Project Gutenberg Australia
a treasure-trove of literature
treasure found hidden with no evidence of ownership

Title: Mutiny on the Bounty (1932)
Author: Charles Nordhoff and James Norman Hall
* A Project Gutenberg Australia eBook *
eBook No.: 0800401.txt
Language:  English
Date first posted: April 2008
Date most recently updated: April 2008

Project Gutenberg Australia eBooks are created from printed editions
which are in the public domain in Australia, unless a copyright notice
is included. We do NOT keep any eBooks in compliance with a particular
paper edition.

Copyright laws are changing all over the world. Be sure to check the
copyright laws for your country before downloading or redistributing this

This eBook is made available at no cost and with almost no restrictions
whatsoever. You may copy it, give it away or re-use it under the terms
of the Project Gutenberg Australia License which may be viewed online at

To contact Project Gutenberg Australia go to


Title: Mutiny on the Bounty (1932)
Author: Charles Nordhoff and James Norman Hall

The Bounty Trilogy
Wyeth Edition

Comprising the Three Volumes:
Mutiny on the Bounty (1932)
Men Against the Sea (1933)
Pitcairn's Island (1934)

[This file contains only MUTINY ON THE BOUNTY]

by Charles Nordhoff and James Norman Hall

Illustrations by N C Wyeth

Grosset and Dunlap, publishers: 1945

* * *


* * *

Captain Viggo Rasmussen, _Schooner Tiaré Taporo_, Rarotonga
Captain Andy Thomson, _Schooner Tagua_, Rarotonga
Old friends who sail the seas the _Bounty_ sailed

* * *


Lieutenant William Bligh, _Captain_
John Fryer, _Master_
Fletcher Christian, _Master's Mate_
Charles Churchill, _Master-at-Arms_
William Elphinstone, _Master-at-Arms's Mate_
"Old Bacchus," _Surgeon_
Thomas Ledward, _Acting Surgeon_
David Nelson, _Botanist_
William Peckover, _Gunner_
John Mills, _Gunner's Mate_
William Cole, _Boatswain_
James Morrison, _Boatswain's Mate_
William Purcell, _Carpenter_
Charles Norman, _Carpenter's Mate_
Thomas McIntosh, _Carpenter's Crew_
Joseph Coleman, _Armourer_

Roger Byam         Robert Tinkler
Thomas Hayward     Edward Young
John Hallet        George Stewart

John Norton
Peter Lenkletter

George Simpson, _Quartermaster's Mate_
Lawrence Lebogue, _Sailmaker_
Mr. Samuel, _Clerk_
Robert Lamb, _Butcher_
William Brown, _Gardener_

John Smith
Thomas Hall

_Able Seamen:_
Thomas Burkitt     John Williams
Matthew Quintal    Thomas Ellison
John Sumner        Isaac Martin
John Millward      Richard Skinner
William McCoy      Matthew Thompson
Henry Hillbrandt   William Muspratt
Alexander Smith    Michael Byrne




On the twenty-third of December, 1787, His Majesty's armed transport
_Bounty_ sailed from Portsmouth on as strange, eventful, and tragic
a voyage as ever befell an English ship. Her errand was to proceed to the
island of Tahiti (or Otaheite, as it was then called), in the Great South
Sea, there to collect a cargo of young breadfruit trees for
transportation to the West Indies, where, it was hoped, the trees would
thrive and thus, eventually, provide an abundance of cheap food for the
negro slaves of the English planters.

The events of that voyage it is the purpose of this tale to unfold.
_Mutiny on the Bounty_, which opens the story, is concerned with the
voyage from England, the long Tahiti sojourn while the cargo of young
breadfruit trees was being assembled, the departure of the homeward-bound
ship, the mutiny, and the fate of those of her company who later returned
to Tahiti, where the greater part of them were eventually seized by H. M.
S. _Pandora_ and taken back to England, in irons, for trial.

The authors chose as the narrator of this part of the tale a fictitious
character, Roger Byam, who tells it as an old man, after his retirement
from the Navy. Byam had his actual counterpart in the person of Peter
Heywood, whose name was, for this reason, omitted from the roster of the
_Bounty's_ company. Midshipman Byam's experience follows closely
that of Midshipman Heywood. With the license of hisorical novelists, the
authors based the career of Byam upon that of I Heywood, but in depicting
it they did not, of course, follow the latter n every detail. In the
essentials, relating to the mutiny and its aftermath, they have adhered
to the facts preserved in the records of the I British Admiralty.

_Men Against the Sea_, the second part of the narrative, is the
story of Captain Bligh and the eighteen loyal men who, on the morning of
lie mutiny, were set adrift by the mutineers in the _Bounty's_
launch, an open boat twenty-three feet long, with a beam of six feet,
nine inches. In this small craft Captain Bligh carried his men a voyage
of 3600 miles, from the island of Tofoa (or Tofua, as it is now called),
in the Friendly, or Tongan Group, to Timor, in the Dutch East Indies. The
wind and weather of _Men Against the Sea_ are those of Captain
Bligh's own log, a series of brief daily notes which formed the chief
literary source of this part of the tale. The voyage is described in the
words of one of those who survived it--Thomas Ledward, acting surgeon of
the _Bounty_, whose medical knowledge and whose experience in
reading men's sufferings would qualify him as a sensitive and reliable

_Pitcairn's Island_, which concludes the tale, is perhaps the
strangest and most romantic part of it. After two unsuccessful attempts
to settle on the island of Tupuai (or Tubuai, as the name is now more
commonly spelled), the mutineers returned to Tahiti, where they parted
company. Fletcher Christian, acting lieutenant of the _Bounty_ and
instigator of the mutiny, once more embarked in the ship for an unknown
destination. With him were eight of his own men and eighteen Polynesians
(twelve women and six men). They sailed from Tahiti in September 1789,
and for a period of eighteen years nothing more was heard of them. In
February 1808, the American sealing vessel _Topaz_, calling at
Pitcairn, discovered on this supposedly uninhabited crumb of land a
thriving community of mixed blood: a number of middle-aged Polynesian
women and more than a score of children, under the benevolent rule of a
white-haired English seaman, Alexander Smith, the only survivor of the
fifteen men who had landed there so long before.

Various and discrepant accounts have been preserved concerning the events
which took place on Pitcairn during the eighteen years preceding the
visit of the _Topaz_. The source of them all, direct or indirect,
was Alexander Smith (or John Adams, as he later called himself). He told
the story first to Captain Folger, of the _Topaz_; then, in 1814, to
Captains Staines and Pipon, of the English frigates _Briton_ and
_Tagus_; then to Captain Beechey, of _H. M. S. Blossom_, in
1825; and finally, in 1829, to J. A. Moerenhout, author of _Voyages aux
Îles du Grand Océan_. Later accounts were recorded by Walter Brodie,
who set down, in 1850, a narrative obtained from Arthur, Matthew
Quintal's son; and by Rosalind Young, in her _Story of Pitcairn
Island_, which gives certain details retained in the memory of Eliza,
daughter of John Mills, who reached the advanced age of ninety-three.

Each of these accounts is remarkable for its differences from the others.
The authors, therefore, after careful study of every existing account,
adopted a chronology and selected a sequence of events which seemed to
them to render more plausible the play of cause and effect.

The history of those early years on Pitcairn was tragic, perhaps
inevitably so. Fifteen men and twelve women, of two widely different
races, were set down on a small island, one of the loneliest in the
world. At the end of a decade, although there were many children, only
one man and ten women remained; of the sixteen dead, fifteen had come to
violent ends. These are the facts upon which all the accounts agree. If,
at times, in the Pitcairn narrative, blood flows over-freely, and horror
seems to pile on horror, it is not because the authors would have it so:
it was so, in Pitcairn history.

But the outcome of those early turbulent years was no less extraordinary
than the threads of chance which led to the settlement of the island. All
who were fortunate enough to visit the Pitcairn colony during the first
quarter of the nineteenth century agree that it presented a veritable
picture of the Golden Age.

Those who are interested in the source material concerning the
_Bounty_ mutiny will find an exhaustive bibliography of books,
articles, and unpublished manuscripts in the Appendix to Mr. George
Mackaness's _Life of Vice-Admiral William Bligh_, published by
Messrs. Angus and Robertson, of Sydney, Australia. Among the principal
sources consulted by the authors were the following: "Minutes of the
Proceedings of a Court-Martial on Lieutenant William Bligh and certain
members of his crew, to investigate the cause of the loss of H. M. S.
_Bounty_"; _A Narrative of the Mutiny on Board His Majesty's Ship
"Bounty_," by William Bligh; _A Voyage to the South Sea_, by
William Bligh; _The Mutiny and Piratical Seizure of H. M. S.
"Bounty_," by Sir John Barrow; _Pitcairn island and the Islanders_,
by Walter Brodie; _Mutineers of the "Bounty" and Their Descendants
in Pitcairn and Norfolk Islands_, by Lady Belcher; _Bligh
of the "Bounty_," by Geoffrey Rawson; _Voyage of H. M. S.
"Pandora,"_ by E. Edwards and G. Hamilton; _The Life of Vice-Admiral
William Bligh_, by George Mackaness; _The Story of Pitcairn
Island_, by Rosalind Young; _Captain Bligh's Second Voyage to the
South Seas_, by I. Lee; _Pitcairn Island Register Book; New South
Wales Historical Records_; Cook's _Voyages_; Hawkesworth's
_Voyages_; Beechey's _Voyages_; Ellis's _Polynesian Researches;
Ancient Tahiti_, by Teura Henry; and _A Memoir of Peter Heywood_.
Two excellent studies of the present-day descendants of the
_Bounty_ mutineers, from the point of view of an anthropologist,
have been made by Dr. Harry Shapiro in his _Descendants of the Bounty
Mutineers_ and _The Heritage of the Bounty_.

We wish to express our cordial thanks to Mr. N. C. Wyeth, whose
illustrations lend so much colour and vividness to the story of the
_Bounty_ and her men.

_June, 1940_.

J. N. H.
C. N.


The British are frequently criticized by other nations for their dislike
of change, and indeed we love England for those aspects of nature and
life which change the least. Here in the West Country, where I was born,
men are slow of speech, tenacious of opinion, and averse--beyond their
countrymen elsewhere--to innovation of any sort. The houses of my
neighbours, the tenants' cottages, the very fishing boats which ply on
the Bristol Channel, all conform to the patterns of a simpler age. And an
old man, forty of whose three-and-seventy years have been spent afloat,
may be pardoned a not unnatural tenderness toward the scenes of his
youth, and a satisfaction that these scenes remain so little altered by

No men are more conservative than those who design and build ships save
those who sail them; and since storms are less frequent at sea than some
landsmen suppose, the life of a sailor is principally made up of the
daily performance of certain tasks, in certain manners and at certain
times. Forty years of this life have made a slave of me, and H continue,
almost against my will, to live by the clock. There is no reason why I
should rise at seven each morning, yet seven finds me dressing,
nevertheless; my copy of the _Times_ would reach me even though I
failed to order a horse saddled at ten for my ride down to Watchet to
meet the post. But habit is too much for me, and habit finds a powerful
ally in old Thacker, my housekeeper, whose duties, as I perceive with
inward amusement, are lightened by the regularity she does everything to
encourage. She will listen to no hint of retirement. In spite of her
years, which must number nearly eighty by now, her step is still brisk
and her black eyes snap with a remnant of the old malice. It would give
me pleasure to speak with her of the days when my mother was still
living, but when I try to draw her into talk she wastes no time in
putting me in my place. Servant and master, with the churchyard only a
step ahead! I am lonely now; when Thacker dies, I shall be lonely indeed.

Seven generations of Byams have lived and died in Withycombe; the name
has been known in the region of the Quantock Hills for five hundred years
and more. I am the last of them; it is strange to think that at my death
what remains of our blood will flow in the veins of an Indian woman in
the South Sea.

If it be true that a man's useful life is over on the day when his
thoughts begin to dwell in the past, then I have served little purpose in
living since my retirement from His Majesty's Navy fifteen years ago. The
present has lost substance and reality, and I have discovered, with some
regret, that contemplation of the future brings neither pleasure nor
concern. But forty years at sea, including the turbulent period of the
wars against the Danes, the Dutch, and the French, have left my memory so
well stored that I ask no greater delight than to be free to wander in
the past.

My study, high up in the north wing of Withycombe, with its tall windows
giving on the Bristol Channel and the green distant coast of Wales, is
the point of departure for these travels through the past. The journal I
have kept, since I went to sea as a midshipman in 1787, lies at hand in
the camphor-wood box beside my chair, and I have only to take up a sheaf
of its pages to smell once more the reek of battle smoke, to feel the
stinging sleet of a gale in the North Sea, or to enjoy the calm beauty of
a tropical night under the constellations of the Southern Hemisphere.

In the evening, when the unimportant duties of an old man's day are done,
and I have supped alone in silence, I feel the pleasant anticipation of a
visitor to Town, who on his first evening spends an agreeable half-hour
in deciding which theatre he will attend. Shall I fight the old battles
over again? Camperdown, Copenhagen, Trafalgar--these names thunder in
memory like the booming of great guns. Yet more and more frequently I
turn the pages of my journal still further back, to the frayed and
blotted log of a midshipman--to an episode I have spent a good part of my
life in attempting to forget. Insignificant in the annals of the Navy,
and even more so from an historian's point of view, this incident was
nevertheless the strangest, the most picturesque, and the most tragic of
my career.

It has long been my purpose to follow the example of other retired
officers and employ the too abundant leisure of an old man in setting
down, with the aid of my journal and in the fullest possible detail, a
narrative of some one of the episodes of my life at sea. The decision was
made last night; I shall write of my first ship, the _Bounty_, of
the mutiny on board, of my long residence on the island of Tahiti in the
South Sea, and of how I was conveyed home in irons, to be tried by
court-martial and condemned to death. Two natures clashed on the stage of
that drama of long ago, two men as strong and enigmatical as any I have
known--Fletcher Christian and William Bligh.

When my father died of a pleurisy, early in the spring of 1787, my mother
gave few outward signs of grief, though their life together, in an age
when the domestic virtues were unfashionable, had been a singularly happy
one. Sharing the interest in the natural sciences which had brought my
father the honour of a Fellowship in the Royal Society, my mother was a
countrywoman at heart, caring more for life at Withycombe than for the
artificial distractions of town.

I was to have gone up to Oxford that fall, to Magdalen, my father's
college, and during that first summer of my mother's widowhood I began to
know her, not as a parent, but as a most charming companion, of whose
company I never wearied. The women of her generation were schooled to
reserve their tears for the sufferings of others, and to meet adversity
with a smile. A warm heart and an inquiring mind made her conversation
entertaining or philosophical as the occasion required; and, unlike the
young ladies of the present time, she had been taught that silence can be
agreeable when one has nothing to say.

On the morning when Sir Joseph Banks's letter arrived, we were strolling
about the garden, scarcely exchanging a word. It was late in July, the
sky was blue, and the warm air bore the scent of roses; such a morning as
enables us to tolerate our English climate, which foreigners declare,
perhaps with some justice, the worst in the world. I was thinking how
uncommonly handsome my mother looked in black, with her thick fair hair,
fresh colour, and dark blue eyes. Thacker, her new maid,--a black-eyed
Devon girl,--came tripping down the path. She dropped my mother a curtsey
and held out a letter on a silver tray. My mother took the letter, gave
me a glance of apology, and began to read, seating herself on a rustic

"From Sir Joseph," she said, when she had perused the letter at length
and laid it down. "You have heard of Lieutenant Bligh, who was with
Captain Cook on his last voyage? Sir Joseph writes that he is on leave,
stopping with friends near Taunton, and would enjoy an evening with us.
Your father thought very highly of him."

I was a rawboned lad of seventeen, lazy in body and mind, with overfast
growth, but the words were like a galvanic shock to me. "With Captain
Cook!" I exclaimed. "Ask him by all means!"

My mother smiled. "I thought you would be pleased," she said.

The carriage was dispatched in good time with a note for Mr. Bligh,
bidding him to dine with us that evening if he could. I remember how I
set out, with the son of one of our tenants, to sail my boat at high tide
on Bridgwater Bay, and how little I enjoyed the sail. My thoughts were
all of our visitor, and the hours till dinner-time seemed to stretch
ahead interminably.

I was fonder, perhaps, of reading than most lads of my age, and the book
I loved best of all was one given me by my father on my tenth
birthday--Dr. Hawkesworth's account of the voyages to the South Sea. I
knew the three, heavy, leather-bound volumes almost by heart, and I had
read with equal interest the French narrative of Monsieur de
Bougainville's voyage. These early accounts of discoveries in the South
Sea, and of the manners and customs of the inhabitants of Otaheite and
Owhyhee (as those islands were then called), excited an interest almost
inconceivable to-day. The writings of Jean Jacques Rousseau, which were
to have such lamentable and far-reaching results, preached a doctrine
which had made converts even among people of consequence. It became
fashionable to believe that only among men in a state of nature, freed
from all restraints, could true virtue and happiness be found. And when
Wallis, Byron, Bougainville, and Cook returned from their voyage of
discovery with alluring accounts of the New Cytheraea, whose happy
inhabitants, relieved from the curse of Adam, spent their days in song
and dance, the doctrines of Rousseau received new impetus. Even my
father, so engrossed in his astronomical studies that he had lost touch
with the world, listened eagerly to the tales of his friend Sir Joseph
Banks, and often discussed with my mother, whose interest was equal to
his, the virtues of what he termed "a natural life."

My own interest was less philosophical than adventurous; like other
youngsters, I longed to sail unknown seas, to raise uncharted islands,
and to trade with gentle Indians who regarded white men as gods. The
thought that I was soon to converse with an officer who had accompanied
Captain Cook on his last voyage--a mariner, and not a man of science like
Sir Joseph--kept me woolgathering all afternoon, and I was not
disappointed when the carriage drew up at last and Mr. Bligh stepped out.

Bligh was at that time in the prime of life. He was of middle stature,
strongly made and inclining to stoutness, though he carried himself well.
His weather-beaten face was broad, with a firm mouth and very fine dark
eyes, and his thick powdered hair grew high on his head, above a noble
brow. He wore his three-cornered black hat athwartships; his coat was of
bright blue broadcloth, trimmed with white, with gold anchor buttons and
the long tails of the day. His waistcoat, breeches, and stockings were
white. The old-fashioned uniform was one to set off a well-made man.
Bligh's voice, strong, vibrant, and a little harsh, gave an impression of
uncommon vitality; his bearing showed resolution and courage, and the
glance of his eye gave evidence of an assurance such as few men possess.
These symptoms of a strong and aggressive nature were tempered by the
lofty brow of a man of intellect, and the agreeable and unpretentious
manner he assumed ashore.

The carriage, as I said, drew up before our door, the footman sprang down
from the box, and Mr. Bligh stepped out. I had been waiting to welcome
him; as I made myself known, he gave me a handclasp and a smile.

"Your father's son," he said. "A great loss--he was known, by name at
least, to all who practise navigation."

Presently my mother came down and we went in to dinner. Bligh spoke very
handsomely of my father's work on the determination of longitude, and
after a time the conversation turned to the islands of the South Sea.

"Is it true," my mother asked, "that the Indians of Tahiti are as happy
as Captain Cook believed?"

"Ah, ma'am," said our guest, "happiness is a vast word! It is true that
they live without great labour, and that nearly all of the light tasks
they perform are self-imposed; released from the fear of want and from
all salutary discipline, they regard nothing seriously."

"Roger and I," observed my mother, "have been studying the ideas of J. J.
Rousseau. As you know, he believes that true happiness can only be
enjoyed by man in a state of nature."

Bligh nodded. "I have been told of his ideas," he said, "though
unfortunately I left school too young to learn French. But if a rough
seaman may express an opinion on a subject more suited to a philosopher,
I believe that true happiness can only be enjoyed by a disciplined and
enlightened people. As for the Indians of Tahiti, though they are freed
from the fear of want, their conduct is regulated by a thousand absurd
restrictions, which no civilized man would put up with. These
restrictions constitute a kind of unwritten law, called _taboo_, and
instead of making for a wholesome discipline they lay down fanciful and
unjust rules to control every action of a man's life. A few days among
men in a state of nature might have changed Monsieur Rousseau's ideas."
He paused and turned to me. "You know French, then?" he asked, as if to
include me in the talk.

"Yes, sir," I replied.

"I'll do him justice, Mr. Bligh," my mother put in; "he has a gift for
languages. My son might pass for a native of France or Italy, and is
making progress in German now. His Latin won him a prize last year."

"I wish I had his gift! Lord!" Bligh laughed. "I'd rather face a
hurricane than translate a page of Caesar nowadays! And the task Sir
Joseph has set me is worse still! There is no harm in telling you that I
shall soon set sail for the South Sea." Perceiving our interest, he went

"I have been in the merchant service since I was paid off four years ago,
when peace was signed. Mr. Campbell, the West India merchant, gave me
command of his ship, _Britannia_, and during my voyages, when I
frequently had planters of consequence as passengers on board, I was many
times asked to tell what I knew of the breadfruit, which flourishes in
Tahiti and Owhyhee. Considering that the breadfruit might provide a cheap
and wholesome food for their negro slaves, several of the West India
merchants and planters petitioned the Crown, asking that a vessel be
fitted out suitably to convey the breadfruit from Tahiti to the West
Indian islands. Sir Joseph Banks thought well of the idea and gave it his
support. It is due largely to his interest that the Admiralty is now
fitting out a small vessel for the voyage, and at Sir Joseph's suggestion
I was recalled to the Service and am to be given command. We should sail
before the end of the year."

"Were I a man," said my mother, whose eyes were bright with interest, "I
should beg you to take me along; you will need gardeners, no doubt, and I
could care for the young plants."

Bligh smiled. "I would ask no better, ma'am," he said gallantly, "though
I have been supplied with a botanist--David Nelson, who served in a
similar capacity on Captain Cook's last voyage. My ship, the
_Bounty_, will be a floating garden fitted with every convenience
for the care of the plants, and I have no fear but that we shall be able
to carry out the purpose of the voyage. It is the task our good friend
Sir Joseph has enjoined on me that presents the greatest difficulty. He
has solicited me most earnestly to employ my time in Tahiti in acquiring
a greater knowledge of the Indians and their customs, and a more complete
vocabulary and grammar of their language, than it has hitherto been
possible to gather. He believes that a dictionary of the language, in
particular, might prove of the greatest service to mariners in the South
Sea. But I know as little of dictionaries as of Greek, and shall have no
one on board qualified for such a task."

"How shall you lay your course, sir?" I asked. "About Cape Horn?"

"I shall make the attempt, though the season will be advanced beyond the
time of easterly winds. We shall return from Tahiti by way of the East
Indies and the Cape of Good Hope."

My mother gave me a glance and we rose as she took leave of us. While he
cracked walnuts and sipped my father's Madeira, Bligh questioned me, in
the agreeable manner he knew so well how to assume, as to my knowledge of
languages. At last he seemed satisfied, finished the wine in his glass,
and shook his head at the man who would have filled it. He was moderate
in the use of wine, in an age when nearly all the officers of His
Majesty's Navy drank to excess. Finally he spoke.

"Young man," he said seriously, "how would you like to sail with me?"

I had been thinking, ever since his first mention of the voyage, that I
should like nothing better, but his words took me aback. "Do you mean it,
sir?" I stammered. "Would it be possible?"

"It rests with you and Mrs. Byam to decide. It would be a pleasure to
make a place for you among my young gentlemen."

The warm summer evening was as beautiful as the day that had preceded it,
and when we had joined my mother in the garden, she and Bligh spoke of
the projected voyage. I knew that he was waiting for me to mention his
proposal, and presently, during a pause in the talk, I summoned up my

"Mother," I said, "Lieutenant Bligh has been good enough to suggest that
I accompany him."

If she felt surprise, she gave no sign of it, but turned calmly to our
guest. "You have paid Roger a compliment," she remarked. "Could an
inexperienced lad be of use to you on board?"

"He'll make a seaman, ma'am, never fear! I've taken a fancy to the cut of
his jib, as the old tars say. And I could put his gift for languages to
good use."

"How long shall you be gone?"

"Two years, perhaps."

"He was to have gone up to Oxford, but I suppose that could wait." She
turned to me half banteringly. "Well, sir, what do you say?"

"With your permission, there is nothing I would rather do."

She smiled at me in the twilight and gave my hand a little pat. "Then you
have it," she said. "I would be the last to stand in the way. A voyage to
the South Sea! If I were a lad and Mr. Bligh would have me, I'd run away
from home to join his ship!"

Bligh gave one of his short, harsh laughs and looked at my mother
admiringly. "You'd have made a rare sailor, ma'am," he remarked--"afraid
of nothing, I'll wager."

It was arranged that I should join the _Bounty_ at Spithead, but the
storing, and victualing, and fitting-out took so long that the autumn was
far advanced before she was ready to sail. In October I took leave of my
mother and went up to London to order my uniforms, to call on old Mr.
Erskine, our solicitor, and to pay my respects to Sir Joseph Banks.

My clearest memory of those days is of an evening at Sir Joseph's house.
He was a figure of romance to my eyes--a handsome, florid man of
forty-five, President of the Royal Society, companion of the immortal
Captain Cook, friend of Indian princesses, and explorer of Labrador,
Iceland, and the great South Sea. When we had dined, he led me to his
study, hung with strange weapons and ornaments from distant lands. He
took up from among the papers on his table a sheaf of manuscript.

"My vocabulary of the Tahitian language," he said. "I have had this copy
made. It is short and imperfect, as you will discover, but may prove of
some service to you. Please observe that the system of spelling Captain
Cook and I adopted should be changed. I have given the matter some
thought, and Bligh agrees with me that it will be better and simpler to
set down the words as an Italian would spell them--particularly in the
case of the vowels. You know Italian, eh?"

"Yes, sir."

"Good!" he went on. "You will be some months in Tahiti, while they are
gathering the young breadfruit plants. Bligh will see to it that you are
given leisure to devote yourself to the dictionary I hope to publish on
your return. Dialects of the Tahitian language are spoken over an immense
space of the South Sea, and a dictionary of the commoner words, with some
little information as to the grammar, will be in demand among mariners
before many years have passed. At present we think of the South Sea as
little less remote than the moon, but depend on it, the rich whale
fisheries and new lands for planting and settlement will soon attract
notice, now that we have lost the American Colonies.

"There are many distractions in Tahiti," he went on after a pause; "take
care that you are not misled into wasting your time. And, above all, take
care in the selection of your Indian friends. When a ship drops anchor in
Matavai Bay the Indians come out in throngs, each eager to choose a
friend, or _taio_, from amongst her company. Bide your time, learn
something of politics on shore, and choose as your _taio_ a man of
consideration and authority. Such a man can be of infinite use to you; in
return for a few axes, knives, fishhooks, and trinkets for his women, he
will keep you supplied with fresh provisions, entertain you at his
residence when you step ashore, and do everything in his power to make
himself useful. Should you make the mistake of choosing as your
_taio_ a man of the lower orders, you may find him dull, incurious,
and with an imperfect knowledge of the Indian tongue. In my opinion they
are not only a different class, but a different race, conquered long ago
by those who now rule the land. Persons of consequence in Tahiti are
taller, fairer, and vastly more intelligent than the _manahune_, or

"Then there is no more equality in Tahiti than amongst ourselves?"

Sir Joseph smiled. "Less, I should say. The Indians have a false
appearance of equality from the simplicity of their manners and the fact
that the employments of all classes are the same. The king may be seen
heading a fishing party, or the queen paddling her own canoe, or beating
out bark cloth with her women. But of real equality there is none; no
action, however meritorious, can raise a man above the position to which
he was born. The chiefs alone, believed to be descended from the gods,
are thought to have souls." He paused, fingers drumming on the arm of his
chair. "You've everything you will need?" he asked. "Clothing, writing
materials, money? Midshipmen's fare is not the best in the world, but
when you go on board, one of the master's mates will ask each of you for
three or four pounds to lay in a few small luxuries for the berth. Have
you a sextant?"

"Yes, sir--one of my father's; I showed it to Mr. Bligh."

"I'm glad Bligh's in command; there's not a better seaman afloat. I am
told that he is a bit of a tartar at sea, but better a taut hand than a
slack one, any day! He will instruct you in your duties; perform them
smartly, and remember--discipline's the thing!"

I took my leave of Sir Joseph with his last words still ringing in my
ears--"Discipline's the thing!" I was destined to ponder over them
deeply, and sometimes bitterly, before we met again.


Toward the end of November I joined the _Bounty_ at Spithead. It
makes me smile to-day to think of the box I brought down on the coach
from London, packed with clothing and uniforms on which I had laid out
more than a hundred pounds: blue tail-coats lined with white silk, with
the white patch on the collar known in those days as a "weekly account";
breeches and waistcoats of white nankeen, and a brace of
"scrapers"--smart three-cornered reefer's hats, with gold loops and
cockades. For a few days I made a brave show in my finery, but when the
_Bounty_ sailed it was stowed away for good, and worn no more.

Our ship looked no bigger than a longboat among the tall first-rates and
seventy-fours at anchor near by. She had been built for the merchant
service, at Hull, three years before, and purchased for two thousand
pounds; ninety feet long on deck and with a beam of twenty-four feet, her
burthen was little more than two hundred tons. Her name--_Bethia_--had
been painted out, and at the suggestion of Sir Joseph Banks she was
rechristened _Bounty_. The ship had been many months at Deptford, where
the Admiralty had spent more than four thousand pounds in altering and
refitting her. The great cabin aft was now rigged as a garden, with
innumerable pots standing in racks, and gutters running below to allow
the water to be used over and over again. The result was that Lieutenant
Bligh and the master, Mr. Fryer, were squeezed into two small cabins on
either side of the ladderway, and forced to mess with the surgeon, in a
screened-off space of the lower deck, aft of the main hatch. The ship
was small to begin with; she carried a heavy cargo of stores and
articles for barter with the Indians, and all hands on board were so
cramped that I heard mutterings even before we set sail. I believe, in
fact, that the discomfort of our life, and the bad humour it brought
about, played no small part in the unhappy ending of a voyage which
seemed ill-fated from the start.

The _Bounty_ was copper-sheathed, a new thing in those days, and
with her bluff, heavy hull, short masts, and stout rigging, she looked
more like a whaling vessel than an armed transport of His Majesty's Navy.
She carried a pair of swivel guns mounted on stocks forward, and six
swivels and four tour-pounders aft, on the upper deck.

All was new and strange to me on the morning when I presented myself to
Lieutenant Bligh, the ship was crowded with women,--the sailors'
"wives,"--rum seemed to flow like water everywhere, and sharp-faced Jews,
in their wherries, hovered alongside, eager to lend money at interest
against pay day, or to sell on credit the worthless trinkets on their
trays. The cries of the bumboat men, the shrill scolding of the women,
and the shouts and curses of the sailors made a pandemonium stunning to a
landsman's ears.

Making my way aft, I found Mr. Bligh on the quarter-deck. A tall, swarthy
man was just ahead of me.

"I have been to the Portsmouth observatory, sir," he said to the captain;
"the timekeeper is one minute fifty-two seconds too fast for mean time,
and losing at the rate of one second a day. Mr. Bailey made a note of it
in this letter to you."

"Thank you, Mr. Christian," said Bligh shortly, and at that moment,
turning his head, he caught sight of me. I uncovered, stepping forward to
present myself. "Ah, Mr. Byam," he went on, "this is Mr. Christian, the
master's mate; he will show you your berth and instruct you in some of
your duties...And, by the way, you will dine with me on board the
_Tigress_; Captain Courtney knew your father and asked me to bring
you when he heard that you would be on board." He glanced at his large
silver watch. "Be ready in an hour's time."

I bowed in reply to his nod of dismissal and followed Christian to the
ladderway. The berth was a screened-off space of the lower deck, on the
larboard side, abreast of the main hatch. Its dimensions were scarcely
more than eight feet by ten, yet four of us were to make this kennel our
home. Three or four boxes stood around the sides, and a scuttle of heavy
discoloured glass admitted a dim light. A quadrant hung on a nail driven
into the ship's side, and, though she was not long from Deptford, a reek
of bilge water hung in the air. A handsome, sulky-looking boy of sixteen,
in a uniform like my own, was arranging the gear in his box, and
straightened up to give me a contemptuous stare. His name was Hayward, as
I learned when Christian introduced us briefly, and he scarcely deigned
to take my outstretched hand.

When we regained the upper deck, Christian lost his air of preoccupation,
and smiled. "Mr. Hayward has been two years at sea," he remarked; "he
knows you for a Johnny Newcomer. But the _Bounty_ is a little ship;
such airs would be more fitting aboard a first-rate."

He spoke in a cultivated voice, with a trace of the Manx accent, and I
could barely hear the words above the racket from the forward part of the
ship. It was a calm, bright winter morning, and I studied my companion in
the clear sunlight. He was a man to glance at more than once.

Fletcher Christian was at that time in his twenty-fourth year,--a fine
figure of a seaman in his plain blue, gold-buttoned frock,--handsomely
and strongly built, with thick dark brown hair and a complexion naturally
dark, and burned by the sun to a shade rarely seen among the white race.
His mouth and chin expressed great resolution of character, and his eyes,
black, deep-set, and brilliant, had something of hypnotic power in their
far-away gaze. He looked more like a Spaniard than an Englishman, though
his family had been settled since the fifteenth century on the Isle of
Man. Christian was what women call a romantic-looking man; his moods of
gaiety alternated with fits of black depression, and he possessed a fiery
temper which he controlled by efforts that brought the sweat to his brow.
Though only a master's mate, a step above a midshipman, he was of gentle
birth--better born than Bligh and a gentleman in manner and speech.

"Lieutenant Bligh," he said, in his musing, abstracted way, "desires me
to instruct you in some of your duties. Navigation, nautical astronomy,
and trigonometry he will teach you himself, since we have no schoolmaster
on board, as on a man-of-war. And I can assure you that you will not sup
till you have worked out the ship's position each day. You will be
assigned to one of the watches, to keep order when the men are at the
braces or aloft. You will see that the hammocks are stowed in the
morning, and report the men whose hammocks are badly lashed. Never lounge
against the guns or the ship's side, and never walk the deck with your
hands in your pockets. You will be expected to go aloft with the men to
learn how to bend canvas and how to reef and furl a sail, and when the
ship is at anchor you may be placed in charge of one of the boats. And,
last of all, you are the slave of those tyrants, the master and master's

He gave me a whimsical glance and a smile. We were standing by the
gratings abaft the mainmast, and at that moment a stout elderly man, in a
uniform much like Bligh's, came puffing up the ladderway. His bronzed
face was at once kindly and resolute, and I should have known him for a
seaman anywhere.

"Ah, Mr. Christian, there you are!" he exclaimed as he heaved himself on
deck. "What a madhouse! I'd like to sink the lot of those Jews, and heave
the wenches overboard! Who's this? The new reefer, Mr. Byam, I'll be
bound! Welcome on board, Mr. Byam; your father's name stands high in our
science, eh, Mr. Christian?"

"Mr. Fryer, the master," said Christian in my ear.

"A madhouse," Fryer went on. "Thank God we shall pay off tomorrow night!
Wenches everywhere, above decks and below." He turned to Christian. "Go
forward and gather a boat's crew for Lieutenant Bligh--there are a few
men still sober."

"There's discipline on a man-of-war at sea," he continued; "but give me a
merchant ship in port. The captain's clerk is the only sober man below.
The surgeon...Ah, here he is now!"

Turning to follow Fryer's glance, I saw a head thatched with thick
snow-white hair appearing in the ladderway. Our sawbones had a wooden leg
and a long equine face, red as the wattles of a turkey cock; even the
back of his neck, lined with deep wrinkles like a tortoise's, was of the
same fiery red. His twinkling bright blue eyes caught sight of the man
beside me. Holding to the ladder with one hand, he waved a half-empty
bottle of brandy at us.

"Ahoy there, Mr. Fryer!" he hailed jovially. "Have you seen Nelson, the
botanist? I prescribed a drop of brandy for his rheumatic leg; it's time
he took his medicine."

"He's gone ashore."

The surgeon shook his head with mock regret. "He'll give his good
shillings to some Portsmouth quack, I'll wager. Yet here on board he
might enjoy free and gratis the advice of the most enlightened medical
opinion. Away with all bark and physic!" He flourished his bottle. "Here
is the remedy for nine tenths of human ills. Aye! Drops of brandy! That's
it!" Suddenly, in a mellow, husky voice, sweet and true, he began to

"And Johnny shall have a new bonnet
And Johnny shall go to the fair,
And Johnny shall have a blue ribbon
To tie up his bonny brown hair."

With a final flourish of his bottle, our surgeon went hopping down the
ladderway. Fryer stared after him for a moment before he followed him
below. Left to myself in the midst of the uproar on deck, I looked about
me curiously.

Lieutenant Bligh, an old hand in the Navy, was nowhere to be seen. On the
morrow the men would receive two months' wages in advance, and on the
following day we should set sail on a voyage to the other side of the
world, facing the hardships and dangers of seas still largely unexplored.
The _Bounty_ might well be gone two years or more, and now, on the
eve of departure, her crew was allowed to relax for a day or two of such
amusements as sailors most enjoy.

While I waited for Bligh in the uproar, I diverted myself in studying the
rigging of the _Bounty_. Born and brought up on the west coast of
England, I had loved the sea from childhood and lived amongst men who
spoke of ships and their qualities as men gossip of horses elsewhere. The
_Bounty_ was ship-rigged, and to a true landsman her rigging would
have seemed a veritable maze of ropes. But even in my inexperience I knew
enough to name her sails, the different parts of her standing rigging,
and most of the complex system of halliards, lifts, braces, sheets, and
other ropes for the management of sails and yards. She spread two
headsails--foretopmast-staysail and jib; on fore and main masts she
carried courses, topsails, topgallants, and royals, and the mizzenmast
spread the latter three sails. That American innovation, the crossjack,
had not in those days been introduced. The crossjack yard was still, as
the French say, a _vergue sèche_,--a barren yard,--and the
_Bounty's_ driver, though loose at the foot, was of the gaff-headed
type, then superseding the clumsy lateen our ships had carried on the
mizzen for centuries.

As I mused on the _Bounty's_ sails and ropes, asking myself how this
order or that would be given, and wondering how I should go about obeying
were I told to furl a royal or lend a hand at one of the braces, I felt
something of the spell which even the smallest ship casts over me to this
day. For a ship is the noblest of all man's works--a cunning fabric of
wood, and iron, and hemp, wonderfully propelled by wings of canvas, and
seeming at times to have the very breath of life. I was craning my neck
to stare aloft when I heard Bligh's voice, harsh and abrupt.

"Mr. Byam!"

I gathered my wits with a start and found Lieutenant Bligh, in full
uniform, at my side. He gave a faint quizzing smile and went on: "She's
small, eh? But a taut little ship--a taut little ship!" He made me a sign
to follow him over the _Bounty's_ side.

Our boat's crew, if not strictly sober, were able to row, and put their
hacks into it with a will. We were soon alongside Captain Courtney's tall
seventy-four. The _Tigress_ paid Mr. Bligh the compliment of piping
the side. Side boys in spotless white stood at attention by the red ropes
to the gangway; the boatswain, in full uniform, blew a slow and solemn
salute on his silver whistle as Bligh's foot touched the deck. Marine
sentries stood at attention, and all was silent save for the mournful
piping. We walked aft, saluting the quarter-deck, where Captain Courtney
awaited us.

Courtney and Bligh were old acquaintances; he had been with Bligh on the
_Belle Poule_, in the stubborn and bloody action of Dogger Bank six
years before. Captain Courtney was a member of a great family--a tall,
slender officer, with a quizzing glass and a thin-lipped ironic mouth. He
greeted us pleasantly, spoke of my father, whom he had known more by
reputation than otherwise, and led us to his cabin aft, where a
red-coated sentry stood at the bulkhead, a drawn sword in his hand. It
was the first time I had been in the cabin of a man-of-war, and I gazed
about me curiously. Its floor was the upper gun-deck and its ceiling the
poop; so the apartment seemed very lofty for a ship. The ports were
glazed, and a door aft gave on the stern-walk, with its carvings and
gilded rail, where the captain might take his pleasure undisturbed. But
the cabin itself was furnished with Spartan bareness: a long settee under
the ports, a heavy fixed table, and a few chairs. A lamp swung in gimbals
overhead; there were a telescope in a bracket, a short shelf of books,
and a stand of muskets and cutlasses in a rack about the mizzenmast. The
table was laid for three.

"A glass of sherry with you, Mr. Bligh," said the captain, as a man
handed the glasses on a tray. He smiled at me in his courtly way, and
raised his glass. "To the memory of your father, young man! We seamen owe
him a lasting debt."

As we drank, I heard a great stir and shuffling of feet on deck, and the
distant sound of a drum. Captain Courtney glanced at his watch, finished
his wine, and rose from the settee.

"My apologies. They're flogging a man through the fleet, and I hear the
boats coming. I must read the sentence at the gangway--a deuced bore.
Make yourselves at home; should you wish to be spectators, I can
recommend the poop."

Next moment he passed the rigid marine at the bulkhead and was gone.
Bligh listened for a moment to the distant drumming, set down his glass,
and beckoned me to follow him. From the quarter-deck a short ladder led
up to the poop, a high point of vantage from which all that went on was
visible. Though the air was crisp, the wind was the merest cat's-paw and
the sun shone in a blue and cloudless sky.

The order to turn all hands aft to witness punishment was being piped by
the boatswain and shouted by his mates. The marines, with muskets and
side-arms, were hastening aft to fall in before us on the poop. Captain
Courtney and his lieutenants stood on the weather quarter-deck, and the
junior officers were gathered to leeward of them. The doctor and purser
stood further to leeward, under the break of the poop, behind the
boatswain and his mates. The ship's company was gathered along the lee
bulwarks--some, to see better, standing in the boats or on the booms. A
tall ninety-eight and a third-rate like the _Tigress_ lay at anchor
close by, and I saw that their ports and bulwarks were crowded with
silent men.

The half-minute bell began to sound, and the noise of drumming grew
louder--the doleful tattoo of the rogue's march. Then, around the bows of
the _Tigress_, came a procession I shall never forget.

In the lead, rowed slowly in time to the nervous beat of the drum, came
the longboat of a near-by ship. Her surgeon and master-at-arms stood
beside the drummer; just aft of them a human figure was huddled in a
posture I could not make out at first. Behind the longboat, and rowing in
time to the same doleful music, came a boat from every ship of the fleet,
manned with marines to attend the punishment. I heard an order "Way
enough!" and as the rowing ceased the longboat drifted to a halt by the
gangway. I glanced down over the rail. My breath seemed to catch in my
throat, and without knowing that I spoke, I exclaimed softly, "Oh, my
God!" Mr. Bligh gave me a sidelong glance and one of his slight, grim

The huddled figure in the bows of the boat was that of a powerful man of
thirty or thirty-five. He was stripped to his wide sailor's trousers of
duck, and his bare arms were bronzed and tattooed. Stockings had been
bound around his wrists, which were stoutly lashed to a capstan bar. His
thick yellow hair was in disorder and I could not see his face, for his
head hung down over his chest. His trousers, the thwart on which he lay
huddled, and the frames and planking of the boat on either side of him
were blotched and spattered with black blood. Blood I had seen before; it
was the man's back that made me catch my breath. From neck to waist the
cat-o'-nine-tails had laid the bones bare, and the flesh hung in
blackened, tattered strips.

Captain Courtney sauntered placidly across the deck to glance down at the
hideous spectacle below. The surgeon in the boat bent over the mutilated,
seized-up body, straightened his back, and looked at Courtney by the

"The man is dead, sir," he said solemnly. A murmur faint as a stir of air
in the treetops came from the men crowded on the booms. The Captain of
the _Tigress_ folded his arms and turned his head slightly with
raised eyebrows. He made a gallant figure, with his sword, his rich laced
uniform, his cocked hat and powdered queue. In the tense silence which
followed he turned to the surgeon again.

"Dead," he said lightly, in his cultivated drawl. "Lucky devil!
Master-at-arms!" The warrant officer at the doctor's side sprang to
attention and pulled off his hat. "How many are due?"

"Two dozen, sir."

Courtney strolled back to his place on the weather side and took from his
first lieutenant's hand a copy of the Articles of War. As he swept off
his cocked hat gracefully and held it over his heart, every man on the
ship uncovered in respect to the King's commandments. Then, in his clear,
drawling voice, the captain read the Article which prescribes the
punishment for striking an officer of His Majesty's Navy. One of the
boatswain's mates was untying a red baize bag, from which he drew out the
red-handled cat, eyeing it uncertainly, with frequent glances to
windward. The captain concluded his reading, replaced his hat, and caught
the man's eye. Again I heard the faint sighing murmur forward, and again
deep silence fell before Courtney's glance. "Do your duty," he ordered
calmly; "two dozen, I believe."

"Two dozen it is, sir," said the boatswain's mate in a hollow voice as he
walked slowly to the side. There were clenched jaws and gleaming eyes
among the men forward, but the silence was so profound that I could hear
the faint creak of blocks aloft as the braces swayed in the light air.

I could not turn my eyes away from the boatswain's mate, climbing slowly
down the ship's side. If the man had shouted aloud, he could not have
expressed more clearly the reluctance he felt. He stepped into the boat,
and as he moved among the men on the thwarts they drew back with set
stern faces. At the capstan bar, he hesitated and looked up uncertainly.
Courtney had sauntered to the bulwarks and was gazing down with folded

"Come! Do your duty!" he ordered, with the air of a man whose dinner is
growing cold.

The man with the cat drew its tails through the fingers of his left hand,
raised his arm, and sent them whistling down on the poor battered corpse.
I turned away, giddy and sick. Bligh stood by the rail, a hand on his
hip, watching the scene below as a man might watch a play indifferently
performed. The measured blows continued--each breaking the silence like a
pistol shot. I counted them mechanically for what seemed an age, but the
end came at last--twenty-two, a pause, twenty-three...twenty-four. I
heard a word of command; the marines fell out and trooped down the poop
ladder. Eight bells struck. There were a stir and bustle on the ship, and
I heard the boatswain piping the long-drawn, cheery call to dinner.

When we sat down to dine, Courtney seemed to have dismissed the incident
from his mind. He tossed off a glass of sherry to Bligh's health, and
tasted his soup. "Cold!" he remarked ruefully. "Hardships of a seaman's
life, eh, Bligh?"

His guest took soup with a relish, and sounds better fitted to the
forecastle than aft, for his manners at table were coarse. "Damme!" he
said. "We fared worse aboard the old _Poule!_"

"But not in Tahiti, I'll wager. I hear you are to pay the Indian ladies
of the South Sea another call."

"Aye, and a long one. We shall be some months in getting our load of
breadfruit trees."

"I heard of your voyage in Town. Cheap food for the West Indian slaves,
eh? I wish I were sailing with you."

"By God, I wish you were! I could promise you some sport."

"Are the Indian women as handsome as Cook painted them?"

"Indeed they are, if you've no prejudice against a brown skin. They are
wonderfully clean in person, and have enough sensibility to attract a
fastidious man. Witness Sir Joseph; he declares that there are no such
women in the world!"

Our host sighed romantically. "Say no more! Say no more! I can see you,
like a Bashaw under the palms, in the midst of a harem the Sultan himself
might envy!"

Still sickened by what I had seen, I was doing my best to make a pretense
of eating, silent while the older men talked. Bligh was the first to
mention the flogging.

"What had the man done?" he asked.

Captain Courtney set down his glass of claret and glanced up absently.
"Oh, the fellow who was flogged," he said. "He was one of Captain
Allison's foretopmen, on the _Unconquerable_. And a smart hand, they
say. He was posted for desertion, and then Allison, who remembered his
face, saw him stepping out of a public house in Portsmouth. The man tried
to spring away and Allison seized him by the arm. Damme! Good topmen
don't grow on every hedge! Well, this insolent fellow blacked Allison's
eye, just as a file of marines passed. They made him prisoner, and you
saw the rest. Odd! We were only the fifth ship; eight dozen did for him.
But Allison has a boatswain's mate who's an artist, they
say--left-handed, so he lays them on crisscross, and strong as an ox."

Bligh listened with interest to Courtney's words, and nodded approvingly.
"Struck his captain, eh?" he remarked. "By God! He deserved all he got,
and more! No laws are more just than those governing the conduct of men
at sea."

"Is there any need of such cruelty?" I asked, unable to keep silent. "Why
did they not hang the poor fellow and have done with it?"

"Poor fellow?" Captain Courtney turned to me with eyebrows raised. "You
have much to learn, my lad. A year or two at sea will harden him, eh,

"I'll see to that," said the Captain of the _Bounty_. "No, Mr. Byam,
you must waste no sympathy on rascals of that stripe."

"And remember," put in Courtney, with a manner of friendly admonishment,
"remember, as Mr. Bligh says, that no laws are more just than those
governing the conduct of men at sea. Not only just, but necessary;
discipline must be preserved, on a merchantman as well as on a
man-of-war, and mutiny and piracy suppressed."

"Yes," said Bligh, "our sea law is stern, but it has the authority of
centuries. And it has grown more humane with time," he continued, not
without a trace of regret. "Keel-hauling has been abolished, save among
the French, and a captain no longer has the right to condemn and put to
death one of his crew."

Still agitated by the shock of what I had seen, I ate little and took
more wine than was my custom, sitting in silence for the most part, while
the two officers gossiped, sailor-like, as to the whereabouts of former
friends, and spoke of Admiral Parker, and the fight at Dogger Bank. It
was mid-afternoon when Bligh and I were pulled back to the _Bounty_.
The tide was low, and I saw a boat aground on a flat some distance off,
while a party of men dug a shallow grave in the mud. They were burying
the body of the poor fellow who had been flogged through the
fleet--burying him below tide mark, in silence, and without religious


At daybreak on the twenty-eighth of November we got sail on the
_Bounty_ and worked down to St. Helen's, where we dropped anchor.
For nearly a month we were detained there and at Spithead by contrary
winds; it was not until the twenty-third of December that we set sail
down the Channel with a fair wind.

A month sounds an age to be crowded with more than forty other men on
board a small vessel at anchor most of the time, but I was making the
acquaintance of my shipmates, and so keen on learning my new duties that
the days were all too short. The _Bounty_ carried six midshipmen,
and, since we had no schoolmaster, as is customary on a man-of-war,
Lieutenant Bligh and the master divided the duty of instructing us in
trigonometry, nautical astronomy, and navigation. I shared with Stewart
and Young the advantage of learning navigation under Bligh, and in
justice to an officer whose character in other respects was by no means
perfect, I must say that there was no finer seaman and navigator afloat
at the time. Both of my fellow midshipmen were men grown: George Stewart
of a good family in the Orkneys, a young man of twenty-three or four, and
a seaman who had made several voyages before this: and Edward Young, a
stout, salty-looking fellow, with a handsome face marred by the loss of
nearly all his front teeth. Both of them were already very fair
navigators, and I was hard put to it not to earn the reputation of a

The boatswain, Mr. Cole, and his mate, James Morrison, instructed me in
seamanship. Cole was an old-style Navy salt, bronzed, taciturn, and
pigtailed, with a profound knowledge of his work and little other
knowledge of any kind. Morrison was very different--a man of good birth,
he had been a midshipman, and had shipped aboard the _Bounty_
because of his interest in the voyage. He was a first-rate seaman and
navigator; a dark, slender, intelligent man of thirty or thereabouts,
cool in the face of danger, not given to oaths, and far above his station
on board. Morrison did not thrash the men to their work, delivering blows
impartially in the manner of a boatswain's mate; he carried a colt, a
piece of knotted rope, to be sure, but it was only used on obvious
malingerers, or when Bligh shouted to him: "Start that man!"

There were much irritation and grumbling at the continued bad weather,
but at last, on the evening of the twenty-second of December, the sky
cleared and the wind shifted to the eastward. It was still dark next
morning when I heard the boatswain's pipe and Morrison's call: "All
hands! Turn out and save a clue! Out or down here! Rise and shine! Out or
down there! Lash and carry!"

The stars were bright when I came on deck, and the grey glimmer of dawn
was in the East. For three weeks we had had strong southwesterly winds,
with rain and fog; now the air was sharp with frost, and a strong east
wind blew in gusts off the coast of France. Lieutenant Bligh was on the
quarter-deck with Mr. Fryer, the master; Christian and Elphinstone, the
master's mates, were forward among the men. There was a great bustle on
deck and the ship rang with the piping of the bos'n's whistle. I heard
the shouting of the men at the windlass, and Christian's voice above the
din: "Hove short, sir!"

"Loose the topsails!" came from Fryer, and Christian passed the order on.
My station was the mizzen-top, and in a twinkling we had the gaskets off
and the small sail sheeted home. The knots in the gaskets were stiff with
frost, and the men setting the fore-topsail were slow at their work.
Bligh glanced aloft impatiently.

"What are you doing there?" he shouted angrily. "Are you all asleep,
foretop? The main-topmen are off the yard! Look alive, you crawling

The topsails filled and the yards were braced up sharp; the _Bounty_
broke out her own anchor as she gathered way on the larboard tack. She
was smartly manned in spite of Bligh's complaints, but he was on edge,
for a thousand critical eyes watched our departure from the ships at
anchor closer inshore. With a "Yo! Heave ho!" the anchor came up and was

Then it was: "Loose the forecourse!" and presently, as she began to heel
to the gusts: "Get the mainsail on her!" There was a thunder of canvas
and a wild rattling of blocks. When the brace was hove short, Bligh
himself roared: "Board. the main tack!" Little by little, with a mighty
chorus at the windlass: "Heave ho! Heave and pawl! Yo, heave, hearty,
ho!" the weather clew of the sail came down to the waterway. Heeling well
to starboard, the bluff-bowed little ship tore through the sheltered
water, on her way to the open sea.

The sun rose in a cloudless sky--a glorious winter's morning, clear,
cold, and sparkling. I stood by the bulwarks as we flew down the Solent,
my breath trailing off like thin smoke. Presently we sped through the
Needles and the _Bounty_ headed away to sea, going like a race
horse, with topgallants set.

That night the wind increased to a strong gale, with a heavy sea, but on
the following day the weather moderated, permitting us to keep our
Christmas cheerfully. Extra grog was served out, and the mess cooks were
to be heard whistling as they seeded the raisins for duff, not, as a
landsman might suppose, from the prospect of good cheer, but in order to
prove to their messmates that the raisins were not going into t heir

I was still making the acquaintance of my shipmates at this time. The men
of the _Bounty_ had been attracted by the prospect of a voyage to
the South Sea, or selected for their stations by the master or Bligh
himself. Our fourteen able-bodied seamen were true salts, not the scum of
the taverns and jails impressed to man so many of His Majesty's ships;
the officers were nearly all men of experience and tried character, and
even our botanist, Mr. Nelson, had been recommended by Sir Joseph Banks
because of his former voyage to Tahiti under Captain Cook. Mr. Bligh
might have had a hundred midshipmen had he obliged all those who applied
for a place in the _Bounty's_ berth; as it was, there were six of
us, though the ship's establishment provided for only two. Stewart and
Young were seamen and pleasant fellows enough; Hallet was a
sickly-looking boy of fifteen with a shifty eye and a weak, peevish
mouth; Tinkler, Mr. Fryer's brother-in-law, was a year younger, though he
had been to sea before--a monkey of a lad, whose continual scrapes kept
him at the masthead half the time. Hayward, the handsome, sulky boy I had
met when I first set foot in the berth, was only, sixteen, but big and
strong for his age. He was something of a bully and aspired to be cock of
the berth, since he had been two years at sea aboard a seventy-four.

I shared with Hayward, Stewart, and Young a berth on the lower deck. In
this small space the four of us swung our hammocks at night and had our
mess, using a chest for a table and other chests for seats. On
consideration of a liberal share of our grog, received each Saturday
night, Alexander Smith, able-bodied, acted as our hammock man, and for a
lesser sum of the same ship's currency, Thomas Ellison, the youngest of
the seamen, filled the office of mess boy. Mr. Christian was caterer to
the midshipmen's mess; like the others, I had paid him five pounds on
joining the ship, and he had laid out the money in a supply of potatoes,
onions, Dutch cheeses (for making that midshipman's dish called "crab"),
tea, coffee, and sugar, and other small luxuries. These private stores
enabled us to live well for several weeks, though a more villainous cook
than young Tom Ellison would be impossible to find. As for drink, the
ship's allowance was so liberal that Christian made no special provision
for us. For a month or more every man aboard received a gallon of beer
each day, and when that was gone, a pint of fiery white _mistela_
wine from Spain--the wine our seamen love and call affectionately "Miss
Taylor." And when the last of the wine was gone we fell back on an ample
supply of the sailor's sheet anchor--grog. We had a wondrous fifer on
board--a half-blind Irishman named Michael Byrne. He had managed to
conceal his blindness till the _Bounty_ was at sea, when it became
apparent, much to Mr. Bligh's annoyance. But when he struck up "Nancy
Dawson" on the first day he piped the men to grog, his blindness was
forgotten. He could put more trills and runs into that lively old tune
than any man of us had heard before a cheeriness in keeping with this
happiest hour of the seaman's day.

We lost a good part of our beer in a strong easterly gale that overtook
the _Bounty_ the day after Christmas. Several casks went adrift from
their lashings and were washed overboard when a great sea broke over the
ship; the same wave stove in all three of our boats and nearly carried
them away. I was off watch at the time, and below, diverting myself in
the surgeon's cabin on the orlop, aft. It was a close, stinking little
den, below the water line--reeking of the bilges and lit by a candle that
burned blue for lack of air. But that mattered nothing to Old Bacchus.
Our sawbones's name was Thomas Huggan and it was so inscribed on the
ship's articles, but he was known as Old Bacchus to all our company. His
normal state was what sailors call "in the wind" or "shaking a cloth,"
and the signal that he had passed his normal state earned him the name by
which all hands on the _Bounty_ knew him. When he had indiscreetly
added a glass of brandy or a tot of grog to the carefully measured supply
of spirits demanded at close intervals by a stomach which must have been
copper-sheathed, it was his custom to rise, balancing himself on his
starboard leg, place a hand between the third and fourth buttons of his
waistcoat, and recite with comic gravity a verse which begins:--

Bacchus must now his power resign.

With his wooden leg, his fiery face, snow-white hair, and rakish blue
eyes, Old Bacchus seemed the veritable archetype of naval surgeons. He
had been afloat so long that he could scarcely recollect the days when he
had lived ashore, and viewed with apprehension the prospect of
retirement. He preferred salt beef to the finest steak or chop to be
obtained ashore, and confided to me one day that it was almost impossible
for him to sleep in a bed. A cannon ball had carried away his larboard
leg when his ship was exchanging broadsides, yardarm to yardarm, with the
_Ranger_, and he had been made prisoner by John Paul Jones.

The cronies of Old Bacchus were Mr. Nelson, the botanist, and Peckover,
the _Bounty's_ gunner. The duties of a gunner, onerous enough on
board a man-of-war, were of the very lightest on our ship, and
Peckover--a jovial fellow who loved a song and a glass dearly--had some
leisure for conviviality. Mr. Nelson was a quiet, elderly man with
iron-grey hair. Though devoted to the study of plants, he seemed to
derive great pleasure from the surgeon's company, and could spin a. yarn
with the best when in the mood. The great event in his life had been his
voyage to the South Sea with Captain Cook, whose memory he revered.

Mr. Nelson's cabin was forward of the surgeon's, separated from it by the
cabin of Samuel, the captain's clerk, and he was to be found more often
in the surgeon's cabin than in his own. All of the cabins were provided
with standing bed places, built in by the carpenters at Deptford, but
Bacchus preferred to sling a hammock at night, and used his bed as a
settee and the capacious locker under it as a private spirit room. The
cabin was scarcely more than six feet by seven; the bed occupied nearly
half of this space, and opposite, under the hammock battens, were three
small casks of wine, as yet unbroached. On one of them a candle guttered
and burned blue.

Another cask served as a seat for me, and Bacchus and Nelson sat side by
side on the bed. Each man held a pewter pint of flip--beer strongly laced
with rum. The ship was on the larboard tack and making heavy weather of
it, so that at times my cask threatened to slide from under me, but the
two men on the settee seemed to give the weather no thought.

"A first-rate man, Purcell!" remarked the surgeon, glancing down
admiringly at his new wooden leg; "a better ship's carpenter never swung
an adze! My other leg was most damnably uncomfortable, but this one's
like my own flesh and bone! Mr. Purcell's health!" He took a long pull at
the flip and smacked his lips. "You're a lucky man, Nelson! Should
anything happen to your underpinning, you've me to saw off the old leg
and Purcell to make you a better one!"

Nelson smiled. "Very kind, I'm sure," he said; "but I hope I shall not
have to trouble you."

"I hope not, my dear fellow--I hope not! But never dread an amputation.
With a pint of rum, a well-stropped razor, and a crosscut saw, I'd have
your leg off before you knew it. Paul Jones's American surgeon did the
trick for me.

"Let's see--it must have been in seventy-eight. I was on the old
_Drake_, Captain Burden, and we were on the lookout for Paul Jones's
_Ranger_ at the time. Then we learned that she was hove-to off the.
mouth of Belfast Lough. An extraordinary affair, begad! We actually had
sight-seers on board--one of them was an officer of the Inniskilling
Fusileers in full uniform. We moved out slowly and came up astern of the
American ship. Up went our colours and we hailed: "What ship is that?"
'American Continental ship _Ranger!_' roared the Yankee master, as
his own colours went up. 'Come on--we're waiting for you!' Next moment
both ships let go their broadsides...Good God!"

The _Bounty_ staggered with the shock of a great sea which broke
into her at that moment. "Up with you, Byam!" ordered the surgeon; and,
as I sprang out of his cabin toward the ladderway, I heard, above the
creaking and straining of the ship and the roar of angry water, a faint
shouting for all hands on deck. Then I found myself in an uproar and
confusion very strange after the peace of the surgeon's snuggery.

Bligh stood by the mizzenmast, beside Fryer, who was bawling orders to
his mates. They were shortening sail to get the ship hove-to. The men at
the clew lines struggled with might and main to hoist the stubborn
thundering canvas to the yards.

My own task, with two other midshipmen, was to furl the mizzen topsail--a
small sail, but far from easy to subdue at such a time. The men below
brailed up the driver and made fast the vangs of its gaff. Presently the
_Bounty_ was hove-to, all snug on the larboard tack, under reefed
fore and main topsails.

The great wave which had boarded us left destruction in its wake. All
three of our boats were stove in; the casks of beer which had been lashed
on deck were nowhere to be seen; and the stern of the ship so damaged
that the cabin was filled with water, which leaked into the bread room
below, spoiling a large part of our stock of bread.

In latitude 39°N. the gale abated, the sun shone out, and we made all
sail for Teneriffe with a fine northerly wind. On the fourth of January
we spoke a French merchant vessel, bound for Mauritius, which let go her
topgallant sheets in salute. The next morning we saw the island of
Teneriffe to the southwest of us, about twelve leagues distant, but it
fell calm near the land and we were a day and a night working up to the
road of Santa Cruz, where we anchored in twenty-five fathoms, close to a
Spanish packet and an American brig.

For five days we lay at anchor in the road, and it was here that the
seeds of discontent, destined to be the ruin of the voyage, were sown
among the _Bounty's_ people. As there was a great surf on the beach,
Lieutenant Bligh bargained with the shore boats to bring off our water
and supplies, and kept his own men busy from morning to night repairing
the mischief the storm had done our ship. This occasioned much grumbling
in the forecastle, as some of the sailors had hoped to be employed in the
ship's boats, which would have enabled them at least to set foot on the
island and to obtain some of the wine for which it is famous, said to be
little inferior to the best London Madeira.

During our sojourn the allowance of salt beef was stopped, and fresh
beef, obtained on shore, issued instead. The _Bounty's_ salt beef
was the worst I have ever met with at sea, but the beef substituted for.
it in Teneriffe was worse still. The men declared that it had been cut
from the carcasses of dead horses or mules, and complained to the master
that it was unfit for food. Fryer informed Bligh of the complaint; the
captain flew into a passion and swore that the men should eat the fresh
beef or nothing at all. The result was that most of it was thrown
overboard--a sight which did nothing to soothe Bligh's temper.

I was fortunate enough to have a run ashore, for Bligh took me with him
one day to wait upon the governor, the Marquis de Branchefortàé. With the
governor's permission Mr. Nelson ranged the hills every day in search of
plants and natural curiosities, but his friend the surgeon only appeared
on deck once during the five days we lay at anchor. Old Bacchus had
ordered a monstrous supply of brandy for himself--enough to do the very
god of wine, his namesake, for a year. Not trusting the shore boats with
such precious freight, he had obtained the captain's permission to send
the small cutter to the pier, and when a man went below to inform him
that his brandy was alongside, the surgeon came stumping to the ladderway
and clambered on deck. The cutter was down to the gunwales with her load;
as there was a high swell running, Old Bacchus stood by the bulwarks
anxiously. "Easy with it!" he ordered with tender solicitude. "Easy now!
A glass of grog all around if you break nothing!" When the last of the
small casks was aboard and had been sent below, the surgeon heaved a
sigh. I was standing near by and saw him glance at the land for the first
time. He caught my eye. "One island's as like another as two peas in a
pod," he remarked indifferently, pulling out a handkerchief to mop his
fiery face.

When we sailed from Teneriffe, Bligh divided the people into three
watches, making Christian acting lieutenant, and giving him charge of the
third watch. Bligh had known him for some years in the West India trade,
and believed himself to be Christian's friend and benefactor. His
friendship took the form of inviting Christian to sup or dine one day,
and cursing him in the coarsest manner before the men the next; but in
this case he did him a real service, since it was ten to one that, if all
went well on the voyage, the appointment would be confirmed by the
Admiralty, and Christian would find himself the holder of His Majesty's
commission. He now rated as a gentleman, with the midshipmen and Bligh;
and Fryer was provided with a grievance both against the captain,
and--such is human nature--against his former subordinate.

Nor were grievances wanting during our passage from Teneriffe to Cape
Horn. The people's food on British ships is always bad and always
scanty--a fact which in later days caused so many of our seamen to desert
to American vessels. But on the _Bounty_ the food was of poorer
quality, and issued in scantier quantities, than any man of us had seen
before. When Bligh called the ship's company aft to read the order
appointing Christian acting lieutenant, he also informed them that, as
the length of the voyage was uncertain, and the season so far advanced
that it was doubtful whether we should be able to make our way around
Cape Horn, it seemed necessary to reduce the allowance of bread to two
thirds of the usual amount. Realizing the need for economy, the men
received this cheerfully, but continued to grumble about the salt beef
and pork.

We carried no purser. Bligh filled the office himself, assisted by
Samuel, his clerk--a smug, tight-lipped little man, of a Jewish cast of
countenance, who was believed, not without reason, to be the captain's
"narker" or spy among the men. He was heartily disliked by all hands, and
it was observed that the man who showed his dislike for Mr. Samuel too
openly was apt to find himself in trouble with Lieutenant Bligh. It was
Samuel's task to issue the provisions to the cooks of the messes; each
time a cask of salt meat was broached, the choicest pieces were reserved
for the cabin, and the remainder, scarcely lit for human food, issued out
to the messes without being weighed. Samuel would call out "Four pounds,"
and mark the amount down in his book, when anyone could perceive that the
meat would not have weighed three:

Seamen regard meanness in their own kind with the utmost contempt, and
that great rarity in the Service, a mean officer, is looked upon with
loathing by his men. They can put up with a harsh captain, but nothing
will drive British seamen to mutiny faster than a captain suspected of
lining his pockets at their expense.

While the _Bounty_ was still in the northeast trades, an incident
occurred which gave us reason to suspect Bligh of meanness of this kind.
The weather was fine, and one morning the main hatch was raised and our
stock of cheeses brought up on deck to air. Bligh missed no detail of the
management of his ship; he displayed in such matters a smallness of mind
scarcely in accord with his commission. This unwillingness to trust those
under him to perform their duties is apt to be the defect of the officer
risen from the ranks,--or "come in through the hawse-hole," as seamen
say,--and is the principal reason why such officers are rarely popular
with their men.

Bligh stood by Hillbrandt, the cooper, while he started the hoops on our
casks of cheese and knocked out the heads. Two cheeses, of about fifty
pounds weight, were found to be missing from one of the casks, and Bligh
flew into one of his passions of rage.

"Stolen, by God!" he shouted.

"Perhaps you will recollect, sir," Hillbrandt made bold to say, "that
while we were in Deptford the cask was opened by your order and the
cheeses carried ashore."

"You insolent scoundrel! Hold your tongue!"

Christian and Fryer happened to be on deck at the time, and Bligh
included them in the black scowl he gave the men near by. "A damned set
of thieves," he went on. "You're all in collusion against me--officers
and men. But I'll tame you--by God, I will!" He turned to the cooper.
"Another word from you and I'll have you seized up and flogged to the
bone." He turned aft on his heel and bawled down the ladderway. "Mr.
Samuel! Come on deck this instant."

Samuel came trotting up to his master obsequiously, and Bligh went on:
"Two of the cheeses have been stolen. See that the allowance is
stopped--from the officers too, mind you--until the deficiency is made

I could see that Fryer was deeply offended, though he said nothing at the
time; as for Christian,--a man of honour,--his feelings were not
difficult to imagine. The men had a pretty clear idea of which way the
wind blew by this time, and on the next banyan day, when butter alone was
served out, they refused it, saying that to accept butter without cheese
would be a tacit acknowledgment of the theft. John Williams, one of the
seamen, declared publicly in the forecastle that he had carried the two
cheeses to Mr. Bligh's house, with a cask of vinegar and some other
things which were sent up in a boat from Long Reach.

As the private stocks of provisions obtained in Spithead now began to run
out, all hands went "from grub galore to the King's own," as seamen say.
Our bread, which was only beginning to breed maggots, was fairly good,
though it needed teeth better than mine to eat the central "reefer's
nut"; but our salt meat was unspeakably bad. Meeting Alexander Smith one
morning when he was cook to his mess, I was shown a piece of it fresh
from the cask--a dark, stony, unwholesome-looking lump, glistening with

"Have a look, Mr. Byam," he said. "What'll it be, I wonder? Not beef or
pork, that's certain! I mind one day on the old _Antelope_--two
years ago, that was--the cooper found three horseshoes in the bottom of a
cask!" He shook his pigtail back over his shoulder and shifted a great
quid of tobacco to his starboard cheek. "You've seen the victualing yards
in Portsmouth, sir? Pass that way any night, and you'll hear the dogs
bark and the horses neigh! And I'll tell you something else you young
gentlemen don't know." He glanced up and down the deck cautiously and
then whispered: "It's as much as a black man's life is worth to pass that
way by night! They'd pop him into a cask like that!" He snapped his
fingers impressively.

Smith was a great admirer of Old Bacchus, whom he had known on other
ships, and a few days later he handed me a little wooden box. "For the
surgeon, sir," he said. "Will you give it to him?"

It was a snuffbox, curiously wrought of some dark, reddish wood, like
mahogany, and very neatly fitted with a lid; a handsome hit of work,
carved and polished with a seaman's skill. I found leisure to visit the
surgeon the same evening.

Christian's watch was on duty at the time. Young Tinkler and I were in
Mr. Fryer's watch, and the third watch had been placed in charge of Mr.
Peckover, a short, powerful man of forty or forty-five, who could
scarcely remember a time when he had not been at sea. His good-humoured
face had been blackened by the West Indian sun, and his arms were covered
with tattooing.

I found Peckover with the doctor and Nelson--squeezed together on the

"Come in," cried the surgeon. "Wait a bit, my lad--I think I can make a
place for you."

He sprang up with surprising agility and pushed a small cask into the
doorway. Peckover held the spigot open while the wine poured frothing
into a pewter pint. I delivered the snuffbox before I sat down on my
cask, pint in hand.

"From Smith, you say?" asked the surgeon. "Very handsome of him! Very
handsome indeed! I remember Smith well on the old _Antelope_--eh,
Peckover? I have a recollection that I used to treat him to a drop of
grog now and then. And why not, I say! A thirsty man goes straight to my
heart." He glanced complacently about his cabin, packed to the hammock
battens with small casks of spirits and wine. "Thank God that neither I
nor my friends shall go thirsty on this voyage!"

Nelson stretched out his hand for the snuffbox and examined it with
interest. "I shall always marvel," he remarked, "at the ingenuity of our
seamen. This would be a credit to any craftsman ashore, with all the
tools of his trade. And a fine bit of wood, handsomely polished, too!
Mahogany, no doubt, though the grain seems different."

Bacchus looked at Peckover quizzically, and the gunner returned the look,

"Wood?" said the surgeon. "Well, I have heard it called that, and worse.
Wood that once bellowed--aye, and neighed and harked, if the tales be
true. In plain English, my dear Nelson, your mahogany is old junk, more
politely called salt beef--His Majesty's own!"

