Project Gutenberg Australia
a treasure-trove of literature
treasure found hidden with no evidence of ownership

Title:      The House in Lordship Lane
Author:     A. E. W. Mason
* A Project Gutenberg of Australia eBook *
eBook No.:  0600201.txt
Edition:    1
Language:   English
Character set encoding:     Latin-1(ISO-8859-1)--8 bit
Date first posted:          March 2006
Date most recently updated: December 2007

This eBook was produced by: Jon Jermey

Project Gutenberg of Australia eBooks are created from printed editions
which are in the public domain in Australia, unless a copyright notice
is included. We do NOT keep any eBooks in compliance with a particular
paper edition.

Copyright laws are changing all over the world. Be sure to check the
copyright laws for your country before downloading or redistributing this

This eBook is made available at no cost and with almost no restrictions
whatsoever. You may copy it, give it away or re-use it under the terms
of the Project Gutenberg of Australia License which may be viewed online at

To contact Project Gutenberg of Australia go to

Title:      The House in Lordship Lane
Author:     A. E. W. Mason


MR. RICARDO sat on an iron chair at an iron table outside a bar and drank
with his coffee a sweet and heady liqueur. Yet he was exhilarated "Nobody
would believe it," he said with a little giggle. But it was Brittany and
summer time. "Browsing with Browning in Brittany," he alliterated
wittily, "and so far I have been fortunate enough not to meet James Lee's
wife." Mr. Ricardo was quite alone. He had sent his luggage home from Aix
and with his suit-case, his fine big Rolls-Royce and his chauffeur was
making a roundabout tour through Brittany to Cherbourg; whence by a
transatlantic liner what was to him a preferable entry to England could
be achieved. But the car had lurched and something had broken. For three
days he must stay in this little town with the uncommon name. But his
liner wasn't due at Cherbourg for four days--and it was Brittany and
summer time.

Moreover, this drowsy little square of Lezardrieux, with the raised
terrace at which he sat, the three sides of shops and houses and the
empty fourth, where a steep cliff of sand and bushes dropped to the pool
of the Lezardrieux river, made a sharp appeal to him. It was operatic.
Below the brow of the hill, he could almost hear the conductor tap with
his baton for attention. That boy in the bright red shirt strolling
across the square might at any moment burst into song. But it would only
have made an anti-climax if he had. For the stout, middle-aged woman who
had waddled out from the bar with a big letter in her hand was now at Mr.
Ricardo's elbow. "You gave my estaminet as your address at Lezardrieux,

"I telegraphed it," Mr. Ricardo agreed. "I had not yet found a lodging in
the town."

"Then this letter is for you, perhaps. There is another English

"Captain Mordaunt. Yes. He owns the small yacht in the pool. Perhaps if
you would let me see the letter, I could tell you for which of us it

For the woman, in her desire that so unusual an occurrence as a letter
should not miscarry, was clasping it tightly to her bosom. As she showed
the face of it, Mr. Ricardo recognised the hand which had written it.

"It's for me," he cried with a little whoop of excitement. He snatched the
envelope from her reluctant hand and tore it open. He read:

'My dear friend,

I accuse the reception of your invitation...'

and sat back, reflecting with toleration, "Yes, he would accuse
something--it's his nature to--and I have no doubt that he has signed his
name like a peer of England." He turned, to the back of the letter. There
it was. "Hanaud"--just "Hanaud"--the name of terror.

"Really, really," Mr. Ricardo said to himself and the smile of amusement
passed from his lips.

After all, it was a year since he had invited Chief Inspector Hanaud of
the Paris Sureté to spend a holiday in Grosvenor Square. Hanaud could
have accused the reception of his letter a year ago. But he had not
accused it. He had kept it on the chance that he might want to accuse it
at a later time. And the time had come.

"But I don't know," said Mr. Ricardo indignantly, as he turned to the
lady of the estaminet. "It is Madame Rollard, is it not?"

It certainly was Madame Rollard, as she assured him. But Mr. Ricardo was
not thinking of Madame Rollard. He hit the offending letter with his

"These are not manners."


"I do not keep a lodging house."


"Definitely no." as though she had fathomed his troubles, and at each
shake her body wobbled like a jelly.

"I must consider," said Mr. Ricardo truculently.

"Yes, yes," said Madame. "There must be thought, and no doubt Calvados to
encourage it"; and she waddled back to her bar.

Over his second Calvados, Mr. Ricardo read the rest of Hanaud's letter,
and one sentence in it dispersed all his irritation: "Besides the
holiday, there is a little thing I have to do, a little perplexity I have
to make clear, in which I shall ask for your help." The letter fluttered
down upon Mr. Ricardo's knees, and he drew in a breath and his face lost
ten years of its age. Those little perplexities! Didn't he know them? He
would be insulted, ridiculed, outraged, baffled, humiliated, used. Yet
there would be thrills, excitements, perils. Life would become once more
a topaz instead of a turquoise. He would be helping to track great
criminals to their doom. He and Hanaud, or, more probably, Hanaud and he.

Mr. Ricardo turned again to the letter; and in a few moments sprang to
his feet. Hanaud would travel by the Channel steamer to Dover to-morrow.
He would reach London by five, Grosvenor Square by five-thirty. But here
was Ricardo, marooned in Lezardrieux. He rushed to the Post Office and
sent off a telegram to his housekeeper. If only he were volatile enough
to travel on that same beam! There was a midnight ship from Havre, but he
couldn't reach Havre. He came back into the square. Oh, he couldn't sit
in that iron chair by that iron table for two more days and, frankly,
however much enthusiasm for Brittany might have hidden the truth from him
at the beginning, he did not like Calvados. In despair he walked to the
edge of the square and looked down into the pool. There were fishing
boats drawn up on the beach, fishing boats afloat at anchor, and amongst
them--yes, undoubtedly--a small ketch yacht. The water in the pool was so
deep that the ketch was moored close enough under the hill to escape a
careless eye. But to Mr. Ricardo's envious gaze, the lustrous black paint
of its sides, its white deck and burnished brass were as explicit as a

"If I only owned it," cried Mr. Ricardo, noting, to be sure, how calm was
the air and the sky how cloudless.

And lo! there was a stir upon the deck. The ketch was slowly beginning to
swing her bows towards the sea. Three men clambered from the fo'c'sle,
removed the covers from the sails and the wheel and pulled the dinghy in
to the starboard side.

Mr. Ricardo looked over his shoulder and saw Captain Mordaunt walking
across the square to the path which slanted down the sand cliff to the

"Captain Mordaunt," he said, stepping to his side. Mr. Ricardo remembered
him as a retired Captain of Grenadiers who passed from cocktail party to
cocktail party but had no intimates; a man dissatisfied, jealous, with a
grudge against the world. But there was no sign of discontent about him
now. His face had smoothed out, there was a smile upon his lips, a
friendliness in his manner.

"Yes, Mr. Ricardo."

Ricardo looked down at the river. A hand was sculling the dinghy towards
the beach.

"That is your ketch."

Mordaunt nodded his head.

"Agamemnon," he said with a laugh. "There was a time when trawler-owners
fancied high-sounding names. I didn't change it when I bought her. But I
added a bathroom."

"Very convenient," said Mr. Ricardo primly.

"Inevitable," returned Captain Mordaunt. "Agamemnon without a bathroom?
He would be alive now."

Mr. Ricardo, whose acquaintance with the classics was limited, felt it
prudent to titter. He added: "You are crossing to England?"

Captain Mordaunt became wary. He looked at the sky; he looked at Mr.
Ricardo. "You would like a passage?"


Captain Mordaunt nodded his head.

"Well," he argued thoughtfully, "I have a spare cabin and the boat's
sound and the weather looks good. But it's the fourth week in August and
one can't count on it, and if it should come on to blow, these little
ketches bounce about a bit, and we're very close to the water of

Mr. Ricardo raised a deprecating hand.

"I am something of a yachtsman, too," he said with a smile; comrade to
comrade, as it were.

Indeed, several times Mr. Ricardo had sailed out of and back into
Brightlingsea harbour on the Dutch barge of a friend, and once, on a
smooth clear day of June, he had made the ocean voyage from Ryde to
Weymouth, but when he said that he was a yachtsman, he was undoubtedly
exaggerating. Mordaunt rather obviously doubted but accepted it."

"Thank you," and Mr. Ricardo hurried away to his lodging with a great
show of pleasure.

But the pleasure was evaporating. Had he not, after all, been in a
needless hurry? Who was Hanaud that he could not be left to investigate
by himself for a day? There was no doubt he had been hasty. That was
certainly a very small Agamemnon swinging round in the pool, as
Agamemnons go. Mr. Ricardo had a suspicion that Captain Mordaunt might
have acquired greater merit if, instead of cramming a bathroom into this
very small Agamemnon, he had bought a bigger Agamemnon with a bathroom in
it already.

"Half an hour, Mr. Ricardo," had said Captain Mordaunt.

"Half an hour," Mr. Ricardo had repeated.

He gave instructions and money to his chauffeur, packed his suit-case,
and was waiting on the beach when the nose of the dinghy grounded upon


THE ketch, with her propeller turning, slipped down the ten miles of the
Lezardrieux river between the buoys and the lighthouses, turned eastwards
at the mouth to avoid the sunken slabs, and wriggled out into the open
sea. A steady wind was blowing on her beam. The engine was switched off,
the sails hoisted, the log run out, and the course laid for the Start.
The land sank out of sight.

Captain Mordaunt followed Mr. Ricardo down to the spare cabin in the
stern of the ketch.

"We will dine early, if you don't mind. There are only four of us all
told, the skipper, the mate, the steward and myself, and at night we want
two on deck when we are crossing the Channel, even if the night's fine. I
can, by the way, lend you a thick coat and a yachting cap."

The first sign of any change came, indeed, when they were eating their
dinner, side by side on the cushioned lounge in the little saloon. The
ketch rose and dipped suddenly with a thud, as if it had met some
unexpected swell of the sea and, a few moments later, the sheets of the
mainsail rattled on the deck as the great wing of canvas was drawn in.
Mordaunt looked up at the tell tale compass fixed above his head.

"The wind has shifted to the north," he said.

The yachtsman of the quiet waters looked anxiously at his host. "Is
that"--he searched for a word--"awkward?" he asked, hoping that the tremor
was unnoticeable in his voice. After all, they were a very long way from
the land.

Mordaunt shrugged his shoulders.

"Prolongs our passage. A cigar?" He reached for a box behind on the
shelf. "Try those dates in brandy! We'll have some coffee," and he rang
the hand-bell.

But whilst they drank their coffee, the movement of the ketch increased.
To Mr. Ricardo she seemed now to hop forward and come down with a noisy
crunch. Mordaunt smiled.

"There's some wind somewhere ahead of us," he said. "Let's go up and see.
You had better put that thick coat on."

When they stepped from the tiny deckhouse on to the deck, Mr. Ricardo
was disturbed.

"Glary," said Hamlin the skipper at the wheel; glary it certainly was.
The sun was sinking in the west, a plate without effulgence, a plate as
yellow as an old spade guinea. The kindness had all died out of the sky
and, when the sun had gone, there were left a livid glare, a cold sea and
this little ship alone in the midst of it.

Mordaunt looked up at the topsail.

"We might carry on until we get the weather news," he said. For these
were the days before the Second War, when Broadcasting House flung out
her warnings and good tidings to all the ships on the near seas.

By nine o'clock night was closing in. Mr. Ricardo was seated in a corner
of the deckhouse. Mordaunt leaned over a small receiver mounted on a
revolving pedestal. Hamlin's big figure blocked the doorway as he bent to
listen; and suddenly, startlingly, a new voice spoke clearly out of the
darkness at their elbows, giving them the weather report.

"A deep depression over Ireland is moving rapidly to the south-east.
There will be a gale in the Channel to-night."

"As a rule, that gives us half an hour," said Hamlin. He and Mordaunt
were out of the deck-cabin in an instant, leaving Ricardo almost sick
with indignation against the radiant cheerful voice which had announced
the direful news.

"Doesn't he know we're out here in a cockle-shell?" he exclaimed. "He's
going home to have supper--a nice hot supper in a nice hot room--on land!
And we're here, drowned men practically."

But there was activity enough upon the dick. A storm jib was set, the
topsail taken down and folded away with the big jib in the locker, the
main and mizzen sails were reefed, and the sidelights burning brightly
lifted on their shelves. The ship was snug and her crew clothed in
oilskins and high boots.

Mr. Ricardo stood in the doorway of the cabin looking forward over its
roof. The ketch still rose and dipped upon the unbroken swell, but ahead
in the darkness lines of white ran out to right and left on the crests of
waves with extraordinary speed.

"Here it comes," said Mordaunt. He raised his hand to the mizzen rigging
on the port side. Hamlin, the skipper, was at the wheel, lifting the boat
gently up to the wind. Mordaunt grinned at Ricardo.

"I should go down and get into your bunk whilst you can," he cried.

Mr. Ricardo shook his head. That was quite unthinkable.

"I'll stay in the deckhouse for a little," he said, and then more
bravely, "this is a new experience for me."

He crouched on the divan in the deckhouse with a foot against the
rail-guard of the companion, and a few moments afterwards the gale broke
upon them like an army. A wave smote the ketch so that it shuddered. Its
crest leaped gaily over the port bow and ran in streams along the deck,
whilst the bulk of it roared away to lee ward from under the keel in an
angry tumble of white fire.

"Disappointed, that's what it was," Mr. Ricardo began, but he could not
go on.

For all about them was noise, noise unbelievable and yet combined into an
awful harmony. The waves hammered and roared; the wind shrilled through
the rigging like a Sabbath of lost souls; the planks groaned and
clamoured that not for one moment longer could they cling together; and,
above all other sounds, the topping-lift thrashed the belly of the
mainsail with the crack of a hundred pistols.

Ricardo was terrified into a hopeless acquiescence.

"It can't go on," he said to himself as he clutched at anything which was
clutchable in the deck-cabin. "That's all. It can't go on."

But it did go on, hour after hour, until Mr. Ricardo actually dozed and
then woke to an incident very pleasant but quite incredible. Mordaunt was
at the helm, the skipper by the port rigging, when Mordaunt held the ship
up to meet a more passionately venomous wave than any which had gone
before. The two men bent their heads as the brine cut their faces like a

"That was a nasty one," cried the skipper.

"A beast!" answered Mordaunt; and then, to Ricardo's stupefaction, they
laughed, not with the wry laughter of the defeated, but heartily,

"Well, perhaps, after all..." thought Ricardo. He was glad that he had not
taken Mordaunt's advice and retired to his bunk. He would have been
ice-cold with terror. He couldn't say that it was warm up here in the
deckhouse, but it was friendly, and near to people who could laugh at the
right moment. Again Mr. Ricardo dozed and woke; and now the mate was at
the wheel whilst Mordaunt stood on one side unclenching his frozen
fingers and Hamlin upon the other. Suddenly they all looked up and, as
they looked, a ghostly twilight was diffused about the world. Mr. Ricardo
was in the mood to believe that here at last was the Day of Judgment, so
unillumined was the light, so pallid the faces lifted to it. But the mate
broke the solemnity of the moment by asserting, "'Tis the dawning," and
after both men had stared at him in admiration of his optimism, the
laughter and the raillery were renewed. The mate was the incorrigible
consoler. Somewhere, high up, beyond apprehension, and almost beyond
faith, a full moon was riding in a blue sky and some sliver of its
radiance slipped through. Mr. Ricardo clambered through the doorway and
looked forward over its roof, clinging with both hands. As far as the
eyes could reach, great black seas, like mountains, raced after each
other in a riot of foam, whilst above his head the swaying topmast seemed
on the point of scraping and snapping; a roof of grey cement, so solid
and so low was the canopy of cloud. But whilst he watched the chink
closed up again and once more there was no light but the white fire of
the waves and the more friendly gleam of the binnacle lamp.

Mr. Ricardo scrambled back to his corner in the deckhouse. He pulled up
the cushion behind him so that his head rested more comfortably upon it.

"After all, we're still afloat," he reflected. "I have not been
seasick"--this he put down less to his panic than to his quality as a
yachtsman--"and those three men, though they are unalarmed, are watchful."

They were more than ever watchful now, it seemed. For more and more often
he heard the man in the bows sing out: "Light ahead, sir."

And more and more often the answer from the man at the wheel: "Right!"

For they were crossing now the crown of the great trunk road which flows
from Ushant to the Port of London.

To the sound of those cries Mr. Ricardo fell asleep, and was only
awakened by someone shaking him by the shoulder. Mordaunt was leaning
over him.

"We can see the light at Start Point," he said.

The motion of the ship had diminished, the noise had lost its terror,
they were feeling the protection of the land, the gale was dying. Again
Mr. Ricardo stood at the cabin door and looked forward. All was darkness,
but in a few seconds he saw, as at the end of a long black iron tube, a
faint glimmer which broadened out to the likeness of a beautiful
incandescent moth and shrivelled again into nothing. Mordaunt, at his
side, began to count: "One, two, three.."

He counted up to twenty, and the light shone again.

"Yes, Start Point," said Mordaunt. "But, of course, we're a long way from
it yet."

Mr. Ricardo stayed thereafter at the deckhouse door, and so was a witness
of the incident which made that night more than ever memorable to him and
perplexed the forgotten Hanaud for so long.

A big ancient rusty iron steamer came lumbering up from the west across
the bows of Agamemnon but yawing as she came, as if she had not made up
her mind whether to run ashore on the long ledge of Start Point or strike
away for the French coast.

"Look out, sir!" cried Hamlin, the skipper, sharply to Mordaunt at the
wheel. "She's a dago with the cabin-boy in command and all the rest of
'em asleep."

It was that spectral hour between night and dawn when all is magnified
and yards are miles. Mordaunt held his ketch up until he had shaken what
wind there was out of her sails; and it was lucky that he did, for his
bowsprit hardly scraped clear of the iron monster's side.

"There! I told you, didn't I?" cried Hamlin, and he pointed to where a
light shone on the name upon a buoy. "A dago!"

All could read the name. El Rey. But they had hardly time to read it. For
a cry, like a wail, was borne to them urgently upon the breeze.

Men who sail in little boats are accustomed to see in the dark of the
night and bad weather light on land, where there is no land, and to hear
voices from the sea, where no men are drowning--so accustomed that they do
not speak of them lest they should be thought to talk foolishly. So now
Mordaunt and his crew looked each to the other, hesitating whether they
should seem to have heard. But the cry reached them again, weaker, yet
nearer, and just over the port bow.

The mate shouted, "Hold on!" and cutting a life-buoy loose from the main
rigging, hurled it out. The ketch was lying now, head in to the wind,
with its sails flapping. Hamlin pulled up out of its slots the panel of
bulwark which opened the port gangway and, flinging himself on his face,
leaned over the side. The mate and the steward joined him, one upon his
knees, the other with a boathook in his hands. From his, position at the
wheel Mordaunt could see nothing of what was happening, but something or
someone was being lifted on board.

It was someone, a slim young man with hair as black as ebony, and a face
of a pallor so thick that it could hardly ever before have met the
daylight. So Mordaunt thought, until the rescued man was stretched on
deck. He was alive but snatching at the air in his exhaustion.

He was dressed in a grey cotton shirt, a jacket and a pair of trousers of
canvas, and he wore sandshoes on his naked feet.

"Brandy," said Mordaunt, and the steward dived down the companion. He
came back with a full glass and, lifting the man's shoulders against his
knee, put the glass to his lips. The young man's face was long, his body
where it showed at the neck and breast just bones in an envelope of skin.
He took a drink of the brandy, threw back his head on the steward's knee
and coughed.

"A martyr by El Greco, without a martyr's saintliness," said Mordaunt,
thinking the stranger beyond hearing.

"A dago," said Hamlin the skipper.

The stranger turned his eyes on Hamlin and said: "Damn your eyes!" in
English unmistakable, and fainted away.

Mordaunt gave his orders. "You had better get him below, rub him down
with a hot towel, give, him a spare suit of pyjamas, and put him to bed
in Mr. Ricardo's berth with a hot-water bottle. You don't mind?"

Mr. Ricardo didn't mind. He was, indeed, fluttering around, trying to
help and getting in everybody's way. Meanwhile a question was troubling
his mind as much as he, in his efforts to help, was troubling Craston,
the mate, and the steward. Why did the name of the ship, El Rey--"The
King"--awaken some vague familiar resonance in his brain? El Rey...El
Rey....No, there was no answer.

When he climbed the companion again on to the deck, the light on Start
Point had been extinguished, the day had come, and the ketch had borne
away upon its course.

"Mind the Skerries' buoy, sir," said Hamlin. "The tide's setting us to
the east."

"I know," Mordaunt answered; and after a moment or two, Hamlin continued:
"A queer thing. That young-fellow-my-lad must have tumbled off the stern
of that ship just as she began to cross our bows. The tide brought him
straight down on us. A bit of good luck, I should say."

Mordaunt grinned and shook his head.

"A bit of good timing, I should."

And with that Mr. Ricardo's memory began to work. El Rey! He had read
about it. Certain States of South America had chartered El Rey--Venezuela,
Colombia, Bolivia--to carry back to their respective countries some
undesirable aliens. She was to call at Spanish and French ports and in
England. Then she was to go on with the rest of her passengers to the
Baltic and Germany. There lay the explanation of something which had
puzzled them, all, but of which no one had spoken. The stranger had a
broad black band about his right leg above the ankle, as though a heavy
iron fetter had for years bitten into his flesh.


MORDAUNT dropped his anchor in the Dart river above the ferry which
crosses from Dartmouth town and the railway station at Kingswear. The
morning was clear, but neither town was yet alert to it. Mordaunt felt in
one of the pigeon-holes at the back of the deckhouse and drew out of it a
plain yellow flag.

"Here you are!" he said and Hamlin took it from his hand. It was the flag
flown by every vessel hailing straight from a foreign port, and no one,
whether passenger or crew, must leave her until the harbour authorities
had given her clearance. Hamlin, the skipper, balanced the folded flag on
the palm of his hand. He was thinking that Captain Mordaunt and his
Agamemnon had sailed in and out of Dartmouth so often that no one on
shore would trouble about his port of departure unless the yellow flag
invited him.

"I am to hoist this?" he asked, thrusting out his under-lip.

Mordaunt nodded his head and added slowly, "Yes."

"You've a good deal to do, Captain Mordaunt, haven't you? You have to lay
up the boat, travel to London, settle your affairs for a long absence..."

"Still," Mordaunt interrupted, "there are rules."

They were both thinking of the stranger with the black band above his
ankle who in the misty dawn had come aboard.

"He'll have to report, of course, when the Customs men come on board,"
said Mordaunt. "I don't see why I should be delayed."

Hamlin was still patting doubtfully the piece of bunting in his hand. It
was clearly important that Mordaunt should not be held up in the Dart
river by regulations at this time. Mordaunt spoke quickly.

"I'll wake him up, whilst you hoist that"; and Mordaunt had only reached
the bottom of the companion when the yellow flag flickered up the mast
like a flame.

The stranger, however, wanted no awakening. He was sitting, shaved and
dressed, down to his shoes, in clothes which belonged to Mordaunt.

"Your steward lent me these," he said.

"And he was quite right," Mordaunt returned with a smile.

A box full of cigarettes and an ash-tray were lying on the table and
Mordaunt pushed the box over to the stranger. "Don't you smoke?"

"Indeed, I do."

"Then try one, please!"

There was something vulpine in the speed of the stranger's thin long
fingers as they darted towards the box; but it was not so startling as
the control which stopped them at the rim of the box and set them tapping
out a bar of a tune before they dropped languidly on one of the paper
tubes. Yet he was starving for a cigarette! So, at all events, Mr.
Ricardo decided, as he sat unnoticeable reading, or pretending to read,
an official report taken from the bookcase above his head; and so, too,
had decided. He said pleasantly:

"You should have helped yourself."

The man from the sea shook his head and laughed.

"That would have put me at too heavy a disadvantage."

He struck a match and lit his cigarette and, as he drew the smoke into
his lungs, he uttered a little moan of delight. "Oh...oh!"

He looked at the brand on the tube. "Turkish."


The stranger inhaled with his eyes closed. How many years had passed
since this enjoyment had been allowed to him? Mr. Ricardo wondered. But,
indeed, it was more than an enjoyment, however sensuous. It seemed to
take from him the suspicion, the fear, the expectation of an enemy in
everyone, which Mr. Ricardo had observed. He sat there smoking, a man
repaired. Mordaunt, with a glance of amusement at him, opened a drawer in
the table.

"I have got something to say to you--by the way, my name's Mordaunt,
Philip Mordaunt--"

He paused for a moment, and for more than a moment afterwards there
followed a disconcerting silence. Then the stranger replied: "And mine is
Devisher--Bryan Devisher."


Mordaunt took from the drawer which he had opened a letter-case and
counted out fifteen pounds in notes.

"Before we talk," he said, "I should be happier if we were on still more
equal terms. Will you borrow these from me?"

Upon the white face a flush slowly spread. "Philip Mordaunt, you said?"

"Yes--Captain," and seeing that Devisher's eyes were wandering about the
cabin, Mordaunt lifted a blotting pad with some paper upon it, placed
them in front of him, and added a pencil from the table drawer. He gave
the name of a club.

Devisher wrote down the address, tucked the paper away in a pocket, and
did the same with the money.

"Thank you!" he said; and as there had been no patronage in the offer, so
there was no servility in the acceptance.

"Now!" said Mordaunt. He was sitting on the couch against the saloon wall
with its lockers and its high ledge, whilst Devisher was on a chair at
the head of the table at his right hand. "Now, the position is this. No
one must leave this ship until the Customs officers come on board. They
won't be here probably for another hour. It's hardly eight yet. But when
they do come, you ought to make a full statement to them."

"I see, yes," Devisher observed, staring down at the mahogany table. He
could not keep the bitterness out of his voice, which already had a
natural rasp, but he could, according to Mr. Ricardo, hide thus the
savage fury of his eyes. "That I fell overboard, for instance."


"Without a passport."


"From the ship, El Rey."


It was as evident to Devisher as to Ricardo on the opposite side of the
saloon, that "the ship El Rey" meant no more to Mordaunt than information
of a merely formal kind.

"With the black mark of a fetter so wide and deep around my ankle, that I
am likely to wear it to the day of my death."

Mr. Ricardo sat up. No, no, he said to himself. Every word up till now
had been inspired by the right spirit and used in the right place. But
this reference to the chain by the man who had worn it--no, no! A lack of
susceptibility to the higher tastes, an indelicacy. Fie, fie, Mr.

Apparently, however, Captain Mordaunt was unconscious of any want of tact
in his guest. He laughed as frankly as Devisher had spoken.

"That's your affair. I don't see how the Customs could make any charge,
whether you declared it or not."

The words were lightly said but not lightly taken. Devisher had so far
kept to the same unemotional key, but now he clapped his hands to his
face and he shivered like a man stricken with a mortal chill. Mordaunt
drew back in discomfort.

"I must tell you," cried Devisher violently, plucking his hands away from
his face; and Mordaunt's discomfort increased. A scene--he had a horror of
it, he had been at every shift he knew to avoid it.

"My name is Devisher, Bryan Devisher, yes. But it's not the name on my
passport in the purser's cabin on El Rey."

"Then you give your real name here," Mordaunt interrupted, but the
interruption went almost unheard and certainly not considered.

"I took part in a revolution over there in Venezuela," the young man
rushed on, the words almost tumbling in a froth like a breaker from his
mouth. "And it was high time, I can tell you. A revolution was wanted,
but it failed. Vicente Gomez, the dictator won, as he always did. I lay
quiet up in Caracas, but I was betrayed--and I think I know, too, who
betrayed me. I spent six years dragging an iron cannon-ball in the
Castilo del Libertador, an island prison in the bay with its cells below
the water-line. Six mortal years until Vicente Gomez died. Then we were
released. I forget how many tons of iron fetters and handcuffs were
thrown into the sea. But after a time, when this ship El Rey was
chartered, I was deported."

To both his auditors the story was true. The white mask of Devisher's
face, which had felt neither sun nor wind for years, bore out his words,
apart from the black ring about his ankle. And the horrors which they
suggested were stark before their eyes.

"But we have a Minister there, a Consul," cried Mr. Ricardo.

"You could have appealed to them," added Mordaunt.

Devisher shrugged his shoulders.

"Not a chance! I hadn't made myself known to any of them whilst I could.
Besides..." and his eyes fell sullenly and, after a moment or two, a
displeasing sly smile twisted his face.

But Mordaunt had had enough. The sly smile had put a full stop at the end
of all this palaver. Confessions were for the priest in the curtained
darkness of his confessional box, not for the tiny saloon of a ketch in
the river Dart on an August morning. He rose to his feet.

"No, no!" he exclaimed, and he rang a hand-bell vigorously.

The steward appeared from the pantry forward before Devisher could add
another word.

"I want a hot bath, Perry, and then we'll all want breakfast."

Breakfast, that was what they wanted. They would be different men with
some good hot bacon and eggs and coffee inside of them. He heard the
water begin to run from the taps in the bathroom beyond his tiny cabin on
his right. He stood for a moment, seized by a fresh idea. He sat down,
took a block of notepaper, envelopes, and a fountain pen out of the

"Yes, whilst I am waiting, I'll write a letter"; and, pulling the
blotting pad towards him, he began to write, slowly, selecting his words,
a very still figure, so that no one interrupted him; Devisher perhaps
because his outburst had been silenced, Ricardo certainly because he was
trying to reconcile this Captain Mordaunt with the Mordaunt against whom
he had brushed at so many six o'clock sherry parties. Then he had been a
flibbertigibbet of a man, querulous, caustic, defeated, the sort of man
who sees others of his age leaving him behind, making their names, and
complains, "If only I could find my vocation, they'd soon be surprised."
But now he had authority, he was solidly sure, and it was not because he
was captain of his boat and knew how to sail it. Even at Lezardrieux, Mr.
Ricardo had discovered serenity and consequently a good-humour in him
which were new.

"Well, I shall get to the bottom of that," he thought cheerfully. For Mr.
Ricardo counted himself a very acute observer of character.

Mordaunt had finished his letter by the time when the steward told him
his bath was ready. He folded it, put it into an envelope and addressed
the envelope. Then he got to his feet.

"You'll please begin breakfast as soon as it's brought in. I'm not going
to hurry"; and he suddenly turned to Devisher. "You may have many
troubles and few friends in front of you, for all I know. I should like
to help you because you came to me out of the sea."

"Meerschaum," Devisher interposed, "but not half as valuable."

Mordaunt was not to be diverted.

"But I shan't be in England. So I can't. But this man can, if anyone
can," and he handed the letter he had written to Devisher. "He's old,
crotchety, very much eighteen-seventy, but he's wise, and if you tell him
everything, he may throw you another life-buoy."

He waited for no answer. Devisher heard the door of the cabin close
whilst he was still reading the address upon the envelope. He repeated
the name aloud on a note of perplexity.

"Septimus Crottle, Esq."

Mr. Ricardo, who had been rent between curiosity and the obligation of
gentlemanly reticence, gave a little jump. Devisher seemed to become
aware of Mr. Ricardo.

"Do you know him?"

"Septimus Crottle?

"Who else?"

"No, I do not."

"Yet you jumped when I read the name."

"Did I?" Mr. Ricardo beamed. He liked people to find significance in his

"You did, but it doesn't matter."

Mr. Ricardo was nettled.

"It might matter," said he stiffly.

"Indeed?" Devisher smiled as he spoke, but with a polite indifference.

"Septimus Crottle is the owner of the Dagger Line of Steamships," said
Mr. Ricardo.

The indifference passed from Devisher's face.


MORDAUNT stripped himself of his suede jerkin, his high sea-boots, and
the rest of his defences against a gale, and slipped into the bath. After
the buffeting of sea and wind, the velvet caress of hot fresh water was a
delight for a Roman emperor. He shaved in it, soaped his limbs, and
emptied his sponge again and again over his head, wondering whether there
could be anything as good as living hard and bathing soft. But it was
Agamemnon's bath. It is true that no lady with a meat axe was secretly
opening the bathroom door, no lads of the village listening timidly in
the road were wailing "Ai, ai! That was a nasty one!" as the axe was
heftily administered. But it was still, in its way, fateful. Mordaunt lay
and relaxed his sinews and steeped his limbs and closed his eyes--and
opened them und closed them again. From far away there was a splash of
sculls, the grating of a rowing boat against a ship's side, and then a
voice, thin and small, as though it spoke through a hundred folds of grey
silk, but cheerful:

"So here you are, back again, Aggy boy."

Mordaunt assured himself solemnly that Aggy Boy was not a name.

"I propose to see about that," and he was apparently still proposing to
see about it, when a hammering upon the door aroused him. The steward's
voice spoke urgently:

"Your breakfast's getting cold, Captain Mordaunt."

And Mordaunt realised that what was happening to his breakfast had
happened to his bath. He climbed out of it with a shiver, and in a
quarter of an hour, and in a shore-going blue suit, he was sitting down
in the saloon to a breakfast fresh from the stove.

Mr. Ricardo at the other side of the cabin was smoking a cigarette.

"Do you mind this whilst you're eating?" he asked, waving it.

"Not a bit," answered Mordaunt. Suddenly he cried out: "Where is

"He has gone, I think."

Mordaunt rose and called up the companion for Hamlin, and Hamlin came
down, contentedly smiling.

"Mr. Devisher?" Mordaunt asked abruptly.

"It's just like this, sir. The Customs didn't come on board, knowing of
us well, but just passed the time of day. The two gentlemen were down in
the saloon, but soon afterwards the--I can't fit my tongue to his name--the
passenger from the foreign ship comes up. I was hauling down the yellow
flag, and he asks what he should do now. I showed him the
harbour-master's office by the slipway, and he said he would go and
report if he could be put ashore. There was a boatman sculling about for
a job So I called him up to the gangway and off the gentleman went."

Mordaunt looked not too pleased.

"Just like that?" he said. "Without a word?

"Oh, yes, sir. He said you were in your bath and not to be disturbed. He
said he'd write to you."

Mordaunt laughed.

"All right," he said, and went on with his breakfast. "After all, he has
saved us some trouble."

"And some delay," Hamlin added quickly. "We should have been kept here
all day, telling the same story over and over."

It was clear both to Mordaunt and Ricardo that the skipper had edged
Devisher over the yacht's side as soon as he got the chance, guessing
that the last place Devisher would visit would be the harbour-master's
office, or the office of any other functionary of the port. Mordaunt,
however, was really troubled--and once more to Mr. Ricardo's surprise; Mr.
Ricardo could see him at a cocktail party a year ago, overshouting some
other gossip to tell his story with a sardonic amusement--lest he had let
loose an equivocal person, if not a bandit, on the world.

"Well, he has gone," said Mordaunt at last.

"With your letter to Mr. Septimus Crottle," Mr. Ricardo added; and now
Mordaunt laughed without any reservation.

"Old Septimus can take it," he cried. "Besides, I shall see Septimus on
Sunday night, and that's before he will."

Mordaunt took a cigar from a mahogany box and split the end of it by the
squeeze of his finger and thumb. He lit it and sat back smiling, as if
the picture of Septimus Crottle banished the picture of a bandit.

"Do you know Crottle? The queerest old bird. Owns the Dagger Line, and
was once a commander--a tyrant in a reefer jacket then, and a tyrant in a
broadcloth frock-coat now. Choked off any young men who came after one
of his daughters, not because they were gold-diggers, but because it was
the business of maidens to wait upon their fathers."

"Amiable patriarch," said Mr. Ricardo.

"Patriarch, yes; amiable, no," Mordaunt returned, and laughed again. "You
should see him on his Sunday nights. In his glory! But he's shrewd, too.
And he'd do you a good turn--" Mordaunt paused, "that is, if you acted on
his advice, of course. You see, he's never in doubt."

Mordaunt was no longer deriding the comic aspect of Septimus Crottle. Mr.
Ricardo suspected, indeed, that he was to hear the explanation of that
change in Mordaunt which had so perplexed him. There was a confusion, a
hesitation, in Mordaunt's manner.

"I never told you how I came across old Septimus, did I? But, of course,
I didn't. I was on this ketch in the Helford river. A great sailor of
small boats had built his home there, and a few of us used to anchor
about his house for his birthday. There were four or five yachts anchored
in the pool above and below and opposite to Helford village. Septimus
came in a schooner with more draught than any of our boats, and anchored
down the river at Passage. Well, that evening--I don't know what made me
do it--I had seen him in the garden that afternoon, an old boy, straight
as a flagstaff, without any inhibitions; and there he was, once the
commander of a ship, now the owner of the Dagger Line. So that night I
sent an excuse from a party on one of the yachts, dined alone, and
afterwards sculled in my dinghy down to the schooner at Passage."

He had found Septimus seated in the shelter of his deck-cabin, with a rug
about his waist and a trifle suspicious that an upstanding young fellow
should row away from a golden company to pass an hour with a solitary old
crab-apple. Septimus Crottle did not ask his new companion why, but he
gave him a large Havana cigar and, as Mordaunt drew a lighter from his
pocket, he objected.

"Will you use the box of wooden matches at your elbow, please."

Mordaunt turned round. A small table had been, placed noiselessly beside
his chair with an ash-tray upon it and a box of Bryant and May's matches.
So much reverence for a cigar seemed to Mordaunt to call for a response,
and as he smoked, it certainly did.

"This really is a wonderful cigar, Mr. Crottle," said Mordaunt, pitching
his praise high.

"It is the best," returned Mr. Crottle, simply and sufficiently. "It's

Philip did not feel that his impulse had been fruitful. On the other
hand, the old man, with his sharp nose and his lean chin, seemed quite
content that the younger man should sit by his side and say nothing. The
tide sang against the planks of the schooner. Up in the pool by Helford
village the lights of the yachts threw out from their skylights a glow of
jewels cased in black velvet. From one, a woman's voice, fresh and clear
as a blackbird's in the dew of the morning, soared in a delight which
knocked against the stars; and Mordaunt found himself pouring out in a
low voice the story of his distress, the twistings and turnings in a
world where he had lost his way.

He had resigned his commission when one of the youngest captains, after
the 1914-18 war, meaning to think over his life and plan what he should
do. He might go into Parliament. He had a house and land in Dorset where
there was an opportunity. Or he might go into business--big business--in
the City. Or he might write--a comedy which would endure with "The Way of
the World" an epic, perhaps, which would stand on the same shelf with
"The Ring and the Book" a novel which would make people cry Fielding
Redivivus. Meanwhile, he did nothing. Some day he would begin, when he
was quite sure of the road which led to greatness. But meanwhile he ran
about from party to party, talking with other young men and women of the
fine thing he was going to do. But one after another the young men passed
him into a different and busier country. One was elected to the House of
Commons, and made a first speech which was the talk of the town. A second
wrote a play which stirred the critics and filled the theatre for a year.
A third wrote a book which was bought as well as read. They would all
come back, of course, as their squibs flickered out. But they didn't come
back, and there was he, still wandering from party to party, jealous,
dissatisfied, hollow as an empty tin. Septimus Crottle listened whilst
the stars slid down the sky and the lights went out in the yachts in the
pool. Then he said quietly: "Great authors! To me they are the
loud-speakers of God." He turned to Mordaunt. "Are you of their company?"

"How should I know?" Mordaunt asked after a pause.

"They have their labels."

"For instance?

"They think less of the name they make than of the work they do."

Mordaunt laughed curtly. Admit that, and he was ruled out! But how could
he not admit that?

"Well, I asked for it," he told himself, and thought that he might just
as well, like Oliver, ask for more. So he said, rather arrogantly:
"Perhaps there are other labels."

Old Crottle was quite unimpressed by his young friend's curling lip.

"Of course." And after a glance at Mordaunt, Septimus looked out over the
dark water, selecting one which would be most suitable.

"They don't nurse long grievances," he said. "They are too busy creating.
They curse and damn for five minutes and then they get on with their

For the second time that night Philip Mordaunt took it on the point of
his chin. He took a whisky and soda afterwards and hoped that he had not
obtruded too long between Mr.Crottle and his repose.

Mr. Crottle, however, confessed to having been flattered by Philip
Mordaunt's visit.

"Besides," he said, standing at the gangway, "everybody enjoys giving
advice, as long as he's quite certain that the advice isn't what the
advised had come to hear."

Mordaunt halted on the first rung of the ladder and stepped on board

"Yes," he said in some surprise, "the curious thing is that I'm not
discouraged. On the contrary, I am relieved."

The sense of relief stayed with Mordaunt as he sculled back to his yacht,
and was no less strong the next morning. Old Septimus had banged the door
on a good many dreams which of late were darkening into torments. He had
left Mordaunt to find another door for himself, and it was evident to Mr.
Ricardo that somehow Mordaunt had succeeded.

Philip looked up at the clock on the wall behind the stove as he ended
his story.

"You'll want to catch the Torbay Limited," he continued. "There it is, in
Kingswear station. Hamlin will land you at the steps and put your bag in
your carriage. I am sorry that I couldn't give you a better passage from


ON that afternoon, Mr. Horbury, Member of Parliament for the Kempston
Division of London, walked from the House of Commons to his office at a
few minutes after four. He had done two useful things t for himself, and
perhaps for his country. He had asked a question and he had voted in a
division. The division took place on the Government's need to occupy the
whole time of the sitting, and was a daily affair, occurring just after
questions were concluded. Thus a shrewd man, and no one had ever denied
shrewdness to Mr. Horbury, could well within the compass of an hour
establish proofs of his stern determination to fulfil his duties towards
his constituents and the State. That the division was a formality,
mattered nothing; that he would not be present to vote upon the serious
question for which the Government claimed the whole sitting, mattered
less. He had had his name duly noted down on the division list, and it
was the division a day which kept the opponent away and confirmed the
constituents in the belief that they had chosen the best sort of man to
represent them.

Mr. Horbury, having thus done his duty, ambled across St. James's Park to
his office in King Street. He was a heavily-lipped, short-legged, obese
man who walked like a pigeon, crossing his toes. He was not noticeable
indeed unless he raised his head, and then the big red face on its bull
neck startled one. For his head, down to a line just below the eyes, was
massive as an emperor's, and the strong eyes were noble. But below the
eyes a curious blend of the animal and the insignificant disgraced his
features. His nose, for in stance, was small and round, his upper lip
long, and the swollen jaw not so much massive as brutal--the jaw of a
great ape welded to the brow of a Caesar, set upon a torso of so slovenly
a vulgarity that the man almost escaped the curiosity of the passers-by.
But there were some to whom he was unknown, people no doubt a little more
sensitive than their neighbours, who felt a chill if he approached, like
that cold aura which, in the legends of the Sabbaths, enfolded the person
of Satan. Mr. Horbury walked clumsily and slowly, round the water where
the pigeons imitated his progress, to the Marlborough Gate, through a
dark and exclusive arcade, and so to his fine panelled offices in King

Mr. Horbury was uneasy. There was a certain danger to be eliminated. Not
so very serious a danger. Daniel Horbury was accustomed to navigating
shoals still more menacing than the shoals of Lezardrieux. But, in order
to eliminate the danger of this afternoon, Horbury would have to
relinquish a victim, a victim plump and ripe, the fruit of a golden tree,
and Mr. Horbury had the greatest detestation of such sacrifices. He went
through the outer office into his own sanctuary. It was panelled with
rosewood. The deep arm-chairs were cushioned with a dark red damask. A
great walnut writing-table, shaped in an arc and fashioned in the days of
Queen Anne, with, the carved pigeon-holes and little doors of its period,
decorated the centre of an Aubusson carpet.

Mr. Horbury paused for a moment upon the threshold, consoled for his
uneasy reflections by the sheen and costliness of his surroundings.

"Not many offices like this, Foster," he said to a clerk who was reading
out a list of names at his elbow.

"No, sir."

Foster was an old-fashioned clerk from Gracechurch Street and knew Big
Business to be more generally associated with worn linoleum, upright
Victorian chairs, and ink-stained writing-tables.

"Will you see Mr. Ricardo at five-thirty?"

"Mr. Ricardo?"

Horbury became very still. Mr. Ricardo! He had never heard of a Mr.
Ricardo. And the unknown was always dangerous.

"It is not convenient," said Horbury. "This afternoon I don't wish to be

Horbury shut the door. On the writing-table lay the last edition of the
Evening Standard. He approached it with a careful carelessness, for there
are times when a prudent man will play-act even to himself alone. He
turned the pages as though they were of little interest, and came
willy-nilly to the shipping news. There, at the very head of the column,
the announcement stood:

"El Rey from South American ports passed Prawle Point at 6 a.m."

Mr. Horbury expected the announcement, yet he was taken aback. Providence
should have intervened, as Providence had often dutifully done, in Mr.
Horbury's affairs. There were, however, occasions when Providence, though
willing, wanted just a trifle of help. Horbury must, in the parliamentary
phrase, explore the avenues. He went to a cupboard and opened it. Two
shelves were disclosed. On the first stood half-a-dozen glasses and a
small wire-cutter; on the lower half a dozen swelling bottles with a
golden-yellow foil guarding the mushroom-headed corks and a famous year
on a printed strip.

The pop of the cork was heard by the clerks and no longer provoked even
the office humorist to imitate the sound of liquid hissing into a glass.

Horbury, in his sanctuary, drank half of his bottle. He lifted the
receiver from the hook of his telephone and dialled LED 0045. In a little
while he heard a door close noisily and, upon the closing of the door, an
eager, wooing voice.

"Is that you, Beautiful?"

Mr. Horbury smiled, showing all his teeth to the gums, but he used a
pleasant voice.

"No, not more so than usual. It's just plain Daniel Horbury speaking."

At the other end of the line there was silence. Daniel Horbury really
smiled this time as he pictured to himself a man shocked into
speechlessness and grey with fear.

"You got my message?" Horbury continued.


"Sorry I use your private number."

"Who gave it to you?"

Horbury made a joke. At least it seemed a joke at the time.

"Mr. Ricardo," he returned. It was the last name which he had heard when
he entered his office, and he rang off before another question could be
put to him.

Mr. Horbury finished off his bottle of champagne, leaning back in his
chair with his short legs crossed under his walnut table. He was tempted,
indeed, to commemorate the name of Mr. Ricardo with a second bottle.
After all, he was wont to argue, as long as you don't begin before eleven
o'clock in the morning, champagne can't do you much harm. It gives a
sparkle to your plans and delays their over-hasty execution.

But to-day execution was needed. He pushed his chair back, unlocked a
drawer and lifted out of it a small chart set flat with drawing-pins upon
a thin ebony board. Five black pins were stuck in the chart, and now
Horbury added a sixth, just seven miles west of Start Point where, at six
o'clock on that morning, El Rey had lumbered past the Prawle Signal
Station on her journey to Thames' mouth. Horbury replaced the map in the
drawer. He then called up his flat in Park Lane. He asked for his wife,
and when she spoke to him there was suddenly another man at Horbury's
desk, one with a laugh in his eyes as well as on his lips, and even a
throb of music in his voice.

"Olivia--that's you? Yes, and the sound of you drives everything else out
of my head--listen now, it's urgent--oh, by the way, I heard you called
beautiful less than half an hour ago--oh, I needn't have rung you up to
tell you that?--you haven't got it at all--I heard you addressed as
‘Beautiful’ over a private line," and he chuckled comfortably. There came
back to him a tiny cry.

"You've been reading my letters!"

"Would I?" cried Horbury indignantly. "The number was given to me by a
Mr. Ricardo."


"A Mr. Ricardo. But don't go away. This is serious. We must go down to
Lordship Lane to-night. At least, I must, and I do hope you will. We are
free to-night, aren't we?"

In a room overlooking Hyde Park a woman half the age of the Obese Romeo
in King Street listened and smiled. "Yes, I'll come," and again Romeo was

"We might sleep there, don't you think? It'll be the full moon. You know
how the big oaks with their black shadows make crazy patterns on the
meadow; and all the birds aren't dumb at the end of August when you're

It was commonplace raillery, but whoever had seen Olivia Horbury, with a
tender smile trembling upon her lips, might well have addressed her as

"What's the plan?" she asked.

"Will you drive the small car and pick me up here at seven-thirty? We
might dine at the Milan Grill, and get to the house at half-past nine.
And somewhere about half-past ten I'll lock the front door, and we shall
be alone in that lovely silence--Beautiful."

He could hear the deep breath she drew and wanted no other answer. He
rang off and settled himself to compose a speech for the September rally
in his constituency. Then he bathed, shaved, and dressed for the evening
in a dinner jacket. He was hardly ready before Foster announced to him
that Mrs. Horbury was waiting for him. He sent the commissionaire out to
the car with the chart, bidding him ask Mrs. Horbury to take care that
the pins were not displaced; and he took from a secret drawer in the
Queen Anne bureau a large sealed envelope which just fitted into the
inside pocket of his jacket.

He slipped on his overcoat and stood once more upon the threshold,
looking here and there about the room. He was merely admiring its sheen
and costliness. It did not occur to him that he would never see it again.


MR. RICARDO arrived in London at half-past three. He had slept in the
train and was looking forward to giving his friend, Monsieur Hanaud, over
a charming little dinner for two, quite a comical account of his night's
adventure on the mail ship Agamemnon, plying between Brittany and the

But, alas! though he rehearsed the scene diligently, letting the real
terrifying danger leak through the amusing episodes, making much of the
mate's miscalculation of the dawn, it was good work wasted. Only Hanaud's
suit-case arrived in Grosvenor Square in time for dinner.

With the bag, however, there was a note of eastern abasement, written
hastily in pencil at Victoria Station. Hanaud had a telephone call and a
visit to make, and he must attend a conference after that with
Superintendent Maltby, who would keep him to dinner.

Mr. Ricardo was torn between testiness and gratitude. On the one hand he
had, in order to fulfil the duties of a host, endured through a long,
dark night the impact of those black, snow-crested waves. On the other
hand, even as he spread his napkin over his knees, his eyes closed and
his head nodded. Mr. Ricardo, in fact, was exhausted, and as soon as the
formula of his dinner was complete, he rang for his butler.

"Thompson, I shall go to bed. You will see when Monsieur Hanaud comes in
that he has everything he wants. You will ask him what he would like for
his breakfast. For me, after my usual breakfast upstairs at eight, I
shall come down at nine-thirty. Will you please tell him?"

"Certainly, sir." And Mr. Ricardo, revived by a glass of old port,
majestically ascended the stairs Not every one in Grosvenor Square had
passed the last night battling in a cockle-shell against a gale. There had
been times when Monsieur Hanaud had treated him lightly. Those times had
gone. Let him give heed now! Let him give heed and listen!

And how right Mr. Ricardo was! If Hanaud had received one hint of the
fine story of Agamemnon and his bath, he would have fled from
Superintendent Maltby and the dubious dishes of Soho to the fastidious
menu at Grosvenor Square.

Yet Mr. Ricardo, for all his fatigue, slept not so well. At some hour,
about which he did not trouble himself to be precise, he was aroused by
one of those penetrating conversations in whispers which people use when
they are trying not to wake their neighbours.

"Really, really," Mr. Ricardo murmured drowsily. "If they would only talk
quietly, I should still be asleep. But those gasps and hisses remind me
of the early days of the Underground, or of First Nights when villains
were villains. I can hear every word."

Addressing thus the emptiness of the room, he did gather that Monsieur
Hanaud had arrived and wished to be called early the next morning.

"There is a telephone, of course, in my bedroom?"

A pause followed, a stately pause, meant to tell Hanaud exactly where he
got off. It was followed by Thompson's most glacial voice.

"I think, sir, you must have forgotten that Mr. Ricardo is sensitive to

"Ah! He would be!"

"There are three telephone instruments in the house, sir. One in the
staff's quarters on its own line. There is a second one in the hall. From
that, again, there is an extension to a third instrument in the library.
I think if you are intending to confer with Scotland Yard during the
hours of darkness, the hall telephone would be the less disturbing."

Certainly, Mr. Ricardo reflected with pleasure, Thompson has the most
dignified modes of expression, and he fell asleep. But at some later
moment, he lay again in the half-way house between consciousness and
dreams and seemed to hear a muffled foot glide by his door and down the
stairs. But Thompson had been wrong.

Although the library was beneath Mr. Ricardo's bedroom, the floor was of
Cubitt's making, so that no sound reached to the room above. On the other
hand, the hall was less furnished, it was hollow, and noises rose from
it. Thus Mr. Ricardo heard a whirr, and another, and another.

"The district," he thought.

Then came four twirls of the dial.

"The number," he continued, and, adopting Thompson's phrase, he explained
the matter with a smile "Hanaud is conferring with Scotland Yard during
the hours of darkness."

That Thompson, being wrong in the matter of resonance might also be wrong
in the destination of Hanaud's message, he was far too sleepy to argue.
He heard no words, he drifted away into another world where Agamemnon
rose out of a black sea with a huge telephone machine in his hand, and
cried "It's the dawning." Mr. Ricardo was aware of nothing thereafter
until the curtain-rings rattled and the blinds were drawn up and his cup
of tea was steaming by his bedside.

He dressed deliberately. The mere fact that his friend had arrived that
morning neither hurried nor halted him. He descended to his library at
nine-thirty, and was surprised. For bending over a copy of The Times sat
Monsieur Hanaud, attired for an English day in the country. He wore a
rough suit of bright yellow, football stockings, and mountaineering
boots. To Mr. Ricardo his appearance was delightful as well as amusing.
Even the familiar blue paper-case of black cigarettes was pleasant to his
eyes, and he sniffed the acrid fumes as a Malayan returning to his native
country after a long absence might sniff his first doerian.

"You have waited for me to share your work. That is kind."

But Hanaud, after greetings of a warmer character than Mr. Ricardo was
used to or, indeed, desired, exclaimed dolefully:

"But there is no work to share. There never was very much. Just a little
affair to be privately arranged which would do justice to a certain
Parisian and at the same time give me a chance to meet my friend. But..."
and before he could even shrug his shoulders the telephone bell rang.

"I tell you afterwards," said Hanaud as Ricardo lifted the receiver to
his ear.

Ricardo confirmed it with a nod. "The message is for you."

Hanaud took the receiver from Ricardo.

"'Allo, 'Allo! Ah, it is the admirable Maltby! Yes, I listen with both my
ears. So!"

And Ricardo saw the look upon his friend's face change from attention to
stupefaction. Hanaud held the ear-piece close against his ear. Finally he
spoke. "In half an hour? Yes I will come. I thank you" and very slowly he
replaced the receiver upon its stand. To Ricardo, watching his friend's
face, the room had lost its comfort. It had become very still, very cold.

"You knew him?" Hanaud asked.


"Daniel Horbury."

Ricardo started. "I know of him," he replied. "Who in London didn't?" He
added cautiously: "I will give you, my friend, some information. It is
said that the police are on his heels."

"Oh! no, no! The information is wrong," cried Hanaud. "He has no heels.
He is a shark."

Mr. Ricardo looked sourly at his friend from the Surete. He must always
have the last word.

"Well, what has Daniel Horbury done now?" Mr.Ricardo asked sulkily.

"Ah, that is it," said Hanaud, nodding his head.

"What is what?

"He has cutted his throat."

Mr. Ricardo pushed back his chair. "Dead?”

"Last night," Hanaud added gloomily. "I shall go to the house. Yes. But
is it worth while? To have Hanaud looking about the room? Yes, the good
superintendent thinks well of it. 'He may see something, that piece of
quicksilver, which we do not, to explain this suicide.' But for me, it's
a tragedy." He threw up his hands in despair.

"How so?"

