Project Gutenberg Australia
a treasure-trove of literature
treasure found hidden with no evidence of ownership

Title: The Franchise Affair (1948)
Author: Josephine Tey [Elizabeth MacKintosh] (1896-1952)
* A Project Gutenberg Australia eBook *
eBook No.: 0800481.txt
Language:  English
Date first posted: June 2008
Date most recently updated: June 2008

This ebook was produced by: Iona Vaughan, Beth Trapaga,
Mark Akrigg & the Online Distributed Proofreading Team

Project Gutenberg Australia eBooks are created from printed editions
which are in the public domain in Australia, unless a copyright notice
is included. We do NOT keep any eBooks in compliance with a particular
paper edition.

Copyright laws are changing all over the world. Be sure to check the
copyright laws for your country before downloading or redistributing this

This eBook is made available at no cost and with almost no restrictions
whatsoever. You may copy it, give it away or re-use it under the terms
of the Project Gutenberg Australia License which may be viewed online at

To contact Project Gutenberg Australia go to


Title: The Franchise Affair (1948)
Author: Josephine Tey [Elizabeth MacKintosh] (1896-1952)


It was four o'clock of a spring evening; and Robert Blair was thinking
of going home.

The office would not shut until five, of course. But when you are the
only Blair, of Blair, Hayward, and Bennet, you go home when you think
you will. And when your business is mostly wills, conveyancing, and
investments your services are in small demand in the late afternoon.
And when you live in Milford, where the last post goes out at 3.45, the
day loses whatever momentum it ever had long before four o'clock.

It was not even likely that his telephone would ring. His golfing
cronies would by now be somewhere between the fourteenth and the
sixteenth hole. No one would ask him to dinner, because in Milford
invitations to dinner are still written by hand and sent through the
post. And Aunt Lin would not ring up and ask him to call for the fish
on his way home, because this was her bi-weekly afternoon at the
cinema, and she would at the moment be only twenty minutes gone with
feature, so to speak.

So he sat there, in the lazy atmosphere of a spring evening in a little
market town, staring at the last patch of sunlight on his desk (the
mahogany desk with the brass inlay that his grandfather had scandalised
the family by bringing home from Paris) and thought about going home.
In the patch of sunlight was his tea-tray; and it was typical of Blair,
Hayward, and Bennet that tea was no affair of a japanned tin tray and a
kitchen cup. At 3.50 exactly on every working day Miss Tuff bore into
his office a lacquer tray covered with a fair white cloth and bearing a
cup of tea in blue-patterned china, and, on a plate to match, two
biscuits; petit-beurre Mondays, Wednesdays and Fridays, digestive
Tuesdays, Thursdays and Saturdays.

Looking at it now, idly, he thought how much it represented the
continuity of Blair, Hayward, and Bennet. The china he could remember
as long as he could remember anything. The tray had been used when he
was very small by the cook at home to take the bread in from the baker,
and had been rescued by his young mother and brought to the office to
bear the blue-patterned cups. The cloth had come years later with the
advent of Miss Tuff. Miss Tuff was a war-time product; the first woman
who had ever sat at a desk in a respectable solicitor's in Milford. A
whole revolution Miss Tuff was in her single gawky thin earnest person.
But the firm had survived the revolution with hardly a jolt, and now,
nearly a quarter of a century later, it was inconceivable that thin
grey dignified Miss Tuff had ever been a sensation. Indeed her only
disturbance of the immemorial routine was the introduction of the
tray-cloth. In Miss Tuff's home no meal was ever put straight on to a
tray; if it comes to that, no cakes were ever put straight on to a
plate; a tray-cloth or a doyley must intervene. So Miss Tuff had looked
askance at the bare tray. She had, moreover, considered the lacquered
pattern distracting, unappetising, and "queer." So one day she had
brought a cloth from home; decent, plain, and white, as befitted
something that was to be eaten off. And Robert's father, who had liked
the lacquer tray, looked at the clean white cloth and was touched by
young Miss Tuff's identification of herself with the firm's interests,
and the cloth had stayed, and was now as much a part of the firm's life
as the deed-boxes, and the brass plate, and Mr. Heseltine's annual

It was when his eyes rested on the blue plate where the biscuits had
been that Robert experienced that odd sensation in his chest again. The
sensation had nothing to do with the two digestive biscuits; at least,
not physically. It had to do with the inevitability of the biscuit
routine; the placid certainty that it would be digestive on a Thursday
and petit-beurre on a Monday. Until the last year or so, he had found
no fault with certainty or placidity. He had never wanted any other
life but this: this quiet friendly life in the place where he had grown
up. He still did not want any other. But once or twice lately an odd,
alien thought had crossed his mind; irrelevant and unbidden. As nearly
as it could be put into words it was: "This is all you are ever going
to have." And with the thought would come that moment's constriction in
his chest. Almost a panic reaction; like the heart-squeezing that
remembering a dentist appointment would cause in his ten-year-old

This annoyed and puzzled Robert; who considered himself a happy and
fortunate person, and adult at that. Why should this foreign thought
thrust itself on him and cause that dismayed tightening under his ribs?
What had his life lacked that a man might be supposed to miss?

A wife?

But he could have married if he had wanted to. At least he supposed he
could; there were a great many unattached females in the district, and
they showed no signs of disliking him.

A devoted mother?

But what greater devotion could a mother have given him than Aunt Lin
provided; dear doting Aunt Lin.


What had he ever wanted that he could not buy? And if that wasn't
riches he didn't know what was.

An exciting life?

But he had never wanted excitement. No greater excitement, that is,
than was provided by a day's hunting or being all-square at the

Then what?

Why the "This is all you are ever going to have" thought?

Perhaps, he thought, sitting staring at the blue plate where the
biscuits had been, it was just that Childhood's attitude of
something-wonderful-tomorrow persisted subconsciously in a man as long
as it was capable of realisation, and it was only after forty, when it
became unlikely of fulfilment, that it obtruded itself into conscious
thought; a lost piece of childhood crying for attention.

Certainly he, Robert Blair, hoped very heartily that his life would go
on being what it was until he died. He had known since his schooldays
that he would go into the firm and one day succeed his father; and he
had looked with good-natured pity on boys who had no niche in life
ready-made for them; who had no Milford, full of friends and memories,
waiting for them; no part in English continuity as was provided by
Blair, Hayward, and Bennet.

There was no Hayward in the firm nowadays; there had not been one since
1843; but a young sprig of the Bennets was occupying the back room at
this moment. Occupying was the operative word, since it was very
unlikely that he was doing any work; his chief interest in life being
to write poems of an originality so pristine that only Nevil himself
could understand them. Robert deplored the poems but condoned the
idleness, since he could not forget that when he had occupied that same
room he had spent his time practising mashie shots into the leather

The sunlight slipped off the edge of the tray and Robert decided it was
time to go. If he went now he could walk home down the High Street
before the sunlight was off the east-side pavement; and walking down
Milford High Street was still one of the things that gave him conscious
pleasure. Not that Milford was a show-place. It could be duplicated a
hundred times anywhere south of Trent. But in its unselfconscious
fashion it typified the goodness of life in England for the last three
hundred years. From the old dwelling-house flush with the pavement that
housed Blair, Hayward, and Bennet and had been built in the last years
of Charles the Second's reign, the High Street flowed south in a gentle
slope--Georgian brick, Elizabethan timber-and-plaster, Victorian stone,
Regency stucco--to the Edwardian villas behind their elm trees at the
other end. Here and there, among the rose and white and brown, appeared
a front of black glass, brazening it out like an overdressed parvenu at
a party; but the good manners of the other buildings discounted them.
Even the multiple businesses had dealt leniently with Milford. True,
the scarlet and gold of an American bazaar flaunted its bright promise
down at the south end, and daily offended Miss Truelove who ran the
Elizabethan relic opposite as a tea-shop with the aid of her sister's
baking and Ann Boleyn's reputation. But the Westminster Bank, with a
humility rare since the days of usury, had adapted the Weavers Hall to
their needs without so much as a hint of marble; and Soles, the
wholesale chemists, had taken the old Wisdom residence and kept its
tall surprised-looking front intact.

It was a fine, gay, busy little street, punctuated with pollarded lime
trees growing out of the pavement; and Robert Blair loved it.

He had gathered his feet under him preparatory to getting up, when his
telephone rang. In other places in the world, one understands,
telephones are made to ring in outer offices, where a minion answers
the thing and asks your business and says that if you will be good
enough to wait just a moment she will "put you thrrrough" and you are
then connected with the person you want to speak to. But not in
Milford. Nothing like that would be tolerated in Milford. In Milford if
you call John Smith on the telephone you expect John Smith to answer in
person. So when the telephone rang on that spring evening in Blair,
Hayward, and Bennet's it rang on Robert's brass-and-mahogany desk.

Always, afterwards, Robert was to wonder what would have happened if
that telephone call had been one minute later. In one minute, sixty
worthless seconds, he would have taken his coat from the peg in the
hall, popped his head into the opposite room to tell Mr. Heseltine that
he was departing for the day stepped out into the pale sunlight and
been away down the street. Mr. Heseltine would have answered his
telephone when it rang and told the woman that he had gone. And she
would have hung up and tried someone else. And all that followed would
have had only academic interest for him.

But the telephone rang in time; and Robert put out his hand and picked
up the receiver.

"Is that Mr. Blair?" a woman's voice asked; a contralto voice that
would normally be a confident one, he felt, but now sounded breathless
or hurried. "Oh, I am so glad to have caught you. I was afraid you
would have gone for the day. Mr. Blair, you don't know me. My name is
Sharpe, Marion Sharpe. I live with my mother at The Franchise. The
house out on the Larborough road, you know."

"Yes, I know it," Blair said. He knew Marion Sharpe by sight, as he
knew everyone in Milford and the district. A tall, lean, dark woman of
forty or so; much given to bright silk kerchiefs which accentuated her
gipsy swarthiness. She drove a battered old car, from which she shopped
in the mornings while her white-haired old mother sat in the back,
upright and delicate and incongruous and somehow silently protesting.
In profile old Mrs. Sharpe looked like Whistler's mother; when she
turned full-face and you got the impact of her bright, pale, cold,
seagull's eye, she looked like a sibyl. An uncomfortable old person.

"You don't know me," the voice went on, "but I have seen you in
Milford, and you look a kind person, and I need a lawyer. I mean, I
need one now, this minute. The only lawyer we ever have business with
is in London--a London firm, I mean--and they are not actually ours. We
just inherited them with a legacy. But now I am in trouble and I need
legal backing, and I remembered you and thought that you would----"

"If it is your car----" Robert began. "In trouble" in Milford meant one
of two things; an affiliation order, or an offence against the traffic
laws. Since the case involved Marion Sharpe, it would be the latter;
but it made no difference because in neither case was Blair, Hayward,
and Bennet likely to be interested. He would pass her on to Carley, the
bright lad at the other end of the street, who revelled in court cases
and was popularly credited with the capacity to bail the Devil out of
hell. ("Bail him out!" someone said, one night at the Rose and Crown.
"He'd do more than that. He'd get all our signatures to a guinea
testimonial to the Old Sinner.")

"If it is your car----"

"Car?" she said, vaguely; as if in her present world it was difficult
to remember what a car was. "Oh, I see. No. Oh, no, it isn't anything
like that. It is something much more serious. It's Scotland Yard."

"Scotland Yard!"

To that douce country lawyer and gentleman, Robert Blair, Scotland Yard
was as exotic as Xanadu, Hollywood, or parachuting. As a good citizen
he was on comfortable terms with the local police, and there his
connection with crime ended. The nearest he had ever come to Scotland
Yard was to play golf with the local Inspector; a good chap who played
a very steady game and occasionally, when it came to the nineteenth,
expanded into mild indiscretions about his job.

"I haven't _murdered_ anyone, if that is what you are thinking," the
voice said hastily.

"The point is: are you _supposed_ to have murdered anyone?" Whatever
she was supposed to have done this was clearly a case for Carley. He
must edge her off on to Carley.

"No; it isn't murder at all. I'm supposed to have kidnapped someone. Or
abducted them, or something. I can't explain over the telephone. And
anyhow I need someone now, at once, and----"

"But, you know, I don't think it is me you need at all," Robert said.
"I know practically nothing about criminal law. My firm is not equipped
to deal with a case of that sort. The man you need----"

"I don't want a criminal lawyer. I want a friend. Someone who will
stand by me and see that I am not put-upon. I mean, tell me what I need
not answer if I don't want to, and that sort of thing. You don't need a
training in crime for that, do you?"

"No, but you would be much better served by a firm who were used to
police cases. A firm that----"

"What you are trying to tell me is that this is not 'your cup of tea';
that's it, isn't it?"

"No, of course not," Robert said hastily. "I quite honestly feel that
you would be wiser----"

"You know what I feel like?" she broke in. "I feel like someone
drowning in a river because she can't drag herself up the bank, and
instead of giving me a hand you point out that the other bank is much
better to crawl out on."

There was a moment's silence.

"But on the contrary," Robert said, "I can provide you with an expert
puller-out-of-rivers; a great improvement on my amateur self, I assure
you. Benjamin Carley knows more about defending accused persons than
anyone between here and----"

"What! That awful little man with the striped suits!" Her deep voice
ran up and cracked, and there was another momentary silence. "I am
sorry," she said presently in her normal voice. "That was silly. But
you see, when I rang you up just now it wasn't because I thought you
would be clever about things" ("_Wasn't_ it, indeed," thought Robert)
"but because I was in trouble and wanted the advice of someone of my
own sort. And you looked my sort. Mr. Blair, do please come. I need you
_now_. There are people from Scotland Yard here in the house. And if
you feel that it isn't something you want to be mixed up in you could
always pass it on to someone else afterwards; couldn't you? But there
may be nothing after all to be mixed up in. If you would just come out
here and 'watch my interests' or whatever you call it, for an hour, it
may all pass over. I'm sure there is a mistake somewhere. Couldn't you
please do that for me?"

On the whole Robert Blair thought that he could. He was too
good-natured to refuse any reasonable appeal--and she had given him a
loophole if things grew difficult. And he did not, after all, now he
came to think of it, want to throw her to Ben Carley. In spite of her
_bêtise_ about striped suits he saw her point of view. If you had done
something you wanted to get away with, Carley was no doubt God's gift
to you; but if you were bewildered and in trouble and innocent, perhaps
Carley's brash personality was not likely to be a very present help.

All the same, he wished as he laid down the receiver that the front he
presented to the world was a more forbidding one--Calvin or Caliban, he
did not care, so long as strange females were discouraged from flinging
themselves on his protection when they were in trouble.

What possible kind of trouble could "kidnapping" be, he wondered as he
walked round to the garage in Sin Lane for his car? _Was_ there such an
offence in English law? And whom could she possibly be interested in
kidnapping? A child? Some child with "expectations"? In spite of the
large house out on the Larborough road they gave the impression of
having very little money. Or some child that they considered "ill-used"
by its natural guardians? That was possible. The old woman had a
fanatic's face, if ever he saw one; and Marion Sharpe herself looked as
if the stake would be her natural prop if stakes were not out of
fashion. Yes, it was probably some ill-judged piece of philanthropy.
Detention "with intent to deprive parent, guardian, etc., of its
possession." He wished he remembered more of his _Harris and Wilshere_.
He could not remember off-hand whether that was a felony, with penal
servitude in the offing, or a mere misdemeanour. "Abduction and
Detention" had not sullied the Blair, Hayward, and Bennet files since
December 1798, when the squire of Lessows, much flown with seasonable
claret, had taken the young Miss Gretton across his saddle-bow from a
ball at the Gretton home and ridden away with her through the floods;
and there was no doubt at all, of course, as to the squire's motive on
that occasion.

Ah, well; they would no doubt be open to reason now that they had been
startled by the irruption of Scotland Yard into their plans. He was a
little startled by Scotland Yard himself. Was the child so important
that it was a matter for Headquarters?

Round in Sin Lane he ran into the usual war but extricated himself.
(Etymologists, in case you are interested, say that the "Sin" is merely
a corruption of "sand," but the inhabitants of Milford of course know
better; before those council houses were built on the low meadows
behind the town the lane led direct to the lovers' walk in High Wood.)
Across the narrow lane, face to face in perpetual enmity, stood the
local livery stable and the town's newest garage. The garage frightened
the horses (so said the livery stable), and the livery stable blocked
up the lane continually with delivery loads of straw and fodder and
what not (so the garage said). Moreover the garage was run by Bill
Brough, ex-R.E.M.E., and Stanley Peters, ex-Royal Corps of Signals; and
old Matt Ellis, ex-King's Dragoon Guards, looked on them as
representatives of a generation which had destroyed the cavalry and an
offence to civilisation.

In winter, when he hunted, Robert heard the cavalry side of the story;
for the rest of the year he listened to the Royal Corps of Signals
while his car was being wiped, oiled, filled, or fetched. Today the
Signals wanted to know the difference between libel and slander, and
what exactly constituted defamation of character. Was it defamation of
character to say that a man was "a tinkerer with tin cans who wouldn't
know a nut from an acorn"?

"Don't know, Stan. Have to think over it," Robert said hastily,
pressing the starter. He waited while three tired hacks brought back
two fat children and a groom from their afternoon ride ("See what I
mean?" said Stanley in the background) and then swung the car into the
High Street.

Down at the south end of the High Street the shops faded gradually into
dwelling houses with doorsteps on the pavement, then to houses set back
a pace and with porticos to their doors, and then to villas with trees
in their gardens, and then, quite suddenly, to fields and open country.

It was farming country; a land of endless hedged fields and few houses.
A rich country, but lonely; one could travel mile after mile without
meeting another human being. Quiet and confident and unchanged since
the Wars of the Roses, hedged field succeeded hedged field, and skyline
faded into skyline, without any break in the pattern. Only the
telegraph posts betrayed the century.

Away beyond the horizon was Larborough. Larborough was bicycles, small
arms, tin-tacks, Cowan's Cranberry Sauce, and a million human souls
living cheek by jowl in dirty red brick; and periodically it broke
bounds in an atavistic longing for grass and earth. But there was
nothing in the Milford country to attract a race who demanded with
their grass and earth both views and tea-houses; when Larborough went
on holiday it went as one man west to the hills and the sea, and the
great stretch of country north and east of it stayed lonely and quiet
and unlittered as it had been in the days of the Sun in Splendour. It
was "dull"; and by that damnation was saved.

Two miles out on the Larborough road stood the house known as The
Franchise; set down by the roadside with the inconsequence of a
telephone kiosk. In the last days of the Regency someone had bought the
field known as The Franchise, built in the middle of it a flat white
house, and then surrounded the whole with a high solid wall of brick
with a large double gate, of wall height, in the middle of the road
frontage. It had no relation with anything in the countryside. No farm
buildings in the background; no side-gates, even, into the surrounding
fields. Stables were built in accordance with the period at the back of
the house, but they were inside the wall. The place was as irrelevant,
as isolated, as a child's toy dropped by the wayside. It had been
occupied as long as Robert could remember by an old man; presumably the
same old man, but since The Franchise people had always shopped at Ham
Green, the village on the Larborough side of them, they had never been
seen in Milford. And then Marion Sharpe and her mother had begun to be
part of the morning shopping scene in Milford, and it was understood
that they had inherited The Franchise when the old man died.

How long had they been there, Robert wondered. Three years? Four years?

That they had not entered Milford socially was nothing to reckon by.
Old Mrs. Warren, who had bought the first of the elm-shaded villas at
the end of the High Street a small matter of twenty-five years ago in
the hope that midland air would be better for her rheumatism than the
sea, was still referred to as "that lady from Weymouth." (It was
Swanage, incidentally.)

The Sharpes, moreover, might not have sought social contacts. They had
an odd air of being self-sufficient. He had seen the daughter once or
twice on the golf-course, playing (presumably as a guest) with Dr.
Borthwick. She drove a long ball like a man, and used her thin brown
wrists like a professional. And that was all Robert knew about her.

As he brought the car to a stop in front of the tall iron gates, he
found that two other cars were already there. It needed only one glance
at the nearer--so inconspicuous, so well-groomed, so discreet--to
identify it. In what other country in this world, he wondered as he got
out of his own car, does the police force take pains to be
well-mannered and quiet?

His eye lighted on the further car and he saw that it was Hallam's; the
local Inspector who played such a steady game on golf-course.

There were three people in the police car: the driver, and, in the
back, a middle-aged woman and what seemed to be either a child or a
young girl. The driver regarded him with that mild, absent-minded,
all-observing police eye, and then withdrew his gaze, but the faces in
the back he could not see.

The tall iron gates were shut--Robert could not remember ever seeing
them open--and Robert pushed open one heavy half with frank curiosity.
The iron lace of the original gates had been lined, in some Victorian
desire for privacy, by flat sheets of cast iron; and the wall was too
high for anything inside to be visible; so that, except for a distant
view of its roof and chimneys, he had never seen The Franchise.

His first feeling was disappointment. It was not the
fallen-on-evil-times look of the house--although that was evident; it
was the sheer ugliness of it. Either it had been built too late to
share in the grace of a graceful period, or the builder had lacked an
architect's eye. He had used the idiom of the time, but it had
apparently not been native to him. Everything was just a little wrong:
the windows the wrong size by half a foot, wrongly placed by not much
more; the doorway the wrong width, and the flight of steps the wrong
height. The total result was that instead of the bland contentment of
its period the house had a hard stare. An antagonistic, questioning
stare. As he walked across the courtyard to the unwelcoming door Robert
knew what it reminded him of: a dog that has been suddenly wakened from
sleep by the advent of a stranger, propped on his forelegs, uncertain
for a moment whether to attack or merely bark. It had the same
what-are-you-doing-here? expression.

Before he could ring the bell the door was opened; not by a maid but by
Marion Sharpe.

"I saw you coming," she said, putting out her hand. "I didn't want you
to ring because my mother lies down in the afternoons, and I am hoping
that we can get this business over before she wakes up. Then she need
never know anything about it. I am more grateful than I can say to you
for coming."

Robert murmured something, and noticed that her eyes, which he had
expected to be a bright gipsy brown, were actually a grey hazel. She
drew him into the hall, and he noticed as he put his hat down on a
chest that the rug on the floor was threadbare.

"The Law is in here," she said, pushing open a door and ushering him
into a drawing-room. Robert would have liked to talk to her alone for a
moment, to orientate himself; but it was too late now to suggest that.
This was evidently the way she wanted it.

Sitting on the edge of a bead-work chair was Hallam, looking sheepish.
And by the window, entirely at his ease in a very nice piece of
Hepplewhite, was Scotland Yard in the person of a youngish spare man in
a well-tailored suit.

As they got up, Hallam and Robert nodded to each other.

"You know Inspector Hallam, then?" Marion Sharpe said. "And this is
Detective-Inspector Grant, from Headquarters."

Robert noticed the "Headquarters," and wondered. Had she already at
some time had dealings with the police, or was it that she just didn't
like the slightly sensational sound of "the Yard"?

Grant shook hands, and said:

"I'm glad you've come, Mr. Blair. Not only for Miss Sharpe's sake but
for my own."


"I couldn't very well proceed until Miss Sharpe had some kind of
support; friendly support if not legal, but if legal so much the

"I see. And what are you charging her with?"

"We are not charging her with anything----" Grant began, but Marion
interrupted him.

"I am supposed to have kidnapped and beaten up someone."

"_Beaten up_?" Robert said, staggered.

"Yes," she said, with a kind of relish in enormity. "Beaten her black
and blue."


"A girl. She is outside the gate in a car now."

"I think we had better begin at the beginning," Robert said, clutching
after the normal.

"Perhaps I had better do the explaining," Grant said, mildly.

"Yes," said Miss Sharpe, "do. After all it is your story."

Robert wondered if Grant were aware of the mockery. He wondered a
little, too, at the coolness that could afford mockery with Scotland
Yard sitting in one of her best chairs. She had not sounded cool over
the telephone; she had sounded driven, half-desperate. Perhaps it was
the presence of an ally that had heartened her; or perhaps she had just
got her second wind.

"Just before Easter," Grant began, in succinct police-fashion, "a girl
called Elisabeth Kane, who lived with her guardians near Aylesbury,
went to spend a short holiday with a married aunt in Mainshill, the
suburb of Larborough. She went by coach, because the London-Larborough
coaches pass through Aylesbury, and also pass through Mainshill before
reaching Larborough; so that she could get off the coach in Mainshill
and be within a three-minute walk of her aunt's house, instead of
having to go into Larborough and come all the way out again as she
would have to if she travelled by train. At the end of a week her
guardians--a Mr. and Mrs. Wynn--had a postcard from her saying that she
was enjoying herself very much and was staying on. They took this to
mean staying on for the duration of her school holiday, which would
mean another three weeks. When she didn't turn up on the day before she
was supposed to go back to school, they took it for granted that she
was merely playing truant and wrote to her aunt to send her back. The
aunt, instead of going to the nearest call-box or telegraph office,
broke it to the Wynns in a letter, that her niece had left on her way
back to Aylesbury a fortnight previously. The exchange of letters had
taken the best part of another week, so that by the time the guardians
went to the police about it the girl had been missing for four weeks.
The police took all the usual measures but before they could really get
going the girl turned up. She walked into her home near Aylesbury late
one night wearing only a dress and shoes, and in a state of complete

"How old is the girl?" Robert asked.

"Fifteen. Nearly sixteen." He waited a moment to see if Robert had
further questions, and then went on. (As one counsel to another,
thought Robert appreciatively; a manner to match the car that stood so
unobtrusively at the gate.) "She said she had been 'kidnapped' in a
car, but that was all the information anyone got from her for two days.
She lapsed into a semi-conscious condition. When she recovered, about
forty-eight hours later, they began to get her story from her."


"The Wynns. The police wanted it, of course, but she grew hysterical at
any mention of police, so they had to acquire it second-hand. She said
that while she was waiting for her return coach at the cross-roads in
Mainshill, a car pulled up at the kerb with two women in it. The
younger woman, who was driving, asked her if she was waiting for a bus
and if they could give her a lift."

"Was the girl alone?"


"Why? Didn't anyone go to see her off?"

"Her uncle was working, and her aunt had gone to be godmother at a
christening." Again he paused to let Robert put further questions if he
was so minded. "The girl said that she was waiting for the London
coach, and they told her that it had already gone by. Since she had
arrived at the cross-roads with very little time to spare, and her
watch was not a particularly accurate one, she believed this. Indeed,
she had begun to be afraid, even before the car stopped, that she had
missed the coach. She was distressed about it because it was by then
four o'clock, beginning to rain, and growing dark. They were very
sympathetic, and suggested that they should give her a lift to a place
whose name she did not catch, where she could get a different coach to
London in half an hour's time. She accepted this gratefully and got in
beside the elder woman in the back of the car."

A picture swam into Robert's mind of old Mrs. Sharpe, upright and
intimidating, in her usual place in the back of the car. He glanced at
Marion Sharpe, but her face was calm. This was a story she had heard

"The rain blurred the windows, and she talked to the older woman about
herself as they went along, so that she paid little attention to where
they were going. When she at last took notice of her surroundings the
evening outside the windows had become quite dark and it seemed to her
that they had been travelling for a long time. She said something about
its being extraordinarily kind of them to take her so far out of their
way, and the younger woman, speaking for the first time, said that as
it happened it was not out of their way, and that, on the contrary, she
would have time to come in and have a cup of something hot with them
before they took her on to her new cross-roads. She was doubtful about
this, but the younger woman said it would be of no advantage to wait
for twenty minutes in the rain when she could be warm and dry and fed
in those same twenty minutes; and she agreed that this seemed sensible.
Eventually the younger woman got out, opened what appeared to the girl
to be drive gates, and the car was driven up to a house which it was
too dark to see. She was taken into a large kitchen----"

"A kitchen?" Robert repeated.

"Yes, a kitchen. The older woman put some cold coffee on the stove to
heat while the younger one cut sandwiches. 'Sandwiches without tops,'
the girl called them."


"Yes. While they ate and drank, the younger woman told her that they
had no maid at the moment and asked her if she would like to be a maid
for them for a little. She said that she wouldn't. They tried
persuasion, but she stuck to it that that was not at all the kind of
job she would take. Their faces began to grow blurred as she talked,
and when they suggested that she might at least come upstairs and see
what a nice bedroom she would have if she stayed she was too fuddled in
her mind to do anything but follow their suggestion. She remembers
going up a first flight with a carpet, and a second flight with what
she calls 'something hard' underfoot, and that was all she remembered
until she woke in daylight on a truckle bed in a bare little attic. She
was wearing only her slip, and there was no sign of the rest of her
clothes. The door was locked, and the small round window would not
open. In any case----"

"_Round_ window!" said Robert, uncomfortably.

But it was Marion who answered him. "Yes," she said, meaningly. "A
round window up in the roof."

Since his last thought as he came to her front door a few minutes ago
had been how badly placed was the little round window in the roof,
there seemed to Robert to be no adequate comment. Grant made his usual
pause for courtesy's sake, and went on.

"Presently the younger woman arrived with a bowl of porridge. The girl
refused it and demanded her clothes and her release. The woman said
that she would eat it when she was hungry enough and went away, leaving
the porridge behind. She was alone till evening, when the same woman
brought her tea on a tray with fresh cakes and tried to talk her into
giving the maid's job a trial. The girl again refused, and for days,
according to her story, this alternate coaxing and bullying went on,
sometimes by one of the women and sometimes by the other. Then she
decided that if she could break the small round window she might be
able to crawl out of it on to the roof, which was protected by a
parapet, and call the attention of some passerby, or some visiting
tradesman, to her plight. Unfortunately, her only implement was a
chair, and she had managed only to crack the glass before the younger
woman interrupted her, in a great passion. She snatched the chair from
the girl and belaboured her with it until she was breathless. She went
away, taking the chair with her, and the girl thought that was the end
of it. But in a few moments the woman came back with what the girl
thinks was a dog whip and beat her until she fainted. Next day the
older woman appeared with an armful of bed-linen and said that if she
would not work she would at least sew. No sewing, no food. She was too
stiff to sew and so had no food. The following day she was threatened
with another beating if she did not sew. So she mended some of the
linen and was given stew for supper. This arrangement lasted for some
time, but if her sewing was bad or insufficient, she was either beaten
or deprived of food. Then one evening the older woman brought the usual
bowl of stew and went away leaving the door unlocked. The girl waited,
thinking it was a trap that would end in another beating; but in the
end she ventured on to the landing. There was no sound, and she ran
down a flight of uncarpeted stairs. Then down a second flight to the
first landing. Now she could hear the two women talking in the kitchen.
She crept down the last flight and dashed for the door. It was unlocked
and she ran out just as she was into the night."

"In her slip?" Robert asked.

"I forgot to say that the slip had been exchanged for her dress. There
was no heating in the attic, and in nothing but a slip she would
probably have died."

"If she ever was in an attic," Robert said.

"If, as you say, she ever was in an attic," the Inspector agreed
smoothly. And without his customary pause of courtesy went on: "She
does not remember much after that. She walked a great distance in the
dark, she says. It seemed a highroad but there was no traffic and she
met no one. Then, on a main road, some time later, a lorry driver saw
her in his headlight and stopped to give her a lift. She was so tired
that she fell straight asleep. She woke as she was being set on her
feet at the roadside. The lorry driver was laughing at her and saying
that she was like a sawdust doll that had lost its stuffing. It seemed
to be still night time. The lorry driver said this was where she said
she wanted to be put off, and drove away. After a little she recognised
the corner. It was less than two miles from her home. She heard a clock
strike eleven. And shortly before midnight she arrived home."


There was a short silence.

"And this is the girl who is sitting in a car outside the gate of The
Franchise at this moment?" said Robert.


"I take it that you have reasons for bringing her here."

"Yes. When the girl had recovered sufficiently she was induced to tell
her story to the police. It was taken down in shorthand as she told it,
and she read the typed version and signed it. In that statement there
were two things that helped the police a lot. These are the relevant

    'When we had been going for some time we passed a bus that had
    MILFORD in a lighted sign on it. No, I don't know where Milford is.
    No, I have never been there.'

"That is one. The other is:

    'From the window of the attic I could see a high brick wall with a
    big iron gate in the middle of it. There was a road on the further
    side of the wall, because I could see the telegraph posts. No, I
    couldn't see the traffic on it because the wall was too high. Just
    the tops of lorry loads sometimes. You couldn't see through the
    gate because it had sheets of iron on the inside. Inside the gate
    the carriage way went straight for a little and then divided in two
    into a circle up to the door. No, it wasn't a garden, just grass.
    Yes, lawn, I suppose. No, I don't remember any shrubs; just the
    grass and the paths.'"

Grant shut the little notebook he had been quoting from.

"As far as we know--and the search has been thorough--there is no other
house between Larborough and Milford which fulfils the girl's
description except The Franchise. The Franchise, moreover, fulfils it
in every particular. When the girl saw the wall and the gate today she
was sure that this was the place; but she has not so far seen inside
the gate, of course. I had first to explain matters to Miss Sharpe, and
find out if she was willing to be confronted with the girl. She very
rightly suggested that some legal witness should be present."

"Do you wonder that I wanted help in a hurry?" Marion Sharpe said,
turning to Robert. "Can you imagine a more nightmare piece of

"The girl's story is certainly the oddest mixture of the factual and
the absurd. I know that domestic help is scarce," Robert said, "but
would anyone hope to enlist a servant by forcibly detaining her, to say
nothing of beating and starving her."

"No normal person, of course," Grant agreed, keeping his eye steadily
fixed on Robert's so that it had no tendency to slide over to Marion
Sharpe. "But believe me in my first twelve months in the force I had
come across a dozen things much more incredible. There is no end to the
extravagances of human conduct."

"I agree; but the extravagance is just as likely to be in the girl's
conduct. After all, the extravagance begins with her. She is the one
who has been missing for----" He paused in question.

"A month," Grant supplied.

"For a month; while there is no suggestion that the household at The
Franchise has varied at all from its routine. Would it not be possible
for Miss Sharpe to provide an alibi for the day in question?"

"No," Marion Sharpe said. "The day, according to the Inspector, is the
28th of March. That is a long time ago, and our days here vary very
little, if at all. It would be quite impossible for us to remember what
we were doing on March the 28th--and most unlikely that anyone would
remember for us."

"Your maid?" Robert suggested. "Servants have ways of marking their
domestic life that is often surprising."

"We have no maid," she said. "We find it difficult to keep one: The
Franchise is so isolated."

The moment threatened to become awkward and Robert hastened to break

"This girl--I don't know her name, by the way."

"Elisabeth Kane; known as Betty Kane."

"Oh, yes; you did tell me. I'm sorry. This girl--may we know something
about her? I take it that the police have investigated her before
accepting so much of her story. Why guardians and not parents, for

"She is a war orphan. She was evacuated to the Aylesbury district as a
small child. She was an only child, and was billeted with the Wynns,
who had a boy four years older. About twelve months later both parents
were killed, in the same 'incident,' and the Wynns, who had always
wanted a daughter and were very fond of the child, were glad to keep
her. She looks on them as her parents, since she can hardly remember
the real ones."

"I see. And her record?"

"Excellent. A very quiet girl, by every account. Good at her school
work but not brilliant. Has never been in any kind of trouble, in
school or out of it. 'Transparently truthful' was the phrase her form
mistress used about her."

"When she eventually turned up at her home, after her absence, was
there any evidence of the beatings she said she had been given?"

"Oh, yes. Very definitely. The Wynns' own doctor saw her early next
morning, and his statement is that she had been very extensively
knocked about. Indeed, some of the bruises were still visible much
later when she made her statement to us."

"No history of epilepsy?"

"No; we considered that very early in the inquiry. I should like to say
that the Wynns are very sensible people. They have been greatly
distressed, but they have not tried to dramatise the affair, or allowed
the girl to be an object of interest or pity. They have taken the
affair admirably."

"And all that remains is for me to take my end of it with the same
admirable detachment," Marion Sharpe said.

"You see my position, Miss Sharpe. The girl not only describes the
house in which she says she was detained; she describes the two
inhabitants--and describes them very accurately. 'A thin, elderly woman
with soft white hair and no hat, dressed in black; and a much younger
woman, thin and tall and dark like a gipsy, with no hat and a bright
silk scarf round her neck.'"

"Oh, yes. I can think of no explanation, but I understand your
position. And now I think we had better have the girl in, but before we
do I should like to say----"

The door opened noiselessly, and old Mrs. Sharpe appeared on the
threshold. The short pieces of white hair round her face stood up on
end, as her pillow had left them, and she looked more than ever like a

She pushed the door to behind her and surveyed the gathering with a
malicious interest.

"Hah!" she said, making a sound like the throaty squawk of a hen.
"_Three_ strange men!"

"Let me present them, Mother," Marion said, as the three got to their

"This is Mr. Blair, of Blair, Hayward, and Bennet--the firm who have
that lovely house at the top of the High Street."

As Robert bowed the old woman fixed him with her seagull's eye.

"Needs re-tiling," she said.

It did, but it was not the greeting he had expected.

It comforted him a little that her greeting to Grant was even more
unorthodox. Far from being impressed or agitated by the presence of
Scotland Yard in her drawing-room of a spring afternoon, she merely
said in her dry voice: "You should not be sitting in that chair; you
are much too heavy for it."

When her daughter introduced the local Inspector she cast one glance at
him, moved her head an inch, and quite obviously dismissed him from
further consideration. This, Hallam, to judge by his expression, found
peculiarly shattering.

Grant looked inquiringly at Miss Sharpe.

"I'll tell her," she said. "Mother, the Inspector wants us to see a
young girl who is waiting in a car outside the gate. She was missing
from her home near Aylesbury for a month, and when she turned up
again--in a distressed condition--she said that she had been detained
by people who wanted to make a servant of her. They kept her locked up
when she refused, and beat and starved her. She described the place and
the people minutely, and it so happens that you and I fit the
description admirably. So does our house. The suggestion is that she
was detained up in our attic with the round window."

"Remarkably interesting," said the old lady, seating herself with
deliberation on an Empire sofa. "What did we beat her with?"

"A dog whip, I understand."

"Have we got a dog whip?"

"We have one of those 'lead' things, I think. They make a whip if
necessary. But the point is, the Inspector would like us to meet this
girl, so that she can say if we are the people who detained her or

"Have you any objections, Mrs. Sharpe?" Grant asked.

"On the contrary, Inspector. I look forward to the meeting with
impatience. It is not every afternoon, I assure you, that I go to my
rest a dull old woman and rise a potential monster."

"Then if you will excuse me, I shall bring----"

Hallam made a motion, offering himself as messenger, but Grant shook
his head. It was obvious that he wanted to be present when the girl
first saw what was beyond the gate.

As the Inspector went out Marion Sharpe explained Blair's presence to
her mother. "It was extraordinarily kind of him to come at such short
notice and so quickly," she added, and Robert felt again the impact of
that bright pale old eye. For his money, old Mrs. Sharpe was quite
capable of beating seven different people between breakfast and lunch,
any day of the week.

"You have my sympathy, Mr. Blair," she said, unsympathetically.

"Why, Mrs. Sharpe?"

"I take it that Broadmoor is a little out of your line."


"Criminal lunacy."

"I find it extraordinarily stimulating," Robert said, refusing to be
bullied by her.

This drew a flash of appreciation from her; something that was like the
shadow of a smile. Robert had the odd feeling that she suddenly liked
him; but if so she was making no verbal confession of it. Her dry voice
said tartly: "Yes, I expect the distractions of Milford are scarce and
mild. My daughter pursues a piece of gutta-percha round the golf

"It is not gutta-percha any more, Mother," her daughter put in.

"But at my age Milford does not provide even that distraction. I am
reduced to pouring weedkiller on weeds--a legitimate form of sadism on
a par with drowning fleas. Do you drown your fleas, Mr. Blair?"

"No, I squash them. But I have a sister who used to pursue them with a
cake of soap."

"Soap?" said Mrs. Sharpe, with genuine interest.

"I understand that she hit them with the soft side and they stuck to

"How _very_ interesting. A technique I have not met before. I must try
that next time."

With his other ear he heard that Marion was being nice to the snubbed
Inspector. "You play a very good game, Inspector," she was saying.

He was conscious of the feeling you get near the end of a dream, when
waking is just round the corner, that none of the inconsequence really
matters because presently you'll be back in the real world.

This was misleading because the real world came through the door with
the return of Inspector Grant. Grant came in first, so that he was in a
position to see the expressions on all the faces concerned, and held
the door open for a police matron and a girl.

Marion Sharpe stood up slowly, as if the better to face anything that
might be coming to her, but her mother remained seated on the sofa as
one giving an audience, her Victorian back as flat as it had been as a
young girl, her hands lying composedly in her lap. Even her wild hair
could not detract from the impression that she was mistress of the

The girl was wearing her school coat, and childish low-heeled clumpish
black school shoes; and consequently looked younger than Blair had
anticipated. She was not very tall, and certainly not pretty. But she
had--what was the word?--appeal. Her eyes, a darkish blue, were set
wide apart in a face of the type popularly referred to as heart-shaped.
Her hair was mouse-coloured, but grew off her forehead in a good line.
Below each cheek-bone a slight hollow, a miracle of delicate modelling,
gave the face charm and pathos. Her lower lip was full, but the mouth
was too small. So were her ears. Too small and too close to her head.

An ordinary sort of girl, after all. Not the sort you would notice in a
crowd. Not at all the type to be the heroine of a sensation. Robert
wondered what she would look like in other clothes.

The girl's glance rested first on the old woman, and then went on to
Marion. The glance held neither surprise nor triumph, and not much

"Yes, these are the women," she said.

"You have no doubt about it?" Grant asked her, and added: "It is a very
grave accusation, you know."

"No, I have no doubt. How could I?"

"These two ladies are the women who detained you, took your clothes
from you, forced you to mend linen, and whipped you?"

"Yes, these are the women."

"A remarkable liar," said old Mrs. Sharpe, in the tone in which one
says: "A remarkable likeness."

"You say that we took you into the kitchen for coffee," Marion said.

"Yes, you did."

"Can you describe the kitchen?"

"I didn't pay much attention. It was a big one--with a stone floor, I
think--and a row of bells."

"What kind of stove?"

"I didn't notice the stove, but the pan the old woman heated the coffee
in was a pale blue enamel one with a dark blue edge and a lot of chips
off round the bottom edge."

"I doubt if there is any kitchen in England that hasn't a pan exactly
like that," Marion said. "We have three of them."

"Is the girl a virgin?" asked Mrs. Sharpe, in the mildly interested
tone of a person inquiring: "Is it a Chanel?"

In the startled pause that this produced Robert was aware of Hallam's
scandalised face, the hot blood running up into the girl's, and the
fact that there was no protesting "Mother!" from the daughter as he
unconsciously, but confidently, expected. He wondered whether her
silence was tacit approval, or whether after a lifetime with Mrs.
Sharpe she was shock-proof.

Grant said in cold reproof that the matter was irrelevant.

"You think so?" said the old lady. "If I had been missing for a month
from my home it is the first thing that my mother would have wanted to
know about me. However. Now that the girl has identified us, what do
you propose to do? Arrest us?"

"Oh, no. Things are a long way from that at the moment. I want to take
Miss Kane to the kitchen and the attic, so that her descriptions of
them can be verified. If they are, I report on the case to my superior
and he decides in conference what further steps to take."

"I see. A most admirable caution, Inspector." She rose slowly to her
feet. "Ah, well, if you will excuse me I shall go back to my
interrupted rest."

"But don't you want to be present when Miss Kane inspects--to hear
the----" blurted Grant, surprised for once out of his composure.

"Oh, dear, no." She smoothed down her black gown with a slight frown.
"They split invisible atoms," she remarked testily, "but no one so far
has invented a material that does not crease. I have not the faintest
doubt," she went on, "that Miss Kane will identify the attic. Indeed I
should be surprised beyond belief if she failed to."

She began to move towards the door, and consequently towards the girl;
and for the first time the girl's eyes lit with expression. A spasm of
alarm crossed her face. The police matron came forward a step,
protectively. Mrs. Sharpe continued her unhurried progress and came to
rest a yard or so from the girl, so that they were face to face. For a
full five seconds there was silence while she examined the girl's face
with interest.

"For two people who are on beating terms, we are distressingly ill
acquainted," she said at last. "I hope to know you much better before
this affair is finished, Miss Kane." She turned to Robert and bowed.
"Goodbye, Mr. Blair. I hope you will continue to find us stimulating."
And, ignoring the rest of the gathering, she walked out of the door
that Hallam held open for her.

There was a distinct feeling of anti-climax now that she was no longer
there, and Robert paid her the tribute of a reluctant admiration. It
was no small achievement to steal the interest from an outraged

"You have no objections to letting Miss Kane see the relevant parts of
the house, Miss Sharpe?" Grant asked.

"Of course not. But before we go further I should like to say what I
was going to say before you brought Miss Kane in. I am glad that Miss
Kane is present to hear it now. It is this. I have never to my
knowledge seen this girl before. I did not give her a lift anywhere, on
any occasion. She was not brought into this house either by me or by my
mother, nor was she kept here. I should like that to be clearly

"Very well, Miss Sharpe. It is understood that your attitude is a
complete denial of the girl's story."

"A complete denial from beginning to end. And now, will you come and
see the kitchen?"


Grant and the girl accompanied Robert and Marion Sharpe on the
inspection of the house, while Hallam and the police matron waited in
the drawing-room. As they reached the first-floor landing, after the
girl had identified the kitchen, Robert said:

"Miss Kane said that the second flight of stairs was covered in
'something hard,' but the same carpet continues up from the first

"Only to the curve," Marion said. "The bit that 'shows.' Round the
corner it is drugget. A Victorian way of economising. Nowadays if you
are poor you buy less expensive carpet and use it all the way up. But
those were still the days when what the neighbours thought mattered. So
the lush stuff went as far as eye could see and no further."

The girl had been right about the third flight, too. The treads of the
short flight to the attic were bare.

The all-important attic was a low square little box of a room, with the
ceiling slanting abruptly down on three sides in conformity with the
slate roof outside. It was lit only by the round window looking out to
the front. A short stretch of slates sloped from below the window to
the low white parapet. The window was divided into four panes, one of
which showed a badly starred crack. It had never been made to open.

The attic was completely bare of furnishing. Unnaturally bare, Robert
thought, for so convenient and accessible a store-room.

"There used to be stuff here when we first came," Marion said, as if
answering him. "But when we found that we should be without help half
the time we got rid of it."

Grant turned to the girl with a questioning air.

"The bed was in that corner," she said, pointing to the corner away
from the window. "And next it was the wooden commode. And in this
corner behind the door there were three empty travelling-cases--two
suitcases and a trunk with a flat top. There was a chair but she took
it away after I tried to break the window." She referred to Marion
without emotion, as if she were not present. "There is where I tried to
break the window."

It seemed to Robert that the crack looked much more than a few weeks
old; but there was no denying that the crack was there.

Grant crossed to the far corner and bent to examine the bare floor, but
it did not need close examination. Even from where he was standing by
the door Robert could see the marks of castors on the floor where the
bed had stood.

"There was a bed there," Marion said. "It was one of the things we got
rid of."

"What did you do with it?"

"Let me think. Oh, we gave it to the cowman's wife over at Staples
Farm. Her eldest boy got too big to share a room with the others any
more and she put him up in their loft. We get our dairy stuff from
Staples. You can't see it from here but it is only four fields away
over the rise."

"Where do you keep your spare trunks, Miss Sharpe? Have you another

For the first time Marion hesitated. "We do have a large square trunk
with a flat top, but my mother uses it to store things in. When we
inherited The Franchise there was a very valuable tallboy in the
bedroom my mother has, and we sold it, and used the big trunk instead.
With a chintz cover on it. My suitcases I keep in the cupboard on the
first-floor landing."

"Miss Kane, do you remember what the cases looked like?"

"Oh, yes. One was a brown leather with those sort-of caps at the
corners, and the other was one of those American-looking canvas-covered
ones with stripes."

Well, that was definite enough.

Grant examined the room a little longer, studied the view from the
window, and then turned to go.

"May we see the suitcases in the cupboard?" he asked Marion.

"Certainly," Marion said, but she seemed unhappy.

On the lower landing she opened the cupboard door and stood back to let
the Inspector look. As Robert moved out of their way he caught the
unguarded flash of triumph on the girl's face. It so altered her calm,
rather childish, face that it shocked him. It was a savage emotion,
primitive and cruel. And very startling on the face of a demure
schoolgirl who was the pride of her guardians and preceptors.

The cupboard contained shelves bearing household linen, and on the
floor four suitcases. Two were expanding ones, one of pressed fibre and
one of rawhide; the other two were: a brown cowhide with protected
corners, and a square canvas-covered hatbox with a broad band of
multi-coloured stripes down the middle.

"Are these the cases?" Grant asked.

"Yes," the girl said. "Those two."

"I am not going to disturb my mother again this afternoon," Marion
said, with sudden anger. "I acknowledge that the trunk in her room is
large and flat-topped. It has been there without interruption for the
last three years."

"Very good, Miss Sharpe. And now the garage, if you please."

Down at the back of the house, where the stables had been converted
long ago into garage, the little group stood and surveyed the battered
old grey car. Grant read out the girl's untechnical description of it
as recorded in her statement. It fitted, but it would fit equally well
at least a thousand cars on the roads of Britain today, Blair thought.
It was hardly evidence at all. "'One of the wheels was painted a
different shade from the others and didn't look as if it belonged. The
different wheel was the one in front on my side as it was standing at
the pavement,'" Grant finished.

In silence the four people looked at the darker grey of the near front
wheel. There seemed nothing to say.

"Thank you very much, Miss Sharpe," Grant said at length, shutting his
notebook and putting it away. "You have been very courteous and helpful
and I am grateful to you. I shall be able to get you on the telephone
any time in the next few days, I suppose, if I want to talk to you

"Oh, yes, Inspector. We have no intention of going anywhere."

If Grant was aware of her too-ready comprehension he did not show it.

He handed over the girl to the matron and they left without a backward
glance. Then he and Hallam took their leave, Hallam still with an air
of apologising for trespass.

Marion had gone out into the hall with them, leaving Blair in the
drawing-room, and when she came back she was carrying a tray with
sherry and glasses.

"I don't ask you to stay for dinner," she said, putting down the tray
and beginning to pour the wine, "partly because our 'dinner' is usually
a very scratch supper and not at all what you are used to. (Did you
know that your aunt's meals are famous in Milford? Even I had heard
about them.) And partly because--well, because, as my mother said,
Broadmoor is a little out of your line, I expect."

"About that," Robert said. "You do realise, don't you, that the girl
has an enormous advantage over you. In the matter of evidence, I mean.
She is free to describe almost any object she likes as being part of
your household. If it happens to be there, that is strong evidence for
her. If it happens not to be there, that is not evidence for you; the
inference is merely that you have got rid of it. If the suitcases, for
instance, had not been there, she could say that you had got rid of
them because they had been in the attic and could be described."

"But she did describe them, without ever having seen them."

