the gentleman for the best part of a
week. And him all the time meaning to sell those letters at once and
clear out, leaving me in the lurch to get on as best I could."

"And what happened then?" Blake asked.

"Well, what do you think, Captain? I followed him and overtook him just
on the top of the Castle Rock. He tried to shove me off, and I gave him
one on the chin and over he went. And that is how Dick Grimshaw met his

"And after that?" Blake said.

"God knows. But Grimshaw was dead, right enough. Bound to be with a
fall like that. But how he managed to be found in Mortmains, I know no
more than the dead."


Margaret set out on that eventful afternoon for Mortmains in a state
that was not far removed from terror. She hardly dared to think of what
might happen in the course of the afternoon or how this strange and
mysterious tragedy was going to end. And yet, a few days ago she had
been happy enough.

She had been happy in the knowledge that she was rid for all time of a
scoundrel who, had he lived, would, sooner or later, have dragged her
down into the gutter. She made no pretence of sorrow or grief; indeed,
why should she in the case of a man she had never cared for and, whom
she had married in a moment when she was suffering from wounded pride
and vanity?

And then she had begun to think. Hers was a logical mind trained to
weigh evidence and she could not conceive that Richard Grimshaw had
come down to Mortmains without having first communicated with Jack
Mortmain. At any rate, he had come down there with the object of
obtaining money. And that the two had met Margaret felt certain. And
yet, Jack Mortmain had declared that he had never met Grimshaw in his
life and had not the slightest idea how the latter had met his death in
the library.

Not that Jack had said this in as many words, indeed, he had been most
reticent on the subject. From a legal point of view, he had not uttered
a single word calculated to prejudice himself in the eyes of the law.
But, on the other hand, ever since the finding of that body, there
had been something strange and almost sinister about him. He had been
restless and moody and, uneasy in his manner. He had wanted to see
Margaret and, at the same time, seemed almost relieved when she had
left him. So strangely different from the Jack Mortmain she used to

And now she had a feeling that the whole story was going to be told.
She braced herself to what she felt was bound to be a terrible ordeal
and when she reached the portico in front of Mortmains, was outwardly
herself again. She rang the bell with a firm hand and forced a smile to
her lips when Farthing flung open the door and bade her enter.

"I suppose Sir John is in?" she asked.

"Indeed, yes, madam," Farthing replied. "He is out in the grounds
somewhere. I will go and fetch him for you."

"And is Captain Blake here, too?" Margaret asked.

"I don't know where he is," Farthing went on to explain. "He went out
quite early this morning. Will you kindly step inside, madam, whilst I
go and look for Sir John?"

Margaret crossed the great hall in the direction of the library. She
ignored Farthing's implied suggestion that she should wait in the west
drawing-room that overlooked the wide panorama of sea and woodland and
turned almost instinctively into the library. It was here that the
great tragedy had been enacted and it was here, she felt instinctively,
that the final act in the drama would be played out. She stood there a
few minutes contemplating one of the finest landscapes in the world and
then she turned to see Mortmain standing behind her.

"You here," he said, in some surprise. "Really, this is an honor that I
hardly expected."

"I don't think either of us will gain anything by your taking that
line," Margaret said coldly. "I came here because Captain Blake asked
me to. He said that he wanted us to have a conference and, more or less
unwillingly, I agreed."

"Then I am not to congratulate myself?"

"Oh, how do I know?" Margaret asked wildly. "I think you must
appreciate the reasons why I have not been here as often as I might.
Oh, Jack, please don't make it any harder for me than it is. You must
know how I am suffering."

Before Mortmain could make reply, the door of the library opened and
Blake came briskly in.

"I am sorry I kept you waiting," he said. "But I have been to Instaple
and back since breakfast. You see, Jack, I asked Margaret to come here
this afternoon because I thought she had a right to be present when the
Mortmains mystery was cleared up."

"Oh, it is to be cleared up, then?" Mortmain sneered.

"That is so," Blake said evenly. "And I am sorry that there has been so
much delay. But there has been a great deal to do, Margaret, and you
must not blame me unduly. Do sit down. We shall be sometime over this
business, and I want to proceed with it as comfortably as possible."

"Go on," Mortmain said. "Make your accusations. Say that I killed
Richard Grimshaw. Don't hesitate."