"There were two rogues who cheated a Parisian years ago. One Horbury, the
second a younger man just released from prison and deported from South
America. Without them both, we have not the evidence. With them both, we
don't want the prosecution. We want the money repaid. Now Horbury has
slitted his throat, and the man from South America..."

"Bryan Devisher," said Ricardo carelessly.

"Yes," replied Hanaud, "that's the.." He stopped, staring at Ricardo with
his mouth open. Never had Ricardo enjoyed such a triumph. His blood sang
proudly in his veins. But outwardly he was as negligent as before.

"What of Bryan Devisher?" he asked.

"He was drownded dead yesterday morning..."

"Off the Start Lighthouse from the ship El Rey," Mr. Ricardo interrupted.

Hanaud nodded gloomily.

"I had made arrangements for a little talk with Devisher after he had
landed. Then we go to Horbury together and he pays the bill. But now
Horbury has slitted his throat and Devisher is drownded."

"But Devisher is not drowned dead."

Hanaud looked at him with awe. Then he seized the telephone and dialled
with ferocity, speaking the while to his companion.

"You will come with me to the house of Daniel Horbury? Yes," and into the
mouthpiece "It is Hanaud. Could I speak to Mister the Superintendent
Maltby? "--and so again to Ricardo "You will use your car, yes? And you
shall tell me about this Devisher as we go. Is that you, Maltby? I am
staying here in the Grosvenor Square with a dear friend who, I can tell
you, has been very helpful to me on many delicate occasions," and Hanaud
did not even project a wink down the mouthpiece. "Yes, I should very much
like his assistance. Yes, I stay with him in the Grosvenor Square when I
come to London. The most charming of hosts."

"Really, really," Mr. Ricardo tittered, blushing in his embarrassment.

"His name?" Hanaud continued. "Mr. Julius Ricardo."

It seemed that something exploded at the other end of the telephone. Was
it laughter? Was it surprise? Was it joy?

"We come in his car, a Rolls-Royce. Very fast, very fine. Give me the
address again." Hanaud wrote it down on a pad of paper and rang off.

"What a coincidence," cried Mr. Ricardo, beaming. "Devisher, me, you,

"Bah!" exclaimed Hanaud, jeering like a schoolboy.

"It might happen once in a hundred times," said Mr. Ricardo.

"But it does happen every day once in a hundred times," Hanaud replied,
and he hurried off to dress himself in less outrageous clothes, whilst
Mr. Ricardo called up his Rolls-Royce, No. 2, to the door.


MR. RICARDO was a trifle uncomfortable as he drove with Hanaud to the
Embankment. Police authorities did not, as a rule, endure easily the
presence of laymen at their investigations, however simple. But he had
heard the voice of Superintendent Maltby as he spoke over the wire. It
was hearty. He had jumped at the name. "Mr. Ricardo! You are staying with
Mr. Ricardo in Grosvenor Square? Bring him along, of course, my dear
Hanaud. The very thing!"

Hearty--yes. Enthusiastic even. But perhaps a little unsettling. He
reflected, however: "It may be that he has heard of my giving Hanaud now
and then a tiny help where social knowledge was needed, or some delicate
impression was to be felt. One never knows. But I was conscious of quite
a shock. Really, I might have been a criminal"; and Mr. Ricardo uttered a
little laugh, an uneasy little laugh, as though the great doors of
Wormwood Scrubs were opening before him.

"And now," said Hanaud, tapping him upon the knee, "you tell me, do you
not, of Bryan Devisher?"

"To be sure."

The car was crossing Battersea Bridge. The sunlight was glittering upon
the water. Seagulls wheeled and swooped in the inimitable beauty of their
flight. Above them and about them was summer, its scents, its warmth; and
against that bright background Mr. Ricardo told the story of how the waif
from the sea came aboard the Agamemnon.

"In my mind, for it would not have been polite to have said it aloud, I
called him meerschaum," said Mr. Ricardo, who had done nothing of the
kind. "See? A piece of meerschaum."

Hanaud, however, was indifferent at the moment to Ricardo's witticisms.
He sat upright, his broad, shaven face very serious. "No, it would not
have been polite to have said anything so stinging aloud," he replied,
his mind far away from his words, and he turned to his companion.

"This man Devisher. Did he really fall overboard?"

Mr. Ricardo replied slowly, "It was thought by the men on Agamemnon that
he took a chance."

"With the odds against him?" said Hanaud.


Hanaud dug his hands into his pockets He was obviously puzzled. "It is
not pleasant, of course, to be landed as an undesirable at Gravesend.
But, after all, he would be alive."

Monsieur Hanaud took his hands from his pockets and threw them up. "It is
something to be alive."

"There might be other charges against him," Ricardo suggested, "waiting
for him at Gravesend. He told us that the name upon his passport was

Monsieur Hanaud waved the suggestion aside. Some other question was
troubling him. "And he went ashore at Dartmouth alone, with fifteen
pounds in his pocket?"


"Did he go to the harbour-master's office?"

"He landed at the slip close to the harbour-master's office, but I think
that if he had gone to the office, some official would have come off to
ask whether we corroborated his story."

Hanaud nodded his head in agreement. Then he asked: "Do you think the
Captain Mordaunt was really asleep in his bath?"

The question had occurred to Mr. Ricardo, but he had made up his mind.

"I do. It is true that Mordaunt was in a hurry to lay up his yacht for
the winter. But he really meant that Devisher must make his position
clear to the authorities."

Hanaud, however, was not so confident. "It will be. Yes. No doubt. But I
should like to converse a little with the Captain Mordaunt, none the

Mr. Ricardo shook his head. That would not be so easy. On Sunday, it was
true, Captain Mordaunt would be present at one of the famous evenings of
Septimus Crottle. But Julius Ricardo did not belong to that circle, and
did not propose to do a gate-crash with Hanaud at his elbow. He said:
"There, my friend, I cannot help you."

"It is a pity," Hanaud returned, staring out of the window. And suddenly
he turned back upon Ricardo. "This Torbay train? He arrives in London at
half-past three?

"Yes," said Ricardo.

"And you travel on him?"


"And you take the luncheon in the dining-car? Yes?

"No. I slept in my compartment."

"Was Devisher upon that train?"

"I don't know. It was a long train with many carriages. I never saw

"So that, for all you know, my friend Ricardo, Bryan Devisher may have
arrived in London at half-past three yesterday afternoon. It is agreed?


Hanaud twisted his body and shook his big shoulders and made the grunts
and moans of discomfort.

"You see how it is," he cried to Mr. Ricardo, who didn't see at all how
it was. "There is my little affair. I wind it up and I take a vacancy.
Good! If it be. But it isn't. My friend, I do not want my little affair
to become your big affair. No."

"And you're afraid of that?" replied Ricardo in surprise.

Hanaud laid his hand impressively on Ricardo's arm.

"So afraid that it gives me the gaiters," he said solemnly.

Mr. Ricardo translated correctly, but, looking into his friend's troubled
face, knew that this was not the moment for correcting the translation.

"You had better tell me what your little affair is."

"I will," Hanaud replied as he pulled his blue-paper packet of cigarettes
from his pocket, "whilst we smoke the Maryland." He offered the packet to
Mr. Ricardo, who recoiled from it as if it were a dish of poison, and
then, having lit one, continued: "It was seven or eight years ago. Daniel
Horbury was in a smaller way of business, but he had his fingers in a
hundred pies, and you know that a day comes when there must be real money
on the table. Mr. Horbury knew the date of that day. Ten thousand pounds
on the table--and he had not one sliver."

"Stiver," Ricardo corrected.

"As I said, one sliver," Hanaud agreed equably. "Mrs. Hubbard, she was
naked. You understand?"

"Positively," said Mr. Ricardo.

"Good! But he has associates, not clerks exactly, and not partners.
Strap-hangers, you call them."

"And sometimes hangers-on," said Mr. Ricardo.

"Amongst them, Bryan Devisher. A valuable one for the Daniel Horburys. He
had good manners, good looks, youth, and he was not odd. Public School
and the entrance into houses of which the good Horbury only knew the
portico. You follow me?

"I am alongside of you," Ricardo observed with his eyes on the window.
Battersea Park had been left behind. The car had skirted the Park,
crossed a main road, dived southward into a street where little houses
with little gardens were succeeding terraces. They might reach the end of
their journey before Hanaud had reached the beginning of his. "You would
be wise to continue."

"I go." Hanaud bounced up and down on the seat, marshalling his facts.
Then he raised an imperative finger.

"First an historical set of pearls disappears. Second, Mr. Devisher sells
them to a jeweller, Gravot, in the Place Vendôme, for ten thousand
pounds. Daniel Horbury has his ten thousand pounds on the table. Act one!

Mr. Ricardo nodded his head.

"But the loss of the pearls is discovered," Hanaud resumed, "and Gravot
of the Place Vendôme must give them back. For that is the law. Gravot
gives them back, but he is out for Devisher's blood."

"I see that," Ricardo agreed.

"But there is no Devisher. He has gone. One of Horbury's little pies was
a revolution in Venezuela. It was needed. The revolution fails. Devisher
finds himself in the Castillo del Libertador, and is there for life, or
for as long as Vicente Gomez lives. So at once there is difficulty. There
is not, without Devisher himself, proof that the ten thousand pounds
Horbury put upon the table were the ten thousand pounds paid by Gravot of
the Place Vendôme."

"So--there's the jeweller..."

"Down the drain, as you say in your picturesque way. Exactly, my friend.
Oh, how quick you are! That Mr. Ricardo--who shall get by him? He
wait--with his glasses not straight upon his nose. Then he pounce--the
jaguar! The criminal? Poor fellow! It is over." Mr. Ricardo wriggled and
blushed and laughed--a small, modest laugh.

"Poor fellow, yes," he said, playing a little tune upon his knees with
his fingers. "It is over."

"But my Gravot," resumed Hanaud after his flatteries had been enjoyed,
"with him the years have passed. He wants now, not the blood, but his
good money. So we try, as I told you, for a friendly settlement."

Mr. Ricardo frowned over the problem very astutely.

"Yes. No doubt nowadays Daniel Horbury could command ten thousand

"Yet he slitted his throat," replied Hanaud quickly. "Explain that to me.
After all, it is not an ordinary behaviour."

"It is not," Mr. Ricardo agreed.

It was not reasonable, he thought, even if Hanaud had come.

"By the way," he asked, "did Horbury know that you had come to London?"

Hanaud was emphatic. Superintendent Maltby knew and perhaps one or two
officials of his service. And a lawyer. But no one else.

"As I told you, we did not wish the prosecution. I called on the
solicitor Preedy, who was employed in the original case, when I left
Victoria Station."

Again Mr. Ricardo was silent. The little houses with the little gardens
were giving place to big houses with big gardens. There were big trees,
too, chestnuts and oaks and beeches, holding up their thick lacework of
leaves and branches, so that even upon the roads there was the cool
refreshment of a green world. But there was clearly no comfort for
Monsieur Hanaud in the pleasure of the morning.

"Tell me," he said, "Devisher--Bryan Devisher--did he talk to you on the

"A little, yes."

"For an example?"

"Wait a moment."

Mr. Ricardo was being bustled, an experience which he disliked extremely.
There was something said. It was at the back of his mind, almost
tangible, really tangible if he wasn't bustled. And suddenly he had it.
"He said that after the revolution failed, he might have got away; but he
was betrayed."

"By Horbury?" Hanaud flashed the question at him.

"He did not say, but he looked as if he knew. Yes, I remember, he was
whiter than ever, his eyes staring and his lips working with a curious
little smile." And Mr. Ricardo shivered suddenly, as he had not shivered
in the saloon of the yacht when the words were spoken.

Hanaud leaned back in the car. After a little while he said slowly: "He
took a chance. Perhaps he took that chance, not because I or Maltby might
be waiting at Gravesend for El Rey to anchor, but because Horbury might
be--or shall we say Horbury's friends? Do you see?"

Mr. Ricardo saw very clearly not merely Devisher's staring eyes and
twisted smile, but saw them lost in a great crowd on the arrival platform
of a railway station. Three-thirty, the Torbay Limited! Devisher had the
advantage of the big rusty steamer by an afternoon--and a night. He had
the advantage of Horbury by an afternoon--and a night--of Horbury, who had
sold him into six years of hell in the Castillo del Libertador.

"But I do not want my little affair eight years old to widen himself out
into the big case of Horbury," cried Hanaud, spreading out his arms in an
extreme vexation. "No! Saperlipopette, I do not want it!"

He took a black cigarette from his blue-paper packet and lit it, and as
he snapped the lighter he shook off from his big shoulders the suspicions
which had troubled him.

"However, we fright ourselves for nothing at all. Men like Horbury! They
commit such follies. They are often in the odd street."

"Queer street," Mr. Ricardo corrected.

"So I said," observed Hanaud. "But you will be disappointed," and he
shook his head sadly at his friend. "That Mr. Ricardo! He likes his bit
of crime," and with a laugh he nudged Mr. Ricardo in the ribs.

There were few things which Ricardo detested more heartily than these
familiar nudges with the elbow. As a rule he left a sufficient space
between himself and Hanaud for them to miss him. But they were travelling
in his second Rolls-Royce, a smaller limousine, with no arm-rest to
protect him, and the elbow jolted him unexpectedly.

"I am not the only one who will be disappointed," he said tartly.

"Who else?

"Gravot of the Place Vendôme," said Ricardo. Hanaud smiled.

"Perhaps not, my friend. This Daniel Horbury had a wife. We shall see.
She might wish to make the amends."

A wife! It was the first time that Mr. Ricardo had ever heard of
Horbury's wife. His horses, to be sure! But a wife! Mr. Ricardo was
conscious of a sinking at his heart. Had he known that a wife would be
present, questioned, harassed, maybe in tears, he would perhaps have sent
Monsieur Hanaud on his quest alone. But he had himself to come, he
reflected; the police wanted him at their side. He recalled the hearty
invitation of Superintendent Maltby over the telephone, but now he
recalled it with relief. Certainly Mr. Ricardo could hardly have refused.

"England expects..." he said to himself--was there a cliché with which he
was unfamiliar?--and he sought an anodyne for his uneasiness in a curious
speculation. Horbury had married either in his youth, when the passions
were hot and the world just waiting to be turned over on its back like a
turtle; or in his maturity, when the years had given him a plump and
purselike semblance. In the one case he would have married a girl of his
own station, but worse educated; in the other a white-fingered daughter
of the counties, disdainful and greedy.

In neither case should I care a tuppenny damn, Mr. Ricardo thought, and
giggled at the common but expressive phrase.

The car was passing upon its right hand the playing fields of a great
school. The school buildings, a fine central hall linked by a covered way
with two big blocks of classrooms, all in deep red brick and white stone,
faced a second main high road. And this road, too, the motor-car crossed.
As it entered a narrower, gently-sloping avenue, Monsieur Hanaud read a
name upon a tin plate. "Lordship Lane. It is here."

On their left hand, large villas lay hidden amongst trees, behind fences
and high laurels. On the right a meadow, set here and there with a great
oak or a chestnut, sloped up to a low hedge and the flank of a
two-storied small white house. Behind it rose a screen of holly, so
thick, so high, that it made a curtain quite isolating the house from its

"White Barn," said Hanaud.

A policeman saluted. The car turned in at the gate and stopped in the
gravelled court in front of the door. Already two cars were parked there.


WHITE BARN was a pleasant oblong unpretentious house without gables or
ornaments. It had neither basement nor front steps, and on the upper
side, between the tall hedge and the house, a garage had been built
without spoiling its symmetry. It was of two storeys only, a small manor
house of some two hundred years of age. The door was in the centre of the
house with a large window on either side, and it was ajar. Hanaud pushed
it open.

"It is permitted...?" he asked.

A man of middle age, with a pair of sharp grey eyes set in an
inconspicuous face, stepped forward.

"It is desired."

"That you, the Superintendent, should be here.."

"Is a compliment to France."

These politenesses having been exchanged, Hanaud introduced Mr. Ricardo,
and the Superintendent's inconspicuous features became at once so vivid
that, according to Ricardo's fancy, they claimed the attention of the

"Mr. Ricardo! It is a pleasure. We shall not ask you anything for the
moment, but later you will, I am sure, help us."

Superintendent Maltby's eyes were widening alarmingly as they looked over
Mr. Ricardo.

"This is Detective-Inspector Herbert," he said, pointing to a second
officer in plain clothes, "and Sergeant Hughes." This was a slight,
smiling man in uniform who moved round between Mr. Ricardo and the door.

"To be sure," said Mr. Ricardo, but he was not comfortable. It seemed
that he had tumbled from the high pulpit of Investigation into the dock.
Before he could remember any crime which he had committed, the offensive
elbow caught him again sharply in the ribs.

"Really, really," he exclaimed in a fluster. He had almost cried aloud,
"Not guilty, m'lud."

Hanaud however, quite unconsciously rescued him from his embarrassment.

"It is charming this house, yes?" he said, and Mr. Ricardo cordially

He had, indeed, been surprised when he first saw it between the trunks of
the trees, by its plain, unbedizened beauty; and the hall matched it. It
was in the shape of a capital T. Where Mr. Ricardo stood, with his back
to the front door, he looked straight down the long leg of the T, past
the staircase, to the door of the service quarters. The broad cross-piece
in which they all stood stretched from side to side of the house. On each
side of the front door a big window looked upon the courtyard, and on
each side, facing the window on the inner wall, was a mahogany door; that
upon Mr. Ricardo's right, or London side, leading to the room which
commanded the garden and the meadow to the edge of the Turnpike Road;
that upon his left, into some chamber hued with a subdued green light by
the holly hedge. The floor of the hall was a dark polished oak, whose
severity was relieved by two or three Eastern rugs. A Sheraton sideboard
spread its elegance under the right-hand window, a small writing-table
received light from the left, and between each mahogany door and the edge
of the long passage, a Chippendale chair, upholstered in a dark red silk,
kept a comely balance.

"So! The Horburys lived here?" said Hanaud. "I should have thought Park
Lane, perhaps, or Piccadilly."

Ricardo smiled. He, too, had found something inconsistent between White
Barn and the hot, equivocal, noisy career of Mr. Daniel Horbury,

"He did live in Park Lane," Superintendent Maltby agreed. "As for this
little house, it may be that Mrs. Horbury--but we shall hear."

A door behind the staircase opened as he spoke. It was obviously a second
door from that room upon the left-hand side which shortened the journey
to the kitchen. A middle-aged woman, broad and stout, with a cotton frock
and a large apron in front of it, waddled into the passage carrying a
breakfast tray and vanished into the kitchen.

"Mrs. Wallace," explained Maltby. "She is the charwoman. She comes every
day at eight, airs the rooms and makes the beds when they have gone to
town. She was with Mrs. Horbury when we came."

"You have seen Madame Horbury?" Hanaud asked.

Maltby shook his head. "I thought it would be more comfortable for the
poor lady if, first of all, we got the body out of the way and the
photographs and the finger prints taken. We will hear now what Mrs.
Wallace has to tell us."

The charwoman came along the passage. Her eyes were red as if she had
been crying and her face was mottled; but now that the shock of her
discovery was dulled, she was beginning to see herself as the one without
whom the story could not be told at all. The Superintendent asked her to
seat herself in one of the chairs and she did with a sniff which might
have been gratitude for his consideration or grief for the loss of "the

"They didn' live here 'xacly," she said, "but they use to be here when
they was firs' married, and Mr. Horbury kep’ on, the house, sort of
sentimental. And every now and then, especial in the summer, they'd dine
early in London and she'd drive him down in the car. Mr. Horbury, he
didn' drive at all but she's a beautiful driver. I expec' what with
parties and speeches and goin's-on, they came down to be quiet-like

"They were fond of one another?" the Superintendent asked.

"Oh, special," replied Mrs. Wallace. "Beauty and the Beast, I use to call
'em, though it seems sort o' sacrilegious now. You could hear them
laughin' in the mornin' gay as gay, and as I says you don't go laughin'
proper with people before breakfast unless you've got hearts attune," she
added surprisingly.

The Superintendent, whilst applauding Mrs. Wallace's philosophy of love,
led her to describe the habits of the household.

"Did you know when Mr. and Mrs. Horbury were coming down for the night?"
he asked. "Did they telephone, for instance?"

"No, sir. Mr. Horbury, he said that was making arrangements. What he
wanted was or-gan-i-sation." She brought out the big word in cautious
syllables. "Oh, he was a one for organisation, was Mr. Horbury. He said
without organisation he wouldn't have a bottle o' Pommery 'o6 in the
'ouse or a pennypiece in the bank. How I did laugh, sir, 'im puttin' a
bottle of champagne before money in the bank, and so did he when I
pointed it out to 'im."

"Yes, that must have seemed very funny to Mr. Horbury," said the
Superintendent dryly. "Now come to last night."

"I did what I always did," she replied. "There are electric fires in the
bedrooms and everywhere except the garden-room. I put the logs there and
the paper all ready to light. In the kitchen I prepared a primus stove
with some fresh eggs and bacon sliced ready in a glass jar, and rolls and
butter and corfy, if they should want a little supper, as it were. Plates
and cups and saucers and glasses and knives and forks, of course. There
were some bottles of the Pommery in the cupboard. They never drank
nothing but the champagne and never more than one bottle, though I think
he drank most o' that. Just brushed her lips with it, as you might say.
Often and often I've found her glass half-full and the bottle empty in
the morning."

"Did they bring friends with them?" asked Maltby, who now let her ramble
on as she willed that he might get lights from as many angles as possible
on this tragedy.

"No, no, never," she replied. "They just come here to be easy. They just
come to be quiet-like together. So I put everything ready and shut up the
house and went away at five o'clock as I always did," she resumed, "and I
came back at eight o'clock punctual this morning and let myself in with
my latchkey."

"Have you got it?" the Superintendent asked, and she produced a small
Yale key on a ring. Maltby balanced it for a moment in the palm of his
hand. "How many are there of these?"

"Three, sir," she answered. "Mr. and Mrs. Horbury each have one."

Maltby nodded his head and gave the key back to her. "Now, when you got

Mrs. Wallace drew a great breath. She was clearly going to put over a big
performance, thought Mr. Ricardo. Not one horrific detail was to be
omitted. She had gone at once to the kitchen. The primus stove was unlit,
the eggs were still in their paper bag, the bacon in its glass jar, the
butter in a curious glass dish with a lid, standing in a glass saucer.
"Irish, Mr. Horbury says. Whatifer, he calls it and what's it fer, I
calls it. Leadeny stuff. It wouldn't do for the village, I can tell you.
When we wants glass, we wants glass, if you understand me."

"Yes, I do understand," replied the Superintendent cordially. His voice
sounded as if he couldn't have endured a piece of Watifer in his house
for a minute.

"So everything was untouched," Mrs. Wallace continued. "I hangs up my
coat and bonnet on the peg behind the door, and I lights the stove and
puts a kettle of water to make myself a nice cup o' tea, and I says,
'Maria, here's an easy day for you.' But I hadn't hardly spoken the words
when I noticed that the drinkin' glasses weren't there. Two there should
have been, and two there weren't. Moreover the cupboard door was open.
Generally it's locked, with the key in the lock. There were two glasses
missing but no bottle missing. That weren't like Mr. Horbury. Allus took
the bottle into the garden-room, he did. 'So they're here arter all,' I
says, 'and lucky I was to put the kettle on to boil for their mornin'
tea.' I hadn't a suspicion in my mind. There! Not one."

"No, indeed. Why should you?" the Superintendent asked sympathetically.

Mrs. Wallace had run back along the passage to open the windows and air
the garden-room. She pointed dramatically to the door in the inner wall
opposite to the hall window on the right of Mr. Ricardo.

"It was ajar," she said, "and the lights still burning." She had flung
the door open with a gesture worthy of Mrs. Siddons, she had advanced a
step, and she had seen "the poor gentleman" still sitting in his chair,
but his body stretched across the little table in front of it, the
blotting-book pushed forward over the edge, his arm outstretched. His
throat was gaping, and just underneath the outstretched hand, lying in a
great pool of blood, was the knife.

"A horrible thing with a long blade and a handle pale blue, just like
Cambridge under Hammersmith Bridge. I shrieked," she cried, and her arms
whirled in the air. "Never had I seen such a sight. Everything went
black. I tottered. I was goin' to faint, I was, when I remembered that
poor woman upstairs. 'My dooty,' I says to myself and after clawing to
the door a bit to steady mysel, I stumbled upstairs to their bed-room
door. And it was locked."

"Locked?" Hanaud cried suddenly in a sharp voice, and bowed his apologies
to the Superintendent.

"Locked," replied Mrs. Wallace, glaring at Hanaud, "which it never had
been before. Never! I used to take their mornin' tea into them regular
as if they were the King and Queen. And now the door was locked."

Hanaud nodded, but he was puzzled. Here was something which needed
explanation. Meanwhile he could not reconcile that locked door and the
wife behind it, with Maria's story of the couple coming down alone to be
“quiet-like together” in their suburban solitude and “gay as gay.” the
next morning.

"What did you do when you found the door locked, Mrs. Wallace?" the
Superintendent asked, keeping her to her story.

"I beat on it," she replied. "I cried 'Open, please! There's horrors,
Mrs. Horbury. Oh! the poor gentleman.' And I heard Mrs. Horbury say, in a
low voice and quite from the floor, as it was: 'Wait! I'll let you in.'
She seemed to bump against the door and unlocked it. But as she unlocked
it, she said again 'Wait! Wait!' and I heard her stumbling into her bed.
Then at last she said, 'Come in!

"And then?" Again it was Maltby who urged her.

"When I went in--it was terrible. There was the twin bed which Mr. Horbury
used, turned down for him, and his fugiamas, as he called them--Japan, you
know--spread out as I had spread them, and Mrs. Horbury in her bed with
the blankets up to her chin, white as a sheet and shivering--oh, as if she
was an iceberg in the Artic Ocean. 'Oh, you poor, poor darlin', I said,
just as if we were both of the same stature. I told her the truth and she
said, still all frozen and her teeth chattering, 'Get me my
dressing-gown. We must ring up the police.' We came down the stairs
together. I pointed to the garden-room and said in a whisper, 'It's in
there.' But she shook her head and rang up the police station."

"Do you remember the message?"

Inspector Herbert of the local constabulary answered for Mrs. Wallace.
"We took it down." He turned towards Sergeant Hughes, who turned back the
leaves of a notebook and read aloud: "This is Mrs. Horbury speaking from
White Barn. Will you please send the proper people up here? My husband
has died--by violence."

Sergeant Hughes then took over the history of events from Maria Wallace,
the charwoman.

"The message was quite clear and quite without hysteria, but the voice
was urgent and distressed. We sent at once what men we had--photographer,
finger-print man--and we rang up the police surgeon, Dr. Claxton. The
french windows into the garden were locked and it looked as if Mr.
Horbury had committed suicide. Since Mr. Horbury was a Member of
Parliament and well known in business circles "--Sergeant Hughes dwelled
for a little longer than need be upon that useful phrase--"we rang up
Scotland Yard and tried to get in touch with Superintendent Maltby, who
had not yet..."

"That's enough about that," the Superintendent interrupted with some

"Certainly, sir," said the Sergeant and crossed out the offending lines.

The Superintendent coughed. "Of course," he explained, "if one sits up
all night..."

"With a sick friend," the Sergeant interpolated, his eyes again stolidly
upon the wall, and the Superintendent, who possessed a sense of humour,
made a good mark against the name of Sergeant Hughes.

"By the time Superintendent Maltby arrived the drudgery had been
completed," Sergeant Hughes read. "The police surgeon, Dr. Claxton, had
met the late Mr. Horbury's doctor, Cornish, at White Barn. They made a
cursory examination to be certain that life was extinct, and after the
police had taken the necessary measurements, Dr. Claxton conveyed the
corpse in the station ambulance to the mortuary, having arranged with Dr.
Cornish to join him later with a view to a full post-mortem
investigation. Whilst the body was being removed, the finger prints and
photographs taken, Inspector Herbert asked Dr. Cornish to look after Mrs.
Horbury and prepare her for an interview with Superintendent Maltby, who
would doubtless wish to ask her some questions."

"Up till now, then," said Maltby, "no one has received any account of
what happened last night?"

"No, sir."

"Beyond that Mrs. Horbury locked her door," said Mr. Ricardo, and, though
the fact was known be the separation of this fact from the rigmarole of
Mrs. Wallace gave to it a new significance. There was a pause, even a
stiffening of attitudes, a silence.

Mr. Ricardo, however, had up to this moment experienced no flashing
revelation which he wished to pass on to his colleagues. From the first
aspect of White Barn he had suffered a confusion. He could hardly
reconcile Horbury with this house, and still less with his retention of
it as a refuge where he and a wife could be "quiet-like together." But
when he had at last accepted these details, he found them weakened, if
not contradicted, in that Mrs. Horbury had gone up to her bedroom alone
and locked the door. Had they quarrelled, Ricardo wondered? Hardly enough
to account for Horbury's suicide, in any case. Horbury and his wife--the
homely background to the flamboyant career--Pommery '06 at Bentano's in
the Strand and domestic felicity in Lordship Lane. For a student of life,
a fascinating case; but, since his wife had locked the bedroom door, an

The silence was broken by Hanaud in a most deferential voice. "May I ask
a question?"

"Of course," Maltby answered. "We shall welcome your assistance, although
I fancy we shall find the Horbury affair not too difficult."

"I thank you," Hanaud answered.

How charmingly correct they both were, Mr. Ricardo reflected, as Hanaud
now turned to the charwoman.

"Was it by means of this telephone that Madame Horbury summoned the
police this morning?"

A telephone machine was standing almost at Hanaud's left hand on the
writing-table beneath the window.

"Yes, sir."

Hanaud looked at the handle of the receiver and with a little bow to
Sergeant Hughes: "I see there are traces of the powder for the finger

"We found some old marks of Mrs. Wallace's fingers which she let us take
and a new, quite clear, set, which we take to have been made by Mrs.
Horbury," answered Hughes.

"Then "--and Hanaud turned back to the charwoman--"is this the only
telephone in the house?"

"No, no, Mounseer. It is a French gentleman, isn't it? This is the one
which I use for ordering things--coal and food, and suchlike. But there is
an extension in the garden-room which Mr. and Mrs. Horbury use when they
want to use it. But that's only onct in a blue moon."

"But if they are rung up, the bell rings here?"

"To be sure," said Maltby with a touch of impatience. What on earth had
the telephone here to do with the case of a man who had cut his throat in
the garden-room? The charwoman, however, was all for giving information.
When would life have another thrill for her like this?

"Yes, Mounseer, the bell rings here and in the garden-room and you can
answer from either."

"You are bound to hear it, then, wherever you are?"

Mrs. Wallace laughed.

"You'd have to be as deaf as a post not to hear it," she said. "Bad as a
firebell, I says. I can shut the kitchen door never so, but let that bell
go off, and there's no being quiet-like until you've answered it."

"Quiet-like," said Mr. Ricardo solemnly, with a nod to the charwoman.
"That is the key word."

"To what?" asked the Superintendent. Mr. Ricardo had not an idea.

But Hanaud hurried to his rescue. "Yes, my friends," he declared with a
serious face, which somehow frightened everyone else in the hall, "I
think we shall find that there is much which is too quiet-like in the
whole of this affair."

"The locked door?" Maltby suggested.

"That is one thing," Hanaud replied, "but only one thing."

Again there was a pause. Then Maltby, shaking from his shoulders some
horror which he did not wish to believe, moved. "Let us see this

He walked to the door upon the right hand, opposite to the window under
which stood the Sheraton sideboard. It was a thick mahogany door with a
glass handle. He took out his handkerchief and wrapped it round the
glass. But Sergeant Hughes interrupted him.

"The only prints upon that handle were the same as those clear prints
upon the telephone on the writing table."

"Mrs. Horbury's then?" said Maltby.


"And one set only?" suddenly Hanaud interposed.


"As she went upstairs--to lock her door? Yes, no doubt," cried Hanaud.
"But when they arrived in the evening, eh, my friend? To spend an evening
quiet-like together. Which of them opened this door?"

"No doubt Olivia Horbury." said the Sergeant, politely condescending.

"Oh, no doubt," cried Hanaud, and there was no politeness at all in his
voice. "And she was kind enough to save us trouble by placing her fingers
on the handle in exactly the same position as she did when she drew the
door to, to go upstairs to her room and lock herself in. That is curious,

Sergeant Hughes looked uncomfortable. Superintendent Maltby was troubled.

"Yes, I don't understand that," he remarked unhappily. "It might, of
course, happen by chance, once..."

And Monsieur Hanaud cut in: "Yes, my friend, once--when the moon is blue."

Superintendent Maltby, with a gesture of annoyance, threw open the door
of the garden-room.


THEY entered an oblong room with panelled walls enamelled white. One or
two girandoles and one or two water-colours decorated the panels. The
carpet was thick and of a warm wine-dark red, and the curtains and
pelmets of heavy silk matched it in colour. A white marble fireplace had
a panel of blue Wedgwood figures below the mantelshelf. Mr. Ricardo was
the last to enter, and, standing by the door, he shut his eyes tight and
asked of himself: "What message has this room for me?"

Apparently it had none. Isolate himself as he might, no message shot
tingling across his mind. And, besides, Mrs. Wallace, the charwoman, was
talking volubly.

"The room was lit and the curtains drawn as though it was still night,
and there was the poor gentleman sprawled across the table, and gore--you
wanted to be a butcher born, you did, not to feel sickish. Then I
screamed and ran out of the room."

It was not wonderful to Mr. Ricardo that she should feel sickish. He
conceived that if his mind had been less alert, he might have felt a
trifle sickish himself. Upon his right hand were two french windows
opening on to a green and pleasant garden with the great meadow beyond a
low hedge. Although birds sang no more, rooks wheeled and cawed about one
of the oaks and, as the branches swayed, the sun threw an ever-changing
pattern of draperies upon the grass. An idyllic place where lovers could
be quiet-like together--especially at night with the curtains drawn and an
aromatic log fire burning on the hearth. Now the small table was pushed
forward, and blood had splashed even on the enamelled wall and coagulated
in what seemed an enormous pool upon the carpet. A blotting-book bound in
a buhl cover, ornamented with mother-of-pearl, had tumbled off the table
and stood on its edges, like a child's tent, on the rim of the dried
pool. Beside it were the splinters of a broken wineglass. Mr. Ricardo
could almost see the heavy figure of the man slumped over the table and
the right arm flung forward just over the spot where a cardboard cover
had been placed to mark the position where the knife had fallen.

The table stood close to the fireplace with a chair, against the wall
behind it, in which Horbury had been sitting. It was small and there
should have been, one would have thought, letters, papers of some sort,
scattered upon the floor. For a fountain pen with its nib exposed had
peeped out beneath his arm.

"There were no papers," Inspector Herbert explained. "It struck me as

The Superintendent walked to the fireplace and, going down on his knees,
poked amongst the ashes. Then he sat back upon his heels. "Yes, it's
curious," he said slowly. "If he burnt papers, he did it thoroughly.
There's nothing here but an old butt of a cigar. He must have tossed that
into the fire, and then put an end to everything."

Hanaud, for his part, was more concerned with the appointments of the
room. The table at which Horbury had sat was on the further side of the
fireplace from the door, and still further along the wall, in the corner,
a cushioned chair with arms was placed. It looked diagonally across the
room towards the door, and the cushion at the back of it was crumpled. A
long table stood against the wall running between that corner and the
windows. Opposite to the fireplace was a sofa with a back, and upon that,
too, there were cushions which had been disarranged. At the end of it a
round mahogany table was placed, and on it was a glass half full of

"It seems that at one moment Madame Horbury sat here with her glass of
champagne at her elbow and, as that good woman tells us," Hanaud said
with a glance towards the charwoman, "she took no more of it than she
usually did. And there upon the floor are the splinters of Horbury's
glass. But why should Horbury, of all men, have put the bottle back in
the cupboard?"

Superintendent Maltby nodded his head. "We don't want to make
difficulties for ourselves, do we?" To him this was a plain case of
suicide by a man of a very stormy history, who might well have found
himself with no option between death or a long term of penal servitude.
"These are small matters."

"Yet there is another. May I again interfere?"

Hanaud was all smiles and deference and entirely at Mister the
Superintendent's disposal. Mister the Superintendent, indeed, was
beginning to wonder whether he had been wise to invite this burly
Frenchman. But he tried not to show it.

"Of course," he said. "My dear Hanaud, we know of your painstaking
methods. A hair on a coat-sleeve, a key lost or found..."

"Lost or found!" cried Hanaud. "Was ever anything more properly, more
profoundly said? My dear Monsieur!"

He walked lightly across the room to the table against the end wall. On
it stood a telephone instrument of the modern kind, ear and mouthpiece in
one, resting on a cradle, and a dial at the foot of the instrument. But
it was not the telephone which had attracted him. Almost, but not quite,
behind the machine, something had gleamed.

"Yes, another little matter, and that, too, out of place," and Monsieur
Hanaud was not the man to keep a note of triumph out of his voice. He
held up a bunch of keys, picking it up daintily by the ring.

"You will observe that there is a Yale latchkey on the ring. Is not this
the bunch of keys which the good Horbury carried on a chain in the pocket
of his trousers? Yes? It seems so. Perhaps Mister Herbert will tell us."

"Them's his keys," said Mrs. Wallace. "I've seen them over and over."

Sergeant Hughes, at a nod from Maltby, took the keys and went out of the
room. When he returned, he addressed himself to Maltby.

"It is the key of the front door, sir."

Maltby crossed to the side table and, taking a piece of chalk from his
pocket, held it above the spot where Hanaud's eye had discovered the

"That the place?" he asked.


Maltby marked the place and both men stood for a moment in a perplexity.
After all, why should Horbury have taken the bunch off the chain on which
he usually carried it?

"If the lock of the door had been stiff, for instance," said Hanaud.
"Yes, it would have been easier to turn it:"

"But the lock wasn't stiff," replied Hughes. "And why should he put the
bunch on the table?"

All three men stared again at the chalk mark on the table. Another little
thing. But an unusual thing. And therefore needing explanation.

"It's certainly odd," Maltby exclaimed. He turned rather savagely upon
the charwoman. "You never saw them off the chain?"

"Never," she declared. "Cross my thumbs!"

"But it might happen?"

Mrs. Wallace sniggered. "And it might rain pigs and chocolate creams,"
she answered, "but it don't."

"Of course"--Maltby disregarded the charwoman's nettled
rejoinder--"Horbury might have wanted to telephone. Standing up straight
after dialling, the edge of the table may have pressed the bunch into his
thigh. He may have taken the keys from the spring hook of the chain and
tossed them where they fell. A little fanciful?" he asked of Sergeant
Hughes, who looked more than a little troubled by this sudden high flight
of his superior officer.

"No, sir, not fanciful at all," he replied, "but"--and he blurted out the
uncontroversial fact--"that telephone wasn't used last night."

Mrs. Wallace sniggered again. But it was Hanaud who spoke, a little
startled perhaps and certainly perplexed.

"I should like to be very sure of that," he said quietly.

"You may be," said the Sergeant. "That--well, that handle thing was tested
for prints. There wasn't a mark of any kind upon it."

"No, and there wouldn't be," cried Mrs. Wallace, folding her arms across
her body. "Not if it wasn't used last night. Yesterday morning I dusted
it, I did, and when I dusts, I dusts."

"Did you take the receiver from the cradle?"

"That I did," she answered. "I holds the spring down, see? With my left
hand. Then I takes off the handle thing. Then I slips one of the two
telephone books on to them supports to keep them down. Then I dusts the
thing thoroughly--earpiece and mouthpiece and all--and slips it back

She contemplated Monsieur Hanaud with an aggressive face, but he answered
her with a bow which was quite disarming. "Madame, I do not doubt you for
a moment. The whole room is an example for housewives."

Mrs. Wallace relaxed from her indignation; and the next moment she
smiled. For Sergeant Hughes added his tribute of praise.

"That's true," he said. "I never saw furniture so clean. There are marks
on Mr. Horbury's chair and table made by him, as we know, and a few on
the mantelshelf and the arm of the settee, where Mrs. Horbury sat with
her glass of champagne. They correspond with the prints on the telephone
in the hall. But, apart from those, nothing at all."

"Except, perhaps," Hanaud suggested, "some on the arms of that chair in
the corner where the cushion is disarranged?"

Hughes was for the moment taken aback.

"No, sir," he answered after a pause. "That's queer, that is. I was here
whilst the finger-print men were at work. There were no prints on that
chair at all. It may be that the cushion was thrown on to the chair,
perhaps by Horbury himself from his chair behind the table."

It seemed, however, that Hanaud had lost interest in the matter.

"Very likely," he said with a shrug of his shoulders and a nod of his
head. "Little things. As the Superintendent tells us wisely, we must not
make too much of them."

A bell rang in the passage and the knocker rattled upon the outside door.

"It will be the doctor," said Herbert, and Maltby nodded to the

"Will you let him in, please, and then we need not keep you from your

The charwoman brought into the parlour a minute afterwards a big-boned,
loose-limbed man, with a genial, bluff manner, and a suit of dark clothes
even looser than his limbs.

"Dr. Claxton," said the charwoman.

"And very many thanks for your help, Mrs. Wallace," Maltby said
gratefully. "When I ring, will you ask Mrs. Horbury if she is ready to
receive us?"

Before Mrs. Wallace was out of the room, Claxton held out to Maltby a
narrow longish cardboard box. "The Inspector at the station wanted you to
see this."

Maltby took off the lid and all could see the gleam of a long-bladed
knife. Hanaud took a step towards it and Maltby made him an apology.

"I forget my manners. Dr. Claxton, I present you to Monsieur Hanaud of
the Paris Sureté."

"It is an honour," returned Dr. Claxton with a keen glance at the

"And Mr. Ricardo," added Maltby with a wave of the hand a little too

But Dr. Claxton turned with a smile and an extended hand.

"Of Grosvenor Square?" he asked, and lifted Mr. Ricardo into a heaven of
delight. He wondered whether, if by any chance he should ever fall ill,
it would seem unusual if he were to send to Lordship Lane for a doctor.
He had no time to solve this important problem at the moment. For Maltby
was kneeling down by that clotted mush of blood on the floor.

"Who would have thought the old man had so much blood in him?" Mr.
Ricardo observed, quoting from Macbeth.

"But he wasn't old," said Maltby.

"Mr. Ricardo was quoting from a standard case before the days of
finger prints," said Claxton.

Mr. Ricardo heaved a sigh of pleasure. He had been feeling rather chilly
in that room. Even Hanaud had been too engrossed in some troublesome
thoughts of his own to keep his friend constantly within the
consultation. Now he had an ally.

"By the way," said Maltby over his shoulder. "The prints on the knife

"Horbury's," said the doctor.

Maltby removed the cover from the blood upon the floor. The shape of the
long knife was as clearly moulded in red as if it had been made in a
sculptor's clay. Maltby took his handkerchief from his pocket and
carefully lifted the knife from the box. It fitted exactly in the space.
To Mr. Ricardo it looked the most murderous of weapons; one side of the
blade was thin and sharp as a razor, the other more than usually broad
and heavy, as though it had been loaded; and what gave to it a curiously
sinister aspect was the pale blue colour of the handle. It was a weapon
of death imitating a child's toy. Even so unimaginative a woman as Mrs.
Wallace had noticed especially that gay bright colour--"Cambridge passing
under Hammersmith Bridge."

"One of the occasions, I suppose," Mr. Ricardo ruminated, "when Oxford
had been embarrassed by their long list of wins and didn't try."

He did not pursue this engaging topic for Hanaud turned a pursed and
frowning face upon the doctor.

"There seems to be no hinge where the blade joins the handle of the

"There is none."

Hanaud nodded his head. He glanced sharply at Ricardo and so back again
to the doctor.

"I see. South American, do you think?"

The Superintendent once more began to show signs of impatience at
Hanaud's excursions beyond the strict boundaries of this garden-room; and
Dr. Claxton drew back from the dangerous game of conjecture.

"No knowledge. No theories," he announced curtly, and Maltby nodded.
"That's sound. Speculation may be the soul of conversation, but it's a
will o' the wisp to a Superintendent of Police."

Hanaud was not at all abashed. He was darting glances on the floor, on
the settee, on the mantelshelf, as if he had not heard one word of the

"If it is your hat you look for, my friend you left it in the hall,"
Maltby continued sweetly, and Inspector Herbert did audibly snigger.
Hanaud smiled apologetically.

"My hat? Yes, there he is. He will not run away. But, Inspector, the
sheath, he does."

"Sheath!" Herbert exclaimed.

"To be sure. The knife, since he does not shut himself, will carry
himself in a sheath. It was on the body perhaps?"

"No," said the doctor and "No," the Inspector agreed. Maltby cried:
"There is a drawer in the table at which Horbury sat. We may have
overlooked it."

He went behind the table and pulled out the drawer with a little more
violence than it needed.

"No," he said and he acknowledged Hanaud's question with a stiff bow.
"But it must be somewhere"; and at once everyone in the room began to
search for it.

"It might be of soft leather," said Herbert.

"Or of stiff leather," said Mr. Ricardo helpfully. He was down on his
knees with the Sergeant. They peered under the chairs and tables, they
turned up the edges of the carpet, they swung back the window curtains.
Maltby picked up the blotting-book, shook it out and replaced it. Hanaud
pushed his hand down at the side and the back of the settee. The few
things which Herbert had taken from the dead man's pockets--a small diary,
a gold pencil, a few half-crowns, a black letter-case with some pound
notes in the partitions, the steel chain with the tab at the end for the
trouser-button--were all arranged upon the mantelshelf. But of any
protection for that deadly weapon with the blue handle, there was nowhere
any sign.

"It is just another of the little things which do perplex me," said
Hanaud, and then the doctor took him up.

"But there is no doubt that this was the knife he used," he argued. "No
shadow of doubt! He had drawn it from left to right across his throat. He
had severed the carotid artery. The blood must have burst from it in
great gouts, as though it had been pumped. He would have died very

"When?" Hanaud asked sharply; and Mr. Ricardo with a jerk drew himself

He knew that here was the question to which Hanaud had been working up
from the first moment when he had entered the room. "When?" Just that!
All the rest, the small particulars discovered which made suicide a
verdict difficult to accept, were the knitting of a pattern to which the
answer to his question was the key. He had no wish, as Ricardo knew, to
see his small affair of the pearls merging in the ever so much bigger
crime of murder. But the plain reason for his life had driven him
irresistibly. Murder must be revealed any where, upon whomsoever the
blame fell. When did Horbury die then? At what hour? Answer!

The doctor answered:

"It is not always possible to be exact. But within limits one is
justified, and in this case Mr. Cornish, a famous surgeon, agreed
absolutely with me. We examined the body of Daniel Horbury in the
mortuary at ten o'clock this morning and we agreed that death had taken
place between ten and twelve hours before."

"Not after midnight then?"

"Certainly not after midnight," Doctor Claxton stated firmly, "and not
before ten. We cannot be more precise."

Hanaud's eyes dropped from the doctor's face, and he stood so with his
eyes on the ground. Then he slipped into an arm-chair below the fireplace
and stared moodily into the ashes. He was not acting. His disarmament was
as apparent as his honesty. There was no one in that room who interrupted
him, no one indeed who stirred.

"My friend, I beg your pardon," he said to Maltby very gently. "Yet
perhaps, in the end, you will say, 'That Hanaud! He was the nuisance, but
he helped.'"

"I should not say he was the nuisance," Maltby returned with a smile.

"Although one might think it," Hanaud answered. "But I will not keep you
on the tip-toes. No! I was very anxious yesterday to settle my little
dispute with this Horbury. So, on arriving in London by the Continental
train, I rang up his office. I did not give my name, but I said my
business was urgent. Horbury was not in his office, but the telephone
number of White Barn was given to me. I dined with you, my friend Maltby,
and I went home to Grosvenor Square. But I could not sleep. I said to
myself, 'That is a slippery one, that Horbury! How do I know that he has
not caught the night train to Rome?' There are reasons besides why he
might. So at half-past two in the morning..."

"Twenty-five minutes to three," Mr. Ricardo interrupted.

"You heard me?"

"I heard you go down the stairs and call up a number on the telephone,
but what number I did not hear."

"Good! I have the corroboration," cried Hanaud. "This was the
number--White Barn."

"You called up this house?" exclaimed Maltby.

"I did."

"At twenty-five minutes to three in the morning?"


"And you got an answer?"

"I tell you what happened. I got cluck-cluck, cluck-cluck, like a clock.
Then that ceased. So someone had lifted the receiver from the cradle. I
said 'It is Mr. Horbury? Excuse please the hour. It is most urgent.'
There was no answer, and I began to wonder whether the receiver had not
been lifted just to stop the bell ringing through the house. Then, after
a moment or two, I heard a little rattle as the handle was replaced on
the spring--and the line went dead."

Again Hanaud received the tribute of silence. Then the detective-inspector
suggested: "Mrs. Horbury perhaps?"

Hanaud shook his head.

"You heard the woman Wallace. There are only two instruments in the
house. One in the hall, the other here. On the telephone in the hall,
there were old prints of hers and one set--mind, only one set--of Mrs.
Horbury's, made this morning when she rang the police."

Nobody wished to accept the consequence of his argument. Not even Hanaud
himself. He looked at the bright and inviting room with its enamelled
walls, its deep cushioned seats, the delicate tracery of the plaster on
the ceiling and the long windows opening on to trim lawn and wide meadow,
where the sunlight and the oaks played a swiftly-moving game in black and

"So then?" Maltby challenged, himself the first to grasp the nettle.

"So then," Hanaud repeated, "at half-past two this morning, in this
room--perhaps the lamps were lit and the curtains drawn and the fire
bright upon the hearth; perhaps the room was dark and the windows open to
the shadows and the silver, as now to the shadows and the gold--someone
stood by that table and with a covered hand lifted the earpiece,
mouthpiece, what you will, and held it,--not to listen to a message, but
to stop the call jangling through the house."

"Someone?" Herbert repeated. "Mrs. Horbury then?"

Hanaud replied thoughtfully: "Yet I do not think it was Madame Horbury.
Imagine it! Horbury has been dead for three to four hours. Someone in
this room hears the telephone, lifts the receiver, does not answer, and
replaces it." He pointed across the room to the table. "Was it then, do
you think, that someone tossed the keys on the table?"

Maltby bent down.

"You have in your mind, Monsieur Hanaud," he stated rather than asked, "a
picture, and perhaps the name of that someone."

"Picture, no! Name, perhaps yes. There was one who--and again I say,
perhaps--had great reason to hate Daniel Horbury."

A look of bewilderment passed over Maltby's face.

"Devisher?" he said.

"Bryan Devisher," said Hanaud.

"But--but--we both know. At Gravesend, he was not on board. He was lost at
sea during the night."

"And that also is true. But he could have been in this house last night.
Let Mr. Ricardo tell us."

He swung round upon Ricardo with the outstretched forefinger of
melodrama; and everyone turned about and stared, incredulous, ready at a
word to contradict.

"Really, really," Mr. Ricardo stammered. He swallowed hurriedly. He was
not averse to his proper share of the limelight. But he preferred that it
should glow brighter and brighter upon him gradually, that he should, as
it were, slide into it. But to stand one moment obscure, and the next
moment lit up like the ghost of Sir Marmaduke--well, really, really! It
was the penalty one paid for the friendship of Hanaud. However, it was an
hour to be registered. He looked at his watch. He gave himself twelve
minutes, and as the clock struck twelve he finished.

"Thank you," said the superintendent warmly. "That is very important,
and, if I may say so who have listened to many stories, very closely

Mr. Ricardo was delighted and would have been more delighted still if
Hanaud had not with a bow and a smirk taken the commendation to himself.
"Really I might be his ventriloquist's dummy," he reflected acidly.

Superintendent Maltby moved to the fireplace and rang the bell. "There is
no evidence that Devisher was here," he said.

"None," Hanaud agreed.

"We shall hear now what Mrs. Horbury has to tell us," said Maltby and the
charwoman opened the door.

"Will you ask Mrs. Horbury if she will receive us?" he asked and, when
she had gone upon her errand, he resumed. "It will be best, I think, that
no mention of Bryan Devisher should be made, no hint given of that story
of the sea which Mr. Ricardo has told to us."

These words were not a hint. They were a definite order, and Maltby
looked to each of his companions in toto for a promise of obedience.

"Good!" he said and Mrs. Wallace came back with a message that Mrs.
Horbury would receive them at once. Mr. Ricardo hung back, but Maltby
took him by the arm with a smile.

"You have been very good. You never spoke out of turn. Will you be my
secretary for half an hour? Let us go!"; and they filed out of the room.

The one word murder, of which all had for so long been thinking, had
never once been spoken.


SHE was standing in the room with the windows looking upon the holly
hedge. But there was space enough between the hedge and the windows for
the sunlight to fall golden upon the gravel path between and to fill the
room with a serene and quiet light.

"I don't want to distress you more than must be," said Maltby gently; and
Olivia Horbury gravely acknowledged his courtesy.

"You have your duty, Superintendent."

She was tall and dressed in a coat and skirt of dark blue and a white
shirt with a collar. Her hair, which was black but had the blue sheen of
a raven's wing, was parted in the middle and drawn softly back, masking
the tops of her ears. Beneath its heavy mass her face was very pale and
her eyes, enormous under the long, upturned lashes, were black as night,
too, and as night unfathomable. Prepared as Mr. Ricardo had been for
someone of a closer kinship with the house than with her gross bandit of
a husband, he was none the less surprised. The broad forehead, the wide
spacing of her eyes, the delicacy of nose and nostril, the short upper
lip and the curve of cheek and jaw gave her beauty; but the supple grace
of her movements, the slenderness of her figure, the long white hands,
made her exquisite besides....She was neither of the Lambeth Walk nor of
bankrupt gentility. He was inclined, with a rare spurt of fancy, to think
that she was born at Sèvres, and there had got lost amongst images with
the colours of pale flowers as lovely as herself. There Horbury, on an
off day between Longchamps and Auteuil, bought her, noticing that she was
alive and so worth more of his money than the others. Her voice, however,
upset Ricardo's fairy tale. For it was not silvery and light, as it
should have been, but full and low.

"Will you sit down, Superintendent--and your friends, of course."

Was there a hint of a question in her use of the word friends? Mr.
Ricardo hoped not. The very last thing for which he wished was to be
turned out of the room. The Superintendent took it up indirectly.

"I don't want any misunderstanding, Mrs. Horbury," he said. "You have a
perfect right to refuse to tell me anything, with or without a solicitor
present. The only person you will definitely be called upon to answer

"The coroner," she interposed. "But I have nothing to hide from you,

She sat upon the opposite side of the table, the bright green hedge
beyond the window behind her. The men began to take their seats opposite,
like so many directors at a board meeting. But Superintendent Maltby was
not satisfied. He had his country's belief in fair play, except, perhaps,
so far as Bryan Devisher was concerned.

"This," he said, laying his hand for a moment on Hanaud's arm, "is
Monsieur Hanaud of the Sureté in Paris. You might object to his presence.
I am in your hands."

Olivia Horbury's eyes moved slowly towards the burly Frenchman. There was
no hostility in them, no change in the stillness of her face.

"I think, of all men, Monsieur Hanaud should be here," she said. "He is
far more in this "--she paused, as though she hated to use high-sounding
words--"tragedy, than perhaps he knows."

Hanaud was disconcerted. He looked inquiringly at Mrs. Horbury; he bobbed
his head at her; he sat down rather heavily. "Dee-flated," said Mr.
Ricardo, but he only said it to himself.

"I should be obliged, madam, if you would tell us what happened here last
night," said Maltby, and the detective-sergeant at once produced a
notebook and an indelible pencil.