"Good Lord!" exclaimed Nelson, examining the snuffbox in real

"Aye, salt beef! Handsome as any mahogany and quite as durable. Why, it
had been proposed to sheathe our West India frigates with it--a material
said to defy the attacks of the toredo worm!"

I took the little box from Nelson's hand, to inspect it with a new
interest. "Well, I'm damned!" I thought.

Old Bacchus had rolled up his sleeve and was pouring a train of snuff
along his shaven and polished forearm. With a loud sniffing sound it
disappeared up his nose. He sneezed, blew his nose violently on an
enormous blue handkerchief, and filled his tankard with _mistela_.

"A glass of wine with you gentlemen!" he remarked, and poured the entire
pint down his throat without taking breath. Mr. Peckover glanced at his
friend admiringly.

"Aye, Peckover," said the surgeon, catching his eye, "nothing like a nip
of salt beef to give a man a thirst. Let the cook keep his slush. Give me
a bit of the lean, well soaked and boiled, and you can have all the
steaks and cutlets ashore. Begad! Just suppose, now, that we were all
wrecked on a desert island, without a scrap to eat. I'd pull out my
snuffbox and have one meal, at any rate, while the rest of you went

"So you would, surgeon, so you would," said the gunner in his rumbling
voice, grinning from ear to ear.


One sultry afternoon, before we picked up the southeast trades, Bligh
sent his servant to bid me sup with him. Since the great cabin was taken
up with our breadfruit garden, the captain messed on the lower deck, in
an apartment on the larboard side, extending from the hatch to the
bulkhead abaft the mainmast. I dressed myself with some care, and, going
aft, found that Christian was my fellow guest. The surgeon and Fryer
messed regularly with Bligh, but Old Bacchus had excused himself this

There was a fine show of plate on the captain's table, but when the
dishes were uncovered I saw that Bligh fared little better than his men.
We had salt beef, in plenty for once, and the pick of the cask, bad
butter, and worse cheese, from which the long red worms had been
hand-picked, a supply of salted cabbage, believed to prevent scurvy, and
a dish heaped with the mashed pease seamen call "dog's body."

Mr. Bligh, though temperate in the use of wine, attacked his food with
more relish than most officers would care to display. Fryer was a rough,
honest old seaman, but his manners at table put the captain's to shame;
yet Christian, who had been a mere master's mate only a few days before,
supped fastidiously despite the coarseness of the food. Christian was on
the captain's right, Fryer on his left, and I sat opposite, facing him.
The talk had turned to the members of the _Bounty's_ company.

"Damn them!" said Bligh, his mouth full of beef and pease, which he
continued to chew rapidly as he spoke. "A lazy, incompetent lot of
scoundrels! God knows a captain has trials enough without being cursed
with such a crew! The dregs of the public houses..." He swallowed
violently and filled his mouth once more. "That fellow I had flogged
yesterday; what was his name, Mr. Fryer?"

"Burkitt," replied the master, a little red in the face.

"Yes, Burkitt, the insolent hound! And they're all as bad. I'm damned if
they know a sheet from a tack!"

"I venture to differ with you, sir," said the master. "I should call
Smith, Quintal, and McCoy first-class seamen, and even Burkitt, though he
was in the wrong..."

"The insolent hound!" repeated Bligh violently, interrupting the master.
"At the slightest report of misconduct, I shall have him seized up again.
Next time it will be four dozen, instead of two!"

Christian caught my eye as the captain spoke. "If I may express an
opinion, Mr. Bligh," he said quietly, "Burkitt's nature is one to tame
with kindness rather than with blows."

Bligh's short, harsh laugh rang out grimly. "La-di-da, Mr. Christian! On
my word, you should apply for a place as master in a young ladies'
seminary! Kindness, indeed! Well, I'm damned!" He took up a glass of the
reeking ship's water, rinsing his mouth preparatory to an attack on the
sourcrout. "A fine captain you'll make if you don't heave overboard such
ridiculous notions. Kindness! Our seamen and kindness as well as they and
Greek! Fear is what they _do_ understand! Without that, mutiny and
piracy would be rife on the high seas!"

"Aye," admitted Fryer, as if regretfully. "There is some truth in that."

Christian shook his head. "I cannot agree," he said courteously. "Our
seamen do not differ from other Englishmen. Some must be ruled by fear,
it is true, but there are others, and finer men, who will follow a kind,
just, and fearless officer to the death."

"Have we any such paragons on board?" asked the captain sneeringly. "In
my opinion, sir," said Christian, speaking in his light and courteous
manner, "we have, and not a few."

"Now, by God! Name one!"

"Mr. Purcell, the carpenter. He..."

This time Bligh laughed long and loud. "Damme!" he exclaimed, "you're a
fine judge of men! That stubborn, thick-headed old rogue! Kindness...Ah,
that's too good!"

Christian flushed, controlling his hot temper with an effort. "You won't
have the carpenter, I see," he said lightly: "then may I suggest
Morrison, sir?"

"Suggest to your heart's content," answered Bligh scornfully. "Morrison?
The gentlemanly boatswain's mate? The sheep masquerading as a wolf?
Kindness? Morrison's too damned kind now!"

"But a fine seaman, sir," put in Fryer gruffly; "he has been a
midshipman, and is a gentleman born."

"I know, I know!" said Bligh in his most offensive way; "and no higher in
my estimation for all that." He turned to me, with what he meant to be a
courteous smile. "Saving your presence, Mr. Byam, damn all midshipmen, I
say! There could be no worse schools than the berth for the making of sea
officers!" He turned to Christian once more, and his manner changed to an
unpleasant truculence.

"As for Morrison, let him take care! I've my eye on him, for I can see
that he spares the cat. A boatswain's mate who was not a gentleman would
have had half the hide off Burkitt's back. Let him take care, I say! Let
him lay on when I give the word or, by God, I'll have him seized up for a
lesson from the boatswain himself!"

I perceived, as the meal went on, that the captain's mess was anything
but a congenial one. Fryer disliked the captain, and had not forgotten
the incident of the cheeses. Bligh made no secret of his dislike for the
master, whom he often upbraided before the men on deck; and he felt for
Christian a contempt he was at no pains to conceal.

I was not surprised, a few days later, to learn from Old Bacchus that
Christian and the master had quitted the captain's mess, leaving Bligh to
dine and sup alone. We were south of the line by this time.

At Teneriffe, we had taken on board a large supply of pumpkins, which now
began to show symptoms of spoiling under the equatorial sun. As most of
them were too large for the use of Bligh's table, Samuel was ordered to
issue them to the men in lieu of bread. The rate of exchange--one pound
of pumpkin to replace two pounds of bread--was considered unfair by the
men, and when Bligh was informed of this he came on deck in a passion and
called all hands. Samuel was then ordered to summon the first man of
every mess.

"Now," exclaimed Bligh violently, "let me see who will dare to refuse the
pumpkins, or anything else I order to be served. You insolent rascals! By
God! I'll make you eat grass before I've done with you!"

Everyone now took the pumpkins, not excepting the officers, though the
amount was so scanty that it was usually thrown together by the men, the
cooks of the different messes drawing lots for the whole. There was some
murmuring, particularly among the officers, but the grievance might have
ended there had not all hands begun to believe that the casks of beef and
pork were short of their weight. This had been suspected for some time,
as Samuel could never be prevailed on to weigh the meat when opened, and
at last the shortage became so obvious that the people applied to the
master, begging that he would examine into the affair and procure them
redress. Bligh ordered all hands aft at once.

"So you've complained to Mr. Fryer, eh?" he said, shortly and harshly.
"You're not content! Let me tell you, by God, that you'd better make up
your minds to be content! Everything that Mr. Samuel does is done by my
orders, do you understand? My orders! Waste no more time in complaints,
for you will get no redress! I am the only judge of what is right and
wrong. Damn your eyes! I'm tired of you and your complaints! The first
man to complain from now on will be seized up and flogged."

Perceiving that no redress was to be hoped for before the end of the
voyage, the men resolved to bear their sufferings with patience, and
neither murmured nor complained from that time. But the officers, though
they dared make no open complaints, were less easily satisfied and
murmured frequently among themselves of their continual state of hunger,
which they thought was due to the fact that the captain and his clerk had
profited by the victualing of the ship. Our allowance of food was so
scanty that the men quarreled fiercely over the division of it in the
galley, and when several men had been hurt it became necessary for the
master's mate of the watch to superintend the division of the food.

About a hundred leagues off the coast of Brazil, the wind chopped around
to north and northwest, and I realized that we had reached the southern
limit of the southeast trades. It was here, in the region of variable
westerlies, that the _Bounty_ was becalmed for a day or two, and the
people employed themselves in fishing, each mess risking a part of its
small allowance of salt pork in hopes of catching one of the sharks that
swam about the ship.

The landsman turns up his nose at the shark, but, to a sailor craving
fresh meat, the flesh of a shark under ten feet in length is a veritable
luxury. The larger sharks have a strong rank smell, but the flesh of the
small ones, cut into slices like so many beefsteaks, parboiled first and
then broiled with plenty of pepper and salt, eats very well indeed,
resembling codfish in flavour.

I tasted shark for the first time one evening off the Brazilian coast. It
was dead calm; the sails hung slack from the yards, only moving a little
when the ship rolled to a gently northerly swell. John Mills, the
gunner's mate, stood forward abreast of the windlass, with a heavy line
coiled in his hand. He was an old seaman, one of Christian's watch--a man
of forty or thereabouts who had served in the West Indies on the
_Mediator_, Captain Cuthbert Collingwood. I disliked the man,--a
tall, rawboned, dour old salt,--but I watched with interest as he
prepared his bait. Two of his messmates stood by, ready to bear a
hand--Brown, the assistant botanist, and Norman, the carpenter's mate.
The mess had contributed the large piece of salt pork now going over the
side; they shared the risk of losing the bait without results, as they
would share whatever Mills was fortunate enough to catch. A shark about
ten feet long had just passed under the bows. I craned my neck to watch.

Next moment a small striped fish like a mackerel flashed this way and
that about the bait. "Pilot fish!" cried Norman. "Take care--here comes
the shark!"

"Damn you!" growled Mills. "Don't dance about like a monkey--you'll
frighten him off!"

The shark, an ugly yellowish blotch in the blue water, was rising beneath
the bait, and all eyes were on him as he turned on his side, opened his
jaws, and gulped down the piece of pork. "Hooked, by God!" roared Mills
as he hove the line short. "Now, my hearties, on deck with him!" The line
was strong and the messmates hove with a will; in an instant the shark
came struggling over the bulwarks and thumped down on deck. Mills seized
a hatchet and struck the fish a heavy blow on the snout; next moment six
or seven men were astride of the quivering carcass, knives out and
cutting away for dear life. The spectacle was laughable. Mills, to whom
the head belonged by right of capture, was seated at the forward end;
each of the others, pushing himself as far aft as possible, to enlarge
his cut of shark, was slicing away within an inch of the next man's rump.
There were cries of "Mind what you are about, there!"

"Take care, else I'll have a slice off your backside!" And in about three
minutes' time the poor fish had been severed into as many great slices as
there had been men bestriding him.

The deck was washed, and Mills was picking up the several slices into
which he had cut his share of the fish, when Mr. Samuel, the captain's
clerk, came strolling forward.

"A fine catch, my good man," he remarked in his patronizing way. "I must
have a slice, eh?"

In common with all of the _Bounty's_ people, Mills disliked Samuel
heartily. The clerk drank neither rum nor wine, and it was suspected that
he hoarded his ration of spirits for sale ashore.

"So you must have a slice," growled the gunner's mate. "Well, I must have
a glass of grog, and a stiff one, too, if you are to eat shark to-day."

"Come! Come! My good man," said Samuel pettishly. "You've enough fish
there for a dozen."

"And you've enough grog stowed away for a thousand, by God!"

"It's for the captain's table I want it," said Samuel.

"Then catch him a shark yourself. This is mine. He gets the best of the
bread and the pick of the junk cask as it is."

"You forget yourself, Mills! Come, give me a slice--that large one
there--and I'll say nothing."

"Say nothing be damned! Here--take your slice!" As he spoke, Mills flung
the ten or twelve pounds of raw fish straight at Samuel's face, with the
full strength of a brawny, tattooed arm. He turned on his heel to go
below, growling under his breath.

Mr. Samuel picked himself up from the deck, not forgetting his slice of
shark, and walked slowly aft. The look in his eye boded no good fortune
to the gunner's mate.

The news spread over the ship rapidly, and for the first time aboard the
_Bounty_ Mills found himself a popular man, though there was little
hope that he would escape punishment. As Old Bacchus put it that night,
"The least he can hope for is a red-checked shirt at the gangway.
Samuel's a worm and a dirty worm, but discipline's discipline, begad!"

I believe that a day will come when flogging will be abolished on His
Majesty's ships. It is an over-brutal punishment, which destroys a good
man's self-respect and makes a bad man worse. Landsmen have little idea
of the savagery of a flogging at the gangway. The lashes are laid on with
the full strength of a powerful man's arm, with such force that each blow
knocks the breath clean out of the delinquent's body. One blow takes off
the skin and draws blood where each knot falls. Six blows make the whole
back raw. Twelve cut deeply into the flesh and leave it a red mass,
horrible to see. Yet six dozen are a common punishment.

As had been predicted, Mills spent the night in irons. The kind hearts of
our British seamen were evident next morning when I was told that his
messmates had saved their entire allowance of grog for Mills, to fortify
him against the flogging they considered inevitable. At six bells Mr.
Bligh came on deck, and bade Christian turn the hands aft to witness
punishment. The weather had grown cooler, and the _Bounty_ was
slipping southward with all sail set, before a light northwest breeze.
The order was piped and shouted forward; I joined the assembly of
officers aft, while the people fell in on the booms and along the ship's
side. All were silent.

"Rig the gratings," ordered Mr. Bligh, in his harsh voice.

The carpenter and his mates dragged aft two of the wooden gratings used
to cover the hatches. They placed one flat on the deck, and the other
upright, secured to the bulwarks by the lee gangway. "The gratings are
rigged, sir," reported Purcell, the carpenter. "John Mills!" said Bligh.
"Step forward!"

Flushed with the rum he had taken, and dressed in his best, Mills stepped
out from among his messmates. His unusual smartness was designed to
mollify the punishment, yet there was in his bearing a trace of defiance.
He was a hard man, and he felt that he had been hardly used.

"Have you anything to say?" asked Bligh of the bare-headed seaman before

"No, sir," growled Mills sullenly.

"Strip!" ordered the captain.

Mills tore off his shirt, flung it to one of his messmates, and advanced
bare-shouldered to the gratings.

"Seize him up," said Bligh.

Norton and Lenkletter, our quartermasters--old pigtailed seamen who had
performed this office scores of times in the past--now advanced with
lengths of spun yarn, and lashed Mills's outstretched wrists to the
upright grating.

"Seized up, sir!" reported Norton.

Bligh took off his hat, as did every man on the ship, opened a copy of
the Articles of War, and read in a solemn voice the article which
prescribes the punishments for mutinous conduct. Morrison, the
boatswain's mate, was undoing the red baize bag in which he kept the cat.

"Three dozen, Mr. Morrison," said Bligh as he finished reading. "Do your

Morrison was a kindly, reflective man. I felt for him A that moment, for
I knew that he hated flogging on principle, and must feel the injustice
of this punishment. Yet he would not dare, under the keen eye of the
captain, to lighten the force of his blows. However unwilling, he was
Bligh's instrument.

He advanced to the grating, drew the tails of the cat through his
fingers, flung his arm back, and struck. Mills winced involuntarily as
the cat came whistling down on his bare back, and the breath flew out of
his body with a loud "Ugh!" A great red welt sprang out against the white
skin, with drops of blood trickling down on one side. Mills was a burly
ruffian and he endured the first dozen without crying out, though by that
time his back was a red slough from neck to waist.

Bligh watched the punishment with folded arms. "I'll show the man who's
captain of this ship," I heard him remark placidly to Christian. "By God,
I will!" The eighteenth blow broke the iron of Mills's self-control. He
was writhing on the grating, his teeth tightly clenched and the blood
pouring down his back. "Oh!" he shouted thickly. "Oh, my God! Oh!"

"Mr. Morrison," called Bligh, sternly and suddenly. "See that you lay on
with a will."

Morrison passed the tails of the cat through his fingers to free them of
blood and bits of flesh. Under the eye of the captain he delivered the
remaining lashes, taking a time that seemed interminable to me. When they
cut Mills down he was black in the face and collapsed at once on the
deck. Old Bacchus stumped forward and ordered him taken below to the sick
bay, to be washed with brine. Bligh sauntered to the ladder-way and the
men resumed their duties sullenly.

Early in March we were ordered to lay aside our light tropical clothing
for warm garments which had been provided for our passage around Cape
Horn. The topgallant masts were sent down, new sails bent, and the ship
made ready for the heavy winds and seas which lay ahead. The weather grew
cooler each day, until I was glad to go below for my occasional evenings
with Bacchus and his cronies, or to my mess in the berth. The surgeon
messed with us now, as well as Stewart and Hayward, my fellow midshipmen,
Morrison, and Mr. Nelson, the botanist. We were all the best of friends,
though young Hayward never forgot that I was his junior in service, and
plumed himself on a knowledge of seamanship certainly more extensive than
my own.

Those were days and nights of misery for every man on board. Sometimes
the wind hauled to the southwest, with squalls of snow, forcing us to
come about on the larboard tack; sometimes the gale increased to the
force of a hurricane and we lay hove-to under a rag of staysail, pitching
into the breaking seas. Though our ship was new and sound, her seams
opened under the strain and it became necessary to man the pumps every
hour. The hatches were constantly battened down, and when the forward
deck began to leak, Bligh gave orders that the people should sling their
hammocks in the great cabin aft. At last our captain's iron determination
gave way, and to the great joy and relief of every man on board he
ordered the helm put up to bear away for the Cape of Good Hope.

The fine weather which followed and our rapid passage east did much to
raise the spirits of the men on board. We had caught great numbers of sea
birds off Cape Horn and penned them in cages provided by the carpenter.
The pintado and the albatross were the best; when penned like a Strasburg
goose and well stuffed with ground corn for a few days, they seemed to us
as good as ducks or geese, and this fresh food did wonders for our

With the returning cheerfulness on board, the _Bounty's_ midshipmen
began to play the pranks of their kind the world over, and none of us
escaped penance at the masthead--penance that was in general richly
deserved. No one was oftener in hot water than young Tinkler, a monkey of
a lad, beloved by every man on the ship. Bligh's severity to Tinkler, one
cold moonlight night, when we were in the longitude of Tristan da Cunha,
was a warning to all of us, and the cause of much murmuring among the

Hallet, Hayward, Tinkler, and I were in the larboard berth. The gunner's
watch was on duty, and Stewart and Young on deck. We had supped and were
passing the time at Ablewhackets--a game I have never seen played ashore.
It is commenced by playing cards, which must be named the Good Books. The
table is termed the Board of Green Cloth, the hand the Flipper; the light
the Glim, and so on. To all a table a table, or a card a card, brings an
instant cry of "Watch," whereupon the delinquent must extend his Flipper
to be severely firked with a stocking full of sand by each of the players
in turn, who repeat his offense while firking him. Should the pain bring
an oath to his lips, as is more than likely, there is another cry of
"Watch," and he undergoes a second round of firking by all hands. As will
be perceived, the game is a noisy one.

Young Tinkler had inadvertently pronounced the word "table," and Hayward,
something of a bully, roared, "Watch!" When he took his turn at the
firking, he laid on so hard that the youngster, beside himself with pain,
squeaked, "Ouch! Damn your blood!"

"Watch!" roared Hayward again, and at the same moment we heard another
roar from aft--Mr. Bligh calling angrily for the ship's corporal. Tinkler
and Hallet rushed for their berth on the starboard side; Hayward doused
the glim in an instant, kicked off his pumps, threw off his jacket, and
sprang into his hammock, where he pulled his blanket up to his chin and
began to snore, gently and regularly. I wasted no time in doing the same,
but young Tinkler, in his anxiety, must have turned in all standing as he

Next moment, Churchill, the master-at-arms, came fumbling into the
darkened berth. "Come, come, young gentlemen; no shamming, now!" he
called. He listened warily to our breathing, and felt us to make sure
that our jackets and pumps were off, before he went out, grumbling, to
the starboard berth. Hallet had taken the same precautions as ourselves,
but poor little Tinkler was caught red-handed--pumps, jacket, and all.
"Up with you, Mr. Tinkler," rumbled Churchill. "This'll mean the
masthead, and it's a bloody cold night. I'd let you off if I could. You
young gentlemen keep half the ship awake with your cursed pranks!" He led
him aft, and presently I heard Bligh's harsh voice, raised angrily.

"Damme, Mr. Tinkler! Do. you think this ship's a bear garden? By God!
I've half a mind to seize you up and give you a taste of the colt! To the
masthead with you!"

Next morning at daylight Tinkler was still at the main topgallant
crosstrees. The sky was clear, but the strong west-southwest wind was icy
cold. Presently Mr. Bligh came on deck, and, hailing the masthead,
desired Tinkler to come down. There was no reply, even when he hailed a
second time. At a word from Mr. Christian, one of the top-men sprang into
the rigging, reached the crosstrees, and hailed the deck to say that
Tinkler seemed to be dying, and that he dared not leave him for fear he
would fall. Christian himself then went aloft, sent the topman down into
the top for a tailblock, made a whip with the studding-sail halliards,
and lowered Tinkler to the deck. The poor lad was blue with cold, unable
to stand up or to speak.

We got him into his hammock in the berth, wrapped in warm blankets, and
Old Bacchus came stumping forward with a can of his universal remedy. He
felt the lad's pulse, propped his head up, and began to feed him neat rum
with a spoon. Tinkler coughed and opened his eyes, while a faint colour
appeared in his cheeks.

"Aha!" exclaimed the surgeon. "Nothing like rum, my lad! Just a sip, now.
That's it! Now a swallow. Begad! Nothing like rum. I'll soon have you
right as a trivet! And that reminds me--I'll have just a drop myself. A
corpse reviver, eh?"

Coughing as the fiery liquor ran down his throat, Tinkler smiled in spite
of himself. Two hours later he was on deck, none the worse for his night

On the twenty-third of May we dropped anchor in False Bay, near Cape
Town. Table Bay is reckoned unsafe riding at this time of year, on
account of the strong northwest winds. The ship required to be caulked in
every part, for she had become so leaky that we had been obliged to pump
every hour during our passage from Cape Horn. Our sails and rigging were
in sad need of repair, and the timekeeper was taken ashore to ascertain
its rate. On the twenty-ninth of June we sailed out of the bay, saluting
the Dutch fort with thirteen guns as we passed.

I have few recollections of the long, cold, and dismal passage from the
Cape of Good Hope to Van Diemen's Land. Day after day we scudded before
strong westerly to southwesterly winds, carrying only the foresail and
close-reefed maintopsail. The seas, which run for thousands of miles in
these latitudes, unobstructed by land, were like mountain ridges; twice,
when the wind increased to a gale, Bligh almost drove his ship under
before we could get the sails dewed up and the _Bounty_ hove-to. I
observed that as long as the wind held southwest or west-southwest great
numbers of birds accompanied us,--pintados, albatross, and blue
petrels,--but that when the wind chopped around to the north, even for an
hour or two, the birds left us at once. And when they reappeared their
presence was always the forerunner of a southerly wind.

On the twentieth of August we sighted the rock called the Mewstone, which
lies near the southwest cape of Van Diemen's Land, bearing northeast
about six leagues, and two days later we anchored in Adventure Bay. We
passed a fortnight here--wooding, watering, and sawing out plank, of
which the carpenter was in need. It was a gloomy place, hemmed in by
forests of tall straight trees of the eucalyptus kind, many of them a
hundred and fifty feet high and rising sixty or eighty feet without a
branch. Long strips of bark hung in tatters from their trunks, or decayed
on the ground underfoot; few birds sang in the bush; and I saw only one
animal--a small creature of the opossum sort, which scuttled into a
hollow log. There were men here, but they were timid as wild
animals--black, naked, and uncouth, with hair growing in tufts like
peppercorns, and voices like the cackling of geese. I saw small parties
of them at different times, but they made off at sight of us.

Mr. Bligh put me in charge of a watering party, giving us the large
cutter and instructing me to have the casks filled in a gully at the west
end of the beach. Purcell, the carpenter, had rigged his saw pit close to
this place, and was busy sawing out plank, with his mates, Norman and
McIntosh, and two of the seamen detailed to the task. They had felled two
or three of the large eucalyptus trees, but the carpenter, after
inspecting the wood, had declared it worthless, and instructed his men to
set to work on certain smaller trees of a different kind, with a rough
bark and firm reddish wood.

I was superintending the filling of my casks one morning when Bligh
appeared, a fowling piece over his arm and accompanied by Mr. Nelson. He
glanced toward the saw pit and came to a halt.

"Mr. Purcell!" he called harshly.

"Yes, sir."

The _Bounty's_ carpenter was not unlike her captain in certain
respects. Saving the surgeon, he was the oldest man on board, and nearly
all of his life had been spent at sea. He knew his trade as well as Bligh
understood navigation, and his temper was as arbitrary and his anger as
fierce and sudden as Bligh's.

"Damme, Mr. Purcell!" exclaimed the captain. "Those logs are too small
for plank. I thought I instructed you to make use of the large trees."

"You did, sir," replied Purcell, whose own temper was rising.

"Obey your orders, then, instead of wasting time."

"I am not wasting time, sir," said the carpenter, very red in the face.

"The wood of the large trees is useless, as I discovered when I had cut
some of them down."

"Useless? Nonsense...Mr. Nelson, am I not right?"

"I am a botanist, sir," said Nelson, unwilling to take part in the
dispute. "I make no pretense to a carpenter's knowledge of woods."

"Aye--that's what a carpenter _does_ know," put in old Purcell. "The
wood of these large trees will be worthless if sawn into plank."

Bligh's temper now got the better of him. "Do as I tell you, Mr.
Purcell," he ordered violently. "I've no mind to argue with you or any
other man under my command."

"Very well, sir," said Purcell obstinately. "The large trees it is. But I
tell you the plank will be useless. A carpenter knows his business as
well as a captain knows _his_."

Bligh had turned away; now he spun about on his heel.

"You mutinous old bastard--you have gone too far! Mr. Norman, take
command of the work here. Mr. Purcell, report yourself instantly to
Lieutenant Christian for fifteen days in irons."

It was my task to ferry Purcell out to the ship. The old man was flushed
with anger; his jaw was set and his fists clenched till the veins stood
out on his forearms. "Calls me a bastard," he muttered to no one in
particular, "and puts me in irons for doing my duty. He hasn't heard the
last of this, by God! Wait till we get to England! I know my rights, I

We were still on the shortest of short rations, and Adventure Bay offered
little in the way of refreshment for our invalids, or food for those of
us who were well. Though we drew the seine repeatedly, we caught few fish
and those of inferior kinds, and the mussels among the rocks, which at
first promised a welcome change in our diet, proved poisonous to those
who partook of them. While Mr. Bligh feasted on the wild duck his fowling
piece brought down, the ship's people were half starved and there was
much muttering among the officers.

The whole of our fortnight in Adventure Bay was marred by wrangling and
discontent. The carpenter was in irons; Fryer and Bligh were scarcely on
speaking terms, owing to the master's suspicions that the captain had
lined his pockets in victualing the ship; and just before our departure,
Ned Young, one of the midshipmen, was lashed to a gun on the quarter-deck
and given a dozen with a colt.

Young had been sent, with three men and the small cutter, to gather
shellfish, crabs, and whatever he might find for our sick, who lived in a
tent pitched on the beach. They pulled away in the direction of Cape
Frederick Henry and did not return till after dark, when Young reported
that Dick Skinner, one of the A.B.'s and the ship's hairdresser, had
wandered off into the woods and disappeared.

"Skinner saw a hollow tree," Young told Mr. Bligh, "which, from the bees
about it, he believed to contain a store of honey. He asked my permission
to smoke the bees out and obtain their honey for our sick, saying that he
had kept bees in his youth and understood their ways. I assented readily,
knowing that you, sir, would be pleased if we could obtain the honey, and
an hour or two later, when we had loaded the cutter with shellfish, we
returned to the tree. A fire still smouldered at its foot, but Skinner
was nowhere to be seen. We wandered through the woods and hailed till
nightfall, but I regret to report, sir, that we could find no trace of
the man."

I chanced to know that Bligh had called for the hairdresser, requiring
his services that very afternoon, and had been incensed at Young when it
was learned that Skinner had accompanied him. Now that the man was
reported missing, Mr. Bligh was thoroughly enraged.

"Now damn you and all other midshipmen!" roared the captain. "You're all
alike! If you had gotten the honey, you would have eaten it on the spot!
Where the devil is Skinner, I say? Take your boat's crew this instant and
pull back to where you saw the man last. Aye, and bring him back this

Young was a man grown. He flushed at the captain's words, but touched his
hat respectfully and summoned his men at once. The party did not return
till the following forenoon, having been nearly twenty-four hours without
food. Skinner was with them this time; he had wandered off in search of
another honey tree and become lost in the thick bush.

Bligh paced the quarter-deck angrily as the boat approached. By nature a
man who brooded over grudges till they were magnified out of all
proportion to reality, the captain was ready to explode the moment Young
set foot on deck.

"Come aft, Mr. Young!" he called harshly. "I'm going to teach you to
attend to your duty, instead of skylarking about the woods. Mr.

"Yes, sir!"

"Come aft here and seize up Mr. Young on that gun yonder! You're to give
him a dozen with a rope's end."

Young was an officer of the ship and rated as a gentleman, a proud,
fearless man of gentle birth. Though Bligh was within his powers as
captain, the public flogging of such a man was almost without precedent
in the Service. Morrison's jaw dropped at the order, which he obeyed with
such evidence of reluctance that Bligh shouted at him threateningly,
"Look alive, Mr. Morrison! I've my eye on you!"

I shall not speak of the flogging of Young, nor tell how Skinner's back
was cut to ribbons with two dozen at the gangway. It is enough to say
that Young was a different man from that day on, performing his duties
sullenly and in silence, and avoiding the other midshipmen in the berth.
He informed me long afterwards that, had events turned out differently,
it was his intention to resign from the Service on the ship's arrival in
England, and call Bligh to account as man to man.

On the fourth of September, with a fine spanking breeze at northwest, we
weighed anchor and sailed out of Adventure Bay. Seven weeks later, after
an uneventful passage made miserable by an outbreak of scurvy and the
constant state of starvation to which we were reduced, I saw my first
South Sea island.

We had gotten our easting in the high southern latitudes, and once in the
trade winds we made a long board to the north on the starboard tack. We
were well into the tropics now and in the vicinity of land. Man-of-war
hawks hovered overhead, their long forked tails opening and shutting like
scissor-blades; shoals of flying fish rose under the ship's cutwater to
skim away and plunge into the sea like whiffs of grapeshot. The sea was
of the pale turquoise blue only to be seen within the tropics, shading
to purple here and there where clouds obscured the sun. The roll of the
Pacific from east to west was broken by the labyrinth of low coral
islands to the east of us,--the vast cluster of half-drowned lands called
by the natives _Paumotu_,--and the _Bounty_ sailed a tranquil

I was off watch that afternoon and engaged in sorting over the articles I
had laid in, at the suggestion of Sir Joseph Banks, for barter with the
Indians of Tahiti. Nails, files, and fishhooks were in great demand, as
well as bits of cheap jewelry for the women and girls. My mother had
given me fifty pounds for the purchase of these things, and Sir Joseph
had added another fifty to it, advising me that liberality to the Indians
would be amply repaid. "Never forget," he had remarked, "that in the
South Sea the Seven Deadly Sins are compounded into one, and that one is
meanness." I had taken this advice to heart, and now, as I looked over my
store of gifts, I felt satisfied that I had laid out my hundred pounds to
good effect. I had been a lover of fishing since childhood, and my hooks
were of all sizes and the best that money could buy. My sea chest was
half filled with other things--coils of brass wire, cheap rings,
bracelets, and necklaces; files, scissors, razors, a variety of
looking-glasses, and a dozen engraved portraits of King George, which Sir
Joseph had procured for me. And down in one corner of the chest, safe
from the prying eyes of my messmates, was a velvet-lined box from Maiden
Lane. It contained a bracelet and necklace, curiously wrought in a design
like the sinnet seamen plait. I was a romantic lad, not without my dreams
of some fair barbarian girl who might bestow her favours on me. As I look
back over the long procession of years, I cannot but smile at a boy's
simplicity, but I would give all my hard-earned worldly wisdom to
recapture if only for an hour the mood of those days of my youth. I had
returned them to my chest when I heard Mr. Bligh's harsh, vibrant voice.
His cabin was scarcely fifteen feet aft of where I sat.

"Mr. Fryer!" he called peremptorily. "Be good enough to step into my

"Yes, sir," replied the master's voice.

I had no desire to eavesdrop on the conversation that followed, but there
was no way to avoid it without leaving my open chest in the berth.

"To-morrow or the day after," said Bligh, "we shall drop anchor in
Matavai Bay. I have had Mr. Samuel make an inventory of the stores on
hand, which has enabled him to cast up an account of the provisions
expended on the voyage so far. I desire you to glance over this book,
which requires your signature."

A long silence followed, broken at last by Fryer's voice. "I cannot sign
this, sir," he said.

"Cannot sign it? What do you mean, sir?"

"The clerk is mistaken, Mr. Bligh. No such amounts of beef and pork have
been issued!"

"You are wrong!" answered the captain angrily. "I know what was taken
aboard and what remains. Mr. Samuel is right!"

"I cannot sign, sir," said Fryer obstinately.

"And why the devil not? All that the clerk has done was done by my
orders. Sign it instantly! Damme! I am not the most patient man in the

"I cannot sign," insisted Fryer, a note of anger in his voice; "not in
conscience, sir!"

"But you _can_ sign," shouted Bligh in a rage; "and what is more,
you _shall!_" He went stamping up the ladderway and on to the deck.
"Mr. Christian!" I heard him shout to the officer of the watch. "Call all
hands on deck this instant!"

The order was piped and shouted forward and, when we assembled, the
captain, flushed with anger, uncovered and read the Articles of War. Mr.
Samuel then came forward with his book and a pen and ink.

"Now, sir!" Bligh ordered the master, "sign this book!"

There was a dead silence while Fryer took up the pen reluctantly.

"Mr. Bligh," he said, controlling his temper with difficulty, "the ship's
people will bear witness that I sign in obedience to your orders, but
please to recollect, sir, that this matter may be reopened later on."

At that moment a long-drawn shout came from the man in the foretop. "Land


The lookout had sighted Mehetia, a small, high island forty miles to the
southeast of Tahiti. I stared ahead, half incredulously, at the tiny
motionless projection on the horizon line. The wind died away toward
sunset and we were all night working up to the land.

I went off watch at eight bells, but could not sleep; an hour later,
perched on the fore-topgallant crosstrees, I watched the new day dawn.
The beauty of that sunrise seemed ample compensation for all of the
hardships suffered during the voyage: a sunrise such as only the seaman
knows, and then only in the regions between the tropics, remote from
home. Saving the light, fluffy "fair-weather clouds" just above the vast
ring of horizon which encircled us, the sky was clear. The stars paled
gradually; as the rosy light grew stronger, the velvet of the heavens
faded and turned blue. Then the sun, still below the horizon, began to
tint the little clouds in the east with every shade of mother-of-pearl.

An hour later we were skirting the reef, before a light air from the
south. For the first time in my life I saw the slender, graceful trunk
and green fronds of the far-famed coconut tree, the thatched cottages of
the South Sea Islanders, set in their shady groves, and the people
themselves, numbers of whom walked along the reef not more than a cable's
length away. They waved large pieces of white cloth and shouted what I
supposed were invitations to come ashore, though their voices were
drowned in the noise of a surf which would have made landing impossible
even had Mr. Bligh hove-to and lowered a boat.

Mehetia is high and round in shape, and not more than three miles in its
greatest extent. The village is at the southern end, where there is a
tolerably flat shelf of land at the base of the mountain, but elsewhere
the green cliffs are steep-to, with the sea breaking at their feet. The
white line of the breakers, the vivid emerald of the tropical vegetation
covering the mountains everywhere, the rich foliage of the breadfruit
trees in the little valleys, and the plumed tops of the coconut palms
growing in clusters here and there, made up a picture which enchanted me.
The island had the air of a little paradise, newly created, all fresh and
dewy in the dawn, stocked with everything needful for the comfort and
happiness of man.

The men walking along the shelf of reef at the base of the cliffs were
too far away for inspection, but they seemed fine stout fellows, taller
than Englishmen. They were dressed in girdles of bark cloth which shone
with a dazzling whiteness in the morning sunlight. They were naked except
for these girdles, and they laughed and shouted to one another as they
followed us along, clambering with great agility over the rocks.

As we rounded the northern end of the island, Smith hailed me from the
top. "Look, Mr. Byam!" he shouted, pointing ahead eagerly. There, many
leagues away, I saw the outlines of a mighty mountain rising from the
sea,--sweeping ridges falling away symmetrically from a tall central
peak,--all pale blue and ghostly in the morning light.

The breeze was making up now, and the _Bounty_, heeling a little on
the larboard tack, was leaving a broad white wake. When I reached the
deck I found Mr. Bligh in a rarely pleasant mood. I bade him good
morning, standing to leeward of him on the quarter-deck, and he saluted
me with a clap on the back.

"There it is, young man," he said, pointing to the high ghostly outlines
of the land ahead. "Tahiti! We have made a long passage of it, a long
hard passage, but, by God, there is the island at last!"

"It looks a beautiful island, sir," I remarked.

"Indeed it is--none more so. Captain Cook loved it only next to England;
were I an old man, with my work done and no family at home, I should ask
nothing better than to end my days under its palms! And you will find the
people as friendly and hospitable as the land they inhabit. Aye--and some
of the Indian girls as beautiful. We have come a long way to visit them!
Last night I was computing the distance we have run by log since leaving
England. To-morrow morning, when we drop anchor in Matavai Bay, we shall
have sailed more than twenty-seven thousand miles!"

Since that morning, so many years ago, I have sailed all the seas of the
world and visited most of the islands in them, including the West Indies,
and the Asiatic Archipelago. But of all the islands I have seen, none
approaches Tahiti in loveliness.

As we drew nearer to the land, with the rising sun behind us, there was
not a man on board the _Bounty_ who did not gaze ahead with emotions
that differed in each case, no doubt, but in which awe and wonder played
a part. But I am wrong--there was one. Toward six bells, when we were
only a few miles off the southern extremity of the island, Old Bacchus
came stumping on deck. Standing by the mizzenmast, with a hand on a
swivel-stock, he stared indifferently for a moment at the wooded
precipices, the waterfalls and sharp green peaks, now abeam of the ship.
Then he shrugged his shoulders.

"They're all the same," he remarked indifferently. "When you've seen one
island in the tropics, you've seen the lot."

The surgeon went stumping to the ladderway, and, as he disappeared, Mr.
Nelson ceased his pacing of the deck to stand at my side. The botanist
was a believer in exercise and kept his muscles hard and his colour fresh
by walking two or three miles on deck each morning the weather permitted.

"Well, Byam," he remarked, "I'm glad to be back! Many a time, since my
voyage with Captain Cook, I've dreamed of revisiting Tahiti, without the
faintest hope that the dream might come true. Yet here we are! I can
scarcely wait to set foot on shore!"

We were skirting the windward coast of Taiarapu, the richest and
loveliest part of the island, and I could not take my eyes off the land.
In the foreground, a mile or more offshore, a reef of coral broke the
roll of the sea, and the calm waters of the lagoon inside formed a
highway on which the Indians travel back and forth in their canoes.
Behind the inner beach was the narrow belt of flat land where the rustic
dwellings of the people were scattered picturesquely among their neat
plantations of the _ava_ and the cloth plant, shaded by groves of
breadfruit and coconut. In the background were the mountains--rising
fantastically in turrets, spires, and precipices, wooded to their very
tops. Innumerable waterfalls plunged over the cliffs and hung like
suspended threads of silver, many of them a thousand feet or more in
height and visible at a great distance against the background of dark
green. Seen for the first time by European eyes, this coast is like
nothing else on our workaday planet; a landscape, rather, of some
fantastic dream.

Nelson was pointing ahead to a break in the line of reef. "Captain Cook
nearly lost his ship yonder," he said, "when the current set him on the
reef during a calm. One of his anchors lies there to this day--there
where the sea breaks high. I know this part of the island well. As you
can see, Tahiti is made up of two lands, connected by the low isthmus the
Indians call Taravao. This before us is the lesser, called Taiarapu or
Tahiti Iti; the great island yonder they call Tahiti Nui. Vehiatua is the
king of the smaller one--the most powerful of the Indian princes. His
realm is richer and more populous than those of his rivals."

All through the afternoon we skirted the land, passing the low isthmus
between the two islands, coasting the rich verdant districts of Faaone
and Hitiaa, and toward evening, as the light breeze died away, moving
slowly along the rock-bound coast of Tiarei, where the reef ends and the
sea thunders at the base of cliffs.

There was little sleeping aboard the _Bounty_ that night. The ship
lay becalmed about a league off the mouth of the great valley of Papenoo,
and the faint land breeze, wandering down from the heights of the
interior, and out to sea, brought with it the sweet smell of the land and
of growing things. We sniffed it eagerly, our noses grown keen from the
long months at sea, detecting the scent of strange flowers, of wood
smoke, and of Mother Earth herself--sweetest of all smells to a sailor.
The sufferers from scurvy, breathing deep of the land breeze, seemed to
draw in new life; their apathy and silence left them as they spoke
eagerly of the fruits they hoped to eat on the morrow, fruits they craved
as a man dying of thirst craves water.

We sighted Eimeo a little before sunset: the small lofty island which
lies to the west of Tahiti, four leagues distant. The sun went down over
the spires and pinnacles of Eimeo's sky line, and was followed into the
sea by the thin golden crescent of the new moon. There is little twilight
in these latitudes and, almost immediately it seemed to me, the stars
came out in a cloudless dome of sky. One great planet, low in the west,
sent a shimmering track of light over the sea. I saw the Cross and the
Magellanic Clouds in the south, and constellations unknown to dwellers in
the Northern Hemisphere, all close and warm and golden against the black
sky. A faint burst of song came from the surgeon's cabin below, where he
was carousing with Peckover; every other man on the ship, I believe, was
on deck.

All along shore we could see the flare of innumerable torches, where the
Indians went about their fishing or traveled from house to house along
the beach. The men of the _Bounty_ stood by the bulwarks or on the
booms, speaking in low voices and gazing toward the dark loom of the
land. A change seemed to come over all of us that night: all unhappiness,
all discontent, seemed banished, giving way to a tranquil content and the
happiest anticipation of what the morrow would bring. Mr. Bligh himself,
walking the deck with Christian, was rarely affable; as they passed me
from time to time I overheard snatches of his talk: "Not a bad voyage,
eh?...Only four down with scurvy, and we'll have them right in a week
ashore...The ship's sound as a walnut...Bad anchorage...We'll soon shift
out of Matavai Bay...A fine place for refreshments..."

I was in the master's watch, and toward midnight Mr. Fryer chanced to
notice me stifling a yawn, for it was many hours since I had slept.

"Take a caulk, Mr. Byam," he said kindly. "Take a caulk! All's quiet
to-night. I'll see that you are waked if we need you."

I chose a place in the shadow of the bitts, just abaft of the main hatch,
and lay down on deck, but, though I yawned with heavy eyes, it was long
before sleep came to me. When I awoke, the grey light of dawn was in the

We had drifted some distance to the west during the night, and now the
ship lay off the valley of Vaipoopoo, from which runs the river that
empties into the sea at the tip of Point Venus, the most northerly point
of Tahiti Nui. It was here that the _Dolphin_, Captain Wallis, had
approached the newly discovered land, and here on this long, low point
Captain Cook had set up his observatory to study the transit of the
planet which gave the place its name. Far off in the interior of the
island, its base framed in the vertical cliffs bordering the valley, rose
the tall central mountain called Orohena, a thin sharp pinnacle of
volcanic rock which rises to a height of seven thousand feet and is
perhaps as difficult of ascent as any peak in the world. Its summit was
now touched by the sun, and as the light of day grew stronger, driving
the shadows from the valley and illuminating the foothills and the rich
smiling coastal land, I fancied that I had never gazed on a scene more
pleasing to the eye. The whole aspect of the coast about Matavai Bay was
open, sunny, and hospitable.

The entrance to the bay bore southwest by west, little more than a league
distant, and a great number of canoes were now putting out to us. Most of
them were small, holding only four or five persons; strange-looking
craft, with an outrigger on the larboard side and a high stern sweeping
up in a shape almost semicircular. There were two or three double canoes
among them, each holding thirty or more people. The Indian craft
approached us rapidly. Their paddlers took half a dozen short quick
strokes on one side, and then, at a signal from the man astern, all
shifted to the other side. As the leading canoes drew near, I heard
questioning shouts: "_Taio_? _Peritane?_ _Rima?_" which is
to say: "Friend? British? Lima?" In the latter case, they were asking
whether the _Bounty_ was a Spanish ship from Peru. "_Taio_!"
shouted Bligh, who knew some words of the Tahitian language.
"_Taio_! _Peritane!_" Next moment the first boatload of Indians
came springing over the bulwarks, and I had my first glimpse at close
quarters of this far-famed race.

Most of our visitors were men--tall, handsome, stalwart fellows, of a
light copper colour. They wore kilts of figured cloth of their own
manufacture, light fringed capes thrown over their shoulders and joined
at the throat, and turbans of brown cloth on their heads. Some of them,
naked from the waist up, displayed the arms and torsos of veritable
giants; others, instead of turbans, wore on their heads the little
bonnets of freshly plaited coconut leaves they call _taumata_. Their
countenances, like those of children, mirrored every passing mood, and
when they smiled, which was often, I was astonished at the whiteness and
perfection of their teeth. The few women who came on board at this time
were all of the lower orders of society, and uncommonly diminutive as
compared with the men. They wore skirts of white cloth falling in
graceful folds, and cloaks of the same material to protect their
shoulders from the sun, draped to leave the right arm free, and not
unlike the toga of the Romans. Their faces were expressive of good
nature, kindness, and mirth, and it was easy to perceive why so many of
our seamen in former times had formed attachments among girls who seemed
to have all the amiable qualities of their sex.

Mr. Bligh had given orders that the Indians were to be treated with the
greatest kindness by everyone on board, though watched closely to prevent
the thefts to which the commoners among them were prone. As the morning
breeze freshened and we worked in toward the entrance with yards braced
up on the larboard tack, the hubbub on the ship was deafening. At least a
hundred men and a quarter as many women overran the decks, shouting,
laughing, gesticulating, and addressing our people in the most animated
manner, as if taking for granted that their unintelligible harangues were
understood. The seamen found the feminine portion of our visitors so
engaging that we had difficulty in keeping them at their stations. The
breeze continued to freshen, and before long we sailed through the narrow
passage between the westerly point of the reef before Point Venus and the
sunken rock called the Dolphin Bank, on which Captain Wallis so nearly
lost his ship. At nine in the forenoon we dropped anchor in Matavai Bay,
in thirteen fathoms.

A vast throng of visitors set out immediately from the beach in their
canoes, but for some time no persons of consequence came on board. I was
joking with a party of girls to whom I had given some trifling gifts,
when Mr. Bligh's servant came on deck to tell me that the captain desired
to see me below. I found him alone in his cabin, bending over a chart of
Matavai Bay.

"Ah, Mr. Byam," he said, motioning me to sit down on his chest. "I want a
word with you. We shall probably lie here for several months while Mr.
Nelson collects our young breadfruit plants. I am going to release you
from further duties on board so that you may be free to carry out the
wishes of my worthy friend, Sir Joseph Banks. I have given the matter
some thought and believe that you will best accomplish your task by
living ashore amongst the natives. Everything now depends on your choice
of a _taio_, or friend, and let me advise you to go slowly. Persons
of consequence in Tahiti, as elsewhere, do not wear their hearts on their
sleeves, and should you make the mistake of choosing a friend among the
lower orders of their society, you will find yourself greatly handicapped
in your work."

He paused and I said, "I think I understand, sir."

"Yes," he went on. "By all means go slowly. Spend as much time as you
wish on shore for a day or two, and when you have found a family to your
liking inform me of the fact, so that I may make inquiries as to their
standing. Once you have settled on a _taio_ you can move your chest
and writing materials ashore. After that I expect to see no more of you
except when you report your progress to me once each week."

He gave me a curt but friendly nod, and perceiving that the interview was
at an end, I rose and took leave of him. On deck, Mr. Fryer, the master,
beckoned me to him.

"You have seen Mr. Bligh?" he asked, raising his voice to make the words
audible in the din. "He informed me last night that on our arrival here
you were to be relieved of duty on board the ship. There is nothing to
fear from the Indians. Go ashore at any time you wish. You are free to
make gifts of your own things to the Indians, but remember--no trading.
The captain has placed all of the trading in the hands of Mr. Peckover.
You are to make a dictionary of the Indian tongue, I understand?"

"Yes, sir--at the desire of Sir Joseph Banks."

"A praiseworthy task--a praiseworthy task! Some slight knowledge of the
language will no doubt be of great service to future mariners in this
sea. And you're a lucky lad, Mr. Byam, a lucky lad! I envy you, on my
word I do!"

At that moment a double canoe, which had brought out a handsome gift of
pigs from some chief ashore, cast off from the ship. I was all eagerness
to set foot on land. "May I go with those people if they'll have me?" I
asked the master.

"Off with you, by all means. Give them a hail."

I sprang to the bulwarks and shouted to catch the attention of a man in
the stern of one of the canoes, who seemed to be in a position of
authority. As I caught his eye, I pointed to myself, then to the canoe,
and then to the beach a cable's length' away. He caught my meaning
instantly and shouted some order to his paddlers. They backed water so
that the high stern of one of the canoes came close alongside, rising
well above the _Bounty's_ bulwarks. As I sprang over the rail and
slid down the hollowed-out stern into the canoe, the paddlers, glancing
back over their shoulders and grinning at me, raised a cheer. The Indian
captain gave a shout, a score of paddles dug into the water
simultaneously, and the canoe moved away toward the land.

From One Tree Hill to Point Venus a curving beach of black volcanic sand
stretches for about a mile and a half. We were heading for a spot about
midway between these two boundaries of Matavai Bay, and I saw that a
considerable surf was pounding on the steep beach. As we drew near the
breakers the man in the stern of the other canoe snatched up a heavy
steering paddle and shouted an order which caused the men to cease
paddling while four or five waves passed under us. A dense throng of
Indians stood on the beach, awaiting our arrival with eagerness. Suddenly
the man beside me began to shout, gripping the haft of his steering
paddle strongly.

"_A hoe_!" he shouted. "_Teie to are rahi_!" (Paddle! Here is
the great wave!) I recollect the words, for I was destined to hear them
many times.

The men bent to their work, all shouting together; the canoe shot forward
as a wave larger than the others lifted us high in the air and sent us
racing for the sands. While the steersman held us stern-on, with efforts
that made the muscles of his arms bulge mightily, we sped far up the
beach, where a score of willing hands seized our little vessel to hold
her against the backwash of the sea. I sprang out as the wave receded and
made my way to high-water mark, while rollers were fetched and the double
canoe hauled ashore with much shouting and laughter, to be housed under a
long thatched shed.

Next moment I was surrounded by a throng so dense that I could scarcely
breathe. But the crowd was good-natured and civil as no crowd in England
could be; all seemed desirous to welcome me with every sign of pleasure.
The clamour was deafening, for all talked and shouted at once. Small
children with bright dark eyes clung to their mothers' skirts and stared
at me apprehensively, while their mothers and fathers pushed forward to
shake my hand, a form of greeting, as I was to learn with some surprise,
immemorially old among the Tahitians.

Then, suddenly as the clamour of voices had begun, it ceased. The people
fell back deferentially to make way for a tall man of middle age, who was
approaching me with an air of easy authority and good-natured assurance.
A murmur ran through the crowd: "_0 Hitihiti!_"

The newcomer was smooth-shaven, unlike most of the Indian men, who wore
short beards. His hair, thick and sprinkled with grey, was close-cropped,
and his kilt and short fringed cloak were of the finest workmanship and
spotlessly clean. He was well over six feet in height, lighter-skinned
than the run of his countrymen, and magnificently proportioned; his face,
frank, firm, and humorous, attracted me instantly.

This gentleman--for I recognized at a glance that he was of a class
different from any of the Indians I had seen hitherto--approached me with
dignity, shook my hand warmly, and then, seizing me by the shoulders,
applied his nose to my cheek, giving several loud sniffs as he did so. I
was startled by the suddenness and novelty of the greeting, but I
realized that this must be what Captain Cook and other navigators had
termed "nose-rubbing," though in reality it is a smelling of cheeks, and
corresponds to our kiss. On releasing me, my new friend stepped back a
pace while a loud murmur of approval, went through the crowd. He then
pointed to his broad chest and said: "Me Hitihiti! You midshipman! What

I was so taken aback at these words of English that I stared at him for a
moment before I replied. The people had evidently been waiting to see
what effect the marvelous accomplishment of their compatriot would
produce, and my display of astonishment turned out to be precisely what
they were hoping for. There were nods and exclamations of satisfaction on
all sides, and Hitihiti, now thoroughly pleased with himself and with me,
repeated his question, "What name?"

"Byam," I replied; and he said, "Byam! Byam!" nodding violently, while
"Byam, Byam, Byam," echoed throughout the crowd. Hitihiti again pointed
to his chest. "Fourteen year now," he said with an air of pride, "me sail
Captain Cook!" "_Tuté! Tuté!_" exclaimed a little old man close by,
as if afraid that I might not understand. "Could I have a drink of
water?" I asked, for it was long since I had tasted any but the foul
water aboard ship. Hitihiti started, and seized my hand.

He shouted an order to the people about us, which sent some of the boys
and young men scampering off inland. He then led me up the steep rise
behind the beach to a rustic shed where several young women made haste to
spread a mat. We sat down side by side, and the crowd, increasing rapidly
as parties of Indians arrived from up and down the coast, seated
themselves on the grass outside. A dripping gourd, filled to the brim
with clear sparkling water from the brook near by, was handed me, and I
drank deep, setting it down, half empty with a sigh of satisfaction.

I was then given a young coconut to drink--my first taste of this cool,
sweet wine of the South Sea--and a broad leaf was spread beside me, on
which the young woman laid ripe bananas and one or two kinds of fruit I
had not seen before. While I set to greedily on these delicacies, I heard
a shout go up from the crowd, and saw that the _Bounty's_ launch was
coming in through the surf, with Bligh in the stern sheets. My host
sprang to his feet. "_0 Parai!_" he exclaimed, and, as we waited for
the boat to land, "You, me, _taio_, eh?"

Hitihiti was the first of the Indians to greet Bligh, whom he seemed to
know well. And the captain recognized my friend at once.

"Hitihiti," he said as he shook the Indian's hand, "you've grown little
older, my friend, though you've some grey hairs now."

Hitihiti laughed. "Ten year, eh? Plenty long time! By God! Parai, you get

It was now the captain's turn to laugh, as he touched his waist, by no
means small in girth.

"Come ashore," the Indian went on emphatically. "Eat plenty pig! Where
Captain Cook? He come Tahiti soon?"

"My father?"

Hitihiti looked at Bligh in astonishment. "Captain Cook your father?" he

"Certainly--didn't you know that?"

For a moment the Indian chief stood in silent amazement; then, with
extraordinary animation, he raised a hand for silence and addressed the
crowd. The words were unintelligible to me, but I perceived at once that
Hitihiti was a trained orator, and I knew that he was telling them that
Bligh was the son of Captain Cook. Mr. Bligh stood close beside me as the
chief went on with his harangue.

"I have instructed all of the people not to let the Indians know that
Captain Cook is dead," he said in a low voice. "And I believe that we
shall accomplish our mission the quicker for their belief that I am his

While I was somewhat taken aback by this piece of deception, I knew the
reverence in which the people of Tahiti held the name of Cook, and
perceived that, according to the Jesuitical idea that the end justifies
the means, Mr. Bligh was right.

As Hitihiti ceased to speak there was a buzz of excited talk among the
Indians, who looked at Bligh with fresh interest, not unmixed with awe.
In their eyes, Captain Cook's son was little less than a god. I took the
opportunity to inform Mr. Bligh that Hitihiti had offered to become my
_taio_, and that with his approval I thought well of the idea, since
I should be able to communicate to some extent with my Indian friend.

"Excellent," said the captain with a nod. "He is a chief of consequence
on this part of the island, and nearly related to all of the principal
families. And, as you say, the English he picked up on board the
_Resolution_ should be of great assistance to you in your work." He
turned to the Indian. "Hitihiti!"

"Yes, Parai."

"Mr. Byam informs me that you and he are to be friends." Hitihiti nodded.
"Me, Byam, _taio_!"

"Good!" said Bligh. "Mr. Byam is the son of a chief in his own land. He
will have gifts for you, and in return I want you to take him to your
house, where he will stop. His work, while we are here, is to learn your
language, so that British seamen may be able to converse with your
people. Do you understand?"

Hitihiti turned to face me and stretched out an enormous hand.
"_Taio_, eh?" he remarked smilingly, and we shook hands on the

Presently a canoe was launched to fetch my things from the ship, and that
night I slept in the house of my new friend--Hitihiti-Te-Atua-Iri-Hau,
chief of Mahina and Ahonu, and hereditary high priest of the temple of


I can still recall vividly our walk that afternoon--from the landing
place to Point Venus, and eastward, behind a second long curving beach of
sand, on which the sea broke high, to the house of my _taio_, set on
a grassy point, sheltered from the sea by a short stretch of coral reef
which supported a beautiful little islet called Motu Au. The islet was
not more than half a cable's length from shore; its beaches were of snowy
coral sand, contrasting with the rich dark green of the tall trees that
grew almost to the water's edge. Between the beach and the islet lay the
lagoon--warm blue water, two or three fathoms deep and clear as air.

We walked in constant shade, under groves of breadfruit trees on which
the fruit was beginning to ripen. Many of these trees must have been of
immense age, from their girth and height; with their broad glossy leaves,
smooth bark, and majestic shape, they are among the noblest of all shade
trees, and certainly the most useful to mankind. Here and there the
slender bole of an old coconut palm rose high in the air; scattered
picturesquely, as if at random, among the groves I saw the houses of the
Indians, thatched with bright yellow leaves of the palmetto and
surrounded by fences of bamboo.

My host, though no more than forty-five, was already many times a
grandfather, and as we approached his house, after a walk of little more
than half an hour, I heard joyful shouts and saw a dozen sturdy children
skipping out to greet him. They halted at sight of me, but soon lost
their fear and began to climb up Hitihiti's legs and examine,
inquisitively as monkeys, the strange garments I wore. By the time we
came to the door the chief had a small boy on each of his shoulders, and
his eldest granddaughter was leading me by the hand.

The house was a fine one--sixty feet long by twenty wide, with a lofty,
newly thatched roof, and, instead of gables, semicircular extensions at
each end, giving the whole an oval shape. Such houses were built only for
chiefs. The ends, supported by pillars of old polished coconut wood, were
open, and the sides were walled by vertical lathes of bright yellow
bamboo, through which the air filtered freely. The floor was of fresh
white coral sand, spread with mats at one end on a thick bed of
sweet-smelling grass called _aretu_. Of furniture there was scarcely
any: small wooden pillows on the family bed, like tiny tables with four
short legs; two or three of the seats used only by chiefs, carved from a
single log of hard red wood; and a stand of weapons hanging on one of the
pillars which supported the ridgepole, including my host's ponderous war

Hitihiti's daughter--mother of two of the younger children accompanying
us--met us at the door. She was a young woman of twenty-five, with a
stately figure and carriage, and the pale golden skin and auburn hair
which are not uncommon among this people. These fair Indians were termed
_ehu_; I have seen men and women of this strain--unmixed with
European blood--whose eyes were blue. My host smiled at his daughter and
then at me.

"0 Hina," he said in introduction. He said something to her in which I
distinguished the word _taio_ and my own name. Hina stepped forward
with a grave slow smile to shake my hand, and then, taking me by the
shoulders as her father had done, she laid her nose to my cheek and
sniffed. I reciprocated this Indian kiss, and smelled for the first time
the perfume of the scented coconut oil with which the women of Tahiti
anoint themselves.

There are perhaps no women in the world--not even the greatest ladies of
fashion in Europe--more meticulous in the care of their persons than were
the Indian women of the upper class. Each morning and evening they bathed
in one of the innumerable clear cool streams, not merely plunging in and
out again, but stopping to be scrubbed from head to foot by their serving
women with a porous volcanic stone, used as we use pumice in our baths.
Their servants then anointed them with _monoi_--coconut oil,
perfumed with the petals of the Tahitian gardenia. Their hair was dried
and arranged, a task which required an hour or more; their eyebrows were
examined in a mirror which consisted of a blackened coconut shell filled
with water, and plucked or shaven with a shark's tooth, to make the
slender arch which was the fashion among them. A servant then brought a
supply of powdered charcoal with which the teeth were scrubbed. When they
were ready to dress, the skirt, or _pareu_, which reached from waist
to the knees and was of snow-white bark cloth, was adjusted so that each
fold hung in a certain fashion. Then came the cloak, which was worn to
protect the upper part of the body from sunburn, which the ladies of
Tahiti dreaded quite as much as the ladies of the English Court. Each
fold of the cloak was arranged just so, and it was ridiculous--to a man,
at least--to watch the long efforts of a tirewoman to please her mistress
in this respect.

Hina's manners were as handsome as her person. She had the smiling
dignity and perfect assurance only to be found among the highest circles
of our own race, a poised urbanity, neither forward nor shy. And this is,
perhaps, a fitting place to say a word for the Indian ladies, so often
and so shamelessly slandered by the different navigators who have visited
their island. Captain Cook alone, who knew them best and was their loyal
friend, has done them justice, saying that virtue was perhaps as common
and as highly prized among them as among our own women at home, and that
to form an impression of the ladies of Tahiti from the women who visited
his ships would be like judging the virtue of Englishwomen from a study
of the nymphs of Spithead. In Tahiti, as in other lands, there are people
given over to vice and lewdness, and women of this kind naturally
congregated upon the arrival of a ship; but, so far as I know, there was
also as great a proportion of faithful wives and affectionate mothers as
elsewhere, many of whom were a veritable honour to their sex.

The house which was to be my dwelling for many months stood, as I have
said, on a grassy point, about a mile to the eastward of Point Venus.
Either by accident or by design, the site was one that commanded in all
directions prospects an artist might have traveled many miles to paint.
On the northern side were the beach, the lagoon, and the beautiful little
island already mentioned; to the south, or directly inland, was the great
valley of Vaipoopoo and a distant glimpse of Orohena, framed in the
cliffs of the gorge; to the west lay Point Venus, with the sea breaking
high on the protecting reefs; and to the east, facing the sunrise, was a
magnificent view of the rocky, unprotected coast of Orofara and Faaripoo,
where the surges of the Pacific thundered and spouted at the base of
stern black cliffs. No doubt because of the beauty of the easterly view
at dawn, the name of our point was Hitimahana--the rising of the sun.

A little crowd of the chief's retainers gathered about us, regarding
their patron's friend with respectful curiosity, and, while Hina gave
some order to the cooks, an exceedingly handsome young girl came out of
the house and, at a word from my _taio_, greeted me as his daughter
had done. Her name was Maimiti, and she was a niece of my host's--a
proud, shy girl of seventeen.

With a nod to Hina my _taio_ led me to his rustic dining room--a
thatched shed in the shade of a clump of ironwood trees, about a hundred
yards distant. The floor of coral sand was spread with mats, on which a
dozen of the broad fresh leaves of the plantain served as our tablecloth.
The men of Tahiti were uncommonly fond of the company of their women,
whose position in society was perhaps as high as that of women anywhere.
They were petted, courted, permitted no share in any hard labour, and
allowed a liberty such as only our own great ladies enjoy. Yet in spite
of all this, the Indians believe that Man was sky-descended, and Woman
earth-born: Man _raa_, or holy; Woman _noa_, or common. Women
were not permitted to set foot in the temples of the greater gods, and
among all classes of society it was forbidden--unthinkable in fact--for
the two sexes to sit down to a meal together. I was surprised to find
that Hitihiti and I sat down alone to our dinner, and that no woman had a
hand either in the cooking or in the serving of the meal.

We sat facing each other across the cloth of fresh green leaves. A
pleasant breeze blew freely through the unwalled house, and the breakers
on the distant reef made a murmuring undertone of sound. A serving man
brought two coconut shells of water, in which we washed our hands and
rinsed our mouths. I felt a sharp hunger, augmented by savoury whiffs of
roasting pork from the cookhouse not far off.

We were given baked fish with cooked plantains and bananas; pork fresh
from the oven, and certain native vegetables which I had never tasted
before; and a great pudding to finish with, served with a sauce of rich,
sweet coconut cream. I was only a lad, with the appetite of a midshipman,
and I had been many months at sea, but though I did my best to maintain
the honour of England by eating enough for three men, my host put me to
shame. Long after repletion forced me to halt, Hitihiti continued his
leisurely meal, devouring quantities of fish, pork, plantains, and
pudding I can only describe as fabulous. At last he sighed and called for
water to wash his hands.

"First eat--now sleep," he said, as he rose. A wide mat was spread for us
under an old branching purau tree on the beach. We lay down side by side
for the siesta which in Tahiti always follows the midday meal.

This was the beginning of a period of my life on which I look back with
nothing but pleasure. I had not a care in the world, save the making of
my dictionary, in which I took the keenest interest, and which gave me
sufficient occupation to prevent ennui. I lived on the fat of the land,
amongst affectionate friends and amid surroundings of the most exquisite
beauty. We rose at dawn, plunged into the river which ran within pistol
shot of Hitihiti's door, ate a light breakfast of fruits, and went about
our occupations until the fishing canoes returned from the sea at eleven
or twelve o'clock. Then, while the meal was preparing, I had a bath in
the sea, swimming across to the islet or sporting in the high breakers
further west. After dinner the whole household slept till three or four
in the afternoon, when I frequently joined them in excursions to visit
their friends. After sundown, when the strings of candlenuts were lit, we
lay about on mats, conversing or telling stories till one after another
dropped off to sleep.

During the voyage out from England I had gone through Dr. Johnson's
dictionary, which had been provided for me, marking such words as seemed
to me in most common usage in everyday speech. I had then set these down
alphabetically--nearly seven thousand in all. My present task was to
discover and set down their equivalents in the Indian tongue. I have
always loved languages; the study of them has been one of the chief
interests of my life, and in my younger days I could pick up a new tongue
more readily, perhaps, than most men. If I am blessed with any talent, it
is the humble one of the gift of tongues.

The language of Tahiti appealed to me from the first, and with the help
of my _taio_, his daughter, and young Maimiti, I made rapid progress
and was soon able to ask simple questions and to understand the replies.
It is a strange language and a beautiful one. Like the Greek of Homer, it
is rich in words descriptive of the moods of Nature and of human
emotions; and, like Greek again, it has in certain respects a precision
that our English lacks. To break a bottle is _parari_; to break a
rope, _motu_ to break a bone, _fati_. The Indians distinguish
with the greatest nicety between the different kinds of fear: fear of a
scolding or of being shamed is _matau_; fear of a dangerous shark or
of an assassin, _riaria_; fear of a spectre must be expressed with
still another word. They have innumerable adjectives to express the
varying moods of sea and sky. One word describes the boundless sea
without land in sight; another the deep blue sea off soundings; another
the sea in a calm with a high oily swell. They have a word for the glance
which passes between a man and a woman planning an assignation, and
another word for the look exchanged by two men plotting to assassinate a
third. Their language of the eyes, in fact, is so eloquent and so
complete that at times they seem scarcely to need a spoken tongue. They
are masters of the downcast eye, the sidelong glance, the direct glance,
the raising of the eyebrow, the lift of the chin, and all the pantomime
with which they can communicate without those about them being aware of
the fact.

I think I may say, in all truth, that I was the first white man to speak
fluently the Tahitian tongue, and the first to make a serious attempt to
reduce the language to writing. Sir Joseph Banks had provided me with a
brief vocabulary, compiled from his own notes and from Captain Cook's,
but as soon as I heard the Indian tongue spoken I realized that, as he
had suggested, a new system of orthography must be devised. Since my work
was to be done for the benefit of mariners, it seemed better to aim at
simplicity than at a high degree of academic perfection, so I devised an
alphabet of thirteen letters--five vowels and eight consonants--with
which the sounds of the language could be set down fairly well.

Hitihiti spoke the Tahitian language as only a chief could, for the lower
orders, as in other lands, possessed vocabularies of no more than a few
hundred words. He was interested in my work and of infinite use to me,
though, as with all his countrymen, mental effort fatigued him if
sustained for more than an hour or two. I overcame this difficulty by
making myself agreeable to the ladies, and dividing my work into two
parts. From Hitihiti I learned the words pertaining to war, religion,
navigation, shipbuilding, fishing, agriculture, and other manly pursuits;
from Hina and Maimiti I obtained vocabularies concerning the pursuits and
amusements of women.

I opened my chest on the day of my arrival at their house and made my
host a present of what I thought would please him and the ladies most.
This was the seal on our pledged friendship, but though my files,
fishhooks, scissors, and trinkets were received with appreciation, I had
the satisfaction of learning, as time went on, that the friendship of an
Indian like Hitihiti was not for sale. He and his daughter and his niece
were sincerely fond of me, I believe, showing their affection in many
unmistakable ways. I must have been an infinite nuisance to them, with my
pen and ink and endless questions, but their patient good-humour was
equal to my demands. Sometimes Maimiti would throw up her hands in mock
despair, and exclaim laughingly: "Let me be! I can think no more!" or the
old chief, after an hour's patient answering of my questions, would say:
"Let us sleep, Byam! Take care, or you will crack your head and mine with
too much thinking!" But on the next morning they were always ready to
help me once more.

Each Sunday I gathered my manuscript together and reported myself on
board the _Bounty_ to Mr. Bligh. I must say, in justice to him, that
whatever task he undertook was thoroughly performed. He showed the
greatest interest in my work, and never failed to run over with me the
list of words I had set down during the week. Had his character in other
respects been equal to his courage, his energy, and his understanding,
Bligh would to-day have his niche in history, among the great seamen of

Shortly after the arrival of the _Bounty_, Mr. Bligh had ordered a
large tent pitched near the landing place, and Nelson and his assistant,
a young gardener named Brown, were now established on shore, with seven
men to help them gather and pot the breadfruit plants.

This tree cannot be propagated from seeds, since it produces none. Mr.
Nelson informed me that in his opinion the breadfruit had been cultivated
and improved from time immemorial, until--as in the case of the
banana--seeds had been entirely eliminated from the fruit. It seems to
thrive best when tended by man, and in the neighbourhood of his
dwellings. When well grown, the breadfruit tree sends out lateral roots
of great length, within a foot or two of the surface of the ground.
Should an Indian desire a young tree to plant elsewhere, he has only to
dig down and cut one of these roots, which, when separated from the
parent tree, immediately sends up a vigorous young plant. When the shoot
has reached the height of a man, it is ready to be transplanted, which is
done by first cutting it back to a height of about a yard, and then
digging down to cut off a small section of the root. Planted in suitable
soil and watered from time to time, not one in a hundred of the young
trees will fail to grow.

Nelson took long walks daily, scouring the districts of Mahina and Pare
for young plants already well grown. The chiefs had ordered their
subjects to give Nelson all he asked for, as a present to be sent to King
George in return for the gifts the _Bounty_ had brought from

The _Bounty's_ people who remained on board seemed to have forgotten
for the time being their captain's severities and the hardships of our
long voyage. Discipline was relaxed; the men were allowed to go
frequently on shore; and except for the surgeon every man of them had his
Indian _taio_, and nearly every one his Indian lass. Tahiti was in
those days a veritable paradise to the seaman--one of the richest islands
in the world, with a mild and wholesome climate, abounding in every
variety of delicious food, and inhabited by a race of gentle and
hospitable barbarians. The humblest A. B. in the forecastle might enter
any house on shore, assured of a welcome. And as regards the
possibilities of dissipation, to which seamen are given in every port,
the island could only be described as a Mohammedan paradise.

When I had been about a fortnight at my _taio_'s house I was
agreeably surprised one morning to receive a visit from some of my
shipmates, who came around from Matavai Bay in a double canoe. She was
paddled by a dozen or more Indians, and three white men sat in the stern.
My host had gone aboard the _Bounty_ that day to dine with Bligh,
and I stood on the beach as the canoe approached, with Hina, Maimiti, and
Hina's husband, a young chief named Tuatau. As the canoe rose on a wave I
saw that the two white men facing me were Christian and Peckover, and a
moment later I was amazed to see Old Bacchus on the thwart aft of them. A
wave reared up behind the little vessel, the Indians dashed their paddles
into the water, and the canoe swept forward and ran far up the beach.