"She described two suitcases, you mean. If your four suitcases had been
a matching set she would have only one chance in perhaps five of being
right. But because you happened to have one of each of the common kinds
her chances worked out at about even."

He picked up the glass of sherry that she had set down beside him, took
a mouthful, and was astonished to find it admirable.

She smiled a little at him and said: "We economise, but not on wine,"
and he flushed slightly, wondering if his surprise had been as obvious
as that.

"But there was the odd wheel of the car. How did she know about that?
The whole set-up is extraordinary. How did she know about my mother and
me, and what the house looked like? Our gates are never open. Even if
she opened them--though what she could be doing on that lonely road I
can't imagine--even if she opened them and looked inside she would not
know about my mother and me."

"No chance of her having made friends with a maid? Or a gardener?"

"We have never had a gardener, because there is nothing but grass. And
we have not had a maid for a year. Just a girl from the farm who comes
in once a week and does the rough cleaning."

Robert said sympathetically that it was a big house to have on her
hands unaided.

"Yes; but two things help. I am not a house-proud woman. And it is
still so wonderful to have a home of our own that I am willing to put
up with the disadvantages. Old Mr. Crowle was my father's cousin, but
we didn't know him at all. My mother and I had always lived in a
Kensington boarding-house." One corner of her mouth moved up in a wry
smile. "You can imagine how popular Mother was with the residents." The
smile faded. "My father died when I was very little. He was one of
those optimists who are always going to be rich tomorrow. When he found
one day that his speculations had not left even enough for a loaf of
bread on the morrow, he committed suicide and left Mother to face

Robert felt that this to some extent explained Mrs. Sharpe.

"I was not trained for a profession, so my life has been spent in
odd-jobs. Not domestic ones--I loathe domesticity--but helping in those
lady-like businesses that abound in Kensington. Lampshades, or advising
on holidays, or flowers, or bric-à-brac. When old Mr. Crowle died I was
working in a tea-shop--one of those morning-coffee gossip shops. Yes,
it is a little difficult."

"What is?"

"To imagine me among the tea-cups."

Robert, unused to having his mind read--Aunt Lin was incapable of
following anyone's mental processes even when they were explained to
her--was disconcerted. But she was not thinking of him.

"We had just begun to feel settled down, and at home, and safe, when
this happened."

For the first time since she had asked his help Robert felt the
stirring of partisanship. "And all because a slip of a girl needs an
alibi," he said. "We must find out more about Betty Kane."

"I can tell you one thing about her. She is over-sexed."

"Is that just feminine intuition?"

"No. I am not very feminine and I have no intuition. But I have never
known anyone--man or woman--with that colour of eye who wasn't. That
opaque dark blue, like a very faded navy--it's infallible."

Robert smiled at her indulgently. She was very feminine after all.

"And don't feel superior because it happens not to be lawyers' logic,"
she added. "Have a look round at your own friends, and see."

Before he could stop himself he thought of Gerald Blunt, the Milford
scandal. Assuredly Gerald had slate-blue eyes. So had Arthur Wallis,
the potman at The White Hart, who was paying three different monetary
levies weekly. So had---- Damn the woman, she had no right to make a
silly generalisation like that and be right about it.

"It is fascinating to speculate on what she really did during that
month," Marion said. "It affords me intense satisfaction that someone
beat her black and blue. At least there is one person in this world who
has arrived at a correct estimate of her. I hope I meet him someday, so
that I may shake his hand."


"With those eyes it is bound to be a 'him'."

"Well," Robert said, preparing to go, "I doubt very much whether Grant
has a case that he will want to present in court. It would be the
girl's word against yours, with no other backing on either side.
Against _you_ would be her statement; so detailed, so circumstantial.
Against her would be the inherent unlikeliness of the story. I don't
think he could hope to get a verdict."

"But the thing is there, whether he brings it into court or not. And
not only in the files of Scotland Yard. Sooner or later a thing like
that begins to be whispered about. It would be no comfort to us not to
have the thing cleared up."

"Oh, it will be cleared up, if I have anything to do with it. But I
think we wait for a day or two to see what the Yard mean to do about
it. They have far better facilities for arriving at the truth than we
are ever likely to have."

"Coming from a lawyer, that is a touching tribute to the honesty of the

"Believe me, truth may be a virtue, but Scotland Yard discovered long
ago that it is a business asset. It doesn't pay them to be satisfied
with anything less."

"If he _did_ bring it to court," she said, coming to the door with him,
"and _did_ get a verdict, what would that mean for us?"

"I'm not sure whether it would be two years' imprisonment or seven
years penal servitude. I told you I was a broken reed where criminal
procedure is concerned. But I shall look it up."

"Yes, do," she said. "There's quite a difference."

He decided that he liked her habit of mockery. Especially in the face
of a criminal charge.

"Goodbye," she said. "It was kind of you to come. You have been a great
comfort to me."

And Robert, remembering how nearly he had thrown her to Ben Carley,
blushed to himself as he walked to the gate.


"Have you had a busy day, dear?" Aunt Lin asked, opening her table
napkin and arranging it across her plump lap.

This was a sentence that made sense but had no meaning. It was as much
an overture to dinner as the spreading of her napkin, and the
exploratory movement of her right foot as she located the footstool
which compensated for her short legs. She expected no answer; or
rather, being unaware that she had asked the question, she did not
listen to his answer.

Robert looked up the table at her with a more conscious benevolence
than usual. After his uncharted step-picking at The Franchise, the
serenity of Aunt Lin's presence was very comforting, and he looked with
a new awareness at the solid little figure with the short neck and the
round pink face and the iron-grey hair that frizzed out from its large
hairpins. Linda Bennet led a life of recipes, film stars, god-children,
and church bazaars, and found it perfect. Well-being and contentment
enveloped her like a cloak. She read the Women's Page of the daily
paper (How To Make A Boutonnière From Old Kid Gloves) and nothing else
as far as Robert was aware. Occasionally when she tidied away the paper
that Robert had left lying about, she would pause to read the headlines
and comment on them. ("MAN ENDS EIGHTY-TWO DAY FAST"--Silly creature!
"OIL DISCOVERY IN BAHAMAS"--Did I tell you that paraffin is up a penny,
dear?) But she gave the impression of never really believing that the
world the papers reported did in fact exist. The world for Aunt Lin
began with Robert Blair and ended within a ten-mile radius of him.

"What kept you so late tonight, dear?" she asked, having finished her

From long experience Robert recognised this as being in a different
category from: "Have you had a busy day, dear?"

"I had to go out to The Franchise--that house on the Larborough road.
They wanted some legal advice."

"Those odd people? I didn't know you knew them."

"I didn't. They just wanted my advice."

"I hope they pay you for it, dear. They have no money at all, you know.
The father was in some kind of importing business--monkey-nuts or
something--and drank himself to death. Left them without a penny, poor
things. Old Mrs. Sharpe ran a boarding-house in London to make ends
meet, and the daughter was maid-of-all-work. They were just going to be
turned into the street with their furniture, when the old man at The
Franchise died. So providential!"

"Aunt Lin! Where do you get those stories?"

"But it's true, dear. Perfectly true. I forget who told me--someone who
had stayed in the same street in London--but it was first-hand, anyhow.
I am not one to pass on idle gossip, as you know. Is it a nice house? I
always wondered what was inside that iron gate."

"No, rather ugly. But they have some nice pieces of furniture."

"Not as well kept as ours, I'll be bound," she said, looking
complacently at the perfect sideboard and the beautiful chairs ranged
against the wall. "The vicar said yesterday that if this house were not
so obviously a home it would be a show place." Mention of the clergy
seemed to remind her of something. "By the way, will you be extra
patient with Christina for the next few days. I think she is going to
be 'saved' again."

"Oh, poor Aunt Lin, what a bore for you. But I was afraid of it. There
was a 'text' in the saucer of my early-morning tea today. 'Thou God
seest me' on a pink scroll, with a tasteful design of Easter lilies in
the background. Is she changing her church again, then?"

"Yes. She has discovered that the Methodists are 'whited sepulchres,'
it seems, so she is going to those 'Bethel' people above Benson's
bakery, and is due to be 'saved' any day now. She has been shouting
hymns all the morning."

"But she always does."

"Not 'sword of the Lord' ones. As long as she sticks to 'pearly crowns'
or 'streets of gold' I know it is all right. But once she begins on the
'sword of the Lord' I know that it will be my turn to do the baking

"Well, darling, you bake just as well as Christina."

"Oh, no, she doesn't," said Christina, coming in with the meat course.
A big soft creature with untidy straight hair and a vague eye. "Only
one thing your Aunt Lin makes better than me, Mr. Robert, and that's
hot cross buns, and that's only once a year. So there! And if I'm not
appreciated in this house, I'll go where I will be."

"Christina, my love!" Robert said, "you know very well that no one
could imagine this house without you, and if you left I should follow
you to the world's end. For your butter tarts, if for nothing else. Can
we have butter tarts tomorrow, by the way?"

"Butter tarts are no food for unrepentant sinners. Besides I don't
think I have the butter. But we'll see. Meanwhile, Mr. Robert, you
examine your soul and stop casting stones."

Aunt Lin sighed gently as the door closed behind her. "Twenty years,"
she said meditatively. "You won't remember her when she first came from
the orphanage. Fifteen, and so skinny, poor little brat. She ate a
whole loaf for her tea, and said she would pray for me all her life. I
think she has, you know."

Something like a tear glistened in Miss Bennet's blue eye.

"I hope she postpones the salvation until she has made those butter
tarts," said Robert, brutally materialistic. "Did you enjoy your

"Well, dear, I couldn't forget that he had five wives."

"Who has?"

"_Had_, dear. One at a time. Gene Darrow. I must say, those little
programmes they give away are very informative but a little
disillusioning. He was a student, you see. In the picture, I mean. Very
young and romantic. But I kept remembering those five wives, and it
spoiled the afternoon for me. So charming to look at too. They say he
dangled his third wife out of a fifth-storey window by the wrists, but
I don't really believe that. He doesn't look strong enough, for one
thing. Looks as if he had chest trouble as a child. That peaky look,
and thin wrists. Not strong enough to dangle anyone. Certainly not out
of a fifth-storey...."

The gentle monologue went on, all through the pudding course; and
Robert withdrew his attention and thought about The Franchise. He came
to the surface as they rose from table and moved into the sitting-room
for coffee.

"It is the most becoming garment, if maids would only realise it," she
was saying.

"What is?"

"An apron. She was a maid in the palace, you know, and wore one of
those silly little bits of muslin. So becoming. Did those people at The
Franchise have a maid, by the way? No? Well, I am not surprised. They
starved the last one, you know. Gave her----"

"Oh, Aunt _Lin!"_

"I assure you. For breakfast she got the crusts they cut off the toast.
And when they had milk pudding..."

Robert did not hear what enormity was born of the milk pudding. In
spite of his good dinner he was suddenly tired and depressed. If kind
silly Aunt Lin saw no harm in repeating those absurd stories, what
would the real gossips of Milford achieve with the stuff of a real

"And talking of maids--the brown sugar is finished, dear, so you will
have to have lump for tonight--talking of maids, the Carleys' little
maid has got herself into trouble."

"You mean someone else has got her into trouble."

"Yes. Arthur Wallis, the potman at The White Hart."

"What, Wallis _again_!"

"Yes, it really is getting past a joke, isn't it. I can't think why the
man doesn't get married. It would be much cheaper."

But Robert was not listening. He was back in the drawing-room at The
Franchise, being gently mocked for his legal intolerance of a
generalisation. Back in the shabby room with the unpolished furniture,
where things lay about on chairs and no one bothered to tidy them away.

And where, now he came to think of it, no one ran round after him with
an ash-tray.


It was more than a week later that Mr. Heseltine put his thin, small,
grey head round Robert's door to say that Inspector Hallam was in the
office and would like to see him for a moment.

The room on the opposite side of the hall where Mr. Heseltine lorded it
over the clerks was always referred to as "the office," although both
Robert's room and the little one behind it used by Nevil Bennet were,
in spite of their carpets and their mahogany, plainly offices too.
There was an official waiting-room behind "the office," a small room
corresponding to young Bennet's, but it had never been popular with the
Blair, Hayward, and Bennet clients. Callers stepped into the office to
announce themselves and usually stayed there gossiping until such times
as Robert was free to see them. The little "waiting-room" had long ago
been appropriated by Miss Tuff for writing Robert's letters in, away
from the distraction of visitors and from the office-boy's sniffings.

When Mr. Heseltine had gone away to fetch the Inspector, Robert noticed
with surprise that he was apprehensive as he had not been apprehensive
since in the days of his youth he approached a list of Examination
Results pinned on a board. Was his life so placid that a stranger's
dilemma should stir it to that extent? Or was it that the Sharpes had
been so constantly in his thoughts for the last week that they had
ceased to be strangers?

He braced himself for whatever Hallam was going to say; but what
emerged from Hallam's careful phrases was that Scotland Yard had let
them understand that no proceedings would be taken on the present
evidence. Blair noticed the "present evidence" and gauged its meaning
accurately. They were not dropping the case--did the Yard ever drop a
case?--they were merely sitting quiet.

The thought of Scotland Yard sitting quiet was not a particularly
reassuring one in the circumstances.

"I take it that they lacked corroborative evidence," he said.

"They couldn't trace the lorry driver who gave her the lift," Hallam

"That wouldn't surprise them."

"No," Hallam agreed, "no driver is going to risk the sack by confessing
he gave anyone a lift. Especially a girl. Transport bosses are strict
about that. And when it is a case of a girl in trouble of some kind,
and when it's the police that are doing the asking, no man in his
senses is going to own up to even having seen her." He took the
cigarette that Robert offered him. "They needed that lorry driver," he
said. "Or someone like him," he added.

"Yes," Robert said, reflectively. "What did you make of her, Hallam?"

"The girl? I don't know. Nice kid. Seemed quite genuine. Might have
been one of my own."

This, Blair realised, was a very good sample of what they would be up
against if it ever came to a case. To every man of good feeling the
girl in the witness box would look like his own daughter. Not because
she was a waif, but for the very good reason that she wasn't. The
decent school coat, the mousy hair, the unmadeup young face with its
appealing hollow below the cheek-bone, the wide-set candid eyes--it was
a prosecuting counsel's dream of a victim.

"Just like any other girl of her age," Hallam said, still considering
it. "Nothing against her."

"So you don't judge people by the colour of their eyes," Robert said
idly, his mind still on the girl.

"Ho! Don't I!" said Hallam surprisingly. "Believe me, there's a
particular shade of baby blue that condemns a man, as far as I'm
concerned, before he has opened his mouth. Plausible liars every one of
them." He paused to pull on his cigarette. "Given to murder, too, come
to think of it--though I haven't met many killers."

"You alarm me," Robert said. "In the future I shall give baby-blue eyes
a wide berth."

Hallam grinned. "As long as you keep your pocket book shut you needn't
worry. All Baby-Blue's lies are for money. He only murders when he gets
too entangled in his lies. The real murderer's mark is not the colour
of the eyes but their setting."


"Yes. They are set differently. The two eyes, I mean. They look as if
they belonged to different faces."

"I thought you hadn't met many."

"No, but I've read all the case histories and studied the photographs.
I've always been surprised that no book on murder mentions it, it
happens so often. The inequality of setting, I mean."

"So it's entirely your own theory."

"The result of my own observation, yes. You ought to have a go at it
sometime. Fascinating. I've got to the stage where I look for it now."

"In the street, you mean?"

"No, not quite as bad as that. But in each new murder case. I wait for
the photograph, and when it comes I think: 'There! What did I tell

"And when the photograph comes and the eyes are of a mathematical

"Then it is nearly always what one might call an accidental murder. The
kind of murder that might happen to anyone given the circumstances."

"And when you turn up a photograph of the revered vicar of Nether
Dumbleton who is being given a presentation by his grateful
parishioners to mark his fiftieth year of devoted service, and you note
that the setting of his eyes is wildly unequal, what conclusion do you
come to?"

"That his wife satisfies him, his children obey him, his stipend is
sufficient for his needs, he has no politics, he gets on with the local
big-wigs, and he is allowed to have the kind of services he wants. In
fact, he has never had the slightest need to murder anyone."

"It seems to me that you are having your cake and eating it very

"Huh!" Hallam said disgustedly. "Just wasting good police observation
on a legal mind. I'd have thought," he added, moving to go, "that a
lawyer would be glad of some free tips about judging perfect

"All you are doing," Robert pointed out, "is corrupting an innocent
mind. I shall never be able to inspect a new client from now on without
my subconscious registering the colour of his eyes and the symmetry of
their setting."

"Well, that's something. It's about time you knew some of the facts of

"Thank you for coming to tell me about the 'Franchise' affair," Robert
said, returning to sobriety.

"The telephone in this town," Hallam said, "is about as private as the

"Anyhow, thank you. I must let the Sharpes know at once."

As Hallam took his leave, Robert lifted the telephone receiver.

He could not, as Hallam said, talk freely over the telephone, but he
would say that he was coming out to see them immediately and that the
news was good. That would take the present weight off their minds. It
would also--he glanced at his watch--be time for Mrs. Sharpe's daily
rest, so perhaps he would have a hope of avoiding the old dragon. And
also a hope of a tête-à-tête with Marion Sharpe, of course; though he
left that thought unformulated at the back of his mind.

But there was no answer to his call.

With the bored and reluctant aid of the Exchange he rang the number for
a solid five minutes, without result. The Sharpes were not at home.

While he was still engaged with the Exchange, Nevil Bennet strolled in
clad in his usual outrageous tweed, a pinkish shirt, and a purple tie.
Robert, eyeing him over the receiver, wondered for the hundredth time
what was going to become of Blair, Hayward, and Bennet when it at last
slipped from his good Blair grasp into the hands of this young sprig of
the Bennets. That the boy had brains he knew, but brains wouldn't take
him far in Milford. Milford expected a man to stop being undergraduate
when he reached graduate age. But there was no sign of Nevil's
acceptance of the world outside his coterie. He was still actively, if
unconsciously, epaté-ing that world. As his clothes bore witness.

It was not that Robert had any desire to see the boy in customary suits
of solemn black. His own suit was a grey tweed; and his country
clientèle would look doubtfully on "town" clothes. ("That awful little
man with the striped suits," Marion Sharpe had said of a town-clad
lawyer, in that unguarded moment on the telephone.) But there were
tweeds and tweeds, and Nevil Bennet's were the second kind. Quite
outrageously the second kind.

"Robert," Nevil said, as Robert gave it up and laid down the receiver,
"I've finished the papers on the Calthorpe transfer, and I thought I
would run into Larborough this afternoon, if you haven't anything you
want me to do."

"Can't you talk to her on the telephone?" Robert asked; Nevil being
engaged, in the casual modern fashion, to the Bishop of Larborough's
third daughter.

"Oh, it isn't Rosemary. She is in London for a week."

"A protest meeting at the Albert Hall, I suppose," said Robert, who was
feeling disgruntled because of his failure to speak to the Sharpes when
he was primed with good news for them.

"No, at the Guildhall," Nevil said.

"What is it this time? Vivisection?"

"You are frightfully last-century now and then, Robert," Nevil said,
with his air of solemn patience. "No one objects to vivisection
nowadays except a few cranks. The protest is against this country's
refusal to give shelter to the patriot Kotovich."

"The said patriot is very badly 'wanted' in his own country, I

"By his enemies; yes."

"By the police; for two murders."


"You a disciple of John Knox, Nevil?"

"Good God, no. What has that to do with it?"

"_He_ believed in self-appointed executioners. The idea has a little
'gone out' in this country, I understand. Anyhow, if it's a choice
between Rosemary's opinion of Kotovich and the opinion of the Special
Branch, I'll take the Special Branch."

"The Special Branch only do what the Foreign Office tells them.
Everyone knows that. But if I stay and explain the ramifications of the
Kotovich affair to you, I shall be late for the film."

"What film?"

"The French film I am going into Larborough to see."

"I suppose you know that most of those French trifles that the British
intelligentsia bate their breath about are considered very so-so in
their own country? However. Do you think you could pause long enough to
drop a note into the letter-box of The Franchise as you go by?"

"I might. I always wanted to see what was inside that wall. Who lives
there now?"

"An old woman and her daughter."

"Daughter?" repeated Nevil, automatically pricking his ears.

"Middle-aged daughter."

"Oh. All right, I'll just get my coat."

Robert wrote merely that he had tried to talk to them, that he had to
go out on business for an hour or so, but that he would ring them up
again when he was free, and that Scotland Yard had no case, as the case
stood, and acknowledged the fact.

Nevil swept in with a dreadful raglan affair over his arm, snatched up
the letter and disappeared with a "Tell Aunt Lin I may be late. She
asked me over to dinner."

Robert donned his own sober grey hat and walked over to the Rose and
Crown to meet his client--an old farmer, and the last man in England to
suffer from chronic gout. The old man was not yet there, and Robert,
usually so placid, so lazily good-natured, was conscious of impatience.
The pattern of his life had changed. Up to now it had been an even
succession of equal attractions; he had gone from one thing to another
without hurry and without emotion. Now there was a focus of interest,
and the rest revolved round it.

He sat down on one of the chintz-covered chairs in the lounge and
looked at the dog-eared journals lying on the adjacent coffee table.
The only current number was _The Watchman_, the weekly review, and he
picked it up reluctantly, thinking yet once more how the dry feel of
the paper offended his finger tips and its serrated edges set his own
teeth on edge. It was the usual collection of protests, poems, and
pedantry; the place of honour among the protests being accorded to
Nevil's future father-in-law, who spread himself for three-quarters of
a column on England's shame in that she refused sanctuary to a fugitive

The Bishop of Larborough had long ago extended the Christian philosophy
to include the belief that the underdog is always right. He was wildly
popular with Balkan revolutionaries, British strike committees, and all
the old lags in the local penal establishment. (The sole exception to
this last being that chronic recidivist, Bandy Brayne, who held the
good bishop in vast contempt, and reserved his affection for the
Governor; to whom a tear in the eye was just a drop of H2O, and who
unpicked his most heart-breaking tales with a swift, unemotional
accuracy.) There was _nothing_, said the old lags affectionately, that
the old boy would not believe; you could lay it on with a trowel.

Normally Robert found the Bishop mildly amusing, but today he was
merely irritated. He tried two poems, neither of which made sense to
him, and flung the thing back on the table.

"England in the wrong again?" asked Ben Carley, pausing by his chair
and jerking a head at _The Watchman_.

"Hullo, Carley."

"A Marble Arch for the well-to-do," the little lawyer said, flicking
the paper scornfully with a nicotine-stained finger. "Have a drink?"

"Thanks, but I'm waiting for old Mr. Wynyard. He doesn't move a step
more than he need, nowadays."

"No, poor old boy. The sins of the fathers. Awful to be suffering for
port you never drank! I saw your car outside The Franchise the other

"Yes," said Robert, and wondered a little. It was unlike Ben Carley to
be blunt. And if he had seen Robert's car he had also seen the police

"If you know them you'll be able to tell me something I always wanted
to know about them. Is the rumour true?"


"_Are_ they witches?"

"Are they supposed to be?" said Robert lightly.

"There's a strong support for the belief in the countryside, I
understand," Carley said, his bright black eyes resting for a moment on
Robert's with intention, and then going on to wander over the lounge
with their habitual quick interrogation.

Robert understood that the little man was offering him, tacitly,
information that he thought ought to be useful to him.

"Ah well," Robert said, "since entertainment came into the country with
the cinema, God bless it, an end has been put to witch-hunting."

"Don't you believe it. Give these midland morons a good excuse and
they'll witch-hunt with the best. An inbred crowd of degenerates, if
you ask me. Here's your old boy. Well, I'll be seeing you."

It was one of Robert's chief attractions that he was genuinely
interested in people and in their troubles, and he listened to old Mr.
Wynyard's rambling story with a kindness that won the old man's
gratitude--and added, although he was unaware of it, a hundred to the
sum that stood against his name in the old farmer's will--but as soon
as their business was over he made straight for the hotel telephone.

There were far too many people about, and he decided to use the one in
the garage over in Sin Lane. The office would be shut by now, and
anyhow it was further away. And if he telephoned from the garage, so
his thoughts went as he strode across the street, he would have his car
at hand if she--if they asked him to come out and discuss the business
further, as they very well might, as they almost certainly would--yes,
of course they would want to discuss what they could do to discredit
the girl's story, whether there was to be a case or not--he had been so
relieved over Hallam's news that he had not yet come round in his mind
to considering what--

"Evening, Mr. Blair," Bill Brough said, oozing his large person out of
the narrow office door, his round calm face bland and welcoming. "Want
your car?"

"No, I want to use your telephone first, if I may."

"Sure. Go ahead."

Stanley, who was under a car, poked his fawn's face out and asked:

"Know anything?"

"Not a thing, Stan. Haven't had a bet for months."

"I'm two pounds down on a cow called Bright Promise. That's what comes
of putting your faith in horseflesh. Next time you know something----"

"Next time I have a bet I'll tell you. But it will still be

"As long as it's not a cow----" Stanley said, disappearing under the
car again; and Robert moved into the hot bright little office and
picked up the receiver.

It was Marion who answered, and her voice sounded warm and glad.

"You can't imagine what a relief your note was to us. Both my mother
and I have been picking oakum for the last week. Do they still pick
oakum, by the way?"

"I think not. It is something more constructive nowadays, I

"Occupational therapy."

"More or less."

"I can't think of any compulsory sewing that would improve my

"They would probably find you something more congenial. It is against
modern thought to compel a prisoner to do anything that he doesn't want

"That is the first time I have heard you sound tart."

"Was I tart?"

"Pure angostura."

Well, she had reached the subject of drink; perhaps now she would
suggest his coming out for sherry before dinner.

"What a charming nephew you have, by the way."


"The one who brought the note."

"He is not my nephew," Robert said coldly. Why was it so ageing to be
avuncular? "He is my first cousin once removed. But I am glad you liked
him." This would not do; he would have to take the bull by the horns.
"I should like to see you sometime to discuss what we can do to
straighten things out. To make things safer----" He waited.

"Yes, of course. Perhaps we could look in at your office one morning
when we are shopping? What kind of thing could we do, do you think?"

"Some kind of private inquiry, perhaps. I can't very well discuss it
over the telephone."

"No, of course you can't. How would it do if we came in on Friday
morning? That is our weekly shopping day. Or is Friday a busy day for

"No, Friday would be quite convenient," Robert said, swallowing down
his disappointment. "About noon?"

"Yes, that would do very well. Twelve o'clock the day after tomorrow,
at your office. Goodbye, and thank you again for your support and

She rang off, firmly and cleanly, without all the usual preliminary
twitterings that Robert had come to expect from women.

"Shall I run her out for you," Bill Brough asked as he came out into
the dim daylight of the garage.

"What? Oh, the car. No, I shan't need it tonight, thanks."

He set off on his normal evening walk down the High Street, trying hard
not to feel snubbed. He had not been anxious to go to The Franchise in
the first instance, and had made his reluctance pretty plain; she was
quite naturally avoiding a repetition of the circumstances. That he had
identified himself with their interests was a mere business affair, to
be resolved in an office, impersonally. They would not again involve
him further than that.

Ah, well, he thought, flinging himself down in his favourite chair by
the wood fire in the sitting-room and opening the evening paper
(printed that morning in London), when they came to the office on
Friday he could do something to put the affair on a more personal
basis. To wipe out the memory of that first unhappy refusal.

The quiet of the old house soothed him. Christina had been closeted in
her room for two days, in prayer and meditation, and Aunt Lin was in
the kitchen preparing dinner. There was a gay letter from Lettice, his
only sister, who had driven a truck for several years of a bloody war,
fallen in love with a tall silent Canadian, and was now raising five
blond brats in Saskatchewan. "Come out soon, Robin dear," she finished,
"before the brats grow up and before the moss grows _right_ round you.
You know how _bad_ Aunt Lin is for you!" He could hear her saying it.
She and Aunt Lin had never seen eye to eye.

He was smiling, relaxed and reminiscent, when both his quiet and his
peace were shattered by the irruption of Nevil.

"Why didn't you _tell_ me she was like that!" Nevil demanded.


"The Sharpe woman! Why didn't you tell me?"

"I didn't expect you would meet her," Robert said. "All you had to do
was drop the letter through the door."

"There was nothing in the door to drop it through, so I rang, and they
had just come back from wherever they were. Anyhow, _she_ answered it."

"I thought she slept in the afternoons."

"I don't believe she ever sleeps. She doesn't belong to the human
family at all. She is all compact of fire and metal."

"I know she's a very rude old woman but you have to make allowances.
She has had a very hard----"

"_Old?_ Who are you talking about?"

"Old Mrs. Sharpe, of course."

"I didn't even see old Mrs. Sharpe. I'm talking about Marion."

"Marion Sharpe? And how did you know her name was Marion?"

"She told me. It does suit her, doesn't it? She couldn't be anything
but Marion."

"You seem to have become remarkably intimate for a doorstep

"Oh, she gave me tea."

"Tea! I thought you were in a desperate hurry to see a French film."

"I'm never in a desperate hurry to do anything when a woman like Marion
Sharpe invites me to tea. Have you noticed her eyes? But of course you
have. You're her lawyer. That wonderful shading of grey into hazel. And
the way her eyebrows lie above them, like the brush-mark of a painter
genius. Winged eyebrows, they are. I made a poem about them on the way
home. Do you want to hear it?"

"No," Robert said firmly. "Did you enjoy your film?"

"Oh, I didn't go."

"You didn't _go_!"

"I told you I had tea with Marion instead."

"You mean you have been at The Franchise _the whole afternoon_!"

"I suppose I have," Nevil said dreamily, "but, by God, it didn't seem
more than seven minutes."

"And what happened to your thirst for French cinema?"

"But Marion _is_ French film. Even you must see that!" Robert winced at
the "even you." "Why bother with the shadow, when you can be with the
reality? Reality. That is her great quality, isn't it? I've never met
anyone as real as Marion is."

"Not even Rosemary?" Robert was in the state known to Aunt Lin as "put

"Oh, Rosemary is a darling, and I'm going to marry her, but that is
quite a different thing."

"Is it?" said Robert, with deceptive meekness.

"Of course. People don't marry women like Marion Sharpe, any more than
they marry winds and clouds. Any more than they marry Joan of Arc. It's
positively blasphemous to consider marriage in relation to a woman like
that. She spoke very nicely of you, by the way."

"That was kind of her."

The tone was so dry that even Nevil caught the flavour of it.

"Don't you like her?" he asked, pausing to look at his cousin in
surprised disbelief.

Robert had ceased for the moment to be kind, lazy, tolerant Robert
Blair; he was just a tired man who hadn't yet had his dinner and was
suffering from the memory of a frustration and a snubbing.

"As far as I am concerned," he said, "Marion Sharpe is just a skinny
woman of forty who lives with a rude old mother in an ugly old house,
and needs legal advice on occasion like anyone else."

But even as the words came out he wanted to stop them, as if they were
a betrayal of a friend.

"No, probably she _isn't_ your cup of tea," Nevil said tolerantly. "You
have always preferred them a little stupid, and blond, haven't you."
This was said without malice, as one stating a dullish fact.

"I can't imagine why you should think that."

"All the women you nearly married were that type."

"I have never 'nearly married' anyone," Robert said stiffly.

"That's what you think. You'll never know how nearly Molly Manders
landed you."

"Molly Manders?" Aunt Lin said, coming in flushed from her cooking and
bearing the tray with the sherry. "Such a silly girl. Imagined that you
used a baking-board for pancakes. And was always looking at herself in
that little pocket mirror of hers."

"Aunt Lin saved you that time, didn't you, Aunt Lin?"

"I don't know what you are talking about, Nevil dear. Do stop prancing
about the hearthrug, and put a log on the fire. Did you like your
French film, dear?"

"I didn't go. I had tea at The Franchise instead." He shot a glance at
Robert, having learned by now that there was more in Robert's reaction
than met the eye.

"With those strange people? What did you talk about?"


"_Hens_, dear?"

"Yes; the concentrated evil of a hen's face in a close-up."

Aunt Lin looked vague. She turned to Robert, as to terra firma.

"Had I better call, dear, if you are going to know them? Or ask the
vicar's wife to call?"

"I don't think I would commit the vicar's wife to anything so
irrevocable," Robert said, dryly.

She looked doubtful for a moment, but household cares obliterated the
question in her mind. "Don't dawdle too long over your sherry or what I
have in the oven will be spoiled. Thank goodness, Christina will be
down again tomorrow. At least I hope so; I have never known her
salvation take more than two days. And I don't really think that I will
_call_ on those Franchise people, dear, if it is all the same to you.
Apart from being strangers and very odd, they quite frankly terrify

Yes; that was a sample of the reaction he might expect where the
Sharpes were concerned. Ben Carley had gone out of his way today to let
him know that, if there was police trouble at The Franchise, he
wouldn't be able to count on an unprejudiced jury. He must take
measures for the protection of the Sharpes. When he saw them on Friday
he would suggest a private investigation by a paid agent. The police
were overworked--had been overworked for a decade and more--and there
was just a chance that one man working at his leisure on one trail
might be more successful than the orthodox and official investigation
had been.


But by Friday morning it was too late to take measures for the safety
of The Franchise.

Robert had reckoned with the diligence of the police; he had reckoned
with the slow spread of whispers; but he had reckoned without the

The _Ack-Emma_ was the latest representative of the tabloid newspaper
to enter British journalism from the West. It was run on the principle
that two thousand pounds for damages is a cheap price to pay for sales
worth half a million. It had blacker headlines, more sensational
pictures, and more indiscreet letterpress than any paper printed so far
by British presses. Fleet Street had its own name for it--monosyllabic
and unprintable--but no protection against it. The press had always
been its own censor, deciding what was and what was not permissible by
the principles of its own good sense and good taste. If a "rogue"
publication decided not to conform to those principles then there was
no power that could make it conform. In ten years the _Ack-Emma_ had
passed by half a million the daily net sales of the best selling
newspaper in the country to date. In any suburban railway carriage
seven out of ten people bound for work in the morning were reading an

And it was the _Ack-Emma_ that blew the Franchise affair wide open.

Robert had been out early into the country on that Friday morning to
see an old woman who was dying and wanted to alter her will. This was a
performance she repeated on an average once every three months and her
doctor made no secret of the fact that in his opinion she "would blow
out a hundred candles one day without a second puff." But of course a
lawyer cannot tell a client who summons him urgently at eight-thirty in
the morning not to be silly. So Robert had taken some new will forms,
fetched his car from the garage, and driven into the country. In spite
of his usual tussle with the old tyrant among the pillows--who could
never be brought to understand the elementary fact that you cannot give
away _four_ shares amounting to one third each--he enjoyed the spring
countryside. And he hummed to himself on the way home, looking forward
to seeing Marion Sharpe in less than an hour.

He had decided to forgive her for liking Nevil. After all, Nevil had
never tried to palm her off on Carley. One must be fair.

He ran the car into the garage, under the noses of the morning lot
going out from the livery stable, parked it, and then, remembering that
it was past the first of the month, strolled over to the office to pay
his bill to Brough, who ran the office side. But it was Stanley who was
in the office; thumbing over dockets and invoices with the strong hands
that so surprisingly finished off his thin forearms.

"When I was in the Signals," Stanley said, casting him an absent-minded
glance, "I used to believe that the Quarter-bloke was a crook, but now
I'm not so sure."

"Something missing?" said Robert. "I just looked in to pay my bill.
Bill usually has it ready."

"I expect it's somewhere around," Stanley said, still thumbing. "Have a

Robert, used to the ways of the office, picked up the loose papers
discarded by Stanley, so as to come on the normal tidy strata of Bill's
arrangement below. As he lifted the untidy pile he uncovered a girl's
face; a newspaper picture of a girl's face. He did not recognise it at
once but it reminded him of someone and he paused to look at it.

"Got it!" said Stanley in triumph, extracting a sheet of paper from a
clip. He swept the remaining loose papers on the desk into a pile and
so laid bare to Robert's gaze the whole front page of that morning's

Cold with shock, Robert stared at it.

Stanley, turning to take the papers he was holding from his grasp,
noticed his absorption and approved it.

"Nice little number, that," he said. "Reminds me of a bint I had in
Egypt. Same far-apart eyes. Nice kid she was. Told the most original

He went back to his paper-arranging, and Robert went on staring.


said the paper in enormous black letters across the top of the page;
and below it, occupying two-thirds of the page, was the girl's
photograph. And then, in smaller but still obtrusive type, below:


and below it a photograph of The Franchise.

Across the bottom of the page was the legend:

            See inside for the story.

He put out his hand and turned over the page.

Yes; it was all there, except for the Sharpes' name.

He dropped the page, and looked again at that shocking frontispiece.
Yesterday The Franchise was a house protected by four high walls; so
unobtrusive, so sufficient unto itself, that even Milford did not know
what it looked like. Now it was there to be stared at on every
bookstall; on every newsagent's counter from Penzance to Pentland. Its
flat, forbidding front a foil for the innocence of the face above it.

The girl's photograph was a head-and-shoulders affair, and appeared to
be a studio portrait. Her hair had an arranged-for-an-occasion look,
and she was wearing what looked like a party frock. Without her school
coat she looked--not less innocent, nor older; no. He sought for the
word that would express it. She looked less--tabu, was it? The school
coat had stopped one thinking of her as a woman, just as a nun's habit
would. A whole treatise could probably be written, now he came to think
of it, on the protective quality of school coats. Protective in both
senses: armour and camouflage. Now that the coat was no longer there,
she was feminine instead of merely female.

But it was still a pathetically young face, immature and appealing. The
candid brow, the wide-set eyes, the bee-stung lip that gave her mouth
the expression of a disappointed child--it made a formidable whole. It
would not be only the Bishop of Larborough who would believe a story
told by that face.

"May I borrow this paper?" he asked Stanley.

"Take it," Stanley said. "We had it for our elevenses. There's nothing
in it."

Robert was surprised. "Didn't you find this interesting?" he asked,
indicating the front page.

Stanley cast a glance at the pictured face. "Not except that she
reminded me of that bint in Egypt, lies and all."

"So you didn't believe that story she told?"

"What do _you_ think!" Stanley said, contemptuous.

"Where do you think the girl was, then, all that time?"

"If I remember what I _think_ I remember about the Red Sea sadie, I'd
say very definitely--oh, but definitely--on the tiles," Stanley said,
and went out to attend to a customer.

Robert picked up the paper and went soberly away. At least one
man-in-the-street had not believed the story; but that seemed to be due
as much to an old memory as to present cynicism.

And although Stanley had quite obviously read the story without reading
the names of the characters concerned, or even the place-names, only
ten per cent of readers did that (according to the best Mass
Observation); the other ninety per cent would have read every word, and
would now be discussing the affair with varying degrees of relish.

At his own office he found that Hallam had been trying to reach him by

"Shut the door and come in, will you," he said to old Mr. Heseltine,
who had caught him with the news on his arrival and was now standing in
the door of his room. "And have a look at that."

He reached for the receiver with one hand, and laid the paper under Mr.
Heseltine's nose with the other.

The old man touched it with his small-boned fastidious hand, as one
seeing a strange exhibit for the first time. "This is the publication
one hears so much about," he said. And gave his attention to it, as he
would to any strange document.

"We are both in a spot, aren't we!" Hallam said, when they were
connected. And raked his vocabulary for some epithets suitable to the
_Ack-Emma_. "As if the police hadn't enough to do without having that
rag on their tails!" he finished, being naturally absorbed in the
police point of view.

"Have you heard from the Yard?"

"Grant was burning the wires at nine this morning. But there's nothing
they can do. Just grin and bear it. The police are always fair game.
Nothing you can do, either, if it comes to that."

"Not a thing," Robert said. "We have a fine free press."

Hallam said a few more things about the press. "Do your people know?"
he asked.

"I shouldn't think so. I'm quite sure they would never normally see the
_Ack-Emma_, and there hasn't been time for some kind soul to send it to
them. But they are due here in about ten minutes, and I'll show it to
them then."

"If it was ever possible for me to be sorry for that old battle-axe,"
Hallam said, "it would be at this minute."

"How did the _Ack-Emma_ get the story? I thought the parents--the
girl's guardians, I mean--were very strongly against that kind of

"Grant says the girl's brother went off the deep end about the police
taking no action and went to the _Ack-Emma_ off his own bat. They are
strong on the champion act. 'The _Ack-Emma_ will see right done!' I
once knew one of their crusades run into a third day."

When he hung up Robert thought that if it was a bad break for both
sides, it was at least an even break. The police would without doubt
redouble their efforts to find corroborative evidence; on the other
hand the publication of the girl's photograph meant for the Sharpes a
faint hope that somebody, somewhere, would recognise it and say: "This
girl could not have been in The Franchise on the date in question
because she was at such-and-such a place."

"A shocking story, Mr. Robert," Mr. Heseltine said. "And if I may say
so a quite shocking publication. Most offensive."

"That house," Robert said, "is The Franchise, where old Mrs. Sharpe and
her daughter live; and where I went the other day, if you remember, to
give them some legal advice."

"You mean that these people are our clients?"


"But, Mr. Robert, that is not at all in our line." Robert winced at the
dismay in his voice. "That is quite outside our usual--indeed quite
beyond our normal--we are not competent----"

"We are competent, I hope, to defend any client against a publication
like the _Ack-Emma_," Robert said, coldly.

Mr. Heseltine eyed the screaming rag on the table. He was obviously
facing the difficult choice between a criminal clientèle and a
disgraceful journal.

"Did you believe the girl's story when you read it?" Robert asked.

"I don't see how she could have made it up," Mr. Heseltine said simply.
"It is such a very circumstantial story, isn't it?"

"It is, indeed. But I saw the girl when she was brought to The
Franchise to identify it last week--that was the day I went out so
hurriedly just after tea--and I don't believe a word she says. Not a
word," he added, glad to be able to say it loudly and distinctly to
himself and to be sure at last that he believed it.

"But how could she have thought of The Franchise at all, or known all
those things, if she wasn't there?"

"I don't know. I haven't the least idea."

"It is a most unlikely place to pick on, surely; a remote, invisible
house like that, on a lonely road, in country that people don't visit
very much."

"I know. I don't know how the job was worked, but that it _is_ a job I
am certain. It is a choice not between stories, but between human
beings. I am quite certain that the two Sharpes are incapable of insane
conduct like that. Whereas I don't believe the girl incapable of
telling a story like that. That is what it amounts to." He paused a
moment. "And you'll just have to trust my judgment about it, Timmy," he
added, using his childhood's name for the old clerk.

Whether it was the "Timmy" or the argument, it was apparent that Mr.
Heseltine had no further protest to make.

"You'll be able to see the criminals for yourself," Robert said,
"because I hear their voices in the hall now. You might bring them in,
will you."

Mr. Heseltine went dumbly out on his mission, and Robert turned the
newspaper over so that the comparatively innocuous GIRL SMUGGLED ABOARD
was all that would meet the visitors' eye.

Mrs. Sharpe, moved by some belated instinct for convention, had donned
a hat in honour of the occasion. It was a flattish affair of black
satin, and the general effect was that of a doctor of learning. That
the effect had not been wasted was obvious by the relieved look on Mr.
Heseltine's face. This was quite obviously not the kind of client he
had expected; it was, on the other hand, the kind of client he was used

"Don't go away," Robert said to him, as he greeted the visitors; and to
the others: "I want you to meet the oldest member of the firm, Mr.

It suited Mrs. Sharpe to be gracious; and exceedingly Victoria Regina
was old Mrs. Sharpe when she was being gracious. Mr. Heseltine was more
than relieved; he capitulated. Robert's first battle was over.

When they were alone Robert noticed that Marion had been waiting to say

"An odd thing happened this morning," she said. "We went to the Ann
Boleyn place to have coffee--we quite often do--and there were two
vacant tables, but when Miss Truelove saw us coming she very hastily
tilted the chairs against the tables and said they were reserved. I
might have believed her if she hadn't looked so embarrassed. You don't
think that rumour has begun to get busy already, do you? That she did
that because she has heard some gossip?"

"No," Robert said, sadly, "because she has read this morning's
_Ack-Emma_." He turned the newspaper front side up. "I am sorry to have
such bad news for you. You'll just have to shut your teeth and take it,
as small boys say. I don't suppose you have ever seen this poisonous
rag at close quarters. It's a pity that the acquaintance should begin
on so personal a basis."

"Oh, no!" Marion said, in passionate protest as her eye fell on the
picture of The Franchise.

And then there was unbroken silence while the two women absorbed the
contents of the inner page.

"I take it," Mrs. Sharpe said at last, "that we have no redress against
this sort of thing?"

"None," Robert said. "All the statements are perfectly true. And it is
all statement and not comment. Even if it were comment--and I've no
doubt the comment will come--there has been no charge so the case is
not _sub judice_. They are free to comment if they please."

"The whole thing is one huge implied comment," Marion said. "That the
police failed to do their duty. What do they think we did? Bribed

"I think the suggestion is that the humble victim has less pull with
the police than the wicked rich."

"Rich," repeated Marion, her voice curdling with bitterness.

"Anyone who has more than six chimneys is rich. Now. If you are not too
shocked to think, consider. We _know_ that the girl was never at The
Franchise, that she could not----" But Marion interrupted him.

"Do _you_ know it?" she asked.

"Yes," Robert said.

Her challenging eyes lost their challenge, and her glance dropped.

"Thank you," she said quietly.

"If the girl was never there, how could she have seen the house!... She
did see it somehow. It is too unlikely for belief that she could be
merely repeating a description that someone else gave her.... How could
she see it? Naturally, I mean."

"You could see it, I suppose, from the top deck of a bus," Marion said.
"But there are no double-decker buses on the Milford route. Or from on
top of a load of hay. But it is the wrong time of year for hay."

"It may be the wrong time for hay," croaked Mrs. Sharpe, "but there is
no season for lorry-loads. I have seen lorries loaded with goods as
high as any hay waggon."

"Yes," Marion said. "Suppose the lift the girl got was not in a car,
but on a lorry."

"There is only one thing against that. If a girl was given a lift on a
lorry she would be in the cabin, even if it meant sitting on someone's
knee. They wouldn't perch her up on top of the load. Especially as it
was a rainy evening, you may remember.... No one ever came to The
Franchise to ask the way, or to sell something, or to mend
something--someone that the girl could have been with, even in the

But no; they were both sure that no one had come, within the time the
girl had been on holiday.

"Then we take it for granted that what she learned about The Franchise
she learned from being high enough on one occasion to see over the
wall. We shall probably never know when or how, and we probably could
not prove it if we did know. So our whole efforts will have to be
devoted, not to proving that she wasn't at The Franchise, but that she
was somewhere else!"

"And what chance is there of that?" Mrs. Sharpe asked.

"A better chance than before this was published," Robert said,
indicating the front page of the _Ack-Emma_. "Indeed it is the one
bright spot in the bad business. We could not have published the girl's
photograph in the hope of information about her whereabouts during that
month. But now that _they_ have published it--her own people, I
mean--the same benefit should come to us. They have broadcast the
story--and that is our bad luck; but they have also broadcast the
photograph--and if we have any good luck at all someone, somewhere,
will observe that the story and the photograph do not fit. That at the
material time, as given in the story, the subject of the photograph
could not possibly have been in the stated place, because they,
personally, know her to have been elsewhere."

Marion's face lost a little of its bleak look, and even Mrs. Sharpe's
thin back looked less rigid. What had seemed a disaster might be, after
all, the means of their salvation.

"And what can we do in the way of private investigation?" Mrs. Sharpe
asked. "You realise, I expect, that we have very little money; and I
take it that a private inquiry is a spendthrift business."

"It does usually run away with more than one had bargained for, because
it is difficult to budget for. But to begin with I am going, myself, to
see the various people involved, and find out, if possible, on what
lines any inquiry should be based. Find out what she was _likely_ to

"Will they tell you that?"

"Oh, no. They are probably unaware themselves of her tendencies. But if
they talk about her at all a picture must emerge. At least I hope so."

There was a few moments' silence.

"You are extraordinarily kind, Mr. Blair."

Victoria Regina had come back to Mrs. Sharpe's manner, but there was a
hint of something else. Almost of surprise; as if kindness was not one
of the things she had normally met with in life; nor expected. Her
stiffly gracious acknowledgement was as eloquent as if she had said:
"You know that we are poor, and that we may never be able to pay you
adequately, and we are not at all the kind of people that you would
choose to represent, but you are going out of your way to do us the
best service in your power, and we are grateful."

"When do you go?" Marion asked.

"Directly after lunch."


"The sooner the better."

"Then we won't keep you," Mrs. Sharpe said, rising. She stood for a
moment looking down at the paper where it lay spread on the table. "We
enjoyed the privacy of The Franchise a great deal," she said.

When he had seen them out of the door and into their car, he called
Nevil into his room and picked up the receiver to talk to Aunt Lin
about packing a bag.

"I suppose you don't see the _Ack-Emma_ ever?" he asked Nevil.

"I take it that the question is rhetoric," Nevil said.

"Have a look at this morning's. Hullo, Aunt Lin."

"Does someone want to sue them for something? It will be sound money
for us, if so. They practically always settle out of court. They have a
special fund for the----" Nevil's voice died away. He had seen the
front page that was staring up at him from the table.

Robert stole a look at him over the telephone, and observed with
satisfaction the naked shock on his cousin's bright young features. The
youth of today, he understood, considered themselves shock-proof; it
was good to know that, faced with an ordinary slab of real life, they
reacted like any other human being.

"Be an angel, Aunt Lin, and pack a bag for me, will you? Just for

Nevil had torn the paper open and was now reading the story.

"Just London and back, I expect, but I'm not sure. Anyhow, just the
little case; and just the minimum. Not all the things I _might_ need,
if you love me. Last time there was a bottle of digestive powder
weighing nearly a pound, and when in heck did I ever need a digestive
powder!... All right, then I _will_ have ulcers.... Yes, I'll be in to
lunch in about ten minutes."

"The blasted _swine_!" said the poet and intellectual, falling back in
his need on the vernacular.

"Well, what do you make of it?"

"_Make_ of it! Of what?"

"The girl's story."

"Does one have to _make_ anything of it? An obvious piece of
sensationalism by an unbalanced adolescent?"

"And if I told you that the said adolescent is a very calm, ordinary,
well-spoken-of schoolgirl who is anything but sensational?"

"Have you seen her?"

"Yes. That was why I first went to The Franchise last week, to be there
when Scotland Yard brought the girl to confront them." Put that in your
pipe and smoke it, young Nevil. She may talk hens and Maupassant with
you, but it is me she turns to in trouble.

"To be there on their behalf?"


Nevil relaxed suddenly. "Oh, well; that's all right. For a moment I
thought you were against her. Against them. But that's all right. We
can join forces to put a spoke in the wheel of this--" he flicked the
paper--"this moppet." Robert laughed at this typically Nevil choice of
epithet. "What are you going to do about it, Robert?"

Robert told him. "And you will hold the fort while I am gone." He saw
that Nevil's attention had gone back to the "moppet." He moved over to
join him and together they considered the young face looking so calmly
up at them.