"Beginning with--?" she asked.

"Your reason for spending the night at White Barn. I understand that it
was not unusual for you and your husband to come here unexpectedly. But
was there yesterday any special reason?"

"Yes," she answered at once. "Dan rang me up yesterday afternoon from
King Street."

"King Street, St. James," said Maltby.


"From his offices?"

"Yes. Witherton's Rooms, where, in the thirties of last century, the
select dined and gambled, and yesterday Daniel only drank a glass of
Pommery '06 and gambled."

A slow and wistful smile changed surprisingly Olivia Horbury's face. It
lost its hard calm and with the calm something of its pallor. A rose-leaf
pink softened it and a tender humour shone in her eyes. She might have
been watching, with more amusement than disapproval, the antics of a not
very well-behaved boy.

"And he was in some trouble?" Maltby asked.

Mr. Ricardo saw the tears suddenly flood her eyes and glisten on her
lashes. He heard her voice check and, for a second, tremble.

"Perhaps. Would I drive him down to White Barn? So many dangers had there
conjured themselves into nothing. Of course, I would! There were no
special arrangements to be made. Daniel changed into his dinner jacket at
the office. I picked him up there and drove him to the Milan Grill, where
we dined. It was, perhaps, half-past seven. He told me nothing at dinner,
but drank--see, I am frank with you, Superintendent!--more than he usually
did. We left the hotel at a few minutes before nine. I noticed the clock
in the small hall. It was the time when the theatres were filling. But
beyond Battersea Bridge there was very little traffic, and I reached
White Barn well before half-past nine."

"You noticed no one in Lordship Lane whom you knew?"

Mrs. Horbury looked at Maltby in surprise. "No. There was no one to
notice," she answered at once. "Not a soul. The gate was open. It is left
open. I drove the car into the space in front of the door and left it so
that it could be backed into the garage. Dan got out and opened the door
of the house with his latchkey."

"That was on his ring of keys?" Maltby asked carelessly.

"Yes," said Olivia, dwelling for a second on the monosyllable. "No

"And he carried the ring in his pocket on a chain?"

The even flow of Mrs. Horbury's narrative was checked. She did not take
her eyes from Maltby's face, but suddenly they were wary.

"As so many people do," Maltby added in an indifferent voice.

"Yes, I suppose he did," she answered. "Anyway, he opened the house door
and came back to the garage."

It was noticeable to Mr. Ricardo, who prided himself considerably upon
the nicety of his observation, that she who had been so slick--he used in
his thoughts that unpleasant word--in her statement of quite unimportant
details, such as the exact time at which they dined and the traffic on
the roads, was now not so sure, was wondering; not what the answer was,
but what it was politic that it should be.

"And I suppose Mr. Horbury backed the car into the garage and locked it
up again?"

"I suppose so."

"He could do that?"

"Oh, yes. He never drove a car because his mind ran off to business in
the midst of Piccadilly, but he could drive," Mrs. Horbury answered.
"Whilst he was putting the car away, I went into the garden-room and lit
the fire. It was dark, but the moon was like gold in a clear dark sky,
and I thought what a pity it was to close out the last of the summer
nights. But Dan liked to be what he called snug--fire burning, blinds
down, curtains drawn, and a glass of the only wine in the world at his
elbow." Again that half smile of amusement and affection gave to her face

"You did share a bottle of champagne yesterday evening, didn't you?" said
Maltby. "And by share, I don't mean divide."

Olivia Horbury bowed her head.

"Yes, but not at once. Dan came in just as I had finished lighting the

"You had left the door open?"

"Yes, and I closed it after he had entered. He flung himself in his chair
at the back of the table. He pulled his fountain pen out of his pocket
and opened the blotting-book."

"Before you go on, may I interrupt?" Maltby asked.

"Of course."

"What had Mr. Horbury done with his coat and hat?"

Olivia looked up at the ceiling as if trying to remember. Then her eyes
were suddenly turned to Mr. Ricardo. Whether she saw him or not, he could
never be sure.

"I don't think he had a hat at all," she explained. "But he certainly
came away from the Milan Grill with a brown overcoat over his
dress-jacket. I expect that he hung it up in the hall."

"He wasn't wearing it, then, in the garden-room?"

"No, I should certainly have noticed it if he had been."

He had taken off his overcoat before he had entered the room.

"Well, you are both in the garden-room," Maltby resumed.

"My husband was in trouble. He said that, to put the lid on, Monsieur
Hanaud was on his way from Paris with a criminal charge against him
which, even if he got the verdict, would ruin his career."

Hanaud sat back in his chair with a look of absolute incredulity upon his
face. "But, madame, this is a lunacy. It was a small affair for him, for
me, too, Hanaud. A small conversation, an injustice put right..."

Mrs. Horbury replied coldly: "My husband did not take it so lightly,
Monsieur Hanaud," and Hanaud threw up his hands.

It was Maltby's moment to take charge again.

"From whom did Horbury hear of Monsieur Hanaud's visit?" he asked.

"I don't know," she said. "He was in great distress and I didn't press
him with questions. He jumped up after that and said that a glass of wine
might help us."

"Yes?" said Maltby, leaning forward a little. He glanced quickly at
Detective-Sergeant Hughes, who was holding his notebook below the table
upon his knees. "Yes?"

"Daniel fetched two glasses of champagne from the kitchen and drank his
own with one gulp."

"Just the two of you standing in the garden-room?"

"Yes. I remember Dan saying with a sort of hysterical laugh: 'That isn't
the proper way to treat a wine like that. Upon my word, I deserve all
that Hanaud can do to me!’"

"He said that?" exclaimed Hanaud without any apologies to the

"I remember it clearly," Mrs Horbury declared; and once more Hanaud sat
back in his chair, but this time with such a look of admiration upon his
face that Mr. Ricardo was quite at a loss to understand it.

"It could not be disputed," he said, bowing to her; and now she was for a
moment disconcerted. "So Horbury does a thing which he had never in his
life done before. He put a bottle of Pommery '06 half-full back in the

Mr.Ricardo was indignant. Hanaud had no manners. He was French, of
course. You had to take that into account. But if ever a man had called a
charming woman a liar to her face, that man was Hanaud of the Paris
Sureté. He just didn't believe that Horbury had put back the half-empty
bottle into the cupboard. Unusual? Perhaps. People did unusual things--he
himself, for instance, who, only two nights ago, had crossed the Channel
in a cockle-boat. However, Olivia Horbury had resumed her story, and it
was more pleasant to listen to her low and melodious voice than to
reflect how curiously wrong Hanaud could be when he was removed from the
perhaps rather sordid purlieus of Paris.

Mrs. Horbury was saying: "Daniel was less discouraged. He had got out of
scrapes just as awkward before. He supposed it was just returning to this
house which so comforted him--but he wondered at times whether the big
fight was worth all it cost--" and then, without a break in her voice,
without any warning change in feature or expression, she uttered a little
cry and covered her face with her hands. She bent her head forward and
the tears ran between her fingers and splashed upon the table. There was
no sound from her throat of a sob, but she pressed her hands tight,
although they could not hold back her tears. Not one of those who saw her
but was distressed. So calm and sedate she had been, she had even laughed
wistfully once or twice as she spoke of Daniel; and then came this flood
of grief as though a gate had burst.

Maltby spoke with compassion: "I am sorry. One cannot help these
interviews being distressing. Perhaps you would like us to wait..."

"No, no!" she cried with a sudden violence. "Let us finish!" She took her
hands away from her face and dried her eyes and swallowed. Then she made
her apology for her outburst. "You are right. It is, of course,
disturbing. But I am almost at an end. For, seeing that Daniel was in an
easier mood, I went up to bed."

"And what time would that be?" Maltby asked easily. "Did you notice?"

"Certainly; there's a clock upon the mantelshelf of the garden-room. It
was half-past ten."

"You expected him to follow you?"

"Yes," she answered. "He gave me three-quarters of an hour, as a rule.
But it had been a tiring evening, and as soon as I was in bed I fell

Monsieur Hanaud now covered his face, but it was to hide a grin, not a
flood of tears. So far, to his thinking, Olivia Horbury had told her tale
cleverly, but there was a snag just ahead of her which he did not see how
she could weather.

"And you slept well?"

"Too well," she answered remorsefully.

"Too well--because you had quarrelled?"

Olivia Horbury was bewildered. She raised her eyes and stared blankly at
the Superintendent. And then to the recognition of all of them
bewilderment became deliberately intended. At first she had been
surprised. Now surprise was being acted.

"If we ever quarrelled, the quarrel ended before we parted," she said,
and waited for a trap to be sprung. Superintendent Maltby obliged.

"How is it, then, since you hadn't quarrelled, and since you expected Mr.
Horbury to follow you in three-quarters of an hour, that your door was
locked against him?"

"But it wasn't!"

The Superintendent jumped in his chair as he heard that calm, quiet
statement. Hanaud looked down at the table; for the smile upon his face
was more pronounced than ever. She would have her answer ready, not a
doubt of it, and quite a good answer, too.

"But, madam," Maltby answered, and now there was a note of sternness in
his voice. He was not a preparatory schoolboy in flannel shorts who must
take what is told him without contradiction. "Your charwoman, Mrs.
Wallace, found your door locked this morning."

"But that's not all she told you," Olivia Horbury returned.

"No, there was more," Maltby admitted.

"Exactly," said Mrs. Horbury. "I left my door on the latch. Daniel, if he
finds me asleep, is careful to make no noise. I slept until I was
awakened by a scream. A scream of horror. I sat up with my heart beating.
I saw that the lights were on, although the sunlight was streaming round
the edges of the blinds. Then I noticed that Dan's bed had not been slept
in, that the coverlet had been turned down, and that his pyjamas were
spread out upon it, waiting for him. Something terrible had happened. I
sprang out of bed, afraid, and I turned the key without thinking. I heard
Mrs. Wallace sobbing and crying out bits of words which I couldn't
understand, and I did "--she shrugged her shoulders--"the fool thing which
women do. I fainted. I know. For when I came to my senses I was lying on
the floor and Mrs. Wallace was banging on the door. I can only have lain
there for a few seconds, but "--and she shivered as she recalled the
moment--"I felt as cold as ice. I unlocked the door and told Mrs. Wallace
to wait until I got into bed again."

She sat with all their eyes upon her, intent upon telling her story
without unnecessary lamentations. If ever a woman was speaking the whole
truth, and nothing but the truth, Mr. Ricardo was certain it was now. If
the telephone had rung at half-past two in the morning, she had not run
down the stairs to answer it, Mr. Ricardo put his hand in his bosom ready
to swear it. Even Maltby seemed to be impressed.

"I see," he said slowly. Then, like one turning to a lighter subject:
"Will you carry your mind back to the hour or two when you and your
husband were in the garden-room?"


"Did Mr. Horbury, during that time, take his keys off the chain in his

Mrs. Horbury's forehead wrinkled. She drew a deep breath or two. "I don't
think that he did."

"Thank you," said Maltby. "There is just one last question which I must
ask you. But I am afraid it is the most trying for you of them all." He
held out his hand to the detective-sergeant.

With a little gasp, Olivia whispered: "That can't be helped."

The detective-sergeant put into Maltby's hand the long, white cardboard
box. It was ornamented with gold lines. It was gay and gleaming, the
sheath of beauty's buckler and weapon, a dainty flickering toy to exploit
a pair of passionate eyes or make malice of an admirable mouth. But the
prettier it looked, the more Olivia Horbury dreaded it. Maltby set it
down on the mahogany table and rather slowly, with his eyes upon Olivia,
"Now!" he whispered. Really, he might have been a conjuror, Mr. Ricardo
thought. And then Maltby suddenly whisked the lid from the box, and there
was no luxurious fan of painted chicken skin with a handle of jade, but
the long, blood-crusted blade and the straight handle of Cambridge blue.

Olivia set her hands against the table's edge and thrust her chair back.
The knife might have been a cobra and she the rabbit, so helplessly she
stared at it.

"Have you ever seen that knife, madam?"

Olivia shook her head once and a second time more violently. But Maltby
must have the word spoken and duly recorded in Hughes' notebook.

"You mean, madam, that you have never seen it before," he said, polite
but insistent.

"I do mean just that," she answered, and, as Maltby covered the box again
with its lid, she uttered a sigh of relief and suddenly swayed in her
chair. Mr. Ricardo uttered a cry. He saw her slipping down by the bed-
room door. "She will fall," he cried.

But however caustic Hanaud might be in words, he was very quick on his
feet when succour was needed. He was already at Olivia's side and
supporting her. "You know what I think?" he asked.

"I do not," replied Maltby.

"I think that a bottle of the Pommery '06 would be the best thing for
Mrs. Horbury."

Mrs. Horbury sprang up at once. "No, please! I am quite well." She turned
to Maltby. "If you have done with me, I will go home."

Maltby bowed to her. "I have to thank you very much for answering my
questions. I shall have to lock up this house for the moment and leave
the constable in charge." He turned to Inspector Herbert. "Mrs. Wallace
must go, too, and will you take her latchkey?"

Herbert went off upon his mission. Mrs. Horbury said: "No doubt you will
want mine, too, Superintendent?"

"I should prefer to have it. Should you need anything here, you have only
to name it to me or Inspector Herbert."

"Thank you," said Olivia. She took a dark blue hat which had been lying
on a chair, pinned it on in front of a mirror, and drew down a veil which
hid her eyes. They gathered in the hall: Mrs. Horbury, the charwoman,
Maltby, Hanaud, Mr. Ricardo, Herbert and Hughes. Mrs. Wallace was the
first to go.

"The detective-inspector has your address," said Maltby. "You will be
wanted at the inquest, of course. Notice will be sent to you."

She went away on foot and then the garage door was opened by Herbert.
"You have petrol enough, madam?"

"More than enough," she answered as she opened the door and climbed into
the car. She drove the little car out into the open and stopped again.

"Monsieur Hanaud," she called, and Monsieur Hanaud advanced from the
group at the garage door. "It is not private," she added, and Hanaud
stopped so that all might hear. "You spoke of some injustice to be put

"Yes, madam."

"You must give me a few days."

"Certainly. It is ages since I was in a vacancy. I will give myself one
now until you are ready."

Olivia Horbury stared for a moment. "I should like your address."

Hanaud smiled. It was the moment for an off-hand gesture, an address
hardly worth giving, so certain it was that he must lodge there. "The
Grosvenor Square. The corner house."

"Oh!" cried Olivia with a little twist of her lips. "Have they got one in
Grosvenor Square now?" and she drove out past the policeman at the gate
and turned her car towards London, her face losing its humour as the
chestnuts and the gardens disappeared. The flat and arid life of the
town--she must get used to that now that Dan, with his rogueries and his
good humour, his preposterous politics and his queer truth to her, had
gone. That, sooner or later, he might go to prison for a long time she
had felt sure, even before she had married. But death--violent, bloody--Dan
hated the sight of blood--this sort of death above all! And as she drove
across Battersea Bridge and past the Houses of Parliament yet a third and
this time a passionate, expression began to burn in her eyes.

* * * * *

The police officers returned to the house. In the upper rooms a bathroom,
two servants’ rooms, a dressing-room for Mr. Horbury, and the big double
bedroom, nothing new was discovered. The windows of the garden-room, its
door, the doors of the dining-room and the kitchen--everything was made

"There will be a man in the house, as well as one outside, until the
inquest's over," said Maltby, as he handed over the keys to Inspector
Herbert. "I have arranged for it at the Station."

They were in the hall, and Maltby was opening the front door when Hanaud
cried: "'Arf a mo! There is somethin' we forget? Yes, no?"

He dashed across the hall, and a rather condescending smile at the antics
of the foreigner which had begun to broaden over Maltby's face was
suddenly frozen there.

Hanaud went straight to a cupboard in the wall. It was not locked. He
pulled it open and there, for all to see, a brown overcoat of a light
weight, and a white silk scarf hung upon a hook.

"Ah!" he cried. "The Horbury's coat!"

He turned it so that the lining showed and the inside pocket in the
breast. He stood up on the tips of his toes to peer into it. Suddenly he
whipped the silk scarf from the hook, shook it out, and spread it over
his palm. He felt in the breast pocket of the overcoat and stood for a
moment, or two afterwards with his back towards his companions, and in
the poise of his head and the stoop of his shoulders there was a bitter
confession of defeat.

Mr. Ricardo, indeed, feared that, he was going to disgrace the whole
confraternity of the Sureté by a shameless attempt to hide his discovery.
But it was not unusual for Mr. Ricardo to be wrong. Hanaud was
double-dyed in his vocation. He would follow relentless through the dark
labyrinth of a crime; but he never pretended when a stiff barrier had to
be climbed; and never denied failure when one simple fact, which could
not fairly be explained away, brought him up all standing and closed the
case. He knew the difference between a full-stop and a semi-colon. So now
he came slowly to his colleagues, holding and hiding his treasure in a
scarf. A semi-colon?--at the least. A full-stop?--maybe.

"It is over," he said, holding forward his swathed hand.

Maltby looked puzzled. "The Case--if it is a Case?" the Superintendent

"Yes. For the Coroner at all events"--the semi-colon, so to speak--"it is

Hanaud turned back with deliberate care the folds of the scarf. Lying
upon it, across the palm of his hand,  was the thick, stiff sheath of a
long knife. It was decorated at the wider end with a pattern in thread of
Cambridge blue.

"And in Horbury's top-coat, eh?"


Maltby looked with a smile of relief at Inspector Herbert. "That settles
it, then."

The knife on the ground beneath Horbury's hand and his finger-marks upon
the handle; the sheath in the pocket of the overcoat in which Horbury had
driven from London: facts. All else was wild surmise.

"For the Coroner, yes," Hanaud repeated as he handed scarf and sheath to
the detective-sergeant.

But for the Red Judge? The full-stop? He was not so sure.


ON the gravelled enclosure where Mr. Ricardo's second Rolls-Royce stood
side by side with the swift but inconspicuous police car, Hanaud spread a
large white hand over his paunch.

"I rumble," he said. "It is the luncheon gong."

Mr. Ricardo bowed eagerly to Superintendent Maltby. "I shall be honoured
if you will join us," he exclaimed, but the Superintendent shook his

"I must go back to the Yard. There are other matters awaiting me." He
noticed the gloom gather on Hanaud's face and hurriedly went on: "You may
be assured that we shall not neglect the interesting points you have
raised. Inspector Herbert will submit a full report, of which you shall
have a copy at the corner house in Grosvenor Square." Not by the twitch
of a muscle did he express his pleasure in that unusual address. "And I
think you should come with me to Mr. Horbury's offices in King Street. At
half-past three? Will you and Mr. Ricardo call for me just before the
half-hour? Meanwhile, I'll send out a call for Bryan Devisher, on the,
chance that he will have something to tell us. And I hope to find all
ready for us at the Yard, some particulars of Mrs. Horbury's history."

Hanaud's face had been growing happier and happier, now that the file was
not to be closed and put away upon its shelf.

"I thank you," he said gratefully.

Maltby was carrying a key with a linen tab tied to it. He called the
constable on duty at the gate.

"This is the charwoman's key. You will be responsible for it, and
Inspector Herbert will see that you are relieved. You will allow no one
to enter the house without his or my leave."

The constable saluted and took the key.

"No one, sir? Not even Mrs. Horbury?"

Hanaud gasped audibly.

"That woman! Above all, no," he whispered, and Maltby took up the words
at once.

"Above all, not Mrs. Horbury."

The constable saluted again and retired to the gate. Maltby glanced
curiously at the Frenchman.

"I thought that you were rather on her side," he said.

And, for a moment, Hanaud hung in a suspense. Should he speak? Shouldn't
he? But he was effervescent. He simply had to.

"That woman!" he cried, and admiration was loud in his voice. "She is a
oner! She is the goods! I tell you. She is out of the top of her

"Really, really," cried Mr. Ricardo, quite shocked.

"An idiom, my friend. I use him," said Hanaud affably.

"Use him properly then," Ricardo remonstrated. "She is out of the top

"So I said, my friend," Hanaud returned, he continued enthusiastically:
"And how she lied! Mind you, she will give back the money of Monsieur
Gravot, even if she starves. In the name of the Place Vendôme, I honour
her for it. But how she lied to us! And with what aplumbing! The woman
screamed, and she jumped out of bed half-awake and turned the key of her
door and fainted. Did she? Oh, no, no!" and his face lost all its humour,
and his voice all its excitement. "Oh, no, no," he repeated in a whisper,
and the lids of his eyes half closed, as though he were watching
somewhere a long way off a scene of horror which nothing could prevent.

"I was looking very sharply, my Maltby, when you placed the long
cardboard fan case down on the table in front of her. I think that
already she knew what was in it. It was not surprise she betrayed. There
was no staring up into your face to read what startling discovery you had
made. No, she gazed at the case, she gathered herself, her feet pressed
upon the ground, her hands gripping each other, to meet with nothing more
than a shock of horror, a recoil of disgust, her second view of that
brutal weapon. She pushed her chair back--yes, with the proper violence,
and no doubt there was nature enough in the violence, but there was no

Undoubtedly both Maltby and Herbert listened with discomfort. It was not
merely that Hanaud's words strengthened an unwelcome suspicion of their
own. But through his heavy features there shone a light, even in his
whispers there sounded an authority which could not but arrest their

"You think she knew already what the thing in the cardboard box was? What
it had done?" cried Ricardo.

"I do," Hanaud returned slowly. "I think that she was present when a
great crime was committed--"

"By Horbury," cried Maltby.

"By Devisher," Mr. Ricardo amended.

"I don't know," said Hanaud.

"And, if she knew, why should she keep silent?" Maltby asked.

"Again, I don't know," Hanaud repeated.

But he was not abandoning his inspiration. If anything, it grew stronger.
For he looked about him, and in that noonday sunlight, with the
blackbirds and the thrushes calling from the garden, he suddenly

"I wish I knew," he cried, a man in distress. "What happened here when
even this house was silent, and nothing moved but the shadows on path and
meadow and lawn, as the moon drenched the world in silver? Let me tell
you what I--see. Her, Olivia Horbury, when the crime was done and the
house empty, climbing the stairs to her room. It was not yet midnight--and
all the long night to live through. She must go to bed, leave the light
on to help the man who needs no more helping. She turns from one side to
the other until--surely it is close on dawn?--suddenly the telephone rings
through the house, shrill enough even to wake that sprawling figure in
the room below. Did she look at her watch and note that the night was not
half spent? And suddenly the telephone stops. Too abruptly, too quickly!
Someone is in the house besides herself and the dead man. A friend? No!
The murderer returned, not trusting her word, to make sure. To make sure
by a second crime. Imagine her panic, if you can? She sprang out of bed,
she locked the door between her and death, and so fell fainting to the
floor, to be awakened hours afterwards by the screams, the banging upon
the panels."

He stopped and a silence followed upon his words. Maltby was the first to
shake off the obsession, but he was troubled, none the less. Although he
strove to speak lightly, his voice betrayed him. "Facts, Monsieur Hanaud!
Facts we must cling to. Not imagination, however subtle."

Hanaud answered with a smile. "Yes, facts, my dear Maltby, and a little
imagination to interpret them. Imagination on a leash--he is the blind
man's dog." He mounted into Mr.Ricardo's car and produced his blue packet
of abominable cigarettes. "Just before half-past three, then!"

"Just before half-past three," cried Maltby from the window of the police
car, "and, my dear colleague, I shall hope for some more idioms from you
in the course of the afternoon."


AT a small table for two in Signor Bentano's restaurant in the Strand,
Monsieur Hanaud tucked the end of his napkin between his collar and his
neck and drank a glass of Porto as an appetiser. It was a restaurant
famous for its cuisine, which was hampered in the evening by an orchestra
in gallery and a crowd on its way to the theatres. But in the morning the
clients were for the most part of the more jovial and sporting business

"So it was here that the Horbury lunched," said Hanaud, looking about
him. "Good! So we get the atmosphere, and that is enough. We eat and we
keep our eyes open, and we talk of the ballet and whether the filet
mignon is as tender here as at Lame's."

And in that way the meal was eaten pleasantly enough, with a bottle of
Clos de Tart to keep it company. At the end of it, Hanaud produced his
inevitable blue packet of black cigarettes. But Mr. Ricardo was firm and
stern. "You shall not," he said. "There are limits. On the borderland of
the Clos de Tart there are Hoyo de Monterrey cigars, but not your
revolting cigarettes."

Monsieur Hanaud was, having been well fed, docile. He lit his cigar. "Am
I allowed a peppermint?" he asked.

Mr. Ricardo smiled indulgently. "You are. A simple glass of Signor
Bentano's brandy will do for me."

Hanaud smiled affably as he sipped his peppermint. "What did your Mr.
Gladstone say in 1884?"

"That will never be known," Ricardo declared firmly. He was not prepared
to argue. By three o'clock Signor Bentano's clients had gone back to
their amusements or their business. At a quarter past, Mr. Ricardo paid
his bill, and the pair travelled in the Rolls-Royce to Scotland Yard.
Maltby and Herbert were waiting, and Maltby handed an envelope to Hanaud.

"You will find in that a copy of all we know about Olivia Horbury. It is
much what you would expect, I think."

Hanaud put the envelope away in his pocket, and the half-hour had not
struck when they were on their way to what had once been Witherton's
Rooms in St. James'.

They were received in a small office of unnoticeable appointments by a
long grey man, as thin as a question mark and almost as bent. He was
handsomely dressed in a dark grey suit with a cutaway morning coat, a
stiff white collar and a grey silk tie. He had a thin grey Chinaman's
moustache, of which he would lure the ends into his mouth and by biting
them assure himself that there was something he need not question. He had
so few qualities akin to the boisterous roguery of Mr. Horbury's career
that all the four men counted him as a watchdog, put in by a firm which
was owed money. The grey man, however, rose to his feet and made a small

"Superintendent Maltby, I believe. I have been instructed to put the
office at your disposal."

"Mr. Foster, then?"


"You have been Mr. Horbury's manager for five years?"

There was still some surprise in Maltby's voice and it brought a sardonic
smile to Foster's mouth. "His managing clerk," he answered, lifting a
hand in correction. "Mr. Horbury's business was, in the main, personal
and conducted by himself. I fancy that I owe my length of service and my
very good salary to the fact that I was honest and that, however
uncongenial some of his activities may have been, I did not pry into what
didn't concern me."

"I see," said Maltby dryly. "It's no use coming to you for secrets."

"No. For I don't know any," said Foster. He crossed the room to a door
and, with something of mockery in the gesture, flung it open. "This,
gentlemen, was Mr. Horbury's private office."

They went into it one by one and stared. Maltby pursed up his lips and
whistled. Rosewood panels decorated the walls, the furniture was
upholstered in red damask, leather arm-chairs stood on each side of the
Adam fireplace, and in the centre, on a thick Aubusson carpet, stood a
beautiful big walnut writing-table, with a semi-circular top of
pigeon-holes and drawers.

"Queen Anne," Mr. Ricardo thought, looking at it with envy.

"Yes, all sheen and costliness," said Mr. Foster, in answer to the
Superintendent's whistle. Maltby, how ever, was less concerned with the
glitter of the office than with his need to reach more familiar terms
with this difficult managing clerk. He had not noticed the irony in
Foster's voice, and was led consequently to make the most unfortunate
mistake. He looked about him with admiration.

"Ah!" he exclaimed. "Big Business, eh?" and saw disdain completely occupy
Foster's face.

"Forty years in the City have led me to associate Big Business with
furniture which invites you to go away as soon as your business is

The Superintendent's approach had been faulty. But he had still one other
pebble if he could fit it somehow into his sling. At the present moment,
however, Foster was not mixing his metaphors. He was driving straight on.

"Mr. Horbury himself, who had the most redeeming sense of humour, knew
quite well that Big Business had nothing to do with the style of this
room. For I ventured, falling, if I may say so, into your mistake,
Superintendent, to expostulate with Mr. Horbury upon it, and he answered,
'My good Foster, the sort of clients you are used to will no doubt
shudder, but the sort of clients I expect will imagine this is the
replica of a nobleman's study.'"

Mr. Ricardo felt internally a sort of warmth. It is, after all, always
pleasant to see a policeman put in his place.

"Big Business," continued Mr. Foster, warming to his theme. He crossed
the room, unlocked a cupboard and flung open the door. On one shelf stood
glasses, capacious goblets of thin glass. On the other bottle upon bottle
of Pommery '06. "Look!" cried Mr. Foster, and he added with the most
assertive waggings of his head, "Cocks don't porp in Big Business."

Mr. Ricardo here felt constrained to intervene. "Mr. Foster means, of
course, that corks don't--" but he was allowed to get no further.

"No, no, my friend," cried Hanaud. "I like him as he is. Cocks don't porp
in Big Business. There is a profundity there." He turned with a bow to
Foster. "I thank you, sir. I use him."

But Mr. Foster was staring curiously at Hanaud. He said to the

"You did not, I think, present me to these gentlemen."

"I am sorry," Maltby answered with a little discomfort. "This is Monsieur
Hanaud of the Sureté of Paris."

He paused, his eyes watching the clerk keenly, but on Foster's face there
was nothing but bewilderment, no realisation that here was Horbury's
enemy; not even any recognition of the name.

"Monsieur Hanaud?" he repeated with an inquisitive glance at the
Frenchman. "But as I told you, Superintendent, Mr. Horbury worked alone."
His eyes came quickly back to the Frenchman's face. "Might I ask you,
sir, whether we owe to your sudden arrival the--the crisis of last night?
If my question is incorrect, I beg you to forget it."

"Your question is incorrect to the last degree," Hanaud returned with a
smile. "But I am glad that you asked. For everywhere I see eyes of
suspicion and hear ditto voices. I came from France yesterday, the
complete incog of the wheel. No one knows me. I came to see the Horbury,
it is true, but on a small matter of business."

Foster's gaze passed doubtfully on.

"And this," said Maltby, "is Mr. Ricardo."

"Oh!" cried Foster. "That is interesting. You rang up Mr. Horbury
yesterday afternoon."

"I did!" exclaimed the astounded Ricardo.

"Yes," said Maltby keenly. "I want the details of that call, Mr.

Ricardo stared blankly at the Superintendent. "You knew about it?"

"Certainly I did. At my first contact with this office I was told that an
unknown Mr. Ricardo had rung up yesterday and obtained from some
incautious clerk Mr. Horbury's address in the suburbs. Come, come, sir!
You have been very quiet about it all, but we have been waiting for you."

Superintendent Maltby, Mr. Foster the clerk, and Inspector Herbert were
all closing in on Mr. Ricardo with determination. He seemed to hear the
handcuffs jingling, he almost looked round for the ewer of his
prison-cell that he might wet his throat.

"Take out your notebook, Inspector, and set down the business Mr. Ricardo
had with Horbury yesterday afternoon."

"I had no business with Horbury," Ricardo persisted.

"And why he wanted the address in Lordship Lane," he exclaimed.

"What time was it when Mr. Ricardo rang up?" Maltby asked.

"Immediately after five," Foster returned; and a great light shone in
upon Ricardo's troubled mind.

"Yes, of course, and he rang up from Victoria Station," he declared,
gazing at Monsieur Hanaud with indignant eyes. "The Continental train was
no doubt punctual."

Hanaud was seldom abashed. "Evidently I rang up from the Victoria
Station. I did not wish my visit to excite the fear, so I did not give my

"That's no excuse for giving mine. And why should people be afraid of
you?" Mr. Ricardo straightened his knees and scoffed at Hanaud's

The Frenchman shook his head in melancholy reproof. "So! You trample on
the poor Hanaud, the alien, the humble one. Yet how you are unjust! It is
a mixture, a jumble up. If I say it is someone who stays with the fine
Mr. Ricardo of Grosvenor Square it becomes, before you can twinkle a
bedpost, Mr. Ricardo himself. You all see that, I am sure."

What Mr. Ricardo saw was that the prison walls were fading into air: what
Superintendent Maltby saw was that a hopeful clue to the suicide of
Horbury, upon which he had set some store, was dead as a doornail.

"Yes, it is a puzzle," said Foster frowning thoughtfully at Maltby. "You
see we are not Big Business, but Switchback Business. Sometimes we are
up, up, up..."

"With cocks porping," Hanaud interposed.

"And the Banks smiling. Sometimes we are down, down, down, with the
creditors filling King Street and Mr. Horbury invisible--and perhaps
Superintendent Maltby not so far away."

"And what was it this time?" Maltby asked quickly, but Foster was equally
quick to avoid an answer. He shrugged his shoulders.

"It was, as I told you, a personal business. We shall know when the
accountants make their report," he said frostily. "But do not expect Big
Business. Even those fine gentlemen," and he pointed to a photograph of a
horse hanging upon a nail, "never won a race except at Ostend."

"Ah," cried Maltby, seizing his opportunity at last, "I'd sooner see a
Rugby football match at Twickenham any day."

Foster gasped. Under the solemn aspect of Superintendent Maltby, he had
found a brother. "Would you?" he cried.

"Rather! Wouldn't you?"

Both faces went back to the Ostend champion, but their thoughts had
nothing to do with the sport of kings. Mr. Foster was turning over in his
mind pictures of finely fought football matches. Maltby was saying
prudently to himself, "You've hooked him. Play him carefully!" With
invariable care, he had left a direction early that morning for a
check-up of Horbury's staff, and of the few discoveries this was
apparently the most valuable. It established him on a brotherly footing
with the old clerk.

"Do you remember the last England and Scotland match?" Foster asked

"My word, yes," Maltby exclaimed ecstatically. He had never seen a Rugby
game since his boyhood. "That was a match!"

"Just a run away from the beginning."

"To the end," Maltby was about to add, and fortunately saved his prestige
by smiling at the ceiling.

"Until the last two quick goals saved us," cried Foster. He laughed
aloud. He almost stood upright. Every Saturday he hurried from the
office, drank a glass of beer, swallowed a sandwich, and passed an
afternoon of enchantment, watching heroes. He turned to Maltby and
grasped him by the arm. "I'll show you what is puzzling me."

He led the Superintendent to a panel of the wall where a large map, was
it?--or cartoon?--was wound up on a spring roller. Foster pulled upon a
string, unrolled it and made the string fast to a nail; and, as if a
military command had been given, everyone in that room took a step
backwards and stared. Maltby was the first to find his tongue.

"It's difficult to surprise me, but if not Big Business, then Hot Stuff!"

Mr. Ricardo, though he sought for a pointed and devastating phrase, could
not achieve it. No doubt he was stunned. "Really, really, what
vulgarity!" he stammered.

Inspector Herbert said nothing and made a note. Perhaps Monsieur Hanaud
was the only one of the four to appreciate it properly. A laugh of
enjoyment, if so thin a sound could be so described, tinkled suddenly.
"He was a--what you call him?--a gamin, a monkey, an urchin, that Horbury!
How I would have liked it if he had lived."

Foster swung round, surprised, and in spite of himself pleased. He was
not as a rule in favour of foreigners. Finicking people who would be
frightened by a good square meal off a saddle of South Down lamb, and
hadn't learnt how to be beaten at games. Yet this one had got nearer to
the truth than any of his visitors.

"That's right, monsieur. A touch of the gutter boy in him, to be sure.
Always winked at himself, whatever roguery he was up to."

The Wembley Stadium had noticeably diminished the correctitude of the
clerk, who chuckled and rubbed his hands. "Half of that was just fun to
him," he cried, pointing to the wall on which the big cartoon blazed.

It represented a crowded House of Commons, Horbury standing in the Prime
Minister's usual place at the Treasury Bench, with his hand on a red box
and an incredulous face turned towards an opponent who had dared to
interrupt him, and the Speaker on his feet with a shocked expression and
these words enclosed, as it were, in a bubble issuing from his lips:
"Order! Order! If it's in Horbury's Newsbag, it is so."

"Pretty crude, the colours," said Maltby with a grin.

"No doubt, but it would nobble the public," Foster returned.

"Horbury's Newsbag," said Maltby. "A newspaper?"

"A weekly," returned Foster.

"But I've never heard of it."

"You were going to," Foster replied. "Switchback Business. A big lottery
on the Derby in Switzerland put us up. Horbury's Newsbag was going to put
us higher. In a fortnight that poster was going to go on every hoarding
big enough to hold it which Horbury could lay his hands upon. A week
afterwards the first number was to be published. He had got his staff for
it. There were to be competitions with tremendous prizes. All the
political stuff he was going to write himself. I warned him that he was
overdoing it. But he wouldn't hear a word. He just looked at that
cartoon--I told you he had a sense of humour--and cried with a grin as
broad as his face, 'I tell you, Foster, Horbury's Newsbag is going to be
Horbury's Nosebag, and pretty full too!' Now mark me, Superintendent
"--and Foster sat down in one of those too easy chairs and shook his
finger at the Superintendent--"and you too, the detective of France.
Horbury said that to me less than a week ago! Well then, explain to me
last night!"

Maltby nodded his head thoughtfully and Hanaud sat himself down at
Foster's side. "There was real money in the bank?" he asked.

Foster answered him a little more stiffly than he would have answered
Maltby. "Lots of it. The accountants, Trenlove and Timmins, a firm of the
highest integrity, will no doubt supply you with a statement."

"You were up, up, up," said Hanaud, "with the cocks porping."

Foster agreed with a smile. "That little joke amused you, eh?" and he
added with a shrug of the shoulders, "but there have been times when the
car rushed head-long down the curve, and there, perhaps, was the
Superintendent at the bottom of the curve, waiting for the smash, and the
razor perhaps not so far from the throat, But last night--no!"

Ricardo was oddly affected by the scene, so that he felt always on the
edge of a revelation, but a revelation which never broke. Maltby, greatly
annoyed that a simple verdict of suicide was becoming less and less
acceptable, and at the same time honestly troubled as to what dark
mystery the evidence was leading to, stood alone, staring now at the
preposterous cartoon, now at the portraits of Horbury's second-class
racehorses. And in the two arm-chairs, side by side, Hanaud and the clerk
talked in low voices quickly together. Anyone who has stumbled into an
accidental witticism and finds it credited to him as intentional will
regard with favour the man who has made this pleasant error. Altogether,
what with this engaging Frenchman and the comrade of Wembley, Foster was
now inclined to give all the help which he had meant to deny.

"Apart from his lottery and the nosebag," Hanaud asked, "was there, do
you think, any private affair which troubled him?" Mr. Foster shook his
head. "Any enemy getting nearer and nearer to him?" Foster looked sharply
at Hanaud and pondered and pondered in vain. "Did you ever hear him
mention Bryan Devisher?"

Foster sprang at the name. Here at all events was something definite,
even if it was definitely to be denied. "I never heard the name before
you spoke it."

The hopefulness died out of Hanaud's voice and Mr. Ricardo recognised
that the moment had come for him to encourage his friend. "But Mr.
Horbury, no doubt, was a man of many secrets," he said.

"Secrets is it?" cried Foster. "To be sure, there were secrets! His, mind

"Yes, his, of course. But sometimes perhaps these secrets had outward
signs with them?"

Superintendent Maltby had swung round upon this question and stood,
holding his attitude, afraid lest a movement catching the eye or ear
should distract Foster's attention.

"Outward signs?" Foster repeated.

"Such as an unlikely visitor and a long conference?"

Mr. Foster reflected, heaved a sigh and shook his head.

"Some unusual thing he did and hid?"

Mr. Foster sat up straight.

"Oh!" he said. "I wonder," and then he sat so long with his eyes bright
and his head on one side like a bird that patience herself could hardly
have borne it.

"I wonder," he whispered to himself, and every head was bent towards him.
But he only relaxed in his chair. He was still seeing something that no
other of them could see. "And hid, you said?" He turned towards Hanaud.

"And hid," Hanaud confirmed.

"Did and hid?"

"Did and hid," repeated Hanaud.

"Yesterday," said Mr. Foster suddenly, and of the four, three started and
smiled, and were warned by a movement of Hanaud's wrist.

"Yesterday," Hanaud whispered.

Foster rose from his chair and crossed the room to the walnut
writing-table. There was a row of pigeon-holes with drawers underneath
them and in the middle a small locked door with walnut wood pillars on
each side. Underneath the table there was a long drawer across and two
smaller drawers, one on each side. Foster pulled at the brass handle of
the smaller and lower drawer on the left-hand side and found it locked.
He looked up at Maltby. "You have Horbury's keys?"

Inspector Herbert advanced, he took an envelope from his pocket and the
bunch of keys from the envelope.

"Thank you!"

Mr. Foster tried one or two before he lit upon the right one. It might
have been play-acting, but, to Ricardo's thought, the man was feverishly
eager now to reveal the secret of that drawer.

"Now we shall see," and he pulled it open. He peered into it, he thrust
his hand into the furthest end of it, and drew it out again with a cry of
disappointment. The drawer was empty. He sat back in Horbury's chair and
looked from face to face, bidding them notice how the fates played with

"But it was there! I saw him put it away when he had done with it and
lock the drawer before he went to his bath. Ah!"

He sprang up, passed through his own room along a corridor. At the end of
the corridor a dressing-room led into a bathroom. A charwoman had
evidently cleaned the room after Horbury had dressed, for the clothes he
had worn in his office lay neatly folded on a couch.

"Oh!" cried Mr. Foster and he darted forward. "To be sure! To be sure! I
had forgotten." He turned round, flourishing triumphantly a copy of an
evening newspaper above his head.

"Was that what you were looking for?" Maltby asked glumly.

"Oh no," he admitted, dropping at once to disappointment. Mr. Foster was
rather like a rock which expands in the sun and contracts sharply in a
frost. "No, and I don't see it anywhere at all. However, we have got the
evening paper," and once more he flourished the paper. He had found it
carefully folded like the clothes and half hidden beneath them. "And that
may help!"

"How?" asked Mr. Ricardo.

But Mr. Foster was lost in thought and to Ricardo's idea, most
provokingly. "I have a notion," Foster exclaimed, and he turned to the

"What we want is a fact," Maltby returned.

Over his shoulder Foster called out, "A notion is the cocoon of a fact."

He hurried down the passage back to Horbury's office, seated himself
importantly in Horbury's chair and, after a definite poise of his left
hand to make clear to all the thing which he was doing, he struck a gong
upon the table with the flat of his palm and sat back, his arms folded.

"Napoleon," Hanaud whispered. "Something will come of it."

A boy came of it. He sat in the general clerks' room, behind Foster's,
and appeared by a parallel doorway.

"John," said Mr. Foster with dignity.

"John yourself," said the boy. "Mr. John Urwick Esquire to you, please!"
So quickly had the discipline of Daniel Horbury's firm disintegrated.

"Mr. John Urwick, will you ask the commissionaire to step here for a

"I don't mind, seeing it's you," John Urwick answered as he swaggered by.
But he swaggered by Mr. Ricardo too, and he, incensed by so much
impertinence crowning so many failures and delays, was carried, to the
very extreme of violence. "Really! Really?" he cried and, swinging his
leg, he landed Mr. John Urwick Esquire a real one in the right place with
the right foot. John with a yelp flew across the room, dropping the Mr.
on one side and the Esquire on the other. He dashed out of the door and
with a speed which marked a new era in his life, brought in the
commissionaire and slunk away behind him to his office. Mr. Ricardo,
however, rather pleased with his resource, was completely occupied by the
commissionaire, who stood at attention before Mr. Foster.

"Brown, you saw Mr. Horbury go away from the office yesterday?"

"I did, sir."

"Did he take anything with him?"

"Yes, sir."

"Do you know what it was?"

"I couldn't help knowing, sir. I was a petty officer in the Navy."

"Oh!" and Mr.Foster was not the only one of that company who was startled
by the answer. "What was it that he took away?"

"A chart, sir," and Foster's hand thumped down upon the table. "Of
course!" and for the first time the Superintendent and his companions
began to learn something of that missing article which had so intrigued
the secretary.

It was a small chart pinned at the four corners on to a flat ebony board
by ordinary flat brass drawing-pins. It was easy enough to carry and it
might have been carried under the arm, but for a difficulty. Pins had
been pricked into the chart as if to mark out a course--only a few of
them, but long ones, black ones with glass heads in the shape and colour
of white ensigns.

Mr. Foster's memory responded to this extra flick. His hand darted to a
small flat box of white cardboard. Within a decorative wreath on the
outside was the name Hamley, and an address. Mr. Foster lifted out the
box from the pigeon-hole in which it lay and opened it. "Like that?" he
asked, holding up just such a pin as Brown had described.

"Exactly that," Brown answered.

Maltby closed the box and took it up from under his nose. Not a very
considerate action, in Mr. Ricardo's judgment, but to be expected.
Fortunately, however, Foster's fingers were still holding the pin which
he had taken out of the box for Brown's inspection. He stepped
noiselessly forward. "One for me, please!" and he snatched at it.

But he only scratched a red line across the back of his hand, for which
the managing clerk made no apology.

"Later on, no doubt," he said, waving the pin back wards and forwards and
using familiar words to answer familiar questions, but with his mind lost
in other matters.

"Horbury was sitting where I am," they heard him say, "and I came in
behind him from my office with some letters for him to sign. Yes. He
hadn't heard me come in. He was bending over something in front of him,
which I now know to be a chart, hunched over it. But where does the
evening paper come in?--wait a bit--I know. Horbury grabbed at it. It was
lying on the top of the desk above the pigeon-holes. He turned over the
pages, hardly read a line at the top of a page, and drove in a new pin
rather viciously. Did he turn the pages of the paper back again--?"

"No," Monsieur Hanaud broke in.

Maltby turned round, half jealous, half friendly.

"How do you know?"

"Look!" Hanaud pointed to the top line of the page. "Shipping news," and
underneath it, "El Rey passed Frawle Point at 6 a.m."

Maltby recognised the name and all that it meant in the shape of further
investigation. He heaved a sigh, reluctant to abandon the simple verdict
of suicide. But he was honest down to the soles of his boots. He smiled
grimly at Hanaud. "Yes, that was the ship which carried Bryan Devisher.
And seven miles farther on, Devisher took a header into a rough sea.
Yes--but damn!"

The oath came from the heart of a busy, overworked public servant who
couldn't have shirked the least item of his job even had he wished to.

Mr. Foster had no ears at this moment for either Hanaud or Maltby. He was
sunk deep in his recollections.

"I was standing"--he looked round--"just where Brown is standing. There
was, yes--I think I can say that--a little gasp of fear when he looked at
the evening paper, and he jabbed rather viciously the last pin into the
chart. By the way--" and he turned round with a smile. "All right, Brown,
that will do," but when Brown had gone, the smile was still upon his
face. "Did you notice those pins? Black pins with the White Ensign
flying. Very characteristic of Horbury. All for King and Country. The old
rogue--you couldn't but like him. He must have gone out of his way to the
toy shop in Regent Street to get those pins. However, there he was
jabbing his pin in, and he was suddenly aware of me behind him. He just
flung himself over the chart and said: 'You can leave those letters on
the little table by the fireplace. I'll sign them before I go,' and he
pulled out the lower drawer on his left hand, as if he were going to
replace the chart as soon as I left the room. But, you see, he took it

Mr. Foster swung round in his chair.

"Yes," said Maltby.

"Yes," said Hanaud.

"Yes," said Mr. Ricardo.

"Yes," said Inspector Herbert.

They stood in a semi-circle about Foster's chair, brooding upon him. Mr.
Ricardo could imagine nothing more intimidating than the group they
formed, and, indeed, felt some secret pleasure that he was one of the
intimidators. Foster was undoubtedly affected. He rubbed the palms of his
hands together, leaning forward in his chair.

"There, that's all," he cried, throwing himself back and meeting
Ricardo's gaze rather than the gaze of any of the others.

"Ah, ha! he looks at you. You are the magnetic one," said Hanaud in a low

Ricardo wished that the charge were true. "I accuse him less," he
answered regretfully.

"It is curious, though, that Horbury should have taken that chart away
with him to White Barn," Foster resumed carelessly. He was seeking an
opportunity of breaking up that arc of intimidating bodies and faces and
slipping out of it. But Hanaud was too quick for him.

"It is still more curious that not a fragment of the chart, not a
splinter of the ebony board, nor even one of the drawing-pins was to be
found at White Barn."

"Yes; that is more curious still," Foster admitted. "Someone must have
taken it away."

"Then you admit a someone," said Maltby sternly.

"No, I do not," cried Foster agitatedly, and then surrendering:

He took the bunch of keys from the lower left-hand drawer where it
dangled and, fitting one to the lock of the small chamber in the middle
of the pigeon-holes, he said:

"There's a letter. It won't help you. I didn't mean to mention it because
it could clearly have nothing whatever to do with your case. It is
written to really Big Business, you know. I was more than a little
astonished that Horbury should be writing at all to this person. However,
he was, and a long letter, too."

"Do you know what it was about?" Maltby asked.

"Not an idea," replied Foster. "But it had enclosures, I remember
noticing that."

"And the address?" said Hanaud.

"Oh, yes. The address, of course. Horbury made no secret from me that
there was such a letter, you must understand. If anything happened to
him--you know the way men talk--I was to see that it went."

"He said that?" exclaimed Mr. Ricardo. "If anything happened to him--"

"I think the material words were I was to see that it went," replied
Foster. "For he said them with a wink..."

"A wink?" repeated Hanaud.

Foster nodded. "A bit phoney, eh? But you'll be able to break the seal
and see for yourselves."

"It was sealed, was it?"

"Yes, black wax. Horbury pointed that out to me and winked again.
Suggestive, eh? Hot stuff, I think, my late employer."

"That's all very well," said Maltby. "But that little cupboard you've
opened is as empty as Mother Hubbard's. There's nothing in it."

Foster grinned. "It's not as easy as all that, you know. There's a little
wooden latch in the roof of it." He felt with the tip of his middle
finger and shot back a wooden peg. Then he stretched his hand in to the
back of the cupboard where a hole had been cut in the side wall. "Here
she comes!" He was now able to slide forward the pillar on the left side
of the cupboard. It was seen to be a narrow drawer set vertically, so
that the opening was at the top. He took it out, turned it upside down
and shook it. It was as empty as the cupboard. He tapped the sides and
shook it a second time. He peered into it.

"It was there!" he cried. "He put it away for safety."

Superintendent Maltby took the drawer and examined it. "Anyone who knew
the trick might have stolen it," he argued.

"No. He would need to open this little door first, and for that he would
want the key."

"Can you tell when he took it away?"

Foster nodded his head. "Yesterday," he answered. "Horbury was very busy
with his first number of the Newsbag. So it was only two days ago that he
had an hour or two to spare. He made up his packet and sealed the
envelope and put it away ready in the secret drawer the day before yester

"Yesterday, then," Maltby agreed. "And ready for use, if the person whom
it affected was not amenable, eh?"

Mr. Foster set back the secret drawer in its place, shot the wooden latch
into its place, locked the cupboard drawer, and, with a great formality,
handed back the keys to the Inspector. He was once more the managing
clerk, official and discreet.

"I could not for a moment, Superintendent, subscribe to any such
suggestion," he said, and Monsieur Hanaud rose with a smile from his

"No, no, my friend, that is clear, and the Superintendent never meant
that you should," he said gaily. "But one thing, you can tell us, the
great boum to whom the package was addressed."

"The Big Noise," Mr. Ricardo said usefully to a rather perplexed managing

"Yes. You certainly have a right to the name," the managing clerk
replied. "It was the name of Septimus Crottle, the head of the great
Dagger Line, and it was addressed to him at his private residence, 41A,
Portman Square."


DINNER was finished. The windows were open and the road across Grosvenor
Square was quiet as a country lane. Yet even so, it was hardly more quiet
than the dining-room where the three men sat about Mr. Ricardo's round
table. Four pale blue candles, set in tall, painted candlesticks of
Battersea enamel burned, and no other light. The three men had pushed
their coffee cups aside; they were smoking; but they were not talking,
until Mr. Ricardo, embarrassed by the silence, must needs break it with a
not very happy fancy.

"My four candles burn in the dusk like little flaming spears, the
brighter as the darkness grows. I have two flaming spears one on each
side of me, and the blacker the problem, the more brilliantly they will
pierce it."

Hanaud shook his head. It was difficult for Ricardo to gauge the hooded
look of his face, but he replied with a gravity in his voice which
Ricardo had heard only once or twice before. "For myself, I could find a
better image in one of your candles than a spear pointing to the truth."


"A heart turned upside down."

Julius Ricardo was as much startled by the quiet voice as by the strange
figure which he used. "By what?" he began, but he felt Maltby's hand
close upon his arm. Hanaud, however, answered the unfinished question.

"By fear."

And for a moment the darkness seemed to deepen and the illumination of
the candles to grow dim.

"I have been feeling like a man who is sent to find a number in one of
the narrow corridors of your new hotels. You cannot find it, and at the
end the corridor turns, and again the corridor turns, and again you
cannot find the room. But for me, I meet fear."

Once more there was silence, but Ricardo no longer wished to interrupt
it, and Maltby's hand was withdrawn from his sleeve. Then Hanaud resumed:

"Permit that I tell you how it grew. First we have a suicide, a thing
simple, and with the Horburys almost natural. The razor close to the
throat, as the good Foster said. But not now. The business is up, up, up.
Horbury's Newsbag becomes Horbury's nosebag. The great poster will be on
all the streets. Laughter and money and cocks porping--yes, yes, yes. But
suicide. No!"

"There was the chart," said Maltby.

"The chart Horbury leans over to hide from the Foster eyes, I do not
forget him. One cannot doubt what he represented with his black glass
pins with the white ensign, and the last pin jammed in angrily opposite
to the Prawle Station. It marked the journey of that old steamship El
Rey, the ports she had put into to deliver back her unsatisfactory
visitors, the Lloyds Stations she had signalled. A trouble, yes. A
danger, perhaps; but to be met to-morrow. That night, no danger at all.
El Rey was still upon its way. It was rounding Beachy Head."

"That's quite right," Maltby agreed. "There was a clerk from Horbury's
office at Gravesend to meet El Rey in the morning. Horbury couldn't have
expected Devisher."

"Yet he took with him to White Barn the chart?" I said Hanaud, pursuing
his own thoughts. "Why?"

"Oh, that's easy," answered Maltby. He leaned back and drew at his cigar
with a greater ease than he had shown before. "He had tried to hide it
already from Foster. He wanted to get rid of it."

"And he certainly did," cried Mr. Ricardo, clenching the matter finally
with a rather irritating laugh.

"How?" asked Hanaud swiftly.

"There was a log fire," Mr. Ricardo replied no less swiftly.

"Saperlipopette!" cried Hanaud, beating with his fist on the table. "That
will not do. That tough white paper of which the charts are made. That
little flat ebony board. All burnt up in a small log fire so that not an
ash of blackened paper, not a splinter of the board, not even a brass
drawing-pin is left to tell us here it was burnt. I am for the miracle,
yes; but miracles must be reasonable."

It did occur to Ricardo that the question whether a miracle could be a
miracle if it was reasonable might be a diverting subject for a debating
society. But Hanaud was too much in earnest. He had never known Hanaud
utter that explosive outrage of a word--Saperlipopette--unless he was in
his most serious mood. So without flippancy he suggested: "That chart may
have been overlooked in White Barn."

Hanaud shrugged his shoulders. "My dear friend! The English police! They
may be accused of the want of imagination, perhaps, but they do not
overlook things, no, not anything. And a little chart nailed on an ebony
board with glass pins pricked in? No, no, let us be serious."

"All the more serious," added Maltby imperturbably, "because a second
search was made in White Barn after we had left Horbury's office this
evening and nothing was found."