The surgeon sprang over the gunwale and came stumping up to greet me, his
wooden leg sinking deep into the sand. I had on only a girdle of the
native cloth, and my shoulders were burned brown by the sun.

"Well, Byam," said Bacchus as he shook my hand, "damme if I didn't think
you an Indian at first! Time I was going ashore, I thought, and where
should I go if not to pay you a visit, my lad! So I bottled off a dozen
of Teneriffe wine." He turned to the gunner, who stood by the canoe.
"Hey, Peckover," he called solicitously, "tell them to be easy with that
hamper--should any of the bottles be broken, it would mean another trip
to the ship."

Christian gave me a handshake, with a glint of amusement in his eyes, and
we waited while the surgeon and Peckover superintended the unloading of a
large hamper of wine. Presently a native came staggering up the beach
with it, and I introduced my shipmates to my Indian friends. Hina and her
husband led the way to the house, and we followed, Maimiti walking with
Christian and me. I had liked Christian from the moment when I first set
eyes on him, but it was not until we reached Tahiti that I came to know
him well. He was a stalwart, handsome man, and more than once, during the
short walk to the house, I saw young Maimiti give him a sidelong glance.

When we were seated on mats on Hitihiti's cool verandah, Old Bacchus
motioned the men to set down the hamper of wine. Still panting from the
exertion of his walk, he fumbled for his snuffbox, pulled up his sleeve,
laid a train of snuff on his polished forearm, and sniffed it up in a
twinkling. Then, after a violent sneeze or two and a flourish of his
enormous handkerchief, he reached into his coat tails and produced a

He and Peckover were soon well under way on a morning's carouse, and
Tuatau loth to leave them while the wine held out, so Christian, Maimiti,
Hina, and I walked away up the beach, leaving the preparations of our
dinner to Hitihiti's numerous cooks. The morning was warm and calm, and
we were glad to walk in the shade of the tall ironwood trees that fringed
the sands. A river little larger than an English brook flowed into the
sea about a mile east of the house, ending in a clear deep pool close to
the beach. Gnarled old hibiscus trees arched together overhead, and the
sun, filtering through their foliage, cast changing patterns of light and
shade on the still water. The two girls retreated into the underbrush and
soon stepped out clad in light girdles of glazed native cloth, which is
nearly waterproof. No women in the world are more modest than the ladies
of Tahiti, but they bare their breasts as innocently as an Englishwoman
shows her face. Standing beside me on the bank, clad in a native kilt
which showed his own stalwart figure to the best advantage, Christian
glanced up at them and caught his breath.

"My God, Byam!" he said in a low voice.

Slenderly and strongly made, in the first bloom of young womanhood, and
with her magnificent dark hair unbound, Maimiti made a picture worth
traveling far to behold. She stood for a moment with a hand on the elder
woman's shoulder, and then, gathering her kilt about her, she ran nimbly
up a gnarled limb that overhung the deep water. Poising herself for an
instant high above the pool, she sprang into the water with a merry
shout, and I saw her swimming with slow easy strokes along the bottom,
two fathoms deep. Christian, a capital swimmer, went in head first, and
Hina followed him with a great splash. For an hour or more we frolicked
in the pool, startling shoals of small speckled fish like trout, and
making the cool green tunnel overhead echo with laughter.

The Indians of Tahiti rarely bathe in the sea except when a great surf is
running. At such times the more daring among the men and women delight in
a sport they call horue--swimming out among the great breakers with a
light board about a fathom long, and choosing their moment to come
speeding in, a quarter of a mile or more, on the crest of a high
feathering sea. Their daily bathing is done in the clear cool streams
which flow down from the mountains everywhere, and though they bathe
twice, and often three times each day, they look forward to the next bath
as though it were the first in a month. Men, women, and children bathe
together with a great hubbub of shouting and merriment, for this is the
social hour of their day, when friends are met, courtships carried on,
and gossip and news exchanged.

After our bath we dried ourselves in the sun, while the girls combed out
their hair with combs of bamboo, curiously carved. Christian was a
gentleman, and very far from a rake, though of a warm and susceptible
temperament. He lagged behind with young Maimiti while we walked back to
the house, and once, turning my head by chance, I saw that the two were
walking hand in hand. They made a handsome couple--the young English
seaman and the Indian girl. The kindly fate which veils the future from
us gave me no inkling of what lay in store for these two--destined to
face together, hand in hand as I saw them now, long wanderings and
suffering, and tragedy. Maimiti cast down her eyes, while a blush
suffused her clear olive cheeks with crimson, and strove gently to
release her hand; but Christian held her fast, smiling at me.

"Every sailor must have his sweetheart," he said, half lightly and half
in earnest, "and I've found mine. I'll stake my life there's not a truer
lass in all these islands!"

Hina smiled gravely and touched my arm as a hint to leave Christian to
his courting. She had liked him at first sight, and knew his rank on
board. And thanks to the uncanny fashion in which news of every sort
spreads among the people of Tahiti, she knew that he had had no traffic
with the women who infested the ship.


From the day of his meeting with Maimiti, Christian missed no opportunity
of visiting us, arriving by day or by night as his duties on board the
_Bounty_ permitted. The Indians, who felt no need of unbroken sleep,
were frequently up and about during the night, and often made a meal at
midnight when the fishers returned from the reef. Old Hitihiti oftentimes
awakened me merely from a desire to converse, or when he suddenly
recollected some word which had escaped his memory during the day. I grew
accustomed to this casual and broken sleep, and learned, like my host, to
make up during the afternoon for what was lost at night.

Christian was soon accepted by the household as the avowed lover of
Maimiti. He seldom came without some little gifts for her, and the
others, and his visits were anticipated with eager pleasure. He was a man
of moods; at sea I had seen him stern, reticent, and almost intimidating
for a fortnight at a time. Then all at once he would unbend, shake off
his preoccupation, and become the heartiest and gayest of companions. No
man knew better how to make himself agreeable to others when he chose;
his sincerity, his education, which went beyond that of most sea officers
of the time, and the charm of his manner combined to win the respect of
men and women alike. And the ardour of his nature, his handsome person
and changing moods, made him what women call a romantic man.

One night, when I had been about six weeks at the house of Hitihiti, I
was awakened gently in the Indian fashion by a hand on my shoulder. The
flare of a candlenut made a dim light in the house, and I saw Christian
standing over me, with his sweetheart at his side.

"Come down to the beach, Byam," he said; "they have built a fire there. I
have something to tell you."

Rubbing the sleep from my eyes, I followed them out of the house, to
where a fire of coconut husks burned bright and ruddy. The night was
moonless and the sea so calm that the breakers scarcely whispered on the
sand. Mats were spread around the fire, and Hitihiti's people lay about,
conversing in low voices while fish roasted on the coals.

Christian sat down, his back to the bole of a coconut palm and an arm
about Maimiti's waist, while I reclined near by. I knew at the first
glance that his gaiety of the weeks past had been succeeded by one of his
sombre moods.

"I must tell you," he said slowly, at the end of a long silence, "Old
Bacchus died last night."

"Good God!" I exclaimed..."What..."

"He died, not of drink, as might have been supposed, but of eating a
poisonous fish. We purchased about fifty pounds of fish from a canoe that
came in from Tetiaroa, and your mess had a string of them fried for
dinner yesterday. They were of a bright red colour and different from the
others. Hayward, Nelson, and Morrison were close to death for six hours,
but they are better now. The surgeon died at eight bells, four hours

"Good God!" I repeated stupidly and mechanically.

"He will be buried in the morning, and Mr. Bligh bids you to be on hand."

At first the news dazed me and I did not realize the full extent of the
loss; little by little the fact that Old Bacchus was no longer of the
_Bounty's_ company came home to me.

"A drunkard," said Christian musingly, as if to himself, "but beloved by
all on board. We shall be the worse off for his death." Maimiti turned to
me, and in the ruddy firelight I saw glistening in her eyes the easy
tears of her race. "_Ua mate te ruau avae hoe_," she said
sorrowfully. (The old man with one leg is dead.)

"I have been many years at sea," Christian went on, "and I can tell you
that the welfare of men on shipboard depends on things which seem small.
A joke at the right moment, a kind word, or a glass of grog is sometimes
more efficacious than the cat-of-nine-tails. With the surgeon gone, life
on the _Bounty_ will not be what it was."

Christian spoke no more that night, but sat gazing into the fire, a
sombre expression in his eyes. Maimiti, a silent girl, laid her head on
his shoulder and fell asleep, while he stroked her hair tenderly and
absently. I lay awake for a long time, thinking of Old Bacchus and of the
trick of fate which had so abruptly closed his career, on a heathen
island, twelve thousand miles from England. Perhaps his jovial shade
would be well content to haunt the moonlit groves of Tahiti, where the
sea he loved was only a pistol shot away--its salt smell in the air and
the thunder of its breakers sounding day and night. And he had died on
shipboard, as he would have desired, safe from the dreaded years of
retirement on shore. Christian was right, I thought; without Old Bacchus,
life on the _Bounty_ could not be the same.

We buried him on Point Venus, close to where Captain Cook had set up his
observatory twenty years before. There was some delay in getting the
consent of Teina, the great chief whom the English had believed to be
king of Tahiti, and who was the first of the Pomares. At last all was
arranged, and the Indians themselves dug the grave, laying it out very
exactly east and west. It was not until four o'clock in the afternoon
that Old Bacchus was laid to rest, Bligh reading the burial service and a
great crowd of Indians--silent, attentive, and respectful--surrounding
us. When the captain and the _Bounty's_ people had gone on board to
see to the auctioning of the dead man's effects, Nelson and Peckover
remained on shore, the former still pale and shaken from fish poisoning.
The Indians had dispersed, and only the three of us lingered by the new
grave, covered with slabs of coral in the Indian style.

Nelson cleared his throat and drew from a bag he carried three glasses
and a bottle of Spanish wine. "We were his best friends on board," he
said to Peckover, "you and Byam and I. I think it would please him if we
added one small ceremony to the burial service Captain Bligh read so
well." The botanist cleared his throat once more, handed us the glasses,
and uncorked his bottle of wine. Then, baring our heads, we drank in
silence to Old Bacchus, and when the bottle was empty we broke our
glasses on the grave.

The relaxation of discipline which had followed the hardships of the
_Bounty's_ long voyage now came to an end as Bligh's harsh and
ungovernable temper once more began to assert itself. I saw something of
what was going on during my visits to the ship, and learned more from
Hitihiti and Christian, who gave me to understand that there was much
murmuring on board.

Each man on the ship, as I have said, had his Indian friend, who felt it
his duty to send out to his _taio_ frequent gifts of food. The
seamen quite naturally regarded this as their own property, to be
disposed of as they wished, but Bligh soon put an end to such ideas by
announcing that all that came on board belonged to the ship, to be
disposed of as the captain might direct. It was hard for a seaman whose
_taio_ had sent out a fine fat hog of two or three hundredweight to
see it seized for ship's stores, and to be forced to dine on a small
ration of poor pork issued by Mr. Samuel. Even the master's hogs were
seized, though Bligh had at the moment forty of his own.

I witnessed unpleasant scenes of this kind one morning when I had gone on
board to wait upon Mr. Bligh. The captain had gone ashore and was not
expected for some time, so I loitered by the gangway, watching the canoes
put out from shore. Young Hallet, the petulant and sickly-looking
midshipman whom I liked least of those in the berth, was on duty to see
that no provisions were smuggled on board, and he stepped to the gangway
as a small canoe, paddled by two men, came alongside. Tom Ellison, the
youngest of the seamen and the most popular with all hands, was in the
bow of the canoe. He dropped his paddle, clambered up the ship's side,
touched his forelock to Hallet, and leaned down to take the gifts his
_taio_ handed up to him. They were a handful of the Indian apples
called vi, a fan, with a handle made of a whale's tooth, curiously
carved, and a bundle of the native cloth. The Indian grinned up at
Ellison, waved his hand, and paddled away. Hallet stooped to take up the
apples laid on deck, and began to eat one, saying, "I must have these,

"Right, sir," said Ellison, though I could see that he regretted his
fruit. "You'll find them sweet!"

"And this fan," said the midshipman, taking it from Ellison's hand. "Will
you give it to me?"

"I cannot, sir. It comes from a girl. You've a _taio_ of your own."

"He pays me no attention these days, What have you there?"

"A bundle of tapa cloth."

Hallet stooped to feel the thick bundle and gave the seaman an evil
smile. "It feels uncommonly like a sucking pig. Shall I call Mr. Samuel?"
Ellison flushed and the other went on, without giving him time to reply,
"See here! A bargain--the fan's mine, and I say nothing about the pig."

Without a word, the young seaman snatched up his bundle and strode off to
the forecastle in a rage, leaving the fan in his superior's hands. I was
about to utter angry words when Samuel, the captain's clerk, walked aft.
Hallet stopped him. "Do you want a bit of tender pork?" he asked in a low
voice. "Then go to the forecastle. I suspect that Ellison has a sucking
pig wrapped up in a bale of the Indian cloth!" Samuel gave him a nod and
a knowing leer, and passed. I stepped forward.

"You little swine!" I said to Hallet.

"You've been spying on me, Byam!" he squeaked.

"And if you were not such a contemptible little sneak, I'd do more than

The captain's boat was approaching, and, swallowing my anger, I began to
prepare the manuscript of my week's work for his inspection. Half an hour
later, when the interview with Bligh was over and we came on deck, I
found Christian at the gangway, to receive a gift of provisions and other
things sent out by Maimiti, a great landowner in her own right.

There were a brace of fat hogs, as well as taro, plantains, and other
vegetables; fine mats, Indian cloaks, and a pair of very handsome pearls
from the Low Islands. Bligh strolled to the gangway, and, seeing the
hogs, called for Samuel and ordered him to take them over for ship's
stores. Christian flushed.

"Mr. Bligh," he said, "I meant these hogs for my own mess."

"No!" answered the captain harshly.

He glanced at the mats and cloaks, which Christian was about to send
below. "Mr. Samuel," he went on, "take charge of these Indian
curiosities, which may be useful for trading in other groups."

"One moment, sir," protested Christian. "These things were given me for
members of my family in England."

Instead of replying, the captain turned away contemptuously toward the
gangway. Maimiti's servant was handing up to Christian a small package
done up in the tapa cloth. "Pearls," said the man in the Indian tongue.
"My mistress sends them to you, to be given your mother in England."
Still deeply flushed with anger, Christian took the package from the
man's hand.

"Did he say pearls?" put in Bligh. "Come--let me see them!" Samuel craned
his neck and I admit that I did the same. Reluctantly, and in angry
silence, Christian unwrapped the small package to display a matched pair
of pearls as large as gooseberries, and of the most perfect orient.
Samuel, a London Jew, permitted himself an exclamation of astonishment.
After a moment's hesitation, Bligh spoke.

"Give them to Mr. Samuel," he ordered. "Pearls are highly prized in the
Friendly Islands."

"Surely, sir," exclaimed Christian angrily, "you do not mean to seize
these as well! They were given me for my mother!"

"Deliver them to Mr. Samuel," Bligh repeated.

"I refuse!" replied Christian, controlling himself with a great effort.

He turned away abruptly, closing his hand on the pearls, and went below.
A glance passed between the captain and his clerk, but though Bligh's
hands were clasping and unclasping behind his back, he said no more.

It was not hard to imagine the feelings of the _Bounty's_ people at
this time--rationed in the midst of plenty, and treated like smugglers
each time they returned from shore. There must have been much angry
murmuring in the forecastle, for the contrast between life on shore and
life on the ship was oversharp. I had a home and my mother to return to,
but the seamen could look forward to nothing in England save the prospect
of the press gang, or begging on the Portsmouth streets. It seemed to me
that if Mr. Bligh continued as he had begun, we should soon have
desertions or worse.

Going on board to report myself one morning in mid-January, I found the
captain pacing the quarter-deck in a rage. I stood to leeward of him for
some time before he noticed me, and then, catching his eye, I saluted him
and said, "Come on board, sir."

"Ah, Mr. Byam," he said, coming to a halt abruptly. "I cannot run over
your work to-day; we'll put it off till next week. The ship's corporal
and two of the seamen--Muspratt and Millward--have deserted. The
ungrateful scoundrels shall suffer for this when I get my hands on them!
They took the small cutter and eight stand of arms and ammunition. I have
just learned that they left the cutter not far from here and set out for
Tetiaroa in a sailing canoe." Mr. Bligh paused, his face set sternly, and
seemed to reflect. "Has your _taio_ a large canoe?" he asked.

"Yes, sir," I replied.

"In that case I shall put the pursuit in your hands. Ask for Hitihiti's
canoe and as many of his men as you think necessary, and sail for
Tetiaroa to-day. The wind is fair. Secure the men without using force if
you can, but secure them! Churchill may give you some trouble. Should you
find that they are not on the island, return to-morrow if the wind

When I had taken leave of the captain, I found Stewart and Tinkler in the

"You've heard the news, of course," said Stewart.

"Yes; Mr. Bligh told me, and I've the task of catching the men." Stewart
laughed. "By God! I don't envy you!"

"How did they make off with the cutter?" I asked.

"Hayward was mate of the watch, and was fool enough to take a caulk. The
men stole away with the cutter while he slept. Bligh was like a madman
when he learned it. He's put Hayward in irons for a month, and threatens
to have him flogged on the day of his release!"

An hour later I found Hitihiti at the house, and told him of my orders
and of the captain's request for the loan of his large sailing canoe. He
agreed at once to let me have her, with a dozen of his men, and insisted
on accompanying the expedition himself.

My host's vessel was of the kind called _va'a motu_--a single
sailing canoe, about fifty feet long and two foot beam. On the larboard
side, at a distance of about a fathom from the hull, was a long
outrigger, or float, made fast to cross booms fore and aft, which crossed
the gunwales and were lashed fast to them. Her mast was tall and strongly
stayed, and her great sail of closely woven matting was bordered with a
light frame of saplings.

I watched idly while Hitihiti's retainers rolled the vessel out from her
shed where she was kept, carefully oiled and chocked high above the
ground. They fetched the mast and stepped it, and set up the standing
rigging all ataut. Then, in their leisurely fashion, the women of the
household fetched bunches of newly husked drinking nuts and other
provisions for the voyage. The men seemed to look forward eagerly to the
expedition--a break in the dreamy monotony of their lives. Counting on
taking the deserters by surprise, they seemed to have no fear of the
muskets, but Hitihiti asked me with some concern if I were sure that
Churchill and his companions had no pistols. When I assured him that the
deserters were not provided with pistols, he brightened at once, and
began to speak of the voyage.

We sailed at two o'clock in the afternoon, with a fresh easterly breeze
on the beam. Tetiaroa lies almost due north of Matavai, about thirty
miles distant. It is a cluster of five low coral islands, set here and
there on the reef which encircles a lagoon some four miles across, and is
the property of what mariners call the royal family--that of the great
chief Teina, or Pomare. It is the fashionable watering place for the
chiefs of the north end of Tahiti; they repair to its shady groves to
recover from the ravages of the _ava_ with which they constantly
intoxicate themselves, and to live on a light wholesome diet of coconuts
and fish. And to Tetiaroa also repair the _pori_--the young girls,
one from each district of Tahiti, who are placed on stone platforms at
certain times of the year, where they may be admired and compared with
their competitors by passers-by. In Tetiaroa, these _pori_ are fed
on a special diet, kept in the shade to bleach their skins, and
constantly rubbed with the perfumed mollifying oil called _monoi_;
and I must do the old women who care for them the justice to remark that
the whole of Europe might be searched without finding a score of young
females lovelier than the pori I saw on one small coral island.

As we bore away for Tetiaroa I began to appreciate the qualities of
Hitihiti's canoe. Amidships, a long, heavy plank, adzed out of a
breadfruit tree, extended from the outrigger float, across the gunwales,
and well outboard on the weather side. Four or five of the heaviest men
of our crew now took their places on this plank, well out to windward, to
prevent us from capsizing in the gusts. Two other men were employed
constantly in bailing, as the canoe tore through the waves at a speed of
not less than twelve knots. The _Bounty_ sailed well, as ships went
in those days, but Hitihiti's little vessel would have sailed two miles
to her one. The chief and I sat side by side on a seat in her high stern,
well above the spray which flew over her bows as she sliced through the

At considerable hazard we ran our canoe over the reef and into the calm
waters of the Tetiaroa lagoon. There we were soon surrounded by small
canoes and swimmers, all eager to impart some information of importance:
the deserters, fearing pursuit, had set sail two or three hours before,
some thought for Eimeo, others for the west side of Tahiti. The wind was
dying away, as it does toward sunset in this region, and since darkness
would soon set in and we had no certain knowledge of Churchill's
destination, Hitihiti deemed it best to spend the night on Tetiaroa, and
return to Bligh with our news when the morning breeze made up.

I shall not forget the night I spent on the coral island. The Indians of
Tahiti are by nature a people given over to levity, passionately devoted
to pleasure, and incapable of those burdens of the white man--worry and
care. And in Tetiaroa, their watering place, they seemed to cast aside
whatever light cares of family and state they feel when at home, and pass
the time in entertainments of every kind, by night and by day. Relieved
of his mission, which I am convinced he would have done his utmost to
accomplish under other circumstances, Hitihiti now seemed to forget
everything but the prospects of entertainment ashore, directing his
paddlers to make at once for the nearest islet, called Rimatuu.

Three or four chiefs and their retinues were on the islet at the time,
and, as its area was no more than five hundred acres, the place seemed
densely populated. We were lodged at the house of a famous warrior named
Poino, whose recent excesses in drinking the _ava_ had nearly cost
him his life. He lay on a pile of mats, scarcely able to move, his skin
scaling off and green as verdigris, but Hitihiti informed me that in a
month he would be quite restored. Several of Poino's relatives had
accompanied him to Tetiaroa, and among them was a young girl, a member of
the great Vehiatua family of Taiarapu, in charge of two old Women. I had
a glimpse of her in the distance as we supped, but thought no more of the
young lady till after nightfall, when I was invited to see a
_heiva_, or Indian entertainment.

Strolling with Hitihiti through the groves, we saw the flare of
torchlight some distance ahead, and heard the beating of the small
drums--a hollow, resonant sound with a strange measure. My friend's head
went up and his step quickened. Ahead of us, in a large clearing, there
was a raised platform of hewn blocks of coral, about which no less than
two or three hundred spectators were seated on the ground. The scene was
brightly illuminated by torches of coconut leaves, bound in long bundles
and held aloft by serving men, who lighted fresh ones as fast as the old
burned out. As we took our places, two clowns, called _faaata_, were
finishing a performance which raised a gale of laughter, and as they
stepped off the platform six young women, accompanied by four drummers,
trooped on to perform. These girls were of the lower order of society,
and their dance was believed by the Indians to ensure the fertility of
the crops. The dress of the dancers consisted of no more than a wreath of
flowers and green leaves about their waists, and the dance itself, in
which they stood in two lines of three, face to face, was of a nature so
unbelievably wanton that no words could convey the least idea of it. But
if the clowns had raised a gale of laughter, the dance raised a
hurricane. Hitihiti laughed as heartily as the rest--the antics of one
girl, in fact, brought the tears to his eyes and caused him to slap his
thigh resoundingly. Presently the dance was over and, in the pause that
followed, my _taio_ informed me that we were now to see a dance of a
very different kind.

The second group of dancers came through the crowd, which parted right
and left before them, each girl escorted by two old women and announced
by a herald, who shouted her name and titles as she stepped on to the
platform. All were dressed alike and very beautifully, in flowing
draperies of snow-white Indian cloth, and the curious headdresses called
_tamau_. They carried fans, with handles curiously carved, and over
their breasts they wore plates of pearl shell, polished till they gleamed
like mirrors, and tinted with all the colors of the rainbow. Selected for
their beauty, nurtured with the greatest care, kept constantly in the
shade, and beautified with the numerous Indian cosmetics, these girls
were of the most exquisite loveliness. Poino's young relative, the second
to be announced, caused a murmur of admiration among the spectators.

Like all the Indians of the upper class, she was a full head taller than
the commoners. Her figure was of the most perfect symmetry, her skin
smooth and blooming as an apricot, and her dark lustrous eyes set wide
apart in a face so lovely that I caught my breath at sight of her. While
the herald announced her long name, and longer list of titles, she stood
facing us, her eyes cast down proudly and modestly. Judging that the
announcement was unintelligible to me, Hitihiti leaned over and whispered
the girl's household name.

"Tehani," he announced in my ear, which is to say "The Darling," a name
by no means inappropriate, I thought. The _hura_ is danced in
couples, and next moment Tehani and the first girl began to dance. The
measure is slow, stately, and of great beauty, the movements of the arms,
in particular, being wonderfully graceful and performed in the most exact
time. When Tehani and her companion retired from the stage, amid hearty
applause, they were succeeded by a brace of clowns, whose antics kept us
laughing till the next pair of girls was ready to dance. But I scarcely
noticed the other performers, for I was eager to return to the house,
whither I knew Tehani had been led. It was fortunate for my work and my
peace of mind, I thought somewhat ruefully, that she was not a member of
Hitihiti's household, yet I knew that I would have given anything I
possessed to have had her there. But I was not destined to see her again
in Tetiaroa, for her two old duennas guarded her closely in a small
separate house.

We sailed about two hours after sunrise, with the east wind abeam, and I
was able to make my report to Mr. Bligh the same afternoon. The deserters
were not apprehended till nearly three weeks later, when they gave
themselves up, worn out by guarding against the constant attempts of the
Indians to capture them. Churchill was given two dozen lashes, and
Muspratt and Millward four dozen each.

The _Bounty_ had at this time been shifted to a new anchorage in the
harbour of Toaroa, where she was moored close to the shore. It had been
Bligh's intention to have Hayward flogged with the deserters, and on the
morning of the punishment, happening to be on board, I saw Hayward's
_taio_, a chief named Moana, standing on deck with a sullen and
gloomy face. But at the last moment the captain changed his mind and
ordered Hayward below, to serve out the balance of his month in irons. On
the same night an incident occurred which might have caused the loss of
the ship and left us marooned among the Indians without the means of
returning to England. The wind blew fresh from northwest all night,
directly on shore, and at daybreak it was discovered that two strands of
the small bower cable had been cut through, and that only one strand was
holding the _Bounty_ off the rocks. Mr. Bligh made a great to-do
about the affair, but it was not till sometime afterwards that I learned
the truth of it.

Hitihiti told me that Moana, Hayward's _taio_, was so incensed at
the prospect of seeing the midshipman flogged that he had gone aboard
that morning with a loaded pistol concealed under his cloak, planning to
shoot Mr. Bligh through the heart before the first stroke of the cat
could be delivered. Seeing his _taio_ escape a flogging, but sent
below to be confined, Moana conceived the idea of releasing his friend by
wrecking the ship. He sent one of his henchmen to sever the cable under
cover of night, and had the man performed his task properly the ship
would infallibly have been lost.

I reflected for some time on Hitihiti's words, and finally, considering
the incident closed and knowing that the cables were now watched with
extra care throughout the night, I came to the conclusion that it was not
necessary to inform Mr. Bligh of what I had learned. To tell him would
only have increased his harshness to Hayward, and caused trouble with
Moana, a powerful chief.

Toward the end of March it became evident to all hands that the
_Bounty_ would soon set sail. More than a thousand young breadfruit
trees, in pots and tubs, had been taken on board, and the great cabin aft
resembled a botanical garden with the young plants standing thick in
their racks, all in a most flourishing condition, their foliage of the
richest dark green. Great quantities of pork had been salted down, under
the captain's direction, and a large sea store of yams laid in. Only Mr.
Bligh knew when we would sail, but it was clear that the day of departure
could not be far off.

I confess that I felt no eagerness to leave Tahiti. No man could have
lived with so kind a host as Hitihiti without becoming deeply attached to
the old man and his family, and my work on the Indian language interested
me more each day. I was now able to carry on ordinary conversations with
some fluency, though I knew enough to realize that a real mastery of this
complex tongue would require years. The vocabulary I had planned was now
complete and had been many times revised as I perceived mistakes, and I
had made good progress on the grammar. Leading a life of the most
delightful ease and tranquillity, and engaged on a congenial task in
which I felt that I was making some headway, it is not to be wondered at
that for days at a time I scarcely gave England a thought. Had it not
been for my mother, I believe that I might have been content to settle
down to a long period of the Indian life, and had I been assured that
another vessel would touch at Tahiti within six months or a year, I
should certainly have asked Mr. Bligh's permission to stop over and
complete my work. Christian, whom I had grown to know well, disliked the
thought of departure as much as I. His attachment to Maimiti was of the
tenderest description, and I knew how he must dread the final parting
from her. Of the midshipmen, Stewart was as deeply attached to his Indian
sweetheart as Christian himself. Young was constantly in the company of a
girl called Taurua, the Indian name for the evening star. Stewart called
his sweetheart Peggy; she was the daughter of a chief of some consequence
on the north end of the island, and devotedly attached to him. A day or
two before the _Bounty_ sailed, Christian, Young, and Stewart
strolled up the beach to call on me, accompanied by Alexander Smith, thy
hammock man. Smith had formed an alliance with a short, dark, lively girl
of the lower orders, who loved him in the robust fashion of a sailor's
lass. He called her Bal'hadi, which was as close as his honest English
tongue could twist itself to Paraha Iti, her true name.

We had been so long in Tahiti, and my shipmates had been so constantly in
the company of the natives, that many of them were able to make
themselves understood to some extent in the Indian language, Both Stewart
and Ellison spoke it remarkably well, and Young and Smith had likewise
made considerable progress in it. Smith, nevertheless, was of the opinion
that, if English were spoken slowly and in a loud voice, it must be a
stupid foreigner indeed who could fail to understand.

As my visitors from the _Bounty_ approached the house I knew
instinctively that Christian had news for me, but he had been so much
among the Indians that he had acquired some notion of their ceremonial
ideas of politeness, which demand a decent interval of light conversation
before any important announcement is made.

Maimiti greeted her lover affectionately, and old Hitihiti had mats
spread for us in the shade and ordered drinking coconuts to be fetched.
My host had asked me, as a last favour, to have made for him a model of
the _Bounty's_ launch, which he admired greatly. He believed that
with the aid of this model his native shipwrights would be able to build
a boat, since I had explained to him the process of warping a plank. I
had entrusted the model making to Smith, who had completed the task in
less than a week, with every dimension true to scale. He walked behind
the others, followed by Bal'hadi, who carried the model on her shoulder.
Hitihiti's face lit up at sight of it.

"Now I shall start my boat," he said to me in the native tongue. "You
have kept your word and I am well content!"

"Let him remember," said Smith, "a foot to the inch and he can't go
wrong, I'll warrant!"

He handed the model to Hitihiti, who took it with every sign of pleasure
and gave me an order to one of his servants, who soon appeared leading a
pair of fine hogs.

"They are for you, Smith," I explained, but my hammock man shook his head

"No use, sir," he said. "Mr. Bligh won't let us keep the pigs our
_taios_ send on board. But if the old chief would give me a sucking
pig, me and my lass could cook and eat it in no time." He smacked his
lips and gave me a hopeful glance.

Hitihiti smiled with pleasure at the request and directed that Smith
should go with one of the Indians to pick out the pig that pleased him
best. A few minutes later the seaman passed us, his sweetheart at his
side and a squealing young porker under his arm. They disappeared into a
thicket near the beach, and presently we heard louder squeals, followed
by silence, and saw a column of smoke rising above the trees. I have a
fancy that the Indian law which prohibited women from dining with men was
broken that day.

Reclining in the shade and drinking the sweet milk of young coconuts, we
had been gossiping idly with the girls, and presently Christian glanced
up and caught my eye.

"I have news for you, Byam," he said. "We are to set sail on Saturday.
Mr. Bligh bids you come on board on Friday night."

As if she understood the words, Maimiti looked at me sorrowfully, took
her lover's hand and held it tight. "Bad news for me, at any rate,"
Christian went on. "I have been very happy here."

"And for me," put in Stewart, with a glance at his Peggy.

Young yawned. "I'm not sentimental," he remarked. "Taurua here will soon
find another fancy man." The lively brown-eyed girl at his side
understood his words perfectly. She tossed her head in denial and gave
him a playful slap on the cheek. Christian smiled.

"Young is right," he said; "when the true seaman leaves one sweetheart he
is already looking forward to the next! But I find it hard to practise
what I preach!"

Toward evening our guests left us to return to the ship, and I was forced
to follow them the next day. I took leave of Hitihiti and his household
with sincere regret, fully convinced that I should never see any one of
them again.

I found the _Bounty_ crowded with Indians, and loaded with coconuts,
plantains, hogs, and goats. The great chief Teina and his wife were the
captain's guests and slept on the ship that night. At daybreak we worked
out through the narrow Toaroa passage, and stood off and on all day,
while Bligh took leave of Teina and made up his parting gifts to the
chief. Just before sunset the launch was sent ashore with Teina and Itea,
while we manned the ship with all hands and gave them three hearty
cheers. An hour later the helm was put up and the _Bounty_ stood off
shore with all sail set.


Now that we were at sea again, I had time to observe the change that had
come over the ship's company as a result of our long island sojourn. In
colour we were almost as brown as the Indians, and most of us were
tattooed on various parts of our bodies with strange designs that added
to our exotic appearance. The Tahitians are wonderfully skilled at
tattooing, and although the process of acquiring it is both slow and
painful, there were few of the men who had not been willing to undergo
the torture for the sake of carrying home such evidence of their
adventures in the South Sea. Edward Young was the most completely
decorated of the midshipmen. On either leg he carried the design of a
coconut tree, the trunk beginning at the heel and the foliage spreading
out over the fleshy part of the calf. Encircling the thighs were wide
bands of conventionalized design, and on his back he had the picture of a
breadfruit tree, done with such spirit that one could all but hear the
rustle of the wind through its branches.

In addition to such pictures, there was scarcely a man on the ship who
had not acquired some words and phrases of the Tahitian language, which
they took care to use in their talk with one another. A few had become
remarkably proficient, and could carry on conversations in which scarcely
a word of English was to be heard. All of them had pieces of the Indian
cloth, and it was a curious sight, in the early mornings when they were
washing down the decks, to see them at their work dressed only in turbans
of tapa, with a strip of the same material about their loins, and
jabbering away with great fluency in the Indian tongue. An Englishman
fresh from home would hardly have recognized them as fellow countrymen.

There was an inward change as noticeable to any thoughtful observer as
these outward ones. Duties were performed as usual, but there was little
heartiness displayed, and this applied to some of the officers as well as
to the men. Never, I fancy, has one of His Majesty's ships been worked
homeward, after long absence, with less enthusiasm.

I was talking of this matter one day with Mr. Nelson, who was always to
be found during the daylight hours in the great cabin, looking after his
beloved breadfruit plants. I felt vaguely uneasy at this time, and it was
always a comforting experience to talk with Mr. Nelson. He was one of
those men who are truly called the salt of the earth, and was a rock of
peace in our somewhat turbulent ship's company. I confessed that I was
disturbed, without knowing exactly why, at the way the ship's work was
going on. Nelson thought there was nothing to be concerned about.

"Does it seem strange to you, my dear fellow, that we should all feel a
little let down after our idyllic life at Tahiti? I am surprised that the
men show as much willingness as they do. My own feelings as I think of
England ahead of us and Tahiti behind are decidedly mixed ones. Yours
must be, too."

"I admit that they are," I replied.

"Imagine, then, how the men must feel, who have so little to go home to.
What have they to expect at the end of the voyage? Before they have been
a week ashore most of them may be seized by some press gang as recruits
for another of His Majesty's ships. Who knows what the situation may be
by the time the _Bounty_ reaches England? We may be at war with
France, or Spain, or Holland, or heaven knows what power; and in that
case, alas for any poor seamen arriving in a home port! They won't even
be given the chance to spend their back pay. The sailor leads a dog's
life, Byam, and no mistake."

"Do you think war with France is likely?" I asked.

"War with France is always likely," he replied, smiling. "If I were an
A.B. I should curse the thought of any war. Think what a paradise Tahiti
has been for our men. For once in their lives they have been treated as
human beings. They have had abundant food, easy duties, and unlimited
opportunities for the sailor's chief distraction, women. I confess that I
was surprised, before we left Tahiti, that the lot of them didn't take to
the hills. Certainly I should have done so had I been in any of their

As the days passed, and we left Tahiti farther and farther astern, the
memory of our life there seemed like that of a dream, and gradually, one
by one, we fell into the old routine. No unhappy incidents occurred to
mar the peace of that period. Captain Bligh took his regular turns on
the quarter-deck, but he rarely spoke to anyone, and most of his time was
spent in his cabin, where he was busy working on his charts of the
islands. So all went quietly enough until the morning of April 23, when
we sighted the island of Namuka, in the Friendly Archipelago. Bligh had
been here before, with Captain Cook, and it was his intention to
replenish our wood and water before proceeding in the direction of
Endeavour Straits.

The wind being to the southward, we had some difficulty in making the
land, and it was not until late afternoon that we came to anchor in the
road, in twenty-three fathoms. The island was much less romantic in
appearance than Tahiti or any of the Society Islands that we had seen,
but I was conscious of the same feeling of awe and wonder I had
experienced elsewhere as I looked upon lands which only a handful of
white men had ever seen, and whose very existence, to say nothing of
their names, was unknown to people at home.

On the morning of the twenty-fourth we weighed and worked more to the
eastward, and again anchored a mile and a half from shore, at a more
convenient place for our watering parties. By this time the arrival of
the ship was known far and wide on shore, and the Indians were arriving
not only from various parts of Namuka, but from neighbouring islands as
well. We had scarcely come to our new anchorage before we were surrounded
with canoes, and our decks were so filled with people that we had
difficulty in performing our duties. At first the confusion was great,
but order was established when two chiefs came aboard whom Bligh
remembered from his visit in 1777. We were able to make them understand
that the decks must be cleared, and they set about it in so resolute and
impetuous a manner that soon all of the Indians, except those in the
chiefs' retinues, were again in their canoes. Captain Bligh then called
me to him to act as interpreter, but I found that my study of the
Tahitian language was of little service here. The Friendly Island speech,
although it has points of resemblance, differs greatly from the Tahitian.
However, with the aid of signs and an occasional word or phrase, we
explained our purpose in corning, and, the chiefs having shouted some
orders to their people, most of the canoes made speedily for shore.

It was Captain Cook who had given the name, "The Friendly Islands," to
this archipelago, but my own impressions of its inhabitants were far from
favourable. They resembled the Tahitians in stature, the colour of the
skin and hair, and it was plain that they belonged to the same great
family; but there was an insolent boldness in their behaviour lacking in
the deportment of the Tahitians. They were thieves of the worst order
and, if offered the slightest opportunity, would seize whatever loose
article lay nearest and leap overboard with it. Christian was strongly of
the opinion that they were not to be trusted in any respect, and
suggested that a strong guard accompany the parties to be sent ashore for
wood and water. Captain Bligh laughed at the notion.

"Surely you're not afraid of the beggars, Mr. Christian?"

"No, sir, but I think we have reason to be cautious in our dealings with
them. In my opinion..."

He was not permitted to finish.

"And who's asked you for your opinion? Damme! If I haven't an old woman
for my second-in-command! Come, Mr. Nelson, we must do something to
reassure these timid souls," and he went down the ladder to the cutter
that was waiting to row him ashore. Mr. Nelson followed--he was to
collect some breadfruit plants to replace several that had died during
the voyage--and the party, including the two chiefs, set out for the

This little scene had taken place before many of the ship's company, and
I could see that Christian had controlled his temper with difficulty. Mr.
Bligh had the unfortunate habit of making such humiliating remarks to his
officers, no matter who might be within hearing. It may be said in his
defense, perhaps, that, being a thick-skinned man, he had no conception
of how galling such remarks could be, particularly to a man like

As it chanced, nothing unusual happened that day. The fact that Mr. Bligh
had gone off with two of the chiefs was a guarantee that his party would
not be molested. Later in the day the natives came off to trade, bringing
the usual island produce pigs, fowls, coconuts, yams, and plantains. The
afternoon and the whole of the following day were given up to this
business, and the third morning the wood and watering parties were sent
ashore in Christian's charge. It was then that his distrust of the
Indians provec fully justified, for we had no sooner set foot on the
beach than they began to make trouble for us. Mr. Bligh had not refused
to send a guard with the ship's boats, but he had given strict orders
that the arms were not to be used. Hayward was in charge of the cutter
and I of the launcn, and Christian went with the shore parties. The
Indians thronged to the watering place, several hundred yards from the
beach. Every effort was made to keep them at a distance, but they became
increasingly bold as the work went on, and we had not been half an hour
ashore before several of the sailors, who were cutting wood, had had
their axes snatched from their hands. Christian performed his work
admirably, in the opinion of all the shore party, and it was thanks to
his coolness that we were not rushed and overwhelmed by the savages. They
outnumbered us fifty to one. We managed to get down our wood and water
without coming to a pitched battle, but when we were getting off, toward
sundown, they rushed us and managed to make off with the grapnel of the

When we arrived on board and our losses were reported by Christian,
Captain Bligh flew into a rage, cursing him in language that would have
been out of place had he been speaking to a common sailor.

"You are an incompetent cowardly rascal, sir! Damn me if you're not! Are
you afraid of a crowd of bloody savages whilst you have arms in your

"Of what service are they, sir, when you forbid their use?" Christian
asked quietly. Bligh ignored this question and continued to pour out such
a flood of abuse that Christian turned abruptly and left him, going down
to his cabin. When in one of his rages Bligh seemed insane. I had never
before met a man of this kind, and my conclusion was, having observed him
so often in this state, that he had little recollection, afterward, of
what he had said or done. I observed that he frequently worked himself
into these passions over matters for which he was really to blame. Being
unwilling to admit a fault in his own conduct, it seemed necessary to
convince himself, through anger, that the blame lay elsewhere.

Usually, after Bligh had given vent to a fit of this sort, we could
promise ourselves several days of calm, during which time he would have
little or nothing to say to us, but it chanced that the following day a
similar incident occurred which was to have the gravest consequences for
all of us. I am no believer in fate. Men's actions, in so far as their
relationships with one another are concerned, are largely under their own
control; but there are times when malicious powers seem to order our
small human affairs for their own amusement, and one of these occasions
must surely have been on the twenty-seventh day of April, in the year

We had sailed from Namuka on the evening of the twenty-sixth and, the
wind being light, had made but little progress during the night. All of
the following day we were within seven or eight leagues of the land. The
supplies we had received from the Indians were being stored away, and the
carpenters were making pens for the pigs and crates for the fowls not
intended for early use. Mr. Bligh had kept to his cabin all the morning,
but early in the afternoon he appeared on deck to give some instructions
to Mr. Samuel, who was in charge of the work of sorting over our
purchases at Namuka. A great many coconuts had been piled up on the
quarter-deck between the guns, and Bligh, who knew to the last ounce how
many yams we had purchased, and the exact number of coconuts, discovered
that a few of the latter were missing. He may have been told of this by
Samuel, but at any rate he knew it.

He ordered all the officers to come on deck immediately, and questioned
each of them as to the number of coconuts he had bought on his own
account, and whether or not he had seen any one of the men helping
himself to those on the quarter-deck. All denied having any such
knowledge, and Bligh, doubtless thinking that the officers were shielding
the men, became more and more angry. At length he came to Christian.

"Now, Mr. Christian, I wish to know the exact number of coconuts you
purchased for your own use."

"I really don't know, sir," Christian replied, "but I hope you don't
think me so mean as to be guilty of stealing yours?"

"Yes, you bloody hound! I _do_ think so! You must have stolen some
of mine or you would be able to give a better account of your own. You're
damned rascals and thieves, the lot of you! You'll be stealing my yams
next, or have the men steal them for you! But I'll make you suffer! I'll
teach you to steal, you dogs! I'll break the spirit of every man of you!
You'll wish you'd never seen me before we reach Endeavour Straits!"

Of all the humiliating scenes that had taken place up to that time, this
was the worst; and yet, considering the nature of the offense committed,
there was something meanly comic about it. Christian, however, could not
see this side of the matter, and small wonder that he could not. No other
captain in His Majesty's service would have made such an accusation
against his second-in-command, to say nothing of his other officers.
Bligh stamped up and down the quarter-deck, his face distorted with
passion, shaking his fists and shouting at us as though we were at the
other end of the ship. Of a sudden he stopped. "Mr. Samuel!"

"Yes, sir," said Samuel, stepping forward.

"You'll stop the villains' grog until further orders. And instead of a
pound of yams per man you'll issue half a pound to all the messes.

"Yes, sir."

"And, by God, I'll reduce you to a quarter of a pound if I find anything
else missing, and make you crawl on your bellies for that!" He then gave
orders that all of the coconuts, belonging to officers and men alike, be
carried aft to add to the ship's stores. When this had been done he
returned to his cabin.

I never remember the ship to have been more silent than she was that
evening. Most of us, doubtless, were thinking of the long voyage ahead.
Another year might pass before the _Bounty_ could reach England.
Meanwhile we should be under the heavy hand of a captain who could do
with us as he pleased; against whose tyranny there could be no appeal. My
own mess was particularly silent, for at this time Samuel was a member of
it, and we knew that anything we might say would be quickly carried to
Captain Bligh. Peckover ate his salt junk and, his half a pound of yams
in a few savage bites, and withdrew. The rest of us were not long in

Mr. Fryer's watch came on at eight o'clock. Most of the ship's company
were on deck during the early hours, owing to the fineness of the
evening. The breeze had been light all day and remained so; we had no
more than steerageway, but the air was refreshingly cool. The moon was in
its first quarter, and by its light we could dimly see, far ahead, the
outline of the island of Tofoa.

Between ten and eleven Bligh came on deck to leave his orders for the
night. He paced up and down the quarter-deck for some time, paying no
attention to anyone. Presently he stopped near Fryer, who ventured to
say: "Sir, I think we shall have a fine breeze by and by. This moon
coming on will be fortunate for us when we approach the coast of New

"Yes, Mr. Fryer, so it will," he replied. A few minutes later he gave his
orders as to the course to be steered, and returned to his cabin. Fryer's
prediction of wind was not to be fulfilled. At midnight, when our watch
went off duty, the sea was like a mill pond, with a glassy sheen upon the
water, reflecting the Southern constellations. Going below, I found it
much too hot for sleep. Tinkler and I came on deck together and stood for
a while by the rail aft, talking of home and what we would choose for our
first meal on shore. Presently, looking around cautiously, he said:
"Byam, do you know that I am a double-dyed villain? I stole one of Mr.
Bligh's missing coconuts."

"So it's you we have to thank for our dressing-down, you little rascal,"
I replied.

"Alas, yes. I'm one of the damned rogues and thieves. I could tell you
the names of two others, but I forbear. We were thirsty and too lazy to
go to the main top for the gun barrel. And there were the coco nuts, such
a tempting sight, a great heap of them between the guns on the
quarter-deck. I wish they were there now; I'd steal another. There's
nothing more refreshing than coconut water. Curse old Nelson's breadfruit
garden! It keeps a man thirsty all the time."

We were all, in fact, envious of our breadfruit plants. Whatever
happened, they had to be watered regularly, and in order to cut down the
amount drunk by the ship's company Bligh had thought of a very excellent
and ingenious arrangement to prevent us from quenching our thirst too
often. Any man who wanted a drink had first to climb to the main top to
fetch a gun barrel left there. He then climbed down with this to the
scuttle butt, outside the galley, inserted the gun barrel into the
bunghole, and, having sucked up his drink, he was required to carry the
drinking tube to the main top again. No man, no matter how thirsty he
might be, was permitted to make more than two of these gun-barrel climbs
during his watch, and a lazy man did without his drink until thirst got
the better of him.

"God be thanked! For once I wasn't suspected," Tinkler went on. "How do
you explain that? If he had asked me I should have denied, of course,
that I'd had anything to do with his rotten coconuts. But I'm afraid my
guilty conscience might have given me away this time. I was so damned
sorry for Christian."

"Did Christian know that you had taken some of the nuts?"

"Not some--only one, mind you! As I've told you, there were fellow
conspirators. Of course he did. In fact, he saw me do it and looked the
other way, as any decent officer was bound to do. It wasn't as though we
were endangering the safety of the vessel. Four coconuts missing, that's
all--I give you my word. Four out of how many thousands? And I was
responsible for only one. Well, if I sleep over my sins, perhaps they
won't seem so black to-morrow."

Tinkler was like the ship's cat; he could curl up anywhere for a nap. He
now lay down by one of the quarter-deck guns, with his arm for a pillow,
and, as I thought, was soon fast asleep.

It was then about one o'clock, and with the exception of the watch there
was no one on deck but Tinkler and myself. Mr. Peckover was standing at
the rail on the opposite side of the deck. I could make out his form
dimly in the starlight. Someone appeared at the after ladder-way. It was
Christian. After half a dozen turns up and down the deck, he observed me
standing between the guns.

"Oh, it's you, Byam?" He came and stood beside me, his elbows on the
rail. I had not seen him since the affair of the afternoon.

At length he asked, "Did you know that he had invited me to sup with him?
Why? Can you tell me that? After spitting on me, wiping his feet on me,
he sent Samuel to ask me to eat at his table!"

"You didn't go?"

"After what had happened? God in heaven, no!"

I had never before seen a man in a mood of such black despair. He seemed
at the last extremity of endurance. I was glad to be there, to be of
service as a confidant, for it was plain that he was in desperate need of
unburdening himself. That Bligh should have asked him to supper was, in
truth, all but incredible, after the events of the afternoon. I suggested
that it might be taken as evidence of an unsuspected delicacy of
conscience in Bligh, but I believed this no more than did Christian

"We're in his power. Officers and men alike, he considers us so many dogs
to be kicked or fondled according to his whim. And there can be no
relief. None. Not till we reach England. God knows when that will be!"

He was silent for some time, staring gloomily out over the starlit sea.
At length he said, "Byam, there's something I wish you would do for me."

"What is it?"

"The chances are there'll be no occasion, but on a long voyage like this
one never knows what may happen. If, for any reason, I should fail to
reach home, I'd like you to see my people in Cumberland. Would that be
too much trouble for you?"

"Not at all," I replied.

"During the last conversation I had with my father, just before I joined
the ship, he asked that I make such an arrangement with someone aboard
the _Bounty_. In case anything should happen, he said that it would
be a comfort to him to talk with one of my friends. I promised, and I've
let half the voyage pass without fulfilling it. I feel better now that I
have spoken."

"You can count on me," I said, shaking his hand.

"Good! That's settled, then."

"Well, Mr. Christian! You're up late."

We turned quickly to find Bligh standing a yard away. He was barefoot and
dressed only in his shirt and trousers. Neither of us had heard him

"Yes, sir," Christian replied, coldly.

"And you, Mr. Byam. Can't you sleep?"

"It's very warm below, sir."

"I hadn't noticed it. A true sailor can sleep in an oven if the case
requires. Or on a cake of ice."

He stood there for a moment as though expecting us to make some reply;
then he turned abruptly and walked to the ladderway, halting to glance at
the trim of the sails before going below again. Christian and I talked in
desultory fashion for a brief time; then he bade me good-night and went
forward somewhere.

Tinkler, who had been lying in deep shadow by one of the guns, sat up and
stretched his arms with a deep yawn.

"Go below, Byam, and show that you are a true seaman. Damn you and
Christian and your gabble! I was just getting drowsy when he came along."

"Did you hear what he said?" I asked.

"About notifying his father in case anything happened? Yes; I couldn't
help eavesdropping. My father made no such request of me--which only goes
to show that he has no hope of my not coming back. I must have a drink.
I've been thinking of nothing but water this past hour, and I'm not
entitled to one before morning. What would you do, in my case?"

"Mr. Peckover has just gone below for a moment," I said. "You might
chance it."

"Has he?" Tinkler leaped to his feet. He ran up the shrouds for the gun
barrel and had carried it aloft again before Peckover returned. As we
went below together I heard three bells strike, and the far-off call of
the lookout in the foretop: "All's well!" I settled myself in my hammock
and was soon asleep.


Shortly after daybreak I was awakened by someone shaking me roughly by
the shoulder, and at the same time I was aware of loud voices, Mr.
Bligh's among them, and the heavy trampling of feet on deck. Churchill,
the master-at-arms, stood by my hammock with a pistol in his hand, and I
saw Thompson, holding a musket with the bayonet fixed, stationed by the
arms chest which stood on the gratings of the main hatch: At the same
time two men, whose names I do not remember, rushed into the berth, and
one of them shouted, "We're with you, Churchill! Give us arms!" They were
furnished with muskets by Thompson and hurried on deck again. Stewart,
whose hammock was next to mine in the larboard berth, was already up and
dressing in great haste. Despite the confused tumult of voices overhead,
Young was still asleep.

"Have we been attacked, Churchill?" I asked; for my first thought was
that the _Bounty_ must have drifted close to one of the islands
thereabout, and that we had been boarded by the savages.

"Put on your clothes and lose no time about it, Mr. Byam," he replied.
"We have taken the ship and Captain Bligh is a prisoner."

Aroused suddenly from the deepest slumber, I did not even then grasp the
meaning of what he said, and for a moment sat gazing stupidly at him.

"They've mutinied, Byam!" said Stewart. "Good God, Churchill! Are you
mad? Have you any conception of what you're doing?"

"We know very well what we're doing," he replied. "Bligh has brought all
this on himself. Now, by God, we'll make him suffer!" Thompson shook his
musket in menacing fashion. "We're going to shoot the dog!" he said; "and
don't you try any of your young gentlemen's tricks on us, or we'll murder
some more of you! Seize 'em up, Churchill! They're not to be trusted."

"Hold your tongue and mind the arms chest," Churchill replied. "Come, Mr.
Byam, hurry into your clothes. Quintal, stand fast by the door there! No
one's to come forward without my orders--understand?"

"Aye, aye, sir!"

Turning my head, I saw Matthew Quintal at the rear entrance to the berth.
Even as I looked, Samuel appeared behind him, dressed only in his
trousers, his thin hair standing awry and his pale face considerably
paler than its wont. "Mr. Churchill!" he called.

"Go back, you fat swine, or I'll run you through the guts!" Quintal

"Mr. Churchill, sir! Allow me to speak to you," Samuel called again.

"Drive him back," Churchill said, and Quintal made so fierce a gesture
with his musket that Samuel vanished without waiting to hear more. "Give
him a prod in the backside, Quintal," someone shouted, and, looking up, I
saw two more armed men leaning over the hatchway.

Without weapons of any sort, there was nothing that Stewart and I could
do but obey Churchill's orders. Both he and Thompson were powerful men
and we should have been no match for them even had they been unarmed. I
immediately thought of. Christian, a man as quick in action as in
decision, but I knew there could be no hope of his still being at
liberty. He was the officer of the morning watch and had doubtless been
rushed and overwhelmed at the very outset of the mutiny, even before
Bligh had been secured. Catching my eye, Stewart shook his head slightly,
as much as to say, "It's useless. There's nothing to be done."

We dressed in short order, and Churchill then ordered us to precede him
along the passage to the fore ladderway. "Keep the others in the berth,
Thompson," he called back. "Leave 'em to me; I'll mind 'em!" Thompson
replied. There were several armed guards at the fore-hatch, among them
Alexander Smith, my hammock man, whose loyalty in whatever situation I
should have thought unquestionable. It was a shock to see him in
Churchill's party, but the scene that presented itself as we came on deck
made me forget the very existence of Smith.

Captain Bligh, naked except for his shirt, and with his hands tied behind
his back, was standing by the mizzenmast. Christian stood before him,
holding in one hand the end of the line by which Bligh was bound and in
the other a bayonet, and around them were several of the able seamen,
fully armed, among whom I recognized John Mills, Isaac Martin, Richard
Skinner, and Thomas Burkitt. Churchill then said to us, "Stand by here.
We mean no harm to either of you unless you take part against us." He
then left us.

Stewart and I had taken it for granted that Churchill was the ringleader
of the mutineers. As already related, after his attempted desertion at
Tahiti he had been severely punished by Bligh. I knew how deeply he hated
him, and it was conceivable that such a man could goad himself even to
the point of mutiny. But that Christian could have done so, no matter
what the provocation, was beyond anything I could have dreamed of as
possible. Stewart's only comment was, "Christian! Good God! Then there's
no hope."

The situation looked hopeless indeed. At this time the only unarmed men I
saw on deck were Captain Bligh and ourselves. The ship was entirely in
the hands of the mutineers. Evidently we had been brought up to divide
the party of midshipmen below, thus preventing any opportunity for our
taking concerted action. In the confusion we made our way aft a little
way, and as we approached the spot where Bligh was standing, I heard
Christian say, "Will you hold your tongue, sir, or shall I force you to
hold it? I'm master of this ship now, and, by God, I'll stand no more of
your abuse!" Sweat was pouring down Bligh's face. He had been making a
great outcry, shouting, "Murder! Treason!" at the top of his voice.

"Master of my ship, you mutinous dog!" he yelled. "I'll see you hung!
I'll have you flogged to ribbons! I'll..."

"_Mamu_, sir! Hold your tongue or you are dead this instant!"

Christian placed the point of his bayonet at Bligh's throat with a look
in his eye there was no mistaking. "Slit the dog's gullet!" someone
shouted; and there were cries of "Let him have it, Mr. Christian!"

"Throw him overboard!"

"Feed the bastard to the sharks!" and the like. It was only then, I
think, that Captain Bligh realized his true situation. He stood for a
moment breathing hard, looking about him with an expression of
incredulity on his face.

"Mr. Christian, allow me to speak!" he begged hoarsely. "Think what you
do! Release me--lay aside your arms! Let us be friends again, and I give
you my word that nothing more shall be said of this matter."

"Your word is of no value, sir," Christian replied. "Had you been a man
of honour things would never have come to this pass."

"What do you mean to do with me?"

"Shoot you, you bloody rogue!" cried Burkitt, shaking his musket at him.

"Shooting's too good for him! Seize him up at the gratings, Mr.
Christian! Give us a chance at him with the cat!"

"That's it! Seize him up! Give him a taste of his own poison!"

"Flay the hide off him!"

"Silence!" Christian called, sternly; and then, to Bligh: "We'll give you
justice, sir, which is more than you have ever given us. We'll take you
in irons to England..."

A dozen protesting voices interrupted him.

"To England? Never! We won't have it, Mr. Christian!"

Immediately the deck was again in an uproar, all the mutineers clamouring
against Christian's proposal. Never was the situation with respect to
Bligh so critical as at that moment, and it was to his credit that he
showed no sign of flinching. The men were in a savage mood, and it was
touch and go as to whether he would be shot where he stood; but he glared
at each of them in turn as though challenging them to do so. Luckily a
diversion was created when Ellison came dashing up flourishing a bayonet.
There was no real harm in this lad, but he loved mischief better than his
dinner, and, being thoughtless and high-spirited, he could be counted
upon to get himself into trouble whenever the opportunity presented
itself. Evidently he considered joining in a mutiny nothing more than a
fine lark, and he now came dancing up to Bligh with such a comical
expression upon his face that the tension was relieved at once. The men
broke into cheers. "Hooray, Tommy! Are you with us, lad?"

"Let me guard him, Mr. Christian!" he cried. "I'll watch him like a cat!"
He skipped up and down in front of Bligh, brandishing his weapon. "Oh,
you rogue! You old villain! You'd flog us, would you? You'd stop our
grog, would you? You'd make us eat grass, would you?"

The men cheered him wildly. "Lay on, lad!" they shouted. "We'll back you!
Give him a jab in the guts!"

"You and your Mr. Samuel! A pair of swindlers, that's what you are!
Cheating us out of our food! You've made a pretty penny between you! You
old thief! You should be a bumboat man. I'll lay you'd make your fortune
in no time!"

It was a bitter experience for Bligh to be baited thus by the least of
his seamen, but as a matter of fact nothing more fortunate for him could
have happened. His life at that moment hung in the balance, and Ellison,
in giving vent to his feelings, relieved the pent-up emotions of men who
were not glib of speech and could express their hatred of Bligh only in
action. Christian realized this, I think, and permitted Ellison to speak
his mind, but he soon cut him short and put him in his place.

"Clear the cutter!" he called. "Mr. Churchill!"

"Aye, aye, sir!"

"Fetch up Mr. Fryer and Mr. Purcell! Burkitt!"

"Here, sir!"

"You and Sumner and. Mills and Martin--stand guard here over Mr. Blight"

Burkitt took the end of the line in one of his huge hairy fists. "We'll
mind him, sir! I'll lay to that!"

"What's your plan, Mr. Christian? We've a right to know," said Sumner.
Christian turned quickly and looked at him. "Mind what you're about,
Sumner!" he said quietly. "I'm master of this ship! Lively, men, with the

Several men climbed into the boat to clear out the yams, sweet potatoes,
and other ship's stores which were kept there, while others unlashed it
and got ready the tackle for hoisting it over the side. Burkitt stood
directly in front of Captain Bligh, holding the point of a bayonet within
an inch of his breast. Sumner stood behind him with his musket at ready,
and the other men on either side. Thompson excepted, they were the
hardest characters among the sailors, and Bligh wisely said nothing to
arouse them further. Others of the mutineers were stationed about the
decks, and there were three at each of the ladderways. I wondered how the
affair had been so well and secretly planned. I searched my memory, but
could recall no incident of a character in the least suspicious.

I had been so intent in watching the scene of which Bligh was the centre
that I had forgotten Stewart. We had become separated, and while I was
searching for him Christian saw me for the first time. He came at once to
where I was standing. His voice was calm, but I could see that he was
labouring under great excitement.

"Byam, this is my affair," he said. "Not a man shall be hurt, but if any
take part against us it will be at the peril of the entire ship's
company. Act as you think best."

"What do you mean to do?" I asked.

"I would have carried Bligh to England as a prisoner. That is impossible;
the men won't have it. He shall have the cutter to go where he chooses.
Mr. Fryer, Hayward, Hallet, and Samuel shall go with him."

There was no time for further talk. Churchill came up with the master and
Purcell. The carpenter, as usual, was surly and taciturn. Both he and
Fryer were horror-stricken at what had happened, but they were entirely
self-possessed. Christian well knew that these two men would seize the
first opportunity, if one presented itself, for retaking the ship, and he
had them well guarded.

"Mr. Byam, surely you are not concerned in this?" Fryer asked. "No more
than yourself, sir," I replied.

"Mr. Byam has nothing to do with it," said Christian. "Mr. Purcell..."

Fryer interrupted him.

"In God's name, Mr. Christian! What is it you do? Do you realize that
this means the ruin of everything? Give up this madness, and I promise
that we shall all make your interest our own. Only let us reach

"It is too late, Mr. Fryer," he replied, coldly. "I have been in hell for
weeks past, and I mean to stand it no longer."

"Your difficulties with Captain Bligh give you no right to bring ruin
upon the rest of us."

"Hold your tongue, sir," said Christian. "Mr. Purcell, have your men
fetch up the thwarts, knees, and gear bolts for the large cutter.
Churchill, let the carpenter go below to see to this. Send a guard with

Purcell and Churchill went down the forward ladderway. "Do you mean to
set us adrift?" Fryer asked.

"We are no more than nine leagues from the land here," Christian replied.
"In so calm a sea Mr. Bligh will have no difficulty in making it."

"I will stay with the ship."

"No, Mr. Fryer; you will go with Captain Bligh. Williams! Take the master
to his cabin while he collects his clothes. He is to be kept there until
I send word."

Fryer requested earnestly to be allowed to remain with the vessel, but
Christian well knew his reason for desiring this and would not hear to
the proposal. He put an end to the matter by sending the master below.

Purcell now returned, followed by Norman and McIntosh, his mates,
carrying the gear for the cutter. Purcell came up to me at once.

"Mr. Byam, I know that you have no hand in this business. But you are, or
have been, a friend to Mr. Christian. Beg him to give Captain Bligh the
launch. The cutter is rotten and will never swim to the land."

This, I knew, was the case. The cutter was riddled with worms and leaked
so badly as to be almost useless. The carpenters were to have started
repairing her that same morning. Purcell would not come with me to speak
of the matter, giving as a reason Christian's dislike of him. "He would
not care to grant any request of mine," he said. "If the cutter is
hoisted out, it will be almost certain death for Captain Bligh and all
who are permitted to go with him."

I wasted no time, but went to Christian at once. Several of the mutineers
gathered round to hear what I had to say. Christian agreed at once. "He
shall have the launch," he said. "Tell the carpenter to have his men fit
her." He then called, "Leave off with the cutter, my lads! Clear the

There were immediate protests, led by Churchill, against this new

"The launch, Mr. Christian?"

"Don't let him have it, sir! The old fox'll get home in her!"

"She's too bloody good for him!"

There was an argument over the matter, but Christian forced his will upon
the others. In fact, they made no determined stand. All were eager to be
rid of the captain, and they had little reason to fear that he would ever
see England again.

The mutineers were in such complete control of the situation that
Christian now gave orders for the rest of those who were not of his party
to be brought on deck. Samuel, Bligh's clerk, was among the first to
appear. He was anything but a favourite with the ship's cormpany, and was
greeted with jeers and threats by his particular enemies. I had supposed
that he would make a poor showing in such a situation. On the contrary,
he acted with spirit and determination. Disregarding the insults of the
sailors, he went directly to Captain Bligh to receive his orders. He was
permitted to go to Bligh's cabin with John Smith, the captain's servant,
to fetch up his clothes. They helped him on with his boots and trousers
and laid his coat over his shoulders.

I saw Hayward and Hallet standing aft by the rail. Hallet was crying, and
both of them were in a state of great alarm. Someone touched my shoulder
and I found Mr. Nelson standing beside me.

"Well, Byam, I'm afraid that we're even farther from home than we
thought. Do you know what they plan to do with us?"

I told him the little I knew. He smiled ruefully, glancing toward the
island of Tofoa, now a faint blur on the horizon.

"I suppose that Captain Bligh will take us there," he said. "I don't much
relish the prospect of meeting any more Friendly Islanders. Their
friendliness is of a kind that we can well dispense with."

The carpenter appeared at the ladderway, followed by Robert Lamb, the
butcher, who was helping to bring up his tool chest.

"Mr. Nelson," he said, "we know whom we have to thank for this."

"Yes, Mr. Purcell, our unlucky stars," Nelson replied.

"No, sir! We have Captain Bligh to thank for it, and him alone! He has
brought it upon us all by his damnable behaviour!"

Purcell had the deepest hatred for Bligh, which was returned with
interest. The two men had not spoken for months save when absolutely
necessary. Nevertheless, when Mr. Nelson suggested that he might be
permitted to stay with the ship if he chose, the carpenter was horrified.

"Stop aboard? With rogues and pirates? Never, sir! I shall follow my

At this moment Churchill, who was everywhere about the decks, caught
sight of us.

"What are you about there, Purcell? Damn your blood! You'd steal our
tools, would you?"

"Your tools, you scoundrel? They're mine, and they go where I go!"

"You shan't take a nail from the ship if I have my way," Churchill
replied. He then called out to Christian, and there was another argument,
not only with respect to the tool chest, but as to the carpenter himself.
Christian was partly in the mind to keep him on the vessel, knowing his
value as a craftsman, but all the others urged against it. Purcell had a
violent temper and was regarded by the men as a tyrant second only to

"He's a damned old villain, sir!"

"Keep the carpenter's mates, Mr. Christian. They're the men for us.

"Make him go in the boat!"

"Make me go, you pirates?" he cried. "I'd like to see the man who'll
_stop_ me!"

Unfortunately, Purcell was as thick-headed as he was fearless, and he now
so far forgot the interests of Bligh's party as to boast of what we would
do as soon as we should be clear of the mutineers.

"Mark my word, you rogues! We'll bring every man of you to justice! We'll
build a vessel to carry us home..."

"So he will, Mr. Christian, if we give him his tools," several men

"The old fox could build a ship with a clasp knife!"

Purcell realized too late what he had done. I believe that Christian
would have given him many of his tools, of which there were duplicates on
board, but having been reminded of what he might do with them, he now
ordered the tool chest to be examined, and Purcell was permitted to have
nothing but a hand saw, a small axe, a hammer, and a bag of nails. Bligh,
who had overheard all that was said, could contain himself no longer.
"You infernal idiot!" he roared at Purcell, and was prevented from saying
more by Burkitt, who placed a bayonet at his throat.

The decks were now filled with people, but Christian took good care that
those not of his party should be prevented from coming together in any
numbers. As soon as the launch had been cleared, he ordered the boatswain
to swing her out. "And mind yourself, Mr. Cole! If you spring a yard or
carry anything away it will go hard with you!" Fifteen or more of us were
ordered to assist him, for the mutineers were too canny to lay aside
their arms and bear a hand.

"Foresail and mainsail there! All ready?"

"Aye, aye, sir!"

"Let go sheets and tacks!"

"All clear, sir!"

"Clew garnets--up with the clews!"

The breeze was still so light as barely to fill the sails, and the dews
of the mainsail and foresail went smoothly up to the quarters of the
yards. The yards were now squared and the braces made fast, and with half
a dozen men holding the launch inboard she was hoisted, swung out over
the bulwarks, and lowered away.

One of the first men ordered into her was Samuel. Hayward and Hallet
followed next. Both were shedding tears and crying for mercy, and they
were half carried to the gangway. Hayward turned to Christian, clasping
his hands imploringly.

"Mr. Christian, what have I ever done that you should treat me so?" he
exclaimed. "In God's name, permit me to stay with the ship!"

"We can dispense with your services here," Christian replied, grimly.
"Into the boat, the pair of you!"

Purcell went next. He required no urging. I think he would have died
rather than remain in the ship now that she had been seized by mutineers.
His few tools were handed down to him by the boatswain, who followed.
Christian ordered Bligh to be brought to the gangway, and his hands were

"Now, Mr. Bligh, there is your boat, and you are fortunate to have the
launch and not the cutter. Go into her at once, sir!"

"Mr. Christian," said Bligh, "for the last time I beg you to reflect!
I'll pawn my honour--I pledge you my word never to think of this again if
you will desist. Consider my wife and family!"

"No, Mr. Bligh. You should have thought of your family long before this,
and we well know what your honour is worth. Go into the boat, sir!"

Seeing that all pleading was useless, Bligh obeyed, and was followed by
Mr. Peckover and Norton, the quartermaster. Christian then handed down a
sextant and a book of nautical tables.

"You have your compass, sir. This book is sufficient for every purpose,
and the sextant is my own. You know it to be a good one." With his hands
freed and once more in command, though only of his ship's launch, Bligh
became his old self again.

"I know you to be a bloody scoundrel!" he shouted, shaking his fist in
Christian's direction. "But I'll have vengeance! Mind that, you
ungrateful villain! I'll see you swinging at a yardarm before two years
have passed! And every traitor with you!"

Fortunately for Bligh, Christian's attention was engaged elsewhere, but
several of the mutineers at the bulwarks replied to him in language as
forceful as the captain's, and it was a near thing that he was not fired

In the confusion I had lost sight of Stewart. We had been hauling
together at one of the braces when the launch was hoisted out, but now I
could find him nowhere. It soon became clear that many were to be allowed
to go with Bligh, and Mr. Nelson and I, who had been standing together by
the bulwarks, were hastening toward the after ladderway when we were
stopped by Christian.

"Mr. Nelson, you and Mr. Byam may stay with the ship if you choose," he

"I have sympathy with you for the wrongs you have suffered, Mr.
Christian," Nelson replied, "but none whatever with this action to
redress them."

"And when have I asked you for sympathy, sir? Mr. Byam, what is your

"I shall go with Captain Bligh."

"Then make haste, both of you."

"Have we permission to fetch our clothes?" Nelson asked. "Yes, but look

Nelson's cabin was on the orlop deck directly below that of Fryer. Two
guards stood by the ladderway on the lower deck. We parted there and I
went to the midshipmen's berth, where Thompson was still on guard over
the arms chest. I had seen nothing of Tinkler and Elphinstone, and was
about to look into the starboard berth to see if they were still there.
Thompson prevented me.

"Never you mind the starboard berth," he said. "Get your clothes and
clear out!"

The berth was screened off from the main hatchway by a canvas-covered
framework. To my surprise, I found Young still asleep in his hammock. He
had been on watch from twelve to four, and this was his customary time
for rest, but it was strange that he could have slept through such a
turmoil. I tried to rouse him, but he was a notoriously heavy sleeper.
Finding the matter hopeless, I left off and began to ransack my chest for
things I should most need. Stacked in the corner of the berth were
several Friendly Island war clubs that we had obtained from the savages
of Namuka. They had been carved from the toa, or ironwood tree, which
well deserved its name, for in weight and texture the wood was indeed
like iron. At the sight of them the thought flashed into my mind, "Could
I strike Thompson down with one of these?" I glanced quickly out the
doorway. Thompson was now seated on the arms chest with his musket
between his knees, facing the passageway leading aft. But he saw me
thrust out my head and, with an oath, ordered me to "look sharp and clear
out of there."