"An attractive face, on the whole," Robert said. "What do you make of

"What I should _like_ to make of it," said the aesthete, with slow
venom, "would be a _very nasty mess_."


The Wynns' home outside Aylesbury was in a countrified suburb; the kind
of district where rows of semi-detached houses creep along the edge of
the still unspoiled fields; selfconscious and aware that they are
intruders, or smug and not caring, according to the character their
builders have given them. The Wynns lived in one of the apologetic
rows; a red-brick string of ramshackle dwellings that set Robert's
teeth on edge; so raw they were, so crude, so hang-dog. But as he drove
slowly up the road, looking for the appropriate number, he was won over
by the love that had gone to the decoration of these regrettable
objects. No love had gone to their building; only a reckoning. But to
each owner, as he took over, the bare little house had represented his
"sufficient beauty," and having found it he served it. The gardens were
small miracles of loveliness; each succeeding one a fresh revelation of
some unsuspected poet's heart.

Nevil really ought to be here to see, Robert thought, slowing down yet
once more as a new perfection caught his eye; there was more poetry
here than in a whole twelve months of his beloved _Watchman_. All his
clichés were here: form, rhythm, colour, total gesture, design,

Or would Nevil see only a row of suburban gardens? Only Meadowside
Lane, Aylesbury, with some Woolworth plants in the gardens?


Number 39 was the one with the plain green grass bordered by a rockery.
It was also distinguished by the fact that its curtains were invisible.
No genteel net was stretched across the windowpane, no cream casement
cloth hung at the sides. The windows were bare to the sun, the air, and
the human gaze. This surprised Robert as much as it probably surprised
the neighbours. It augured a nonconformity that he had not expected.

He rang the bell, wishing that he did not feel like a bagman. He was a
suppliant; and that was a new role for Robert Blair.

Mrs. Wynn surprised him even more than her windows did. It was only
when he had met her that he realised how complete a picture he had
built in his mind of the woman who had adopted and mothered the child
Betty Kane: the grey hair, the solid matronly comfortable figure, the
plain broad sensible face; perhaps, even, an apron, or one of those
flowered overalls that housewives wear. But Mrs. Wynn was not at all
like that. She was slight and neat and young and modern and dark and
pink-cheeked and still pretty, and had a pair of the most intelligent
bright brown eyes Robert had ever seen.

When she saw a stranger she looked defensive, and made an involuntary
closing movement with the door she was holding; but a second glance
seemed to reassure her. Robert explained who he was, and she listened
without interrupting him in a way he found quite admirable. Very few of
his own clients listened without interrupting; male or female.

"You are under no obligation to talk to me," he finished, having
explained his presence. "But I hope very much that you won't refuse. I
have told Inspector Grant that I was going to see you this afternoon,
on my clients' behalf."

"Oh, if the police know about it and don't mind----" She stepped back
to let him come past her. "I expect you have to do your best for those
people if you are their lawyer. And we have nothing to hide. But if it
is really Betty you want to interview I'm afraid you can't. We have
sent her into the country to friends for the day, to avoid all the
fuss. Leslie meant well, but it was a stupid thing to do."


"My son. Sit down, won't you." She offered him one of the easy chairs
in a pleasant, uncluttered sitting-room. "He was too angry about the
police to think clearly--angry about their failure to do anything when
it seemed so proved, I mean. He has always been devoted to Betty.
Indeed until he got engaged they were inseparable."

Robert's ears pricked. This was the kind of thing he had come to hear.


"Yes. He got engaged just after the New Year to a very nice girl. We
are all delighted."

"Was Betty delighted?"

"She wasn't jealous, if that is what you mean," she said, looking at
him with her intelligent eyes. "I expect she missed not coming first
with him as she used to, but she was very nice about it. She _is_ a
nice girl, Mr. Blair. Believe me. I was a schoolmistress before I
married--not a very good one, that is why I got married at the first
opportunity--and I know a lot about girls. Betty has never given me a
moment's anxiety."

"Yes. I know. Everyone reports excellently of her. Is your son's
fiancée a schoolfellow of hers?"

"No, she is a stranger. Her people have come to live near here and he
met her at a dance."

"Does Betty go to dances?"

"Not grown-up dances. She is too young yet."

"So she had not met the fiancée?"

"To be honest, none of us had. He rather sprang her on us. But we liked
her so much we didn't mind."

"He must be very young to be settling down?"

"Oh, the whole thing is absurd, of course. He is twenty and she is
eighteen. But they are very sweet together. And I was very young myself
when I married and I have been very happy. The only thing I lacked was
a daughter, and Betty filled that gap."

"What does she want to do when she leaves school?"

"She doesn't know. She has no special talent for anything as far as I
can see. I have a notion that she will marry early."

"Because of her attractiveness?"

"No, because----" she paused and apparently changed what she had been
going to say. "Girls who have no particular bent fall easily into

He wondered if what she had been going to say had any remote connection
with slate-blue eyes.

"When Betty failed to turn up in time to go back to school, you thought
she was just playing truant? Although she was a well-behaved child."

"Yes; she was growing bored with school; and she had always said--which
is quite true--that the first day back at school is a wasted one. So we
thought she was just 'taking advantage' for once, as they say. 'Trying
it on' as Leslie said, when he heard that she hadn't turned up."

"I see. Was she wearing school clothes on her holiday?"

For the first time Mrs. Wynn looked doubtfully at him; uncertain of his
motive in asking.

"No. No, she was wearing her week-end clothes.... You know that when
she came back she was wearing only a frock and shoes?"

Robert nodded.

"I find it difficult to imagine women so depraved that they would treat
a helpless child like that."

"If you could meet the women, Mrs. Wynn, you would find it still more
difficult to imagine."

"But all the worst criminals look innocent and harmless, don't they?"

Robert let that pass. He wanted to know about the bruises on the girl's
body. Were they fresh bruises?

"Oh, quite fresh. Most of them had not begun to 'turn' even."

This surprised Robert a little.

"But there were older bruises as well, I take it."

"If there were they had faded so much as to be unnoticeable among all
the bad new ones."

"What did the new ones look like? A whipping?"

"Oh, no. She had actually been knocked about. Even her poor little
face. One jaw was swollen, and there was a big bruise on the other

"The police say that she grew hysterical when it was suggested that she
should tell them her story."

"That was when she was still ill. Once we had got the story out of her
and she had had a long rest, it was easy enough to persuade her to
repeat it to the police."

"I know you will answer this frankly, Mrs. Wynn: Has there never been
any suspicion in your mind that Betty's story might not be true? Even a
momentary suspicion?"

"Not even a momentary one. Why should there be? She has always been a
truthful child. Even if she hadn't, how could she invent a long
circumstantial story like that without being found out? The police
asked her all the questions they wanted to; there was never any
suggestion of accepting her statement as it stood."

"When she first told her story to you, did she tell it all in a piece?"

"Oh, no; it was spread over a day or two. The outline, first. And then
filling in the details as she remembered them. Things like the window
in the attic being round."

"Her days of coma had not blurred her memory."

"I don't think they would in any case. I mean, with Betty's kind of
brain. She has a photographic memory."

Has she indeed! thought Robert; both ears erect and wide open.

"Even as a small child she could look at the page of a book--a child's
book, of course--and repeat most of the contents from the picture in
her mind. And when we played the Kim game--you know? the objects on the
tray--we had to put Betty out of the game because she invariably won.
Oh, no, she would remember what she saw."

Well, there was another game in which the cry was "Growing warm!"
Robert remembered.

"You say she was always a truthful child--and everyone supports you in
that--but did she never indulge in romanticising her own life, as
children sometimes do?"

"Never," said Mrs. Wynn firmly. The idea seemed faintly to amuse her.
"She couldn't," she added. "Unless it was the real thing it was no use
to Betty. Even playing dolls' tea-parties, she would never imagine the
things on the plates as most children are quite happy to do; there had
to be a real thing there, even if it was only a little cube of bread.
Usually it was something nicer, of course; it was a good way to wangle
an extra and she was always a little greedy."

Robert admired the detachment with which she considered her longed-for
and much-loved daughter. The remains of a schoolmistress's cynicism? So
much more valuable, anyhow, for a child than a blind love. It was a
pity that her intelligence and devotion had been so ill-rewarded.

"I don't want to keep on at a subject that must be unpleasant for you,"
Robert said. "But perhaps you could tell me something about the

"Her parents?" Mrs. Wynn asked, surprised.

"Yes. Did you know them well? What were they like?"

"We didn't know them at all. We never even saw them."

"But you had Betty for--what was it?--nine months?--before her parents
were killed, hadn't you?"

"Yes, but her mother wrote shortly after Betty came to us and said that
to come to see her would only upset the child and make her unhappy and
that the best thing for everyone would be to leave her to us until such
times as she could go back to London. She said would I talk to Betty
about her at least once every day."

Robert's heart contracted with pity for this unknown dead woman who had
been willing to tear her own heart out for her only child. What
treasure of love and care had been poured out in front of Betty Kane,
child evacuee.

"Did she settle down easily when she came? Or did she cry for her

"She cried because she didn't like the food. I don't remember her ever
crying for her mother. She fell in love with Leslie the first
night--she was just a baby, you know--and I think her interest in him
blotted out any grief she might have felt. And he, being four years
older, was just the right age to feel protective. He still does--that
is why we are in this mess today."

"How did this _Ack-Emma_ affair happen? I know it was your son who went
to the paper, but did you eventually come round to his----"

"Good heavens, no," Mrs. Wynn said indignantly. "It was all over before
we could do anything about it. My husband and I were out when Leslie
and the reporter came--they sent a man back with him when they heard
his story, to get it first-hand from Betty--and when----"

"And Betty gave it quite willingly?"

"I don't know how willingly. I wasn't there. My husband and I knew
nothing about it until this morning, when Leslie laid an _Ack-Emma_
under our noses. A little defiantly, I may add. He is not feeling too
good about it now that it is done. The _Ack-Emma_, I should like to
assure you, Mr. Blair, is not normally my son's choice. If he had not
been worked-up----"

"I know. I know exactly how it happened. And that
tell-us-your-troubles-and-we'll-see-right-done is very insidious
stuff." He rose. "You have been very kind indeed, Mrs. Wynn, and I am
exceedingly grateful to you."

His tone was evidently more heartfelt than she had expected and she
looked doubtfully at him. What have I said to help you? she seemed to
be asking, half-dismayed.

He asked where Betty's parents had lived in London, and she told him.
"There is nothing there now," she added. "Just the open space. It is to
be part of some new building scheme, so they have done nothing to it so

On the doorstep he ran into Leslie.

Leslie was an extraordinarily good-looking young man who seemed to be
entirely unaware of the fact--a trait that endeared him to Robert, who
was in no mood to look kindly on him. Robert had pictured him as the
bull-in-a-china-shop type; but on the contrary he was a rather
delicate, kind-looking boy with shy earnest eyes and untidy soft hair.
He glared at Robert with frank enmity when his mother presented him and
had explained his business there; but, as his mother had said, there
was a shade of defiance in the glare; Leslie was obviously not very
happy with his own conscience this evening.

"No one is going to beat my sister and get away with it," he said
fiercely when Robert had mildly deplored his action.

"I sympathise with your point of view," Robert said, "but I personally
would rather be beaten nightly for a fortnight than have my photograph
on the front page of the _Ack-Emma_. Especially if I was a young girl."

"If you had been beaten every night for a fortnight and no one did
anything about it you might be very glad to have your photograph
published in any rag if it got you justice," Leslie observed
pertinently and brushed past them into the house.

Mrs. Wynn turned to Robert with a small apologetic smile, and Robert,
taking advantage of her softened moment, said: "Mrs. Wynn, if it ever
occurs to you that anything in that story of Betty's does not ring
true, I hope you won't decide that sleeping dogs are best left."

"Don't pin your faith to that hope, Mr. Blair."

"You would let sleeping dogs lie, and the innocent suffer?"

"Oh no; I didn't mean that. I meant the hope of my doubting Betty's
story. If I believed her at the beginning I am not likely to doubt her

"One never knows. Someday it may occur to you that this or that does
not 'fit.' You have a naturally analytic mind; it may present you with
a piece of subconscious when you least expect it. Something that has
puzzled you deep down may refuse to be pushed down any more."

She had walked to the gate with him, and as he spoke the last sentence
he turned to take farewell of her. To his surprise something moved
behind her eyes at that light remark of his.

So she wasn't certain after all.

Somewhere, in the story, in the circumstances, there was some small
thing that left a question in that sober analytical mind of hers.

What was it?

And then, with what he always remembered afterwards as the only perfect
sample of telepathic communication in his experience, he paused as he
was stepping into his car, and said: "Had she anything in her pockets
when she came home?"

"She had only one pocket; the one in her dress."

"And was there anything in it?"

There was the faintest tightening of the muscles round her mouth. "Just
a lipstick," she said, evenly.

"A lipstick! She is a little young for that, isn't she?"

"My dear Mr. Blair, they start experimenting with lipstick at the age
of ten. As a wet-day amusement it has taken the place of dressing-up in
Mother's things."

"Yes, probably; Woolworth is a great benefactor."

She smiled and said goodbye again and moved towards the house as he
drove away.

What puzzled her about the lipstick? Robert wondered, as he turned from
the uneven surface of Meadowside Lane on to the black smooth surface of
the main Aylesbury-London road. Was it just the fact that the fiends at
The Franchise should have left it with the girl? Was that what she
found odd?

How amazing that the worry in her subconscious mind had communicated
itself so instantly to him. He had not known that he was going to say
that sentence about the girl's pockets until he heard himself saying
it. It would never have occurred to him, left to himself, to wonder
what was in the pocket of her frock. It would not occur to him that the
frock might have a pocket at all.

So there was a lipstick.

And its presence was something that puzzled Mrs. Wynn.

Well; that was a straw that could be added to the little heap he had
collected. To the fact that the girl had a photographic memory. To the
fact that her nose had been put out of joint without warning only a
month or two ago. To the fact that she was greedy. To the fact that she
was bored with school. To the fact that she liked "reality."

To the fact--above all--that no one in that household, not even
detached sensible Mrs. Wynn, knew what went on in Betty Kane's mind. It
was quite unbelievable that a girl of fifteen who had been the centre
of a young man's world could see herself supplanted over-night without
reacting violently to the situation. But Betty had been "very nice
about it."

Robert found this heartening. It was proof that that candid young face
was no guide at all to the person who was Betty Kane.


Robert had decided to kill a great many birds with one stone by
spending the night in London.

To begin with, he wanted to have his hand held. And in the
circumstances no one would hold his hand to better purpose than his old
school friend Kevin Macdermott. What Kevin did not know about crime was
probably not so anyhow. And as a well-known defending counsel his
knowledge of human nature was extensive, varied, and peculiar.

At the moment the betting was evens whether Macdermott would die of
high blood-pressure before he was sixty, or grace the Woolsack when he
was seventy. Robert hoped the latter. He was very fond of Kevin.

They had first gravitated towards each other at school because they
were both "going in for Law," but they had become and remained friends
because they were complementary. To the Irishman, Robert's equanimity
was amusing, provocative, and--when he was tired--restful. To Robert,
Kevin's Celt flamboyance was exotic and fascinating. It was typical
that Robert's ambition was to go back to the little country town and
continue life as it was; while Kevin's was to alter everything that was
alterable in the Law and to make as much noise as possible in the doing
of it.

So far Kevin had not altered much--though he had done his best where
some judges' rulings were concerned--but he had made considerable noise
in his effortless, slightly malicious, fashion. Already the presence of
Kevin Macdermott in a case added fifty per cent to its newspaper
value--and a good deal more than that to its cost.

He had married--advantageously but happily--had a pleasant house near
Weybridge and three hardy sons, lean and dark and lively like their
father. For town purposes he kept a small flat in St. Paul's
Churchyard, where, as he pointed out, he "could afford to look down on
Queen Anne." And whenever Robert was in town--which was not oftener
than Robert could help--they dined together, either at the flat or at
the latest place where Kevin had found good claret. Outside the Law,
Kevin's interests were show hacks, claret, and the livelier films of
Warner Brothers.

Kevin was to be at some Bar dinner tonight, so his secretary had said
when Robert had tried to reach him from Milford; but he would be
delighted to have a legitimate excuse for dodging the speeches, so
would Robert go along to St. Paul's Churchyard after dinner, and wait
for him.

That was a good thing; if Kevin came from a dinner he would be relaxed
and prepared to settle down for the evening; not restless and with
three-quarters of his mind still back in the court-room as he sometimes

Meanwhile, he would ring up Grant at Scotland Yard and see if he could
spare him some minutes tomorrow morning. He must get it clear in his
mind how he stood in relation with Scotland Yard: fellow sufferers, but
on opposite sides of the fence.

At the Fortescue, the Edwardian old place in Jermyn Street, where he
had stayed ever since he was first allowed to go to London on his own,
they greeted him like a nephew and gave him "the room he had last
time"; a dim comfortable box with a shoulder-high bed and a
buttoned-plush settee; and brought him up a tray on which reposed an
out-size brown kitchen teapot, a Georgian silver cream jug, about a
pound of sugar lumps in a sixpenny glass dish, a Dresden cup with
flowers and little castles, a red-and-gold Worcester plate made for
"their Maj's" William IV and his Queen, and a much buckled kitchen
knife with a stained brown handle.

Both the tea and the tray refreshed Robert. He went out into the
evening streets feeling vaguely hopeful.

His search for the truth about Betty Kane brought him, only half
consciously, to the vacant space where that block of flats had been;
the spot where both her parents had died in one shattering burst of
high explosive. It was a bare neat space, waiting its appointed part in
some plan. Nothing was there to show that a building had ever stood on
the spot. Round about, the unharmed houses stood with blank smug faces,
like mentally deficient children too idiot to have understood the
meaning of a disaster. It had passed them by and that was all they knew
or cared about.

On the opposite side of the wide street, a row of small shops still
stood as they had obviously stood for fifty years or more. Robert
crossed to them and went into the tobacconist's to buy cigarettes; a
tobacconist-and-newsagent knows everything.

"Were you here when that happened?" Robert asked, leaning his head
towards the door.

"When what happened?" asked the rosy little man, so used to the blank
space that he had long ago become unaware of it. "Oh, the incident? No,
I was out on duty. Warden, I was."

Robert said that he had meant was he here in business at the time.

Oh, yes; yes, certainly he had the business then, and for long before
it. Brought up in the neighbourhood, he was, and succeeded his father
in the business.

"You would know the local people well, then. Do you remember the couple
who were caretakers of the block of flats, by any chance?"

"The Kanes? Of course I do. Why wouldn't I remember them? They were in
and out of this place all day. He for his paper in the morning, and
then her for her cigarettes shortly after, and then back for his
evening paper and her back for the third time probably for cigarettes
again, and then he and I used to have a pint at the local when my boy
had finished his lessons and would take over for me here. You knew
them, sir?"

"No. But I met someone the other day who spoke of them. How was the
whole place wrecked?"

The little pink man sucked his teeth with a derisive sound.

"Jerry-built. That's what it was. Just jerry-built. The bomb fell in
the area there--that's how the Kanes were killed, they were down in
their basement feeling fairly safe--and the whole thing just settled
down like a house of cards. Shocking." He straightened the edge of a
pile of evening papers. "It was just her bad luck that the only evening
in weeks that she was at home with her husband, a bomb had to come." He
seemed to find a sardonic pleasure in the thought.

"Where was she usually, then?" Robert asked. "Did she work somewhere in
the evenings?"

"Work!" said the little man, with vast scorn. "Her!" And then,
recollecting: "Oh, I'm sorry, I'm sure. I forgot for the minute that
they might be friends of----"

Robert hastened to assure him that his interest in the Kanes was purely
academic. Someone had remembered them as caretakers of the block of
flats, that was all. If Mrs. Kane was not out working in the evenings
what was she out doing?

"Having a good time, of course. Oh, yes, people managed to have a good
time even then--if they wanted it enough and looked hard enough for it.
Kane, he wanted her to go away to the country with that little girl of
theirs, but would she? Not her! Three days of the country would kill
her she said. She didn't even go to see the little thing when they
evacuated her. The authorities, that is. With the rest of the children.
It's my opinion she was tickled to death to have the child off her
hands so that she could go dancing at nights."

"Whom did she go dancing with?"

"Officers," the little man said succinctly. "A lot more exciting than
watching the grass grow. I don't say there was any actual harm in it,
mind you," he said hastily. "She's dead, and I wouldn't like to pin
anything on her that she isn't here to unpin, if you take my meaning.
But she was a bad mother and a bad wife, that's flat and no one ever
said anything to the contrary."

"Was she pretty?" Robert asked, thinking of the good emotion he had
wasted on Betty's mother.

"In a sulky sort of way, yes. She sort of smouldered. You wondered what
she would be like when she was lit up. Excited, I mean; not tight. I
never saw her tight. She didn't get her excitement that way."

"And her husband?"

"Ah, he was all right, Bert Kane was. Deserved better luck than that
woman. One of the best, Bert was. Terribly fond of the little girl.
Spoiled her, of course. She had only to want something and he got it
for her; but she was a nice kid, for all that. Demure. Butter wouldn't
melt in her little mouth. Yes, Bert deserved better out of life than a
good-time wife and a cupboard-love kid. One of the best, Bert was...."
He looked over the roadway at the empty space, reflectively. "It took
them the best part of a week to find him," he said.

Robert paid for his cigarettes and went out into the street both
saddened and relieved. Sad for Bert Kane, who had deserved better; but
glad that Betty Kane's mother was not the woman he had pictured. All
the way to London his mind had grieved for that dead woman; the woman
who had broken her heart for her child's good. It had seemed to him
unbearable that the child she had so greatly loved should be Betty
Kane. But now he was free of that grief. Betty Kane's mother was
exactly the mother he would have chosen for her if he were God. And she
on her part looked very like being her mother's daughter.

"A cupboard-love kid." Well, well. And what was it Mrs. Wynn had said?
"She cried because she didn't like the food, but I don't remember her
crying for her mother."

Nor for that father who so devotedly spoiled her, apparently.

When he got back to the hotel he took his copy of the _Ack-Emma_ from
his despatch case, and over his solitary dinner at the Fortescue
considered at his leisure the story on Page Two. From its
poster-simplicity opening--

    "On a night in April a girl came back to her home clad in nothing
    but a frock and shoes. She had left home, a bright happy schoolgirl
    with not a ..."

to its final fanfare of sobs, it was of its kind a small masterpiece.
It did perfectly what it set out to do. And that was to appeal to the
greatest number of readers with one and the same story. To those who
wanted sex-interest it offered the girl's lack of clothes, to the
sentimentalist her youth and charm, to the partisan her helpless
condition, to the sadist the details of her beatings, to the sufferer
from class-hatred a description of the big white house behind its high
walls, and to the warm-hearted British public in general the impression
that the police had been, if not "nobbled," then at least lax, and that
Right had not been Done.

Yes. It was clever.

Of course the story was a gift for them--which is why they had sent a
man back immediately with young Leslie Wynn. But Robert felt that, when
really on their mettle, the _Ack-Emma_ could probably make a good story
of a broken connecting-rod.

It must be a dreary business catering exclusively for the human
failings. He turned the pages over, observing how consistently each
story was used to appeal to the regrettable in the reader. Even GAVE
AWAY A MILLION, he noticed, was the story of a disgraceful old man
unloading on his income-tax and not of a boy who had climbed out of a
slum by his own courage and enterprise.

With a slight nausea he put the thing back in his case, and took the
case with him to St. Paul's Churchyard. There he found the "daily"
woman waiting for him with her hat on. Mr. Macdermott's secretary had
telephoned to say that a friend of his was coming and that he was to be
given the run of the house and left alone in it without scruple; she
had stayed merely to let him in; she would now leave him to it; there
was whisky on the little table by the fire, and there was another
bottle in the cupboard, but it might, if you asked her, be wise not to
remind Mr. Macdermott about it or he would stay up too late and she had
great trouble getting him up in the morning.

"It's not the whisky," Blair said, smiling at her, "it's the Irish in
him. All the Irish hate getting up."

This gave her pause on the doorstep; evidently struck by this new idea.

"I wouldn't wonder," she said. "My old man's the same, and he's Irish.
It's not whisky with him, just original sin. At least that's what I
always thought. But perhaps it's just his misfortune in being a

It was a pleasant little place; warm and friendly, and peaceful now
that the roar of the city traffic was still. He poured himself a drink,
went to the window to look down on Queen Anne, paused a moment to note
once more how lightly the great bulk of the church floated on its base;
so proportioned, so balanced, that it looked as if one could take it up
on a palm and dandle it there; and then sat down and, for the first
time since he had gone out that morning to see a maddening old woman
who was changing her will again, relaxed.

He was half asleep when he heard Kevin's key in the lock, and his host
was in the room before he could move.

Macdermott tweaked his neck in an evil pinch as he passed behind him to
the decanters on the table. "It's beginning, old boy," he said, "it's

"What is?" Robert asked.

"The thickening of that handsome neck of yours."

Robert rubbed his neck lazily where it stung. "I do begin to notice
draughts on the back of it, now you come to mention it," he said.

"Christ, Robert! does nothing distress you," Kevin said, his eyes pale
and bright and mocking under their black brows, "even the imminent
prospect of losing those good looks of yours?"

"I'm a little distressed at the moment, but it isn't my looks."

"Well, what with Blair, Hayward, and Bennet, it can't be bankruptcy; so
I suppose it's a woman."

"Yes, but not the way you mean."

"Thinking of getting married? You ought to, Rob."

"You said that before."

"You want an heir for Blair, Hayward, and Bennet, don't you?" The calm
certainty of Blair, Hayward, and Bennet had always pricked Kevin into
small gibes, Robert remembered.

"There is no guarantee that it wouldn't be a girl. Anyhow, Nevil is
taking care of that."

"The only thing that young woman of Nevil's will ever give birth to is
a gramophone record. She was gracing a platform again the other day, I
hear. If she had to earn the money for her train fares she mightn't be
so willing to dash about the country being the Vocal Minority." He sat
down with his drink. "I needn't ask if you are up on business. Sometime
you really ought to come up and see this town. I suppose you dash off
again tomorrow after a 10 a.m. interview with someone's solicitors."

"No," Robert said. "With Scotland Yard."

Kevin paused with his glass half-way to his mouth. "Robert, you're
slipping," he said. "What has the Yard to do with your Ivory Tower?"

"That's just it," Robert said equably, ignoring this additional flick
at his Milford security. "It's there on the doorstep and I don't quite
know how to deal with it. I want to listen to someone being intelligent
about the situation. I don't know why I should unload it on you. You
must be sick of problems. But you always did do my algebra for me."

"And you always reckoned the stocks and shares ones, if I remember
rightly. I was always a fool about stocks. I still owe you something
for saving me from a bad investment. Two bad investments," he added.


"Tamara, and Topeka Tin."

"I remember saving you from Topeka Tin, but I had nothing whatever to
do with your breaking with Tamara."

"Oh, hadn't you, indeed! My good Robert, if you could have seen your
face when I introduced you to her. Oh, no, not that way. Quite the
contrary. The instantaneous _kindness_ of your expression, that blasted
English mask of courtesy and good breeding--it said everything. I saw
myself going through life introducing Tamara to people and watching
their faces being well-bred about it. It cured me of her in record
time. I have never ceased to be grateful to you. So produce what is in
the despatch case."

Nothing escaped Kevin, Robert thought, taking out his own copy of Betty
Kane's statement to the police.

"This is a very short statement. I wish you would read it and tell me
how it strikes you."

He wanted the impact on Kevin, without preliminaries to dull the edge
of it.

Macdermott took it, read the first paragraph in one swift eye movement,
and said: "This is the _Ack-Emma_'s protégée, I take it."

"I had no idea that you ever saw the _Ack-Emma_" Robert said,

"God love you, I feed on the _Ack-Emma_. No crime, no _causes
célèbres_. No _causes célèbres_, no Kevin Macdermott. Or only a piece
of him." He lapsed into utter silence. For four minutes his absorption
was so complete that Robert felt alone in the room, as if his host had
gone away. "Humph!" he said, coming out of it.


"I take it that your clients are the two women in the case, and not
this girl?"

"Of course."

"Now you tell me your end," Kevin said, and listened.

Robert gave him the whole story. His reluctant visit, his growing
partisanship as it became clear that it was a choice between Betty Kane
and the two women, Scotland Yard's decision not to move on the
available evidence, and Leslie Wynn's rash visit to the offices of the

"So tonight," Macdermott said, "the Yard is moving heaven and earth to
find corroborative evidence that will back up the girl's story."

"I suppose so," said Robert, depressed. "But what I want to know is: Do
you or do you not believe the girl's story?"

"I never believe anyone's story," Kevin pointed out with gentle malice.
"What you want to know is: Do I find the girl's story believable? And
of course I do."

"You do!"

"I do. Why not?"

"But it's an absurd story," Robert said, more hotly than he had

"There is nothing absurd about it. Women who live lonely lives do
insane things--especially if they are poor gentlewomen. Only the other
day an elderly woman was found to have kept her sister chained up to a
bed in a room no bigger than a good-sized cupboard. She had kept her
like that for three years, and had fed her on the crusts and potato
skins and the other scraps that she didn't want herself. She said, when
it was discovered, that their money was going down too fast and this
was her way of making ends meet. She had quite a good bank balance
actually, but it was the fear induced by insecurity that had sent her
crazy. That is a much more unbelievable--and from your point of view
absurd--story than the girl's."

"Is it? It seems to me just an ordinary tale of insanity."

"Only because you know it happened. I mean, that someone had actually
seen the thing. Suppose, on the contrary, that the rumour had merely
gone round; that the crazy sister had heard it and released her victim
before any investigation could be made; that the investigators found
only two old ladies living an apparently normal life except for the
invalidism nature of one of them. What then? Would you have believed
the 'chained-up' tale? Or would you, more likely, have called it an
'absurd story'?"

Robert sank a little deeper into his depression.

"Here are two lonely and badly-dowered women saddled with a big house
in the country; one of them too old to do much household work and the
other loathing it. What is the most likely form for their mild insanity
to take? The capture of a girl to be servant to them, of course."

Damn Kevin and his counsel's mind. He had thought that he had wanted
Kevin's opinion, but what he had wanted was Kevin's backing for his own

"The girl they capture happens to be a blameless schoolgirl,
conveniently far from her home. It is their bad luck that she is so
blameless, because since she has never been caught out in a lie to
date, everyone is going to take her word against theirs. If I were the
police I would have risked it. It seems to me they are losing their

He shot an amused glance at Robert, sunk in his chair, glooming down
his long legs at the fire. He sat for a moment or two enjoying his
friend's discomfiture.

"Of course," he said, at length, "they may have remembered a parallel
case, where everyone believed the girl's heart-rending story and were
very thoroughly led up the garden."

"A parallel!" Robert said, folding his legs and sitting up. "When?"

"Seventeen-something. I forget the exact date."

"Oh," said Robert, dashed again.

"I don't know what is 'Oh' about it," Macdermott said mildly. "The
nature of alibis has not changed much in two centuries."


"If the parallel case is any guide the girl's story is an alibi."

"Then you believe---- I mean you find it believable--that the girl's
story is all nonsense?"

"A complete invention from beginning to end."

"Kevin, you are maddening. You said you found it believable."

"So I do. I also find it believable that it is a tissue of lies. I am
not briefed for either side. I can make a very good case out for
either, at the shortest notice. On the whole I should prefer to be
counsel for the young woman from Aylesbury. She would be wonderful in
the witness box, and from what you tell me neither of the Sharpes would
be much help, visually, to a counsel."

He got up to help himself to more whisky, holding out his other hand
for Robert's glass. But Robert was in no mood for conviviality. He
shook his head without lifting his gaze from the fire. He was tired and
beginning to be out of temper with Kevin. He had been wrong to come.
When a man had been a counsel in the criminal courts as long as Kevin
had, his mind had only points of view, not convictions any more. He
would wait until Kevin had half-finished the glass he was now sitting
down with, and then make a movement to go. It would be good to put his
head on a pillow and forget for a little that he was responsible for
other people's problems. Or rather, for the solution of them.

"I wonder what she was doing all that month," Kevin said
conversationally, taking a large gulp of practically neat whisky.

Robert's mouth opened to say: "Then you _do_ believe the girl is a
fake!" but he stopped himself in time. He rebelled against dancing any
more this evening to Kevin's piping.

"If you drink so much whisky on top of claret, what _you_ will be doing
for a month is a cure, my lad," he said. And to his surprise Kevin lay
back and laughed like a schoolboy.

"Oh, Rob, I love you," he said delightedly. "You are the very essence
of England. Everything we admire and envy in you. You sit there so
mild, so polite, and let people bait you, until they conclude that you
are an old tabby and they can do what they like with you, and then just
when they are beginning to preen themselves they go that short step too
far and wham! out comes that business-like paw with the glove off!" He
picked Robert's glass out of his hand without a by-your-leave and rose
to fill it and Robert let him. He was feeling better.


The London-Larborough road was a black straight ribbon in the sunshine,
giving off diamond sparks as the crowded traffic caught the light and
lost it again. Pretty soon both the air and the roads would be so full
that no one could move in comfort and everyone would have to go back to
the railways for quick travel. Progress, that was.

Kevin had pointed out last night that, what with present ease of
communications, it was quite on the cards that Betty Kane had spent her
month's vacation in Sydney, N.S.W. It was a daunting thought. She could
be anywhere from Kamchatka to Peru, and all he, Blair, had to do was a
little thing like proving she wasn't in a house on the Larborough-Milford
road. If it were not a sunny morning, and if he were not sorry for
Scotland Yard, and if he didn't have Kevin to hold his hand, and if he
were not doing pretty well on his own so far, he might have felt

Feeling sorry for Scotland Yard was the last thing he had anticipated.
But sorry he was. All Scotland Yard's energies were devoted to proving
the Sharpes guilty and Betty Kane's story true; for the very good
reason that they believed the Sharpes to be guilty. But what each one
of them ached in his private soul to do was to push Betty Kane down the
_Ack-Emma_'s throat; and they could only do that by proving her story
nonsense. Yes, a really prize state of frustration existed in those
large calm bodies at the Yard.

Grant had been charming in his quiet reasonable way--it had been rather
like going to see a doctor, now he came to think of it--and had quite
willingly agreed that Robert should be told about any letters that the
_Ack-Emma_ might provoke.

"Don't pin your hopes too firmly to that, will you," he had said, in
friendly warning. "For one letter that the Yard gets that has any worth
it gets five thousand that are nonsense. Letterwriting is the natural
outlet of the 'odds.' The busybodies, the idle, the perverted, the
cranks, the feel-it-my-duties----"

"'Pro Bono Publico'----"

"Him and 'Civis'," Grant said with a smile. "Also the plain depraved.
They all write letters. It's their _safe_ outlet, you see. They can be
as interfering, as long-winded, as obscene, as pompous, as one-idea'd,
as they like on paper, and no one can kick them for it. So they write.
My God, how they write!"

"But there is a chance----"

"Oh, yes. There is a chance. And all these letters will have to be
weeded out, however silly they are. Anything of importance will be
passed on to you, I promise. But I do remind you that the ordinary
intelligent citizen writes only one time in five thousand. He doesn't
like what he thinks of as 'poking his nose in'--which is why he sits
silent in a railway carriage and scandalises the Americans, who still
have a hick interest in other folk--and anyhow he's a busy man, full of
his own affairs, and sitting down to a letter to the police about
something that doesn't concern him is against all his instincts."

So Robert had come away pleased with the Yard, and sorry for them. At
least he, Robert, had a straight row to hoe. He wouldn't be glancing
aside every now and then and wishing it was the next row he was hoeing.
And moreover he had Kevin's approval of the row he had chosen.

"I mean it," Kevin had said, "when I say that if I were the police I
should almost have risked it. They have a good enough case. And a nice
little conviction is always a hitch up the ladder of promotion for
someone. Unfortunately--or fortunately for the citizen--the man who
decides whether there is a case or not is the chap higher up, and he's
not interested in any subordinate's speedy promotion. Amazing that
wisdom should be the by-product of office procedure."

Robert, mellow with whisky, had let the cynicism flow past him.

"But let them just get one spot of corroboration, and they'll have a
warrant at the door of The Franchise quicker than you can lift a
telephone receiver."

"They won't get any corroboration," said the mellow Robert. "Why should
they? How could they? What we want to do is to disprove the girl's
story ourselves, so that it doesn't damn the Sharpes' lives for as long
as they live. Once I have seen the aunt and uncle tomorrow we may have
enough general knowledge about the girl to justify a start on our own

Now he was speeding down the black shining Larborough road on the way
to seeing Betty's relations in Mainshill; the people she had stayed
with on the memorable holiday. A Mr. and Mrs. Tilsit, they were.
Tilsit, 93 Cherrill Street, Mainshill, Larborough--and the husband was
travelling agent for a firm of brush-makers in Larborough and they had
no children. That was all Robert knew about them.

He paused for a moment as he turned off the main road in Mainshill.
This was the corner where Betty Kane waited for her bus. Or said she
waited. Over there on the other side, it must have been. There was no
side turning on that side; nothing but the long stretch of unbroken
pavement as far as one could see in either direction. A busy enough
road at this time of day; but empty enough, Robert supposed, in the
doldrum hour of the late afternoon.

Cherrill Street was one long series of angular bay windows in dirty red
brick, their forward surface almost scraping the low red-brick wall
that hemmed them in from the pavement. The sour soil on either side of
the window that did duty for a garden had none of the virtues of the
new-turned earth of Meadowside Lane, Aylesbury; it grew only thin
London Pride, weedy wallflowers, and moth-eaten forget-me-not. The
same housewife's pride obtained in Cherrill Street as in Aylesbury, of
course, and the same crisp curtains hung at the windows; but if there
were poets in Cherrill Street they found other outlets for their soul
than gardens.

When he had rung unavailingly, and then knocked, at
93--indistinguishable from the others as far as he could see except by
its painted numerals--a woman flung up the bedroom window next door,
leaned out and said:

"You looking for Mrs. Tilsit?"

Robert said that he was.

"She's gone to get her groceries. The shop at the corner."

"Oh, thanks. If that's all, I'll wait."

"Shouldn't wait if you want to see her soon. Should go and fetch her."

"Oh. Is she going somewhere else?"

"No, just the grocer's; it's the only shop round here. But she takes
half a morning deciding between two brands of wheat flakes. You take
one packet up right firm and put it in her bag and she'll be quite

Robert thanked her and began to walk away to the end of the street,
when she hailed him again.

"Shouldn't leave your car. Take it with you."

"But it's quite a little way, isn't it?"

"Maybe, but it's Saturday."


"School's out."

"Oh, I see. But there's nothing in it----" "to steal," he was going to
say but amended it to "Nothing in it that's movable."

"Movable! Huh! That's good. We had window-boxes once. Mrs. Laverty over
the way had a gate. Mrs. Biddows had two fine wooden clothes posts and
eighteen yards of clothes rope. They all thought they weren't movable.
You leave your car there for ten minutes you'll be lucky to find the

So Robert got obediently into the car, and drove down to the grocer's.
And as he drove he remembered something, and the memory puzzled him.
This was where Betty Kane had been so happy. This rather dreary, rather
grimy street; one of a warren of streets very like itself. So happy
that she had written to say that she was staying on for the rest of her

What had she found here that was so desirable?

He was still wondering as he walked into the grocer's and prepared to
spot Mrs. Tilsit among the morning customers. But there was no need for
any guesswork. There was only one woman in the shop, and one glance at
the grocer's patient face and the cardboard packet in the woman's
either hand, made it plain that she was Mrs. Tilsit.

"Can I get you something, sir," the grocer said detaching himself for a
moment from the woman's ponderings--it wasn't wheat flakes this
morning, it was powdered soap--and moving towards Robert.

"No, thank you," Robert said. "I am just waiting for this lady."

"For me?" the woman said. "If it's the gas, then----"

Robert said hastily that he wasn't the gas.

"I _have_ a vacuum cleaner, and it's going fine," she offered, and
prepared to go back to her problem.

Robert said that he had his car outside and would wait until she had
finished, and was beating a hasty retreat; but she said: "A car! Oh.
Well, you can drive me back, can't you, and save me carrying all those
things. How much, Mr. Carr, please?"

Mr. Carr, who had taken a packet of soap-flakes from her during her
interest in Robert and wedged it into her shopping-bag, took her money,
gave her change, wished her a thankful good-day, and cast a pitiful
glance at Robert as he followed the woman out to his car.

Robert had known that it was too much to hope for another woman with
Mrs. Wynn's detachment and intelligence, but his heart sank as he
considered Mrs. Tilsit. Mrs. Tilsit was one of those women whose minds
are always on something else. They chat brightly with you, they agree
with you, they admire what you are wearing, and they offer advice, but
their real attention is concentrated on what to do with the fish, or
what Florrie told them about Minnie's eldest, or where they have left
the laundry book, or even just what a bad filling that is in your right
front tooth; anything, everything, except the subject in hand.

She seemed impressed with the appearance of Robert's car, and asked him
in to have a cup of tea--there being apparently no hour of the day when
a cup of tea was not a possible article of diet. Robert felt that he
could not drink with her--even a cup of tea--without making plain his
position of opposing counsel, so to speak. He did his best, but it was
doubtful if she understood; her mind was so plainly already deciding
whether to offer him the Rich Tea or the Mixed Fancy biscuits with his
tea. Mention of her niece made none of the expected stir in her

"A most extraordinary thing, that was, wasn't it?" she said. "Taking
her away and beating her. What good did they think that was going to do
them? Sit down, Mr. Blayne, come in and sit down. I'll just----"

A bloodcurdling scream echoed through the house. An urgent,
high-pitched, desperate screaming that went on and on, without even a
pause for breath.

Mrs. Tilsit humped her parcels in a movement of exasperation. She
leaned near enough to Robert to put her mouth within shouting distance
of his ear. "My kettle," she yelled. "I'll be right back."

Robert sat down, and again considered the surroundings and wondered why
Betty Kane had found them so good. Mrs. Wynn's front room had been a
living-room; a sitting-room warm with human occupation and human
traffic. But this was clearly a "best" room, kept for visitors who were
not intimate enough to be admitted to the back regions; the real life
of the house was in the poky room at the back. Either kitchen or
kitchen-sitting-room. And yet Betty Kane had elected to stay. Had she
found a friend? A girl-next-door? A boy-next-door?

Mrs. Tilsit came back in what seemed like two minutes, bearing a tray
with tea. Robert wondered a little at this promptness of action until
he saw the tray's contents. Mrs. Tilsit had not waited to make a
decision; she had brought them both; Thin Wine and Sweet Shortbread. At
least, he thought, watching her pour, that this woman explained one of
the oddities in the affair: the fact that when the Wynns had written to
have Betty sent home at once, her aunt had not flown to a telegraph
office to break the news that Betty had left for home nearly a
fortnight ago. The Betty who had gone a fortnight previously would be
much less real in Mrs. Tilsit's mind than the jelly that was cooling on
the back window-sill.

"I wasn't worried about her," Mrs. Tilsit said, as if in echo to his
thoughts. "When they wrote from Aylesbury about her, I knew she would
turn up. When Mr. Tilsit came home he was quite upset about it; he goes
away for a week or ten days at a time you know; he's agent for Weekses;
carried on like a mad thing, he did; but I just said you wait and
she'll turn up all right, and she did. Well, nearly all right."

"She said she enjoyed her holiday here enormously."

"I suppose she did," she said vaguely, not looking gratified as Robert
had expected. He glanced at her and realised that her mind was already
on something else. The strength of his tea, if one was to judge by the
direction of her eye.

"How did she pass her time? Did she make friends?"

"Oh, no, she was in Larborough most of the time."


"Oh, well, when I say most of the time, I do her an injustice. She
helped with the house in the mornings, but in a house this size and me
used to doing everything myself there isn't much to do. And she was
here on holiday, wasn't she, poor thing, after all that school work.
What good all that book work is to a young girl I don't know. Mrs.
Harrap's daughter over the way could hardly write her name but she
married the third son of a lord. Or perhaps it was the son of a third
son," she said, looking doubtful. "I forget for the minute. She----"

"How did she spend her time in Larborough? Betty, I mean."

"Pictures, mostly."

"Pictures? Oh, the cinema. I see."

"You can do that from morning till night if you're given that way, in
Larborough. The big ones open at half-past ten and they mostly change
mid-week and there's about forty of them, so you can just go from one
to another till it's time to go home."

"Is that what Betty did?"

"Oh, no. She's quite sensible, Betty is. She used to go in to the
morning round because you get in cheaper before noon, and then she'd go

"Bus-riding. Where?"

"Oh, anywhere the fancy took her. Have another of these biscuits, Mr.
Bain; they're fresh from the tin. She went to see the castle at Norton
one day. Norton's the county town you know. Everyone imagines
Larborough is because it's so big, but Norton's always been----"

"Did she not come home to lunch, then?"

"What? Oh, Betty. No, she'd have coffee lunch somewhere. We always have
our real meal at night anyhow, you see, with Mr. Tilsit being out all
day, so there was always a meal waiting when she came home. It's always
been my pride to have a good nourishing sit-down meal ready for my----"

"What time would that be? Six?"

"No, Mr. Tilsit doesn't usually manage home before half-past seven."

"And I suppose Betty was home long before then?"

"Mostly she was. She was late once because she went to an afternoon
show at the pictures, but Mr. Tilsit he created about it--though I'm
sure he had no need to, what harm can you come to at the pictures?--and
after that she was always home before him. When he was here, that is.
She wasn't so careful when he was away."

So the girl had been her own mistress for a good fortnight. Free to
come and go without question, and limited only by the amount of holiday
money in her pocket. It was an innocent-sounding fortnight; and in the
case of most girls of her age it undoubtedly would have been that. The
cinema in the morning, or window gazing; a coffee lunch; a bus-ride
into the country in the afternoon. A blissful holiday for an
adolescent; the first taste of unsupervised freedom.

But Betty Kane was no normal adolescent. She was the girl who had told
that long and circumstantial story to the police without a tremor. The
girl with four weeks of her life unaccounted for. The girl that someone
had ended by beating unmercifully. How, then, had Betty Kane spent her
unsupervised freedom?

"Did she go to Milford on the bus, do you know?"

"No, _they_ asked me that, of course, but I couldn't say yes or not."


"The police."

Yes, of course; he had forgotten for the moment that the police would
have checked Betty Kane's every sentence to the limit of their power.

"You're not police, I think you said."

"No," Robert said yet once again, "I'm a lawyer. I represent the two
women who are supposed to have detained Betty."

"Oh, yes. You told me. I suppose they have to have a lawyer like anyone
else, poor things. To ask questions for them. I hope I'm telling you
the things you want to know, Mr. Blayne."

He had another cup of tea in the hope that sooner or later she would
tell him something he wanted to know. But it was mere repetition now.

"Did the police know that Betty was away on her own all day?" he asked.

She really thought about that. "That I can't remember," she said. "They
asked me how she passed her time and I said that mostly she went to
pictures or bus-riding, and they said did I go with her and I
said--well, I'll have to admit I told a white lie about it and said
that I did now and then. I didn't want them to think that Betty went to
places alone. Though of course there was no harm in it."

What a mind!

"Did she have letters while she was here?" he asked as he was taking
his leave.

"Just from home. Oh, yes, I would know. I always took the letters in.
In any case they wouldn't have written to her, would they?"


"Those women who kidnapped her."

It was with a feeling of escape that Robert drove in to Larborough. He
wondered if Mr. Tilsit had always been away "ten days at a time" from
his home, or if he had got the travelling job as an alternative to
flight or suicide.

In Larborough, Blair sought out the main garage of the Larborough And
District Motor Services. He knocked at the door of the small office
that guarded one side of the entrance, and went in. A man in a bus
inspector's uniform was going through papers on the desk. He glanced up
at Robert and without asking his business continued his own affairs.

Robert said that he wanted to see someone who would know about the
Milford bus service.

"Time table on the wall outside," the man said without looking up.

"I don't want to know about times. I know them. I live in Milford. I
want to know if you ever run a double-decker bus on that route."

There was silence for a long time; a silence expertly calculated to end
at the point where Robert was about to open his mouth again.

"No," said the man.

"Never?" Robert asked.

This time there was no answer at all. The inspector made it plain that
he was finished with him.

"Listen," Robert said, "this is important. I am a partner in a firm of
solicitors in Milford, and I----"

The man turned on him. "I don't care if you are the Shah of Persia;
there are _no double-decker buses on the Milford run_! And what do
_you_ want?" he added as a small mechanic appeared behind Robert in the

The mechanic hesitated, as if the business he had come on had been
upset by a newer interest. But he pulled himself together and began to
state his business. "It's about those spares for Norton. Shall I----"

As Robert was edging past him out of the office he felt a tug on his
coat and realised that the little mechanic wanted him to linger until
he could talk to him. Robert went out and bent over his own car, and
presently the mechanic appeared at his elbow.

"You asking about double-decker buses? I couldn't contradict him
straight out, you know; in the mood he's in now it'd be as much as my
job's worth. You want to _use_ a double-decker, or just to know if they
ever run at all? Because you can't _get_ a double-decker on that route,
not to travel in, because the buses on that run are all----"

"I know, I know. They are single-decks. What I wanted to know was
whether there _ever_ are two-deck buses on the Milford route."

"Well, there are not supposed to be, you understand, but once or twice
this year we've had to use a double-decker when one of the old single
ones broke down unexpected. Sooner or later they'll be all double-deck,
but there isn't enough traffic on the Milford run to justify a double,
so all the old crocks of singles eventually land on that route and a
few more like it. And so----"

"You're a great help. Would it be possible to find out exactly when a
double-decker did run on that route?"

"Oh, certainly," the mechanic said, with a shade of bitterness. "In
this firm it's recorded every time you spit. But the records are in
there," he tilted back his head to indicate the office, "and as long as
_he's_ there there's nothing doing."

Robert asked at what hour there would be something doing.

"Well: he goes off at the same time as me: six. But I could wait a few
minutes and look up the schedules when he's gone if it's very important
to you."

Robert did not know how he was going to wait through the hours till six
o'clock, but six o'clock it would have to be.

"Righto. I'll meet you in the Bell, that's the pub at the end of the
street, about a quarter past six. That do?"

That would do perfectly, Robert said. Perfectly.

And he went away to see what he could bribe the lounge waiter at the
Midland into giving him out of hours.


"I suppose you know what you're doing, dear," Aunt Lin said, "but I
can't help thinking it's very odd of you to defend people like that."

"I am not 'defending' them," Robert said patiently, "I am representing
them. And there is no evidence whatever that they are 'people like

"There is the girl's statement, Robert. She couldn't just have made all
that up."

"Oh, couldn't she!"

"What advantage would it be to her to tell a lot of lies!" She was
standing in his doorway passing her prayer-book from one hand to the
other as she put on her white gloves. "What else could she have been
doing if she wasn't at The Franchise?"