"Very well." Mr. Ricardo would accept the disappearance of the chart by
another agency than the log fire. The explanation was to be found with
the explanation of Horbury's death in Hanaud's hinted theory of the

"Very well. The man Devisher comes to White Barn. It is the address of
Horbury which he remembers. He comes late, he quarrels, having good
reason for a quarrel. He murders--that was your fear--and, taking the chart
with him, he goes--"


The abrupt question shot at him across the table brought Mr. Ricardo to a
stop. After all, that was to be considered, and at once a mountain of
difficulties confronted him. Devisher had arrived probably at half-past
three in London, in a borrowed suit of clothes, what was left of fifteen
pounds after his fare and his luncheon had been paid, and no luggage. He
had found his way to Lordship Lane, if the theory of a revengeful murder
were accepted, unnoticed, and had unnoticed got away in the middle of the
night to some place where he could lie in safety.

"Ever since you gave us his name and description, the search has gone
on," said Maltby gloomily. "Hotels, lodging-houses, shelters--a man
without passport or luggage."

"Add that he has not been in England or in touch with anyone in England
for seven years, shall we say?--and then that he disappears as easily as
if he had a place in every thieves' kitchen in London--that is hard to

"But it might happen," cried Mr. Ricardo, "and perhaps it might be the
more likely to happen if he were unaware that anyone was looking for him."

Monsieur Hanaud threw up his hands.

"We lose ourselves in the dialectic. We make up the fairy tale. We sober
policemen! I tell you my trouble."

He pushed everything away from in front of him--plates, cups and saucers,
table-mats--making an empty space as though he were about to deal a pack
of cards.

"In the first place, there is no reason for suicide. The excellent Foster
makes that clear. In the second, Horbury has a poor little wretch whom he
has injured, due to arrive in England this morning. Horbury has made his
arrangements that the man shall be met. That he was afraid of him there
is no sign. But the man was already in England. It may be that he made
his way to White Barn last night. It may be that he murdered Horbury--just
settling his account. I do not say no. But I do not say yes. I say that
if he was at White Barn, taking a desperate chance, he blundered in upon
some much bigger affair, and must be hidden away now."

Superintendent Maltby pushed out his under-lip and glowered at the
mahogany table.

"I haven't got that," he protested. "Devisher was not alone, or, at all
events, ceased to be alone? Of course, his disappearance, a man without
money or luggage or friends--yes, I suppose you might infer that there
were others, or one other, who was concerned in seeing that he got safely

"And the wife," Hanaud added quickly. "Olivia Horbury. Let us not forget
her. Whatever we told her, whatever we showed her, she was not startled.
Full of horror, as anyone would be who was forced to live over again some
dreadful hours, but surprised--no. She knew. She was present. Yet she
would not speak."

"Perhaps she had been cowed..." Ricardo began, but he suffered his very
frequent experience of never being allowed to finish a sentence.

"Ah! Ah! Ah!" exclaimed Hanaud. "I see you. But she was not cowed to-day
with the police at the gate and in the house. Then what was the
compulsion which shut her lips? Something grim--something brutal. The sure
knowledge that if she spoke, she would follow on the husband's road. Oh,
there was someone else at White Barn last night, and that someone

"Devisher?" Mr. Ricardo suggested "To recover the chart on the ebony

Hanaud nodded his head once or twice, dissatisfied but unable to
disregard the argument. "It may be. He would not want the chart
discovered. It points too clearly towards him."

"But you yourself think that someone else came for something else?" said

There was amusement in his voice and, at the same time, respect. It was
amusing that Hanaud should so shut his eyes to the obvious explanations
of Horbury's death, suicide or murder by Bryan Devisher; that he should
chase in his mind some phantasm of his own creation. And yet, he had the
power to leave one uneasy. That image of a narrow corridor, and another,
and another, and at the end--fear. Maltby certainly did not like it.

"You think Mrs. Horbury is in danger?" he said.

"That, I think, could be," replied Hanaud.

"From Devisher?" Maltby persisted, and Hanaud suddenly thrust forth his
hands, palms outwards.

"No, no, no! My Maltby. I am not here to make the confusion, to tickle
you with the red-hot poker. Joey in the woodpile. No! I abandon you for
your delight and go upon my vacancy."

And the three men lost at once their tension. Cigars were renewed, a
business-like decanter of Armagnac went forth upon its rounds. Maltby,
Ricardo, both were at pains to discover the ideal place where Hanaud
might pass his vacancy. "Margate," said Maltby. Ricardo plumped for
Brighton. But the unaccountable Hanaud had already his own plan.

"Cathedrals," he said "I like to sit on the pavement under a stripy
awning at a marble table and look at them. They are solid. If I cross the
road to one and say, 'I arrest you,' it does not mind. It just says,
'Here is that foolish little Hanaud,' and very far away, in the depths of
her, I hear a chuckle. Yes, I shall to see a cathedral to-morrow. I am
told she is very beautiful."

It was astonishing, even to Ricardo, to discover so much romance under
the practical urgency of Hanaud's character, but he was startled to hear
the Frenchman add: "She has what is rare, perhaps, the flying buttocks."

Maltby jumped in his chair. Mr. Ricardo looked coldly at his friend. "A
French cathedral, no doubt," he commented acidly.

"No, no!" Monsieur Hanaud was as serious as a man could be. "I shall not
give you the laugh by pronouncing the barbaric word of the city which she
makes beautiful. No, I shall lead a porter at the rail way station to a
board. I shall point with my stick, I shall press money into his thorny

"Horny," said Mr. Ricardo.

"And I shall say," continued Hanaud, without paying the slightest
attention to Ricardo's interruption, "'Please to buy me the go and return
ticket to that unpronounceable place. For I am now upon my vacancy.'"

Superintendent Maltby stubbed out the butt of his cigar into an ash-tray.

"I should like to see the porter's reaction to your request," he said,
and then the smile left his face. "So you give up?" he cried with a
challenge in his voice; and, indeed, that was to Ricardo the most
astounding factor in the whole case. Hanaud gave up. He would go on a
vacancy and moon under a stripy awning on Gothic architecture.

"Yes, my dear Maltby. You shall have your way. You shall make that
amusing Horbury a fellow of the sea. It shall all be as you wish. And yet
I hope that when I come back and have my little meeting with the adorable
Madame Horbury and carry off my cheque for the patient Gravot of the
Place Vendôme, you, as you say good-bye, will tell me something I much
wish to know."

"Oh?" Superintendent Maltby put his interrogation suspiciously. "And what
is that something?"

Hanaud shrugged his shoulders. He flapped a hand and flung the subject
away. Yet he was curious.

"Yes, I would like to know what Switchback Business had to write to Big
Business. What Horbury's Newsbag had to say to the great Dagger Line of
Steamships. And what Daniel Horbury enclosed to Septimus Crottle in so
carefully sealed an envelope."

"But that letter has disappeared," cried Ricardo.

"Precisely, my friend," Hanaud returned. "That is why I am curious."


WHEN the unobtrusive Thompson slid into Mr. Ricardo's bedroom the next
morning with his morning tea, carried over land through how many
countries, lest one tang of the sea should tincture its fragrance, he
carried in upon the tray a note from Hanaud. Mr. Ricardo was grateful. No
man was less hail-fellow-well-met in the morning, than he. Rosy-cheeked
people who hardly knocked before they bustled in, nephews and nieces and
such-like modern importunities, were not allowed. The act of getting up
was a slow and quiet ritual, to be conducted without words. Not until he
was afoot and dressed would he consider with what rocks and stones and
trees he was to be rolled round in earth's diurnal course.

It was, therefore, with a desire to do what he could for his friend that
he opened his note. Mr. Ricardo read that Hanaud had put off his visit to
the unpronounceable city owing to the persistence of a surprising idea.
He himself must see this Septimus Crottle. He had no authority by which
he could claim an interview. He was of no account in this Horbury affair.
It was even possible that Septimus had never heard the name of Hanaud,
for nothing was more curious than the smallness of the orbits within
which fame was circumscribed. As Mr. Ricardo had himself observed, no one
could answer what Mr. Gladstone had said in 1884. Well, then, it would be
desirable that Hanaud should have an introduction to Septimus Crottle,
and who could give it but that excellent Mister the Captain Mordaunt,
who, one might think--No? Yes?--had a passion for introducing strangers to
Septimus Crottle. Monsieur Hanaud threw himself at the feet of his dear
friend. 'I understand, the note concluded, that Septimus Crottle is
difficult, but as you know I am at my best with difficult people. You
have seen me at work. I am inspired, I soar.' and he signed in his usual
style as a peer of the realm.

Mr. Ricardo derided the signature and scoffed in his mild way at the
vanity of the writer. But he, too, was reluctant to leave this odd matter
of Horbury's letter to Septimus Crottle undiscovered. He wanted to know
the answer to a host of other questions besides. Who had come to the
house and lifted the telephone receiver in the early morning? Why had
Olivia Horbury locked her door? And when? And why, with Horbury's Newsbag
ready to become Horbury's nosebag, had Horbury drawn that unusual
blue-handled knife across his carotid artery--if he had?

Mr. Ricardo accordingly rose, dressed with his usual circumspection, and
found Captain Mordaunt preparing to eat his luncheon at his club and more
than a little worried. He drew Ricardo into the bar as if he had been his
dearest friend. "A cocktail before we lunch?"

The invitation was, in the modern phrase, telescoped. "I'd rather have a
Manzanilla," said Mr. Ricardo, and the barman gazed at him with the awe
due to a customer who knew of a drink unknown to the barman.

"We're just out of it, sir," he said. He thought of embroidering his
statement with the news that there had been a great run lately on that
there drink, but the theme was dangerous.

"A glass of your driest sherry, then," said Mr. Ricardo, and with Uncle
Pepe the barman walked on solid ground.

At luncheon, Mordaunt began whilst Mr. Ricardo was still twittering.
Maltby had called on him this morning, Maltby with an infernal fellow
with a notebook. Where was Bryan Devisher? Why wasn't his arrival
notified to the authorities? Etcetera, etcetera.

"I am bound to say that Maltby was pleasant," Mordaunt continued. "He
seemed to know already all that I was telling him."

Mr. Ricardo smiled wisely. "He was checking up the statement I had
already made."

Mordaunt stared at his companion and leaned forward eagerly. "Perhaps you
can help, Mr. Ricardo. I must leave England on Monday. Ticket taken,
cabin booked. All that could stop me would be the police."

"You're not involved in any way," said Mr. Ricardo confidently. "You did
all that a reasonable man in a hurry could be expected to do. I am here.
We told the same story, no doubt. I am sure that Maltby won't want you to

Captain Mordaunt was greatly relieved. His voice lightened, his face lost
its gloom and, as he looked at the trim and decorous Mr. Ricardo, a smile
came and went upon his lips.

"So there is an affair of a kind?" he suggested. Mr. Ricardo seemed to
weigh his inclination to talk against his reticence as an unofficial
sleuth. "Yes. I can say so much--there is," he said darkly.

"And you are in it, of course."

In a whisper, attended by a knowing smile, Mr. Ricardo replied: "Up to
the neck."

"Crime, then?"

Crime, the wonderful word. It drew the two men together in a net. That
crime fascinated Mr. Ricardo was known to all his acquaintances. But were
they not fascinated, too? Let a man say in any company that he has been
present at the Old Bailey when an crime is being probed and established,
a silence will follow upon his words, however carelessly he may speak
them. He may be merely the dullard, the last-wicket-rabbit brought in to
make up the party, but at once he becomes the cynosure. He will be plied
with questions. He will not relapse into obscurity until all that he can
contribute on the characters, the passions, and the event which have
woven the dark pattern, has been brought to light. And even then each one
of the party with a small pang of regret, reflect: "If only I had been in
his place, I should have noticed so much more."

So now Captain Mordaunt, though his hopes were cast overseas, leaned
forward with shining eyes. "Yes. You are known to be a student of crime,
Mr. Ricardo."

At such moments Mr. Ricardo was apt to become a trifle fatuous. He
laughed affectedly. "Not really? A dilettante, perhaps. But a student?
Well, perhaps others might say so."

"Maltby said that you had got the little Frenchman with you."

"Little! My dear Mordaunt! He's as big as a bull and quite as

"I'd like to meet him," said Mordaunt; and there was a great deal more
than mere curiosity in the warmth of his voice.

"My dear fellow," said Ricardo, "nothing could be easier."

He had his cue, and over the luncheon table he told Mordaunt all that he
knew of the Horbury puzzle.

"Devisher has disappeared. Yes, an ominous fact. Yet Hanaud seems to set
as much--no, I am inexact--more importance upon the sealed letter with the
enclosures addressed by Horbury to Septimus Crottle. Has he received it?
If so, why does he keep it to himself? Does he know nothing about it?
Hanaud would very much like to make Crottle's acquaintance."

"Septimus Crottle is a queer old bird," said Mordaunt doubtfully.

"A crotchety patriarch, I think you called him," Mr. Ricardo added.
"Hanaud is aware that he must tread gently."

"Yes, but the old man doesn't," replied Mordaunt. "He's a trampler." He
thought for a moment. "I tell you what. We'll have some coffee and a
cigar upstairs whilst I see what I can do."

They went upstairs to the smoking-room. Coffee and liqueurs of brandy
were put beside them on small stools.

"Cigars," ordered Mordaunt, and at once Mr. Ricardo broke in.

"Claro, please! At this hour not a Colorado."

"Good God, man," Mordaunt exclaimed, "I'm not offering you a beetle";
and, having established Mr. Ricardo in comfort, he went off to the
telephone office. He returned in a quarter of an hour.

"It is all right. I didn't mention the letter or, indeed, anything about
Horbury's death. I should think he'll go straight up in the air when he
hears that Horbury has written to him at all. But that's your pigeon. All
I said was that Hanaud and you want to have a word with him."

"And he's willing?"

"Yes. A nice bit of crime, you know! I am going to him on Sunday evening
and I'll take you and the Frenchman with me. But I warn you. You have got
to fit in. Sunday night is his company night. There's a ritual. The
family, one or two friends. We have a glass of port, then someone reads a
book, then the girls--there isn't one of them under thirty--are sent off to
bed, and then you'll get your conversation. You're not to dress, and you
have your dinner before you go. I'll come to your house at ten minutes to

Mr. Ricardo drew back. The order of the day was not to him a phrase for

"Then we must dine at seven!" he exclaimed incredulously.

"Yes, the old man moves with the times," said Mordaunt. "When he was
captain of the steam-packet Tunis he dined at six."


SEPTIMUS CROTTLE lived in a big Victorian house in a big Victorian way.
There was now no outward sign upon him that he had not lived upon the
land all his life. The weather had faded from his cheeks, and neither an
eye of steel nor an aura of tremendous authority are qualities limited to
sea captains. It might, indeed, have been Mr. Dombey who received his
three new guests at eight o'clock of the evening in his dining-room in
Portman Square. He wore a long frock-coat of broadcloth, and above the
folds of a black satin neckcloth, decorated with a single pearl of great
size, two sharp points of white and glossy collar clipped his face.

"You will drink a glass of port, gentlemen," Septimus said. "Mary, set
some chairs and glasses."

There was no manservant in the house; patriarchs, after all, are waited
upon by maidens. Mary cleared three places at the long table, one upon
Crottle's right for Monsieur Hanaud and two upon his left for Mordaunt
and Mr. Ricardo. The ladies, of course, had already retired to the

"I welcome you to my house, Monsieur Hanaud," said Septimus, holding up
his glass of wine.

"It was gracious of you to invite me, Mr. Crottle," Hanaud returned,
holding up his.

Both men bowed and drank, and Hanaud, as he put his glass down, exclaimed
in an ecstasy: "And this is a wonderful glass of Porto which you are
giving me!"

"It's the best," said Septimus, quite simply. "It's mine. George, fill
Monsieur Hanaud's glass."

A fair-haired youth upon Ricardo's right obeyed with a broad grin upon
his face and a twinkle in his eye.

"The guv'nor decanted it himself from his own private bin, Monsieur
Hanaud," he said genially. "There aren't many to whom he shows that

Hanaud tasted his wine and looked up at the ceiling. He tasted it again
and held it for a long time in his mouth, and swallowed it at last
slowly, with his eyes closed. Mr. Ricardo was disgusted with his friend's
behaviour. To Hanaud, Porto was Porto, and the blacker it was and the
stickier it was, the more Hanaud enjoyed it. "Look at the hypocrite," Mr.
Ricardo said to himself. "He's obsequious."

But obviously Septimus was pleased. "I shall offer you a cigar," he
continued, "but I am afraid that must wait until after our reading. Mean
while I should like to present to you my nephew, George Crottle. The
gentleman sitting on the other side of Captain Mordaunt you may perhaps

Hanaud looked at a thin, tall, narrow man with a grey moustache.

"Yes, yes," he said with an air of surprise as he held out his hand. "I
certainly have had the honour to meet him."

"Mr. Alan Preedy is one of the Line's solicitors."

"But in a very small way," Preedy put in modestly. "I don't aspire to
famous cases."

"No doubt they will come," Hanaud protested.

"But not, I hope, in connection with the Dagger Line," said George
Crottle in mock dismay.

"I think that is unlikely," said Septimus, with a touch of irritation in
his voice. "I have another nephew"--and the irritation was still
audible--"who apparently is not giving us the pleasure of his company

"I beg your pardon, sir," Preedy interrupted rather eagerly, as if he
recognised that a smooth relationship between the elder and the younger
branches of the Crottle firm was one of his duties. "I fancy Mr. James
arrived a moment ago."

Septimus turned his head and listened.

"I can't hear a sound," said George. "Old James has carted us, this night
of all nights, when our Uncle Septimus is reading."

Septimus looked at his nephew with approval, but Alan Preedy still
appeared for the absent one.

"It was a taxi stopping at the door which I heard, and the passing of
change makes the driver, as a rule, undress himself by several layers of
clothes. Ah, there he is!"

Alan Preedy had hardly finished before the housebell rang, but he had
finished. Mr. Ricardo looked with admiration at the lawyer, upon whose
face there rose a blush.

"Yes," said George gaily to Ricardo, "if I wanted to listen at a keyhole,
I should brief Preedy as my substitute. It's quite a gift."

Monsieur Hanaud seemed to be concentrating his attention upon his Porto,
and said nothing.

James Crottle, a tall, dark and grim young man, entered the room. He made
his apologies to his uncle, clapped Preedy heartily upon the shoulder,
and said with a laugh:

"The law's delays are nothing to a taxicab's."

He nodded to Mordaunt, was introduced to Hanaud and Ricardo, and took his
seat at the table on the side of the Frenchman. The difference between
him and George was remarkable. George, the fair-haired youth, seemed by
comparison with him of almost feminine good looks. There was a supple
grace in his slim figure and a friendliness in his smile and eyes which
James was without. James leaned a little forward and said to Hanaud: "My
uncle did not tell us that we were to have the honour to-night of meeting
anyone so distinguished as you."

There was just a hint of a question in his words which Septimus took up:
"Monsieur Hanaud has, I gather, some matter of importance which he wishes
to talk over with me afterwards."

Coffee was brought in on a great silver tray, and Ricardo, under such
security as the clatter of the cups granted him, said to his neighbour,
Alan Preedy: "This is to me the greatest blessing of the evening so far.
For keep my head from nodding during a reading, that I cannot do."

"Septimus isn't so bad," Preedy returned. "It's his turn to read
to-night, thank the Lord! You'll see, he'll probably keep you awake."

At that moment the parlourmaid entered the room and announced to Septimus
that the ladies were assembled in the drawing-room and that the clock had
struck the hour three minutes ago.

"Then I suppose that we had better go, Mary," he said with a smile.

"Yes, sir, and the room all prepared as if it was for a Church Service,"
she answered.

For perhaps a minute Mr. Septimus did not budge, a little colour rose
into his face, the smile remained upon his mouth, and a sparkle of fire
revived the youth of his eyes. He looked and smiled straight ahead of
him, savouring in advance the small ritual of the assembly, the resonance
of his voice, the stillness of his audience as he held it in a magic web.
There was romance in these Sunday nights for Septimus Crottle. At this
hour, once in every fourth week, he recaptured some shadow of the thrill
and glory of his first command. When he opened the book, he stepped again
upon his bridge. He was no longer the owner of the Dagger Line, concerned
with questions of policy, he was the young Lord and Master of his ship,
of its passengers, its crew and its cargo. He stood at the pilot's side
in Southampton Water with his eyes fixed upon tropical harbours, where
after weeks of vigilance he would hear the thunderous rattle of the
anchor chains in the bows. He rose from his chair, his old wrinkled face
eager and radiant. "Let us go!" he cried on a rising note.

Mordaunt noticed the change and smiled. "He has dropped his pilot. He has
set his course between the Spithead Forts for the Nab. Has he the
clusters of palm trees in his vision, a scent of strange perfumes in his
nostrils, the sing-song of coolies in his ears? And he's only stepping
from a dining-room to a drawing-room in Portman Square."

But this was Mordaunt's thought and his alone. It was prompted by the
same instinctive sympathy which had once made him row down Helford River
to Passage to hear some home-truths from this redoubtable old man.

Mr. Ricardo was not given to such fancies. He was simply troubled by the
knowledge that for an hour, in a room where every curtain, every piece of
furniture was certain to offend the eye, he must listen to this old
fellow droning out the pages of a book. Monsieur Hanaud, for his part,
was puzzled, and he was showing that he was puzzled--showing it so much
indeed that as he walked towards the door of the room, he felt a hand
upon his sleeve. He turned and saw George Crottle at his elbow.

"Something, I can see, is perplexing you, Monsieur Hanaud. Can I help?"

Hanaud was at once all contrition and apology. He stammered, he spread
out his hands.

"It was an impoliteness....I beg you to forgive. The habit grows of
itself....One asks oneself the questions, and suddenly one is guilty of
an inconvenience."

"Not a bit," George replied. "I could see you looking from James to me
and from me to James."

Hanaud was more confused than ever. "I had no right to make the
comparison," he said.

"No. And I should not have been surprised. So often one sees it--in

"Who don't seem to belong to the same litter, eh?" George returned with a
laugh. "James!" and the dark young man turned back from the door.

"'What is it?" he asked, not too pleasantly.

"All is discovered! We are lost!" George resumed, and he turned again to
Hanaud. "You are right, Monsieur Hanaud, we are not brothers at all, and,
what's more, our names aren't even Crottle."

James uttered a small cry of impatience and followed the rest of the
party out of the room. George, however, detained the Frenchman. He burst
into a laugh as he watched James's abrupt departure. "You may as well
have the facts, Monsieur, especially as they throw an amusing light on
Uncle Sep's quarter-deck style."

Uncle Sep's sister Maria had married William Martindale, and had had one
son, George. But William Martindale was already a widower with a stepson
by his first marriage, James Urquhart. Thus both James and George were in
no blood relationship to each other. William Martindale was himself a
partner in a firm of small prosperity, and upon his death, Septimus
bought up the Line, added the few good cargo ships which it owned to the
Dagger fleet, and took both boys into the management. James was by three
years the elder, but George was the actual nephew, and it was generally
understood that on Crottle's death or retirement, George Martindale would
become Chairman of the Line. James, however, was to be left substantially
in it, a director and a partner.

"Then one morning," continued George, "we both woke up to read in The
Times that we had changed our names to Crottle. It isn't what you'd call
a pretty name and, as you could see, James is still peeved about it--all
the more because the old man, neither before nor since, has ever said a
word about it to either of us. He just did it--the bit of brimstone in our
treacle, but there's such a lot of treacle that I, at all events, didn't
notice the bitter taste at all."

Monsieur Hanaud thanked him for the explanation, and added: "It is, after
all, natural that Mr. Crottle should like to leave his name associated
with the great Dagger Line. One day, no doubt, he will be Lord Crottle."

"Not he," cried George with a laugh. "He's Mr. Crottle of the Dagger
Line--and proud of it."

But they were in the doorway of the drawing-room now, where conversation
was exchanged in low voices, as if they were all in the porch of a
church. Monsieur Hanaud was presented by George to the three daughters of
Septimus. It was Mordaunt's story that the Patriarch had turned a most
deliberate back upon suitors for their hands. Certainly all three of them
were in their thirties. Anne, the youngest, a large handsome woman with a
high colour and pronounced features; Audrey, smaller, prettier, but
beginning to look a little like a horse; and Agatha, the eternal
spinster, angular, acrimonious, awkward. Her hair, gathered in a tight
bun, was already grey, and her face, with its high thin nose and a bitter
mouth, had lost, so worn it was and tired, any pretension to charm which
it might have had. She gave Monsieur Hanaud a hand so thin that it caused
him a little shock, as though he had shaken hands with a skeleton; and
whereas the other two sisters had shown some little excitement, not at
meeting him, but at the recurrence of this weekly ceremonial, she greeted
him with a dull eye and a languid voice. "I hope you won't be too bored."

"I?" exclaimed Hanaud. "But I am never bored, even when there is reason
to be. So how could I be bored here?"

Mr. Ricardo caught the words and once more whispered "hypocrite." The
room was just what he expected. Not one artistic nerve in him but twanged
distressfully. The curtains were of crimson rep with pelmets disfigured
by yellow rectangles; the chairs of black painted wood, with thin gold
lines, were upholstered tightly in black and green silk with buttons sunk
in little pits; and wherever an antimacassar could be hung, it was hung.
One particular piece shook Mr. Ricardo to his centre--a cabinet without a
curve, made in black painted wood. There was an oblong bevelled mirror in
the raised central back, and below the level surface two cupboards with
bouquets of roses painted on the doors. His eye, indeed, rested with
pleasure upon an oval mahogany table, a Regency cabinet in white and gold
in a corner of the room, and an arm-chair by Chippendale in which
Septimus was to sit. An electric lamp with a green shade burned upon the
table, and the book from which Septimus Crottle was to read lay closed
within the circle of light.

"All ready?" asked George of the company, and each one took the seat
arranged. The chairs were grouped in an irregular curve. Thus Hanaud was
sitting almost behind old Mr. Crottle's shoulder; two daughters, Anne and
Audrey, came next; the lawyer, Preedy, sat at the head of the table, and
Agatha was at his right. Mr. Ricardo sat at Agatha's right and beyond her
Mordaunt. George occupied the end of the table fronting Alan Preedy, and
between George and his uncle was an empty place for James. Thus, in a
free space, sat Mr. Septimus Crottle of the Dagger Line.

It was remarkable how clearly that order was established in Ricardo's
mind; for his was not a tidy mind. Yet he had hardly to shut his eyes,
before he could see each one of those ten people sitting upright and
stiff, side by side. It is, perhaps, still more remarkable that Ricardo
grasped exactly why the positions were so accurately registered in his

"All ready?" asked George at the table; and at once, by gesture or word,
assent was made. Mr. Ricardo expected that now the book would be opened
and the reading begin. But George cried over his shoulder "Go!" and James
switched off the lights of the room. There was only one left burning,
that of the lamp with the green shade upon the table. James slipped into
the empty chair. The room sank to darkness, the ugliness of its equipment
vanished. Above the coats of the men and the dresses of the women an arc
of faces gleamed, all set towards the one lamp, faces lifeless and pallid
as masks; and Mr. Ricardo understood that, however dull the book and
however inadequate the reader, not once would his head nod or his eyes
close until the reading was finished.

He was conscious of an excitement which ran through his veins and
throbbed in his ears. For a moment or two he could not trace it to its
source. There was the old man with his wrinkled features in the full
bright light and, in spite of his frock-coat and upstanding stock, of
some obvious brotherhood with the sea. There was, above the green shade
of the lamp, the circle of white dead faces. But to neither of these
causes was due the expectancy racing through him. He came to the
explanation at last and, though he knew it for an illusion and the merest
of accidents, it did not lose its hold. The book which lay upon the table
directly beneath the lamp was bound in cloth of exactly the same pale
colour as the painted handle of the knife which had caused Horbury's
death. It shone in the gloom of that room; it alone shone: it claimed the
eyes; it seemed to Ricardo to make a promise--or perhaps a threat. More
likely a threat, since it was with a definite relief that he saw the old
man's thickly-veined hands open the book somewhere towards the end where
a ribbon marked the place.

Septimus began to read. For a little while Ricardo did not notice the
theme of the book. Words followed words in the rhythm of prose--so much he
observed, but he was too surprised by the voice of the reader to take to
himself their meaning. The voice was clear and musical and muted to the
compass of the room, but it was troubled, so troubled that the reader
seemed to find in this far-off story of Marie Antoinette--for here and
there her name came and went amongst the words--some quite personal and
startling application. Mr. Ricardo began to listen now to what was read,
and it was read so faithfully that the stodgy room in Portman Square
vanished altogether, and he moved in the squalor of the Conciergerie,
amongst ruffianly gaolers and elegant dandies and great ladies awaiting,
with a jest to hide their fears, the creak and rumble of the tumbrils at
door. Against that background the wail of a boy rose and fell like a

Marie Antoinette had paid for the folly of her and her inadequate life.
Septimus read of the Dauphin--a boy, sickly, spoilt, but punished by such
drawn-out cruelty as, even in these days, few boys have endured. He
needed playmates of his own age, he was allowed none. He wanted fresh
air, open fields, sunlight and good food. He was given instead the foul,
overbreathed vapours of the Conciergerie, a small cell with a high small
window on a hall, and once a day a word or two of abuse from his gaoler
as his food and his jug of water were brought in to him. The Dauphin of
France was too dangerous a magnet for all that was left in France or
abroad of the old regime. But he couldn't be tried. He couldn't be sent
to the guillotine. Even the rabble shrank from that abominable horror.
What the most abject slander could do to asperse his character was done.
But it was not enough. He must disappear. So he was left, locked up in
his cell, a child without books, without clean linen, without a doctor,
without a mother, to get through each day and night and the next and the
next as best he could. Finally the gaoler ceased to show his face or
utter a word. Once a day a panel was opened, food and water were pushed
through, and the panel was closed again. That was all. And after an
eternity--of what torrents of tears, of what gusts of passion, of what
lonely despair!--neither the plate of food, nor the jug of water were
touched. For twenty-four hours, for forty-eight hours they were left, and
then for the first time in weeks the door of the dark cell was unlocked.

Old Septimus read so far, controlling his voice, but stopping now and
again to control it, and bending his head a little lower over the page.
Then suddenly he stopped, closed the book, and raised a face so ravaged
with horror, so old beyond all age, that it imposed silence upon all that
company. It was a silence as heavy as a pall, and it was broken at last
by one deep sigh.

Every head had been lowered or shaded by a hand or fixed upon the reader,
and all had been a little dazed. That one deep sigh must have seemed to
have been breathed by a corporate voice, to have issued from the blended
emotions of them all. But it was a shock to all. It jarred upon all except
Septimus Crottle at the table. He was still in the Conciergerie, standing
at the door of the cell as the key at last grated in the lock. But to the
rest it was grievous. There had been no pity in it, no horror, no
refusal. Construed into words it meant "At last!" Something long sought
for had been discovered.

Septimus finished before his hour was up, but at the end of a chapter, so
that it was natural that he should halt there. He closed the book slowly
after marking the page with the ribbon, and said in a voice which
surprised the audience, so unmoved and ordinary it was once more: "I
think we can stop this book here and choose another one for our next

He rose, and the bright sheen of the blue cover moved out of the circle
of light, to Ricardo's relief. Septimus walked to a table which stood
under a window at the end of the room. It had a drawer with a couple of
gilt handles. Septimus pulled one of them, but the drawer remained
closed. For a moment he was puzzled, and a frightened voice cried
"Father, it's locked."

The cry sprang from the mouth of Agatha. She jumped up and, pushing the
chairs apart, hurried to the mantelshelf. But she was too late. For even
while she was fumbling in a china box set on a ledge by the mirror,
Septimus pulled the handle again. But this time it was a tug, a jerk, and
with a crack the drawer burst open.

"It was locked. Why?"

"The key caught in one's dress."

Agatha showed the key to Septimus. It was rather long.

"You see how it juts out. I took it from the lock." But Septimus had
still one foot in the Conciergerie. He nodded his head.

"The drawer's no use to me now," he said, and Hanaud was already at his
side. Cumbrous though he was, no one moved so swiftly, so unsuspiciously
as Hanaud when he chose. "Can I help, Monsieur Crottle?" he asked, and he
laid his hand upon the top of the open drawer.

"No, the lock's broken," interposed Agatha. "It's a gimcrack affair,
anyway," and as in the room the lights were turned up she shut the drawer
so violently that Hanaud had barely time to snatch his hand away.

"Did I catch your fingers?" Agatha asked, staring at him angrily, and
obviously hopeful that she had.

"No, no, mademoiselle." Hanaud returned with a smile. "You would have to
be quicker than that."

He turned towards Crottle, who walked to the one solid piece of furniture
in the room--a Chippendale bureau which stood against a wall opposite to
the cabinet. It had a bookcase with shelves and glass doors on the top
and below it a front which could be let down to make a writing-table.
Septimus Crottle let the front down, pushed the book in, locked up the
front again, and pocketed the key. He said in a curious, hard, resentful
voice, which astonished no one who had heard him reading, and would have
astonished anyone who had not: "I never want to see that book again."

He was once more Septimus Crottle, the owner of the great Dagger Line. He
stepped out to Mordaunt. "You're off to-morrow, Mordaunt, and I'm sorry
to say not on one of my ships. But my ships sail on Fridays, so it
couldn't be helped. I'm going to tell you that your letter put you up a
peg or two in my esteem." A sudden smile made his face very pleasant and
friendly. "This is your last night in England, so you will have letters
to write. I am to talk with these gentlemen"--he waved a hand towards
Ricardo and Hanaud--"so I'll say good night and good luck."

He shook hands with Mordaunt, but for a few seconds did not move. Then he
said "Yes," and took a step or two towards the door; and again he said
"Yes," adding, as once more he moved on, "If there's anything we can do
for you, write to me," and this time he reached the door. But there he
turned, having made up his mind. He came straight back into the middle of
the room challenging them all to blame him if they dared. "Meanwhile,
Mordaunt, you might perhaps do something for me."

His voice was now firm but gentle, and Ricardo wondered afterwards
whether something of the pity which he had felt and imposed upon his
audience for that young victim of a nation's revolt was still working
within him.

"My youngest daughter--Rosalind. She was lovely to look at. She said she
was stifled in this house. I didn't understand that. She married against
my will. Leete, the name was. She may be still where you are going. I
think the marriage has turned out ill. God knows, I take no pride in
that! So, if you meet her, will you tell her that her place is here--and

So it was not pity which had moved him, not even compunction, Mr. Ricardo
thought, but just the patriarch's feeling that, owing to the wrong-headed
folly of one of the family, there was an uncomfortable gap which should
be closed.

"Of course I will, sir," said Mordaunt, and at once voices broke out in a
babble. The only words Ricardo distinguished were spoken by George
Crottle enthusiastically: "It would be fine to have Rosie back again."

Septimus turned with an apology to his two new guests, and he included in
his smile Mr. Alan Preedy. "But these are family matters. You have
something to say to me, Monsieur Hanaud. Will you and your friend come
along with me to the smoking-room? George, and James too, perhaps, since
in so much they take my place. To everyone else, good night."

He led the four men to a room along the corridor behind the drawing-room.


IT always gave Mr. Ricardo a pinch, as it were, of malicious pleasure to
see Hanaud's discomfort when he drank a whisky and soda; and a still
stronger and more satisfactory pinch to watch his inability to cope with
a big cigar. Hanaud would so much sooner have smoked one of his own black
abominations. Thus Mr. Ricardo's spirit, which had been undoubtedly
depressed by the reading in the drawing-room, rose with a bound when
Septimus, standing by a tray which held bottles of soda-water and a
black, pot-bellied bottle of whisky, invited his guests to drink.

"A whisky and soda, Monsieur Hanaud?"

"What would be an English evening without it?" Hanaud returned with a
flourish. He took a tumbler from the tray and held it out to Septimus.
But, even so, there was a twisting of his nostrils as the smell of the
liquor reached them, and a gentle writhing of his features, as he
realised that he must actually drink it, which was reminiscent of the
Christian martyrs. Worse, how ever, was to come. As Hanaud stood with the
tumbler in one hand and the other fumbling in his pocket for a cigarette,
Septimus produced a large box of cigars from a cabinet.

"But that is a big box, Monsieur Crottle!"

"They are big, big cigars," Ricardo replied gleefully.

"They look wonderful," said Monsieur Hanaud. He stared doubtfully into
the box, advancing and withdrawing a hand; rather, Ricardo thought, like
a young lady in the days of his youth on the steps of a bathing machine
dipping her toes into the water on some bleak summer morning.

"They're the best," Septimus explained. "They are mine."

Hanaud quivered as he took a cigar of a length associated with one
English aristocrat and two English statesmen.

"You'll spoil me," he said, holding up a warning finger to Septimus; and,
indeed, Mr. Ricardo fancied that that might really happen before Hanaud
had reached the end of his cigar. However, diplomacy meant doing a good
many repugnant things with an air of extreme pleasure, for the sake of
establishing a position, didn't it?

"Have a light," said Septimus, and he struck a big wooden match. "You
wouldn't, I am sure, insult that cigar with a briquet."

"I would not, indeed," cried Hanaud, hastily withdrawing his hand from
his pocket. He carried his cigar and his tumbler to a chair which really
was easy and settled himself into it with deliberation. He was marking
time. Certainly there was a little noise outside the room for which,
indeed, Hanaud was to blame. He had been the last of the five to enter
the smoking-room and he had not latched the door. The front door closed
once, gently, as Alan Preedy, quiet, as gentlemen of the law should be,
departed. Then followed a rustle of skirts and a couple of high-pitched
voices on the stairs. The ladies were going to bed--or two of them, at all

"Now, Monsieur Hanaud, in what way can I help you?" said Septimus,
upright in a straight-backed chair.

"I shall tell you frankly," Hanaud replied, and he felt in his pockets.
He looked at Ricardo. "You can oblige me. I left, or I think I left, a
little diary in a topcoat in the hall."

"I'll get it for you," Ricardo answered readily. He had, in truth, not
needed the quick glance which Hanaud had thrown at him. He was really
wanted now!

"It's the grey coat," said Hanaud.

"I remember," said Ricardo.

He didn't remember at all, but he went out of the room. In front of him
stretched the long corridor to the inner of the two hall doors, empty--but
not quite silent. A strange sound made itself faintly heard as he
listened. What it was that Hanaud wanted of him, he could not imagine.
All the more reason, therefore, to miss nothing, however infinitesimal.
The strange sound was rather like the bleating of a sheep. And it came
from the drawing-room just in front of the smoking-room, through the open
door. And the room was still lit, although the girls, as Septimus had
called them, had gone up to bed.

But Ricardo had only heard two voices. Was the third bleating in the
drawing-room, and which of the three would it be? He advanced stealthily,
noiselessly. He, Julius Ricardo, of Grosvenor Square, was primitive
man-trapper, Redskin with the scalping-knife--Mr. Ricardo loved the
picture--or perhaps not primitive man at all, but the man of to-day,
acute, erudite, the sleuth--Mr. Ricardo liked the picture still more. He
held his breath, he moved on tiptoe--and stopped. From the spot where he
stood he stared through the doorway into a long oblong mirror against the
drawing-room wall. He saw reflected in it the gimcrack table with the
gilt handles, and the drawer once more open and, in front of it, seated
in the chair which she had used during the reading, Agatha. But not the
Agatha of the reading. This was a woman stricken. She sat with her hands
to her face, shuddering. At times the shuddering mounted to a sob of
horror and so stopped altogether. But it began again, and again so ended.
Ricardo noticed that there lay upon her lap a card which had been torn
across in two pieces; and even from where he stood he could see that
there was writing on the card.

As he watched, he was aware of a change in her. Instead of the horror
there was now uneasiness. She moved her shoulders, the hands fluttered
upon her face; and he was warned. People who do not know that they are
watched, sometimes by some instinct suspect it. He himself was the cause
of her uneasiness. He stooped low. He had time to see her snatch her
hands from her face, stare with a violent shiver at the torn pieces of
the card, and then drop them into a wastepaper basket by the side of the
cabinet. The carpet was thick and he made no noise. He stood straight up
now, pulling down his coat. He said in a voice no louder than was
natural: "The grey topcoat? All right."

He walked forward past the door of the drawing-room, humming a little
tune to himself. He was extremely careful not to direct one glance into
the lighted room; and as he reached the contraption by the hall door,
with its hat-and-coat rack and its tin trough for umbrellas, he so
rattled it that only the most obsessed people in the world could have
been unaware that he was pretending with every artifice that he was not
pretending. However, it was one of the most obsessed people whom he had
to deceive; and whilst he was fumbling in the empty pockets of a coat, he
heard a click as a light was switched off, and a moment later the hiss
and rustle of a dress upon the stairs.

"There's nothing," Mr. Ricardo was saying aloud. Really, he was playing
his part admirably. "I can't understand it." He heard a door shut
upstairs. Then he stopped at once his untheatrical piece of theatre. But
he waited, listening for that door perhaps to open again; it did not. Now
he hurried back along the corridor. He slipped into the dark
drawing-room. Enough light crept in from the hall to define the plan of
the room. But he must not stumble over furniture and he must be quick. He
slid between the chairs to the wastepaper basket. A great fear was
troubling him that the basket might be full with the litter of the day.
But his fingers assured him that, except for two small pieces of
pasteboard, the basket was empty. He snatched those pieces up. Above his
head he heard a woman's heels tapping. He slipped out and returned to the

"I can't find it," he said. "I am very sorry."

"Oh!" said Hanaud, disappointed. "Well, I've no doubt that I can remember
all that's necessary," he added encouragingly, and Ricardo, with
confidence, shut the door.

Hanaud was leaning forward to speak, when Septimus said: "You have let
your cigar go out, Monsieur Hanaud."

"And if you think that's a good beginning, my friend, you are wrong,"
Ricardo commented silently.

Even Hanaud realised his fault. "I have, indeed. It is not to be
pardoned. But with a wooden match, I light him again. So."

"Now blow once."

Monsieur Hanaud blew.

"Now you can smoke it."

Hanaud drew in a breath. "It is delicious," he said.

"Of course," replied Septimus.

"But I waste the time. There was a man of whom, Monsieur Crottle, you
will only have heard. Daniel Horbury."

From neither James nor George was there a start nor any movement.

"He committed suicide," said Septimus.

"So it is said."

"An inquest will be held on Tuesday."

"And that same verdict will probably be given."

"But you don't believe it, Monsieur Hanaud?"

There was no shrugging of the shoulders now in Monsieur Hanaud, no
flourishing of arms. “I don't believe it, Monsieur Crottle."

"And whether it was suicide or murder--I take murder to be the only

Crottle paused, but his eyes met only a face of wood, and he resumed:
"How am I concerned?"

"He wrote a letter to you, sir."

The sentence was thrown quickly at Septimus--a grenade to produce an
explosion. All it produced was a smile of amusement on Crottle's old
pippin of a face.

"They all do."

Hanaud was clearly puzzled. "They?" he repeated.

"Horbury and men like him," Septimus repeated.

"What is it, then, they want?"

"A passage on the Dagger Line, Monsieur Hanaud, to the land of their
dreams--a land where there are no extradition treaties."

"But there were enclosures in the letter."

"There would be. Passages must be paid for."

"And he didn't send the letter at once. He kept it by him."

"That, also, they all do--for Mr. Micawber's immortal reason."

"Something turning up," Mr. Ricardo interpreted.

Hanaud was disappointed. He refused to accept the obvious and practical
conclusions of Septimus Crottle.

"But Monsieur Crottle, you will pardon me. Horbury was not in distress.
In fact"--if it came to idiomatic phrases, Hanaud could hold his own--"in
fact," he exclaimed triumphantly, "he was upsidaisy."


"Yes. We have the evidence, eh, my friend," and he turned to Ricardo.
"Horbury's nosebag."

"But was he upsidaisy with the police, Monsieur Hanaud?" Septimus
answered with his eyes twinkling.

Hanaud, however, was ready for him there. "The Superintendent Maltby had
no intention to arrest him."

Septimus Crottle smiled. "It might be that the Superintendent Maltby
didn't explain, even to you, Monsieur Hanaud, all that he had in his
mind. I am afraid that, after all, you have found a mare's nest."

"And I, no doubt, am the foal," Hanaud returned quickly.

Mr. Ricardo was in the mood to applaud the witticism, even though it was
founded on a mispronunciation. He did not like to see his friend so put
down. Even Septimus began to laugh, but corrected himself immediately.
Instead of a congratulation, he implied a censure. He said: "You have
again let your cigar go out."

"It is the excitement," returned Hanaud. He rose, and young George
Crottle was in front of him with a match-box in his hand. For a moment
Hanaud stared at him as if he had forgotten his presence. Then he looked
from him to James. Then he said: "Oh, yes, Mr. George Crottle! Mr. James
Crottle! You agree, of course, with your uncle?"

The question, though out of keeping no doubt with the times, was quite
appropriate to this particular uncle and nephews, so masterful the one,
so debonair or amenable the others.

"Yes, I should say old Horbury wrote the letter," replied the debonair
George, "and put it away on the chance that he might some time want it in
a hurry. There it was."

"But there it isn't," replied Hanaud.

"It has disappeared?" asked James. He looked quickly at his uncle.

"Without trace. We have searched the office, Horbury's desk, his
blotting-pad, and his house."

"'White Barn?" said James Crottle.

"Yes," answered Hanaud, and Septimus appeared surprised.

"You know the house?" he asked of his nephew.

"The name was in the evening papers," George explained.

"There is no reason that I can see"--and Hanaud, who had started
smoothly, now halted and pronounced slowly each word, as if he had just
begun to see--"why Horbury should have taken the letter to White Barn. But
he may have done."

"However, it wasn't there, and, mind you, we looked everywhere, Maltby
and I."

"In the blotting-book?" James asked.

"The one on the floor?" said Hanaud, and George Crottle chuckled loudly.

"I've heard that Horbury did a good deal of his business over a bottle,
or bottles, of Pommery, but I never thought that he couldn't stand up to
it and had to keep his blotting-book on the floor."

A little long-winded Mr.Ricardo thought. Rather silly, too. George
Crottle, with all his good fellowship, might become a rattle, when a
gaffe had been made, to cover up the man who had made it. But the rally
of dialogue was swift enough to cover more than a gaffe. Moreover, Hanaud
chose that moment to close a subject which had become interesting to
Ricardo. He flung himself away from George Crottle and the big offending
box of Bryant and May.

"In a moment I ask for the match, Monsieur George, the splutter, the
flame. Yes, I shall ask for them," and with a laugh he challenged George
to contradict him. "But at the moment"--he turned, still smiling, to
Septimus--"it is to you, Mr. Crottle, that I would like to tell all, if
you will have the patience to listen to me."

"Of course," replied Septimus.

"I have little concern in this affair," and Hanaud explained the case of
Devisher and Gravot of the Place Vendôme. "That is all settled. I shall
carry back from the widow Horbury in notes of the Bank of England the
money owed to him. But I went with Maltby"--and he described with a quiet
force what he had seen and what he had inferred; the sudden determination
of the Horburys to spend the night at the house in Lordship Lane, the
manner of Olivia Horbury itself--"to read what people say is one thing,
to hear them saying it is very much another --the locked door, the
telephone receiver lifted and replaced in the dark of the morning, the
absence of all the natural finger prints on the furniture, the want of any
reason why suicide should have been committed, the disappearance of
Devisher. "Yes, and something more, the disappearance of a little chart,
fixed on an ebony board."

"Chart?" exclaimed Septimus, sitting forward.

"Chart?" George Crottle echoed.

"Chart?" James Crottle repeated.

They were men of the sea, the three of them. Charts were part of their
business. There were rolls of charts in the cupboards of the offices of
the Dagger Line. It was inevitable that the Crottles should sit up and
wonder what in the world Daniel Horbury was doing with a chart.

"Yes. It was marked, too, with pins, little black glass pins, with a
white ensign on the top, such as you may buy at a toyshop. They seemed to
mark the passage of a steamship--El Rey, which brought Devisher home."

"And the chart has disappeared?" Septimus asked.

"Yes," replied Hanaud, "with the letter."

"Burnt, no doubt," George returned.

"Cartridge paper," said Septimus with a shake of the head.

"And the ebony board, too? Yes, it is possible. There was a small fire at
White Barn. But why should Horbury be so anxious to burn so carefully
that not splinter of the wood nor an edge of the cartridge paper should
be left for us to find? And after so much trouble to stretch his chart
flat and prick it day by day? It doesn't sound reasonable."

Septimus Crottle nodded his head.

"No, it doesn't. But this man, Devisher? He was rescued by Mordaunt's
yacht. He left Kingswear by the Torbay Express"--once more Septimus went
over the old ground. "Devisher is the man to look for."

"No doubt," said Hanaud. "Yes, no doubt, and Maltby is looking for him."

Septimus Crottle was watching Hanaud's face closely. "But he has

Hanaud nodded his head. "Yes. Like Horbury's letter to you, the marked
chart and the ebony board."

"With them, perhaps," suggested George Crottle, and Hanaud swung swiftly
round to him.

"Then Devisher was at White Barn on Thursday night," returned Hanaud, and
George Crottle's face flamed red. He began to make in a kind of hurry
some faltering suggestions which seemed superlatively foolish to Mr.

"Then he will have taken the letter."

"From the blotting-book on the floor," Hanaud interposed with a grin.

"And the chart," James Crottle added without remarking upon the
interposition, "and gone off according to his plan."

Hanaud broke in again, shaking his head as if thus he shook all the plans
away into the air.

"How can he have made plans, Mr. James? He arrived in London by the
Torbay Express. He had no luggage, no friends, a borrowed suit of
clothes, and ten or eleven pounds, and he had been at least six years
away, buried in a foreign prison. Yet, within a few hours, he has made
such fine plans that he can commit a murder in Lordship Lane and make a
vanishing that all the police in London cannot explain."

Septimus Crottle was as interested now as if some baffling crime had been
committed on a ship under his command.

"But he has disappeared, Monsieur Hanaud! That's the fact, the impossible
fact which is always happening."

"I do not lose sight of him. It is one of the facts which make me think
he did not murder on Thursday night. I think that somehow he fitted in
with other plans--maybe Horbury's, if, indeed, Horbury did the slitting,
maybe some unknown murderer's." He turned with confidence to Ricardo. "My
very good friend and consultationist"--Ricardo shivered a little at the
coinage of that new and, alas! adoptable word--"Ricardo was for some hours
on Mordaunt's boat with Devisher. Tell us what you thought of Bryan
Devisher, Mr. Julius."

Among the innumerable irritations which vexed the even flow of Mr.
Ricardo's spirit, perhaps none hurt so much as liberties taken with his
name. To be "Mr. Julius" was to be a younger son addressed by a superior
being--like a butler, say. He was being bidden to speak up and tell his
little story. On the other hand, his good name as a man of observation
was at stake, and that was more important than irritation. Mr. Ricardo
spoke up.

"He did not seem to be revengeful. He was hard, yes. But six years in the
island dungeon had killed, I think, the spirit in him. To lie soft and
easy was the idea, and he saw a way of realising it, so long as he could
get away from the steamer El Rey without reporters, and the police
checking up on him. No, I agree with Hanaud, I doubt if he was the man to
commit a murder."

"So the murderer escapes," said George Crottle with a smile of sympathy.
"I am afraid we all prefer a laugh at the police to the capture of a

Hanaud took up the statement very good-humouredly. He laughed with George

"Yes, to be sure, that is so. But why do we prefer a laugh at the police?
Because, in our heart and soul, we know that the criminal will not
escape, after all."

"He will do it again, you mean?"

"I mean more. The little offences, if they escape, at once there is some
bad example and some harm is done. That is all. But the big crimes like
murder, they may not escape. Once or twice, in the blue of the moon,
there may be a nobility and it never fails to be recognised. Oh, never!
But, as a rule, Monsieur George, accept the creed of an old tracker, the
two remarkable characteristics of the big crime are its meanness and its

Septimus Crottle was undoubtedly interested. He nodded his head, sitting
upright in his high-backed chair.

James Crottle said with a trifle of cynicism: "It would need a bold man
to hold out against you and Mr. Ricardo."

"I hope that one day, Monsieur Hanaud," Septimus added, "you will come on
some other than a Sunday evening and tell me in detail a few of your

"I hope," cried Hanaud, "that I may give you some day the whole story of
the night at White Barn in the Lordship Lane."

As this was spoken, it took on a more important meaning, certainly in
Hanaud's ears, no less certainly in Mr. Ricardo's. Hanaud glanced slyly
at George Crottle and James.

"It may be, after all, that I make a mistake. Once I made one. In this
case, however, I am sure."

"Although the coroner's jury will say suicide?" James Crottle asked.


"But in that case it is over."

"No. You see, Mr. James, Maltby is not satisfied."


The exclamation came from Septimus. What this flibbertigibbet of a
Frenchman, who hadn't the stomach to let him smoke a Romeo and Juliet
Corona cigar, thought, was one thing--of the mere weight of a cigarette,
say. What the Superintendent Maltby, of the tenacious, deliberate mind,
thought, was quite another--of the weight of a Romeo and Juliet Corona
cigar, in fact.

"Therefore, if the letter from the late Horbury were to reach you,"
Hanaud continued, as he rose from his chair, "it might, perhaps, help to
send it on to Maltby."

"I will do so," said Septimus, accompanying his two guests to the front

Hanaud drove home uncomfortably by Ricardo's side in the Rolls-Royce
No. 1, which had that evening arrived by way of Cherbourg. He had many
postures, but no words, and experience had made Mr. Ricardo too wary to
provoke them.


ONCE the two friends were seated in the study of the corner house, Hanaud
had to speak.

"A peppermint frappé?" he asked, and added, rather proud of what he
thought to be a humorous phrase, "Can do?"

"I should think nothing is more unlikely," Ricardo returned as he rang
the bell. "Thompson, could yon manage a peppermint frappé at this hour?"

Thompson came as near to a smile as his code of manners permitted.

"Monsieur asked for one once some years ago and caught us at a
disadvantage. A few moments, monsieur."

So Hanaud sipped his peppermint frappé and smoked his black cigarettes,
whilst Ricardo reflected on the oddities of friendship.

Suddenly Hanaud smiled: "You shall tell me what you saw when you were
kind enough to search for the diary I had not left in my topcoat."

Ricardo made a grimace. "It was not pleasant."

"The Miss Agatha, then?"


Ricardo described her shuddering in horror with the broken drawer open at
her side and the torn pieces of a card upon her lap.

"She swept them into the wastepaper basket," he continued, "and after I
was in the hall she turned out the lights and went up to bed."

"Dropped them--just like that--in the wastepaper basket?" Hanaud mused,
"and turned out the lights."

"But that didn't baffle me," cried Mr. Ricardo triumphantly. "I knew Miss
Agatha might perhaps hear the snap of the switch if I turned the lights
on, so I didn't touch it. I knew she might wonder if a chair or a table
were overturned, so I slipped like an eel between them"; and Mr. Ricardo,
to make this piece of sleuthing as admirable and vivid to Hanaud as it
was to himself, twisted and slid towards the table; and undoubtedly
Hanaud did admire--little cries of admiration broke from him. He had hands
raised ready to applaud. Mr. Ricardo loved that moment, and to complete
the movement with a most dramatic finish, he plunged his hand into his
trouser pocket and flung the two pieces of pasteboard below Hanaud's eyes
upon the table.

Well, where were the words of praise? Or, if not of praise, of thanks,
for a most difficult example of the detective's art? Mr. Ricardo opened
his eyes. He had closed them as he had flung the pasteboard fragments--and
he saw Hanaud staring at those fragments in consternation.