At this moment Morrison came along the passageway, and as luck would have
it Thompson's attention was attracted by someone calling him from above.
I beckoned Morrison into the berth, and he dodged in without having been
seen. There was no need for words. I handed him one of the war clubs and
took another for myself; then, together, we made a last effort to waken
Young. Not daring to speak, we nearly shook him out of his hammock, but
we might have spared ourselves the trouble. I heard Thompson call out,
"He's getting his clothes, sir. I'll have him up at once." Morrison drew
back by the door and raised his club, and I stood at ready on the other
side, for we both expected Thompson to come in for me. Instead of that he
shouted, "Out of there, Byam, and be quick about it!"

"I'm coming," I called, and again looked out of the doorway. My heart
sank as I saw Burkitt and McCoy coming along from the fore hatchway. They
stopped by the arms chest to speak to Thompson. Both had muskets, of
course. Our chance to get at Thompson and the arms chest was lost unless
they should pass on. Fortune was against us. We waited for at least two
minutes longer and the men remained where they were. I heard Nelson's
voice calling down the hatchway: "Byam! Lively there, lad, or you'll be
left behind!" And Tinkler's: "For God's sake, hasten, Byam!"

It was a bitter moment for Morrison and me. The opportunity had been a
poor one at best, but had there been time something might have come of
it. We quickly put the war clubs aside and rushed out, colliding with
Thompson, who was coming to see what I was about.

"Damn your blood, Morrison! What are you doing here?"

We didn't wait to explain, but ran along the passage to the ladder-way.
Morrison preceded me, and in my haste to reach the deck, cumbered as I
was with my bag of clothes, I slipped and fell halfway down the ladder,
giving my shoulder a wrench as I struck the gratings. I clambered up
again and was rushing toward the gangway when Churchill seized me.
"You're too late, Byam," he said. "You can't go." "Can't go? By God, I
_will!_" I exclaimed, giving him a shove which loosened his hold and
all but toppled him over. I was frantic, for I saw the launch being
veered astern, one of the mutineers carrying the painter aft. Burkitt and
Quintal were holding Coleman, the armourer, who was begging to go into
the boat, and Morrison was struggling with several men who were keeping
him back from the gangway. We were, in fact, too late; the launch was
loaded almost to the point of foundering, and I heard Bligh shouting: "I
can take no more of you, lads! I'll do you justice if ever we reach

When the launch had drifted astern, the man holding the painter took a
turn with it around the rail and threw the free end to someone in the
boat. Those left in the ship now crowded along the rail, and I had
difficulty in finding a place where I could look over the side. I was
sick at heart, and appalled at the realization that I was, indeed, to be
left behind among the mutineers. Norton was in the bow of the launch
holding the end of the painter. Bligh was standing on a thwart, astern.
Of the others, some were seated and some were standing, and the boat was
so heavily loaded as to have no more than seven or eight inches of
freeboard. There was a great deal of shouting back and forth, and Bligh
was contributing his full share to the tumult by bellowing out orders to
those in the boat, and curses and imprecations against Christian and his

Some of the mutineers looked on silently and thoughtfully, but others
were jeering at Bligh, and I heard one of them shout: "Go and see if you
can live on half a pound of yams a day, you bloody villain!" Fryer called
out, "In God's name, Mr. Christian, give us arms and ammunition! Think
where we go! Let us have a chance to defend our lives!" Others, the
boatswain among them, joined earnestly in this plea.

"Arms be damned!" someone shouted back.

"You don't need 'em."

"Old Bligh loves the savages. He'll take care of you!"

"Use your rattan on 'em, boatswain!"

Coleman and I sought out Christian, who was standing by one of the cabin
gratings, out of sight of the launch. We begged him to let Bligh have
some muskets and ammunition.

"Never!" he said. "They shall have no firearms."

"Then give them some cutlasses at least, Mr. Christian," Coleman urged,
"unless you wish them to be murdered the moment they set foot on shore.
Think of our experience at Namuka!"

Christian consented to this. He ordered Churchill to fetch some cutlasses
from the arms chest, and a moment later he returned with four, which were
handed into the boat. Meanwhile, Morrison had taken advantage of this
opportunity to run below for some additional provisions for the launch.
He and John Millward brought up a mess kid filled with pieces of salt
pork, several calabashes of water, and some additional bottles of wine
and spirits, which they lowered into the boat.

"You cowards!" Purcell shouted, as the cutlasses were handed in. "Will
you give us nothing but these?"

"Shall we lower the arms chest, carpenter?" Isaac Martin asked,
jeeringly. McCoy threatened him with his musket. "You'll get a bellyful
of lead in a minute," he shouted.

"Bear off and turn one of the swivels on 'em!" someone else called. "Give
'em a whiff of grape!"

Burkitt now raised his musket and pointed it at Bligh. Alexander Smith,
who was standing beside him, seized the barrel of the musket and thrust
it up. I am convinced that Burkitt meant to shoot Bligh, but Christian,
observing this, ordered him to be dragged back, deprived of his arms, and
placed under guard. He made a terrific struggle, and it required four men
to disarm him.

Meanwhile, Fryer and others were urging Bligh to cast off lest they
should all be murdered. This Bligh now ordered to be done, and the launch
dropped slowly astern. The oars were gotten out, and the boat, so low in
the water that she seemed on the point of foundering, was headed toward
the island of Tofoa, which bore northeast, about ten leagues distant.
Twelve men made a good load for the launch. She now carried nineteen, to
say nothing of the food and water and the gear of the men.

"Thank God we were too late to go with her, Byam!"

Morrison was standing beside me.

"Do you mean that?" I asked.

He was silent for a moment, as though considering the matter carefully.
Then he said, "No, I don't. I would willingly have taken my chance in
her--but it's a slim chance indeed. They'll never see England again."

Tinkler was sitting on a thwart. Mr. Nelson, and Peckover, Norton,
Elphinstone, the master's mate, Ledward, the acting surgeon all were as
good as dead, more than a thousand miles from any port where they might
expect help. About them were islands filled with the cruelest of savages,
who could be held at bay only by men well armed. Granted that some might
escape death at the hands of the Indians, what chance had so tiny a boat,
so appallingly loaded, to reach any civilized port? The possibility was
so remote as to be not worth considering.

Sick at heart, I turned away from the sight of the frail craft, looking
so small, so helpless, on that great waste of waters. There had been a
cheer from some of the mutineers: "Huzza for Tahiti!" as Christian had
ordered, "Get sail on her!" Ellison, McCoy, and Williams had run aloft to
loose the fore-topgallant sail. Afterward a silence had fallen over the
ship, and the men stood by the bulwarks, gazing at the launch growing
smaller and smaller as we drew away from her. Christian, too, was
watching, standing where I had last seen him, by the cabin grating. What
his thoughts were at this time it would be impossible to say. His sense
of the wrongs he had suffered at Bligh's hands was so deep and
overpowering as to dominate, I believe, every other feeling. In the
course of a long life I have met no others of his kind. I knew him, I
suppose, as well as anyone could be said to know him, and yet I never
felt that I truly understood the workings of his mind and heart. Men of
such passionate nature, when goaded by injustice into action, lose all
sense of anything save their own misery. They neither know nor care,
until it is too late, what ruin they make of the lives of others.

It was getting on toward eight o'clock when the launch had been cast off.
Shortly afterward the breeze, from the northeast, freshened, and the
_Bounty_ gathered way quietly, slipping through the water with a
slight hiss of foam. The launch became a mere speck, seen momentarily as
she rose to the swell or as the sunlight flashed from her oars. Within
half an hour she had vanished as though swallowed up by the sea. Our
course was west-northwest.


Our company was divided, and, though linked together by a common
disaster, we were not to share a common fate. I doubt whether a ship has
ever sailed from England whose numbers, during the course of her voyage,
were to be so widely scattered over the face of the earth, and whose
individual members were to meet ends so strange and, in many cases, so

There had gone with Bligh, in the launch:

John Fryer, _Master_
Thomas Ledward, _Acting Surgeon_
David Nelson, _Botanist_
William Peckover, _Gunner_
William Cole, _Boatswain_
William Elphinstone, _Master's Mate_
William Purcell, _Carpenter_

Thomas Hayward
John Hallet
Robert Tinkler

John Norton
Peter Lenkletter

George Simpson, _Quartermaster's Mate_
Lawrence Lebogue, _Sailmaker_
Mr. Samuel, _Clerk_
Robert Lamb, _Butcher_

John Smith
Thomas Hall

Of those who remained in the _Bounty_, the following had taken an
active part in the mutiny:

Fletcher Christian, _Acting Lieutenant_
John Mills, _Gunner's Mate_
Charles Churchill, _Master-at-Arms_
William Brown, _Gardener_

_Able Seamen:_
Thomas Burkitt
Matthew Quintal
John Sumner
John Millward
William McCoy
Henry Hillbrandt
Alexander Smith
John Williams
Thomas Ellison
Isaac Martin
Richard Skinner
Matthew Thompson

Those in the _Bounty_ with, but not of, Christian's party, were:

Edward Young
George Stewart

James Morrison, _Boatswain's Mate_
Joseph Coleman, _Armourer_
Charles Norman, _Carpenter's Mate_
Thomas McIntosh, _Carpenter's Crew_
William Muspratt, _Able Seaman_

Also Michael Byrne, the half-blind seaman, and myself. William Muspratt
had, for a moment, pretended to be of the mutineers' party and lad
accepted a musket offered to him by Churchill. He had overheard Fryer say
that he hoped to form a party to retake the vessel, and I am certain he
had taken the musket for no other reason than to assist Fryer. When he
saw that the matter was hopeless, he immediately laid aside his arms.
Coleman, Norman, and McIntosh had been prevented From going in the launch
because the mutineers had need of their services as artificers. Smiths
and carpenters can no more be dispensed with on a ship at sea than can
seamen themselves.

It was but natural that those who had taken no part in the mutiny should
be looked upon with suspicion by those who had. Most of the seamen,
however, showed no active hostility against us. Churchill ordered us to
remain on deck, but forward of the mizzenmast, and there we awaited
Christian's pleasure. Burkitt, who had been deprived of his musket and
placed under arms, lest he should shoot Captain Bligh, was again set at
liberty. He and Thompson now began baiting and jeering at us, and McCoy
and John Williams joined with them. For a moment it seemed likely that
there would be a pitched battle between us, and there is no doubt that
the non-mutineers would have had the worst of it. Fortunately for us,
Christian soon restored order. He came forward, his eyes blazing with

"Get about your work, Thompson," he ordered. "Burkitt, if I have any more
trouble from you, I'll put you in irons and keep you there!"

"That's how it is to be, is it?" Thompson replied. "Well, we won't have
it, Mr. Christian. We ain't mutinied to have you come the Captain Bligh
over us!"

"No, by God, we haven't!" Martin added; "and that you'll find!"

Christian looked at them for a moment without speaking, and there was
that in his eyes to relieve any apprehensions one might have had as to
his ability to cope with the situation. The four turbulent men dropped
their glances sullenly. Several of the seamen were standing by, Alexander
Smith among them. "Order all hands aft, Smith," said Christian. He
returned to the quarter-deck and paced up and down while the men
collected. Then he turned and faced them.

"There is one matter we will decide once for all," he began, quietly,
"and that is who is to be captain of this ship. I have taken her with
your help, in order to be rid of a tyrant who has made life a burden to
all of us. Make no mistake about our status from this time on. We are
mutineers, and if we should be discovered and taken by one of His
Majesty's vessels, not a man of us but will suffer death. That
possibility is not so remote as some of you may think. Should Mr. Bligh
succeed in reaching England, immediately upon his arrival there a ship of
war will be sent in search of us. Should the _Bounty_ not be
reported in a year's time, or, at the latest, two years, a ship will be
sent, nevertheless, to discover, if possible, the reason for her
disappearance. Bear this in mind, all of you. We are not only mutineers
but pirates as well, for we have run away with one of His Majesty's armed
vessels. We are cut off from England forever, except as prisoners whose
fate, if taken home, is certain.

"The Pacific is wide, and still so little known that we need never be
taken except as the result of our own folly. In our situation a leader is
essential, one whose will is to be obeyed without question. It should be
needless to tell British seamen that no ship, whether manned by mutineers
or not, can be handled without discipline. If I am to command the
_Bounty_ I mean to be obeyed. There shall be no injustice here. I
shall punish no man without good cause, but I will have no man question
my authority.

"I am willing that you shall decide who is to command the _Bounty_.
If there is some man most of you prefer in my place, name him, and I will
resign my authority. If you wish me to lead you, mind what I have said. I
mean to be obeyed."

Churchill was the first to speak. "Well, men, what have you to say?"

"I'm for Mr. Christian!" Smith called out.

There was an immediate hearty agreement with Smith on the part of all the
mutineers with the exception of Thompson and Martin; but when Christian
called for a show of hands, even these two raised theirs with the others.

"We have another matter to decide," Christian went on. "There are a
number of men with us who took no part in seizing the vessel. They would
have gone with Mr. Bligh had opportunity permitted..."

"Put 'em in irons, sir," Mills called out. "They'll do us a mischief if
they can."

"On this ship, there shall be no putting of anyone in irons without good
cause," Christian replied. "These men are not to be blamed for taking no
part with us. They decided as seemed best to them, and I respect their
decisions; but I shall know how to act if they show toward us any sign of
treachery. It is for them to decide now what their treatment with us
shall be."

He then called each of us in turn, beginning with Young, and asked
whether he could count upon our cooperation, as members of the ship's
company, so long as we remained in the _Bounty_. Young decided, then
and there, to throw in his lot with the mutineers.

"Chance has decided this matter for me, Mr. Christian," he said. "I will
not say that I would have helped you take the ship had I been awake at
the time of the mutiny, but now that you have taken her, I am content
that it should be so. I have no great desire to see England again.
Wherever you may go you can count on me to go with you."

Of the neutral party, he was alone in this decision.. The rest of us
promised to obey orders, to assist in every way in working the ship, and
to refrain from all treachery so long as we should remain aboard of her.
Our numbers being what they were, this was the only thing we could do.
Christian neither asked, nor, I think, expected, that we should not
desert if an opportunity presented itself.

"That is sufficient," he said when he had heard us out. "I require from
you no more than that. But you will understand that I must protect myself
and these men from capture. In doing so I shall consider our interests
before your own. You could not expect me to do otherwise."

He then appointed his officers. Young was made master, Stewart the
master's mate, myself quartermaster, Morrison boatswain, and Alexander
Smith boatswain's mate. Churchill was master-at-arms, as before. Burkitt
and Hillbrandt were appointed quartermaster's mates. Millward and Byrne
were to be the cooks. We were divided into three watches.

These matters being decided, we went about our duties. A part of the
great cabin was fitted up as Christian's quarters, and as soon as they
were ready the arms chest was removed there. He used it for his bed, and
kept the keys always on his own person. One of the mutineers stood on
guard, day and night, at the doorway to the cabin. As for Christian
himself, he messed alone, and rarely spoke to anyone except to give an
order. The captain of a vessel lives, of necessity, a solitary existence,
but never could there have been one more lonely than Fletcher Christian.
Despite the bitterness I felt toward him at this time, my heart softened
as I watched him pacing the quarter-deck hour after hour, by day and by
night. All the gaiety had gone out of him; there was never the hint of a
smile on his face--only an expression of sombre melancholy.

Stewart, Young, and I messed together, as usual, but our meals were not
the jolly affairs they had so often been in the past. It wasimpossible to
become accustomed to the emptiness and silence of the ship. We avoided
speaking of those who had gone in the launch, as one avoids speaking of
the recently dead, but we were reminded of them at every turn; and the
thought of their probable fate, and our own, put a damp upon our spirits
hard to overcome. But this applied to Stewart and me rather than to
Young. He seemed to have few regrets for the turn our fortunes had taken;
indeed, he looked forward with pleasure, rather than otherwise, to the
prospect of spending the remainder of his life on some island in the
South Sea.

"We may as well make the best of it, lads," he said one evening when we
were discussing the future. "It's far from a bad best, if you look at the
matter sensibly. I've always wanted a life of ease. Ever since reading
Captain Wallis's and Captain Cook's accounts of their discoveries in the
Pacific, I've dreamed of nothing but tropical islands. When the chance
came to ship with the _Bounty_ I was the happiest man in England.
I'm willing to confess now that, had it been possible, I would have
deserted the ship at Tahiti."

"We shall never see Tahiti again, that is certain," said Stewart,
gloomily. "It will be the last place Mr. Christian will consider as a
refuge. He knows only too well that a ship of war will turn up there,
sooner or later, in search of us."

"What does it matter?" asked Young. "There are scores, hundreds of other
islands where we can live as happily. I advise the pair of you to put all
thoughts of home out of your minds. The chances of your ever seeing
England again are very remote. Make the most of what life offers you

Remote indeed they seemed then. After parting with the launch we had
followed the course the ship was then on, west-northwest, until well into
the afternoon; then we bore off to the eastward, since which time our
general course had been east by south. We were now in unknown seas, in so
far as I knew, off the track of any ship that had explored the Pacific.
It was clear that Christian was in search of undiscovered islands, for we
hove-to at night lest we should pass any in the darkness. Those days and
nights were as peaceful as any that I remember. The absence of Bligh was
a godsend to all of us, mutineers and non-mutineers alike. There was no
more of the continual feeling of tension, of uncertainty as to what would
happen, whenever the captain appeared upon deck. Christian maintained the
strictest discipline, but no one had cause to complain of his justice. He
was a born leader of men, and knew how to rule them without the perpetual
'floggings and abuse which Bligh considered so essential. After the
turbulent events of the mutiny the men seemed glad of the tranquillity
which had settled over the ship. The breeze blew steadily from the
northeast, and the _Bounty_ nosed her way quietly along as though
she had mastered the task of sailing herself and required no further help
from us. The moon waxed and was on the wane when, one morning shortly
after sunrise, land was descried bearing west by north.

Late in the afternoon we approached to within a mile of the reef which
seemed to enclose the island, forming a shallow lagoon where we saw many
canoes plying back and forth. The island appeared to be about eight miles
long. The interior was mountainous like that of Tahiti, although the land
was not so high, and the lowlands surrounding it were covered with the
same luxuriance of vegetation. As in most of the islands in that part of
the Pacific, deep water came directly up to the reef, and we coasted
along, close inshore. Several canoes, with ten or a dozen men in each,
put off from the beach and soon came up with us. The Indians resembled
the Tahitians in colour, stature, and the manner of their dress, and it
was evident that they had never seen a European vessel before. We tried
to persuade them to come alongside, and at last one of them paddled
abreast of us at a distance of about thirty yards.

The men were strongly made, with handsome features and well-formed
bodies. At Christian's order I spoke to them in the Tahitian language,
asking them the name of their land. This they understood, and replied
that it was Rarotonga. They seemed utterly astonished at my words. One of
them replied at some length, but his speech was largely unintelligible.
For all our friendly gestures we could not persuade them to approach more
closely. Some trinkets Christian wished to give them were wrapped in a
cloth and lowered over the side on a piece of planking. When we had let
this drift well astern, they approached and took the parcel and the plank
as well, which they put into their canoe without unwrapping the cloth to
see what it contained.

Having failed in our efforts to persuade any of them to come on board,
Christian gave orders to make sail, much to the regret of all of us, for
this island was scarcely less beautiful than Tahiti, and, judging by the
actions of the men in the canoes, the people would not have opposed our
landing. It has always remained a puzzle to me why Christian did not
choose this island as his hiding-place; for Rarotonga lies nearly seven
hundred miles southwest of Tahiti, and at this time he had no reason to
believe that its existence was known to any Europeans save ourselves. His
reason may have been that, in coasting the entire length of one side of
the island, no possible anchorage was to be seen; or perhaps, at this
time, he was so disturbed in mind as to have no definite plans for the

One evening, greatly to my surprise, he sent for me to sup with him. The
afterpart of the great cabin had been partitioned off for his use, and
there I found him, seated at his table, with a copy of one of Captain
Cook's charts outspread before him. He greeted me with formal politeness,
but when he had dismissed the sentinel stationed outside and had closed
the door, he fell back into the old friendly manner customary between us
before the mutiny.

"I have asked you to sup with me, Byam," he said, "but you need not
accept unless you choose."

I responded, against my inclination, to his friendly overtures. I had
come to resent bitterly the ruin he had brought upon us all; but under
the influence of his appealing kindly manner I found my indignation
melting away. I stood before Fletcher Christian, my friend, not the
mutineer who had cast nineteen men adrift in a small boat thousands of
miles from home. To those who blame me I can merely say that they never
knew the man.

He was in great need of someone to whom he could unburden his thoughts,
and I had not been five minutes in his cabin before he was speaking of
the mutiny.

"When I think of Bligh," he said, "I have no regrets. None whatever. I
have suffered too much at his hands ever to care what his fate may be.
But for those who went with him..."

He shut his eyes tightly and pressed his knuckles against them, as though
to blot from his mind the picture of the small open boat, filled, almost
to the point of foundering, with innocent men. Such desolation of heart
was apparent in his voice and the expression on his face that I pitied
him deeply. I knew that he would never know peace again--never until his
last day. He begged me to profit by his example and never act upon
impulse, and for all my sympathy I could not avoid saying that a mutiny
so carefully and secretly planned could hardly be called an act of

"Good God!" he exclaimed. "Did you think it was planned? Ten minutes
before Bligh was seized I had no more thought of mutiny than you
yourself. Had it been an act of deliberation...Is it possible that you
could have believed it?"

"What else could I think?" I replied. "It happened in your watch. When I
was awakened by Churchill I found you in complete possession of the ship,
with armed men stationed at the hatchways and all about the decks. It is
inconceivable to me that all this could have happened without

"And yet it did," Christian replied, earnestly. "It was all the work of
five minutes. Let me tell you...Do you remember the talk we had the night
before, during Peckover's watch?"


"I asked that, in case anything happened to me during the voyage home,
you would explain the circumstances to my people when you reached
England. My reason for speaking of this matter was that I planned to
leave the ship before the morning watch. I had taken no one into my
confidence except the quartermaster, John Norton, a man whom I knew I
could trust. I was not willing that you should know. I wanted to spare
your feelings until I had gone, and it was certain that you would have
tried to dissuade me. Norton had managed to make, secretly, a tiny raft
upon which I hoped to reach the island of Tofoa. With the sea as calm as
it was, I had every reason to think that I could make the land."

"You really meant to cut yourself off for all time from home and

"Yes. I was in hell, Byam! I had suffered from Bligh's tyranny to the
limit of my endurance. When he accused me, that same afternoon, with
stealing his coconuts, I felt that I could bear no more."

"I know," I said; "you were sorely tried, but we were all in the same
sorry situation with you."

"I didn't think of that. I thought only of the shame of the accusation;
of the contemptible, sordid meanness of the man who could bring such a
charge against his officers. I thought as well of the long voyage ahead
of us, and I knew that I could not and would not endure another year of
such torment.

"But luck was against me. The calmness and beauty of the night, so
favourable otherwise to my purpose, were against me. As you know, most of
the ship's company were on deck and, almost becalmed as we were, it would
have been impossible to slip away unseen. At last I decided that the plan
would have to be abandoned, temporarily at least. I should have to wait
until we passed some other island farther to the westward.

"Even at four o'clock, when I took charge of the deck from Peck-over, the
thought of mutiny had not occurred to me. Believe this; I assure you that
it is true. I paced up and down for some time, brooding over the repeated
insults I had received from Bligh. I don't defend myself; I merely relate
the facts. I was in a mood to kill the man. Yes, that thought crossed my
mind more than once: why not murder him and be done with it? The
temptation was all but overpowering. This will give you an indication of
the state of my feelings at that time. I was, in sober truth, out of my

"As you know, Hayward was the mate of my watch. In order to regain
control of myself I went in search of him, and found him stretched out in
the lee of the cutter, asleep. At another time such neglect of duty would
have aroused my anger. We were in unknown waters, and Bligh had rightly
given orders that the strictest watch should be kept, no matter how far
we might be from land. Hayward was in charge of the forward deck, and
three of the men, taking their cue from him, were asleep. I stood for a
moment looking down at Hayward, and then, as plainly as though they had
been spoken, I heard the words, 'Seize the ship.'

"From that moment my brain worked with the utmost clearness and
precision. It appeared to function outside of me; I had only to obey its
commands. I realized what an opportunity had presented itself, but not at
all the wrong I should be doing the rest of you. Burkitt was awake,
standing in the waist by the bulwarks on the larboard side. He had been
frequently punished by Bligh and I knew that I could count on his help,
but I didn't reveal my plan then--for I now had a plan. I asked him to
come below with me and waken Churchill, Martin, Thompson, and Quintal,
without disturbing anyone else, and to tell them I wanted to see them at
the fore ladderway. Meanwhile I went to Coleman's hammock, roused him
quietly, and asked for the key to the arms chest, saying that I wanted a
musket to shoot a shark. He gave it to me, turned over in his hammock,
and fell asleep again.

"I found Hallet asleep on the arms chest. As he was also of my watch, I
roused him with a show of anger and set him on deck by the after
ladderway. He was badly frightened at being caught, and begged me in a
low voice to say nothing of the matter to Captain Bligh. Burkitt and the
men he had awakened were awaiting me. They fell in at once with my plan.
We provided ourselves with muskets and pistols, and I placed Thompson
sentinel over the arms chest. We then roused McCoy, Williams, Alexander
Smith, and others, every man of them promising his hearty support. They
were given arms, and when I had placed sentinels at the hatchways we went
to Bligh's cabin. The rest you know."

He fell silent and sat for some time with his head in his hands, staring
at the deck between his feet. At length I forced myself to say, "What
chance do you think Bligh has of reaching England?"

"Little enough. Timor is the nearest place where they could expect help.
It is twelve hundred leagues from the place where the launch was cast
adrift...When I seized the ship my only thought was that I would carry
Bligh home in irons. The men wouldn't have it; you saw that for yourself.
I was forced to give way on that point. Then came the question of who was
to go with him. My plan was, at first, to send only Fryer, Samuel,
Hallet, and Hayward, but I could not refuse to let any others go with him
who wished to; in fact, not to have done so would have been highly
dangerous. Fryer, Purcell, Cole, and Peckover would, I knew, make every
effort to form a party for retaking the ship, if kept with us...Well,
enough of this. What is done can't be undone. I now have to think of the
men who are with me. The least I can do is to prevent them from being

"And what of the rest of us?"

"I have been expecting that question. You have every right to ask it. I
can't hope that any of you will give up all thoughts and hope of home and
throw in your lot with us as Young has done. My predicament is only less
hard than the one I have brought you into." He rose and stood by one of
the stern ports, looking out to westward, where the sun had just set.
Presently he turned to me again. "If I should take you to Tahiti and
allow you to part company from us, none of you would feel bound to keep
silence about the mutiny. For the present, much as I regret it, I must
keep you with us. I can say no more. You must be content with that."

Of his immediate plans Christian said nothing, although he gave me to
understand that we should be making land within a few days. On the
morning of May 28, precisely four weeks after the mutiny, an island was
seen dead to windward, distant about six leagues. We spent most of that
day in beating up to it, and were becalmed toward nightfall about three
miles off the western end. At dawn, when the trade wind made up again, we
coasted along the barrier reef which lay a great way offshore, in places
as far as two miles. Stewart, who had a perfect memory for latitudes and
longitudes and for any chart he had seen, was convinced that this island
was Tupuai, which had been discovered by Captain Cook. After nearly two
months at sea, the place seemed a Garden of Eden to all of us and,
mutineers and nonmutineers alike, we were eager to go ashore. There were
various small islands scattered along the reef, and between them, across
the lagoons, we had entrancing glimpses of the main island. All along the
coast we saw evidences of a numerous population.

Christian now informed us that there was a pass through the reef into the
lagoon, and that he meant to take the ship inside; but when we came
abreast of the entrance we found a formidable array of Indians awaiting
us. The entire male population of the island must have gathered there. We
estimated their numbers at eight or nine hundred. All were armed with
spears, clubs, and canoe loads of stones for repelling our entrance.
There was no doubt of the hostility of their intentions; they would have
none of our friendly overtures, but brandished their spears and sent such
showers of stones on our decks from their slings that several of our men
were hurt. We were forced to draw off the land, and from the masthead it
was clear that the passage into the lagoon and the lagoon itself was
scattered with coral shoals which would make navigation of the ship
difficult, even granted that we were unmolested by the Indians. With them
in opposition all hope of a landing had to be abandoned. Some of the
mutineers were for turning the guns on the Indians, and had we done so we
could have killed hundreds of them and brought the remainder under
subjection; but Christian would have none of this plan. He was resolved
that, wherever we went, we would make a peaceful settlement or none at

He now called a conference on the quarter-deck of the men of his own
party, and the rest of us, with the exception of Young, were sent
forward, out of hearing. At the end of a quarter of an hour the men
dispersed to their duties, and it was plain that some decision had been
reached pleasing to all of them. The ship was headed north.

Young was bound to say nothing of what had taken place at the meeting,
and we refrained from asking him embarrassing questions. But, knowing our
position, we also knew that north, if that course were to be held for
several days, could mean only one thing: our destination was Tahiti.
Morrison, Stewart, and I talked in whispers in the berth that evening. We
scarcely dared hope for such good fortune as a return to Tahiti. There,
if anywhere, we stood some chance of meeting any vessel that might be
sent out to search for the _Bounty_. We might have to wait for
several years, but a vessel was certain to come at last. We resolved
that, if the _Bounty_ called there, we would never come away in her.
We would escape, somehow, and conceal ourselves until the ship had put to
sea again.


On the day following our decision to escape, should the ship put in at
Tahiti, Christian sent for me once more. I found him with Churchill in
his cabin, and when he had motioned me to the settee he dismissed the
sentinel and closed the door. Christian looked stern, sad, and careworn,
but Churchill, who stood by the door with folded arms, greeted me with a
smile. He was a tall, powerful fellow, in middle life, with cold blue
eyes and a determined reckless face.

"I have sent for you, Mr. Byam," said Christian formally, "to acquaint
you with our decision regarding you and your companions who had no hand
in the taking of the ship. We bear you no yet circumstances oblige us to
take every precaution for our own safety. We are now steering for Tahiti,
where we shall stop for a week or more while we load livestock and

My face must have betrayed my thoughts, for Christian shook his head. "My
first thought," he went on, "was to leave you there, where sooner or
later you might hope for a ship to take you home. But the men would have
none of it, and I fear that they are right."

He glanced at Churchill, who nodded, still standing with folded arms.
"No, Mr. Byam," said the master-at-arms, "we had it out in the forecastle
last night--a regular Dover-court. Not a man on the ship but wishes you
well, but we can't allow it."

"They are right," said Christian gloomily; "we can neither leave you on
Tahiti nor let you set foot on shore. The men were for keeping the lot of
you below decks, under guard, but I persuaded them that if you and Mr.
Stewart and Mr. Morrison would give parole not to mention the mutiny to
the Indians, nor to say anything which might prejudice our interests, we
might safely permit you to come on deck while we are at anchor in

"I think I understand, sir," I replied, "though I must admit that we had
hoped to be left in Tahiti, whither we supposed the ship to be bound."

"Impossible!" Christian said. "I hate to carry you away against your
will, but it is essential to the safety of your shipmates. None of us
will ever see England again--we must make up our minds to that. You may
tell the others that it is my intention to search out one of the many
unknown islands in this sea, land our stores and livestock, destroy the
ship, and settle there for good, hoping never again to see a strange
white face."

"Aye, Mr. Christian," put in Churchill approvingly. "It is the only way."

Christian stood up, to notify me that the interview was at an end, and I
went on deck with a sinking heart. With the fresh east wind abeam, the
_Bounty_ was sailing fast on the starboard tack, rolling slowly and
regularly to the lift of the swell. I stood by the lee gangway, watching
the blue water swirl past the ship's side, and striving to collect my
thoughts. Stewart and I had often discussed in privacy our hopes and
fears for the future, and now, unless we found means to escape during the
ship's sojourn in Matavai, our hopes seemed destined to come to naught.
It was true that the parole demanded of us, if we were to be allowed on
deck, contained no mention of escape, but I had no doubt that we should
be closely watched. And even if we were lucky enough to escape, I
realized that the chances were a hundred to one we should be retaken.
Christian would have invented some plausible tale to account for the
absence of Bligh and the others, and, as captain of the ship, the chiefs
would be on his side. For the reward of a musket or two, they would have
the mountains and valleys of the interior scoured by men certain to find
us, no matter how distant and secret our hiding-place. Our only chance--a
slender one, indeed--would be to get possession of a fast sailing canoe
and make for the islands to leeward of Tahiti, whither the authority of
Teina and the other great chiefs of north Tahiti did not extend. Once
there, even though Christian learned our destination and gave pursuit, we
might be able to dodge from island to island till he wearied of the

To leave the ship under the eyes of the mutineers would be hard indeed;
to set sail at once, in a fast and seaworthy canoe, watered and
provisioned for a voyage across the open sea, would be harder still. Yet
hardest of all was the thought of the alternative: "England--home, lost
to us forever."

As I stood by the gangway, deep in these disquieting reflections, Stewart
touched my arm. "Look," he said; "they are throwing the plants
overboard!" Directed by Young, a line of men had formed on the ladderway,
and they were beginning to pass the pots from hand to hand. A man by the
rail, aft, pulled up each young plant by the roots and flung it
overboard, while others emptied the earth into the sea and carried the
pots to the forehatch. We carried more than a thousand young breadfruit
trees, all in flourishing condition, and now the _Bounty_ left a
wake of their rich green foliage tossing on the blue swell. They had been
gathered and cared for with infinite pains; to obtain them we had
suffered hardships, braved unknown seas, and sailed more than
twenty-seven thousand miles, in fair weather and foul. And now the
plants, eagerly awaited in the West Indies, were going overboard like so
much unwanted ballast.

"Waste!" remarked Stewart presently. "Futility and waste! And, like a
good Scot, I hate both!"

It was sad to reflect on the results of the expedition: the plants thrown
overboard; Bligh and his companions probably drowned or killed by
savages; the mutineers, desperate and unhappy, planning to hide away
forever from the face of mankind; ourselves forced to share the same hard

Later, in the privacy of the berth, I told Stewart of my interview with
Christian and of the gloomy prospect ahead of us. "We must tell Morrison
as soon as possible," he said.

He was silent for some time, his thin, bronzed face expressionless. At
last he looked up. "At least I'll see Peggy."

"That's certain, if you give your parole."

"I'd give that, and more, for a glimpse of her!" He rose abruptly and
began to pace back and forth nervously. I said nothing, and presently he
went on in a low voice: "Forgive me for inflicting my thoughts on
you--seamen are sentimental, and I have been long at sea. But Peggy might
be the means of effecting our escape--I can think of no other."

"That she might!" I exclaimed, for I had given the subject much anxious
thought. "She could obtain a canoe for us--a favour we could ask of no
other person in Matavai. Since we must give our parole we cannot make
known the true state of affairs, nor why we desire to leave the ship. You
will have to tell Peggy that we are planning to desert, as Churchill and
the others deserted, in order to live among the Indians after the ship is
gone. The chiefs alone own vessels large enough to take us to the Leeward
Islands, and both Teina and Hitihiti feel themselves too much indebted to
the friendship of King George to take part in what they would regard as a
conspiracy against him. Peggy's father is under no such obligation."

Stewart seated himself once more. His mind was quicker than my own, and
he had perceived in an instant what had taken me some time to puzzle out.

"Precisely," he said. "Peggy is our only chance. I could arrange
everything in ten minutes alone with her. It must be on a night when the
wind holds from the east. The canoe will be paddled past the ship as if
outbound on one of their night passages to Tetiaroa, and her crew must
make some disturbance which will draw the men of the watch to that side
of the _Bounty_. We can then slip overboard on the other side and
swim to Peggy's vessel, which will lie hove-to while they get sail on
her. With good luck, no one will observe us in the dark."

"By God, Stewart! I believe it can be done!"

"Must be done, rather! Morrison and I are Navy men, and we have our
careers to think of. But there have been many times when I have longed to
stay here."

On the evening of the fifth of June we raised the highlands of Tahiti,
far ahead and ghostly among the clouds, and on the following afternoon
we sailed into Matavai Bay and dropped anchor close to Point Venus. Every
man on board had been instructed what to tell the Indians of his
acquaintance who might make inquiries: at Aitutaki we had fallen in with
Captain Cook, Bligh's father, who was forming an English settlement on
that island. Bligh, Nelson, and others of the _Bounty's_ crew had
been taken aboard Cook's ship, and he had ordered the _Bounty_ to
leave the breadfruit plants with him, and return to Tahiti to trade for
further stores and whatever livestock it might be possible to obtain. The
ship was then to set sail in search of another island suitable for

The Indians flocked out to the ship--Teina, Hitihiti, and the other
chiefs curious to know why we had returned so soon and what had become of
the absent members of the ship's company. The story invented by Christian
satisfied them completely, and since he was popular--much more so than
Bligh--the natives promised to furnish everything we desired, and the
trading was friendly and brisk.

I dined with Christian that evening; his sweetheart and old Hitihiti, my
_taio_, were the other guests. With the girl--who would eat
nothing--at his side, Christian seemed to have shaken off for the moment
the sombre mood from which he had not emerged since the mutiny. He raised
his glass and smiled at me across the table.

"To our sweethearts," he said lightly. "You can drink to mine, Byam,
since you have none of your own." Maimiti smiled gravely and touched the
glass with her lips, but my _taio_ drained his wine at a gulp.

"Stop ashore my house, Byam," he said.

I could feel Christian's eyes on me as I replied. "I'm sorry," I said;
"but we shall be here only a few days, and Mr. Christian has informed me
that I shall be needed on board."

Hitihiti was evidently surprised at this. He turned to Christian, who

"Yes," he said. "He will be needed on board during the whole time we are
at anchor here." The old chief understood enough of discipline on a
British ship to let the subject drop.

Peggy had come on board during the afternoon, and when I went on deck
after dinner I saw the couple seated by the mainmast, in the shadow of
the pumps. Stewart's arm was about her waist and they were speaking
together in the Indian tongue. When she had gone ashore, Stewart,
Morrison, and I met by agreement on the main hatch. Young was the officer
of the watch, and since we were at anchor and the night was calm, he had
given his men permission to sleep on deck. He was a carefree,
unsuspicious fellow, and now he lolled on the poop, his head turned
toward the dark loom of the land. Taurua, his Indian sweetheart, kept the
watch with him--a slender ghostly figure, shrouded in white tapa. The
night was chilly, for it was winter in Tahiti, and Matavai Bay was a
black mirror to reflect the stars.

"I have talked with Peggy," said Stewart in a low voice, "and explained
our determination to desert the ship. She thinks that I am leaving for
her sake--a half-truth, at least. As for you two, she believes that you
are enamoured of the Indian life, or of some of the young ladies on
shore. Peggy will aid us with her whole heart. Unfortunately, the only
large canoe her family possesses is at Tetiaroa. She will send a small
vessel to fetch it to-morrow if the wind is fair."

"Then let us pray for a fair wind," said Morrison seriously.

"I wish we could take the others," I said.

"There will be no chance of that," Morrison replied. "Christian means to
keep them confined below till the ship sails."

"In any case there would be too many," said Stewart. "Their very numbers
would make escape impossible."

Morrison shrugged his shoulders. "No--we can think only of ourselves. I
have only one desire, one thought--to return to England. A ship will
come, you may count on that, though we may have to wait two or three
years for her. We shall have to be patient, that is all."

"Patient?" Stewart remarked. "Well, I could put up with three years
here--or with four or five! And Byam is a lover of the Indian life."

"Damn the Indian life," said Morrison without a smile. "Who knows what
wars are going on, what chances for prize-money and promotion we are

I went to sleep with a light heart that night, for our escape seemed a
certainty, and the prospect of a year or two among the Indians was far
from displeasing. At dawn I saw Peggy's light double canoe, paddled by
half-a-dozen stalwart fellows, set out for Tetiaroa, and all through the
forenoon I watched every sign of the weather anxiously. Nature herself
now took a hand against us. The day turned chilly and films of cloud
began to stream seaward off the mountains. We were in the lee of the high
land, and Matavai Bay remained still as a lake, but the wind had chopped
around to the south and was blowing up one of the boisterous southerly
storms the Indians call _maraai_. Gazing out to sea, I perceived the
line of whitecaps at the end of the lee, and knew that as long as the
south wind held, no canoe would even attempt to return from the island
north of us.

Day after day the strong south wind blew, while we traded for our strange
cargo. Hogs, fowls, dogs, and cats came on board till the ship resembled
a menagerie, and finally the bull and the cow left on Tahiti by Captain
Cook. Goats skipped about comically on deck, among mounds of taro, sweet
potatoes, and yams. And little by little our hope, which had run so high,
began to change to fear. There were signs that Christian was nearly ready
to sail, and Peggy's face, when she visited her lover on board, grew
haggard with anxiety. I shall not dwell on our suspense. It is enough to
say that on the ninth day the wind shifted to northeast and brought our
sailing canoe in, four hours after the shift. This was at noon and all
was arranged for our escape the same night, but now at the last moment
fate turned against us once more. At two o'clock in the afternoon
Christian ordered the anchor up and, close-hauled on the starboard tack,
the _Bounty_ sailed out of Matavai Bay.

The months from June to September of that year, 1789, are a nightmare in
my memory, and since they have little to do with the main thread of this
narrative, I shall give them no more space than they deserve.

In spite of our hostile reception when we first visited Tupuai, Christian
had determined to settle on that island. We were now southbound, like
modern Noahs on our Ark, with livestock of various kinds to increase and
multiply on the island, and even a few Indian Eves to become the
grandmothers of a new race--half white, half brown. Christian's Maimiti
was on board, and Young's Taurua; and Alexander Smith, distrustful of the
ladies of Tupuai, had persuaded Bal'hadi to accompany him. Nor was any
great degree of persuasion necessary, for the Indians were passionately
fond of travel and adventure of any sort. Long after Tahiti had
disappeared below the horizon north of us, it was discovered that we had
on board nine Indian men, twelve women, and eight boys, most of them

Our reception on Tupuai was at first friendly, owing to the Tahitian
passengers, who explained our desire to settle on the island. With
incredible labour we hauled the ship up on land and built thatched
shelters to protect her decks from the sun. We then built a fort, on a
point of land purchased from one of the chiefs, and surrounded it with a
moat twenty feet deep and twice as wide, all hands, including Christian
himself, taking part in the work. The men murmured much at this truly
Herculean labour, but Christian's foresight was soon evident. Our goats,
loosed to increase among the mountains of the interior, descended on the
taro gardens of the Indians, which they cultivate and water with infinite
pains. Unable to capture or kill the wary animals, the people came to us,
asking us to shoot them with our muskets. When we refused, explaining
that the progeny of the marauders would provide an important supply of
food, the Indians at first murmured and then broke out in open hostility,
declaring that they would never cease their efforts until we were either
exterminated or driven from the island for good. Time after time they
attacked our fortress furiously, only to be driven off by the fire of our
four-pounders and swivels, and before long it became impossible to
venture outside save in strong parties, heavily armed. Our lives grew
insupportable; even the hardiest among us wearied of the constant
fighting, and early in September, perceiving that all hands were heartily
sick of the place, Christian assembled the lot of us and called for a
show of hands. All were for leaving Tupuai; sixteen expressed a desire to
be left on Tahiti, and the rest wished to sail away with the
_Bounty_ to search for some uninhabited island where they might
settle in peace. On being informed of our decision to leave Tupuai, the
Indians agreed to cease hostilities while we launched and watered the
ship, and after a week of labour such as falls to the lot of few men, we
got the _Bounty_ launched, her sails bent, and water and stores
aboard. At the last moment, on the verge of leaving this ill-omened
place, we nearly lost the ship in a tremendous squall which made up
unperceived during the night. As it was, we lost the spare gaff of the
driver and all our spare topgallant yards.

At daybreak, with a fresh breeze at east, we weighed and sailed out
through the narrow passage, heartily glad to be clear of a place where we
had met with nothing but misfortune and strife, and five days later,
after an agreeable voyage, we were at anchor once more in Matavai Bay.
The following men had decided to remain on the ship:--Fletcher Christian,
Acting Lieutenant; John Mills, Gunner's Mate; Edward Young, Midshipman;
William Brown, Gardener; Isaac Martin, William McCoy, John Williams,
Matthew Quintal, and Alexander Smith, Able Seamen.

The rest of the _Bounty's_ company had elected to remain on Tahiti.
I was overjoyed at this sudden change in my fortunes, as were Stewart and
Morrison. My old friend Hitihiti was among the first of the Indians to
come off to us, and when I informed him that I hoped to go ashore and
make my home at his house, his face beamed with smiles. As he had come
out in a double canoe large enough to freight all my belongings ashore, I
lost no time in asking Christian's permission to leave the ship. I found
him at the main hatch, superintending the division of the muskets,
cutlasses, pistols, and ammunition, of which each man was to have his

"By all means," he said, looking up from the paper in his hand. "Go
ashore whenever you like. And take a musket with you and a supply of lead
to mould bullets. We are so short of powder that I can give only a few
charges to each man. You will stop with Hitihiti, of course?"

"That is my intention, sir."

"I shall see you to-night, then. I wish to speak to you and to Stewart--I
shall! ask him to be there An hour after sundown."

My hammock man and his lusty Indian wench lent me a hand to get my things
out of the berth, and after a farewell glance about the _Bounty's_
decks, and a silent handshake with Edward Young, I followed my belongings
into Hitihiti's canoe.

It was like a homecoming to return once more to the house of my
_taio_, to greet Hina and her husband, and to see Hitihiti's
grandchildren running to welcome me. I had lived so long among these kind
people that they seemed joined to me by ties closer than those of mere

When I had stowed my belongings and precious manuscript I became at once
the centre of a circle of all ages, eager to hear the story of our
adventures. I recounted at length, in the Indian tongue, the history of
our attempt to settle on Tupuai, and ended by expressing some sympathy
with the people of that island, who, after all, had done no more than
repel what they considered an invasion of their home. Hina shook her head

"No!" she exclaimed; "you are wrong. I have seen some of those people,
who came here in a large canoe five years ago. They are savages! You
should have killed them all and taken their island!"

"You are fierce, Hina," I said with a smile. "Why should we kill innocent
men, whose only fault was love of their land? Had we desired to kill
them, Christian would not have allowed it."

"He was foolish, then. Did they not try to kill him, and you? But what
will you do, now that you have returned? Shall you be long among us?"

"To-morrow or the day after, Christian and eight of the others will set
sail for Aitutaki to rejoin Captain Cook. The rest of us, who love your
island, have permission to settle here."

All of us who were to be left on Tahiti had given our words to tell the
same story, and, little as I liked the task, I lied with a brazen face.
Hina leaned towards me and seized me in a strong embrace, smelling at my
cheek affectionately.

"Ah, Byam," she said, "we are delighted, all of us! The house has been
empty since you sailed away!"

"Aye," said her husband heartily. "You are one of us, and we shall not
let you go!"

Early in the evening Stewart appeared on the path from Matavai,
accompanied by Peggy and her father, olti Tipau. Hitihiti had returned to
the ship, to fetch Christian and his niece. I walked down to the beach
with Stewart and his sweetheart, leaving the old chief to gossip with the
others in the house.

The calm Pacific nuzzled lazily at the sands, and we sat quietly, as if
the beauty of the evening had cast upon us a spell of silence and

Twilight was fading to night when Stewart started slightly and gazed out
to sea. "There they come!" he said. Rising and falling on the gentle
swell outside the reef, I saw the double canoe--a moving shadow on the
waters. She came on rapidly, and before long her prows grounded on the
sand and Christian sprang out, turning to help Maimiti over the high
gunwale. He nodded to us, saying only, "Wait for me here," and followed
Hitihiti to the house to take leave of his sweetheart's family. At a word
from Stewart, Peggy followed him.

The sight of Christian on the twilit beach had moved me deeply. It was
not hard to imagine his feelings on the eve of this final departure from
Tahiti. Presently I heard a rustle in the bushes behind us, and his step
falling softly on the sand. We rose, but he motioned us to seat
ourselves, and sank down cross-legged beside us, casting aside his hat
and running his fingers through his thick dark hair.

"This is the last time I shall see you," he said abruptly, after a long
silence. "We shall sail in the morning, as soon as the wind makes up.

"I have told you the story of the mutiny," he went on; "remember that I,
and I alone, am responsible. In all probability, Bligh and those with him
are long since dead--drowned or killed by savages. In the case of Bligh,
I have no regrets; the thought of the others, innocent men, lies heavy on
my conscience. You know the circumstances; they may explain, even to some
extent excuse, the action I took, but they can never exonerate me. I am a
mutineer and, since I made off with one of His Majesty's ships, a pirate
as well. It is my duty to guide and protect those who have chosen to
follow me. You know my plans. This is the greatest ocean in the world,
set with innumerable islands. On one of them--north, or south, or east,
or west of here--we shall settle, and destroy the ship. You shall see us
no more--I promise you that."

Again silence fell upon us. The stillness of the night was broken only by
the faint lap and wash of the sea, and far down the beach, where a fire
of coconut husks made a ruddy point of light, I heard the wail of an
awakening child.

"Sooner or later," Christian went on, after a long pause, "a British
man-of-war will drop anchor here. If Bligh, or any of his men, succeed in
reaching England, the Admiralty will dispatch a ship at once, to
apprehend the mutineers. If, as I fear, all those in the _Bounty's_
launch are lost, a vessel will be sent out, after a reasonable period of
waiting, in search of us. When she comes, I desire you earnestly to go
out to her at once and give yourselves up to the officer in command--you
two, and the others who had no hand in the mutiny. You are innocent, and
no harm can come to you. As for the others, let them behave as they think
best. Since they refuse to follow me, I am forced to wash my hands of

"Once before, Byam, in a moment of desperation, I requested you to
communicate with my father, in the event of my not reaching home. Fate
was against me that night! Had I succeeded in leaving the ship...My
father is Charles Christian, of Mairlandclere, in Cumberland. Will one of
you, the first to reach England, go to him and explain the circumstances
of the mutiny? Tell him the story as I have told it to you, and explain
particularly that my design was only to relieve Bligh of his command and
take him home in irons. A full acquaintance with the truth may extenuate
in my father's eyes, though never justify, the crime I have committed.
Will you do this for me?"

Christian stood up and Stewart and I sprang to our feet. I was the first
to seize Christian's hand.

"Yes," I said, too moved for further speech.

A moment later Christian turned to hail the house. "Maimiti!" he called,
in his strong seaman's voice. She must have been awaiting the call, for
she appeared almost instantly, a slender white figure flitting under the
palms. The paddlers followed her, seized the canoe, and dragged it into
the wash of the sea. The Indian girl came to me without a word and
embraced me tenderly in the fashion of her people. Still in silence she
embraced Stewart, and sprang into the canoe. Christian shook our hands
for the last time. "God bless you both!" he said.

We stood on the beach, watching the double canoe fade into the night. At
dawn, when I walked out of the house for a plunge in the sea, the
_Bounty_ was standing offshore with all sail set, heading north,
with the light easterly breeze abeam.


Though I had reason to congratulate myself on my present situation, the
week following the _Bounty's_ departure was an unhappy time for me.
For the first time in my life, I think, I began to question the doctrines
of the Church in which I had been brought up, and to ask myself whether
human destiny was ordered by divine law or ruled by chance. If God were
all-powerful and good, I thought, with a lad's simplicity, why had He
permitted one man, in a moment of not unrighteous anger against
oppression and injustice, to ruin his own life and the lives of so many
others? Many a good and innocent man had accompanied Bligh in the launch:
where were they now? The majority of the mutineers themselves were simple
fellows with a grievance that might have led better men to revolt. Held
in subjection by the iron law of the sea, they had endured with little
complaint the hardships of the long voyage and the temper of a man
considered brutal in a brutal age. Had Bligh not goaded his junior
officer beyond endurance, no other man on the ship would have raised the
cry of mutiny, and the voyage would have been completed peacefully. But
one moment of passion had changed everything. Out of the whole ship's
company, only seven of us--those who had had no hand in the mutiny and
were now awaiting the first English ship--had come out of the affair
scot-free. And our fate could scarcely be termed enviable--marooned for
an indefinite time among Indians, on an island at the very ends of the
earth. As for the mutineers who had chosen to remain on Tahiti, I knew
only too well what their fate was likely to be. Young Ellison, who had
been our mess boy, was often in my thoughts at this time. He had no
realization of the gravity of the part he had played. Yet I knew that
unless he quitted Tahiti before the arrival of a British man-of-war, our
sea law would infallibly condemn him to death.

During those days of doubt and depression at Hitihiti's house, when Hina
strove to divert my thoughts and my good old _taio_ tried
fruitlessly to cheer me up, I ceased to be a boy and became a man.
Morrison was settled with Poino, the famous warrior who lived not far
off, and Stewart was living with Peggy, in the house of Tipau, at the
foot of One Tree Hill. I went frequently to pass the time of day with
these two friends, and from their example learned to be ashamed of my
fruitless depression. Morrison and Millward, who lived with Stewart at
Poino's house, were already planning the little schooner they eventually
built, and in which, without awaiting the arrival of a ship from home,
they hoped to sail to Batavia, whence they might get passage to England.
Stewart, who loved gardening, worked daily at beautifying the grounds
about the new house old Tipau was building for him. When I mentioned my
thoughts to him, he only smiled and said: "Never worry about what you
cannot change," and went on with his digging, and planting, and laying
out of paths. Perceiving at last that hard work was the remedy for my
greensickness, I set to once more on my dictionary and was soon absorbed
in the task.

One morning, about ten days after the departure of the _Bounty_, I
found myself unable to sleep and set out for a walk on the long curving
beach that led to Point Venus. It was still an hour before dawn, but the
stars were bright and the northerly breeze blowing from the region of the
equator made the air warm and mild. A dog barked at me as I passed an
encampment of fishermen asleep on the sands under blankets of bark cloth.
Their great net, hung on stakes to dry, stretched for a quarter of a mile
along my path. At the very tip of the point, sheltered by the reef and
provided with a deep, safe entrance, lies one of the most beautiful
little harbours on the island, resorted to by travelers in sailing canoes
who wish to pass the night on shore. The water is always calm and
beautifully clear, and a good-sized vessel can be moored so close in
shore than a man may leap from her stern to the beach.

The point was a favourite resort of mine at this hour, for the view up
the coast at sunrise was one I loved. I was pleased to find the cove
deserted, and, settling myself comfortably on one of the high sand dunes,
I gazed eastward, where the first faint flush of dawn was beginning to
appear. At that moment a slight sound caught my ear, and, glancing
seaward, I perceived that a large sailing canoe was stealing in through
the passage. Her great brown sails of matting were ghostly blots on the
sea, and presently I could hear the low commands of the man at the
masthead, conning her in. She came on fast under her press of sail,
rounded-to smartly inside, and dropped her stone anchor with a resounding
plunge. The sails were furled while paddlers brought her stern to the
land, and a man sprang ashore to make fast her stern-line to a coconut

From the size of the vessel and the number of her crew, I judged that she
carried passengers of consequence, but whoever they were, they still
slept under the little thatched awning aft. Several of the crew came on
land to build a fire of coconut husks and prepare food for the morning
meal, and I saw two women helped ashore, who strolled away westward along
the point and disappeared.

It was full daylight, with the rim of the sun just above the horizon,
when I rose, unperceived by the travelers, and walked across to the large
river which emptied into the sea on the west side of the point. It was
called Vaipoopoo, and close to the mouth there was a long reach of deep
clear water in which I loved to swim--a quiet and beautiful spot, distant
from the habitations of the Indians. The water was a good twenty yards
across and so deep that a boat of twelve tons burthen might have entered
to a distance of a quarter of a mile. Tall old mape trees arched
overhead, their buttressed roots forming many a rustic seat along the

I had long since chosen such a seat for myself, high above the still
water and at a distance of about a cable's length from the beach.
Frequently in the late afternoon I spent an hour or two alone at this
place, listening to the rustling of the trees high overhead, and watching
the small speckled fresh-water fish as they rose for their evening meal
of flies. In my fancy I had named this spot Withycombe, after our home in
England, for indeed there were moments when the place seemed English to
the core, when I fancied myself in the warm summer twilight at home,
watching the trout rise in one of our West Country streams.

To Withycombe, then, I repaired for my morning bath. I threw off the
light mantle of Indian cloth from my shoulders and girded up the kilt
about my waist. Next moment I slipped into the deep clear water and swam
leisurely downstream, drifting with the gentle flow of the current. High
in a tree overhead a bird was singing--an _omaomao_, whose song is
sweeter than that of our English nightingale.

As I drifted downstream I perceived suddenly, seated among the buttressed
roots of an old tree, a young girl lovely as a water-sprite. I must have
made some slight splashing sound, for she turned her head with a little
start and gazed full into my eyes. I recognized her at once--she was
Tehani, whom I had seen in Tetiaroa long before. She gave no sign of
shyness or embarrassment, for a girl of her position had in those days
nothing to fear by day or by night, alone or in company. A rude word to
her would have been the cause of instant death to the offender; an act of
violence to her person might easily have brought on a devastating war.
This sense of security imparted to the girls of Tehani's class an
innocent assurance of manner which was by no means the least of their

"May you live!" I said, Indian-fashion, rounding-to against the current.

"And you!" replied Tehani, with a smile. "I know who you are! You are
Byam, the _taio_ of Hitihiti!"

"True," said I, eager to prolong the conversation. "Shall I tell you who
you are? You are Tehani, Poino's relative! I saw you in Tetiaroa, when
you danced there."

She laughed aloud at this. "Ah, you saw me? Did I dance well?"

"So beautifully that I have never forgotten that night!"

"_Arero mona_!" she exclaimed mockingly, for the Indians call a
flatterer "sweet tongue."

"So beautifully," I went on as if I had not heard, "that I said to
Hitihiti: 'Who is yonder girl, lovelier than any girl in Tahiti, who
might be the young goddess of the dance herself?"

"_Arero mona_!" she mocked again, but I could see the blush mantling
her smooth cheeks. She had just come out of the river and her brown hair
lay in damp ringlets on her shoulders. "Come--let us see which can swim
further under water, you or I!" Tehani slipped into the stream, and dived
so smoothly that she scarcely rippled the still water. Clinging to the
great root which had been her seat, I watched for what seemed an
interminable time. The river turned in a bend about fifty yards below me,
and at last, from out of sight beyond the bend, I heard Tehani's voice.
"Come," she called gaily. "It is your turn to try!"

I dove at the words and began to swim downstream, about a fathom deep.
The water was clear as air and I could see the shoals of small bright
fish scatter before me and seek refuge among the shadowy boulders below.
On and on I went, determined that no girl should excel me in the water,
an element I have always loved. Aided by the current, my progress was
swift, and finally, when my lungs would endure no more and I felt
satisfied that I had won, I came to the surface with a gasp. A chuckle
musical as the murmur of the stream greeted me, and shaking the water
from my eyes I saw the girl seated on a long root, flush with the water,
a full ten yards beyond.

"You came up there?" I asked in some chagrin.

"I have not cheated."

"Let us rest for a little while, and then I shall try again."

Tehani patted the root beside her. "Come and rest here," she said.

I pulled myself up beside her, shaking the wet hair back from my eyes.
Moved by common impulse, our two heads turned, and Tehani's clear brown
eyes smiled into mine. She turned away suddenly and all at once I felt my
heart beating fast. Her hand was close to mine on the rough gnarled root;
I took it gently, and since it was not withdrawn I locked my fingers in
hers. She bent her head to gaze into the clear water and for a long time
neither of us spoke.

I gazed, not at the water, but at the beautiful girl at my side. She wore
only a light kilt of white cloth, and her bare shoulder and arm, turned
to me, were smooth as satin and of the most exquisite proportions. Her
feet and hands, small and delicately made, might have been envied by a
princess, and Phidias himself could have produced in cold marble nothing
one half so lovely as her young breasts, bared in all innocence. In her
face I saw sweetness and strength.

"Tehani!" I said, and took her hand in both of mine.

She made no answer, but raised her head slowly and turned to me. Then all
at once, and without a word between us, she was in my arms. The faint
perfume of her hair intoxicated me, and for a time the beating of my
heart made speech impossible. It was the girl who spoke first.

"Byam," she asked, stroking my wet hair caressingly, "have you no wife?"

"No," I replied.

"I have no husband," said the girl.

At that moment I heard a woman's voice calling from downstream: "Tehani!
Tehani O!" The girl hailed back, bidding the caller to wait, and turned
to me.

"It is only my servant who came ashore with me. I bade her wait at the
mouth of the stream while I bathed."

"You came from Tetiaroa?" I asked, with her head on my shoulder and my
arm about her waist.

"No, I have been to Raiatea with my uncle. We have been two days and two
nights at sea."

"Who is your uncle?"

The girl turned to me in real astonishment. "You do not know?" she said


"Yet you speak our tongue like one of us! Strange men, you English--I
have never talked with one of you before. My uncle is Vehiatua, of
course, high chief of Taiarapu."

"I have often heard of him."

"Are you a chief in your own land?"

"A very small one, perhaps."

"I knew it! Knew it the moment I laid eyes on you! Hitihiti would not
take as his _taio_ a common man."

Again we fell silent, both conscious that our words reflected only the
surface of our minds. "Tehani!" I said.


She raised her head and I kissed her in the English fashion, full on the
lips. We walked back to the cove hand in hand, while the servant followed
us, her eyes round with wonder.

Vehiatua had come ashore and was at breakfast when we came to the cove.
He was a nobly proportioned old man, with thick gray hair and a manner of
cheerful, good-natured dignity. His retainers were grouped about him as
he ate, serving him with breadfruit, grilled fish fresh from the coals,
and bananas from a great bunch they had brought ashore. The old chief's
tattooing, which covered every portion of his body save his face, was the
most beautiful and intricate I have ever seen. I was glad that I wore
only my kilt, for it is discourteous to approach the great Indian chiefs
with covered shoulders. Vehiatua gave no sign of surprise at sight of me.

"Eh, Tehani," he called out affectionately to his niece. "Your breakfast
is ready for you on board. And who is the young man with you?"

"The _taio_ of Hitihiti--Byam is his name."

"I have heard of him." And then, turning to me courteously, Vehiatua
asked me to join him at his meal. I sat down beside him, nothing loth,
and answered this questions regarding Hitihiti and the _Bounty_, of
which he had heard much. He expressed surprise at my knowledge of the
Indian tongue, and I told him of my mission and how my _taio_ had
aided me.

"And now you and the others are settling on Tahiti to remain among us?"
Vehiatua asked.

"For a long time, at any rate," I replied. "It is possible that when the
next British ship arrives, in two years or three, King George may send
word that one or all of us must go home."

"Aye," said the old aristocrat, "one must obey one's king!"

Presently Tehani came ashore, her breakfast over and her toilet made,
very different from the young tomboy who had beaten me at diving so short
a time before. Her beautiful hair, dried in the sun, combed out and
perfumed, was dressed in the Grecian fashion, low on the nape of her
neck. Her mantle of snow-white cloth was draped in classic folds, and she
walked ahead of her little band of women with an air of dignity few
English girls of sixteen could have assumed. The chief gave me a nod and
rose to his feet.

"Let us go to the house of my kinsman," he said.

A stout muscular fellow crouched before Vehiatua, hands braced on his
knees. The chief vaulted to his shoulders with the ease of long practice,
and the human horse stood upright with a grunt. Vehiatua, Teina, and two
or three other great chiefs of those days were never permitted to walk,
for the touch of their feet rendered a commoner's land theirs. Wherever
they went, save in their own domains, they were borne on the backs of men
trained to the task.

With Tehani at my side, I followed her uncle down the beach, walking on
the hard moist sand at the water's edge. As we passed the encampment of
fishermen they hastened to throw off the mantles from their shoulders and
seat themselves on the sand. To remain standing while a high chief passed
would have been the greatest of insults.

"_Maeva te arii_!" was their greeting. (Hail to the chief!)

"May you live," said Vehiatua affably; "and may your fishing prosper!"

Old Hitihiti met us before his door, throwing off his mantle and stepping
forward with bare shoulders to greet his friend. A meal was being
prepared, and though our visitor had just eaten a prodigious quantity of
food, he expressed his willingness to share in a second breakfast. Tehani
and Hina knew each other well and seemed to have much to talk over. From
the glances Hina cast at me from time to time, I suspected that Tehani
was telling her of our meeting in the stream.

Toward noon, when the others had sought out shady places in which to
spread their mats for a nap, I found my _taio_ awake. He was alone,
under his favourite hibiscus tree close to the beach, and I told him of
my meeting with the girl, and that I loved her too dearly for my peace of

"Why not marry her, if she is willing?" asked Hitihiti, when I had done.

"I think she might be willing, but what would her parents say?"

"She has none; both are dead."

"Vehiatua then."

"He likes you."

"Very well. But suppose we were married, and an English ship came with
orders that I must go home."

My _taio_ shrugged his great shoulders in despair. "You English are
all alike," he said impatiently; "you make yourselves miserable by
thinking of what may never happen! Is not to-day enough, that you must
think of to-morrow and the day after that? The thought of an English ship
makes you hesitate to marry the girl you fancy! And ten years, or twenty,
might pass before another ship arrives! Enough of such talk! Yesterday is
gone; you have to-day; to-morrow may never come!"

I could not help smiling at my old friend's philosophic outburst, not
without its grain of sound common sense--called "common" because it is so
rare. Worry over the future is without doubt the white man's greatest
strength and greatest weakness in his quest of happiness--the only
conceivable object in life. To the people of Tahiti, worry over the
future was unknown; their language indeed contained no word with which to
express such an idea.

No doubt Hitihiti was right, I reflected; since I was destined to live a
long time among the Indians, I was justified in adopting their point of
view. "You are my _taio_," I said. "Will you intercede for me with
Vehiatua? Tell him that I love his niece dearly, and desire to marry

The old chief clapped me on the back. "With all my heart!" he exclaimed.
"You have been too long without a wife! Now let me sleep."

Tehani was awake before the others had finished their siesta, and I found
her strolling on the beach. We were alone, and she came to me swiftly.
"Sweetheart," I said, "I have spoken to my _taio_, and he has
promised to ask Vehiatua for your hand. I have not done wrong?"

"I spoke to my uncle before he lay down to sleep," Tehani replied,
smiling. "I told him I wanted you for my husband and must have you. He
asked if you were willing, and I said that I must have you, willing or
not! 'Do you want me to make war on Hitihiti and kidnap his friend?' he
asked. 'Yes,' said I, 'if it comes to that!' He looked at me
affectionately and then said: 'Have I ever denied you anything, my little
pigeon, since your mother died? This Byam of yours is English, but he is
a man nevertheless, and no man could resist you!' Tell me, do you think
that is true?"

"I am sure of it!" I answered, pressing her hand.

When we returned to the house the sun was low, and the two chiefs, who
had dismissed their followers, were conversing earnestly. "Here they
are!" said Vehiatua, as we came in hand in hand.

"And well content with one another," remarked my _taio_ smilingly.

"Vehiatua gives his consent to the marriage," he went on to me. "But he
makes one condition--you are to spend most of your time in Tautira. He
cannot bear to be separated from his niece. You will sympathize with him,
Byam, and I too can understand. But you must come often to visit old
Hitihiti, you two!"

"You are to be married at once, Tehani says, and in my house," said the
chief of Taiarapu. "You can sail with me to-morrow, and Hitihiti and Hina
will follow in their single canoe. They will represent your family at the
temple. You two may consider yourselves betrothed."

I rose at these words and went into the house to open my box. When I
returned, I carried the bracelet and the necklace purchased in London so
long before. I showed them first to Vehiatua, who turned them admiringly
in his hands.

"My gift to Tehani," I explained. "With your permission."

"She should be happy, for no girl in these islands possesses such things.
I have seen gold, and know that it is very precious and does not rust
like iron. A royal gift, Byam! What may we give you in return?"

"This!" I said, clasping the necklace about Tehani's neck, and taking her
by the shoulders as if I would carry her off.

Vehiatua chuckled approvingly. "Well answered!" he said. "A royal gift in
truth. For three and seventy generations she can count her ancestors back
to the gods! Look at her! Where in all these islands will you find her

Early the next morning, Vehiatua's men carried my belongings to the cove,
and presently we went on board and the paddlers drove the vessel out
through the passage, in the morning calm. She was the finest of all the
Indian ships I had seen--her twin hulls each well over a hundred feet
long, and twelve feet deep in the holds. Her two masts, well stayed and
fitted with ratlines up which the sailors could run, spread huge sails of
matting, edged with light frames of wood. On the platform between the two
hulls was the small house in which the chief and his women slept, and it
was here, sheltered from the rays of the sun, that I was invited to
recline during our forty-mile voyage.

We paddled westward, skirting the long reefs of Pare, till the wind made
up, and then, spreading our sails, we raced down the channel between
Tahiti and Eimeo, with a fresh breeze at north-northeast. Toward noon,
when we were off the point of Maraa, the wind died away and presently
made up strong from the southeast, so that we were obliged to make a long
board out to sea. I perceived at this time that the large Indian canoes,
like Vehiatua's, could outpoint and outfoot any European vessel of their
day. With the wind abeam they would have left our best frigates hull-down
in no time, and, close-hauled, they would lay incredibly close to the

The sea was rough off shore, and nearly all of the women on board were
sick, but I was delighted to observe that Tehani was as good a sailor as
I. She was _tapatai_, as the Indians said--fearless of wind and sea.
As we approached the southern coast of Tahiti Nui, she pointed out to me
the principal landmarks on shore, and on Taiarapu, beyond the low isthmus
toward which we were steering. The southeast wind fell away an hour
before sunset, as we were entering a wide passage through the reefs. The
sails were furled and, with a score of paddlers on each side, we rowed
into a magnificent landlocked bay, where the fleets of all the nations of
Europe might have cast anchor, secure from any storm. This bay is on the
south side of the Isthmus of Taravao, and is one of the finest and most
beautiful harbours in the world.

The isthmus was uninhabited and overgrown with jungle, for the Indians
believed it to be the haunt of evil spirits and unfit to be inhabited by
men. We slept on board Vehiatua's vessel that night, and next
morning--since the passage around the southeast extremity of Taiarapu was
judged dangerous, owing to the violent currents and sunken reefs
extending far out to sea--our vessel was dragged on rollers across the
isthmus, a distance of about a mile and a half, by a great company of
people from the near-by district of Vairao, summoned for the purpose. The
principal chiefs and landowners of Tahiti, on their voyages around the
island, always have their canoes dragged across this low land, and in the
course of centuries a deep smooth path has been worn in the soil. The
Vairao people performed their task with remarkable order and
cheerfulness, and in less than three hours' time our vessel was launched
on the north side. At Pueu we entered a passage through the reef and
traveled the rest of the distance in the smooth sheltered water close
along shore. It was mid-afternoon when we reached Tautira, where Vehiatua
resided most of the time.

The chief was received ceremoniously by the members of his household, by
the priest of the temple, who offered up a long prayer of thanks that
Vehiatua had been preserved from the dangers of the sea, and by a vast
throng of his subjects, to whom his justice and good nature had endeared

A meal had been prepared, for news of our coming had preceded us, and
when Vehiatua, Taomi, the old priest, Tuahu, Tehani's elder brother, and
I sat down to eat on the great semicircular verandah of the house, I
caught my breath at the magnificence of the prospect. The house, shaded
by old breadfruit trees, stood on high land, close to the deep clear
river of Vaitepiha. To the east, the blue plain of the Pacific stretched
away to the horizon; to the north and west, across ten miles of calm sea,
Tahiti Nui swept up in all its grandeur to the central peaks; and to the
west I gazed into the heart of the great valley of Vaitepiha, where
cascades hung from cliffs smothered in vegetation of the richest green,
and ridges like knife-blades ran up to peaks like turrets and spires. No
man in the world, perhaps, save Vehiatua, possessed a house commanding
such a view.

Hitihiti and his daughter arrived next day, and the ceremonies of my
marriage with Tehani began on the day following. Vehiatua's first act was
to present me with a fine new house, on the beach, about a cable's length
distant from his own. It had been built for the under chief of the
district, a famous warrior. This good-natured personage moved out
cheerfully when informed that Vehiatua desired the house for his
son-in-law--for so he was kind enough to consider me.