Robert bit back a "You'd be surprised!" It was always best with Aunt
Lin to take the line of least resistance.

She smoothed her gloves into place. "If it's just that you're being
noble, Robert dear, I must say you are just being wrong-headed. And do
you have to go out to the _house_! Surely they could come to the office
tomorrow. There's no hurry is there? It isn't as if someone was going
to arrest them on the spot."

"It was my suggestion that I should go out to The Franchise. If someone
accused _you_ of stealing things off Woolworth's counter and you
couldn't disprove it, I don't suppose you would enjoy walking down
Milford High Street in broad daylight."

"I mightn't like it but I should most certainly do it, and give Mr.
Hensell a piece of my mind."

"Who is Mr. Hensell?"

"The manager. Couldn't you come to church with me first and then go out
to The Franchise; it's such a long time since you've been, dear."

"If you stand there much longer you'll be late for the first time in
ten years. You go and pray that my judgment may be perfected."

"I shall most certainly pray for you, dear. I always do. I shall also
put up a little one for myself. All this is going to be very difficult
for me."

"For you?"

"Now that you're acting for those people I shan't be able to talk about
it to anyone. It is quite maddening, dear, to sit silent and hear
everyone telling for gospel truth things you know for a fact are wrong.
It's like wanting to be sick and having to postpone it. Oh, dear, the
bells have stopped, haven't they? I'll just have to slip into the
Bracketts' pew. They won't mind. You won't stay to lunch at that place,
will you, dear."

"I don't suppose that I shall be invited."

But his welcome at The Franchise was so warm that he felt that he might
very well be invited after all. He would say no, of course; not because
Aunt Lin's chicken was waiting but because Marion Sharpe would have to
do the washing up afterwards. When there was no one there they probably
ate off trays. Or in the kitchen, for all anyone knew.

"I am sorry we refused to answer the telephone last night," Marion
said, apologising again. "But after the fourth or fifth time it really
was too much. And we didn't expect you to have news so soon. After all
you had only set out on Friday afternoon."

"Your telephone callers: were they male or female?"

"One male, and four female, as far as I remember. When you rang this
morning I thought it was beginning again, but they seem to be
late-sleepers. Or perhaps they don't really get evil-minded much before
evening. We certainly provided the Saturday evening's entertainment for
the country youths. They congregated in a group inside the gate and
cat-called. Then Nevil found a bar of wood in the out-house----"


"Yes, your nephew. I mean, your cousin. He came to pay what he called a
visit of condolence, which was very nice of him. And he found a bar
that could be wedged in the gateway to keep the thing shut; we have no
key for it, you see. But of course that didn't stop them for long. They
hoisted each other up on the wall, and sat there in a row being
offensive until it was time for them to go to their beds."

"Lack of education," old Mrs. Sharpe said thoughtfully, "is an
extraordinary handicap when one is being offensive. They had no
resource at all."

"Neither have parrots," Robert said. "But they can be provocative
enough. We must see what police protection we can claim. Meanwhile I
can tell you something pleasanter about that wall. I know how the girl
saw over it."

He told them about his visit to Mrs. Tilsit and his discovery that the
girl amused herself by bus-riding (or said she did) and his subsequent
visit to the Larborough And District Motor Services garage.

"In the fortnight that the girl was at Mainshill there were two
breakdowns of single-deck buses due to go out on the Milford run; and
each time a double-decker had to be substituted. There are only three
services each way daily, you know. And each time the breakdown happened
to the bus due to go out on the mid-day service. So there were at least
two occasions in that fortnight when she could have seen the house, the
courtyard, you two, and the car, all together."

"But could anyone passing on top of a bus take in so much?"

"Have you ever travelled on the upper deck of a country bus? Even when
the bus is going at a steady thirty-five, the pace seems funeral. What
you can see is so much further away, and you can see it so much longer.
Down below, the hedges brush the window and the pace seems good because
things are closer. That is one thing. The other is that she has a
photographic memory." And he told them what Mrs. Wynn had said.

"Do we tell the police this?" Mrs. Sharpe asked.

"No. It doesn't prove anything; just solves the problem of how she knew
about you. When she needed an alibi she remembered you, and risked your
not being able to prove that you were somewhere else. When you bring
your car to the door, by the way, which side of the car is nearest the

"Whether I bring it round from the garage or in from the road the off
side is next the door, because it's easier to get out of."

"Yes; so that the near side, with the darker paint on the front wheel,
would be facing the gate," Robert said conclusively. "That is the
picture she saw. The grass and the divided path, the car at the door
with the odd wheel, two women--both individual--the round attic window
in the roof. She had only to look at the picture in her mind and
describe it. The day she was using the picture for--the day she was
supposed to have been kidnapped--was more than a month away and it was
a thousand to one against your being able to say what you had done or
where you had been on that day."

"And I take it," Mrs. Sharpe said, "that the odds are very much greater
against our being able to say what she has done or where she has been
in that month."

"The odds are against us, yes. As my friend Kevin Macdermott pointed
out last night, there is nothing to hinder her having been in Sydney,
N.S.W. But somehow I am far more hopeful today than I was on Friday
morning. We know so much more about the girl now." He told them of his
interviews in Aylesbury and Mainshill.

"But if the police inquiries didn't unearth what she was doing that

"The police inquiries were devoted to checking her statement. They
didn't start, as we do, with the premise that her statement is untrue
from beginning to end. They checked it and it checked. They had no
particular reason to doubt it. She had a blameless reputation, and when
they inquired from her aunt how she had spent her holiday time they
found that it had consisted of innocent visits to the cinema and
country bus-rides."

"And what do _you_ think it consisted of?" Mrs. Sharpe asked.

"I think she met someone in Larborough. That, anyhow, is the obvious
explanation. It's from that supposition that I think any inquiry of
ours should start."

"And what do we do about engaging an agent?" asked Mrs. Sharpe. "Do you
know of one?"

"Well," Robert said, hesitating, "it had crossed my mind that you might
let me pursue my own inquiries a little further before we engage a
professional. I know that----"

"Mr. Blair," the old woman said, interrupting him, "you have been
called into this unpleasant case without warning, and it cannot have
been very willingly; and you have been very kind in doing your best for
us. But we cannot expect you to turn yourself into a private inquiry
agent on our behalf. We are not rich--indeed we have very little to
live on--but as long as we have any money at all we shall pay for what
services are proper. And it is not proper that you should turn yourself
into a--what is it?--a Sexton Blake for our benefit."

"It may not be proper but it is very much to my taste. Believe me, Mrs.
Sharpe, I hadn't planned it with any conscious thought of saving your
pocket. Coming home in the car last night, very pleased with what I had
done so far, I realised how much I should hate giving up the search to
someone else. It had become a personal hunt. Please don't discourage me

"If Mr. Blair is willing to carry on a little longer," Marion
interrupted, "I think we should thank him heartily and accept. I know
just how he feels. I wish I could go hunting myself."

"There will no doubt come a time when I shall have to turn it over to a
proper inquiry agent whether I want to or not. If the trail leads far
from Larborough, for instance. I have too many other commitments to
follow it far. But as long as the search is on our doorsteps I do want
to be the one to pursue it."

"How had you planned to pursue it?" Marion asked, interested.

"Well, I had thought of beginning with the coffee-lunch places. In
Larborough, I mean. For one thing, there can't be so very many of them.
And for another, we do know that, at any rate at the beginning, that
was the kind of lunch she had."

"Why do you say 'at the beginning'?" Marion asked.

"Once she had met the hypothetical X, she may have lunched anywhere.
But up till then she paid for her own lunches, and they were 'coffee'
ones. A girl of that age prefers a bun lunch anyhow, even if she has
money for a two-course meal. So I concentrate on the coffee-places. I
flourish the _Ack-Emma_ at the waitresses and find out as tactfully as
a country lawyer knows how whether they have ever seen the girl in
their place. Does that sound like sense to you?"

"Very good sense," Marion said.

Robert turned to Mrs. Sharpe. "But if you think you will be better
served by a professional--and that is more than possible--then I shall
bow out with----"

"I don't think we could be better served by anyone," Mrs. Sharpe said.
"I have expressed my appreciation already of the trouble you have gone
to on our behalf. If it would really please you to run down

"Moppet," supplied Robert happily.

"Mopsy," Mrs. Sharpe amended, "then we can only agree and be grateful.
But it seems to me likely to be a very long run."

"Why long?"

"There is a big gap, it seems to me, between meeting a hypothetical X
in Larborough, and walking into a house near Aylesbury wearing nothing
but a frock and shoes and well and truly beaten. Marion, there is still
some of the Amontillado, I think."

In the silence that succeeded Marion's departure to fetch the sherry
the quiet of the old house became apparent. There were no trees in the
courtyard to make small noises in the wind and no birds to chatter. The
silence was as absolute as the midnight silence of a small town. Was it
peaceful, Robert wondered, after the crowded life of a boarding-house?
Or was it lonely and a little frightening?

They had valued its privacy, old Mrs. Sharpe had said in his office on
Friday morning. But was it a good life shut in behind the high walls in
the perpetual silence?

"It seems to me," Mrs. Sharpe said, "that the girl took a great risk in
choosing The Franchise, knowing nothing of the household or its

"Of course she took a risk," Robert said. "She had to. But I don't
think it was as big a gamble as you think."


"No. What you are saying is that for all the girl knew there might be a
large household of young people and three maid-servants at The


"But I think she knew quite well that there was no such thing."

"How could she?"

"Either she gossiped with the bus-conductor, or--and I think this is
the more likely--she overheard comment from her fellow-passengers. You
know the kind of thing: 'There are the Sharpes. Fancy living alone in a
big house like that, just the two of them. And no maids willing to stay
in a lonely place so far from shops and the pictures----' and so on. It
is very much a 'local' bus, that Larborough-Milford one. And it is a
lonely route, with no wayside cottages, and no village other than Ham
Green. The Franchise is the only spot of human interest for miles. It
would be more than human nature is capable of to pass the combined
interest of the house, the owners, and their car without comments of
some kind."

"I see. Yes, that makes sense."

"I wish, in a way, it _had_ been through chatting with the conductor
that she learned about you. That way, he would be more likely to
remember her. The girl says she was never in Milford and doesn't know
where it is. If a conductor remembered her, we could at least shake her
story to that extent."

"If I know anything of the young person she would open those child-like
eyes of hers and say: 'Oh, was that Milford? I just got on a bus and
went to the terminus and back.'"

"Yes. It wouldn't take us very far. But if I fail to pick up the girl's
trail in Larborough, I'll try her picture on the local conductors. I do
wish she was a more memorable creature."

The silence fell round them again while they contemplated the
un-memorable nature of Betty Kane.

They were sitting in the drawing-room, facing the window, looking out
on the green square of the courtyard and faded pink of the brick wall.
And as they looked the gate was pushed open and a small group of seven
or eight people appeared and stood at gaze. Entirely at their ease they
were; pointing out to each other the salient points of interest--the
favourite being apparently the round window in the roof. If last night
The Franchise had provided the country youth with its Saturday evening
entertainment, it was now, so it would seem, providing Sunday morning
interest for Larborough. Certainly a couple of cars were waiting for
them outside the gate, since the women of the party wore silly little
shoes and indoor frocks.

Robert glanced across at Mrs. Sharpe, but except for a tightening of
her always grim mouth she had not moved.

"Our public," she said at last, witheringly.

"Shall I go and move them on?" Robert said. "It's my fault for not
putting back the wooden bar you left off for me."

"Let them be," she said. "They will go presently. This is what royalty
puts up with daily; we can support it for a few moments."

But the visitors showed no sign of going. Indeed, one group moved round
the house to inspect the out-buildings; and the rest were still there
when Marion came back with the sherry. Robert apologised again for not
having put up the bar. He was feeling small and inadequate. It went
against the grain to stay there quietly and watch strangers prowling
round as if they owned the place or were contemplating buying it. But
if he went out and asked them to move on and they refused to, what
power had he to make them go? And how would he look in the Sharpes'
eyes if he had to beat a retreat to the house and leave these people in

The group of explorers came back from their tour round the house and
reported with laughter and gesticulation what they had seen. He heard
Marion say something under her breath and wondered if she were cursing.
She looked like a woman who would have a very fine line in curses. She
had put down the sherry tray and had apparently forgotten about it; it
was no moment for hospitality. He longed to do something decisive and
spectacular to please her, just as he had longed to rescue his
lady-love from burning buildings when he was fifteen. But alas, there
was no surmounting the fact that he was forty-odd and had learned that
it is wiser to wait for the fire-escape.

And while he hesitated, angry with himself and with those crude human
creatures outside, the fire-escape arrived in the person of a tall
young man in a regrettable tweed suit.

"Nevil," breathed Marion, watching the picture.

Nevil surveyed the group with his most insufferable air of superiority,
and it seemed that they wilted slightly, but they were evidently
determined to stand their ground. Indeed, the male with the sports
jacket and the pin-striped trousers was clearly preparing to make an
issue of it.

Nevil looked at them silently for a further few seconds and then fished
in his inner pocket for something. At the first movement of his hand a
strange difference came over the group. The outer members of it
detached themselves and faded unobtrusively through the gate; the
nearer ones lost their air of bravado, and became placatory. Finally
the sports-jacket made small rejecting movements of surrender and
joined the retreat through the gate.

Nevil banged the gate to behind them, levered the wooden bar into
place, and strolled up the path to the door wiping his hands
fastidiously on a really shocking handkerchief. And Marion ran out to
the door to meet him.

"Nevil!" Robert heard her say. "How did you do it?"

"Do what?" Nevil asked.

"Get rid of those creatures."

"Oh, I just asked their names and addresses," Nevil said. "You've no
idea how discreet people become if you take out a notebook and ask for
their name and address. It's the modern equivalent to: 'Fly, all is
discovered.' They don't wait to ask your credentials in case you may
actually have some. Hello, Robert. Good morning, Mrs. Sharpe. I'm
actually on my way to Larborough, but I saw the gate open and these two
frightful cars outside so I stopped to investigate. I didn't know
Robert was here."

This quite innocent implication that of course Robert was capable of
dealing equally well with the situation was the unkindest cut of all.
Robert could have brained him.

"Well, now that you are here and have so expertly rid us of the
nuisance you must stay and drink a glass of sherry," Mrs. Sharpe said.

"Could I come in and drink it on my way home in the evening?" Nevil
said. "You see, I'm on my way to lunch with my prospective
father-in-law and it being Sunday there is a ritual. One must be there
for the warming-up exercises."

"But of course come in on your way home," Marion said. "We shall be
delighted. How shall we know it is you? For the gate, I mean." She was
pouring sherry and handing it to Robert.

"Do you know morse?"

"Yes, but don't tell me you do."

"Why not?"

"You look a most unlikely morse addict."

"Oh, when I was fourteen I was going to sea, and I acquired in the heat
of my ambition a lot of incidental idiocies. Morse was one of them. I
shall hoot the initials of your beautiful name on the horn, when I
come. Two longs and three shorts. I must fly. The thought of talking to
you tonight will support me through luncheon at the Palace."

"Won't Rosemary be any support?" Robert asked, overcome by his baser

"I shouldn't think so. On Sundays Rosemary is a daughter in her
father's house. It is a role that does not become her. _Au revoir_,
Mrs. Sharpe. Don't let Robert drink all the sherry."

"And when," Robert heard Marion ask as she went with him to the door,
"did you decide not to go to sea?"

"When I was fifteen. I took up ballooning instead."

"Theoretical, I suppose."

"Well, I gassed about gases."

Why did they sound so friendly, so at ease, Robert wondered. As if they
had known each other a long time. Why did she like that light-weight

"And when you were sixteen?"

If she knew how many things Nevil had taken up and dropped in his time
she might not be so pleased to be the latest of them.

"Is the sherry too dry for you, Mr. Blair," Mrs. Sharpe asked.

"No, oh no, thank you, it is excellent." Was it possible that he had
been looking sour? Perish the thought.

He stole a cautious glance at the old lady and thought that she was
looking faintly amused. And old Mrs. Sharpe being amused was no
comfortable sight.

"I think I had better go before Miss Sharpe bars the gate behind
Nevil," he said. "Otherwise she will have to come to the gate again
with me."

"But won't you stay and have lunch with us? There is no ritual about it
at The Franchise."

But Robert made his excuses. He didn't like the Robert Blair he was
becoming. Petty and childish and inadequate. He would go back and have
ordinary Sunday lunch with Aunt Lin and be again Robert Blair of Blair,
Hayward, and Bennet, equable and tolerant and at peace with his world.

Nevil had gone by the time he reached the gate, in a flurry of sound
that shattered the Sabbath quiet, and Marion was about to close the

"I can't think that the Bishop approves of his future son-in-law's
means of transport," she said looking after the roaring object as it
streaked down the road.

"Exhausting," Robert said, still caustic.

She smiled at him. "I think that is the first witty pun I have ever
heard anyone make," she said. "I hoped you would stay for lunch, but in
a way I'm rather relieved that you aren't."

"Are you indeed?"

"I made a 'shape' but it didn't stand up. I'm a very bad cook. I do
faithfully what it says in the book but it hardly ever works out.
Indeed I'm surprised to death when it does. So you will be better off
with your Aunt Lin's apple tart."

And Robert suddenly and illogically wished that he was staying, to
share the "shape" that had not stood up and to be gently mocked by her
along with her cooking.

"I'll let you know tomorrow night how I get on in Larborough," he said
matter-of-factly. Since he was not on hens-and-Maupassant terms with
her he would keep the conversation to practicalities. "And I'll ring up
Inspector Hallam and see if one of their men can give a look round The
Franchise once or twice a day; just to show the uniform, so to speak,
and to discourage idlers."

"You are very kind, Mr. Blair," she said. "I can't imagine what it
would be without you to lean on."

Well, if he couldn't be young and a poet, he could be a crutch. A dull
thing, a thing resorted to only in emergencies, but useful; useful.


By half-past ten on Monday morning he was sitting in front of a
steaming cup of coffee in the Karena. He began with the Karena because
when one thinks of coffee at all one thinks of a Karena, with the smell
of the roasting coffee downstairs in the shop and the liquid version
waiting upstairs among the little tables. And if he was going to have a
surfeit of coffee he might as well have some good stuff while he could
still taste it.

He was holding the _Ack-Emma_ in his hand with the girl's photograph
open to the gaze of the waitresses as they passed, hoping vaguely that
his interest in it might cause one of them to say: "That girl used to
come in here every morning." To his surprise the paper was gently
removed from his grasp, and he looked up to see his waitress regarding
him with a kind smile. "That is last Friday's," she said. "Here." And
she proffered that morning's _Ack-Emma_.

He thanked her and said that while he would be glad to see this
morning's paper he would like to keep the Friday one. Did this girl,
this girl on the front page of Friday's, ever come in there for coffee?

"Oh, no, we'd have remembered her if she did. We were all discussing
that case on Friday. Imagine beating her half to death like that."

"Then you think they did."

She looked puzzled. "The paper says they did."

"No, the paper reports what the girl said."

She obviously did not follow that. This was the democracy we deified.

"They wouldn't print a story like that if it wasn't true. It would be
as much as their life's worth. You a detective?"

"Part time," Robert said.

"How much do you get an hour for that?"

"Not nearly enough."

"No, I suppose not. Haven't got a Union, I suppose. You don't get your
rights in this world unless you have a Union."

"Too true," said Robert. "Let me have my bill, will you?"

"Your check, yes."

At the Palace, the biggest and newest of the cinemas, the restaurant
occupied the floor behind the balcony and had carpets so deep that one
tripped on them, and lighting so subdued that all the cloths looked
dirty. A bored houri with gilt hair, an uneven hem to her skirt, and a
wad of chewing gum in her right jaw, took his order without ever
glancing at him, and fifteen minutes later put down a cup of washy
liquid in front of him without letting her eyes stray even
approximately in his direction. Since in the fifteen minutes Robert had
discovered that the never-look-at-the-customers technique was
universal--presumably they were all going to be film stars the year
after next and could not be expected to take any interest in a
provincial clientèle--he paid for the untasted liquid and left.

At the Castle, the other big cinema, the restaurant did not open until

At the Violet--royal purple everywhere and yellow curtains--no one had
seen her. Robert, casting subtleties aside, asked them bluntly.

Upstairs at Griffon and Waldron's, the big store, it was rush hour and
the waitress said: "Don't _bother_ me!" The manageress, looking at him
with absent-minded suspicion, said: "We never give information about
our customers."

At the Old Oak--small and dark and friendly--the elderly waitresses
discussed the case interestedly with him. "Poor love," they said. "What
an experience for her. Such a nice face, too. Just a baby. Poor love."

At the Alençon--cream paint and old-rose couches against the
walls--they made it plain that they had never heard of the _Ack-Emma_
and could not possibly have a client whose photograph appeared in such
a publication.

At the Heave Ho--marine frescos and waitresses in bell-bottomed
trousers--the attendants gave it as their unanimous opinion that any
girl who took a lift should expect to have to walk home.

At the Primrose--old polished tables with raffia mats and thin
unprofessional waitresses in flowered smocks--they discussed the social
implications of lack of domestic service and the vagaries of the
adolescent mind.

At the Tea-Pot there was no table to be had, and no waitress willing to
attend to him; but a second glance at the fly-blown place made him sure
that, with the others to choose from, Betty Kane would not have come

At half-past twelve he staggered into the lounge of the Midland, and
called for strong waters. As far as he knew he had covered all the
likely eating-places in the centre of Larborough and in not one of them
had anyone remembered seeing the girl. What was worse, everyone agreed
that if she had been there they would have remembered her. They had
pointed out, when Robert was sceptical of that, that a large proportion
of their customers on any one day were regulars, so that the casuals
stood out from the rest and were noted and remembered automatically.

As Albert, the tubby little lounge waiter, set his drink in front of
him, Robert asked, more out of habit than volition: "I suppose you've
never seen this girl in your place, Albert?"

Albert looked at the front page of the _Ack-Emma_ and shook his head.
"No, sir. Not that I recollect. Looks a little young, sir, if I may say
so, for the lounge of the Midland."

"She mightn't look so young with a hat on," Robert said, considering

"A hat." Albert paused. "Now, wait a minute. A _hat_." Albert laid his
little tray down and picked up the paper to consider it. "Yes, of
course; that's the girl in the green hat!"

"You mean she came in here for coffee?"

"No, for tea."


"Yes, of course, that's the girl. Fancy me not seeing that, and we had
that paper in the pantry last Friday and chewed the rag over it for
hours! Of course it's some time ago now, isn't it. About six weeks or
so, it must be. She always came early; just about three, when we start
serving teas."

So that is what she did. Fool that he was not to have seen that. She
went into the morning round at the cinema in time to pay the cheaper
price--just before noon, that was--and came out about three, and had
tea, not coffee. But why the Midland, where the tea was the usual dowdy
and expensive hotel exhibit, when she could wallow in cakes elsewhere?

"I noticed her because she always came alone. The first time she came I
thought she was waiting for relations. That's the kind of kid she
looked. You know: nice plain clothes and no airs."

"Can you remember what she wore?"

"Oh, yes. She always wore the same things. A green hat and a frock to
match it under a pale grey coat. But she never met anyone. And then one
day she picked up the man at the next table. You could have knocked me
over with a feather."

"You mean: he picked her up."

"Don't you believe it! He hadn't even thought of her when he sat down
there. I tell you, sir, she didn't look that sort. You'd expect an aunt
or a mother to appear at any moment and say: 'So sorry to have kept you
waiting, darling.' She just wouldn't occur to any man as a possible.
Oh, no; it was the kid's doing. And as neat a piece of business, let me
tell you, sir, as if she had spent a lifetime at it. Goodness, and to
think that I didn't spot her again without her hat!" He gazed in wonder
at the pictured face.

"What was the man like? Did you know him?"

"No, he wasn't one of our regulars. Dark. Youngish. Business gent, I
should say. I remember being a little surprised at her taste, so I
don't think he could have been up to much, now I come to think of it."

"You wouldn't know him again, then."

"I might, sir, I might. But not to swear to. You--er--planning any
swearing to, sir?"

Robert had known Albert for nearly twenty years and had always found
him of an excellent discretion. "It's like this, Albert," he said.
"These people are my clients." He tapped the photograph of The
Franchise, and Albert gave vent to a low whistle.

"A tough spot for you, Mr. Blair."

"Yes, as you say: a tough spot. But mostly for them. It is quite
unbelievably tough for them. The girl comes out of the blue one day
accompanied by the police, to whom she has told this fantastic story.
Until then neither of the two women has ever set eyes on her. The
police are very discreet, and decide that they haven't enough evidence
to make it a good case. Then the _Ack-Emma_ hears about it and makes
capital out of it, and the story is all over Britain. The Franchise is
wide open, of course. The police can't spare men to afford constant
protection, so you can imagine the lives these women are leading. My
young cousin, who looked in before dinner last night, says that from
lunch-time on crowds of cars arrived from Larborough, and people stood
on the roofs or hoisted themselves up on the wall to stare or take
photographs. Nevil got in because he arrived at the same time as the
policeman on the evening beat, but as soon as they left the cars were
swarming again. The telephone went continually until they asked the
Exchange not to put through any more calls."

"Have the police dropped it for good, then?"

"No, but they can't do anything to help _us_. What they are looking for
is corroboration of the girl's story."

"Well, that's not very likely, is it? For them to get, I mean."

"No. But you see the spot we are in. Unless we can find out where the
girl was during the weeks she says she was at The Franchise, the
Sharpes will be in the position of being permanently convicted of a
thing they haven't even been accused of!"

"Well, if it's the girl in the green hat--and I'm sure it is, sir--I'd
say she was what is known as 'out on the tiles,' sir. A very cool
customer she was for a girl that age. Butter wouldn't melt in her

"Butter wouldn't melt in her little mouth," the tobacconist had said of
the child Betty.

And "on the tiles" was Stanley's verdict on the pictured face that was
so like "the bint he had had in Egypt."

And the worldly little waiter had used both phrases in his estimate of
her. The demure girl in the "good" clothes, who had come every day by
herself to sit in the hotel lounge.

"Perhaps it was just a childish desire to be 'grand'," the nice side of
him prompted; but his common sense refused it. She could have been
grand at the Alençon, and eaten well, and seen smart clothes at the
same time.

He went in to have lunch, and then spent a large part of the afternoon
trying to reach Mrs. Wynn on the telephone. Mrs. Tilsit had no
telephone and he had no intention of involving himself in a Tilsit
conversation again if he could help it. When he failed he remembered
that Scotland Yard would most certainly, in that painstaking way of
theirs, have a description of the clothes the girl was wearing when she
went missing. And in less than seven minutes, he had it. A green felt
hat, a green wool frock to match, a pale grey cloth coat with large
grey buttons, fawn-grey rayon stockings and black court shoes with
medium heels.

Well, at last he had it, that setting-off place; that starting-point
for inquiry. Jubilation filled him. He sat down in the lounge on his
way out and wrote a note to tell Kevin Macdermott that the young woman
from Aylesbury was not such an attractive brief as she had been on
Friday night; and to let him know, of course,--between the lines--that
Blair, Hayward, and Bennet could get a move on when it was necessary.

"Did she ever come back?" he asked Albert, who was hovering. "I mean,
after she had 'got her man'."

"I don't remember ever seeing either of them again, sir."

Well, the hypothetical X had ceased to be hypothetical. He had become
plain X. He, Robert, could go back tonight to The Franchise in triumph.
He had put forward a theory, and the theory had proved fact, and it was
he who had proved it a fact. It was depressing, of course, that the
letters received so far by Scotland Yard had all been merely anonymous
revilings of the Yard for their "softness" to the "rich," and not
claims to have seen Betty Kane. It was depressing that practically
everyone he had interviewed that morning believed the girl's story
without question; were, indeed, surprised and at a loss if asked to
consider any other point of view. "The paper said so." But these were
small things compared to the satisfaction of having arrived at that
starting-point; of having unearthed X. He didn't believe that fate
could be so cruel as to show that Betty Kane parted with her new
acquaintance on the steps of the Midland and never saw him again. There
_had_ to be an extension of that incident in the lounge. The history of
the following weeks demanded it.

But how did one follow up a young dark business gent who had tea in the
lounge of the Midland about six weeks previously? Young dark business
gents were the Midland's clientèle; and as far as Blair could see all
as like as two peas anyhow. He was very much afraid that this was where
he bowed out and handed over to a professional bloodhound. He had no
photograph this time to help him; no knowledge of X's character or
habits as he had had in the case of the girl. It would be a long
process of small inquiries; a job for an expert. All he could do at the
moment, so far as he could see, was to get a list of residents at the
Midland for the period in question.

For that he went to the Manager; a Frenchman who showed great delight
and understanding in this _sub rosa_ proceeding, was exquisitely
sympathetic about the outraged ladies at The Franchise, and
comfortingly cynical about smooth-faced young girls in good clothes who
looked as if butter wouldn't melt in their mouths. He sent an underling
to copy the entries from the great ledger, and entertained Robert to a
_sirop_ from his own cupboard. Robert had never subscribed to the
French taste for small sweet mouthfuls of unidentifiable liquids drunk
at odd times, but he swallowed the thing gratefully and pocketed the
list the underling brought as one pockets a passport. Its actual value
was probably nil, but it gave him a nice feeling to have it.

And if he had to turn over the business to a professional, the
professional would have somewhere to start his burrowing. X had
probably never stayed at the Midland in his life; he had probably just
walked in for tea one day. On the other hand, his name might be among
that list in his pocket; that horribly long list.

As he drove home he decided that he would not stop at The Franchise. It
was unfair to bring Marion to the gate just to give her news that could
be told over the telephone. He would tell the Exchange who he was, and
the fact that the call was official, and they would answer it. Perhaps
by tomorrow the first flood of interest in the house would have
subsided, and it would be safe to unbar the gate again. Though he
doubted it. Today's _Ack-Emma_ had not been calculated to have an
appeasing effect on the mob mind. True, there were no further
front-page headlines; the Franchise affair had removed itself to the
correspondence page. But the letters the _Ack-Emma_ had chosen to print
there--and two-thirds of them were about the Franchise affair--were not
likely to prove oil on troubled waters. They were so much paraffin on a
fire that was going quite nicely anyhow.

Threading his way out of the Larborough traffic, the silly phrases came
back to him; and he marvelled all over again at the venom that these
unknown women had roused in the writers' minds. Rage and hatred spilled
over on to the paper; malice ran unchecked through the largely-illiterate
sentences. It was an amazing exhibition. And one of the oddities of it
was that the dearest wish of so many of those indignant protesters
against violence was to flog the said women within an inch of their
lives. Those who did not want to flog the women wanted to reform the
police. One writer suggested that a fund should be opened for the poor
young victim of police inefficiency and bias. Another suggested that
every man of goodwill should write to his Member of Parliament about
it, and make their lives a misery until something was done about this
miscarriage of justice. Still another asked if anyone had noticed Betty
Kane's marked resemblance to Saint Bernadette.

There was every sign, if today's correspondence page of the _Ack-Emma_
was any criterion, of the birth of a Betty Kane cult. He hoped that its
corollary would not be a Franchise vendetta.

As he neared the unhappy house, he grew anxious; wondering if Monday,
too, had provided its quota of sightseers. It was a lovely evening, the
low sun slanting great golden swathes of light over the spring fields;
an evening to tempt even Larborough out to the midland dullness of
Milford; it would be a miracle if, after the correspondence in the
_Ack-Emma_, The Franchise was not the mecca of an evening pilgrimage.
But when he came within sight of it he found the long stretch of road
deserted; and as he came nearer he saw why. At the gate of The
Franchise, solid and immobile and immaculate in the evening light, was
the dark-blue-and-silver figure of a policeman.

Delighted that Hallam had been so generous with his scanty force,
Robert slowed down to exchange greetings; but the greeting died on his
lips. Along the full length of the tall brick wall, in letters nearly
six feet high was splashed a slogan. "FASCISTS!" screamed the large
white capitals. And again on the further side of the gate: "FASCISTS!"

"Move along, please," the Force said, approaching the staring Robert
with slow, polite menace. "No stopping here."

Robert got slowly out of the car.

"Oh, Mr. Blair. Didn't recognise you, sir. Sorry."

"Is it whitewash?"

"No, sir; best quality paint."

"Great Heavens!"

"Some people never grow out of it."

"Out of what?"

"Writing things on walls. There's one thing: they might have written
something worse."

"They wrote the worst insult they knew," said Robert wryly. "I suppose
you haven't got the culprits?"

"No, sir. I just came along on my evening beat to clear away the usual
gapers--oh, yes, there were dozens of them--and found it like that when
I arrived. Two men in a car, if all reports are true."

"Do the Sharpes know about it?"

"Yes, I had to get in to telephone. We have a code now, us and the
Franchise people. I tie my handkerchief on the end of my truncheon and
wave it over the top of the gate when I want to speak to them. Do you
want to go in, sir?"

"No. No, on the whole I think not. I'll get the Post Office to let me
through on the telephone. No need to bring them to the gate. If this is
going to continue they must get keys for the gate so that I can have a

"Looks as though it's going to continue all right, sir. Did you see
today's _Ack-Emma_!"

"I did."

"Strewth!" said the Force, losing his equanimity at the thought of the
_Ack-Emma_, "you would think to listen to them we were nothing but a
collection of itching palms! It's a holy wonder we're not, come to
that. It would suit them better to agitate for more pay for us instead
of slandering us right and left."

"You're in very good company, if it's any consolation to you," Robert
said. "There can't be anything established, respectable, or
praiseworthy that they haven't slandered at some time or other. I'll
send someone either tonight or first thing in the morning to do
something about this--obscenity. Are you staying here?"

"The sergeant said when I telephoned that I was to stay till dark."

"No one over-night?"

"No, sir. No spare men for that. Anyhow, they'll be all right once the
light's gone. People go home. Especially the Larborough lot. They don't
like the country once it gets dark."

Robert, who remembered how silent the lonely house could be, felt
doubtful. Two women, alone in that big quiet house after dark, with
hatred and violence just outside the wall--it was not a comfortable
thought. The gate was barred, but if people could hoist themselves on
to the wall for the purpose of sitting there and shouting insults, they
could just as easily drop down the other side in the dark.

"Don't worry, sir," the Force said, watching his face. "Nothing's going
to happen to them. This is England, after all."

"So is the _Ack-Emma_ England," Robert reminded him. But he got back
into the car again. After all, it _was_ England; and the English
countryside at that; famed for minding its own business. It was no
country hand that had splashed that "FASCISTS!" on the wall. It was
doubtful if the country had ever heard the term. The country, when it
wanted insults, used older, Saxon words.

The Force was no doubt right; once the dark came everyone would go


As Robert turned his car into the garage in Sin Lane and came to a
halt, Stanley, who was shrugging off his overalls outside the office
door, glanced at his face and said: "Down the drain again?"

"It isn't a bet," Robert said, "it's human nature."

"You start to be sorry about human nature and you won't have time for
anything else. You been trying to reform someone?"

"No, I've been trying to get someone to take some paint off a wall."

"Oh, work!" Stanley's tone indicated that even to expect someone to do
a job of work these days was being optimistic to the point of folly.

"I've been trying to get someone to wipe a slogan off the walls of The
Franchise, but everyone is extraordinarily busy all of a sudden."

Stanley stopped his wriggling. "A slogan," he said. "What kind of
slogan?" And Bill, hearing the exchange, oozed himself through the
narrow office door to listen.

Robert told them. "In best quality white paint, so the policeman on the
beat assures me."

Bill whistled. Stanley said nothing; he was standing with his overalls
shrugged down to his waist and concertinaed about his legs.

"Who've you tried?" Bill asked.

Robert told them. "None of them can do anything tonight, and tomorrow
morning, it seems, all their men are going out early on important

"It's not to be believed," Bill said. "Don't tell me they're afraid of

"No, to do them justice I don't think it's that. I think, although they
would never say so to me, that they think those women at The Franchise
deserve it." There was silence for a moment.

"When I was in the Signals," Stanley said, beginning in a leisurely
fashion to pull up his overalls and get into the top half again, "I was
given a free tour of Italy. Nearly a year it took. And I escaped the
malaria, and the Ities, and the Partisans, and the Yank transport, and
most of the other little nuisances. But I got a phobia. I took a great
dislike to slogans on walls."

"What'll we get it off with?" Bill asked.

"What's the good of owning the best equipped and most modern garage in
Milford if we haven't something to take off a spot of paint?" Stanley
said, zipping up his front.

"Will you really try to do something about it?" Robert asked, surprised
and pleased.

Bill smiled his slow expansive smile. "The Signals, the R.E.M.E. and a
couple of brooms. What more do you want?" he said.

"Bless you," Robert said. "Bless you both. I have only one ambition
tonight; to get that slogan off the wall before breakfast tomorrow.
I'll come along and help."

"Not in that Savile Row suit, you won't," Stanley said. "And we haven't
a spare suit of----"

"I'll get something old on and come out after you."

"Look," Stanley said patiently, "we don't need any help for a little
job like that. If we did we'd take Harry." Harry was the garage boy.
"You haven't eaten yet and we have, and I've heard it said that Miss
Bennet doesn't like her good meals spoiled. I suppose you don't mind if
the wall looks smeary? We're just good-intentioned garage hands, not

The shops were shut as he walked down the High Street to his home at
Number 10, and he looked at the place as a stranger walking through on
a Sunday might. He had been so far from Milford during his day in
Larborough that he felt that he had been away for years. The
comfortable quiet of Number 10--so different from the dead silence of
The Franchise--welcomed and soothed him. A faint smell of roasting
apples escaped from the kitchen. The firelight flickered on the wall of
the sitting-room, seen through its half-open door. Warmth and security
and comfort rose up in a gentle tide and lapped over him.

Guilty at being the owner of this waiting peace, he picked up the
telephone to talk to Marion.

"Oh, _you_! How nice," she said, when at last he had persuaded the Post
Office that his intentions were honourable; and the warmth in her voice
catching him unawares--his mind being still on white paint--caught him
under the heart and left him breathless for a moment. "I'm so glad. I
was wondering how we were going to talk to you; but I might have known
that you would manage it. I suppose you just say you're Robert Blair
and the Post Office gives you the freedom of the place."

How like her, he thought. The genuine gratitude of "I might have known
that you would manage"; and then the faint amusement in the sentence
that followed.

"I suppose you've seen our wall decoration?"

Robert said yes, but that no one ever would again, because by the time
the sun rose it would have gone.


"The two men who own my garage have decided to obliterate it tonight."

"But--could seven maids with seven mops----?"

"I don't know; but if Stanley and Bill have set their minds on it,
obliterated it will be. They were brought up in a school that doesn't
tolerate frustrations."

"What school is that?"

"The British Army. And I have more good news for you: I have
established the fact that X exists. She had tea with him one day.
Picked him up at the Midland, in the lounge."

"Picked him up? But she is just a child, and so---- Oh, well, she told
that story, of course. After that anything is possible. How did you
find out that?"

He told her.

"You've had a bad day at The Franchise, haven't you," he said, when he
had finished the saga of the coffee shops.

"Yes, I feel dirty all over. What was worse than the audience and the
wall was the post. The postman gave it to the police to take in. It is
not often that the police can be accused of disseminating obscene

"Yes, I imagine it must have been pretty bad. That was only to be

"Well, we have so few letters that we have decided that in future we
shall burn everything without opening them, unless we recognise the
writing. So don't use typescript if you write to us."

"But do you know my handwriting?"

"Oh, yes, you wrote us a note, you remember. The one Nevil brought that
afternoon. Nice handwriting."

"Have you seen Nevil today?"

"No, but one of the letters was from him. At least, it wasn't a

"A document of some kind?"

"No, a poem."

"Oh. Did you understand it?"

"No, but it made quite a nice sound."

"So do bicycle bells."

He thought she laughed a little. "It is nice to have poems made to
one's eyebrows," she said. "But still nicer to have one's wall made
clean. I do thank you for that--you and what's-their-names--Bill and
Stanley. If you want to be very kind perhaps you would bring or send us
some food tomorrow?"

"Food!" he said, horrified that he had not thought of that before; that
was what happened when you lived a life where Aunt Lin put everything
down in front of you, all but put the stuff in your mouth; you lost
your capacity for imagination. "Yes, of course. I forgot that you would
not be able to shop."

"It isn't only that. The grocer's van that calls on Monday didn't come
today. Or perhaps," she added hastily, "it came and just couldn't call
our attention. Anyhow, we should be so grateful for some things. Have
you got a pencil there?"

She gave him a list of things, and then asked: "We didn't see today's
_Ack-Emma_. Was there anything about us?"

"Some letters on the correspondence page, that is all."

"All anti, I suppose."

"I'm afraid so. I shall bring a copy out tomorrow morning when I bring
the groceries, and you can see it for yourselves."

"I'm afraid we are taking up a great deal of your time."

"This has become a personal matter with me," he said.

"Personal?" She sounded doubtful.

"The one ambition of my life is to discredit Betty Kane."

"Oh; oh, I see." Her voice sounded half relieved, half--could it
be?--disappointed. "Well, we shall look forward to seeing you

But she was to see him long before that.

He went to bed early, but lay long awake; rehearsing a telephone
conversation that he planned to have with Kevin Macdermott; considering
different approaches to the problem of X; wondering if Marion was
asleep, in that silent old house, or lying awake listening for sounds.

His bedroom was over the street, and about midnight he heard a car
drive up and stop, and presently through the open window he heard
Bill's cautious call; not much more than a throaty whisper. "Mr. Blair!
Hey, Mr. Blair!"

He was at the window almost before the second utterance of his name.

"Thank goodness," whispered Bill. "I was afraid the light might be Miss

"No, she sleeps at the back. What is it?"

"There's trouble at The Franchise. I've got to go for the police
because the wire is cut. But I thought you'd want to be called, so

"What kind of trouble?"

"Hooligans. I'll come in for you on my way back. In about four

"Is Stanley with them?" Robert asked, as Bill's great bulk merged with
the car again.

"Yes, Stan's having his head bound up. Back in a minute." And the car
fled away up the dark silent High Street.

Before Robert had got his clothes on he heard a soft "ssshush" go past
his window, and realised that the police were already on their way. No
screaming sirens in the night, no roaring exhausts; with no more sound
than a summer wind makes among the leaves the Law was going about its
business. As he opened the front door, cautiously so as not to wake
Aunt Lin (nothing but the last trump was likely to wake Christina) Bill
brought his car to a standstill at the pavement.

"Now tell me," Robert said, as they moved away.

"Well, we finished that little job by the light of the headlamps--not
very professional, it isn't, but a lot better than it was when we got
there--and then we switched off the heads, and began to put away our
things. Sort of leisurely like; there was no hurry and it was a nice
night. We'd just lit a cigarette and were thinking of pushing off when
there was a crash of glass from the house. No one had got in our side
while we were there, so we knew it must be round the sides or the back.
Stan reached into the car and took out his torch--mine was lying on the
seat because we'd been using it--and said: 'You go round that way and
I'll go the other and we'll nip them between us.'"

"Can you get round?"

"Well, it was no end of a business. It's hedge up to the wall end. I
wouldn't like to have done it in ordinary clothes, but in overalls you
just push hard and hope for the best. It's all right for Stan; he's
slim. But short of lying on the hedge till it falls down there's no way
through for me. Anyhow we got through, one on each side, and through
the one at the back corners, and met in the middle of the back without
seeing a soul. Then we heard more crashing of glass, and realised that
they were making a night of it. Stan said: 'Hoist me up, and I'll give
you a hand after me.' Well, a hand would be no good to me, but it
happens that the field level at the back comes fairly high up the
wall--in fact I think it was probably cut away to build the wall--so
that we got over fairly easily. Stan said had I anything to hit with
besides my torch and I said yes, I had a spanner. Stan said: 'Forget
your bloody spanner and use your ham fist; it's bigger.'"

"What was he going to use?"

"The old rugby tackle, so he said. Stan used to be quite a good
stand-off half. Anyhow we went on in the dark towards the sound of the
crashing glass. It seemed as if they were just having a breaking tour
round the house. We caught up with them near the front corner again,
and switched on our torches. I think there were seven of them. Far more
than we had expected, anyhow. We switched off at once, before they
could see that we were only two, and grabbed the nearest. Stan said:
'You take that one, sergeant,' and I thought at the time he was giving
me my rank out of old habit, but I realise now he was bluffing them we
were police. Anyhow some of them beat it, because though there was a
mix-up there couldn't have been anything like seven of them in it.
Then, quite suddenly it seemed, there was quiet--we'd been making a lot
of noise--and I realised that we were letting them get away, and Stan
said from somewhere on the ground: 'Grab one, Bill, before they get
over the wall!' And I went after them with my torch on. The last of
them was just being helped over, and I grabbed his legs and hung on.
But he kicked like a mule, and what with the torch in my hand he
slipped from my hands like a trout and was over before I could grab him
again. That finished me, because from inside that wall at the back is
even higher than it is at the front of the house. So I went back to
Stan. He was still sitting on the ground. Someone had hit him a wallop
over the head with what he said was a bottle and he was looking very
cheap. And then Miss Sharpe came out to the top of the front steps, and
said was someone hurt? She could see us in the torchlight. So we got
Stan in--the old lady was there and the house was lit by this time--and
I went to the phone, but Miss Sharpe said: 'That's no use. It's dead.
We tried to call the police when they first arrived.' So I said I'd go
and fetch them. And I said I'd better fetch you too. But Miss Sharpe
said no, you'd had a very hard day and I wasn't to disturb you. But I
thought you ought to be in on it."

"Quite right, Bill, I ought."

The gate was wide open as they drew up, the police car at the door,
most of the front rooms lit, and the curtains waving gently in the
night wind at the wrecked windows. In the drawing-room--which the
Sharpes evidently used as a living-room--Stanley was having a cut above
his eyebrow attended to by Marion, a sergeant of police was taking
notes, and his henchman was laying out exhibits. The exhibits seemed to
consist of half bricks, bottles, and pieces of paper with writing on

"Oh, Bill, I told you not to," Marion said as she looked up and saw

Robert noted how efficiently she was dealing with Stanley's injury; the
woman who found cooking beyond her. He greeted the sergeant and bent to
look at the exhibits. There was a large array of missiles but only four
messages; which read, respectively: "Get out!" "Get out or we'll make
you!" "Foreign bitches!" and "This is only a sample!"

"Well, we've collected them all, I think," the sergeant said. "Now
we'll go and search the garden for footprints or whatever clues there
may be." He glanced professionally at the soles that Bill and Stanley
held up at his request, and went out with his aide to the garden, as
Mrs. Sharpe came in with a steaming jug and cups.

"Ah, Mr. Blair," she said. "You still find us stimulating?"

She was fully dressed--in contrast to Marion who was looking quite
human and un-Joan-of-Arc in an old dressing-gown--and apparently
unmoved by these proceedings, and he wondered what kind of occasion
would find Mrs. Sharpe at a disadvantage.

Bill appeared with sticks from the kitchen and lighted the dead fire,
Mrs. Sharpe poured the hot liquid--it was coffee and Robert refused it,
having seen enough coffee lately to lost interest in it--and the colour
began to come back to Stan's face. By the time the policemen came back
from the garden the room had acquired a family-party air, in spite of
the waving curtains and the non-existent windows. Neither Stanley nor
Bill, Robert noticed, appeared to find the Sharpes odd or difficult; on
the contrary they seemed relaxed and at home. Perhaps it was that the
Sharpes took them for granted; accepting this invasion of strangers as
if it were an every-day occurrence. Anyhow, Bill came and went on his
ploys as if he had lived in the house for years; and Stanley put out
his cup for a second helping without waiting to be asked.
Involuntarily, Robert thought that Aunt Lin in their place would have
been kind and fussy and they would have sat on the edge of the chairs
and remembered their dirty overalls.

Perhaps it was the same taking-for-granted that had attracted Nevil.

"Do you plan to stay on here, ma'am?" the sergeant asked as they came
in again.

"Certainly," Mrs. Sharpe said, pouring coffee for them.

"No," Robert said. "You mustn't, you really must not. I'll find you a
quiet hotel in Larborough, where----"

"I never heard anything more absurd. Of course we are going to stay
here. What do a few broken windows matter?"

"It may not stop at broken windows," the sergeant said. "And you're a
great responsibility to us as long as you are here; a responsibility we
haven't really got the force to deal with."

"I'm truly sorry we are a nuisance to you, sergeant. We wouldn't have
bricks flung at our windows if we could help it, believe me. But this
is our home, and here we are staying. Quite apart from any question of
ethics, how much of our home would be left to come back to if it was
left empty? I take it if you are too short of men to guard human
beings, you certainly have no men to guard empty property?"

The sergeant looked slightly abashed, as people so often did when Mrs.
Sharpe dealt with them. "Well, there is that, ma'am," he acknowledged,
with reluctance.

"And that, I think, disposes of any question of our leaving The
Franchise. Sugar, sergeant?"

Robert returned to the subject when the police had taken their
departure, and Bill had fetched a brush and shovel from the kitchen and
was sweeping up the broken glass in room after room. Again he urged the
wisdom of a hotel in Larborough, but neither his emotion nor his common
sense was behind the words. He would not have gone if he had been in
the Sharpes' place, and he could not expect them to; and in addition he
acknowledged the wisdom of Mrs. Sharpe's view about the fate of the
house left empty.

"What you want is a lodger," said Stanley, who had been refused
permission to sweep up glass because he was classed as walking-wounded.
"A lodger with a pistol. What d'you say I come and sleep here of
nights? No meals, just sleeping night watchman. They all sleep anyhow,
night watchmen do."

It was evident by their expressions that both the Sharpes appreciated
the fact that this was an open declaration of allegiance in what
amounted to a local war; but they did not embarrass him with thanks.

"Haven't you got a wife?" Marion asked.

"Not of my own," Stanley said demurely.

"Your wife--if you had one--might support your sleeping here," Mrs.
Sharpe pointed out, "but I doubt if your business would, Mr.--er--Mr.

"My business?"

"I imagine that if your customers found that you had become night
watchman at The Franchise they would take their custom elsewhere."

"Not them," Stanley said comfortably. "There's nowhere else to take it.
Lynch is drunk five nights out of seven, and Biggins wouldn't know how
to put on a bicycle chain. Anyhow, I don't let my customers tell me
what I do in my spare time."

And when Bill returned, he backed Stanley up. Bill was a much married
man and it was not contemplated that he would ever sleep anywhere
except at home. But that Stanley should sleep at The Franchise seemed
to both of them a natural solution of the problem.

Robert was mightily relieved.

"Well," Marion said, "if you are going to be our guest at nights you
might as well begin now. I am sure that head feels like a very painful
turnip. I'll go and make up a bed. Do you prefer a south view?"

"Yes," said Stanley gravely. "Well away from kitchen and wireless

"I'll do what I can."

It was arranged that Bill should slip a note into the door of Stanley's
lodgings to say that he would be in for lunch as usual. "She won't
worry about me," Stanley said, referring to his landlady. "I've been
out for nights before now." He caught Marion's eye, and added:
"Ferrying cars for customers; you can do it in half the time at night."