"You picked them out of the tub?" he said quietly.

"Of course. Wasn't I right?"

"No, my friend."

"But there was a word written on the card."

"I read it when Septimus jerked open the drawer."

"I am sorry if I did wrong," said Mr. Ricardo tartly. Hanaud was swift to
reassure his friend. It was not that Mr. Ricardo had done wrong. No, no!
On the contrary! He had done too much right. Miss Agatha's agitations,
they were suggestive, and described with a particularity only to be found
in a master--and with an economy, too--it is so rare to use few words when
many would do. It did not really matter so much that he had removed the
two pieces of card.

"In any case the servants would have emptied them into the dustbin in the
morning," said Ricardo, once more smiling.

"No, no."

The contradiction came like a slap in the face.

"Why no, no?"

"Because," said Hanaud sweetly, "at this moment, perhaps, or perhaps in
an hour or in two hours, Agatha will wake uneasy. And in a little while
she will understand why she is uneasy. That torn card--it should be burnt.
She will creep down in the dark, with a torch, perhaps--and the
pieces--they have gone! Oh, in the long run it does not matter. Very
likely she will, think, 'Oh, it is that inquisitive one from France, he
was at the elbow of Septimus,' and she will be more discreet. But..."

"But what?" Mr.Ricardo demanded impatiently

Hanaud finished his peppermint and stubbed out his cigarette. "I should
not be quick to destroy those two pieces of card," he replied slowly. "It
is for you, of course, to say....For me, I wait upon the exquisite
Madame Horbury to-morrow morning and in the afternoon I return to Paris.
But, my friend, if I were you, I should lock them up. One never knows."

He stood up and, with a complete change of tone, added: "We go to bed,
no, yes? We will not lose the sleep? We meet at the luncheon, when I say
to you farewell. What I owe to you!" and Hanaud betook himself upstairs.

Mr. Ricardo took the ash-tray on which Hanaud's cigarette still smouldered
and emptied it into the fireplace. As he replaced it on the table, he
saw the torn pieces of the card; and it flashed across his thoughts that
he had never read the word written across them.

He fitted them together. It was a word, of course, but it was more--a
name. And as Mr. Ricardo read the name he was seized with a discomfort,
the same sort of discomfort as had seized upon Hanaud in the motor-car.
Fear, in other words. The fear a man might have as he looked down into a
pit. For the name written upon the card was Horbury--with an initial in
front of it--D--yes, of course, D. Mr. Ricardo was half inclined to let
those two pieces of card follow the cigarette ash into the fire. But in
his mind's eye he saw Hanaud's face again, serious and alarmed. He locked
the pieces safely in a drawer of his private desk.


THE flat on the first floor of Audley Court had neither the elegance of
White Barn nor the opulent glitter of Horbury's office. It was not
furnished to a period. A Sheraton writing-table stood side by side with a
marqueterie cabinet. Comfort was the note of it, and quiet colours,
restful to tired eyes. Hanaud's first thought, indeed, as he moved into
the sitting-room and across to the window and looked over the tree tops
of the avenue to the wide grassland of the park, was that here was a
refuge for a far-thinking statesman rather than for a double-dealer in
the equities.

"Mrs. Horbury will be here immediately," said the butler with a bow.

Hanaud beheld his broad shoulders and his lean strength with contentment
and, as the man turned away, he said firmly: "'Arf a mo'!"

The butler, used to all conditions of men, turned about stolidly and

"You've been a sailor," said the perspicacious visitor. The butler
complimented Hanaud with as much of a smile as he allowed himself on

"Admirals at sea and generals on land wouldn't agree about that, sir. But
name of Hanworth to both."

Hanaud was puzzled and then especially pleased.

"I have him. A marine."

Yes, sir."

"We have them, too. Les Fusiliers-Marine--yes? They are much thought of
and they think much of themselves. Good! Then you stay here?"

"I don't know, sir, whether Mrs. Horbury will require me."

"But if she does--?"

"Her service is a pleasure, sir," Hanworth replied. A little sententious,
no doubt--the super-marine on duty--but, however you looked at it, good
marks for Olivia Horbury.

"Ha!" said Hanaud to himself as Hanworth left the room; and "Ha!" he said
to himself again, drumming on the window-pane contentedly; and a quiet
voice with a tremor of amusement broke in upon his contentment.

"The name was Gravot, I think, Monsieur Hanaud?" He swung round. Olivia
Horbury was seated at a table under the second of the two windows.

"Ah, madame, you make the heart beat," he said.

"You flatter me, Monsieur Hanaud."

"Yes, that way, too. But at the, moment it is the noiselessness."

"Monsieur Hanaud, do you wish me to believe that you belong to the day
when women's gowns whispered and their bangles rattled and all the birds
in the garden piped 'she is here, she is here'?"

"I try, madame, to be of my day and the Code Napoleon--" He broke off,
noticing that she sat with an open cheque book in front of her.

"No, please, that is not possible now. I had hoped to return to Paris
with one like that. But now there must be lawyers and hindrances." He
pointed to the cheque book. "Instead, perhaps, a little signed letter on
the crested paper that as soon as the probations are over a cheque will
be posted."

"But, Monsieur Hanaud, that's what I was doing." She put a slender
forefinger on the twopenny stamp. "Perhaps you don't know that that was
Daniel's crest."

She smiled as she spoke and Hanaud laughed, and Olivia laughed again.

"What a woman!" Hanaud exclaimed to his soul. "She can make the joke
about the good Horbury's honesty, but none the less yesterday she was in
tears for him." Indeed, as he watched her writing the cheque, her
laughter dwindled to a whimper and the tears once more filled her eyes.

She scribbled a note, put it into an envelope with the cheque, sealed it,
and rang the bell.

"I have drawn the cheque on my private account. The branch of the bank I
deal with is on the ground floor of the next block of flats. I have
already arranged with the manager. Hanworth will bring you back a draft
upon the Paris branch." She sent Hanworth off with the sealed envelope.
"He will not be five minutes."

Hanaud felt a trifle uncomfortable. After all, it was a large sum of

"It may be months before the estate is finally wound up," he said.

"A year, monsieur. And since there is no reason that Monsieur Gravot of
the Place Vendôme, who has waited so long for his money, should wait for
another year, you shall take it back to him." She got up with a swift
movement and invited him to a chair. "I don't want you, Monsieur Hanaud,
to misunderstand me. Daniel and I were the very best of friends. Lots of
people, no doubt, will give you quite another picture of him, and theirs
may be true from their points of view; I'll go further, and say it is.
For me it was all different."

There was a suggestion in her tone that he could have her story if he
wished; and at that moment there was nothing Hanaud wished more. A
younger daughter of an impoverished family, she had been carefully
educated so that she might earn her living as a teacher in a high school.

"I was almost learned in those days," and she spoke of them as so remote
that they were difficult and, astonishing to remember. "But it wasn't any
good, for I couldn't teach. I could chatter, but I couldn't instruct. I
could get enjoyment myself out of Virgil, say--oh, yes, you needn't look
so surprised, Monsieur Hanaud, it's not, as you might say, a
politeness--but I couldn't impart it. So I thought that I would go on the

"Ah!" said Hanaud.

"Yes," said Olivia, taking up his exclamation relentlessly. "You think
Daniel might have noticed me in the back row of the chorus, but could
hardly have had the entrée into a high school."

That is exactly what Hanaud had thought, but, having once been chided for
his manners, he did not propose to fail again.

"No, no, Madame Horbury," he cried. "It was that I saw you myself upon
the boards--the lady of Scotland coming down the stairs with the

"Yes, and both acting equally well--no, I am wrong," she answered, and
again her lips curved in good humour and her eyes for a second danced,
"for the candle had a flame and I hadn't. I was no better on the stage
than I was in the high school. But I didn't believe it, of course. I
wanted my opportunity. I was playing small parts, maids, you know, with
the tea-tray--I suppose that I didn't look so impossible--"

Here Monsieur Hanaud broke in with a flourish: "Every great lady must
have prayed for such a maid!"

"Hadn't we better say every great husband?" she replied dryly. "Anyway,
you are quite right. Daniel was dabbling in theatrical management, and I
sat next to him at a supper party. He was full of fun, perhaps, isn't the
right word--jocularity's better, and very sympathetic. My opportunity
would come. Not a passionate part, no, a static part--arranging everything
for the passionate ones, without leaving a trace of one's mascara on
one's cheeks. As you see, he knew that I couldn't act. Yet "--and there
came a tenderness into her voice, whilst neither her eyes nor her lips
lost their humour--"yet he put up a play for me."

"Because he hoped that the quiet looks and the quiet part might draw the

Olivia shook her head gently. "No, because he wanted me to marry him, and
he knew that if I did, without failing in a big part, I should always
feel aggrieved that I had never had my chance."

"The play did fail?"

Olivia Horbury shivered, and half of her shivering, even so long
afterwards, was serious.

"I was scarified. I wanted to put all the dramatic critics into a bag
with a couple of cats and throw it into the Bosphorus. Daniel filled the
house with paper for a month, but that wanted more canvassing than ever
he did to get into Parliament. We got married immediately afterwards."

That had been six years ago. Olivia had been twenty-two years old at the
time of the marriage, and for the next two years they had lived at White
Barn in Lordship Lane.

"I fell in love with the house as soon as I saw it."

"The holly hedge? It was already there, of course?"

Olivia's face grew soft. Her eyes beamed. "I am glad you remembered it,"
she said warmly. "It was there, but it was ragged. It was like a man who
wants his hair cutting. And there were holes in it. I looked after it
myself. Days and days in the autumn I stood on a ladder and clipped it.
We had a gardener to look after the flowers. But the holly hedge was my
job. I let nobody else touch it. I saw it grow glossy and the holes fill
up until it was a great high evergreen wall." She laughed happily. "Even
now I drive down and spend delightful days looking after it."

"Even now?" Hanaud pressed the question with a smile.

"Even now. Still no one must touch it except me."

She checked her eager speech rather suddenly and turned towards the
window. Once she threw a swift glance towards him and saw that he was
watching her.

"But though we took this flat afterwards, when we had money," she resumed
quickly, "it was because Dan had to see people. We wanted to keep White
Barn for ourselves. So perhaps, Monsieur Hanaud, you can understand my
willingness to settle the account of your jeweller in the Place Vendôme.
Whenever we were on number seventeen with the carrées and the
transversales and seventeen won, a good wedge of the winnings was handed
over to me. Of course, it was borrowed again, fairly often at the
beginning, but of late Dan was on seventeen quite often."

Hanworth returned to the flat with the draft upon the Paris branch of the
Bank. Olivia looked it through and handed it to Hanaud.

"It is correct?" she asked.

"It is oke," he returned, as though indeed it were something more, and
taking from his pocket-book a receipt by Gravot et Cie of the Place
Vendôme, he laid it upon her writing-table. Then he bowed over her hand.

"So," said she, "it is all ended."


He turned and walked towards the door. But he walked ever more slowly,
and when his hand was on the knob of the door he stopped altogether.

"For my friend, Gravot, yes," he repeated.

"There will be other claimants? Maybe," she asked and answered behind

"I was not thinking of claimants," he replied, and he turned round
towards her rather swiftly and dramatically. It was a disservice to
Hanaud that, although he could keep drama out of his thoughts, he never
could out of his actions; and generally it was transpontine drama. He saw
a young woman without any of the tender humour which had moved her a few
minutes ago, wary and suspicious.

"Of whom, then?" She was as curt as she was wary.

"I cannot say for sure."

"In other words, you don't know."

"I don't know," Hanaud agreed.

No three words were more repugnant for Hanaud to utter amongst little
people in connection with a small case; and none easier when he was
coping with big problems and intelligent minds. And at all events Olivia
Horbury was--relieved?--yes, relieved by his ignorance. Her face grew less
tight, her eyes less wary; she drew a breath. Hanaud had expected
dismissal. He was invited to continue.

"I do not for one moment think that Horbury used that blue-handled knife
himself," he said, and saw her lips twitch and a gleam of horror in her
eyes as he thus described the weapon. "And my good friend, the
Superintendent Maltby, begins to think with me. But, see! I am in a
special debt to you. Moreover, now you stand all queenly and prickles, I
will say it."

Suddenly the smile for which Hanaud had ceased to hope glimmered again
upon her lips. She sat down in a chair. "You shall," she said.

"At White Barn, I was moved. There was something I did not understand,
something in all this grim tragedy, pleasant and disturbing, of which I
now have a tiny hold." He was discovering a Titania permanently in love
with Bottom, though of that couple he had never heard. If Racine had
imagined such a pair, Hanaud would surely have quoted him, for he was
well up in Racine. But, unfortunately, Racine only dealt in the heroes of
Troy and the ghosts of Sophocles, and with these Horbury and White Barn
had no connection.

"So I will say, I beg you to be careful." He nodded his head.

"And why, Monsieur Hanaud?"

The question was gently, but firmly put. Olivia was guarding her secrets.
Hanaud hesitated over his answer. But he felt, and felt strongly, that he
could speak more exactly to Olivia than he would have dared with weaker
vessels. He said: "Because there may be danger for you again."

Olivia did not move, and there was more deliberation than surprise in her
face. "Again?" she asked.

"Yes. There was danger when, in the middle of the night, a telephone
receiver was lifted from its cradle in an empty house and you locked your

Olivia's face grew white as a plaster mask. Even her lips were bloodless.
But in her eyes there was fear. And yet, for Hanaud, not enough fear. She
was keeping her secrets, and Hanaud felt the danger grow and seep into
this room like a miasma and fold about her till darkness grew between
them. Olivia got up from her chair. If the danger was not to end, talk of
it should.

"I thank you," she said and her voice was warm. Hanaud accepted her
decision. But he had a practical word.

"You keep the marine?"

There was urgency in his voice. A Fusilier-Marine of twenty years' service
with the honourable discharge! To be fostered, yes.

Olivia's voice broke into an open, joyous laugh. "Of course! If he will
stay and wait upon a lone woman in Lordship Lane."

"You go back there?"

"As soon as the formalities allow."

She waited now for him to give the sign that their interview was ended
and, as he bowed to her, she rang the bell. As she heard the front door
close she said slowly, "I have lost a friend."

But Hanaud was a persistent animal and was not so sure.


LUNCHEON was over at the corner house. Hanaud ate the last of his
brandied cherries and, with a sigh of content, brought forth his

"To-night I shall be in Paris. My vacancy is past. The cathedrals which I
so much wished to see--"

"From a café opposite with a striped awning," Mr. Ricardo interposed with
more of regret than sarcasm in his voice. Hanaud from time to time opened
a door upon a different and intriguing world, and now the door was to
close. But more than the closing door he regretted its tiler. Strict but
impish, relentless yet kind, Hanaud seasoned Mr.Ricardo's ineffective
days and raised him at times into high consideration. The corner house
would be very empty after the four o'clock express had steamed out to
Folkestone. Mr. Ricardo foresaw himself suffering a nostalgia for the
smell of the black cigarettes from the blue-paper packets and--he actually
coined a portmanteau word--the argotistical flourishes of Hanaud's speech.
He felt that, but for Thompson, he would have tried a peppermint frappé
last thing at night. He summed, him up, at all events, in the lingo
Hanaud might have used, "He's a one."

"A cognac with your coffee in the study?" Mr. Ricardo suggested.

"Superb!" answered Hanaud; and in a few minutes; seated in a comfortable
chair with a Maryland between his lips, his coffee smoking at his elbow
and an ancient goblet of fine glass, worthy of its little pool of
condensed sunlight, in his hand, he was gazing across the square. His
luggage was packed. Thompson would book it to Paris and find a seat for
him on the train. He should have been at ease, but his shoulders twitched
and his eyes were gloomy, and even when he set the golden pond gently
swirling just beneath his nose, it released no sunlight on his face.

"I do not like things unfinished," he exclaimed. "Pictures which trail away
to a corner like the train of a lady's dress, books which another author
completes, crimes which are not solved--especially crimes which are not
solved because other crimes come after them."

"Imitation crimes," said Mr.Ricardo, and it is deplorable that he, so
fastidious and indeed finicking, should at this moment have committed the
vulgar crime of using a noun when an adjective would be correct.

"Not only those," Hanaud answered, concerned with facts and indifferent
to grammar. "They are not so difficult. But the crimes which follow
because someone has a glimpse into the crime which is not explained."

"And you have that glimpse?" Ricardo was startled into asking.

"I have," Hanaud answered simply as he exhaled a little cloud of smoke.
"Yes, I have him, but not enough of him to paint the rest of the picture
or write the last chapters of the book." He shrugged his shoulders. "But,
after all, he is Maltby's pigeon."

"Then the jeweller of the Place Vendôme must still whistle for his
cheque?" Mr. Ricardo was sorry. When Hanaud failed, he felt that he lost
a few plumes himself.

"No, no." Hanaud pulled his pocket-book from the breast of his coat and
slipped back the band of india-rubber which held it shut.

"See! An envelope. Inside the envelope a banker's draft on Paris and a
little note for Gravot of Madame Horbury's regrets."

He showed them to Ricardo and replaced the draft in the envelope, whilst
his friend's eyes lingered over Olivia's apology. "O. Horbury," Mr.
Ricardo said as he came to the signature.

"Yes," Hanaud observed with a good deal of significance. "We have seen
that name written before--you and I."

There was a note in Hanaud's voice which puzzled Ricardo. As if they two
had been especially privileged.

"We? You and I? No!"

For answer Hanaud pointed to the drawer in which were locked away two
torn halves of a pasteboard card.

"But 'D. Horbury' was the name written," cried Ricardo. "D for Daniel."
He was straining his eyes, as if he could force the name to take shape
upon the air. "Yes, D for Dan--"

He got up and, taking his keys from his pocket, opened the drawer. He
brought the two pieces of card to a small table by the side of his chair
and fitted them together.

"D. Horbury," he insisted. "Of course, my dear man! D...." and his voice

The name was written in some sort of flurry. The initial was attached to
the name, as if the writer ha written it without lifting the pen from the
card; great was the need to write it out and have done it for good.
Suppose that you started to write O, beginning at the top and following
down on the right-hand side and up on the left, and then made a twirl at
the top so that the pen might run away to the first letter of the
surname, H, you might indeed mistake it for a D, as he himself had done.
The more he looked at the writing, the surer he felt. O for Olivia, not D
for Daniel--yes, but why?

Mr. Ricardo was not very alert to whispers from the dark pools of fear
where knowledge ends, but here something which troubled him, for which he
must find, if he could, some quite simple and comfortable explanation. He
had seen Agatha Crottle's face at the exact moment when the lock was
broken and the drawer, with a sound of splintering wood, burst open.
There had been such a look of terror in her eyes, such a sickly
convulsion of her features as he hoped never to see again. He had slammed
a shutter across that vision in his mind and by no word had reopened it.
But it was in front of him now.

"You saw her that night when she was alone," said Hanaud with a challenge
in his voice.

"I saw her in a mirror. But her hands covered her face. Tears were
falling between her fingers and running down the backs of her hands. She
was in a storm of misery. Why?" Hanaud could explain it. He had sent him
on a pretence just to see and bring back that story. "You expected that I
should see what I did," Ricardo cried.

Hanaud shook his head gravely.

"I was not sure."

"It was--it was frightening."

And now, as gravely, Hanaud nodded.

"Yes, that is the word," he said. "You have heard of people who hate
enough to summon death to help them. They use a sort of witchcraft."

Hanaud's voice dropped as he spoke, and to Ricardo the room, even on that
day of late summer, had suddenly grown cold.

"They write the name of their enemy on a card, and they lock it away in a
drawer where no one will see it. They make of that drawer a coffin. And
it has been known--whether by chance or some dreadful power of evil--that
the victim has fallen sick, has faded until, in an agony of remorse, the
would-be murderer has unlocked the drawer and torn up the card."

"As she did--Agatha?" cried Ricardo in a great relief.

"I wonder," Hanaud replied sombrely. "One of the name of Horbury has died
violently. But not the woman. She had never unlocked the drawer. She did
not mean it to be unlocked. Are you sure those passionate tears were not
tears of bitter anger? Isn't it even possible that she thought that she
had killed the man when she had meant to kill the wife? In that extremity
she might have believed it."

Mr. Ricardo, of course, chose the obvious explanation of the words. "But
you can't mean," he gasped, "that Miss Agatha had set her heart on that
fat rogue Horbury!"

"I don't," Hanaud answered with a grin upon his face in which there was
neither humour nor amusement.

"Upon someone else, then?"

"Obviously," replied Hanaud.

"Who--oh, I see--who had set his heart on Olivia Horbury?"

"So it would seem."

So here was Mr. Ricardo faced with the triangle of the dramatists. Two
women and a man or two men and a woman. It was a triangle of the first
sort in this case. A man pursued by Agatha who had set his longings on

"Who is it?" cried Ricardo.

"I wish I knew," Hanaud returned, and the lines of disappointment
deepened on Ricardo's face. After all, what's the use of a walking Who's
Who if it doesn't answer your questions?--he asked of himself indignantly.

The Frenchman continued:

"The unknown man. Perhaps my friend, the murderer. There is now something
we did not have before, a reason for murder."

They had Devisher, to be sure, or they would have, if they could lay
their hands upon him. But neither Ricardo, nor Hanaud, nor indeed Maltby,
had any real belief in the guilt of Devisher. Ricardo was thrown back
upon his disinclination to accept the picture of Agatha Crottle presented
to him.

"She is middle-aged. I can't believe she ever had a lover," he cried.
"She is of the kind which finds its consolation in religion."

And there Hanaud wholly agreed with him.

"Yes, yes, she goes to church, no doubt of it, and prays with all her
soul. But to such, what is the witchcraft of the locked drawer but a more
desperate prayer? She is helping. Oh, I have seen them, the religious
ones, the unconsidered ones, the world's faded, pitiable wallflowers,
when passion comes to them for the first time in middle age they can be

And so quietly, yet with such significance, did Hanaud let that word fall
from his lips that once more Ricardo gazed into a black pit with horror
in his eyes.

But Thompson, the unfailing, brought the grim conference to an end. The
Rolls-Royce (No. 1) was at the door. He himself was now starting in the
second car. A quarter of an hour and they should follow.

"I shall come with you," said Ricardo, and he stood by the train's side
after Hanaud had taken his seat.

"You will come back, I hope," he said.

Hanaud shrugged his shoulders.

"It may be," and he suddenly leaned out of the window. "I will tell you a
little thing. Maltby will press at the inquest for an open verdict. This
affair is not ended, my friend."

"And there will be danger before it is ended," Ricardo declared.

But this danger struck first of all where neither of them expected it.


It was Mr. Ricardo's way when some high narrative of fact or fancy was
acclaimed, to discover some detail or episode, which no one else had
remarked, and to applaud it to the exclusion of all other details, and
indeed, of the whole pattern. The detail or episode may have been quite
insignificant. That did not matter. His concentration upon it made
strangers wonder for a moment whether he were not a very deep fellow. And
indeed, Mr. Ricardo enjoyed that pleasant sense of equality with his
betters which comes from travelling first on a second-class ticket. Thus
it was he who noticed what a vastly important part in the explication of
the Horbury Affair was played by the one who had the smallest concern in
it. "Mordaunt," Mr. Ricardo would say, standing on his hearthrug before
the fire and nodding his head sagely like a mandarin in ivory, "Please
don't forget Mordaunt." He should have added "verb. sap.,” and perhaps we
might add it for him.

For on the morning when probate of Horbury's will was granted to his
widow--that is a few weeks after Horbury's death--Philip Mordaunt was
walking along the street of' Nubar Pasha, in Cairo. It was half-past
eleven. The wide platform of Shepheard's Hotel was as yet sparsely
occupied and he passed it with a distinct pleasure. He had the time but
no longer the wish to explore it. He passed the Esbekiyeh Gardens and
crossed the head of the road leading to the great Bazaar. Later, when the
platform outside Shepheard's was filled and the alleys of the Mouski
empty, he would walk that way, but for the moment he had a happier task.
He continued along the straight broad avenue of Abdul Azziz. Upon his
left hand the great sand cliffs of the Nile Valley were closing in. Just
behind this street the houses were thinning out on the rising ground.
Spaces of brown earth, broken walls, an Arab cemetery replaced them; and
then it came into view--the village of Elaoui.

It hung like a cage under the high edge of the cliff, tiny, yet, in that
clear air, distinct--three sides of a square rather like Lezardrieux,
except in one particular, and an awkward particular. At Lezardrieux the
road from the square down to the river ran backwards and forwards across
the slope in reasonable gradients, sometimes invisible under a cliff,
sometimes in full view on a plateau. From Elaoui one road, straight as
the blade of a sword, dropped like a precipice from the outcrop of rock
on which centuries ago the village was built. It dropped for a mile in
length till it joined the desolation of broken walls without which no
eastern city is complete; and throughout that mile not a building nor a
tree cast a shadow across it. Moreover, it was lighted at night at the
top, where it passed between old brick walls into the village square, and
half-way down, and, most usefully for a keen-eyed watchman in the square,
at the bottom where at last it swerved amongst the ruins and was lost.
Mordaunt could see it, plain as a panel painted white in a wall of pale
red. Not a car, however swift, could ascend that road without advertising
its approach. And it was the only road, as the village about the square
was one house with a hundred tunnels and passages; for the inhabitants of
the village were one close-knit, remote family. A formidable village
under the eaves of the high Mokattam Hills--an island with a single
causeway, always watched, and time to spare!

Mordaunt took his first look at the Elaoui village, as he walked along
the street of Abdul Azziz, with as much indifference as he could
counterfeit, and suddenly came to a halt. Straight ahead of him, the
owner of a little bar had set out a few iron tables and iron chairs on
the pavement; and at one of these, facing him, sat a man he knew. A man
whom be had last seen on his yacht in Dartmouth Harbour, wearing a suit
of his clothes and with fifteen pounds of his money in his pocket.
Devisher! Yes, Devisher, but now a Devisher whose face had begun to fill
out, who wore white flannel trousers and white buckskin shoes and a grey
coat and waistcoat suitable to the season and the place. It perplexed
Mordaunt for a moment that, although they were face to face and the
distance with each step that he took narrowing between them, Devisher did
not see him. Mordaunt laughed, and the laugh brought no look of
recognition to Devisher's face.

"Well," Mordaunt reflected, laughing again at the image of the
dead-and-gone Mordaunt which rose in his mind, "that would have annoyed
me a few months ago. I couldn't have believed that anyone who had once
seen the Mordaunt who was shortly to electrify the world wouldn't have
known him again."

There was a vanity, too, even in that reflection, Mordaunt began to
recognise. But he was too beset by curiosity to continue his analysis.
Devisher did not see him because all the senses that he had were gathered
and blended into one. He was listening as the blind listen, to hear
something far away beyond the hearing of the men with vision. His eyes, a
little down-turned, were empty.

Mordaunt was already abreast of the table, but instead of passing on he
dropped his hand sharply on Devisher's shoulder and slid into the iron
chair opposite. Devisher' reaction to that clap of the hand was
astonishing. With a yelp which was sharp with terror, Devisher sprang to
his feet. He looked around wildly and brought his eyes down at last
Mordaunt's face.

"You?" he gasped, and then cried sharply: "What are you doing here?"

Philip Mordaunt answered meekly: "Cairo--early October--mayn't I? Or do you
already own the town?"

Devisher laughed a little uneasily, but he was bringing his nerves under
control and made a shift to excuse his cry of fear.

"You might have realised, Captain Mordaunt, that for the residents of the
Castillo del Libertador, the laying on of hands was a rite seldom
associated with pleasure."

"I am sorry," Mordaunt answered. "What are you drinking?"

"Beer. Not so bad."

Mordaunt rapped upon the table and two long glasses topped with snow were
set before them.

"Here's luck!" said Devisher as he drank.

"The skin off your nose!" replied Mordaunt.

"I, too, take in the Sunday newspapers," said Devisher, and Mordaunt
produced a cigar case. "Will you?" he asked, holding out the case.

"No, thank you."

Mordaunt pinched the end of one of the cigars and put it between his lips
and felt in his pocket for a box of matches. But the box was hardly out
before he heard a tiny click and a spirit-fed lighter was burning under
his nose.

"Why waste a match? Try this!" cried Devisher with a curious urgency.

Mordaunt had it on the tip of his tongue to answer that he preferred a
wooden match, but a startling conjecture suddenly struck him dumb. It
wasn't probable; it was hardly tenable at all. But if it were true? It
explained the expectancy and concentration of Devisher, the eager offer
of his cigar lighter, his presence at this hour, at this bar, in this
broad street under the hanging village of Elaoui. Did it explain, too,
Devisher's presence in Cairo? Mordaunt must discover the answer to that
question. It was not busybody's work. It was his appointed work. But he
must approach it cunningly and he was a novice in the art.

Luckily for Mordaunt, Devisher was not at his ease. He had a question or
two which clamoured for answers.

"You know," he began as he lit a cigarette and put his lighter back into
his pocket, "when I saw you in the cabin of your yacht--whether it was
something you said or just an impression that I got--I thought you had
evolved out of your experiences a sort of complete new pattern to which
you were going to fit your life."

"I had?" asked Philip, apparently as much at sea now as he had been on
his yacht.

"Yes," Devisher added, with just a hint of disdain for the man who made a
plan but couldn't act on it. "And then, a month or so later, I find you
strolling along a street of Cairo, the complete tourist, a walking poster
for Mr. Cook."

Mordaunt's face flushed. The contemptuous good-humour stung him and he
leaned forward sharply to show Mr. Bryan Devisher how wrong he was. But
he showed nothing. A warning bell was beginning to ring rather urgently
in his brain. Devisher's scorn was meant to sting, and to sting him into
admissions, if admissions there were. Mordaunt lowered his head. He drank
his beer silently, shamefacedly. The rush of blood into his face might as
truly have expressed his shame as his anger.

"You are quite right," he confessed. "I had made a plan. I was going to
do wonders. But you know what I did do? "--and he uttered a harsh little
laugh--. "I fell asleep in my bath. That's me, I am afraid."

He leaned back in his chair, with now and then a jerk of amusement, and
now and then a pull at his beer, and now and then a puff at his cigar.

"The complete tourist. Not so bad for you, Mr. Devisher, but too hard a
stroke to be pleasant to me. After I had had the nerve too, one night on
the Helford river, to give old Septimus Crottle a full history--" Mordaunt
broke off suddenly. He had been tilting his chair on to its back legs. He
brought the forelegs down with a bang upon the stones. "Of course," he
cried. "I gave you a letter to old Septimus, didn't I?"

Devisher was not prepared for that question being flung at him. He was
distracted, too, by the crash of the chair legs upon the stones. He could
listen and talk, but he couldn't listen as he wished to listen if the
talk was to be punctuated by these exclamation marks.

"Yes, you did."

"And you used it, I hope."

Devisher jumped at the suggestion. It explained at once his presence in
Cairo, his means of livelihood. He would have been compelled to offer
some explanation to the man who had seen him last in such distressful
circum stances. Here was a providential explanation provided by this
simpleton. Devisher smiled and spread out his hands. "Well, you see. I am


"To be sure."

"The Dagger Line?"

"Thanks to you."

And Philip Mordaunt began to doubt. Septimus? Was there anything in the
world so dear to that old man's heart as the Dagger Line? Its prestige,
the beauty of its ships, their efficiency and speed? Mordaunt had written
a fair letter to Septimus, concealing nothing which he knew, not even the
deep black ring round Devisher's ankle. To try such an applicant out in
an office under his eye--yes, that the old tyrant might do. But to send
him at once abroad to a place so important in the shipping world as the
Canal--that didn't sound like Septimus at all.

"You're stationed at Port Said, I suppose?"

"No, here. The Line has an office in Cairo."

Well, that might be so. Mordaunt leaned back in his chair, and Devisher
said with a smile. "It looks as if the old man has taken a risk. But that
isn't the case really. I have merely routine work. As you saw, probably,
I didn't want responsibility. Checking up on passages, passing the time
of day with Cook's and the travel agents. And I'm not alone in the
office. It just suits me, and if it doesn't run to cocktails at
Shepheard's, it does to a decent glass of beer in the street of Abdul

He had hardly finished when a match was struck upon the other side of the
street. Devisher did not turn his head, but he heard--Mordaunt was sure of
it. There was a quick flicker in his eye--Mordaunt classed it with the
scratch of the match upon the emery paper--and a relaxation of his face. A
signal had been given and taken. Mordaunt, for his part, could look
across the road. He saw a tall youth in an Arab gown standing outside a
cheap provision shop with a cigarette in his mouth which he had just
lighted, and a big box of Bryant & May's matches in his hand. The young
Arab drew at his cigarette to make sure that it was alight and then,
putting the match-box into his pocket, strolled away.

High up above their heads the village of Elaoui clung under the rim of
the hill. Mordaunt was tempted to draw Devisher's attention to it and
watch confusion trouble his face. But he bethought him of a better way,
which would not betray himself.

Devisher was looking at his watch.

"Twelve o'clock!" he said, and he finished his glass of beer. "That will
give me just the hour I want before lunch." He looked around for waiter
and summoned him. "I had a glass before you came," and as he paid for it,
Mordaunt said blandly:

"I'm very glad that we met, and I'm very glad, too, that things have
smoothed themselves out for you. I'll write to old Septimus to-day and
tell him that I've met you and thank him."

Now he saw more than confusion rise in Devisher's f ace. He saw fear. He
heard a quick gasp.

"I've already done that," exclaimed Devisher.

"But not for me," Mordaunt returned with a laugh. "I wish you could. I
hate letter-writing. But this one I must write myself."

He watched Devisher hurry away. Septimus and the Dagger Line could not
blend with Elaoui and a young Arab striking a match in the street of
Abdul Azziz. The sooner he wrote to Crottle to thank him for giving
Devisher a chance, the better. That was all that he need do; and, indeed,
he wrote the letter and posted it that evening.

But it was already too late.


MORDAUNT sat for a few minutes longer at his iron table. The functions of
Devisher in Cairo and the unlikely action of Septimus Crottle were put
aside. He rose a little reluctantly and turned back to the great Bazaar.
Midday had emptied its narrow streets. He stopped once at a small booth
and bought a packet of cigarettes from an old white-bearded Arab in a
blue cloak. At a corner he turned to the north-east and walked into a
quarter where the indifference and quiet of decay followed with an
astonishing abruptness upon the noisy bargainings of the Bazaar. He came
to a silent open space.

Mordaunt had seldom seen anything more desolate. Once, no doubt, it had
been built upon. For it had certainly never been laid out as a garden or
a place of ornament and rest. Here, for instance, a wall began for no
reason, continued for a few yards, and for no reason ceased. Here a mound
of bricks with a floor of bricks spread like an open fan about it showed
where a house had slipped to the ground. Everywhere the earth was uneven
and in colour of a dull yellow and was withdrawing, it seemed, from sight
under a yellow pall made of its own dust. Were there a flint upon that
ground, it had no facet from which the sun could strike a spark. The
whole place was melancholy and more silent than the desert, as all places
will be where dwellings are relapsing slowly into the shapeless earth
from which they sprang.

As Mordaunt leaned forward he saw on his left hand two trees of tamarisk
which stood within a wall at the path's side. He had begun to hope that
he had missed his way. But his courage sank now. The house of the

He went forward to it. It was a large house with a gate and, within the
gate, three brick steps led up to the door. Again the hope that he had
been misled encouraged him; so little sign was there that anyone for many
years had made a home of it. But he had instructions nowadays. He opened
the gate, mounted the three steps, and smartly knocked upon the door with
the crook of his stick.

To his surprise, it was opened so quickly that he seemed to have been
awaited. A young woman, indeed she was little more than a girl, stood in
the doorway with a look of eagerness upon her white face. Never had
anyone in Mordaunt's experience appeared so out of place as this girl in
this dusty area of ruin. She was slender, dressed in a coat and skirt of
dark grey, shabby, no doubt, but as trim and tidy as when it came first
from its George Street tailor in London, and with nothing of Egypt in her
dark blue eyes. Mordaunt had not a doubt that here his walk ended. But
there was obviously no such conviction in the woman in the doorway. There
had been a welcome for someone, but it had faded into bewilderment at the
sight of him; and even that bewilderment had not been able to master her
disappointment. She was very white. The youth of her face was spoilt by
her fatigue and under the broad forehead her eyes brooded upon him

"You have come to the wrong house, I think," she said.

To Mordaunt, this gracious English voice was lovely as music, however
commonplace the words. "I am sure not," he answered. "In a way, no doubt,
I am sorry, but in a way perhaps I am glad." If Mordaunt had been at
pains to replace her distress with a return of her bewilderment, he could
hardly have done better. "You are Mrs. Leete."

Now, indeed, she was surprised. The white brows drew together under the
swathe of fair hair which crowned her head. "Yes."

In the admission there was a question.

"When I left London, your father, Mr. Septimus Crottle, asked me to bring
you a message."

For a moment her face softened. A smile almost flickered across her lips,
as though she saw Septimus suddenly in his frock-coat with the points of
his high white collar cupping his cheeks. All that she said, however, was
again "Yes?" but now in a voice less hostile.

"Mr. Crottle wished you to know that your place was always kept for you
in Portman Square."

Once more the smile almost curved her lips and the ghost of a smile
glimmered in the dark pools of her eyes.

"Next to Agatha's, was it? Do Sunday nights still go on?"

"Rather," Mordaunt exclaimed, commending them.

"Yes, riotous, weren't they?" she answered dryly, and added thoughtfully:
"I ran out--that was the phrase--but I may come back--to 1870--if I wish."
She remained silent, and then threw up her head "Wouldn't it have been
better for all of them--Anne Audrey and Agatha--if they had run out, too!
"--and recovering from her outburst, "I should, of course, very much like
to hear all you have to tell me. But to-day--" and again distress took her
by the throat so that her voice broke. "If you will give me your address,
I'll write to you."

Mordaunt pulled out of his pocket a small diary with loose leaves. He was
saved one awkward moment; it was all the more welcome since there were
many others ahead. He wrote his name and title on one leaf and handed it
to her.

"Yobosci," she began as she read. "That's captain, I think. Captain
Philip Mordaunt--" and as her eyes ran along the written words, she
stopped abruptly and began again. "The Coastguard Directorate. I see."

There was no resentment in her voice and no suggestion that Mordaunt had
set a trap for her. "I see," merely meant, "It was expected." Mordaunt,
however, took the words to himself.

"No doubt I should have put my duty first," he stammered.

"We are all recommended to do that," she answered gravely.

"What I said was true," he exclaimed.

Rosalind Leete looked puzzled.

"No doubt," she replied.

"I mean--your father's message. He did send it."

She looked--and again with a trifle of amusement--at his face, so troubled
lest he should be thought guilty of a despicable subterfuge. "I never
thought for a moment that you had made the message up."

"Thank you," said Mordaunt fervently, and so began to stammer again. "As
for the other matter"--no other matter had been mentioned but neither
pretended that it didn't exist--"as for this other matter--it's--well--it's

"It would be," said Rosalind Leete. Clearly she had to help him out. "As
you pointed out, it's a matter of your duty and it should have come

Mordaunt caught at the word. "Yes."

Rosalind stepped aside in the hall and he crossed the threshold. She shut
the front door and threw open the door of the room which looked out upon
the empty space. Mordaunt walked into a room, meagrely equipped but clean
as soap and a scrubbing brush could make it. One or two cotton mats were
spread upon the bare floor. The furniture was of painted deal and
upholstered in brown plush, a sofa, an arm-chair and half a dozen
straight-backed chairs--a suite in fact from a Cairene Bon Marché. But
more pitiable than any sign of poverty was the absence of any of those
trifles which, through their private associations, will make a home out
of the barest lodgings. Septimus had declared that the marriage had
failed. Mordaunt had thought, "There spoke the architect of his family,
angry because a brick had fallen from its place." But clearly the
marriage had failed. There was not a photograph in the style of ten or
fifteen years ago, not some little toy or book which linked the grievous
to-day with a pleasant schoolroom, not some small picture or statue on
which one hangs a dream. Mordaunt's face was compassionate as he stood in
that inhospitable room. He had a queer vision of the girl setting those
small memorials out when she and her husband came first to live there and
removing them one by one as the shadows darkened upon their lives until
the room became the cold waiting-room of a railway station.

"Now," she said.

"I want to see Professor Leete."

That the title was no longer Leete's by right, Mordaunt knew, but still
to attach it to his name might give her a momentary comfort. It seemed,
however, that she would have no pretences.

"Then you didn't know?" she cried.

But the cry was so wild, the look so amazed, that more must have happened
than the loss of Leete's professorship. Rosalind clapped her hand
suddenly to her mouth to stop the hysteria in which her voice was rising.
But she succeeded. She drew away her hand and let it fall by her side.

"What else should I know?" he asked.

"What you shall know," she answered.

The words were not clipped. There was nothing whatever dramatic in her
gesture. She walked to a door at the side of the room and opened it.

"He is here," she said.

Mordaunt followed her into a bedroom as mean in its equipment as the
parlour. But it had a dignity which the other room had not. For in the
bed a dead man lay swathed already for the grave. He had the likeness of
a man of middle age, with black hair growing thin and a face so
discoloured and emaciated that it was shocking to see. Moreover, there
was no peace in it.

Mordaunt bent his head towards Rosalind.

"I was abrupt. I am sorry. This--you were right--I didn't know,", and he
looked at her full in the face. "Can I help you?"

"I don't think so," she answered quietly.

"It happened--?"

"This morning at five o'clock."

"You had a doctor?"

"An Egyptian. Dr. Achmed Agami. He has been attending my husband. He is
very kind. You know that here there must be no delays. He is arranging

There were possibilities of delay, a simple form of embalming, but no
doubt the doctor had explained that. If there were no friends to escort
Leete to his grave, and Mordaunt thought that he had shaken off all of
them except this girl, delay was little to be desired.

"The actual cause was, I suppose, malaria?"

Rosalind Leete looked at him with surprise.

"Yes. How could you tell that?"

For one might have thought that he had starved to death, even with those
wrappings about his throat and neck.

"It ends that way so often," said Mordaunt gently.

And it begins so easily, so pleasantly. Perhaps a reward for a day's
overwork, perhaps idly as an experiment, perhaps, as with the fellaheen,
to gratify a lust. There were a thousand entrances into that fatal
Enchanted Cavern.

"It began in Luxor?" he asked.

"In the Valley of the Kings," she answered. "He was sent out with an
American Mission. Why it began, I don't know," and for the second time
her voice broke. "I hope that it wasn't my fault."

Mordaunt wondered how much of truth there was in that self-reproach. It
might have been that she had run out to escape from the sea-discipline of
the house in Portman Square rather than from any love of her professor.
Somehow disappointment had come.

"You went to him straight from your father's house?" Even as he spoke, he
realised the question's impertinence, but she answered at once.

"We had arranged everything on tip-toes. We were married in St. Bride's,
at the back of Fleet Street, on a Friday morning and left by the
boat-train for Brindisi."

Had he looked for so much more from her than she, with all the promise of
her youth, had to give him? For she must have been glorious three years
ago before poverty and shame had reclothed her in distress. It was
certainly distress rather than grief, distress and a gnawing sense of
guilt, which numbed her now.

Mordaunt could read the history of their marriage easily enough, once the
lure of the drug had caught him. The man's loss of interest in his most
fascinating work, his long absences, the growing slovenliness of his
dress and his looks, the whispers which became open talk, the loss of
discipline amongst the men employed, the dismissal, the flight to a
native quarter in Cairo, the growing urgency for the drug, the
diminishing means to gratify it, more boracic to less heroin--until in the
end it came to an Arab in a back room of the Mouski using an hypodermic
needle which was never disinfected. Hence malaria and this polluted
skeleton of an outcast who had once ruled men and held his head high.

Mordaunt turned towards Rosalind Leete.

"You are alone here?" he asked.

"There is a woman. She is buying food now. She has been very helpful."

"But she doesn't sleep here?"

Rosalind Leete looked about the room.

"We have nothing worth anybody's while to steal."

Nevertheless this grim morning had been foreseen. It was properly
humbling to Philip Mordaunt to realise that all the high services which
he had begun to watch himself rendering to the hapless daughter of
Septimus Crottle had already been discounted. Rosalind had sufficient
money to pay all that was due, she had taken a room in an English
boarding-house in the Sharià Abdin. She had been working in the Museum
for Henry Scobell, one of the greatest of English Egyptologists, owing to
a certain skill which she had acquired in photography and typewriting.

"So you have been the breadwinner in Cairo?" he Maid.

"He was too ill," she answered, and the noise of wheels broke in upon her

She looked out of the window as a van stopped before the house and a
sharp movement warned him that here, after all, were friendly offices
which a deputy might take over.

Mordaunt was the only mourner besides herself at the burial in the
English cemetery that afternoon.

"I am grateful," she said as they walked away, "and in a day or two I
should like to talk to you. I shouldn't wonder if I could help you," she
added with a ghost of a smile.

"Did you ever hear of the village of Elaoui?" he asked.

She repeated the name. "No."

"Nor of a match struck at a certain hour in a certain place?"


"Yet I think we might help one another, nonetheless," he said as he left
her at her door.


ON a Sunday morning Mordaunt waited anxiously in the gardens of Gezireh
for coming of Rosalind Leete. He would hardly have admitted anxiety. For
he could find no excuse for it in the help which so far she had given
him. A few small tradesmen, like the little Arab with the white beard and
the blue coat from whom once Mordaunt had bought cigarettes, had been
gathered in for selling slippers of hashish, and a few more important
dealers in carpets for selling the more deadly heroin. But the profits
were so great that there were always others to take the risks.

There was the troublesome business that, although just when at one time
the traffic in drugs seemed to be mastered, it had broadened out with a
violence and fatality too big, it seemed, for the private trafficker and
most difficult to explain. It was thought--no, it was believed--and surely
it was more than believed, it was known--that a great and bloody-minded
nation which called crime culture and theft civilisation and enslavement
hegemony, had, as a wise policy, set out to corrupt and destroy the
Egyptians by the illicit smuggling drugs into that country. It was no
longer a case of this or that man, or this or that company, running
hashish or heroin or cocaine into Egypt for profit at the risk of penal
servitude for its officials on the spot. It was a national policy aiming
at a national destruction. It was the curse of the fellaheen that he
would starve rather, than control his lusts, leave his family to starve
and himself, within a few months, die, an idiot and a pauper. However
carefully he had tilled his land and paid his dues, however many the
hours he had given to the tiny canals and ditches which had watered his
fields and secured some sort of a livelihood for his family and himself,
they would have no memories to restrain him. There were no cords which
would bind him to the mast of his daily work, once the siren music
condensed within those dark blue paper bags was allowed to swell. All
would go, industry, food, life. Colossal! One of the great signal posts
from which the world's traffic was controlled would lie open for a great
and worthy nation to use it entirely for its own advantage. A people
would have perished--well, great nations march to their destiny over roads
ballasted by corpses. That was dutiful!

So the slippers of hashish and the envelopes of thick blue paper, filled
with the sparkling white crystals of heroin were sunk in waterproof bags
off Mersa Matruli, or were carried across Sinai on the back of camels,
and were ferried across the Canal. But a centre was needed where all this
vital fodder could be collected in safety and distributed with as little
danger as was possible. For a national policy, and so magnificent a
policy as the destruction of another nation by the most corrupt and
vicious incitements, organisation was needed--good, careful organisation,
such as this high-class, A.1., sedulous nation had always at its command.
It was a short-sighted nation, physically, and something of that short
sight had crept into its plans as well as into the eyes which passed them
as perfect.

The centre had been found, the clearing-house, in the village of Elaoui.
Approached by a single road which could be watched night and day and
whence ample warning could be given, that honeycomb of houses was the
best hiding-place near Cairo. It had moreover a most saintly mosque,
dating from the twelfth century, of which one of the Elaoui family was
the priest. That this sacred building did, in fact, hide those dangerous
cargoes, no one of the authorities concerned could doubt. But the mosque
could not be searched. Another point of junction must be discovered,
where the village under the rim of the hill touched the great city by the

And it was discovered after a great deal of patience.

The family of the Elaoui held itself strictly aloof. If a member of it
went down into the city, he made his home there. He was not an outcast,
but he had lost his Place in the home circle. He remained on terms of
friendship with his kinsmen and, when occasion served, he did business
with such as descended to do business with him. There were a good many of
that upland who had married and made their homes in Cairo and, carrying
on tradition, they cultivated a secret clanship. With the gradual storage
of the forbidden drugs in that unassailable village, the opportunity for
mutual service arrived. As soon as enough had been gathered in those
rambling dwellings and that saintly mosque to soak the town, a youth
strolled down from the village to the street of Abdul Azziz and at twelve
o'clock noon precisely struck a wooden match in front of a certain
provision shop. There was no crime in that. But it was the sign for the
Elaoui men in the city to make their secret bargains with the actual
dealers, a carpet seller with a big shop in a main street, or a lesser
one, like the seller of cigarettes in the blue cloak on the edge of  the great
Bazaar; and in a day or so the traffic was in full swing. At times a
dealer was caught and disappeared for years into the grim convict prison.
But he never talked. At times a youth was seen to strike his match at the
appointed time in the appointed street. But if a man couldn't light a
cigarette in a public place at midday, what was the world coming to? The
secret of the distribution had been kept, and with that problem the new
and unknown officer in the Coastguard Directorate was set to deal.

Mordaunt thought over his problem as he waited for Rosalind on a bench in
that long avenue which leads at last to the Anglo-American Hospital. So
far fortune had served him. He had seen the match actually struck. He had
noticed expectation in the bearing of a man whom he knew before the match
was struck and relaxation afterwards; and the man himself was suspect.

Mordaunt wondered whether he had been wise to inform Bryan Devisher that
he would write to thank Septimus for his kindness. There had been a quite
unmistakable flash of fear across Devisher's face. Yet who but Septimus
could have appointed him to a seat in the offices of the Dagger Line?

Mordaunt shrugged his shoulders. The question was not worth a minute of
debate. For Mordaunt had written on the evening of his encounter with
Devisher thanking Septimus for so readily helping his acquaintance and
hoping, without any great conviction, that good would come of it. The
letter should have reached London now. It would probably be delivered on
Monday morning at the office of the Company. He had addressed his letter
to the Chief Office rather than to Portman Square, since it was upon a
business matter. Well, in ten days, if not before, he would have an
answer; and, as he pushed the trouble away from him, a small hand fell
lightly on his shoulder and he looked up to find some other trouble
waiting to take its place.

"I am late," said Rosalind.

"There is always an excuse for it," Philip replied as he rose from the
bench, "and to-day I'm afraid a reason."

Rosalind nodded and sat down beside him.

"Yes. I had to decide. It was difficult. James thought, that since I had
got this job with Mr. Scobell, I might as well get on with it."

"James?" Mordaunt asked, rather at a loss. "Is he the successor to

"Not that I know. I suppose George and James are equal. But James saw no
reason why I should go back. I couldn't help. George, however, is a real
Crottle. We ought to be together, the lot of us, in one room!"

Her lips twisted a little crookedly even at this moment as she thought of
the code of the Crottles. But Mordaunt knew her well enough to be assured
that her trouble was real. She sat with her hands folded in her lap, very
quiet, looking straight ahead of her.

"What has happened?" he asked.

"My father."

He hesitated. But her face was troubled and perplexed, rather than

"He is ill?"

"Not unless he has lost his memory," and she swung round to Mordaunt,
"and can you imagine Septimus doing that?"

"No," Mordaunt answered, and now the nature of the disaster was clear.
"Septimus has vanished?"

"Yes. He is lost altogether. Of course we always say that such things
can't happen nowadays. But they always are happening."

Mordaunt sat and stared at Rosalind. He was never very quick to recognise
and separate the sets of complications which one event might cause. And
several questions were struggling to take form in his thoughts. One came
first, and he asked it of her rather breathlessly. "When did Septimus

Rosalind gave him the date and Mordaunt traced it back to a day which
began forty-eight hours after match had been struck in the street of
Abdul Azziz--and after Mordaunt had warned Devisher that he meant to write
a letter of thanks to Septimus. Meanwhile Rosalind explained. "I got this
telegram this morning from George. The Line has two offices, the main big
one in Leadenhall Street and a smaller one in Whitehall, which Father, of
late years, used. You know how he lived?"

"By watches."

"He had no fixed rule as to the hour when he went to his office, but he
left it at six every day, from Monday to Friday."

This was his daily walk, whether fine or wet, whether winter or summer.
On this Friday--it was a Friday and the footpaths, for that reason
perhaps, a little less crowded than at six o'clock they usually were--he
would have walked up Whitehall until he was opposite the mouth of Downing
Street. There he would have crossed the road, passed through Downing
Street, traversed St. James's Park to the Mall, and walked up the slope
of the Green Park to Piccadilly. At times, if the weather was very fine,
he would prolong his constitutional to Hyde Park Corner and the Marble
Arch, but as a rule it came to an end in Piccadilly opposite to the Turf
Club. Here he hailed a taxi and was driven home to Portman Square.

Now on this Friday night a fog was settling like a brown blanket on the
town and the month being October, the nights were closing in. Septimus
was recognised by a policeman under the lamp-post at the entrance to
Downing Street--and was never seen again. The nephews waited for some days
on the chance that some body would have met and recognised Septimus, but
now George had thought it wise to telegraph the news to Rosalind and
summon her home.

"And you are going?" Mordaunt asked, and when she agreed he nodded his
head once or twice like someone reckoning that here was a disaster to be
added to the rest.

"I am not going for any but rather mean reasons," Rosalind continued.
"They have always expected me--my family, my father, too--to come crawling
home, asking for shelter and the run of the cupboard: I want to go back
and show them that one needn't necessarily fail. I want to wave a
flag--yes, it's beastly and boastful, I know--for five minutes. Then I
shall come back again.''

"And find me packed off on an easier job, I expect."

Suddenly Rosalind struck the seat with the palm of her hand. "No, no!"
she cried with a curious violence. She sprang to her feet. "We have had
failures, both of us. But we are not to continue having failures. We are
going to do well--both of us." And she turned away abruptly to hide
perhaps the colour which rushed in her face. She was aware, quite
unwittingly, of a community in their lives. She had paraded it too far,
buoyantly, she had brandished it. She turned back again to Philip with
quite another impulse.

"You will still be digging into your problem," she cried. "I want to see
the end of it. If you are ready to blow the Last Post outside the walls
of Elaoui, wait please, until I can hear the notes, however far away I

She had the eagerness of a child, she was so certain that the great cause
must prevail, that Mordaunt laughed with her on a wave of confidence.

"I'll try. As you come steaming into Cairo in three weeks, you shall hear
them faint as fairy chimes from the edge of the hill."

They were moving away to take their luncheon for once in the grill-room
of Shepheard's when the idea came into Mordaunt's head. It was such a
scintillating and illustrious idea, such an idea amongst ideas, that
Mordaunt wondered how he came by it. He stopped dead on the bridge
between the island and the city.

"My word!" he cried.

If ideas were to come to him of such beauty, why, he might solve the
problem of Elaoui before Rosalind came back.

"But I wouldn't like that to happen, Rosalind," he exclaimed.

"No, Philip, it wouldn't be pleasant," Rosalind returned, and it was
noticeable perhaps, although neither of them noticed it, that this was
the first time that in talking together they were using their Christian

"No. I want you to be in on it," he said.

"Nothing could be more lucid," replied Rosalind.

"Of course," said he, and he suddenly began to walk forward at a great

"Philip, I can't keep up," she replied; and he stopped again, full of

"It was the idea."

"Yes, ideas do run away with one," she answered.

"And this one, oh, I want it to be ever so clear."