Into my new house I moved at once, with Hitihiti, his daughter, her
husband, and the people of their household who had accompanied them from
Matavai. Early in the morning my party and I set out for Vehiatua's
house, carrying with us numerous gifts. These were termed the o--which is
to say, with truly extraordinary brevity, "insurance of welcome." When
these presents had been formally received, both families joined in a slow
and stately parade to my house, while servants in the rear brought the
bride's gifts--livestock, cloth, mats, furniture, and other things which
would be useful to the new household. A throng of Vehiatua's subjects
lined the path, and a band of strolling players caused constant laughter
with their antics and songs.

In the house, Hina, who represented the female side of my "family,"
spread a large new mat, and on it a sheet of new white cloth. Vehiatua
was a widower, and his older sister, a thin, white-haired old lady,
straight and active as a girl, acted for his clan. Her name was Tetuanui,
and she now spread upon Hina's cloth, half overlapping it, a snow-white
sheet of her own. This symbolized the union of the two families, and
Tehani and I were at once ordered to seat ourselves on the cloth, side by
side. To the right and left of us were arrayed a great quantity of
gifts--mats, capes, and wreaths of bright featherwork. We were then
enjoined to accept these gifts in formal phrases, and when we had done so
Hina and Tetuanui called for their _paoniho_. Every Indian woman was
provided with one of these barbarous little implements--a short stick of
polished wood, set with a shark's tooth keen as any razor. They were used
to gash the head, causing the blood to flow down copiously over the face,
on occasions of mourning and of rejoicing. While the spectators gazed at
them in admiration, the two ladies now did us the honour of cutting their
heads till they bled in a manner which made me long to protest. Taomi,
the priest, took them by the hands and led them around and around us, so
that the blood dripped and mingled on the sheet on which we sat. We were
then directed to rise, and the sheet, stained with the mingled blood of
the two families, was carefully folded up and preserved.

Vehiatua had dispatched to the mountains, the night before, a brace of
his _piimato_, or climbers of cliffs. The office of these men was
hereditary, and every chief kept one or two of them to fetch the skulls
of his ancestors when required for some religious ceremony, and to return
them afterwards to the secret caves, high up on the cliffs, where they
were kept secure from desecration by hostile hands. The _piimato_
carried in each hand a short pointed stick of ironwood, and with the aid
of these they climbed up and down vertical walls of rock to which a
lizard could scarcely cling. The skulls of Vehiatua's ancestors were to
be witnesses of the religious ceremony presently to take place.

When the ceremony of the bride's reception in my house was over, we
paraded slowly back to the house of Vehiatua, and went through a
precisely similar ceremony there, even to the bloodletting and the folded
sheets. This marked my reception into the house of Tehani's family. We
next sat down to a feast, the men apart from the women, which lasted till

The social part of the marriage was now over; the religious remained. It
was performed in Vehiatua's family _marae_, or temple, on the point
not far from his house. Old Taomi, the priest, led the solemn procession.
The temple was a walled enclosure, shaded by huge banyan trees and paved
with flat stones. Along one side a pyramid thirty yards long and twenty
wide rose in four steps to a height of about forty feet, and on top of it
I perceived the effigy of a bird, curiously carved in wood. Accompanied
by Hitihiti and his daughter, I was led to one corner of the enclosure,
while Tehani, with Vehiatua and other relatives, took her place opposite
me. The old priest then approached me solemnly and asked:

"You desire to take this woman for your wife; will not your affection for
her cool?"

"No," I replied.

Taomi next walked slowly across to where my young bride awaited him, and
put the same question to her, and when she answered, "No," he made a sign
to the others, who advanced from their respective corners of the
_marae_ and unfolded the two sheets of white cloth, on which the
blood of the two families was mingled. Other priests now came forward,
bearing very reverently the skulls of Vehiatua's ancestors, some of them
so old that they seemed ready to crumble at a touch. These silent
witnesses to the ceremony were placed carefully in a line on the
pavement, so that their sightless eyes might behold the marriage of their
remote descendant.

The girl and I were told to seat ourselves on the bloodstained sheets of
cloth, hand in hand, while our relatives grouped themselves on either
side. The priest then called upon the mighty chiefs and warriors whose
skulls stood before us, giving each man his full name and resounding
titles, and calling upon him to witness and to bless the union of Tehani
with the white man from beyond the sea. When this was done, old Taomi
turned to me.

"This woman will soon be your wife," he said seriously. "Remember that
she is a woman, and weak. A commoner may strike his wife in anger, but
not a chief. Be kind to her, be considerate of her." He paused, gazing
down at me, and then addressed Tehani: "This man will soon be your
husband. Bridle your tongue in anger; be patient; be thoughtful of his
welfare. If he falls ill, care for him; if he is wounded in battle, heal
his wounds. Love is the food of marriage; let not yours starve." He
paused again and concluded, addressing us both: "_E maitai is mai te
mea ra e e na reira orua_!" This set phrase might be translated: "It
will be well, if thus it be with you two!"

The solemnity of old Taomi's words and manner impressed the girl beside
me so deeply that her hand trembled in mine, and, turning my head, I saw
that there were tears in her eyes. In the dead silence following his
words of admonition, the priest began a long prayer to Taaroa, the god of
the Vehiatua clan, beseeching him to bless our union and to keep us in
bonds of mutual affection. At last he finished, paused, and then called
suddenly: "Bring the _tapoi!_"

A neophyte came running from the rear of the temple, carrying a great
sheet of the sacred brown cloth made by men. The priest seized it, spread
it wide, and flung it over us, covering Tehani and me completely. Next
moment it was flung aside and we were told to rise. The marriage was
over, and we were now embraced in the Indian fashion by the members of
both clans. Of the days of feasting and merrymaking that followed our
wedding there is no need to speak.


It means little to say that I was happy with Tehani. It may mean more to
state that only two women have left their mark on my life--my mother and
the Indian girl. Long before the birth of our daughter I had resigned
myself to the prospect of a life of tranquil happiness in Tautira; the
sense of my immense remoteness from England grew stronger with the
passage of time, and the hope that a ship might come faded into the
background of my thoughts. Had it not been for my mother, who alone
seemed to lend reality to memories of England, I am by no means certain
that the arrival of a ship would have been welcome to me. And since I
felt assured that neither Bligh nor any of those with him in the launch
would ever reach home, I knew that my mother would be in no distress on
my account until it became evident that the _Bounty_ was long
overdue. Adopting old Hitihiti's tropical philosophy, I put the past and
the future out of mind, and for eighteen months--the happiest period of
my entire life I enjoyed each day to the full.

With her marriage, Tehani seemed to take on a new dignity and
seriousness, though in the privacy of our home she showed at times that
she was still the same wild tomboy who had beaten me at swimming in
Matavai. I was working on my dictionary every day, and Sir Joseph Banks
himself could not have entered into these labours with greater enthusiasm
than did my wife. She directed our household with a firmness and skill
that surprised me in so young a girl, leaving me free to do my writing
and to divert myself with fishing parties, or with hunting wild boars in
the hills. But I preferred excursions in which Tehani could accompany me,
and missed many a boar hunt in order to take my wife on short voyages in
our sailing canoe.

About a month after our marriage, Tehani and I sailed down to Matavai for
a visit to my _taio_. I was eager to see old Hitihiti, as well as
Stewart, Morrison, and other friends among the _Bounty's_ people
settled there. The distance is about fifty miles, and with the strong
trade wind abaft the beam we made the passage in less than five hours,
arriving early in the afternoon.

"Your friends are building a ship," Hitihiti informed me as we dined.
"Morrison and Millward, the man with him at the house of Poino, are
directing the task, and several others are helping. They have laid the
keel and made fast the stem and stern. They are working on the point, not
far from the sea."

Toward evening we strolled across to the little shipyard--Hina, her
father, Tehani, and I. Morrison had chosen a glade about a hundred yards
from the beach, an open grassy spot shaded by tall breadfruit trees. A
crowd of Indians sat about on the grass, watching the white men at work.
Their interest was intense, and in return for the privilege of being
spectators they kept the shipbuilders more than supplied with food. The
great chief Teina, to whom the land belonged, was there, with his wife
Itea. They greeted us affably, and at that moment Morrison glanced up and
caught my eye. He laid down his adze, wiped the sweat from his eyes, and
took my hand heartily.

"We have heard of your marriage," he said. "Let me wish you happiness."

I made him known to Tehani, and as he pressed her hand young Tom Ellison
came up to me. "What do you think of our ship, Mr. Byam?" he asked.
"She's only thirty feet long, but Mr. Morrison hopes to sail her to
Batavia. We've christened her already: _Resolution_ is to be her
name. By God, it takes resolution to build a ship without nails, or
proper tools, or sawn-out plank!"

I shook hands with old Coleman, the _Bounty's_ armourer, and with
the German cooper, Hillbrandt. Norman and McIntosh, the carpenter's
mates, were there, and Dick Skinner, the hairdresser who had been flogged
in Adventure Bay. All worked with a will, under Morrison's direction;
some impelled by a desire to reach England, others, conscious of their
guilt, by the fear that a British ship might take them before their
little vessel could set sail.

At sunset the shipwrights laid down their tools, and, leaving Tehani to
return to the house with Hina and my _taio_, I accompanied Morrison
to his residence at the foot of One Tree Hill. He and Millward lived with
the warrior Poino, their friend, a stone's throw from Stew-art's house.

I found Stewart pottering about his garden in the dusk. He had made
Tipau's wild glen a place of ordered beauty, with paths leading this way
and that, bordered with flowering shrubs, and shaded rockeries where he
had planted many kinds of ferns. He made me welcome, straightening his
back and shaking the earth from his hands.

"Byam, you'll stop to sup, of course? And you too, Morrison?"

Ellison passed us at that moment on his way over the hill, for he lived
in Pare, a mile to the west. Stewart liked the lad and called out to him:
"I say, Tom! Won't you stop the night? It will be like old times."

"With all my heart, Mr. Stewart!" he said, grinning. "I'm half afraid to
go home, anyhow."

"What's wrong?" asked Morrison.

"That wench of mine again. Last night she caught me giving her sister a
kiss. I swear there was no harm intended, but do you think she would
listen to reason? She knocked her sister down with a tapa mallet, and
would have done the same for me if I had not run for it."

Stewart laughed. "I've no doubt you deserved it."

Peggy was calling us into the house, and half an hour later we sat down
to our evening meal, served by old Tipau's slaves. Stewart's dining room
was a large thatched house open to the air, and decorated with hanging
baskets of ferns. A man stood at one end, holding aloft a torch which
illuminated the place with a flickering glare. Peggy had gone off to sup
with her women, and Tipau preferred to eat his meal alone.

"How long will it take you to complete your vessel?" I asked Morrison.

"Six months or more. The work goes slowly with so few tools."

"You hope to reach Batavia in her?"

"Yes. From there we can get passage home on a Dutch ship. Five of us are
to make the attempt--Norman, McIntosh, Muspratt, Byrne, and I. Stewart
and Coleman prefer to wait here for an English ship."

"I feel the same," I remarked. "I am happy in Tautira, and glad of the
chance to work on my Indian dictionary."

"As for me," said Stewart, "I find Tahiti a pleasant place enough. And I
have no desire to be drowned!"

"Drowned be damned!" exclaimed Morrison impatiently. "Our little schooner
will be staunch enough to sail around the world!"

"You haven't told Mr. Byam about _us_," put in Ellison. "We are
going to start a little kingdom of our own. Desperate characters we
are--not one but would swing at the yardarm if taken by a British ship!
Mr. Morrison has promised to set us down on some island west of here."

"It is the best thing they can do," said Morrison. "I shall try to find
an island where the people are friendly. Tom is coming, as are Millward,
Burkitt, Hillbrandt, and Sumner. Churchill intends to stay here, though
he's certain to be taken and hanged. Dick Skinner believes it his duty to
give himself up and suffer for his crime. As for Thompson, he is more of
a beast than a man, and I would not have him on board."

"Where is Burkitt?" I asked.

"He and Muspratt are living in Papara," said Stewart, "with the chief of
the Teva clan."

"They offered to join us in the work," Morrison added, "but neither man
has any skill."

I was glad to have news of the _Bounty's_ people, most of whom I
liked. We talked late into the night, while Tipau's man lit torch after
torch from the bundle at his side. The moon was rising when I took leave
of my friends and trudged home along the deserted beach.

I had occasion, the next morning, to recall what Morrison had said of
Thompson, the most stupid and brutal of the _Bounty's_ crew. He and
Churchill had struck up an oddly assorted friendship, and spent most of
their time sailing about the island in a small canoe, fitted with a sail
of canvas. Thompson disliked the Indians as much as he distrusted them,
and on shore was never without a loaded musket in his hand.

Going down to the beach for an early bath in the sea, I found the pair
encamped by their canoe, with a sucking pig roasting on the coals near
by. "Come--join us at breakfast, Mr. Byam," called Churchill, hospitably.

Thompson looked up, scowling. "Damn you, Churchill," he growled--"Let him
find his own grub. We've no more than enough for ourselves."

Churchill flushed. "Hold your tongue, Matt," he exclaimed, "Mr. Byam's my
friend! Go and learn manners from the Indians, before I knock them into
your head!"

Thompson rose and stalked off to a sandhill, where he seated himself
sulkily, his musket between his knees. I had already breakfasted, and as
I turned away I saw a dozen men pulling a large sailing canoe up on the
beach, and the owner and his wife approaching us. The man carried in his
arms a child of three or four years. They stopped by Churchill's canoe to
admire its sail of canvas, and turned to wish us good day. The Indian
woman leaned over the boom to examine the stitching of the bolt rope, and
at that moment I heard Thompson's harsh voice.

"Get out of it!" he ordered abruptly.

The Indians glanced up courteously, not understanding the words, and
Thompson shouted again: "Grease off, damn you!" The Indian couple glanced
at us in bewilderment, and Churchill was opening his mouth to speak when
suddenly, without further warning, the seaman leveled his musket and
fired. The ball passed through the child and through the father's chest;
both fell dying on the beach, staining the sand with their blood. The
woman shrieked and people began to run toward us from the house.

Churchill sprang to his feet and bounded to where Thompson sat, with the
smoking musket in his hand. One blow of his fist stretched the murderer
on the sand; he snatched up the musket, seized Thompson's limp body under
the arms, and ran, dragging him, to where the canoe lay in the wash of
the sea. Setting the musket carefully against a thwart, he tossed his
companion into the bilges as if he had been a dead pig, then sprang into
the canoe, pushing off as he did so. Next moment he had sail on her; the
little vessel was making off swiftly to the west before the gathering
crowd understood what had occurred.

I rushed to the dying father and his small daughter, but perceived at
once that there was nothing to be done for them. Within five minutes both
expired. The moment it was ascertained that they were dead the frantic
mother seized her _paoniho_ and gashed her head in a shocking
manner, while blood covered her face and shoulders. The crew of her
vessel armed themselves with large stones and were beginning to gather
about me threateningly when Hitihiti appeared. He grasped the situation,
and the sullen murmur of the people died away as he held up an arm for

"This man is my _taio_," he said; "he is as innocent as yourselves!
Why do you stand there chattering like women? You have weapons! Launch
your canoe! I know the man who killed your master; he is an evil-smelling
dog, and not one of the Englishmen will lift a hand to protect him!"

They set off at once in pursuit, but, as I learned afterwards, they were
unable to come up with the fugitives. The dead were buried the same
night, and Hina and Tehani did their best to comfort the poor woman,
whose home was on the neighbouring island of Eimeo. The sequel to this
tragedy came a fortnight later, when Tehani and I returned to our home.

Fearing to land on the west side of Tahiti, and wishing to put the
greatest possible distance between themselves and Matavai, Churchill had
steered his canoe through the dangerous reefs at the south end of
Taiarapu and sailed on to Tautira, where Vehiatua, supposing him to be
one of my friends, had welcomed him. But Thompson's reputation had
preceded him, and he found himself shunned and abhorred by all. Churchill
was by this time heartily sick of his companion and desired nothing
better than to be rid of him. He told me as much when he came to my house
on the evening of our arrival, musket in hand.

"I've half a mind to shoot the fellow!" he remarked. "Hanging's too good
for him! But damn me if I can shoot a man in cold blood! I was a fool not
to leave him to be dealt with by the Indians in Matavai!"

"They'd have made short work of him," I said.

"And a bloody good job! I'm done with him. I told him to-day he could
have the canoe if he'd get out of here and not come back."

"Leave him to the Indians," I suggested. "They'd have killed him long
since had he not been with you."

"Aye. Look--there he is now."

Thompson was seated alone on the beach, half a cable's length from us,
with the air of a man brooding over his wrongs, as he nursed the musket
between his knees.

"The man's half mad," growled Churchill. "You've a musket, Byam; best
load it and keep it handy till he's gone."

"Are you planning to stop in Tautira?" I asked after a pause.

"Yes. I like the old chief--your father-in-law, whatever he is--and he
seems to like me. He's a fighting man, and so is the other chief,
Atuanui. We were planning a bit of a war last night. He says if I'll help
him he'll give me a piece of land, with a fine young wife thrown in. But
come--it is time we went to his house."

Vehiatua had bidden us to witness a _heiva_ that evening--a night
dance of the kind I had seen in Tetiaroa long before. We found the
grounds bright with torchlight and thronged with spectators, and when we
had greeted our friends, Tehani and I seated ourselves with Churchill on
the grass, on the outer fringe of the audience.

The drums had scarcely struck up when I heard an Indian shout warningly
behind us, followed instantly by the report of a musket. Churchill
attempted to spring to his feet, but sank down coughing beside me, the
musket dropping from his nerveless hand. Women were shrieking and men
shouting on all sides, and I heard Vehiatua's voice boom out above the
uproar: "Aye! Kill him! Kill him!" In the flickering torchlight I saw
Thompson break away from the scuffle behind me and begin to run toward
the beach with ungainly bounds, still clinging to his musket. Atuanui,
the warrior chief, snatched up a great stone and hurled it with his
giant's arm. It struck the murderer between the shoulders, and sent him
sprawling. Next moment the Indian warrior was upon him, beating out his
brains with the same stone that had brought him down. When I returned to
the house, Churchill was dead.

Since the Indians made war, and abandoned plans for war, for reasons
which struck me as frivolous in the extreme, the loss of Churchill was
accepted as an unfavourable omen by Vehiatua's priests, and the
expedition planned against the people of the south coast of Eimeo was
given up. I was secretly glad to be freed from the duty of taking up arms
against men to whom I bore no and settled down with relief to a tranquil
domestic life and my studies of the Indian tongue.

I shall not cumber this narrative with my observations on the life and
customs of the Indians--their religion, their intricate system of
_tapu_, their manner of making war, their _arioi_ society, and
their arts and sciences, all of which have been fully described by Cook,
Bougainville, and other early visitors to Tahiti. But I shall do the
people of Tahiti the justice to mention two of their customs, shocking in
themselves, but less so when the reasons for them are made clear. I
allude to infanticide and human sacrifice.

Nowhere in the world are children cherished more tenderly than in the
South Sea, yet infanticide was considered by the Indians a praiseworthy
act of self-sacrifice. The object of the _arioi_ society--the
strolling players whose chiefs were of the most considerable families in
Tahiti--was to set an example both to chiefs and to commoners, as a
warning against overpopulating the island. Should a member of the society
give birth to a female child, it was killed at once, in the quickest and
most painless manner, and their greatest term of contempt was _vahine
fanaunau_--a fertile woman. The Indians had a perfect understanding of
the dangers of overpopulation, and guarded against them by making large
families unfashionable. Cruel as the method seems, it should not be
criticized without reflecting that men increase, while the amount of
habitable land on a small island remains the same.

As for human sacrifice, the ceremony was rarely performed, and then only
on the altar of Oro, god of war. The victim was taken unaware and killed
mercifully, by a sudden blow from behind, and he was without exception a
man who, in the opinion of the chiefs, deserved death for the public
good. In a land where courts, judges, and executioners were unknown, the
prospect of being sacrificed to the god of war restrained many a man from
crimes against society.

The people of Tahiti were fortunate in many respects--the climate, the
fertility of their island, and the abundance of food to be obtained with
little effort; yet they were still more fortunate, perhaps, in their lack
of money or any other general medium of exchange. Hogs, mats, or bark
cloth might be given as a reward for building a house or the tattooing of
a young chief, but such property was perishable, and considered a gift
rather than an exchange. Since there was nothing that a miser might
hoard, avarice, that most contemptible of human failings, was unknown,
and there was little incentive to greed. To be accused of meanness was
dreaded by chief and commoner alike, for a mean man was considered an
object of ridicule. By our introduction of iron, and inculcation of the
principles of barter, there is no doubt that we have worked the Indians
infinite harm.

On the fifteenth of August, 1790, our daughter Helen was born. The child
was given Tehani's name and long title, which in truth I cannot
recollect, but I gave her my mother's name as well. She was a lovely
little creature, with strange and beautiful eyes, dark blue as the sea,
and since she was our first-born, or _matahiapo_, her birth was the
occasion for ceremonies religious and political.

A large enclosure had been fenced on the sacred ground behind Vehiatua's
family temple, and three small houses built within. The first was called
"The House of Sweet Fern," in which the mother was to be delivered of her
child; the second was known as "The House of the Weak," where mother and
child would pass a fortnight afterwards; the third was called "The Common
House" and had been built to shelter Tehani's attendants. For six days
after our little Helen was born, silence reigned on sea and land along
the coast of Tiarapu; all of the commoners retiring into the mountain
fastnesses, where they might converse, build fires for their cooking, and
live in comfort till the restriction was over.

On the seventh day I was admitted into the House of the Weak, and saw my
daughter for the first time. Vehiatua and I went together, for no man
save Taomi, the priest, had set foot within the enclosure till that time.
It was dark in the house, and for a moment I could scarcely make out
Tehani on her couch of soft mats and tapa, nor the tiny newcomer, waving
chubby fists at me.

Our child was three months old when Stewart and Peggy sailed around the
island to visit us. They had a small daughter of their own, as I had
learned some time before, and the two young mothers found in their
children an inexhaustible subject of conversation. Stewart spent a week
with us, and one day of the seven stands out in my memory.

It was still dark when I rose that morning, but when I emerged from my
plunge into the river the fowls were beginning to flutter down from the
trees. As I stood on the bank, breathing deep of the cool morning air, I
felt a touch on my shoulder and found my wife beside me.

"They are still asleep," she said; "you should see Helen and little
Peggy, side by side! Look, there is not a cloud in the sky! Let us take a
small canoe and paddle to Fenua Ino--the four of us, and the children,
and Tuahu."

We had often spoken of spending a day on the islet of Fenua Ino, a place
I had never visited, and, knowing that Stewart would enjoy the trip, I
assented readily. We chose a single canoe, stocked her with provisions
and drinking-nuts, and installed the two sleeping babies on soft tapa,
side by side in the shell of a large sea-turtle, well polished and
cleaned, and shaded with green coconut fronds. Tuahu, my brother-in-law,
was a tall, powerful young man, a year older than I, and as pleasant a
companion as I have ever known. He took his place in the stern, to steer
us through the reefs, and set us a lively stroke. Stewart and I had long
since become accomplished hands in a canoe, and our wives were strong,
active girls, able to wield a paddle with any man.

For five miles south from Tautira, the coast is sheltered by a reef at
some distance from the land, and is perhaps the richest and most densely
populated district in all Tahiti. This was the coast I had seen when the
_Bounty_ first approached the island, so long before. Then the reef
ceases, and the Pacific thunders against the tall green cliffs called Te
Pari--a wild region, uninhabited and believed to be the haunt of evil
spirits. At the beginning of the cliffs, where the reef ended, was the
small coral island, about half a mile from shore, where we planned to
spend the day.

We spread our mats in the shade of a great unfamiliar tree, and Tuahu
fetched our lunch and the turtle shell. Stewart called to his wife:
"Bring the children, Peggy. Byam and I will keep an eye on them, and have
a yarn while you and Tehani explore the island."

Stewart and I stretched ourselves out comfortably in the shade. Our
daughters slept in their odd cradle, starting a little from time to time
as babies do, but never opening an eye.

"Byam, what do you suppose has become of Christian?" Stewart asked.
"Sometimes I think that he may have killed himself."

"Never! He felt too deeply his responsibility toward the others."

"Perhaps you are right. By this time they must have settled on some
island--I wonder where!"

"I have often puzzled over that question," I replied. "They might have
gone to one of the Navigators' Islands, or to any of the coral islands we
passed on the voyage north."

Stewart shook his head. "I think not," he said; "those places are too
well known. There must be scores of rich islands still uncharted in this
part of the sea. Christian would be more apt to search for some such
place, where he would be safer from pursuit."

I made no reply and for a long time we lay sprawled in the shade, our
hands behind our heads. I felt deeply the lonely peace and beauty of the
islet. Beyond the long white curve of the reef, a northerly breeze
ruffled the Pacific gently. I groped in memory for a phrase of Greek and
at last it came to me--"wine-dark sea." Stewart spoke, half to himself,
as if putting his thoughts into words: "What a place for a hermit's

"Would you like to live here?" I asked.

"Perhaps. But I would miss the sight of English faces. You, Byam, living
alone among the Indians, do you never miss your own kind?"

I thought for a moment before I replied: "Not thus far."

Stewart smiled. "You are half Indian already. Dearly as I love Peggy, I
would be less happy at Matavai without Ellison. I've grown fond of the
lad, and he spends half his time at our house. It's a damned shame he had
to meddle in the mutiny."

"There's not an ounce of harm in the young idiot," I said; "and now he
must sail away with Morrison and pass the rest of his days in hiding, on
some cannibal island to the west. All for the pleasure of waving a
bayonet under Bligh's nose!"

"They'll be launching the _Resolution_ in another six weeks,"
remarked Stewart. "Morrison has done wonders! She's a staunch little
ship, fit to weather anything."

Our wives were approaching us, followed by Tuahu, who carried a mass of
sweet-scented flowers which they had woven into wreaths for us.

One flower in particular, in long sprays and wonderfully fragrant, took
my fancy. It was unknown on Tahiti, and our companions were trying to
recall its name.

"It is common in the low islands east of here, where the people eat man,"
said Tuahu; "I saw hundreds of the trees in Anaa, when I was there last
year. They have a name for it in their language, as we have in ours, but
I forget both."

"_Tafano!_" exclaimed Tehani, suddenly.

"Aye, that's it!" said her brother, and I made a note of the word for my

We fetched the baskets of food for the girls, and retired to a little
distance, Indian fashion, to eat our own lunch. When it was over and we
were together once more, in the shade, Tuahu recounted the legend of the

"Shall I tell you why no men live here?" he began. "It is because of the
danger at night. Several times in the past men have tried to sleep here,
out of bravado, or because they did not know. All have crossed to Tahiti
in the morning silent and dejected, and died soon after, raving mad.
Since the very beginning, a woman has come here each night when the sun
has set. She is more lovely than any mortal, with a melodious voice, long
shining hair, and eyes no man can resist. Her pleasure is to seduce
mortal men, knowing that her embraces mean madness and death."

Stewart winked at me. He plucked two blades of coarse grass, a long and a
short, and held them out. "Come," he said banteringly, with a glance at
the girls, "we'll draw to see who stops the night."

But Tehani snatched the grass from his hand. "Stop the night if you
like," she said to Stewart, "but Byam goes ashore! I want no demon-woman
for him, nor mortal girls who would swim out to impersonate her!"

Stewart sailed for Matavai on the day after our picnic, and' four months
passed before I saw him again. Yet as I review those months in memory,
they seem no longer than so many weeks. It has often been observed--with
a justice for which I can vouch--that in the South Sea men lose their
sense of the passage of time. In a climate where perpetual summer reigns
and there is little to distinguish one week from another, the days slip
by imperceptibly.

That year of 1790 was the happiest and seemed the shortest of my entire
life. And 1791 began happily enough; January passed, and February, and
toward the middle of March Tehani sailed with Vehiatua to the other side
of the island, to take part in some religious ceremony. The Indian
ceremonies of this nature were wearisome to me, and I decided to remain
in Tautira, with my brother-in-law. My wife had been gone a week or more
when the ship came.

Tuahu and I had been amusing ourselves at a _heiva_ the night
before, and, returning late to bed, I slept till the sun was up. Tuahu
woke me with a hand on my shoulder. "Byam!" he said in a voice breathless
with excitement. "Wake up! A ship! A ship!"

Rubbing the sleep from my eyes, I followed him to the beach, where
numbers of people were already gathering. All were staring out to the
east, into the dazzling light of the morning sun. There was a light
breeze at east by north, and far offshore, so far that she was hull-down
and her courses hidden by the curve of the world, I saw a European ship.
Topsails, topgallants, and royals--looking small, dark, and weatherbeaten
in the level light--were visible, though the distance was still too great
to guess at her nationality. The Indians were in great excitement.

"If a Spanish ship," I heard one man say, "she will put in here."

"And if French, she will go to Hitiaa!"

"British ships always go to Matavai," said Tuahu, glancing at me for

"Do you think she is British?" asked Tetuanui, my wife's old aunt. I
shrugged my shoulders, and an Indian said: "She is not Spanish, anyway.
They are standing off too far."

The vessel was approaching the land on the starboard tack, and it was
clear that she was not steering for the Spanish anchorage at Pueu. She
might have been a French frigate making for Bougainville's harbour, or a
British vessel bound for Matavai. We seated ourselves on the grass, and
presently, as she drew slightly nearer and the light increased, I was all
but convinced, from the shape of her topsails, that she was British. I
sprang to my feet.

"Tuahu," I said, "I believe she's British! Let us take your small sailing
canoe and run down to Matavai."

My brother-in-law sprang up eagerly. "We shall beat them there by hours,"
he exclaimed; "this wind always blows strongest close to land. They will
be becalmed offshore."

We made a hasty breakfast on cold pork and yams, left over from the night
before, had the canoe well stocked with provisions and drinking nuts, and
set sail within the hour, accompanied by one man. As Tuahu had predicted,
the wind blew strong alongshore, while the vessel four or five miles
distant lay almost becalmed. With the fresh breeze abeam, our canoe tore
through the sheltered water within the reefs, headed out into the open
sea at Pueu, and sailed past Hitiaa and Tiarei. It was mid-afternoon when
we ran through the gentle breakers before Hitihiti's house. The place was
deserted, for news of the ship had preceded us, and my _taio_, with
all his household, had repaired to the lookout point on One Tree Hill.


Throughout the day the Indians had been coming to Matavai in great
numbers, and many canoes were drawn up on the beach, belonging to those
who had arrived from remote parts of the island. When I climbed One Tree
Hill, late in the afternoon, I found it thronged with people keeping a
lookout for the vessel. The excitement was intense. It was such a scene
as must have presented itself twenty-four years earlier when Captain
Wallis arrived in the _Dolphin_, the first European vessel to visit
the island. The crowd was so great that I had difficulty in finding
Stewart. Presently I spied him with some of the Matavai people, standing
near the ancient flowering tree which gave the hill its name. He made his
way to me at once.

"I've been expecting you all day, Byam," he said. "What can you tell me
of the ship? You must have seen her as you were coming round the coast."

"Yes," I replied. "She's an English frigate, I should say."

"I thought as much," he replied, sadly. "I suppose I should be glad. In
one sense, I am, of course. But fate has played a sorry trick upon us.
You must feel that, too?"

I did feel it, profoundly. The first sight of the vessel had given me a
moment of keen happiness. I knew that it meant home; but after all these
months Tahiti was home as well, and I realized that I was bound to the
island by ties no less strong than those which drew me from it. Either to
go or to stay seemed a cruel choice; but we well knew that there would be
no choice. Our duty was plain. We should have to go aboard as soon as the
ship came to anchor and report the mutiny.

We had little doubt that the vessel had been sent out in search of the
_Bounty_. The Indians, of course, had no inkling of this. They
believed that the awaited ship probably belonged to Captain Cook, coming
for additional supplies of young breadfruit trees, and that Captain
Bligh, his supposed son, would be with him. While Stewart and I were
talking, a messenger from Teina was sent in search of us. He wished to
see us at his house. We sent back word that we would come shortly.

"What of our wives and children?" Stewart asked gloomily. "It may seem
strange to you, Byam, but the truth is that I have never before realized
that we should have to go. England seems so far away, as though it were
on another planet.

"I know," I replied. "My feeling has been the same."

He shook his head mournfully. "Let's not talk of it. You are certain the
ship is English?"

"All but certain."

"In that case, I'm sorry for poor Morrison. He left in the schooner four
days ago. They may be well on their way westward by this time."

Morrison's plans, he told me, had not changed. All the mutineers
remaining on Tahiti, with the exception of Skinner, had decided to go
with him in the _Resolution_. They had agreed among themselves to go
ashore at some island to the westward where there would be little chance
of their ever being discovered. Morrison, Norman, McIntosh, Byrne, and
Muspratt would then try to make their way to Batavia, on the island of
Java, where they hoped to sell the schooner and take passage in some ship
bound to Europe.

"It's a desperate venture for all of them," Stewart continued. "There are
Ellison, Hillbrandt, Burkitt, Millward, and Sumner to be left at some
island yet to be decided upon. God knows what their fate will be! They
have firearms and think they will be able to defend themselves until they
can establish friendly relations with the people. But what can five men
do against hundreds of savages? We know what the islanders to the
westward are like; our experiences at Namuka taught us that. They are as
good as dead, in my opinion."

"They will have a fighting chance at least," I said. "In any event it
will be better than being taken home to be hung."

"Yes, they were wise to go, no doubt. What chance do you think Morrison
has of reaching Batavia?"

We discussed the matter at length. Morrison was an excellent navigator,
and five men were ample to work the little schooner. They were provided
with a compass and one of Captain Bligh's charts of the passage through
Endeavour Straits; but looked at in the most hopeful light, it seemed
doubtful indeed that the _Resolution_ would ever reach Batavia.
Stewart told me that the schooner had first gone to the district of
Papara, on the southern side of Tahiti, to pick up McIntosh, Hillbrandt,
and Millward. It was possible, he thought, that the schooner might still
be there.

Presently a great shout went up from the watchers on the hill. The
frigate had been sighted as she emerged from behind a distant headland.
She was four or five miles offshore, and the dying wind was so light that
we knew she could not make the land before dark. Evidently her captain
realized this, for shortly afterward the ship hove-to under her topsails.

Some of the Indians remained on the hill, but most of them, seeing that
the vessel did not intend to come in that night, descended with us. On
our way to Teina's house we met Skinner and Coleman, who had been on an
excursion into the mountains and had only just heard the news of the
frigate. Coleman was deeply moved when I told him that the ship was,
almost certainly, English. More than any of us, with the exception of
Morrison, had he longed for home. He had a wife and children there and
had formed no alliance with any of the Tahitian women. Tears of joy
dimmed his eyes, and without waiting for further information he rushed up
the hill for a sight of the vessel that would take him to England.

Stewart and I were concerned for Skinner. He had long since repented of
the part he had taken in the mutiny, and was, in fact, the only one of
the mutineers who had done so. His sense of guilt had grown stronger as
the months had passed. A deeply religious man, he had brooded over his
disloyalty to the Crown and was determined to give himself up at the
first opportunity. We knew that repentance, however sincere, would have
no weight with a court-martial. His doom was certain if he surrendered
himself. Guilty though he undoubtedly was, we had no desire to see the
poor fellow clapped into irons and taken to England to be hung. But he
would not listen to our suggestions that he try to hide himself while
there was yet time.

"I have no wish to escape," he said. "I know what will happen when I
surrender myself, but my death will be a warning to others who may be
tempted to mutiny."

We pleaded with him for some time, but it was useless, so we left him and
proceeded to Teina's house. We found the chief at supper, which he asked
us to share with him, and while we ate he plied us with questions
concerning the vessel. How many guns was she likely to carry? How many
men? Would King George be aboard? And the like. All the Tahitians had a
great desire to see the King of England, and Bligh, as well as the
British captains who had visited the island before him, had played upon
their credulity to the extent of giving them reason to hope that the King
might some day visit Tahiti.

We explained to Teina that King George had great dominions, and was so
occupied with affairs at home, particularly in wars with neighboring
nations, that he had little opportunity for voyaging to such far places.

"But Tuté will come," Teina said, with conviction. (Tuté was the
universal name for Captain Cook, the nearest they could come to the sound
of it; and Bligh was called Parai.) "Parai promised that Tuté would come.
This must be his ship." He went on to conjecture what the purpose of this
visit might be. He believed that Cook and Bligh, if the latter chanced to
be with him, would now decide to remain permanently at Tahiti. He would
urge them to do so, and would set aside great tracts of land for their
use and provide them with as many servants as they might want. With their
help he would bring the whole of Tahiti under subjection; then we would
all proceed to the island of Eimeo, and on to Raiatea and Bora Bora,
conquering each of these islands in turn. And he promised that Stewart
and I should be made great chiefs, and that our children should grow in
power after us.

It must have been well past midnight when we left Teina's house, but none
of the people there or elsewhere thought of sleep that night. Those who
had come from distant parts were encamped along the beach and among the
groves inland, and the light of their fires illuminated the entire circle
of the bay. Canoes were still arriving, most of them small craft
containing ten or a dozen men, bringing island produce to be bartered for
the trade goods of the vessel. As we walked down the beach we saw one
huge canoe, containing fifty or more paddlers, just entering the bay. Her
men were singing as they urged her forward, and the blades of the paddles
flashed in the firelight as they approached. It was an interesting sight
to watch them berth her. With her great curved stern rising high above
the water, she looked like some strange sea monster. She was heavily
loaded and grounded at some distance from the beach, whereupon all the
men leaped out and brought her farther along. There must have been one
hundred people in her, to say nothing of the cargo of pigs and fowls.
When these had been unloaded, rollers were placed under her keel, and
with twenty or thirty men on each side she was quickly run up the long
slope of the beach to level ground.

We went to Stewart's house, which stood just under One Tree Hill, on the
western side of the bay. Here, too, everyone was astir. Peggy, Stewart's
wife, with their little daughter asleep on the mat beside her, was
sorting over great rolls of tapa cloth, selecting the finest pieces as
gifts for her husband's friends on the ship. She took it for granted that
we must know everyone aboard, and it was plain that she had no suspicion
of what the arrival of the vessel might mean to us both. Presently I went
off to seek Tuahu and my other friends from Tautira who were encamped
near by. By this time dawn was not far off, and Tuahu suggested that we
should take a canoe and paddle out to sea to meet the vessel.

"If it is a strange ship, Byam, the captain will be glad of a pilot into
the bay. But I think it is Parai coming back to see us. We shall be the
first to met him."

I agreed to the proposal at once, and taking old Paoto, Tuahu's servant,
with us, we hauled our canoe to the water, and a few moments later had
rounded Point Venus and were well out to sea.

Tahiti had never seemed so beautiful as on that morning, in the faint
light of dawn. The stars were shining brightly when we set out, but they
faded gradually, and the island stood out in clear, cold silhouette
against the sky. We paddled steadily for half an hour before we caught
sight of the ship, and then drifted to wait for her to come up with us.
The breeze was of the lightest, and an hour later she was still at a
considerable distance. She was a frigate of twenty-four guns, and,
although I was convinced that she was British, my heart leaped when at
last I saw the English colours.

In my first eagerness to go off to her, I had forgotten that I was
dressed as an Indian and not as an English midshipman. My only remaining
uniform had come to grief at Tautira. I had not worn it from the day I
left the _Bounty_, but had kept it carefully wrapped in a piece of
tapa cloth hanging from a rafter in my house. Thinking it safe there, I
had not examined the parcel in many months, and when at last I did so I
found that it had been nearly devoured by rats, and was past all hope of
repair. This mattered nothing then, for I had long since adopted the
Tahitian costume, and for the most part wore nothing but a girdle of tapa
and a turban of the same material. Reminded now of my half-naked
condition, I was tempted to turn back, but it was too late to reconsider.
The vessel was only a few hundred yards distant and had altered her
course to pick us up.

The larboard bulwarks were crowded with men, and I saw the captain on the
quarter-deck with his spyglass leveled at us, and a group of officers
standing behind him. As the ship came alongside we paddled with her, and
a line was thrown to us from the gangway. I clambered aboard and Tuahu
after me. Paoto remained in the canoe, which was veered astern and towed
after us.

My skin was as brown as that of the Indians themselves, and, with my arms
covered with tattooing, it is not strange that I should have been
mistaken for a Tahitian. A lieutenant stood at the gangway, and as we
reached the deck sailors and marines alike crowded close for a better
view. The lieutenant smiled ingratiatingly and patted Tuahu on the
shoulder. "Maitai! Maitai!" (Good! Good!) he said. This was evidently the
only Indian word he knew.

"You can address him in English, sir," I said, smiling. "He understands
it very well. My name is Byam, Roger Byam, late midshipman of His
Majesty's ship _Bounty_. If you like, I shall be glad to pilot you
in to the anchorage."

The expression on the lieutenant's face altered at once. Without replying
he glanced me up and down, from head to foot.

"Corporal of marines!" he called.

The corporal advanced and saluted.

"Fall in a guard and take this man aft."

To my astonishment four men with muskets and bayonets fixed were told
off, and I was placed in the midst of them, and in this manner marched to
the captain, who awaited us on the quarter-deck. The lieutenant preceded
us. "Here's one of the pirates, sir," he said.

"That I am not, sir!" I replied. "No more than you yourself!"

"Silence!" the captain ordered. He regarded me with an expression of cold
hostility, but I was too incensed at the accusation to hold my tongue.

"Allow me to speak, sir," I said. "I am not one of the mutineers. My name

"Did you hear me, you scoundrel? I ordered you to be silent!"

I was hot with shame and anger, but I had self-possession enough not to
give way further to it, and I was certain that the misunderstanding with
respect to me would soon be cleared up. I saw Tuahu regarding me with an
expression of utter amazement. I was not permitted to speak to him.

The most humiliating treatment was yet to come. The armourer was sent
for, and a few moments later handcuffs were placed upon me and I was
taken under guard to the captain's cabin, there to await his pleasure.
Two hours passed, during which time I was kept standing by the door. I
saw no one except the guards, who refused to speak to me. Meanwhile the
ship had been worked into Matavai Bay and came to anchor at the same spot
where the _Bounty_ had lain upon her arrival nearly three years
earlier. Through the ports I could see the throngs of Indians along the
shore and canoes putting off to the frigate. In one of the first of these
were Coleman and Stewart. Stewart was dressed in his midshipman's
uniform, and Coleman in an old jacket and a pair of trousers patched with
pieces of tapa cloth, all that remained of his European clothing. Their
canoes passed under the counter and I saw no more of them for some time.

The frigate was called the _Pandora_, and she was commanded by
Captain Edward Edwards, a tall spare man with cold blue eyes and pale
bony hands and face. As soon as the ship was safely anchored he came to
his cabin, followed by one of his lieutenants, Mr. Parkin. He seated
himself at his table and ordered me to be brought before him. I protested
at once against the treatment I had received, but he ordered me to be
silent, and sat for some time regarding me as though I were a curiosity
brought to him for examination. Having finished his scrutiny, he leaned
back in his chair and gazed sternly at my face.

"What is your name?"

"Roger Byam."

"You were a midshipman on His Majesty's armed vessel, the _Bounty_?"

"Yes, sir."

"How many of the _Bounty's_ company are now on the island of

"Three, I believe, not counting myself."

"Who are they?"

I gave him their names.

"Where is Fletcher Christian, and where is the _Bounty_?"

I told him of Christian's departure with eight of the mutineers, and of
all the events that had taken place at Tahiti since that time. I told him
of the building of the schooner, under Morrison's supervision, and of
Morrison's intention to sail with her to Batavia, where he hoped to find
a homeward-bound ship.

"A likely story!" he said grimly. "In that case, why did not you go with

"Because the schooner was not well found for so long a voyage. It seemed
to me wiser to wait here for the arrival of an English ship."

"Which you never expected to see, no doubt. You will be surprised to
learn that Captain Bligh, and the men who were driven from his ship with
him, have succeeded in reaching England?"

"I am profoundly glad to hear it, sir."

"And you will be equally surprised to learn that all the facts of the
mutiny, including that of your own villainy, are known."

"My villainy, sir? I am as free from guilt in that affair as any member
of your own ship's company!"

"You dare to deny that you plotted with Christian to seize the

"Surely, sir, you must know that some of us who were left in the ship
were compelled to remain for lack of accommodation in the launch? There
were nine of us who took no part whatever in the mutiny. The launch was
so overloaded that Captain Bligh himself begged that no more men should
be sent into her; and he promised, if ever he reached England, to do
justice to those of us who were forced to remain behind. Why, then, am I
treated as though I were a pirate? If Captain Bligh were here..."

Edwards cut me short.

"That will do," he said. "You will meet Captain Bligh in good time, when
you have been taken to England to suffer the punishment you so richly
merit. Now then, will you or will you not tell me where the _Bounty_
is to be found?"

"I have told you all that I know, sir."

"I shall find her and those who went with her, be sure of that. And I
promise that neither you nor they shall gain by an attempt to shield

I was too angry and sick at heart to reply. Never, during all the months
that had passed since the mutiny, had I suspected that I might be
considered a member of Christian's party. Although I had not been able to
speak with Bligh on the morning the ship was seized, Nelson, and others
who went in the launch, knew of my loyalty and of my intention to leave
with them. I had supposed that Bligh himself must have known, and I could
not imagine what might have happened to cause me to be listed among the
mutineers. I was eager to know the fate of those who had gone with Bligh,
and how many of them had reached England safely, but Edwards would not
permit me to inquire.

"You are here to be questioned, not I," he said. "You still refuse to
tell me where Christian is?"

"I know no more than you do, sir," I replied.

He turned to the lieutenant.

"Mr. Parkin, have this man sent below, and see to it that he has no
communication with anyone...Wait a moment. Ask Mr. Hayward to step in."

My surprise at the mention of Hayward's name must have been apparent. A
moment later the door opened, and Thomas Hayward, my former messmate on
the _Bounty_, appeared. Forgetting my shackles, I stepped forward to
greet him, but he' gazed at me with a look of contempt, at the same time
putting his hands behind his back.

"You know this man, Mr. Hayward?"

"Yes, sir. He is Roger Byam, a former midshipman on the _Bounty_."

"That will do," said Edwards. With another cool glance at me, Hayward
went out, and I was taken by the guard to the orlop deck, to a place
evidently prepared for prisoners, next to the bread room. It was a foul
situation, below the water line, and nauseating with the stench of the
bilges. The only means of ventilation was a ladderway some distance
forward. Irons were now placed on my legs as well as on my wrists, and
here I was left, with two guards outside the door at either end of the
compartment. About an hour later, Stewart, Coleman, and Skinner were
brought down and ironed in the same manner. No one, save the guard who
brought our food, was permitted to enter the place, and we were forbidden
to speak to each other. There we lay the whole of that interminable day,
as wretched in mind and body as men could well be.


During the next four days, Stewart, Coleman, Skinner, and I were
conscious of little save our own misery. A frigate's orlop deck is a foul
place in which to be confined at any time, and with the ship at anchor,
in the lee of a tropical island, the heat and stench were scarcely to be
endured. Our sentinels were changed every two hours, and I remember with
what longing we watched the departing guard returning to the freshness of
the open air. Food was brought to us morning and evening, and only thus
were we able to distinguish night from day, for no sunlight penetrated to
our quarters. Our victuals were the rancid salt beef and hard bread which
the _Pandora_ had carried all the way from England, with never an
addition of the fresh meat, fruit, and vegetables which the island
furnished in such abundance. But more than food we craved fresh air and
the luxury of movement. Our leg irons were made fast to ringbolts in the
planking, and although we could rise to our feet, we could take no more
than one short step in either direction.

On the fifth morning of our confinement, the corporal of marines appeared
with an extra guard. My leg irons were removed and I was taken up the
ladderway and aft along the gundeck to a cabin on the starboard side of
the vessel. It was the surgeon's cabin, and the surgeon himself, Dr.
Hamilton, was awaiting me there. He dismissed the guard and then,
observing that I was in handcuffs, recalled the corporal and requested
that these be removed. The man was reluctant to comply.

"Lieutenant Parkin's orders were..."

"Nonsense," the doctor interrupted. "Take them off. I'll answer for this
man's safety." The irons were then removed and once more the corporal
retired. The surgeon turned the key in the lock, smiling as he did so.

"I'm not taking this precaution against yourself, Mr. Byam," he said. "I
wish our conversation to be uninterrupted. Please to be seated."

He was a sturdily built man of forty, or thereabout, with a pleasant
voice and manner. He looked like a ship's surgeon and a capable one. I
felt drawn to him immediately. After the treatment accorded us by Edwards
and Parkin, mere courtesy seemed, by contrast, the highest of virtues. I
seated myself on his clothes chest and waited for him to speak.

"First," he said, "about your studies of the Tahitian language. You will
wonder how I know of them. Of that, presently. Have you continued them
during your sojourn here?"

"I have, sir," I replied. "Not a day has passed that I have not added to
my dictionary. I have also compiled a grammar for the use of those who
may wish to study the language hereafter."

"Good! Sir Joseph Banks was not mistaken, I see, in the confidence he
placed in you."

"Sir Joseph! You know him, sir?" I asked, eagerly.

"Not as intimately as I could wish. In fact, I met him only shortly
before the _Pandora_ sailed; but he is an esteemed friend of friends
of mine."

"Then you can tell me whether he believes me guilty in this affair of the
mutiny. Do you yourself, sir, think I could have been so mad as to have
joined it? And yet I have been treated by Captain Edwards as though I
were one of the ringleaders."

The surgeon regarded me gravely for a moment.

"I will say this, Mr. Byam, if it will afford you comfort. You have not
the look of a guilty man. As for Sir Joseph, despite all that has been
said against you, he still believes in your innocence...

"Wait! Allow me to continue," he went on as I was about to interrupt him.
"I am as ready to hear what you have to say as you are to speak; but let
me first inform you how serious the charges laid against you seem to be.
I have been informed on this matter by Sir Joseph, who has not only
talked with Captain Bligh, but has read the sworn statement concerning
the mutiny which he has furnished to the Admiralty. I will not give the
details. One will suffice to show how deeply you are implicated. On the
night before the _Bounty_ was seized, Captain Bligh himself, coming
on deck during the middle watch, surprised you and Mr. Christian in
earnest conversation. And Captain Bligh, so he insists, overheard you say
to Mr. Christian: 'You can count on me, sir,' or words to that precise

I was so taken aback as to be speechless for a moment. However strange it
may seem, although I had the clearest recollection of the conversation
with Christian, this vastly important detail had quite slipped from
memory. The excitement of the events immediately following had, I
suppose, driven it from my mind. Now that it had been recalled to me, I
realized at once how black the appearances against me must be, and that
Bligh was justified in placing the most damning construction upon what I
had said. What could he have believed except that I was pledging my
allegiance to Christian in his plan to seize the ship?

Dr. Hamilton sat with his hands clasped, his elbows on the arms of his
chair, waiting for me to speak.

"It is plain from your manner, Mr. Byam, that you have a recollection of
such a conversation."

"I have, sir. I said those very words to Mr. Christian, and under the
circumstances described by Captain Bligh." I then proceeded to tell him
the whole story of the mutiny, omitting nothing. He heard me through
without comment. When I had finished he gazed at me keenly; then he said,
"My boy, you have convinced me, and here's my hand on it!" I shook it
warmly. "But I must tell you that my conviction is due to your manner
rather than to the matter you have related. You must see for yourself
that the very plausibility of your story is against it."

"How is that, sir?" I asked.

"Understand--I believe you; but put yourself in the place of the ships'
captains who will sit at the court-martial. Your sincerity of manner in
telling the story will have weight with them too, but they will be
justified in ascribing this to your longing to escape death. As to the
story, could you blame them for thinking it a little too perfect to fit
the facts? It meets your necessities so well. The damning words to
Christian are completely explained. And your going below, on the morning
of the mutiny, just before the launch was cast off, is perfectly
explained as well. There is not one of those captains who will not say to
himself: 'This is such a tale as one would expect an intelligent
midshipman, eager to save his life, to invent.'"

"But, as I have told you, sir, Robert Tinkler overheard the conversation
with Christian. He can corroborate every word of my testimony."

"Yes; Tinkler, I think, saves you. Your life is in his hands. He reached
England safely with the rest of Captain Bligh's party. To return to your
story, you see how difficult it will be to convince a court-martial that
Mr. Christian, presumably a man of intelligence and one capable of
reflection, would have considered the mad plan of casting himself adrift
on a tiny raft, for the purpose of making his way, alone, to an island
peopled with savages?"

"It would not seem improbable if they knew Christian's character and the
abuse he had received from Captain Bligh."

"But these officers will know nothing of Christian's character, and their
sympathies will all be with Captain Bligh. You will have to prove your
story of that conversation beyond the shadow of a doubt. Was there no one
at that time to whom he revealed his plan to leave the ship? Such a man
would be a most important witness for you."

"Yes; John Norton, one of the quartermasters. He prepared the raft for

The surgeon opened a drawer in his table and brought forth a paper. "I
have here a list of the men who went with Captain Bligh in the launch.
Twelve of the party survived to reach England."

He glanced down the list, and then looked at me gravely.

"Norton, I am sorry to say, is not one of them. According to this record
he was killed by the savages on the island of Tofoa."

It was a shock to me to learn of Norton's death, and I realized what a
misfortune the lack of his evidence would be for me. Mr. Nelson, too, was
dead, having succumbed to a fever when the party reached Coupang. Mr.
Nelson was not only my friend; he was also a witness who could have
vouched for my intention to leave the ship. With these two gone, my
chance for acquittal seemed much less hopeful. Dr. Hamilton took a more
encouraging view of the situation.

"You must not be disheartened," he said. "Tinkler's evidence is vastly
more important to you than that of Norton and Mr. Nelson, and you may be
sure that he will be summoned. Sir Joseph Banks will see to it that every
scrap of evidence in your favour is brought to bear. No, take my word for
it, your case is far from hopeless."

His quiet confident manner reassured me, and for the time I put aside all
thought of what my fate might be. Mr. Hamilton then related, briefly,
what I was most eager to hear: the story of what had happened to Bligh
and his party after the launch had been cast adrift. They had first
called at the island of Tofoa, for water and other refreshment, but the
savages, seeing that the party lacked the means of defending themselves,
attacked them in such numbers that a massacre of the entire company was
barely averted. As it happened, Norton was the only man to be killed.
Their subsequent adventures made up a record of appalling hardships, and
had any one but Bligh been in command, there is little doubt that the
launch would never have been heard of again. On the fourteenth of June,
forty-seven days after the mutiny, they reached the Dutch settlement at
Coupang Bay, on the island of Timor, a distance of more than twelve
hundred leagues from Tofoa. After recuperating for two months among the
kindly inhabitants of Coupang, a small schooner was purchased and fitted
out for the voyage to Batavia, where they arrived on October I, 1789.
Here three more of the party died: Elphinstone, Lenkletter, the remaining
quartermaster, and Thomas Hall, a seaman. Ledward, the acting surgeon,
was left behind at Batavia, and the rest of the party embarked in ships
of the Dutch East India Company for the voyage home. Robert Lamb, the
butcher, died on the passage, leaving but twelve of the nineteen men who
had set out from the _Bounty's_ side.

"In all the annals of our maritime history there has never been such an
open-boat voyage as this," Dr. Hamilton continued. "You will understand
the excitement and interest aroused when Bligh reached England. I was
then in London, and for weeks the story of the mutiny and the voyage of
the launch were the chief topics of conversation everywhere. The whole
country rang with Bligh's praises, and the sympathy for him is universal.
It would be useless to deny the fact, Mr. Byam--those who remained in the
_Bounty_ are all considered scoundrels of the blackest description."

"But did Captain Bligh say nothing," I asked, "of the men who were kept
against their inclination? I fully understand, now, his bitterness toward
me, but there are others whom he knows to be innocent, and he pledged
himself to do them justice if ever he reached England. Stewart and
Coleman are in irons at this moment, as you may know. They are as
guiltless as any of those who went with Captain Bligh."

"I have read the instructions furnished to Captain Edwards by the
Admiralty," he replied. "They contain a list of the names of those who
remained in the _Bounty_, and you are all considered mutineers. No
distinction is made amongst you, and Captain Edwards is instructed to
keep you so closely confined as to preclude all possibility of escape."

"Does this mean that we shall be confined where we are now until the
_Pandora_ reaches England?"

"Not if Captain Edwards will follow my advice. His instructions also say
that, in confining you, he is to have a proper regard for the
preservation of your lives. In this matter I am equally responsible with.
him, and I would not answer for the life of a pig kept for months on end
on the orlop deck. I shall do my best to persuade him to remove you to
more healthful quarters."

"And if possible, sir," I urged, "persuade him to permit us to speak with
one another."

"God bless my soul! Do you tell me that he has denied you that small
privilege?" The surgeon regarded me with a grim smile. "Captain Edwards
is a just man, Mr. Byam. You will understand, perhaps, what I mean by
this? He will carry out his instructions to the letter, and if ever he
errs, it will not be on the side of leniency. But I think that I can
promise you relief in some small matters. At any rate, be assured that I
shall try. To return to the matter of your studies: you have your
manuscripts at your house, I presume?"

All of my personal belongings had been left at Tautira. I told the
surgeon of my friend, Tuahu, and that, if I might send him word, he would
bring my chest to the ship. Dr. Hamilton asked that I write his name on a
slip of paper.

"I will find him," he said. "Sir Joseph is extremely anxious that these
manuscripts of yours should not be lost."

"It would be a godsend to me, sir, if I might continue my work on the
voyage home."

"Sir Joseph had requested this very thing, in case you should be found,"
the surgeon replied. "Captain Edwards will, I believe, grant permission."

This news cheered me greatly. I should have an occupation that would
suffice to make the long confinement endurable, and as Stewart, Coleman,
and Skinner were all proficient in the Indian tongue, if we were
permitted to converse my studies could be carried on with their help.

Mr. Hamilton glanced at his timepiece.

"I must send you below soon," he said. "I had Captain Edwards's consent
to this interview that I might question you with respect to the
manuscripts. He is ashore this morning. I have taken advantage of the
fact to enlarge upon my privilege."

He rose, unlocked the door of his cabin, glanced out, and closed it

"I shall enlarge upon it still more," he said. "Sir Joseph has charged me
with another commission. In case you could be found, he asked me to
deliver this letter to you."

Dr. Hamilton busied himself with some papers of his own while I read my
letter. It was from my mother, of course. I still have it to this day,
but I need not consult it to refresh my memory. For all the years that
have passed, I can recall it, word for word:--


I have only just learned that I may have this precious opportunity to
write to you. I must make every moment count, and waste none in
unnecessary words.

When Captain Bligh returned with the news of the dreadful fate of the
_Bounty_, I wrote to him at once, and received from him the letter
which I enclose. What may have happened to turn him against you, I cannot
conceive. After the receipt of so cruel a message I did not again write
to him, but you must not believe that I have been greatly distressed. I
know you too well, dear Roger, to have the least doubt of your

I know what your anxiety, on my account, will be upon the arrival of the
_Pandora_, when you learn that you are counted among the mutineers.
Imagine then, dear son, that you have been able to write to me,
explaining fully the circumstances, and imagine that your letter has
reached me. I am as certain as though I had this letter before me that
events over which you had no control caused you to remain in the
_Bounty_, and I await with perfect confidence your homecoming and
the clearing of your name from this infamous charge.

My only concern for you is at the thought of the hardships you may have
to suffer as a prisoner on the long voyage to England. But they can be
borne, and remember, my son, that home is beyond them.

Sir Joseph has talked with Captain Bligh, and you will be gratified to
know that he does not share Mr. Bligh's belief that you were one of his
enemies. I have not been told upon what ground you are charged with
conspiracy, but in closing his letter to me, Sir Joseph said: 'I
confidently expect that the proof of your son's innocence only awaits the
day when the _Pandora_ returns and all the facts shall be known.' I
not only expect it. I am as sure of it as I am of the light of
to-morrow's sun.

Good-bye, my dear Roger. I may not write more. The _Pandora_ is to
sail within three or four days, and my letter must go to London by this
night's coach. God bless you, my son, and bring you safely home! Believe
me, my dear boy, I can smile at the thought of the preposterous charge
against you. May England breed many such villains as you are supposed to

Dr. Hamilton was kindness itself. Our quarters on the orlop deck were as
dark as a cave and I could never have read my letter there. He permitted
me to go over it again and again in his cabin until I knew it by heart.
The enclosed letter from Bligh to my mother was, surely, the most cruel
and heartless message that has ever been sent to the mother of an absent

LONDON, April 2nd, 1790.


I received your letter this day, and feel for you very much, being
perfectly sensible of the extreme distress you must suffer from the
conduct of your son, Roger Byam. His baseness is beyond all description,
but I hope you will endeavour to prevent the loss of him, heavy as the
misfortune is, from affecting you too severely. I imagine he is, with the
rest of the mutineers, returned to Otaheite.

I am, Madame,


I returned to our dark hole in a vastly different frame of mind than when
I left it. As we passed along the lower deck I caught glimpses through
the scuttles of the Matavai beach, and the canoes and the boats from the
frigate plying back and forth between the ship and the shore. Those brief
bright glimpses brought home to me the preciousness of freedom, the
inestimable boon of being merely alive and at liberty. I made no attempt
to compute the length of time that must pass before it could be mine


The following morning our prison was cleaned for the first time since we
had been confined there, and lighted with two additional candles. A
bucket of sea water was then furnished us and we were permitted to wash
our hands and faces. We were in a truly deplorable condition, only less
filthy than the prison itself, and we begged the master-at-arms to allow
us a complete bath.

"I have been ordered to give you one bucket of water and no more," he
said. "Make haste, for the captain is coming directly."

We had no sooner finished our hurried toilet than Captain Edwards
entered, followed by Lieutenant Parkin. The master-at-arms called out,
"Prisoners! Stand!" We rose to our feet, and Edwards glanced around the
compartment and from one to another of us. The stench of the place was
frightful, and our naked bodies gleamed with sweat in the dim light. From
the appearance of my fellow prisoners I knew what a disgusting appearance
I myself must present. My intention had been to protest against the
inhumanity of such a place of confinement; but believing that conditions
would speak eloquently enough for themselves, I decided to say nothing.
Edwards turned to the master-at-arms.

"Command them to hold out their hands," he said.

"Prisoners, hold out your hands!"

We obeyed, and Edwards examined our handcuffs and leg irons. It chanced
that Stewart's manacles fitted somewhat loosely to his wrists, and
Edwards noticed this.

"Mr. Parkin, see to it that the armourer inspects all of these irons," he
said. "I shall hold him responsible if any prisoner shall be able to free

"I shall attend to the matter immediately, sir," Parkin replied.

Edwards continued to regard us coldly for a moment or two.

"Inform the prisoners that, in future, they may converse with one
another. But let them understand this: they shall speak only in English.
If I hear of as much as a single word passing between them in the Indian
language, the permission I have granted shall be withdrawn."

This information was conveyed to us through the proper channel.

"And under no circumstances whatever is any prisoner to speak to a
sentinel or to any member of the ship's company except Mr. Parkin or the
corporal in charge of the guard. I shall severely punish any infringement
of this order."

Parkin was in general charge of us. I felt an instinctive aversion for
this man. He was short, thickset, and excessively hairy, with eyebrows
that met in an irregular line over his nose. The vice of cruelty was
written plain on his face, and we had not been long in discovering the
character of the man in whose power we were. Thus far he had displayed it
in various small ways, but Edwards had now given him the kind of
opportunity he craved. No sooner had the captain left us than Parkin
himself made an inspection of our irons, beginning with Stewart, whom he
ordered to lie down and stretch up his hands. He then grasped the chain
connecting the handcuffs, and, placing his foot against Stewart's chest,
he strained and tugged with all his strength, succeeding at length in
wrenching off the irons, taking the skin from Stewart's knuckles and the
backs of both hands as he did so. As the handcuffs came away he nearly
fell over backward. In his anger, Stewart forgot his helpless position.
He sprang to his feet, and had Parkin been within reach Stewart would
have knocked him down.

"You filthy beast!" he said. "Do you call yourself an officer?"

Parkin had a high soft voice, almost feminine in quality, in strange
contrast to his swarthy, hairy appearance.

"What did you say?" he asked. "Repeat that."

"I called you a filthy beast," said Stewart, "and so you are!"

He was as near to Parkin as his irons would permit him to go. The
lieutenant took care to keep beyond reach.

"You will regret that," he said. "I promise that you will repent of it
more than once before you're hung."

I am unable to say whether he would have tried the irons of the rest of
us in the same manner. I was resolved that he should not test mine in
that fashion; but at that moment the armourer appeared and Parkin ordered
him to carry on the examination. It would have been impossible for any of
us to have freed ourselves from the leg irons, but Parkin ordered all the
handcuffs to be altered so that they should fit more tightly. When they
had been repaired and brought back, it was only with great difficulty
that they could be fastened upon us.

Meanwhile, I told the others of my conversation with the surgeon. We
forgot our wretched situation in the pleasure of being permitted to
converse again, and the day passed more rapidly than the previous five
had done. Realizing now that we had nothing to hope for until we reached
England, we resolved to make the best of things, and to devise methods of
passing the time. Of the four of us, Skinner alone had nothing to hope
for, and yet he was the most cheerful of us all. I began to suspect, at
this time, that the man was not wholly right in his mind. He said more
than once that, if the decision were again to be made, he would give
himself up to justice as he had done, and he seemed to look forward with
pleasure to the day when he would be hung.

We were careful to obey Edwards's order with respect to the sentinels. We
had no desire to make trouble for them, and Parkin was spying about at
all hours. But there was a seaman, James Good, whose name was an
indication of his kindly nature. He was the man usually sent with our
food, and he never failed to whisper to us welcome bits of news as he
handed round our plates. "Mr. Parkin's gone ashore, sir," he would say;
"you won't be bothered this morning." Or, "I'll fetch you a bit of fresh
meat for your supper." Whenever possible he would bring us morsels of
fresh pork or breadfruit or sweet potatoes wrapped in a handkerchief
inside his blouse. This he did with the connivance of the cooks. Had any
of these men been discovered, they would have been severely flogged, and
yet they cheerfully ran the risk in order to lighten the misery of our

But never had Good brought us such welcome news as on the evening when he
informed us that we were to be moved to other quarters.

"Have you heard the knockin' and 'ammerin' on deck, sir?" he whispered to
me. "The carpenters are makin' a proper 'ouse for you up there."

We had heard, at times, the sounds of hammering, and now that we knew it
concerned us, it was music to our ears. The following day we were
unshackled from the filthy planking of our dungeon, marched up the
ladderway, along the lower deck, and up a second ladderway to the pure
air of the upper deck. At first our eyes were so dazzled by the
brilliance of the sunshine that we could scarcely see, and so lost half
the pleasure of our moment in the open. It was, in fact, no more than a
moment. Edwards was present, and the master-at-arms ordered us into our
new prison at once. We mounted the ladder to the top of the box, which
stood on the quarter-deck. There was a scuttle about eighteen inches
square through which we descended inside.

This place was to be our prison for as long as we remained on the
_Pandora_. It was called "the roundhouse," but more often we
prisoners referred to it as "Pandora's Box." It was eleven feet long at
the deck and eighteen feet wide at the bulkhead. There were two scuttles,
nine inches square, in the bulkhead, and these, with the one in the roof,
were heavily barred and gave us what light we had. Across the deck midway
between the walls was a line of fourteen heavy ringbolts to which the leg
irons were to be attached. We were now made fast in the corners of the
compartment, Stewart and Skinner next the bulkhead, and Coleman and I on
the after side. Our leg irons were cylindrical bands three inches wide
with a twelve-inch length of chain which passed through a ringbolt. One
key unlocked all the leg irons and another the handcuffs. The keys were
carried by the master-at-arms.

As in our former prison, we could stand up and move half a pace in either
direction, and we had full headroom. The floor was the deck itself, and
on either side were small scupper holes. In fair weather the roof scuttle
was left open save for the iron grating, and two sentries continually
paced the roof. The monotonous, everlasting tread of their feet so close
overhead became a sound as wearisome to us as the clinking of our chains
through the ringbolts.

We could not suppose that so large a prison had been prepared for four
men, and by each of the unoccupied ringbolts lay a pair of leg irons
ready for use. Evidently Captain Edwards had reason to believe that he
would soon take others of the _Bounty's_ company. That Christian and
his party had returned was so improbable as not to be worth considering.
The only remaining possibility was that the departure of the
_Resolution_ from Papara had been delayed, and that she was either
captured or about to be. We were not long kept in doubt. Two days later,
the grating over the roof scuttle was raised, and Morrison, Norman, and
Ellison were brought down and chained beside us.

This was a meeting such as none of us had hoped for. Morrison and Norman
had not yet recovered from their astonishment at being treated as
pirates. Ellison was the same scatter-brained youngster he had always
been. Excitement in any form was the breath of life to him, and to be
considered a desperate character, chained up like a wild beast, was his
conception of a lark. Fortunately he had no sense of the gravity of his
situation, and we did nothing to remind him of it. Of all those who had
taken part in the mutiny, he was the one I most hoped would escape

The armourer, supervised by Parkin, fitted handcuffs to the new captives,
and Ellison being no more than a boy, Parkin tried upon him the same
measures he had used with Stewart. Ordering him to lie down, he placed
one foot on his chest and tried to draw the handcuffs over his hands. For
a moment Ellison endured this treatment in silence; then he said,
smiling, "Leave off, sir. I'll give you these things if you want them,
but you can't get them that way."

Parkin's only reply was to let go the chain so suddenly that Ellison fell
back, striking his head heavily on the deck. Parkin's eyes shone with
delight as Ellison sat up, rubbing his head. He ordered him to stretch up
his hands again, but this time Ellison was prepared, and when Parkin let
go the chain the boy fell back on one shoulder and avoided striking his

"That's one for me, sir," he said with a grin.

The lieutenant was breathing heavily, not so much from exertion as from
emotion. The fact that a common seaman and a mutineer beside had dared to
speak to him was more than he could endure.

"Lie down!" he ordered.

A look of fear came into Ellison's eyes as he obeyed. He stretched up his
arms, expecting Parkin to grasp the chain again. Instead of that he
kicked Ellison in the side, as cruel a blow as was ever given a
defenseless man.

"That will teach you how to speak to an officer," he said, in his soft
bland voice. The armourer was a witness of this foul proceeding. "Good
God, sir!" he exclaimed in spite of himself. By a happy chance Parkin
stood within reach of Morrison, who drew back his manacled fists and gave
him a blow which sent him staggering in my direction. I had barely time
to fetch him another that knocked him off his balance, and as he fell he
struck his head against one of the ringbolts. He got up slowly and looked
from one to another of us without speaking. Presently he turned to the

"You may go, Jackson," he said. "I shall know how to deal with this." The
armourer went up the ladder, and Parkin stood looking down at Ellison,
who was lying on his belly with his hands pressed against his side.

"Oh, you dogs!" he exclaimed softly, as though speaking to himself. "I
could have you flogged to death for this. But I'm to see you hung!
Remember that--I'm to see you hung!" He then went up the ladder, the
grating was lifted for him, and he climbed out.

Had not the armourer witnessed the brutal assault upon Ellison, I have no
doubt that we should have suffered for our rebellious conduct. But
evidently Parkin feared that the truth would come out if complaint should
be made to the captain. At any rate, no action was taken, and for several
days we saw no more of the man. Ellison suffered great pain, but youth
and natural toughness of body were in his favour, and he quickly

As soon as we were alone again, Morrison gave us an account of the taking
of the schooner. Having called at Papara to pick up McIntosh, Hillbrandt,
and Millward, they had decided to take advantage of the fine weather to
salt down some extra casks of pork. Several days were spent in this work,
and on the morning of what was to have been their last day on the island,
most of the men made an excursion far up the Papara Valley for a supply
of mountain plantains. Morrison, Ellison, and Norman remained with the
schooner, and toward noon word reached the district of the arrival of a
vessel at Matavai. Before any action could be taken, a ship's launch
filled with marines appeared.

"Norman and I could have danced for joy at sight of the English
uniforms," Morrison went on; "but when we thought of the others we felt
less happy. They were certain of capture now and I had no time to send
them warning. The launch was upon us five minutes after she had rounded
the point. She came alongside and you can imagine our astonishment when
we saw that Thomas Hayward, in a lieutenant's uniform, was in charge of

"I suppose you fell on each other's necks, Morrison," Stewart put in. "He
didn't condescend to speak to me, but ordered his men to clap me in
irons. He remained with the schooner with most of the marines. We were
sent back with the launch."

"Mr. Hayward is in a difficult position; we must remember that," said

"In a position that precisely suits the little cad," said Stewart, hotly.
"He knows that we are as innocent as he himself."

"Do you remember how he whimpered when Christian ordered him into the
launch?" asked Morrison.

"So he did, Coleman," said Norman. "Him and Mr. Hallet both begged to
stay with the ship, and that's something none of us was guilty of."