They tacked down the curtains in all the ground-floor rooms to provide
some protection for their contents if it rained before morning, and
Robert promised to get glaziers out at the earliest possible moment.
Deciding privately to go to a Larborough firm, and not risk another
series of polite rebuffs in Milford.

"And I shall also do something about a key for the gate, so that I can
have a duplicate," he said as Marion came out with them to bar the
gate, "and save you from being gate-keeper as well as everything else."

She put out her hand, to Bill first. "I shall never forget what you
three have done for us. When I remember tonight it won't be these clods
that I shall remember," she tilted her head to the windowless house,
"but you three."

"Those clods were local, I suppose you know," Bill said as they drove
home through the quiet spring night.

"Yes," Robert agreed. "I realised that. They had no car, for one thing.
And 'Foreign bitches!' smells of the conservative country, just as
'Fascists!' smells of the progressive town."

Bill said some things about progress.

"I was wrong to let myself be persuaded yesterday evening. The man on
the beat was so sure that 'everyone would go home when it grew dark'
that I let myself believe it. But I should have remembered a warning I
got about witch-hunts."

Bill was not listening. "It's a funny thing how unsafe you feel in a
house without windows," he said. "Take a house with the back blown
clean off, and not a door that will shut; you can live quite happily in
a front room provided it still has windows. But without windows even a
whole undamaged house feels unsafe."

Which was not an observation that provided Robert with any comfort.


"I wonder if you would mind calling for the fish, dear," Aunt Lin said
on the telephone on Tuesday afternoon. "Nevil is coming to dinner, and
so we are going to have an extra course of what we were going to have
for breakfast. I really don't see why we should have anything extra
just for Nevil, but Christina says that it will keep him from making
what she calls 'inroads' on the tart that is going to do again on her
night-out tomorrow. So if you wouldn't mind, dear."

He was not looking forward greatly to an extra hour or two of Nevil's
society, but he was feeling so pleased with himself that he was in a
better humour to support it than usual. He had arranged with a
Larborough firm for the replacement of the Franchise windows; he had
miraculously unearthed a key that fitted the Franchise gate--and there
would be two duplicates in existence by tomorrow; and he had personally
taken out the groceries--together with an offering of the best flowers
that Milford could supply. His welcome at The Franchise had been such
that he had almost ceased to regret the lack of light exchanges on
Nevil lines. There were, after all, other things than getting to
Christian-name terms in the first half-hour.

In the lunch hour he had rung up Kevin Macdermott, and arranged with
his secretary that when Kevin was free in the evening he would call him
at 10 High Street. Things were getting out of hand, and he wanted
Kevin's advice.

He had refused three invitations to golf, his excuse to his astounded
cronies being that he had "no time to chase a piece of gutta-percha
round a golf course."

He had gone to see an important client who had been trying to interview
him since the previous Friday and who had been provoked into asking him
on the telephone if "he still worked for Blair, Hayward, and Bennet."

He had got through his arrears of work with a mutely reproachful Mr.
Heseltine; who, although he had allied himself on the Sharpe side,
still obviously felt that the Franchise affair was not one for a firm
like theirs to be mixed up in.

And he had been given tea by Miss Tuff out of the blue-patterned china
on the lacquer tray covered by the fair white cloth and accompanied by
two digestive biscuits on a plate.

It was lying on his desk now, the tea-tray; just as it had been a
fortnight ago when the telephone had rung and he had lifted the
receiver to hear Marion Sharpe's voice for the first time. Two short
weeks ago. He had sat looking at it in its patch of sunlight, feeling
uneasy about his comfortable life and conscious of time slipping past
him. But today, the digestive biscuits held no reproach for him because
he had stepped outside the routine they typified. He was on calling
terms with Scotland Yard; he was agent for a pair of scandalous women;
he had become an amateur sleuth; and he had been witness of mob
violence. His whole world looked different. Even the people he met
looked different. The dark skinny woman he used to see sometimes
shopping in the High Street, for instance, had turned into Marion.

Well, one result of stepping out of a routined life was, of course,
that you couldn't put on your hat and stroll home at four o'clock of an
afternoon. He pushed the tea-tray out of his way, and went to work, and
it was half-past six before he looked at the clock again, and seven
before he opened the door of Number 10.

The sitting-room door was ajar as usual--like many doors in old houses
it swung a little if left off the latch--and he could hear Nevil's
voice in the room beyond.

"On the contrary, I think you are being extremely silly," Nevil was

Robert recognised the tone at once. It was the cold rage with which a
four-year-old Nevil had told a guest: "I am extremely sorry that I
asked you to my party." Nevil must be very angry indeed about

With his coat half off Robert paused to listen.

"You are interfering in something you know nothing whatever about; you
can hardly claim that is an intelligent proceeding."

There was no other voice, so he must be talking to someone on the
telephone; probably keeping Kevin from getting through, the young

"I am not infatuated with anyone. I never _have_ been infatuated with
anyone. It is you who are infatuated--with ideas. You are being
extremely silly, as I said before.... You are taking the part of an
unbalanced adolescent in a case you know nothing about; I should have
thought that was sufficient evidence of infatuation.... You can tell
your father from me that there is nothing Christian about it, just
unwarranted interference. I'm not sure it isn't incitement to
violence.... Yes, last night.... No, all their windows broken, and
things painted on their walls.... If he is so interested in justice he
might do something about that. But your lot are never interested in
justice, are they? Only in injustice.... What do I mean by your lot?
Just what I say. You and all your crowd who are for ever adopting
good-for-nothings and championing them against the world. You wouldn't
put out a finger to keep a hard-working little man from going down the
drain, but let an old lag lack the price of a meal and your sobs can be
heard in Antarctica. You make me sick.... Yes, I said you make me
sick.... Cat-sick. Sick to my stomach. I retch!"

And the bang of the receiver on its rest indicated that the poet had
said his say.

Robert hung up his coat in the cupboard and went in. Nevil with a face
like thunder was pouring himself out a stiff whisky.

"I'll have one too," Robert said. "I couldn't help overhearing," he
added. "That wasn't Rosemary, by any chance?"

"Who else? Is there anyone else in Britain capable of an ineffable
silliness like that?"

"Like what?"

"Oh, didn't you hear that bit? She has taken up the cause of the
persecuted Betty Kane." Nevil gulped some whisky, and glared at Robert
as if Robert were responsible.

"Well, I don't suppose her stepping on the _Ack-Emma_ bandwagon will
have much effect one way or another."

"The _Ack-Emma_! It isn't the _Ack-Emma_. It's the _Watchman_. That
mental deficient she calls father has written a letter about it for
Friday's issue. Yes, you may well look squeamish. As if we weren't
coping with enough without that highfalutin nugget of perverted
sentimentality putting in its sixpenceworth!"

Remembering that the _Watchman_ was the only paper ever to have
published any of Nevil's poems, Robert thought this showed slight
ingratitude. But he approved the description.

"Perhaps they won't print it," he said, less in hope than looking for

"You know very well they will print anything he chooses to send them.
Whose money saved them just when they were going down for the third
time? The Bishop's, of course."

"His wife's, you mean." The Bishop had married one of the two
grand-daughters of Cowan's Cranberry Sauce.

"All right, his wife's. And the Bishop has the _Watchman_ for a lay
pulpit. And there isn't anything too silly for him to say in it, or too
unlikely for them to print. Do you remember that girl who went round
shooting taxi-drivers in cold blood for a profit of about
seven-and-eleven a time? That girl was just his meat. He sobbed himself
practically into a coma about her. He wrote a long heart-breaking
letter about her in the _Watchman_, pointing out how under-privileged
she had been, and how she had won a scholarship to a secondary school
and hadn't been able to 'take it up' because her people were too poor
to provide her with books or proper clothes, and so she had gone to
blind-alley jobs and then to bad company--and so, it was inferred, to
shooting taxi-drivers, though he didn't actually mention that little
matter. Well, all the _Watchman_ readers _lahved_ that, of course; it
was just their cup of tea; all criminals according to the _Watchman_
readers are frustrated angels. And then the Chairman of the Board of
Governors of the school--the school she was supposed to have won a
scholarship to--wrote to point out that so far from winning anything
was she that her name was 159th out of two hundred competitors; and
that someone as interested in education as the Bishop was should have
known that no one was prevented from accepting a scholarship through
lack of money, since in needy cases books and money grants were
forthcoming automatically. Well, you would have thought that that would
shake him, wouldn't you? But not a bit. They printed the Chairman's
letter on a back page, in small print; and in the very next issue the
old boy was sobbing over some other case that he knew nothing about.
And on Friday, so help me, he'll be sobbing over Betty Kane."

"I wonder--if I went over to see him tomorrow----"

"It goes to press tomorrow."

"Yes, so it does. Perhaps if I telephoned----"

"If you think that anyone or anything will make His Lordship keep back
a finished composition from the public gaze, you're being naïve."

The telephone rang.

"If that's Rosemary, I'm in China," Nevil said.

But it was Kevin Macdermott.

"Well, sleuth," said Kevin. "My congratulations. But next time don't
waste an afternoon trying to ring up civilians in Aylesbury, when you
can get the same information from Scotland Yard by return."

Robert said that he was still sufficiently civilian not to think in
terms of Scotland Yard at all; but that he was learning; rapidly.

He sketched the happenings of last night for Kevin's benefit, and said:
"I can't afford to be leisurely about it any more. Something must be
done as quickly as possible to clear them of this thing."

"You want me to give you the name of a private agent, is that it?"

"Yes, I suppose it has come to that. But I did wonder----"

"Wonder what?" Kevin asked, as he hesitated.

"Well, I did think of going to Grant at the Yard and saying quite
frankly that I had found out how she could have known about the Sharpes
and about the house; and that she had met a man in Larborough and that
I had a witness of the meeting."

"So that they could do what?"

"So that they could investigate the girl's movements during that month
instead of us."

"And you think they would?"

"Of course. Why not?"

"Because it wouldn't be worth their while. All they would do when they
found out that she was not trustworthy would be to drop the case
thankfully into oblivion. She has not sworn to anything so they could
not prosecute her for perjury."

"They could proceed against her for having misled them."

"Yes, but it wouldn't be worth their while. It won't be easy to unearth
her movements for that month, we may be sure. And on top of all that
unnecessary investigation they would have the job of preparing and
presenting a case. It's highly unlikely that an overworked department,
with serious cases flooding in at their doors, are going to all that
bother when they could quietly drop the thing on the spot."

"But it's supposed to be a department of Justice. It leaves the

"No, a department of the Law. Justice begins in court. As you very well
know. Besides, Rob, you haven't brought them any proof of anything. You
don't know that she ever went to Milford. And the fact that she picked
up a man at the Midland, and had tea with him, doesn't do anything to
disprove her story that she was picked up by the Sharpes. In fact the
only leg you have to stand on is Alec Ramsden, 5 Spring Gardens,
Fulham, South West."

"Who is he?"

"Your private sleuth. And a very good one, take it from me. He has a
flock of tame operators at call, so if he is busy himself he can supply
you with a fairly good substitute. Tell him I gave you his name and he
won't palm off a dud on you. Not that he would, anyhow. He's the salt
of the earth. Pensioned from the Force because of a wound 'received in
the course of duty.' He'll do you proud. I must go. If there's anything
else I can do just give me a ring sometime. I wish I had time to come
down and see The Franchise and your witches for myself. They grow on
me. Goodbye."

Robert laid down the receiver, picked it up again, asked for
Information, and obtained the telephone number of Alec Ramsden. There
was no answer and he sent a telegram saying that he, Robert Blair,
needed some work done urgently and that Kevin Macdermott had said that
Ramsden was the man to do it.

"Robert," said Aunt Lin coming in pink and indignant, "did you know
that you left the fish on the hall table and it has soaked through to
the mahogany and Christina was waiting for it."

"Is the gravamen of the charge the mahogany or keeping Christina

"Really, Robert, I hardly know what's come over you. Since you got
involved in this Franchise affair you've changed entirely. A fortnight
ago you would never have dreamed of putting a parcel of fish down on
polished mahogany and forgetting all about it. And if you had you would
be sorry about it and apologise."

"I do apologise, Aunt Lin; I am truly contrite. But it is not often I
am saddled with a responsibility as serious as the present one and you
must forgive me if I am a little jaded."

"I don't think you are jaded at all. On the contrary, I have never seen
you so pleased with yourself. I think you are positively _relishing_
this sordid affair. Only this morning Miss Truelove at the Anne Boleyn
was condoling with me on your being mixed up in it."

"Was she indeed? Well, I condole with Miss Truelove's sister."

"Condole about what?"

"On having a sister like Miss Truelove. You _are_ having a bad time,
aren't you, Aunt Lin."

"Don't be sarcastic, dear. It is not pleasant for anyone in this town
to see the notoriety that has overtaken it. It has always been a quiet
and dignified little place."

"I don't like Milford as much as I did a fortnight ago," Robert said
reflectively, "so I'll save my tears."

"No less than four separate charabancs arrived from Larborough at one
time or another today, having come for nothing but to inspect The
Franchise _en route_."

"And who catered for them?" Robert asked, knowing that coach traffic
was not welcome in Milford.

"No one. They were simply furious."

"That will larn them to go poking their noses. There is nothing
Larborough minds about as much as its stomach."

"The vicar's wife insists on being Christian about it, but I think that
that is the wrong point of view."


"Yes; 'reserving our judgment,' you know. That is merely feebleness,
not Christianity. Of course I don't discuss the case, Robert dear; even
with her. I am the soul of discretion. But of course she knows how I
feel, and I know how she feels, so discussion is hardly necessary."

What was clearly a snort came from Nevil where he was sunk in an easy

"Did you say something, Nevil dear?"

The nursery tone clearly intimidated Nevil. "No, Aunt Lin," he said

But he was not going to escape so easily; the snort had only too
clearly been a snort. "I don't grudge you the drink, dear, but is that
your _third_ whisky? There is a Traminer for dinner, and you won't
taste it at all after that strong stuff. You mustn't get into bad
habits if you are going to marry a Bishop's daughter."

"I am not going to marry Rosemary."

Miss Bennet stared, aghast. "Not!"

"I would as soon marry a Public Assistance Board."

"But, Nevil!"

"I would as soon marry a radio set." Robert remembered Kevin's remark
about Rosemary giving birth to nothing but a gramophone record. "I
would as soon marry a crocodile." Since Rosemary was very pretty Robert
supposed that "crocodile" had something to do with tears. "I would as
soon marry a soap-box." Marble Arch, Robert supposed. "I would as soon
marry the _Ack-Emma_." That seemed to be final.

"But Nevil, dear, _why_!"

"She is a very silly creature. Almost as silly as the _Watchman_."

Robert heroically refrained from mentioning the fact that for the last
six years the _Watchman_ had been Nevil's bible.

"Oh, come, dear; you've had a tiff; all engaged couples do. It's a good
thing to get the give-and-take business on a firm basis before
marriage; those couples who never quarrel during their engagement lead
surprisingly rowdy lives after marriage; so don't take a small
disagreement too seriously. You can ring her up before you go home

"It is a quite fundamental disagreement," Nevil said coldly. "And there
is no prospect whatever of my ringing her up."

"But Nevil, dear, what----"

The three thin cracked notes of the gong floated through her protest
and gave her pause. The drama of broken engagements gave place on the
instant to more immediate concerns.

"That is the gong. I think you had better take your drink in with you,
dear. Christina likes to serve the soup as soon as she has added the
egg, and she is not in a very good mood tonight because of getting the
fish so late. Though why that should make any difference to her I can't
think. It is only grilled, and that doesn't take any time. It's not as
if she had had to wipe the fish juice off the mahogany, because I did
that myself."


It further upset Aunt Lin that Robert should have breakfast next
morning at 7.45 so that he could go early to the office. It was another
sign of the degeneration that the Franchise affair was responsible for.
To have early breakfast so that he might catch a train, or set out for
a distant meet, or attend a client's funeral, was one thing. But to
have early breakfast just so that he could arrive at work at an
office-boy hour was a very odd proceeding, and unbefitting a Blair.

Robert smiled, walking up the sunny High Street still shuttered and
quiet. He had always liked the early morning hours, and it was at this
hour that Milford looked its best; its pinks and sepias and creams as
delicate in the sunlight as a tinted drawing. Spring was merging into
summer, and already the warmth of the pavement radiated into the cool
air; the pollarded limes were full out. That would mean shorter nights
for the lonely women at The Franchise, he remembered thankfully. But
perhaps--with any luck--by the time the summer was actually here their
vindication would be complete and their home no longer a beleaguered

Propped against the still closed door of the office was a long thin
grey man who seemed to be all bones and to have no stomach at all.

"Good-morning," Robert said. "Did you want to see me?"

"No," said the grey man. "You wanted to see me."

"_I_ did?"

"At least so your telegram said. I take it you're Mr. Blair?"

"But you can't be here already!" Robert said.

"It's not far," the man said laconically.

"Come in," said Robert trying to live up to Mr. Ramsden's standard of
economy in comment.

In the office he asked as he unlocked his desk: "Have you had

"Yes, I had bacon and eggs at the White Hart."

"I am wonderfully relieved that you could come yourself."

"I had just finished a case. And Kevin Macdermott has done a lot for

Yes; Kevin, for all his surface malice and his overcrowded life, found
the will and the time to help those who deserved help. In which he
differed markedly from the Bishop of Larborough, who preferred the

"Perhaps the best way would be for you to read this statement," he
said, handing Ramsden the copy of Betty Kane's statement to the police,
"and then we can go on with the story from there."

Ramsden took the typescript, sat down in the visitors' chair--folded up
would be a more accurate description of his action--and withdrew
himself from Robert's presence very much as Kevin had done in the room
in St. Paul's Churchyard. Robert, taking out his own work, envied them
their power of concentration.

"Yes, Mr. Blair?" he said presently; and Robert gave him the rest of
the story: the girl's identification of the house and its inmates,
Robert's own entrance into the affair, the police decision that they
would not proceed on the available evidence, Leslie Wynn's resentment
and its result in the _Ack-Emma_ publicity, his own interviews with the
girl's relations and what they revealed, his discovery that she went
bus-riding and that a double-decker did run on the Milford bus-route
during the relevant weeks, and his unearthing of X.

"To find out more about X is your job, Mr. Ramsden. The lounge waiter,
Albert, knows what he looked like, and this is a list of residents for
the period in question. It would be too great luck that he should be
staying at the Midland, but one never knows. After that you're on your
own. Tell Albert I sent you, by the way. I've known him a long time."

"Very good. I'll get over to Larborough now. I'll have a photograph of
the girl by tomorrow, but perhaps you could lend me your _Ack-Emma_ one
for today."

"Certainly. How are you going to get a proper photograph of her?"

"Oh. Ways."

Robert deduced that Scotland Yard had been given one when the girl was
reported missing, and that his old colleagues at Headquarters would not
be too reluctant to give him a copy; so he left it at that.

"There's just a chance that the conductor of one of those double-decker
buses may remember her," he said as Ramsden was going. "They are
Larborough And District Motor Services buses. The garage is in Victoria

At half-past nine the staff arrived--one of the first being Nevil; a
change in routine which surprised Robert: Nevil was usually the last to
arrive and the last to settle down. He would wander in, divest himself
of his wrappings in his own small room at the back, wander into "the
office" to say good morning, wander into the "waiting-room" at the back
to say hello to Miss Tuff, and finally wander into Robert's room and
stand there thumbing open the bound roll of one of the esoteric
periodicals that came for him by post and commenting on the permanently
deplorable state of affairs in England. Robert had grown quite used to
running through his morning post to a Nevil obbligato. But today Nevil
came in at the appointed time, went into his own room, shut the door
firmly after him, and, if the pulling in and out of drawers was any
evidence, settled down to work at once.

Miss Tuff came in with her notebook and her dazzling white peter-pan
collar, and Robert's normal day had begun. Miss Tuff had worn peter-pan
collars over her dark frock for twenty years, and would have looked
undressed, almost indecent, without them now. A fresh one went on every
morning; the previous day's having been laundered the night before and
laid ready for putting on tomorrow. The only break in the routine was
on Sundays. Robert had once met Miss Tuff on a Sunday and entirely
failed to recognise her because she was wearing a jabot.

Until half-past ten Robert worked, and then realised that he had had
breakfast at an abnormally early hour and was now in need of more
sustenance than an office cup of tea. He would go out and have coffee
and a sandwich at the Rose and Crown. You got the best coffee in
Milford at the Anne Boleyn, but it was always full of shopping females
("_How_ nice to see you, my dear! We _did_ miss you so at Ronnie's
party! And _have_ you heard....") and that was an atmosphere he would
not face for all the coffee in Brazil. He would go across to the Rose
and Crown, and afterwards he would shop a little on behalf of the
Franchise people, and after lunch he would go out and break to them
gently the bad news about the _Watchman_. He could not do it on the
telephone because they had no telephone now. The Larborough firm had
come out with ladders and putty and recalcitrant sheets of glass and
had replaced the windows without fuss or mess. But they, of course,
were Private Enterprise. The Post Office, being a Government
department, had taken the matter of the telephone into avizandum and
would move in their own elephantine good time. So Robert planned to
spend part of his afternoon telling the Sharpes the news he could not
tell them by telephone.

It was still early for mid-morning snacks and the chintz and old oak of
the Rose and Crown lounge was deserted except for Ben Carley, who was
sitting by the gate-legged table at the window reading the _Ack-Emma_.
Carley had never been Robert's cup-of-tea--any more than, he suspected,
he was Carley's--but they had the bond of their profession (one of the
strongest in human nature) and in a small place like Milford that made
them very nearly bosom friends. So Robert sat down as a matter of
course at Carley's table; remembering as he did so that he still owed
Carley gratitude for that unheeded warning of his about the feeling in
the countryside.

Carley lowered the _Ack-Emma_ and regarded him with the too-lively dark
eyes that were so alien in this English Midland serenity. "It seems to
be dying down," he said. "Only one letter today; just to keep something
in the kitty."

"The _Ack-Emma_, yes. But the _Watchman_ is beginning a campaign of its
own on Friday."

"The _Watchman_! What's _it_ doing climbing into the _Ack-Emma_'s bed?"

"It wouldn't be the first time," Robert said.

"No, I suppose not," Carley said, considering it. "Two sides of the
same penny, when you come to think of it. Oh, well. That needn't worry
you. The total circulation of the _Watchman_ is about twenty thousand.
If that."

"Perhaps. But practically every one of those twenty thousand has a
second cousin in the permanent Civil Service in this country."

"So what? Has anyone ever known the permanent Civil Service to move a
finger in any cause whatever outside their normal routine?"

"No, but they pass the buck. And sooner or later the buck drops
into--into a--a----"

"A fertile spot," Carley offered, mixing the metaphor deliberately.

"Yes. Sooner or later some busybody or sentimentalist or egotist, with
not enough to do, thinks that something should be done about this and
begins to pull strings. And a string pulled in the Civil Service has
the same effect as a string pulled in a peep-show. A whole series of
figures is yanked into action, willy-nilly. Gerald obliges Tony, and
Reggie obliges Gerald, and so on, to incalculable ends."

Carley was silent a moment. "It's a pity," he said. "Just when the
_Ack-Emma_ was losing way. Another two days and they would have dropped
it for good. In fact they're two days over their normal schedule, as it
is. I have never known them carry a subject longer than three issues.
The response must have been terrific to warrant that amount of space."

"Yes," Robert agreed, gloomily.

"Of course, it was a gift for them. The beating of kidnapped girls is
growing very rare. As a change of fare it was beyond price. When you
have only three or four dishes, like the _Ack-Emma_, it's difficult to
keep the customers' palates properly tickled. A tit-bit like the
Franchise affair must have put up their circulation by thousands in the
Larborough district alone."

"Their circulation will slack off. It's just a tide. But what I have to
deal with is what's left on the beach."

"A particularly smelly beach, let me say," Carley observed. "Do you
know that fat blonde with the mauve powder and the uplift brassiere who
runs that Sports Wear shop next the Anne Boleyn? She's one of the
things on your beach."


"She lived at the same boarding-house in London as the Sharpes, it
seems; and she has a lovely story as to how Marion Sharpe once beat a
dog half to death in a rage. Her clients loved that story. So did the
Anne Boleyn customers. She goes there for her morning coffee." He
glanced wryly at the angry flush on Robert's face. "I needn't tell you
that she has a dog of her own. It has never been corrected in its
spoiled life, but it is rapidly dying of fatty degeneration through the
indiscriminate feeding of morsels whenever the fat blonde is feeling

There were moments, Robert thought, when he could very nearly hug Ben
Carley, striped suits and all.

"Ah, well, it will blow over," said Carley, with the pliant philosophy
of a race long used to lying low and letting the storm blow past.

Robert looked surprised. Forty generations of protesting ancestors were
surprised in his sole person. "I don't see that blowing over is any
advantage," he said. "It won't help my clients at all."

"What can you do?"

"Fight, of course."

"Fight what? You wouldn't get a slander verdict, if that's what you're
thinking of."

"No. I hadn't thought of slander. I propose to find out what the girl
was really doing during those weeks."

Carley looked amused. "Just like that," he said, commenting on this
simple statement of a tall order.

"It won't be easy and it will probably cost them all they have, but
there is no alternative."

"They could go away from here. Sell the house and settle down somewhere
else. A year from now no one outside the Milford district will remember
anything about this affair."

"They would never do that; and I shouldn't advise them to, even if they
would. You can't have a tin can tied to your tail and go through life
pretending it isn't there. Besides, it is quite unthinkable that that
girl should be allowed to get away with her tale. It's a matter of

"You can pay too high a price for your damned principles. But I wish
you luck, anyhow. Are you considering a private inquiry agent? Because
if you are I know a very good----"

Robert said that he had got an agent and that he was already at work.

Carley's expressive face conveyed his amused congratulation at this
swift action on the part of the conservative Blair, Hayward, and

"The Yard had better look to its laurels," he said. His eyes went to
the street beyond the leaded panes of the window, and the amusement in
them faded to a fixed attention. He stared for a moment or two and then
said softly: "Well! of all the nerve!"

It was an admiring phrase, not an indignant one; and Robert turned to
see what was occasioning his admiration.

On the opposite side of the street was the Sharpes' battered old car;
its odd front wheel well in evidence. And in the back, enthroned in her
usual place and with her usual air of faint protest at this means of
transport, was Mrs. Sharpe. The car was pulled up outside the grocer's,
and Marion was presumably inside shopping. It could have been there
only a few moments or Ben Carley would have noticed it before, but
already two errand boys had paused to stare, leaning on their bicycles
with voluptuous satisfaction in this free spectacle. And even while
Robert took in the scene people came to the doors of neighbouring shops
as the news flew from mouth to mouth.

"What incredible folly!" Robert said angrily.

"Folly nothing," said Carley, his eyes on the picture. "I wish they
were clients of mine."

He fumbled in his pocket for change to pay for his coffee, and Robert
fled from the room. He reached the near side of the car just as Marion
came out on to the pavement at the other side. "Mrs. Sharpe," he said
sternly, "this is an extraordinarily silly thing to do. You are only

"Oh, good morning, Mr. Blair," she said, in polite social tones. "Have
you had your morning coffee, or would you like to accompany us to the
Anne Boleyn?"

"Miss Sharpe!" he said appealing to Marion, who was putting her
packages down on the seat. "You must know that this is a silly thing to

"I honestly don't know whether it is or not," she said, "but it seems
to be something that we must do. Perhaps we have grown childish with
living too much to ourselves, but we found that neither of us could
forget that snub at the Anne Boleyn. That condemnation without trial."

"We suffer from spiritual indigestion, Mr. Blair. And the only cure is
a hair of the dog that bit us. To wit, a cup of Miss Truelove's
excellent coffee."

"But it is so unnecessary! So----"

"We feel that at half-past ten in the morning there must be a large
number of free tables at the Anne Boleyn," Mrs. Sharpe said tartly.

"Don't worry, Mr. Blair," Marion said. "It is a gesture only. Once we
have drunk our token cup of coffee at the Anne Boleyn we shall never
darken its doors again." She burlesqued the phrase in characteristic

"But it will merely provide Milford with a free----"

Mrs. Sharpe caught him up before he could utter the word. "Milford must
get used to us as a spectacle," she said dryly, "since we have decided
that living entirely within four walls is not something that we can


"They will soon grow used to seeing monsters and take us for granted
again. If you see a giraffe once a year it remains a spectacle; if you
see it daily it becomes part of the scenery. We propose to become part
of the Milford scenery."

"Very well, you plan to become part of the scenery. But do one thing
for me just now." Already the curtains of first-floor windows were
being drawn aside and faces appearing. "Give up the Anne Boleyn
plan--give it up for today at least--and have your coffee with me at
the Rose and Crown."

"Mr. Blair, coffee with you at the Rose and Crown would be delightful,
but it would do nothing to relieve my spiritual indigestion, which, in
the popular phrase, 'is killing me'."

"Miss Sharpe, I appeal to you. You have said that you realise that you
are probably being childish, and--well, as a personal obligation to me
as your agent, I ask you not to go on with the Anne Boleyn plan."

"_That_ is blackmail," Mrs. Sharpe remarked.

"It is unanswerable, anyhow," Marion said, smiling faintly at him. "We
seem to be going to have coffee at the Rose and Crown." She sighed.
"Just when I was all strung up for a gesture!"

"Well, of all the nerve!" came a voice from overhead. It was Carley's
phrase over again but held none of Carley's admiration; it was loaded
with indignation.

"You can't leave the car here," Robert said. "Quite apart from the
traffic laws it is practically Exhibit A."

"Oh, we didn't intend to," Marion said. "We were taking it round to the
garage so that Stanley can do something technical to its inside with
some instrument he has there. He is exceedingly scornful about our car,
Stanley is."

"I dare say. Well, I shall go round with you; and you had better step
on it before we are run in for attracting a crowd."

"Poor Mr. Blair," Marion said, pressing the starter. "It must be horrid
for you not to be part of the landscape any more, after all those years
of comfortable merging."

She said it without malice--indeed there was genuine sympathy in her
voice--but the sentence stuck in his mind and made a small tender place
there as they drove round into Sin Lane, avoided five hacks and a pony
that were trailing temperamentally out of the livery stable, and came
to rest in the dimness of the garage.

Bill came out to meet them, wiping his hands on an oily rag. "Morning,
Mrs. Sharpe. Glad to see you out. Morning, Miss Sharpe. That was a neat
job you did on Stan's forehead. The edges closed as neat as if they had
been stitched. You ought to have been a nurse."

"Not me. I have no patience with people's fads. But I might have been a
surgeon. You can't be very faddy on the operating table."

Stanley appeared from the back, ignoring the two women who now ranked
as intimates, and took over the car. "What time do you want this
wreck?" he asked.

"An hour do?" Marion asked.

"A year wouldn't do, but I'll do all that can be done in an hour." His
eye went on to Robert. "Anything for the Guineas?"

"I've had a good tip for Bali Boogie."

"Nonsense," old Mrs. Sharpe said. "None of that Hippocras blood were
any good when it came to a struggle. Just turned it up."

The three men stared at her, astonished.

"You are interested in racing?" Robert said, unbelieving.

"No, in horseflesh. My brother bred thoroughbreds." Seeing their faces
she gave her dry cackle of laughter, so like a hen's squawk. "Did you
think I went to rest every afternoon with my Bible, Mr. Blair? Or
perhaps with a book on black magic. No, indeed; I take the racing page
of the daily paper. And Stanley would be well advised to save his money
on Bali Boogie; if anything in horseflesh ever deserved so obscene a
name that animal does."

"And what instead?" Stanley asked, with his usual economy.

"They say that horse sense is the instinct that keeps horses from
betting on men. But if you must do something as silly as betting, then
you had better put your money on Kominsky."

"Kominsky!" Stanley said. "But it's at sixties!"

"You can of course lose your money at a shorter price if you like," she
said dryly. "Shall we go, Mr. Blair?"

"All right," Stan said. "Kominsky it is; and you're on to a tenth of my

They walked back to the Rose and Crown; and as they emerged from the
comparative privacy of Sin Lane into the open street Robert had the
exposed feeling that being out in a bad air-raid used to give him. All
the attention and all the venom in the uneasy night seemed to be
concentrated on his shrinking person. So now in the bright early-summer
sunlight he crossed the street feeling naked and unprotected. He was
ashamed to see how relaxed and seemingly indifferent Marion swung along
at his side, and hoped that his self-consciousness was not apparent. He
talked as naturally as he could, but he remembered how easily her mind
had always read the contents of his, and felt that he was not making a
very good job of it.

A solitary waiter was picking up the shilling that Ben Carley had left
on the table, but otherwise the lounge was deserted. As they seated
themselves round the bowl of wallflowers on the black oak table Marion
said: "You heard that our windows are in again?"

"Yes; P.C. Newsam looked in on his way home last night to tell me. That
was smart work."

"Did you bribe them?" Mrs. Sharpe asked.

"No. I just mentioned that it was the work of hooligans. If your
missing windows had been the result of blast you would no doubt still
be living with the elements. Blast ranks as misfortune, and therefore a
thing to be put up with. But hooliganism is one of those things that
Something Must Be Done About. Hence your new windows. I wish that it
was all as easy as replacing windows."

He was unaware that there had been any change in his voice, but Marion
searched his face and said: "Some new development?"

"I'm afraid there is. I was coming out this afternoon to tell you about
it. It appears that just when the _Ack-Emma_ is dropping the
subject--there is only one letter today and that a mild one--just when
the _Ack-Emma_ has grown tired of Betty Kane's cause the _Watchman_ is
going to take it up."

"Excelsior!" said Marion. "The _Watchman_ snatching the torch from the
failing hands of the _Ack-Emma_ is a charming picture."

"Climbing into the _Ack-Emma_'s bed," Ben Carley had called it; but the
sentiment was the same.

"Have you spies in the _Watchman_ office, Mr. Blair?" Mrs. Sharpe

"No; it was Nevil who got wind of it. They are going to print a letter
from his future father-in-law, the Bishop of Larborough."

"Hah!" said Mrs. Sharpe. "Toby Byrne."

"You know him?" asked Robert, thinking that the quality of her tone
would peel the varnish off wood if spilt on it.

"He went to school with my nephew. The son of the horse-leech brother.
Toby Byrne, indeed. He doesn't change."

"I gather that you didn't like him."

"I never knew him. He went home for the holidays once with my nephew
but was never asked back."


"He discovered for the first time that stable lads got up at the crack
of dawn, and he was horrified. It was slavery, he said; and he went
round the lads urging them to stand up for their rights. If they
combined, he said, not a horse would go out of the stable before nine
o'clock in the morning. The lads used to mimic him for years
afterwards; but he was not asked back."

"Yes; he doesn't change," agreed Robert. "He has been using the same
technique ever since, on everything from Kaffirs to crêches. The less
he knows about a thing the more strongly he feels about it. Nevil was
of the opinion that nothing could be done about the proposed letter,
since the Bishop had already written it, and what the Bishop has
written is not to be contemplated as waste-paper. But I couldn't just
sit and do nothing about it; so I rang him up after dinner and pointed
out as tactfully as I could that he was embracing a very doubtful
cause, and at the same time doing harm to two possibly innocent people.
But I might have saved my breath. He pointed out that the _Watchman_
existed for the free expression of opinion, and inferred that I was
trying to prevent such freedom. I ended up by asking him if he approved
of lynching, because he was doing his best to bring one about. That was
after I saw it was hopeless and had stopped being tactful." He took the
cup of coffee that Mrs. Sharpe had poured out for him. "He's a sad
come-down after his predecessor in the See; who was the terror of every
evil-doer in five counties, and a scholar to boot."

"How did Toby Byrne achieve gaiters?" Mrs. Sharpe wondered.

"I assume that Cowan's Cranberry Sauce had no inconsiderable part in
his translation."

"Ah, yes. His wife. I forgot. Sugar, Mr. Blair?"

"By the way, here are the two duplicate keys to the Franchise gate. I
take it that I may keep one. The other you had better give to the
police, I think, so that they can look round as they please. I also
have to inform you that you now have a private agent in your employ."
And he told them about Alec Ramsden, who appeared on doorsteps at
half-past eight in the morning.

"No word of anyone recognising the _Ack-Emma_ photograph and writing to
Scotland Yard?" Marion asked. "I had pinned my faith to that."

"Not so far. But there is still hope."

"It is five days since the _Ack-Emma_ printed it. If anyone was ever
going to recognise it they would have by now."

"You don't make allowances for the discards. That is nearly always the
way it happens. Someone spreads open their parcel of chips and says:
'Dear me, where did I see that face?' Or someone is using a bundle of
newspapers to line drawers in a hotel. Or something like that. Don't
lose hope, Miss Sharpe. Between the good Lord and Alec Ramsden, we'll
triumph in the end."

She looked at him soberly. "You really believe that, don't you," she
said as one noting a phenomenon.

"I do," he said.

"You believe in the ultimate triumph of Good."



"I don't know. I suppose because the other thing is unthinkable.
Nothing more positive or more commendable than that."

"I should have a greater faith in a God who hadn't given Toby Byrne a
bishopric," Mrs. Sharpe said. "When does Toby's letter appear, by the

"On Friday morning."

"I can hardly wait," said Mrs. Sharpe.


Robert was less sure about the ultimate triumph of good by Friday

It was not the Bishop's letter which shook his faith. Indeed the events
of Friday did much to take the wind out of the Bishop's sails; and if
Robert had been told on Wednesday morning that he would bitterly regret
anything that served to deflate the Bishop he would not have believed

His Lordship's letter had run very true to form. _The Watchman_, he
said, had always set its face against violence and was not now, of
course, proposing to condone it, but there were occasions when violence
was but a symptom of a deep social unrest, resentment, and insecurity.
As in the recent Nullahbad case, for instance. (The "unrest,
resentment, and insecurity" in the Nullahbad case lay entirely in the
bosoms of two thieves who could not find the opal bracelet they had
come to steal and by way of reprisal killed the seven sleeping
occupants of the bungalow in their beds.) There were undoubtedly times
when the proletariat felt themselves helpless to redress a patent
wrong, and it was not to be marvelled at that some of the more
passionate spirits were moved to personal protest. (Robert thought that
Bill and Stanley would hardly recognise the louts of Monday night under
the guise of "passionate spirits"; and he held that "personal protest"
was a slight understatement for the entire wrecking of the ground floor
windows of The Franchise.) The people to be blamed for the unrest (the
_Watchman_ had a passion for euphemism: unrest, under-privileged,
backward, unfortunate; where the rest of the world talked about
violence, the poor, mentally deficient, and prostitutes; and one of the
things that the _Ack-Emma_ and the _Watchman_ had in common, now he
thought about it, was the belief that all prostitutes were
hearts-of-gold who had taken the wrong turning)--the people to be
blamed for the unrest were not those perhaps misguided persons who had
demonstrated their resentment so unmistakably, but the powers whose
weakness, ineptitude and lack of zeal had led to the injustice of a
dropped case. It was part of the English heritage that justice should
not only be done but that it should be shown to be done; and the place
for that was in open court.

"What good does he think it would do anyone for the police to waste
time preparing a case that they were fore-ordained to lose?" Robert
asked Nevil, who was reading the letter over his shoulder.

"It would have done _us_ a power of good," Nevil said. "He doesn't seem
to have thought of that. If the Magistrate dismissed the case the
suggestion that his poor bruised darling was telling fibs could hardly
be avoided, could it! Have you come to the bruises?"


The bruises came near the end. The "poor bruised body" of this young
and blameless girl, his lordship said, was a crying indictment of a law
that had failed to protect her and now failed to vindicate her. The
whole conduct of this case was one that demanded the most searching

"That must be making the Yard very happy this morning," Robert said.

"This afternoon," amended Nevil.

"Why this afternoon?"

"No one at the Yard would read a bogus publication like the _Watchman_.
They won't see it until someone sends it to them this afternoon."

But they had seen it, as it turned out. Grant had read it in the train.
He had picked it off the bookstall with three others; not because it
was his choice but because it was a choice between that and coloured
publications with bathing-belle covers.

Robert deserted the office and took the copy of the _Watchman_ out to
The Franchise together with that morning's _Ack-Emma_, which had quite
definitely no further interest in the Franchise affair. Since the
final, subdued letter on Wednesday it had ceased to mention the matter.
It was a lovely day; the grass in the Franchise courtyard absurdly
green, the dirty-white front of the house glorified by the sun into a
semblance of grace, the reflected light from the rosy brick wall
flooding the shabby drawing-room and giving it a smiling warmth. They
had sat there, the three of them, in great contentment. The _Ack-Emma_
had finished its undressing of them in public; the Bishop's letter was
not after all as bad as it might have been; Alec Ramsden was busy on
their behalf in Larborough and would without doubt unearth facts sooner
or later that would be their salvation; the summer was here with its
bright short nights; Stanley was proving himself "a great dear"; they
had paid a second short visit to Milford yesterday in pursuance of
their design to become part of the scenery, and nothing untoward had
happened to them beyond stares, black looks, and a few audible remarks.
Altogether, the feeling of the meeting was that it all might be worse.

"How much ice will this cut?" Mrs. Sharpe asked Robert, stabbing her
skinny index finger at the correspondence page of the _Watchman_.

"Not much, I think. Even among the _Watchman_ clique the Bishop is
looked at slightly sideways nowadays, I understand. His championship of
Mahoney didn't do him any good."

"Who was Mahoney?" Marion asked.

"Have you forgotten Mahoney? He was the Irish 'patriot' who put a bomb
in a woman's bicycle basket in a busy English street and blew four
people to pieces, including the woman, who was later identified by her
wedding ring. The Bishop held that Mahoney was merely misguided, not a
murderer; that he was fighting on behalf of a repressed minority--the
Irish, believe it or not--and that we should not make him into a
martyr. That was a little too much for even _Watchman_ stomachs, and
since then the Bishop's prestige is not what it was, I hear."

"Isn't it shocking how one forgets when it doesn't concern oneself,"
Marion said. "Did they hang Mahoney?"

"They did, I am glad to say--much to his own pained surprise. So many
of his predecessors had benefited from the plea that we should not make
martyrs, that murder had ceased to be reckoned in their minds as one of
the dangerous trades. It was rapidly becoming as safe as banking."

"Talking of banking," Mrs. Sharpe said, "I think it would be best if
our financial position were made clear to you, and for that you should
get in touch with old Mr. Crowle's solicitors in London, who manage our
affairs. I shall write to them explaining that you are to be given full
details, so that you may know how much we have to come and go on, and
can make corresponding arrangements for the spending of it in defence
of our good name. It is not exactly the way we had planned to spend

"Let us be thankful we have it to spend," Marion said. "What does a
penniless person do in a case like this?"

Robert quite frankly did not know.

He took the address of the Crowle solicitors and went home to lunch
with Aunt Lin, feeling happier than he had at any time since he had
first caught sight of the _Ack-Emma_'s front page on Bill's desk last
Friday. He felt as one feels in a bad thunderstorm when the noise
ceases to be directly overhead; it will still continue, and probably
still be very unpleasant, but one can see a future through it, whereas
but a moment ago there was nothing but the dreadful "now."

Even Aunt Lin seemed to have forgotten The Franchise for a spell and
was at her woolly and endearing best--full of the birthday presents she
was buying for Lettice's twins in Saskatchewan. She had provided his
favourite lunch--cold ham, boiled potatoes, and brown-betty with thick
cream--and moment by moment he was finding it more difficult to realise
that this was the Friday morning he had dreaded because it would see
the beginning of a _Watchman_ campaign against them. It seemed to him
that the Bishop of Larborough was very much what Lettice's husband used
to call "a busted flush." He couldn't imagine now why he had wasted a
thought on him.

It was in this mood that he went back to the office. And it was in this
mood that he picked up the receiver to answer Hallam's call.

"Mr. Blair?" Hallam said. "I'm at the Rose and Crown. I'm afraid I've
got bad news for you. Inspector Grant's here."

"At the Rose and Crown?"

"Yes. And he's got a warrant."

Robert's brain stopped functioning. "A search warrant?" he asked

"No; a warrant to arrest."


"I'm afraid so."

"But he _can't_ have!"

"I expect it's a bit of a shock for you. I admit I hadn't anticipated
it myself."

"You mean he has managed to get a witness--a corroborative witness?"

"He has two of them. The case is sewn up and tied with ribbon."

"I can't believe it."

"Will you come over, or shall we go to you? I expect you'll want to
come out with us."

"Out where? Oh, yes. Yes, of course I shall. I'll come over to the Rose
and Crown now. Where are you? In the lounge?"

"No, in Grant's bedroom. Number Five. The one with the casement window
on the street--over the bar."

"All right. I'm coming straight over. I say!"


"A warrant for both?"

"Yes. For two."

"All right. Thank you. I'll be with you in a moment."

He sat for a moment getting back his breath, and trying to orientate
himself. Nevil was out on business, but Nevil was not much of a moral
support at any time. He got up, took his hat, and went to the door of
"the office."

"Mr. Heseltine, please," he said, in the polite formula always used in
the presence of the younger staff; and the old man followed him into
the hall and out to the sunlit doorway.

"Timmy," Robert said. "We're in trouble. Inspector Grant is here from
Headquarters with a warrant to arrest the Franchise people." Even as he
said the words he could not believe that the thing was really

Neither could old Mr. Heseltine; that was obvious. He stared, wordless;
his pale old eyes aghast.

"It's a bit of a shock, isn't it, Timmy?" He shouldn't have hoped for
support from the frail old clerk.

But shocked as he was, and frail, and old, Mr. Heseltine was
nevertheless a law clerk, and the support was forthcoming. After a
lifetime among formulae his mind reacted automatically to the letter of
the situation.

"A warrant," he said. "Why a _warrant_?"

"Because they can't arrest anyone without one," Robert said a trifle
impatiently. Was old Timmy getting past his work?

"I don't mean that. I mean, it's a misdemeanour they're accused of, not
a felony. They could surely make it a summons, Mr. Robert? They don't
need to _arrest_ them, surely? Not for a misdemeanour."

Robert had not thought of that. "A summons to appear," he said. "Yes,
why not? Of course there's nothing to hinder them arresting them if
they want to."

"But why should they want to? People like the Sharpes wouldn't run
away. Nor do any further harm while they are waiting to appear. Who
issued the warrant, did they say?"

"No, they didn't say. Many thanks, Timmy; you've been as good as a
stiff drink. I must go over to the Rose and Crown now--Inspector Grant
is there with Hallam--and face the music. There's no way of warning The
Franchise because they have no telephone. I'll just have to go out
there with Grant and Hallam hanging round my neck. And only this
morning we were beginning to see daylight, so we thought. You might
tell Nevil when he comes in, will you? And stop him doing anything
foolish or impulsive."

"You know very well, Mr. Robert, I've never been able to stop Mr. Nevil
doing anything he wanted to do. Though it has seemed to me that he has
been surprisingly sober this last week. In the metaphorical sense, I

"Long may it last," Robert said, stepping out into the sunlit street.

It was the dead period of the afternoon at the Rose and Crown and he
passed through the hall and up the wide shallow stairs without meeting
anyone, and knocked at the door of Number Five. Grant, calm and polite
as always, let him in. Hallam, vaguely unhappy-looking, was leaning
against the dressing-table in the window.

"I understand that you hadn't expected this, Mr. Blair," Grant said.

"No, I hadn't. To be frank, it is a great shock to me."

"Sit down," Grant said. "I don't want to hurry you."

"You have new evidence, Inspector Hallam says."

"Yes; what we think is conclusive evidence."

"May I know what it is?"

"Certainly. We have a man who saw Betty Kane being picked up by the car
at the bus stop----"

"By _a_ car," Robert said.

"Yes, if you like, by _a_ car--but its description fits that of the

"So do ten thousand others in Britain. And?"

"The girl from the farm, who went once a week to help clean The
Franchise, will swear that she heard screams coming from the attic."

"_Went_ once a week? Doesn't she go any longer?"

"Not since the Kane affair became common gossip."

"I see."

"Not very valuable pieces of evidence in themselves, but very valuable
as proof of the girl's story. For instance she really did miss that
Larborough-London coach. Our witness says that it passed him about half
a mile down the road. When he came in sight of the bus-stop a few
moments later the girl was there waiting. It is a long straight road,
the main London road through Mainshill----"

"I know. I know it."

"Yes; well, when he was still some way from the girl he saw the car
stop by her, saw her get in, and saw her driven away."

"But not who drove the car?"

"No. It was too far away for that."

"And this girl from the farm--did she volunteer the information about
the screaming?"

"Not to us. She spoke about it to her friends, and we acted on
information, and found her quite willing to repeat the story on oath."

"Did she speak about it to her friends before the gossip about Betty
Kane's abduction got round?"


That was unexpected, and Robert was rocked back on his heels. If that
was really true--that the girl had mentioned screaming before there was
any question of the Sharpes being in trouble--then the evidence would
be damning. Robert got up and walked restlessly to the window and back.
He thought enviously of Ben Carley. Ben wouldn't be hating this as he
hated it, feeling inadequate and at a loss. Ben would be in his
element; his mind delighting in the problem and in the hope of
outwitting established authority. Robert was dimly aware that his own
deep-seated respect for established authority was a handicap to him
rather than an asset; he needed some of Ben's native belief that
authority is there to be circumvented.

"Well, thank you for being so frank," he said at last. "Now, I'm not
minimising the crime you are accusing these people of, but it _is_
misdemeanour not felony, so why a warrant? Surely a summons would meet
the case perfectly?"

"A summons would be in order certainly," Grant said smoothly. "But in
cases where the crime is aggravated--and my superiors take a grave view
of the present one--a warrant is issued."

Robert could not help wondering how much the gadfly attentions of the
_Ack-Emma_ had influenced the calm judgments at the Yard. He caught
Grant's eye and knew that Grant had read his thought.

"The girl was missing for a whole month--all but a day or two," Grant
said, "and had been very badly knocked about, very deliberately. It is
not a case to be taken lightly."

"But what do you gain from arrest?" Robert asked, remembering Mr.
Heseltine's point. "There is no question of these people not being
there to answer the charge. Nor any question of a similar crime being
committed by them in the interval. When did you want them to appear, by
the way?"

"I planned to bring them up at the police court on Monday."

"Then I suggest that you serve them with a summons to appear."

"My superiors have decided on a warrant," Grant said, without emotion.

"But you could use your judgment. Your superiors can have no knowledge
of local conditions, for instance. If The Franchise is left without
occupants it will be a wreck in a week. Have your superiors thought of
that? And if you arrest these women, you can only keep them in custody
until Monday, when I shall ask for bail. It seems a pity to risk
hooliganism at The Franchise just for the gesture of arrest. And I know
Inspector Hallam has no men to spare for its protection."

This right-and-left gave them both pause. It was amazing how ingrained
the respect for property was in the English soul; the first change in
Grant's face had occurred at the mention of the possible wrecking of
the house. Robert cast an unexpectedly kind thought to the louts who
had provided the precedent, and so weighted his argument with example.
As for Hallam, quite apart from his limited force he was not likely to
look kindly on the prospect of fresh hooliganism in his district and
fresh culprits to track down.