"It's certainly a little involved at the moment."

"Then I've put it wrong," said Philip.

"You haven't put it at all," replied Rosalind. Philip Mordaunt stopped
and stared at her.

"No, I suppose I haven't," he conceded. "But we'll go along slowly--"

"We are not moving at all now," Rosalind interposed.

Mordaunt looked at the bridge as if he expected it to be a staircase on
the Underground Railway.

"No, we're not," he remarked with surprise.

He walked on again with Rosalind at his side, but now more discreetly.

"Your boat leaves Port Said?"

"To-morrow evening."

"You'll get off at Marseilles?"


"And take the Blue Train?"


"Right. I'll tell you what, Rosalind! I'll get it all clear in my mind
and whilst we are lunching I'll reel it off."

"That would be a change," said Rosalind and, with a little gurgle of
amusement, she walked by the side of her frowning companion up the long
street to the hotel. They had a wash, they drank a cocktail, they sat
down to luncheon in the grill-room, and Mordaunt was ready with his idea.

"I took to Portman Square the last time I saw your father, an
acquaintance of mine, Julius Ricardo."

"He was on your yacht with Bryan Devisher."

"Exactly. And with Ricardo, a friend of his, a French detective of mark,


"Hanaud was a big, heavy man with thick black hair and a blue jowl. He
looked rather like a French comedian. He appeared to be as clumsy as a
rhino, but he moved as lightly as an antelope, and he had quiet eyes
which saw everything and a voice which was of no account and suddenly had
all the authority in the world. I watched him whilst Septimus was
reading--a book about Marie Antoinette's boy, the young Dauphin of France,
and it seemed to me afterward that if I had wanted an account of that
queer event with nothing left out, I might have got it from him."'

Rosalind Leete was listening now and with much the same concentration as
Hanaud had shown. She no longer interrupted.

"Hanaud was very interested in the death of Daniel Horbury. He had a
question or two to ask of Septimus which I didn't hear, and he was, I
think, inclined to believe that somehow Bryan Devisher was concerned in

"Oh!" She recoiled ever so slightly. "Bryan Devisher," she repeated.

"That's the man to keep in mind," said Mordaunt cheerfully. As long as
you kept him in mind, it seemed that all the inferences would come
trotting up one after another by themselves. "From the moment he deserted
the Agamemnon in Dartmouth Harbour to the moment when I found him by
chance in the Sharia Abdul Azziz, he disappeared altogether, although the
police the next day were searching for him."

"He disappeared with a letter from you to my father?"


"A letter of recommendation?"

"No. Of introduction, yes. I gave what I knew of his history."

"The black rim round the ankle?"


"The Horbury swindle over the necklace?"

"I didn't know of it when I wrote the letter."

Rosalind nodded at him with a frowning brow. "There's a lesson for you
not to write letters to other people's fathers recommending engaging

"You weren't other people. You aren't other people. Devisher wasn't
engaging. And the letter wasn't delivered," he countered, and then came
dolefully to the honest conclusion: "Yet I am beginning to be afraid that
that letter did all the harm."


"I suppose because I am only just beginning to think things out," he said
so contritely that Rosalind's hand slipped across the table and gave his
arm upon the table a friendly and comforting shake. "You see, he couldn't
have delivered the letter because he couldn't have done it until some
time on the day when the police net was out for him--the Friday."

"Still, when you found him here, he was engaged in the office of the
Dagger Line," she argued, and Mordaunt took her up at once.

"All the more reason to suggest that he hadn't delivered it. The Dagger
Line was almost the Holy Grail to Septimus. To put an unknown man out of
a prison straight away into the Dagger Line here--in Cairo--no, Septimus
would never have done it. If I hadn't been sure of it at once, I ought to
have been absolutely sure the moment I saw the terror in Devisher's face
when I told him that I should write to Septimus and thank him."

"But you did write that day."

"Yes, I wrote," said Mordaunt emphasising the word. For it condemned him.
He pointed towards her hand-bag at her elbow. "You received a telegram. I
gave him a week, a clear week, to telegraph or telephone."

A silence followed whilst Rosalind followed out the possibilities which
that difference of time suggested. This was how the story ran then:
Devisher had friends who were expecting him in England, rogues of quality,
the Horburys in fact. They had hidden him, obtained for him somehow this
cover in the Steamship Office and sent him to take his profits and risks
in the drug racket in Cairo. But if Mordaunt's letter of thanks ever
reached old Septimus Crottle, the whole scheme would be blown sky-high.
Therefore Septimus must be kidnapped, removed, got out of the way
somehow, until Mordaunt's letter could be surely intercepted and

Rosalind shrank from facing that tragical dilemma--but she did face it.
Septimus Crottle came of a tough yeoman stock. He could face--he had
faced--disasters and conspiracies. She knew of no secret flaws in that old
and stubborn man which would defeat him. And such a hue and cry would be
raised that all England would be searching for him and not searching in

This was the legend which commended itself to those two novices over the
luncheon table.

"I will write carefully a letter to Hanaud explaining everything, the
striking of the match, what it means, Devisher's recognition of it, my
foolish letter to Crottle--everything."

"Yes," said Rosalind.

"I'll give you the letter this evening in an open envelope. You will read
it and then gum it down so that no one else can read it. I'll send Hanaud
a telegram saying that you will leave the Blue Train at the Gare du Nord
on the morning when you arrive, and that you will call on him at the
Sureté that morning and go on by the afternoon train to England."

"But"--Rosalind asked doubtfully--"you say he's important. Will he see me?

"I introduced him to Septimus. Of course he will," Mordaunt replied.
"Besides, he's interested in the letter Horbury wrote to Crottle which
was never delivered. Oh, he'll see you," and as if to make sure that a
meal so dismal should not end in frowns and gloom, he added: "If you have
any luck you'll meet Mr. Ricardo."


FAITHFUL to her instructions from a more experienced traveller, Rosalind
continued in the Blue Train from the Gare de Lyon to the Gare du Nord. At
the Gare du Nord she descended and followed a porter, who carried her two
travelling cases up the steps to the small hotel in the station building.
A letter was handed to her by the manageress in which Hanaud begged her
to make no fixed arrangements, assured her that his debt to his English
friends would not be diminished by the utmost help which he could give to
her, and that by the time she had made herself comfortable and taken her
little breakfast, a messenger would come for her. By his signature, he
was still a member of the Peerage. Rosalind enjoyed an admirable hot
bath, a change into a well-tended black suit, a white silk shirt with a
frill of lace, a pair of beige silk stockings and shoes as admirable as
her bath, and took an equally admirable little breakfast in the
restaurant. When she had finished her cigarette a messenger bowed before
her. Monsieur Hanaud was at her disposal. She followed him to a car in
the courtyard and was whisked away through the traffic by a driver, who
used his gong rather as a musical instrument playing a coloratura solo
than as a motorist's signal, across the bridge to the Sureté. In an
office looking out upon the quay and the river, Monsieur Hanaud received

"You will see in England that dear Mr. Ricardo," he said as he held open
an agate cigarette-box. "Will you, please, at some time suitable,
indicate to him I do not offer to my friends those deplorable cigarettes
in a blue-paper cover which hurt him so much when he smells me smoking
them. A match? So! You have a letter for me I think? Thank you! Will you
sit here whilst I read it?"

He put her into a comfortable chair whilst he read the letter, and it was
not in order to make her feel more at her ease that he read it with, now
and then, an exclamation of pleasure. When he had finished it, he laid it
down and thumped it with little blows of his fist.

"So--o--o!" he exclaimed slowly and he became aware of his guest. He had
gleaned something out of that letter more than they knew who had sent it.

"Madame, the letter is helpful. I sympathise with you over the absence of
your father, Mr. Crottle, but I do not think it will be for long.
Meanwhile, I say that you and the good Mordaunt torture yourselves
without the reason if you think the kidnap was to anticipate Mordaunt's
letter of thanks."

"Then you are acquitting Bryan Devisher of having any share in all this
trouble of the Horburys and the Crottles?"

"Oh, I am? Am I? I plead at all events that we do not exaggerate the
share. Listen, as they say in the films," he continued, hitching his
chair forward and then casting his glance in a wide sweep about the room.
He lowered his voice, he nodded his head with the sagacity of an
alderman. "I will tell you the truth. The negro in the firewood is a bird
of another colour."

"Oh, I thank you!" she cried warmly. "That does make everything so

Hanaud had the grace to blush. He had intended to save himself from a
young lady's questions by making the young lady feel foolish. All that he
had succeeded in doing was to make himself look ever so much more foolish
than she could have felt. However, he was not a man of grudges. To get
your own back was not really a necessity. He laughed with friendliness.

"I tell you, madame, something more. You are the first to link with the
affair of Crottle the affair of Horbury. Yes, they are one. What happened
on that moonlit night at White Barn? Who was there? And why? Hours
afterwards, when all was over and the moonlight growing grey, who lifted
the telephone mouthpiece from its cradle to silence it? And who
silenced--oh, something ever so much more important than the
telephone...?" He was following his own fancies and forebodings as they
had crowded in upon him that August morning in the white house beneath
the beech trees and the oaks.

"Who or what silenced Olivia Horbury? Why did she lock her door? For how
long did she lie in a swoon against it? Only when we know all that
happened at White Barn between the great holly hedge and the toll gate
road on that night of late August--only then shall we put an end to the
chain of crimes which began there. Daniel Horbury is murdered. That is no
great harm, you may say. But Septimus Crottle disappears--and next--ah,
what comes next?" He broke off with a shiver of the shoulders, so violent
so unexpected, that Rosalind was shocked by it.

"Unless we are quick," Hanaud continued. He folded Mordaunt's letter to
him without noticing what he was doing, slowly and carefully, so that
each crease crossed the paper exactly as it had done; all his urgency
rang in the whisper of his voice.

"Yes, unless we are very quick."

Hanaud looked up. He saw Rosalind Leete with a pair of startled eyes
staring at him from a face as white as paper. Was it she? Or that other
woman of whom he dreaded to hear? He moved to bring himself back from that
corner of London. Outside the window those cries were rising from the
quay, that flashing silver flood was the river Seine under the midday
sun. Besides, this one's hair was of the colour of a summer sunset. That
one's hair in London of the midnight.

"I frightened you," he said remorsefully.

"You did."

"I am sorry."

"You will come to London perhaps?"

There was an insistence in Rosalind's question which made him smile.

"Yes, I must pay for frightening you," he cried and was met with frowns
and disfavour. 

"I am serious," she said.

Hanaud opened a drawer and produced a passport, a special request from
the Sureté that all help needed shall be granted to him, a special
authorisation from the Home Office and finally a ticket.

"As soon as Captain Mordaunt telegraphed to me of your coming, I wrote to
my friend the Superintendent, Maltby, and at once everything was made
easy. But I must say frankly that there is nothing which I can do which
Maltby cannot do. We had many talks together, I think in the end we saw
with one eye. But frankly, too, I do not like unfinished things."

Hanaud was preening himself upon the nobility of his character, whilst he
disclaimed all superiority to his English colleague. He had a false
modesty which earned him jeers and sarcasms and disparagements and a true
modesty which kept warm for him the loyalty of his department. It was the
false modesty which was talking now, mimicking a humility which he did
not possess and depreciating the social value of his calling.

"Now you, Madame Leete, by what route do you travel?"

"I proposed, if I was free, to travel by the afternoon train."

"Arriving at ten-thirty or so?"


Hanaud sat for a minute without speaking. Then he proposed to her a
change. "If you do not arrive to-night," he said, "I do not think that
anything we fear can happen. You are expected to bring important

"About Bryan Devisher, yes."

"But no one knows yet what your information is. It may be of more
importance than anyone thinks. Therefore it will be waited for."


"But if you arrive to-night, you do not know who will meet you or how
many there will be in the house to hear your story; and before that
awkward hour of midnight it may be known that you have not so much to
tell after all."

Rosalind sat back in her chair. She was breathing rather quickly. She was
still frightened. Nay, she was more frightened than ever. She felt so
near, as this man talked to her, to some grim lake of horrors writhing
just beyond her feet. "What do you want me to do?" she asked.

"Keep for us this night safe."

Monsieur Hanaud did not much like the sea. He preferred the shortest
Channel crossing. But, if he had affairs to wind up, he could sleep
without malaise on the steamer from Havre to Southampton. It was
convenient. There was time to dine on arrival at Havre, and time to dine
well. There were private cabins on the ship, one of which he would
procure for Madame, as well as change her ticket. "La Gare d'Orléans,
Madame." A clerk should accommodate her ticket at Mr. Cook's. And
to-morrow morning Mr. Ricardo should meet them on the quay in his Rolls-
Royce No. 1, and drive with them to London.

Hanaud rang the bell and consigned her to his clerk. But while that man
waited outside the door, the truth forced its way to speech.

"We are neither such clever ones, nor such fools as people think. A crime
may be committed. Such crafty plans may be invented to hide it up that we
could never unravel them. But very often a little accidental thing
happens, a change of weather, the departure of a train changed by an
hour, some unexpected visitor at a late hour of the night. Ah, if we are
quick to seize up that small scrap of grit which blows in from the window
and spoils the smooth fine machine, to know it for what it is, then
Madame"--no, he couldn't keep it down, the other side of him must have
its turn--"then, Madame Leete, one becomes Hanaud."

At all events this should be said. By travelling on the Havre packet to
Southampton Rosalind did more than save a night. She saved a life.


There were warm salutations by Hanaud and a deprecatory reception of them
by Mr. Ricardo on the quayside. The rest is silence. It was, besides,
early in the morning and the rugs folded in Rolls-Royce No. 1 were
appealing. Rosalind had drunk tea and Hanaud what passed for coffee on
the ship. Mr. Ricardo had done as much at the South-Western Hotel.
Hanaud's papers had wafted the two travellers through the Customs house.
The car flowed round Bargate and along the street Above Bar to

"We breakfast here, the English breakfast. Yes, I am the cosmopolitan. I
like him. I eat him. The eggs, the bacon, the sole, the mutton chops and
the Oxford marmalade. The night was untroubled?--yes "--this with a glance
of enquiry towards Mr. Ricardo. "So for half an hour! Then we go on to
London. We send Mrs. Leete home in a cab from Waterloo Station. We
collect Maltby: over the luncheon at the corner house we hold the council
of war. Then perhaps we stretch out the hand--and make an arrest," he was
going to add. "But," he stopped and heaved a prodigious sigh--"we are in
England. Prisoners will not keep in the cell here. They must be aired in
public before the magistrates at once, yes, and the police must be ready
with their case, pronto, pronto."

Mr. Ricardo, who was prepared like any true-blue to enter the lists for
habeas corpus, regarded his friend's lament as a tribute rather than as a
challenge, and the car drove on through the woods of Hartley Wintney
whilst the shadows were folded away. It was broad daylight when they
dropped down the hill to Cobham and swept up the left-hand turn on to the
open Fairmile. Gorse and heather and the straight white road running
through, and not a soul to be seen. At least, so it seemed.

There was no one visible ahead. Monsieur Hanaud, who was sitting opposite
to Mr. Ricardo with his back to the bonnet, asked suddenly: "You permit?"

Without waiting for an answer, he turned and rapped upon the glass panel
and within a few yards the car stopped. Hanaud turned towards Rosalind.

"Mrs. Leete, I beg you to answer me a question."

"If I can."

"Of whom was Miss Agatha enamoured?"

Rosalind listened. She was amazed, then she intrigued, then she was
wildly amused. She broke a laugh.

"Agatha! Oh, poor Agatha!"

There was no malice, no scorn in the laughter. It was sufficiently
affectionate to persuade her audience that would have wished a lover on
Agatha if she could.

"Of no one, then?"

Rosalind took the question seriously. Her thoughts ran back to olden
days. She shook her head.

"It's six years since I ran out. There was no one then. No one was ever
expected by the rest of us. Perhaps we made it obvious--you know how cruel
women can be without meaning it--and she--"

Hanaud, who was listening in an excitement which no other in the car
understood, broke in:

"So that was it, perhaps. She was told too often that she was the
spinster, that there was no man for her, and she invented one. Oh, it is
no new thing."

Rosalind, however, would not accept the calumny.

"She was religious. No! If there were a love story, even if it were only
a dream of a love story, it would have a real live person for its hero.
And I think," Rosalind added, looking out of the window, "such an
apparition would have so astonished her--at the beginning, at all
events--that she must have had very good reasons for believing in his


This fantastic story of the coffin and the locked drawer began to slide
out of a grim fairyland into the land fact. "Then Miss Agatha is rich?"

"One might call her so. She was the first child. My mother left her what
she had, shares in the Dagger Line, when they were worth very little and
they are now worth a good deal."

"Rich in her own right?"


"To be signed away over her own hand?"

"If she so chose."

And the coffin slid out stark before Hanaud's eyes. The outrageous
improbability became solid. Someone in desperate need of money had
advanced, had pretended, had prolonged the pretences in the hope of
eventual escape, had inspired a passion, had betrayed in what bower his
hopes really had their home. Hanaud raised his hands and let them fall
rather helplessly. If only he knew what had happened between the holly
wall and the turnpike road on that night of ending August!

"If there has been anything, it began after I had gone away," said

Hanaud smiled gratefully.

"You have told me, not for the first time, more than you think to have
told me. I should have asked you this question before."

"Why?" she asked bluntly.

"Because, if I had waited for another five minutes, I should not have had
the chance ever to ask it of you at all."

To the surprise of everyone, he tapped again upon the glass, and, sliding
it to one side, gave an order to the chauffeur.

"Back the car slowly with the least fussiness possible, until I tap. Then

The chauffeur looked behind him. No car was approaching. No one stirred
at all in all that wide expanse of heath and road and sky except one old
man resting upon a bench at the edge of the common above the road, with
his hands to his face and his elbows propped upon his knees.

The car slid gently past him below, but he took no notice of it. It
seemed at first that he was in an abstraction, staring at the ground with
his temples between his fingers. Hanaud tapped gently on the glass and
the car stopped without a sound. It was seen then that the tips of the
old man's fingers were working.

Hanaud leaned forward and noiselessly opened the door of the car at the
side of the bank.

"Madame Leete," he said, "there is your father. I saw him as our car


THE man on the bench certainly did not recognise the voice and it is
doubtful if he heard the words He was occupied. On the ground between his
feet were a small pile of strips of sticking-plaster; and now and again
his fingers added to it from his brows and the sockets of his eyes.
"Father," Rosalind repeated; but the old man was not ready, and the small
group stood about him and waited. It was curious to Mr. Ricardo, rather
horrible to Rosalind, and quite comprehensible to Hanaud that this
sticking-plaster covered no wound; the skin below it was patched and
discoloured, but there was no mark of a knife or a blow; and one of
these patches, crossing the lips diagonally from a nostril to the chin,
showed to what purpose the plaster had been put. His eyes had been hooded
and his mouth had been gagged.

He lifted his head and became aware of the group about him. He looked at
Ricardo and at Hanaud and at Rosalind, and then sat back and drew in some
great breaths of air. Then he looked again at Rosalind, and suddenly
barked out with a resentful note in his voice: "Rosalind, eh?"

Then he laughed as she shrank a foot or so away from him. "There, my
girl, I'm not barking at you for leaving the ship, but for seeing me in
this humiliating condition when you come back."

He held out a hand to her, and with the help of his other hand and the
back of the seat he managed to struggle to his feet. He looked at Hanaud
and then at Ricardo, balancing himself with difficulty. There was very
little in him of the Septimus Crottle whom they could remember. He was
shrunken now and a good decade had been added to his years. But the very
spirit of the man had gone. They could see it by the way he clung to his
daughter's arm for protection--he, the patriarch!

"Mordaunt sent you--Mordaunt, who thought--what was his word?--that I had no
inhibitions, that I was free of the terrors, of the weaknesses, of the
degradations under which other men fall--!" and his voice rose in a
scream suddenly, as a car rose up above the hill at Cobham and raced
forward towards the group. He sank down upon the bench behind them. But
the car went past without slackening. There were people in it, men and
women laughing and talking. Septimus watched it between the bodies of his
friends, at first only with his eyes, then with a trembling finger until
it disappeared in the dust, and then until the dust itself had cleared

"All my life I have had that fear," he went on, communing with himself
rather than talking to his companions, "of being shut away in a silent

"Like the Dauphin of France," Hanaud exclaimed suddenly.

"A small dark place, where no one came, where one spoke, whence you
couldn't escape," he continue "until--until you died all by yourself. All
my life had been afraid of it. That's why I liked the bridge of my ship. The
wide air and the stars in front of me. I tried to laugh the fear out of
me--to bully it out of me--and then it happened."

"How?" asked Hanaud, and Septimus Crottle drew back. He tried to throw a
great deal of surprise and scorn into his looks.

"What! Don't you know? You and your friend Maltby? The police?" and then,
in a panic of shame and fear: "Strange that I should remember names, but
of what happened to me that night--nothing."

To Mr. Ricardo it occurred that there was a question still more important
to be answered. How did the old boy come to find himself alone on the
Fairmile in the early morning with his face visored and latticed with
sticking plaster? And, arising out of the answer to that question,
whatever it might be, was it wise for them all to be standing in plain
view on the high footpath above the road?

He suggested that Mr. Crottle might find the cushions of his car more
comfortable than the hard rails of the park seat by the roadside. But
Crottle was suspicious on the instant. He looked at the great car, at the
white empty road, at Mr. Ricardo.

"How do I know?" he asked, and his head twisted from side to side.

"You can trust me, sir, in any case," declared Hanaud And Mr. Ricardo
reflected how seldom Hanaud seemed to be important when he most cried
himself up to be and how remarkably dominant and inspiring he could grow
when he was not thinking of himself at all. Yesterday in Paris, he had
been an expert speaking out of his knowledge and of the wisdom which
knowledge had brought. To-day it was Hernani, and not a very good Hernani

Mr. Ricardo's suggestion was obviously reasonable, and the whole party
moved to the car. But, even in those few moments, it became still more
noticeable how his experience had crippled Septimus, how swift and
complete his disintegration had been. He walked irresolutely with his
shoulders bowed and eyes which, despite his will, searched at every
rustle for an enemy. Even in the car he must sit with his hand upon the
lock of the door and the long stretch of road visible ahead of him and
the driver's mirror well within his vision.

"We will go forward slowly?" Hanaud asked.

And suddenly, with a flash of cunning, Septimus replied with another
question: "Where to?"

Hanaud nodded with some satisfaction. He had his own answer to that
question and wanted no conflict with Septimus over it.

"Let us see!"

He made a sign to Mr. Ricardo and, as the car moved on towards London,
Septimus Crottle was questioned as to what he remembered of his

"I left the office--it's almost at the corner of Parliament Street--at six,
as I usually did. There was a thick fog, turning brown, and night coming
on. It seemed to me the moment to shorten speed, eh? I've crept across
the Bay in my young days in that sort of weather. There was a street
light opposite to Downing Street. I remember crossing there. There was a
policeman standing just under the light."

"There was," Hanaud agreed.

"I crossed, walked through Downing Street, descended the steps at the
end, and passed the Memorial to the Guards opposite to the Parade--"

At that point Septimus Crottle came to an abrupt stop.

"Well?" Hanaud asked, and, shaking his head, Crottle answered in a sullen
voice: "I remember not one thing more. The Guards Memorial, yes. I
crossed the road, wondering whether I was going to be run down by a car.
I crossed quickly and I almost ran into the stone of the Memorial. But I
didn't. No, I didn't. But I don't remember one thing more until--" and the
old man began to shake. A few little cries, they were less cries than the
sobs of child lost in some jungle of horrors, broke from him and grew in
loudness. His hand fidgeted with the handle of the door. He looked about
him as a man looks, caught by his enemies. He whimpered.

"We shall leave it there," Monsieur Hanaud cried cheerfully, "until we
collect the admirable Maltby," and a shadow of a smile brightened
Septimus Crottle's face. "If my case is in his hands,--" he cried.

"But it is, Mr. Crottle," said Hanaud. "We have talked together, he in
the Scotch Yard and I in Paris, over the vanishment of monsieur and of
something else which I, the obstinate, congregate with it."

Septimus looked up curiously and bowed.

"But there is now a little thing, is there not?" and he made his two
fingers run along the arm of the seat and spring into the air. Hanaud was
nervous, Ricardo decided. Now, why? There was a problem, or--to adopt the
humorous slang which Mr. Ricardo thought it modern to approve--or was
there? But he was nervous. Yes. Once more the fingers ran daintily along
the arm at his side and sprang into the air.

"Yes, there is a small--"

"Don't do that, please," cried Septimus, watching the two nimble fingers.
"It confuses me. What do you mean by it? Do it again and I'll jump into
the road." The old man, suspicious of this unusual if harmless manoeuvre,
was watching Hanaud alertly, one hand upon the lock of the door.

"It's all right, father," said Rosalind, and she turned apologetically to
Hanaud. "I expect that any new movement disturbs him."

"Yes. Certainly any movement so typically French," added Mr. Ricardo
sternly but with a warm inward satisfaction.

"Yes, it was French," Rosalind confirmed. She was eager to make
discomfort comfortable for her good friend of the Sureté. She had no
reason to realise that if there was one point outside his profession upon
which Hanaud prided himself, it was his anomalous internationalism. It
was just the Frenchiness of the gesture which worried him.

Mr. Ricardo hugged himself with pleasure, and who shall grudge it to him?
Hanaud's ears would burn. So English wasn't he? "Mon pied!" Mr. Ricardo
exclaimed silently--and aloud: "It'll be all right when we get hold of

"Ah, yes, Maltby," Mr. Crottle repeated happily.

Mr. Ricardo nodded towards Hanaud.

"We will drive straight to the Yard. Maltby will not dance his fingers
along the arm of the seat. At the Yard--" and a blank determined negative
came explosively from the most unexpected quarter:


It was Septimus who uttered the word. He was looking from one to the
other with just that bright flash of cunning in his eyes which they had
all noticed before when he was sitting on the garden seat.

"Maltby, yes--with Monsieur Hanaud, to whose kindness I am deep in debt,"
Crottle continued, "but privately. It is the full morning now. If we
drive into Scotland Yard we may be seen. There will be many on the

"At home, then!" cried Rosalind, but still Septimus shook his head. "I
have servants. I have three daughters--besides you, Rosalind. Within an
hour the evening correspondents would be knocking at the door. It is not
known that I have come back. I shall go to a nursing home where no
inquiries would be answered."

With an "Ouf!" Monsieur Hanaud showed them as radiant a face as a man of
his sallow complexion could. "The nursing home, it is good. But better
still is the house of my good friend Mr. Ricardo."

There was a pause. Mr. Ricardo was not quite sure that he welcomed this
interruption of his routine. Also, if the invitation had to be offered,
he would, on the whole, have preferred to offer it himself. But Hanaud
rushed on. There was an entrance through the Mews at the back of the
house. Also, since it would quickly be seen that he, Hanaud of the Sureté
was visiting once more his old friend, it would be natural for the good
Maltby to call. As for visitors, Thompson, the invaluable, would reject
them, and no doubt Maltby would lend a fine young fellow who could fit
himself into one of Mr.Ricardo's liveries. There were many spare rooms in
the corner house. No one would be so pleased as Mr.Ricardo to help in
this affair.

Mr. Ricardo could do nothing but agree. He certainly did object to the
lack of ceremony in the requisition of his house and perhaps still more
to the trifle of malice in Hanaud's smile. If Maltby was necessary before
the necessity for silence could be explained, so, too, was Mr. Ricardo's
fine house in Grosvenor Square.

"Ah, ah, you make fun of your poor Hanaud. Well, well!" Hanaud exclaimed
gaily. "After all, we are twins."

"Personally, I should prefer to say 'quits,'" Mr. Ricardo replied acidly.

Thus, in any case, it was decided. Septimus was smuggled unnoticed
through the Mews at the back of Ricardo's house and the car was driven on
to Waterloo Station with Rosalind and Hanaud.

"I take you out of your way," Rosalind protested, but Hanaud shook his
head and got in beside her.

"We must be sure that the appearance of papa has not altered the story to
be told," he argued. "You are to say that Mordaunt saw Bryan Devisher in
the street of Abdul Azziz and drank a bottle of beer with him?"


"That Devisher said that he had presented Mordaunt's letter of
introduction to Septimus and that Septimus had appointed him to a
position in the Cairo office of the Dagger Line."


"That Mordaunt had written to Septimus to thank him for his kindness."


Hanaud nodded his head.

"And that Devisher was really concerned with a nation's policy to rot the
Egyptian people with drugs."

Hanaud swung round to the girl. He frowned, he pursed his lips.

"You would say that?" he asked. "Because a match is struck in a street?"

Rosalind was astonished. He had listened to her in Paris without seeming
to doubt a word of the story she told.

"Would it be fair to say the match was struck because heroin had come to
Elaoui?" He was drumming on his knees, troubled by a doubt whether he was
fair to a possible enemy. Rosalind found it a little difficult to
identify Hanaud with this extremely scrupulous officer.

"You think that I should forget that circumstance?" she cried.

"Ah, circumstance--yes, the convenient word. But suppose the true word is
coincidence. Then you tell your story and this poor man--ouf!"

Rosalind glanced at him again. She said firmly: "I will not mention the
match-box, nor Elaoui, nor Philip's idea at all."

Monsieur Hanaud's relief was curiously great. It was all very well to wish
to be fair, but to wish for it much, as first his anxiety and now his
relief established, Rosalind did not believe. She was not, however, give
time to debate the question in her thoughts. Hanaud chattered to her
about her sisters until they reached the station. They had to discover a
train from Southampton which would fit in with her arrival in a taxi at
Portman Square. They were fortunate there, for a train was due in ten

"Shall I say you crossed with me, Monsieur Hanaud?" she asked as he stood
by the door of the taxi.

He shook his head. "No, madame. You can, I am sure, find a friend whom
you wished to seize the opportunity to visit. Better still, you went to
the Paris office of your Line to find out whether they had news of him.
So you missed the boat-train."

He stood back and drew a long breath of relief as Rosalind's cab drove
off. He sent Mr. Ricardo's Rolls-Royce back to Grosvenor Square and took
another to Scotland Yard. He took a hurried luncheon with Maltby at a
little restaurant in Soho, and at half-past two he looked, at his watch.

"Septimus Crottle has something to tell us," he said.

"Let us go," said Maltby; and, finding a taxi at the door--in those days
such miracles happened--they drove to the corner house in Grosvenor


INDEED Septimus had something to tell. He sat in an arm-chair in a big
room overlooking the Square and overlooked by none. He was bathed,
shaven, dressed in clean linen borrowed from Ricardo, with a dark-blue
dressing-gown over all. But, the marks of terror were still engraved upon
his face and his eyes were the eyes, unmistakably explicit, of one who
has passed through the shadows of death. They tell no story, they deny
that they have a story to tell, but they inspire the prayer, "God forbid
that I should suffer as this man has!" And he was years older, shrunken
in his spirit and his courage as much as in his frame. He was like, too,
some sharp and watchful animal of the forests and the heath. The simplest
little unexpected sound set him quivering and, still worse, cringing, as
if there were no end to the new horrors which stood darkly about him.
That this man had ever commanded a great ship through gales and reefs,
across the wide oceans of the world, and brought his cargoes and his
passengers safe to far ports, seemed to the most unimaginative of his
visitors beyond credulity itself to believe.

Happily Mr. Ricardo had an inspiration from a kindly heart. He came into,
the room with Maltby and Hanaud at his heels, carrying a box of Havana
cigars. It was all very well for Septimus to tell the world that his
cigars were the best, but they were no better than Ricardo's. And, as he
held out the box, Ricardo said: "I thought that you might like to lunch
alone, Mr. Crottle, after these stormy times, but these I hope you will
enjoy in company."

The old man's face lit up with the cigar. Mr. Ricardo could have done
nothing more wise. The smoke curling upwards, the fragrance which comes
from nowhere but Havana, with all its associations of ease and
pleasurable moments, brought comfort and a smile to Septimus Crottle.

"I thank you," he said warmly to Ricardo, and Hanaud, must add his

"He has the tact, my friend Ricardo. Not from the books of the deportment
writers. No, no, he has it here," and he laid his hand admiringly upon
his heart.

Septimus, however, was finding his recollection crystallise more easily
into speech, now that he had cigar between his lips.

"When I became conscious, my eyes were covered," he said with a shiver of
disgust. "I was aware we were in a car--a man--I think--I can't be sure, but
I doubt if my instincts would lead me astray--a man of the sea and a
woman." He was silent for a little while, and went on choosing rather
meticulously his words. "Afterwards--I can't say more than that now at
events--there was I with the nightmare of a life discovered and made
true--oh, yes, discovered! When the nightmare began, I can't remember, for
I've always remembered the nightmare,"--he shut his eyes and shivered,
looking back over years of watchfulness and years of imagined horror.

"To be confronted with it, eh?" he looked at Hanaud and from Hanaud to
Ricardo, perhaps with some vague idea that they, who had been present
when his voice had broken over the dreadful history of the young Dauphin,
would picture to themselves with what detail that history had been staged

"They had a lanthorn, which they set upon a white deal table. They
emptied my pockets. They took everything from me except two things.
This," he took out of his waistcoat pocket a small thin diary with a
single thin pencil in a sheath. "They were very jocose about it. It would
pass the time for me to read in the daylight by the chinks of the
shutters the engagements I was going to keep. Oh, very jocose they were,
and unwise. And the second thing was this. They were funny about this,

The second thing was an old battered silver watch with an old strap and
buckle, which he took from his watch-pocket. It was as big as a turnip,
thick and round, and indeed, to modern eyes, looked comical enough. But
Septimus Crottle handled it as fondly as if it had been a jewel fashioned
by Cellini.

"I bought that when I was an apprentice in a clipper. Very funny they
were about that, too. What a fortunate thing it was for me that, when I
wanted to know the time, I shouldn't have to ask a policeman! Very funny,
and still more unwise." He looked at the clock. "Listen," he said.

The hands made the hour to be three and the silence was broken by three
faint little silvery chimes from Crottle's watch.

"A repeater!" exclaimed Ricardo.

"A repeater. They didn't know. It was just a piece of luggage. They left
it with me and slammed the door and locked it. I was in the dark with the
watch in my hand and, as I stood there, I heard above the roof of the
house the drone of an aeroplane, the throb and pulse of its engines, the
rush overhead and the swift decline to silence. Even at that moment it
was pleasant, companionable, a promise. I asked my watch the time. It was

The next morning, by a ray of light, a golden ray on which the sun danced
like Blondin on his tight-rope into the black room, Septimus had ticked
off in his diary the day, October the eighth, on which he had been taken,
and this new day which had come. That night, too, the friendly aeroplane
roared at midnight a friendly "Here I am," and was gone. Septimus Crottle
could test his watch by its passage. There was a water-tap and a basin
and a bucket and a straw mattress in his shuttered room besides the deal
table. At times--and with difficulty he blurted out a word here and
there--he must stand silent with his face to the wall, whilst the room was
cleaned and his food brought in. But no one spoke and, like all
prisoners, he began to live little things, and, above all, for the
moments when could tick off the day in his diary and when the aeroplane
announced from afar its approach, thundered overhead and died away.

"In a little while I was able to expect it," he said, "sitting in the
dark. Then I would hear it and press the spring of the repeater. It was
punctual like a postman, sometimes on the tick of twelve, sometimes few
seconds later. I think that waiting for the noise it kept me alive all
through that first week. And the one night it didn't come at all."

To each one of his auditors, so completely were the held by the sombre
fire of his eyes and the simplicity his tale, the sudden drop of his
voice to a whisper brought the same shock of catastrophe which the
absence of the aeroplane had brought to him.

"Even later on...?" Hanaud began in a hush.

"That night it never passed overhead at all."

"You are sure?"

"I lay awake until the morning was a grey mist in the room."

"And what morning was this?" cried Maltby with curious violence.

Old Septimus opened his diary.

"The fourteenth of October. Look! I put a ring about the line which
marked the day. For it looked as if I had lost my only friend."

Maltby almost snatched the diary from his hand.

"Yes, the fourteenth. But you heard it the next night?"

Septimus came to life again. There was a smile upon his face, a kind of
lilt in his voice.

"Yes, I heard it the next night. And every night of the six nights which
followed. I heard it even yesterday."

But Maltby had not waited to hear the end of that sentence. He was out of
the room. They heard his feet running down the stairs to the hall; and a
moment afterwards his voice upon the telephone.

But they distinguished none of the words; and now that Septimus had come
to the end of his narrative, the fatigue of his adventure was upon him
and his head nodding on his shoulders. A bedroom, however, had been
prepared for him and Mr. Ricardo's housekeeper, a matron and such as one
could count upon in that household, was at the door.

"A nice sleep, a nice dinner in bed..."

"And another nice cigar after the dinner," said Crottle with a grin at

"And the gentleman will be himself again," observed Mrs. Ffennell, the
housekeeper, "if he isn't that already."

But there was still some knowledge for which Hanaud could not endure to
wait until the next morning.

"Before you go, sir," he exclaimed, throwing himself in front of Septimus
and his hands flapping signals of distress to Ricardo.

"Let us finish with it. You are wondering how you came to find me on a
bench half-way along the Fairmile?"

"But exactly," cried Hanaud.

"Well, I can't tell you. All I know is that these people, the man and the
woman, talked late. I heard their voices through the floorboards. Then I
heard the motor-car being brought from somewhere. I used my watch. It was
three in the morning. They came up the stairs almost immediately
afterwards with the lanthorn. But I was not able to see much, as you
know," and now there was more anger than horror at the indignities which
he had suffered. "I was no match for them, even if I had possessed my
usual strength. I got up and dressed, whilst they hurried me."

He stopped for a moment whilst he straightened out his recollections.

"Yes. They were frightened. It gave me a sudden shock of pleasure," and
Crottle's face cracked with grin more blissful than any which Hanaud
could remember. "Their hands shook. They spoke too quickly to be
understood, as if the hangman were at their heels."

Again the old man's voice dropped to a whisper. "When I could see
nothing, nor speak, they were busy with the room. There were nails torn
out of the shutters and the shutters folded back. The mattress was
pulled out of the room. It all took a few minutes I think the room was
dismantled Then I was taken down to the car. They spoke in whispers. We
drove off quietly and slowly. Then we drove faster and for hours. But
whether we went backwards and forwards, or straight, is more than I can
tell. They turned me out about seven o'clock--a little later perhaps."

He stood for a moment. Mr. Ricardo was looking at his diary. Summer time
would end in a couple of days now. The dawn would just be showing when
Septimus Crottle was pushed out of the car at the edge of the common.

"Yes, we passed about eight," Mr. Ricardo declared but Hanaud did not

"That's all I have to tell you," said the old man.

Mr. Ricardo sprang to his feet and went with him to the door. There Mrs.
Ffennell, the housekeeper, and Thompson awaited him and led him to his

"That was interesting," said Mr. Ricardo as he came back into the room.
He saw Hanaud still seated in his chair, his face troubled and perplexed.

"Yes," he continued, "a terrible story. Did you follow Crottle's
reactions? Now that old fear was at the top of his mind, now the
mishandling, the affront to his dignity."

Mr. Ricardo was excited. He was living great deep moments. He took a
glance at the window. Outside, in the Square, men and women were going
about their ordinary business, unaware of all that was happening up here
just above their heads. An old man telling a story of cruelty, and Hanaud
and Maltby and himself launched out to catch the criminals.

"A strange, grim story, my friend," he cried with pride. He almost added,
"Find its equal in France, if you can!"

But, before he could utter so outrageous a boast, Hanaud quietly

"Do you know what I find most curious? They were frightened. The man and
the woman. In the middle of the night they must take the old fellow away,
dump him somewhere along an empty road and fly off. They were frightened.
Why? No one challenged them. Why?"

He was still pondering this question when the door was flung open. Maltby
came back into the room and his face was alight.

"Mr. Crottle?" he asked.

"He has gone to bed."

"Good. There will be a plain-clothes officer in the house to-night. He
will run no danger."

Hanaud looked up at him.

"You have news?"

Maltby nodded his head. Mr. Ricardo could have shaken him. He had no
vivacity, no emotions? But at last Maltby spoke.

"The Western Air Company flies a nightly service from Heston. It stops at
Taunton, Exeter and Plymouth. It leaves Heston at eleven. On the night of
the fourteenth of October the engine failed a quarter of an hour after it
had taken off. It was able to return to Heston. There was no service to
Plymouth that night."


THERE were not many travelling by the Airway on that night, and the three
men at the back of the car could talk and watch without interruption. Two
nights had passed since the moon was full, but the black curtain was
rolled back from the sky now, and more and more clearly the tranquil
countryside reached out below, great trees and their shadows on fields of
silver-grey, long rounded ridges of turf and rock which sprang high and
broke off, rivers like glistening highways. And now and then they sank
low enough to imagine that by holding their breath they could hear the
lowing of cows.

"We could hear of no other service which missed a beat, as you might say,
on the night of Thursday, October the fourteenth," Maltby declared in
answer to a question from Hanaud.

"Ten minutes now," said Mr. Ricardo looking at his watch, and Hanaud
fetched out of his pocket the clumsy silver chronometer of Septimus
Crottle. He laid it face upwards on the table between them, and all three
bent their heads over the white face.

"Twelve minutes, by the old man's repeater," said Hanaud.

Mr. Ricardo was regarding his friend with awe. He looked round
suspiciously. There were three naval officers on their way to Plymouth, a
journalist bound for Exeter, and a couple of holiday folk for Cornwall.
But they were all to the front of the car. He turned hack to Hanaud.

"I should never have thought of that," he said, reproaching himself, "if
I lived till I was a hundred. You actually borrowed the watch from Mr.

Hanaud shook his head.

"I took it when he wasn't looking."

Whether borrowed or taken, the watch was an advantage. It gave them an
absolute precision for their arrangements.

"If you, Monsieur Hanaud, will watch on this side of the plane, Mr.
Ricardo and I will look after the other."

Maltby moved across the aisle and drew back the curtain. Ricardo placed
himself in the seat in front and both stared down through the moonlit
air. The aeroplane was travelling along a big whale-backed ridge like one
of the Berkshire Downs. Here and there the smooth turf was broken by a
black outcrop of rock; here and there in a scoop of the sides there grew
a little spinney of larches. Below and along the three men watched with a
concentration which spread through the car and provoked the curiosity of
the other travellers, so that their conversation ceased and they, too,
began to look downwards, but for what they did not know.

On the table in front of Hanaud the monstrous watch of Septimus ticked,
it seemed to Ricardo, louder and louder with each second. He saw now,
beside the surface of the down below him, flat meadows to his right, with
cut ditches in which water gleamed, and a long way forward and to his
right a sprinkling of lights which betokened a town. Bitter thoughts came
into his mind "We are on the wrong airline. There will be another
company running a different service. Perhaps, if Maltby hadn't booked us
as ordinary passengers! In front there, in the pilot's cabin, a man would
see more clearly." Why was it so important to hide their movements?
Secrecy--hush, hush--there could be too much of it.

Mr. Ricardo was beginning to boil with exasperation, when suddenly
Hanaud's finger closed upon a spring and the clear, yet tiny chimes,
chimes of the little people, tinkled with a strange incongruity through
that most modern of carrier wagons.

"We shall miss it," Ricardo cried, and even as he cried he saw it, just
ahead, just before the down broke off abruptly in the plain. It stood in
the open upon a slope of ground, with a break like a quarry in the side
of the down behind it, a farm-house without a light in any window, and
not another house visible its neighbourhood. Ricardo turned excitedly
towards the Superintendent. "Do you see? Do you see?" he asked in a
whisper, and the rudder of the aeroplane gave a wriggle. The machine was
turning, so that it would move straight over the house towards the
grouped lights of the city. In a second Hanaud would see it upon his
side. Mr. Ricardo rushed across the cabin. Hanaud was sitting with his
face at the window and his hands curved about it to shut out the light
above and behind him.

"Look! Look!"; and the aeroplane swung clear of the down and swept across
the fields and dykes of Sedgemoor to the airport on the edge of the city.

"Did you see?" asked Ricardo.

Hanaud picked up the watch and tucked it away in his pocket, a little
embarrassed by his friend's excitement. But Maltby cleared the air with a
most unveracious story.

"The house was probably not that house, but one of an earlier date. But
certainly Monmouth was taken there. His men had broken before Colonel
Kirke's pikes on this flat land. Monmouth, I think, was found under a
truss of straw in one of the outbuildings."

Maltby noticed the other passengers turning away with a smile from these
historical enthusiasts, and the aeroplane took the ground.

As they dismounted a big man in a blue suit advanced towards them.
"Superintendent Maltby? My name's Lance. Inspector Lance."

The two men shook hands.

"There are rooms for your party engaged at the hotel," said Lance, "and I
would rather talk there."

A car was waiting, and a few minutes afterwards Inspector Lance, in a
comfortable sitting-room warmed by a bright fire, with a hot grog at his
elbow, was administering, not without a certain pleasure, the coldest of
cold douches to his colleague from the Metropolis.

"I am afraid that you have wasted your time, Superintendent. If I had
only known before," and he sighed as he looked into the coals.

"You couldn't, because we didn't," Maltby answered.

"Yesterday, for instance," said Lance slowly.

Maltby smiled.

"If we had known yesterday, I should have been able to give you a much
more complete account of how much we needed your help than I could over
the telephone this afternoon."

Inspector Lance admitted by implication to have had his plumage a trifle

"The call sounded a little abrupt." Nobody could be humbler than Maltby
when something was to be gained by humility.

"It must have," he agreed remorsefully. But there had been no time for
the courtesies. He had only just that moment learnt what air service
failed on the night of October 14th. "But perhaps now you will, over
another glass of this excellent whisky, allow me to tell you a little
more particularly of our need."

He rang the bell, and on the appearance of the Boots--for it was then half
an hour after midnight--said "Repeat!"

The Boots looked at Hanaud, and, whether he was naturally sympathetic or
just wished to spare him an unnecessary journey up and down the stairs,
pointed out: "The foreign gentleman has drunk nothing."

"I want nothing," Hanaud snapped. As if he couldn't pass for an idiomatic
Englishman anywhere!

Maltby was suddenly afraid that here again the proper courtesies had been

"This is Monsieur Hanaud of the Sureté in Paris," he said, addressing the
whole room. He tried to gather a few bouquets from his recollections, but
once again the notice was too short, "of whose activities you will not
need me to remind you."

It was not very good, no, and Hanaud was justly annoyed.

"You will not join us, monsieur?" asked Lance, and Ricardo seized the
moment gleefully.

"Hanaud is partial to a peppermint frappé, which he is unlikely to get at
this hour of the night in the west of England. So perhaps a glass of
Porto or a cup of coffee?

"Ah! Coffee!" cried Hanaud, and the Boots went away upon his errand.

Meanwhile Maltby filled in those details of the history of Septimus
Crottle which he had not had the time to give over the telephone. When he
had finished, Inspector Lance threw his hands up in the air.

"The luck of the thing! Of all the unchancy businesses," and he swung
round, now thoroughly mollified, to his companions.

"Arkwright's. That's the name of the place. A farm once, and not so bad.
But the owner, old Mrs. Destries over to Bridgewater, sold off most of
the land, and the house stood there unlet for a long time."

In the end a man, Frank Barnish, with his wife, had hired it. It had a
few acres of grazing land, which they let, and made do with a vegetable
plot, a small orchard, a couple of pigs and some chickens. He had been a
sailor, it seemed, but they made no friends; he, a hulking big fellow,
cantankerous and sullen, and she a good match for him. They gave no
trouble but, nobody liked them; they never fitted in. They were just
solitary people in a solitary place. They had some money of late weeks,
and had bought somewhere in London an old motor-car.

"A battered old blue thing to look at," said Lance. "But once I saw her
coming into the town, and she could go."

He looked straight at Maltby and added: "So it's just your bad luck,

Maltby was tired by now of vague assertions that his luck was out. He
answered shortly: "What is?"

"That you didn't come yesterday."

"They have gone?"

Inspector Lance nodded. He got up and offered a cigarette to Maltby,
began to offer one to Monsieur Hanaud, but, seeing what he was smoking,
fell back aghast, and was offered and accepted a cigar for himself by

"Yes. Upon receipt of your message--sounds like old days, doesn't it,
Superintendent?--in accordance with instructions, I proceeded, etcetera,

"The people who put through the message to you from the Yard don't seem
to have used very much tact, I am afraid," Maltby replied dryly.

"Oh, that's all right. Urgency and good manners have different patterns,"
said Lance. He conveyed to everyone in the room a pleasant sense of
enjoyment. Here were two important officials from London and Paris and a
tertium quid all of a flutter, who had flown down to teach the West
Country yokels their business, whereas if they had only talked with
reasonable clarity over the telephone...

"You see, we sent out a police-officer upon the receipt of your message
to keep an eye upon Arkwright's, and he reported that there was no one

"When was that, Inspector?"

"About seven o'clock."

"And where did he report from?"


The Barnishes had a telephone in a living-room which they never used,
except perhaps for telephoning. The police-officer had found the door on
the latch and not an answer to a cry.

"I told him to hold on and I would send him another man to keep him
company. Empty houses at night are creepy things. We shall find the two
men there in the morning. There's obviously nothing more that we can do
until then."

Inspector Lance picked up his hat and threw the stump of his cigar into
the fireplace.

"No, indeed," said Hanaud, at his sweetest, "and should ever fortune send
you on the air to Paris, may I do no less for you!"

Inspector Lance looked a trifle doubtfully at Hanaud, as though he were
not quite sure how to interpret that sentence. He bowed, however, and
remarked: "I hope that you'll all be comfortable."

He was just opening the door when he came to a halt. He clicked his tongue
several times against his palate in annoyance, shut the door, and marched
back into the centre of the room.

"It is by our mistake, perhaps, that the Barnishes have escaped you. I
hope not. We had our local duty to do, and no word from you earlier, I
think, than four."

Hanaud leaned forward. What little pellet of discomfort was the Inspector
now going to discharge upon them? One fairly potent in aroma, Hanaud
gathered from the slow-savouring smile of penitence which waited upon his

"We knew nothing until then," Maltby declared. "We telephoned as soon as
we knew."

"Yes, but what a pity! You see, a farmer who grazes his sheep on the down
at the back of Arkwright's sent in the morning before a shepherd to
complain of a dog which had killed some of his ewes. The man thought that
the dog was an Irish wolf-hound. Well, you gentlemen of the Yard will
know that an Irish wolf-hound's like a German. He can't be cured. So,
naturally, we got to work and, naturally, Arkwright's was the first


Hanaud jumped from his chair.

"Arkwright's was the nearest house. Also, Barnish was a morose,
unfriendly man. It might, perhaps, give him a sullen sort of pleasure to
injure a neighbour, especially with some cruelty added. Moreover, if he
had a dog, he hadn't something else which went with it--a dog licence."

"And when did you send your officer?" Hanaud asked.

"Let me see. The shepherd reached us about twelve. We sent Cox out--yes--as
soon as he had had his dinner. He went off upon his bicycle at two
o'clock or thereabouts."

"Yesterday?" said Maltby.

"Well--conveniently but incorrectly," Inspector Lax replied, and he looked
at the clock on the mantel "It's getting on towards two o'clock in the
morning--yes, we'll call it yesterday. Cox bicycled out to Arwright's at
two o'clock on the afternoon of Tuesday."

"Tuesday," said Mr. Ricardo with approval. He did not mean to be a cipher
in these agreements and explanations, even though, whenever he did put in
his everybody else turned and stared at him as though had only at that
moment materialised in the room. "Tuesday afternoon at two."

"Barnish was at home," Lance continued. "It's a curious old house,
shingle and bricks and little windows. There's an archway through to the
yard at the back and the front door, as you might say, is on the
right-hand side under the arch."

"Then Cox got off his bicycle," Mr. Ricardo suggested, to help a rather
lame story on to its climax, and met the thoughtful glance of the

"Ah, now, did he?" the Inspector asked. "Did he get off his bicycle? Or
did he just stop at the door, like, with one foot on the ground and the
other on the pedal? We'll have to consider of that. It didn't occur to
any of us that you gentlemen would think the point important."

There was only one action for Mr. Ricardo to take, and he took it. Hadn't
the Duke of Wellington once gone on his knees to a ridiculous Spanish
General had felt himself insulted? "The matter being important--down I
plumped," wrote the Duke and, fortified with that example, Mr. Ricardo

"I won't interrupt again. I apologise, Inspector, on my knees," he said

Inspector Lance was mollified.

"He did get off, I think, for as he was propping his bicycle against the
wall, the house door being a bit open, he heard a chair flung back and a
dish clattering on the floor, as if the Barnishes had been fairly
startled, and in a second Barnish was blocking the doorway, with a face
like thunder. He began with a quarrelsome, 'What do you want?' and then
saw Cox's uniform. Cox said he turned quite sickish in colour, but looked
better when he was asked whether he had an Irish wolf-hound or any sort
of dog."

Barnish said that he had none, and stood in the doorway as if that ended
the matter. But Cox was pertinacious and said that he would go in and
have a look round. For a moment it seemed that Barnish would hinder him,
as, of course, he had a right to do, but he stood aside at last.

"'All right,' he said. 'But you people in your uniforms, you upset women,
you know.'"

And certainly when Cox pushed his way into the kitchen he saw a very
frightened woman. But there was no dog, though he looked into the cellar
to find him. Cox did not go upstairs. First, because the stairs weren't
visible from the kitchen. They were behind a door at the end of a
corridor. Second, if the animal were locked up anywhere, it would be in
the outbuildings. Cox searched the outbuildings beyond the arch, with
Barnish and his wife treading upon his heels, and it had none of the
pleasure of a treasure-hunt. He was very glad to make sure that there was
no dog upon the premises, get upon his bicycle again--this last the
Inspector underlined with a formal little bow to Mr. Ricardo--and report
to headquarters.

"Cox wasn't comfortable about his visit to Arkwright's," Lance continued.
"There was something about the two Barnishes which he didn't understand.
something which gave him gooseflesh, he said, and Cox isn't the man to
get queer fancies. Then, at four o'clock to-day, you telephoned."

Inspector Lance walked to the door.

"You would like to see Arkwright's, no doubt," he said. Hanaud directed
an imploring glance towards Maltby and Maltby understood and replied
accordingly: "Very much, if it could be early."

"We'll make it eight o'clock if you like, and you could catch a fast
train up to London at nine-fifteen."

Thus it was arranged. Hanaud stood looking into the fire after Lance had
gone with a curious smile breaking the composure of his face and then
vanishing and recurring again. He was remembering the speech he had made
to Mrs. Leete in Paris, and how pat this example had come upon it. A plot
was worked out, watertight, undiscoverable, with its sequences and
rehearsals; a foggy night, a kidnapping, a lonely farm where, sooner or
later, release could be arranged, unless, happiest consequence of all,
madness solved all the troubles and made truth an acrostic which none
could ever read. But for two small accidents! An aeroplane crossing the
sky each night above the prison house at midnight, and a sheep-killing
dog which brought a policeman from town.

"No doubt," said Hanaud, "Barnish and his wife thought the game was up,
the dog licence an excuse for the snoop, and, one, two, they get rid of
their prisoner and disappear. The little accidents one cannot foresee,
they burst open perfect crimes."

But the morning was advancing, and no one, not even Mr. Ricardo, was
willing to listen further.

"Yes," said Maltby curtly. "Rouse and two people who walk a mile or so
home from a country dance. And a newsboy sent back one morning for a
fresh batch of papers who passes a door three times, and sees it shut,
and finds it open, and next time it's shut again. Oh, yes! Suppose we go
to bed!"