"But why should I say anything of the kind," Blake asked. "I have never
accused you of murdering Grimshaw."

"Indeed? I fail to appreciate the fine distinction. You asked me, in
this very room, not so very long ago, to explain to you how I murdered
my hated rival."

"Certainly I didn't. I asked you how you killed him, which is another
thing altogether. And you didn't answer, because I wouldn't let you. I
had my reasons at the time, but we can speak quite freely now and I ask
you the question again."

"And I absolutely deny it," Mortmain said. "Whether Grimshaw was
murdered or whether he died through an accident I don't know. One thing
is absolutely certain. I never laid a hand upon him, and I never saw
him until he was lying dead in this very room on that fatal morning we
all know of."

"And I believe you implicitly," Blake said.

Mortmain stared at the speaker in astonishment.

"You implicitly believe me?" he echoed. "Then why all this mystery? Why
this suggestion that I am little less than a blood-thirsty criminal?"

"Because I am waiting for you to speak," Blake went on. "My dear
fellow, I may be a policeman, but, at the same time, I am your friend.
That is, within the lines of my duty to the office I hold. And, because
I am your friend, I implore you to let us hear your side of the story

"But there is no side to my story," Mortmain said stubbornly.

"Oh, yes, there is, my dear fellow. There is a very remarkable side to
your story. So remarkable, indeed, that nobody would ever believe it
unless absolute evidence to the contrary was forthcoming. If I told all
that I knew in a Court of Justice you would be extremely lucky if you
escaped the extreme penalty. Just think. Here is your deadliest rival a
corpse under your own roof. He comes to see you because, he is hard up
for money and because he expects to blackmail you."

"Blackmail me," Mortmain cried. "How?"

"Through certain letters in his possession," Blake went on.

"Now, Margaret, will you kindly tell me whether or not you destroyed
the letters that Jack here wrote to you during your engagement? After
you were married, or perhaps before, did you put those letters in the

Margaret blushed rosy as the dawn.

"No, I didn't," she confessed. "Of course, when I married Richard
Grimshaw I ought to have done so. But I didn't. You see I never made
the slightest pretence of caring for my husband and, in my heart, I
never changed. I suppose, being a woman, I kept those letters out of

"And you have them at the present moment, I suppose?"

"Indeed I haven't," Margaret blushed. "They disappeared somewhere.
Perhaps I put them away so carefully that I forgot where they were. But
they are no longer in my possession."

"Naturally enough, because your husband stole them," Blake said. "He
stole them and read them and, being the kind of scoundrel he was, he
said nothing to you, neither did he destroy them, because he hoped
that some day he might be able to turn them into money. They were very
loving letters, I think."

"Why do you go on like this, torturing the poor girl?" Mortmain burst
out. "As a matter of fact, they were passionate letters, the sort
of letters that a literary man would write. And in the hands of a
filthy-minded reader they might have conveyed a wrong impression."

"Yes, so I thought," Blake said absently.

"Damnation," Mortmain cried. "Do you mean to stand there and actually
tell me you have read those letters?"

"I have," Blake said calmly. "As a matter of fact, they are in my
pocket at the present moment. Now, please be calm, Jack. Don't
make a fool of yourself and don't say things that you will regret
afterwards. Those letters came into my possession in the course of my
investigations down here and they have an important bearing on the
case, as you will see presently. In a way, they are going to do your
cause a great deal of good. And now, as you won't speak let me talk.
As far as I can gather, Richard Grimshaw was in dire need of money. He
didn't know where to turn to get it. He knew that his wife could not
find him all that he wanted so he thought he might make use of those
letters. He came down here for the express purpose of doing so. He took
rooms with Mrs. Whiddon in her moorland farm, and, from thence he was
going to conduct his campaign. I suppose that he never came to see you,
or wrote for an interview?"

"I have said, over and over again," Mortmain declared hotly, "that I
never saw the man in my life, neither have I had any communication with
him whatever."

"Well, it doesn't matter very much," Blake resumed. "He came down here
with the letters, intending to sell them to you for a good round price.
And I have not the slightest doubt you would have paid it, if only for
Margaret's sake."