Into the long pause Hallam said tentatively: "There is something in
what Mr. Blair says. Feeling in the countryside is very strong, and I
doubt if they would leave the house untouched if it was empty.
Especially if news of the arrest got about."

It took nearly half an hour to convince Grant, however. For some reason
there was a personal element in the affair for Grant, and Robert could
not imagine what it could be, or why it should be there.

"Well," the Inspector said at length, "you don't need me to serve a
summons." It was as if a surgeon was contemptuous at being asked to
open a boil, Robert thought, amused and vastly relieved. "I'll leave
that to Hallam and get back to town. But I'll be in court on Monday. I
understand that the Assizes are imminent, so if we avoid a remand the
case can go straight on to the Assizes. Can you be ready with your
defence by Monday, do you think?"

"Inspector, with all the defence my clients have we could be ready by
tea-time," Robert said bitterly.

To his surprise, Grant turned to him with a broader smile than was
usual with him; and it was a very kind smile. "Mr. Blair," he said,
"you have done me out of an arrest this afternoon, but I don't hold it
against you. On the contrary, I think your clients are luckier than
they deserve in their solicitor. It will be my prayer that they are
less lucky in their counsel! Otherwise I may find myself talked into
voting them a testimonial."

So it was not with "Grant and Hallam hanging round his neck" that
Robert went out to The Franchise; not with a warrant at all. He went
out in Hallam's familiar car with a summons sticking out of the pocket
of it; and he was sick with relief when he thought of the escape they
had had, and sick with apprehension when he thought of the fix they
were in.

"Inspector Grant seemed to have a very personal interest in executing
that warrant," he said to Hallam as they went along. "Is it that the
_Ack-Emma_ has been biting him, do you think?"

"Oh, no," Hallam said. "Grant's as nearly indifferent to that sort of
thing as a human being can be."

"Then why?"

"Well, it's my belief--strictly between ourselves--that he can't
forgive them for fooling him. The Sharpes, I mean. He's famous at the
Yard for his good judgment of people, you see; and, again between
ourselves, he didn't much care for the Kane girl _or_ her story; and he
liked them even less when he had seen the Franchise people, in spite of
all the evidence. Now he thinks the wool was pulled over his eyes, and
he's not taking it lightly. It would have given him a lot of pleasure,
I imagine, to produce that warrant in their drawing-room."

As they pulled up by the Franchise gate and Robert took out his key,
Hallam said: "If you open both sides I'll drive the car inside, even
for the short time. No need to advertise the fact that we're here." And
Robert, pushing open the solid iron leaves, thought that when visiting
actresses said "Your policemen are wonderful" they didn't know the half
of it. He got back into the car and Hallam drove up the short straight
drive and round the circular path to the door. As Robert got out of the
car Marion came round the corner of the house, wearing gardening gloves
and a very old skirt. Where her hair was blown up from her forehead by
the wind it changed from the heavy dark stuff that it was to a soft
smoke. The first summer sun had darkened her skin and she looked more
than ever like a gipsy. Coming on Robert unexpectedly she had not time
to guard her expression, and the lighting of her whole face as she saw
him made his heart turn over.

"How nice!" she said. "Mother is still resting but she will be down
soon and we can have some tea. I----" Her glance went on to Hallam and
her voice died away uncertainly. "Good afternoon, Inspector."

"Good afternoon, Miss Sharpe. I'm sorry to break into your mother's
rest, but perhaps you would ask her to come down. It's important."

She paused a moment, and then led the way indoors. "Yes, certainly. Has
there been some--some new development? Come in and sit down." She led
them into the drawing-room that he knew so well by now--the lovely
mirror, the dreadful fireplace, the bead-work chair, the good "pieces,"
the old pink carpet faded to a dirty grey--and stood there, searching
their faces, savouring the new threat in the atmosphere.

"What is it?" she asked Robert.

But Hallam said: "I think it would be easier if you fetched Mrs. Sharpe
and I told you both at the same time."

"Yes. Yes, of course," she agreed, and turned to go. But there was no
need to go. Mrs. Sharpe came into the room, very much as she had on
that previous occasion when Hallam and Robert had been there together:
her short strands of white hair standing on end where they had been
pushed up by her pillow, her seagull's eyes bright and inquiring.

"Only two kinds of people," she said, "arrive in noiseless cars.
Millionaires and the police. Since we have no acquaintances among the
former--and an ever-widening acquaintance with the latter--I deduced
that some of _our_ acquaintances had arrived."

"I'm afraid I'm even less welcome than usual, Mrs. Sharpe. I've come to
serve a summons on you and Miss Sharpe."

"A summons?" Marion said, puzzled.

"A summons to appear at the police court on Monday morning to answer a
charge of abduction and assault." It was obvious that Hallam was not

"I don't believe it," Marion said slowly. "I don't believe it. You mean
you are charging us with this thing?"

"Yes, Miss Sharpe."

"But how? Why now?" She turned to Robert.

"The police think they have the corroborative evidence they needed,"
Robert said.

"What evidence?" Mrs. Sharpe asked, reacting for the first time.

"I think the best plan would be for Inspector Hallam to serve you both
with the summonses, and we can discuss the situation at greater length
when he has gone."

"You mean, we have to accept them?" Marion said. "To appear in the
public court--my mother too--to answer a--to be accused of a thing like

"I'm afraid there is no alternative."

She seemed half intimidated by his shortness, half resentful at his
lack of championship. And Hallam, as he handed the document to her,
seemed to be aware of this last and to resent it in his turn.

"And I think I ought to tell you, in case he doesn't, that but for Mr.
Blair here it wouldn't be a mere summons, it would be a warrant; and
you would be sleeping tonight in a cell instead of in your own beds.
Don't bother, Miss Sharpe: I'll let myself out."

And Robert, watching him go and remembering how Mrs. Sharpe had snubbed
him on his first appearance in that room, thought that the score was
now game all.

"Is that true?" Mrs. Sharpe asked.

"Perfectly true," Robert said; and told them about Grant's arrival to
arrest them. "But it isn't me you have to thank for your escape: it is
old Mr. Heseltine in the office." And he described how the old clerk's
mind reacted automatically to stimulus of a legal sort.

"And what is this new evidence they think they have?"

"They have it all right," Robert said dryly. "There is no thinking
about it." He told them about the girl being picked up on the London
road through Mainshill. "That merely corroborates what we have always
suspected: that when she left Cherrill Street, ostensibly on her way
home, she was keeping an appointment. But the other piece of evidence
is much more serious. You told me once that you had a woman--a
girl--from the farm, who came in one day a week and cleaned for you."

"Rose Glyn, yes."

"I understand that since the gossip got round she doesn't come any

"Since the gossip----? You mean, the Betty Kane story? Oh, she was
sacked before that ever came to light."

"_Sacked?_" Robert said sharply.

"Yes. Why do you look so surprised? In our experience of domestic
workers sacking is not an unexpected occurrence."

"No, but in this case it might explain a lot. What did you sack her

"Stealing," said old Mrs. Sharpe.

"She had always lifted a shilling or two from a purse if it was left
around," supplemented Marion, "but because we needed help so badly we
turned a blind eye and kept purses out of her way. Also any small
liftable articles, like stockings. And then she took the watch I'd had
for twenty years. I had taken it off to wash some things--the soapsuds
rise up one's arms, you know--and when I went back to look for it it
had gone. I asked her about it, but of course she 'hadn't seen it.'
That was too much. That watch was part of me, as much a part of me as
my hair or my fingernails. There was no recovering it, because we had
no evidence at all that she had taken it. But after she had gone we
talked it over and next morning we walked over to the farm, and just
mentioned that we would not be needing her any more. That was a
Tuesday--she always came on Mondays--and that afternoon after my mother
had gone up to rest Inspector Grant arrived, with Betty Kane in the

"I see. Was anyone else there when you told the girl at the farm that
she was sacked?"

"I don't remember. I don't think so. She doesn't belong to the farm--to
Staples, I mean; they are delightful people. She is one of the
labourer's daughters. And as far as I remember we met her outside their
cottage and just mentioned the thing in passing."

"How did she take it?"

"She got very pink and flounced a bit."

"She grew beetroot red and bridled like a turkeycock," Mrs. Sharpe
said. "Why do you ask?"

"Because she will say on oath that when she was working here she heard
screams coming from your attic."

"Will she indeed," said Mrs. Sharpe, contemplatively.

"What is much worse, there is evidence that she mentioned the screams
before there was any rumour of the Betty Kane trouble."

This produced a complete silence. Once more Robert was aware how
noiseless the house was, how dead. Even the French clock on the
mantelpiece was silent. The curtain at the window moved inwards on a
gust of air and fell back to its place as soundlessly as if it were
moving in a film.

"That," said Marion at last, "is what is known as a facer."

"Yes. Definitely."

"A facer for you, too."

"For us, yes."

"I don't mean professionally."

"No? How then?"

"You are faced with the possibility that we have been lying."

"Really, Marion!" he said impatiently, using her name for the first
time and not noticing that he had used it. "What I am faced with, if
anything, is the choice between your word and the word of Rose Glyn's

But she did not appear to be listening. "I wish," she said
passionately, "oh, how I wish that we had one small, just one small
piece of evidence on our side! She gets away--that girl gets away with
everything, everything. We keep on saying 'It is not true,' but we have
no way of _showing_ that it is not true. It is all negative. All
inconclusive. All feeble denial. Things combine to back up her lies,
but nothing happens to help prove that we are telling the truth.

"Sit down, Marion," her mother said. "A tantrum won't improve the

"I could kill that girl; I could kill her. My God, I could torture her
twice a day for a year and then begin again on New Year's day. When I
think what she has done to us I----"

"Don't think," Robert interrupted. "Think instead of the day when she
is discredited in open court. If I know anything of human nature that
will hurt Miss Kane a great deal worse than the beating someone gave

"You still believe that that is possible?" Marion said incredulous.

"Yes. I don't quite know how we shall bring it about. But that we shall
bring it about I do believe."

"With not one tiny piece of evidence for us, not one; and evidence
just--just _blossoming_ for her?"

"Yes. Even then."

"Is that just native optimism, Mr. Blair," Mrs. Sharpe asked, "or your
innate belief in the triumph of Good, or what?"

"I don't know. I think Truth has a validity of its own."

"Dreyfus didn't find it very valid; nor Slater; nor some others of whom
there is record," she said dryly.

"They did in the end."

"Well, frankly, I don't look forward to a life in prison waiting for
Truth to demonstrate its validity."

"I don't believe that it will come to that. Prison, I mean. You will
have to appear on Monday, and since we have no adequate defence you
will no doubt be sent for trial. But we shall ask for bail, and that
means that you can go on staying here until the Assizes at Norton. And
before that I hope that Alec Ramsden will have picked up the girl's
trail. Remember we don't even have to know what she was doing for the
rest of the month. All we have to show is that she did something else
on the day she says you picked her up. Take away that first bit and her
whole story collapses. And it is my ambition to take it away in

"To undress her in public the way the _Ack-Emma_ has undressed us? Do
you think she would mind?" Marion said. "Mind as we minded?"

"To have been the heroine of a newspaper sensation, to say nothing of
the adored centre of a loving and sympathetic family, and then to be
uncovered to the public gaze as a liar, a cheat and a wanton? I think
she would mind. And there is one thing she would mind particularly. One
result of her escapade was that she got back Leslie Wynn's attention;
the attention she had lost when he became engaged. As long as she is a
wronged heroine she is assured of that attention; once we show her up
she has lost it for good."

"I never thought to see the milk of human kindness so curdled in your
gentle veins, Mr. Blair," Mrs. Sharpe remarked.

"If she had broken out as a result of the boy's engagement--as she very
well might--I should have nothing but pity for her. She is at an
unstable age, and his engagement must have been a shock. But I don't
think that had very much to do with it. I think she is her mother's
daughter; and was merely setting out a little early on the road her
mother took. As selfish, as self-indulgent, as greedy, as plausible as
the blood she came of. Now I must go. I said that I would be at home
after five o'clock if Ramsden wanted to ring up to report. And I want
to ring Kevin Macdermott and get his help about counsel and things."

"I'm afraid that we--that I, rather--have been rather ungracious about
this," Marion said. "You have done, and are doing, so much for us. But
it was such a shock. So entirely unexpected and out of the blue. You
must forgive me if----"

"There is nothing to forgive. I think you have both taken it very
well. Have you got someone in the place of the dishonest and
about-to-commit-perjury Rose? You can't have this huge place entirely
on your hands."

"Well, no one in the locality would come, of course. But Stanley--what
would we do without Stanley?--Stanley knows a woman in Larborough who
might be induced to come out by bus once a week. You know, when the
thought of that girl becomes too much for me, I think of Stanley."

"Yes," Robert said, smiling. "The salt of the earth."

"He is even teaching me how to cook. I know how to turn eggs in the
frying-pan without breaking them now. 'D'you have to go at them as if
you were conducting the Philharmonic?' he asked me. And when I asked
him how he got so neat-handed he said it was with 'cooking in a bivvy
two feet square.'"

"How are you going to get back to Milford?" Mrs. Sharpe asked.

"The afternoon bus from Larborough will pick me up. No word of your
telephone being repaired, I suppose?"

Both women took the question as comment not interrogation. Mrs. Sharpe
took leave of him in the drawing-room, but Marion walked to the gate
with him. As they crossed the circle of grass enclosed by the branching
driveway, he remarked: "It's a good thing you haven't a large family or
there would be a worn track across the grass to the door."

"There is that as it is," she said, looking at the darker line in the
rough grass. "It is more than human nature could bear to walk round
that unnecessary curve."

Small talk, he was thinking; small talk. Idle words to cover up a stark
situation. He had sounded very brave and fine about the validity of
Truth, but how much was mere sound? What were the odds on Ramsden's
turning up evidence in time for the court on Monday? In time for the
Assizes? Long odds against, wasn't it? And he had better grow used to
the thought.

At half-past five Ramsden rang up to give him the promised report; and
it was one of unqualified failure. It was the girl he was looking for,
of course; having failed to identify the man as a resident at the
Midland, and having therefore no information at all about him. But
nowhere had he found even a trace of her. His own men had been given
duplicates of the photograph and with them had made inquiries at the
airports, the railway termini, travel agencies, and the more likely
hotels. No one claimed to have seen her. He himself had combed
Larborough, and was slightly cheered to find that the photograph he had
been given was at least easily recognisable, since it had been readily
identified at the places where Betty Kane had actually been. At the two
main picture houses, for instance--where, according to the box-office
girls' information, she had always been alone--and at the ladies'
cloakroom of the bus-station. He had tried the garages, but had drawn

"Yes," Robert said. "He picked her up at the bus-stop on the London
road through Mainshill. Where she would normally have gone to catch her
coach home." And he told Ramsden of the new developments. "So things
really are urgent now. They are being brought up on Monday. If only we
could prove what she did that first evening. That would bring her whole
story crashing down."

"What kind of car was it?" Ramsden asked.

Robert described it, and Ramsden sighed audibly over the telephone.

"Yes," Robert agreed. "A rough ten thousand of them between London and
Carlisle. Well, I'll leave you to it. I want to ring up Kevin
Macdermott and tell him our woes."

Kevin was not in chambers, nor yet at the flat in St. Paul's
Churchyard, and Robert eventually ran him to earth at his home near
Weybridge. He sounded relaxed and amiable, and was instantly attentive
when he heard the news that the police had got their evidence. He
listened without remark while Robert poured out the story to him.

"So you see, Kevin," Robert finished, "we're in a frightful jam."

"A schoolboy description," Kevin said, "but exquisitely accurate. My
advice to you is to 'give' them the police court, and concentrate on
the Assizes."

"Kevin, couldn't you come down for the week-end, and let me talk about
it to you? It's six years, Aunt Lin was saying yesterday, since you
spent a night with us, so you're overdue anyhow. Couldn't you?"

"I promised Sean I'd take him over to Newbury on Sunday to choose a

"But couldn't you postpone it? I'm sure Sean wouldn't mind if he knew
it was in a good cause."

"Sean," said his doting parent, "has never taken the slightest interest
in any cause that was not to his own immediate advantage. Being a chip
off the old block. If I came would you introduce me to your witches?"

"But of course."

"And would Christina make me some butter tarts?"


"And could I have the room with the text in wools?"

"Kevin, you'll come?"

"Well, it's a damned dull country, Milford, except in the winter"--this
was a reference to hunting, Kevin's only eye for country being from the
back of a horse--"and I was looking forward to a Sunday riding on the
downs. But a combination of witches, butter tarts, and a bedroom with a
text in wools is no small draw."

As he was about to hang up, Kevin paused and said: "Oh, I say, Rob?"

"Yes?" Robert said, and waited.

"Have you considered the possibility that the police have the right of

"You mean, that the girl's absurd tale may be true?"

"Yes. Are you keeping that in mind--as a possibility, I mean?"

"If I were I shouldn't----" Robert began angrily, and then laughed.
"Come down and see them," he said.

"I come, I come," Kevin assured him, and hung up.

Robert called the garage, and when Bill answered asked if Stanley was
still there.

"It's a wonder you can't hear him from where you are," Bill said.

"What's wrong?"

"We've just been rescuing that bay pony of Matt Ellis's from our
inspection pit. Did you want Stan?"

"Not to speak to. Would you be very kind and ask him to pick up a note
for Mrs. Sharpe on his way past tonight?"

"Yes, certainly. I say, Mr. Blair, is it true that there is fresh
trouble coming about the Franchise affair--or shouldn't I ask that?"

Milford! thought Robert. How did they do it? A sort of
information-pollen blown on the wind?

"Yes, I'm afraid there is," he said. "I expect they'll tell Stanley
about it when he goes out tonight. Don't let him forget about the note,
will you?"

"No, that's all right."

He wrote to The Franchise to say that Kevin Macdermott was coming down
for Saturday night, and could he bring him out to see them on Sunday
afternoon before he left to go back to town?


"Does Kevin Macdermott _have_ to look like a tout when he comes to the
country?" Nevil asked, the following evening as he and Robert waited
for the guest to finish his ablutions and come down to dinner.

What Kevin in country clothes actually looked like, Robert considered,
was a rather disreputable trainer of jumpers for the smaller meetings;
but he refrained from saying that to Nevil. Remembering the clothes
that Nevil had startled the countryside with for the last few years, he
felt that Nevil was in no position to criticise anyone's taste. Nevil
had turned up to dinner in a chaste dark grey suit of the most
irreproachable orthodoxy, and seemed to think that his new conformity
made him free to forget the experimentalism of his immediate past.

"I suppose Christina is in the usual lather of sentiment?"

"A lather of white of egg, as far as I have been able to judge."

Christina regarded Kevin as "Satan in person," and adored him. His
Satanic qualities came not from his looks--though Kevin did indeed look
a little like Satan--but from the fact that he "defended the wicked for
the sake of worldly gain." And she adored him because he was
good-looking, and a possibly reclaimable sinner, and because he praised
her baking.

"I hope it's a soufflé, then, and not that meringue stuff. Do you think
that Macdermott could be lured into coming down to defend them at
Norton Assizes?"

"I think he is much too busy for that, even if he were interested. But
I'm hoping that one of his dogs-bodies will come."

"Primed by Macdermott."

"That's the idea."

"I really don't see why Marion should have to slave to provide
Macdermott with lunch. Does he realise that she has to prepare and
clear away and wash up every single thing, to say nothing of carting
them to and fro a day's journey to that antediluvian kitchen?"

"It was Marion's own idea that he should come to lunch with them. I
take it that she considers the extra trouble worth while."

"Oh, you were always crazy about Kevin; and you simply don't know how
to begin to appreciate a woman like Marion. It's--it's _obscene_ that
she should be wasting her vitality on household drudgery, a woman like
that. She should be hacking her way through jungles, or scaling
precipices, or ruling a barbarous race, or measuring the planets. Ten
thousand nit-wit blondes dripping with mink have nothing to do but sit
back and have the polish on their predatory nails changed, and Marion
carts coal. Coal! _Marion!_ And I suppose by the time this case is
finished they won't have a penny to pay a maid even if they could get

"Let us hope that by the time this case is finished they are not doing
hard labour by order."

"Robert, it _couldn't_ come to that! It's unthinkable."

"Yes, it's unthinkable. I suppose it is always unbelievable that anyone
one knows should go to prison."

"It's bad enough that they should go into the dock. Marion. Who never
did a cruel, or underhand, or shabby thing in her life. And just
because a---- Do you know, I had a lovely time the other night. I found
a book on torture, and I stayed awake till two o'clock choosing which
one I would use on the Kane."

"You should get together with Marion. That is her ambition too."

"And what would yours be?" There was a faint hint of scorn in the tone,
as though it was understood that the mild Robert would have no strong
feelings on the subject. "Or haven't you considered it?"

"I don't need to consider it," Robert said slowly. "I'm going to
undress her in public."


"Not that way. I'm going to strip her of every rag of pretence, in open
court, so that everyone will see her for what she is."

Nevil looked curiously at him for a moment. "Amen," he said quietly. "I
didn't know you felt like that about it, Robert." He was going to add
something, but the door opened and Macdermott came in, and the evening
had begun.

Eating solidly through Aunt Lin's superb dinner, Robert hoped that it
was not going to be a mistake to take Kevin to Sunday lunch at The
Franchise. He was desperately anxious that the Sharpes should make a
success with Kevin; and there was no denying that Kevin was
temperamental and the Sharpes not everyone's cup of tea. Was lunch at
The Franchise likely to be an asset to their cause? A lunch cooked by
Marion? For Kevin who was a gourmet? When he had first read the
invitation--handed in by Stanley this morning--he was glad that they
had made the gesture, but misgiving was slowly growing in him. And as
one perfection succeeded the other in unhurried procession across Aunt
Lin's shining mahogany, with Christina's large face hovering in eager
benevolence beyond the candle-light, the misgiving swelled until it
took entire possession of him. "Shapes that did not stand up" might
fill his breast with a warm, protective affection; but they could
hardly be expected to have the same effect on Kevin.

At least Kevin seemed glad to be here, he thought, listening to
Macdermott making open love to Aunt Lin, with a word thrown to
Christina every now and then to keep her happy and faithful. Dear
Heaven, the Irish! Nevil was on his best behaviour, full of earnest
attention, with a discreet "sir" thrown in now and again; often enough
to make Kevin feel superior but not often enough to make him feel old.
The subtler English form of flattery, in fact. Aunt Lin was like a
girl, pink-cheeked and radiant; absorbing flattery like a sponge,
subjecting it to some chemical process, and pouring it out again as
charm. Listening to her talk Robert was amused to find that the Sharpes
had suffered a sea-change in her mind. By the mere fact of being in
danger of imprisonment, they had been promoted from "these people" to
"poor things." This had nothing to do with Kevin's presence; it was a
combination of native kindness and woolly thinking.

It was odd, Robert thought, looking round the table, that this family
party--so gay, so warm, so secure--should be occasioned by the dire
need of two helpless women in that dark silent house set down among the
endless fields.

He went to bed with the warm aura of the party still round him, but in
his heart a chill anxiety and an ache. Were they asleep out there at
The Franchise? How much sleep had they had lately?

He lay long awake, and wakened early; listening to the Sunday morning
silence. Hoping that it would be a good day--The Franchise looked its
worst in rain, when its dirty-white became almost grey--and that
whatever Marion made for lunch would "stand up." Just before eight
o'clock a car came in from the country and stopped below the window,
and someone whistled a soft bugle call. A company call, it was. B
Company. Stanley, presumably. He got up and put his head out of the

Stanley, hatless as usual--he had never seen Stanley in any kind of
head covering--was sitting in the car regarding him with tolerant

"You Sunday snoozers," said Stanley.

"Did you get me up just to sneer at me?"

"No. I have a message from Miss Sharpe. She says when you come out
you're to take Betty Kane's statement with you, and you're on no
account to forget it because it's of the first importance. I'll say
it's important! She's going round looking as if she had unearthed a

"Looking happy!" Robert said, unbelieving.

Like a bride. Indeed I haven't seen a woman look like that since my
cousin Beulah married her Pole. A face like a scone, Beulah has; and
believe me that day she looked like Venus, Cleopatra, and Helen of Troy
rolled into one."

"Do you know what it is that Miss Sharpe is so happy about?"

"No. I did cast out a few feelers, but she's saving it up, it seems.
Anyhow, don't forget the copy of the statement, or the responses won't
come right, or something. The pass-word's in the statement."

Stanley proceeded on his way up the street towards Sin Lane, and Robert
took his towel and went to the bathroom greatly puzzled. While he
waited for breakfast he looked out the statement from among the papers
in his dispatch case, and read it through again with a new attention.
What had Marion remembered or discovered that was making her so happy?
Betty Kane had slipped somewhere, that was obvious. Marion was radiant,
and Marion wanted him to bring the Kane statement when he came. That
could only mean that somewhere in the statement was proof that Betty
Kane was lying.

He reached the end of the statement without finding any likely sentence
and began to hunt through it again. What could it be? That she had said
it was raining, and that it--perhaps--had not been raining? But that
would not have been vital, or even important to the credibility of her
story. The Milford bus, then? The one she said she had passed, when
being driven in the Sharpes' car. Were the times wrong? But they had
checked the times long ago, and they fitted nearly enough. The "lighted
sign" on the bus? Was the time too early for a sign to be lighted? But
that would have been merely a slip of memory, not a discrediting factor
in her statement.

He hoped passionately that Marion in her anxiety to obtain that "one
small piece of evidence" on their side was not exaggerating some
trifling discrepancy into proof of dishonesty. The descent from hope
would be worse than no hope at all.

This real worry almost obliterated the social worry of the lunch from
his mind, and he ceased to care greatly whether Kevin enjoyed his meal
at The Franchise or not. When Aunt Lin said to him, covertly, as she
set off for church: "What do you think they'll give you for lunch,
dear? I'm quite sure they live on those toasted flake things out of
packets, poor things," he said shortly: "They know good wine when they
taste it; that should please Kevin."

"What has happened to young Bennet?" Kevin asked as they drove out to
The Franchise.

"He wasn't asked to lunch," Robert said.

"I didn't mean that. What has happened to the strident suits and the
superiority and the _Watchman_ aggressiveness?"

"Oh, he has fallen out with the _Watchman_ over this case."


"For the first time he is in a position to have actual personal
knowledge of a case the _Watchman_ is pontificating about, and it has
been a bit of a shock to him, I think."

"Is the reformation going to last?"

"Well, do you know, I shouldn't be a bit surprised if it did. Apart
from the fact that he has got to an age when they normally give up
childish things, and was due for a change, I think he has been doing
some revision and wondering if any of the other _Watchman_ white-headed
boys were any more worthy of championing than Betty Kane. Kotovich, for

"Hah! The patriot!" Kevin said expressively.

"Yes. Only last week he was holding forth on our duty to Kotovich; our
duty to protect and cherish him--and eventually provide him with a
British passport, I suppose. I doubt if today he would be quite so
simple. He has grown up wonderfully in the last few days. I didn't know
he even possessed a suit like the one he was wearing last night. It
must be one he got to go to his school prize-giving in, for he
certainly has worn nothing so sober since."

"I hope for your sake it lasts. He has brains, the boy; and once he got
rid of his circus tricks would be an asset to the firm."

"Aunt Lin is distressed because he has split with Rosemary over the
Franchise affair, and she is afraid he won't marry a Bishop's daughter
after all."

"Hooray! More power to him. I begin to like the boy. You put a few
wedges into that split, Rob--casual-like--and see that he marries some
nice stupid English girl who will give him five children and give the
rest of the neighbourhood tennis parties between showers on Saturday
afternoons. It's a much nicer kind of stupidity than standing up on
platforms and holding forth on subjects you don't know the first thing
about. Is this the place?"

"Yes, this is The Franchise."

"A perfect 'mystery house'."

"It wasn't a mystery house when it was built. The gates, as you can
see, were scroll work--rather nice work, too--so that the whole place
was visible from the road. It was the simple operation of backing the
gate with the iron sheeting that converted the house from something
quite ordinary to something rather secret."

"A perfect house for Betty Kane's purpose anyhow. What a piece of luck
for her that she remembered it."

Robert was to feel guilty afterwards that he had not had greater faith
in Marion; both over the matter of Betty Kane's statement and over the
lunch. He should have remembered how cool-minded she was, how analytic;
and he should have remembered the Sharpe gift for taking people as they
found them and its soothing effect on the persons concerned. The
Sharpes had made no effort to live up to Aunt Lin's standard of
hospitality; no effort to provide a formal dining-room lunch. They had
set a table for four in the window of the drawing-room where the sun
fell on it. It was a cherrywood table, very pleasant in grain but sadly
needing polishing. The wine glasses, on the other hand, were polished
to a diamond brilliance. (How like Marion, he thought, to concentrate
on the thing that mattered and to ignore mere appearance.)

"The dining-room is an incredibly gloomy place," Mrs. Sharpe said.
"Come and see it, Mr. Macdermott."

That too was typical. No sitting round with their sherry making small
talk. Come and see our horrible dining-room. And the visitor was part
of the household before he knew it.

"Tell me," Robert said to Marion as they were left alone, "what is this
about the----"

"No, I am not going to talk about it until after lunch. It is to be
your liqueur. It is a piece of the most astonishing luck that I should
have thought of it last night, when Mr. Macdermott was coming to lunch
today. It makes everything quite different. It won't stop the case, I
suppose, but it does make everything different for us. It is the 'small
thing' that I was praying for to be evidence for _us_. Have you told
Mr. Macdermott?"

"About your message. No, I haven't said anything. I thought it
better--not to."

"Robert!" she said looking at him with a quizzical amusement. "You
didn't trust me. You were afraid I was havering."

"I was afraid you might be building more on a small foundation
than--than it would hold. I----"

"Don't be afraid," she said, reassuringly. "It will hold. Would you
like to come to the kitchen and carry the tray of soup for me?"

They had even managed the service without fuss or flurry. Robert
carried the tray with four flat bowls of soup, and Marion came after
him with a large dish under a Sheffield plate cover, and that seemed to
be all. When they had drunk their soup, Marion put the large dish in
front of her mother, and a bottle of wine in front of Kevin. The dish
was a pot-au-feu chicken with all its vegetables round it; and the wine
was a Montrachet.

"A Montrachet!" Kevin said. "You wonderful woman."

"Robert told us you were a claret lover," Marion said, "but what is
left in old Mr. Crowle's cellar is long past its best. So it was a
choice between that and a very heavy red burgundy that is wonderful on
winter evenings but not so good with one of the Staples' fowls on a
summer day."

Kevin said something about how seldom it was that women were interested
in anything that did not bubble, or alternatively explode.

"To be frank," Mrs. Sharpe said, "if these parcels had been saleable we
should probably have sold them, but we were exceedingly glad that they
were too scrappy and varied for that. I was brought up to appreciate
wine. My husband had a fairly good cellar, though his palate was not as
good as mine. But my brother at Lessways had a better one, and a fine
palate to match."

"Lessways?" Kevin said, and looked at her as if searching for a
resemblance. "You're not Charlie Meredith's sister, are you?"

"I am. Did you know Charles? But you couldn't. You are too young."

"The first pony I ever had of my own was bred by Charlie Meredith,"
Kevin said. "I had him for seven years and he never put a foot wrong."

And after that, of course, both of them ceased to take any further
interest in the others, and not over-much in the food.

Robert caught Marion's amused and congratulatory glance at him, and
said: "You did yourself grave injustice when you said you couldn't

"If you were a woman you would observe that I have not cooked anything.
The soup I emptied out of a can, heated it, and added some sherry and
flavouring; the fowl I put into a pot just as it came from Staples,
poured some boiling water over it, added everything I could think of
and left it on the stove with a prayer; the cream cheese also came from
the farm."

"And the wonderful rolls to go with the cream cheese?"

"Stanley's landlady made those."

They laughed a little together, quietly.

Tomorrow she was going into the dock. Tomorrow she was going to be a
public spectacle for the delight of Milford. But today her life was
still her own, and she could share amusement with him; could be content
with the hour. Or so it seemed if her shining eyes were any evidence.

They took the cheese plates from under the noses of the other two, who
did not even pause in their conversation to remark the action, carried
the trays of dirty dishes away to the kitchen and made the coffee
there. It was a great gloomy place with a floor of stone slabs, and an
old-fashioned sink that depressed him at sight.

"We put the range on only on Mondays when the scrubbing is done,"
Marion said, seeing his interest in the place. "Otherwise we cook on
the little oil stove."

He thought of the hot water that ran so instantly into the shining bath
when he turned the tap this morning, and was ashamed. He could hardly
visualise, after his long years of soft living, an existence where
one's bathing was done in water that was heated over an oil burner.

"Your friend is a charmer, isn't he," she said, pouring the hot coffee
into its jug. "A little Mephistophelian--one would be terribly afraid
of him as opposing counsel--but a charmer."

"It's the Irish," Robert said, gloomily. "It comes as natural to them
as breathing. Us poor Saxons plod along our brutish way and wonder how
they do it."

She had turned to give him the tray to carry, and so was facing him
with their hands almost touching. "The Saxons have the two qualities
that I value most in this world. Two qualities that explain why they
have inherited the earth. Kindness and dependability--or tolerance and
responsibility, if you prefer the terms. Two qualities the Celt never
had; which is why the Irish have inherited nothing but squabbles. Oh
damn, I forgot the cream. Wait a moment. It's keeping cold in the
wash-house." She came back with the cream and said, mock rustic: "I
have heard tell as how there's things called refrigerators in some
folks' houses now, but we don't need none."

And as he carried the coffee to the sunlight of the drawing-room he
visualised the bone-chilling cold of those kitchen quarters in winter
with no roaring range as there had been in the palmy days of the house
when a cook had lorded it over half a dozen servants and you ordered
coal by the wagon load. He longed to take Marion away from the place.
Where he would take her he did not quite know--his own home was filled
with the aura of Aunt Lin. It would have to be a place where there was
nothing to polish and nothing to carry and practically everything was
done by pressing a button. He could not see Marion spending her old age
in service to some pieces of mahogany.

As they drank their coffee he brought the conversation gently round to
the possibility of their selling The Franchise at some time or other
and buying a cottage somewhere.

"No one would buy the place," Marion said. "It is a white elephant. Not
big enough for a school, too remote for flats, and too big for a family
these days. It might make a good madhouse," she added, thoughtfully,
her eyes on the high pink wall beyond the window; and Robert saw
Kevin's glance flash over her and run away again. "It is quiet, at
least. No trees to creak, or ivy to tap at the window-panes, or birds
to go yap-yap-yap until you want to scream. It is a very peaceful place
for tired nerves. Perhaps someone would consider it for that."

So she liked the silence; the stillness that had seemed to him so dead.
It was perhaps what she had longed for in her London life of noise and
elbowing and demands; her life of fret and cramped quarters. The big
quiet ugly house had been a haven.

And now it was a haven no longer.

Some day--Oh-please-God-let-it-happen--some day he would strip Betty
Kane for ever of credit and love.

"And now," Marion said, "you are invited to inspect the 'fatal attic'."

"Yes," Kevin said, "I should be greatly interested to see the things
that the girl professed to identify. All her statements seemed to me
the result of logical guesses. Like the harder carpet on the second
flight of stairs. Or the wooden commode--something that you would
almost certainly find in a country house. Or the flat-topped trunk."

"Yes, it was rather terrifying at the time, the way she kept hitting on
things we had--and I hadn't had time to gather my wits--it was only
afterwards I saw how little she really had identified in her statement.
And she did make one complete bloomer, only no one thought of it until
last night. Have you got the statement, Robert?"

"Yes." He took it out of his pocket.

They had climbed, she, and Robert and Macdermott, the last bare flight
of stairs and she led them into the attic. "I came up here last night
on my usual Saturday tour round the house with a mop. That is our
solution to the housekeeping problem, in case you are interested. A
good large mop well soaked in absorbent polish-stuff run over every
floor once a week. It takes five minutes per room and keeps the dust at

Kevin was poking round the room, and inspecting the view from the
window. "So this is the view she described," he said.

"Yes," Marion said, "that is the view she described. And if I remember
the words of her statement, as I remembered them last night, correctly,
then she said something that she can't---- Robert, would you read the
bit where she describes the view from the window?"

Robert looked up the relevant passage, and began to read. Kevin was
bending slightly forward staring out of the little round window, and
Marion was standing behind him, smiling faintly like a sibyl.

"'From the window of the attic,'" read Robert, "'I could see a high
brick wall with a big iron gate in the middle of it. There was a road
on the further side of the wall, because I could see the telegraph
posts. No, I couldn't see the traffic on it because the wall was too
high. Just the tops of lorry loads sometimes. You couldn't see through
the gate because it had sheets of iron on the inside. Inside the gate
the carriage-way went straight for a little and then divided in two
into a circle up to the door. No, it wasn't a garden, just----'"

"What!" yelled Kevin, straightening himself abruptly.

"What what?" Robert asked, startled.

"Read that last bit again, that bit about the carriage-way."

"'Inside the gate the carriage-way went straight for a little and then
divided in two into a circle up to the----'"

Kevin's shout of laughter stopped him. It was an abrupt monosyllable of
amused triumph.

"You see?" Marion said into the sudden silence.

"Yes," Kevin said softly, his pale bright eyes gloating on the view.
"That was something she didn't reckon with."

Robert moved over as Marion gave way to let him have her place, and so
saw what they were talking about. The edge of the roof with its small
parapet cut off the view of the courtyard before the carriage-way
branched at all. No one imprisoned in that room would know about the
two half circles up to the doorway.

"You see," Marion said, "the Inspector read that description when we
were all in the drawing-room. And all of us knew that the description
was accurate. I mean, an accurate picture of what the courtyard is
like; so we unconsciously treated it as something that was finished
with. Even the Inspector. I remember his looking at the view from the
window but it was quite an automatic gesture. It didn't occur to any of
us that it would not have been as described. Indeed, except for one
tiny detail it was as described."

"Except for one tiny detail," Kevin said. "She arrived in darkness and
fled in darkness, and she says she was locked in the room all the time,
so she could have known nothing of that branching drive. What does she
say, again, about her arrival, Rob?"

Robert looked it up and read:

"'The car stopped at last and the younger woman, the one with the black
hair, got out and pushed open big double gates on to a drive. Then she
got back in and drove the car up to a house. No, it was too dark to see
what kind of a house, except that it had steps up to the door. No, I
don't remember how many steps; four or five, I think. Yes, definitely a
small flight of them.' And then she goes on about being taken to the
kitchen for coffee."

"So," Kevin said. "And her account of her flight? What time of night
was that?"

"Sometime after supper if I remember rightly," Robert said, shuffling
through the pages. "After dark, anyhow. Here it is." And he read:

"'When I got to the first landing, the one above the hall, I could hear
them talking in the kitchen. There was no light in the hall. I went on
down the last flight, expecting every moment that one of them would
come out and catch me, and then made a dash for the door. It wasn't
locked and I ran straight out and down the steps to the gate and out to
the road. I ran along the road--yes, it was hard like a highroad--until
I couldn't run any longer and I lay in the grass till I was feeling
able to go on.'"

"'It was hard, like a highroad,'" Kevin quoted. "The inference being
that it was too dark to see the surface she was running on."

There was a short silence.

"My mother thinks that this is enough to discredit her," Marion said.
She looked from Robert to Kevin, and back again, without much hope.
"But you don't, do you." It was hardly a question.

"No," Kevin said. "No. Not alone. She might wriggle out of it with a
clever counsel's help. Might say that she had deduced the circle from
the swing of the car when she arrived. What she would normally have
deduced, of course, would be the ordinary carriage sweep. No one would
spontaneously think of anything as awkward as that circular drive. It
makes a pretty pattern, that's all--which is probably why she
remembered it. I think this tit-bit should be kept as make-weight for
the Assizes."

"Yes, I thought you would say that," Marion said. "I'm not really
disappointed. I was glad about it, not because I thought that it would
free us of the charge, but because it frees us of the doubt that must
have--must have----" She stammered unexpectedly, avoiding Robert's

"Must have muddied our crystal minds," finished Kevin, briskly; and
cast a glance of pleased malice at Robert. "How did you think of this
last night when you came to sweep?"

"I don't know. I stood looking out of the window, and at the view she
described, and wishing that we might have just one small tiny
microscopic piece of evidence on _our_ side. And then, without
thinking, I heard Inspector Grant's voice reading that bit in the
drawing-room. Most of the story he told us in his own words, you know.
But the bits that brought him to The Franchise he read in the girl's
words. I heard his voice--it's a nice voice--saying the bit about the
circular carriage-way, and from where I was at that moment there was no
circular carriage-way. Perhaps it was an answer to unspoken prayer."

"So you still think that we had best 'give' them tomorrow and bank
everything on the Assizes?" Robert said.

"Yes. It makes no difference actually to Miss Sharpe and her mother. An
appearance in one place is very like an appearance in another--except
that the Assizes at Norton will probably be less unpleasant than a
police court in one's home town. And the shorter their appearance
tomorrow the better from their point of view. You have no evidence to
put before the court tomorrow, so it should be a very short and formal
affair. A parade of _their_ evidence, an announcement that you reserve
your defence, an application for bail, and _voilà_!"

This suited Robert well enough. He did not want to prolong tomorrow's
ordeal for them; he had more confidence in any case in a judgment
framed outside Milford; and most of all he did not want, now that it
had come to a case, a half-decision, a dismissal. That would not be
sufficient for his purpose where Betty Kane was concerned. He wanted
the whole story of that month told in open court, in Betty Kane's
presence. And by the time the Assizes opened at Norton, he would,
please God, have the story ready to tell.

"Whom can we get to defend them?" he asked Kevin as they drove home to

Kevin reached into a pocket, and Robert took it for granted that what
he was looking for was a list of addresses. But what he produced was
obviously an engagement book.

"What is the date of the Assizes at Norton, do you know?" he asked.

Robert told him, and held his breath.

"It's just possible that I might be able to come down myself. Let me
see, let me see."

Robert let him see in complete silence. One word, he felt, might ruin
the magic.

"Yes," Kevin said. "I don't see why I shouldn't--short of the
unforeseen. I like your witches. It would give me great pleasure to
defend them against that very nasty piece of work. How odd that she
should be old Charlie Meredith's sister. One of the best, the old boy
was. About the only approximately honest horse-coper known in history.
I have never ceased to be grateful to him for that pony. A boy's first
horse is very important. It colours his whole after-life; not only his
attitude to horseflesh; everything else as well. There is something in
the trust and friendship that exists between a boy and a good horse

Robert listened, relaxed and amused. He had realised, with a gentle
irony untinged with any bitterness, that Kevin had given up any thought
of the Sharpes' guilt long before the evidence of that view from the
window was presented to him. It was not possible that old Charlie
Meredith's sister could have abducted anyone.


"It's a perpetual wonder to me," Ben Carley said, eyeing the
well-populated benches in the little court, "how so many of the lieges
have so little to do on a Monday morning. Though I must say it's some
time since the gathering has had so much tone. Have you noticed the
Sports Wear? Back row but one, in a yellow hat that doesn't go with her
mauve powder _or_ her hair. If she's left that little Godfrey girl in
charge, she's going to be short of change tonight. I got that girl off
when she was fifteen. She'd been swiping cash since she could walk and
she's still swiping it. No female to be left alone with a till, believe
me. And that Anne Boleyn woman. First time I've ever seen her in court.
Though how she's avoided it so long I don't know. Her sister's for ever
paying out cheques to cover her R.D. ones. No one's ever discovered
what she does with the money. Someone blackmailing her, perhaps. I
wonder who. I wouldn't put it past Arthur Wallis, at the White Hart.
Three different orders to pay every week, and another on the way, just
won't come out of a potman's pay."

Robert let Carley burble on without listening to him. He was only too
conscious that the audience in court was not the usual Monday morning
collection of loafers putting off time until they opened. The news had
gone round, by the mysterious Milford channels, and they had come to
see the Sharpes charged. The normal drabness of the court was gay with
women's clothes; and its normal drowsy silence sibilant with their

One face he saw which should have been hostile but was oddly friendly:
that of Mrs. Wynn, whom he had last seen standing in her lovely little
patch of garden in Meadowside Lane, Aylesbury. He could not think of
Mrs. Wynn as an enemy. He liked her, admired her, and was sorry for her
in advance. He would have liked to go over and say how d'you do to her,
but the game had been laid out on the squares now and they were
chequers of different colour.

Grant had not appeared so far, but Hallam was there, talking to the
sergeant who had come to The Franchise the night the hooligans wrecked
the windows.

"How's your sleuth doing?" Carley asked, during a pause in his running

"The sleuth's all right, but the problem is colossal," Robert said.
"The proverbial needle just gives itself up by comparison."

"One girl against the world," mocked Ben. "I'm looking forward to
seeing this floosie in the flesh. I suppose after all the fan mail
she's had, and the offers of marriage, and the resemblance to Saint
Bernadette, she'll think a country police court too small an arena for
her. Did she have any stage offers?"

"I wouldn't know."

"I suppose Mama would repress them anyhow. That's her there with the
brown suit, and she looks a very sensible woman to me. I can't think
how she ever came to have a daughter like----. Oh, but she was adopted,
wasn't she? An Awful Warning. It's a constant wonder to me how little
folk know about the people they live with. There was a woman over at
Ham Green had a daughter that was never out of her sight as far as she
knew, but daughter walked out in a pet one day and didn't come back and
frantic mother goes howling to the police and police discover that the
girl who has apparently never been away from mother for a night is a
married woman with a child and has merely collected child and gone to
live with husband. See police records if not believing Ben Carley. Ah,
well, if you grow dissatisfied with your sleuth let me know and I'll
give you the address of a very good one. Here we go."

He rose in deference to the Bench, while continuing a monologue on the
Bench's complexion, possible temper, and probable occupation yesterday.

Three routine cases were disposed of; old offenders apparently so used
to the procedure that they anticipated the drill, and Robert half
expected someone to say "Wait for it, can't you!"

Then he saw Grant come in quietly and sit in an observer's position at
the back of the Press bench, and he knew that the time had come.

They came in together when their names were called, and took their
places in the horrid little pew as if they were merely taking their
places in church. It _was_ rather like that, he thought: the quiet, and
observant eyes, and the suggestion of waiting for a performance to
begin. But he suddenly realised what he would be feeling if it were
Aunt Lin in Mrs. Sharpe's place, and was fully aware for the first time
of what Marion must be suffering on her mother's behalf. Even if the
Assizes saw them cleared of the charge, what would compensate them for
what they had endured? What punishment fit Betty Kane's crime?

For Robert, being old-fashioned, believed in retribution. He might not
go all the way with Moses--an eye was not always compensation for an
eye--but he certainly agreed with Gilbert: the punishment should fit
the crime. He certainly did not believe that a few quiet talks with the
chaplain and a promise to reform made a criminal into a respect-worthy
citizen. "Your true criminal," he remembered Kevin saying one night,
after a long discussion on penal reform, "has two unvarying
characteristics, and it is these two characteristics which make him a
criminal. Monstrous vanity and colossal selfishness. And they are both
as integral, as ineradicable, as the texture of the skin. You might as
well talk of 'reforming' the colour of one's eyes."

"But," someone had objected, "there have been monsters of vanity and
selfishness who were not criminal."

"Only because they have victimised their wives instead of their bank,"
Kevin had pointed out. "Tomes have been written trying to define the
criminal, but it is a very simple definition after all. The criminal is
a person who makes the satisfaction of his own immediate personal wants
the mainspring of his actions. You can't cure him of his egotism, but
you can make the indulgence of it not worth his while. Or almost not
worth his while."

Kevin's idea of prison reform, Robert remembered, was deportation to a
penal colony. An island community where everyone worked hard. This was
not a reform for the benefit of the prisoners. It would be a nicer life
for the warders, Kevin said; and would leave more room in this crowded
island for good citizens' houses and gardens; and since most criminals
hated hard work more than they hated anything in this world, it would
be a better deterrent than the present plan which, in Kevin's
estimation, was no more punitive than a third-rate public school.

Looking at the two figures in the dock Robert thought that in the "bad
old days" only the guilty were put in the pillory. Nowadays, it was the
untried who bore the pillory and the guilty went immediately into a
safe obscurity. Something had gone wrong somewhere.

Old Mrs. Sharpe was wearing the flat black satin hat in which she had
appeared at his office on the morning of the _Ack-Emma_ irruption into
their affairs, and looked academic, respectable, but odd. Marion too
was wearing a hat--less, he supposed, out of deference to the court
than as some protection against the public gaze. It was a country felt,
with a short brim; and its orthodoxy lessened to some extent her normal
air of being a law unto herself. With her black hair hidden and her
brilliant eyes shadowed she looked no swarthier than a normal
out-of-doors woman might. And though Robert missed the black hair and
the brilliance he thought that it was all to the good that she should
look as "ordinary" as possible. It might lessen the pecking-to-death
instinct in her hostile fellows.

And then he saw Betty Kane.

It was the stir on the Press bench that told him she was in court.
Normally the Press bench was occupied by two bored apprentices in the
art of reporting: one for the _Milford Advertiser_ (once weekly, on
Fridays) and one combining the _Norton Courier_ (twice weekly, Tuesdays
and Fridays) with the _Larborough Times_ and anyone else who would take
the stuff. But today the Press bench was filled, and the faces there
were neither young nor bored. They were the faces of men invited to a
meal and quite ready for it.

And Betty Kane was two-thirds of what they had come for.

Robert had not seen her since she stood in the drawing-room at The
Franchise in her dark blue school coat, and he was surprised all over
again by her youth and her candid innocence. In the weeks since he had
first seen her she had grown into a monster in his mind; he thought of
her only as the perverted creature who had lied two human beings into
the dock. Now, seeing the actual physical Betty Kane again, he was
nonplussed. He _knew_ that this girl and his monster were one, but he
found it difficult to realise. And if he, who felt that he now knew
Betty Kane so well, reacted like that to her presence, what effect
would her child-like grace have on good men and true when the time

She was wearing "week-end" clothes, not her school things. A cloudy
blue outfit that made one think of forget-me-nots and wood-smoke and
bluebells and summer distances, and was further calculated to bedevil
the judgment of sober men. Her young and simple and very-well-brought-up
hat stood back from her face and showed the charming brow and the
wide-set eyes. Robert absolved Mrs. Wynn, without even having to
consider the matter, from any conscious dressing of the girl for the
occasion, but was bitterly aware that if she had lain awake at nights
devising the outfit it could not have served its purpose better.

When her name was called and she walked to the witness stand, he stole
a glance at the faces of those who could see her clearly. With the sole
exception of Ben Carley--who was looking at her with the interest one
accords a museum exhibit--there was only one expression on the faces of
the men: a sort of affectionate compassion. The women, he observed, had
not surrendered so easily. The more motherly ones obviously yearned to
her youth and her vulnerability, but the younger ones were merely avid;
without emotion other than curiosity.