To bed they went. And a few minutes after eight that morning they were
trampling, with a little more noise than perhaps was necessary, about the
squalid house and precincts of Arkwright's Farm. Why they were noisy, no
one of them was quite sure, no one would have admitted it if he had been
sure. Horror and fear and suffering had left behind them in that house an
air which was heavy and charged with dim threats. For no reason, each one
looked quickly over his shoulder when he had passed a door, or, if he
turned a sharp corner, made shift to return upon his steps in silence to
see whether he was followed. And in one room the three of them halted
with one accord. It was a bare room with no furniture in it but a deal
table in a squat tower with a broken window over the back yard and a
little hatch upon the corridor.

All eagerly agreed with Lance that it was the service hatch which had
turned their suspicions into certainties. But it was nothing of the kind.
As they stood in the wretched room, they knew that they had reached the
end of their search. There was an oppression which weighed upon their
brains, a cruelty which clutched at their hearts until they hurt. Maltby
stepped forward, but very quietly, like a churchwarden in a church, and,
pulling forward one of the shutters from the clip which held it to the
outside wall, showed them where the screws had fixed it to the window

"Yes," he said, as though he were confirming some thing they were all
agreed about, "it was here."

"Yes, the room is hateful," said a voice which Ricardo hardly recognised
as Hanaud's, so quiet and yet so respectful was the sound of it. But no
more was said. Inspector Lance was looking at his watch. "If you
gentlemen want to catch the nine-fifteen--" and Hanaud started again into

"I think we do," said Maltby, and to Hanaud: "You agree?"

But Hanaud's face was so smoothed out with relief that no words were
needed from him. He uttered them none the less, and they remained for a
long while stark in Mr. Ricardo's thoughts.

"What I see and smell and touch through all this house, and, above all,
in this empty room, is cruelty. We ought to be quick."


"The first thing to do always," said Maltby, "is put people in their
proper places."

"The difficulty is to know what are their proper places," Hanaud

"Well, I know mine," said Septimus. "I am Chaarman of the Dagger Line of
Steamships, and my first business is to know what sort of hash my young
directors have made of my business during my weeks of absence."

He pressed the butt of his cigar down in an ash-tray and looked towards
Maltby. "And perhaps you, Superintendent, could find time to come with me
and learn whether any demand for ransom has been made?"

"Ransom? Ah! That is an idea. Yes," Hanaud cried with a bright look, as
though the suggestion of ransom was one of those original strokes of
genius which suddenly illuminate a mystery. "You will go to your main
office in Leadandall Street?

"Leadenhall Street," Mr. Crottle corrected.

"Yes, so I said," Hanaud replied. "Then if I come with you, perhaps, Mr.
Crottle, you will tell a clerk to find a cabin for me on a nice big ship
to Cherbourg?"

Mr. Crottle turned with a little disappointment in his face. "You are

Hanaud shrugged his shoulders. "You sail on Fridays. I remember that you
said so."

"Yes, but to-day--this morning--" Maltby exclaimed in perplexity, "you
spoke very seriously."

"I am a serious person," said Hanaud.

"You spoke some other words," Maltby hesitated to repeat them in Mr.
Crottle's presence. "And after them, 'We ought to be quick.'"

"So, you see, I shall only have a few hours to roll with my friend

For a moment there was the silence of stupefaction. But Mr. Ricardo was
an expert interpreter: "He means to loaf," he explained; but it was not
the alluring picture of Hanaud and Ricardo rolling in each others' arms
across Grosvenor Square which had brought Maltby so sharply up. He and
Hanaud were staring at one another. Quite slowly Hanaud nodded thrice,
and the doubt cleared away from Maltby's face.

"Very well."

Now, all these vague sentences and vaguer glances which had been spoken
and exchanged since Hanaud had asked Septimus for a passage to Cherbourg
were intelligible enough to Mr. Ricardo. The affair would finish before
to-night. The whole affair. Horbury as well as Crottle. That was clear.
But the conversation up to that moment was a different matter altogether.

It took place after luncheon in Ricardo's dining-room. The three--Maltby,
Hanaud and Ricardo--had got back to the house to find Septimus up and
dressed and impatiently walking an imaginary bridge in Mr. Ricardo's
library; and whilst Julius was ordering luncheon and the appropriate wine
to go with it, and causing as much delay as was possible, the other two
had some kind of a conference with Septimus Crottle. From that conference
resulted undoubtedly Crottle's proposal to present himself at once at his
head office with Maltby, and Hanaud's decision to seek at the same place
a passage to Cherbourg. The conversation, however, seemed natural and
spontaneous enough, but there was no debate, and to Mr. Ricardo, who
liked now and then to enliven his language with a slang word, it all
sounded phoney. It gave him the impression that he was being deliberately
excluded from the climax. He didn't like that at all.

"After all, where would they have been without me?" he asked of himself
indignantly. He had noticed things every now and then. He had been the
first to distinguish Arkwright's Farm, hadn't he? And here they were
leaving him at home. In fact, here was Septimus holding out his hand to

"I thank you very much for your hospitality," he said. "From the office I
shall go home to Portman Square, where I shall look forward to the
pleasure of seeing you."

It was almost worse to hear Maltby observing with a kindly nod: "You
will, perhaps, let me disturb you again when we have put our heads
together with the young directors?"

Mr. Ricardo, indeed, was almost in tears. An outsider, he! The mere
caretaker of the corner house! And at that, as Crottle and Maltby were
going out of the door, the voice of Hanaud fell upon his ears like balm
upon an open wound.

"Let them go first in a taxi. We follow in the Rolls-Royce. It will be

"But it's in the garage," cried Ricardo in despair.

Hanaud shook his head with a beaming smile.

"I took the liberty. I spoke to Thompson. It was not my place. You

"But I am grateful," Ricardo explained; and the taxi was still in sight
across the square when the Rolls-Royce slid noiselessly to the door. It
was not Mr. Ricardo's habit to look with any complacency upon intruders
who took upon themselves to ride his small thunders and direct his
storms, but he rejoiced that they were easily able to keep the taxicab
within their vision.

"It is the fault of Monsieur Crottle," Hanaud explained, rather nobly to
Mr. Ricardo's thinking. "He cannot forgive me for that I prefer the
peppermint and the cigarette."

Mr. Ricardo must answer nobility with nobility. "No, no, my friend, blame
me and Maltby. It is not formal and correct that I should be here."

And so, disputing gracefully, they drove up to the door of the Dagger
Line in Leadenhall Street on the number plate of the taxi; and Mr.
Ricardo stepped nimbly from the car to the annoyance of Superintendent
Maltby. But he said nothing. For Septimus walked straight from the street
into the big front office.

By the door a commissionaire sat at a small desk and at the sight of
Septimus he uttered a cry. Then he rose to his feet and stood with his
hand at the salute. And that was more than enough. Behind a long counter
which ran from wall to wall there were many desks. From each of those
desks there rose a man with some warm exclamation of welcome in his
mouth. They crowded to the long counter. One or two of the chief clerks
held out their hands, and as Septimus, for once in a way openly moved,
grasped them and said with a smile of mock surprise, "Well, upon my word,
I seem to be popular with my officers," there broke forth laughter and
rapping on the long mahogany board, and a lift of voices which were
obviously going to end in a rousing chorus of "For he's a jolly good

But the welcome never rose to that height. For, just when all Leadenhall
Street was about to ring with a celebration which really belonged more to
Lloyds across the way, a bell rang and an angry voice shouted through the
room on a loud-speaker: "I can't hear myself speak."

Septimus stepped back and all the joyous clamour died suddenly. Mr.
Ricardo noticed a change in Crottle's face which baffled his
understanding. It moved in a second from good humour to an anger so
violent as to pass belief. That so much fire could blaze in old eyes, or
that an old face, carved by time, could twist into a shape so malignant,
was the strangest of metamorphoses. It was the flash of a moment, like
some swift scene in a moving picture, so swift that it was almost
invisible, but so vivid that it left a memory more real and complete
than a mountain of detail could have done.

Crottle lowered his head then, so that none could see his face, and stood
as still as a statue in a silence which had grown constrained and somehow
rather alarming. Then, in a quiet voice, he said:

"That complaint came from my room, I think."

The head clerk flushed and stammered. "Yes, sir. They moved in there."


"Mr. George and Mr. James."

"I see."

It was more than a trifle shocking to Mr. Ricardo to see how deeply the
old man was moved by this encroachment of his nephews. They had been
tactless, culpably tactless, too ready to assume that Septimus's chair
empty and too quick to share it. The business of the Dagger Line had to
go on, that was evident, but they could have controlled it for a few
weeks without changing their offices. They wanted all the trappings at
once. It was not very clever. At the same time, the old man's rage was
quite extravagant.

"I'm glad I didn't serve under him," was one of Ricardo's thoughts, and,
"Upon my word, Rosalind was quite right to run out," another. For still
Septimus dared not show them his face and, though his body was quiet, his
voice shook.

"Well," he said at last, "it's a good rule to take the first of the tide.
Only the tide don't always run true," and in an effort to smile with good
humour he contrived the ugliest grimace which Ricardo had ever seen.

A clerk lifted a flap in the counter.

"I'll tell the young gentlemen that you have returned, sir," he said, and
at once Septimus stopped him.

"You won't, indeed," Septimus replied; and now there was some pleasure in
his voice, a rather acid pleasure. He laughed. "We'll surprise them. You,
too, Mr. Ricardo. I'm glad that we didn't leave you behind after all."

Septimus was chuckling with enjoyment. Schoolboyish, perhaps, and a grim
sort of schoolboyishness at that, Ricardo reflected. Septimus was
preparing his surprise with all the dramatic effects and an audience into
the bargain. He would relish his little triumph, but Ricardo would have
bet a large slice of his fortune that not a glimpse would Crottle give to
either of his heirs of the misery and torture which he had endured at
Arkwright's farm.

"Come," said Septimus, and he led the way into a passage at the side of
the main office.

"The first door's my room," he said, stopping before it. "The next door
is theirs. You'll be able, in their room, Monsieur Hanaud, to select your
cabin to Cherbourg."

He looked about him to make sure that his audience was complete, and then
gently opened the door and stepped inside. The two nephews were seated
opposite to each other at a big leather-padded table, George with his
back to the door and James with his face to it. But his face was bent
upon his papers and George did not turn.

"I didn't ring," said James without looking up. "Mr. George objected very
properly to the noise."

"No doubt my welcome home was a little obstreperous," said Septimus, and
at the sound of his voice James dropped his papers and sprang to his
feet. He was white as a sheet.

"George," he cried sharply. For George had no risen, had not even turned
his head, so engrossed was he upon his work.

"I am sorry," he said, looking up towards James. But the attitude and the
pallor of his stepbrother's face startled him. He came out of a dream, a
dream of ships and cargoes. "What is it?" he began, and he turn round
with a perplexity so marked upon his face that he seemed hardly yet aware
of any new big crisis in the affairs of the Dagger Line. But now he saw
Septimus standing two feet from him. He reeled back against the desk. His
voice rang out in a cry of delight, his face beamed, and if he didn't
hold out his hands it was because they clutched the edge of the table
behind him to hold him up.

"You, sir! At last! Thank Heaven! We've wanted you!"

"And my room, too," said Crottle dryly--a reply which, to Mr. Ricardo,
lowered the whole dignity of this welcome home.

"Well, we had to find our way, sir, through so many complications which
you naturally had kept under your own control," George explained
apologetically. "You have been away a long time."

"A fortnight," answered Septimus.

"A fortnight, yes," said George. "A long time, sir, for the Dagger Line
with a jury-rigged rudder," and he laughed and made a little bow. "We
were afraid," he explained again, "that something had happened to you.
You were staying...?"

And Septimus took him up in the same cordial tone.

"At Arkwright's Farm. A few miles from Sedgemoor."

"Sedgemoor?" George repeated with hardly a stammer, and "Sedgemoor,"
James Crottle repeated again, idiotically. "Why, that's where...

"Yes, where Monmouth was defeated, wasn't it?" added George.

Septimus nodded his head.

"I think we might read about it on a Sunday evening. It would make
kindlier reading than the history of the Dauphin of France."

"My word, yes," said George Crottle heartily, and Septimus took a step

"By the way," he asked easily, "do either of you remember that we
employed a man named Barnish on one of our ships? "--and at Ricardo's side
even Hanaud jumped a little.

James Crottle was obviously troubled, but less by the name, Ricardo would
have said, than by the oddity of the question.

"Barnish?" James echoed, and again "Barnish?" but on different

"Frank Barnish," Septimus repeated and, as George Crottle shook his head,
he turned and drew Maltby into the room. "But it doesn't matter. This is
Superintendent Maltby of Scotland Yard," he explained. "The
Superintendent will see if the staff can turn up his name," and with a
pleasant nod he dismissed the Superintendent upon this business. Then, as
though he had just noticed Hanaud and Ricardo for the first time, he
called them forward.

"Monsieur Hanaud and Mr. Ricardo, you do know. Monsieur Hanaud pays us the
compliment of wishing to return to Paris via Cherbourg on one of our
ships. If you," and he looked towards Hanaud and Ricardo, "will go into
the office which my nephews use as a rule, Jenkins will see what he can
do for you."

He waved his hand to the head clerk, who was standing just within the
doorway, and then unlatched a communicating door between his office and
that of the nephews.

George moved forward.

"I had better see that they are comfortable..." he began, but Septimus
interrupted him with a laugh.

"Oh, they will only have a minute or so to wait. Jenkins will go along to
them. It's obvious from what you said when I first came in that we have a
bit of work to do, and the sooner we confer about it, the quicker we'll
get it done."

He opened the connecting door and invited Hanaud and his friend to enter.
He shut the door behind them and, seeing that Jenkins had already gone
and closed the door upon the passage, he drew up a chair to their table.

"Now let's put our three heads together," he cried, relaxing into some
sort of gaiety. Indeed, neither of his two nephews could ever have seen
the old man in a more genial mood.

* * * * *

There were two tables in this second room. Into a chair by the nearest
Hanaud dropped, exhausted with admiration.

"But he is superb," he cried, "absolutely superb! And it was shattering,
mind you, all of it quite shattering. But none the less, he was superb!"
and, putting the tips of his fingers to his lips, Hanaud blew a fervent
kiss to so glorious a comedian.

Julius Ricardo was inclined to think the applause a little too French and
explosive, but he realised that some tribute from himself was due. So he
said: "Yes, he was remarkable, especially after those dreadful days he
must have spent at Arkwright's Farm," and he did not notice the
open-mouthed stupefaction with which Hanaud received the comment.

It was natural indeed that he should not. For Hanaud was already engaged
in a kind of visual catalogue of the room's contents. A big single
knee-hole table for James, another like it for George, a filing cabinet,
a bookcase in which some Admiralty Guides kept company with some naval
almanachs, some chairs, a shelf against the wall, on which stood a
chronometer in a mahogany box and--just what Hanaud was looking for.

"Ha!" said he, and he was out of his chair and across the room with that
light, swift step, which, after all these years, Ricardo could never quite
reconcile with his cumbrous build. Behind the chronometer, on the shelf,
was a roll of big charts. And suddenly Ricardo was aware that Hanaud had
a pair of fine india-rubber gloves upon his hands. But when he had slipped
them on, he had not one idea.

Hanaud lifted the charts carefully from the shelf and brought them over
to the table.

"Listen for Jenkins in the passage," he said, "but he'll give us time."

Hanaud unrolled the charts and they sprang back into a roll.

"There are some paper weights."

He nodded to two which he had pushed aside--heavy things of bronze and
malachite. Under Hanaud's direction, Ricardo placed them, one at each
corner of the lower end of the charts. He unrolled the charts again from
the bottom and held them flat. The one uppermost was a big chart of the
English Channel. He let it slip from his fingers and it rolled itself
again down to the paper weights. The next one was of the Indian Ocean,
and the third of the Mediterranean Sea, and the fourth of the Great
Barrier Reef on the coast of Australia. They were in no sort of order at
all, and from the clean look of them and the speed with which each one
rolled, itself up the moment it was released, it looked as if the had not
been examined for many a day.

Hanaud looked at, and let go, seven of them quickly and then stopped with
a little cry. From the side of the last sheet, so quick to hide its
secrets, the corner of another paper was sticking out--and, of course,
just a that moment Jenkins must knock upon the passage door.

Hanaud swore, and not his favourite polysyllabic oath: "Will you stand in
front of the table, please, friend?"

He ran to the door and opened it. But he planted himself in the doorway
and thrust his hands in his pockets.

"You can arrange for me? So! That is good. The Formosa. On the Friday, to
be sure."

Mr. Ricardo, with some surprise, heard Hanaud making his plans, but it
was altogether a surprising day for Mr. Ricardo.

"Then you will make out for me a ticket and I pick him up at the desk as
I go out. Yes? I thank you. You are the kindness itself." He closed the
door upon Jenkins. "And please to keep the snotty nose out of this room
for the future."

"Really, really," said Ricardo, who disliked such phrases. Monsieur
Hanaud, on the other hand, was radiant because he had used this one so

"It is not a pleasant word?" he asked.

"It is not," said Mr. Ricardo with severity.

Hanaud nodded his head vigorously once or twice.

"I thought so. It was used upon me once in my early days by an English
chauffeur who thought I was examining too inquisitively the interior of
his good lady's motor-car. However, work, not words--how often do our good
statesmen tell us so!"

Hanaud was again at the table. He uncurled the seventh map and there,
lying upon the centre of it was a much smaller chart with, here and
there, pin-points marked upon it.

"Do you see?" he asked in a low voice. "Do you see the corners where it
has been stretched out and fixed by drawing-pins to a board?"

"Yes," said Ricardo. "I do."

It was a small chart of the western seaboard of Europe; the southern
coastline of Spain, Gibraltar, Portugal, the Bay of Biscay and the
English Channel.

"Look where the pins were set. Cadiz first, then round on the west at
Lisbon, next up at Vigo. El Rey had landed her undesirables in Spain and
Portugal. Then straight across the Bay to Brest, where she discharges her
French load. Then across to the Start, just after she made her number. Do
you remember Foster, Horbury's clerk? On the afternoon of the night when
he died, Horbury, reading in the Evening Standard that El Rey had made
her number at Lloyd's station at Prawle Point at six in the morning,
stuck in his little black pin with the white top there, at the Start
lighthouse, just by, and chanced a final one opposite to Selsea
Bill--see?--which he reckoned El Rey to have reached just at that moment."

"El Rey?" exclaimed Mr. Ricardo, staring at the map. He remembered very
clearly that rusty old iron boat in the dim of the morning floundering
amidst a welter of white foam at the end of the bowsprit of Agamemnon.

"And here, just beyond Start Point, you picked up the passenger with the
black rim round his ankle."

"Yes--Devisher," he cried.

"Bryan Devisher," Hanaud agreed. "At last we know," Ricardo exclaimed,
"the murderer of Daniel Horbury."

Hanaud choked suddenly and swallowed and came to himself. He made a low

"As your proverb says. The costumier is alway right."

But Hanaud had not yet finished with the chart. Whilst talking to Jenkins
he had slipped off a glove in his pocket, and he began to press the
ungloved fingers of that hand upon the chart.

"Now yours, please!"


Mr. Ricardo hesitated, wondering whether or no he was condoning or
implicating himself in some great crime. But Hanaud seized his hand and
dabbed it down upon the paper in one place and in another.

"There!" he said, and he began to roll up the charts again with great
care. "They must look just as they did."

"They?" said Mr. Ricardo in a hushed voice. "Yes. But what have we done?"

Hanaud carried the roll back to the shelf and meticulously replaced it
behind the chronometer.

"We?" he asked. "Why, we have left our evidence quite beyond all
challenge that we saw the Horbury's chart with the pin-pricks, slipped,
as we expected to find it, in a sheaf of other charts in the office of
the younger Mr. Crottles."

Mr. Ricardo stepped back.

"Oh!" he whispered.

He was in a maze. He was also conscious, proudly conscious, that the
presentiment which had so stirred him at Lezardrieux was true. He was
engaged in the elucidation of a great and mysterious crime.

"Oh!" he said again.

He looked at the door which communicated with the office of Septimus
Crottle. He pointed towards it.

"You did not expect that you would be interrupted from that room?"

"No," Hanaud answered. "I thought that Mr. Septimus would prevent it."

So this was the explanation of those secret conferences before luncheon
at the corner house. It was reckoned a possibility, perhaps more than a
possibility, that the small chart which had disappeared from White Barn
on the night of Horbury's death might be found in a roll of charts in one
particular office of the Line. It had been arranged that Hanaud should
have time to search for it.

"It was one of the nephews, then," said Ricardo in a whisper.

Hanaud did not pretend to misunderstand him.

"Which?" he asked.

"Why not both?" asked Ricardo.

"Why not?" Hanaud echoed.

"We must find out," Ricardo urged.

"I think we shall to-night," replied Hanaud. "Now we ought to say that
the ticket is arranged."

He went to the communicating door and knocked upon it and entered.
Septimus was seated at the head of the table discussing genially with his
young partners the affairs of the Line. Was it possible that those two
young men, or one of them, had murdered Horbury and planned the
sequestration of Septimus, and that Septimus knew of it at this moment?
Ricardo could hardly believe it.

"It is fixed?" cried Septimus. "We carry the great detective to
Cherbourg, do we?"

“Septimus is untrue to Septimus,” Mr. Ricardo reflected. “There's something
in it.” Aloud, Septimus continued: "That is good news to compensate for
our bad news."

"Ah!" Hanaud replied. "My sincere regrets. It is not, I hope, serious."

Septimus was obviously not overwhelmed. "Not very serious, but
troublesome, as all new arrangements are. Preedy has left us."

The statement took both Hanaud and Ricardo by surprise. Preedy? It was
almost an effort to remember him. Of such small importance had he seemed
to be in the great affairs of the Line.

"Why has he gone, Mr. Crottle?" Ricardo asked, and, with a touch of
malice in his tone, Septimus answered:

"He saw the red light."

Both George and James ducked their heads a little over their papers.

"He is in trouble with his lungs. He is leaving--I think, George, that you
said he had left--for Switzerland, and will be away for two years."

"That is unfortunate," said Hanaud, and Septimus agreed.

"Preedy was a very useful ally. These Barnishes, for instance. It looks
as if they had got away. But Preedy would have laid his hands upon them.
Well, it can't be helped! I shall see you at my house to-night"; and with
a wave of his hand Septimus dismissed them.

Ricardo had entered the corridor by the second door. He saw Hanaud emerge
from Septimus's room, close the door, and lean against it.

"Preedy! I never gave a thought to him!" he muttered, his mind disturbed.
"Should I have? For what reason?"

Although he only communed with himself, his last question reached
Ricardo's ears and he answered it: "Preedy had a special gift."

Hanaud answered: "Yes, to be sure."

They walked slowly along the corridor to the main office. Ricardo had, in
fact, answered Hanaud's question better than either of them knew.

At the, counter in the outmost office Hanaud asked for and received his
ticket by the SS Formosa to Cherbourg. And that again stirred Mr. Ricardo
indescribably. Hanaud, who hated the sea, who never travelled to England
except by the shortest passage between Calais and Dover, meant actually
to sail on an ocean-going steamship to Cherbourg. Oh, certainly Mr.
Ricardo was in the way of great events.


SEPTIMUS arrived in a small car, with a constable on the seat by the side
of the driver, at the corner house half an hour after Hanaud and Ricardo.
Maltby had sent the car for him, and it was as well, Ricardo reflected.
For it was no longer the Septimus whom anger had inspired to establish
his old authority and sow confusion amongst his partners. He was tired;
the fire had gone from him; he was that haggard and humbled man on the
bench above the Fairmile.

"Maltby told me that he would be here," he complained in a weak,
querulous voice, as he was shown by Thompson into the library.

"A cup of tea, sir," Ricardo suggested, and the old man had hardly raised
the cup to his lips before Maltby hurried in.

"I have some news," he said as Ricardo handed a cup to him.

"Good?" Hanaud asked.

"It fits in."

He leaned forwards to Septimus.

"Frank Barnish was the bo'sun of your first oil-driven ship."

"The Acropolis. Was he?" exclaimed Septimus with a sudden smile. But the
smile was for that adventure in new ships rather than for her bo'sun.

"Yes, sir. He gave trouble, drank too much, resented orders, and, once
the voyage was over, was not signed on again. It was a grievance which he
didn't forget. He had the reputation of being a revengeful fellow although
a capable seaman, never held up a job for long. It must have been
a blessing for him when he was put in to Arkwright's Farm."

"That wouldn't have been a long job, either," said Septimus. "More than
that, it wasn't meant to be a long job."

And he sat for a moment or two shaking. He was back in that shuttered
room at Arkwright's.

"Come, sir, that's all over," Maltby declared. "We are looking after you

"Yes, yes," Septimus cried eagerly, and he caught Maltby by the arm. "I
have great confidence in you, Maltby. You were to give me some
instructions, I think."

He asked for them rather pitifully.

"I think you should go home, sir. There is a constable in the front of
your car. There will be another outside your house. I shall be obliged if
you will refuse to discuss your absence at all, but just take everything
easily. If you will leave it all to us, we will keep in touch with you."

Words--and words which meant nothing at all--but they satisfied Septimus.
He rose from his chair with some difficulty and went downstairs on
Maltby's arm. Ricardo, at the window, watched the car drive away in the
darkness. In old age, he thought, how swift the change can be from great
authority to exhaustion and how permanent! It was the horror which
Septimus had suffered that filled his mind now, no longer the audacity of
the crime nor its authors. Maltby spoke at his shoulder in attune with
his thoughts:

"It's a new family that the old gentleman will find in Portman Square.
One of the daughters ran out, did she? Well they've all run out now. New
clothes, a theatre or two, friends to entertain. A little cruel it
sounds, perhaps. But after those years of submission and boredom and
orders and what not, to be expected, what? Pretty natural. I don't think
he'll round them up again. Patriarchs don't go down in the twentieth
century. Or do they?"

"And Miss Agatha?" Hanaud asked suddenly from the room behind them. But
Maltby merely shrugged his shoulders in surprise. He had no answer to
that question; and now that Septimus had been packed off home, he was
anxious and hurried. Hanaud pointed to the chairs.

"In a dry we finish everything."

Maltby was puzzled but took a seat.

"He means in a sec," Ricardo explained, and took another. Maltby nodded
and turned to Hanaud.

“So you have found something?"

"That chart."

Maltby sat back in his chair.

"The chart with the black pins which Horbury brought from his office to
White Barn on Thursday, August the twenty-sixth."

"And which Devisher took away?" said Maltby.

"But he didn't take it away," cried Hanaud. "We found it this afternoon
slipped into a great roll of charts in the office of the young Crottles."

"You are sure?" Maltby exclaimed. He was more astounded, more troubled
than Ricardo expected.

"So you see. The affair of Horbury and the affair of Crottle--they are

It was Hanaud's old point once more enforced upon unwilling ears.

"There is the vanishing of Devisher, too," Hanaud continued, ticking off
the points on his fingers.

"Still..." Maltby doubted

"The man without money and without friends. There is his reappearance,

"I know, but.."

"There is the telephone which was lifted and replaced. There is the
blotting-book. There is the door which was locked."

Hanaud was rushing back through the events of that night of death,
Thursday, August the twenty-sixth.

Still Maltby was not convinced, though what course Hanaud was urging
upon him, Ricardo could not tell.

"And there was another night. Oh, if you had been there you would not
doubt--when, in a deep silence, a sigh was breathed."

Maltby stared between his knees at the carpet. "There is not enough," he
said, shaking his head.

"Not when we add to-day the finding of the chart?" Maltby rose
ponderously to his feet, whilst Hanaud watched his every movement with
hopeful, eager eyes. "We must be quick," he said. Maltby nodded his great

"This is our one night. After the old man's appearance at his office,
to-night there will be action," Hanaud argued.

Maltby flung back his head and swore. "If only we had the Barnishes!" he

"The Barnishes!" cried Hanaud in almost a scream of disdain. "They are

Maltby frowned gloomily at the Frenchman. A man who had to decide between
peace and war might look like that. So might a youth who had to choose
between a blonde and a brunette. He heaved a great sigh. He made a great
resolve--to hesitate again.

"I must go to the Yard," he said, and as disappointment deepened on
Hanaud's face: "I shall make all the arrangements, however--you know." He
nodded portentously. "And I shall come back. Let me see!"

Ricardo interrupted.

"But, my dear Hanaud, you are dining with Septimus. He said so in his

Hanaud swept the interruption away.

"Comedy, my dear friend. The false invitation which leaves me free. It
was arranged."

"I shall come back with full authority," said Maltby, his breast
swelling, "but..." and he relapsed again into doubt. "A little before
eight, then. That will give us time--if we move," he said, looking at his

"Then perhaps you will dine here?" said Mr. Ricardo, and Hanaud took him
up at once.

"Yes, yes, we will dine! But not the big dinner, no. Some hors d'oeuvres
perhaps, the joint, the sweet, the coffee. Admirable."

"Really, really." Mr. Ricardo addressed dumbly the vacant air. "Do I keep
the inn, The Policemen's Rest?"

But Maltby was clattering down the stairs, and Hanaud was urging him to
hurry. Hanaud came back to the library and dropped into a chair, limp and

"It is but and but and but with that man!" he exclaimed moodily. "He will
never--no, never--come up and be scratched."

Whether Mr. Ricardo was still contemplating himself as the appointed
innkeeper to the police, who shall say? He cried indignantly, for he had
the strongest possible views upon this necessity of the times: "I bet you
he has been vaccinated over and over again."

Hanaud stared at him.

"The vaccination? You talk of this at this hour!" He danced in a rage
about the room and suddenly slipped, tame as a cat, to Ricardo's side.
"It is not yet six of the clock, no. And at the moment when I most need
his friendship, I gibe. Yes, I gibe fatally!" Smooth, soft words, and the
voice so remorseful, so tender.

"What do you want now?" Ricardo asked laughing--though he did not wish to

"The Rolls-Royce."


"Not the Rolls-Royce No. 1. No, no, my friend! I ask for no such
enormity. But the Rolls-Royce No. 2. the wee, wee one."

He smiled like a child asking for his father's second gold watch and
confident that he would get it.

"I have no wee, wee car," Mr. Ricardo said firmly. But it was clear to
him that Hanaud was passionately anxious to go somewhere. After all, he
wanted help.

"I doubt if I shall have a chauffeur waiting," he objected. "I have given
no orders."

"A chauffeur!" cried Hanaud, and he thumped his chest. "I, Hanaud, I am
the best chauffeur in Europe."

There was no answer to this statement, except the most direct of
negatives; and Ricardo had no authority to make it.

"Come!" he said.

He led Hanaud to the back of the house and to the garage in the Mews. He
threw open the doors whilst Hanaud climbed into the car.

"You go to Scotland Yard?" he asked.

"Perhaps," said Hanaud, fiddling with the instruments.

"And you will drive on the wrong side of the road?"

"I will."

Ricardo stood at the side and saw Rolls-Royce No. 2 dash out into the
street, scatter a handful of people in the roadway and disappear.

"It may be that he is the best driver in Europe, but there are no signs of
it," he said to himself. However, what did it matter, even if Rolls-Royce
No. 2 became a scrap heap? Agitations were here. The world was bubbling.
Great criminals sitting at their ease would feel the handcuffs on their
wrists. If only Maltby had the courage. "But, but..." Mr. Ricardo could
take it to his soul with pride that he had never said "But but..." when
Rolls-Royce No. 2 had been commandeered. He had let it go to a man who
must drive on the wrong side of the road, if he was to survive.

Ricardo shut the garage door and returned to the front of his house. He
ordered the short dinner which Hanaud demanded. It was to be on the table
at eight, with the Burgundy--say the Musigny, a lighter wine and more fit
to precede a nocturnal expedition. Coffee to follow and perhaps a glass
of Armagnac. He did not want fingers to tremble on the trigger of a
pistol. Mr. Ricardo waited. The clocks chimed--the hour of seven, the half
hour which followed; and Hanaud tumbled into the room, his dress
dishevelled, his face dirty, his hands scratched and bleeding, yet with
so proud a look of conquest in his face that Mr. Ricardo thought of
Napoleon at Marengo, and, being English, of Wellington on the mountain of
Bussaco. His eyes sparkled, his arms were spread out in an ecstasy. But
Ricardo noticed, above all, the lines of dirt upon his face, the torn
collar, blood upon the knuckles, the dust upon the clothes.

"You have had a smash!" he cried.

"No, I am not hurt," Hanaud answered, "but I thank you for the thought."
It was not for him to recognise that Ricardo's thought was for Rolls-
Royce No. 2. "It was nothing. Just once I was on the right side of the
road and I meet a taxicab. But I was quick--oh, I surprise myself. The
driver he threw a name at me--the name--not nice. I forgive him with a wave
of the hand, and I drove on. I keep on the wrong side of the road
carefully, and Rolls-Royce No. 2, she has the right to be proud. Look, it
is seven-thirty. We have a quarter of an hour before Maltby arrives."

"Yes," said Ricardo eagerly. He was to hear, no doubt, the story of Rolls-
Royce No. 2's adventures, "Over a glass of Porto, you shall..." But he
got no further.

"But first the wash!" Hanaud exclaimed "I disgust myself. I change the
clothes. But not the smoking. Nor for you, my friend. It will not be
But--But Maltby, but Maltby, winner of the Derby Round. You shall see!
To-night we prowl!"

Hanaud was half-way up the stairs to his bedroom before he had finished
talking. Ricardo delayed following his example for just the time it took
to order Royce No. 1 to be ready at the door by half-past eight.

Washed and dressed in inconspicuous clothes, the two men descended into
the study with five minutes to spare before the time of Maltby's arrival.

"A Porto," Ricardo cried gaily as he filled Hanaud's glass. "For me the

There was just time, he reflected, for him to hear the story of his
friend's adventures and the reason for all his excitement.

"There's something I want to tell you very much," said Hanaud, as he lit
a cigarette and sipped his Porto.

"Yes, you would wish it!" cried Ricardo. "Such old compères as we are,"
and with a most unusual gesture he clinked his glass against Hanaud's.
But, alas! he was to be disappointed.

"There was much misunderstanding. I was hurt. 'He makes a jest of me,' I
said, whereas Maltby explained that his mistake was to imagine that I
understood English which, as you know, I do."

Ricardo sank back. He was to be told, after all, nothing more than the
tale of some ridiculous squabble which he and Maltby had in olden days.
He could have groaned.

"But the first day, when I came on Gravot's account and dined with Maltby
in Soho, all was put right."

"So you told me," Ricardo answered acidly. And he had lent the man his
Rolls-Royce, too!

"But I did not tell you the story of the misunderstanding." Hanaud leaned
forward smiling, so urgently did he feel that he must tell it.

"Fire away," said Ricardo with resignation. "I'm here to be shot."

"The fact is," he said to himself, "I'm not audience enough for the real
thing. He wants Maltby and myself to be paralysed together."

Hanaud fired away accordingly.

"There was a dead Frenchman in Golden Square with a bottle beside him..."

That was as far as he got in this never-to-be-told story, when the door
was opened and Maltby announced.


THEY stood about the fireplace, Ricardo upon one side, Maltby on the
other, and Hanaud, serene, masterful, in the middle. The Manzanilla and
the Port were forgotten. It was the scene of three men, Ricardo realised;
the inevitable great scene of the plays of Sardou; and this one
stage-managed--produced was the modern word, wasn't it?--by Hanaud, chief
dramatist of the Sureté Française.

"I have a present for you," said Hanaud, smiling.

"There is only one present," Maltby grumbled.

"And here it is," said Hanaud. Slowly he brought out from the inner
pocket of his jacket an oilskin wrapper fastened with a button, He
offered it to Maltby with a bow. For a moment Maltby stared at it. Then
he raised his eyes to Hanaud's face. Then he pounced upon the present. He
carried it to a small table farther back from the fire, and the group of
three was formed again about it.

Maltby unbuttoned the wrapper and took from it a folder of morocco
leather, which might hold perhaps a button-hook, a penknife, a nail file,
a pair of tweezers, such as a woman travelling light might take in her
suit-case. This he unwrapped and disclosed, folded length wise on the
washleather lining, a letter in an envelope, so folded that the seal was
not cracked.

With a little cry Maltby tossed the morocco case aside and flattened the
letter upon the table under the palm of his hand. It seemed that he was
afraid to reveal even to himself the name of him to whom the letter was
written, so long he looked from one face to another, so firmly he held
the envelope flat upon the table. At last he lifted up his hand sharply
and there was the name for all three of them to read 'Septimus Crottle,
Esq.,' and the address in Portman Square.

On a writing-table by the window a tortoiseshell paper-knife with a
silver handle was gleaming. Maltby fetched it and pulled up a chair.

"Let us see where we are." he said, tapping the letter with the
tortoiseshell blade. "This is presumably the letter which Horbury took
away from his office on the afternoon of Thursday, August the

"With the chart," cried Hanaud.

"Yes," Maltby agreed.

"Which we found this afternoon in the office of the younger Crottles,"
said Hanaud.

Again Maltby agreed. He took the paper-knife and slit the top of the

"It ought to have gone to Mr. Septimus before I opened it," he said

"But since you have opened it," Hanaud suggested, and he had no twinges
of conscience.

"We might as well read--" said Maltby doubtfully.

"What that old rogue Daniel Horbury had to say to him. Yes, yes!" cried
Hanaud, and he turned to Ricardo. "You agree, my friend? To be sure.

"I think," said Ricardo, "that you are the most lawless person in the
world. Still, I agree."

And Maltby, with his forefinger and his thumb, slipped out of the
envelope a letter with two enclosures folded within it. He flattened his
hand upon the enclosures as they dropped on to the table.

"Horbury's letter first, I think."

"Yes, yes," said Hanaud, and though he sat upright at the table, his feet
were dancing with impatience upon the carpet.

Maltby read it through without the omission of a word. It was written in
Horbury's dutiful style. He was a public man and a Member of Parliament.
His first thought was that his obligations demanded in no uncertain
manner that he should communicate the enclosures at once to the Crown
Prosecutor for such action as he deemed fit. On the other hand, he could
not shut his eyes to the high prestige of the Dagger Line and its
importance as a commercial asset to the country. On the whole, then, he
had determined, though with some heavy doubts, that the patriotic thing
to do was send the two documents straight to Mr. Septimus Crottle as
Chairman of the Line, and leave them in his hand. He remained Mr.
Crottle's obedient servant.

"Send them straight, to be sure," said Maltby with grunt. "So he keeps
them in the secret drawer of his desk. The damned old blackmailer!"

He dropped the letter with disgust upon the table and took up the two
enclosures. As he read them his face grew very grave, and he nodded his
head twice or three times to Hanaud.

"Yes, these are enough," he said.

The first was a receipt for three thousand pounds made out to Kapitan von
Kluckner, Military Attaché, and signed George Crottle. The second was an
undertaking that SS Harold, a freight carrier of the Dagger Line, would
call at a certain port in the Adriatic Sea and take on board two hundred
kilogrammes of hashish and five hundred grammes of heroin from Sofia for

And this undertaking, too, was addressed to Kapitan von Kluckner and
signed by George Crottle.

Of the three, Ricardo alone was plunged in confusion George? George
Crottle, drug-runner in the pay of a foreign Embassy? The kidnapper,
then, of old Septimus? George, with his charm and his slim figure and his
bright fair hair. It was not possible! But Hanaud and Maltby kept
exchanging glances as though they met at last on friendly ground. Maltby
packed Horbury's letter and enclosures away in his pocket-book; and
Thompson at the door announced that dinner was served.

It was a meal taken in haste and seasoned with little conversation. The
presence of Thompson prevented all discussion but that of world affairs,
and nobody at the table was for the moment interested in them. Coffee was
served in the dining-room. An extraordinary habit, Mr. Ricardo reflected,
that of drinking black coffee and liqueurs after meals when obviously
there was work waiting to be done. Cigars were on the way round, too.
“Then we shall never get off!” A small fellow for Maltby--that was sensible.
Hanaud only ate his own black cigarettes. Well, he might as well smoke a
small cigar himself and, like Maltby and his friend, sip this very
seductive yellow Chartreuse. Even Mr. Ricardo realised that there was no
need for hurry, and he was inclined to resent the strokes of a nearby
clock. Maltby counted the strokes.

"Nine," said he.

Hanaud looked at his watch.

"Nine," said he.

For both men the search was ended, conclusions had been reached, action
was now to be taken, peace of mind had come. They might be wrong, but the
question was for others to decide, not for them.

Thompson entered.

"Sergeant Hughes is in the hall, sir."

"Sergeant Hughes!" Ricardo repeated. For some vague reason the name was

"We wanted a young man," said Maltby. "I got him moved up to the Yard."

He remembered now the young officer in uniform who took notes at White
Barn. "Why?" he asked.

"I liked his cheek," Maltby replied with a grin. "Shall we go?"

Sergeant Hughes saluted as the three men descended the stairs.

"All quiet, Sergeant?

"Up till I left, sir. There's a journey proposed for to-night."

"So I supposed," said Maltby.

"But," and Sergeant Hughes looked puzzled, "it's a short journey with no

"Just as far as White Barn and back," Hanaud suggested, and Maltby

"Yes, that criminal stays and fights," and Ricardo had reason afterwards
to reflect how wrong these great men could sometimes be.

A small black police car stood in front of the Rolls-Royce.

"Hadn't I better give you and Sergeant Hughes a lift? We shall otherwise
leave you behind," said Mr.Ricardo grandly.

Hanaud sniggered--a malicious snigger. Maltby answered.

"We don't look much to be sure, by the side of your elephant, Mr.
Ricardo. But we can go--I don't say faster than the wind, for the wind's
quite out of date as a comparison, but faster than an empty army lorry in
a crowded street"; and he doubled himself up into the black car with
Sergeant Hughes, whilst Hanaud and Ricardo climbed into the elephant.
There was a man in plain clothes by the driver and no address was given.
The cars started, kept their distance like ships in line ahead, and they
did, to Hanaud's delight, pass an empty army lorry in the Brompton Road.

In a quieter road the cars stopped; and as the occupants alighted, a
uniformed constable saluted Maltby and spoke a few words to him. Maltby
beckoned to the rest of his party and went forward. On the right-hand
side of the road a crescent of small and attractive Regency houses curved
about a garden. The houses were lit up for the most part and the blinds
drawn. But in front of one of them a small car stood with its lamps

Suddenly there was a cluster of the uniformed police about a gate which
led through the garden to a front door. The room to the right of the
round white stone arch of the portico was lit. Maltby walked up to the
door and rang the bell. The shrill sound of it rang through the house,
but there was no answer, no movement at all in that lighted room. Ricardo
had in his mind the picture of a man there suddenly stricken by that bell
as by a stroke of paralysis. There was not a lift of the blind, not the
shifting of a chair.

Maltby rang a second time with a louder insistence. From inside the room
a shadow was cast upon the blind. A man stood with the light behind him.
Then he moved somewhere to the back of the room so that no shadow was any
longer shown. Even then a few unnecessary seconds passed before a door
into the passage was opened and steps approached. The front door was
unlatched. There was no light in the passage except the panel which
glowed from the open doorway. The young man had withdrawn into the
darkness behind it.

"My servants are away for the evening. Will you kindly come to-morrow?"

"Mr. George Crottle," said Maltby.

"I, too, have an appointment. I shall be obliged..."

"I am Superintendent Maltby. My business won't wait," Maltby stated.

There followed a few seconds of silence.

"You will make it, please, as short as you can," George Crottle replied
pleasantly. "Will you come in?"

He led the way into a sitting-room, furnished with comfort and elegance.
It was brightly lit and a writing bureau from which the chair had been
thrust back filled a corner of the room. Maltby was followed by Hanaud,
Ricardo and Sergeant Hughes. Crottle, as he closed the door, saw two
uniformed constables in the porch.

"Rather a large escort, Superintendent, haven't you?" he said coolly. His
face was pale, but his voice was composed, and the only sign of
disturbance which he showed was that only now, for the first time, did he
recognise Hanaud and Ricardo.

"Oh!" he exclaimed, nodding at them with a smile; and some wariness was
now audible in his tones. "I had the pleasure of meeting you, I think, in
Portman Square. Will you sit down?"

Maltby, in a formal voice, cut across these politenesses. "Mr. George
Crottle, I must ask you some questions. You need not answer them unless
you wish to. But I must warn you that if you do, your answers will be
written down and may be used in evidence."

In fact, Sergeant Hughes had already a large notebook open and a pencil
in his hand.

"You may sit down if you wish," Maltby continued.

"Of course," Crottle answered, but he remained standing.

"You are George Crottle, employed by your uncle, Mr. Septimus Crottle, in
the service of the Dagger Line of steamships?"

"No," cried George Crottle, and it was only now, when all was relaxed,
that those present realised under how much tension George Crottle had
preserved his calm. He had seemed at ease before, he was at ease now.

"No, no, Superintendent, that won't do. I am a director and a partner.
The old boy was in a fairly black rage when he turned up this afternoon
and found that my stepbrother and myself had annexed his office. I
thought that he would pay us out in some way. But, my word, it's pretty
hot to suggest that I had anything to do with his disappearance."

George must have been either completely innocent of any share in the
abduction of Septimus, or completely sure that the Barnishes were safe
from the police.

"For I suppose that's what the patriarch has been doing?" he added. And
now he did sit down and took at random a small cigar from a box on a
table at his side, pinched the end and reached out his left hand for a
box of wooden matches lying on a sofa.

"No, sir," said Maltby solidly, "we have no charge from Mr. Septimus. I
must ask you what you were doing on the night of Thursday, August the

George Crottle sat with the match-box still in his extended hand.

"August the twenty-sixth? That's a long time ago, Superintendent. I can't
remember off-hand. But there's a day-book on the desk in the corner which
might tell us."

He pointed with the matches towards the bureau where he had been sitting.
Maltby turned his head towards it, and during that glance George Crottle
put the cigar between his teeth. Hughes found the book upon the flat
surface of the bureau and flipped back the pages to the month of August.

"There is no entry on that date."

George Crottle shrugged his shoulders.

"It was the day before the steamship Sheriff sailed from Southampton,"
said Maltby.

Crottle frowned, looked at Maltby as though the answer were to be
discovered in his face, and shook his head."

"No," he said between his teeth, "No."

Maltby took a step nearer to him and, taking his letter-case from his
pocket-book, showed to Crottle an empty envelope sealed with a black
seal, but slit open at the top.

"You know this envelope?"

"I have never seen it."

"But you know the handwriting?"

Crottle leaned back in his chair.


"It is Daniel Horbury's?"


These monosyllables were uttered with a most convincing perplexity. He
closed his hand over the match-box and with a sly smile began to draw it
to his chest, But whilst his hand was still moving, Maltby struck his arm
with a swift and violent blow and snatched the match-box from his hand.

"George Crottle," he said, "I arrest you for the murder of Daniel Horbury
at his house of White barn on the night of the twenty-sixth of August."

Mr. Ricardo felt the floor turning underneath him. He was prepared for
George Crottle's arrest for the abduction of Septimus, or for conspiring
with the Kapitan von Kluckner, but on a charge of murder, no. If,
however, Mr. Ricardo did not know where he stood, George Crottle
certainly did. With a backward jerk of his head, he drew the whole length
of that small cigar between his teeth. He crushed it with a snap of his
jaws. A tiny tinkle of glass was heard, for a fraction of a second his
face was convulsed with all the agony of the world, and then he fell dead
into the arms of Maltby and Hughes.

In Crottle's pocket was found a flat black silk cord with a slip-knot
which ran very easily and smoothly; and in a locked drawer of the bureau
a manuscript.


The manuscript which Maltby found locked in George Crottle's bureau
offered a complete account of the crimes without a sign of remorse. On
the other hand, it was very vain--youth's passionate cry for authority
over age alternating with youth's despair at age's authority over youth.
He had completed the inevitable drudgery which precedes mastery in either
the arts or industry, to find himself in the end a cipher in a
counting-house. Septimus Crottle should have handed over the Dagger Line
years ago to nimbler wits and wider views. But he had not and this is
what had come of his obstinacy--a perpetual maddening threat which he was
going to get rid of to-night.

"I go out to-night to play my last hand. If I succeed I shall destroy
this manuscript, although its logic might hold a lesson for students and
its narrative another for authors."

The statement cleared up those difficulties which Hanaud and Mr. Ricardo
had been unable to resolve. But it contained disclosures which affected
not merely the high prestige of the Dagger Line, but the policy of the
Realm. It was, therefore, after earnest consideration, suppressed. George
Crottle could not, after all, be brought to trial, the two Barnishes had
disappeared, and, although Mrs. Horbury was amenable to the law for her
secrecy, there was no certainty that the verdict would condemn her. An
inquest was held in due course, at an early hour, and, coinciding with
the proximity of a general election, provoked little attention. Maltby,
however, had a copy of the manuscript and bade Hanaud and his friend to a
luncheon on the next Sunday at his Cottage at Thames Ditton. They were
bidden to come early so that the manuscript might be read and finished
with before luncheon. Hanaud was able to prolong his vacancy until
Monday, and thus on a Sunday of early autumn the great Rolls-Royce No. 1
rolled down to that pleasant village at eleven o'clock in the morning.
Maltby, in his riverside cottage, was an amiable host, a trifle too fussy
perhaps. He set out a great jug of ale and glasses on a tablecloth of
pink and white squares, pulled up some comfortable chairs, invited his
friends to take their seats, and took from a drawer a few typewritten
sheets of paper taped into a blue cover.

"Will you read it, sir?" he asked of Ricardo, and Ricardo responded

"Certainly not, my dear Maltby. The story is yours, and I want to listen
to it."

There was a noticeable relief in Maltby's voice as he accepted the task
and quickly drawing up a chair to the table he began to read:

"I was dipped. Horses which never won, women who always lost and cards
which never dealt you a house without giving to your neighbour four of a
kind. I didn't know where to turn. There was only Septimus, and to
confide in him meant humiliation which I was not prepared to endure, even
if he were prepared--a thing I very much doubted--to overlook my

"This is some years ago now--the actual date isn't necessary. I was
crossing the Green Park one lovely day of early June when a very young
voice ordered me to stop. I obeyed at once. I was in the mood to find an
omen in any occurrence, however trivial. My name was called, 'George!
George!' I looked round, only to be once more disappointed. The call had
come out of the air, a clear bell full of promise. But there rose up from
a seat my cousin Agatha."

"I want you to come with me," she cried in the breathless way she had--at
all events when she talked with me.

I guessed a church or a picture gallery, but I had hardly the time to
shake my head, when she added: "To the Caledonian Market."

Could any proposal be more crazy? Yet just for that reason more
appealing. The Caledonian Market, where junk jostled treasures, or so
they say. Of course, I would go, and the blood rushed into her face when
she clutched my arm as I told her so. We stopped a taxi in the Mall and
drove out past Smithfield. I was careful, you'll understand, not to ask
Agatha the reason for her choice. Only fools analyse inspirations, wise
men act on them. There might be something in those old Arabian stories.

"Suppose I found a bottle with a genius in it!" I said, laughing

"Oh, dear, I wish you'd always be like this to me," she answered. Boring?
Yes, but Agatha did bore.

In the market it was junk, junk all the way, and imitations under my feet
like mad. No doubt there were pieces of Ming under the Doulton, but there
was no stoppered bottle from the dreams of Scheherazade, and I couldn't
see the Ming. I was feeling deflated when, looking up from a job lot of
culinary articles, I saw a man whom I knew, Herr Kapitan von Kluckner,
the foreign Military Attaché. I should not probably have paid to him any
attention had he not met my eyes with a frown of displeasure and changed
his quick, purposeful step into the saunter of an idle foreigner,
sneering at the oddities of London. I watched him curiously from a
distance and was still more surprised to see him entering a barber's shop
on the east side of the market.

"Now, what in the world induces the elegant Military Attaché to come up
to the Caledonian Market to get himself shaved?" I asked, and Agatha, for
once on the spot, pointed to the name above the shop, and said: "Do you
think that Mr. Straws alters his name and writes music in his spare

A week or so later I began to meet the Herr Kapitän here and there at
luncheon or at dinner. I suppose that he had his spies poking their noses
and their sharp ears into all sorts of places. Anyway, at one house,
where I had been losing a great deal of money, he took me aside for a drink
and talked. It was absurd that there should be any enmity between the two
countries. In fact, they could now help each other very considerably
without compromising each other's independence. Each country stood
primarily for itself--that was clear. But; apart from that clear
principle, there were many smaller opportunities of mutual help. "For
instance..." he began, and broke off as others approached us. He talked
for a few minutes, and then said he must be off, for he had a busy day in
front of him. "I must get myself shaved, today," he said with a laugh as
he smoothed his chin, and away he went. He had made an appointment with
me. That's what it came to I had long since made up my mind that the
barber's shop was a letter-box in which spies could post their letters.
But it was more than that. It was a house of assignation, and I felt that
it was a duty to discover what the Herr Kapitän was up to.

But he wouldn't know my motive and it was like his impertinence to expect
me. A curtain covered the doorway of Mr. Straws' establishment. It led
into a passage at the side of the shop, and a man was waiting in the
passage. He marched off to the back of the house without a word and, in a
room too mean and undistinguished for a design so vast, a proposal was
made to me. The destruction of a race. The death of Egypt. Not by shells
or bombs or fire but by subtler weapons. Heroin, cocaine, hashish!
Children would not be born, work would not be done, starvation would
follow, and a decadent people would make place for the legions of the

I was dazzled. England would share, of course, and England, in
contributing the Dagger Line, could pull an oar. It was a nightmare
turned into an idea. It was colossal. It was a prairie fire with its
rolling smoke, its roar and its crackle and its glare, eating up the dead
dry grass. I walked out with a good fat cheque in my pocket and my head

It wasn't so difficult. We had freighters as well as passenger ships. I
had served in both the South American and the Eastern trade, and knew the
routine of the ports. We shipped a good deal of furniture, most of it
sound, of course, but, betwixt and between, pieces which held a fortune.
We had help, too. A consul would want a new consular outfit--not that he,
good man, was ever aware of it. But the outfit would arrive all right in
a fine big trunk and would be collected on the quay by a dragoman (of
sorts) who could pass his stuff through the Customs without examination.
Sometimes it was a case of books, which never reached the library of the
Minister who didn't expect it. We picked the cargo up in our small
freighters from surprising places. Sofia gave us--when I say gave, there
was no giving in that trade--a good deal at ports in the east of Europe.
But, of course, notes had to be written, commitments acknowledged,
receipts sent. The trading bills were all Sir Garnet, of course. But,
keeping pace with those bills, there were more intimate acknowledgments
to be made. My Herr Kapitän saw to that.

I don't think that I was careless. There was once a letter which I wrote
in Pevensey Crescent and which I thought that I had posted. I had a new
servant just about then. There was another which was not received, a
little too frank about some freight from Sofia which we were to pick up
at Salonika. Those two letters worried me a little, and I got rid of my
servant, thinking that the carelessness was his. Until one morning a
message came over the telephone from Horbury. It came to Pevensey
Crescent. He said that he had two interesting documents upon which he
would be honoured if I would give him my advice. I was alarmed. I didn't,
know Horbury, but I knew that blackmail was his business, and the fact
that I was comfortably paying off my debts may well have attracted his
attention. But I did know Olivia. I had met her at supper parties and at
dances more than once. I couldn't believe that she had married that
pigeon-toed old beetle for anything but his money. She was always easy to
look at and she had moments of great beauty. I had nursed an idea that
one day, when I had a bit more time, we might see a good deal more of one
another. So I thought that it might be prudent if I probed her a little
before I answered Daniel.