"I would," Mortmain murmured. "I would have done anything to save her

"Yes, I expected you to say that. But circumstances prevented a meeting
between you and, therefore----"

"Then you admit that?" Mortmain cried.

"Yes I admit that. And now, perhaps I had better put my cards--and the
letters--on the table."


Blake proceeded to do as he had suggested. He took the fateful letters
from his pocket and handed them over to Margaret.

"There you are," he said. "These are your property and nobody else has
the right to see them. I had to read them myself; at least, I had to
read two of them, because, directly that bundle came into my hands,
I saw that they were Jack's writing and that they were addressed to
you. I took them from Cleghorn's fingers myself. Perhaps I had better
explain to you in what circumstances I got them."

With that, Blake went on to explain how he had worked from the very
first to discover the motive which had brought Grimshaw down to
Mortmains on his blackmailing errand. He told his eager listeners all
about the man with the black moustache and how he disappeared from Mrs.
Ridge's cottage, only to return again in the disguise of the pallid
man with the blue glasses. Then he went on to say how the man who had
called himself Barton had been followed to the farmhouse on the moor
and the circumstances in which he had been taken red-handed with those
letters in his possession. After that, Blake explained that the man
called Barton was no other than the badly wanted murderer, Cleghorn,
who had been roving the country at liberty for many months after the
commission of the Wedbridge crime.

"What an amazing entanglement," Mortmain cried. "Then you mean to say
that you have actually got the Wedbridge murderer by the heels? Where
is he now?"

"Well, by this time I suppose he is in Holloway Jail," Blake smiled.
"It was a bit of blind luck, but there you are. I have had a long talk
with him and he made full confession. Of course, he recognised that we
had overwhelming evidence against him and that is why he made no fight
of it. And now, perhaps I had better tell you how this crafty murderer
comes to be mixed up in what is called the Mortmains mystery."

"More mystery?" Margaret sighed. "Oh, dear."

"My dear young lady, the two mysteries were one. And when I come to
explain them you will see how they dovetail one into another," Blake
said. "You see, Richard Grimshaw was a personal friend of Barton, or
Cleghorn, or whatever you like to call the Wedbridge murderer. As far
as I can make out, Grimshaw owed the other a considerable amount of
money. Cleghorn knew that Grimshaw had it in his power to blackmail our
friend here but he didn't know how--he merely took the statement for
granted. He wanted money pretty desperately and, not trusting Grimshaw,
followed him down here. In fact, he hardly allowed his fellow criminal
out of his sight. And then they quarrelled, as such men inevitably do."

"Stop a moment," Margaret interrupted. "This Cleghorn must have known
something about my letters or he would never have gone back to the old
farmhouse to look for them."

"Yes, but it doesn't follow that he knew they were your letters," Blake
pointed out. "It was quite natural that Cleghorn should know that some
documents were at the bottom of the conspiracy, and he must have been
aware that Grimshaw had them in his possession. Then, as nothing of the
sort was found, at any rate, nothing of the kind was mentioned at the
inquest, Cleghorn came to the logical conclusion that those papers were
somewhere in the farmhouse. That is how he walked into our trap. And
when he told me that he had killed Richard Grimshaw----"

A sudden cry broke from both listeners.

"Killed Grimshaw?" Mortmain exclaimed hoarsely. "Do you mean to say
that there was another murder?"

"I think you know that as well as I do," Blake smiled. "Those two men
had a quarrel, a second quarrel. It was on the top of the Castle Rock
on the very night that Grimshaw's body was found in this room and only
about three or four hours before. I don't think it was a deliberate
murder, but, anyhow, those two scoundrels came to blows and Grimshaw
toppled over the Castle Rock onto the sands below. His skull was
fractured and he probably died instantly. Mind you, I had that from
Cleghorn himself. And now, Jack, as man to man, will you kindly tell
me how the dead body of that miscreant found its way from the sands to
the spot where it was discovered in this library. Why did you take that
body and bring it here?"

Mortmain gazed at his friend in open-mouthed amazement. For the moment,
he was too surprised to speak.