Hayward's superior, contemptuous attitude was naturally resented by all
of us who had taken no part in the mutiny. Making all possible allowances
for him, we still found it inexcusable.

The other men were soon brought in from Papara. There were seven of them:
McIntosh, Hillbrandt, Burkitt, Millward, Sumner, Muspratt, and Byrne. The
roundhouse was none too large, now, for our accommodation. Eight men were
chained so that they slept with their heads at the bulkhead, and six on
the opposite side. I was in the corner, on the starboard side aft, with
Muspratt on my left. I had reason to be grateful for my chance position
in the roundhouse. Two or three days after we had been confined there, I
discovered in one of the wall planks a knot that had become loosened as
the green lumber dried in the sun. I tried for several nights, without
success, to draw it out. James Good, our steward, came to my assistance.
He pushed the knot in to me, and thereafter I had a tiny window through
which I had a glimpse of the bay and the shore line beyond. Sometimes, as
the _Pandora_ shifted her position with the current, I had Stewart's
house directly opposite my window, and although we were too far distant
to enable me to distinguish the people moving about there, I could easily
imagine who they were.

I watched canoes and the ship's boats coming and going. Many of the
people in the canoes I knew; they were old friends of one or another of
us. As they approached, I could see them more and more distinctly until
they were cut off from view by the side of the vessel. Several times I
saw Peggy, Stewart's wife, being paddled around the ship by her father or
one of her brothers. With what longing she gazed in our direction! Her
father, wisely, never brought her within earshot. She would have been
certain to cry out to her husband had she thought him within hearing,
only adding to the misery of them both. I said nothing to Stewart of the
matter. I had no desire to harrow his feelings any more than was already
the case with him.

One morning while I was standing on lookout, Muspratt, who was keeping
watch for me, gave the warning, "Hatchway!" and I had barely time to
thrust in the knot before the master-at-arms descended the ladder,
followed by Edwards. It was an unexpected visit, the first we had had
from the captain since our confinement in the roundhouse. Our prison had
not been cleaned in all that time, and I will say no more of its
condition than that fourteen chained men were obliged to obey the calls
of nature in that close-walled space.

Edwards halted at the foot of the ladder.

"Master-at-arms, why is this place in such a filthy state?"

"Mr. Parkin's orders were that it was to be cleaned once a week, sir."

"Have it washed out immediately, and report to me when it is done."

"Very good, sir."

Edwards lost no time in leaving the place; then, to our great joy, swabs
were handed down to us, and bucket after bucket of salt water. When we
had scoured our quarters thoroughly, passing the swabs from hand to hand,
we scrubbed each other. To be clean once more had a wonderful effect upon
our spirits. Some of the men sang and whistled at the work, sounds that
contrasted strangely with the clinking of manacles, but these cheerful
noises were cut short by a curt order from the master-at-arms. In half an
hour we had the place as clean as salt water and good will could make it,
whereupon the master-at-arms returned, followed, this time, by Dr.
Hamilton. The surgeon threw a quick glance in my direction, and there was
a friendly glint in his eyes; otherwise he gave no indication that we had
met before. He passed along the line, glancing over our bodies in a
professional manner, and stopped before Muspratt.

"That needs attention, my man," he said, indicating a great boil on
Muspratt's knee. "Have him sent to the sick-bay at ten, Mr. Jackson."

"Yes, sir."

Dr. Hamilton had fully as much dignity as the captain, but he did not
feel it necessary to address us through an inferior officer.

"Are any of the rest of you suffering from boils or other humours?" he
asked. "If so, speak up, and I'll attend to you at the same time.
Remember, it is my duty to care for your health as well as that of the
ship's company. You must not hesitate to inform me when you need my

"May I speak, sir?" Stewart asked.


"Would it be possible, while the ship remains here, for us to be supplied
now and then with fresh food?"

Morrison eagerly seconded this request.

"We have friends among the Indians, sir, who would be only too glad to
send us fruit and cooked vegetables if this could be permitted."

"And it would save the ship's stores, sir," Coleman added. Dr. Hamilton
glanced from one to another of us.

"But you're having fresh food," he said.

"No, sir, begging your pardon," said Coleman. "Only salt beef and hard

Dr. Hamilton looked at the master-at-arms.

"That's been their victuals, sir. Mr. Parkin's orders."

"I see," the surgeon replied. "I'll look into the matter. Perhaps it can
be arranged."

We thanked him warmly, and he went on deck again.

It was plain from the events of that morning that Parkin's treatment of
us had been without the knowledge of the captain or of Dr. Hamilton.
Edwards was willing to be ignorant of the lieutenant's cruelty, but from
that day forth Dr. Hamilton made us frequent visits. We were never again
compelled to lie in our own filth, and our food was the same as that
given to the seamen of the _Pandora_.


One morning early in May, Stewart and I were freed from our leg irons and
conducted to the place used as the sick-bay on the lower deck. We found
Dr. Hamilton awaiting us in the passageway outside. He said nothing, but
motioned us to enter. We went in, not knowing what to expect, and the
door was closed behind us. Tehani and Peggy were there, with our little

Tehani came close and put her arms around me, speaking in a low voice
directly into my ear, lest she should be heard by those outside. "Listen,
Byam. I have no time for weeping. I must speak quickly. Atuanui is here
with three hundred Tautira men, his best warriors. They have been coming
around the coast from both sides, five or ten each time. For many days I
have been trying to see you. There was no chance. At last it comes. They
will attack the ship at night. In the darkness the great guns will do us
little harm. What we fear is that you may be killed by the soldiers
before we can reach you. That is why the attack has not yet been made.
Are you all in the house they have built on the deck? Are you chained?
Atuanui wishes to know how you are guarded there."

I was so overcome with joy at seeing Tehani and our little daughter that
I was unable to speak for a moment.

"Tell me, Byam, quickly! We shall not have long to speak."

"How long have you been at Matavai, Tehani?"

"Three days after you left Tautira, I came. Did you think I would desert
you? It is Atuanui and I who have made this plan. All of your friends are
eager to attack."

"Tehani," I said, "you must tell Atuanui that there is no chance to save
us. He and all of his men would be killed."

"No, no, Byam! We will club them to death before they can use their guns.
We will save you from these evil men. Atuanui wishes to attack to-morrow
night. There is no moon. It must be done quickly, for the ship is soon to

It was useless trying to explain to Tehani the reason for our
imprisonment. She could not understand; and, indeed, we had only
ourselves to blame, for, as already related, the fact of the mutiny had
been kept a secret from all the Tahitians.

"We know. That captain, Etuati, has told Hitihiti that you are bad men.
He says he must take you to England to be punished. Hitihiti does not
believe this. No one believes it."

Meanwhile, Stewart's wife had told him what Tehani had told me. There was
but one way of preventing an attack upon the frigate. We explained that
all of the prisoners were chained, hand and foot; that we were entirely
helpless and would undoubtedly be killed before the ship could be taken.
I told Tehani, which was true, that Captain Edwards was prepared for such
an attack, and our guards under orders to shoot us at the first sign of
any attempt at rescue on the part of our friends on shore. We succeeded
at last in convincing our wives of the hopelessness of the plan.

Until this moment Tehani and Peggy had kept their emotions under control.
Realizing now that nothing could be done, Peggy broke down in a flood of
passionate weeping heart-rending to see. Stewart tried in vain to comfort
her. Tehani sat on the floor at my feet, her head buried in her arms,
making no sound. Had she wept I would have been better able to bear it. I
knelt beside her with our child in my arms. For the first time in my life
I tasted to the full the bitterness of true misery.

Presently Stewart could endure no more. He opened the door. Dr. Hamilton
and the guards were waiting outside. He motioned them to come in. Peggy
clung to him desperately, and it was only with the greatest difficulty
that he could disengage her fingers. Had it not been for Tehani she would
have had to be carried from the ship. Tehani's grief was beyond tears, as
mine was. We held each other close, for a moment, without speaking. Then
she lifted up Peggy, and supported her as we went out. Stewart and I
followed, carrying our children. At the gangway we gave them to the
servants who had come with our wives. Stewart begged to be taken to the
roundhouse at once. I was conducted to Dr. Hamilton's cabin and was
deeply grateful for the privilege he gave me of being alone there for a
few moments. Through the port I saw the canoe, with my friend Tuahu and
Tipau, Peggy's father, at the paddles, leave the side of the ship. One of
the servants held Peggy's child. Tehani sat on a thwart in the bow,
holding our little Helen in her arms. I watched the canoe growing smaller
and smaller, with such despair in my heart as I had never known till

I was still standing at the port when Dr. Hamilton entered.

"Sit down, my boy," he said. His eyes were moist as he looked at me. "I
persuaded Captain Edwards to consent to this meeting. My intentions were
of the best, but I didn't realize how cruel a trial it would be for all
of you."

"I can speak for Stewart as well as for myself, sir. We are deeply
grateful to you."

"Would you mind telling me your wife's name?"

"Tehani. She is the niece of Vehiatua, the chief of Taiarapu."

"She is a noble woman, Mr. Byam. I was greatly impressed by her dignity
and poise. I don't mind confessing that my ideas of the Indian women have
altered greatly, now that I have seen them. My conception had been gained
from the stories about them that circulate in England. I had supposed
them all wanton little creatures without character or depth of feeling. I
see more clearly every day how mistaken this conception was. We call
these people savages! I realize now that in many respects we are the
savages, not they."

"You have not seen my wife before?" I asked.

"On the contrary, I have seen her every day this past month. She has been
moving heaven and earth in her attempts to see you. Stewart's wife has
been doing the same. Until yesterday, Captain Edwards refused all
requests of the Indians for permission to visit the prisoners. He fears
that they may attempt to rescue you."

"He has reason to fear it, sir."

"Reason to fear it? How is that?"

I would gladly have avoided speaking of what Tehani had told me, and
could I have been certain that Atuanui would abandon his plan, I would
have said nothing. But I knew his fearless impetuous nature, and neither
he nor Tehani had any conception of the murderous effect of great guns
loaded with grape. They had never seen them fired, and it was more than
possible that Atuanui might yet be persuaded of the feasibility of his
plan. Therefore I told the surgeon of the plan to attack the frigate, and
of what I had done to prevent its being carried out. He was astonished at
the news.

"We have had no suspicion that anything of the sort was afoot," he said.
"You have done well to tell me of this. An attack would mean the death of
scores, if not hundreds, of the Indians."

"Captain Edwards can easily avoid all danger," I said. "He will have only
to keep a strong guard on shore and to prohibit any gathering of canoes
near the ship."

The surgeon then told me that he had received from Tuahu the manuscripts
of my dictionary and grammar.

"I have your private Journal as well," he added. "Would you permit me to
look into this latter sometime, or does it contain matters which you wish
no one to see?"

I told him that it contained nothing but a day-to-day account of my
experiences from the time of leaving England until the arrival of the
_Pandora_, which he was welcome to read, if he chose.

"I shall appreciate that privilege," he replied. "Your Journal will be of
great value to you in later years. If you like, I will take care of all
these papers for you. They can go into the bottom of my small medicine
chest, and there they will be certain of reaching England safely. With
respect to the dictionary, Captain Edwards knows of the great interest
Sir Joseph Banks takes in it, and you are to be permitted to work on it
during the passage home."

This was a welcome assurance indeed. I had looked forward with dread to
our long voyage. I now mentioned the captain's prohibition against our
speaking in Tahitian among ourselves. "If this could be removed, sir, I
could be given much help by the other prisoners, and perform a service to
them at the same time, by giving them something to occupy their minds."

The surgeon promised to intercede with the captain on this account, and
as soon as the _Pandora_ sailed the permission was granted.

All the next day the ship's boats were kept busy bringing off provisions,
and the tents and implements of the carpenters and armourers which had
been set up on the beach near our anchorage. Our steward, James Good,
told us that the frigate was to sail within twenty-four hours. Edwards
had gained no information with respect to Christian and the
_Bounty_, and apparently had come to the conclusion that we had told
the truth in saying that we knew nothing of Christian's possible
destination. All that day I gazed my fill at the green land where I had
been so happy, and during the night I heard every bell strike, followed
by the clear calls of the sentinels in various parts of the ship.
Fortunately, no attempt was made to seize the frigate. At dawn we were
under way. At ten o'clock, looking from my knot-hole window, I saw
nothing but empty sea.

There followed a weary time for the fourteen men confined in "Pandora's
Box." My dictionary proved a blessing to nearly all of us. On our second
day at sea it was brought to me by Dr. Hamilton himself, together with
writing materials, and the surgeon had had the carpenter make me a small
table which rested on the floor across my lap as I sat in my corner. The
green island timber of which the roundhouse had been made was beginning
to shrink in the hot sun, and sufficient light streamed through the
cracks between the planks to enable me to write without straining my eyes
greatly. The prohibition against speaking in the Indian tongue was
lifted, and the other men entered with pleasure into my studies. Stewart,
Morrison, and Ellison were accomplished linguists, only a little less
proficient in Tahitian than in English. Ellison surprised me. He spoke
the language with a purer accent than any of us, and seemed to have
absorbed his knowledge of it without the least effort. He pointed out
many fine distinctions between words that had escaped me. This poor lad
had never known who his parents were. He had been kicked from larboard to
starboard ever since he could remember, and it had never occurred to him
that he had a good mind. It saddened me to think that such a youngster,
with an excellent capacity for education, had received none, while many a
dull-witted son of wealthy parents was offered advantages he was not
equipped to profit by.

There were grey days of continual violent squalls when it was impossible
to work on the dictionary. The frigate laboured heavily through the seas,
rolling and pitching, and we rolled with her, each man clinging to his
ringbolt in an attempt to maintain his position. Often we were thrown to
the extent of our chains, and our wrists and ankles were terribly galled
by the bands of iron around them. To add to our misery in seasons of bad
weather, the rain trickled down upon us day and night through the
uncaulked seams in the roof of our prison, and we slept, or, better,
tried to sleep, on boards slimy wet.

We had been several days at sea when we learned that the _Pandora_
was not alone on this voyage. She was accompanied by the
_Resolution_, the little schooner which Morrison and the others had
built. Edwards had fitted her out as a tender to the frigate, and she was
commanded by Mr. Oliver, the master's mate of the _Pandora_, with a
crew of a midshipman, a quartermaster, and six seamen. She was a
beautiful little craft and outsailed the frigate in any kind of weather.
Many and many a time poor Morrison, and the men who were to have gone
with him in the _Resolution_, had occasion to lament their fate in
being captured at Papara. Whatever hardships they might have suffered
would have seemed light indeed compared with the misery of existence in
"Pandora's Box."

Henry Hillbrandt soon began to show signs of breaking under the strain of
confinement. By nature he was a man of brooding, melancholy disposition,
and it was evident that thoughts of the court-martial ahead of us were
preying upon his mind. I remember well the evening when he first gave
evidence of this. The sea was dead calm, but a fine cold rain had been
falling since morning, and we were cold, wet, and miserable. It must have
been toward midnight that I was wakened from a doze by the sound of
Hillbrandt's voice. It was pitch-dark in the roundhouse. Hillbrandt was
praying in low monotonous tones that went on interminably. Seamen,
however irreverent some of them may be, invariably respect those of a
religious temperament, and rarely interfere with another man's prayers.
Although I could see nothing in the darkness, I knew that the other men
were awake, listening to Hillbrandt. He continued for at least half an
hour, praying God to save him from being hanged. It was the same thing
over and over again. At last I heard Millward's voice: "Hillbrandt! For
God's sake, _mamu!_" (Be quiet!)

Hillbrandt broke off.

"Who was that? Was it you, Millward?"

"Yes. We want no more of your praying."

"No," someone else put in. "Pray to yourself if you must, Hillbrandt, but
give us a rest."

Of a sudden Hillbrandt broke out in a violent fit of sobbing. "We're
doomed, men," he said; "doomed, every one of us! We're to be hanged,
think of that! Choked to death at the end of a rope!"

"Damn your blood! Hold your tongue, will you?" I heard Burkitt say.
"Choke him off, Sumner, if he says another word!"

Sumner was chained next to Hillbrandt. "That I will!" he replied. "I'll
save the hangman one dirty job if he don't let up!"

One topic, our possible fate when we reached England, was never mentioned
in the roundhouse. With the exception of Hillbrandt and Skinner, present
misery was enough for all of us, without anticipating events to come.

The events of that dreary time are only less unpleasant to recall than
they were to endure. We had no knowledge of whither we were bound, except
that it was in the general direction of home. James Good, our only source
of information, told us that Captain Edwards was making a zigzag course
to westward, calling at every island raised, in search of the
_Bounty_. We had to form our own conclusions as to where we were
from the little I could see through my knothole window. Some of the
others could also see something of what was taking place outside through
the cracks that began to appear in the walls as the planking shrunk under
the tropical sun. I kept a record of the days. We left Tahiti on May 9,
1791. On the nineteenth of May we sighted an island which all who could
view it recognized at once. It was Aitutaki, discovered by Captain Bligh
after the departure of the _Bounty_ from Tahiti, and shortly before
the mutiny. There was great excitement in the roundhouse that morning.
The ship came close inshore and hove-to on the larboard tack while the
cutter was being lowered. We saw one of the lieutenants and fifteen men
go off in the boat.

"We'll have Christian and the others here before nightfall; I'll venture
my day's rations on it," said Coleman.

"Nonsense, Coleman," said Stewart. "Christian would never be so foolish
as to choose any hiding-place known to Captain Bligh."

"What of Tupuai, Mr. Stewart?" Norman asked. "Christian would have stayed
there if the Indians had been friendly, and that island was known to
Captain Bligh."

"What do you think, Byam?" Stewart asked.

My opinion was, and Morrison and most of the others agreed, that
Christian would never again seek an asylum on a known island, more
particularly on any island that Bligh had visited. Nevertheless, we
waited with impatience for the return of the cutter. The frigate stood
off and on all day, and toward sunset we saw the cutter putting off from
shore. I had an excellent view of her as she approached, and when I could
say, with certainty, that none of Christian's party was in her, Ellison
gave a cheer, and clapped his manacled hands together. We all felt as he
did: we wanted Christian and the men with him to escape. As soon as the
cutter was hoisted on board we stood out to sea, and that is the last we
saw of Aitutaki.

Every day or two we had glimpses of the. _Resolution_ and knew that
she was following us from island to island. She came up with us again
when we were within sight of a low island, or atoll, which consisted of a
number of small islands connected by long stretches of barren reef, the
whole enclosing a lagoon of considerable extent. We saw the schooner
being revictualed from the frigate, and then she stood in for shore with
a cutter and one of the yawls in tow. The schooner was proving of great
service to Edwards in his search. Owing to her light draft, she could
examine, close inshore, the various islands at which we touched. The
following day James Good brought us most interesting news. The boats'
crews had gone ashore at the atoll, and had discovered on the beach of
one of the islands a spar marked "_Bounty's_ Driver Gaff."

This discovery caused no less excitement in the roundhouse than it did,
presumably, in Captain Edwards's cabin. The captain evidently considered
the find as proof that the _Bounty_ had called at this island, or
had passed near it. We knew better, but we took good care .to keep the
information to ourselves. This driver gaff was, unquestionably, one of
the missing spars that had gone adrift at Tupuai, and had been carried by
winds and currents these many miles to leeward.

During the next two months we cruised north and south among the islands
of the Union Group, the Navigator and the Friendly Archipelagoes, still
searching for some trace of the _Bounty_. On the twenty-first of
June, in a night of very thick weather, we lost the _Resolution_.
The frigate cruised about in that vicinity for several days, but the
schooner was seen no more, whereupon Captain Edwards proceeded to Namuka,
in the Friendly Islands, the appointed place of rendezvous in case the
vessels should become separated. Namuka, it will be remembered, was the
island where the _Bounty_ had put in for refreshment only a few days
before the mutiny. The _Pandora_ anchored where the _Bounty_
had lain, and from my knot-hole I could sec the familiar scene: the
scattered thatched houses of the Indians among the groves, the watering
place where the grapnel had been stolen, and the same throngs of thieving
savages crowding about the ship in their canoes.

The _Pandora_ remained here from July 28 until the second of August,
waiting for the _Resolution_, and during that time the Indians
proved as troublesome to the frigate's watering parties as they had to
those of the _Bounty_. The schooner having failed to appear, she was
given up as lost, and Captain Edwards now decided to proceed on the
homeward voyage without further loss of time. Accordingly, we sailed from
Namuka, and the following afternoon passed within view of the island of
Tofoa, and within a few miles of the very spot where the mutiny had taken
place so many months before. The interest of the men in the roundhouse,
as we peered through the cracks at the blue outline of Tofoa, may be
imagined. To me, the events of that melancholy morning, and all that had
since passed, seemed unreal, and our present misfortunes the experiences
of a nightmare from which I should wake, presently, to find myself still
at home, in England. I had the strange feeling that I had traveled
backward in time and was living again through the events of the night
preceding the mutiny.


I will pass briefly over the events of August. They were, no doubt,
interesting enough to the members of the _Pandora's_ company. To the
prisoners in the roundhouse they passed with interminable slowness.
Islands were raised and left behind as we proceeded toward Endeavour
Straits. We were sailing much the same course as that followed by Captain
Bligh in his open-boat voyage to Timor, and as we ploughed through that
vast ocean scattered with islands and shoals all but unknown to white
men, I gained a truer conception of the remarkable nature of Bligh's
achievement. That he should have succeeded in bringing seventeen men,
without arms, and so meagrely provided with food and water, through fair
weather and foul, to a destination nearly four thousand miles from his
point of departure seemed in the nature of a miracle. This achievement
was our principal topic of conversation in the roundhouse. Whatever our
personal feelings toward Bligh, there was not one of us who did not feel
proud, as Englishmen, of his voyage in the _Bounty's_ launch.

We saw little of Edwards. Three or four times, perhaps, in the course of
the voyage thus far, he had made an official inspection, merely stopping
at the foot of the ladder, glancing coldly from one to another of us, and
going out again. We were at the mercy of Parkin, who made existence as
wretched for us as he dared. As we approached Endeavour Straits even
Parkin ceased to visit us, this duty being left to the master-at-arms.
The lieutenants as well as the captain himself were continually occupied
with the navigation of the ship. Every day one, and sometimes two, of the
ship's boats were sent out in advance of the frigate, for we had now
reached the northern extremity of the Great Barrier Reef which extends
along the eastern coast of Australia, as treacherous an extent of
shoal-infested ocean as any on the surface of the globe. Our course was
extremely tortuous, among reefs and sand-bars innumerable, and all day
long we could hear the calls of the men heaving the lead as we worked our
way slowly along. Not even the prisoners suffered from boredom at this
time. Those of us who could see something of what was taking place
outside kept constant watch, reporting to others the dangers sighted or

The twenty-eighth of August was a dismal day of alternate calms and black
squalls which greatly increased the dangers of navigation. Looking from
my knot-hole at dawn, I saw that we were in the midst of a labyrinth of
reefs and shoals upon which the sea broke with great violence. The
frigate had been hove-to during the night, and now one of the boats, with
Lieutenant Corner in command, had gone ahead to seek for a possible
passage. We could see little of what was taking place, but the orders
continually shouted from the quarter-deck indicated only too clearly the
difficulties in which the ship found herself. Once, as we wore about, we
passed within half a cable's length of as villainous a reef as ever
brought a sailor's heart into his mouth.

So it went all that day, and as evening drew on it was apparent that we
were in greater danger than we had been at dawn. The launch was still far
in advance of us, and a gun was fired as a signal for her to return.
Darkness fell swiftly. False fires were burned and muskets fired to
indicate our position to the launch. The musket fire was answered from
the launch, and as the reports became more distinct we knew that she was
slowly approaching. All this while the leadsmen were continually
sounding, finding no bottom at one hundred and ten fathoms; but soon we
heard them calling depths again: fifty fathoms, forty, thirty-six,
twenty-two. Immediately upon calling this latter depth the ship was put
about, but before the tacks were hauled on board and the sails trimmed,
the frigate struck, and every man in the roundhouse was thrown sprawling
to the length of his chain.

Before we could recover ourselves the ship struck again, with such force
that we thought the masts would come down. It was now pitch-dark, and to
make matters worse another heavy squall bore down upon us. Above the
roaring of the wind we could hear the voices of the men, sounding faint
and thin as orders were shouted. Every effort was made to get the ship
free by means of the sails, but, this failing, they were furled and the
other boats put over the side for the purpose of carrying out an anchor.
The squall passed as suddenly as it had come, and we now heard distinctly
the musket shots of the men in the returning launch.

The violence of the shocks we had received left no doubt in our minds
that the ship had been badly damaged. I heard Edwards's voice: "How does
she do, Mr. Roberts?" and Roberts's reply: "She's making water fast, sir.
There's nearly three feet in the hold."

The effect upon the prisoners of this dreadful news may be imagined.
Hillbrandt and Michael Byrne began to cry aloud in piteous voices,
begging those outside to release us from our irons. All our efforts to
quiet them were useless, and the clamour they made, with the tumult of
shouting outside and the thunder of the surf on the reef where we lay,
added to the terror and gloom of the situation.

Hands were immediately turned to the pumps, and orders were given that
other men should bail at the hatchways. Presently the grating over the
roundhouse scuttle was unlocked and the master-at-arms entered with a
lantern. He quickly unshackled Coleman, Norman, and McIntosh, and ordered
them on deck to lend a hand. We begged the master-at-arms to release all
of us, but he gave no heed, and when he had gone out with the three men
the iron grating was replaced and locked as before.

Some of the prisoners now began to rave and curse like madmen, wrenching
at their chains in the vain effort to break them. At this time Edwards
appeared at the scuttle and sternly ordered us to be silent.

"For God's sake, unshackle us, sir!" Muspratt called. "Give us a chance
for our lives!"

"Silence! Do you hear me?" Edwards replied; then, to the master-at-arms,
who stood beside him by the scuttle: "Mr. Jackson, I hold you responsible
for the prisoners. They are not to be loosed without my orders."

"Let us bear a hand at the pumps, sir," Morrison called, earnestly.

"Silence, you villains!" Edwards called, and with that he left us.

Realizing now that pleading was useless, the men quieted down, and we
resigned ourselves to the situation in that mood of hopeless apathy that
comes over men powerless to help themselves. Within an hour another
tempest of wind and rain struck us, and again the frigate was lifted by
the seas and battered with awful violence on the reef. These repeated
shocks threw us from side to side and against the walls and each other,
so that we were dreadfully cut and bruised. As nearly as we could judge,
the ship was being carried farther and farther across the reef. At length
she lay quiet, down by the head, and we heard Lieutenant Corner's voice:
"She's clear, sir!"

It must then have been about ten o'clock. The second squall had passed,
and in the silence that followed the screaming of the wind we could
plainly hear the orders being given. The guns were being heaved over the
side, and the men who could be spared from bailing and pumping were
employed in thrumbing a topsail to haul under the ship's bottom, in an
endeavor to fother her. But the leak gained so fast that this plan had to
be abandoned, and every man on board, with the exception of our guards
and ourselves, fell to bailing and pumping.

Edwards's conduct toward us is neither to be explained nor excused. The
reef upon which the _Pandora_ had struck was leagues distant from
any land, with the exception of a few small sand-bars and stretches of
barren rock. Had we been free, there would have been no possibility of
escape; and yet Edwards doubled the guard over the roundhouse and gave
orders to the master-at-arms to keep us chained hand and foot.
Fortunately, we did not realize the imminence of our danger. The
roundhouse being on the quarter-deck, we were high above the water, and
while we knew that the ship was doomed, we did not know that the leak was
gaining so rapidly. It was, in fact, a race between the sea and daylight,
and had the frigate gone down in the night, every man on board of her
must have perished.

In the first grey light of dawn, we realized that the end was a matter,
not of hours, but of minutes. The frigate's stern was now high out of
water, and the pitch of the deck made it impossible to stand. The boats
were lying close by, and the officers were busy getting supplies into,
them. In the forward part of the vessel the water was fast approaching
the gun-ports. Men swarmed on top of the roundhouse and were going into
the boats by the stern ladders. We called to those outside, begging and
pleading that we might not be forgotten, and some of the men began
wrenching at their leg irons with the fury of despair. What the orders
respecting us were, or whether any had been given, I know not, but our
entreaties must have been heard by those outside. Joseph Hodges, the
armourer's mate, came down to us and removed the irons of Byrne,
Muspratt, and Skinner; but Skinner, in his eagerness to get out, was
hauled up with his handcuffs on, the two other men following close
behind. Then the scuttle was closed and barred again. This was done, I
believe, by the order of Lieutenant Parkin, for a moment before I had
seen him peering down at us.

Hodges had not noticed that the scuttle had been closed. He was unlocking
our irons as rapidly as possible when the ship gave a lurch and there was
a general cry of "There she goes!" Men were leaping into the water from
the stern, for the boats had pushed off at the first appearance of motion
in the ship. We shouted with all our strength, for the water was
beginning to flow in upon us. That we were not all drowned was due to the
humanity of James Moulter, the boatswain's mate. He had scrambled up on
the roof of the roundhouse in order to leap into the sea, and, hearing
our cries, he replied that he would either set us free or go to the
bottom with us. He drew out the bars that fastened the scuttle to the
coamings, and heaved the scuttle overboard. "Hasten, lads!" he cried, and
then himself leaped into the sea.

In his excitement and fear, the armourer's mate had neglected to remove
the handcuffs of Burkitt and Hillbrandt, although they were free of their
leg irons. We scrambled out, helping each other, and not a moment too
soon. The ship was under water as far as the mainmast, and I saw Captain
Edwards swimming toward the pinnace, which was at a considerable
distance. I leaped from the stern and had all I could do to clear myself
from the driver boom before the ship went down. I swam with all my
strength and was able to keep beyond the suction of the water as the
stern of the frigate rose perpendicularly and slid into the sea. Few
seamen know how to swim, and the cries of drowning men were awful beyond
the power of words to describe. All hatch covers, spare booms, the coops
for fowls, and the like, had been cut loose, and some of the men had
succeeded in reaching floating articles; but others went down almost
within reach of planks or booms that might have saved them. I swam to one
of the hatch covers and found Muspratt at the other end. He was unable to
swim, but told me that he could hang on until he should be picked up. I
swam to a short plank, and, with this to buoy me, started in the
direction of one of the boats. I had been in the water nearly an hour
before I was taken up by the blue yawl. Of the prisoners, Ellison and
Byrne had been rescued by this boat, which was now filled with men, and
we set out for a small sandy key on the reef at a distance of about three
miles from where the ship went down. This was the only bit of land above
water anywhere about, although there were shoals on every side near
enough to the surface for the sea to break over them.

There was quiet water at the key, which was nearly encircled by reef, and
we had no difficulty in landing. As soon as the men were disembarked,
with such provision as the boat contained, the yawl was sent back to the
scene of the wreck. Ellison, Byrne, and I were kept at the oars, and
Bowling, the master's mate, was at the tiller. We made a wide search
among floating wreckage, and so strong were the currents thereabout that
we took up men as far as three miles from the reef where the ship had
struck. We rescued twelve in all, among them Burkitt, clinging to a spar
with his handcuffs still on his wrists. It was nearly midday before we
returned to the key, and by that time the other boats had assembled
there. The sand-bar, for it was no more than that, was about thirty paces
long by twenty wide. Nothing grew there--not a sprig of green to relieve
the eyes from the blinding glare of the sun. Captain Edwards ordered a
muster of the survivors, and it was found that thirty-three of the ship's
company and four of the prisoners had been drowned. Of the prisoners,
Stewart, Sumner, Hillbrandt, and Skinner were missing.

Morrison told me that he had seen Stewart go down. He had not been able
to get clear of the ship as she foundered. A heavy spar had shot up from
the broken water, and as it fell Stewart was struck on the head and sank
instantly. Of all the events that had happened since the _Bounty_
left England, excepting only my parting from my wife and little daughter,
Stewart's death was the one that cast the deepest gloom upon my spirit. A
better companion and a truer friend, in good fortune and bad, never

Captain Edwards ordered tents to be erected with the sails from the
ship's boats, one for the officers and one for the men. We prisoners were
sent to the windward end of the sand-bar, and, as there was no
possibility of escape, we were not guarded in the daytime; but two
sentinels were placed over us at night, lest ten of us should attack a
ship's company nearly ten times our strength. Nor were we permitted to
speak to anyone save each other. During our five months' confinement in
the frigate, our bodies, which had become inured to tropical sunlight at
the time of our capture, had bleached, and were almost as white as that
of any counting-house clerk in London. Most of us were stark naked, and
our skin was soon terribly blistered by the sun. We begged to be allowed
to erect a shelter for ourselves with one of the sails not in use, but
Edwards was so lacking in humanity as to refuse this request. Our only
recourse was to wet the burning sand at the water's edge and bury
ourselves in it up to the neck.

The suffering from thirst was scarcely to be endured. Nearly all of us
had swallowed quantities of salt water before we had been rescued by the
boats, which added to our torture. The provision that had been saved was
so scanty that each man's allowance on the first day spent on the key was
two musket-balls' weight of bread and a gill of wine. No water was issued
that day. Lieutenant Corner made a fire with some bits of driftwood,
placed a copper kettle over it, and, by saving the drops of steam
condensed in the cover, got about a wineglass full of water, which was
issued to the ship's company, a teaspoonful per man, until the supply was
exhausted. One of the seamen, a man named Connell, went out of his senses
from drinking salt water.

We prisoners were far too miserable to converse. We lay by the water's
edge, covered by sand and longing for darkness; and when it came we were
only a little less wretched than before. Our raging thirst and our burned
and blistered bodies made sleep impossible. The following morning the
_Pandora's_ master was sent in the pinnace to the scene of the wreck
to learn whether anything else might be recovered from it. He returned
with a part of the topgallant masts which were above water, and with a
cat which he had found perched on the cross-trees. This poor animal was
saved only to be sacrificed to the needs of shipwrecked seamen. It was
cooked and eaten that same day, and a cap was made from its fur to cover
the bald head of one of the officers who had lost his wig.

The following day was a repetition of the preceding one. In the early
morning a search was made in the shallow water along the sand-bar for
shellfish, and a number of giant cockles were discovered; but the thirst
of every man was so great that these could not be eaten and had to be
thrown away. The carpenters were employed in preparing the boats for the
long voyage ahead of us. The floor boards were cut into uprights which
were fastened to the gunwales, and around these canvas was stretched to
prevent the sea from breaking into the boats, for they would all be so
heavily loaded as to leave very little freeboard.

On the morning of August 31, the repairs to the boats having been
completed, Captain Edwards mustered the company. We prisoners were herded
together, under guard, a little to one side of the others. Officers,
seamen, and prisoners alike, we were as gaunt and woebegone a crowd as
had ever been cast ashore from a shipwrecked vessel. Edwards was clad in
his shirt, trousers, and pumps, without stockings. Dr. Hamilton was in a
like costume except that he had lost his shoes; but he had saved his
medicine chest, and he took an opportunity to whisper to me that my
Journal and manuscripts had been saved with it. Most of the sailors were
naked to the waist, but had managed to come ashore in their trousers,
and, with the exception of three or four, wore turbans made of large red
or yellow handkerchiefs twisted about their heads, a common article of
dress among the men at sea. Of the prisoners, four of us were stark
naked, and the others had only rags of pulpy Indian bark cloth about
their waists. We were all without hats and our bodies were seared and
blistered by the sun. Muspratt in particular suffered terribly from his
burns. Our condition spoke eloquently for us, but Edwards would have done
nothing had it not been that Dr. Hamilton urged him to allow the naked
men to have some remnants of canvas. It was owing to the surgeon that
they had some slight covering from the pitiless sun.

Edwards walked up and down in front of the company for some time. We were
gathered in a half-circle before the boats, which were ready to be
launched. The sky was cloudless and the sea of the deepest blue, save
where it broke over the reefs and shoals that stretched away before us.
We waited in silence for the captain to speak. Presently he turned and
faced us.

"Men," he said, "we have a long and dangerous voyage ahead of us. The
nearest port at which we can expect help is the Dutch settlement on the
island of Timor, between four and five hundred leagues from this place.
We shall pass various islands on our way, but they are inhabited by
savages from whom we have nothing to expect but the barbarity common to
such people. Our supply of provision is so scant that each man's
allowance will be small indeed; but it will be sufficient to maintain
life even though we are unable to add to it during the passage. Each of
us, officers, men, and prisoners alike, will receive the following
allowance, which will be issued each day at noon: two ounces of bread,
half an ounce of portable soup, half an ounce of essence of malt, two
small glasses of water, and one of wine. It is to be hoped that we shall
be able to add to our supplies during the voyage, but this cannot be
counted upon.

"With favouring winds and weather we may be able to reach Timor in
fourteen or fifteen days, but I must warn you that we can scarcely expect
such good fortune. But within three weeks, if we meet with no accidents
on the way, we shall be approaching our destination. Most of our
provision must be carried in the launch, and for this reason, as well as
for support and defense, the boats must keep together.

"I expect implicit obedience from every man, and cheerful and immediate
compliance with the orders issued by your officers. Our safety depends
upon this, and any infringement of discipline will be severely dealt

"Captain William Bligh, in a boat laden more deeply than any of ours, and
with provision even more scanty, has made the same voyage that we are to
make. He must have passed near this spot, and at that time he and his men
had sailed and rowed their boat between six and seven hundred leagues.
And he arrived at Timor with the loss of only one man. What he has done,
we can do."

Edwards now turned to us.

"As for you," he continued, "you are not to forget that you are pirates
and mutineers being taken to England to suffer the punishment you so
richly merit. I am ordered by His Majesty's Government to have a proper
regard for the preservation of your lives. This duty I shall continue to

This was the first, indeed the only, time he condescended to address us

The boats were now dragged into the water, and our company was
distributed among them. Morrison, Ellison, and I were assigned to the
captain's pinnace.

We were delayed in starting owing to the condition of the seaman Connell,
the man who had drunk salt water to allay his thirst. All through the
previous night he had been raving mad, and it was plain that he had only
a few hours to live. In his condition it was impossible to take him into
any of the boats. His sufferings were horrible, and offered an object
lesson to anyone who might have been tempted to follow his example. Death
came mercifully at about ten o'clock in the morning, and in his haste to
embark Edwards read no burial service over the body. A shallow grave was
scooped in the sand, and it was the work of no more than five minutes to
bury him there. A lump of sun-blackened coral was placed as a headstone.
No British seaman, I imagine, has had a lonelier grave.

We now quickly embarked, and, with the pinnace in the van, set out on our
voyage to Timor.


We had a fair wind and a calm sea, and the sail was hoisted directly we
left the key. Edwards sat at the tiller. He looked as gaunt and ill-kempt
as any of his men, but his lips were set in their usual thin line, and
from the expression on his face he might have been walking the
quarter-deck of the _Pandora_. One of the men cried, "Ho for Timor,
lads!" but there was no response. We were so tortured by thirst that
scarcely a word passed among the company.

Morrison, Ellison, and I had been placed in the bow of the pinnace. Her
burden of twenty-four men brought her low in the water and made it
impossible for Edwards to separate us from the seamen; but lest we should
somehow contaminate them, he took the precaution of placing Hayward, and
Rickards, the master's mate, next to us. When it was necessary for either
of them to take the tiller, Packer, the gunner or Edmonds, the captain's
clerk, took his place. When the wind failed we took our turns at the oars
with the others, but we were never permitted to forget that we were
pirates on the way to a rope's end on some ship of war in Portsmouth
Harbour. Hayward evidently felt the awkwardness of his situation in being
placed directly beside us in a small boat; but under Edwards's watchful
eye he managed to maintain toward us his usual manner of contemptuous

The calm sea was less than half a dozen miles in extent; then we found
ourselves, as before the wreck, in the midst of a maze of sandbars and
half-drowned reefs, leagues distant from any land. The currents and
tide-rips were as strong as they were treacherous, and it was necessary
to take in sail and trust to the oars; but with the boat so heavily laden
it was heart-breaking work keeping clear of the shoals. The floor of the
sea was a miracle of vivid colouring, but its beauty became hateful to
us, and I remember with what longing we looked ahead for the deep blue
water that meant safety.

At midday our allowance of food and water was issued. Edwards had devised
a pair of scales, using two musket balls for weights, and the water and
wine were measured in a small glass. We had but two of these glasses, and
it was necessary for each man to drink his allowance at once so that
others might be served; but later we provided ourselves with clam shells
which enabled us to sip as slowly as we pleased.

All the morning the four boats had kept within a mile of one another, and
the work at the oars had increased our thirst to the point of agony. Most
of us were without hats, and the heat of the tropical sun was like a
heavy weight upon the brain. The only relief from it was to wet such
garments as we had and place them on our heads, and many sponged their
bodies, as well, with sea water, but the absorption through the skin of
the salts in the water increased thirst and gave a nauseating taste to
the saliva. Some of the men, made reckless by suffering, begged or
demanded an increased allowance of water, and one of them, in the launch,
after he had drunk his own allowance, tried to seize the glass of another
as it was being passed from hand to hand, and the precious liquid was
spilled. The man was immediately knocked senseless by Bowling, one of the
master's mates, who clubbed him over the head with an emptied bottle.
Under the circumstances, it was a well-deserved punishment. Edwards now
spoke to the company.

"It is my purpose," he said, "to bring every man of you safe to Timor;
but if we have another incident of this kind, the one responsible for it
shall be shot. Let each man remember that his sufferings are shared by
all of the others. To-morrow we shall be close in with the coast of
Australia. Somewhere along that coast we shall undoubtedly find water; I
promise that we shall not leave it until we do. Meanwhile, bear in mind
what I have said."

From the condition of my own parched lips and swollen tongue, I was able
to appreciate what an effort it must have cost Edwards to make even so
brief an address to the company. We proceeded on our way, the four boats
keeping within view of each other during the afternoon, and before sunset
we had passed through the worst of the reefs and had more open water
before us. The pinnace, which was still in the van, lay-to to allow the
other boats to come up with her, and we made fast, bow and stern, lest we
should become separated during the night. Never, I imagine, have men
welcomed the coming of darkness more gratefully. The breeze was cool, and
carried us smoothly on the way we would go. Oars were laid over the
thwarts, and by this means we were able to stow two tiers of men, which
gave us room to' stretch our limbs a little.

At dawn the lines were again cast off, and each boat proceeded as best it
could. We were now close in with the northernmost coast of Australia, but
whether it was the continent itself or one of the innumerable islands
adjoining it, no one of us knew. The land had an arid look, and we gazed
at it with hopeless eyes, for it seemed unlikely that we should find
water there. The pinnace and the red yawl were close together at this
time. For several hours we coasted along within half a mile of the shore.
We saw no signs of man or beast, and the vegetation was nothing more than
scattered trees and hardy shrubs that looked as tortured with thirst as

We came to an inlet that deeply indented the coast. The breeze died down,
the oars were gotten out, and we rowed into the bay. Here the water was
like a sheet of glass, reflecting the sky and the brown shore line. It
was about three miles to the head of the bay, but, eager though we were
to reach it, we made but slow progress in our enfeebled condition. As we
approached we saw a narrow valley where the vegetation was of a much
richer green, which made it all but certain that water was to be found
there. At last we brought up within wading distance of the beach, and in
their eagerness some of the men leaped into the water; but Edwards
ordered them back until a guard had been told off in each of the boats to
watch over the prisoners. The rest of the company were then permitted to
go ashore, and we watched with feverish eyes as they spread out along the
bay and proceeded inland. Then a shout was heard, and all of them rushed
like madmen to one spot. An excellent spring had been found within fifty
yards of the beach. It was all that our guards could do to prevent
themselves from rushing after the others.

The delay was torture, but our turn came at last. We drank and drank and
drank again until we could hold no more. Nothing mattered now. Having
been relieved from the most terrible of all man's bodily sufferings, we
were content. Those whose thirst was quenched crawled into the shade of
the trees and fell asleep at once. They lay sprawled like dead men,
around the spring. Edwards would gladly have remained here, but the
launch and the blue yawl had, somehow, missed the bay and, shut in by
land as we were, it was impossible to signal them. Therefore the men were
kicked or buffeted awake by the officers, and having filled our small
keg, the teakettle, two bottles, and even a pair of water-tight boots
belonging to the gunner, we re-embarked. Several of the seamen were so
exhausted that it was impossible to waken them. They were carried aboard
and dropped into the bottom of the boats.

When we had emerged from the bay we saw the launch and the blue yawl far
ahead of us. We made all haste to come up with them and signalled by
musket fire; but the signals were not heard, and it was not until
mid-afternoon that we managed to get abreast of them. They had found no
water and we were now too far to leeward to permit them to return to the
bay where the spring was. Edwards issued three wineglasses of water to
each man in the two boats, and we made sail again.

At daybreak the following morning we were not far from an island that
proved to be inhabited. It looked much less desolate than the mainland.
The white sandy beach soon gave way to rising ground where there was
abundant vegetation. We searched eagerly for a landing place; but we had
been seen from afar, and as we proceeded the Indians gathered in ever
greater numbers, following us along the beach. They were jet-black in
colour and stark naked, and armed with spears and bows and arrows.
Finding a break in the reef, we entered a narrow lagoon and approached to
within half a cable's length of the shore. In a moment the place was
thronged with savages in a state of great excitement, and it was evident
that they had never before seen white men. We made signs to them that we
wanted water, and after much persuasion half a dozen of them were coaxed
near enough to the boats to enable us to give them some buttons cut from
various articles of clothing. They took the keg of the pinnace, the only
container of any size that we had for water, and presently returned with
it filled. The eager, desperate haste with which we drank would have
offered a pitiful sight to any civilized observer, but the savages
laughed and yelled with delight as they watched us. The keg was soon
emptied and again given to them, but upon bringing it back a second time
they placed it on the beach and made signs for us to come and fetch it.
This Edwards would not allow to be done, suspecting treachery, and he
ordered the boats to push off to a safer distance. At this sign of
timidity on our part the natives rushed forward to the water's edge and
discharged a shower of arrows at us. Fortunately no one was hit, although
there were many narrow escapes. One arrow struck a thwart in our boat,
piercing an oak plank an inch thick. A volley was then fired over their
heads, and the sound and the smoke so frightened them that all ran for
their lives, and in an instant the beach was deserted. The pinnace pushed
in to recover the keg. We got it, and none too soon, for the savages
rushed out again, but we made off before any harm was done.

The savages were so numerous and so hostile that Edwards abandoned hope
of refreshment here. Other islands were in view at this time, and rather
than risk the loss of any of the company, we were ordered to proceed to
the nearest of these. About two o'clock in the morning we entered a small
bay which I still remember with the keenest pleasure. It was a cool
cloudless night, with a late moon casting a glamorous light over the
glassy surface of the water. The four boats entered in complete silence
as a precaution against the presence of savages. We disembarked upon a
beach of coral sand, packed hard and firm, and delightfully cool to our
bare feet. The prisoners were taken aside under a guard, and two parties
were told off to make an exploration of the place. The rest of the
company remained by the boats with their arms in readiness. In about an
hour's time the search parties returned with the welcome news that the
place was deserted, and that they had found water. Every man had his
thirst quenched that night. Sentinels were then posted, and all of the
others stretched out on the cool sand for the sleep so desperately

I awoke shortly after dawn, feeling completely refreshed and very hungry.
The bay was still in shadow, but the light was streaming up from behind
the green hills enclosing it. Morrison was awake, but the rest of the
prisoners, as well as the _Pandora's_ company, were sleeping as
though they would never have done. Edwards let them have their sleep out,
but as the men awakened they were sent out in small parties to search for
food. A pleasanter refuge than this bay afforded could scarcely have been
found, except for the fact that no food-bearing trees could be
discovered, nor did those searching the shallows of the bay have any
better success. Morrison and I proposed to the master-at-arms that the
prisoners be permitted to forage for the ship's company. The request was
carried to Edwards, who granted it with great reluctance. To be indebted
to a group of pirates and mutineers for benefits of any kind was opposed
to all his ideas of fitness; but, his own men having failed to discover
anything save a few sea snails, we were sent out, well guarded, to see
what we could do.

We made fishlines of bark cut into thin strips and braided, and we
devised fish hooks with some nails furnished us by the carpenter. With
other nails and long slender poles cut from the bush, we made fish
spears, and, thus provided, we set out with the ever-present marines
accompanying us in one of the ship's boats.

During our long sojourn at Tahiti we had learned how and where to search
for shellfish, and within two hours we returned with the boat loaded with
fish, lobsters, mussels, and the like, enough for two good meals for the
whole company. We received no word of thanks from Edwards, and
immediately we had returned we had the guard round us as before; but it
was enough for us to see with what relish all hands partook of the meal.

We remained at this place, which Edwards named "Laforey's Island," all of
that day and the following night. We found no Indians, but it was plainly
used by them as a place of frequent resort. The ground in the vicinity of
the spring was much footworn, and two or three well-used paths led over
the hills toward the interior. Near the shore we found some heaps of
sun-bleached human bones which gave us reason to believe that the people
were cannibals. On the morning of September 2 we again embarked, greatly
refreshed, and before nightfall had reached the open sea beyond Endeavour

For all the years that have passed, I still have a clear recollection of
the feeling of horror and gloom that, at this time, seized the greater
part of the men in the pinnace. Timor was still a thousand miles distant,
and not many of us had more than a dim hope of reaching it. We had far
more than our share of faint-hearts, for the _Pandora's_ crew had
been made up largely of landsmen, with no sense of the traditions of the
sea, unaccustomed to the dangers and hardships which sailors take as a
matter of course. Above all, they were ignorant of what a good ship's
boat can do when ably handled. Luckily, most of the _Pandora's_
officers were thorough seamen, and there was a saving leaven of the same
type among the men.

Now that we were once more in the open sea, new dangers presented
themselves. There was a heavy westerly swell running, and with our boats
so deep in the water we were kept bailing constantly. Our only vessels
were some giant mussel shells we had found at Laforey's Island, and they
were heavy and ill-adapted to the purpose. During the first day we had
not a moment of rest. The wind had come round to the east and, running
counter to the swell, made a dangerous sea. There were times when every
man of us was bailing who could be spared for the purpose, and at midday
it was only with great difficulty that the food and water could be

At nightfall the boats were again fastened to each other, but the
towlines broke repeatedly, and we were in such danger of being dashed to
pieces against each other that we were obliged to cast off and trust to
Providence that we should be able to keep together. Muskets were fired in
each of the boats at two-hour intervals, but these signals could not
always be made, owing to our powder being wetted. At dawn we found
ourselves widely scattered, and the blue yawl was so far to windward that
for an hour or two we thought we had lost her; but at last we caught
sight of her masthead as she rose to the crest of a sea.

By midday we had again assembled, and the meagre allowance of food and
water was passed around. Those noonday meetings have left a series of
indelible pictures in my mind. I see the blue yawl or the launch slowly
approaching, looking inconceivably small and lonely, now lost to view in
the trough of the sea, now clearly outlined against the sky as it rose to
the swell. At last it is near enough so that we can make out the figures
of the men, bailing, bailing, bailing, without respite. Now we are within
half a cable's length of each other, and I see the faces, gaunt and
hollow-eyed, and the expression of unutterable weariness upon each of
them. We would stare at each other like so many spectres. Sometimes
Edwards would call across to one of his officers: "How do you prosper,
Mr. Corner?" or, "Is it well with your company, Mr. Passmore?" And the
reply would come back, "We're not doing badly, sir." Then we would
approach each other as closely as we dared while the precious food and
water were being passed from boat to boat.

Dr. Hamilton was a tower of strength to the men in the red yawl. He
suffered as much as the rest of us, but he heartened and encouraged
everyone at these midday meetings. I was glad for the sake of Muspratt
and Burkitt that the surgeon was with them, for Parkin was in charge of
the red yawl, and he would have found the means to increase the misery of
the prisoners had it not been for the doctor.

A curious incident occurred in the pinnace at one of these noonday
assemblies. An elderly sailor named Thompson had carried with him from
the wreck of the _Pandora_ a small bag of dollars, his savings
during many years. When the day's allowance of water was being issued, a
wineglass was passed to the man sitting next him, a Scot named McPherson.
Prompted by his raging thirst, Thompson offered the whole of his savings
for this small glass of water. McPherson's struggle was a bitter one. His
desire for the dollars--and it was a goodly sum, sewed up in a canvas
bag--was' almost equally balanced by his desire for the two or three
mouthfuls of water the glass contained. The rest of us forgot our misery
for a moment as we waited to see the result. Presently the master's mate
said: "Do one thing or the other and be quick about it."

"Give me the bag," said McPherson, but while Thompson was loosening the
cord which held it to his waist, the Scot thought better of the matter
and drank his allowance of water at a gulp.

The sufferings of the older men were, naturally, greater than those of
the younger ones. A midshipman, who was no more than a boy, sold his
allowance of water two days running for another man's allowance of bread.
So terrible is thirst that several of the men drank their own urine. They
died, without exception, in the sequel of the voyage.

We again attempted to keep the boats together by towing, during the
nights of the fifth and sixth of September, but the lines broke as usual,
and the strain on the boats was so great that we were obliged to abandon
this method of keeping together during the night. Edwards had given his
officers the exact latitude of Timor, and the longitude by the timekeeper
on that date. This in case we should become separated. Fortunately, we
managed to keep within sight of each other during the whole of the
following week. In the pinnace we caught one booby, and the blood and
flesh were divided into twenty-four shares and distributed in the old
seaman's manner of "Who shall have this?" This good fortune came on the
eleventh of September, at a time when we were sorely in need of it.

On the morning of the thirteenth land was sighted, a faint bluish blur on
the Western horizon. At first we could not believe it possible that Timor
was within view, but as the morning wore on even the skeptics were
convinced that it was land and not cloud that we saw. We were so wretched
in mind and body that we could not even summon up the strength to cheer
when Rickards said, "It's Timor, lads. No doubt of it."

To add to our misery, it fell dead calm about the middle of the
afternoon. The oars were gotten out and we proceeded wearily on. The
boats now separated, each one being in haste to make the land. Some of
the older men in the pinnace were by now so helpless that they lacked the
strength to sit upright. They lay huddled in the bottom of the boat,
moaning and crying out for water.

By noon of the following day we were close in with the land. The other
boats were not in sight. The torture of thirst had become so great that
Edwards decided to pass out our remaining supply of water, which came to
half a bottle per man. This greatly refreshed us and we proceeded along
the coast, seeking a possible landing place.

I remember nothing of the hinterlands of Timor. I have in mind only a dim
picture of green hills and distant mountains. Every man's gaze, like my
own, was fixed on the foreshore. There was a high surf running, and for
several hours we found no place at which a boat could be landed without
risk of its being dashed to pieces. Toward sunset we came to a more
sheltered part of the coast, and two of the sailors swam ashore with
bottles fastened about their necks. They proceeded along the beach, the
boat following, until it was almost dark, without finding so much as a
muddy creek where we might have refreshed ourselves. Having taken them
aboard again, we stood off the land. We had the breeze again and made
good progress during the night. The next morning we found an excellent
landing place, and near it the water so urgently needed. I doubt whether
some of the men could have survived another day without it, for we had
been upon short rations so long that all the bodily juices were dried up.

About twelve o'clock on the night of September 15, the pinnace came to a
grapnel off the float by the fort in Coupang Bay. It was a calm night
with the sky ablaze with stars. The settlement was asleep. A ship was
anchored not far from where we lay, and two or three smaller craft, but
in the darkness we were unable to see whether any of the other boats of
the _Pandora_ had arrived. The night was profoundly still. On the
high rampart of the fort a dog stood, barking mournfully. That was our
welcome to Coupang. Worn out with our long journey, we remained where we
were until daylight, sleeping huddled in our places, and never, I
imagine, have men slept more soundly.

I shall give only a brief account of our experiences from the morning of
our arrival at Coupang until the day when we sighted the cliffs of Old
England. Captain Edwards and his men doubtless enjoyed the stay at
Coupang, where they were the guests of the Dutch East India Company. As
for the prisoners, we were guests of another sort. We were taken at once
to the fort and placed in stocks in the guardroom, a dreary place with a
bare stone floor, and lighted by two small barred windows high in the
wall. Parkin took charge of us again, and he saw to it that we lacked
even the most primitive means for comfort. Edwards never once visited us,
but we were not forgotten by Dr. Hamilton. During the first week at
Timor, he was kept busy attending the _Pandora's_ sick, several of
whom died within a few days of our arrival; but as soon as he was free to
do so he paid us a visit, accompanied by the Dutch surgeon of the place.
So foul was our prison by that time that before they could enter it the
place had to be scrubbed out by slaves, and ourselves with it. We begged
Dr. Hamilton to use his influence so that Lieutenant Corner might be
placed in charge of us; but Corner being a decent and humane man, Edwards
would not consent to this. We remained in Parkin's care, and he made our
life so wretched that we wished ourselves dead a dozen times over before
we reached the Cape of Good Hope.

On October 6 the entire company was embarked on the _Rembang_, a
Dutch East India ship, for the passage to Batavia, on the island of Java.
The _Rembang_ was an ancient vessel, and leaked so badly that it was
necessary to work the pumps every hour in the twenty-four. We prisoners
were kept at this work, and, exhausting though it was, we preferred it to
confinement below decks. Near the island of Flores a great storm arose,
which struck us so suddenly that every sail on the ship was torn to
ribbons. The Dutch sailors believed the vessel lost, and there was reason
to think so, for the pumps became choked and useless at the time when we
most needed them, and the ship was fast driving on a lee shore only seven
miles distant. It was due to Edwards, who took command, and the exertion
of some of our British tars, that we weathered the storm.

We arrived at Samarang on October 30, and here, to the amazement and
delight of everyone, we found the schooner _Resolution_, from which
we had become separated among the Navigators' Islands four months
earlier. After losing sight of the _Pandora_, Oliver, the master's
mate in charge of the _Resolution_, had cruised about for several
days in search of us, and had then proceeded to the Friendly Islands.
Namuka was the island appointed for a rendezvous in case of such an
emergency, but Oliver had gone to Tofoa, mistaking this island for
Namuka, and so had missed us. He and his crew of nine had undergone
dangers and hardships equal to, if not greater than, our own. Upon
reaching the great reef that stretches between New Guinea and the coast
of Australia, they had searched in vain for an opening, and then formed
the desperate resolve of running over the reef on the crest of a sea. It
was a chance in a hundred, but they succeeded, and were later saved from
death by thirst when they met a small Dutch vessel beyond Endeavour
Straits. Having been supplied with food and water, they pursued their
voyage to Samarang, where we found them.

Edwards sold the _Resolution_ at Samarang, and the money was divided
among the _Pandora's_ crew for the purchase of clothing and other
necessities. This seemed hard upon Morrison and the other prisoners who
had built the schooner. Not a shilling did they receive, but they at
least had the satisfaction of knowing that they had built a staunch
little ship, as good as any turned out by the shipwrights of England.
After her sale at Samarang she had a long and honourable career in the
western Pacific, and made the record passage between China and the
Sandwich Islands.

At Samarang the _Rembang_ was reconditioned and we proceeded to
Batavia, where the company was divided and transshipped to four vessels
of the Dutch East India Company for the long voyage to Holland. Captain
Edwards, with Lieutenant Parkin, the master, purser, gunner, clerk, two
midshipmen, and the ten prisoners from the _Bounty_, embarked on the
_Vreedenburg_, and on January 15, 1792, we arrived at the Cape of
Good Hope, where we found H.M.S. _Gorgon_ awaiting orders for
England. Edwards therefore left the _Vreedenburg_ and took passage
for all of his party on the _Gorgon_. We remained at the Cape for
nearly three months, during which time we were confined on the
_Gorgon_. Mr. Gardner, first lieutenant of that vessel, treated us
with great humanity. We were chained by one leg only, instead of having
both feet and both hands in irons as heretofore, and we were given an old
sail to lie upon at night, a luxury we had not enjoyed during the
previous twelve months. On the long passage to England we were permitted
to remain on deck for several hours each day to enjoy the fresh air. This
circumstance was galling to Edwards, who would have kept us below during
all that weary time; but as the ship was not his, he was not in a
position to protest.

On the nineteenth of June we arrived off Spithead, and before dark had
anchored in Portsmouth Harbour. Four years and six months had passed
since the _Bounty's_ departure from England, during which time we
had spent nearly fifteen months in irons.


Every vessel in Portsmouth Harbour knew of the arrival of the
_Gorgon_, and that she had brought home with her some of the
notorious _Bounty_ mutineers. The harbour was crowded with shipping
at this time, merchant vessels and ships of war. Among the latter was
H.M.S. _Hector_, and on the morning of June 21, 1792, we were
transferred to this vessel to await court-martial. It was a cloudy day,
threatening rain, with a fresh breeze blowing, and the choppy waves
slapped briskly against the bow of the boat. As we passed ship after ship
we saw rows of heads looking down at us from the high decks, and groups
of men crowded at the gun-ports for a view of us. We knew only too well
what they were thinking and saying to each other: "Thank God I'm not in
any of those men's boots!"

We were received with impressive solemnity on board the _Hector_. A
double line of marines with fixed bayonets were drawn up on either side
of the gangway. There was a deep silence as we passed between them and
down to the lower gundeck. No doubt we looked like pirates in our
nondescript clothing acquired here and there all the way from Timor to
England. Some of us were without hats, others without shoes, and none of
us had anything resembling a uniform. The rags that we wore consisted of
cast-off garments given us by various kind-hearted English sailors at
Batavia and at Table Bay,--chiefly by men of the _Gorgon_,--and they
were in a wretched state indeed by the time we reached home. We were
conducted to the gun room which lay right aft, and it was a great relief
to find that the treatment to which Edwards had so long accustomed us was
now a thing of the past. We were regarded, not as condemned men, but as
prisoners awaiting trial, and what a world of difference this made can be
appreciated only by men who have been placed in a similar situation.
Neither leg irons nor handcuffs were placed upon us, and we had the
freedom of the gun room, which was guarded by marines. We had decent
food, hammocks to sleep in, and were granted all privileges comportable
with our position as prisoners.

Considering our hardships and the fact that we had been so long in irons,
it is remarkable that we were all in good health. None of us had been ill
in all that time, and yet many of the _Pandora's_ company had been
continually ailing, and more than a dozen of them had died at Timor and
Samarang and Batavia. No doubt Edwards took credit to himself for our
condition, but he deserved none. We were well, not because of his
treatment, but in spite of it.

We had not been above an hour on board the _Hector_ when I was
summoned to the cabin of Captain Montague, who commanded the vessel. He
dismissed the guard and bade me, in a most kindly fashion, to be seated.
No mention was made of the mutiny. For a quarter of an hour he chatted
with me in the courteous, affable manner he might have used toward one of
his officers whom he had asked to dine with him. He questioned me at
length concerning the wreck of the _Pandora_, and our subsequent
adventures on the voyage to Timor. He was evidently interested in the
story, but I was sure that I had not been summoned merely to entertain
him with an account of our experiences. At length he opened a drawer in
his table and drew forth a small packet which he handed to me.

"I have some letters for you, Mr. Byam. You may have as much time as you
like here, alone. When you are ready to return to your quarters you have
only to open the door and inform the guard."

He then left me, and I opened the packet with trembling hands. It
contained a letter from Sir Joseph Banks, written only a few days
earlier, upon his receipt of the news of the _Gorgon's_ arrival. He
informed me that my mother had died six weeks before, and enclosed a
letter to me written the night before her death, forwarded to him by our
old servant, Thacker.

I was grateful indeed to Captain Montague for the privilege of half an
hour's privacy in his cabin; but there was no relief, then or later, for
the desolation of heart I felt. Scarcely a day had passed, in the years
since the _Bounty_ had left England, that I had not thought of my
mother and longed for her, and the consciousness of her love had
sustained me through all the weary months of our imprisonment. There was
never any question of her belief in my innocence, but she was as proud in
spirit as she was gentle and kind-hearted, and the slur cast upon our
good name by the event of the mutiny--above all, the fact that Bligh
considered me among the guiltiest of the mutineers--was a shock beyond
her strength to withstand. There was nothing of this in her letter; I had
the facts, later, from Thacker, who told me that my mother's health had
begun to fail from the day when she had received the letter from Bligh. I
have made all possible allowances for him. He had reason to believe that
I was an accomplice of Christian; but a man with a spark of humanity
would never have written the letter he sent to my mother. I no more
forgive him the cruelty of it now than I did when I first read it.

It was the irony of my fate that, having been blessed with the steadfast
love of two women, I should now--at a time when I most needed them--be
separated from my mother by death and from my Indian wife by half the
circumference of the globe. Upon these two I had centred all my
affections. Now that my mother was gone, I clung to the memory of Tehani
more tenderly than ever before.

What might now happen seemed a matter of little consequence. I could not
imagine life in England without my mother; the thought that I might lose
her had never occurred to me. But when I became calmer, I realized that,
for her sake at least, it was necessary to clear our name from the stigma
attached to it. I must prove my innocence beyond all question.

Sir Joseph Banks came to see me only a few days after I had received his
letter. My own father could not have been kinder. He had seen my mother
only a few weeks before her death, and he gave me all of the small
details of that visit. He remembered everything she had said, and he
allowed me to question him to my heart's content. I felt immeasurably
comforted and strengthened. Sir Joseph was one of those men who seem
members of a race apart; who find themselves equally at hone among all
kinds and conditions of people. In appearance he was a typical John Bull,
solidly made, with the clear ruddy complexion our English climate gives.
He seemed to radiate energy, and no man could be five minutes in his
presence without being the better for it. At this time he was President
of the Royal Society, and his name was known and honoured, not only in
England, but on the Continent as well. I doubt whether there was a busier
man in London, and yet, during those anxious weeks before the
court-martial, one would have thought that his only concern was to see to
it that all of us were given justice and fair play.

He quickly roused me from my despairing mood, and I found myself talking
with interest and enthusiasm of my Tahitian dictionary and grammar. I
told him that my manuscripts had been saved from the wreck of the
_Pandora_ and were in the care of Dr. Hamilton, now on his way home
with the rest of the _Pandora's_ survivors.

"Excellent, Byam! Excellent!" he said. "There is one gain, at least, from
the voyage of the _Bounty_." He had the faculty of entering with
enthusiasm into another man's work, and of making him feel that there was
nothing more important. "I shall see Dr. Hamilton the moment he arrives
in England. But enough of this for the present. Now I want your story of
the mutiny--the whole of it--every detail."

"You have heard Captain Bligh's account, sir? You know how black the case
against me appears to be?"

"I do," he replied, gravely. "Captain Bligh is my good friend, but I know
his faults of character as well as his virtues. His belief in your guilt
is sincerely held; yet allow me to say that I have never for a moment
doubted your innocence."

"Is Captain Bligh now in England, sir?" I asked.

"No. He has again been sent to Tahiti to fulfill the task of conveying
breadfruit plants to the West Indies. This time, I hope, the voyage will
be successfully completed."

This was serious news for me. I felt certain that, if I could confront
Bligh, I could convince him of my innocence, force him to acknowledge
that he had been mistaken in jumping to the conclusion that the
conversation with Christian had concerned the mutiny. With him gone, only
his sworn deposition at the Admiralty would confront me, and there was no
possibility of its being retracted.

"Put all that aside, Byam," said Sir Joseph. "There is no help for it,
and all your desire to confront Bligh won't bring him back in time for
the court-martial. Now proceed with your story, and remember that I am
completely in the dark with respect to the part you played."

I then gave him, as I had given Dr. Hamilton, a complete account of the
mutiny, and of all that had happened since. He allowed me to finish with
scarcely an interruption. When I had done so I waited anxiously for him
to speak.

"Byam, we may as well face the facts. You are in grave danger. Mr.
Nelson, who knew of your intention to go in the launch with Bligh, is
dead. Norton, the quartermaster, who could have corroborated your story
of Christian's intention to escape from the _Bounty_ on the night
before the mutiny, is dead."

"I know it, sir. I had the information from Dr. Hamilton."

"Your chance of acquittal depends almost entirely upon the testimony of
one man: your friend Robert Tinkler."

"But he returned safely to England."

"Yes, but where is he now?...He must be found at once. You say that he is
a brother-in-law of Fryer, the master of the _Bounty_?"

"Yes, sir."

"In that case I should be able to get trace of him. I can learn, at the
Admiralty, on what ship Fryer is now serving."

I had, somehow, taken it for granted that Tinkler would know of the need
I should have for him if ever I returned home; but Sir Joseph pointed out
to me the fact that Tinkler would be quite ignorant of this.

"It is not at all likely," he said, "that he will know of Bligh's
depositions at the Admiralty. And it will no more have occurred to him
than it did to you that your conversation with Christian could be
construed as evidence against you. The chances are that Tinkler will have
forgotten that Bligh overheard it. No; take my word for it, he will have
no fears on your account. Not a moment must be lost in finding him."

"How soon will the court-martial take place, sir?" I asked.

"That rests with the Admiralty, of course. But this matter has been
hanging fire for so long that they will wish to dispose of it as soon as
possible. It will be necessary to wait until the rest of the
_Pandora's_ company arrive, but they should be nearing England by
this time."

Sir Joseph now left me. He was to return to London by that night's coach.

"You shall hear from me shortly," he said. "Meanwhile, rest assured that
I shall find your friend Tinkler if he is to be found in England." Our
conversation had taken place in Captain Montague's cabin. The other
prisoners were anxiously awaiting my return to the gun room. Sir Joseph
was the first visitor we had had; in fact, we were not permitted to see
anyone except persons officially connected with the forthcoming
court-martial. Sir Joseph was not, perhaps, so connected, but his
interest in the _Bounty_ and his influence at the Admiralty gave him
access to us.

I gave the others an account of my conversation with him, omitting only
his opinion of the fate in store for Millward, Burkitt, Ellison, and
Muspratt. These men were, he thought, doomed past hope, with the possible
exception of Muspratt. Byrne was entirely innocent of any part in the
mutiny, but the poor fellow had been treated as a condemned man for so
long that he had more than half come to believe himself guilty. As for
Coleman, Norman, and McIntosh, it was inconceivable to any of us that
they would be convicted. Morrison was in a situation only less dangerous
than my own, and it grieved me to think that I was responsible for it.
Our delay below decks on the morning of the mutiny, in the hope of
getting possession of the arms chest, was known only to ourselves, and
the chances were that the story would be regarded as a fiction invented
afterward to explain our absence at the time the launch put off.

We had talked of the forthcoming court-martial so often during the long
passage to England that we had little more to say to each other now that
the event loomed so ominously near. At times, as a relief from anxiety,
we spoke of our happy life at Tahiti, but for the most part we spent our
days silently, each man engaged in his own reflections; or we stood at
the gun-room ports looking out at the busy life of the harbour. There
were times when I was seized with a sense of the unreality of this
experience, like that one feels upon waking from some dream in which the
events have been more than usually disconnected and fantastic. Hardest of
all to realize was the fact that we were indeed at home again, lying at
anchor only a few miles from Spithead, whence the _Bounty_ had
sailed so long ago.

Meanwhile, owing to the kindness of Sir Joseph, we were provided with
decent clothing in which to appear before the court-martial. This small
diversion was a most welcome one, and to be properly clothed again had an
excellent effect upon our spirits.

Ten days passed before I had further word from Sir Joseph. The letter I
then received I still have in my possession, although it is now faded and
worn with age. To reread it is to recall vividly the emotion I felt on
the morning when it was handed to me by the corporal of the guard at the
gun-room door.


I can imagine with what anxiety you are awaiting word from me. I regret
that I cannot go to Portsmouth at this time, for I should much prefer to
give you my news by word of mouth. This being impossible, a letter must

Upon returning to London I went directly to the Admiralty office, where I
learned that Fryer is now at his home in London, awaiting summons to
testify at the court-martial. I sent for him at once and learned that
Tinkler, shortly after his return to England, was offered a berth as
master's mate on the _Carib Maid_, a West India merchantman. The
captain of the vessel was a friend of Fryer's, and as it was a good berth
for the lad, offering opportunity for advancement, he accepted

Tinkler returned from his first voyage a year ago, and shortly afterward
set out on a second one. Fryer received word, not three months since,
that the _Carib Maid_ was lost with all hands in a hurricane near
the island of Cuba.

It would be useless to deny the fact that this is a great misfortune for
you. Even so, your situation, I believe, is not hopeless. I have had a
long conversation with Fryer, who speaks of you in the most friendly
terms. He is convinced that you had no hand in the mutiny, and his
testimony will be valuable.

Cole, Purcell, and Peckover I have also seen. They are now stationed at
Deptford, awaiting summons to the court-martial. They all speak highly of
you, and Purcell tells me that you yourself told him of your intention to
leave in the launch with Bligh. They all know of Bligh's conviction that
you were an accomplice of Christian, and it speaks well for your
character among them that they all believe you innocent.

My good friend, Mr. Graham, who has been Secretary to different admirals
on the Newfoundland Station these past twelve years, and who has,
consequently, acted as Judge Advocate at courts-martial all of that time,
has offered me to attend you. He has a thorough knowledge of the service,
uncommon abilities, and is a good lawyer. He already has most of the
evidences with him.