"I--don't--believe--it!" Ben said, _sotto voce_, while she was taking
the oath. "You mean that child was on the loose for a month? I don't
believe she's ever kissed anything but the book!"

"I'll bring witnesses to prove it," muttered Robert, angry that even
the worldly and cynical Carley was succumbing.

"You could bring ten irreproachable witnesses and still not get a jury
to believe it; and it's the jury who count, my friend."

Yes, what jury would believe any bad of her!

Watching her as she was led through her story, he reminded himself of
Albert's account of her: the "nicely brought-up girl" whom no one would
have thought of as a woman at all, and the cool expertness with which
she attached the man she had chosen.

She had a very pleasant voice; young and light and clear; without
accent or affectation. And she told her tale like a model witness;
volunteering no extras, explicit in what she did say. The pressmen
could hardly keep their eyes on their shorthand. The Bench was
obviously doting. (God send there was something tougher at the
Assizes!) The members of the police force were gently perspiring in
sympathy. The body of the court breathless and motionless.

No actress had ever had a better reception.

She was quite calm, as far as anyone could see; and apparently unaware
of the effect she was having. She made no effort to make a point, or to
use a piece of information dramatically. And Robert found himself
wondering whether the understatement was deliberate and whether she
realised quite clearly how effective it was.

"And did you in fact mend the linen?"

"I was too stiff from the beating, that night. But I mended some

Just as if she were saying: "I was too busy playing bridge." It gave an
extraordinary air of truth to what she said.

Nor was there any sign of triumph in the account of her vindication.
She had said this and that about the place of her imprisonment, and
this and that had proved to be so. But she showed no overt pleasure in
the fact. When she was asked if she recognised the women in the dock,
and if they were in fact the women who had detained and beaten her, she
looked at them gravely for a moment of silence and then said that she
did and they were.

"Do you want to examine, Mr. Blair?"

"No, sir. I have no questions."

This caused a slight stir of surprise and disappointment in the body of
the court, who had looked forward to drama; but it was accepted by the
initiates without remark; it was taken for granted that the case would
go forward to another court.

Hallam had already given his statement, and the girl was now followed
by the corroborative witnesses.

The man who had seen her picked up by the car proved to be a Post
Office sorter called Piper. He worked on a postal van which the L.M.S.
ran between Larborough and London, and he was dropped off at Mainshill
station on the return journey because it was near his home. He was
walking up the long straight London road through Mainshill, when he
noticed that a young girl was waiting at the stop for the London
coaches. He was still a long distance from her but he noticed her
because the London coach had overtaken him about half a minute
previously, before he had come within sight of the bus stop; and when
he saw her waiting there he realised that she must just have missed it.
While he was walking towards her but still some distance away, a car
overtook him at a good pace. He did not even glance at it because his
interest was concentrated on the girl and on whether when he came up
with her he should stop and tell her that the London bus had passed.
Then he saw the car slow down alongside the girl. She bent forward to
talk to whoever was in it, and then got in herself and was driven away.

By this time he was near enough to describe the car but not to read the
number. He had not thought of reading the number anyhow. He was merely
glad that the girl had got a lift so quickly.

He would not take an oath that the girl in question was the girl he had
seen give evidence, but he was certain in his own mind. She had worn a
palish coat and hat--grey he thought--and black slippers.


Well, those shoes with no straps across the instep.

Court shoes.

Well, court shoes, but he called them slippers. (And had every
intention, his tone made it clear, of going on calling them slippers.)

"Do you want to examine, Mr. Blair?"

"No, thank you, sir."

Then came Rose Glyn.

Robert's first impression was of the vulgar perfection of her teeth.
They reminded him of a false set made by a not very clever dentist.
There surely never had been, never could be, any natural teeth as
flashily perfect as those Rose Glyn had produced as substitutes for her
milk teeth.

The Bench did not like her teeth either, it seemed, and Rose soon
stopped smiling. But her tale was lethal enough. She had been in the
habit of going to The Franchise every Monday to clean the house. On a
Monday in April she had been there as usual, and was preparing to leave
in the evening when she heard screaming coming from upstairs somewhere.
She thought something had happened to Mrs. or Miss Sharpe and ran to
the foot of the stairs to see. The screaming seemed to be far away, as
if it came from the attic. She was going to go upstairs, but Mrs.
Sharpe came out of the drawing-room and asked her what she was doing.
She said someone was screaming upstairs. Mrs. Sharpe said nonsense,
that she was imagining things, and wasn't it time that she was going
home. The screaming had stopped then, and while Mrs. Sharpe was talking
Miss Sharpe came downstairs. Miss Sharpe went with Mrs. Sharpe into the
drawing-room, and Mrs. Sharpe said something about "ought to be more
careful." She was frightened, she did not quite know why, and went away
to the kitchen and took her money from where it was always left for her
on the kitchen mantelpiece, and ran from the house. The date was April
the 15th. She remembered the date because she had decided that next
time she went back, on the following Monday, she would give the Sharpes
her week's notice; and she had in fact done that, and had not worked
for the Sharpes since Monday April the 29th.

Robert was faintly cheered by the bad impression she was patently
making on everyone. Her open delight in the dramatic, her Christmas
Supplement glossiness, her obvious malice, and her horrible clothes,
were unhappily contrasted with the restraint and good sense and good
taste of her predecessor in the witness box. From the expressions on
the faces of her audience she was summed up as a slut and no one would
trust her with sixpence.

But that did nothing to discount the evidence she had just given on

Robert, letting her go, wondered if there was any way of pinning that
watch on her, so to speak. Being a country girl, unversed in the ways
of pawnshops, it was unlikely that she had stolen that watch to sell
it; she had taken it to keep for herself. That being so, was there
perhaps some way of convicting her of theft and so discrediting her
evidence to that extent?

She was succeeded by her friend Gladys Rees. Gladys was as small and
pale and skinny as her friend was opulent. She was scared and ill at
ease, and took the oath hesitatingly. Her accent was so broad that even
the Court found difficulty in following her, and the prosecution had
several times to translate her wilder flights of English into something
nearer common speech. But the gist of her evidence was clear. On the
evening of Monday the 15th April she had gone walking with her friend,
Rose Glyn. No, not anywhere special, just walking after supper. Up to
High Wood and back. And Rose Glyn had told her that she was scared of
The Franchise because she had heard someone screaming in an upstairs
room, although there was supposed not to be anyone there. She, Gladys,
knew that it was Monday the 15th that Rose had told her that, because
Rose had said that when she went next week she was going to give
notice. And she had given notice and had not worked for the Sharpes
since Monday the 29th.

"I wonder what dear Rose has got on her," Carley said, as she left the
witness box.

"What makes you think she has anything?"

"People don't come and perjure themselves for friendship; not even
country morons like Gladys Rees. The poor silly little rat was
frightened stiff. She would never have come voluntarily. No, that
oleograph has a lever of some sort. Worth looking into if you're stuck,

"Do you happen to know the number of your watch?" he asked Marion as he
was driving them back to The Franchise. "The one Rose Glyn stole."

"I didn't even know that watches had numbers," Marion said.

"Good ones do."

"Oh, mine was a good one, but I don't know anything about its number.
It was very distinctive, though. It had a pale blue enamel face with
gold figures."

"Roman figures?"

"Yes. Why do you ask? Even if I got it back I could never bear to wear
it after that girl."

"It wasn't so much getting it back I thought of, as convicting her of
having taken it."

"That would be nice."

"Ben Carley calls her 'the oleograph,' by the way."

"How lovely. That is just what she is like. Is that the little man you
wanted to push us off on to, that first day?"

"That's the one."

"I am so glad that I refused to be pushed."

"I hope you will still be as glad when this case is over," Robert said,
suddenly sober.

"We have not yet thanked you for standing surety for our bail," Mrs.
Sharpe said from the back of the car.

"If we began to thank him for all we owe him," Marion said, "there
would be no end to it."

Except, he thought, that he had enlisted Kevin Macdermott on their
side--and that was an accident of friendship--what had he been able to
do for them? They would go for trial at Norton little more than a
fortnight hence, and they had no defence whatever.


The newspapers had a field-day on Tuesday.

Now that the Franchise affair was a court case, it could no longer
provide a crusade for either the _Ack-Emma_ or the _Watchman_--though
the _Ack-Emma_ did not fail to remind its gratified readers that on
such and such a date they had said so and so, a plain statement which
was on the surface innocent and unexceptionable but was simply loaded
with the forbidden comment; and Robert had no doubt that on Friday the
_Watchman_ would be taking similar credit to itself, with similar
discretion. But the rest of the Press, who had not so far taken any
interest in a case that the police had no intention of touching, woke
with a glad shout to report a case that was news. Even the soberer
dailies held accounts of the court appearance of the Sharpes, with
headings like: EXTRAORDINARY CASE, and: UNUSUAL CHARGE. The less
inhibited had full descriptions of the principal actors in the case,
including Mrs. Sharpe's hat and Betty Kane's blue outfit, pictures of
The Franchise, the High Street in Milford, a school friend of Betty
Kane, and anything else that was even approximately relevant.

And Robert's heart sank. Both the _Ack-Emma_ and the _Watchman_, in
their different ways, had used the Franchise affair as a stunt.
Something to be used for its momentary worth and dropped tomorrow. But
now it was a national interest, reported by every kind of paper from
Cornwall to Caithness; and showed signs of becoming a _cause célèbre_.

For the first time he had a feeling of desperation. Events were
hounding him, and he had no refuge. The thing was beginning to pile up
into a tremendous climax at Norton and he had nothing to contribute to
that climax; nothing at all. He felt as a man might feel if he saw a
stacked heap of loaded crates begin to lean over towards him and had
neither retreat nor a prop to stay the avalanche.

Ramsden grew more and more monosyllabic on the telephone, and less and
less encouraging. Ramsden was sore. "Baffled" was a word used in boys'
detective stories; it had not until now had even the remotest
connection with Alec Ramsden. So Ramsden was sore, monosyllabic, and

The one bright spot in the days that followed the court at Milford was
provided by Stanley, who tapped on his door on Thursday morning, poked
his head in, and seeing that Robert was alone came in, pushing the door
to with one hand and fishing in the pocket of his dungarees with the

"Morning," he said. "I think you ought to take charge of these. Those
women at The Franchise have no sense at all. They keep pound notes in
tea-pots and books and what not. If you're looking for a telephone
number you're as likely as not to find a ten-shilling note marking the
butcher's address." He fished out a roll of money and solemnly counted
twelve ten-pound notes on to the desk under Robert's nose.

"A hundred and twenty," he said. "Nice, ain't it?"

"But what _is_ it?" Robert asked, bewildered.



"Don't tell me you didn't have anything on! After the old lady giving
us the tip herself. Mean to say you _forgot_ about it!"

"Stan, I haven't even remembered lately that there was such a thing as
the Guineas. So you backed it?"

"At sixties. And that's the tenth I told her she was on to, for the

"But--a tenth? You must have been plunging, Stan."

"Twenty pounds. Twice as much as my normal ceiling. Bill did a bit of
good too. Going to give his missus a fur coat."

"So Kominsky won."

"Won by a length and a half on a tight rein; and was that a turn up for
the book!"

"Well," Robert said, stacking the notes and banding them, "if the worst
comes to the worst and they end up bankrupt, the old lady can always do
a fair trade as a tipster."

Stanley eyed his face for a moment in silence, apparently not happy
about something in his tone. "Things are pretty bad, 'm?" he said.

"Fierce," said Robert, using one of Stanley's own descriptions.

"Bill's missus went to the court," Stan said, after a pause. "She said
she wouldn't believe that girl even if she told her there were twelve
pennies in a shilling."

"Oh?" Robert said, surprised. "Why?"

"Much too good to be true, she said she was. She said no girl of
fifteen was ever as good as that."

"She's sixteen now."

All right, sixteen. She said she was fifteen once and so were all her
girl friends, and that wide-eyed-wonder didn't fool her for a moment."

"I'm very much afraid it will fool a jury."

"Not if you had an all-woman jury. I suppose there's no way of wangling

"Not short of Herod measures. Don't you want to give this money to Mrs.
Sharpe yourself, by the way?"

"Not me. You'll be going out there sometime today, and you can give it
to her if you like. But see you get it back and put it in the bank or
they'll be picking it out of flower vases years hence and wondering
when they put that there."

Robert smiled as he put the money away in his pocket to the sound of
Stanley's departing feet. Endlessly unexpected, people were. He would
have taken it for granted that Stan would have revelled in counting
those notes out in front of the old lady. But instead he had turned
shy. That tale of money in tea-pots was just a tale.

Robert took the money out to The Franchise in the afternoon, and for
the first time saw tears in Marion's eyes. He told the tale as Stanley
had told it--tea-pots and all--and finished: "So he made me his
deputy"; and it was then that Marion's eyes had filled.

"Why did he mind about giving it to us?" she said, fingering the notes.
"He's not usually so--so----"

"I think it may be that he considers that you need it now, and that
that makes it a delicate affair instead of a matter-of-fact one. When
you gave him the tip you were just the well-off Sharpes who lived at
The Franchise, and he would have turned over the proceeds to you with
éclat. But now you are two women out on bail of £200 each in your
personal recognizances and of a similar sum by one surety on behalf of
you each; to say nothing of having the expenses of a counsel to come;
and are therefore, I think, in Stan's mind not people that one can hand
over money to easily."

"Well," said Mrs. Sharpe, "not all my tips have had a margin of a
length-and-a-half on the right side. But I don't deny that I am very
glad to see the percentage. It was very kind of the boy."

"Should we keep as much as ten per cent?" Marion asked doubtfully.

"That was the arrangement," Mrs. Sharpe said equably. "If it hadn't
been for me he would be short by the amount of a bet on Bali Boogie at
this moment. What _is_ a Bali Boogie, by the way?"

"I am glad you came," Marion said, ignoring her mother's quest for
education, "because something unexpected has happened. My watch has
come back."

"You mean you've found it?"

"No, oh, no. She sent it back through the post. Look!"

She produced a small, very dirty, white cardboard box, which contained
her watch with the blue enamel face and the wrapping that had been
round the watch. The wrapping was a square of pinkish tissue paper with
a circular stamp reading SUN VALLEY, TRANSVAAL, and had evidently
started life embracing an orange. On a torn piece of paper was printed:
I DON'T WANT NONE OF IT. The capital I was dotted like a small letter,
after the fashion of illiterates.

"Why do you think she turned squeamish about it?" Marion wondered.

"I don't for a moment think she did," Robert said. "I couldn't imagine
that girl ever relinquishing anything that her hand had closed over."

"But she did. She sent it back."

"No. Someone sent it back. Someone who was frightened. Someone with a
rudimentary conscience, too. If Rose Glyn had wanted to be rid of it
she would have thrown it into a pond, without a second thought. But X
wants to be rid of it and to make restitution at the same time. X has
both a bad conscience and a frightened soul. Now who would have a bad
conscience about you just now? Gladys Rees?"

"Yes, of course you are right about Rose. I should have thought of
that. She never would have sent it back. She would have put her heel on
it sooner. You think perhaps she gave it to Gladys Rees?"

"That might explain a lot. It might explain how Rose got her to court
to back up that 'screaming' story. I mean, if she had been the receiver
of stolen goods. When you come to think of it, Rose could have very
little chance of wearing a watch that the Staples people must quite
often have seen on your wrist. It is much more likely that she was
'large' with it in favour of her friend. 'A little thing I picked up.'
Where does the Rees girl belong to?"

"I don't know where she belongs to; somewhere the other side of the
county, I think. But she has come to work for that isolated farm beyond

"Long ago?"

"I don't know. I don't think so."

"So she could wear a new watch without question. Yes, I think it was
Gladys who sent back your watch. If ever there was an unwilling witness
it was Gladys on Monday. And if Gladys is shakeable to the point of
sending back your property, a faint hope begins to dawn."

"But she has committed perjury," Mrs. Sharpe said. "Even a moron like
Gladys Rees must have some glimmering of awareness that that is not
well seen in a British court."

"She could plead that she was blackmailed into it. If someone suggested
that course to her."

Mrs. Sharpe eyed him. "Isn't there anything in English law about
tampering with a witness?" she asked.

"Plenty. But I don't propose to do any tampering."

"What do you propose to do?"

"I must think it over. It is a delicate situation."

"Mr. Blair, the intricacies of the Law have always been beyond me, and
are always likely to be, but you won't get yourself put away for
contempt of court, or something like that, will you? I can't imagine
what the present situation would be like without your support."

Robert said that he had no intention of getting himself put away for
anything. That he was a blameless solicitor of unblemished reputation
and high moral principles and that she need have no fear either for
herself or for him.

"If we could knock the prop of Gladys Rees from under Rose's story it
would undermine their whole case," he said. "It's their most valuable
piece of evidence: that Rose had mentioned the screaming before there
was any suggestion of a charge against you. I suppose you couldn't see
Grant's face when Rose was giving evidence? A fastidious mind must be a
great handicap in the C.I.D. It must be sad to have your whole case
depend on someone you would hate to touch with a barge-pole. Now I must
be getting back. May I take the little cardboard box and the scrap of
paper with the printing?"

"It was clever of you to have seen that Rose would not have sent it
back," Marion said, putting the scrap of paper into the box and giving
it to him. "You should have been a detective."

"Either that or a fortune-teller. Everything deduced from the egg-stain
on the waistcoat. _Au revoir._"

Robert drove back to Milford with his mind full of this new
possibility. It was no solution to their predicament, but it might be a

In the office he found Mr. Ramsden waiting for him; long, grey, lean,
and dour.

"I came to see you, Mr. Blair, because it wasn't a thing that could be
said over the telephone very well."


"Mr. Blair, we're wasting your money. Do you happen to know what the
white population of the world is?"

"No, I don't."

"Neither do I. But what you're asking me to do is to pick this girl out
of the white population of the world. Five thousand men working for a
year mightn't do it. One man might do it tomorrow. It's a matter of
pure chance."

"But it always has been that."

"No. In the first days the chances were fair. We covered the obvious
places. The ports, the airports, the travel places, the best known
'honeymoon' places. And I didn't waste your time or money in any
travelling. I have contacts in all the big towns and in a lot of the
smaller ones, and I just send them a request saying: 'Find out if such
and such a person stayed at one of your hotels,' and the answer is back
in a few hours. Answers from all over Britain. Well, that done, we are
left with a small proposition called the rest of the world. And I don't
like wasting your money, Mr. Blair. Because that is what it will amount

"Do I understand that you are giving up?"

"I don't put it like that, exactly."

"You think I should give you notice because you have failed."

Mr. Ramsden stiffened noticeably at the word "failed."

"It's throwing good money away on a long chance. It isn't a business
proposition, Mr. Blair. It isn't even a good gamble."

"Well, I have something for your consideration that is definite enough
to please you, I think." He fished the little cardboard box out of his
pocket. "One of the witnesses on Monday was a girl called Gladys Rees.
Her role was to supply evidence that her friend Rose Glyn had talked to
her about screams at The Franchise long before the police were
interested in the place. Well, she supplied the evidence all right, but
not _con amore_, as you might say. She was nervous, unwilling, and was
obviously hating it--in contrast to her friend Rose who was having the
time of her life. One of my local colleagues suggested that Rose had
got her there by pressure, but that didn't seem very likely at the
time. This morning, however, the watch that Rose stole from Miss Sharpe
came back by post in this box, with the printed message enclosed. Now
Rose would never have bothered to return the watch; she has no
conscience at all. Nor would she have written the note; having no
desire to repudiate anything. The conclusion is inescapable, that it
was Gladys who received the watch--Rose could not have worn it without
detection anyhow--and that that was how Rose got her to back up her

He paused to let Ramsden comment. Mr. Ramsden nodded; but it was an
interested nod.

"Now we can't approach Gladys with any kind of argument without being
accused of intimidating witnesses. I mean, getting her to go back on
her story before the Assizes is not possible. All we can do is to
concentrate on breaking her down at the Assizes. Kevin Macdermott could
probably do it by force of personality and persistent questions, but I
doubt it; and anyhow the Court might stop him before he had achieved
anything. They are apt to look sideways on him when he begins to ride a

"They are?"

"What I want to do is to be able to put this printed scrap into court
as evidence. To be able to say that it is Gladys Rees's writing. With
the evidence that it was she who had the stolen watch, we make the
suggestion that Rose used pressure on her to testify to what is not
true, Macdermott assures her that if she was blackmailed into giving
false evidence she will probably not be punished for it, and she breaks
down and confesses."

"So you want another specimen of Gladys Rees's printing."

"Yes. And coming along just now I was thinking about it. I have the
impression that her present job is her first one, so it can't be very
long since she left school. Perhaps her school could furnish one. Or
anyhow, provide a starting-off place. It would be enormously to our
advantage if we could come by a specimen without _provocateur_ methods.
Do you think you could do something about it?"

"I'll get you a specimen, yes," Ramsden said; as who should say: Give
me any reasonable commission and it will be executed. "Did the Rees
girl go to school here?"

"No, I understand she comes from the other side of the county."

"All right, I'll find out. Where is she working now?"

"At an isolated place called Bratt's Farm; over the fields from
Staples, the place behind The Franchise."

"And about the search for the Kane girl----"

"Isn't there anything you could still do in Larborough itself? I can't
teach you anything about your business, I know that, but she _was_ in

"Yes, and where she was we traced her. In public places. But X may
_live_ in Larborough, for all we know. She may just have gone to ground
there. After all, a month--or practically a month--is an odd time for
that sort of disappearance, Mr. Blair. That sort of thing usually
ranges from a week-end to ten days but not longer. She may just have
gone home with him."

"Do you think that is what happened?"

"No," Ramsden said slowly. "If you want my honest opinion, Mr. Blair,
it is that we have missed her at one of the exits."


"That she went out of the country, but looking so different that that
butter-wouldn't-melt photograph didn't convey her at all."

"Why different?"

"Well, I don't suppose she was provided with a phoney passport, so she
would presumably travel as his wife."

"Yes, of course. I took that for granted."

"And she couldn't do that looking as she does. But with her hair swept
up and some make-up on, she would look quite different. You have no
idea the difference sweeping-up hair-dressing makes to a woman. The
first time I saw my wife with one I didn't recognise her. It made her
so different, if you want to know, that I felt quite shy with her; and
we'd been married twenty years."

"So that's what you think happened. I expect you're right," Robert said

"That's why I don't want to waste any more of your money, Mr. Blair.
Looking for the girl in the photograph is not much use, because the
girl we're looking for didn't look a bit like that. When she _did_ look
like that, people recognised her at first glance. At the cinemas and
what not. We traced her easily enough during her time on her own in
Larborough. But from then on it's a complete blank. Her photograph
doesn't convey her to anyone who saw her after she left Larborough."

Robert sat doodling on Miss Tuff's nice fresh blotting-paper. A
herring-bone pattern; very neat and decorative. "You see what this
means, don't you? We are sunk."

"But you have this," Ramsden protested, indicating the printed scrap of
paper that had come with the watch.

"That merely destroys the police case. It doesn't disprove Betty Kane's
story. If the Sharpes are ever to be rid of this thing the girl's story
has to be shown to be nonsense. Our only chance of doing that is to
find out where she was during those weeks."

"Yes. I see."

"I suppose you have checked on private owners?"

"Planes? Oh, yes. The same thing goes there. We have no photograph of
the man, so he might be any one of the hundreds of private owners who
went abroad with female companions in the specified time."

"Yes. Pretty well sunk. Not much wonder Ben Carley was amused."

"You're tired, Mr. Blair. You've been having a worrying time."

"Yes. It isn't very often a country solicitor has something like this
dumped on his shoulders," Robert said wryly.

Ramsden regarded him with what amounted on the Ramsden visage to a
smile. "For a country solicitor," he said, "it seems to me you're not
doing badly, Mr. Blair. Not badly at all."

"Thanks," Robert said, really smiling. Coming from Alec Ramsden that
was practically an O.M.

"I shouldn't let it get you down. You've got an insurance against the
very worst happening--or will, when I get that printed evidence."

Robert flung down the pen he had been doodling with. "I'm not
interested in insurance," he said with sudden heat. "I'm interested in
justice. I have only one ambition in life at this moment. And that is
to have Betty Kane's story disproved in open court. To have the full
account of what she did during those weeks made public in her presence
and duly backed up by irreproachable witnesses. What are our chances of
that, do you think? And what--tell me--what have we left untried that
could possibly help us?"

"I don't know," Mr. Ramsden said, seriously. "Prayer, perhaps."


This, oddly enough, was also Aunt Lin's reaction.

Aunt Lin had become gradually reconciled to Robert's connection with
the Franchise affair as it moved from the provincial-unsavoury to the
national-celebrated. It was, after all, no disgrace to be connected
with a case that was reported in _The Times_. Aunt Lin did not, of
course, read _The Times_, but her friends did. The vicar, and old
Colonel Whittaker, and the girl at Boots and old Mrs. Warren from
Weymouth (Swanage); and it was vaguely gratifying to think that Robert
should be solicitor for the defence in a famous trial, even if the
defence was against a charge of beating a helpless girl. And of course
it had never even remotely shadowed her mind that Robert would not win
the case. She had taken that quite placidly for granted. In the first
place Robert himself was so clever; and in the second Blair, Hayward,
and Bennet could not conceivably be connected with a failure. She had
even regretted in her own mind, in passing, that his triumph would take
place over at Norton and not in Milford where everyone might be there
to see.

So that the first hint of doubt came as a surprise to her. Not a shock,
since she still could not visualise the prospect of failure. But
definitely as a new thought.

"But, Robert," she said, sweeping her foot round under the table in an
effort to locate her footstool, "you don't suppose for a moment that
you are going to _lose_ the case, do you?"

"On the contrary," Robert said, "I don't suppose for a moment that we
shall win it."


"In trial by jury it is customary to have a case to put to the jury. So
far we have no case. And I don't think that the jury is going to like
that at all."

"You sound quite pettish, dear. I think you are allowing the thing to
get on your nerves. Why don't you take tomorrow afternoon off and
arrange a golf four? You have hardly golfed at all lately and it can't
be good for your liver. Not golfing, I mean."

"I can't believe," Robert said wonderingly, "that I was ever interested
in the fate of 'a piece of gutta-percha' on a golf course. That must
have been in some other life."

"That is what I say, dear. You are losing your sense of proportion.
Allowing this affair to worry you quite unnecessarily. After all, you
have Kevin."

"That I take leave to doubt."

"What do you mean, dear?"

"I can't imagine Kevin taking time off and travelling down to Norton to
defend a case that he is fore-ordained to lose. He has his quixotic
moments, but they don't entirely obliterate his common sense."

"But Kevin promised to come."

"When he made that promise there was still time for a defence to
materialise. Now we can almost count the days to the Assizes and still
we have no evidence--and no prospect of any."

Miss Bennet eyed him over her soup spoon. "I don't think, you know,
dear," she said, "that you have enough faith."

Robert refrained from saying that he had none at all. Not, anyhow,
where divine intervention in the Franchise affair was concerned.

"Have faith, my dear," she said happily, "and it will all come right.
You'll see." The charged silence that succeeded this evidently worried
her a little, for she added: "If I had known you were doubtful or
unhappy about the case, dear, I should have said extra prayers about it
long ago. I am afraid I took it for granted that you and Kevin would
manage it between you." "It" being British justice. "But now that I
know you are worrying about it I shall most certainly put up some
special petitions."

The matter-of-fact application-for-relief tone with which this was
uttered restored Robert's good humour.

"Thank you, darling," he said in his normal good-natured voice.

She laid the spoon down on her empty plate and sat back; and a small
teasing smile appeared on her round pink face. "I know that tone," she
said. "It means that you're humouring me. But there's no need to, you
know. It's I who am right about this, and you are wrong. It says quite
distinctly that faith will move mountains. The difficulty always is
that it takes a quite colossal faith to move a mountain; and it is
practically impossible to assemble so large a faith, so mountains are
practically never moved. But in lesser cases--like the present one--it
is possible to have enough faith for the occasion. So instead of being
deliberately hopeless, dear, do _try_ to have some confidence in the
event. Meanwhile I shall go along to St. Matthew's this evening and
spend a little time praying that you will be given a piece of evidence
tomorrow morning. That will make you feel happier."

When Alec Ramsden walked into his room next morning with the piece of
evidence, Robert's first thought was that nothing could prevent Aunt
Lin taking credit for it. Nor was there any hope of his not mentioning
it, since the first thing she would ask him at luncheon, in bright
confident tones, would be: "Well, dear, did you get the evidence I
prayed for?"

Ramsden was both pleased with himself and amused; so much could be
translated, at any rate, from the Ramsden idiom into common knowledge.

"I had better confess frankly, Mr. Blair, that when you sent me to that
school I had no great hopes. I went because it seemed to be as good a
starting-place as any, and I might find out from the staff some good
way of getting acquainted with Rees. Or rather, letting one of my boys
get acquainted. I had even worked out how could get printed letters
from her without any fuss, once one of my boys got off with her. But
you're a wonder, Mr. Blair. You had the right idea after all."

"You mean you've got what we wanted!"

"I saw her form mistress, and was quite frank about what we wanted and
why. Well, as frank as need be. I said Gladys was suspected of
perjury--a penal servitude affair--but that we thought she'd been
blackmailed into giving her evidence, and to prove it was blackmail we
needed a sample of any printed letters she ever wrote. Well, when you
sent me there I took it for granted that she would not have printed a
single letter since she left the kindergarten. But the form mistress--a
Miss Baggaly--said to give her a minute to think. 'Of course,' she
said, 'she was very good at drawing, and if I have nothing perhaps the
visiting art-mistress might have something. We like to keep good work
when our pupils produce it.' As a comfort for all the duds they have to
put up with, I suppose, poor things. Well, I didn't have to see the
art-mistress, because Miss Baggaly hunted through some things, and
produced this."

He laid a sheet of paper down on the desk in front of Robert. It
appeared to be a free-hand map of Canada, showing the principal
divisions, towns and rivers. It was inaccurate but very neat. Across
the bottom was printed DOMINION OF CANADA. And in the right-hand corner
was the signature: Gladys Rees.

"It seems that every summer, at breaking-up time, they have an
exhibition of work, and they normally keep the exhibits until the next
exhibition the following year. I suppose it would seem too callous just
to toss them out the day after. Or perhaps they keep them to show to
visiting big-wigs and inspectors. Anyhow, there were drawers full of
the stuff. This," he indicated the map, "was a product of a
competition--'Draw a map of any country from memory in twenty
minutes'--and the three prize winners had their answers exhibited. This
was a 'third equal'."

"I can hardly believe it," Robert said, feasting his eyes on Gladys
Rees's handiwork.

"Miss Baggaly was right about her being good with her hands. Funny,
when she stayed so illiterate. You can see where they corrected her
dotted Capital I's."

You could indeed. Robert was gloating over the place.

"She has no mind, the girl, but a good eye," he said, considering
Gladys's idea of Canada. "She remembered the shape of things but not
the names. And the spelling is entirely her own. I suppose the 'third
equal' was for the neat work."

"Neat work for us anyhow," Ramsden said, laying down the scrap of paper
that had come with the watch. "Let us be thankful she didn't choose

"Yes," Robert said. "A miracle." (Aunt Lin's miracle, his mind said.)
"Who is the best man at this sort of thing?"

Ramsden told him.

"I'll take it up to town with me now, tonight, and have the report
before morning, and I'll take it round to Mr. Macdermott at breakfast
time, if that's all right with you."

"Right?" said Robert. "It's perfect."

"I think it might be a good idea to fingerprint them too-and the
little cardboard box. There _are_ judges who don't like handwriting
experts, but the two together would convince even a judge."

"Well," Robert said, handing them over, "at least my clients are not
going to be sentenced to hard labour."

"There's nothing like looking on the bright side," Ramsden commented
dryly; and Robert laughed.

"You think I'm ungrateful for such a dispensation. I'm not. It's a
terrific load off my mind. But the real load is still there. Proving
that Rose Glyn is a thief, liar, and blackmailer--with perjury thrown
in as a sideline--leaves Betty Kane's story still untouched. And it is
Betty Kane's story that we set out to disprove."

"There's still time," Ramsden said; but half-heartedly.

"About all there is time for is a miracle."

"Well? Why not? They happen. Why shouldn't they happen to us? What time
shall I telephone you tomorrow?"

But it was Kevin who telephoned on the morrow; full of congratulations
and jubilation. "You're a marvel, Rob. I'll make mincemeat of them."

Yes, it would be a lovely little exercise in cat-and-mouse play for
Kevin; and the Sharpes would walk out of the court "free." Free to go
back to their haunted house and their haunted existence; two half-mad
witches who had once threatened and beaten a girl.

"You don't sound very gay, Rob. Is it getting you down?"

Robert said what he was thinking; that the Sharpes saved from prison
would still be in a prison of Betty Kane's making.

"Perhaps not, perhaps not," Kevin said. "I'll do my best with the Kane
over that howler about the divided path. Indeed, if Miles Allison
weren't prosecuting I could probably break her with it; but Miles will
probably be quick enough to retrieve the situation. Cheer up, Rob. At
the very least her credit will be seriously shaken."

But shaking Betty Kane's credit was not enough. He knew just how little
effect that would have on the general public. He had had a large
experience lately of the woman-in-the-street, and had been appalled by
the general inability to analyse the simplest statement. Even if the
newspapers were to report that small bit about the view from the
window--and they would probably be much too busy reporting the more
sensational matter of Rose Glyn's perjury--even if they reported it, it
would have no effect on the average reader. "They tried to put her in
the wrong but they were very quickly put in their place." That is all
it would convey to them.

Kevin might successfully shake Betty Kane's credit with the Court, the
reporters, the officials, and any critical minds who happened to be
present; but on the present evidence he could do nothing to alter the
strong feeling of partisanship that Betty Kane's case had aroused
throughout the country. The Sharpes would stay condemned.

And Betty Kane would "get away with it."

That to Robert was a thought that was even worse than the prospect of
the Sharpes' haunted life. Betty Kane would go on being the centre of
an adoring family; secure, loved, hero-worshipped. The once easy-going
Robert grew homicidal at the thought.

He had had to confess to Aunt Lin that a piece of evidence had turned
up at the time specified in her prayers, but had pusillanimously
refrained from telling her that the said evidence was good enough to
destroy the police case. She would call that winning the case; and
"winning," to Robert, meant something very different.

To Nevil too, it seemed. And for the first time since young Bennet came
to occupy the back room that used to be his, Robert thought of him as
an ally; a communal spirit. To Nevil, too, it was unthinkable that
Betty Kane should "get away with it." And Robert was surprised all over
again at the murderous rage that fills the pacifist-minded when their
indignation is roused. Nevil had a special way of saying "Betty Kane":
as if the syllables were some poison he had put in his mouth by mistake
and he was spitting it out. "Poisonous," too, was his favourite epithet
for her. "That poisonous creature." Robert found him very comforting.

But there was little comfort in the situation. The Sharpes had accepted
the news of their probable escape from a prison sentence with the same
dignity that had characterised their acceptance of everything, from
Betty Kane's first accusation to the serving of a summons and an
appearance in the dock. But they, too, realised that the thing would be
escape but not vindication. The police case would break down, and they
would get their verdict. But they would get it because in English law
there was no middle course. In a Scots court the verdict would be Not
Proven. And that, in fact, would be what the result of the Assizes
verdict next week would amount to. Merely that the police had not had
good enough evidence to prove their case. Not that the case was
necessarily a bad one.

It was when the Assizes were only four days away that he confessed to
Aunt Lin that the evidence did suffice to defeat the charge. The
growing worry on that round pink face was too much for him. He had
meant merely to give her that sop and leave the matter there; but
instead he found himself pouring it all out to her as he had poured out
his troubles as a small boy; in the days when Aunt Lin was an
omniscient and omnipotent angel and not just kind, silly Aunt Lin. She
listened to this unexpected torrent of words--so different from the
normal phrases of their meal-time intercourse--in surprised silence,
her jewel-blue eyes attentive and concerned.

"Don't you see, Aunt Lin, it isn't victory; it's defeat," he finished.
"It's a travesty of justice. It isn't a verdict we're fighting for;
it's justice. And we have no hope of getting it. Not a ghost of a

"But why didn't you tell me all this, dear? Did you think I would not
understand, or agree, or something?"

"Well, you didn't feel as I did about----"

"Just because I didn't much like the look of those people at The
Franchise--and I must confess, dear, even now, that they aren't the
kind of people I naturally take to--just because I didn't much like
them doesn't mean that I am indifferent to seeing justice done,

"No, of course not; but you said quite frankly that you found Betty
Kane's story believable, and so----"

"That," said Aunt Lin calmly, "was before the police court."

"The court? But you weren't at the court."

"No, dear, but Colonel Whittaker was, and he didn't like the girl at

"Didn't he, indeed."

"No. He was quite eloquent about it. He said he had once had a--a
what-do-you-call-it--a lance-corporal in his regiment, or battalion or
something, who was exactly like Betty Kane. He said he was an injured
innocent who set the whole battalion by the ears and was more trouble
than a dozen hard-cases. Such a nice expression: hard-cases, isn't it.
He finished up in the greenhouse, Colonel Whittaker said."

"The glasshouse."

"Well, something like that. And as for the Glyn girl from Staples, he
said that one glance at her and you automatically began to reckon the
number of lies there would be per sentence. He didn't like the Glyn
girl either. So you see, dear, you needn't have thought that I would be
unsympathetic about your worry. I am just as interested in abstract
justice as you are, I assure you. And I shall redouble my prayers for
your success. I was going over to the Gleasons' garden party this
afternoon, but I shall go along to St. Matthew's instead and spend a
quiet hour there. I think it is going to rain in any case. It always
does rain at the Gleasons' garden party, poor things."

"Well, Aunt Lin, I don't deny we need your prayers. Nothing short of a
miracle can save us now."

"Well, I shall pray for the miracle."

"A last-minute reprieve with the rope round the hero's neck? That
happens only in detective stories and the last few minutes of

"Not at all. It happens every day, somewhere in the world. If there was
some way of finding out and adding up the times it happens you would no
doubt be surprised. Providence does take a hand, you know, when other
methods fail. You haven't enough faith, my dear, as I pointed out

"I don't believe that an angel of the Lord is going to appear in my
office with an account of what Betty Kane was doing for that month, if
that is what you mean," Robert said.

"The trouble with you, dear, is that you think of an angel of the Lord
as a creature with wings, whereas he is probably a scruffy little man
in a bowler hat. Anyhow, I shall pray very hard this afternoon, and
tonight too, of course; and by tomorrow perhaps help will be sent."


The angel of the Lord was not a scruffy little man, as it turned out;
and his hat was a regrettably continental affair of felt with a tightly
rolled brim turned up all round. He arrived at Blair, Hayward, and
Bennet's about half-past eleven the following morning.

"Mr. Robert," old Mr. Heseltine said, putting his head in at Robert's
door, "there's a Mr. Lange in the office to see you. He----"

Robert, who was busy, and not expecting angels of the Lord, and quite
used to strangers turning up in the office and wanting to see him,
said: "What does he want? I'm busy."

"He didn't say. He just said he would like to see you if you were not
too busy."

"Well, I'm scandalously busy. Find out tactfully what he wants, will
you? If it is nothing important Nevil can deal with it."

"Yes, I'll find out; but his English is very thick, and he doesn't seem
very willing to----"

"English? You mean, he has a lisp?"

"No, I mean his pronunciation of English isn't very good. He----"

"The man's a foreigner, you mean?"

"Yes. He comes from Copenhagen."

"Copenhagen! Why didn't you tell me that before!"

"You didn't give me a chance, Mr. Robert."

"Show him in, Timmy, show him in. Oh, merciful Heaven, do fairy-tales
come true?"

Mr. Lange was rather like one of the Norman pillars of Notre Dame. Just
as round, just as high, just as solid and just as dependable-looking.
Far away at the top of this great round solid erect pillar his face
shone with friendly rectitude.

"Mr. Blair?" he said. "My name is Lange. I apologise for bothering
you"--he failed to manage the TH--"but it was important. Important to
you, I mean. At least, yes I think."

"Sit down, Mr. Lange."

"Thank you, thank you. It is warm, is it not? This is perhaps the day
you have your summer?" He smiled on Robert. "That is an idiom of the
English, that joke about one-day summer. I am greatly interested in the
English idiom. It is because of my interest in English idiom that I
come to see you."

Robert's heart sank to his heels with the plummet swoop of an express
lift. Fairy-tales, indeed. No; fairy-tales stay fairy-tales.

"Yes?" he said encouragingly.

"I keep a hotel in Copenhagen, Mr. Blair. The hotel of the Red Shoes it
is called. Not, of course, because anyone wears red shoes there but
because of a tale of Andersen, which you perhaps may----"

"Yes, yes," Robert said. "It has become one of our tales too."

"Ah, so! Yes. A great man, Andersen. So simple a man and now so
international. It is a thing to marvel at. But I waste your time, Mr.
Blair, I waste your time. What was I saying?"

"About English idiom."

"Ah, yes. To study English is my hubby."

"Hobby," Robert said, involuntarily.

"Hobby. Thank you. For my bread and butter I keep a hotel--and because
my father and his father kept one before me--but for a hub ... a hobby?
yes; thank you--for a hobby I study the idiomatic English. So every day
the newspapers that they leave about are brought to me."


"The English visitors."

"Ah, yes."

"In the evening, when they have retired, the page collects the English
papers and leaves them in my office. I am busy, often, and I do not
have time to look at them, and so they go into the pile and when I have
leisure I pick one up and study it. Do I make myself clear, Mr. Blair?"

"Perfectly, perfectly, Mr. Lange." A faint hope was rising again.

"So it goes on. A few moments of leisure, a little reading in an
English paper, a new idiom--perhaps two--all very without excitement.
How do you say that?"


"So. Placid. And then one day I take this paper from the pile, just as
I might take any of the others, and I forget all about idiom." He took
from his capacious pocket a once-folded copy of the _Ack-Emma_, and
spread it in front of Robert on the desk. It was the issue of Friday,
May the 10th, with the photograph of Betty Kane occupying two-thirds of
the page. "I look at this photograph. Then I look inside and read the
story. Then I say to myself that this is most extraordinary. Most
extraordinary it is. The paper say this is the photograph of Betty
Kann. Kann?"


"Ah. So. Betty Kane. But it is also the photograph of Mrs. Chadwick,
who stay at my hotel with her husband."


Mr. Lange looked pleased. "You are interested? I so hoped you might be.
I did so hope."

"Go on. Tell me."

"A fortnight they stayed with me. And it was most extraordinary, Mr.
Blair, because while that poor girl was being beaten and starved in an
English attic, Mrs. Chadwick was eating like a young wolf at my
hotel--the cream that girl could eat, Mr. Blair, even I, a Dane, was
surprised--and enjoying herself very much."


"Well, I said to myself: It is after all a photograph. And although it
is just the way she looked when she let down her hair to come to the

"Let it down!"

"Yes. She wore her hair brushed up, you see. But we had a ball with
costume---- Costume?"

"Yes. Fancy dress."

"Ah. So. Fancy dress. And for her fancy dress she lets her hair hang
down. Just like that there." He tapped the photograph. "So I say to
myself: It is a photograph, after all. How often has one seen a
photograph that does not in the least resemble the real person. And
what has this girl in the paper to do, possibly, with little Mrs.
Chadwick who is here with her husband during that time! So I am
reasonable to myself. But I do not throw away the paper. No. I keep it.
And now and then I look at it. And each time I look at it I think: But
that _is_ Mrs. Chadwick. So I am still puzzled, and going to sleep I
think about it when I should be thinking about tomorrow's marketing. I
seek explanation from myself. Twins, perhaps? But no; the Betty girl is
an only child. Cousins. Coincidence. Doubles. I think of them all. At
night they satisfy me, and I turn over and go to sleep. But in the
morning I look at the photograph, and all comes to pieces again. I
think: But certainly beyond a doubt that is Mrs. Chadwick. You see my


"So when I am coming to England on business, I put the newspaper with
the Arabic name----"

"Arabic? Oh, yes, I see. I didn't mean to interrupt."

"I put it into my bag, and after dinner one night I take it out and
show it to my friend where I am staying. I am staying with a compatriot
of mine in Bayswater, London. And my friend is instantly very excited
and say: But it is now a police affair, and these women say that never
have they seen the girl before. They have been arrested for what they
are supposed to have done to this girl and they are about to be tried
for it. And he calls to his wife: 'Rita! Rita! Where is the paper of a
week last Tuesday?' It is the kind of household, my friend's, where
there is always a paper of a week last Tuesday. And his wife come with
it and he shows me the account of the trial--no, the--the----"

"Court appearance."

"Yes. The appearance in court of the two women. And I read how the
trial is to be at some place in the country in a little more than a
fortnight. Well, by now, that would be in a very few days. So my friend
says: How sure are you, Einar, that that girl and your Mrs. Chadwick
are one? And I say: Very sure indeed I am. So he say: Here in the paper
is the name of the solicitor for the women. There is no address but
this Milford is a very small place and he will be easy to find. We
shall have coffee early tomorrow--that is breakfast--and you will go
down to this Milford and tell what you think to this Mr. Blair. So here
I am, Mr. Blair. And you are interested in what I say?"

Robert sat back, took out his handkerchief, and mopped his forehead.
"Do you believe in miracles, Mr. Lange?"

"But of course. I am a Christian. Indeed, although I am not yet very
old I have myself seen two."

"Well, you have just taken part in a third."

"So?" Mr. Lange beamed. "That makes me very content."

"You have saved our bacon."


"An English idiom. You have not only saved our bacon. You have
practically saved our lives."

"You think, then, as I think, that they are one person, that girl and
my guest at the Red Shoes?"

"I haven't a doubt of it. Tell me, have you the dates of her stay with

"Oh, yes, indeed. Here they are. She and her husband arrived by air on
Friday the 29th of March, and they left--again by air, I think, though
of that I am not so certain--on the 15th of April, a Monday."

"Thank you. And her 'husband,' what did he look like?"

"Young. Dark. Good-looking. A little--now, what is the word?
Too-bright. Gaudy? No."


"Ah. There is it. Flashy. A little flashy, I think. I observe that he
was not greatly approved of by the other Englishmen who came and went."

"Was he just on holiday?"

"No, oh, no. He was in Copenhagen on business."

"What kind of business?"

"That I do not know, I regret."

"Can't you even make a guess? What would he be most likely to be
interested in in Copenhagen?"

"That depends, Mr. Blair, on whether he was interested in buying or

"What was his address in England?"


"Beautifully explicit. Will you forgive me a moment while I telephone?
Do you smoke?" He opened the cigarette box and pushed it towards Mr.

"Milford 195. You will do me the honour of having lunch with me, Mr.
Lange, won't you? Aunt Lin? I have to go to London directly after
lunch.... Yes, for the night. Will you be an angel and pack a small bag
for me?... Thank you, darling. And would it be all right if I brought
someone back to take pot-luck for lunch today?... Oh, good.... Yes,
I'll ask him." He covered the mouthpiece, and said: "My aunt, who is
actually my cousin, wants to know if you eat pastry?"

"Mr. Blair!" Mr. Lange said, with a wide smile and a wide gesture for
his girth. "And you ask a Dane?"

"He loves it," Robert said into the telephone. "And I say, Aunt Lin.
Were you doing anything important this afternoon?... Because what I
think you ought to do is to go to St. Matthew's and give thanks....
Your angel of the Lord has arrived."

Even Mr. Lange could hear Aunt Lin's delighted: "_Robert!_ No, not

"In the flesh.... No, not a bit scruffy.... Very tall and beautiful and
altogether perfect for the part.... You'll give him a good lunch, won't
you?... Yes, that's who is coming to lunch. An angel of the Lord."

He put down the telephone and looked up at the amused Mr. Lange.

"And now, Mr. Lange, let us go over to the Rose and Crown and have some
bad beer."


When Robert went out to The Franchise, three days later, to drive the
Sharpes over to Norton for the Assizes on the morrow, he found an
almost bridal atmosphere about the place. Two absurd tubs of yellow
wallflowers stood at the top of the steps; and the dark hall gleamed
with flowers like a church decorated for a wedding.

"Nevil!" Marion said, with an explanatory wave of her hand to the
massed glory. "He said the house should be _en fête_."

"I wish that I had thought of it," Robert said.

"After the last few days, it surprises me that you can think at all. If
it were not for you, it is not rejoicing we should be today!"

"If it weren't for a man called Bell, you mean."


"Alexander Bell. He invented the telephone. If it weren't for that
invention we should still be groping in the dark. It will be months
before I can look at a telephone without blenching."

"Did you take turn about?"

"Oh, no. We each had our own. Kevin and his clerk at his chambers, me
at his little place in St. Paul's Churchyard, Alec Ramsden and three of
his men at his office and wherever they could find a telephone that
they could use uninterruptedly."

"That was six of you."

"Seven of us with six telephones. And we needed them!"

"Poor Robert!"

"At first it was fun. We were filled with the exhilaration of the hunt,
of knowing that we were on the right track. Success was practically in
our laps. But by the time we had made sure that none of the Chadwicks
in the London telephone book had any connection with a Chadwick who had
flown to Copenhagen on the 29th of March, and that all the Air line
knew about him was that two seats had been booked from Larborough on
the 27th, we had lost any feeling of fun we had started with. The
Larborough information cheered us, of course. But after that it was
pure slog. We found out what we sold to Denmark and what she bought
from us, and we divided them up between us."

"The merchandise?"

"No, the buyers and sellers. The Danish tourist office was a god-send.
They just poured information at us. Kevin, his clerk, and I took the
exports, and Ramsden and his men took the imports. From then on it was
a tedious business of being put through to managers and asking: 'Have
you a man called Bernard Chadwick working for you?' The number of firms
who _haven't_ got a Bernard Chadwick working for them is unbelievable.
But I know a lot more about our exports to Denmark than I did before."

"I have no doubt of it!"

"I was so sick of the telephone that when it rang at my end I nearly
didn't pick it up. I had almost forgotten that telephones were two-way.
A telephone was just a sort of quiz instrument that I could plug into
offices all over the country. I stared at it for quite a while before I
realised that it was after all a mutual affair and that someone was
trying to call me for a change."

"And it was Ramsden."

"Yes, it was Alec Ramsden. He said: 'We've got him. He buys porcelain
and stuff for Brayne, Havard and Co.'"

"I am glad it was Ramsden who unearthed him. It will comfort him for
his failure to run down the girl."

"Yes, he's feeling better about it now. After that it was a rush to
interview the people we needed and to obtain subpoenas and what not.
But the whole lovely result will be waiting for us in the court at
Norton tomorrow. Kevin can hardly wait. His mouth waters at the

"If it was ever in my power to be sorry for that girl," Mrs. Sharpe
said, coming in with an over-night bag and dumping it on a mahogany
wall-table in a way that would have turned Aunt Lin faint, "it would be
in a witness-box facing a hostile Kevin Macdermott." Robert noticed
that the bag, which had originally been a very elegant and expensive
one--a relic of her prosperous early married life, perhaps--was now
deplorably shabby. He decided that when he married Marion his present
to the bride's mother would be a dressing-case; small, light, elegant
and expensive.