"You are very wonderful," he managed to say presently. "I wanted to
see the wheels go round, like the little boy in 'Helen's Babies.' You
see, I am what is called a realist in fiction, and I hate to set down
second-hand impressions. I am working on a grim mystery story now, and
it was more than essential that I should see how Scotland Yard does
its work. I don't think anybody else would believe it, but I think you

"I am quite sure I shall," Blake said encouragingly.

"Very well, then. On that particular morning I got up as usual and
dressed myself for the prawning expedition. It was barely daylight and
I need not tell you now that there was nothing whatever the matter with
my alarm clock. I slipped into my fishing kit and crept silently out of
the house. Not a soul was about or likely to be for hours. I went down
the zig-zag path onto the beach and across the sands so as to skirt the
Castle Rock and reach the bay beyond. It was just light enough for me
to see some foreign body lying at the base of the rock. Another moment
and I knew that I had found a dead man. He had turned over with the
force of the fall, and I could see the fracture that had caused his
death. And then the strange temptation came over me, that weird sort of
imaginative chimera that is peculiar to most novelists worthy of the
name. You know we live half our time in a world of our own, a world
filled with strange people. There came over me an irresistible impulse
to take that body into my house and place it in the library in exactly
the circumstances in which it was found. My idea was to baffle the
police, and to get you down here and watch how you worked. So I carried
out my scheme, carefully removing every trace of sand from the clothing
of the dead man, never dreaming for a moment that he was my deadliest
enemy. It was a coincidence almost beyond human credulity."

"It was nothing of the kind," Blake interrupted. "So you can rule the
coincidence out. The man came down here to blackmail you and he was
followed by another scoundrel who had determined that he should not get
away with the whole plunder. Go on; what happened after that?"

"Well, I went back to bed again, taking care to make it appear that
my alarm had failed me and that I had never been out of bed at all.
Once I was easy in my mind over that I felt that my path was clear. I
got you to come down here because I hoped to see how you worked. It
never occurred to me that I was not to share in your investigations.
And then you can imagine what my feelings were like when Margaret came
along on behalf of her paper and identified the body as that of her
husband. I knew that she would try and believe me to be innocent of a
dastardly crime and that she would do her best to shield me. But would
she really, in her heart of hearts, think I was innocent. This is the
problem that has been haunting me night and day and rendering my life
absolutely miserable. Over and over again I have been on the verge of
confessing my insane folly. I didn't regard it as insane folly at the
time, but we need not go into that. The question I kept on turning over
and over in my brain was how far so wild a yarn would obtain credence
even amongst my best friends. I couldn't see how they could believe
it. But now, since you have heard the real story of Richard Grimshaw's
death from the man who was actually responsible for it, I can speak
more freely, and show you how far it is possible for a novelist to go
into the grotesque and fantastic in pursuit of an ideal. But how did
you manage to find out?"

"Well, I don't think I ought to tell you," Blake smiled. "Why give away
the secrets of the profession? And why show how easy it is when you
know how it is done. Mind you, I had a very valuable assistant in your
friend, Deacon."

"Oh, Deacon was in it, was he?" Mortmain asked.

"Very much so. But perhaps I had better let you have the whole story
and give you an exposition of the way in which we detectives use the
man of science these days. Now listen."

Mortmain listened accordingly. He heard all about the sand mixed
with the blood at the base of the dead man's skull and all about the
photograph of the wax impression of the shoe with its india-rubber sole.

"And that is about all," Blake said. "Of course, this story will have
to be told. You can't very well keep it quiet and choke scandal at the
same time. There will be a good deal of sensation over the methods of a
certain novelist, but it will all be forgotten in a few days and then
you two can live happy ever afterwards, like the characters in fairy
stories. Just one moment, I have forgotten something."

But Blake had forgotten nothing. It was merely his tactful way of
effecting an exit and leaving the others alone. They stood in silence
for some time looking out over the glorious landscape to the peaceful
sea beyond and the woods that lay like a green mantle to the west--a
haunt of ancient peace and silence with the spirit of it upon them.

"Have you got anything to say, Margaret?" Mortmain murmured.

Margaret faced him with her soul in her eyes.

"Can you ever forgive me," she faltered.

"My dear," he whispered. "There is nothing to forgive. We were both to
blame and we have both paid for our pride and folly. But we shall find
all the peace we want here, I think."

The End.

This site is full of FREE ebooks - Project Gutenberg Australia