Farewell, my dear Byam. Keep up your spirits, and rest assured that I
shall be watchful for your good. I shall certainly attend the
court-martial, and now that my friend, Graham, has consented to go down,
I shall be more at ease than if you were attended by the first counsel in

My feeling upon reading this letter may be imagined. Sir Joseph had done
what he could to soften the blow to me, but I was under no doubt as to
the seriousness of my position. I knew that, without Tinkler's evidence,
my case was all but desperate, no matter how ably it might be presented.
Nevertheless, I clung to hope as a man will. I resolved to fight for my
life with all the energy I possessed. In one sense, the stimulus of
danger was a blessing in disguise, for it kept me from brooding over my
mother's death. I put out of mind every thought not connected with the
approaching trial.

Sea officers, as I had been informed by Sir Joseph, have a great aversion
to lawyers. I was well content, therefore, to have Mr. Graham, a Navy man
himself, as my representative. Morrison resolved to conduct his own case.
Coleman, Norman, McIntosh, and Byrne, who had every reason to hope that
they would be cleared of the charges against them, secured the services
of a retired sea officer, Captain Manly, to represent and advise all four
of them; and an officer from the Admiralty, Captain Bentham, was
appointed by the Crown to care for the interests of the other men.

We were visited by these gentlemen during the following week, but the
first to come was Mr. Graham. He was a tall spare man in his late
fifties, of distinguished bearing, and with a quiet voice and manner that
inspired confidence. From the moment of seeing him I was sure that my
fortunes could not be in better hands. None of us had any knowledge of
court-martial proceedings, and at my request Mr. Graham permitted us to
question him with respect to these matters.

"I have the morning at your disposal, Mr. Byam," he said, "and I shall be
glad to be of what assistance I can to any of you."

"I mean to conduct my own case, sir," Morrison said. "I should like
particularly to know the exact wording of the Article under which we are
to be tried."

"I can give you that precisely, from memory," Mr. Graham replied. "It is
Article Nineteen, of the Naval Articles of War, which reads as follows:
'If any person, in or belonging to the Fleet, shall make, or endeavour to
make, any mutinous assembly, upon any pretense whatsoever, every person
offending herein, being convicted thereof by the sentence of the
Court-Martial, shall suffer death.'"

"Has the Court no alternative course?" I asked.

"None. It must acquit, or convict and condemn to death."

"But supposing, sir, that there are extenuating circumstances," Morrison
added. "Supposing that a mutiny arises in a ship, as it did in ours,
where a part of the company have no knowledge of any intention to seize
the vessel, and who take no part in the seizure?"

"If they remain in the vessel with the mutinous party, the law considers
them equally guilty with the others. Our martial law is very severe in
this matter. The man who stands neuter is considered an offender with him
who lifts his hand against his captain."

"But there were some of us, sir," Coleman added, earnestly, "who would
gladly have gone with Captain Bligh when his party was driven from the
ship into the launch. We were retained against our will by the mutineers,
who had need o our services."

"Such a situation calls for special consideration by the Court and will
doubtless receive it," Mr. Graham replied. "If the men so retained can
prove their innocence of any complicity, they stand in no danger."

"Sir, may I speak?" asked Ellison.

"Certainly, my lad."

"I was one of the mutineers, sir. I'd no hand in starting the trouble,
but like all the rest of us I had no love for Captain Bligh, and I joined
in when I was asked to. Is there any hope for me?"

Mr. Graham regarded him gravely for a moment.

"I prefer not to give an opinion on that," he said. "Suppose we let the
question be decided by the court-martial itself."

"I'm not afraid of the truth, sir. If you think there's no chance, I'd be
obliged if you'd tell me so."

But Mr. Graham would not commit himself. "Let me advise all of you not to
prejudge your cases," he said. "I have sat through many a court-martial,
and, as in any civil court of law, one is not justified in forming an
opinion as to a possible verdict until all the evidence is in. And so you
see, young man," he added, turning to Ellison, "how mistaken I should be
in attempting to tell you what I think."

The days dragged by with painful slowness. Before this time most of the
men had received letters from their families. Some of them were many
months old, but they were read none the less eagerly for that. With the
exception of the letter received from my mother, at Tahiti, no news from
families or friends had reached any of us during the more than four years
we had been absent from home. Poor Coleman's family lived in Portsmouth,
but he was not permitted to see them. Of all the married members of the
_Bounty's_ company, he was, I suspect, the only man who had remained
faithful to his wife during our sojourn at Tahiti. To be prevented from
seeing her and his children after all these years was a cruel blow.

July passed, and August, and still we waited.


On the morning of September 12, the ten prisoners on board the
_Hector_ were ordered to hold themselves in readiness to proceed to
H.M.S. _Duke_. It was a grey, chilly, windless day, so still that we
could hear ships' bells from far and near it riking the half-hours and
the hours. The _Duke_ was anchored abreast of the _Hector_ and
about a quarter of a mile distant. Shortly before eight o'clock we saw a
longboat, with a guard of marines in dress uniform, put off from the
great ship's side and approach the _Hector_, and on the stroke of
the hour a solitary gun was fired from the _Duke_. It was the signal
for the court-martial. Our time had come.

I cannot speak of the emotions of my fellow prisoners at that solemn
moment, but I know that my own feeling was one of profound relief. We had
waited too long and endured too much to be capable of intense emotion--at
least, that was the case with me. I felt unutterably weary, in body and
mind, and if I desired anything it was peace--the peace of certainty as
to my fate, whatever it might be. I remember how impatient I was to
arrive on board the _Duke_. One's sense of time is largely a matter
of mood, and the voyage from the _Hector_ to the gangway of the
larger ship, brief as it was, seemed all but interminable.

The court-martial was held in the great cabin of the _Duke_, which
extended the width of the vessel, from the forward limit of the poop to
the stern gallery. The quarter-deck was thronged with people, chiefly
officers in full-dress uniform who had assembled from the many ships of
war in the harbour to attend the proceedings. There were also a number of
civilians, Sir Joseph Banks among them. Dr. Hamilton, whom I had last
seen at the Cape of Good Hope, was standing with the other officers of
the _Pandora_ by the bulwarks on the larboard side of the deck.
Edwards was there, of course, with his satellite, Parkin, beside him. He
glanced us over with his habitual air of cold hostility, and he appeared
to be thinking: "These scoundrels freed from their irons? What gross
neglect of duty!"

On the other side of the deck were gathered the officers of the
_Bounty_, looking self-conscious and ill at ease in that company of
ships' captains and admirals and rear admirals. It was a strange meeting
for old shipmates, and many were the silent messages that passed back and
forth as we looked eagerly at each other. Mr. Fryer, the master, was
there, and Cole, the boatswain, and Purcell, the carpenter, and Peckover,
the gunner. A clear picture flashed into mind of the last view we had had
of them as they looked up at us from the launch across the widening space
of blue water. Little any of us thought then that we should ever meet

The hum of conversation died away to silence as the door of the great
cabin opened. Audience was admitted. The spectators filed into the room;
then we were marched in with a guard, a lieutenant of marines with a
drawn sword in his hand preceding us. We were ranged in a line by the
bulkhead on the right-hand side of the door. During the first day's
proceedings we were compelled to stand, but owing to the length of the
trial, a bench was later provided for us.

A long table stood fore and aft in the middle of the cabin, with a chair
at the head for the President of the Court; the other members sat along
the sides at his right and left. A little to the right and to the rear of
the President's seat was a small table for the Judge Advocate, and
another, on the opposite side, for the writers who were to transcribe the
proceedings. At still another table sat the advisors to the prisoners. On
either side of the door leading to the stern gallery, and along the
walls, were settees occupied by the sea officers and civilians who
attended as spectators.

At nine o'clock precisely, the door opened again and the members of the
Court filed in to their places. At the order of the master-at-arms the
audience rose, and when the members of the Court were in their places,
all were seated again. The names of the twelve men who held over us the
power of life and death were as follows:--

The Right Honourable Lord Hood, Vice Admiral of the Blue, and
Commander-in-Chief of His Majesty's ships and vessels at Portsmouth
Harbour, _President_

Captain Sir Andrew Snape Hammond, Bart.
Captain John Colpoys
Captain Sir George Montague
Captain Sir Roger Curtis
Captain John Bazeley
Captain Sir Andrew Snape Douglas
Captain John Thomas Duckworth
Captain John Nicholson Inglefield
Captain John Knight
Captain Albemarle Bertie
Captain Richard Goodwin Keats

My lethargy of the earlier part of the morning left me as I gazed at the
impressive scene before me. At first my attention was fully engaged with
our judges, whose faces I examined one by one as the opportunity
presented itself. They were, for the most part, men in middle life, and
one would have known them anywhere, in any dress, for officers in His
Majesty's Navy. As I looked at their stern, wind-roughened, impassive
faces, my heart sank. I recalled Dr. Hamilton's words: "But these men
will know nothing of Christian's character, and their sympathies will all
be with Captain Bligh. You will have to prove your story of that
conversation with Christian beyond the shadow of a doubt." The only one
of the twelve men who might, I thought, be willing to give a prisoner the
benefit of a doubt was Sir George Montague, captain of the _Hector_.

Our names were called, and we stood before the Court while the charges
against us were read. This document was of considerable length, and
recapitulated the history of the _Bounty_ from the time of her
departure from England until she was seized by the mutineers. Then
followed Bligh's sworn statement, his own account of the mutiny, a
document of great interest to all of us, and to me in particular. The
statement, which follows, was read by the Judge Advocate:--

I respectfully beg to submit to the Lords Commissioners of
the Admiralty the information that His Majesty's armed vessel,
_Bounty_, under my command, was taken from me by some of the
inferior officers and men on the 28th of April, 1789, in the following

A little before sunrise, Fletcher Christian, who was mate of the ship and
officer of the watch, Charles Churchill, master-at-arms, Thomas Burkitt,
seaman, and John Mills, gunner's mate, came into my cabin, and, while I
was asleep, seized me in my bed and tied my hands behind my back with a
strong cord; and, with cutlasses and bayonets fixed at my breast,
threatened me with instant death if I spoke or made the least noise. I
nevertheless called out so loud for help that everyone heard me and were
flying to my assistance; but all of my officers except those who were
concerned in the mutiny found themselves secured by armed

I was now hauled upon deck in my shirt and without a rag else, and
secured by a guard abaft the mizzenmast, during which the mutineers
expressed much joy at my position.

I demanded of Christian the cause of such a violent act, but no answer
was given but, "Hold your tongue, sir, or you are dead this instant!" He
held me by the cord which tied my hands, and threatened to stab me with
the bayonet he held in his right hand. I, however, did my utmost to rally
the disaffected villains to a sense of their duty, but to no

The boatswain was ordered to hoist the launch out, and while I was kept
under a guard with Christian at their head, the officers and men not
concerned in the mutiny were ordered into the boat. This being done, I
was told by Christian: "Sir, your officers and men are now in the boat
and you must go with them," and the guard carried me across the deck with
their bayonets presented on every side. Upon attempting to make some
resistance, one of the villains said to another: "Damn his eyes, the dog!
Blow his brains out!" I was at last forced into the boat and we were then
veered astern, in all, nineteen souls.

While the boat was yet alongside, the boatswain and carpenter and some
others collected several necessary things, and with some difficulty a
compass and quadrant were got, but no arms of any kind and none of my
maps or drawings. The size of the boat was 23 feet from stem to stern,
and rowed six oars. We were cast adrift with the following provision: 25
gallons of water, 150 pounds of bread, 30 pounds of pork, 6 quarts of
rum, and 6 bottles of wine.

The boat was so lumbered and deep in the water that it was believed we
could never reach the shore, and some of the pirates made their joke of
this. I asked for arms, but the request was received with the greatest
abuse and insolence. Four cutlasses were, however, thrown into the boat
at the last moment, and in this miserable situation we set out for the
island of Tofoa, one of the Friendly Islands, ten leagues distant from
where the ship then was. This island we reached at seven o'clock the same
evening, but the shore being very steep and rocky, we could find no
chance of landing till the following day.

During our search for water at this island we were attacked by the
savages and barely escaped with our lives, one of our number, John
Norton, a quartermaster, being killed as he attempted to recover the
launch's grapnel.

After considering our melancholy situation, I was earnestly solicited by
all hands to take them toward home; and when I told them that no hope of
relief remained for us until we came to Timor, a distance of 1200
leagues, they all agreed to live upon one ounce of bread per man each
day, and one gill of water. Therefore, after recommending this promise
forever to their memory, I bore away for New Holland and Timor, across a
sea but little known, and in a small boat laden with 18 souls, without a
single map of any kind, and nothing but my own recollection and general
knowledge of the situation of places to direct us.

After enduring dangers and privations impossible to describe, we sighted
Timor on the 12th of June, and on the morning of the 15th, before
daylight, I anchored under the fort at the Dutch settlement at Coupang.
This voyage in an open boat I believe to be unparalleled in the history
of Navigation.

At Timor my boat's company were treated with the greatest humanity by the
Governor and the officers of the Dutch East India Company. Here, for 1000
Rix dollars--for which I gave bills on His Majesty's Government--I
purchased a small schooner, thirty-four feet long, which I fitted for sea
under the name of His Majesty's schooner, Resource. In this vessel we
proceeded by way of Surabaya and Samarang to the Dutch settlement of
Batavia, where I sold the Resource and, with my people, embarked for
Europe in ships of the Dutch East India Company.

The lists, which I herewith submit, of those who were cast adrift with me
in the launch and those who remained in the _Bounty_ will show the
strength of the pirates.

I beg leave to inform their Lordships that the secrecy of the mutiny was
beyond all conception, so that I cannot discover that any who were with
me had the least knowledge of it.

It is of great importance to add that, on the night preceding the mutiny,
coming upon deck during the middle watch, according to my custom, I
discovered Fletcher Christian, the ringleader of the pirates, in earnest
conversation with Roger Byam, one of the midshipmen. In the darkness of
the deck I was not observed by these men, who were standing on the
starboard side of the quarter-deck between the guns; nor had I any
apprehension at that time that their conversation was not innocent. But
as I approached, unseen, I saw Roger Byam shake hands with Christian, and
I distinctly heard him say these words: "You can count on me," to which
Christian replied:

"Good! That's settled, then." The moment they discovered me they broke
off their talk. I have not the slightest doubt that this conversation
concerned the forthcoming mutiny.

A moment of deep silence followed the reading of Captain Bligh's
statement. I was conscious of the gaze of many pairs of eyes directed
upon me. No more damning statement could have been brought forward, and
it was only too plain how deep an impression it had made upon the Court.
How, without Tinkler's evidence, could it possibly be refuted? A sense of
the hopelessness of my situation came over me. I knew that had I been in
the place of any of my judges, I should have felt certain of the guilt of
at least one of the prisoners.

The Judge Advocate asked: "Do you wish me to read the names on the
appended lists, my lord?"

Lord Hood nodded. "Proceed," he said.

The lists were then read--first the names of those who had gone in the
launch with Bligh, then of those who remained with Christian's party. One
thing that astonished me was Bligh's silence with respect to Coleman,
Norman, and McIntosh. He well knew of their desire to go with him in the
launch, and that they had been prevented from doing so by the mutineers.
The barest justice demanded that he should have acknowledged their
innocence; yet he made no distinction between them and the guiltiest
members of Christian's party. To this day I am unable to account for his
injustice to these men.

John Fryer, master of the _Bounty_, was now called. He had not
changed in the least since I had last seen him, on the morning of the
mutiny. He glanced quickly in our direction, but there was time for no
more than a glance. He was directed to stand at the end of the table,
opposite Lord Hood, and was sworn.

The Court said: "Inform the Court of all the circumstances within your
knowledge concerning the running away with His Majesty's ship,

I shall give Fryer's testimony with few omissions, for it provides a
clear picture of what was seen by the _Bounty's_ master on the day
of the mutiny.

"On the 28th of April, 1789, we tacked and stood to the south'ard and
westward until the island of Tofoa bore north; then we steered
west-northwest. In the first part of the evening we had little wind. I
had the first watch. The moon was at that time in its first quarter.
Between ten and eleven o'clock, Mr. Bligh came on deck agreeable to his
usual custom, to leave his orders for the night. After he had been on
deck some little time, I said, 'Sir, we have got a moon coming on which
will be fortunate for us when we come on the coast of New Holland.' Mr.
Bligh replied, 'Yes, Mr. Fryer, so it will,' which was all the
conversation that passed between us. After leaving his orders, he went
off the deck.

"At twelve o'clock everything was quiet on board. I was relieved by Mr.
Peckover, the gunner. Everything remained quiet until he was relieved, at
four o'clock, by Mr. Christian. At the dawn of day I was much alarmed,
whether from the noise Mr. Bligh said he made or by the people coming
into my cabin, I cannot tell. But when I attempted to jump up, John
Sumner and Matthew Quintal laid their hands upon my breast and desired me
to lie down, saying, 'You are a prisoner, sir. Hold your tongue or you
are a dead man, but if you remain quiet, there is no person on board that
will hurt a hair of your head.'

"I then, by raising myself on the locker, which place I always slept on
for coolness, saw Mr. Bligh in his shirt, with his hands tied behind him,
going up the ladder, and Mr. Christian holding him by the cord. The
master-at-arms, Charles Churchill, then came to my cabin and took a brace
of pistols and a hangar, saying, 'I will take care of these, Mr. Fryer.'
I asked what they were going to do with their captain. 'Damn his eyes!'
Sumner said. Put him into the boat and let the dog see if he can live on
half a pound of yams a day.' 'Into the boat!' I said. 'For God's sake,
what for?' 'Sir,' Quintal said, 'hold your tongue. Christian is captain of
the ship, and recollect that Mr. Bligh has brought all this upon

"I then said, 'What boat are they going to put Captain Bligh into?' They
said, 'The large cutter: 'Good God!' I said, 'the cutter's bottom is
almost out of her, being very much eaten with worms.' 'Damn his eyes,'
Sumner and Quintal said, 'it is too good for him even so!' I said, 'I
hope they are not going to set Captain Bligh adrift by himself?' They
answered, 'No. Mr. Samuel, his clerk, and Mr. Hayward and Mr. Hallet are
going with him.'

"At last I prevailed on them to call on deck to Christian to give me
permission to go up, which, after some hesitation, he granted. Mr. Bligh
was standing by the mizzenmast with his hands tied behind his back, and
there were several men guarding him. I said, 'Mr. Christian, consider
what you are about.' 'Hold your tongue, sir,' he replied. 'I have been in
hell for weeks past. Captain Bligh has brought all this on himself.'

"Mr. Purcell, the carpenter, had been permitted to come on deck at the
same time with myself, and Mr. Christian now ordered him to have the gear
for the large cutter brought up. When we came to Mr. Christian, Mr. Byam
was talking with him. I said, 'Mr. Byam, surely you are not concerned in
this?' He appeared to be horrified at such a thought. Mr. Christian said,
'No, Mr. Fryer, Mr. Byam has no hand in this business.' I then said, 'Mr.
Christian, I will stay with the ship,' thinking that, if permitted to do
so, a chance might offer for retaking the vessel. Christian replied, 'No,
Mr. Fryer, you will go with Captain Bligh.' He then ordered Quintal, one
of the seamen under arms, to conduct me to my cabin while I collected
such things as I should need.

"At the hatchway I saw James Morrison, the boatswain's mate. I said to
him, 'Morrison, I hope you have no hand in this?' He replied, 'No, sir, I
have not.' 'If that's the case,' I replied, in a low voice, 'be on your
guard. There may be an opportunity for recovering ourselves.' His answer
was, 'I'm afraid it is too late, Mr. Fryer.'

"I was then confined to my cabin, and a third sentinel was put on, John
Millward, who, I thought, seemed friendly. Mr. Peckover, the gunner, and
Mr. Nelson, the botanist, were confined in the cockpit, to which place I
persuaded the sentinels to let me go. Mr. Nelson said, 'What is best to
be done, Mr. Fryer?' I said to them, 'If we are ordered into the boat,
say that you will stay on board, and I flatter myself that we shall
recover the ship in a short time.' Mr. Peckover said, 'If we stay we
shall all be deemed pirates.' I told them not; that I would answer for
them and everyone that would join with me. At the time we were talking,
Henry Hillbrandt, the cooper, was in the bread room, getting some bread
to be put into the boat for Captain Bligh. I suppose he must have heard
our conversation and had gone on deck to tell Mr. Christian, as I was
immediately ordered up to my cabin. I heard from the sentinels that
Christian had consented to give Mr. Bligh the launch, not for his own
sake but for the safety of those who were going with him. I asked if they
knew who was to go with Captain Bligh, and they said they believed a
great many.

"Soon after this, Mr. Peckover, Mr. Nelson, and myself were ordered upon
deck. Captain Bligh was then at the gangway. He said, 'Mr. Fryer, stay
with the ship.' 'No, by God!' Christian replied. 'Go into the boat or I
will run you through,' pointing his bayonet at my breast. I then asked
Christian to permit Mr. Tinkler, my brother-in-law, to go with me.
Christian said, 'No,' but after much solicitation he permitted him to go.

"I cannot say who was in the boat first, Mr. Bligh or myself; however, we
were both on the gangway together. All of this time there was very bad
language made use of by the people to Captain Bligh. We begged that they
would give us two or three muskets into the boat, but they would not
consent to it. The boat was then ordered astern. After lying astern for
some time, four cutlasses were handed in, the people at the same time
making use of very abusive language. I heard several of them say, 'Shoot
the dog!' meaning Captain Bligh. Mr. Cole, the boatswain, said, 'We had
better cast off and take our chance, for they will certainly do us a
mischief if we stay much longer.' Captain Bligh very readily agreed.
There was little wind. We got out the oars and rowed directly astern. Our
reason for so doing was that we should sooner be out of reach of the

"As soon as the boat was cast off I heard Christian give orders to loose
the topgallant sails. They steered the same course as Captain Bligh had
ordered, and continued to do so for the time we saw them.

"The confusion that prevailed on board was so great, and our attention,
from that time to our arrival at Timor, so much taken up by regard for
the preservation of our lives, that it was not possible for me to make
any note or memorandum, even if I had had the means to do so, which I had
not. This account is an exact statement of the case to the best of my

"The following is the list of persons that I observed under arms:
Fletcher Christian, Charles Churchill, the master-at-arms, Thomas
Burkitt, one of the prisoners, Matthew Quintal, John Millward, one of the
prisoners, John Sumner and Isaac Martin. Joseph Coleman, armourer, one of
the prisoners, wished to come into the boat and called several times to
us to recollect that he had no hand in the business. Charles Norman, one
of the prisoners, and Thomas McIntosh, another of the prisoners, also
wished to come with us, but were prevented by the mutineers, who had need
of their services on the ship. Michael Byrne, another of the prisoners,
wished, I think, to come with us as well, but feared to do so lest the
boat should be lost."

Fryer here ended his testimony.

The Court asked: "You have named seven persons who were under arms. Did
you believe that these were the only persons under arms?"

Fryer: No.

The Court: What was your reason for so believing?

Fryer: From hearing the people in the boat say so, but I did not see any
more, to the best of my recollection.

The Court: Inform the Court of the time you remained on deck at each of
the times when you went on deck.

Fryer: About ten minutes or a quarter of an hour.

The Court: When you were upon the quarter-deck, did you see any of the
prisoners active in obeying any orders from Christian or Churchill?

Fryer: I saw Burkitt and Millward under arms as sentinels.

The Court: When the launch was veered astern, did you observe any of the
prisoners join in the bad language which you say passed upon that

Fryer: Not to the best of my recollection. I saw Millward upon the
taffrail with a musket in his hand. There was so much noise and confusion
that I could not hear one man from another.

The Court: You also say that when the cutlasses were handed into the
boat, very bad language was used by the mutineers. Did any of the
prisoners join in it upon that occasion?

Fryer: Not to my recollection. It was a general thing among the whole.

The Court: Did you see Thomas Ellison, one of the prisoners, upon the
morning of the mutiny?

Fryer: Not at first. Later I did.

The Court: What was he doing?

Fryer: He was standing near Captain Bligh, but I cannot charge my memory
as to what he was doing.

The Court: Did he have arms in his hands?

Fryer: I am not certain whether he had or no.

The Court: Did you see William Muspratt?

Fryer: No.

The Court: When Mr. Bligh and you were ordered into the boat, did any
person assist, or offer to assist Mr. Christian in putting those orders
into execution?

Fryer: Yes. Churchill, Sumner, Quintal, and Burkitt.

The Court: Were you near enough, when you heard Christian order the
topgallant sails to be loosed, to know any of the people who went upon
the yards?

Fryer: I saw only one, who was a boy at that time--Thomas Ellison.

The Court: How many men did it require to hoist out the launch?

Fryer: It might be done with ten men.

The Court: Did you see any of the prisoners assist in hoisting her out?

Fryer: Yes. Mr. Byam, Mr. Morrison, Mr. Coleman, Norman and McIntosh all
assisted; but this was done at Mr. Cole's, the boatswain's, orders,
passed through him by Mr. Christian.

The Court: Did you consider these men as assisting the mutineers or as
assisting Captain Bligh?

Fryer: I considered them as assisting Captain Bligh, as giving him a
chance for his life.

The Court: What reason had you to imagine that John Millward was friendly
toward you at the time he was placed sentinel over you?

Fryer: He appeared to be very uneasy in his mind, as though he had taken
arms reluctantly.

The Court: You say that you obtained permission for Tinkler to join the
boat with you. Had he been compelled to remain in the ship?

Fryer: He had been told by Churchill that he was to stay aboard to be his
servant, and came to tell me in my cabin.

The Court: In what part of the ship were the youngsters berthed?

Fryer: On the lower deck, on either side of the main hatchway.

The Court: Did you observe whether there was a sentinel over the main

Fryer: Yes. I omitted to mention that Thompson was stationed there by the
arms chest, with a musket and a bayonet fixed.

The Court: Did you consider him to have been a sentinel over the
midshipmen's berth?

Fryer: Yes; over the berth and the arms chest at the same time.

The Court: Do you know that, on that day, any effort was made by any
person in the ship to recover her?

Fryer: No.

The Court: What time elapsed from the first alarm to the time of your
being forced into the boat?

Fryer: About two hours and a half, or three hours, to the best of my

The Court: What did you suppose to be Mr. Christian's meaning when he
said that he had been in hell for weeks past?

Fryer: I suppose he meant on account of the abuse he had received from
Captain Bligh.

The Court: Had there been any very recent quarrel?

Fryer: The day before the mutiny, Mr. Bligh charged Christian with
stealing his coconuts.

The prisoners were now permitted to question the witness, and I was
ordered to speak first. Fryer must have felt the strangeness of our
situation as much as did I, myself. He had been more than kind to me
during our long association on the _Bounty_, and to meet for the
first time since the mutiny under those circumstances, when our
conversation could be only of the most formal kind, was a strain upon the
self-control of both of us. I was certain that he considered me as
innocent as himself, and that he felt nothing but good will toward me. I
asked three questions.

Myself: When you came upon deck the first time, and found me in
conversation with Mr. Christian, did you overhear anything that was said?

Fryer: No, Mr. Byam. There was...

Lord Hood interrupted.

"You must reply to the prisoner's questions by addressing the Court," he
said. The master therefore turned to the President.

Fryer: I cannot recollect that I overheard any of the conversation.

Myself: Had you any reason to believe that I was a member of Mr.
Christian's party?

Fryer: None whatever.

Myself: If you had been permitted to remain in the ship, and had you
endeavoured to form a party to retake the vessel, would I have been among
those to whom you would have opened your mind?

Fryer: He would have been among the very first to whom I would have
spoken of the matter.

The Court: You say that you had no reason to believe Mr. Byam member of
Christian's party. Did you not consider the fact that when you came upon
deck he was in conversation with Mr. Christian a suspicious circumstance?

Fryer: I did not; for Mr. Christian spoke to many of those, during the
mutiny, who were not members of his party.

The Court: During your watch, on the night before the mutiny, did you
observe Mr. Christian and the prisoner, Byam, together on deck?

Fryer: No. To the best of my recollection, Mr. Byam was on deck during
the whole of my watch, and Mr. Christian did not appear at all.

The Court: Did you speak to Mr. Byam at this time?

Fryer: Yes, upon several occasions.

The Court: Did he appear to be disturbed, or nervous, or anxious in mind?

Fryer: Not in the least.

I felt deeply grateful to Fryer, not only for the matter of his testimony
concerning myself, but even more for the manner of it. It must have been
plain to all the Court that he considered me innocent.

Morrison asked: "Did you observe any part of my conduct, particularly on
that day, which would lead you to believe that I was one of the

Fryer: I did not.

The other prisoners questioned him in turn, and poor Burkitt only made
his case appear even worse than it had before, for Fryer was obliged to
repeat and enlarge upon the details of Burkitt's activity as one of the

The master then withdrew and Mr. Cole, the boatswain, was called to the
stand. His testimony necessarily covered much the same ground; but while
this was true in the case of each of the witnesses, there were important
points of difference in their evidence. Each man had witnessed events
from different parts of the ship, and their interpretation of what they
saw, as well as their recollection of it after so long an interval of
time, varied considerably.

I learned from Cole's evidence that he had seen Stewart and me dressing
in the berth on the early morning of the mutiny, with Churchill standing
guard over us. His testimony was of melancholy importance to Ellison, and
the more damaging because of the evident reluctance with which he gave
it. Cole had a great liking for Ellison, as had most of the ship's
company. Nevertheless, being a man of strict honesty and a high sense of
duty, he was obliged to say that he had seen Ellison acting as one of the
guards over Bligh. He passed lightly and quickly over the mention of his
name, hoping that the Court might not notice it. His evident struggle
between the desire to spare all of the prisoners as much as possible, and
the necessity for telling the truth, was apparent to all, and won him the
sympathy of the Court but no mercy. When he had finished he was at once
probed for further information concerning Ellison.

The Court: You say that when you were allowed upon deck, you saw the
prisoner, Ellison, among the other armed men. How was he armed?

Cole: With a bayonet.

The Court: Was he one of the guards over Captain Bligh?

Cole: Yes.

The Court: Did you hear the prisoner, Ellison, make any remarks?

Cole: Yes.

The Court: What were they?

Cole: I heard him call Captain Bligh an old villain.

I then asked: "When you saw Stewart and me dressing in the berth, with
Churchill standing over us with a pistol, did you hear any of the
conversation that passed between us and Churchill and Thompson?"

Cole: No, I heard nothing of the conversation. There was too much noise
and confusion.

Ellison: You say that I was armed with a bayonet, Mr. Cole. Did you see
me use it in any way?

Cole: By no means, lad. You...

"Address your replies to the Court."

Cole: He never once offered to use his bayonet. He merely flourished it
in Captain Bligh's face.

At this reply I saw the hint of a grim smile on the faces of some of the
members of the Court. Cole added, earnestly: "There was no, real harm in
this lad. He was only a boy at that time, and full of mischief and high

The Court: Do you think this in any way excuses him for taking part in a

Cole: No, sir, but...

"That will do, Boatswain," Lord Hood interrupted. "Are there any further
questions from the prisoners?"

Morrison: Do you recollect, when I came on deck after you had called me
out of my hammock, that I came to you abaft the windlass and said, 'Mr.
Cole, what is to be done?' and that your answer was, 'By God, James, I do
not know, but go and help them with the cutter'?

Cole: Yes, I do remember it.

Morrison: Do you remember that, in consequence of your order, I went
about clearing the cutter? And afterward the launch, when Mr. Christian
ordered that boat to be hoisted out instead of the cutter?

Cole: Yes.

Morrison: Do you remember that I brought a towline and grapnel out of the
main hold and put them into the launch? And do you remember calling me to
assist you to hoist a cask of water out of the hold, and at the same time
threatening John Norton, the quartermaster, that he should not go in the
boat if he was not more attentive in getting things into her?

Cole: I have every reason to believe that he was employed in this
business under my direction. I remember telling Norton that, for he was
frightened out of his wits.

Morrison: Do you recollect that I assisted you when you were getting your
own things, which were tied up in part of your bedding, into the boat?

Cole: I had forgotten this, but it is strictly true. I had no reason at
any time to suppose that he was concerned in the mutiny.

Morrison: After I had helped you put your things into the boat, did I not
then run below to get my own, hoping to be allowed to go with Captain

Cole: I know that he went below, and I make no doubt that it was for the
purpose of getting his clothes to come with us.

The Court: Did the prisoner, Morrison, seem eager to go into the boat?

Cole: None of us was eager, for we never expected to see England again.
But he was willing to go, and I make no doubt he would have gone had
there been room.

Burkitt then asked: "When you came aft to get the compass out of the
binnacle, did not Matthew Quintal come and say he would be damned if you
should have it? And you then said, 'Quintal, it is very hard you'll not
let us have a compass when there's plenty more in the storeroom'? Then
did you not look hard at me, and did I not say, 'Quintal, let Mr. Cole
have it, and anything else that will be of service to him'?"

Cole: I know that Quintal objected to letting the compass go, though I do
not remember that Burkitt said anything, but he was standing near by. The
confusion was so great that it was impossible I could take notice of
everything particularly.

Burkitt: During the time that you say I was under arms, do you recollect
hearing me give any orders, or making use of bad language?

Cole: I only observed that he was under arms.

Millward: Can you say whether I took a musket willingly, or only because
of Churchill's orders?

Cole: I do not know whether it was by Churchill's order or not. He took
the musket.

The Court: Were all the people who were put into the boat bound, or were
they at liberty in going into her?

Cole: They were not bound, but they marched them who were below on deck
with sentinels at different times.

The Court: Were there no other arms in the ship but those in the arms
chest in the main hatchway?

Cole: Not to my knowledge.

The Court: At what time did day break on that morning?

Cole: I suppose about a quarter before five, or half-past four.

The Court put many other questions to the boatswain beside those given
here. He was examined closely, as Fryer had been, concerning the men in
Christian's watch, those he saw under arms, my own relationship with
Christian, and the like. His evidence made it plain that, although
Morrison, Coleman, Norman, McIntosh, and myself all assisted in hoisting
out the launch, this was done at the boatswain's orders, and could not be
construed as evidence that we were of the mutineers' party.

At the conclusion of Cole's testimony, the Court adjourned for the day,
and we were again conveyed to the gun room of the _Hector_. Mr.
Graham came, bringing a brief note from Sir Joseph, which read: "Now you
know the worst, Byam. Keep up a good heart. Both Fryer and Cole have
struck excellent blows for you to-day. It is evident that their opinion
of your character made an impression upon the Court."

Mr. Graham talked with me for half an hour, going over the evidence in
detail, instructing me further as to the questions I should ask of the
witnesses yet to be heard. He refused to give an opinion as to what he
thought of my chances. "If you can, keep your mind from dwelling upon the
outcome," he said. "It is not my part either to hearten or discourage you
unduly, but I think it well that you have no illusions about your
situation. It is grave but not hopeless. Meanwhile, be assured that I
shall do everything in my power to help you."

"May I ask one more question, Mr. Graham?" I said.

"Certainly. As many as you like."

"In your heart, do you believe me innocent or guilty?"

"I can answer that without a moment's hesitation. I believe you

This heartened me greatly, and gave me reason to hope that some, at
least, of the members of the Court might feel as he did.

There was little conversation in the gun room that evening. As long as
daylight served, Morrison sat by a port, with his Bible on his knee,
reading aloud to Muspratt, who had requested this. Ellison turned into
his hammock early and was asleep within five minutes. Four men among us
had little to fear. The events of the first day's hearing made it
increasingly plain that Coleman, Norman, McIntosh, and Byrne were all but
certain of acquittal. Burkitt and Millward paced up and down the room in
their bare feet. The soft padding of Burkitt's feet was the last sound I
heard before I went to sleep.


At nine o'clock the following morning the hearing was resumed. As we were
marched into the great cabin I noticed that it was even more closely
packed with spectators than it had been the previous day. The same
solemnity marked the proceedings, and Court and spectators alike attended
the examination of the witnesses with the same air of absorbed interest.

William Peckover, gunner of the _Bounty_, was called in and sworn.
The remarkable thing about his testimony was that he claimed to have seen
but four men under arms during the whole of the mutiny--Christian,
Burkitt, Sumner, and Quintal. I do not believe that he deliberately
falsified his testimony. I think he must have reasoned in this way: "The
mutiny took place so long ago, how can I be certain as to whom I saw
under arms? I have a clear recollection of only four. The other lads
shall have the benefit of the doubt. God knows they need it!" Immediately
he had finished, he was questioned on this point.

The Court: How many people did the _Bounty's_ company consist of?

Peckover: Forty-three, I believe, at this time.

The Court: State again how many of those you saw under arms.

Peckover: Four.

The Court: Was it your opinion that four people took the ship irom nine
and thirty?

Peckover: Not by any means.

The Court: Give your reasons for thinking so.

Peckover: There certainly must have been more concerned or they would not
have taken the ship from us. But these are all I can say, positively,
that I saw under arms.

The Court: What were your particular reasons for submitting when you saw
but four men under arms?

Peckover: I came naked upon the deck, with only my trousers on, and there
I saw Burkitt with a musket and a bayonet, and Mr. Christian alongside of
Captain Bligh, and a sentry at the gangway, but who he was I do not

The Court: Did you expostulate with Mr. Christian on his conduct?

Peckover: I did not.

The Court: Did you see Mr. Byam that morning?

Peckover: Yes. I saw him standing by the booms talking with Mr. Nelson,
the botanist. Then he went below, and I did not again see him until the
launch had been ordered astern.

The Court: Where was he then?

Peckover: I saw him for a moment at the taffrail.

The Court: What are your reasons for believing that Coleman, Norman,
McIntosh, and Byrne were averse to the mutiny?

Peckover: When they were looking down upon us from the stern they
appeared to wish to come into the boat, what slight view I had of them. I
was busy stowing things in the boat, so that I remember only Coleman
calling to me.

The Court: You have said that, in talking with Mr. Purcell, he said to
you that he knew whose fault the business was, or words to that effect.
Do you apprehend that Mr. Purcell alluded to any of the prisoners?

Peckover: No. I think he alluded to Captain Bligh, owing to the abuse so
many of the ship's company had received from him. The Court: What was the
nature of this abuse?

Peckover: Many severe punishments for slight offenses, and foul and
abusive language to all hands. Try as they would, neither officers nor
men could ever do anything to please him.

Morrison then questioned the gunner, and brought out even more clearly,
not only that he had never been under arms, but also that he had done
everything in his power to supply the launch with provision and
much-needed articles so that the men in her might have a better chance
for their lives. Morrison conducted his case remarkably well.
Unfortunately, the questions I put were to little purpose. Peckover had
been officer of the middle watch on the night before the mutiny. He had
seen Christian and me upon deck at that time, but had heard nothing of
our conversation; nor had he heard any of the conversation that passed
between Nelson and me the following morning.

Purcell, the carpenter, next took the stand. He was the same burly,
heavy-jowled man whom I had heard say to Nelson on the morning of the
mutiny: "Stop aboard? With rogues and pirates? Never, sir! I shall follow
my commander." I had great respect for the old fellow. No one could have
hated Bligh more, but there was never any hesitation in Purcell's
decisions when it came to a matter of duty. His evidence was of great
importance to me, but whether it helped or prejudiced my case it was
difficult to say. Purcell gave the names of seventeen men whom, he stated
with conviction, he had seen armed; among them, Ellison, Burkitt, and
Millward. Muspratt he omitted to name.

The Court asked: "In the former part of your evidence you say that you
asked Mr. Byam to intercede with Christian for the launch instead of the
cutter. Why did you speak of this matter to Byam? Did you consider him
one of the mutineers?"

Purcell: By no means. But I knew him to be a friend of Mr. Christian. I
also knew that Christian had no liking for me and would have listened to
no request I might have made.

The Court: Do you believe that it was owing to the prisoner Byam's
intercession that Christian permitted the launch to be hoisted out
instead of the cutter?

Purcell: Yes; and had we not been given the launch none of us would ever
have seen England again.

The Court: What had been the relations between Christian and Byam
throughout the voyage of the _Bounty_ to Tahiti and during the
sojourn there?

Purcell: Most friendly.

The Court: Name any others whom you believe to have been particularly
friendly with Mr. Christian.

Purcell: Mr. Stewart was one. I can think of no others that I could say
were intimate with him. Mr. Christian was not an easy man to know.

The Court: Do you think it likely that Mr. Christian would not have
divulged his plans for the mutiny to Mr. Byam, his most intimate friend?

Purcell was taken aback by this question, put to him by Captain Hammond,
who sat on Lord Hood's right. He lowered his head like an old bull at

Purcell: Yes, I do think it likely. Mr. Christian was not a man to
involve his friends in trouble, and he must have known that Mr. Byam
would remain loyal to his commander.

The Court: Where was Byam just before the launch was veered astern?

Purcell: I do not know. I had seen him upon deck a few moments before,
and he had told me of his intention to go with Captain Bligh. I think he
must have gone to the midshipmen's berth for his clothes.

The Court: Did you see Morrison at this time?

Purcell: No.

The Court: Do you think it possible that the prisoners, Byam and
Morrison, may have feared to go into the boat and that they went below to
avoid the necessity of leaving the ship?

Purcell: No, I do not. They must have been prevented from coming. They
were not cowards as both Mr. Hayward and Mr. Hallet were...

Lord Hood interrupted, sternly admonishing the carpenter to reply only to
the questions asked of him.

The Court: Putting every circumstance together, declare to this Court,
upon the oath you have taken, how you considered Mr. Byam's behaviour,
whether as a person joined in the mutiny or as a person wishing well to
Captain Bligh.

Purcell: I by no means considered him as a person concerned in the

The Court: Did you consider Morrison as a mutineer?

Purcell: I did not.

A pause followed. Lord Hood said: "The prisoners may now question the

Myself: How deep in the water was the launch when the last of the people
went into her?

Purcell: We had seven and one-half inches of freeboard, amidships.

Myself: Do you think others might have come into her without endangering
the safety of all?

Purcell: Not one more could have entered her. Captain Bligh himself
begged that no more should be sent off. When we lost Norton, the
quartermaster, who was killed by the savages at Tofoa, for all our regret
at the poor fellow's death we were glad to have the boat lightened of his
weight. It gave the rest of us so much more chance of life.

The following morning, Friday, September 14, Thomas Hayward gave his
evidence. We had awaited this most eagerly. Hayward was the mate of
Christian's watch and on deck at the time the mutiny started. I, in
particular, was curious to know whether his story would corroborate the
account given me by Christian on the day he had called me into his cabin.
Hayward made no mention whatever of having been asleep on watch at the
time the ship was seized. He said that he was standing aft at that
moment, looking over the side at a shark, and that Christian had told him
to oversee the vessel while he went below to lash his hammock.

"A moment later," he went on, "to my unutterable surprise, I saw
Christian, Charles Churchill, Thomas Burkitt, one of the prisoners, John
Sumner, Matthew Quintal, William McCoy, Isaac Martin, Henry Hillbrandt,
and Alexander Smith coming aft, armed with muskets and bayonets. On my
going forward to prevent their proceedings, I asked Christian the cause
for such an act, and he told me to hold my tongue, instantly. Martin was
left as a sentinel on deck, and the rest of the party proceeded to Mr.
Bligh's cabin.

"I heard the cry of 'Murder!' from Mr. Bligh, and heard Christian call
for a rope. John Mills, contrary to all orders, cut the deep-sea line and
carried a piece of it to them. Thomas Ellison, who was at the helm,
quitted it and armed himself with a bayonet. The ship's decks now began
to be thronged with men. I saw George Stewart, James Morrison, one of the
prisoners, and Roger Byam, another of the prisoners, standing by the

"As soon as the launch was out, John Samuel, the captain's clerk, John
Hallet, midshipman, and myself were ordered into her. We requested time
sufficient to collect a few clothes, which was granted. About this time I
spoke to either Stewart or Byam, I cannot be positive which, but I think
it was Byam. I told him to go into the boat, but in my hurry I cannot
remember to have received an answer. When I came upon deck again I saw
Ellison standing as one of the sentries over Captain Bligh. We were then
forced into the boat. I remember hearing Robert Tinkler, who was not yet
in the launch, call out, 'Byam, for God's sake, hasten!' A moment later
Tinkler himself came into the launch. He was among the last to enter.
When we were towing astern of the ship, I saw the prisoners, Byam and
Morrison, standing at the taffrail among the other mutineers. They seemed
well content to be there. I remember hearing Burkitt use very abusive
language, and I distinctly heard Millward jeering at Captain Bligh. This
is all that I know of the mutiny in His Majesty's ship _Bounty_."

The Court asked: "You say that Burkitt used very abusive language while
the launch lay astern. To whom did it seem to be addressed?"

Hayward: To the boat's people generally, I should say.

The Court: Can you recall what Millward said when he jeered at Captain

Hayward: Yes, precisely. He said, "You bloody villain! See if you can
live on half a pound of yams a day."

The Court: What number of armed men did you perceive on the _Bounty_
on the morning of the mutiny?

Hayward: Eighteen.

The Court: Did you hear any of the conversation that passed between
Christian and Byam with respect to having the launch in the place of the

Hayward: No.

The Court: Were you on deck during the middle watch on the night before
the mutiny?

Hayward: No.

The Court: Do you know at what time the prisoner, Byam, came down to the
berth on that night?

Hayward: Yes. I chanced to be awake at that time and I heard the ship's
bell strike half-past one.

The Court: How do you know that it was Byam who came in?

Hayward: His hammock was next to mine on the larboard side of the berth.

The Court: Relate everything you remember with respect to Morrison.

Hayward: I remember seeing Morrison assisting to clear the yams and other
supplies out of the launch before she was hoisted out, but I am doubtful
whether he was at first under arms or not.

The Court: Do you mean by this that he was later under arms?

Hayward: I believe that he was, but I cannot say positively.

The Court: Did he appear to you, by his conduct, to be assisting the
mutineers, or was he merely obeying the orders that were given to get the
boat out?

Hayward: If I were to give it as my opinion, I should say that he was
assisting the mutineers. He perhaps might wish to get the boat out to get
quit of us as soon as possible.

The Court: Relate all you know of Ellison.

Hayward: Ellison was at the helm at the outbreak of the mutiny. Soon
after the people had gone below to secure Captain Bligh, quitted the helm
and armed himself with a bayonet. Before going into the boat I saw him as
a sentinel over Captain Bligh, and I remember him saying, "Damn him, I
will be sentinel over him!"

The Court: Relate all you remember of Muspratt.

Hayward: I remember seeing Muspratt on the larboard side of the waist
with a musket in his hand.

The Court: Relate all you remember of Burkitt.

Hayward: I saw Thomas Burkitt come aft, following Christian and Churchill
when they went to Captain Bligh's cabin, and I saw him descend the after
ladder with them. He was armed with a musket and a bayonet. After the
launch was astern I saw him at the taffrail, and heard him using very
abusive language to us in the boat.

The Court: Relate what you remember of Millward.

Hayward: I saw him armed as one of the sentinels, and after the boat was
veered astern, I saw him at the taffrail, where he jeered at Captain
Bligh, as I have said.

The Court: Have you any reason to believe that the prisoner, Byam, would
have been prevented from going in the boat at the time you did, had he
desired to do so?

Hayward: No.

The Court: Where was he at the time the launch was veered aft?

Hayward: I cannot say, but a moment later I saw him at the taffrail,
looking down at us with the other mutineers.

The Court: Did you hear him make any remarks at that time?

Hayward: I am doubtful whether I did or not.

The Court: You have given it as your opinion that Morrison was assisting
the mutineers so as to get Captain Bligh and his party out of the ship as
soon as possible. In the former part of your evidence you have said that
the prisoner, McIntosh, was also assisting to hoist the launch out, and
that you did not look upon him as a mutineer. What is the reason for your
thinking differently of them?

Hayward: The difference was in the countenances of the two. The
countenance of Morrison seemed to be rejoiced and that of McIntosh

Morrison then asked: "You say that you observed joy in my countenance,
and you have given it as your opinion that I was one of the mutineers.
Can you declare, before God and this Court, that such evidence is not the
result of a private pique?"

Hayward: No, it is not the result of a private pique. It is an opinion I
formed after quitting the ship, from the prisoners not coming with us
when they had as good an opportunity as the rest, there being more boats
than one.

Morrison: One of the boats, as you know, was badly eaten with worms. Are
you certain that we might have had the other?

Hayward: Not having been present at any conference among you, I cannot

Morrison: Can you deny that you were present when Captain Bligh begged
that the boat might not be overloaded; and can you deny that he said,
"I'll do you justice, lads"?

Hayward: I was present at the time Mr. Bligh made such a declaration, but
understood it as respecting the clothes and other heavy articles with
which the boat was already too full.

Ellison now put a question which brought into this grimly serious trial
the only touch of humour that attended it.

Ellison: You know that Captain Bligh used these words: "Don't let the
boat be overloaded, lads. I'll do you justice." And you say you think
this alluded to the clothes and other heavy articles in the launch. Do
you honestly think that the words, "I'll do you justice," alluded to the
clothes? Or did they allude to Coleman, McIntosh, Norman, Byrne, Mr.
Stewart, Mr. Byam, and Mr. Morrison, who would have gone in the launch if
there had been room?

Ellison scored a point here, for us, not for himself. Even the members of
the Court maintained with difficulty their expressions of dignified

Hayward: If Captain Bligh made use of the words, "My lads," it was to the
people already in the boat and not to those in the ship.

The Court: Your opinion, then, is that Captain Bligh was not alluding to
any of the people remaining in the ship?

Hayward, realizing that the Court itself considered his opinion
preposterous, then acknowledged that Bligh might have been referring to
those in the ship.

The malicious manner in which he had testified astonished me. This was
particularly true in his evidence concerning Morrison and me. He must
have known, in his heart, that we were as innocent as himself; yet he
lost no opportunity to throw what doubt he could upon the purity of our
intentions. Morrison he had never liked, and this ill-will was heartily
returned; but my relations with Hayward on the _Bounty_, although
never cordial, had not been unfriendly. I had the clearest recollection
of the events of the mutiny. Hayward had never once spoken to me on that
morning, and Stewart had told me that he had only seen Hayward at a
distance. And yet Hayward had testified that he had told one or the other
of us to go into the boat. The true facts were that he was so terrified
throughout the whole of this time as to be ignorant of what he did, or
said. It was my opinion at the time of the court-martial, and it is so
still, that he arranged his recollections of what had taken place so as
to put his own actions in the most favourable possible light. He was a
man easily dominated by others of stronger character, and I believe that
his long association with Captain Edwards, of the _Pandora_, who
considered all of us piratical scoundrels, had completely coloured
Hayward's own opinions.

John Hallet was called next. He was now in his twentieth year, and I
scarcely recognized the thin, frightened-looking boy I had known on the
_Bounty_ in the grown man who stood before us. He was dressed in a
handsome lieutenant's uniform--a long-tailed coat of bright blue, with
white cuffs and lapels and gold anchor buttons. He wore white silk
breeches and stockings, and his black pumps shone like mirrors. As he
entered the great cabin he removed his cocked hat and placed it under his
arm, halting to make a sweeping bow to the President as he did so. Upon
taking the stand he glanced at us with an air that said only too plainly:
"You see how I have risen in the world? And what are you? Pirates and

His story was the briefest of any of those yet given, but it was of grave
importance to Morrison and myself. He stated with conviction that when
the launch was about to leave the _Bounty_, he had seen Morrison at
the taffrail, armed with a musket. He also named Burkitt, Ellison, and
Millward as having been armed. His evidence with respect to myself came
when he was being questioned by various members of the Court.

The Court: Did you see Roger Byam on the morning of the mutiny?

Hallet: I remember to have seen him once.

The Court: What was he doing at that time?

Hallet: He was on the platform on the larboard side, upon deck, standing
still and looking attentively toward Captain Bligh.

The Court: Was he armed?

Hallet: I cannot say that he was.

The Court: Had you any conversation with him?

Hallet: No.

The Court: Do you know whether he was or was not prevented from coming
into the boat?

Hallet: I do not know that he ever offered to go into the boat.

The Court: Did you hear any person propose to him to go into the boat?

Hallet: No.

The Court: Do you know any other particulars respecting him on that day?

Hallet: While he was standing as I have before related, Captain Bligh
said something to him, but what, I did not hear; upon which Byam laughed,
and turned and walked away.

The Court: Relate all you know of the conduct of James Morrison on that

Hallet: When I first saw him he was unarmed; but he shortly afterward
'appeared under arms.

The Court: How was he armed?

Hallet: With a musket.

The Court: At what part of the ship was he when you saw him so armed?

Hallet: It was when the boat was veered astern. He was leaning over the
taffrail, calling out in a jeering manner, "If my friends inquire for me,
tell them I am somewhere in the South Sea."

The Court: Relate all you know respecting Thomas Ellison.

Hallet: He appeared early under arras, and came up to me and insolently
said, "Mr. Hallet, you need not mind this. We are only going to put the
Captain on shore, and then you and the others may return."

The Court: Describe to the Court the situation of Captain Bligh when the
prisoner, Byam, laughed and walked away, as you have described.

Hallet: He was standing with his arms bound, Christian holding the cord
in one hand, and a bayonet to his breast with the other.

Upon the advice of Mr. Graham, I refrained from questioning Hallet at
this time.

"This is the gravest accusation that has been made against you," he
whispered, "excepting only Bligh's. Do not examine Hallet upon it now. It
will be best to wait until the Court hears your defense. At that time you
will have the opportunity to recall any of the witnesses you choose."

Morrison asked: "You say that you saw me armed at the taffrail. Can you
declare, positively, before God and this Court, that it was I and no
other person whom you saw under arms?"

Hallet: I have declared it.

Morrison: You have sworn that I did jeeringly say, "Tell my friends, if
they inquire for me, that I am somewhere in the South Sea." To whom did I
address this sneering message?

Hallet: I did not remark that it was addressed to anyone in particular.

Morrison: Do you remember that I did, personally, assist you to haul one
of your chests up the main hatchway, and whether or not I was armed then?

Hallet: The circumstances concerning the chest I do not remember. I have
before said that I did not see you under arms till after the launch had
been veered astern.

The witness withdrew, and John Smith, who had been Captain Bligh's
servant, was called. He was the last witness, and the only one of the
_Bounty's_ seamen who gave evidence. In fact, there were only three
of the able seamen of the _Bounty's_ company, John Smith, Thomas
Hall, and Robert Lamb, who had not been of Christian's party; and of
these both Lamb and Hall were dead. Smith's evidence was not of
importance to any of us who were before the Court. He testified that, at
Christian's orders, he had served out rum to all those under arms; also
that he had gone to Captain Bligh's cabin to fetch up his clothes and
other articles which were put into the launch.

This concluded the evidence given by members of the _Bounty's_
company who went into the launch. Captain Edwards and the lieutenants of
the _Pandora_ were then called in turn, to testify as to the
_Pandora's_ sojourn at Tahiti when the fourteen prisoners were
taken. At the sight of Edwards and Parkin, I was conscious of the same
feeling of hot anger experienced how many times during the dreary months
when we were in their power. Nevertheless, I must do them the justice to
say that their evidence as to the proceedings at Tahiti was scrupulously
exact. Edwards told how I had come off to the ship when she was still
several miles out at sea, explaining who I was and giving him exact
information with respect to the other _Bounty_ men then on the
island. He also acknowledged that the other men had given themselves up
voluntarily. We should have liked to question him with respect to the
inhuman treatment we had received at his hands, but this did not concern
the mutiny, so we said nothing.

These were the last of the Crown witnesses, and the Court adjourned until
the following day, when we were to be heard in our own defense.


Being the only midshipman among the prisoners, I should, as a matter of
course, have been the first to be called for my defense; but when the
Court met on the Saturday morning, I requested, and was granted,
permission to defer presenting my case until Monday morning. Coleman,
whose acquittal was a foregone conclusion, was ready to be heard, and was
therefore called. His statement was brief, and, having given it, he
questioned Fryer, Cole, Peckover, Purcell, and others, all of whom
testified as to Coleman's innocence, and that he had been detained in the
_Bounty_ against his will. The Court then adjourned.

Nearly the whole of Sunday I spent with my advisor, Mr. Graham. Captain
Manly and Captain Bentham, advisors to the other prisoners, came with
him, and the three groups separated to various parts of the gun room so
as not to disturb one another.

I had already prepared, in writing, a rough copy of my defense. Mr.
Graham went over this with great care, pointing out various omissions and
making suggestions as to the arrangement of the matter. He instructed me
as to the witnesses I should call and examine, after my defense had been
read, and the questions I should ask each one. Hayward had testified that
he had been awake on the night before the mutiny and had heard me come
down to the berth at half-past one.

"This evidence is of importance to you, Mr. Byam," Mr. Graham said. "You
have told me that Tinkler went down with you at that time and that you
bade each other good-night?"

"Yes, sir."

"Then Hayward must have heard you speak. We must see to it that he
acknowledges this. If we can prove that Tinkler was with you it will bear
out your account of the conversation with Christian, which Tinkler
overheard. Hallet struck you a heavy blow in saying that you turned away
laughing after Captain Bligh had spoken to you."

"There was not a word of truth in the statement, sir," I said, hotly.

"I am sure there was not. In my opinion neither Hayward nor Hallet made a
favourable impression upon the Court. But their evidence cannot be
disregarded. Together, it is enough to condemn Morrison; his situation
now is much more grave than it was. Did you have an opportunity to
observe the actions of Hayward and Hallet on the morning of the mutiny?"

"Yes, I saw them a number of times."

"What can you say of them? Were they cool and self-possessed?"

"On the contrary, they were both frightened out of their wits the whole
time, and both were crying and begging for mercy when they were ordered
into the launch."

"It is extremely important that you should bring this out. When you
question the other _Bounty_ witnesses, you must examine each of them
upon this point. If they agree with you, that Hallet and Hayward were
much alarmed, it will throw doubt upon the reliability of their

It was late in the afternoon when Mr. Graham rose to go.

"I think we have covered everything, Mr. Byam," he said. "Do you
wish to read your defense, or would you prefer that I read it for you?"

"What do you think I should do, sir?"

"I advise you to read it, unless you think you may be too nervous." I
told him that I had no apprehensions on that score.

"Good!" he replied. "Your story will make a deeper impression if given in
your own voice. Read it clearly and slowly. You must have noticed that
several members of the Court seem to be all but convinced of your guilt?
It is apparent in the questions they have asked the witnesses."

"I have noticed it, sir."

"I suggest that, as you read, you keep these particular men in mind. If
you do this the manner of your reading will take care of itself. It is
unnecessary to remind you that you are fighting for your life. This is
certain to make your words sufficiently impressive."

By this time the advisors to the other prisoners had completed their
work, and they left the _Hector_ with Mr. Graham. No day, in all the
interminable months we had passed as prisoners, had slipped by so quickly
as this one.

On Monday morning, September 17, the solitary gun boomed from the
_Duke_, the signal for assembling the court-martial. We were
conveyed on board with the usual guard of marines, and arrived a good
half-hour before the opening of the Court. Although I had told Mr. Graham
that he need have no fears about my coolness, I felt anything but
self-possessed as the minutes slowly passed. As we were marched across
the quarter-deck, I caught a glimpse of Sir Joseph and Dr. Hamilton among
the crowd of officers and civilians waiting there. I dreaded that daily
ordeal of mounting the gangway of the _Duke_, and the march, two by
two, along the deck to the great cabin. We were objects of curiosity to
everyone, and many of the officers stared at us as though we were wild
animals. At least, so it seemed to me, but no doubt I was unusually
sensitive at that time, and imagined insolence and hostility on faces
which revealed nothing more than natural curiosity.

A few minutes before nine the spectators were all in their places, and on
the stroke of the hour the members of the Court filed in. All in the room
rose and remained standing until Lord Hood and the other officers had
taken their places.

A moment of silence followed; then the master-at-arms called: "Roger
Byam, stand forth!"

I rose and waited, facing Lord Hood.

"You have been accused, with others, of the mutinous and piratical
seizure of His Majesty's armed vessel, _Bounty_. You have heard the
Crown's witnesses. The Court is now ready to receive whatever you may
have to say in your own defense. Are you prepared?"

"Yes, sir."

"Raise your right hand."

I was then sworn, and I remember how my hand trembled as I held it up. I
looked toward Sir Joseph for comfort, but he sat with his hands clasped
around his knee, gazing straight before him. The Court waited for me to
proceed. For a moment, panic seized me. The eyes of everyone in the room
were turned toward me, and their faces became a blur before my own. Then,
as though it were someone else, a long distance away, I heard my own
voice speaking:--

"My lord, and gentlemen of this Honourable Court: The crime of mutiny,
for which I am now arraigned, is one of so grave a nature as to awake the
horror and indignation of all men, and he who stands accused of it must
appear an object of unpardonable guilt.

"In such a character it is my misfortune to appear before this Tribunal.
I realize that appearances are against me, but they are appearances only,
and I declare before God and the members of this Court that I am
innocent; that I have never been guilty, either in thought or in deed, of
the crime with which I am charged."

Once I was fairly started, I regained my self-control, and, bearing in
mind Mr. Graham's advice, I read on, slowly and deliberately. I explained
fully the conversation with Christian on the night before the mutiny,
showing that it had nothing to do with that event. I then told the story
of the ship's seizure as it concerned myself. I told of my conversation
with Mr. Purcell and Mr. Nelson, both of whom knew that I meant to leave
the ship. I told of going below, at the same time with Mr. Nelson, to
fetch my clothes, preparatory to going into the launch, and how, in the
midshipmen's berth, an opportunity seemed to present itself for seizing
the arms chest from Thompson. I told how Morrison and I, with Friendly
Island war clubs in our hands, waited for a chance to attack Thompson,
and how that chance was thwarted; and how Morrison and I then rushed upon
deck, only to find that we were too late to go with Captain Bligh.

"My lord and gentlemen," I concluded, "it is a heavy misfortune for me
that the three men are dead whose evidence would prove, beyond all doubt,
the truth of what I say. John Norton, the quartermaster, who knew of
Christian's intention to leave the _Bounty_ on the night before the
mutiny, and who prepared for him the small raft upon which Christian
meant to embark, is dead. Mr. Nelson died at Batavia; and Robert Tinkler,
who overheard all of my conversation with Christian, has been lost at sea
with the vessel upon which he was serving. Fortune, I realize, has been
against me. Lacking the evidence of these three men, I can only say, I
entreat you to believe me! My good name is as precious to me as life
itself, and I beg of you, my lord and gentlemen, to consider the
situation in which I am placed; to remember that I lack those witnesses
whose evidence would, I am certain, convince you of the truth of every
statement I have made.

"To the mercy of this Honourable Court I now commit myself."

It was impossible to guess how my words had impressed the Court. Lord
Hood sat with his chin propped upon one hand, listening with grave
attention. I glanced hastily at the others. Two or three of them were
making memoranda of points in my story. One captain, with a long
cadaverous face, sat with eyes lowered, and one might have thought him
asleep. I had observed him before. He had maintained the same position
throughout the hearing, and the same air of apparent inattention; but he
was among the keenest of the questioners. No point that might throw light
upon the events of the mutiny, or the trustworthiness of the witnesses,
escaped him. He addressed his questions without lifting his eyes, as
though he had the witness pinned down to the table between his elbows.

Another of the captains whom I feared most sat on Lord Hood's left, the
farthest from him on that side, and the nearest to the stand for the
witnesses. Hour after hour he sat as rigid as though he were made of
bronze. Once he had taken his seat at the table, only his eyes were
permitted freedom of movement; his glances were keen and swift, like the
thrust of a rapier. When I had finished, the eyes of this latter captain
were directed upon me for a moment, and, brief as the glance had been, it
chilled me to the heart. I again recalled what Dr. Hamilton had said at
the time of our first conversation on the _Pandora_: "There is not
one of those captains who will not say to himself, 'This is such a tale
as one would expect an intelligent midshipman, eager to save his life, to

It seemed to me, judging by the faces of the men before me, that, with
the exception of Captain Montague, each of them was thinking those very
words. I felt utterly weary, physically and spiritually. Then I saw Sir
Joseph looking straight at me in his kindly, heartening manner, as much
as to say: "Well done, my lad! Never say die!" His glance gave me new
reserves of strength and courage.

"My lord," I said, "may I now call what witnesses are available to me?"

Lord Hood nodded. The master-at-arms went to the door and called, "John
Fryer! This way!"

The _Bounty's_ master took the stand, was again sworn, and awaited
my questions.

Myself: What watch had I on the day of the mutiny?

Fryer: He was in my watch, the first watch of the preceding evening.

Myself: Had you stayed in the ship, in the expectation of retaking her,
was my conduct, from the time when you first knew me to this, in which
you are to answer the question, such that you would have entrusted me
with your design, and do you believe that I would have favoured it? (I
had been instructed by Mr. Graham to ask this question again.)

Fryer: I should not have hesitated in opening my design to him, and I am
sure that he would have favoured it.

Myself: Did you consider those people who assisted in hoisting out the
launch as helping Captain Bligh or the mutineers?

Fryer: Those without arms, as assisting Captain Bligh.

Myself: How many men, including Captain Bligh, went into the launch?

Fryer: Nineteen.

Myself: What height from the water was the gunwale of the launch when she
put off from the ship?

Fryer: Not more than eight inches, to the best of my knowledge and

Myself: Would the launch have carried more people?

Fryer: Not one more, in my opinion, without endangering the lives of all
who were in her.

Myself: Did you, at any time during the mutiny, see me armed?

Fryer: No.

Myself: Did Captain Bligh speak to me at any time on the morning of the

Fryer: Not to my knowledge.

Myself: Did you observe, on that morning, that I was guilty at any time
of levity of conduct?

Fryer: I did not.

Myself: Did you see Mr. Hayward on deck during the time of the mutiny?

Fryer: Yes; several times.

Myself: In what state was he? Did he appear to be composed, or was he
agitated and alarmed?

Fryer: He was greatly agitated and alarmed, and crying when he was forced
into the boat.

Myself: Did you see Mr. Hallet on that morning?

Fryer: Yes; upon several occasions.

Myself: In what state did he appear to be?

Fryer: He was greatly frightened and crying when he went into the boat.

Myself: What was my general character on the _Bounty_?

Fryer: Excellent. To the best of my recollection he was held in high
esteem by everyone.

The Court asked: "After the launch had left the ship, and during the
voyage to Timor, was the subject of the mutiny often discussed among

Fryer: No, not often. Our sufferings were so great, and the efforts
necessary for the preservation of our lives so constant, that we had
little time or inclination to speak of the mutiny.

The Court: Did you, during that voyage, or at any time thereafter, hear
Captain Bligh refer to a conversation he had overheard between Christian
and the prisoner, Byam, which took place in the middle watch on the night
before the mutiny?

Fryer: I did not.

The Court: Did you, at any time, hear him refer to the prisoner, Byam?

Fryer: Yes; upon more than one occasion.

The Court: Can you recall what he said?

Fryer: On the day of the mutiny, after the launch had been cast off and
we were rowing toward the island of Tofoa, I heard Mr. Bligh say,
referring to Mr. Byam, "He is an ungrateful scoundrel, the worst of them
all except Christian." He later repeated this opinion several times, in
much the same words.

The Court: Did anyone in the boat speak in Byam's defense?

Fryer: Yes, I did, as well as various others. But Captain Bligh bade us
hold our tongues. He would allow nothing to be said in Mr. Byam's favour.

The Court: Did you at any time hear Robert Tinkler refer to a
conversation between Christian and Byam which took place in the middle
watch on the night before the mutiny?

Fryer: I cannot recall that I did.

The Court: Did Robert Tinkler ever speak in defense of Byam?

Fryer: Yes. He never believed him implicated in the mutiny. On the
occasion I have mentioned, when Captain Bligh first accused Mr. Byam,
Tinkler, forgetting himself, said, warmly: "He is not one of the
mutineers, sir. I would stake my life upon it!" Captain Bligh silenced
him instantly.

The Court: Robert Tinkler was your brother-in-law, was he not?

Fryer: He was.

The Court: He has been lost at sea?

Fryer: He has been reported lost with his ship, the _Carib Maid_,
among or near the West Indies.

The Court: Were your relations with Captain Bligh cordial or the reverse?

Fryer: They were far from cordial.

Cole, the boatswain, was summoned next, and was followed by Mr. Purcell.
I put to each of them the same questions I had asked of the master, and
they replied to them as he had done. The questions asked by the members
of the Court were much the same, and both men were examined particularly
as to whether either Bligh or Tinkler had ever referred to my
conversation with Christian, upon which the fact of my guilt or innocence
so strongly depended. Neither of them could remember having heard any
reference made to this conversation. I had strongly hoped that Mr.
Peckover, the gunner, and officer of the middle watch, might have
overheard something of this conversation, but he could say only what
further incriminated me, that he had seen Christian and me in
conversation on the quarter-deck during that watch.

The Court asked: "At what time did you observe Christian and the
prisoner, Byam, in conversation?"

Peckover: It might have been at about one o'clock.

The Court: Was it the prisoner's, Byam's, custom to remain on deck at
night after the end of his watch?

Peckover: I cannot say that it was.

The Court: Was it Mr. Christian's habit to be much on deck at night, when
not on duty?

Peckover: No, not as a general thing, but it was not unusual for him to
come up at night to observe the state of the weather.

The Court: What, in your opinion, was their reason for remaining so long
on the deck on this particular night?

Peckover: I suppose they wished to enjoy the coolness of the upper deck.

The Court: When Captain Bligh came on deck, during your watch, what did
he do?

Peckover: He paced up and down for a few moments.

The Court: Did Christian and the prisoner, Byam, perceive him?

Peckover: I cannot say. The moon had set before that time and it was dark
upon deck.

The Court: Did Captain Bligh speak with Christian and Byam?

Peckover: I believe he did, but I did not hear what he said.

The Court: At what time did Byam go below to the berth?

Peckover: It may have been about half-past one.

The Court: Did Christian go below at that time?

Peckover: I cannot be certain. I believe he remained on deck.

The Court: Did you, at any time during your watch on that night, see John
Norton, one of the quartermasters?

It was Sir George Montague, captain of the _Hector_, who put this
question. I do not know why it had not occurred to me to ask it, or how
Mr. Graham could have failed to suggest it to me. The reason may have
been that Norton, being dead, seemed as out of the matter as Mr. Nelson
himself, or any of the others who had died. Immediately Captain Montague
had spoken I realized how important the question was.

Peckover: Yes; I saw Norton at about two o'clock.

The Court: Upon what occasion?

Peckover: I had heard the sound of hammering by the windlass, and myself
went forward to see what the cause of it was. I found Norton at work upon
something, and asked him what he was about at that hour of the night. He
told me that he was repairing a hencoop for some fowls we had bought of
the savages at Namuka.

The Court: Did you see at what work he was engaged?

Peckover: No, not clearly. It was quite dark, but I made no doubt that he
was engaged as he said.

The Court: Did you have any further conversation with him?

Peckover: I told him to leave off; that there was time enough for making
hencoops in the daytime.

The Court: Was not such work the business of the carpenters of the

Peckover: Yes; but it was not uncommon for Norton to assist them when
there was much carpenter's work to be done.

The Court: Had you ever known Norton to be so employed at night before?

Peckover: Never before, that I can remember.

The Court: Do you think it might have been a small raft upon which the
quartermaster was working?

Peckover: Yes, it might have been. As I have said, it was dark and I took
no particular notice of what the object was.

The Court, particularly in the person of Captain Montague, questioned the
gunner carefully on this matter, but Peckover could not remember that he
had seen Christian and Norton in conversation during that evening.
Nevertheless, here was a ray of hope for me--a bit of evidence, and the
only one, to bear out my story that Christian had intended to desert the
ship during that night, and that he had taken Norton into his confidence.

Hayward followed on the witness stand, but for all my questioning he
would not acknowledge that Tinkler had come down to the berth with me on
the night before the mutiny. And yet he must have heard us bid each other
good-night. At that time we were standing within two paces of his
hammock, and he had said that he heard me come in. Hallet clung to his
story that I had laughed and turned away when, as he said, Captain Bligh
spoke to me. But I could see that his sullen, insolent manner of clinging
to it had made an unfavourable impression upon the Court.

My case rested here, and Morrison was next called for his defense. He was
cool and self-possessed. His story was perfectly clear, well presented,
and, I thought, wholly convincing. He confirmed my story as to the reason
we had been below at the time the launch was veered astern. Of the
witnesses he called, Fryer, Cole, Purcell, and Peckover bore out all that
he said, with the exception of his reason for not being on deck in time
to go with the launch; for of this matter, of course, they could know
nothing. Hallet and Hayward were the only witnesses who had testified to
having seen him under arms, and he forced both of them to admit that they
might have been mistaken.