"It will never be in my power," Marion said, "to have even a passing
sensation of sorrow for that girl. I would swat her off the earth's
face as I would swat a moth in a cupboard--except that I am always
sorry about the moth."

"What had the girl intended to do?" Mrs. Sharpe asked. "Had she
intended to go back to her people at all?"

"I don't think so," Robert said. "I think she was still filled with
rage and resentment at ceasing to be the centre of interest at 39
Meadowside Lane. It is as Kevin said long ago: crime begins in egotism;
inordinate vanity. A normal girl, even an emotional adolescent, might
be heart-broken that her adopted brother no longer considered her the
most important thing in his life; but she would work it out in sobs, or
sulks, or being difficult, or deciding that she was going to renounce
the world and go into a convent, or half a dozen other methods that the
adolescent uses in the process of adjustment. But with an egotism like
Betty Kane's there is no adjustment. She expects the world to adjust
itself to her. The criminal always does, by the way. There was never a
criminal who didn't consider himself ill-done-by."

"A charming creature," Mrs. Sharpe said.

"Yes. Even the Bishop of Larborough would find some difficulty in
thinking up a case for her. His usual 'environment' hobby-horse is no
good this time. Betty Kane had everything that he recommends for the
cure of the criminal: love, freedom to develop her talents, education,
security. It's quite a poser for his lordship when you come to consider
it, because he doesn't believe in heredity. He thinks that criminals
are made, and therefore can be unmade. 'Bad blood' is just an old
superstition, in the Bishop's estimation."

"Toby Byrne," Mrs. Sharpe said with a snort. "You should have heard
Charles's stable lads on him."

"I've heard Nevil," Robert said. "I doubt if anyone could improve on
Nevil's version of the subject."

"Is the engagement definitely broken, then?" Marion asked.

"Definitely. Aunt Lin has hopes of the eldest Whittaker girl. She is a
niece of Lady Mountleven, and a grand-daughter of Karr's Krisps."

Marion laughed with him. "Is she nice, the Whittaker girl?" she asked.

"Yes. Fair, pretty, well-brought-up, musical but doesn't sing."

"I should like Nevil to get a nice wife. All he needs is some permanent
interest of his own. A focus for his energies and his emotions."

"At the moment the focus for both is The Franchise."

"I know. He has been a dear to us. Well, I suppose it is time that we
were going. If anyone had told me last week that I should be leaving
The Franchise to go to a triumph at Norton I wouldn't have believed it.
Poor Stanley can sleep in his own bed from now on, instead of guarding
a couple of hags in a lonely house."

"Isn't he sleeping here tonight?" Robert asked.

"No. Why should he?"

"I don't know. I don't like the idea of the house being left entirely

"The policeman will be round as usual on his beat. Anyhow, no one has
even tried to do anything since the night they smashed our windows. It
is only for tonight. Tomorrow we shall be home again."

"I know. But I don't much like it. Couldn't Stanley stay one more
night? Until the case is over."

"If they want to wreck our windows again," Mrs. Sharpe said, "I don't
suppose Stanley's being here will deter them."

"No, I suppose not. I'll remind Hallam, anyhow, that the house is empty
tonight," Robert said, and left it there.

Marion locked the door behind them, and they walked to the gate, where
Robert's car was waiting. At the gate Marion paused to look back at the
house. "It's an ugly old place," she said, "but it has one virtue. It
looks the same all the year round. At midsummer the grass gets a little
burnt and tired-looking, but otherwise it doesn't change. Most houses
have a 'best' time; rhododendrons, or herbaceous borders, or Virginia
creeper, or almond blossom, or something. But The Franchise is always
the same. It has no frills. What are you laughing at, Mother?"

"I was thinking how _bedizened_ the poor thing looks with those tubs of

They stood there for a moment, laughing at the forbidding, dirty-white
house with its incongruous decoration of frivolity; and laughing, shut
the gate on it.

But Robert did not forget; and before having dinner with Kevin at The
Feathers in Norton he called the police station at Milford and reminded
them that the Sharpes' house would be empty for that one night.

"All right, Mr. Blair," the sergeant said, "I'll tell the man on the
beat to open the gate and look round. Yes, we still have a key. That'll
be all right."

Robert did not quite see what that would achieve; but then he did not
see what protection could be afforded in any case. Mrs. Sharpe had
said, if anyone was minded to break windows then the windows would
inevitably be broken. He decided that he was being fussy, and joined
Kevin and his law friends with relief.

The Law talks well, and it was late before Robert went to bed in one of
the dark panelled rooms that made The Feathers famous. The
Feathers--one of the "musts" of American visitors to Britain--was not
only famous but up to date. Pipes had been led through the linen-fold
oak, wires through the beamed ceilings, and a telephone line through
the oak planks of the floor. The Feathers had been providing comfort
for the travelling public since 1480, and saw no reason why it should

Robert fell asleep as soon as his head touched the pillow and the
telephone at his ear had been ringing for some moments before he became
aware of it.

"Well?" he said, still half-asleep. And became instantly wide awake.

It was Stanley. Could he come back to Milford? The Franchise was on


"It's got a good hold, but they think they can save it."

"I'll be over as soon as I can make it."

He made the twenty miles in a door-to-door time that the Robert Blair
of a month ago would have considered reprehensible in the achievement
of another, and quite inconceivable as an achievement of his own. As he
tore past his own home at the lower end of Milford High Street and out
into the country beyond, he saw the glow against the horizon, like the
rising of a full moon. But the moon hung in the sky, a young silver
moon in the pale summer night. And the glow of the burning Franchise
wavered in sickening gusts that tightened Robert's heart with
remembered horror.

At least there was no one in the building. He wondered if anyone had
been there in time to rescue what was valuable from the house. Would
there be anyone there who could distinguish what was valuable from what
was worthless?

The gates were wide open and the courtyard--bright in the flames--was
crowded with the men and machines of the Fire Service. The first thing
he saw, incongruous on the grass, was the bead-work chair from the
drawing-room; and a wave of hysteria rose in him. Someone had saved
that, anyhow.

An almost unrecognisable Stanley grabbed his sleeve and said: "There
you are. I thought you ought to know, somehow." Sweat trickled down his
blackened face, leaving clear rivulets behind them, so that his young
face looked seamed and old. "There isn't enough water. We've got quite
a lot of the stuff out. All the drawing-room stuff that they used every
day. I thought that's what they'd want, if it had to be a choice. And
we flung out some of the upstairs stuff but all the heavy stuff has
gone up."

Mattresses and bed-linen were piled on the grass out of the way of the
firemen's boots. The furniture stood about the grass as it had been set
down, looking surprised and lost.

"Let's take the furniture further away," Stanley said. "It's not safe
where it is. Either some lighted bits will fall on it or one of those
bastards will use it to stand on." The bastards were the Fire Service,
doing their sweating and efficient best.

So Robert found himself prosaically carting furniture through a
fantastic scene; miserably identifying pieces that he had known in
their proper sphere. The chair that Mrs. Sharpe had considered
Inspector Grant too heavy for; the cherrywood table they had given
Kevin luncheon at; the wall-table that Mrs. Sharpe had dumped her bag
down on only a few hours ago. The roar and crackle of the flames, the
shoutings of the firemen, the odd mixture of moonlight, head-lights,
and wavering flame, the mad juxtaposition and irrelevance of the bits
of furniture, reminded him of how it felt to be coming round from an

And then two things happened together. The first floor fell in with a
crash. And as the new spout of flame lit the faces round him he saw two
youths alongside whose countenances were alive with gloating. At the
same moment he became aware that Stanley had seen them too. He saw
Stanley's fist catch the further one under the chin with a crack that
could be heard even over the noise of the flames, and the gloating face
disappeared into the darkness of the trampled grass.

Robert had not hit anyone since he gave up boxing when he left school,
and he had no intention of hitting anyone now. His left arm seemed to
do all that was necessary of its own accord. And the second leering
face went down into obscurity.

"Neat," remarked Stanley, sucking his broken knuckles. And then,
"Look!" he said.

The roof crumpled like, a child's face when it is beginning to cry;
like a melting negative. The little round window, so famous and so
ill-reputed, leaned forward a little and sank slowly inwards. A tongue
of flame leapt up and fell again. Then the whole roof collapsed into
the seething mass below, falling two floors to join the red wreck of
the rest of the interior. The men moved back from the furnace heat. The
fire roared in unrestricted triumph into the summer night.

When at last it died away Robert noticed with a vague surprise that the
dawn had come. A calm, grey dawn, full of promise. Quiet had come too;
the roar and the shoutings had faded to the soft hiss of water on the
smoking skeleton. Only the four walls stood, blurred and grimy, in the
middle of the trampled grass. The four walls and the flight of steps
with their warped iron railing. On either side of the doorway stood
what remained of Nevil's gay little tubs, the soaked and blackened
flowers hanging in unrecognisable shreds over their edges. Between them
the square opening yawned into a black emptiness.

"Well," said Stanley, standing beside him, "that seems to be that."

"How did it begin?" asked Bill, who had arrived too late to see
anything but the wreck that was left.

"No one knows. It was well alight when P.C. Newsam arrived on his
beat," Robert said. "What became of those two chaps, by the way?"

"The two we corrected?" Stanley said. "They went home."

"It's a pity that expression is no evidence."

"Yes," Stanley said. "They won't get anyone for this any more than they
got anyone for the window-breaking. And I still owe someone for a crack
on the head."

"You nearly broke that creature's neck tonight. That ought to be some
kind of compensation to you."

"How are you going to tell them?" Stanley said. This obviously referred
to the Sharpes.

"God knows," Robert said. "Am I to tell them first and let it spoil
their triumph in court for them; or am I to let them have their triumph
and face the awful come-down afterwards?"

"Let them have their triumph," Stanley said. "Nothing that happens
afterwards can take that away from them. Don't mess it up."

"Perhaps you are right, Stan. I wish I knew. I had better book rooms at
the Rose and Crown for them."

"They wouldn't like that," Stan said.

"Perhaps not," Robert said, a shade impatiently. "But they have no
choice. Whatever they decide to do they will want to stay here a night
or two to arrange about things, I expect. And the Rose and Crown is the
best available."

"Well," Stanley said, "I've been thinking. And I'm sure my landlady
would be glad to have them. She's always been on their side, and she
has a spare room, and they could have that sitting-room in front that
she never uses, and it's very quiet down there, that last row of
Council houses facing on the Meadows. I'm sure they'd rather have that
than a hotel where they would be stared at."

"They would indeed, Stan. I should never have thought of it. You think
your landlady would be willing?"

"I don't think; I'm sure. They're her greatest interest in life at the
moment. It would be like royalty coming to stay."

"Well, find out definitely, would you, and telephone me a message to
Norton. To The Feathers at Norton."


It seemed to Robert that at least half Milford had managed to pack
itself into the Court at Norton. Certainly a great many citizens of
Norton were milling round the outer doors, vocal and frustrated;
furious that when a case of national interest was being decided at
"their" Assizes they should be done out of their right to witness it by
an influx of foreigners from Milford. Wily and deceitful foreigners,
too, who had suborned the Norton youth to keep places in the queue for
them; a piece of forethought which had not occurred to Norton adults.

It was very warm, and the packed court stirred uneasily throughout the
preliminaries and through most of Miles Allison's account of the crime.
Allison was the antithesis of Kevin Macdermott; his fair, delicate face
that of a type rather than a person. His light dry voice was
unemotional, his method matter-of-fact. And since the story he was
telling was one which they had all read about and discussed until it
was threadbare, they withheld their attention from him and amused
themselves by identifying friends in court.

Robert sat turning over and over in his pocket the little oblong of
pasteboard that Christina had pressed into his hand on his departure
yesterday, and rehearsing phrases for afterwards. The pasteboard was a
bright Reckitt's blue and bore in gold letters the words: NOT A SPARROW
SHALL FALL, and a picture in the right upper corner of a robin with an
out-size red breast. How, wondered Robert, turning the little text over
and over in his fingers, did you tell someone that they had no home any

The sudden movement of a hundred bodies and the subsequent silence
brought him back to the court-room, and he realised that Betty Kane was
taking the oath preparatory to giving evidence. "Never kissed anything
but the book," Ben Carley had said of her appearance on a similar
occasion. And that is what she looked like today. The blue outfit still
made one think of youth and innocence; speedwell, and camp-fire smoke,
and harebells in the grass. The tilted-back brim of her hat still showed
the childish forehead with its charming hair line. And Robert, who knew
now all about her life in the weeks she was missing, found himself being
surprised all over again at sight of her. Plausibility was one of the
first endowments of the criminal; but up to now such plausibility as he
had had to deal with was of the old-soldier-ten-bob-note kind. Easily
recognised for what it was. The work of amateurs at the job. It occurred
to him that for the first time he was seeing the real thing at work.

Once again she gave her evidence in model fashion; her clear young
voice audible to everyone in court. Once again she had her audience
breathless and motionless. The only difference this time was that the
Bench was not doting. The Bench, indeed, if one was to judge by the
expression on the face of Mr. Justice Saye, was very far from doting.
And Robert wondered how much the judge's critical gaze was due to
natural distaste for the subject, and how much to the conclusion that
Kevin Macdermott would not be sitting there ready to defend the two
women in the dock unless they had a thundering good defence.

The girl's own account of her sufferings did what her counsel's had not
done: roused the audience to an emotional reaction. More than once they
had given vent to a united sigh, a murmur of indignation; never overt
enough to rank as a demonstration, and so bring down the Court's
rebuke, but audible enough to show which way their sympathies lay. So
that it was in a charged atmosphere that Kevin rose to cross-examine.

"Miss Kane," began Kevin in his gentlest drawl, "you say that it was
dark when you arrived at The Franchise. Was it _really_ so dark?"

This question, with its coaxing tone, made her think that he did not
want it to be dark, and she reacted as he intended.

"Yes. Quite dark," she said.

"Too dark to see the outside of the house?"

"Yes, much too dark."

He appeared to give that up and try a new tack.

"Then the night you escaped. Perhaps that was not quite dark?"

"Oh, yes. That was even darker, if possible."

"So that you could not possibly have seen the outside of the house on
some occasion?"


"Never. Well, having settled that point, let us consider what you say
you could see from the window of your prison in the attic. You said in
your statement to the police, when you were describing this unknown
place where you were imprisoned, that the carriage-way from the gate to
the door 'went straight for a little and then divided in two into a
circle up to the door'."


"How did you know it did that?"

"How did I know it? I could see it."

"From where?"

"From the window in the attic. It looked out on the courtyard in front
of the house."

"But from the window in the attic it is possible to see only the
straight part of the carriage-way. The edge of the roof cuts off the
rest. How did you know that the carriage-way divided in two and made a
circle up to the door?"

"I saw it!"


"From that window."

"You want us to understand that you see on a different principle from
ordinary beings? On the principle of the Irishman's gun that shoots
round corners. Or is it all done by mirrors?"

"It is the way I described!"

"Certainly it is the way you described; but what you described was the
view of the courtyard as seen by, let us say, someone looking over the
wall at it; not by someone looking at it from the window in the attic.
Which you assure us was your only view of it."

"I take it," said the Court, "that you have a witness to the extent of
the view from the window."

"Two, my lord."

"One with normal vision will be sufficient," said the Court dryly.

"So you cannot explain how, speaking to the police that day in
Aylesbury, you described a peculiarity that you could not possibly have
known about, if your story was true. Have you ever been abroad, Miss

"Abroad?" she said, surprised by the change of subject. "No."


"No, never."

"You have not, for instance, been to Denmark lately? To Copenhagen, for

"No." There was no change in her expression but Robert thought that
there was the faintest uncertainty in her voice.

"Do you know a man called Bernard Chadwick?"

She was suddenly wary. Robert was reminded of the subtle change in an
animal that has been relaxed and becomes attentive. There is no
alteration in pose; no actual physical change. On the contrary, there
is only an added stillness; an awareness.

"No." The tone was colourless; uninterested.

"He is not a friend of yours."


"You did not, for instance, stay with him at a hotel in Copenhagen?"


"Have you stayed with anyone in Copenhagen?"

"No, I have never been abroad at all."

"So that if I were to suggest that you spent those missing weeks in a
hotel in Copenhagen and not in an attic at The Franchise, I should be

"Quite mistaken."

"Thank you."

Miles Allison, as Kevin had anticipated, rose to retrieve the

"Miss Kane," he said, "you arrived at The Franchise by car."


"And that car, you say in your statement, was driven up to the door of
the house. Now, if it was dark, as you say, there must have been
side-lights on the car, if not head-lights; which would illuminate not
only the carriage-way but most of the courtyard."

"Yes," she broke in, before he could put it to her, "yes, of course I
must have seen the circle then. I knew I had seen it. I knew it." She
glanced at Kevin for a moment, and Robert was reminded of her face when
she saw that she had guessed correctly about the suitcases in the
cupboard, that first day at The Franchise. If she knew what Kevin had
waiting for her, Robert thought, she would have no spare thought for a
passing triumph.

She was succeeded in the witness-box by Carley's "oleograph"; who had
bought both a new frock and a new hat for her appearance at Norton--a
tomato-red frock and a puce hat with a cobalt ribbon and a pink
rose--and looked more luscious and more revolting than ever. Again
Robert was interested to note how her relish of her part discounted,
even with this more emotional audience, the effect of what she said.
They didn't like her, and in spite of their _parti pris_ attitude their
English distrust of malice cooled their minds towards her. When Kevin,
cross-examining, suggested that she had in fact been dismissed and had
not "given in her notice" at all, there was a So-that's-it! expression
on every second face in court. Apart from an attempt to shake her
credit, there was not much that Kevin could do with her, and he let her
go. He was waiting for her poor stooge.

The stooge, when she arrived, looked even less happy than she had
looked in the police court at Milford. The much more impressive array
of robes and wigs clearly shook her. Police uniforms were bad enough,
but in retrospect they seemed positively home-like compared with this
solemn atmosphere, this ritual. If she was out of her depth in Milford,
she was obviously drowning here. Robert saw Kevin's considering eye on
her, analysing and understanding; deciding on his approach. She had
been scared stiff by Miles Allison, in spite of his patient quietness;
evidently regarding anything in a wig and gown as hostile and a
potential dispenser of penalties. So Kevin became her wooer and

It was positively indecent, the caress that Kevin could get into his
voice, Robert thought, listening to his first sentences to her. The
soft unhurried syllables reassured her. She listened for a moment and
then began to relax. Robert saw the small skinny hands that had been
clutched so tightly together on the rail of the box slacken and spread
slowly to a prone position. He was asking about her school. The fright
had faded from her eyes and she was answering quite calmly. Here, she
quite obviously felt, was a friend.

"Now, Gladys, I am going to suggest to you that you did not want to
come here today and give evidence against these two people at The

"No, I didn't. Indeed I didn't!"

"But you came," he said; not accusing, just making the statement.

"Yes," she said; shamefaced.

"Why? Because you thought it was your duty?"

"No, oh no."

"Was it because someone forced you to come?"

Robert saw the judge's instant reaction to this, but so out of the tail
of his eye did Kevin. "Someone who held something over your head?"
finished Kevin smoothly, and his lordship paused. "Someone who said:
'You say what I tell you to say or I'll tell about you'?"

She looked half-hopeful, half-bewildered. "I don't know," she said,
falling back on the escape of the illiterate.

"Because if anyone made you tell lies by threatening what they would do
to you if you didn't, they can be punished for it."

This was clearly a new idea to her.

"This court, all these people you see here, have come here today to
find out the truth about something. And His Lordship up there would
deal very sternly with anyone who had used threats to make you come
here and say something that was not true. What is more, there is a very
heavy punishment for persons who take an oath to speak truth and tell
what is not true; but if it so happened that they had been frightened
into telling lies by someone threatening them, then the person who
would be punished most would be the person who made the threats. Do you
understand that?"

"Yes," she said in a whisper.

"Now I am going to suggest to you what really happened, and you will
tell me whether I am right." He waited for her agreement, but she said
nothing, so he went on. "Someone--a friend of yours, perhaps--took
something from The Franchise--let us say, a watch. She did not want the
watch herself, perhaps, and so she handed it on to you. It may be that
you did not want to take it, but your friend is perhaps a domineering
person and you did not like to refuse her gift. So you took it. Now I
suggest that presently that friend proposed to you that you should back
up a story she was going to tell in court and you, being averse to
telling lies, said no. And that she then said to you: 'If you don't
back me up I shall say that you took that watch from The Franchise one
day when you came to see me'--or some other threat of that sort."

He paused a moment but she merely looked bewildered.

"Now, I suggest that because of those threats you did actually go to a
police court and did actually back up your friend's untrue story, but
that when you got home you were sorry and ashamed. So sorry and ashamed
that the thought of keeping that watch any longer was unbearable to
you. And that you then wrapped up the watch, and sent it back to The
Franchise by post with a note saying: 'I don't want none of it'." He
paused. "I suggest to you, Gladys, that that is what really happened."

But she had had time to take fright. "No," she said. "No, I never had
that watch."

He ignored the admission, and said smoothly: "I am quite wrong about

"Yes. It wasn't me sent back the watch."

He picked up a paper and said, still mildly: "When you were at that
school we were talking about, you were very good at drawing. So good
that you had things put up for show at the school exhibition."


"I have here a map of Canada--a very neat map--which was one of your
exhibits and which indeed won you a prize. You have signed it here in
the right-hand corner, and I have no doubt that you were proud to sign
such a neat piece of work. I expect you will remember it."

It was taken across the court to her, while Kevin added:

"Ladies and Gentlemen of the Jury, it is a map of Canada which Gladys
Rees made in her last year at school. When his lordship has inspected
it he will no doubt pass it on to you." And then, to Gladys: "You made
that map yourself?"


"And wrote your name in the corner."


"And printed DOMINION OF CANADA across the bottom?"


"You printed those letters across the bottom that read: DOMINION OF
CANADA. Good. Now, I have here the scrap of paper on which someone
wrote the words: I DON'T WANT NONE OF IT. This scrap of paper, with its
printed letters, was enclosed with the watch that was sent back to The
Franchise. The watch that had gone missing while Rose Glyn was working
there. And I suggest that the printing of I DON'T WANT NONE is the same
as the printing of DOMINION OF CANADA. That it was written by the same
hand. And that that hand was yours."

"No," she said, taking the scrap of paper as it was handed to her and
putting it hastily down on the ledge as though it might sting her. "I
never. I never sent back no watch."

"You didn't print those letters that read: I DON'T WANT NONE OF IT?"


"But you did print those letters that read DOMINION OF CANADA?"


"Well, later in this case I shall bring evidence that these two
printings are by the same hand. In the meantime the jury can inspect
them at their leisure and arrive at their own conclusions. Thank you."

"My learned friend has suggested to you," said Miles Allison, "that
pressure was brought on you to come here. Is there any truth in that


"You did not come here because you were frightened of what might happen
to you if you didn't?"

She took some time to think over this, evidently disentangling it in
her mind. "No," she ventured at last.

"What you said in the witness-box at the police court, and what you
have said today, is the truth?"


"Not something that someone suggested you might say?"


But the impression that was left with the jury was just that: that she
was an unwilling witness repeating a story that was someone else's

That ended the evidence for the prosecution and Kevin went straight on
with the matter of Gladys Rees; on the housewife principle of "getting
his feet clear" before he began the real work of the day.

A handwriting expert gave evidence that the two samples of printing
which had been put into court were by the same hand. Not only had he no
doubt about it, but he had rarely been given an easier task. Not only
were letters duplicated in the two samples but combinations of letters
were similarly duplicated, combinations such as DO and AN and ON. As it
was evident that the jury had already made up their minds for
themselves on this point--no one who saw the two samples could doubt
that they were by the same hand--Allison's suggestion that experts
could be wrong was automatic and half-hearted. Kevin demolished it by
producing his fingerprint witness, who deponed that the same
fingerprints were to be found on each. And Allison's suggestion that
the fingerprints might not be those of Gladys Rees was a last-stand
effort. He had no wish that the Court might put it to the test.

Now that he had established the fact that Gladys Rees had, when she
made her first declaration, been in possession of a watch stolen from
The Franchise and had returned it immediately after that declaration,
with a conscience-stricken note, Kevin was free to deal with Betty
Kane's story. Rose Glyn and her story had been sufficiently discredited
for the police to be already laying their heads together. He could
safely leave Rose to the police.

When Bernard William Chadwick was called, there was a craning forward
and a murmur of interrogation. This was a name that the newspaper
readers did not recognise. What could he be doing in the case? What was
he here to say?

He was here to say that he was a buyer of porcelain, fine china, and
fancy goods of various kinds for a wholesale firm in London. That he
was married and lived with his wife in a house in Ealing.

"You travel for your firm," Kevin said.


"In March of this year did you pay a visit to Larborough?"


"While you were in Larborough did you meet Betty Kane?"


"How did you meet her?"

"She picked me up."

There was an instant and concerted protest from the body of the court.
Whatever discrediting Rose Glyn and her ally had suffered, Betty Kane
was still sacrosanct. Betty Kane, who looked so much like Bernadette,
was not to be spoken of lightly.

The judge rebuked them for the demonstration, involuntary though it had
been. He also rebuked witness. He was not quite clear, he inferred,
what "picking up" involved and would be grateful if the witness would
confine himself to standard English in his replies.

"Will you tell the Court just how you did meet her," Kevin said.

"I had dropped into the Midland lounge for tea one day, and
she--er--began to talk to me. She was having tea there."


"Quite alone."

"You did not speak to her first?"

"I didn't even notice her."

"How did she call attention to her presence, then?"

"She smiled, and I smiled back and went on with my papers. I was busy.
Then she spoke to me. Asked what the papers were, and so on."

"So the acquaintance progressed."

"Yes. She said she was going to the flicks--to the pictures--and
wouldn't I come too? Well, I was finished for the day and she was a
cute kid so I said yes, if she liked. The result was that she met me
next day and went out to the country in my car with me."

"On your business trips, you mean."

"Yes; she came for the ride, and we would have a meal somewhere in the
country and tea before she went home to her aunt's place."

"Did she talk about her people to you?"

"Yes, she said how unhappy she was at home, where no one took any
notice of her. She had a long string of complaints about her home, but
I didn't take much notice of them. She looked a pretty sleek little
outfit to me."

"A what?" asked the judge.

"A well-cared for young girl, my lord."

"Yes?" Kevin said. "And how long did this idyll in Larborough persist?"

"It turned out that we were leaving Larborough on the same day. She was
going back to her people because her holiday was over--she had already
extended it so that she could run about with me--and I was due to fly
to Copenhagen on business. She then said she had no intention of going
home and asked me to take her with me. I said nothing doing. I didn't
think she was so much of an innocent child as she seemed in the lounge
at the Midland--I knew her better by that time--but I still thought she
was inexperienced. She was only sixteen, after all."

"She told you she was sixteen."

"She had her sixteenth birthday in Larborough," Chadwick said with a
wry twist of the mouth under the small dark moustache. "It cost me a
gold lipstick."

Robert looked across at Mrs. Wynn and saw her cover her face with her
hands. Leslie Wynn, sitting beside her, looked unbelieving and blank.

"You had no idea that actually she was still fifteen."

"No. Not until the other day."

"So when she made the suggestion that she should go with you you
considered her an inexperienced child of sixteen."


"Why did you change your mind about her?"

"She--convinced me that she wasn't."

"Wasn't what?"


"So after that you had no qualms about taking her with you on the trip

"I had qualms in plenty, but by then I had learned--what fun she could
be, and I couldn't have left her behind if I had wanted to."

"So you took her abroad with you."


"As your wife?"

"Yes, as my wife."

"You had no qualms about any anxiety her people might suffer?"

"No. She said she still had a fortnight's holiday to come, and that her
people would take it for granted that she was still with her aunt in
Larborough. She had told her aunt that she was going home, but had told
her people that she was staying on. And as they never wrote to each
other it was unlikely that her not being in Larborough would become
known to her people."

"Do you remember the date on which you left Larborough?"

"Yes; I picked her up at a coach stop in Mainshill on the afternoon of
March the 28th. That was where she would normally have got her bus

Kevin left a pause after this piece of information, so that its full
significance should have a chance. Robert, listening to the momentary
quiet, thought that if the court-room were empty the silence could not
be more absolute.

"So you took her with you to Copenhagen. Where did you stay?"

"At the Red Shoes Hotel."

"For how long?"

"A fortnight."

There was a faint murmur of comment or surprise at that.

"And then?"

"We came back to England together on the 15th of April. She had told me
that she was due home on the 16th. But on the way over she told me that
she had actually been due back on the 11th and would now have been
missing for four days."

"She misled you deliberately?"


"Did she say why she had misled you?"

"Yes. So that it would be impossible for her to go back. She said she
was going to write to her people and say that she had a job and was
quite happy and that they were not to look for her or worry about her."

"She had no compunction about the suffering that would cause parents
who had been devoted to her?"

"No. She said her home bored her so much she could scream."

Against his will, Robert's eyes went to Mrs. Wynn, and came away again
at once. It was crucifixion.

"What was your reaction to the new situation?"

"I was angry to begin with. It put me in a spot."

"Were you worried about the girl?"

"No, not particularly."


"By that time I had learned that she was very well able to take care of

"What exactly do you mean by that?"

"I mean: whoever was going to suffer in any situation she created, it
wouldn't be Betty Kane."

The mention of her name suddenly reminded the audience that the girl
they had just been hearing about was "the" Betty Kane. "Their" Betty
Kane. The one like Bernadette. And there was a small uneasy movement; a
taking of breath.


"After a lot of rag-chewing----"

"Of what?" said his lordship.

"A lot of discussion, my lord."

"Go on," said his lordship, "but do confine yourself to English,
standard or basic."

"After a lot of talk I decided the best thing to do would be to take
her down to my bungalow on the river near Bourne End. We used it for
weekends in the summer and for summer holidays, but only rarely for the
rest of the year."

"When you say 'we,' you mean your wife and you."

"Yes. She agreed to that quite readily, and I drove her down."

"Did you stay there with her that night?"


"And on the following nights?"

"The following night I spent at home."

"In Ealing."


"And afterwards?"

"For a week after that I spent most nights at the bungalow."

"Was your wife not surprised that you did not sleep at home?"

"Not unbearably."

"And how did the situation at Bourne End disintegrate?"

"I went down one night and found that she had gone."

"What did you think had happened to her?"

"Well she had been growing very bored for the last day or two--she
found housekeeping fun for about three days but not more, and there
wasn't much to do down there--so when I found she had gone I took it
that she was tired of me and had found someone or something more

"You learned later where she had gone, and why?"


"You heard the girl Betty Kane give evidence today?"

"I did."

"Evidence that she had been forcibly detained in a house near Milford."


"That is the girl who went with you to Copenhagen, stayed there for a
fortnight with you, and subsequently lived with you in a bungalow near
Bourne End?"

"Yes, that is the girl."

"You have no doubt about it?"


"Thank you."

There was a great sigh from the crowd as Kevin sat down and Bernard
Chadwick waited for Miles Allison. Robert wondered if Betty Kane's face
was capable of showing any emotion other than fear and triumph. Twice
he had seen it pulse with triumph and once--when old Mrs. Sharpe
crossed the drawing-room towards her that first day--he had seen it
show fear. But for all the emotion it showed just now she might have
been listening to a reading of Fat Stock prices. Its effect of inward
calm, he decided, must be the result of physical construction. The
result of wide-set eyes, and placid brow, and inexpensive small mouth
always set in the same childish pout. It was that physical construction
that had hidden, all those years, the real Betty Kane even from her
intimates. A perfect camouflage, it had been. A facade behind which she
could be what she liked. There it was now, the mask, as child-like and
calm as when he had first seen it above her school coat in the
drawing-room at The Franchise; although behind it its owner must be
seething with unnameable emotions.

"Mr. Chadwick," Miles Allison said, "this is a very _belated_ story,
isn't it?"


"Yes. This case has been a matter for press-report and public comment
for the past three weeks, or thereabouts. You must have known that two
women were being wrongfully accused--if your story was true. If, as you
say, Betty Kane was with you during those weeks, and not, as she says,
in the house of these two women, why did you not go straight to the
police and tell them so?"

"Because I didn't know anything about it."

"About what?"

"About the prosecution of these women. Or about the story that Betty
Kane had told."

"How was that?"

"Because I have been abroad again for my firm. I knew nothing about
this case until a couple of days ago."

"I see. You have heard the girl give evidence; and you have heard the
doctor's evidence as to the condition in which she arrived home. Does
anything in your story explain that?"


"It was not you who beat the girl?"


"You say you went down one night and found her gone."


"She had packed up and gone?"

"Yes; so it seemed at the time."

"That is to say, all her belongings and the luggage that contained them
had disappeared with her."


"And yet she arrived home without belongings of any sort, and wearing
only a dress and shoes."

"I didn't know that till much later."

"You want us to understand that when you went down to the bungalow you
found it tidy and deserted, with no sign of any hasty departure."

"Yes. That's how I found it."

When Mary Frances Chadwick was summoned to give evidence there was what
amounted to a sensation in court, even before she appeared. It was
obvious that this was "the wife"; and this was fare that not even the
most optimistic queuer outside the court had anticipated.

Frances Chadwick was a tallish good-looking woman; a natural blonde
with the clothes and figure of a girl who has "modelled" clothes; but
growing a little plump now, and, if one was to judge from the
good-natured face, not much caring.

She said that she was indeed married to the previous witness, and lived
with him in Ealing. They had no children. She still worked in the
clothes trade now and then. Not because she needed to, but for
pocket-money and because she liked it. Yes, she remembered her
husband's going to Larborough and his subsequent trip to Copenhagen. He
arrived back from Copenhagen a day later than he had promised, and
spent that night with her. During the following week she began to
suspect that her husband had developed an interest elsewhere. The
suspicion was confirmed when a friend told her that her husband had a
guest at their bungalow on the river.

"Did you speak to your husband about it?" Kevin asked.

"No. That wouldn't have been any solution. He attracts them like

"What did you do, then? Or plan to do?"

"What I always do with flies."

"What is that?"

"I swat them."

"So you proceeded to the bungalow with the intention of swatting
whatever fly was there."

"That's it."

"And what did you find at the bungalow?"

"I went late in the evening hoping I would catch Barney there too----"

"Barney is your husband?"

"And how. I mean, yes," she added hastily, catching the judge's eye.


"The door was unlocked so I walked straight in and into the
sitting-room. A woman's voice called from the bedroom: 'Is that you,
Barney? I've been so lonely for you.' I went in and found her lying on
the bed in the kind of negligée you used to see in vamp films about ten
years ago. She looked a mess, and I was a bit surprised at Barney. She
was eating chocolates out of an enormous, box that was lying on the bed
alongside her. Terribly nineteen-thirty, the whole set-up."

"Please confine your story to the essentials, Mrs. Chadwick."

"Yes. Sorry. Well, we had the usual exchange----"

"The usual?"

"Yes. The what-are-you-doing-here stuff. The wronged-wife and the
light-of-love, you know. But for some reason or other she got in my
hair. I don't know why. I had never cared very much on other occasions.
I mean, we just had a good row without any real hard feelings on either
side. But there was something about this little tramp that turned my
stomach. So----"

"Please, Mrs. Chadwick!"

"All right. Sorry. But you did say tell it in my own words. Well, there
came a point where I couldn't stand this floo---- I mean, I got to a
stage when she riled me past bearing. I pulled her off the bed and gave
her a smack on the side of the head. She looked so surprised it was
funny. It would seem no one had ever hit her in her life. She said:
'You hit me!' just like that; and I said: 'A lot of people are going to
hit you from now on, my poppet,' and gave her another one. Well, from
then on it was just a fight. I own quite frankly that the odds were all
on my side. I was bigger for one thing and in a flaming temper. I tore
that silly negligée off her, and it was ding-dong till she tripped over
one of her mules that was lying on the floor and went sprawling. I
waited for her to get up, but she didn't, and I thought she had passed
out. I went into the bathroom to get a cold wet cloth and mopped her
face. And then I went into the kitchen to make some coffee. I had
cooled off by then and thought she would be glad of something when she
had cooled off too. I brewed the coffee and left it to stand. But when
I got back to the bedroom I found that the faint had been all an act.
The little--the girl had lit out. She had had time to dress, so I took
it for granted that she had dressed in a hurry and gone."

"And did you go too?"

"I waited for an hour, thinking Barney might come. My husband. All the
girl's things were lying about, so I slung them all into her suitcase
and put it in the cupboard under the stairs to the attic. And I opened
all the windows. She must have put her scent on with a ladle. And then
when Barney didn't come I went away. I must just have missed him,
because he did go down that night. But a couple of days later I told
him what I had done."

"And what was his reaction?"

"He said it was a pity her mother hadn't done the same thing ten years

"He was not worried as to what had become of her?"

"No. I was, a bit, until he told me her home was only over at
Aylesbury. She could quite easily cadge a lift that distance."

"So he took it for granted that she had gone home?"

"Yes. I said, hadn't he better make sure. After all, she was a kid."

"And what did he say in answer to that?"

"He said: 'Frankie, my girl, that "kid" knows more about
self-preservation than a chameleon.'"

"So you dismissed the affair from your mind."


"But it must have come to your mind again when you read accounts of the
Franchise affair?"

"No, it didn't."

"Why was that?"

"For one thing, I never knew the girl's name. Barney called her Liz.
And I just didn't connect a fifteen-year-old schoolgirl who was
kidnapped and beaten somewhere in the Midlands with Barney's bit. I
mean, with the girl who was eating chocolates on my bed."

"If you had realised that the girls were identical, you would have told
the police what you knew about her?"


"You would not have hesitated owing to the fact that it was you who had
administered the beating?"

"No. I would administer another tomorrow if I got the chance."

"I will save my learned friend a question and ask you: Do you intend to
divorce your husband?"

"No. Certainly not."

"This evidence of yours and his is not a neat piece of public

"No. I wouldn't need collusion. But I have no intention of divorcing
Barney. He's fun, and he's a good provider. What more do you want in a

"I wouldn't know," Robert heard Kevin murmur. Then in his normal voice
he asked her to state that the girl she had been talking about was the
girl who had given evidence; the girl who was now sitting in court. And
so thanked her and sat down.

But Miles Allison made no attempt to cross-examine. And Kevin moved to
call his next witness. But the foreman of the jury was before him.

The jury, the foreman said, would like his lordship to know that they
had all the evidence they required.

"What was this witness that you were about to call, Mr. Macdermott?"
the judge asked.

"He is the owner of the hotel in Copenhagen, my lord. To speak to their
having stayed there over the relevant period."

The judge turned inquiringly to the foreman.

The foreman consulted the jury.

"No, my lord; we don't think it is necessary, subject to your
lordship's correction, to hear the witness."

"If you are satisfied that you have heard enough to arrive at a true
verdict--and I cannot myself see that any further evidence would
greatly clarify the subject--then so be it. Would you like to hear
counsel for the defence?"

"No, my lord, thank you. We have reached our verdict already."

"In that case, any summing-up by me would be markedly redundant. Do you
want to retire?"

"No, my lord. We are unanimous."


"We had better wait until the crowd thins out," Robert said. "Then
they'll let us out the back way."

He was wondering why Marion looked so grave; so unrejoicing. Almost as
if she were suffering from shock. Had the strain been as bad as all

As if aware of his puzzlement, she said: "That woman. That poor woman.
I can't think of anything else."

"Who?" Robert said, stupidly.

"The girl's mother. Can you imagine anything more frightful? To have
lost the roof over one's head is bad---- Oh, yes, Robert my dear, you
don't have to tell us----" She held out a late edition of the
_Larborough Times_ with a Stop Press paragraph reading: THE FRANCHISE,
NIGHT. "Yesterday that would have seemed to me an enormous tragedy. But
compared with that woman's calvary it seems an incident. What _can_ be
more shattering than to find that the person you have lived with and
loved all those years not only doesn't exist but has never existed?
That the person you have so much loved not only doesn't love you but
doesn't care two hoots about you and never did? What is there _left_
for someone like that? She can never again take a step on to green
grass without wondering if it is bog."

"Yes," Kevin said, "I couldn't bear to look at her. It was indecent,
what she was suffering."

"She has a charming son," Mrs. Sharpe said. "I hope he will be a
comfort to her."

"But don't you _see_," Marion said. "She _hasn't_ got her son. She has
nothing now. She thought she had Betty. She loved her and was as sure
of her as she loved and was sure of her son. Now the very foundations
of her life have given way. How is she to judge, any longer, if
appearances can be so deceptive? No, she has nothing. Just a
desolation. I am bleeding inside for her."

Kevin slipped an arm into hers and said: "You have had sufficient
trouble of your own lately without saddling yourself with another's.
Come; they'll let us go now, I think. Did it please you to see the
police converging in that polite casual way of theirs on the

"No, I could think of nothing but that woman's crucifixion."

So she too had thought of it as that.

Kevin ignored her. "And the indecent scramble for a telephone that the
Press indulged in the moment his lordship's red tail was through the
door? You will be vindicated at great length in every newspaper in
Britain, I promise you. It will be the most public vindication since
Dreyfus. Wait here for me, while I get out of these. I shan't be a

"I suppose we had best go to a hotel for a night or two?" Mrs. Sharpe
said. "Have we any belongings at all?"

"Yes, quite a few, I'm glad to say," Robert told her; and described
what had been saved. "But there is an alternative to the hotel." And he
told them of Stanley's suggestion.

So it was to the little house on the outer rim of the "new" town that
Marion and her mother came back; and it was in the front room at Miss
Sim's that they sat down to celebrate; a sober little group: Marion,
her mother, Robert, and Stanley. Kevin had had to go back to town.
There was a large bunch of garden flowers on the table which had come
with one of Aunt Lin's best notes. Aunt Lin's warm and gracious little
notes had as little actual meaning as her "Have you had a busy day,
dear?" but they had the same cushioning effect on life. Stanley had
come in with a copy of the _Larborough Evening_ News which carried on
its front page the first report of the trial. The report was printed
under a heading which read: ANANIAS ALSO RAN.

"Will you golf with me tomorrow afternoon?" Robert asked Marion. "You
have been cooped up too long. We can start early, before the
two-rounders have finished their lunch and have the course to

"Yes, I should like that," she said. "I suppose tomorrow life will
begin again and be just the usual mixture of good and bad. But tonight
it is just a place where dreadful things can happen to one."

When he called for her on the morrow, however, all seemed well with
life. "You can't imagine what bliss it is," she said. "Living in this
house, I mean. You just turn a tap and hot water comes out."

"It is also very educational," Mrs. Sharpe said.


"You can hear every word that is said next door."

"Oh, come, Mother! Not every word!"

"Every third word," amended Mrs. Sharpe.

So they drove out to the golf course in high spirits, and Robert
decided that he would ask her to marry him when they were having tea in
the club-house afterwards. Or would there be too many people
interrupting there, with their kind words on the result of the trial?
Perhaps on the way home again?

He had decided that the best plan was to leave Aunt Lin in possession
of the old house--the place was so much hers that it was unthinkable
that she should not live there until she died--and to find a small
place for Marion and himself somewhere else in Milford. It would not be
easy, these days, but if the worst came to the worst they could make a
tiny flat on the top floor of Blair, Hayward, and Bennet's. It would
mean removing the records of two hundred years or so; but the records
were rapidly arriving at museum quality and should be moved in any

Yes, he would ask her on the way home again.

This resolution lasted until he found that the thought of what was to
come was spoiling his game. So on the ninth green he suddenly stopped
waggling his putter at the ball, and said: "I want you to marry me,

"Do you, Robert?" She picked her own putter out of her bag, and dropped
the bag at the edge of the green.

"You will, won't you?"

"No, Robert dear, I won't."

"But Marion! Why? Why not, I mean."

"Oh--as the children say, 'because'."

"Because why?"

"Half a dozen reasons, any one of them good by themselves. For one, if
a man is not married by the time he is forty, then marriage is not one
of the things he wants out of life. Just something that has overtaken
him; like flu and rheumatism and income-tax demands. I don't want to be
just something that has overtaken you."

"But that is----"

"Then, I don't think that I should be in the least an asset to Blair,
Hayward, and Bennet. Even----"

"I'm not asking you to marry Blair, Hayward, and Bennet."

"Even the proof that I didn't beat Betty Kane won't free me of being
'the woman in the Kane case'; an uncomfortable sort of wife for the
senior partner. It wouldn't do you any good, Robert, believe me."

"Marion, for heaven's sake! Stop----"

"Then, you have Aunt Lin and I have my mother. We couldn't just park
them like pieces of chewing-gum. I not only love my mother, I _like_
her. I admire her and enjoy living with her. You, on the other hand,
are used to being spoiled by Aunt Lin---- Oh, yes, you are!--and would
miss far more than you know all the creature comforts and the cosseting
that I wouldn't know how to give you--and wouldn't give you if I knew
how," she added, flashing a smile at him.

"Marion, it is _because_ you don't cosset me that I want to marry you.
Because you have an adult mind and a----"

"An adult mind is very nice to go to dinner with once a week, but after
a lifetime with Aunt Lin you would find it a very poor exchange for
good pastry in an uncritical atmosphere."

"There is one thing you haven't even mentioned," Robert said.

"What is that?"

"Do you care for me at all?"

"Yes. I care for you a great deal. More than I have ever cared for
anyone, I think. That is, partly, why I won't marry you. The other
reason has to do with myself."

"With you?"

"You see, I am _not_ a marrying woman. I don't want to have to put up
with someone else's crochets, someone else's demands, someone else's
colds in the head. Mother and I suit each other perfectly because we
make no demands on each other. If one of us has a cold in the head she
retires to her room without fuss and doses her disgusting self until
she is fit for human society again. But no husband would do that. He
would expect sympathy--even though he brought on the cold himself by
pulling off clothes when he grew warm instead of waiting sensibly to
get cool--sympathy and attention and feeding. No, Robert. There are a
hundred thousand women just panting to look after some man's cold; why
pick on me?"

"Because you are that one woman in a hundred thousand, and I love you."

She looked slightly penitent. "I sound flippant, don't I? But what I
say is good sound sense."

"But, Marion, it is a lonely life----"

"A 'full' life in my experience is usually full only of other people's

"--and you will not have your mother for ever."

"Knowing Mother as I do, I have no doubt that she will outlive me with
perfect ease. You had better hole out: I see old Colonel Whittaker's
four on the horizon."

Automatically he pushed his ball into the hole. "But what will you do?"
he asked.

"If I don't marry you?"

He ground his teeth. She was right: perhaps her mocking habit of mind
would not be a comfort to live with.

"What had you and your mother thought of doing now that you have lost
The Franchise?"

She delayed over her answer, as if it were difficult to say. Fussing
with her bag, and keeping her back to him.

"We are going to Canada," she said.

"Going away!"

She still had her back to him. "Yes."

He was aghast. "But Marion, you can't. And why to Canada?"

"I have a cousin who is a professor at McGill. A son of Mother's only
sister. He wrote some time ago to ask Mother if we would go out to keep
house for him, but by that time we had inherited The Franchise and were
very happy in England. So we said no. But the offer is still open. And
we--we both will be glad to go now."

"I see."

"Don't look so downcast. You don't know what an escape you are having,
my dear."

They finished the round in a business-like silence.

But driving back to Sin Lane after having dropped Marion at Miss Sim's,
Robert smiled wryly to think that to all the new experiences that
knowing the Sharpes had brought to him was now added that of being a
rejected suitor. The final, and perhaps the most surprising, one.

Three days later, having sold to a local dealer what had been saved of
their furniture, and to Stanley the car he so much despised, they left
Milford by train. By the odd toy train that ran from Milford to the
junction at Norton. And Robert came to the junction with them to see
them on to the fast train.

"I always had a passion for travelling light," Marion said, referring
to their scanty luggage, "but I never imagined it would be indulged to
the extent of travelling with an over-night case to Canada."

But Robert could not think of small-talk. He was filled with a misery
and desolation that he had not known since his small soul was filled
with woe at going back to school. The blossom foamed along the line
side, the fields were burnished with buttercups, but the world for
Robert was grey ash and drizzle.

He watched the London train bear them away, and went home wondering how
he could support Milford without the hope of seeing Marion's thin brown
face at least once a day.

But on the whole he supported it very well. He took to golfing of an
afternoon again; and although a ball would always in the future be for
him a "piece of gutta-percha," his form had not seriously deteriorated.
He rejoiced Mr. Heseltine's heart by taking an interest in work. He
suggested to Nevil that between them they might sort and catalogue the
records in the attic and perhaps make a book of them. By the time
Marion's goodbye letter from London came, three weeks later, the soft
folds of life in Milford were already closing round him.

    MY VERY DEAR ROBERT (wrote Marion).

    This is a hasty _au revoir_ note, just to let you know that we are
    both thinking of you. We leave on the morning plane to Montreal the
    day after tomorrow. Now that the moment is almost here we have
    discovered that what we both remember are the good and lovely
    things, and that the rest fades to comparative insignificance. This
    may be only nostalgia in advance. I don't know. I only know that it
    will always be happiness to remember you. And Stanley, and
    Bill--and England.

    Our united love to you, and our gratitude


He laid the letter down on his brass and mahogany desk. Laid it down in
the afternoon patch of sunlight.

Tomorrow at this time Marion would no longer be in England.

It was a desolating thought, but there was nothing to do but be
sensible about it. What, indeed, was there to do about it?

And then three things happened at once.

Mr. Heseltine came in to say that Mrs. Lomax wanted to alter her will
again, and would he go out to the farm immediately.

Aunt Lin rang up and asked him to call for the fish on his way home.

And Miss Tuff brought in his tea.

He looked for a long moment at the two digestive biscuits on the plate.
Then, with a gentle finality, he pushed the tray out of his way and
reached for the telephone.


The summer rain beat on the air-field with a dreary persistence. Every
now and then the wind would lift it and sweep the terminus buildings
with it in one long brush-stroke. The covered way to the Montreal plane
was open on either side and the passengers bent their heads against the
weather as they filed slowly into it. Robert, moving up at the tail of
the queue, could see Mrs. Sharpe's flat black satin hat, and the short
strands of white hair being blown about.

By the time he boarded the plane they were seated, and Mrs. Sharpe was
already burrowing in her bag. As he walked up the aisle between the
seats Marion looked up and saw him. Her face lighted with welcome and

"Robert!" she said. "Have you come to see us off?"

"No," Robert said. "I'm travelling by this plane."

"Travelling!" she said, staring. "_You_ are?"

"It's a public conveyance, you know."

"I know, but--you're going to Canada?"

"I am."

"What for?"

"To see my sister in Saskatchewan," Robert said demurely. "A much
better pretext than a cousin at McGill."

She began to laugh; softly and consumedly.

"Oh, Robert, my dear," she said, "you can't imagine how revolting you
are when you look smug!"


This site is full of FREE ebooks - Project Gutenberg Australia