So I called on her in her ormulu flat in Park Lane that afternoon. As a
rule with women I have been fairly astute. I have made my approaches with
discretion and, on the whole, I have not been unfortunate. But this time
I was out of breath, as it were, and I rushed my fences.

She was difficult. I stammered a few love passages and she supplied with
a kindly smile the words for which, in my passion, I was supposed to be
at a loss. Disconcerting! I gave her my private telephone number at the
office and I told her that I gave it to very few, She wrote it down
carefully in a little book, saying, "Harem, I suppose, is the operative

I asked her casually whether Daniel had spoken to her about me, and she
replied "Oh, no," as if I were not nearly grown up enough to interest
Daniel. Then she gave me a cup of China tea and a cucumber sandwich and
sent me away. I ought to have left in a rage, but I felt like a cat. If
you say "Puss, puss, puss, lovely pussie," it just walks away, but if you
pull its tail and turn your back on it, it rubs itself against your legs.
I began, in fact, to ring her up on my private line.

But I had, nevertheless, to make an appointment with Daniel. He had the
receipt and the details of the cargo at Salonika, and there was no
getting round them. Horbury was formal and grave. As a legislator, he had
his duty to do. I must see that. He ought to send these papers straight
to the Public Prosecutor. But he had no wish to be hard, and if he sent
them to Septimus, the harm would be stopped, and I should escape a long
term of penal servitude.

"'Why not say a stretch?" I inquired, foolishly disdainful.

"Because a stretch is only a year, and I couldn't promise you that," he

"Boys will be boys," was his next line, "but happily you can't sin
without payment, or civilisation would be down the drain. Oh, Daniel
Horbury knew his stuff, and I left his office a slave. What I got from
Herr Kapitän Peter I had to pay to Legislator Paul, and the more the
better. But that wasn't the worst of it..."

Here Maltby lifted his eyes from his manuscript.

"We can realise, without reading of it, the perpetual terror which George
Crottle endured. So I come at once to his account of the Thursday night
when he obeyed Horbury's summons and paid his first visit to White Barn."

Hanaud sat forward on the edge of his chair; his perplexities were to be
resolved. Mr. Ricardo saw the gulls swooping and wheeling over Battersea
Bridge on the sunlit morning when he drove out of London to Lordship
Lane. Maltby turned over a couple of typewritten pages of lamentations
and resumed his tale.


I didn't intend murder. I had played with the grim word sometimes during
the last months, no doubt; and I had the blue-handled knife. I bought it
a long time ago in Uruguay, and, being at the age when what you want to
do you want to do one plus, I got proficient in throwing it. It had lain
in an old box, but I got it out. Did you ever notice how many commons
there are close to London with small woods on them where you can wander
most of the day and never meet a soul? I had reason to, for I acquired a
greater proficiency than I had ever had. I could pin a strip of white
paper round the trunk of a tree, walk away with my knife in its sheath
within my breast pocket, turn, and it seemed that as I flashed my hand
the white paper split and the knife was quivering in the bark. I carried
it about with me always. But that was not because I definitely meant to
use it, but because the possession of it, the sense of it against my
ribs, made me feel less paltry.

Of course the idea must have been in my mind. I had, in fact, prepared a
hidey-hole for myself in the West Country in case it should be necessary.
But I had never formulated a time or a place or a definite point of the
dialogue which I should reach before--before the collar of white paper
split. Certainly I did not on this Thursday evening. For I took Preedy
with me. Preedy was a smart, quick, sedulous small-job attorney who had
been very useful in resisting claims when I was in trouble and in
settling them when I was better off. I had managed, in return, to slip
him into the company's affairs. A few small cases which he handled very
well did his reputation a world of good. He was devoted to me, and I
certainly should not have taken him to White Barn had I definitely meant
to turn the grim word into fact. Indeed, he was so angry that I had
allowed myself to be blackmailed without consulting him, that I seldom
mentioned Horbury to him at all.

There's only one answer to the blackmailer--no answer. A lagging, like
God's sunlight, hots it up for the blackmailer as well as the
blackmailed, and the blackmailer knows it.

But this particular summons, made, of course, over the telephone to
Pevensey Crescent, hinted at mutual benefits and a settlement. Preedy
wanted to go first and look round before I came. We had neither of us
visited White Barn before, but Horbury had given me the bearings so
accurately that a mistake could hardly be made. Preedy arrived in his
small car a few minutes after half-past nine. A small garage stood on the
left-hand side of the house, but the door was locked and the little
courtyard was empty. A light, however, was burning in the hall and
Preedy, leaving his car on the right of the yard, rang the bell. The
lock, he noticed, was of the Yale kind. A man who was undoubtedly, to
Preedy's thinking, Horbury, opened the door and silently contemplated a

"This is Mr. Horbury's house?" asked Preedy.

"But there's no fishing," said Daniel, and he began to close the door.

"George has not arrived?" Preedy asked again quickly.

"No," said Horbury, "but we are expecting the Dragon along at any
moment," and he closed the door a little more.

"I am on the staff of the Dagger Line," Preedy hurried to explain, "and I
am George Crottle's private solicitor."

For a moment Daniel Horbury was disturbed. Then his face cleared and
split with a grin.

"Upon my word," he said heartily, "in George's place I should have
brought my solicitor with me, too. Meanwhile, come in and meet the

Mr. Alan Preedy looked and looked again, and drew a deep breath. Olivia
laughed and blushed.

"I must apologise, Mrs. Horbury," said Preedy. "For the most honest
compliment I have ever received," and then Preedy says, to the surprise
of them both, he lifted up a finger.

"Crottle's here," he said quietly, and with so much certainty that, after
a moment of stupor, they began to peer into the corners of the room.
Preedy smiled.

"He has just crossed the Turnpike Road into the Lane."

"Has he now?" cried Horbury, suddenly, as he thought, tumbling to the
joke. He listened and nodded "He's wearing shoes with crêpe soles."

"He's driving an Austin twelve," Preedy corrected, and suddenly a small
car drove into the courtyard and stopped.

"My word!" said Horbury. He saw vistas of high service done for him by
Alan Preedy. The man might hear the most valuable conversations from
impossible distances. "You and I must have a talk, Mr. Preedy, one of
these days," and, as if to emphasise the wish, the front-door bell rang

It was I who rang. The season was the season of full moon, and a silver
light, daylight almost without its harshness, made the world suave and
nearly kind Preedy's car stood to the right of White Barn, and there was
room for me to park mine between his car and the door.

Horbury came to the front door. He did not offer to shake my hand, but
his voice cooed: "Your first visit to my refuge, Mr. Crottle? You'll
hope, no doubt, that it will be the last." He opened a cupboard by the
side of the front door and I saw his light brown overcoat hanging on a
peg. "What, no overcoat? You boys! Your friend Preedy's just the same.
Wish I could risk it."

"So Preedy's before me?" I said as I hung my hat next to Horbury's

"Yes, he's talking to Olivia in the garden-room."

I stood, a little startled. "Mrs. Horbury is here, too?"

Horbury nodded his head. "She knows nothing of our little secret and
there'll be no necessity to go into details. But I'm no chauffeur, and
the fewer people who know of our meeting here, the better. Olivia drove
me down. Romantic, eh? Back to the old house in the suburbs! We shall
sleep here to-night after you have gone. Just the two of us in the empty
house. Beautiful!" And he reached up and snapped the light off in the
hall. Horbury's little speech was steeped in malice and the grin on his
face was impish. He stood very still in the black hall, listening to me
breathing and no doubt savouring it with enjoyment. Playing with fire?
No, but with a long, heavy, blue-handled knife. No doubt it was very

"Might I hear what you have to say to me?" I said quietly. "The nut,
after all, can't be expected to enjoy the cracks of the crackers, even if
they are wisecracks."

Horbury threw open the door of the lighted garden-room.

"Beautiful, you know Mr. George Crottle, don't you," said Horbury with a
chuckle. "Isn't it a disgrace to me that you thought of this wonderful
name for Olivia before I did?"

He knelt down by the fire and warmed his hands. "Chilly, these nights,"
he said as he stood up again. I didn't answer. On the floor, by the side
of a table, a small chart was pinned on a board. But I wasn't curious
about that. I saw Olivia come forward from her corner. She was dressed in
a black gown of satin with a short coat of white ermine which, as the
room grew warm, she had thrown open. Against the background of fur, the
slender white neck and throat rose from the black gown, too slender, it
seemed, for that small head with its heavy coronal of hair. She was as
delicate to the eye as china, rose-white, with the velvet of the crimson
rose upon her lips, a creature of health and fire. And I hated her. So
they've made a joke of me! Robbed me and laughed at me. A harlequin on a
string--that's what I am; and quite slowly I slid my left hand down the
breast of my jacket. The comforting hard feel! Beautiful? Yes, she was at
that moment, with a look of concern upon her face and question in her
eyes. Very likely she knew nothing of this blackmailing business, knew
only that I made love to her and laughed at me for my pains. I think that
I began to hate her at that moment.

"You go over there, Beautiful," said Horbury, "and smoke a cigarette
whilst I have a word or two with these gentlemen."

Olivia moved away to a cushioned chair at the corner of the wall. Horbury
invited me to a seat on the divan and sat himself on a chair with its
back to the wall and with the little table in front of him with a
blotting-book upon it--a lady's blotting-book from a suburban drawing
room. Buhl and mother-of-pearl. Preedy--you have to take note of him, if
you please--he found a chair with arms like the chair at Horbury's table,
a good chair of Chinese Chippendale with a seat of crimson brocade, and
moved it a little so that he sat with his back to the wall on the side of
the fireplace opposite to Horbury. Thus all three, Preedy, Horbury and
Olivia, were sitting in a parallel, facing the garden windows. I alone
sat with my back to them. Not that that mattered, for the blinds were
pulled down and the curtains drawn across them. Horbury, Preedy and I, on
the other hand, made an isosceles triangle, of which I was the apex,
Preedy and Horbury the angles at the base.

Horbury then told us the story of Bryan Devisher, which Preedy, with his
lawyer's eye for facts, condensed into a few sentences.

"There was a lady with a very rich husband in a very big house in the
Bayswater Road. She loved the graceful Bryan, and he pinched her pearls,
lovely pearls, milk and moonlight. This, remember, was before the Japs
had taught the oyster their barbarous efficiency. He sold the pearls to a
French jeweller. I think he tried the usual trick of substituting a lump
of coal, but it didn't work. Where the cash went, it is, perhaps, not
necessary to state."

"And how do you know all this?" Horbury exclaimed, startled.

"The lady who loved so unwisely brought her secrets to me in the Gray's
Inn Road," Preedy returned.

"And you advised her.."

"To make a clean breast of it to her husband." He smiled idiotically. "A
happy metaphor, what?"

"You mean, you advised her to confess to her husband that she had loved
and been robbed?"

"I did," said Preedy, and I blew a long whistle of derision.

"I hope," he said with dignity, "that I should give the same correct
advice to erring wives on all occasions. But I am bound to admit that
there were special reasons in this case. Devisher had been spirited away;
and although strong suspicions pointed to certain people, there wasn't
actual evidence."

"And she took your advice?" I asked.

"She did. There was the usual uproar. The police were called in. The
husband was going to have a divorce, a resonant, shattering divorce.
Wasn't he just? Then it died down. The pearls came back, you see. The
French jeweller had to give them up, since that's the law. Then the
husband recollected that he had run out of the course once or twice
himself and that he wanted to get into Parliament and reckoned that it
wouldn't help to let the electors see what his wife thought of him.
Finally came an evening when he had a good dinner, and a successful game
of bridge, when his wife looked her best in her prettiest frock, and we
ring down the curtain on a domestic scene."

"And what has all this to do with me?" I cried.

"Wait, sir, if you please," said Preedy, and then, "Ah!" as Horbury
stooped and picked up the chart from the floor.

Horbury glanced again at Alan Preedy in surprise. "Then you know of this,
too?” he asked, tapping the ebony board.



"Hanaud, the French detective, called on me at five-thirty this
afternoon. He came straight from Victoria Station. But continue, please!
My friend's impatient!"

Daniel Horbury described the journey of El Rey. "I marked on this chart,
from Lloyd's reports, the harbours at which the ship discharged its
undesirables. It signalled Prawle Point at six this morning and will
discharge her English batch at Gravesend to-morrow morning. One of that
batch is Bryan Devisher."

He stood up and, laying the flat of his left hand upon the blotting-book
as if he needed its support, took from the mantelshelf a thin little dark
blue book. When he sat down again he was aware of a change in the room, a
tension, a greater depth in the silence. He looked sharply towards me and
saw that my eyes were fixed with more than a little concern upon Preedy.
He had been sitting up straight and fairly stiff against the wall, but
was, now stiffer than ever and withdrawn into some solitude of his own.
His face was shuttered, his eyes blank, he gave me the impression of some
lonely lighted house in the country which has suddenly gone black at the
distant wail of a warning.

"You weren't listening to me?" cried Horbury roughly.

He obviously liked to be listened to, as a Member of Parliament should
be. Preedy's eyes--I can't say opened--for they were open before, but they
lived again and a smile took the severity from his face and deepened the
wrinkles at the corners of his mouth.

"Believe me, I was listening," said Preedy. "You are proposing a deal, I

Horbury leaned back in his chair. "You are quick, Mr. Preedy."

"We have to be in the Gray's Inn Road." he retorted. "You want a cabin."


"On the Dagger Line."


"For Bryan Devisher?"

"As soon as can be."


"I don't mind as long as it's far away and there's a job for him at the
end of it," said Horbury.

"On the Company's staff?"

"That would be desirable," said Daniel Horbury.

"And what do you offer in return?"

Horbury's replies had been thought out, but they were no quicker than
Preedy's questions, which came rattling on the answers like the sharp
bursts of a machine-gun. Horbury relaxed now, smiling contentedly. "Ah
There we are!" he said.

"Are we?"

"To be sure."

Daniel had no doubts. If there was no eagerness in Preedy's face, there
was enough of it in mine.

"I propose that a couple of letters which, if I had strictly regarded my
duty to my country, I should have sent to the Public Prosecutor, but
which I have addressed to Mr. Septimus Crottle, should be handed over for
delivery to Mr. George Crottle."

I interrupted here with a good deal too much fervour to please my
solicitor Preedy.

"We have a ship the Sheriff, sailing from Southampton at five o'clock
to-morrow afternoon. We have a cabin or two free. One of the firm usually
goes to Southampton to see the firm's ship off, and it's my turn

No doubt I was a little too ready to agree. I was indeed ready to invite
the unknown Devisher, to travel in my car to Southampton, when Preedy
objected: "Even so, he'll want a new passport, won't he?"

Daniel Horbury handed him the small blue book. Preedy turned it over and
opened it.

"The photograph was taken more than six years ago," agreed Horbury.

"When you sent him gun-running to Venezuela," Preedy replied. He turned
to the page with the photograph and nodded his head.

"Yes, I expect that that will get him on board, especially if he motors
with you."

He gave me a nod and a smile. There was, after all, very little which got
by Alan Preedy. But he had, nevertheless, not done with his difficulties.
"But will he go? There's no case against him. The pearls are back, the
wife and husband reconciled."

"But he doesn't know that," said Horbury. "Besides, the Frenchman's
here, you said."


"Acting for Gravot of the Place Vendôme."

Again Preedy grinned at Horbury. "I see you know the name all right.
Curious, isn't it?" But Horbury was not the sort of man to be offended by
a little sarcasm. He didn't even blush, and Preedy continued. "Hanaud
says Gravot has cooled down, too. He doesn't want any extradition. He
wants his cash back."

"But Devisher doesn't know that either. Besides, he probably hasn't got a
farthing, and a pleasant cruise on a tip-top liner with a comfortable
easy job at the end of it--not too bad," Horbury explained anxiously.
"Further," and he looked down at the table and added with a hard note in
his voice, "he's obnoxious to me."

Preedy laughed.

"Obnoxious is an excellent word. A dandy of a word. All right! When you
hand over to me the letter to Septimus Crottle...."

"On the quay-side."

"I see."

Preedy tucked the passport away in his pocket. "You'll go down by


"Then I'll go in George's car and hand over the passport to Devisher as
you hand the letter to George."

Horbury beamed. "Good!" he cried, He sprang up from his chair and, still
supporting himself with the flat of his left hand, took a cigar from the
mantelshelf and bit off the end.

"The ship is the Sheriff," I said, and I gave the number of the quay at
which she berthed.

Horbury took a pen from his waistcoat pocket, lifted a tiny corner of the
blotting-book and wrote the name Sheriff upon it. Then he put the pen
away in his pocket, lit the cigar and blew a ring of smoke into the air.

"There!" he said, a man conscious of a rather virtuous day's work. "Now
it's all Sir Garnet."

I suppose that since I have already used it, I got that old phrase from
him. Anyway, he folded his fat arms across his chest and concentrated on
blowing exactly rounded rings of smoke into the air. I expect that he was
wondering why we didn't get up from our chairs, say "Until to-morrow, by
the Sheriff," and take our leave. I was wondering that, too, but, after
all, if you bring a solicitor with you, you're a mug if you don't use
him. I watched Preedy. He sat stiff and straight against the wall and
looked as if he didn't mean to move until the Day of Judgment. He was
puzzled, too, and annoyed. Finally he seemed to flare up.

"What I don't understand, Mr. Horbury, is why all the flummery? Why all
the pretence? Surely we can fix everything now and have done with it?"

"My dear fellow!" cried Horbury. "My dear fellow!" and even to me, Preedy
at that moment seemed a daunting figure. He sat up so inhumanly straight,
he spoke with so impersonal a tone, he gazed with so unwinking a stare
across the room. One of the gods or kings from the Old Nile come back to
sit in judgment.

"My dear fellow, I wouldn't of course bring those letters here, no, not
I!"; and the way in which he held tightly pressed against each other the
covers of his blotting-book proved to me that there was a good deal more
than the word 'Sheriff' between the leaves.

I couldn't help wondering for a moment whether, for all his
effectiveness, I had been wise to bring Preedy. If Horbury and I had been
alone, those infernal letters might already have been in the fire and an
order for a cabin on the Sheriff in Horbury's pocket. But we were two men
against one, and the rules of the game which we were playing excluded
neither violence nor any kind of treachery.

"They are safely locked away where they can't be found," he exclaimed
with a slobbering sort of laugh, and Preedy cut in across his words very
quietly now.

"I wasn't thinking of your bits of paper," he said.

He moved at last. It was curiously startling to see. His head turned
round until he faced Horbury and he asked, with the annoyance most people
feel when they see someone complicating a perfectly simple question: "Why
on earth don't you let him in?"

In reply to Horbury's look of bewilderment, he stretched out an arm with
his forefinger pointed towards the curtained windows across the room.
Even then no one except Olivia at once understood. She had been sitting
not far away, forgotten in the urgency of our deal, but alert to each
step of it and to the three characters who were conducting it. She rose
from her chair and turned towards us. Was there something protective in
her attitude? In her mere rising from her chair? Something which cleared
the fog from Daniel's brain? His eyes followed the line of Preedy's arm,
straight as a bar to the finger's end.

"Let who in?"


Horbury tried to scoff. "Rubbish!" he cried, and laughed, but the laugh
was more of a sob of anxiety than a laugh. "Devisher is at this moment
tumbling up and down in an old iron ship off Beachy Head" and then in an
appeal for confirmation, "Isn't that true?"

Preedy's answer came at once, not to be denied; and the very gentleness
of his voice made it more than ever implacable. "I have heard the
footsteps of a man for the last half-hour. I could almost draw a map of
your garden from the sound of them."

No other words could have so affected Horbury. They were the drops in the
laboratory phial which change in a second the red to blue. Terror swept
over him. He saw a panther slinking, padding his garden paths, waiting
for the guests to go--Devisher. It was one thing to send an agent to
Gravesend who would promise compensation, claim El Rey's passenger as his
friend, wrap him in the favour of a Member of Parliament and bring him
along to King Street, St. James's, in broad daylight. It was quite
another thing to find him hiding in this quiet garden for a solitary
interview with him in an empty house. Horbury uttered a little screech
and his face turned yellow. The whole casing of the man collapsed, his
small mouth dropped open--it looked horrid, obscene, and his eyes could
not turn from the curtains.

There was no doubt why he was afraid. He had sent Devisher out of the
country and then betrayed him to that soft-hearted man, the Dictator of
Venezuela. He had imagined himself free of him until the Judgment Day and
here he was in the moonlit garden of White Barn with six years of the
Castillo del Libertador behind him. I had never seen so much fear made
visible. And I enjoyed it! My word, how I enjoyed it!

"You are afraid, Mr.Daniel Horbury," I said with a chuckle of pleasure
"You don't mind facing a body of shareholders thirsting for your blood. A
mellifluous voice and silky-smooth words, and they want to give you what
you've left them. But one man with a nasty account to settle, waiting in
a lonely garden--that's quite a different affair."

And quietly, just as quietly as Preedy talked, Olivia came across the
room to Horbury's side.

"Hold your tongue," she said to me.

Why couldn't she stay in her corner? It wasn't her business we were
discussing. She had been told to stay there. But he was throwing out his
left hand to her and she took it and held it and willed him to

"Well, if he is here--I don't see how he can be--yes, we had better get him
in," he quavered, "whilst we're all together. Then, when we've settled
everything, Mr. Preedy, perhaps, will take him back to town."

Nobody said a word. Nobody doubted that somehow, translated from the
moonlit Channel, Devisher was waiting in the moonlit garden. Olivia put
an end to the tension. She uttered a little cry of revolt. "I can't bear

Preedy's arm fell straight to his side--a decision given and not to be
gainsaid. Olivia moved--did she ever walk?--across the room to the

"Let us make quite sure first," Horbury quavered.

"You must put out the lights, then."

"Oh, no," Horbury wailed, but no one took any notice of him at all.

There was but the one switch to control all the lights in the room,
although, here and there, the walls were plugged for standard lamps, and
that switch was at the side of the door into the hall. I stood up and,
after turning round, walked to the door. It was set in the wall at a
right-angle to the garden wall. I turned. Preedy still sat stiff against
his wall like the effigy of a god. Horbury had been smoking a cigar when
the warning of Devisher's presence had stunned him. The cigar had fallen
from his mouth and bounced upon the table. He had put it into his mouth
again and, just in order to do something, was drawing upon it, though
only the tiniest grey spirals of vapour curled up from an edge and the
end was as black as that ebony board on which the chart was fixed.

Olivia stood by the curtains. "Wait! The fire," she said.

"It is out," I answered, but the grate was obscured from me by the back
of the divan.

"Then go!" Olivia ordered, and I turned down the switch. But I had been
wrong about the fire. As the darkness fell, one of the logs sent forth a
little spurt of flame which strengthened into a flickering blaze and
gleamed upon the white ceiling and sparkled in every polished panel in
the room. I heard a small gasp of relief from Horbury--how he was
petrified by this ordeal!--and though I took no stock of it, I noticed
that the spiral of smoke from his black cigar was a trifle heavier.

The log moved in the grate, the spurt of flame died altogether, the fire
was out and the last glimpse of Daniel Horbury was gone.

"Now," Olivia whispered.

Without letting one ring rattle upon the pole, she drew the curtains
apart so that one panel of the long glass door was exposed from the
lintel to the ground. A thin curtain of brown linen hung over it and the
moon made of it a sheet of silver and dappled the floor about its edges
with pools of silver, but left the hollow of the room black with the
depth of a Rembrandt.

Except for the shadows of some boughs of the oak trees in the meadow
beyond the garden, the screen was blank. Yet so completely had Preedy
taken the mastery of our minds that no one holding his breath in the darkness of the room doubted that he had only to wait in order to see it

One could not see or hear Olivia move, but a sharp click rang like a
pistol shot through the darkness. She had unlocked the glass door. Again
one could not see or hear Olivia move, but I know now that without
touching chair or table she slipped back to her seat in the corner of the
room. I remained by the light switch at the angle, and suddenly a figure
was on the blind, to me at all events it looked gigantic and grotesque.
Daniel Horbury yelped--there is no other word for the sharp, queer cry of
pain which broke from him. But the figure advanced and the nearer it
came, the less formidably supernatural it became. It was now no more than
a huge man, clumsy but dangerous still, for it lurched this way and that,
a night bird scouting for a victim. And now, as he advanced yet nearer,
he was slender as a youth and his twistings mere hesitation and timidity.
He wore a felt hat and, since his back was towards the moon, it was
impossible to distinguish his features. As if he were tired of waiting
for the cars in the courtyard to take their departure, he came forward
on tip-toe across a gravel path and laid his ear against the glass pane of
the door. Satisfied, apparently, that the room was empty, he tried the
handle and the glass door swung open at his touch. He stepped over the
threshold silently and easily into--of course--an empty room.

"Who's there?"

This wasn't the challenge of the buccaneer. His voice was a whisper, his
question an appeal.

"Devisher!" cried Horbury.

No one answered him. But Bryan Devisher had not spent six years in the
dungeons of the Castillo del Libertador for nothing. He knew his mistake
as soon as he had made it. There were others in the room besides
Horbury. He sprang to one side out of that picture frame of moonlight.

"This is a trap, what?"

And, by the most wondrous luck, Horbury's cigar glowed red. He had puffed
and drawn the black thing into life, unaware of what he was doing.
Devisher flung the curtains across the glass door. There was no caution
about the rings on the pole this time. They rattled like all the clogs on
the French market stones. His voice changed to anger.

"A trap!" he repeated.

Oh, it was Devisher--and my great moment. Never did I deserve it. He
dashed for the door, close at my side, stopped, searched for the handle,
breathing hard. And precisely then, with one movement, as I had been
taught, I tore the knife from its sheath and flung it. It sped true,
true, true, with a hiss. For the fraction of a second I saw it by the
light of Horbury's cigar curve down and inwards and take him by the
throat. I heard a horrible gurgle, a heavy fall of a heavy body upon the
table, a jet like a fountain bursting, and a burning cigar described a
circle in the air. But I had my own to do. Devisher was dragging and
scuffling at the door. He had forgotten, in his absence of more than six
years the height of the handle from the ground and whether the door
opened inwards or outwards. I grappled with him, the blood surging in
every vein. I was free from the old rogue with the lovely voice and the
silky-smooth words and the cruelty of a cat.

"No, you don't!" I cried. "You don't get away like that! No, sir!"

But I found the handle for him nonetheless, and tore open the door. He
had shaken me off and flung himself through the doorway in a trice. I
didn't make it very difficult for him. He was as panic-stricken as old
dead Demosthenes Junior had been, but he kept his wits and, once he was
out in the hall, he slammed the door hard and locked us all in. In the
sudden silence, drop-drop-drop, measured like the drops from a medicine
bottle, pattered on the floor. Olivia's voice rose in a scream.

"Lights! Lights! Lights!"

Never did Hamlet's uncle call for them so eagerly. I turned the switch
and the room sprang to light.

Preedy stooped, picked up a burning cigar from the mat and tossed it into
the fire. So far as I remember, that was the third movement he had made
during that evening.


Olivia was near to the centre of the room when the lights were turned
on. Horbury's gross body had fallen forward over the blotting-book and
the table, but in his panic he had drawn its legs so tightly to him as a
defence that he was wedged in his chair. His head was turned towards me,
so that she could not see the wound at his throat. But the pool of blood
upon the floor and the blue-handled knife amongst it could have left her
in no doubt of his death. She did not touch him but she covered her face
with her hands, and then, taking them away, said in a pitiful quiet
voice: "Daniel! Oh, Daniel!"

I was hurt by her appeal. You may think that unimportant, but I was. It
sounded as if a child were complaining of some injustice and asking for
it to be explained to her; and explained by the one man who would never
explain anything any more--not even to an assembly of shareholders in the
Cannon Street Hotel who wanted to know where their dividends had gone to.
Did I utter some sort of cry? I don't know, but I felt that her face
turned suddenly towards me. In a fluster I rattled the handle of the

"He has locked us in."

As I spoke I heard the whirr of an engine starting. And a car turned to
the left out of the courtyard and raced down to the Turnpike Road, the
noise of the engine dwindling as it went.

"He has locked us all in together," she said, and it seemed to me that a
cruel, bitter little smile for a second on her lips. "There has been
murder done. We must ring up the police."

She was walking back towards the telephone on the long table close to the
corner in which she had been sitting, when once more Preedy took charge.

"Wait, please, Mrs. Horbury!"

Olivia stopped and turned. "Why? There has been murder done."

Again she looked straight at me. Did she know? Yes, but by nothing she
had seen or heard. Perhaps her soul had claimed the truth from me and
mine had been forced to answer. My secret was hers, too, I felt quite
sure, and fortunately Preedy was there to stand between us.

"Murder, if you will," he said clearly. "He has stolen one of our cars,
Crottle's or mine." There was a look of bewilderment in Olivia s eyes
"This man, Devisher, Bryan Devisher," Preedy explained. "But he can't get
far. If you telephone now, he may very likely be caught within the hour.
And then, of course, nothing could save him. He had suffered damnably--I
am sorry to say it here and now--at Horbury's hands. If ever a man had a
motive to take the law into his hands, Bryan Devisher had."

"Bryan Devisher?" she repeated thoughtfully.

"He has come straight from South America. I suppose that he had planned
somehow to arrive a day before his time. He waits in the garden of a
house he knew, no doubt well, in olden days, until he thinks the coast is
clear. He uses a South American way of adjusting his wrongs and, as you
said, locks us all in together and bolts."

"Bryan Devisher?" Olivia repeated. When she used the name before she had
been bewildered. Now she was realising how exactly he fitted the niche
which was being built for him--Bryan Devisher, Murderer.

"Yes, no doubt he can be caught, tried, hanged. It is as you will."

Olivia looked at Preedy. She transferred her thoughts to him. He was now
the antagonist, not I.

"You see," he went on, speaking reasonably, "Crottle and I are here. We
are the witnesses. We saw Horbury in a panic. We saw Devisher come into
the room with the moonlight behind him. We heard the swish of the knife,
the struggle of George Crottle to arrest him, the slamming of the door,
and the key turned in the lock."

How could she fight all this evidence? But she stood where she was,
giving no ground.

"But why were we here?" he resumed. "George Crottle and Preedy, his
lawyer. What were we doing at White Barn on this night? We shall be
asked. And we shall have to answer."

"What will you answer?"

The question was stubborn and resentful. It matched her white, still
face, the upright defiance of her stance.

"The truth," answered Preedy. "We were blackmailed. The wickedest crime
in the Calendar of Justice. Worse than murder, judges say. More cruel,
more"--and his voice dropped a little out of consideration for her, but
lost none of its determination--"more mean."

Her head flashed up in revolt against the word and dropped again.

"If it's not murder, then, what is it?" she asked.


It was a hard choice and Preedy left it so. The decision must be hers.
She stood and shifted a foot, following the pattern of the carpet whilst
she made it, She might accuse me, of course. I could see the thought in
her mind as she lifted a rebellious face towards me. But, if I had
planned murder, should I have brought my lawyer with me to see it done?
Devisher was so much the more obvious criminal and usually the obvious
criminal is the right criminal. Moreover, she wouldn't want the wrong man
to go to the scaffold and she wouldn't want to listen to a true story of
blackmail by Daniel and the judge's comments upon it. She suddenly sat
down upon a chair as though her knees failed her.

"He was very good to me," she said in a whisper, her head bowed, her
hands clasped together. And the battle was over.

"We must have the door unlocked," said Preedy briskly. "Perhaps Mrs.
Horbury will do it, since you have a key."

Olivia looked blank until Preedy pointed out that she would have to go
round by the garden and let herself in at the front door.

"Oh, yes."

She fetched her handpbag from the chair in the corner and took from it a
bunch of keys. She thrust the curtain aside and the moonlit garden seemed
to be waiting for her.

"There was once a tree spoiling all the prospect," she said with a little
break in her voice. "Oh, not a beech tree, but just a negligible Scotch
fir, and I had it cut down, so that the eyes travel without fatigue
across the lawn to a sunk fence and beyond that over the long meadow to
the Turnpike Road. I had a curious sense of freedom when the tree had

She stood looking out and behind her the blood from Horbury's throat
which had splashed upon the table began again to slip from its polished
surface. Again it fell slowly and horribly, one and one and one. The
sound seemed to hush all the world so that it might be heard the better.
Olivia's face was twisted with pain. She turned and flung the words at

"Do you hear? You with the quick ears? Doesn't each drop cry aloud for

"I'm thinking of the cost of vengeance," he replied, "to all of us. To
you. And even to him."

Olivia turned back to the window. I think that she saw Horbury alive and
in the dock, sentenced. For she whispered, more to herself than to either
of us: "Day after endless day. The vision--this--" and she reached out her
hand towards the meadows and the trees, "narrowing with each year until
it vanished."

She spoke as if you could punish a dead body. Then she did the last thing
I wanted her to do. She took the key of the door from the small ring of
keys which she held. She offered it, shining in the palm of her hand, to

"One of you. I stay with my man."

There was a gleam of admiration of her in Preedy's eyes, and when he
bowed to her, as he did, it was, I think, as much to conceal a little
smile of defeat as to acknowledge her words with respect.

"You, George," he said to me, and Olivia turned her hand above an
occasional table. As she walked away from it towards her dead husband's
side, the key tinkled on the mahogany surface.

I took it, went out by the garden door and round by a little path to the
front of the house. I noticed that it was my small car, the one nearest
to the front door, which Devisher had taken. Then I let myself in. But I
didn't immediately return to the garden-room. One Yale latchkey is like
another, and I had in my pocket one which fitted the drawer of my desk. I
compared the pair by the hall lamp, but it would not do to exchange them.
Olivia's key was marked by three scratches at intervals, mine had no
clues to ownership at all. I put my own key back in my pocket. The
cupboard door stood open. My hat hung on a peg next to Horbury's coat. I
took the sheath of the knife from my coat breast pocket and, after wiping
it clean, put it into the pocket of Horbury's coat. On unlocking the door
of the garden-room I saw Preedy busily polishing the furniture frames and
the tables.

"You sat at the corner of that divan all the time," he said to me.


He began to enumerate the places where finger prints might have been found
of others besides Horbury and Olivia--the garden-door and the door into
the hall for instance.

"There's the outside of the door into the hall," he said. "Devisher will
have left the palm of his hand upon the panels."


I had a picture of Devisher slamming the door and locking us in. I turned
towards it, and Olivia said: "You will leave my key, please."

I dropped her latchkey on the same table which she had used. Polishing
the outer panels with the door half open, I saw her identify her key and
replace it on its ring. I drew a breath of relief that I had not tried to
substitute a key of my own for hers.

"There, I think that will do. Now it remains--a rather gruesome business,
I am afraid--to make a tableau which the police can reconstruct in the

Olivia drew back with a shiver. "Oh, no!"

"Must!" cried Preedy, and for the first time roughly. "It's getting late.
We can't go on advancing and retreating. We are not dancing the Lancers."

He approached her impatiently, almost threateningly. I suppose that from
the other side I closed in upon her. For she looked at me sharply and
then back again at the set and quiet features of Preedy. Quiet they were,
but there was now a menace in the room, a chill.

"There have been pacts, haven't there?" said Preedy.


She was really bewildered.

"Don't ask me to take you for a fool. You understand well enough. Pacts.
The coroners' courts are full of them."

Her eyes opened wide. She looked at Preedy. She looked at me. I think
that we must both by now have been standing quite close to her.

"Suicide pacts," she said with a little falter in her voice. But she
didn't move, not a foot, not a hand. I don't think it would have been
lucky for her if she had. We were all three as motionless as effigies.
All three might move as sedately or as violently as the plot demanded,
but not one alone. No, indeed. But I believed, I still believe, that if
she had been absolutely certain that I and not the innocent Devisher
would be convicted of the murder, she would have taken her risks of us
and let Horbury's blackmailing be exposed. But she had no such certainty.
Whatever she might say, the evidence pointed to Devisher and not to me.

"Then that's settled," said Preedy. "We all three have the same secret to
hide. Will you bring the little table--yes, the one from which you took
your key, and set it between the corner of the divan and--well, here?"

He pointed to Horbury.

"Now, please sit on the divan, your hand perhaps on the end so as to
leave your prints."

He then asked her where the champagne, the famous Pommery 'o6, was kept.
He left us together, and I can't remember a period more embarrassing.
But, in truth, he worked quickly. He came back with two goblets of the thin
glass which Horbury affected. One was half full, and that he placed on
the occasional table by Olivia. The other he set on the table over which
Horbury lay. There was just room for it. He had a cloth in his hand and
he wiped away from the glasses all traces of his own handling of them.

"Will you touch that with your fingers and your lips," he said, pointing
to the half-filled glass in front of her. But she nodded to the glass on
Horbury's table.

"That one first."

Preedy handed it to her and she drank it with a little nod and a small
wistful smile towards the horror sprawled over the table. She drank it to
the last drop, partly as a tribute to a good many pleasant hours spent
with her ogre at White Barn, partly because she was as near exhaustion as
a woman well could be. A little colour rose into her face as she handed
back the empty glass to him. Preedy balanced it once more on the table,
and then with a push toppled it off on to the ground, where the thin
glass smashed into splinters.

"We were sitting here?" she asked. "Just the pair of us?"

"Yes. Then you left him and went up to bed."

"And fell asleep?"

"Yes. You heard nothing until your servant screamed in the morning."

"And I waked," she said sardonically, and so paused and shivered, "to
find the door unlocked?"

She thought upon the endless hours of darkness during which she must lie
and listen, and perhaps hear that dead man struggling to rise from the
table. Where she had shivered, she now shuddered so that her teeth

"'What if the vigil--for that it must be--persuaded no one?" she asked.

Preedy set out his argument. Men like Horbury had always troubles which
were secret. He had weathered storms, no doubt, but men lose heart at the
last. "And so, sitting up here alone at night, and, if things were well
with him, perhaps thinking that he was, after all, doing his best for
you, he sought this way out. There is one more thing to be done, alas!"

On the floor, amidst the congealing blood, lay the long, thin-bladed
knife with its gay blue handle. Preedy knelt, took his handkerchief from
his pocket, and stooped.


The cry broke from Olivia Horbury passionately. Her eyes were ablaze, her
arm stretched out with, a pointing finger as steady as justice itself.
Preedy sat back on his heels.

"His fingers held that knife!"

That one fact swept all the arguments for our decision out of her mind.

"Yes," answered Preedy.

"His fingers were the last to hold it."


"The murderer's."

Proof was there lying in that red pool--proof which would hang.


I expostulated. Who knew but that some unlucky chance might send us a
visitor who would know us again--a stranger asking his way, a motorist who
had run short of petrol, a neighbour with sickness in the house whose
telephone was under repair. Preedy waited with his eyes on Olivia.

"There must be other ways by which guilt comes home," she said. "Let me,
please, do what must be done."

She knelt in Preedy's place. He handed her a clean handkerchief and,
taking up the heavy knife by its blade delicately from the congealing
blood in which it lay, she wiped the handle. Then, lifting it to
Horbury's out-thrown hand, she placed it in his palm and closed his
fingers about it. She opened them again. It needed now some effort, but
she made it and, still holding it by the blade under the handkerchief,
she replaced it exactly where it had lain.

"That is all?"

"Yes. We can go."


She rose to her feet and with such a look of horror upon her face as
neither of us had ever seen. She tore the curtain aside from the glass
door and passed into the garden. Heaven knows what her thoughts were, but
they did not hold her long. Long enough, however, to give me the chance
of which I had begun to despair. A steel chain ran from Horbury's waist
into his trouser pocket and the pocket gaped. At the end of the chain a
ring of keys hung by a spring hook. I had the time to release the ring
from the spring hook, replace the chain and thrust the keys into my
pocket, when the garden door was slammed fast and locked. Olivia came
back into the room and drew the curtains again so carefully that not a
fold was disarranged, not a thread of light shone out upon the lawn.

I took up the ebony board with the chart pinned upon it. Preedy was
looking about the room, touching a chair here and there with his

"We ought to have left the prints of the woman who cleans the room," he
said, "but we couldn't." He turned to me. "You turned on the lights."


He dusted the switch with the white handkerchief and I noticed that a
faint blue stain had been left upon the cambric by the handle of the

"You will leave the lights on, of course," he said to Olivia who was
following us. In the hall she latched the door and locked it. Preedy
stopped at once.

"I am afraid not," he said gently. "In the morning the door must be found

Olivia bowed her head and unlocked it. Then she held open the front door
of the house. A small breath of wind was rustling amongst the boughs of
the trees.

"There was much that was sordid--worse, if you will--in my husband's life,"
said Olivia. "You were right. I would not wish his story to be known to
the world, just so that a man called Devisher might be hanged. No!" and
she added, after a pause, "there would have to be a much better reason
than that." Though her voice was low, her eyes were fierce, her face
quite haggard and all its beauty gone. "Yes, a much stronger reason."

And upon the two men who listened to her a sense of new danger rolled
like a tide.


WE rolled Preedy's car out on to the road, although there was really no
reason for such secrecy. Preedy was in an excellent mood, one moment
whistling a tune, another assuring me in answer to some anxious question,
that it was all Sir Garnet. Certainly he was correct in one particular.
The problem of Devisher was solved.

We found my car outside the gardens of Pevensey Crescent and Devisher
inside it. He knew the truth and, at the same time, his own danger. He
wanted no trouble any more. He had already endured his life-time's share
and, knowing as much as he did, he applied with some confidence for the
opportunity of an easy life in some quiet corner of the world. This took
place over a whisky and soda in my parlour.

"What about Cairo?" I asked a little too promptly to please Preedy.

"All that has got to stop," he said. "I am going up to the Caledonian
Market myself to see about it."

"But there are cargoes arranged and some on the way."

"They will be the last," said Preedy, and he looked at Devisher. "Well,
for the moment, Cairo. Then what about Ceylon, where every prospect
pleases? They tell me that as you approach that island a delightful aroma
of spices floats out to you across the sea."

"Either place will be A.1. for me," Devisher agreed with relief.

It was arranged there and then. I was not expected at the office the next
morning. I was to start in my car with Devisher at half-past eight. There
would be traffic already on the roads and I must never exceed the speed
limit or in any way attract attention. I was to drive to Southampton
through Camberley and Hartley Row. At Basingstoke and Winchester I was to
buy some ready-made clothes, shirts, flannels, underclothes and shoes.
Devisher would have his new passport. Since I was well-known to the dock
officials, there would be no trouble at the gates. I was to make him out
a ticket in the Southampton office of the Line and see him off with the
ship. I had the resident staff part of the Line under my control and
could arrange by a telegram for his arrival at Port Said to be expected.
Then Preedy took him away for the night.

Preedy was equally confident that I should have no trouble with Olivia.
She wouldn't move, for her dead husband's sake. But, although I had not
argued, I had not agreed. The amitié amoureuse, which was all I was going
to allow her with Daniel, would in time wear off. And then? I could not
but remember the bitterness of her last words. They had frightened

I had, however, already taken Horbury's keys from his pocket and I meant
to use them that night. I remembered that whenever Horbury had risen from
his chair, he had kept a solid hand upon his blotting-book, and that when
he had written in it the name of the ship Sheriff, he had lifted the
stiff cover only just enough to use a corner of the blotting-paper. That
precious letter to Septimus was between the covers of buhl and
mother-of-pearl. Horbury had brought it to White Barn, had meant to hand it
over, but I suppose lost his confidence in us at the last minute. I meant
to get it before the police did. I don't think that Preedy had noticed me
lifting Horbury's keys. He had been too busy polishing away finger prints
and I hadn't consulted him. This, the last achievement of the night, I
proposed to carry out alone.

Instead of backing the car into the little garage at the side of my
house, I drove it away to Battersea. I would keep within the speed limit
all the way to Southampton, but there was no reason why I should follow
that good advice to-night. Night, I say, but it was half-past two in the
morning when I left the car under the trees at the side of the road. A
risk? Yes, but I had to take it. The choice lay between driving into the
courtyard and very likely arousing Olivia's attention, or leaving the car
beyond the reach of her ears The chances of a policeman discovering it
were about fifty-fifty.

There was no one whom I could see or hear. The moon was still bright and
the world asleep. I crept up to the house and let myself in with
Horbury's key, taking the bunch with me as soon as the hall door was
open. I fixed up the latch so that I could get away quickly if it became
necessary and I stood still for a few moments in the black hall,
listening, until the silence itself began to roar in my ears I moved like
a ghost to the garden-room door and noiselessly turn the handle with my
fingers wrapped in my handkerchief The lights were burning. Horbury was
sprawled across his table; but there was a change in the room since last
I had seen it--a change which caught me by the heart and stopped the blood
in my veins. The blotting-book was on its edges on the floor now instead
of lying flat under the weight of Horbury's body.

As soon as I recovered my breath, I crossed the room on tip-toe and
stooped over it. It stood half-open, the back uppermost. There was no
letter under it, none between the leaves. No danger from the woman
upstairs! Oh, wasn't there? She had come back to this room when she was
alone. She had pushed the blotting-book from under Horbury's body. I
could hear the buttons of his waistcoat scratching across the metal
cover. She had taken the letter to Septimus out of it and then she had
toppled it on to the edge of the congealing blood on the floor. What a
damnable woman! I was wondering what I should do when the telephone rang
on the long table against the wall. It wasn't possible! I stood up stiff
as a tombstone. No, it wasn't possible! Who should be ringing up White
Barn at half-past two in the morning? The love-nest? No! But there the bell
was, one, two, pause, one, two, pause. It had got to be stopped. It
wasn't until I lifted the receiver from its cradle that I realised that I
had acknowledged the call. Someone was in the house then, more, was in
the room where a man had committed suicide three to four hours before and
where he still lay sprawled across the table. I heard a voice calling
Horbury. It seemed to come out of my hand. I looked down and saw that my
hand was bare. I was not going to answer the call--not I! The noise of
ringing had ceased--that was one good thing. I took my handkerchief from
my breast-pocket with my left hand and carefully wiped the handle between
the ear and the mouthpiece. Then I replaced it on its cradle. The sound
was not renewed at all events. The caller had ceased to call.

I rubbed the sweat off my forehead. I was streaming with it. I was
thinking that, whatever happened, never in all my life could I be so
startled again. And the next moment the thought was disproved. The last
horror of that night capped all. Somewhere, above my head, a key was
turned in a lock and someone fell. I didn't stay after that. I tossed
Horbury's ring of keys on to the table by the instrument. Then I fled.
Oh, yes, even in my panic, I pulled to the door of the garden-room and
opened the front door of the house with my handkerchief about my hand. I
did it without reflecting, for I was incapable of reflection. I ran down
the lane. It was still deserted. To put the proper finish on the night, I
should have found that some thief had run away with my car. But, beyond
expectation, it was there where I had left it. I drove back to London. My
word, the lighted streets! I eased the car very gently into its garage
and went to bed.

Mistakes, of course, were made. Preedy made one on this night. He cleaned
the garden-room of fingerprints so thoroughly that the absence of them would be
suspicious. I don't see how that could have been helped, however, and I
don't count that as his mistake. Where he really went wrong was in the
matter of a bottle of Pommery '06. He opened it in the pantry without
leaving marks on it, but, having filled two glasses, he stoppered the
bottle again and put it back amongst the others. There is not very much
to be said for Daniel Horbury, but he never opened a bottle of Pommery
'06 without making sure that the very last drop was going to be squeezed
out of it.

I, however, erred more completely. I should never have taken Horbury's
keys from his pocket and returned to White Barn. I should never have
taken up the telephone receiver from its cradle. I should have slipped
Daniel's ring of keys once more upon his spring lock. But all these
errors are nothing compared with the folly I was guilty of in letting
myself go when old Sept broke down over the captivity of the young
Dauphin! It is said that I sighed! I let out a great big 'O' of delight.
For the first time I had found a weak spot in the chain-mail of the old
boy's authority. My hide-out became a prison. The Barnishes wouldn't be
sorry to have Captain Septimus under their charge for a little. Captain
Septimus had sacked Fred Barnish at five minutes' notice. A few weeks of
Arkwright's Farm for Septimus and I saw myself Chairman and Managing
Director of the Dagger Line. And then all's spoilt because a copper walks
into the farm because he suspects that Barnish is keeping a dog without
having a dog licence! Well, I ask you!

However, even so, I might perhaps have got through but for the idiot
Ricardo and the preposterous Nosey Parker from Paris.

* * * * *

Maltby was caught off his guard by the final sentence. He had meant to
leave it out altogether, but discovered himself floundering amongst the
opening words. He was then forced to read it without the omission of a
word. Mr. Ricardo flushed with shame, but Hanaud jabbed him in the ribs
with his elbow.

"Without Mr. Ricardo," he cried, "where should I be? Like the good
George, I ask you. I should still be driving over the Bridge of Battersea
amongst the seagulls. As for mistakes, it is possible that once or twice
in my life I make one," he said dreamily. "I do not know."


AT luncheon the conversation was desultory, but a few additions were
made, chiefly by Maltby, to complete the pattern of the story. For
instance, certain changes were taking place in the staff of a foreign
Embassy and a barber's shop on the edge of the Caledonian Market had been
closed down. The presence of Mordaunt, as an officer in the Egyptian
Coastguard Service, had caused one more upheaval to the unfortunate Bryan
Devisher. He had been moved on, overnight, as it were, to Delagoá Bay,
where a small trade had been carried on by the Dagger Line. He was now
dismissed from that service altogether and was working as book-keeper in
a Portuguese store. It would be for the Egyptian Government to ask for
his extradition if it thought it worth while, but it probably would not.

"And now," said Maltby, "there is one question which we all wish to ask,
Monsieur Hanaud."

Luncheon was over. Coffee smoked upon the table and a cigar, a pipe, a
cigarette smoked in the air, dimming the bright aspect of the Thames.

Monsieur Hanaud beamed.

"Ask!" he answered with simplicity.

"Where was the Crottle letter hidden?"

"And how did you find out?"

The questions were fired at him from right and left.

"It was not so difficult to find out, but it was amusing all the same.
Maltby, with Bryan Devisher and the Dagger Line and the Caledonian Market
all on his shoulders at once, he leaves that little problem to me!
Listen! The letter was in the blotting-book. Horbury had come to make a
bargain. It was not in his nature that he should not have with him his
evidence that there was a bargain to be made. That was clear the next day
when in the secret drawer in Horbury's office the letter was no longer to
be found. But I was sure of it in the morning. I could not see how, in
falling forward, Horbury had pushed that book with its heavy cover off
the table. It seemed to me to have been worked from under him by someone
else. The book was empty. Who, then, had the letter? Someone had come
back for it. Someone who heard the telephone ring hours after Horbury was
dead? Had he found it? I thought not. I thought that the lady who faced
us in the dining-room would have had the courage to secure that weapon
for herself as soon as she was left alone. Well, then, where was it? The
police went through the house with a toothbrush...."

"Comb," said Mr. Ricardo.

"As I said," Hanaud continued imperturbably, "and they did not find it.
Therefore it was not in the house. But it was near."

"In Olivia Horbury's hand-bag," Ricardo suggested.

"Not safe enough," replied Maltby.

"And too bulky for her dress," Hanaud corroborated. "So I smoke a
cigarette and I reflect. The garden?--with a gardener one day a week,
that's what it looked like. Yes?"

"Yes," said Ricardo; and Maltby, looking out on his own patch of
carefully tended flowers, nodded vigorously.

"But there was a fine thing in that garden which was tended with all the
loving care it merited."

"The holly hedge," cried Maltby.

"Yes. It stood twenty feet high. It was clipped. It was smooth as a yew
hedge. I wondered. Then, when I called on that kind lady for the money
for my patient Gravot of the Place Vendôme, I praise the fine hedge and
her face lights up. Always in the old days when they were poor, she had
clipped it on a ladder and looked after it herself, and still trusted it
to no one. Then, a little quickly, she adds that it requires little
attention now. 'Once a year. I clipped it in the autumn,' and, rather red
in the face, she wished me good morning. So I have it! Carefully wrapped
in waterproof rubber, it is, when it is advisable to hide it, hidden in
the hedge. Then I make pictures. It will be high, yes. We will need the
ladder. It will be at the end near the road. No, no. Then I get from
Maltby a description of her bedroom. There are two windows opening on to
meadows and one window opposite the holly hedge. I do not need to seek
more. On a level with the window, whence it could just be seen, thrust
into the hedge out of reach."

At this moment, Monsieur Hanaud looked at his watch and leaped to his

"My dear friends, I have to fly. I have promised to say good-bye to a
young lady at the boat-train on the Victoria Station at five o'clock."

"Oh, you Frenchmen! Ha! ha!" roared Maltby, shaking with delight.

"No, no!" replied Hanaud, catching up his hat and his gloves and his
stick. "The days of the wink and the gay twinkle in the eyes are past
for me. I say good-bye in all respect to a lady who returns to her duties
in Cairo as the secretary of a famous archaeologist."

"Oh!" cried Ricardo, to whom this announcement was news. "Mrs. Rosalind

"Mrs. Leete," Hanaud agreed with a smile. "It is pleasant to see the young
so devoted to such serious topics as Neferti and the mummies of dead
kings. But I do not think that her duties will be prolonged."

"And how is that?" asked Maltby, who had no liking for allusions.

"I gather from a word dropped here and there that the excellent Mordaunt
will be on the quay at Port Said."

Mordaunt and Rosalind. Yes, you have got to have it, you know....Well,
perhaps you needn't. We can more suitably complete the pattern of this
story with the few words which passed between the two unlikely friends
the next morning at the corner house and Hanaud's departure for the

For the end of the holiday so often postponed had really come. At two
o'clock in the afternoon, Hanaud was to take the train to Folkestone.
Meanwhile, over his cigarette after breakfast, he looked backwards to the
morning at the end of August when, with seagulls swooping over the river,
he had driven with Ricardo across Battersea Bridge.

"Until you told me the story of Devisher's rescue, I was ready to accept
the theory of Horbury's suicide. But that made a difference, eh? Here was
a man, free as any stranger in London, with as black a score against
Horbury as a man could have. Also he knew White Barn as Horbury's home.
Someone was at White Barn unexpectedly that night. Otherwise all the
usual, natural fingerprints wouldn't have been removed. Someone was too
anxious. But, if Devisher had broken in and exacted his revenge, what was
he doing in the house three and a half to four hours after he had
committed his murder? And why did Olivia Horbury protect him?"

Ricardo nodded his head very wisely.

"So I began to wonder whether there was not, besides Devisher, someone
else in the garden-room. And I was puzzled by that word 'Sheriff' written
on the corner of the blotting-pad. Yes, I was very puzzled. Could there
perhaps be something else which explained Mrs. Horbury's silence, the
lifting of the telephone receiver, the locked door, the Sheriff

"That afternoon Septimus Crottle swung into the picture," said Ricardo.

"The name of Crottle brought Maltby to help us. Why was it that this man
without money, without friends, Bryan Devisher, could not be found?
Because, on Friday afternoon, the steamship Sheriff of the Dagger Line
sailed with a last-minute passenger whom George Crottle had motored that
morning to Southampton. The beautiful routine work, my friend, of the
British police!"

Hanaud and Mr. Ricardo said good-bye a few hours later on the platform at
Victoria Station, Mr. Ricardo all friendship and regret, Monsieur Hanaud
a little lost, as though he had forgotten something important to
remember. But, as the whistle blew and, the train started, his face
cleared. He stood in the doorway of the coach, beaming.

"You are quite yourself, eh?" cried the anxious Ricardo.

Hanaud nodded. He had remembered. He laughed. He answered: "I am all Sir


This site is full of FREE ebooks - Project Gutenberg Australia