The Court adjourned for lunch. At one o'clock it reassembled, and Norman,
McIntosh, and Byrne were quickly heard. Their innocence had already been
clearly established and, advisedly, they had made their pleas brief.

Burkitt, Millward, and Muspratt came next. The guilt of the first two was
so evident that little could be said in extenuation of it. Both men had
been willing mutineers from the beginning.

Ellison was the last to be heard. He had written his own defense, and
Captain Bentham let it stand as it was, believing that the naive boyish
way in which Ellison had explained his actions would make the only appeal
for clemency the poor lad could hope for. I well remember the conclusion
of his plea: "I hope, honourable gentlemen, you'll be so kind as to take
my case under consideration, as I was only a boy at the time, and I leave
myself to the clemency and mercy of this Honourable Court."

By this time it was nearly 4 P.M. The Court adjourned, and we were taken
back to the _Hector_ to await its verdict.


Tuesday, the eighteenth of September, 1792, was a typically English
autumn day, with a grey sea and a grey sky. It had rained during the
early morning, but by the time the gun was fired from the _Duke_,
assembling the court-martial, the downpour had changed to a light drizzle
through which the many ships of war at anchor could be seen dimly. At
length the sky lightened perceptibly, and the sun shone wanly through.
The _Duke's_ quarter-deck was thronged with people awaiting the
opening of the Court. Sir Joseph and Dr. Hamilton were there. On the
other side of the deck were the _Bounty_ witnesses and the officers
of the _Pandora_.

Throughout the court-martial no relatives or friends of the prisoners had
been permitted to attend the hearings. Even had such permission been
granted, now that my mother was dead, I had no relatives who might have
come. This was a consolation to me. Whatever my fate, it was good to be
certain that none of my kin was waiting that morning for the verdict that
would either clear me or condemn me to death.

But as my glance went over the crowd my pulse quickened at seeing Mr.
Erskine, my father's solicitor and the old friend of both of my parents.
He was then well into his seventies. He had stopped with us at Withycombe
many a time, and the great treats of my life, as a youngster, had been my
rare visits to London with my father, when I had seen much of Mr.
Erskine. He had often taken me to view the sights of London, and his
kindnesses upon these occasions made them among the happiest of my
boyhood recollections. For the first time since the beginning of the
court-martial I was deeply stirred, and I could see that Mr. Erskine
controlled his own emotion with difficulty. His association with my
parents and Withycombe was so close that he seemed like a near and deeply
loved relative.

Presently the door of the great cabin was opened and the spectators filed
in to their places. The prisoners followed, and we stood waiting while
the members of the Court took their seats. The master-at-arms called,
"Roger Byam!"

I stood in my place.

The President asked, "Have you anything further to say in your defense?"

"No, my lord."

The same question was put to each of us. The spectators were then asked
to leave the room, the prisoners were marched out, and the door of the
great cabin closed behind us. We were taken into the waist, by the
foremast. The spectators stood in groups about the quarter-deck, or
walked up and down, talking together. We could hear nothing they said;
indeed, a silence seemed to have fallen over the ship. There were seamen
going about routine duties, but they performed them in a subdued,
soundless manner as though they were officiating at church.

Mr. Graham had visited me on the previous evening. He had told me how I
might know, the moment I entered the room to learn my fate, what that
fate was to be. A midshipman's dirk would be lying on the table before
the President. If the dirk were placed at right angles to me, I should
know that I had been acquitted. If it lay with the point toward the foot
of the table where I was to stand, I should know that I had been

I felt strangely indifferent as to which it might be. Presently I fell
into a kind of stupor, a waking dream, in which blurred images passed
over the surface of consciousness, stirring it but little more than the
ghost of a breeze disturbs the surface of a calm sea.

It must have been at about half-past nine that the Court had been
cleared. When I roused myself from my reverie, an immeasurable period of
time seemed to have elapsed; and indeed, the sun had passed the meridian.
I heard the ship's bells strike one o'clock. The clouds had vanished, the
sky was pale blue, and the sunlight had that golden quality which
beautifies whatever it touches, giving a kind of splendour to familiar,
common objects. The _Duke's_ great guns looked magical in that
light, and the throng on the quarter-deck, in their varicoloured
uniforms, with sudden gleams of light flashing from epaulettes or sword
hilts, seemed like figures out of some romantic tale rather than officers
of His Majesty's Navy.

The door of the great cabin reopened at last. The master-at-arms
appeared, announcing that audience was admitted; then I heard my name
called. The sound of the syllables seemed strange to me; it was as though
I had never heard them before.

I was accompanied by a lieutenant with a drawn sword and a guard of four
men with muskets and bayonets fixed. I found myself standing at the end
of the long table, facing the President. The midshipman's dirk was lying
on the table before him. Its point was toward me.

The entire Court rose. Lord Hood regarded me in silence for a moment.

"Roger Byam: having heard the evidence produced in support of the charges
made against you; and having heard what you have alleged in your own
defense; and having maturely and deliberately weighed the whole of the
evidence, this Court is of the opinion that the charges have been proved
against you. It doth, therefore, judge that you shall suffer death by
being hanged by the neck on board such of His Majesty's ships of war, and
at such a time and such a place as the Commissioners for executing the
office of Lord High Admiral of Great Britain and Ireland, or any three of
them for the time being, shall, in writing, under their hands, direct."

I waited, expecting to hear more, knowing at the same time that there was
nothing more to be said. Then a voice--whose, I do not know--said, "The
prisoner may retire." I turned about and was marched out of the great
cabin, back to where the others were waiting.

I felt little emotion; only a sense of relief that the long ordeal was
over. A true conception of all the horror and ignominy of this end was to
come later. At the time sentence was pronounced I was merely stunned and
dazed by the finality of it. Evidently the expression on my face told the
others nothing, for Morrison asked, "What is it, Byam?"

"I'm to be hung," I said, and I shall never forget the look of horror on
Morrison's face. He had no time to reply, for he was called next. We
watched as the door of the cabin closed behind him. Coleman, Norman,
McIntosh, and Byrne stood in a group, waiting their turns, and I remember
how the others drew closer to me, as though for mutual protection and
comfort. Ellison touched my arm and smiled, without speaking. Burkitt
stood clasping and unclasping his huge hairy hands.

The door opened again and Morrison was marched back to us. His face was
pale, but he had himself well under control. He turned to me with a
bitter smile. "We must enjoy life while we can, Byam." A moment later he
added, "I wish to God _my_ mother were dead."

I felt a welcome surge of anger. Morrison had, unquestionably, been
convicted upon the evidence of two men, Hayward and Hallet. They alone of
the witnesses had testified to having seen him under arms. Having heard
the evidence of the other witnesses, I had never for a moment doubted
that Morrison's name would be cleared; nor, I think, had he himself
doubted. I could find nothing to say to comfort him.

Coleman followed. When he came out of the courtroom again, the guard
stood to one side and Coleman walked, a free man, to one side of the
quarter-deck. Norman, McIntosh, and Byrne were escorted in in turn, and
as they came out the guard stood aside in each case, and they joined
Coleman. Byrne was sobbing with joy and relief. The poor chap was almost
blind, and groped his way to the others, his hands outstretched and the
tears streaming down his face. Although their acquittal had been all but
certain, now that they were actually at liberty their dazed manner and
their bewilderment as to what to do with themselves would have touched
any man's heart.

Burkitt, Ellison, Millward, and Muspratt were called in quick succession.
All were found guilty and condemned to death. Immediately after sentence
had been pronounced upon Muspratt, the spectators came out into the
sunshine of the quarter-deck. We expected to see the members of the Court
follow, but when the room had been cleared the door was closed again.
Something, evidently, was to follow. The strain of waiting during the
next half-hour was hardly to be borne.

Audience was again admitted, and the master-at-arms appeared at the door.

"James Morrison!"

Again Morrison was marched in. When he returned, he came as near to
giving way to his emotion as I had ever seen him do. He had been
recommended to His Majesty's mercy. This meant, almost certainly, that
the recommendation of the Court would be followed and Morrison pardoned.
A moment later Lord Hood came out, followed by the captains who had sat
with him. The court-martial was at an end.

Muspratt looked at me in such a desolate manner that my heart went out to
him. I put my hand on his shoulder, but there was nothing to be said. In
the silence of the ship, I could hear the faint hum of conversation from
the quarter-deck. I saw Sir Joseph, Mr. Erskine, and Dr. Hamilton
standing together by the larboard bulwarks. They were not permitted to
come to us at that time, a circumstance for which I was deeply grateful.

Mercifully, we were not compelled to wait long on the _Duke_. The
guard was drawn up; we were escorted to the gangway and clambered down
the side into the longboat waiting to convey us back to the
_Hector_. Another boat was lying alongside. There were no marines in
her--only six seamen at the oars. Directly we had pushed off, we saw the
freed men descending the side to be taken ashore. We had no opportunity
to bid them good-bye and Godspeed, and when their boat put off from the
side of the _Duke_, ours had almost reached the _Hector_.
Ellison stood and waved his hat, and they waved back as they passed
around the _Duke_ and turned toward the shore. A moment later they
were cut off from view. I never saw any man of them again.

During the whole time of our confinement on board the _Hector_ we
had been treated with great kindness by Captain Montague. We were, of
course, carefully guarded, with marines stationed in the gun room as well
as outside the door, but aside from that there had been little to remind
us of the fact that we were prisoners. Now that we had been condemned and
were awaiting execution of sentence, Captain Montague did all he could to
make our situation endurable. He granted me the privilege of being
confined in a cabin belonging to one of his lieutenants who was absent on
leave. After eighteen months of imprisonment, during which time I had had
not a moment of privacy, I was able to appreciate this courtesy at its
full value. Twice daily I was permitted to go to the gun room for the
purpose of exercise and to see the others.

Sir Joseph Banks, the most considerate of men, did not come to see me
until the second day after we had been condemned, so that when he did
come, late in the afternoon, I was prepared to meet him. I was then most
eager to see him, and when I opened the door of my cabin to find him
standing there, my heart leaped with pleasure.

He gripped my hand in both of his, then turned to take a bulky parcel
from the seaman who had brought him to the cabin.

"Sit down, Byam," he said. He laid the parcel on the small table and
proceeded to remove the wrappings.

"I've brought you an old companion and friend. Do you recognize it?" he
added, as he laid aside the last of the wrappings. It was the manuscript
of my Tahitian dictionary and grammar.

"Allow me to say this," he went on. "I have gone over your manuscripts
with great interest, and I know enough of the Tahitian language to
appreciate the quality of the work you've done. It is excellent, Byam;
precisely what is needed. This book, when it is published, will be of
great value, not only practically but philosophically. Now tell me this:
how much time would you require to put it into final shape, ready for the

"Do you mean that I may work on it here?"

"Would you care to do so?"

I was in need, heaven knows, of something to occupy my mind. Sir Joseph's
thoughtfulness touched me deeply.

"Nothing would please me more, sir," I replied. "I am under no illusions
as to the importance of this work..."

"But it is important, my dear fellow," he interrupted. "Make no mistake
about that. I've brought your manuscripts not merely out of consideration
for you. This task must be completed. The Royal Society is greatly
interested, and it has been suggested to me that an introductory essay
accompany the volume, in which the Tahitian language shall be discussed
generally, and its points of difference to any of our European tongues
pointed out. Such an essay is quite beyond me. I had only a superficial
knowledge of the Tahitian speech, acquired during my sojourn on the
island with Captain Cook, and I have forgotten most of what I learned at
that time. Only you can write this essay."

"I shall be glad to attempt it," I replied, "if there is sufficient

"Could you complete it in a month?"

"I think so."

"Then a clear month you shall have. I have enough influence at the
Admiralty to be able to promise you that."

"I shall make the most of it, sir."

"Do you prefer not to talk of the events of the...of the past week?" he
asked, after a brief silence.

"It doesn't matter, sir. If there is something you wish to say..."

"Only this, Byam. It is needless to tell you what my feelings are. There
has never been a more tragic miscarriage of justice in the history of His
Majesty's Navy. I know how embittered you must be. You understand why.
you have been condemned?"

"I believe I do, sir."

"There was no alternative, Byam. None. All the palliating
circumstances--the fact that no man had seen you under arms, the
testimony as to the excellent character you bore, and all the rest--mere
not sufficient to offset Bligh's damning statement as to your complicity
with Christian in planning the mutiny. That statement stood unchallenged,
except by yourself, throughout the court-martial. Only your friend
Tinkler could have challenged and disproved it. Lacking his evidence..."

"I understand, sir," I replied. "Let us say no more about it. What seems
to me not only a tragic but a needless miscarriage of justice applies to
poor Muspratt. There is no more loyal-hearted seaman afloat than
Muspratt, and he is to be hung solely upon the evidence of one
man--Hayward. Muspratt's testimony as to why he took arms is strictly
true. It was for the purpose of helping Fryer in case he was able to form
a party for retaking the ship. The instant he saw that the party could
not be formed, he put down the musket."

"I agree with you, and you will be glad to know that there is still hope
for Muspratt. Say nothing, of course, to the poor fellow about this, but
I have it upon good authority that he may yet be reprieved."

That same afternoon, when I saw Muspratt in the gun room, I was tempted,
for the first time in my life, to betray a matter entrusted to me in
confidence. It would be impossible to say how badly I wanted to give
Muspratt a glimmer of hope, the merest hint of what might happen in his
case. I refrained, however.

Those September days were as beautiful as any that I remember. A
transparent film of vapour hung high in the air, diffusing the light of
the sun, so that the very atmosphere seemed to be composed of a golden
dust transforming every object it fell upon. So it was, day after day,
without change. The _Hector_ was moored, bow and stern, and the view
from my cabin was always the same, but I never tired of it. I had a
prospect of the harbour looking toward the Channel and the Isle of Wight,
with a great first-rate and three seventy-fours anchored not far distant.
I saw boats passing back and forth, their oars dipped in gold, and the
men in them seemed transfigured in the pale light. Knowing how brief a
time remained to me, I found nothing unworthy of interest and attention.
Even the common objects in my small cabin,--the locker, the table, and
the inkwell before me,--seen in various lights at different hours of the
day, I found beautiful and wondered that I had failed to notice such
things before.

I was not wholly wretched at this time. A man who knows that he is to
die, that his fate is fixed and irrevocable, seems to be endowed, as a
recompense, with the faculty of benumbed acquiescence. The thing is
there, slowly or swiftly approaching, but for the most part he is
mercifully spared the full realization that it must and will come. There
are moments, however, when he is not spared. Now and then, particularly
at night, I would be gripped by a sense of horror that struck me to the
heart. I would feel the rope about my throat, and see the faces of the
brawny seamen who were waiting the order to hoist me to the yardarm; and
I would hear the last words that would ever strike my ear: "And may God
have mercy upon you." At such times I would pray silently for the courage
to meet that moment when it should come.

Of the other condemned men, Ellison best endured the cruel waiting. He
had lost his old gaiety of manner, but it was replaced by a quiet courage
to face the facts that was beyond praise. Burkitt became more and more
like a wild beast at bay. Every time that I was taken to the gun room for
exercise I would find him pacing up and down, turning his head from side
to side with the same expression of dazed incredulity on his face. He had
the mighty chest of a Viking and his limbs would have made those of three
ordinary men. He had never known an ache or a pain in his life save those
inflicted by some boatswain's mate with a cat-o'-nine-tails. To men with
such a power of life in them, death has no reality until it is at hand.
Even now, I could see that Burkitt had not entirely given up hope. There
was always the possibility of escape. He was narrowly watched by the
guards; the eyes of one or another of them were upon him constantly.

Millward and Muspratt were sunk in moods of hopeless apathy, and rarely
spoke to anyone. No one knew on what day the execution would be carried
out. Not even the captain of the _Hector_ would know until the
Admiralty order had been received. Meanwhile, Morrison was kept in a
state of what would have been, for me, the most harrowing anxiety.
Although recommended to the King's clemency, there was always the
possibility that mercy would be refused. The days passed and no pardon
came, but Morrison was his usual calm self, and he discussed my work on
the dictionary as though he had no other interest in the world. Had he
been condemned to die with the rest of us, Morrison would have awaited
the ordeal with the same fortitude.

Mr. Graham came to bid me farewell before leaving Portsmouth. He told me,
as Sir Joseph had done, that the Court had no alternative in imposing
sentence upon me; and, although he did not say so directly, he gave me to
understand that I could not hope for a reprieve. The following afternoon
Mr. Erskine came, remaining until dusk, during which time I settled my
affairs and made my will. My only living relative was a cousin on my
mother's side, a lad of fifteen who lived in India with his father. It
was strange to think that our old home at Withycombe and the rest of our
family fortune would go to this boy whom I had never seen.

I shall not venture to say how I would have passed those days without
work to engross my thoughts. Once again my dictionary proved to be the
greatest of blessings, and it was not long before I was able to give it
the whole of my attention. Every one of those manuscript pages was
fragrant with Tahiti and memories of Tehani and our little Helen. Some of
them the baby had torn or finger-marked, and I could plainly hear her
mother's voice as she took them quickly from her, scolding her lovingly:
"Oh, you little mischief! Is this the way you help your father?"

Scarcely a word but brought memories thronging back. "Tafano"--I well
remembered the circumstances which added that to my lexicon. The sweet
poignant odour of the flower seemed to rise from the page where I had
written it, and I lived again the happy day that Stewart and Peggy and
Tehani and I had spent on the little island in the Tautira lagoon.

I worked all day long, and every day, and by the middle of October my
task was completed, in so far as the dictionary and grammar were
concerned. I proceeded at once to write the introductory essay, for I
knew that the time remaining to me must be short.

The strain of waiting was telling upon all of us. Although he failed to
show it, Morrison must have found it hardest to bear. To me, it seemed
the refinement of cruelty to keep him so long in doubt as to his fate. A
month had passed, and still he received no word.

I had received several letters from Sir Joseph, but there was no mention
of Admiralty news; nor did I expect any. He himself would not know the
day set for the execution.

On the twenty-fifth of October, I was revising, for the fourth or fifth
time, the introductory essay for my dictionary, when there came a knock
at the door. Every summons of this sort brought a cold sweat to my
forehead, but this one was immediately followed by a well-remembered
voice: "Are you there, Byam?" and I opened the door to Dr. Hamilton.

I had not seen him since the closing day of the court-martial. He
informed me that he had just been appointed surgeon to the
_Spitfire_, then stationed at Portsmouth. It was one of the ships I
could see from my cabin window. She was on the eve of sailing for the
Newfoundland station, and the doctor had come to bid me good-bye.

We talked of the _Pandora_, the shipwreck, the voyage to Timor, and
of those two monsters of inhumanity, Edwards and Parkin. Dr. Hamilton was
no longer under the necessity of concealing his feelings concerning
either of these men. Parkin he loathed, of course, but his opinion of
Edwards was, naturally, more fair and just than my own.

"I quite understand your feeling toward him, Byam," he said; "but the
truth is that Edwards is not the beast you think him."

"Have you forgotten the morning of the wreck, Doctor, when we were
chained hand and foot until the very moment when the ship went down?" I
asked. "That our lives were saved was due entirely to the humanity of
Moulter, the boatswain's mate. And have you forgotten how later, when we
were on the sand-bar, Edwards refused to give us a sail that was not in
use, so that we might protect our naked bodies from the sun?"

"I agree with you there; that _was_ cruelty of the monstrous sort;
no excuse whatever can be made for it. But otherwise, Byam...Well, you
must remember the character of the man. He has a high sense of what he
considers his duty, but not a grain of imagination--nothing remotely
resembling what might be called uncommon sense. You will remember my
telling you of his Admiralty instructions? He was ordered to confine his
prisoners in such a manner as to preclude all possibility of escape, and
at the same time to have a due regard for the preservation of their
lives. Captains of the Edwards kind should never be given truly
responsible positions; they are fitted to carry out only the letter and
never the spirit of Admiralty orders. One can at least say this for him:
he acted in accordance with what he considered his duty."

"I'm afraid, sir," I replied, "that I can never take so lenient a view of
him. I have suffered too much at his hands."

"I don't wonder, Byam. I don't wonder at all. You have..."

The doctor was in the very midst of a sentence when the door was flung
open and Sir Joseph entered. He was breathing heavily as though he had
been running, and I could see that he was labouring under great emotion.

"Byam, my dear lad!"

He broke off, unable to say more. I felt an icy chill at my heart. Dr.
Hamilton rose hastily, and looked from Sir Joseph to me and back again.

"No...Wait...It's not what you think...One moment..." He took a stride
into the tiny cabin and gripped me by the shoulders. "Byam...Tinkler is
safe...He is found...He is in London now; at this moment!"

"Sit you down, lad," said Dr. Hamilton. I needed no urging. My legs felt
as weak as though I had been lying in bed for months. The surgeon took a
small silver flask from his pocket, unscrewed the top, and offered it to
me. Sir Joseph sat in the chair at my table and mopped his forehead with
a large silk handkerchief. "Will you prescribe for me as well, Doctor?"
he asked.

"Please forgive me, sir," I said, handing him the flask.

"Good heaven, Byam, don't apologize!" he replied. "Necessity knows no
laws of deportment." He took a pull at the flask and returned it to the
surgeon. "Damn fine brandy, sir. I'll wager it has never done better
service than here, this day...Byam, I came from London as fast as a light
chaise would bring me. Yesterday, at breakfast, I was glancing through my
_Times_. In the shipping news I chanced to see an item announcing
the arrival of the West Indiaman _Sapphire_ with the survivors of
the crew of the _Carib Maid_, lost on a passage between Jamaica and
the Havannah. I need not tell you that I left my breakfast unfinished.
When I arrived at the dock I found the _Sapphire_ already
discharging her cargo. The _Carib Maid_ people had gone ashore the
evening before. I traced them to an inn near by. Tinkler was there, on
the point of setting out to the house of his brother-in-law, Fryer. Like
the other _Carib Maid_ survivors, he was still dressed in various
articles of clothing furnished by the _Sapphire_'s company. He
looked the part of a shipwrecked mariner, but I gave him no time for
excuses. I bundled him into my carriage and carried him straight to Lord
Hood. As luck would have it, the Admiral was in Town; he had dined with
me the night before. Tinkler, of course, was in the greatest bewilderment
at all this. I said nothing of my reason for wanting him--not a word. At
half-past ten Lord Hood and I were at the Admiralty with Tinkler between
us, dressed just as he had come ashore, in a seaman's jersey and boots
three sizes too large for him.

"Now what has happened, or what will happen, is this: Tinkler will be
examined before the Admiralty Commissioners, who alone have the power to
hear his evidence. By the grace of God and my copy of yesterday's
_Times_, that evidence cannot be impeached as biased or prejudiced.
Tinkler knows nothing of the court-martial. He has not seen Fryer, and he
does not know that you are within ten thousand miles of London. I left
him at the Admiralty, in proper charge, and came in all haste to

I could think of nothing to say. I merely sat, staring like a dumb man,
at Sir Joseph.

"Will the court-martial be reconvened to pass upon this evidence?" Dr.
Hamilton asked.

"No, that cannot be done; it is unnecessary that it should be done. The
Admiralty Commissioners who will receive Tinkler's evidence have the
power, in case the new testimony warrants it, of reversing the verdict of
the court-martial in Byam's case, and completely exonerating him. We
shall have their decision within a few days, I hope."

My heart sank at this. "Will it require days, sir, for the decision to be
made?" I asked.

"You must bear up, lad," Sir Joseph replied. "I understand, God knows,
how hard the waiting will be; but official wheels turn slowly."

"And my ship, the _Spitfire_, sails to-morrow," said Dr. Hamilton,
ruefully. "I shall have to leave England without knowing your fate,

"Perhaps it's just as well, Doctor," I replied.

Sir Joseph opened his mouth to speak, and then gazed blankly at me.

"Byam, I'm afraid I've made an unpardonable mistake! The realization has
only this moment come to me! Good God, what have I done! You should have
been told nothing of all this until the decision of the Commissioners has
been given!"

"Not at all, sir," I replied. "You shan't be allowed to condemn yourself.
You have given me reason to hope. Even though the hope prove unfounded, I
shall be none the less grateful."

"You truly mean that?"

"Yes, sir."

He gave me a keen, scrutinizing glance. "I see that you do. I am glad I
came." He rose. "And now I must leave you again. I shall go back to
London at once. I must be there to expedite matters as much as possible
for you." He shook my hand. "If it is good news, Byam, Captain Montague
shall receive it for you by messenger riding the best horses that ever
galloped the Portsmouth road."


Sir Joseph Banks carried my completed manuscripts back to London with
him. Having finished my work, I asked permission to take up my quarters
in the gun room again, and returned the same evening. The strain of
waiting was less hard to endure in company. I told only Morrison of
Tinkler's return; it would have been cruel to have informed the others,
men deprived of all hope of life.

Morrison's Bible proved a resource to all of us during those last days.
It was the same copy he had carried with him on the _Bounty_, and
had been preserved even through the wreck of the _Pandora_. We read
aloud, in turn, to the others, and we continued for hours so as to
prevent ourselves from thinking of what was soon to come. Millward and.
Muspratt had aroused themselves from their stupor of despair. My liking
and respect for these men increased greatly at this time. Tom Ellison had
never for a moment lost his courage. It was a bitter thought that this
lad, who had not an ounce of harm in him, was to lose his life as the
result of a boyish indiscretion, at a time when he was most fitted to
live. Only Burkitt remained as he had been from the day when sentence was
pronounced. Except for brief intervals at mealtime, he paced up and down,
hour after hour. Occasionally he would sit down for a moment, his head
between his hands, staring dully at the floor; then he would lift his
great shaggy head and glance around the room as though he had never seen
it before, and a moment later spring to his feet and resume his pacing.

On the morning of October 26, we watched the _Spitfire_ getting up
her anchors. It was a windless day, and boats' crews from the
_Hector_ and the _Brunswick_ were sent to assist in towing her
out of the harbour. We saw, or thought we saw, Dr. Hamilton standing on
the poop as the ship moved slowly out toward Spithead. Whether or not it
was the surgeon, we knew that he was thinking of us that morning as we
were thinking of him and wishing him Godspeed.

We welcomed every diversion, however slight; not a ship's boat crossing
our line of vision escaped us. We criticized the way her men handled the
oars, and conjectured as to where she was going and why. And every time
the door of the gun room opened, every time the guard was changed or food
was brought, I felt the cold chill about my heart that every condemned
man must have known. Many a time during those weeks did I wish that the
Admiralty Commissioners might have stood in our places for one day. The
needless cruelty inflicted upon six men, prolonged during a period of
more than a month, gave me a disgust for official routine which I retain
to this day.

On the Sunday afternoon, Morrison was reading aloud to the rest of us. It
was a cold day of drizzling rain, and Morrison was sitting close to one
of the ports, holding his Bible on a level with his eyes that he might
benefit by what dim light there was. All of us, excepting Burkitt, were
gathered around him as we listened to that most beautiful of all the

The Lord is my shepherd; I shall not want.

Morrison read on in his clear musical voice, choosing those psalms that
had comforted many generations of men in time of trouble. Of a sudden he
halted in the midst of a sentence, and turned his head quickly toward the
door. In so far as I remember we had heard nothing,--no sound, no voice,
no tread of feet,--and yet we rose together and stood waiting, our eyes
turned in the same direction. Burkitt stopped short and looked from the
guards to us and back again. "What's up?" he asked, hoarsely. There was
no need to reply. The door opened and a lieutenant of marines entered,
followed by the master-at-arms and a guard of eight men.

It was all but dark in the room and we could scarcely distinguish the
faces of the men who had entered. The master-at-arms carried a paper in
his hand. He crossed to one of the ports and held it up to the dim light.

"Thomas Burkitt--John Millward--Thomas Ellison."

"The prisoners named step forward," the lieutenant ordered.

The three men moved to the centre of the room. Handcuffs were snapped
upon their wrists, and they were placed in the centre of the guard, four
men in front and four behind.

"Forward, march!"

They were gone in an instant without a word of farewell being said.
Morrison, Muspratt, and I stood where we were, and the door was closed
and locked once more. A moment later, as we peered from the ports, we saw
one of the _Hector's_ cutters put off from the gangway, and in the
last grey light of the autumn afternoon we could distinguish the three
shackled men on a thwart astern. Moored abreast of the _Hector_ and
about four hundred yards distant was H.M.S. _Brunswick_. We saw the
cutter pass under her counter and disappear.

The anxiety of the night that followed is painful to recall. Morrison,
Muspratt, and I made no pretense of sleeping. We sat by one of the ports,
now and then peering out into the darkness toward the _Brunswick_,
talking in low voices of the men who had gone. We knew well enough that
it was their last night of life. The fact that we had been left behind
gave us reason to hope that their fate was not to be ours. My heart went
out to poor Muspratt, whose anguish of mind may be imagined. I did not
dare hint, even now, at what Sir Joseph had told me concerning him, but I
was glad that Morrison encouraged him to hope.

"Your case has been taken under consideration, Muspratt; I am sure of
it," he said. "I have never doubted that it would be. The fact that we
have been left here proves that there is something in the wind concerning

"What do you think, Mr. Byam?" asked Muspratt.

"That Morrison is right," I replied. "He has been recommended to the
King's clemency. The Court's appeal on his behalf must have been granted.
You and I have been left here with him. Don't you see, Muspratt? If they
intended to hang us, we would have been sent to the _Brunswick_ with
the rest."

"But maybe they want to hang them first? Or what if they're going to hang
us on the _Hector_?"

So we talked the night long, and God knows it was long. We considered
every possibility, every conceivable reason for our separation from the
others. And the minutes and the hours dragged by, and at last the
darkness was suffused with the ashy light of dawn, through which the huge
mass of the _Brunswick_ grew more and more distinct.

Our guard was changed with the watch, at eight bells. No news came. One
of the few prohibitions imposed upon us--and a quite just one--was that
we should not speak to the guards, so we had no means of knowing what
news was current on the ship. At nine o'clock, Morrison, who was standing
by a port, turned and said, "They've run up the signal for punishment on
the _Brunswick_."

On all British ships, eleven o'clock in the morning was the hour for
inflicting punishment. We had no doubt as to whom the _Brunswick's_
signal concerned. Ellison, Burkitt, and Millward had but two hours to

At half-past ten we saw one of the _Hector's_ longboats, filled with
seamen, put off to the _Brunswick_. Boats from other vessels in the
harbour followed; the men in them, we knew, were being sent to witness
the execution. Muspratt remained at the port, gazing toward the
_Brunswick_ as though fascinated by the sight of her lofty yards.
Morrison and I paced the room together, talking in the Indian tongue of
Teina and Itea and other friends at Tahiti, in a desperate attempt to
occupy our minds. It was getting on toward the hour when Captain Montague
entered, followed by the lieutenant who had come the night before. A
glance at the captain's face told us all we needed to know, but if there
was still doubt in our minds it was banished when the lieutenant ordered
the guard to dismiss. The men filed quickly out, glancing back at us with
friendly smiles. Captain Montague unfolded the paper in his hand.

"James Morrison--William Muspratt," he called.

The two men stepped forward. Captain Montague glanced at them over the
top of the paper he held, a kindly gleam in his blue eyes. He then read,

"In response to the earnest appeal of Lord Hood (Admiral of the Blue, and
President of the Court-Martial by which you have been tried, convicted,
and condemned to death for the crime of mutiny on His Majesty's armed
transport, _Bounty_), who, by reason of certain extenuating
circumstances, has begged that you may not be compelled to suffer the
extreme penalty prescribed by our just laws, His Majesty is graciously
pleased to grant to you, and each of you, a free and unconditional

"Roger Byam."

I took my place beside my two comrades.

"The Commissioners for executing the Office of Lord High Admiral of Great
Britain and Ireland, having received and heard the sworn testimony of
Robert Tinkler, former midshipman of His Majesty's armed transport,
_Bounty_, are convinced of your entire innocence of the crime of
-mutiny, for which you have been tried, convicted, and condemned to
death. The Lord's Commissioners do, therefore, annul the verdict of the
Court-Martial as it respects your person, and you stand acquitted."

Captain Montague then stepped forward and shook each of us warmly by the

"I have no doubt," he said, "that three loyal subjects have been spared
to-day for further usefulness to His Majesty."

My heart was too full for words. I could only mutter, "Thank you, sir!"
but Morrison would not have been Morrison had he not been prepared even
for such a moment as this.

"Sir," he said, earnestly, "when the sentence of the law was passed upon
me, I received it, I trust, as became a man; and if it had been carried
into execution, I should have met my fate, I hope, in a manner becoming a
Christian. I receive with gratitude my Sovereign's mercy, for which my
future life shall be faithfully devoted to His service."

Captain Montague bowed gravely.

"Are we now at liberty, sir?" I asked, doubtingly.

"You are free to go this moment if you choose."

"You will understand, sir, that we desire, if possible, to avoid..."

The captain turned to the lieutenant. "Mr. Cunningham, will you see to it
that a boat is ordered at once?"

Captain Montague accompanied us to the upper deck, and a few moments
later we were informed that the boat was waiting at the gangway. As I
bade farewell to the captain he said, "I hope, Mr. Byam, to have the
pleasure of meeting you again soon, under more fortunate circumstances."
We climbed hastily down the side, and the midshipman in charge of the
boat's crew gave orders to push off. We were in no position to enjoy the
sweetness of those first moments of freedom. Six bells had struck while
we were waiting on deck. Within two cables' lengths of us lay the
_Brunswick_, her lofty masts and yards clearly outlined against the
grey sky, and on our way to the wharf at Portsmouth we had to pass
directly under her carved and gilded stern. Three men on her upper deck
were standing at the very brink of death. Well we knew what was happening
there. We sat with averted faces. We drew away from her, the seamen
pulling at their oars steadily and in silence, but I saw that their eyes
were all turned in the same direction, toward the tall ship now astern.

Of a sudden a great gun broke the silence with a reverberating roar.
Against my will I turned my head. A cloud of smoke half hid the vessel,
but as it billowed out and drifted slowly away I saw three small black
figures suspended in mid-air, twitching as they swayed slowly from side
to side.

Captain Montague had given me a letter from Sir Joseph, written at the
Admiralty immediately after the decision of the Commissioners was known.
He had taken inside places for us on that night's London coach. As a
postscript he had written: "Mr. Erskine expects you at his house. You
must not disappoint the old gentleman, Byam. You will want to see no one
for several days; I quite understand that. When you have had the time you
need alone, will you send me word? I have something of importance to

Nothing could have been more characteristic of Sir Joseph than this
postscript. With all his bluff, hearty, manly qualities, he combined the
delicacy and thoughtfulness of a woman.

The three of us were too shaken in mind for conversation--too sore in
spirit, too bewildered at the change in our fortunes. We sat gazing out
at the fields of home gradually fading from view as the autumn evening
closed in. Opposite me in the coach there was a vacant place, and it
remained unoccupied all the way to London, which we reached at daylight
the following morning. But for me, all through the night, Tom Ellison sat
there. I heard his laughter, his cheery voice. I saw him peering eagerly
out of the window, missing nothing, enjoying everything, engaging in
conversation the old gentleman who sat next to me. "Yes, sir, we've been
away from home five long years, lacking one month. If you've ever been a
sailor you'll know what this journey means to us...What's that,
sir?...No, no; much farther than that. Ever hear of an island called
Tahiti? Well, that's where we've been. If you was to dig a hole straight
through the earth you'd come out somewhere near it."

Sea Law. Just--yes; just, savage, and implacable. I would have given the
whole of the Articles of War and all those who wrote them to have had Tom
Ellison sitting, in the flesh, opposite me in that seat in the London

It saddens me to think of our brief, casual farewells. There was reason
for this. We three had been together so long, it was inconceivable that
we could drift apart. We stood outside the booking office at the Angel,
St. Clements, Strand, watching foot passengers, carts, chaises, and
hackney coaches passing by. Morrison and I were both well provided with
money, he by his family and I by Mr. Erskine, but Muspratt, we knew, had
not two ha'pence to rub together in his pocket. His home was in Yarmouth,
where he had lived with his mother and two younger sisters. Morrison was
bound to the North Country.

"See here, Muspratt," he said, "how are you off for rhino?"

"Oh, I'll manage, Mr. Morrison," he replied. "I've ridden shanks' mare to
Yarmouth before now."

"And your mother's waiting for you there? He's not to ride shanks' mare
this time, eh, Byam?"

"That he is not!" I replied, heartily. We pressed five pounds each upon
him, and it did our hearts good to see the expression of amazement and
delight on Muspratt's face. We shook his hand warmly and he hurried away
at once to book his seat in the Yarmouth coach. We stood looking after
him as he made his way down the crowded street. He turned and waved to us
from the corner, and disappeared.

"Well, Byam?" said Morrison. I gripped his hand.

"God bless you, lad!" he said. "We must never lose track of each other."
A moment later I was alone, among strangers, for the first time in five

I could not have wished for a kinder, more considerate host than Mr.
Erskine, my father's old friend. He had long been a widower, and still
lived, with three elderly servants, in the house in Fig-Tree Court, near
the Temple, where I had last visited him on my way to join the
_Bounty_. The silence of that well-ordered house, where I had no
appointments to keep and might do as I pleased from morning till night,
was as healing to my spirit as the breath of the sea to a man at the end
of a long illness. I wandered about the quiet streets in the vicinity of
the Temple, or sat for hours by the window in my pleasant room
overlooking Fig-Tree Court, where scarcely a dozen passers-by were to be
seen in the course of an afternoon. And I thought of nothing. I had to
accustom myself by degrees to the business of living--to the very thought
that the gift of life was still mine to enjoy. Meanwhile, I was scarcely
more animate than the two old trees that cast faint shadows on the
pavement in the wan autumnal sun.

I had gone for my usual walk that day. When I returned, at five o'clock,
Mr. Erskine had not yet come in, but Clegg, his butler, met me in the

"There's a gentleman waiting to see you, sir. He's in the library."

I took the stairs three at a time. I knew that my letter would bring him
at the earliest possible moment. I flung open the door. There was
Tinkler, standing with his back to the sea-coal fire.

Mr. Erskine was engaged that evening. At least, he sent word by Clegg to
that effect; but my belief is that, upon coming home and learning that
Tinkler was there, he had retired to his own room for no other reason
than that we might have the evening together, alone. We had dinner in the
library, in front of the fire. There was so much to be said that we
scarcely knew how or where to begin. Tinkler had not yet recovered from
his astonishment at the manner in which he had been pounced upon and
kidnapped by Sir Joseph Banks.

"Remember, Byam, that I still thought of you as being somewhere on the
other side of the world. When I had returned from my first voyage to the
West Indies, I had heard that a ship, the _Pandora_, had been sent
out to search for the _Bounty_. That was the extent of my
information about you, and months had passed since that time. I had heard
nothing of Edwards's return, and not a word of the court-martial. I had
cone ashore the previous evening, in clothing borrowed from men on the
_Sapphire_, the ship that had rescued us. Another time I'll tell you
the story of the _Carib Maid_ and how she was lost. Only ten of us
survived,--the other boats were lost,--and there we were at an inn about
a stone's throw from the dock where the _Sapphire_ was berthed. I'd
had a glorious breakfast of eggs and bacon, and was just on the point of
setting out for my brother-in-law's house when a fine carriage and pair
drove up, and before I could say How-do-you-do or God bless me I found
myself inside, sitting opposite Sir Joseph Banks.

"I had never laid eyes on him until that moment. He gave not even a hint
of what he required of me, but I imagined that it must, somehow, concern
the _Bounty_. 'Possess your soul in patience, Mr. Tinkler,' he said.
'I shall see to it that Mr. Fryer is notified of your arrival. I will
merely say this, now: Mr. Fryer will strongly approve of my taking you in
charge in this high-handed fashion.' With that I had to be content. Sir
Joseph gave some instructions to his coachman and we drove westward at
more than a smart clip. Presently we stopped before a very splendid
house. Sir Joseph leaped out, strode up to the door, vanished, and ten
minutes later out he came again with Admiral Hood in tow! Naturally, I
was more mystified than ever, but I felt highly flattered at having two
such guardians. We drove straight to the Admiralty.

"I shan't go into the details. Sir Joseph and the Admiral left me in
charge of a Captain Maxon--Matson--some such name. He was a very
courteous, pleasant, and vigilant companion, and didn't let me out of his
sight for a moment. I spent the rest of that day, the following night,
and until ten o'clock the next morning in his company. We told each other
the stories of our lives, but all I gathered from him as to the business
in hand was that it concerned the _Bounty_.

"Promptly at ten that morning, I was taken before the Board of Admiralty
Commissioners. Picture me, still dressed in the cast-off clothing of
three men, standing before that august assembly! I was sworn, and then
graciously permitted to sit down.

"'Mr. Tinkler, will you please to inform the Commissioners of anything
you may know concerning Roger Byam, former midshipman of His Majesty's
armed transport, _Bounty_.'

"You can imagine, Byam, how the mention of your name affected me. I felt
a cold shiver of apprehension running with considerable speed up my spine
and on to the roots of my hair. I had by no means forgotten how often
Bligh had damned you as a piratical scoundrel without permitting any of
us to say a word in your defense. Believe me, I had tried; and the second
time I attempted it I thought he meant to throw me out of the boat. Now I
thought, 'By God, old Byam's caught! He's in trouble, here or somewhere.'
I looked from' one to another of the Commissioners for a hint of what was
expected of me.

"'Do you mean, sir, concerning his present whereabouts?' I asked.

"'No. Perhaps the question was a little vague. You are quite naturally
mystified. We wish to know the particulars, if you recall them, of a
conversation said to have taken place on the quarter-deck of the
_Bounty_ between Mr. Fletcher Christian and Mr. Byam on the night
previous to the mutiny on that ship. Did you overhear such a

"I remembered it at once, and it was at that moment, Byam, that light
began to dawn upon me.

"'Yes, sir,' I replied; 'I remember it quite well.'

"'Reflect carefully, Mr. Tinkler. A man's life depends upon what you
shall now depose concerning that conversation. Take as much time as you
need to collect your thoughts. Omit no smallest detail.'

"The whole business came clear to me, Byam. I knew then precisely what
was wanted, and you may thank God that my memory is as yet unimpaired by
old age. But here's the extraordinary thing: from the night when you and
Christian were talking between the larboard guns on the quarter-deck
until the moment when I stood before the Commissioners, I'd forgotten the
immensely important fact that Bligh had overheard a part of what you
said. Wouldn't you think that might have stuck in my mind? There's a
reasonable explanation, of course: during the boat voyage to Timor, and
afterward, old Bligh never once, to my knowledge, explained why he
considered you of Christian's party. We all believed that the reason was
your failing to appear on deck before the launch was veered astern. And
we knew that Christian had spoken to you a number of times on the morning
of the mutiny. Furthermore, you were Christian's friend. That was more
than enough to make the old rascal damn you straight out.

"You may believe that I took my time in proceeding. I told the story from
the moment when we went on deck together during Peckover's watch. I'd
forgotten nothing. I even told them how I'd confessed to you that I was
one of the culprits who had stolen Bligh's invaluable coconuts. I told
them how I lay down to take a caulk between the guns just before
Christian came along and engaged you in conversation. But above
everything, Byam, thank heaven and Robert Tinkler for this: I remembered
how Bligh came up at the very moment you were shaking Christian's hand,
when you said, 'You can count on me.'

"The Commissioners sat leaning forward in their chairs. One old fellow
sat with a hand cupped behind his ear. On his behalf I spoke with.
particular slowness and distinctness. Mr. Christian replied: "Good,
Byam," or "Thank you, Byam," I cannot be certain which, and they shook
hands upon it. At this moment Mr. Bligh interrupted them; they had not
heard him approach. He made some remark about their being up late,

"'That will do, Mr. Tinkler,' I was told. I was ushered out of the room,
and...well, old lad, here we are!"

"You know, Byam," Tinkler went on, after a moment of silence, "I've often
wondered whether that affair of the coconuts was not the actual cause of
the mutiny. Do you remember how Bligh abused Christian?"

"I'm not likely to forget that," I replied.

"I can recall Bligh's very words: 'Yes, you bloody hound! I do think so!
You must have stolen some of mine or you would be able to give a better
account of your own!' What a thing to say to his second-in-command! I
more than half believe that was what goaded Christian to desperation.
What do you think?"

"Let's not talk of it, Tinkler," I said. "I'm sick to death of the

"Forgive me, lad. Of course you are."

"But I'd like nothing better than to hear about your voyage in the launch
to Timor."

"I'll say this, Byam: in that situation, Bligh was beyond all praise. He
was the same old blackguard, and he ruled us with an iron hand, but, by
God, he brought us through! I don't believe there's another man in
England who could have done it."

"What prevented him and Purcell from murdering each other, cooped up as
they were in a small boat?"

"It was a near thing, a very near thing. Matters came to a head at a
small island on the Great Barrier Reef. We were in a desperate situation
and had put in there for the night. I've forgotten how the dispute
started, but I remember Bligh and Purcell standing on a sandy beach
facing each other like a couple of old bulls. We were damn near dead of
hunger and thirst, but these two still had fight in 'em. Bligh made a
stride to the boat, took two of our four cutlasses, and handed one to the
carpenter. 'Now, sir,' he said, 'defend yourself or forever hold your
peace!' The rest of us scarecrows stood looking on; we were too wretched
to care what might happen. And Purcell backed down. He apologized. That
was the only time there was ever a question of Bligh's authority."

"Do you remember Coupang, Tinkler?"

"Coupang! That heaven on earth! Let me tell you how we came in. It was
about three in the morning...but wait a minute! How about filling my
glass? As a host, Byam, you leave something to be desired."

And so it went the night through.


I had spent a week at Fig-Tree Court when I sent Sir Joseph the message
he had asked for. I supposed that he wished to see me for some reason
connected with my Indian dictionary, and now that the first numbness of
mind succeeding my acquittal had passed, I looked forward with pleasure
to the interview; and it would give me an opportunity to ask whether I
might render any services to him, or to the Royal Society, upon my return
to the South Sea.

The death of my mother had severed my last tie with England, and I had
been through so much that all ambition, all a young man's craving for a
life of action, seemed dead in me. I may, perhaps, be excused for my
feeling of bitterness at this time. English faces seemed strange to me,
and English ways harsh and even cruel. I longed only for Tehani and the
tranquil beauty of the South Sea.

It was my intention to inform Sir Joseph of my plan to leave England for
good. I was possessed of ample means to do as I pleased--even to purchase
a vessel, should that prove necessary. Ships would be sailing from time
to time for the newly formed settlement at Port Jackson, in New South
Wales, and, once there, I might find it possible to buy or charter a
small ship to take me to Tahiti. I knew that, for my mother's sake, I
could not leave England without paying a visit to Withycombe, and I both
dreaded and longed to see our old house, so filled with memories.

Sir Joseph's reply to my message was an invitation to dinner on the same
evening, and I found him in company with Captain Montague, of the
_Hector_. We discussed for a time the events taking place in Europe,
which pointed to an early outbreak of war. Presently Sir Joseph turned to

"What are your plans, Byam?" he asked. "Shall you return to the Navy, or
go up to Oxford, as your father hoped?"

"Neither, sir," I replied. "I have decided to return to the South Sea."
Montague set down his glass at my words, and Sir Joseph looked at me in
astonishment, but neither man spoke.

"There is nothing, now, to keep me in England," I added.

Sir Joseph shook his head slowly. "It had not occurred to me that you
were considering Tahiti," he said. "I feared that, in your present state,
you might intend to give up the sea for the seclusion of an academic
career. But the, my lad!"

"Why not, sir?" I asked. "I am free of obligations at home, and I should
be happy there. Saving yourself and Captain Montague and a handful of
other friends, there is no one in England I wish to see again."

"I understand--I understand," Sir Joseph remarked kindly. "You have
suffered much, Byam; but remember, time will heal the deepest wounds. And
remember another thing: if I may say so, you have obligations, and
weighty ones."

"To whom, sir?" I inquired.

My host paused, thoughtfully. "I see that it has not even occurred to
you," he said. "It is a delicate matter to explain. Montague, suppose I
leave it to you?"

The captain sipped his wine as if pondering how to begin. Presently he
looked up. "Sir Joseph and I have spoken of you more than once, Mr. Byam.
You have obligations, as he says."

"To whom, sir?" I asked once more.

"To your name; to the memory of your father and mother. You have been
imprisoned and tried for mutiny, and though you were acquitted and are
as innocent as Sir Joseph or myself, something--a little unpleasant
something--may cling to your name. _May_ cling, I say; whether or not it
shall, rests with you. If you choose to follow some career ashore, or,
worst of all, decide to bury yourself in the South Sea, men will say,
when your name is spoken of: 'Roger Byam? Yes, I remember him well; one
of the _Bounty_ mutineers. He was tried by court-martial and acquitted
at the last moment. A near thing!' Public opinion is a mighty force, Mr.
Byam. No man can afford to disregard it."

"If I may speak plainly, sir," I replied, warmly, "damn public opinion! I
am innocent, and my parents--if there is a life beyond death--know of my
innocence. Let the others believe what they will!"

"You were a victim of circumstance and have been hardly used," said
Captain Montague, kindly. "I understand very well how you feel; but Sir
Joseph and I are right. You owe it to the honourable name you bear to
continue the career of a sea officer. War is in the air; your part in it
will soon silence the whispers. Come, Byam! To speak plainly, I want you
on the _Hector_, and have saved a place in the berth for you."

Sir Joseph nodded. "That's what you should do, Byam."

I was still in a nervous condition as the result of my long imprisonment
and the suspense I had been through. Captain Montague's kindness moved me

"Uncommonly good of you, sir," I muttered. "Indeed I appreciate the
offer, but..."

"There's no need for an immediate decision," he interrupted. "Think over
what I have said. Let me know your decision within a month. I can hold
the offer open until then."

"Yes, take your time," said Sir Joseph. "We'll say no more of it

Captain Montague took leave of us early; afterward Sir Joseph led me to
his study, hung with weapons and ornaments from distant lands. "Byam," he
said, when we had settled ourselves before the fire, "there is a question
I have long desired to ask you. You know me for a man of honour; if you
see fit to answer, you have my word that I will never divulge the reply."

He paused. "Proceed, sir," I said; "I will do my best."

"Where is Fletcher Christian--can you tell me?"

"Upon my word, sir," I replied, "I do not know, nor could I hazard a

He looked at me for a moment with his shrewd blue eyes, rose briskly, and
pulled down a great chart of the Pacific from its roller on the wall.
"Fetch the lamp, Byam," he said.

Side by side, while I held the lamp, we scanned the chart of the greatest
ocean in the world. "Here is Tahiti," he said. "What course was the
_Bounty_ steering when last seen?"

"Northeast by north, I should say."

"It might have been a blind, of course, but the Marquesas lie that way.
The Spaniard, Mendaña, discovered them long ago. Rich islands, too, and
only a week distant with the wind abeam. See, here they are."

"I doubt it, sir," I replied. "Christian gave us to understand that it
was his intention to seek out an island as yet unknown. He would not have
risked settling on a place likely to be visited."

"Perhaps not," he replied, musingly. "Edwards touched at Aitutaki, I

"Yes, sir," I replied, and as I glanced at the dot of land in the immense
waste of waters, a sudden thought struck me. "By God!" I exclaimed.

"What is it, Byam?"

"I must tell you in confidence, Sir Joseph."

"You have my word."

"I told you that I could not even hazard a guess, but I had forgotten one
possibility. After the mutiny, when we were sailing eastward from Tofoa,
we raised a rich volcanic island not marked on any chart. It lies to the
southwest of Aitutaki, distant not more than one hundred and fifty miles,
I believe. We did not land, but the Indians came out in their canoes, and
seemed friendly enough. I questioned one man in the language of Tahiti,
and he told me the name of the place was Rarotonga. The mutineers were
eager to go ashore, but Christian would have none of it. Yet, when he
left Tahiti for the last time, he must have thought of this rich unknown
island, so close to the west. If I were to search for Christian now, I
should go straight to Rarotonga and be pretty sure of finding him there."

Eighteen years were to pass before I learned how mistaken I was in this
opinion. Sir Joseph listened attentively. "That's interesting," he said.
"Captain Cook had no idea there was land so close to Aitutaki. A high
island, you say?"

"Two or three thousand feet, at least. The mountains are rugged and green
to the very tops. There is a broad belt of coastal land; it looked rich
and populous."

"The very place for them! Is the island large?"

"Nearly the size of Eimeo, I should say."

"Gad, Byam!" he exclaimed, regretfully; "I'd like to report
the discovery. But have no fear--the secret is safe with
me...Christian...poor devil!"

"You knew him, sir?"

He nodded. "I knew him well."

"He was my good friend," I said. "There was provocation, God knows, for
what he did."

"No doubt. It's strange...I had supposed that Bligh was his best friend."

"I am sure that Captain Bligh thought so, too...I've a sad task ahead of
me. I promised Christian that I would see his mother if ever I reached

"His people are gentlefolk; they live in Cumberland."

"Yes, sir; I know."

Sir Joseph rolled up the chart. I glanced at the tall clock against the
wall. "Time I was getting home, sir," I said.

"Aye, bedtime, lad. But one word before you go. Let me advise you, most
earnestly, to consider Captain Montague's offer. You are sore in spirit,
but that will pass. Montague and I are older men. We know this sorry old
world better than you. Give up the idea of burying yourself in the South

"I'll think it over, sir," I said.

Day after day I put off my visit to Withycombe. I dreaded leaving the
quiet old house in Fig-Tree Court, and when at last I took leave of Mr.
Erskine I had already been to Cumberland and back on Christian's errand.
Of my interview with his mother I shall not speak. On a chill winter
evening, with a fine rain drizzling down, I alighted from the coach in
Taunton, and found our carriage awaiting me. Our old coachman was dead,
and his son, the companion of many a boyhood scrape, was on the box. The
street was ankle-deep in mud, with pools of water glimmering in the faint
gleam of the lamps. I stepped into the carriage, and we went swaying down
the rutty, dimly lighted street. The faint musty smell of leather was
perfume to me, and brought back a flood of memories--of rainy Sundays in
the past when we had driven to church. Here, in the door, was the pocket
into which my mother used to slip her prayer book, nearly always
forgotten until we were about to enter our pew. I could hear the very
tones of her voice, humorous and apologetic: "Oh, Roger! My prayer book!
Run back and fetch it, dear." And there seemed to linger in the old coach
the fragrance of English lavender, which she preferred to all the scents
of France.

The rain fell steadily, and the horses trotted on, splashing through
pools, slowing to a walk on the hills. Tired with my long journey from
London, I fell into a doze. When I awoke, the wheels were crunching on
the gravel of the Withycombe drive, and ahead of us I could see the
lights of the house. For a moment, five years were blotted from my mind;
I was returning from school for the Christmas holidays, and my mother
would be listening for the carriage, ready to run to the door to welcome

Thacker was standing under the portico, and the butler and the other
servants--a forlorn little group, it seemed to me. Never, save on that
night, have I seen tears in Thacker's eyes.

A few moments later I was seated alone in the high-ceilinged dining-room,
filled with shadows and memories. The candles on the table burned without
a flicker, and in their yellow light our old butler moved noiselessly
about, filling my glass and setting before me food that I ate without
knowing what it was. It had been my privilege to dine here on Sundays, as
a small boy, and on other evenings to come in to say good-night when my
father and mother were at dessert--a good-night enriched by a walnut, or
a handful of raisins or Spanish figs. Here I had dined with my mother,
after my father's death; here Bligh had dined with us on that night so
long ago. Save for him and his letter my mother might be opposite me
now...I rose and went upstairs.

In my father's study, high up in the north wing, I stretched out in a
long chair under the chandelier. His spirit seemed to fill the place: his
collection of sextants in the cabinet, the astronomical charts on the
wall, the books in their tall shelves--all were eloquent of him. I took
down a leather-bound volume of Captain Cook's _Voyages_, but found
it impossible to read. I was listening for my mother's light footstep in
the passage outside, and her voice at the door: "Roger, may I come in?"
At last I took up a candle and made my way along the hallway, passing the
door of my mother's room on the way to my own. Into her room I dared not
go that night. I fancied her there, as I had seen her a hundred times in
the past, reading in bed, with her thick hair tumbled on the pillow, and
a candle on the table at her side.

West winds, blowing off the Atlantic, made that December a warm and rainy
month, and I took many a long walk along the muddy lanes, with the rain
in my face and the wind moaning through the leafless trees. A change, so
gradual as to be almost imperceptible, was coming over me; I was
beginning to realize that my roots, like those of my ancestors, were deep
in this West Country soil. Tehani, our child, the South Sea--all seemed
to lose substance and reality, fading to the ghostliness of a beautiful,
half-remembered dream. Reality lay here--in the Watchet churchyard, in
Withycombe, among the cottages of our tenants. And the solid walls of our
old house, the order preserved within, through death and distress,
brought home to me the sense of a continuity it was my duty to preserve.
Little by little my bitterness dissolved.

Toward the end of the month my decision was made. It cost me dear at the
time, but I have since had no cause to regret it. I wrote to Captain
Montague that I would join his ship, and enclosed a copy of the letter in
a longer one to Sir Joseph Banks. Two days later, on a grey windless
morning, I stood under the portico, waiting for the carriage which was to
take me to Taunton to catch the London coach. The Bristol Channel lay
like polished steel under the low clouds, and the air was so still that I
could hear the cawing of the rooks from far and near. Two fishing boats
were working out to sea, their sails hanging slack, and the men at the
sweeps. I was watching them creeping laboriously toward the Atlantic when
I heard Tom's chirrup to the horses, and the sound of wheels on the


I joined Captain Montague's ship in January, 1793, and hostilities broke
out in the following month, the beginning of our wars with the allied
nations of Europe--the stormiest and most critical period of British
naval history, which was to culminate, after twelve years of almost
constant actions, in the great sea fight off the coast of Spain. I had
the honour of fighting the Dutch at Camperdown, the Danes at Copenhagen,
and the Spanish and French at Trafalgar, and it was after that most
glorious of victories that I was promoted to the rank of captain.

Throughout the period of the wars I had many a dream of being stationed
in the Pacific upon the establishment of peace, but a sea officer in time
of war has little leisure for reflection, and as the years passed my
longing to return to the South Sea grew less painful, and the sufferings
I had endured less bitter in memory. It was not until the summer of 1809,
when in command of the _Curieuse_, a smart frigate of thirty-two
guns, captured from the French, that my dream came true. I received
orders to set sail for Port Jackson, in New South. Wales, and thence to
Valparaiso, touching at Tahiti on the way.

I had on board a half-company of the Seventy-third Regiment, sent out to
relieve the New South Wales Corps; the remainder of the regiment had gone
ahead, on board the ships _Dromedary_ and _Hindostan_. Four
years before, through the influence of Sir Joseph Banks, Lord Camden had
appointed Captain Bligh governor of New South Wales; now the notorious
Rum Rebellion had run its course, and a new governor, Colonel Lachlan
Macquarie, had been sent to take charge of the troubled colony. Accusing
Bligh of harsh and tyrannical misuse of his powers, Major Johnston, the
senior officer of the New South Wales Corps, and a Mr. MacArthur, the
most influential of the settlers, had seized the reins of government and
kept Bligh a prisoner in Government House for more than a year.

During the long voyage out, by the Cape of Good Hope and through Bass
Straits, Bligh was often in my thoughts. For his belief that I was one of
the mutineers, and my sufferings as a prisoner, I had never blamed him at
heart. But the letter to my mother, which had certainly been the cause of
her death, was another matter. I had no desire to affront him in public,
yet I knew I could never take his hand. He had played the part of a brave
captain in the wars; at Copenhagen, Nelson had congratulated him on the
quarter-deck of the _Elephant_. But now, as his career was drawing
to a close, the history of the _Bounty_ was repeating itself, and
Bligh was once more the central figure in a mutiny. I had no means of
determining the justice of the case, but the fact was strange, to say the

We left Spithead in August, and it was not until February, 1810, that the
_Curieuse_ entered the magnificent harbour of Port Jackson, and cast
anchor in Farm Cove, exchanging salutes with the three British ships of
war moored close by--the _Porpoise_, the _Dromedary_, and the
_Hindostan_. While we were making all snug, a boat put off from the
latter ship, bringing her captain, John Pascoe, on board. Pascoe had had
the honour of serving as Nelson's flag-lieutenant at Trafalgar, and was
an old friend of mine. It was a hot 'day of the antipodean summer, and a
blistering sun shone down from a cloudless sky. I ushered my guest into
the cabin, where it was cooler than on deck, and ordered the steward to
make a pitcher of claret punch. Pascoe sank down on a settee, mopping his
face with a large silk handkerchief.

"Whew! I'll wager hell is no hotter than Sydney just now!" he exclaimed.
"And, by God, their climate is no hotter than their politics! What have
you heard of all this in England?"

 "Only rumours; we know nothing of the truth."

"The truth is hard to get at, even here. No doubt there is justice on
both sides. The rum traffic has been the ruin of the colony, and it was
in the hands of the military officers. Bligh perceived the evil and
attempted to stop it, using the same famous tact and consideration which
brought on the _Bounty_ mutiny. As governor, he was invested with
far more power than the King enjoys at home, but his only means of
enforcing it was the Rum Puncheon Corps, as they are called. You know at
least the result: Bligh a prisoner in Government House, and the
administration in the hands of Major Johnston, a puppet for Mr.
MacArthur, the richest settler in the colony. A pretty mess!"

"What will happen now?"

"The Seventy-third stays here and the Cores returns to England. Johnston,
MacArthur, and Bligh will have it out at home. Colonel Macquarie, whom I
brought out, remains as governor."

Pascoe was eager for news from home, and we gossiped for a time.
Presently he rose. "I must be pushing off, Byam," he said: "Bligh has
ordered us to sail this afternoon."

When I had taken leave of him at the gangway, I ordered a boat and went
ashore to arrange for the debarkation of the troops, and wait upon the
governor. It was indeed a fiery day, and as I trudged up the path that
led to Government House I sank ankle-deep in dust. The anteroom in which
I was asked to take a chair was dark and cool.

"His Excellency is occupied for the moment, Captain Byam," said the
A.D.C. who received me. He bowed and sat down to continue his writing,
and next moment, from beyond the closed door, I heard a strident voice
raised angrily. In an instant I felt myself twenty years younger,
transported as if by magic to the deck of the _Bounty_ on the
afternoon before the mutiny. The same harsh voice, unchanged by a score
of years, rang out in memory, as if repeating the words which had goaded
Christian to madness: "Yes, you bloody hound! I _do_ think so. You
must have stolen some of mine or you would be able to give a better
account of your own. You're damned rascals and thieves, the lot of you!"

The voice in the cabinet ceased and I heard the deep, conciliatory murmur
of the governor. Then Bligh broke out again. His grievances had lost
nothing in the two years he had brooded over them.

"Major Johnston, sir? By God! The man should be taken out and shot! As
for MacArthur, I took his measure the first time I laid eyes on him.
'What, sir?' I said, 'are you to have such flocks of sheep and cattle as
no man ever heard of before? No, sir! I have heard of you and your
concerns, sir! You have got five thousand acres of the finest land, but,
by God, you shan't keep it!' 'I have received the land by order of the
Secretary of State,' replied MacArthur, coolly, 'and on the
recommendation of the Privy Council.' 'Damn the Privy Council!' said I,
'and the Secretary of State, too! What have they to do with me?'"

Again I heard the deep conciliatory murmur of the Governor's voice,
interrupted by Bligh's strident tones: "Sydney, sir? A sink of iniquity!
A more depraved, licentious lot of rascals don't exist! The settlers? God
save the mark! They're worse than the convicts--the very scum of the
earth! You must know how open I am to mercy and compassion, but, by God,
sir, such qualities are wasted here! Rule them with a hand of iron! Rule
them by fear!"

There was a scraping of chairs and the door was flung open. A stout burly
man in captain's uniform stood in the doorway, his face purple with
emotion and heat. Without a glance at me, he strode truculently across
the room, while the A.D.C. sprang up and hastened to open the outer door.
Captain Bligh gave him neither word nor glance as he brushed past. Next
moment he was gone. The tired young A.D.C. closed the door, and turned to
me with a faint smile. "Thank God!" he murmured devoutly, under his

We came in sight of Tahiti on a morning in early April, passing to the
north of Eimeo with a fine breeze at west by north. But the wind chopped
around to the east as we approached the land, and we were all day long
working up to Matavai Bay. My lieutenant, Mr. Cobden, must have had some
inkling of what was passing in my mind, for he and the master saw to it
that I was disturbed by no detail of the working of the ship.

Communication with Tahiti was all but impossible in those days, and not
once, during the twenty years that had passed since I had embraced Tehani
in the _Pandora's_ sick bay, had I had word of her, or of our child.
In 1796, having learned that the ship _Duff_ was to sail for Tahiti
with a cargo of missionaries,--the first in the South Sea,--I had been at
some pains to make the acquaintance of one of those worthy men, and
received his promise to search out my Indian wife and child, and send me
word of them when the ship returned to England. But no letter came back
to me. In Port Jackson, I had met and talked with some of these same
missionaries, and told them of my orders to visit Tahiti and report on
the condition of the people. Their accounts of the island were of a most
melancholy nature. Considering their lives and those of their wives and
children in danger, the missionaries had embarked for Port Jackson on a
vessel providendaily lying at anchor in Matavai Bay. They had spent
twelve years on Tahiti, learned the language (they were kind enough to
say that my dictionary had been of the greatest aid to them), and worked
unremittingly at their task of preaching the Gospel. Yet not a single
convert had been made. War, and the diseases introduced by the visits of
European ships, had destroyed four fifths of the people, I was told, and
the future of the island appeared dark indeed. As for Tehani, not one of
the worthy missionaries had ever heard of her, nor set foot on Taiarapu,
where I supposed her still to reside.

As my ship approached the land on that April afternoon, Tahiti wore the
green and smiling aspect I remembered so well, and it was hard to believe
that an island so fair to the eye could be the scene of war and
pestilence. A flood of memories overwhelmed me as Point Venus came in
sight, and One Tree Hill, and the pale green of the shoal called Dolphin
Bank. Yonder was the islet, Motu Au, opposite Hitihiti's house; close at
hand I saw Stewart's shady glen, and the mouth of the small valley where
Morrison and Millward had resided with Poino. And closer still was the
mouth of the river in which I had first met Tehani, so long ago. I was
only forty years old,--robust and in the prime of life,--yet as I conned
the frigate through the narrow passage I knew so well, I had the feeling
which comes to very old men, of having lived too long. Centuries seemed
to have elapsed since I had looked last on the scene now before me. I
dreaded setting foot on shore.

It was strange as we dropped anchor to see that no canoes put out. A few
people were discernible along the beach, watching us apathetically, but
they were pitifully few beside the throngs of former days, and where once
the thatched roofs of their dwellings had been clustered thick under the
trees, there was scarcely a house to be seen. Even the trees themselves
had a withered, yellow look, for, as I was to learn, the victorious party
had hacked and girdled nearly every breadfruit tree in Matavai.

At last a small patched canoe put out to us with two men on board. They
were dressed in cast-off scraps of European clothing and were no more
than beggars, for they had nothing to exchange for what we gave them.
They addressed us in broken English. I was pleased, when they spoke
together in their own tongue, to find that I understood pretty well what
they said. I inquired for Tipau, Poino, and Hitihiti, but received only
shrugs and blank stares in reply.

It lacked an hour of sunset when my boat's crew landed .me on Hitihiti's
point. I ordered them to await my coming on the Matavai beach, and turned
inland alone, at the very spot where the surgeon had stumped through the
sand twenty years before. Not a human being was to be seen, nor could I
find a trace of my _taio's_ house. The point, formerly covered with
a well-kept lawn, was now grown over with rank weeds, and the path
leading to the temple of Fareroi, once trodden by countless feet, was
scarcely discernible. On my way to the still reach of river where I had
met Tehani, I halted at sight of an old woman, squatting motionless on
the sand as she gazed out to sea. She looked up at me dully, but
brightened when she found that I addressed her in her own tongue, though
haltingly. Hitihiti? She had heard of him, but he was dead long since.
Hina? She shook her head. She had never heard of Tipau, but remembered
Poino well. He was dead. She shrugged her shoulders. "Once Tahiti was a
land of men," she said; "now only shadows fill the land."

The river was unchanged, and though the bank was overgrown with
vegetation, I found my way to my seat among the roots of the ancient
_mapé_ tree. The noble tree stood firmly rooted and flourishing, and
the river ran on with the same faint murmuring sound. But my youth was
gone, and all my old friends dead. For a moment anguish gripped me; I
would have renounced my career and all I possessed in the world to have
been twenty years younger, sporting in the river with Tehani.

I dared not think of her, nor of our child. I had resolved to sail to
Tautira on the morrow and dreaded what I might discover there. Presently
I rose, crossed the river at a shallow place, and walked toward One Tree
Hill. The groves of breadfruit trees which had once provided food for
innumerable people were now hacked, yellow, and drooping; in place of
scores of neat Indian cottages, only a few filthy hovels were to be seen;
and where a thousand people had lived only twenty years before I met
scarce a dozen on my walk.

Proceeding down the eastern slope of One Tree Hill I soon reached
Stewart's glen where I had passed so many happy hours. There I sat me
down on a flat stone, close to the spot where his house had once stood.
Not a trace of the house remained, nor of the garden he had tended with
such care, though I found what I took to be the remains of one of his
rockeries for ferns. Stewart's bones, overgrown with coral, lay mingled
with the _Pandora's_ rotting timbers on a reef off the Australian
coast. Where was Peggy? Where was their child? The sun had set, and the
shadows were deepening in the glen. Sadly I rose and made my way over the
steep rocky trail that led to Matavai.

Next morning I took the pinnace and a dozen men and sailed around the
east side of Tahiti Nui to Taiarapu. The eastern coast seemed in a more
flourishing state than Matavai, and I was agreeably surprised to find
that Vehiatua's former realm had not been desolated by war. But
pestilence had done its work, and scarce one man was to be found where
five had lived in my time. As we approached Tautira, I strained my eyes
for the sight of Vehiatua's tall house on the point. It was gone, but
presently I perceived with emotion that my own house, or one like it,
stood on the spot where I had lived. The boat grounded on the sand, while
a score of people, with brighter faces than those of Matavai, stood on
the beach to welcome us. I scanned their countenances while my heart beat
painfully, but there was no man or woman I knew. I dared not ask for
Tehani, and the missionaries in Port Jackson had informed me that
Vehiatua was dead, so, telling my people to bargain for a supply of
coconuts, I set off in search of someone known to me. The little crowd of
Indians stopped by the boat. I was glad to be left alone.

I took the well-remembered path, and before I had walked halfway to the
house I met a middle-aged man of commanding presence, who halted at sight
of me. Our eyes met, and for an instant neither spoke.

"Tuahu?" I said.

"Byam!" He stepped forward to clasp me in the Indian embrace. There were
tears in his eyes as he looked at me. Presently he said, "Come to the

"I was on my way there," I replied, "but let us stop a moment where we
can be alone."

He understood perfectly what was in my mind, and waited with downcast
eyes while I mustered up courage to ask a question his silence answered
only too eloquently.

"Where is Tehani?"

"_Ua mate_--dead," he replied quietly. "She died in the moon of
Paroro, when you were three moons gone."

"And our child?" I asked after a long silence.

"She lives," said Tuahu. "A woman now, with a child of her own. Her
husband is the son of Atuanui. He will be high chief of Taiarapu one
day. You shall see your daughter presently."

Tuahu waited in considerate silence for me to speak. "Old friend and
kinsman," I said at last, "you know how dearly I loved her. All these
years, while my country has been engaged in constant wars, I have dreamed
of coming back. This place is a graveyard of memories, and I have been
stirred enough. I wish to see my daughter; not to make myself known to
her. To tell her that I am her father, to embrace her, to speak with her
of her mother, would be more than I could endure. You understand?"

Tuahu smiled sorrowfully. "I understand," he said.

At that moment I heard a sound of voices on the path, and he touched my
arm. "She is coming, Byam," he said in a low voice. A tall girl was
approaching us, followed by a servant, and leading a tiny child by the
hand. Her eyes were dark blue as the sea; her robe of snow-white cloth
fell from her shoulders in graceful folds, and on her bosom I saw a
necklace of gold, curiously wrought like the linnet seamen plait.

"Tehani," called the man beside me, and I caught my breath as she turned,
for she had all her dead mother's beauty, and something of my own mother,
as well. "The English captain from Matavai," Tuahu was saying, and she
gave me her hand graciously. My granddaughter was staring up at me in
wonder, and I turned away blindly:

"We must go on," said Tehani to her uncle. "I promised the child she
should see the English boat."

"Aye, go," replied Tuahu.

The moon was bright overhead when I re-embarked in the pinnace to return
to my ship. A chill night breeze came whispering down from the depths of
the valley, and suddenly the place was full of ghosts,--shadows of men
alive and dead,--my own among them.


This site is full of FREE ebooks - Project Gutenberg Australia